Discussion Locked

Certifications doesn't measure

0 helpful
414 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

414 replies

by sullivanjss

Well monyhunter@hotmail.com I must say that it sounds like you have money well spent! And now has a career now instead of some job you don't like.
I myself have been working in the IT industry for over 8 years now and only have the A+ Certification. And have been working on the MCP+I track since last year. It's tough but hearing your story makes me want to succeed even more.

by tary1

You don't need certifications to get your foot in the door. If you have no prior experience or schooling then you might need certifications but if you go to school and get atleast an associate's degree, you'll have no trouble at all getting an interview. Don't get me wrong though, I believe that certifications will only help you in the long run but their not a substitute for knowledge and or experience.

by eby

Wish I had time to read all the posts. I've been on most sides of the various issues presented. IMHO, it seems the biggest problem is hiring managers can't separate the wheat from the chaff, so unqualified personell end up in the wrong positions.Most of the people who have to decide who to hire cannot properly interview, etc. If this were corrected, most of the issues raised here (paper certs vs. experience, need a job to get experience to get a job)would be resolved, I believe.

by teburlew

You have a very good point. Many organizations do not have senior enough technical staff to do an in depth tech interview. Or, they don't let their techies talk with the candidates. As a result, I agree with you middle or upper management, without review by an internal techie, make their decision on the "look and feel" of the candidate to the best ability to understand the technology (usually only as a user, or former techie twice removed). I know this note will generage irate responses from just those middle to upper managers who were once technical but chose to lead by position/authority rather than lead by example. Also, it doesn't take that long to read all the responses here; just two hours a day just to keep up.

by ogwonu

Though I'm not yet certified, I agree,
somewhat, with suhreed's observation. I know
quite a few MCSEs that don't know jack about
computers. A friend of mine who works in a
bank hired 2 MCSEs. Needless to say, they
found out that the MCSEs were only in name.
But, if one wants to get ahead in this
increasingly competitive world, certification
is the way,

by pizza7

I just wanted to say a few things here. If you are experienced, you really do not have any excuses for not taking a certification exam. If you have both experience and the cert, it will make you more powerful and management will likely reward yourefforts (or find someone who will).

I study with the intent of learning the material very well. I am a hands on guy and can't just simply read a book and take an exam. I have to at least play with something to see what makes it tick.

Management does put some credance into certs and it is a way to open doors. I work for a consulting firm and it is the same thing there. I do not try to pass myself off as an experienced veteran when applying anywhere. They know where I am at.

Unfortunately, some people try to circumvent the system. They chase that piece of paper and don't care to understand the concepts. This problem exists in every disclipline. People even try to pass themselves off as doctors and get quite far.

The bottom line in all of this is HOW GOOD DO YOU WANT TO BE. Successful people are always trying to become better. They always search for better information.

In the end, the pretenders will surface. Computers understand command lines. If you don't know what you are doing, it will become readily apparent.......

by jarnette

I'm an IT consultant for a Hospital and I have to admit that the market is tough. There is this need for people to work in IT but it seems to fall into the depths of the EXP w/o EXP pitfall. I was fortunate that this hospital has an exceptional temp program, I got lucky, and paid my dues by working my ass off and moved up. If I didn't prove my skills and willingness to learn I would have been out on my butt months ago. That's part of the temp contract that my supervisor and myself had to sign. I've only been working in IT for about a year(I REALLY worked hard) and plan on taking the MCSE 2000 track. Last year I looked at websites for the NT track and I was surprised and almost disappointed at how easy it was to get questions/answers off of the web. The problem is that it is TOO easy, make it harder, make it near impossible. I think certs R important to land that entry level position w/o EXP. EXP is important to prove reliability and competence. No one should get a 60,000+ job with apaper cert but they should get a 30 to 50,000 entry level spot to prove their skills, once EXP is gained, move them up and pay them more,(or risk losing them) if they don't cut it keep them at the low position or get rid of them. I think there should be some sort of clause instituted and assumed by all paper certs that they must prove that the certs are worth much more than the paper it was laser printed on. The REAL problem is that big brother industry doesn't follow the same hiring model thatthis hospital implements.

by business

My peeve about certs is that every other commercial on the radio is for some training facility that says that absolutely anyone ("even if you've never turned a computer on") can go to one of their 5 day camps and get certified and instantly land some amazing tech job. They always throw around insanely large salaries. I think it's completely misleading to those who don't understand that there's so much more to a succesful, high paying tech career than the paper and it's insulting to the rest of us who work years developing our careers through a variety of education, certs, and experience.

by dmerril

You have to ask yourself just what is the motive for certification? More to the point, who's motive is driving the program?

by cpetrich

...the Designing and Implementing SQL Server 7 appears so daunting?

I have developed Ansi compliant sql database apps for a decade. Our latest effort is a time input system in VB with SQL Anywhere on the back end.

I must admit that the SQL Server material is perfectly understandable, but a real stretch to memorize for testing purposes. Especially when I look at the syntax for SELECT and INSERT. Cripes!

How can someone so totally boneheaded as the fellow described possibly pass?

by dmerril

Certification has never been about quality in any of its forms. It has to do with the marketing of a product and the cynical use of people as a resource by Corporate America. What is needed are answers to the questions: 1. Who is promoting certification and who profits the most from it? 2. Why is standardization and quality control lacking? What we need is a redefinition of the Information Technology worker. This includes both the professional and the technician! By this I mean are we (the IT worker) simply a resource to be used by business or are we really valuable capital to be nurtured and developed. Certification, education, degree programs, and training are all important because it requires the use of all of these resources to build capital. If the IT worker is only a resource, well then you use ?it? right along with all the other resources to produce revenue and cut costs.

by evilthor

to all of those who whine about certs meaning nothing and know it all just take the tests if they are so easy and up your income. or you may dial 1-800-boo-hooo and ask for extension WAAHH

by teburlew

You understand this to it's fullest extent when you are a consultant. The "pimps" (salesforce) need all the glitz and glitter they can show (certs, degrees, experience) in order to peddle their wares (consultants). They don't call some firms body shops for nothing. Kind of sickening to realize just how important we all are to some companies isn't it? Very few companies treat us as intellectual capital. Most view us as expendable resources.

by evilthor

Sure we all agree that certs do not a IT capable person make. But they do give a well rounded background on which to build hands on experience. Furthermore, for each moronic action you have caught a newbie doing because of inexperience I can also cite wrongful actions done by experienced techs who have never bother to delve into the complexities or quirks of software and hardware.

