Discussion Locked

Certifications doesn't measure

0 helpful
414 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

414 replies

by mtg289

I agree 100 percent, most jobs won't even look at you if you are not certified. I just passed my A+ and I am studying for an MCP. I really don't know where I am headed for certifications... Do I want to go with Microsoft first or do I want to go with Cisco, but I know that you should not take any certification test without a little hands on experience. Anyone can just memorize it from a book and like someone else in this discussion said you are cheating yourself if you do that. Hands on really helps for learning. I had much more confidence to take my A+ after I built my own computer.

by dwilcox22

Ten years ago I had experience (now 19 years plus) in IT. When I decided that I wanted to move to another job I found that I could not get one with out a college degree. Experience was important, but still I needed that degree.

I went to college and got an Associates Degree in Computer Technology. After I graduated I found a job and was hired with a 50% increase in pay from my previous job.

What I'm saying is this -- What ever makes you marketable, you do.

IT is ever changing and an ITperson must stay in step.

I see that I need to have some certs to stay in step.

by eocfjq

After wading through voluminous messages about the importance of certifications, it seems plain to me that the people that say certifications are unimportant and easy to get, are the people that don't have them. I have 7 Novell and Microsoft certifications that did not come easy. However, that just gave me the basis for getting a job in networking. Experience is very important but brain surgery is not self taught.
There is an old saying,"When you try and succeed, you get accomplishment. When you try and fail, you get experience." I know people with a LOT of experience.

by dwilcox22

After reading the messages, I have seen both sides. Mostly what I see from those with years of experience is that those with certifications are not doing the job that the certs imply they are capable of.
I know that I learn something new with everyproblem. Being able to research and find the answer is what most of use do.
To stay with the changing times I am confident the it experience with certifications is the way to go. Do I have any certs? No. But I am working to that end. It is those are smart that can pass an exam the first time admire. There are those of us who have to study a little harder. I have found the exams to some what difficult. Do they apply to real life situation? Not always.
Personally I would not hire a certified anything without experience except in the entry-level area. It is experience and the ablilty to pass the exams that count. Does that make me a bad manager. No it is to heed the way of caution. I have to deal with mission critical hardware and software.Those with out experience can really cause problems, and have.

by ivobrugman

Many people are experienced in certain areas, often there own network environment. By experience they know there own network en can make things happen, maybe not even knowing why it happens. Last I met a system administrator who works with cisco product for years within the same company. After looking in the the CCNA course material some things, not much, where more clear and some things he did not know and considered them a added value to his knowledge. With certifications you start out with abase knowledge with a good structure, on which you should built. Certifications is nothing more or less than the exams you took in school, any school. One difference maybe, this you can directly use in real life en brings you more money with which you can pay your morgage......

by rbblas

Getting certified is important. It not only guages your knowledge but, provides insite to some of the products we work with. Experience or not any good experienced certified IT professional should disseminate his/her experience. I agree certification is just a piece of paper and not everyone can trouble shoot. That's why people who are in the right position should provide a helping hand to someone hungry to learn.

by ab3_tek

I must admit you have a sound hypothesis. I nor you can be blamed for taking the certification path when, like you stated, our companies would lose there solution provider status and not to mention some sort of credibility. Sure we know our stuff but how can this be proven to a customer before the contract is signed?... Besides as long as they keep giving me raises (another 5 grand for passing my Nortel cert last week) I will keep on certifying. I am a 24-year-old Sr. Network Engineer and make more than my older more experienced colleagues solely because of my certs. That is because it also shows ambition, dedication, and initiative when one pursues something and achieves that something. Ever try telling an interviewing employer that you don't NEED your Degree in Electrical Engineering. "I know the stuff so why would I need a little piece of paper saying I do?" You most certainly will be laughed out of his office because that little piece of paper is important. It shows you had the discipline and perseverance to achieve something and that you can play the game. The certification game!

MCSE, MCP+I, CNA, CCNA, CCDA, NNCSS

by jpenn

Does anyone remember why vendor certifications were started? Because colleges weren't teaching what the IT world needed. We seem to have forgotten that vendor certs are ment to replace/augment that other great certification... college. That's right, college is just a certification source. No experience, just a piece of paper that says you know enough to start at the bottom and gain the experience needed for high level positions. 'Paper' MCSE's are the same as college grads in CS. They know enough to be dangerous. Experience is just being able to look back at alot of mistakes you've learned from. It's being able to say 'been there, done that' to the stupid mistakes others make. People who go back to 'school' to get high level certs are getting a kind of master's degree. I feel that I can look objectively at this because I have no college degree (even with 180+ hours) and MCP (one test, so far). I started in a DP tech position, and now 4.5 years later, my position is high enough that in order to get a promotion I have to become management(eeeeck!) Get the certs, get the degree, but don't think they are a silver bullet to six figures. The certs SAY you are capable, experience SHOWS you are capable.
P.S. maybe starting in government is a good idea. Better starting pay/benefits than corp. and more reachable requirements. Start low, work up.

by ivobrugman

It is not the fault of the certification that you did not benefit from it. Seems you are one of the people who thought having you certification would mean the world. Unix has also enough certifications which will bring you more money. Being certified, as an extra besides experience, will provide extra money, if not, you are doing something very wrong. It seems to me you have more of a problem with Microsoft. What does it matter that you encounter an MCP who can not map a network drive. Does this mean MCP is worth nothing? I will not go in to that. I wish you all the best with Unix, maybe you should choose Red Hat Linux, then you can certify again......

by ivobrugman

Not every certified person is the same. One got his a** kicked with transcenders in two weeks, the other one took it more seriously and really worked to understand and try things. Unfortunatly, you can not tell the difference just by looking....

by fluxit

Most employers who hire only certs are networking houses. I would never work for them. All you do is firefight all the time. Its a no win situation. The money is made over blood.

by tcporet

if you have an A+ Cert you can or should be able to build computers and install an OS so build them and sell them while you are waiting. an apprentice program would be excellent if it were standardized community wide and the training needs to be accepted community wide. with all of the companies looking for qualified personal that if you have any kind of cert you should be able to get your foot in the door somewhere. you may have to re-locate but that is something that you have to be willing todo to find work in the field you have chosen.

by ckaylam

Certification is just the beginning (get basic knowledge about particular system)
Most of the technical problem solutions are not mentioned on the textbook.

