Certifications doesn't measure
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by sullivanjss
Well monyhunter@hotmail.com I must say that it sounds like you have money well spent! And now has a career now instead of some job you don't like.
I myself have been working in the IT industry for over 8 years now and only have the A+ Certification. And have been working on the MCP+I track since last year. It's tough but hearing your story makes me want to succeed even more.
by tary1
by eby
by teburlew
by ogwonu
Though I'm not yet certified, I agree,
somewhat, with suhreed's observation. I know
quite a few MCSEs that don't know jack about
computers. A friend of mine who works in a
bank hired 2 MCSEs. Needless to say, they
found out that the MCSEs were only in name.
But, if one wants to get ahead in this
increasingly competitive world, certification
is the way,
by pizza7
I just wanted to say a few things here. If you are experienced, you really do not have any excuses for not taking a certification exam. If you have both experience and the cert, it will make you more powerful and management will likely reward yourefforts (or find someone who will).
I study with the intent of learning the material very well. I am a hands on guy and can't just simply read a book and take an exam. I have to at least play with something to see what makes it tick.
Management does put some credance into certs and it is a way to open doors. I work for a consulting firm and it is the same thing there. I do not try to pass myself off as an experienced veteran when applying anywhere. They know where I am at.
Unfortunately, some people try to circumvent the system. They chase that piece of paper and don't care to understand the concepts. This problem exists in every disclipline. People even try to pass themselves off as doctors and get quite far.
The bottom line in all of this is HOW GOOD DO YOU WANT TO BE. Successful people are always trying to become better. They always search for better information.
In the end, the pretenders will surface. Computers understand command lines. If you don't know what you are doing, it will become readily apparent.......
by jarnette
I'm an IT consultant for a Hospital and I have to admit that the market is tough. There is this need for people to work in IT but it seems to fall into the depths of the EXP w/o EXP pitfall. I was fortunate that this hospital has an exceptional temp program, I got lucky, and paid my dues by working my ass off and moved up. If I didn't prove my skills and willingness to learn I would have been out on my butt months ago. That's part of the temp contract that my supervisor and myself had to sign. I've only been working in IT for about a year(I REALLY worked hard) and plan on taking the MCSE 2000 track. Last year I looked at websites for the NT track and I was surprised and almost disappointed at how easy it was to get questions/answers off of the web. The problem is that it is TOO easy, make it harder, make it near impossible. I think certs R important to land that entry level position w/o EXP. EXP is important to prove reliability and competence. No one should get a 60,000+ job with apaper cert but they should get a 30 to 50,000 entry level spot to prove their skills, once EXP is gained, move them up and pay them more,(or risk losing them) if they don't cut it keep them at the low position or get rid of them. I think there should be some sort of clause instituted and assumed by all paper certs that they must prove that the certs are worth much more than the paper it was laser printed on. The REAL problem is that big brother industry doesn't follow the same hiring model thatthis hospital implements.
by business
by dmerril
by cpetrich
...the Designing and Implementing SQL Server 7 appears so daunting?
I have developed Ansi compliant sql database apps for a decade. Our latest effort is a time input system in VB with SQL Anywhere on the back end.
I must admit that the SQL Server material is perfectly understandable, but a real stretch to memorize for testing purposes. Especially when I look at the syntax for SELECT and INSERT. Cripes!
How can someone so totally boneheaded as the fellow described possibly pass?
by dmerril
by evilthor
by teburlew
by teburlew
by evilthor
by tecalote
by evilthor
1. gee if you are that good you could certify in 30 days and probably double your income.
2. sounds like those certified techs either eked through or were not properly supervised for hands on experience.
3. industry standards are set by employers in those fields. whom do you think should set the standards?