by tecalote

Just a note, within the last month I have seen 2 instances of meaningless Certifications. The first was an MCSE sitting next to me in a class who turned and asked me how to rename a file in DOS. The second was while interviewing people for an Desktop support position, the candidate had an MCSE and a CNE. When asked how to boot W9x to Safe mode he asked "what's that?"

by it's not easy being green

I have come to relize, when I interveiw anyone for a tech/Admin position, I need to have them crack a case and start naming parts. Except for the A+ exams, the exams say that you have a solid understanding of 1 specific operating system. To boot in "Safe Mode" means nothing to a Win NT "tech" if they have experience or not, quiz your canidate! Make sure they know what is expected of them and they can preform a job. If your hiring manager is non-technical and only wants to see a peice of paper, turn around and leave the interveiw. No reason to either have unreasonable expectations in either direction.

by evilthor

1. gee if you are that good you could certify in 30 days and probably double your income.
2. sounds like those certified techs either eked through or were not properly supervised for hands on experience.
3. industry standards are set by employers in those fields. whom do you think should set the standards?
4. the tests are put together by people in the field and do measure how to do the job. you are blaming the wrong people. all the people who can pass a driving test are not necessarily gooddrivers even after years of experience because they do not apply what they have learned

by clarkes

Because so many employers like you expect everyone to be able to hit the ground running, no newcommers like myself can get the experience you want. This is why there is an IT crisis! Stop trying to get something for nothing, and train someone.

by baklaguy

He or she may have a certification but that doesn't automatically make them an unteachable sloppy moron as many of you suggest. I agree that certification isn't all that it is cracked up to be but potential tech workers need somewhere to start. Ifyou do have workers who are entirely too incompetent to work with then you need to talk to your supervisor and see if there is anything that can be done. Have a discussion with the recruiters about their screening process. Talk to your supervisor and tell them that they need to drastically improve their hiring criteria.

by teburlew

Screening process... What Screening process? Oh, so you want to thoroughly check out credentials BEFORE hiring. I know I have been slightly negative at times in this discussion, but you just hit a very good point. The lack of proper tech screening by any management before hiring. As a result, those of us here on the front lines not only get all the blame, but see first hand the mistakes our administrative "giants" put us through. In my current company and the previous three I had to talk in depth with at least three techies before I was called back to talk with anyone from management. Currently, I am one of several senior techs who is part of the interview process. I usually take 45 minutes to an hour with each candidate and cover 25 to 35 very technical questions based on the contents of their resume. In addition to me, candidates have the same process with one or two other techies and take a written exam. Then, if we all say "go ahead", and they score high enough on the exam, the candidate gets to talk with HR and management. As a result, I don't care if the person has a cert or not, a college degree or not, or any combination of the two. The reality is that after two to three of us grill someone for an hour each, and they take a written exam, we pretty much know if the candidate can perform on the job. I started out well before certifications were even though about, in a time when Assembler was considered a "high level language" since we no longer had to program in binary. Therefor I don't put much stock in certifications even though I am finally breaking down to take mine; not for the money, but just for the fun of it.

by fieldse

I work in a shop as a network engineer/ PC Support, and was "put into " this position by necessity. I would LOVE to have someone mentor me. and would also loved to have had the luxury of having the time to truly lay a solid foundation.My question is...with comments and sentiments like that one abounding in the field, How likely am I to ask for Help ? There are a lot of times that I have sought people out,, and really regreted it.

by afreden

You're absolutely correct. I work in a very technical environment with Microsoft as our bigegst client, and certifications are extrememly important. People with the certifications will get the interviews, but during the interviews - if they don't have the experience to back it up - they are weeded out. People need the certifications for the job hunt process especially. It's disheartening that so many people believe that certifications are meaningless. One thing I do notice, however, is that most people who say that have none.

by teburlew

I don't know about things in your country, but here in North America, USA and Canada, we are NOT all like what is depicted by the post from FcoRom. There are many companies that hire and train because we recognize the need to nurture and grow good talent. Even in the consulting world, we encourage bright young "newbies" with proven POTENTIAL to join us. In June, I interviewed and recommended we a self-taught just graduating non-CS major student. He is an active contributing team member. Heis growing his skills and experience while making a good living. I hope I am not the only person with blinders on who looks for the good in people rather than the bad. The post you answered and several others have gotten quite vicious and super negative. I don't blame you for your response. Please remember there are many of us out there who look forward to training and growing new talent. It is just that some people forgot what it was like when they were starting out.
Good luck. ReverendThomas E. Burlew

by larry

tell me, when your new to the IT profession, where do you get the experence if no one will hire you because you don't have the experence? your statement is just a smoke screen to justify not hiring newbies

by larry

I have been working as an network administrator for 2 1/2 years. I got this job because I worked as a data processor/manager in the military. I went through all of the courses to get my MCSE but only took the NT server 4.0. I don't have an experenced Cert. Tech. to mentor me. I have to find out what I don't know on my own. I think as long as you can show you have been to school (most schools give you a certificate of completion) that should be enough to get in the door. Only the DOOR. NT 4 or 2000 is only a program and "School" teaches only programs. We use other programs that give me more trouble then anything I learned at "school" and I can normaly call the company that makes it and get the needed information from them. I have found that learning by doing is most gratifying and gives me more of a good feeling knowing that "I" found the answer to a problem and fixed it myself. I won't say I am the best or that I know alot because I am still learning and most likly will never stop learning, but The other companies that have software (and hardware) don't require you to have a Certification to use their products like Microsoft does. They are only a company. Each person that pays all of that money to get Cert. just keeps Bill Gates rich. He does'nt care, its the person who pays you to do the job you were hired for. And furthermore, Those with College Degrees! I have a degree in underwater basket weaving. I can get a job because I have a degree (go figure)

by richard.meyer42

I have been in the industry for 18 years. I am just starting MCSE classes. In the companies I have worked for, Certs are everything. Without Certs there is not much chance of advancement. Microsoft is not the only company that has Certs. Novell has certs and every major computer and peripheral manufacturer requires the technicians to be hardware certified (to perform warranty work on their product). Let's not forget Cisco either. I have tons of hardware experience and some network experience but I cannot make the move into networking until I have a Cert from Microsoft or Novell.

by larry

it just seems pointless to get/have a Novell or Cisco Cert. When you don't have anything that needs the use of them. I am not going to medical school to be a plumber.

by larry

In my younger days, I was a Fire Rescueman. we had a older man faint at an airshow. One of the "booked learned" medics almost killed the man. If it was'nt for the experence of having done the job before and knowing what to do my partner and I would'nt have been able to save him.