For me , to become computer professional. Need both certification and experience

by brandon_ricci

Those who received there certifications with know experience and threw fast tracks that teach you just enough to pass an exam may not measure up. However those who have taken college courses like the 1-yaer Cisco Networking Academy Program do learn quit a bit. I do not recommend fast tracks for those who do not have any experience. I do place a value on certifications. It's up to the interviewer to decide if an applicant has enough knowledge to successfully execute the job he/she is applying for.

by trogershsd

i agree with yah! jerry there are to many mcse out there that are a real danger to there employer,even though both sides of the issue have valid points to consider, i have to conclude that there are to many people out there going for this mcse cert.just for the money,and are unwilling to start at the bottom as well as not haveing a real clear cut tought process on how to achive there goal,personally i think anyone contempateing getting there mcse, should first get there A+ credentials get a job at a entry-level pos. such as front desk help or hardware tech support, spend maybe 6months to a year at it, then slowly move up the food chain,get ther next cert. and some exp. in that certifacation. then on up to the next level, even if that means staying with your employer for a while, in the long run youll not only have the exp. but also the certs, to go with it,but from what i can tell all these so called paper tigers, want is to start at the top and not from the bottom,and from friends of mine in the industry, i have nothing to worry about, because it is one thing to get the job! another to keep it,whitch from what ive been hearing, these so called paper tigers are getting blown out,so even at the age of 47 im not worried,when im done even though it may take a couple of more years ill have not only the certs but the exp. to back it up,all because i decided to start at the bottom and work my way up,nothing is more scarry than to have a so called paper tiger call me up on the phone and cry for help, like the one mcse who could not even get his own personal comp. to boot up after it had crashed, it took me just 20 or so min. to identify and fix his problem and had him up and running again, much to great appreaciation from him.which really made me wonder how well he is doing at his job since he couldnt even figure out how to troubleshoot what is called a no-post/no-video problem

by maduca

I agree that the certs really don't mean much. It's more of a way to ackknowledge yourself so that you will get the chance to show what you know. I have actualy seen ads in the New York Times that specify "experience needed, NOT CERTIFICATIONS". I know many IT managers that will ask you your qualifications and if respond "MCSE" they will say " so, big deal" I figure it this way, there are guys in Major Leauge Baseball that have a batting average of .190, they suck, but they are in the leauge. The better players make up for these guys and thats the way it is. I am actually happy that the 2000 certs are being forced, so that we get rid of the "paper MCSE's" out there.

by teburlew

Congratulations. It is about time that someone started thinking of a solution instead of simply rehashing that this industry is totally screwed up and needs some help.

What you are proposing is similar to what the DPMA and AMA tried to get off the ground ten years ago. The only problem at that time was that there were not enough "masters" to mentor the up and coming techies. As a result, most of the chapters I was a member of degraded themselves to large social clubs of techies.

You have a good idea as long as those of us in IT who care about helping others don't geet greedy. Personally, I love being a mentor, not only to associates at my company, but to any IT professional who asks for help. Something like this might work if monitored by an online organization and NOONE received monitary reward for their participation. /TEB

by teburlew

Your last sentence leads to one of the big problems. It is the person doing the interview and or hiring that can't see the forest through the trees. Many companies look at credentials and the cert as gospel. Unfortunately, these managers don't know if someone with a cert is any better than someone else because the manager can't ask the right questions.

Yes, I don't have my certs yet, but as a Sr. Tech Architect, that doesn't bother me. However, when I interview someone that is certified,I ask a much harder set of questions than I do to someone without a certification simply because that piece of paper claims they have the knowledge.

In the last 5 years I have only hired 3 out of 15 people with certification. The other non-certified candidates won out over certified candidates because at the interview, the certified candidates could not find their way out of a wet paper bag.

Don't get me wrong. I am all for certification and plan to get mine to help my employer keep ourMCSP rating. What I am saying is that if you have the cert, as Tim said in his note, be honest about your knowledge. You go a lot farther that way. /TEB

by teburlew

When certifications started out, that is exactly the way it was. It was a recognition for "A job well done, good and faithfur servant." and proof that you could do the work you were already doing. Then, somehow in the 90's when the Yuppies thoughtIT was the way to go to "make the big bucks", it got all turned around.

Now, too many people expect two things just because they are certified; 1) a job, and 2) lots of money. It doesn't work that way. I know that many bright energetic people without experience but with the cert get hired and do well. They would have done well regardless, but the cert did get them the interview that won them the position. Restated:... interview gets job not cert. Cert only opens door.

Next comes the hype of better money just because you are certified; bull. Companies today look at the bottom line. They have a budget for hiring and for promotions. In both cases, management wants to pay the least to get the most. Just getting the cert can not guarentee more money. It is taken into consideration at your annual review, but even then, if the company is not making EVA targets, don't hold your breath for a big increase.

Looking for big money from the start just because you are certifiec? Again, nice dream. Today too many companies rely on job salary ranges. These are ment to level the playing field when hiring new people. Having a certification cannot guarentee you will get anything more than not having the certification. Having the cert is good for you and many help the company, but they don't have to pay you more because you have it. /TEB

by teburlew

Your first four words are totally correct. Guilds are for craftsmen. I don't know about you, but as a consumate technogeek, I consider what I do as a craft. Yes, it is a professional craft, but a craft none the less. When I am designing a web page or creating a solution to distribute portions of a database using satellite links to connect the users worldwide, I am "crafting" a solution.

I agree with your logic that we are not a trade. But, having a professional guild is a very good idea. Some of us "old timers" love to mentor others to learn some of the tricks and techniques that make us famous to our clients. Like Scotty on Star Treck, many of us are known as meriacle workers. Well, guess what, we weren't born that way, we werementored along to become the wizards we are today.

Wizards, magicians, have guilds. None of them are considered tradespeople. Even though I am a Sr. Technical Architect, DBA, and DBM, with close to 30 years experience, I have never considered myself anything other than a craftsperson. One who crafts programs, or networks, or databases, or web sites. Raise your sites and think of how you and others like yourself can help the next generation of IT professionals come up through the ranks; Ido.

Reverend Thomas E. Burlew, Senior Technical Architect and Consultant.

by teburlew

Your point is well taken. There is definately a need to blend the lines between corporate professional boundries. One area that this has happened is in the area of marketing. The industry is recognizing that the keepers of the corporate gold (knowledge and data) are no longer the Finance and Marketeers, but the IT staff. This is why the shift for DataBase Marketeers is coming into our camp. There is no reason why other traditionally "business school" areas of business won't come here either. Some companies here in Wisconsin send their business executives to IT training and send their IT staff to business school. You stated the reason very well. It is happening, but very slowly.

by fluxit

I too rcv'd handed down skill over the 20 years total I have been in IT and everyone does. The word GUILD implies to many that we are less than professionals. As a craftman's or tradesman tasks are repetitive. He always approaches a his work the same way. You can join copper pipes only one way by sweating with mask and solder. In IT rarely will two people approach the same problem in the same way. Techie's have a set of tools, experience and a unique situation in front of them. They must understand not only the technical apsects of thier design but the business impacts it has. They in essence must be creative businessmen. They must be able to discern one approach from another. I can see your point and I also see that your focus is narrow. You described to me a person who is tasked with a job, enjoys the work and completes it very well. Did you have any regard for why that solution was choosen? Who decided that course of action, an accountant? Were you ever frustrated by a solution that consumed your time to maintain and not one would listen to your better solution? That sounds almost like an assembly man's job you've been in to me. How can IT people advance in the business world when we are always under the thumb of someone else?What we 'craft' is business solutions. Being a in techie guild does not make us much of a business solution provider when resource people and accountants are considered professionals.

The type of training you are alluding to passing down is experience and situational awareness. That can be formally trained. If the IT industry formed a comphrensive professional organization and offered training in accounting, business operations, situational awareness, etc... then we would be propelled into abetter future and seniors as yourself could use leverage the org to 'mentor' others through the training.

by teburlew

I moved this discussion to "To Guild or Not to Guild: Is the Question". There appears to be enough interest here to warrant moving this sub-topic to it's own thread. This way, we can still discuss the original intent of suhreed@bigfoot.com here and the professional organization elsewhere.