4. the tests are put together by people in the field and do measure how to do the job. you are blaming the wrong people. all the people who can pass a driving test are not necessarily gooddrivers even after years of experience because they do not apply what they have learned
by clarkes
by baklaguy
by teburlew
by fieldse
by afreden
by teburlew
I don't know about things in your country, but here in North America, USA and Canada, we are NOT all like what is depicted by the post from FcoRom. There are many companies that hire and train because we recognize the need to nurture and grow good talent. Even in the consulting world, we encourage bright young "newbies" with proven POTENTIAL to join us. In June, I interviewed and recommended we a self-taught just graduating non-CS major student. He is an active contributing team member. Heis growing his skills and experience while making a good living. I hope I am not the only person with blinders on who looks for the good in people rather than the bad. The post you answered and several others have gotten quite vicious and super negative. I don't blame you for your response. Please remember there are many of us out there who look forward to training and growing new talent. It is just that some people forgot what it was like when they were starting out.
Good luck. ReverendThomas E. Burlew
by larry
by larry
by larry
by larry
by mdonley
by mbr2
I didn't know NT had been around 10 yrs.
When did Windows 95 come out, 1985?
by teburlew
by teburlew
by teburlew
by teburlew
by hailes103z
If you just graduated college, Congrats! You have a "paper" and probably need to work on your job search skills. All I see is BA wanted. Certifications are mentioned as a must about 1 of every 13 to 18 job listings asking for BA in some kind of computer related degree.
Some of us had unrecognized training and 3 yrs. exp. with no school, no certifications and no money to get either. Feel lucky for what you get. I have a family to take care and the job outlook is poor. I know my job and I learned it the hard way. I get no respect for what I know in the civilian world. It's like moving to a new planet. You'll be fine, just wish me luck.
by ger van hees
This is true, but in my experience paper counts only if your experience is also up to date.
I have had several employers who see certs as a first sign of basic knowledge and then look at the experience as the second criteria.
Fact is that you canlie about your experience, but not about certification unless you buy them.
by sneakypet
by teburlew
by hmanjr
I'm also taking the NT4 track, just starting my self. According to the MCSE question and answer page at the Microsoft site if you pass the 4 core for NT you can continue to work on the NT 4 MCSE using electives from the Win 2000 track.
Q. If I have passed all core exams in the Windows NT 4.0 MCSE track by December 31, 2000, but have not yet passed my elective exams by that date,can I still continue to earn my certification?
A. Yes, if you have passed all core exams in the Windows NT 4.0 MCSE track exams by December 31, 2000, you may continue to earn your MCSE certification in the Windows NT 4.0 track, as long as the electives you select have not retired.
by tbrigham
I have read quite a few of the responses and comments on certification and feel I need to give my $.02 worth. I have been in the computer industry for over 20 years, worked with PC's since 1986. I never felt getting certifications was that important. I didn't feel a college diploma was either. They both carry the same impications. They are just a piece of paper but the represent hard work not experience. The individuals deserve to be recognized for the work and given a chance to gain experience.
I have waisted many years in not getting any certifications. I got my A+ threee years ago with very little study. I will agree that those were easy to me. (They should have been with over 10 years experience) I recieved certification for Checkpoint Firewall software a year ago and that WASN'T easy. I just returned from a 20 day bootcamp for Windows 2000 MCSE. I didnt succeed. I passed several tests and recieved my MCP and plan to finish the tests in the next couple of months. But to the individual who said the Microsoft tests were easy... I say go take the new tests for Windows 2000 Core and tell me those are easy.
Sorry to ramble... just one old man's opinion.
by negoc8r
by jhofstee
by fluxit
by white wolf
by hacbmis
by oridjinn
I have been in this industry for about 6 years now, and I have been doing great at my job with the ability to adapt to various technical environments and the ability to be self-taught. Its not until just recently that I have started pursuing certifications just because the resume value that they tend to add. I have noticed that more and more companies are starting to wisen up to the fact that its not all about certifications because they see the lack of experience effects their job performance greatly. Companies are starting to look more at experience rather than certification and this is affecting alot of individuals who are in pursuit of a career change. I have noticed that alot of training companies are promising up to(in small type) 60,000 per year with an MCSE. What the training companies fail to mention is that this is the average salary of someone with 6+ years experience in the field. So after the trainee has slapped down 8,000 dollars for training to make 60k, they findthey can't without experience... and how do they get experience, by starting out with a job that is a helpdesk position that pays 25k. Plus, half of the students pursueing the career change don't have the technical ability nor the capacity to handle a technical job. How do we fix this you ask? We have the training companies give full disclosure for all students and all students should be required to take a short adaptive test to see if they are technically capable to handle these types of jobs. Unfortunately there are a ton of MCSE's out there that are getting screwed on the deal and what is going to happen when the MCSE gets retired?