by mdonley

I think what you are experiencing is something that I have hit on before. If the people doing the evaluation/hiring do not have the requisite knowledge to weigh a prospective employees experience or competency, then the only thing they can do is go for certified candidates. That way, if things don't work out, they can always say; "Don't blame me, The guy/gal had all the right credentials". It is often a matter of COA.

by mbr2

I didn't know NT had been around 10 yrs.
When did Windows 95 come out, 1985?

by teburlew

Remember, what we call NT today is Version 4... Heck, I was running NT 3.51 back when Windows 3.11 came out. Win95 came out the tail end of 1994 hence the name. It is just that until the mid to late 1990's NT was not popular outside of the engineering or development world.

by teburlew

You may have to find a mentor outside of your company. Case-in-point: I am working with someone from another discussion on being a DBA and/or DBM. He contacted me through my email. I never met him, but have been providing as much support and suggestions as I can. Pick on someone from this forum. Join AMA or DPMA, or some other professional organization. Go to local chapter meetings, make contacts and find a mentor there. When I was on the board of directors, Toronto, Canada chapter of DPMA, we encouraged chapter memebers to help others. We posted questions and problems and asked for volunteers to help those struggling with a problem. If you get really stuck, ask me. I don't guarentee I have the answer, but I may be able to pointyou in the right direction. /TEB

by teburlew

I said this before in response to a similar question. One great untapped area to get experience in is non-profit or not-for-profit organizations. To the new hire, they pay as much as corporate America. Unfortunately, once you have a fair amount of experience, you cannot afford the cut in pay to work there. But, they along with IPO companies (startups) are willing to give the newbie a leg up so to speak. Don't be afraid at starting at the beginning, "it's a very good place to start". Today, too many people have high expectations of making a lot of money in IT. Unfortunately, you don't start out at the top. Since you have to start somewhere, go non-profit where you are appreciated and can make a name for yourself. Then, after a short while (1-3 years) if you want a change, look at moving into the cut throat world of corporate IT. Good luck. /TEB

by teburlew

Sounds like you need to find out what direction you want to take your career. Yes, you are in charge, noone else can make up your mind as to what you want to do. You mentioned management; consider a couple local college courses in business management. You also mention getting one or more certs. That's great if you want to stay technical but useless to managers. Try talking to one of your company HR people, or post one or more questions in a TechRepublic.com Career discussion. On another note; do you enjoy your work? If so, why are you worring about making changes? Sit down and write down everything you like and hate about your job. Then list the things you are good and bad at. Finally, list the things you like and dislike doing.Now you are ready to do a needs assessment to determine where you want to go in your career. Your choices will tell you if you should go to night school, get a cert, stay where you are, move on, or whatever. Unless you do the analysis, you will continue asking yourself these same questions and having the same doubts over and over and over.....

by hailes103z

If you just graduated college, Congrats! You have a "paper" and probably need to work on your job search skills. All I see is BA wanted. Certifications are mentioned as a must about 1 of every 13 to 18 job listings asking for BA in some kind of computer related degree.
Some of us had unrecognized training and 3 yrs. exp. with no school, no certifications and no money to get either. Feel lucky for what you get. I have a family to take care and the job outlook is poor. I know my job and I learned it the hard way. I get no respect for what I know in the civilian world. It's like moving to a new planet. You'll be fine, just wish me luck.

by ger van hees

This is true, but in my experience paper counts only if your experience is also up to date.
I have had several employers who see certs as a first sign of basic knowledge and then look at the experience as the second criteria.
Fact is that you canlie about your experience, but not about certification unless you buy them.

by sneakypet

I am one of the unfortune one in that I begain studying for the MCSE,Windows NT.Not to speak of the money I lost now I have to pay again to get the Windows 2000 training.I have taken two test.Now I am confused on what to do? I don't think this is fair This is not to stop Technology

by teburlew

If you can finish the NT before December 31 this year, continue on your NT track. Then, you have a year in which to re-certify on 2000. Since I know NT, that is the route I am taking. Hope this helps. /TEB

by hmanjr

I'm also taking the NT4 track, just starting my self. According to the MCSE question and answer page at the Microsoft site if you pass the 4 core for NT you can continue to work on the NT 4 MCSE using electives from the Win 2000 track.

http://www.microsoft.com/trainingandservices/default.asp?PageID=mcp&PageCall=faq&SubSite=cert/mcse&AnnMenu=mcse

Q. If I have passed all core exams in the Windows NT 4.0 MCSE track by December 31, 2000, but have not yet passed my elective exams by that date,can I still continue to earn my certification?
A. Yes, if you have passed all core exams in the Windows NT 4.0 MCSE track exams by December 31, 2000, you may continue to earn your MCSE certification in the Windows NT 4.0 track, as long as the electives you select have not retired.

by tbrigham

I have read quite a few of the responses and comments on certification and feel I need to give my $.02 worth. I have been in the computer industry for over 20 years, worked with PC's since 1986. I never felt getting certifications was that important. I didn't feel a college diploma was either. They both carry the same impications. They are just a piece of paper but the represent hard work not experience. The individuals deserve to be recognized for the work and given a chance to gain experience.
I have waisted many years in not getting any certifications. I got my A+ threee years ago with very little study. I will agree that those were easy to me. (They should have been with over 10 years experience) I recieved certification for Checkpoint Firewall software a year ago and that WASN'T easy. I just returned from a 20 day bootcamp for Windows 2000 MCSE. I didnt succeed. I passed several tests and recieved my MCP and plan to finish the tests in the next couple of months. But to the individual who said the Microsoft tests were easy... I say go take the new tests for Windows 2000 Core and tell me those are easy.
Sorry to ramble... just one old man's opinion.

by negoc8r

A year ago thats what I was doing.Without a certification program I probably would still be doing it. "A+" got my foot in the door(with less money). Since then I've earned the MCSE and Networks+ with my eye on Cisco. the small certification has led to a job at a large legal (multi state) firm w/400+ users at my location.If I had listened to all the "Pros" who say certification was worthless, I would not be looking at a long and VERY prosperous career in networking. What you do,you do for yourself. Don't let someone not in your position hold you back!