/TEB

by brandon_ricci

I believe that if the interviewer is not asking the right questions then he/she is the problem and the person who hired the interviewer did not ask the right questions, or he/she did not receive good training. In this case it seems that crap rolls up hill. It is important to understand if the position available requires many years experience and the company is unwilling to provide training then don?t interview people without the required experience on their resume. In other words if a job requires 10 years of experience don?t interview applicants with none. If job only requires limited experience and a MCSE or CCNA etc. then again only interview applicants with those required skills. Get it? YES and where I am living there are dozens of CCNAs and MCSEs just out of school that have no experience and are getting hired buy companies every day. Those of you with no experience! Don't give up! and don't let these guys get you doun.

by kraeg

Saying that a practical test should be mandatory is fine in theory but what about all the good people who are trying to break in to IT. If they aren't in IT now they won't have the practical knowledge and if they don't have access to a nework for example and can't get an entry level postion without a cert, where do they get the practical experience. Labs on courses are all well and good but how much practise can you get once or twice in a lab. People who want to break in to IT need a way to learn and be tested on the theory. They can then get an entry level position and make their way up by gaining practical experience. I agree totally that anyone who takes a theory exam and then thinks they know it all and expects to get a top position is in a dream world. But most of us understand that the cert is the first step and the best you can expect is an entry level position. the learning starts after the cert not before.

by kraeg

We all agree that someone with only a paper cert and no experience isn't as good as someone with experience. But, as I've said before, it is difficult to get the experience without having an IT job. And, it's difficult to get an IT job without the cert. So there is value in getting a paper cert so long as you only expect to get an entry level position and don't try to bull-shit the employer that you know it all. I am studying for my MCSD now. I don't work in IT but want to. I don't expect to get any position except an entry level one. But I won't even be looked at without a cert. I am trying to gain practical experience. I am doing lab work on the course and have offered my services free to anyone who wants them so long as 1 they realize Iam slow and learning and 2 let me add the project to my resume. I am going to break in to IT and am prepared to work hard for it, I don't expect anything for nothing.

by boonchung

Like or not, its the only way of measuring one's competency.If future developement dictates developement of skills and knowledge, then this issue would not have arisen.

by fluxit

Vendor certifications are not the only way. What other industries use vendor certs? Accounting, Engineering, Attorney's, nursing? NOT! No one but the IT industry uses vendor certs as a means to 'measure?' ability. They arose out of the need to train people to use thier product, to build market recognition, to make money.

The IT industry needs a standard to measure against. Why not measure knowledge, problem solving skill, understanding of the industry tools and conventions. Why not require degrees from accredited schools? Look at how other professions deal with qualifications. Professional Engineer, CPA, passing the bar. When hiring a cost accountant do you seek someone who has a accounting cert? When hiring an mechanical engineer doyou hire someone who passed a few vendor exams for using autocad? Of course not you hire someone you has proven thier artful use of knowledge and skill to solve business problems.

we are thinking all wrong... we need to flush out the seat of the pants guy and focus on those who actually understand the technology.

by hljanzen

I am A+ and MCSE certified and I can't get a job without experience, and I can't get experience without a job, Which leaves me to volunteer for the next 5 or 6 months untill I'm so far in debt that I'll have to take anything that comes along. (Get experience)

by joseacosta

I agree! i teach the MCSE program in a college and when my students get out and take a test after they memorize the stuff .. Put them to work or give them real life tasks they all FAIUL..
This is an educational institution problem worldwide.

by ivobrugman

Jose,

-What are the goals of your course?
-What are the goals of the test? Did they have practise before, if not, what are you testing, how much they can mess up?
-Are the goals of the course and the test the same, why not?
-IF you would give a transcender test on lets say NT server right after administering and core, most of them will not reach 600 points and a lot will be less than 500. Why? this has very little (in this fase of being and IT professional) to do with understanding. Same for your "real-life" test. Very few of us memorize all this stuff, being a teacher you must know how much you forget in a weeks time...They just do not know the stuff, they do not know simple dialog boxes and stuff like that (and not only dialog boxes but RAS, tcp/ip and performance monitor...they forget that to). It depends on the persons intelligence and entrance level what his gain will be at the end of the course. You can not tell me the all memorize the stuff, this is not true, nobody memorizes whole courses.
-Why do they fail, and this is important.
Did you analyse this?

When you start playing tennis, you first take lessons, after that you train......

I have a teaching degree in geography. Never teached geography but used the teaching skills to deliver good quality training on MCSE courses and some backoffice courses. This was my way into IT. At this moment I work at UNISYS in the consultancy practice (Netherlands).

by chike

If you think that microsoft exams are easy
try the SQL 7 Design exam.
I don't Know anybody who thinks it is easy.

by tim leedy

In my opinion, and I stress the word opinion, there is a place for certification as a means of evaluating a person's skills. Certification can be a litmus test for a particular skill set. But, if the certification is used as the sole criteria for employment it's going to cause problems for both the employer and the employee. As joseacosta@teacher.com wrote in a previous post, most people who take the certification tests pass because of memorization. It is the mark of a good Techie to be able to take the knowledge needed to pass the certification and be able to use it to SOLVE real-world problems. That is the one failure of the certifications, they don't reflect the individual's ability to think.

by ivobrugman

hi,

Thinking as you explain is something you can do when you have a certain amount of knowledge. For every problem to be solved you find the knowledge you have and try to connect knowledge parts into a solution. Or based on the knowledge you haveyou try things. When you would have more theoretical knowledge, you might not had to try (and error) but have a solution right away. Not al knowledge can be in your head but it really starts with knowing stuff. If you would look at 10.0.0.2 would you know that it is an IP number? yes, but this purely based on theoretical knowledge, or what do you think. Also, real problems in the world are often simple things, not thought of by people who have a fragmented set of theoretical knowledge, often gained by experience in there little network environment, where they know it all. Outside of this protected environment, experience matters less.

by fluxit

Got a story for you:

?Pa, pa!?, He yelled, ?come quick. Sis and the hired hand are up in the hayloft. She?s got her skirt hiked up and he?s got his overall?s down. If you don?t come quick they?ll pee all over the hay!?

?Son!? the father resounded in a calming tone, ? You certainly got your facts right but you came to the wrong conclusions?

It sounds as though you are attempting to explain the learning process. Learning is a perfectly ordered indeterminate system and often expressed in terms of experience. There is supervised and unsupervised or free will learning. When looking at 10.0.0.2 in a learning process the experiences that you have would be recalled and information such as domain, host table, alias, router tables, etc would come up and your lines of logic would then be appropriately weighed as you explore for new information or knowledge regarding this tid bit of information. The theoretical portion of information is just as important as the practical portion.

You made a great case but your conclusion is all wrong. Experience is most important outside of the sheltered little network. It is what you fall back on to learn more about what is in front of you. The more experienced you are less time you will spendexploring lines of logic that are dead ends. Moreover, it was theory that built the relationships so we knew which lines of logic to explore.