Thomas Wagenhauser, MCSE, CCIE, A+
Director of Information Technology
by studmuffin
You raised some good points. Apparently the new MCSE track (Windows 2000) is supposed to be harder, but we'll see. MCSE used to be a valued certification at one time, but it lost value over time because of the relative ease it became to become an MCSE. Personally I would like to get the MCSE, and move on to Cisco Network Support Certifications (CCNA,CCNP,CCIE), but don't lump all certs as
the same, because Cisco certs (especially CCIE) are supposedly much more difficult to obtain than a Microsoft one. Nortel certification exams are supposed to be no piece of cake either, but since I'm interested in LANS/WANS and Routers and Switches, I might consider getting some Nortel certifications after Cisco, plus a Red
Hat Certified Engineer. Actually's Sun Solaris certification and the RHCE are supposed to be tough exams, so they're probably certifications worth studying for.
That's just me though, I could be wrong.
by n_er_g
by blackdog
by spettit
by dwilcox22
by bub59
I have been in the computer repair field for years.I just recieved my A+ cert and am now working on my N+. I have not found anyone that is willing to let me work or watch someone else work on networks at all.their fine with me doing my job(i.e. computer tech) but I am not allowed to even take my own time to watch a networker do there job.
So I am doing the N+ curriculum on my own, hoping that someone will hire me just on the N+ cert. It's a terrible way to get experience but it,s the best wecan do sometimes.
by teburlew
by mgtaylor
by trying...
by trying...
by jigans
I am MCP+I, MCSE, CNA & working in the field of networking..
I have found soman mcses who are a lot far from the basics.. Who doesn't even know the booting process... The don't know the can't access FAT32 from NT...One i found was trying to install two PDCS in one domain!!!!!
Actually microsoft tests are damn easy.. & There question bank is really limited.. & what i have seen is in most of the exams 25-30% questions are common among all test takes... Microsoft should create some clear policyto keep the value of MCSE alive.. Here in india Some non-CTEC people does what .. They gethers questions from 15-20 recent test takers & creats PASSING GURANTEE TEST BACK & CHARGES Rs. 1500/ paper....What i look is now these certifications are loosing values bcoz of poor test management & privacy management...
by oe1962
I have engineer degree and I had 7 years computer and electronic equipment repair experience when first time I came to this country in 1990. People wouldn't hire me I couldn't speak english language very well. Then over the years I have learn the language but people was telling me I didn't have experience in America. How would i get experience if nobody gives me a chance.
After I get A+ and Network+ certified they started to offer me a jobs. What is the catch? Nobody cares about experience. Piece of paper(certificate) talks bull s??? walks.
by fluxit
What would you think of a Computer Technicians guild, generally modeled after that of the construction trades? The type of organization I am thinking of would have skill levels similar to Apprentice, Journeyman, Technician, Master, &c, and provide the support structure necessary to help when a technician gets stuck.
I would be thinking that a guild of this type would vouch for the skills of the technicians within it, and could build a market in the community for quality. Plus, the small and medium shops with only one computer guy would have the support of the entire Guild, not just their own brains.
I was also thinking this could provide the real hands-on training that so many certification programs lack, taught by the guild members themselves.
What do you all think? Good idea, bad idea? BTW, I am NOT discussing a union. This would be a Technicians Guild, membership to which entitles you to certain benefits. (Maybe even TechRepublic would want to run this one, eh? But I am thinking more on the lines of local chapters and meeting groups.)
Give me some ideas, or contact me directly, if you want to.
Brian Lusk
brianlusk@netzero.net
by shanghai sam
by fluxit
First off, I appreciate your candor and your response. It is a much needed perspective. I invite you to continue to share your perspective, because if there is anything along these lines that would work, it would have to work for all IT pros and IT newbies.
I actually have found that the bulk of the IT staff (I'm talking technicians, not managers) come home quite filthy from the days labors.