by jhofstee

I was in a book store in the computer section with several other men. Two of them knew each other. One of the gentlemen was wearing a hardware polo shirt. The third gentlemen saw his shirt and inquired to where he got it because he used that product. A nice friendly chat followed about how he and his friend work for the company as design engineers. When they ask third gentleman what he does. He replied "I'm a lawyer, but I want to get certified so i can move into IT and make the really good money." The man wearing the polo said, "Well that's good, but I will never work with you. I hate people who do not live, breath, and dream computers and then get certified and think they can make the big money. Hey your a really nice guy, but give this up your too late. Look if you make it great, but I'm sick and tried of paper certs. People who are certified with no experience." Then the two gentleman walked away. Leaving this lawyer to ponder what they said. Watching him for a few moments he began place the self study guides back and started to look at the books called pratical guides to this software and that. Albeit it was very rude, for someone whose been clawing up the ladder for several years part of me felt good that these guys where willing to scariface their reputation for several words of disgust towards paper cert pushers, but then again maybe they hate lawyers. I didn't stick around long enough to see what the lawyer ended up doing, but I have never seen such a switch in moodduring a conversion. Oh well I wasn't on the receiving end. Maybe this type of reaction will start to show up more and more. Not for me to judge I have only one cert and it hasn't done me any good yet.

by fluxit

I suppose that lawyer really was not doing his job as the average hourly rate for attorney's is at least twice that of IT people. My college roommate spent 11 yrs as a electrical engineer drawing $80k/yr. He crossed into law as a patent attorney andnow draws well over $300k/yr. Nonetheless, the combination of IT and Law could draw an incredible amount of money. Especially as the freedom of the internet act is coming to a end soon and regulation of the internet will quickly follow. Perhaps thatrude individual should consider crossing into law and spend time over in the legal book section. I think there is a lot of monmey to be made in IT security and persuing hackers.

by white wolf

Most companies treat cert as a "golden brand" on your butt to get by the cronies at the door... This is a horrible oversimplification of choosing who should get the responbility of Maintaining a network, or company computers! Yes, the people certifying these are also to blame. If your certifying that someone can do a particular job, they darn well better have those skills! Period. If a test CAN'T provide proof, then why does the Cert exist? Most of the time it's because of some cert companies greed to make more money by rounding up as many newbies and dupping them into believing that a cert = Job. When it doesn't neccessarily happen to be that way! That's where the problem truely exists. Changing the tests will only create more inventive ways to get around them. I'm not saying experience is king, because every tech should be able to prove he or she knows thier stuff. And a Cert is one way to prove that, but we'll always have those who intend to cheat thier way around getting the authentic knowledge.

by hacbmis

It used to be that when you got experience in the job you were doing then you got certified. Anyone in the service can tell you that. How would you like a certified mechanic that has never work on a car but read the book, work on yours. I think not. So, why doesn't that work in this field?

by oridjinn

I have been in this industry for about 6 years now, and I have been doing great at my job with the ability to adapt to various technical environments and the ability to be self-taught. Its not until just recently that I have started pursuing certifications just because the resume value that they tend to add. I have noticed that more and more companies are starting to wisen up to the fact that its not all about certifications because they see the lack of experience effects their job performance greatly. Companies are starting to look more at experience rather than certification and this is affecting alot of individuals who are in pursuit of a career change. I have noticed that alot of training companies are promising up to(in small type) 60,000 per year with an MCSE. What the training companies fail to mention is that this is the average salary of someone with 6+ years experience in the field. So after the trainee has slapped down 8,000 dollars for training to make 60k, they findthey can't without experience... and how do they get experience, by starting out with a job that is a helpdesk position that pays 25k. Plus, half of the students pursueing the career change don't have the technical ability nor the capacity to handle a technical job. How do we fix this you ask? We have the training companies give full disclosure for all students and all students should be required to take a short adaptive test to see if they are technically capable to handle these types of jobs. Unfortunately there are a ton of MCSE's out there that are getting screwed on the deal and what is going to happen when the MCSE gets retired?

Thomas Wagenhauser, MCSE, CCIE, A+
Director of Information Technology

by studmuffin

You raised some good points. Apparently the new MCSE track (Windows 2000) is supposed to be harder, but we'll see. MCSE used to be a valued certification at one time, but it lost value over time because of the relative ease it became to become an MCSE. Personally I would like to get the MCSE, and move on to Cisco Network Support Certifications (CCNA,CCNP,CCIE), but don't lump all certs as
the same, because Cisco certs (especially CCIE) are supposedly much more difficult to obtain than a Microsoft one. Nortel certification exams are supposed to be no piece of cake either, but since I'm interested in LANS/WANS and Routers and Switches, I might consider getting some Nortel certifications after Cisco, plus a Red
Hat Certified Engineer. Actually's Sun Solaris certification and the RHCE are supposed to be tough exams, so they're probably certifications worth studying for.
That's just me though, I could be wrong.

by n_er_g

You are part of the problem. It would be a real shame if every employer thought the way you do. Even if you go to school for years to get a CS degree, even if you have certifications SOMEONE MUST give you a foot in the door opportunity at some point. It is very discouraging to study VERY hard and obtain Certs & degrees only to be told you "need more experience". These companies that give you that line are fools. They have a goldmine of untapped, unmolded, talent before them and refuse to nurture it because you haven't had "real world" experience! Well tell that to my home network, my CNA and the degree I'm working on. Tell that to my wife who gets mad at me because I stay up until 3am reading and researching. Tell that to my 1 1/2 year old son when he wants daddy to spend time with him but his nose is in a book. I guess all of that sacrifice doesn't count for anything. I'm rambling now, but I'm passionate about what I study and am pissed that I can't get more positive responses from IT firms.

by blackdog

Knowledge is tested by exams but there is now test to complete to determain the level of experience, that should be addressed. By completing practical exams aswell as book knowledge experience could be added

by spettit

Attitudes like yours are a big part of what's wrong with this industry. Face it your a wannabee. But not bad enough to conform to what is rapidly becoming an occupational standard. Do enough to get by. That's the motto of guys like you. If I got a dime for all the times I ran across a non certifieds inability to take advantage of the true functionality of todays technology simply because he was unaware... well, I'd take a nice vacation. But because you and guys like you are so entrenched in your lack of professionalism there will always be the "I wanna get rich quick" freaks out there bangin down our doors because what do you have that they don't except exp. which if your honest with yourself is limited to your "do enough to get by" disposition.

by grillmaster93

Im A+ certified also,six months of interviewing,nothing yet.They always say they want someone with experience.This certificate is supposed to be equivalent to six months experience.I'm 47 changing careers , so it might be a double whammy!I am now working on my NET+ certificate,but im wondering if this will do any good.I'm thinking age discrimination?

by dwilcox22

My best advise is to go to you local computer store whether it is Best Buy or locally owed. Most likely they can use the help. You may or may not have done this.

by bub59

I have been in the computer repair field for years.I just recieved my A+ cert and am now working on my N+. I have not found anyone that is willing to let me work or watch someone else work on networks at all.their fine with me doing my job(i.e. computer tech) but I am not allowed to even take my own time to watch a networker do there job.