Coincidentally, this learning process I described is the theoretical foundation for Artificial Intelligence and how humans learn as applied to your practical situation. The experience is held in a database which is often referred to as a Matrix. There is a project underway to determine the parameters of this matrix. Torrey Pines Institute has a NueralNet that behaves as a humand mind would.

by tomsal

As someone who has been working in both the tech support and networking field (I wear both hats at my job) for about 5 years now - I'm just now getting my MCSE /MCP+I cert...two tests left TCP/IP and IIS. I think certs are great to supplement experience, but they are horrible if used in PLACE OF experience..this is where the problem lies today. You have people trading questions on braindumps, basically they know answers to memorized questions and not real life scenarios. I'll admit with my experience I've been taking my time - about 6 months to earn my MCSE, but then I carefully read the books cover to cover, do volumes and volumes of practice tests and I quiz myself. I found that NT workstation, server and net essentials was very easy. NTServer/Enterprise was a bit tougher, but nothing major. I'm told TCP/IP is a pain but I'll survive because I WANT TO LEARN..NOT JUST PASS A TEST! So then for us who really bust are backs and apply our trade for real, we must keep the "paper people" in check when they ask us for jobs. I turned away a 21 year old guy last month who inquired about a system engineer position - he had ZERO IT experience, fresh out of a 2 year college and he got his MCSE from a 2 week boot camp...this all sounds goodright? He DID NOT KNOW WHAT THE FUNCTION OF WINS IS!!! He was asking $45,000 TO START! True story.

Well that's my two cent contribution.

Take care everyone.

-Tom

by tomsal

I agree. I'll have open "slots" for Tech Support and possibly a System Engineer come next spring when our company does a major relocation and expansion. I'll give newbies a shot - if they have the attitude that they really WANT to work in this fieldand they show that spark of "Let me show you what I can do". But unfortunately for the System Engineer I'll need a more experienced person with some hands on behind him/her and yes...certified.

by evansj

I agree. Certs are more than paper. Would we say a DEGREE is just paper? Relax learn the trade. And a cert here or there sure won't hurt.

by evansj

I've just complete certification and find people look at you different. Make no mistake, you may get somewhere without one, but one in the bag is worth it. Yeah, it's a pain in the you-know-what, but the industry is moving to choosing those with certs over those without. And, many folks fussing about them don't have them. If you are fussing, and have one, I'm not talking about you.

by m.a.s. matrix

Certification to me is just one more way Microsoft can rip people off. Look what they are doing with NT4.0. Talking about taking off of the MCSE and putting on Win2k. They are trying to force on people only after 1 1/2 of NT4.0 being out. Most of the companies running 4.0 just upgraded to 4.0 and got their admins certified. Now they are trying to get these companies and individules to give them thousands more to get recertified again. I am getting tired of it, school is a waist of time for me if they are not putting 4.0 on the MCSE next year.

by jyip

Those who quote one or two exceptions will not disqualify the statement that certifications certainly measures. In order to at least have some basic understanding of the OS you will be working on, you need to study the OS in depth. The fact is thatmost people will never sit down for hundreds of hours to massage the theory and perform the hands-on, of course, there will be exceptions (but there will be very very few).
Of course, being certified without the necessary work experience is never an expert. The same thing is true for those MCPs who also went in to take another course in order to qualify them to teach. These MCPs (most of them) do not have a complete understanding of the MS Windows NT/2000 OS, but they are teaching people on the subjec(s)
for those potential MCPs/MCSEs. The same applies to CNEs/CNAs or CLAs... But I rather put my confidence on those with the proper certifications on the job that they are doing!

by jmcfall

I feel sorry for the corperations and individuals that are paying out the wazzu for a pice of paper that isn't good after two years anyway. As far as the testing is concerned... they are geared for the no nothings that want to be certafied in something. It would be nice if the tests had something on the BASICS of computing due to the fact of if you don't know basics then you don't know jack! Wouldn't it be nice if people had to pass a DOS test before they could proceed to the next level? That (I'm sure) would stop all the dumb and crippling mistackes made by those "PROS" that got there pice of paper out of a Cracker Jacks box. If anyone wants to take a fun cert. test go to brainbench.com and take there tests... lots of OLD BASICS covered in there!

by ivobrugman

-You mean you do not want to certify every two years.
-companies need certified people to get there status the customer looks at, such as authorized support centre en stuff like that.
Same goes for cisco, being gold partner or whatever means you paid and have a certain amount of certified people, or didn't you know that....
-Certifications pay, proven fact.
-You do not need real dos. You are a bit stuck in the past. An Cisco certified person does not need DOS, if he does it will not be much, or are you referring to only microsoft.......If you kick on DOS, please do, take a lot of DOS tests and look how far you will come with that.
-there are a lot of tests which cover the basic you so desperatly want, A+, network +, stuff like that.
-Brainbench also covers the other tests as well.
-Having a bachelors degree is the same as having certificates on your name. It means the same, you have the ability to learn stuff.
-Certifying is the basis of general knowledge. After that comes experience, or do you think that all experienced people were born that way. If they did not certify, and there ar ofcourse a lot, they learned by making mistakes, including very stupid ones....wouw...that is cool?
-Finally, DOS is a good thing to know but I think you give it far to much credit and value. If you know 95/98 or NT very well, you know the important DOS stuff to, depends on how well you understand these OS's.......

regards,

Ivo Brugman

by fluxit

I agree that the certs value is only about 2 years before the software changes. The followon posting i disagree with that certs and a bachelor are the same. They are not. The premise behind a 4 yr degree is to train your mind in a discipline of thought and develop your mind as a tool. Certs principally teach you how to use a software package and how that package relates to standards. I also disagree with the remark that certs pay, its a proven fact. I have not seen to date any measures or data to support that at all. My own experience is they do not pay.

JMCfall is on target wanting to know the basics. they are important. I'll tell you that I worked on a network that was all NT but the test of my ability was that I could script a complex dos 6.22 batch file loading environment variables and menu options to run a 10 yr old dos program that was a cash cow for the employer. They thought I was a genius because no one else could make it work. In the end I saved the company $24k in support cost and generated an additional revenue of about $100k with the dos program.

This is an important point. While I had these technical skills they were not the focus. Nor was my ego. What was important was that I identify a business solution and effected it through technical means to generate a revenue stream and reduced cost. This is what companies really are looking for. Not techies with thier ego's and certs. They want business solutions and problem solvers.

by trying...

Imagine if, in order to be able to post here, a basic command of the English language was a pre-requisite--we would not have to waste time and bandwidth reading stuff of the caliber of what you just wrote. Yes, I am trying to be a paper MSCE.

by evansj

I have to agree; I took the Oracle 7 DBA cert exam which was pretty stout. I took their computer technician exam which was very stout. I passed the Oracle test (As well I should having worked with the RDBMS for 3 years). The technician was another matter. I also took their Windows 98 exam and passed. The bottom line was my experience saw me through. But how recognized is Brainbench? Oracle's cert is considered the standard so I had to get it as well.

by flowcom

The problems with a lot of "PaperMCP's/MCSE's" are any with no experience. They come out with a chip on thier shoulder and think that the book is the way it is. With some experience they quickly learn that the book is only the starter point. Books cannot teach the way life in an IT enviroment really works. It may expalin browser elections up an down, but will it give the correct senerio that fits your situation if it happens. Porbably not. That is when experience comes into play!

by fluxit

Find a job with the skills you have and politic your way into an IT job. I had a guy from the loading docks do this. He had marginal skill. Asked to help out in IT with a crunch we had. His boss agreed and sent him over for several hours a day. Thenhe stayed over an extra hour a day and did data entry and organized the data for us. all this went on his resume. Today he's working in IT making more than that on the docks.

People got to learn that you do not walk into a career change or new career unless you're 22 yrs old and just completed at least 2 yrs of post primary schooling. You slide into a new job from another position. That is the way it works. I guess too many people just lack the necessary understanding.