As a Network Administrator, I spend at least as much time under a desk as I do sitting at it. And, in a lot of these environments, under the desk is certainly not clean. Understand, I also sit in the executive board room and make strategic IT decisions with the President (and owner) of the company.
My contention is that the bulk of the real IT pros today learned their trade from their own experience, the help of other technicians/programmers and a lot of hard labor. Formalized training is (generally) the product of the last few years of the IT business. In fact, In 1993 or so, most firms didn't have a "CTO". The computer staff was almost a step-child, a money hole, or a "necessary" cost to the corporation. Only in the last few years has IT changed to being a strategic part of the whole enterprise.
It is my desire to pass the hard-won information gleaned from IT pros around. Now, the Apprentice, Journeyman style approach may not work in the IT fields, but what would?
Brian Lusk
brianlusk@netzero.net
P.S. Please, I invite you to respond. This is the feedback I truly need.
by gnutter
by shamii
Hello
I just want to say that certificates can`t assure that you are really capable of doing some things in that field.Now a days a lot of certifcates are available from brainbench too.Although their question are standard but you can`t trust them and it may be possible that somebody else has helped you while the test which is against the sould of a test and so the certificate will also be fake.Certificates are not trustworthy and an interview should be conducted to assure about the knowledge of a person although if he has a certifiacte.
by studmuffin
by dwilcox22
by monyhunter
by larry
how am I to reply to that? Your name says it all. Iam not out for the money. I have a good job and I work with a lot of good people. I don't use UNIX cause we got rid of it but we still use PICK. I have not gone to school to learn PICK because I learned on my own (and do a good job of it)Maybe if you read some of my other posts you'd know that I have said there are others out there besides Microsoft. I just don't need them
P.S. there is no need to be so unkind with calling names
by sheilau
by ojamro
by kbnet
by yruhere
I am a complete newbie here, but I really need some helpful input regarding my situation. I am a professional educator and administrator living in Seoul Korea. I have recently resigned my position in order to study Korean at a university and computers on my own. My Korean skills are limited to basic conversation, so academia is out of the question, hence I am unable to study formally here. Without any help or guidance, I have self-educated myself from ground zero to the point where I know most major applications for the Windows platform. I can build a computer without much difficulty... mind you I can't read the manuals 100% so some things I can't do. I can program HTML with ease, CSS with reference materials, read simple Perl, program simple javascript, and modify Visual Basic macros with ease. I used to program shell scripts when I was in high school and university for both the DOS and UNIX platforms. I can easily install Linux. I've successfully installed NT with no difficulty. (I haven't tried 2000 yet, but I expect it would be the same.) I've setup DNS and IP information on a Win98 and Win95 network before. (I had a LOT to take care of in my administration duties.)
I spend virtually all of my free time studying various programs and languages. I can't get into a school for formal study, so doing an MSCE or other certification is not an option at the moment.
If anyone can offer me some constructive advice on what I should be tinkering with and experimenting with, Iwould be very grateful.
by jgruber
by fluxit
by jschling
by fluxit
by fluxit
Yes, you have several good points there. Believe me, I strongly agree that the IT professional on the corporate level is required to be knowledgeable in all these areas to prevent being railroaded by the CPAs.
You mentioned a very successful training program that you implemented in your corporation. This is the type of knowledge that needs to be spread around. Unfortunately, many IT Managers are more manager than IT. You apparently have the IT background and have successfully made a career of managing IT staffs.
My concern is that relying on corporations to spread the knowledge around is not really working. Paid training is either prohibitively expensive for the average person or takes many years to complete, and lacks the real world experience that is really what makes the man.
Visionaries and Techies need to be equally served by the idea. I'm not just talking about technical knowledge, but managerial knowledge, supervisory knowledge, financial knowledge, everything.
So, how can we spread that knowledge around?
Brian Lusk
by fluxit
by bassplayer
by bassplayer
by mfh
I support you. As it is a vicous circle where
it is insisted that you should have experience and no body is ready to hire a person with qualification (university degree or certification) to give him a chance to gain experience.
So if a man is not get hired due to lack of experience then from where companies will get experienced people? Definitely they have to lure people from another organisation by offering lucrative salary & perks.