So I am doing the N+ curriculum on my own, hoping that someone will hire me just on the N+ cert. It's a terrible way to get experience but it,s the best wecan do sometimes.

by teburlew

I not only agree with your sentiment, but applaud you and your family for your diligance and hard work. Not all companies or hiring managers are like the one beginning this sub-thread. In order to find a company willing to take you on, you may have to move (at their expense), but it will probably be worth it. Also, I have suggested before, look at positions in the public sector (government) and/or non-profit or not-for-profit companies. Another good place to "prove yourself" is with a venture startup pre-IPO company. In order to find these takes lots of hours on-line and in obscure job sites, but the organizations who help individuals like yourself are out there and actually appreciate someone with your desire. Good luck. /TEB

by mgtaylor

I have worked in the IT field for over 10 years. I see the cert-flyers come and go. At a blink anyone can memorize a few items that are essential to passing these tests. They don't teach mcgyver tactics in boot camps and 3 day seminars! Save your money and build a refurbishable test lab for your personal use and learning! An adaptive, quick, non stagnated mind will make a cert-work at all costs- KEEP that job for more than a month with personal experience and obtained knowledge!

by trying...

Thanks for your posting. It is reassuring to some of us. I am following your path. I am somewhat weary of the bitterness I find around here. Shit, after all, it is just bits we are talking about here... In the final analysis, I am glad I am not the grammar teacher of some of our so-called technological elite. I understand fear when I see it.

by clive(maddog)mills

I have 5 years plus exp. in using and abusing comp. and am currently looking to MCSE or MCP+I certification in order to change and hopefully improve my job prospects , going from being a welder and small garage repair shop owner to being an it pro.But I worry about how I will get a job at (40) with no real experiance once I get certified, I find it hard to beleve that once I am certified I will be able too work in IT and earn this big money (30-50 grand) within a couple of years .But I fancya change (from welding ) I want the money ,who dos'nt so I am going to get the certs and have a go

by jigans

I am MCP+I, MCSE, CNA & working in the field of networking..
I have found soman mcses who are a lot far from the basics.. Who doesn't even know the booting process... The don't know the can't access FAT32 from NT...One i found was trying to install two PDCS in one domain!!!!!
Actually microsoft tests are damn easy.. & There question bank is really limited.. & what i have seen is in most of the exams 25-30% questions are common among all test takes... Microsoft should create some clear policyto keep the value of MCSE alive.. Here in india Some non-CTEC people does what .. They gethers questions from 15-20 recent test takers & creats PASSING GURANTEE TEST BACK & CHARGES Rs. 1500/ paper....What i look is now these certifications are loosing values bcoz of poor test management & privacy management...

by oe1962

I have engineer degree and I had 7 years computer and electronic equipment repair experience when first time I came to this country in 1990. People wouldn't hire me I couldn't speak english language very well. Then over the years I have learn the language but people was telling me I didn't have experience in America. How would i get experience if nobody gives me a chance.
After I get A+ and Network+ certified they started to offer me a jobs. What is the catch? Nobody cares about experience. Piece of paper(certificate) talks bull s??? walks.

by fluxit

It appears that you had more hurdles to overcome than experience. The way you get experience is not by walking into the job and getting the experience while being paid for the IT job. Let alone a cert is really meaningless because YOU have no experience. You must have already had a job doing something. Did you work on a computer? Did you help out in any way with the computers or volunteer time in the IT dept? Did you have a computer at home? What computer problems did you solve? These ar the ways you get experience then sell that to an potential employer. A little brown nosing can help launch your IT career. Too many people think like you and its ashame. Perhaps I ought to start my own certification and take your money too. I could be filthy rich!

by Member 21361443

What would you think of a Computer Technicians guild, generally modeled after that of the construction trades? The type of organization I am thinking of would have skill levels similar to Apprentice, Journeyman, Technician, Master, &c, and provide the support structure necessary to help when a technician gets stuck.

I would be thinking that a guild of this type would vouch for the skills of the technicians within it, and could build a market in the community for quality. Plus, the small and medium shops with only one computer guy would have the support of the entire Guild, not just their own brains.

I was also thinking this could provide the real hands-on training that so many certification programs lack, taught by the guild members themselves.

What do you all think? Good idea, bad idea? BTW, I am NOT discussing a union. This would be a Technicians Guild, membership to which entitles you to certain benefits. (Maybe even TechRepublic would want to run this one, eh? But I am thinking more on the lines of local chapters and meeting groups.)

Give me some ideas, or contact me directly, if you want to.

Brian Lusk
brianlusk@netzero.net

by shanghai sam

I think that is a great idea. that would give the industry a means to ensure that technicians would gradually gain experience (Real World) and would have proven skills. I think that a mentoring program would be great too. With programs like this,us young guys could learn some of the tricks and benefits of experience from some of the older guys. I know that some of you have been IT pro's since ENIAC, and they didn't have all these books, and videos, and training & certification options backthen. But, rather than complain that we've got some piece of paper and don't know shit, how about sharing some of that knowledge and experience that you worked so hard to get. Doing so will make our IT community stronger. Besides, all that piece of paper says is that we have the desire and capacity to learn and that we took the time to invest in our future and the company's belief in us, and that we don't know it all (else we wouldn't have spent all that money on training). All I am saying is that we need to share the wisdom and not the wise cracks.

by fluxit

Guilds are for craftsman such as carpenters, electricians, plumbers, aircraft mechanics, etc... Guilds are designed for journeymen who rcv handed down techniques of a trade through OJT. Technology should not be though of as a trade but rather a professional career. Certainly an argument can be made that IT is a trade. But that thinking wrongfully places IT in the pecking order of careers. How many IT people come home at the end of the day greasy or dirty after a days work? Other than cablers none. How many tradesman sit in business meetings helping make decisions that impact the performance of a business? none other than the owner of a trade oriented business. The point is that we need some of the benfits of a Guild but presentation of the IT member should be more professional than trade. Development of IT professionals should be more methodical and target understanding technologies, building skills with tools, and developing situational awareness through a professional organization. Many such organizations already exist such as the AICPA for CPA's and APICS for resource professionals.

by Member 21361443

First off, I appreciate your candor and your response. It is a much needed perspective. I invite you to continue to share your perspective, because if there is anything along these lines that would work, it would have to work for all IT pros and IT newbies.