Example, my college roommate spent 11 yrs as a engineer at Hughes. Bored with the work and facing potential right sizing, he went back to school in the evenings. At work he request to work in another area of the company, the patent office as a clerk just before they started re-organizing. 2 yrs later he passed the California bar. Found a law firm that does patents, tripled his pay, and now works as he wants.

by zither

and I'll say it again. Certification is like a college degree (or a high school diploma). It's a benchmark. An indicator that you know the theory. That's it. It doesn't mean you are ready to be totally in charge, it doesn't mean you have real-world experience and it's no substitute.

Now, that said, I am sick and tired of hearing the term "Paper MCSE" and I am doubly sick and tired of people ragging on people with certifications. Everyone has to start somewhere. For some it's hands on and for others it's books and theory.

Now, I will admit that there are people out there who are certified and I can't help but wonder how. And there are people out there who seem to think that, upon receipt of those "magic letters" they suddenly becomeUbermen, capable of ANYTHING.

But there are also people out there who are certified and with a little experience could really kick butt. Who simply want something to back up their claims of "I can do this entry level admin job if you give me a chance".

And, finally, there are those (like me) who are still relatively new to the industry and learning more and more each day working on a help desk and doing a lot of self study. Certification is a way to gauge how far they've come.

So, if you don't like the idea of certification, don't get certified. But stop ragging on those of us who do.

by fluxit

Certs are not like a college degree. I have both and know the difference. There is no theory to know with a certification. Moreover, certs are based on your ability to take a series adaptive exams. These exams often have questions that are not real world and to my knowledge never have theory in them. Most target vendor specific things and often advance points the vendors want to make such differences in thier software from others.

A college degree on the otherhand is far more comprehensive teaching theory, problem solving, and provides the student with a set of tools. Communications, mathematical, business methods, etc... The student walks away with a new way of thinking like one would learn a new language.

unfortunately too much emphasis is placed on the cert and not on a degree. Mainly because employers do not want to pay for the dergeed person. AH! does this indicate a lower value placed on the cert? do certs really advance salary or having a degree do that? Why do so many University Presidents remark that they got to put the value back into a college degree? When you have the cert do employers tell you that you are over qual'd? when you do not have the cert do employer tell you they can't pay top dollar? Its all aboutthe employer willingness to pay. not whether you have a cert.

To get the money but kissing is the best remedy. Read 55 secrets to Power networking!

by ivobrugman

Hi,

I have both too and I also think (different way of saying) it is not the same. But do not overestimate collage. Most test you will pass if you just know the theory and memorized stuff. Do not act as if you thought up all new stuff in those years, this you do when doing a thesis. Then you're supposed to really make up something new which is substantial. For instance when studying medicine, do you think you're all that when you finish collage, or finishing lawschool, the study starts when you finish. The basis you have there is not to be compared with some certificate from MS, Novell or Cisco, allthough having done your CCIE should on the other hand not to be compared with MCSE or CNE. Besides, there are not many real adaptive exams at this time. What is real world? Everybody act as if the reallife problems are that big. The big problem in this stage of networking with people who do not know enough is that you have a vast amount of little problems, like a wrong subnet, a static IP with DHCP, subnetting errors, wrong profile path, wrong permissions, etc, relatively simple things.
I worked some time on a 2nd line support (3rd line was microsoft in this case), a lot of problems can be solved by plane knowledge, also a lot by experience, Big problems where often software design errors or network design errors, which ofcourse you normally will nog be able to answer with a fresh MCSE paper, received after a boot camp. ofcourse.

It is rediculous to mention all certifications under the same roof.

payment, mmm, can talk about that to, other time.

by ravencomputer

I agree with your comments wholeheartedly.After working on SAAB and VOLVO products for 20 years I decided to change careers and persue network engineering. Initially I focused on certification and found that path disagreeable. I concluded that the certification exams were a useful way to measure my understanding and were in some ways useful to confidence building. After 5 years of study and field work I finally understand where I fit in this new line of work and it is not the place I thought Iwas going to. The combination of testing and field experience helped me find my own depth.

by adadl

TO WHOMEVER CAN HELP,
I have a B.A in MIS, Marketing, and Business Admin-long story and I'm in my 30's. I currently work as a helpdesk analyst with 5 years experience with the A+ certification and am working on my MCSE
NT 4.0 before the end of the year. I don't have any Networking experience and just recently Passed my Networking essentials EXAM and am studying for the Workstation exam. The question is:
1. If I were to teach at a college which I may get the chance to teach A+, and Networking classes after I get my MCSE NT 4.0 would I be able to go back into the work force as a consultant/helpdesk tier3/Networking even though I may not have that much experience in networks(even after passing the MCSE tests?). Is it possible or a difficult transition from teaching and going back to the workforce and try to get a consulting job? Or maybe doing a little consulting during summers when I won't be teaching would help?
Thanks
Luis

by kilo watt

The military has tied certification, or specialty levels to experience for years. I'd love to see a requirement for MCSE certification to include 3 years experience with the same employer AND completion of CTT! That would add value. Military promotions were tied to meeting the level requirements. IT certs should do the same.

by cpufixerjr

Last year I went into my high schools school-to-work program. Since I'm into computers I decided to go and "shadow" at a computer store. While there I learned all the basics needed to get the A+. When the school year ended I was ready to get my A+. I got it over the summer, and its something I'm proud of. When I started looking for a job though I quickly found out that most employers want you to have graduated. Now i'm a senior and while looking at colleges I found out that because of my a+ I can go to work at the university's tech department.

Even though I don't have much in the field experience, certification has helped me alot. Not only has it gotten me a job lined up during college, but it also boosted my confidence in my abilities. So in my opinion, they are well worth it. The a+ shows that the little experience I got while shadowing was enough to know my stuff.

by christa phillips

The ones complaining about the Certs are the ones that don't have them or have had someone with more Certs than experience step above them in the career line. You have to start somewhere and if I were looking at two prospective employees I would chose the one with Certs because they took the time to study and train for the test. The Certs are very important and ALL ITs know it. If you are so smart and have so much experience, what's the problem with taking a simple test to prove it?

by kilo watt

I'm not saying don't get the certs. Yes they are important, but tie an experience qualifier to it, not just the passing of a test or two. The MOUS AI has stepped toward this by requiring some proof of technical training experience as a requirementin addition to testing.

by tomsal

Don't make a generalization of MCSEs that they are know nothings - I hate when people generalize. What applies to one does NOT apply to another. If you combine my work experience with my experience of just support/building/programming as a personal hobby/past time -- I have about 15 years under my belt and just now got my certs. I certainly do know my job - like the back of my hand.

Sounds like your techs are just of the paper variety, and if your company hired them don't go bashing them fornot knowing their job - they shouldn't of been hired if they were properly reviewed and evaluated.

Who's more the fool? The one who leads the way or the one who follows?

-later

by tomsal

Thanks evilthor@usa.net , I agree with your post. I think its funny how these "I clean up after certified techs and I'm not even certified types" sound like grumpy old men. Like you pointed in your post - if they are such GODS of IT Wisdom, why don't they go get certified - it should be a matter of weeks for them. I guess since I waited for YEARS being in the field until I went for certification this year - I guess now I'm a know nothing because I'm certified...lol

And you know, I'd feel so guilty for getting a 25% raise upon showing that piece of paper...really I do....NOT!

