I have been installing wireless routers for some time, since the word is out to "AVERAGE JOE" that
every 12 year old is scanning hundreds of computers
24 hours a day to see who is open on the web. It used to be nothing short of ridiculous for Ma and Pa to purchase a firewall router and try to read the manuals and go online to read the FAQs for HELP and
SUPPORT, and now, with wireless, the situation is worse. There are thousands upon thousands of wireless routers out there, and judging by the huge array on the store shelves, the trend will mushroom - no one wants ethernet cables snaking all over the place...
Here is my earlier email to DLINK, who supplies thousands of stores with their wireless equipment,
and the email, although about the wire ethernet,
is completely applicable...
I helped one person who put in a DLINK, and then,
after weeks of frustration, ripped it out, put back a wireless. I can't imagine how many customers are lost by the manufacturer's stupidity.
EMAIL to DLINK:
_______________________________________________
After carefully reading thru the CD MANUAL on the
DI-604, it occured to me that the technical writer
has his head up his fatty acids.
The "END USER" of the typical DLINK router is
a family, with 2.4 kids, 3.1 cars, and 2.7
computers on cable or ADSL High-Speed....
All the way thru your "Helpful" manual, you
list things like:
RN&t*d Settings :
" If you WANT your TCMP246 turned on, you MUST
make sure that the 9J4H*#G settings is
set to your ICMP56HtR request number."
How the hell does Mom and Pop Joe computer user know if they
" WANT " the TCMP246 turned on?
Telling them that the TCMP246 is a subnet request
modifier delimiting protocol packet enhancement filter
with subnet gateway filters to accept or prevent
IRT46IEEE router pings, only makes the stupidity of
your so called " HELP " read me's in the manual even more
cryptic.
Ma and Pa have 3 computers.
They want administrative control on their main computer.
They want Billy to connect to your DLINK hub, from
his computer in his room. How do they do this? In Eeengleesh?
They want Salley to connect to your DLINK router, from
her computer in her room. How do they do this? In Eeengleesh?
They want to block all outside access, including PING requests
from getting into their system.
They want to know IMMEDIATELY, how to put in the longest,
most secure PASSWORDS possible, to prevent anyone,
(like Billy's computer hacker friends) on the inside
of the network, or outside on the web, from getting
into their home computer system. How do they do this? In Eeenglish?
Pleeeeze?
If you are trying to show off how technically advanced you are to your
collegues in the Communications business, you are doing a fine job.
If you believe for even a moment that your so called "MANUAL ",
is helping John Q. Public, you are so full of yourself, that
you are blinded by your own arrogance.
A good example of your clearly arrogant, self-serving,
missleading, even fraudulent behaviour is your coverage of one
of the most important topics in the entire process - that of
changing the stupid DEFAULT PASSWORDS.
There is a general principal of JUSTICE used in the United States
of America :
truth is definded as:
The truth, the whole truth, and nothing BUT the truth.
Your coverage of PASSWORDS, fails on 2 out of 3 counts of
this definition. You do not " LIE " per se, you just
just do NOT tell the whole truth, avoiding details of the correct
parameters of the legal passwords, like they were the plague,
and showing PASSWORDS which are SOMETHING BESIDES THE TRUTH,
clearly demonstrating to the users, excellent, 31 character
password fields, which, if the user types in, YOUR SOFTWARE
ACCEPTS, in fact, not only does your software allow 31 bit
entries, IT ASKS THE USER TO CONFIRM a second time !!!
While your LEGAL department may point out that this deception
is " NOT A LIE ", in ordinary English, this is fraudulent,
deceptive, false advertising, and you clearly show a level of security
in password length that you have no intention of supporting.
I will be watching your advertising, your website manuals,
and your installation CD's in the near future, for clear
changes in this fraudulent practise. ...
I have installed a few of these units over the years, but
until now, never analysed the stupidities of your INSTRUCTIONS,
READ-ME's, Manuals, DIAGRAMS, and Examples...
In the past, helping other people set up your typical
"HOME USER" D LINK routers, I always used simple, easy
to remember passwords, which I asked the " HOME USER" to
choose, and being short, and simple, they accidentally
fit the stupid, narrow parameter, short requirements
of your " UNDISCLOSED", " UNMENTIONED", " UNDOCUMENTED",
" CLEARLY AVOIDED REFERENCE ", programming.
However, since every 12 year old in the country has access
to clear instructions on the web on how to set up snoop programs
to monitor thousands on on-line users, and clear instructions
on how to break simple passwords, I MYSELF followed your
clearly documented, clearly printed, 31 field length password
examples, and after re-entering them, was locked out of my
own DLINK unit, forcing me to reset the damned thing
and re- initializing the hardware and software repeatedly,
until I realized that your Clearly printed Examples were
a LIE. False Advertising. False Security.
CONCLUSION:
You are NOT giving any instructions at all to the many thousands
of " HOME USERS" on how to set up the router and Firewall,
connect Billy's and Salley's computer, and change passwords and
settings IMMEDIATELY, to give the highest level of security,
which they falsely believe that they are getting...
In fact, the DEFAULT settings of the unit, as shipped are a total
JOKE, with wide open options and passwords that any 12 year
old can defeat. Emphasis in the manuals on the ABSOLUTE NEED
to IMMEDIATELY change default settings and passwords, is totally
missing, and obsucured with mumbo-jumbo technicaleeze, which
is as clear as mud.
Choosing to populate your CD's and Manuals and Examples, and
leaflets, and Demonstrations with TECHNOSPEAK is not against
the law.
It is stupid, and arrogant, and hurts your SALES, but, not illegal.
However, the deliberate AVOIDANCE of password parameters, coupled
with CLEARLY printed examples of 31 digit PASSWORD fields,
which your own software accepts, ( twice), likely IS false
advertising, making the USER believe that 31 digit, high- security
passwords are possible, when in fact, they are not.
I will pass around JPGs of your manuals, your set up wizards, your
CD pages, your online manuals, your instructions, etc. all
regarding PASSWORDS, to see if others agree that this is
fraudulent advertising...
I will be watching the next revision of your software, and your
packaging to see if this FRAUD is corrected.
It would be wonderful as well, to see clear instructions in
English, on how to connect Billy's and Salley's computer to
your equipment. In English.
ROBIN
Dec 16th 2K4
__________________________________________________
Since this email, above, to DLINK, I have analysed
their manuals further, and have discovered the
deliberate use of OBFUSCATED sentence structure to
deliberately confuse users - " If you do not want
the Armt39.Vb3.n not active, then you must not
choose to not allow the ISP/ntr/34%3:49 activity"
SETTINGS : Allow, Dissable
Given the sentence structure, what do you click on? How many users happen to have another computer online beside them, to PING the resulting choice to determine if it is valid? For that matter, how many users would know how to PING what address in the first place. Finally, If someone has 384 computers to look after, and does know how to PING, would they bother to take the time to PING to verify the setting?
Setting the wireless routers is really simple.
Understanding the deliberate obfuscation provided by the Manufacturers is a nightmare. And it is getting worse.
There is not a single person with a mobile wireless unit, that I know of, that does not
get dozens of connections wherever they go. There
is not a single person in a home or SOHO environment that does not pick up neighbouring signals, and the occurances are getting more frequent.
Blame the manufacturers for arrogance, obfuscation, and shipping units with all security OFF, and all PORTS open, - this means that the
users will not phone in, asking "why won't this work", - and therefore a cheap way to decrease costs in SUPPORT, while maintaining an arrogant posture of "ONLY we, know what we are doing"...
ROBIN