I actually have found that the bulk of the IT staff (I'm talking technicians, not managers) come home quite filthy from the days labors.

As a Network Administrator, I spend at least as much time under a desk as I do sitting at it. And, in a lot of these environments, under the desk is certainly not clean. Understand, I also sit in the executive board room and make strategic IT decisions with the President (and owner) of the company.

My contention is that the bulk of the real IT pros today learned their trade from their own experience, the help of other technicians/programmers and a lot of hard labor. Formalized training is (generally) the product of the last few years of the IT business. In fact, In 1993 or so, most firms didn't have a "CTO". The computer staff was almost a step-child, a money hole, or a "necessary" cost to the corporation. Only in the last few years has IT changed to being a strategic part of the whole enterprise.

It is my desire to pass the hard-won information gleaned from IT pros around. Now, the Apprentice, Journeyman style approach may not work in the IT fields, but what would?

Brian Lusk
brianlusk@netzero.net

P.S. Please, I invite you to respond. This is the feedback I truly need.

by shamii

Hello
I just want to say that certificates can`t assure that you are really capable of doing some things in that field.Now a days a lot of certifcates are available from brainbench too.Although their question are standard but you can`t trust them and it may be possible that somebody else has helped you while the test which is against the sould of a test and so the certificate will also be fake.Certificates are not trustworthy and an interview should be conducted to assure about the knowledge of a person although if he has a certifiacte.

by studmuffin

If there is doubt as to the credentials, in this case the IT certifications of an applicant, there's one way to find out for sure. Contact the vendor company or organization that is responsible for the certitification program. If the applicant is lying or telling the truth about the certification he or she has, it can be found out with no problem, because I'm sure the organizations that are responsible for certifications have a database of people who have a specific certification, or the company does.

by dwilcox22

What I see the posts are saying is not the issue of experience, but the issue of those who attain a certification that implies they know something, but in reality do not. I'm an IT professional with 19 plus years experience with out a certification.I would hire someone who demonstrates the basic knowledge for what they are hired form with or without a certification. The big thing is to be honest with the prospective employer. I to have had my bad experiences with those "who know". Many new to the IT profession think that certifications are all important. They are not. I would not hire someone with certifcation and no college. I would at least require 2 years of college focusing on computer technology for an entry level position. These aremy mininum requirements. If I hire consultants for a project, they must provide me with documentation that they have succeeded in a similar project before I consider them. --- my 2 cents :-)

by monyhunter

Are you saying there is no need to get a ccna or cna because no one uses it anymore? If this is the case you are a stupid plumber. Do you think that all there is out in the world is NT? I really hope you are not this crazy. Do you know what big powerfull MICROSOFT uses to run MSN and HOTMAIL? They use UNIX servers. Not just one or two but hundreds even thousands. I work at HP and a lady I work with is married to one of the big wigs for microsoft and all he does it build huge data centersfield with UNIX servers. Makes you stop and think that NT is not so great after all.

by larry

how am I to reply to that? Your name says it all. Iam not out for the money. I have a good job and I work with a lot of good people. I don't use UNIX cause we got rid of it but we still use PICK. I have not gone to school to learn PICK because I learned on my own (and do a good job of it)Maybe if you read some of my other posts you'd know that I have said there are others out there besides Microsoft. I just don't need them
P.S. there is no need to be so unkind with calling names

by sheilau

Until recently, I was not certified in anything in my field. However, I had nearly 10 years of experience, and a solid history of customer service and computer industry knowledge. Not only was I lacking certifications, I did not have a college education. Despite that, I was hired on as a consultant to an extremely large company, and am currently in the process of hiring on full time. Although I agree that certifications enhance your resume and should be pursued as a means of furthering youreducation and knowledge , I believe that any company that only sees the paper is obviously not going to get what they pay for - sometimes it IS experience that counts.

by ojamro

I agree with you. I have a two year degree in Computer Science and recently decided to go through the MCSE+I AND A+ Certification. While certification is important, experience plays a major role in your career path. I have extensive experience in sales/management and intend to use my work experience to obtain an "entry level" position in an IT Company. Unfortunately, it seems people in this panel feel they are automatically 'EXPERIENCED' once they receive their paper "certs".

by kbnet

I was once told, you will never become sucessfull if you forget where you came from.. It sounds to me you have forgotten that, what ever position you hold (because you did not tell us) how did you get that position did you come out of the womb with the experience you need to hold your current position or did some who obviously were more man or women then you, give you a chance to succeed. Always remember no matter what degrees you may hold or certifications you may have ultimately inorder to start a career somebody has to believe in you and give you a chance...

by yruhere

I am a complete newbie here, but I really need some helpful input regarding my situation. I am a professional educator and administrator living in Seoul Korea. I have recently resigned my position in order to study Korean at a university and computers on my own. My Korean skills are limited to basic conversation, so academia is out of the question, hence I am unable to study formally here. Without any help or guidance, I have self-educated myself from ground zero to the point where I know most major applications for the Windows platform. I can build a computer without much difficulty... mind you I can't read the manuals 100% so some things I can't do. I can program HTML with ease, CSS with reference materials, read simple Perl, program simple javascript, and modify Visual Basic macros with ease. I used to program shell scripts when I was in high school and university for both the DOS and UNIX platforms. I can easily install Linux. I've successfully installed NT with no difficulty. (I haven't tried 2000 yet, but I expect it would be the same.) I've setup DNS and IP information on a Win98 and Win95 network before. (I had a LOT to take care of in my administration duties.)

I spend virtually all of my free time studying various programs and languages. I can't get into a school for formal study, so doing an MSCE or other certification is not an option at the moment.