So some body should come forward to help newly certified people providing practical apprenticeship like CISCO has recently arranged with different companies to provide necessary practical training sfter certification.
I am a new OCP of Oracle trying to migrate from Electrical Engineering to IT Field snd facing this hurdle in addition to my age barrier.
Md. Farid Hasan
by cakes77
Good column. If we are very concerned about customer service we must remember to "close the loop". Don't make customers go through the motions of filling out survey forms and then react by either ignoring them or by sending a fake "thanks for responding-sorry,
have a nice day" card.Once in College Park Maryland at a Pizza Hut, I filled a response card out after having to sit at a table for an hour before even getting waited on. I handed it to the on duty manager and while I was leaving I saw him throw it in the trash!
by sheilau
by larry
Our forefathers did'nt have tech schools to learn a trade, they were given the skills by their predecessors. Why is it we lost the will to share our knowledge. Is it the money thing? Yes we all need it, but some of us just can't afford $100.00 a test.
I think anyone who has the oppertunity to work with you will get alot.
by j_bonvicini
That is the sad fact about Microsoft MCSE curriculum. Up until Windows 2000, almost anyone who had a general understanding of computers could read the Exam Cram books or the Microsoft Certified Press books and memorize some questions and answers and when it comes time for their MCSE test, all they do is spit out the answer. But then if you ask them why that answer is the correct one, they are totally baffled. I know many co-workers who did this and they had no previous Windows NT experience. Certification should be an add on to existing NT experience to show you are certified to do what you have been doing. The 2000 exams are a lot harder and they wil truly eliminate the so called "paper-MCSE's"... Microsoft has actually hurt their own image as being a techonology leader.
Cisco's CCNA and CCIE and CCMP are much harder than Microsoft's...
jbonvicini@ato.com
by gholt418
by jschling
by dwilcox22
One of the problems that I face daily is the lack of knowledge that most users have. My answer has been a users group. I want my users to have the tools to their job. I request time with my users to find out how they getting things done and if thereare changes that need to be made in the process. With all of that said.
I have not seen one mention of the local computer users group. Many cities have these not to mention community colleges and universities.
A lot can be learned there and a lot of information can be given.
If you haven't joined a local users group join on. From these meeting you network you ablities and maybe learn something also. I have.
by fluxit
by jschling
by duster52
Ok, here's my two cents....
In my opinion the tests for the various certifications simply measure your ability to memorize that companies 'answer' based on their view point of the world. They do not truly evaluate your ability to function as an IT professional in the real world.
That being said, if an individual attains a certification, they have achieved an assumed base line of knowledge. There is a basic level of ability and a basic skill set that they now have to live up to (and maintain).
A certification is important for a couple of reasons: 1) it provides a measurable base skill set and basic level of knowledge; 2) it is a demonstration of the ability to learn; and 3) it is a demonstration of a desire by the individual to improve themselves.
A certification gives a person a 'starting point.' I equate a certified person without experience to a 16 year old who just got his driver's license -- all the potential in the world, but dangerous as h---!
by studmuffin
Just which vendor certs are we talking about?
If you mean A+,CNE,MCSE you may be right. But if you're talking something like CCIE,Sun Solaris or Red Hat Certified Engineer, these are definitely high end certifications. Sure it's great to have experience, but there are employers who won't hired new IT people unless they have a certification, now what?
by ivobrugman
First let me say that is really strange that and MCP+I who has been acting as a trainer for years is not MCSE or MCT (if not). This seems a case of being more catholic than the Pope. Certification counts, in dollars, or dutch guilders in my case (which eventually is needed to pay your morgage, that is the way it is). Second, getting exams is no crime. Everyone has started with zero experience, why must al the (now) experienced people talk like you talk. There is only (if any) one to blame here,Microsoft or Sylvan Prometric. When it is that easy, you can make money with it, why should you not certify. It is stupid not to do it, careerwise. Support centres lose there status if they do not have a certain amount of certified people, same goesfor solution providers and stuff like that. There are really no reasons not to certify, so....
I currently hold mcse+i, MCT, CCNA, MCP2000 and some other stuff. But, i do not pretend I know it all. That is important. I work at UNISYS.
by ky sparky
Sort by Trending