Discussion Locked

Best Hard Drive? Worst Hard Drive?

0 helpful
113 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

113 replies

by dean

I myself swear by Samsung spinpoint drives. I use them personally and currently run 2x 120GB spin points and 1 80GB spinpoint. Never had a problem with any spinpoint for years.

by x-marcap

The ancient Micropolis is over 15 years old. It cost 4000.00 on the invoice. The machine it is in was 386/16 modified up to 386/25. 16 serial ports.

It is used by kids for Hangman, WP and spreadsheet appilcations.

9600 baud available on all sessions...

by guygo

In the past month, I have installed over 2,000 Seagate 400 and/or 500GB drives in the equipment I manufacture. My failure rate is below 2%, and Seagate replaces them no questions asked. I have used the Hitachi DeskStar 400 and 500 GB drives, and got appx 5% fallout. The Maxtors we used to use got way too hot, and would die prematurely due to overheating. If you want reliability (and who doesn't), go with the 'Gate!

by ek1017

I've owned several Maxtors and several Western Digital over the years. I had two Maxtors die within 2-3 years, but I've never had any problems with a WD drive. Maxtors are much less expensive, but the real cost is in the loss of data, having to reinstall programs, etc.. WD is for me!

by setirich

Recently (within the last 1/2 year) I've had three fail where I've never had a failure before. 2 Maxtors, 1 was doa from the store, and both the Maxtors where bought on "sale"...200gb for about$75 each.

The WD was a 120 about 2 years old...\

Fortunately, I keep three versions of everything for instances like this, and I was ok, other than the hassles. I think people use these drives like they were made for 24/7 operation, and they are not. They aren't made for constant spinning...I set mine to shut off after and hour of non-use...

If I were building a mission critical raid, I'd think carefully about the brand/warranty etc of the disks I purchased...all these cheap ones only have 1 year...the "good" wd's have 3. I guess you get what you pay for, eh?

bye-the-way, the drives Maxtor sent back where 250's...not the 200's. Ok...I don't mind...

Rich

by bachware

This isn't a direct reply to your post, but I want to add some of my experience with HDD reliability and failure:

1. The head-fork mechanism gets a lot of cluster-search activity when drives fragment. Therefore, even though the newer, faster HDDs still fetch clusters rapidly enough to be smooth even though the file system is fragmented, doing regular (i.e., weekly) defragmentation should help prolong the life of this critical fork component that gets beaten to death.

2. The platter motor has to do most of its work when spinning up the cylinder (working against its moment of inertia), so having a drive spin down when inactive for too short a time is probably a bad idea. I have auto-spindown turned off. The small amount of energy necessary to keep it spinning, and the wear and tear on bearings, is probably much less, then.

3. The high-density, robot-assembled, surface-mount electronics do fail more readily if the computer interior isn't well ventilated, and it overheats. I have TWO fans: One blows the cooling air in, the other at the other grille exhausts it.]

I'm very satisfied with my Maxtor IDE HDD. Sorry to hear you've had bad experiences with yours.

by eod

Internals never had one until a Maxtor failed but it lasted for 7 years. There is plenty of mad users. Internal 1 year warranty you have to pay a fee to make 2 years.My old 386 the HD never failed; ir ran for 10-12 years. The only say, "back up daily to CD or dvd". I have played/tested/whatever. I had 10 boxes up ans runnning until 3 years ago (my MS got real bad).

Externals...I had thought Maxtor was the way to go so I got the 250GB when it first came out $250ish. Thought it would be solid. I died after 15 months. There TS guys laughed at me. I had an old Buslink which had its ups & dowms. I play with a WD 80GB. My new WD 320GB which has tons of problems.

I burn a CD every couple of days. If I buy a program I burn it righ away. I got s bunch of medis (free after rebate). several HDs (free aftr rebatw).

by anndroid

we have had 4 complete failures of Maxtor HD's in 2 months (three separate machines). Data not recoverable on the first two--essential irreplaceable client data. FYI: one WAS the back-up!! One was not vital. The other was out of the box as a replacement.
Absolutely under no condition will Maxtor go into any of our 23 computers -- and that's just the ones we two head-honchos use. Employee machine will not have them either. Absent a person visit from the Maxtor CEO with generous gratuties, they can pound sand.

by tommyraynet

I spend a day doing video rendering. Next morning, when I tried to upload, it gave me an error to FORMAT Y/N?

I called Seagate. The morons could not even help me much with my issue, I had to fix it myself. They wanted $700 to $2000 to get the data off of it, not help the consumer!

I have a 5-Year Warranty that may cover the mechanics of the drive, but the data is very important, and they seem anxious to make a buck off of it.

If a guy like me can spend a couple hours and fix it himself, after the "tech support" failed to do so, well that surely lessens my estimation of Seagates capabilities as even being close to knowledgable. Especially if thier "techs" cannot do something over the phone that I did on my own. (With the help of google of course).

So... be WARY, make BACKUPS, but of course anyone here has a problem already so... just realize that they want your money for your either unfortunate lack of funds or lack of efficiency in making appropriate backups.

The deal is basically; "Hey, drive failed we replace, but you responsile for data on said drive". I am just still astonished how they either were so incapable knowledge wise, or so purposely looking to make a buck rather than help the consumer.

(What residential non biz customer wants to spend so much, $700 start to as much as $2,000, for something that can be gotten for FREE?)

This is my two cents. I had a 7200 250GB. If I wanna do without it for 2-3 weeks, I can have it replaced. Of course, within hours if you pay them money.

So warranties are okay, but they aren't the saviour we all need. The saviour is (1) Decent and Honest Tech Support and assistance when things DO fail.

I got my own data back immediately for free. They got diddly. THAT makes ME happy right there! :)

by steve

I'm one of those users that manufacturers hate - clumsily droping hard drives, or knocking my portables across the room as i trip over their cables... I have a few hard drives kicking around, pile of dead Maxtors, a tempramental but still working western digital (i'm trying, but the damn thing won't die!) and 3 seagates which are the afore mentioned dropped (onto a wooden floor from 2 metres), portable tripped (and sent flying across the room in ubs caddy) and a third which has been in and out of more computers than santa down chimneys on Xmas eve. the seagates just seem unbelievably robust(yes all three still work flawlessly!!!) - i know what i'm buying next!!!

by ozi eagle

Unfortunately, drives manufactured several years ago gives no indication of how well that brand's current drives will last today.

Appropos the costing of a current system, in another post, I was working for our water supply authority in the mid 80's and the internal newsletter came around with an article about the VAXes having been fiited with dual 1 GB HDDs, at a cost of $10,000. It shows how much technology has improved abd the cost benefit derived therefrom.

by nitwit

fail! fail! fail! avoid at all costs

they will fail and take all your data with it!

please i beg you not to purchase any lacie drives

their customer service dept is truly dreadful

This discussion is closed to new replies.