If anyone can offer me some constructive advice on what I should be tinkering with and experimenting with, Iwould be very grateful.

by jgruber

Certifications are a great way for young IT professionals to get their foot in the door. I am currently a college student and half of the people I talk to tell me I need some experience and the other half tell me that I need to beef up my resume with all these certifications. So I tried both. I am currently a junior in college (first in my major, 10th in my whole class) and I am already an A+ certified Technician, have my MCSE, I am working on my CNE, and have already started talking Master's level courses to get my MBA. Now that I have all that to throw on my resume when I want to start my career, someone will want to show me the ropes. Don't you think its worth considering some people for a job working for you if they are a fast learner and show desire like mine? They obviously took the time and spent the money to become certified for a reason, not just to pad their resume.

by fluxit

I run a cell that monitors a large WAN for IT Attacks and network status. My staff had marginal technical skill. Mainly they knew Win98 and NT. However, we had firewalls, UNIX, intrusion detection, Network management probes, Data collectors etc... My workforce was almost robotic performing procedures over and over. I was seeing no situational awareness and rcv'd no feedback. So I set out to create my own training program (PERSONNEL QUALIFICATION STANDARD). I established 3 tiers. Foundational knowledge, Skills and tooling Development, and training on situational awareness. The return I got was phenomenal. My staff now is regularly providing feedback and has situational awareness solving problems without my involvement. While my PQS program is guild like I also interjected other training to provide upward mobility for those desiring it. Moreover, I recently canx my membership in 2 professional organizations because they did not provide the requisite value. APICS and the AICPA. to continue...

by jschling

Sounds like your giving them the old military training techniques. They work very good and are able to identify your shortcomings and provide some fire to get your people going. We all get into ruts doing the same old thing day in and day out and take things for granted.

by fluxit

It is true that I was a Naval Officer running maintenance on aircraft. During those years I learned a lot about getting the job done and managing people. TRaining is one of the biggest things in the Navy.

by fluxit

In a letter I wrote to the APICS org I stated that the biggest problem in American business is we are too specialized having CPA's, resource people, and technology people with thier respective blinders. The staff's at all levels need to cross more. But as this relates to IT people desktop support should understand the users job. Administrators should understand business operations and flows. IT managers should understand Operational and financial accounting methods. Senior IT managers should known the social responsibility of business as well as how to best leverage technology. I see the IT professional evolving as the next principal in a business unseating the stronghold accounts have had since the 70's. But to do this the IT professionalmust view himself as much more than a techie tradesman. If not then he'll surcumb to the whims of accountants. This gives me chills. Its erie to think of it. As my experience having had worked in a CPA firm is that accountants lack basic technology skill and understanding as well as the ability to take complex IT concepts and express them in simple business impact terms. They always go for the low $ irrespective of benefit.

by Member 21361443

Yes, you have several good points there. Believe me, I strongly agree that the IT professional on the corporate level is required to be knowledgeable in all these areas to prevent being railroaded by the CPAs.

You mentioned a very successful training program that you implemented in your corporation. This is the type of knowledge that needs to be spread around. Unfortunately, many IT Managers are more manager than IT. You apparently have the IT background and have successfully made a career of managing IT staffs.

My concern is that relying on corporations to spread the knowledge around is not really working. Paid training is either prohibitively expensive for the average person or takes many years to complete, and lacks the real world experience that is really what makes the man.

Visionaries and Techies need to be equally served by the idea. I'm not just talking about technical knowledge, but managerial knowledge, supervisory knowledge, financial knowledge, everything.
So, how can we spread that knowledge around?

Brian Lusk

by fluxit

One thing I learned over the years is how to learn. There are numerous models out there such as benchmarking, nueral nets, knowledge mgt, and complex adaptive mgt (CAM) that model learning. Some are experience driven and others are collobrative. Youneed to discern what works for you and the specific situation you are in. Benchmarking is the most common but limits your knowledge to the same mistakes that others made. It is a single pillar of experience/knowledge. nueral nets are AI and dynamic learning systems that can be adapted to compliment human learning. Knowledge mgt are libraries systems from which knowledge can be drawn. CAM is a network of knowledge pillars from which learning is only acquired once and shared. it amazes me that wein the IT industry are talking like we are tradesmen performing routine task or work from templates like a CPA who has his nose in the GAAP manual. Our systems are polymorphic. There are no two the same. the IT industry should be advanced enough develop dynamic resources. Let's do it. Let's start an IT org that develops strong IT players through leveraged technologies. Do you have Database skils and web skills? This needs to be center on object oriented databases, information exchange requirements (IERs), and knowledge facilities (KFACs).

by bassplayer

I'm employed as a Sr. Web Engineer/Consultant in Silicon Valley (since 1998). My employer is a Microsoft Certified Solution Provider. My credentials: high school diploma and 1.5 semesters in a community college. My salary is in the low six-figures and I still manage to turn down job offers which frequently come in my direction. My demonstrated skills: I'm somewhat organized, I read a lot of books on web development, and somehow I manage to find solutions to customer problems faster than my certified peers. I do plan to get certified when I have time. My point is, don't let the lack of a certificate affect your self-worth and self-esteem. Realize that you probably have other skills that can offset those requirements. Don't be afraid to tella prospective employer what you CAN do; develop your references from the people you've helped, and another thing: DEVELOP YOUR OWN WEB SITE!!! I can't believe how many developers don't have their own sites! This alone will vastly improve your chances of getting a great job. Hey, 5 years ago, I was a stressed-out secretary; don't stand in the way of your own success. Cheers.

by bassplayer

Ask yourself why you're in the IT profession in the first place; and be honest with yourself. Is it because you enjoy the type of work it involves? Do you get excited about programming, setting-up networks, or designing, planning and building web sites? Or, are you just in it for the money and/or prestige? If you're just in it for the money, then, do yourself a favor and lock yourself in a dark room for a week and THINK about what you really want to do for a living. You'll never get beyond mediocre in this profession. The people who really succeed in IT (or anything), do it out of love; and when you love to do something, you do it with a passion; when you do something with a passion, you want to learn more about it -- you eat, sleep and crap technology! Most of the time, that will be all you can think of... it's an OBSESSION!!! If this describes you, then, that first hurdle you encountered about having "no experience" won't be a problem; after all, you're not going to let something small like that stop you from achieving your dream, are you? Ok, here's a tip - build a web site and cultivate the hell out of it; demonstrate everything that you possibly can on it- get creative with the skills that you have, then learn how to make itwork on the web. Keep refining it. Show it to everyone. I don't care if the only job you've ever had was at a burger joint down the street -- if you do your homework and prepare yourself in this manner, the odds are good that somebody will be impressed enough with your site to overlook your lack of experience. As a former headhunter, I've seen this happen more than a few times; what you can do with confidence, and the speed and accuracy in the way you do it can offset what you don't have.

by mfh

I support you. As it is a vicous circle where
it is insisted that you should have experience and no body is ready to hire a person with qualification (university degree or certification) to give him a chance to gain experience.
So if a man is not get hired due to lack of experience then from where companies will get experienced people? Definitely they have to lure people from another organisation by offering lucrative salary & perks.
So some body should come forward to help newly certified people providing practical apprenticeship like CISCO has recently arranged with different companies to provide necessary practical training sfter certification.
I am a new OCP of Oracle trying to migrate from Electrical Engineering to IT Field snd facing this hurdle in addition to my age barrier.
Md. Farid Hasan

by rearviewmirror

People who are "paper" MCSE's or any other cert for that matter are weeded out when it comes to the employment selection process if the IT manager is on top of it, if not, then the new collegues of this paper person are going to let them know they are not at the level they should be for the position.