Another thought came to me as well...what the hell are you doing in the IT field if you hate learning? This field is all about constantly updating your skills with change..if you are so against certs - seems like you are stubborn against change...WRONG industry to be in for that attitude!

by jcasserly

I cannot obtain working knowledge until
I am certified. I have learned globs and
more from studing for my certification.

by jcasserly

I cannot obtain working knowledge until
I am certified. I have learned globs and
more from studying for my certification.

by §ilhouette

I have to disagree...

A lot of the top techies in the large corporation I work for are female - in fact a lot of the senior IT management are too, and they are just as ruthless as the males if not more so.

I'm a female techie and I too live and breathe computers but I certainly have never felt any bias from others in this regard.

I started in IT only 3 years ago having spent 19 years in secretarial work. I earn ?46,000+ per year - and without a certificate.

I'm trying NOT having the certificates and being female - its hard learning "in at the deep end" but I'm doing alright thank you.

by greendragon

I applaud you.I am new to the technology feild myself .I have worked mostly manual labor positions in my lifetime.I now hold A+
certification and am stidying the mcse NT track which I just started and must complete before december as they are retiring the tests.I hold my ability as a professional in high regard .I am serious about my vocation and I am always trying to better myself .I pray that when I am ready to take my place in the technological world that I may find somone as understanding as you.

by bellmark

I am being brutally honest here. I am new to this field with only 1 1/2 years of Win 95/98 experience and also Office 97/2K. I am starting school in October, but I'm looking for a place where I can go to get experience. I live in the Tampa Bay area of FL. What suggestions do you have for me to find someone who will let me in the door to get the hands-on experience that I need?

by fluxit

Assess all your skills and sale the other skills too. also do two things...

1. set up a computer network at home with what ever you can come up with. this is your training lan. tell employers about it.

2. knock on doors. find anyone who will hire you to work on weekends or evenings supporting their two or three computers. to do this: make up a really nice flyer. xerox them off and either mail'em or hand post them. Go to a strip office park or office building where there are just small offices. hand them out. Or get the building address and mail to all the suites. Followup by calling or having face time with every office there. Ask to speak with the Owner or General manager. Say Hi my name is Mr Bell and I am technolcoy professional who is seeking to assist you in your computing and business needs. I run a little side business in which I fix hardware and software issues for a reasonable of $50/hr.

When you get these jobs and you will with a little effort - be sure to get a letter of recommendation of reference from them. They are not interested in your experience only your ability to solve a problem. sell that...

by jimmyc930

I agree 100%!! I am in school right now, taking an NT course, and will go for my certs, (A+, Network+, MCP).. Asap. Now, I have some experience with computers, but how will I get more of the experience that I need (and the Exp. those of you will only accept)to get a job?? I am cooking for a restaurant while in school, because no one will look at me. No Certs..Not enough experience....is what they tell me. So is there something I am missing here??? What do I need to do here??? Show me how and Iwill do it, WHATEVER it is!! By the way....How did those of you whom will ONLY accept experience get YOUR experience???????????

by khan82178

I agree experiance is the key to confidece, but can or should we prevent education with self thought "every one for big money', Who does not want to prosper;The best solution in my opinion is that schools running these displines and making big money be bound by law to give 6 month hands on training or arrange internship and provide certificate to hands on traing; we should persue through techrepulic to authourities to guard the interest of students at private institutions who are charging $9000 Plus and giving no proper hands on training. My survey shows that majority of students or persons working at different jobs doing this course or courses of the type get only jobs on data entry type or to that match on their previous typing speed and these school claim that out of so many students so many got jobs but which, the one they paid $9000.00 plus or just typing. lets not discourage new comers but help them by putting the schools on right path through law

by ssah

Most of the people complaining about certifications dont have them. Employers want people who are dedicated to their field of interest and who have enough initiative to achieve these certifications. Not someone that is stagnant. You know that theindustry is requiring these and you wont work to get them. Whats up with that?

by teburlew

Some of us try to get our certifications out of the way. But, when you lead multiple client projects on a 60 hour week, there is not much time to take the exams. I have cancelled all my exam times this year due to client priorities. I don't complain, just haven't had the time to take them. Cert exams are things one does during down-time between contracts. When you don't have any down-time, you don't have the time to take the exam. Contracts are income, down-time is non-productive, so thatis the perfect time to take the exams.

by tonyaaa2

There is a definate place and call for
Certification, but first we must remold the
corporate mindset. Experience more
often than not should take precedence
over a Certification in todays standards,
however that is far from the case.Check
your local classifieds and you will see
that more often than not a cert is really all
that is required to get in the door infact
quite often a cert with no expreince will
get you a higher starting pay than
experience with no cert.Who would you
rather have digging into your network,
someone who has lived and breathed
TCP/IP for the last 10 years or someone
who has spent the last month at home
memorizing some obscure answers?
Corporate mindset has gone askew to
the side of the paper professor.
Experience is good but a Cert is better or
so it seems to the corporate masses.

A cert should carry some prestiege but
there should be more to it than just
passing a test. The certification process
should involve some predetermined
amount of practical experience or some
length of formal classroom training. After
all would you want a doctor operating on
you if all he did was take the tests and
never actually had seen a patient before?
I think not yet more and more that is what
is happening in the corporate world that
we live in today. I for one find this very
alarming.

Let's not discount the Cert, but rather
let's set standards required to achive one.
Let's put things in perspective. The Cert
sould be something that you work
towards much like a PHD, first you get
your BS (tech schools, specialized
seconday schools, real world underfire
experience) then you continue to expand
your knowledge by going on to aquire
your various certifications.

by teburlew

Good idea, but you need clout to pull it off. Why not start by demanding that the idiots who do the interviewing have some smarts? In my company, every new candidate, certified or not must pass three technical interviews and two management interview before we consider making an offer or not. At least one of these technical interviews must be with with an architect or practice lead. As a senior architect, I usually do one of the interviews. I expect everyone we hire to answer 30 to 100 questions based on information on their resume. Then we do a hands-on test and an in-the-lab practicum. When we finish, we know if the candidate can perform or not. On average, a good set of interviews can be done over three days.

Back to answeringyou; if corporations would wise up, we wouldn't need to change their mindset. We only need to make them find their minds in the first place.
/TEB

by donq

To my way of thinking everything the programmer writes code to manage SHOULD be clearly understood BEFORE learning a programming language. It's central to his/her understanding just as the alphabet is central to my point. Until Programming Language and/or Application Certifications DEMAND the individual being tested (for a MCSD) clearly understands electronic Data Modeling (and/or Database Normalization) he/she will continue to provide fragmented applications that flood the industry. Regretfully we think we are so smart we forgot to learn the basics BEFORE entering the electronic data storage (and manadement) arena. - Don Quigg

by kaufman919

I'm new to the IT field, but I would have to agree with what you said. Most people I hear that want to get a Microsoft, want to get it because they think it will give them more money. I don't think a lot of people realize that it's not a degree.

by hacbmis

I think the only true test of knowledge at a interview is a hands on test. Given a situation and solve it. A broken network or software problem etc..., then evaluate and hire or not.

by whombo

Having been in the 'industry' for 17 years, many serving as a hands-on technical manager, I've seen many changes in the valuation of certifications.