by cakes77

Good column. If we are very concerned about customer service we must remember to "close the loop". Don't make customers go through the motions of filling out survey forms and then react by either ignoring them or by sending a fake "thanks for responding-sorry,
have a nice day" card.Once in College Park Maryland at a Pizza Hut, I filled a response card out after having to sit at a table for an hour before even getting waited on. I handed it to the on duty manager and while I was leaving I saw him throw it in the trash!

by sheilau

OK - I have read most of all of the postings in this thread (slow day on the phones), and I think that it's something that will never be solved to anyone's satisfaction. On one hand you have the techs with experience but no certicication, and on the other you have the "paper MCSEs". Somewhere in the middle you have all the rest. Each feels that they have something to protect, and each is right. However, a true IT department has the flexibility to cover all the bases. On our help desk team,we have to MSCSEs, several A+ techs, and some who are just starting out in the IT industry. Who does it benefit to say "You can't come in here because you don't have...." Unless I am mistaken (and that happens), this sounds a lot like discrimination, and that's not fair to anyone. When I was first starting out, I had NOTHING - no cert, no college education, no experience. It is only because someone took a chance on me and my abilities that I am where I am today. Over the course of my career, I have picked up both certifications and experience, and feel that I am a better technician for it. I also feel that part of my job as an experienced technician is to assist those who do not have the experience. After all, I'm not going to live forever - if I stand at the door saying you can't come in to anyone who lacks the skills I have, how long before we have no one at all? And that's my soapbox theory for the day!!

by larry

Our forefathers did'nt have tech schools to learn a trade, they were given the skills by their predecessors. Why is it we lost the will to share our knowledge. Is it the money thing? Yes we all need it, but some of us just can't afford $100.00 a test.
I think anyone who has the oppertunity to work with you will get alot.

by j_bonvicini

That is the sad fact about Microsoft MCSE curriculum. Up until Windows 2000, almost anyone who had a general understanding of computers could read the Exam Cram books or the Microsoft Certified Press books and memorize some questions and answers and when it comes time for their MCSE test, all they do is spit out the answer. But then if you ask them why that answer is the correct one, they are totally baffled. I know many co-workers who did this and they had no previous Windows NT experience. Certification should be an add on to existing NT experience to show you are certified to do what you have been doing. The 2000 exams are a lot harder and they wil truly eliminate the so called "paper-MCSE's"... Microsoft has actually hurt their own image as being a techonology leader.

Cisco's CCNA and CCIE and CCMP are much harder than Microsoft's...

jbonvicini@ato.com

by gholt418

I have found that the people with the most problem with people that have certifications are those who do not. I have 3 years of day in and day out experience, I went to training 2 years after work, passed all of the exams first time through. Most people around me who complain about the younger workers with certifications could pass the test if they wanted to. They also make more mistakes and I have to spend more time looking over their work than my admins with certifications. If nothing else certifications prove to me that someone has the self determitaion to accomplish things, not stand around and complain about them.

by jschling

I probably could spend a couple of hours telling you some really good funny stories about MCSE expertise. It's nice to know that Microsoft is killing it's own program with all these people who think they will make a lot of money only because they took a test....

by dwilcox22

One of the problems that I face daily is the lack of knowledge that most users have. My answer has been a users group. I want my users to have the tools to their job. I request time with my users to find out how they getting things done and if thereare changes that need to be made in the process. With all of that said.
I have not seen one mention of the local computer users group. Many cities have these not to mention community colleges and universities.
A lot can be learned there and a lot of information can be given.
If you haven't joined a local users group join on. From these meeting you network you ablities and maybe learn something also. I have.

by fluxit

You are one of the elite, Every Little Information Technologist Envy.Be creative use personal web servers, IIS, or Apache to setup an intranet. Have your staff write 1 pg tech briefs put them online and have the users access them as a library of information. Tell your staff that they have to convey this info to a lay person in simple terms. Make it a challenge. I have such tech briefs and use them to educate people.

by jschling

well if you guys work for the same company you should have helped him out with his problem, regardless if he was certified or not. Let's not let our ego or pride get int he way....remember, just when you think you know everything you realize that you know nothing. I bet you can remember when you needed help, regardless of your problem. Anyways, NT has not been out for 10 years, remember your past and the past of Microsoft.

by duster52

Ok, here's my two cents....

In my opinion the tests for the various certifications simply measure your ability to memorize that companies 'answer' based on their view point of the world. They do not truly evaluate your ability to function as an IT professional in the real world.

That being said, if an individual attains a certification, they have achieved an assumed base line of knowledge. There is a basic level of ability and a basic skill set that they now have to live up to (and maintain).

A certification is important for a couple of reasons: 1) it provides a measurable base skill set and basic level of knowledge; 2) it is a demonstration of the ability to learn; and 3) it is a demonstration of a desire by the individual to improve themselves.

A certification gives a person a 'starting point.' I equate a certified person without experience to a 16 year old who just got his driver's license -- all the potential in the world, but dangerous as h---!

by studmuffin

Just which vendor certs are we talking about?
If you mean A+,CNE,MCSE you may be right. But if you're talking something like CCIE,Sun Solaris or Red Hat Certified Engineer, these are definitely high end certifications. Sure it's great to have experience, but there are employers who won't hired new IT people unless they have a certification, now what?

by ivobrugman

First let me say that is really strange that and MCP+I who has been acting as a trainer for years is not MCSE or MCT (if not). This seems a case of being more catholic than the Pope. Certification counts, in dollars, or dutch guilders in my case (which eventually is needed to pay your morgage, that is the way it is). Second, getting exams is no crime. Everyone has started with zero experience, why must al the (now) experienced people talk like you talk. There is only (if any) one to blame here,Microsoft or Sylvan Prometric. When it is that easy, you can make money with it, why should you not certify. It is stupid not to do it, careerwise. Support centres lose there status if they do not have a certain amount of certified people, same goesfor solution providers and stuff like that. There are really no reasons not to certify, so....

I currently hold mcse+i, MCT, CCNA, MCP2000 and some other stuff. But, i do not pretend I know it all. That is important. I work at UNISYS.

by ky sparky

As of yet I'm not certified and may not ever be. The thing I have been going inside computers since 1987 and consider myself very confident in what I do. So do the people who call me for support. The paper says you passed a test, not that you know what you're doing. The best out there don't have all the answers.