In the early/mid 1990's most consultants and IT workers who had certifications in their respective fields of expertise were highly desired. They had true hands-on implementation and multiple environment experienced skills. The biggest difference between then and now is simple: there was not the same type of information resources available to people back then without major financial impact. In those days, one could not pay $100 and get comprehensive study guides as in today. A single topic would typically be from 500-several thousand dollars, often becoming a $8000 solution for self-study. In addition, sample tests compiled from hundreds if not thousands of previous tests were not available for one to study up on as they are today.

Boot camps started popping up after the demand for more certified professionals exceeded the supply, thus churning out more certified professionals in a shorter time frame. (3-6 months as opposed to the average 6-18 months).

Since the emergence of ongoing, newer technology the supply/demand issue posed an even bigger problem, it was too difficult to certify people without actual on-hands experience because many companies had yet to implement such costly technologies... So, in a nutshell, the guides got easier and the tests became more generic.

I for one, would never undermind or put down anyone who has acquired any such certifications (even if it's Home Ec 101), but I do have very little respect for those who acquire such certification and act out their God-like tendancies because they're "certified". No certification will ever pass hands-on experience.

Certifiably yours,
-BJ

by tigre_269

I agree with BJ. I've only been in the business for about 6 years, but I have met many certified individuals who had absolutely no clue what they were doing. I'm an MCSE, CNA with experience, and I'm always researching and studying to learn more and increase my knowledge. Those certifications just gave me a basic foundation of that particular O.S. No dis-credit to any certification, but with out any underlying knowledge and experience, a certification alone doesn't mean much.

by helper

I agree with a few of you that a cert. is a fine thing to have, but it is no substitute for experience. Also a cert. in no place to start your IT carrier.
To start your it carrier you need to get an education i.e. A bachelor?s degree in computing science would be a good start. The cert. process was fist put in place to certify people in the field on a certain product. I as an IT manager would not hire anyone who does not have a post secondary degree related to computers, or experience.
The people creating these certificate programs should wake up to the fact that there should be pre requisites to getting certified. For example a university degree or 5 years experience in IT. So we as IT professionals should demand that there be a new classification such as Master MCSE or Master CNE and set some very rigorous requirements to enter the program. (Note to Microsoft, Stop changing the requirements for every new product that comes along you already make enough money on the software you don?t need to nickel and dime your IT professionals on every new certification) This will put a value on having the new certificate and help identify all of the paper MCSE people out there. Thus if you are new to the IT world and have an MCSE with no experience or no degree you would not be eligible for the certification. This would allow the employer to view your MCSE and know up front that you will need to be trained and closely supervised in your day to day operations until you get your experience and qualify to write the Master MCSE. Where as a Master MCSE would have already proven to the IT community and employers that they have the right stuff and can tackle any problem thrown at them.

Thanks for reading my opinion

by blair.mcfarlain

I have seen too often where an MCSE certified applicant (albeit competent and able) get a job and a more experienced (and more able) applicant gets turned down because he / she doesn't have that paper.

I personally know people who are MCSE and only have half the experience of others who are more qualifed but don't have the MCSE (or other certification) I see too many ads for cram courses or overnight courses that have you memorize a core set of questions / answers and allow you to pass in amore generic sense.

I think that the tests should be more detailed, and not written by trainers but rather by professionals in the field with real world questions that actually gauge your level of intelligence in that field.

An MCSE will get your foot in the door and get you a big salary right away, but if you don't (or rather can't) cut the mustard, you will be gone soon enough, and that will be a bad mark on you.

by rocbike4

I have worked in the health care field for 20 years on the clinical-patient side of the business. Other than being a manager, which doesn't interest me, I have reached the ceiling as far as earning certifications and promotions are concerned. I havea BS in Health Care Services Administration, and will be taking the A+ cert test this month in order to get in the hospital's IS department as a computer support tech. The job description only requires a high school education with one year's experience in the IS field. After getting my foot in the door with the A+ cert., I will be working toward
my CNA since the hospital I work for is currently using a NOVELL LAN. My point is I wouldn't even be considered for a position in IS if I didn't havesomething to show for it besides experience. I am sure this point of view is quite common for those people who are changing careers. Experience is great for those who have it, but for those who don't, certifications show we have the ability and interest to get ahead and be profitable for the company we want to work for.

by rzan

I agree with you to some extent. I have been in that situation and now see many of my friends in that same pool of rejected inexperienced people. Most IT jobs, or any job for that fact, are obtained through having the right connections. I'm not saying that certification isn't important, I'm CNE, MCP myself, but having a piece of paper without anything to show for it won't get you past the technical recruiter's desk. The biggest problem with newbies recently certified is that they automatically assume they can ask for six figure salaries from employers who aren't as stupid they think. Nobody will give you a six figure salary, even if you 100 certs, if you can't demonstrate proficiency in your field. You have to start off with a low salary and work your way up...just get your foot in the door for now. If settling for a low salary is what gets you in, then do it and stop being conceited. Even if getting experience means working for no money doing small network installs for friendsand associates, DO IT..it only add to your experience. I know many people changing careers into IT for the money. If all you are concerned about is making money in this field, then I suggest you STOP now and find another line of work. IT Bounty hunters don't last long as soon as the industry shifts towards a new direction. You have to put a lot of time and dedication into this field if you are going to make it a promising career.

by archibald

I don't have a problem with newbies. I have a problem with newbies jump into the pool and can't swim. They create problems where there are no second chances and endanger data.

by brittreynolds

Nice attitude Brandon. I completely agree that for the inexperienced, obtaining certification is a completely viable approach to beginning a career that will blossom once experience is gained on top of certification. I think there are alot of oldschoolers out there that have practical experience but are intimidated by folks that take the steps to document their knowledge. They would benefit by welcoming people like you on board.

by capn mac

I work in a training center and I always mention to my students studying a certification track that the cert is only the beginning... nothing can replace actual experience. But in today's market, you can't seem to get real experience without first having a piece of paper that says your certified...

As for how hard the cert tests are... Microsoft is raising the bar for the Windows 2000 certifications, both for the candidates and the instructors that want to teach the candidates...

Someone with a cert in Win 2000 will have worked hard for it.

by capn mac

I work in a training center and I always mention to my students studying a certification track that the cert is only the beginning... nothing can replace actual experience. But in today's market, you can't seem to get real experience without first having a piece of paper that says your certified...

As for how hard the cert tests are... Microsoft is raising the bar for the Windows 2000 certifications, both for the candidates and the instructors that want to teach the candidates...

Someone with a cert in Win 2000 will have worked hard for it.

by coyotech

I like that idea. I'm kind of a journeyman level network tech. I've explained alot of things to beginners and asked alot of questions of more experienced people. Sometimes I've gotten alot of help, more often not much. Speaking in general, why not help a less experienced person out? If you don't, they find the answer somewhere else and keep learning, and you're left with a petty attitude that everyone can see, and no advantage! I like the guild idea. Not everyone is able and willing to do this kind of work. Those of us who are ought to work together and be willing to help each other out in a reasonable way. One generation of good teachers brings along another generation of good teachers, and everyone benefits from greater knowledge and better colleagues. If your only advantage is someone else's ignorance, you don't have much to recommend you.

by jmudavid

Pardon me if I toot my own horn, but I am a graduating senior this year. CIS major, Honors student, 3.9 GPA in my major, 3.4 cum. The problem is this, I am getting looked over by many of the big IT firms and can't figure it out. They are taking people that don't do nearly as well as I do understanding the material. I have some experience and I have the grades, yet many companies don't seem interested. I am wondering if some of you hiring managers have any suggestions. What do you all wantin us new graduates. I work very well under pressure and I learn quickly while I am working on projects. What more can you all want? Can anybody throw me a bone here? Sorry, had to vent a little, I work my butt off to get good grades and get experience, yet sometimes it seems to get me nowhere. I realize sometimes that is a fact of life, but I figured I would just ask and see if there was something I was missing. Thanks, and sorry if I was rambling. Pardon me if I toot my own horn, but Iam a graduating senior this year. CIS major, Honors student, 3.9 GPA in my major, 3.4 cum. The problem is this, I am getting looked over by many of the big IT firms and can't figure it out. They are taking people that don't do nearly as well as Ido understanding the material. I have some experience and I have the grades, yet many companies don't seem interested. I am wondering if some of you hiring managers have any suggestions. What do you all want in us new graduates. I work very wellunder pressure and I learn quickly while I am working on projects. What more can you all want? Can anybody throw me a bone here? Sorry, had to vent a little, I work my butt off to get good grades and get experience, yet sometimes it seems to get me nowhere. I realize sometimes that is a fact of life, but I figured I would just ask and see if there was something I was missing. Thanks, and sorry if I was rambling.

by jjervell

Take a look at the Cisco certifications. Here is a certification track that has something to it. First, the CCNA requires a higher score to pass and to become a certified trainer one has to score in a certain percentile in the four exams on the CCNP. And do we need to even discuss the CCIE written and Lab, which on the average only 4% pass the Lab the first time.
So yeah, some certifications count and others count only if they are coupled with verifiable experience.

by ellegua

I am a MCP, working towards my MCSE in Win2K. I am working a help desk in a company that's prepping me to become a network administrator with different tasks revolving around security and building and setting up web servers.

Although I've seenthe infamous "paper" MCSE's I remember when I first begin the route to certification. Knowing that I would have to know my stuff and not depend on the acronym tacked on to the end of my name was the only thing that saved me. This, if not already realized by those guys who already have that almighty burnable piece of paper, will be the only thing to save those who know, and enjoy the challenge of walking the walk and talking the talk.

The only persons who should envy the paper MCSE are other paper pursuers who believe media hype and don't want to know, except through trial and error, that you can't set up Win NT Server on a stand-alone.

by mohammad_amer

I'm an Oracle DBA from Egypt,after working in It field for more than 8 years now,only experience matters here in Egypt,they don't look for certifications or any qualifications,only how much projects you have been through.Here they are still so classic,even in their interviews.

by pjs_2000

I personally feel that unless qualifications address real problems similar to those found in the work-place which can be varied from a simple printer problem to full Network failure they will become meaningless and soon. Yes they should be updated each year to reflect the changes in the IT industry but they should also tackle the grass roots of IT, from understanding the components that form together to build a P.C. through to understanding the theories behind Networking and how implementing ITcan improve as well as the problems a company can face.

by aidapcqn

I've been in a computer environment/support for the last 10 years.. and have yet pursued a certification.. of course I've been with the same company for 12 years.. and been thru several system migration/conversion... Worked from straight dos environment to Novell then NT... Now getting into Firewall, routers... but somehow it doesn't feel like 100% career unless there's that "piece of paper" certification... or is it just a mind set that of feeling left out from all these young generations with all sort of certifications... and not quite sure how employer base their candidate for an IT position... is it more towards experience .. or experience + certification???

by iak

I bet you were not expecting a reply from Australia.
I don't know where in the world you are, but I guess probably the US.
I am writing to you to see if a PICK forum, or discussion list can be organized within TechRepublic. Like a place where people can ask PICK questions and get answers from peers.
I am also very keen on PICK as it has been used by us for more than 15 years now and its reliable, easy to use and a natural when it comes to feeding HTML, XML, etc with data.
However, we're also using, UNIX and we have integrated the two platforms well.

Good luck with whatever you do

by g_zollar

While I have many "skills" polishing one or more (closely related) as an Apprentice (with pay?) would be great.
Database and programming.
Tech Writing and whatever and so on.
Would trade with a feldgling trainer with Web skills my experience for thiers.
If you are cross skilled as I you have to be a "rookie" in one or more.

by ghlbeyerlein

One of my colleagues at the ill-fated CLC had his students take Brainbench's Novell certification. He felt very strongly towards the validity of brainbench.

I've taken some of their tests (MS Office exams) and found them to be challenging enoughto make me think and ponder. Being a former Word instructor, that suprised me a bit.

My current system admin has taken some of their exams as well. We both think that it is a good tool, and you can't beat the price of their on-line tests (99%of them are free). $8 for a paper-cert, not too shabby.

Does it replace experience? No. Will it replace the A+, Net+, MCP, MCSE exams? Probably not, but as stated before, it offers a great place, at a great price, to take exams of a similar (if not more difficult) calliber.

by zamski

You aren't kidding about the tests being challenging. I really sweated when I took mine without preparing properly. Despite the fact that these tests are open book (if you choose), the small amount of time alloted to answering tough questions makes that fact almost moot. The only thing I do not like about these tests is that some of the questions are not significant in the sense that they do not test conceptual knowledge but instead test specific facts that anyone can easily look up.

by mwc

I got my CNE in 1994. I had a home network and no technical experience. I didn't know squat then and neither do you until you've been in the filed for years (and survived I might add- I know many paper MCSEs and paper CNEs who had to quite within weeks in a real job!). Luckily I did get a job where I was able to use my head and learn on my feet. Then I went to an integration firm for 4 years and got MCSE while there. Now I'm a Director of IT. (I do have a college degree but not in IT) MCSE means absolutely nothing to me when someone trys to tell me about their technical ability. It means nothing. I have friends who never certified in anything and they are wizards with this stuff.

by ssah

I would not want to work for a company like that. It is all about you. Most reputable organizations provide training, some even up to six months. An employee is an investment. I started in this field by getting my MCSE and then finding a job. Inow have a few years of experience and if I left my job now they would be hurting. The qualities they invested in were my dedication, quickness to learn, dependability, and the ability to complete the tasks that were before me. You can hear the attitude in many of the so called "experienced" that are against hiring the "newbie". You do not know everything, I am positive there are a few things that even I can teach you. Especially, some english.

by robertcohen

As part of the course, your pass mark should have several paratical exercises completed in the classroom.

This will assess the contribution of the person and the his or hers comprehension.

Also just like all Compaq Courses, if you fail in thispart, you cannot sit the exam. The exam also should be taken straight away while it is fresh in one head, not six weeks later when MS or Novell decide to change the goalposts. (See my discussion under CERTIFICATION ARGUMENTS for more.)

Hopefully this will filter out the trash and only let the quality suceed, furthermore BootCamps (NOVELL BrainShare) should be encouraged and should count towards certification. If you can pratically proove to the examiner you are a sucess you will be PASS.Keeping quiet, messing about and don't participate is FAIL.

TIME to do away with Computer Adaptec test, and back to the traditional pen and paper test + praticals and orals. Then the level and quality will raise once again!

Robert Cohen.ASE (Netware), CNE, CNA
robertcohen@bigfoot.con