Discussion Locked

connecting to unsecured wireless: is it hijacking?

0 helpful
342 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I came in today to my job at CNet Network's Cambridge office, and had to wait in the lobby for a fire alarm to clear.

I pulled out my laptop and decided to see if there were any available networks...turns out there were 10, 3 or 4 of which were not secured. So, I proceded to IM with my colleage Steven upstairs. Before long Steven asked me "so you don't have any qualms about hijacking a wireless connection?"

When I setup a wireless access point, I consciously assume that if I set it to broadcast the SSID and disable security it's tantamount to offering a public service.

However, Steven's question threw me for a loop, because I think he has a point as well...no one gave me permission to connect to the access point. Just because my computer connects automatically doesn't necessarily make it right.

Any thoughts out there on the legalities or general ettiquitte of this?

342 replies

by cactus pete

You were in the lobby... There is a fairly reasonable expectation that any hotspot you found was meant for visiting vendors and clients to use, and it was unlocked fro a reason.

However, you probably could have been able to tell that from the SSID.

You're an adult - you should be able to tell if you're hijacking or not.

Of course, if you're not sure, then you probably are.

And if you really wanted to be a good citizen, you'd let the owner of the device know what's happening - they may have missed one while setting up the wireless network. Something like that isn't just the right thing to do - it's also a great networking tool.

by jdmercha

I agree.

I'm no attorney but I think from a legal standpoint (in the US at least) the frequency spectrum used by wireless networks is an unlicensed public spectrum. Meaniing anyone can broadcast or receive signals on that spectrum as long as such activities do not interfere with other devices nearby. Devices using that spectrum are limited to a maximum signal strength.

by dmouzakis

What if you found an RJ45 plug near your seat in the lobby? What if a patch cord was attached to it? What I want to say is that applying technology is also about responsibility. Everyone who sets up a wireless network must deal with security. For the same reason that you would never install an RJ45 plug outside your company?s building. Let?s face it. We are not living in an ideal world. The moral dilemma in our times is not about using the resources, but about the use of them.

by kobrak1

No one would assume that an RJ45 connection is set up for all to use freely. However, wireless hotspots have been routinely set up for public use.

by wcp83

You were in the lobby so it was probably meant to be, but if it was not then I think its ok because you have an administrator that is not doing his/her job. I would bring it to their attention and let them know. If that was left that wide open then just imagine what their wired network security must be like?????

by lipl1

If you go out and it's waiting for you to use I don't feel it is truly hijacking. To me "hijacking / trespassing" is braking into a secured system and yes you should at least attempt to let the local admin know.

by maxwell edison

.
In my opinion, if there's no law against it, then it's okay. Whether it's nice and/or ethical, however, is another issue. Are you cyber-trespassing? Well, maybe you are, but that doesn't necessarily make it wrong.

If your automobile broke down out in the country, and by taking the most direct route -- across someone's farm -- you were only one mile away from a service station, compared to three miles if you stayed on the roads going around his land, would it be legally trespassing if you took the shortcut? I don't think it would be, unless, of course, there was a no trespassing sign clearly posted. Sure, the land owner could ask you to turn around and leave, but if it's not posted you certainly couldn't get in any trouble for it.

In the case of cyber-trespassing, I might suggest that if such a wireless connection is indeed configured with security measures and such, then that would be the equivalent of a cyber-no-trespassing sign. But if there was no cyber-sign, so to speak, as long as you don't break into his cyber-farm-house, then taking a shortcut across his cyber-land is just that.

On deptrak's suggestion of telling them about their unsecured network, It reminds me of a story I read about a somewhat related incident.

There was a very enterprising network security expert in Houston, Texas who would drive around various business areas looking for unsecured wireless connections. When he found one, he would tap into that company's network and find something that he could show to the business management to illustrate how unsecure their network really was. He would then, of course, offer his services to help them achieve a more secure network. Well, one particular business didn't think too much of his methods, and they called the Harris County Sheriffs Department and asked that the guy be arrested. He was indeed arrested, he had to post bail, and had to appear in court to answer whatever charges were filed against him. However, since he could show that no malice was intended, and that he did not break any existing laws, the charges were dismissed. But he did have to go through the hassle and expense of the arrest and court appearance. (True story. An Internet search could probably reveal the more precise details.)

So I'd say there's really nothing legally wrong with cyber-trespassing. But I might suggest that you remain alert for any cyber-shotguns.

by cactus pete

Of course, all Ned need do to inform them of the unsecured access point is tell htem that he saw it while he was in the lobby on his laptop.

by maxwell edison

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2003/02/24/ethical_wireless_hacker_is_innocent/

I did indeed get some of the "details" wrong, but it did happen, and it did happen in Harris County Texas. But the guy actually accessed the County's network, not a private business. And there was more to the story as well.

I like my version better. I think I'll stick with that one. (That's how urban legends are born, you know.)

And I realize that you were suggesting an innocent "heads-up" to that business. But it just reminded me of the story.

by it_lobo

Trespassing law could apply to wireless access points.

If you think it is wrong, IT IS WRONG.

Technically, a person violates the law against trespassing by knowingly going onto someone else's land without consent.

by maxwell edison

.
In some jurisdictions trespassing is an offense that is covered by a specific criminal code. In other jurisdictions, however, it is not considered a crime because there is no criminal code on the books. Moreover, I believe the circumstances could determine whether or not a transgression took place. For example, there's no way I could have someone arrested for going into my unfenced backyard without my consent. What if I lived on a golf course, for example, and people came into my yard to retrieve their errant golf shots? What if school kids cut across my unfenced yard as a shortcut? I didn't necessarily give the kids or the golfers my permission to do so, but I didn't put up a fence to prevent it either. If I tried to have them arrested for trespassing, I'd probably receive a tongue-lashing for wasting the officer's time.

by techjock

As a hunter I can attest to the fact that it's unwise to hunt on someone's farm without their permission, but that involves potentially removing things from their property (game).

In fact, in every location I've ever hunted or leased land for hunting, if the land isn't posted, you can hunt there. On three seperate hunt leases, we were required to post No Hunting signs so that each sign was visible from it's neighbor.

Putting up a wireless network is really no different. You are using public airwaves, in an unlicensed spectral band, and if you don't post otherwise (ie No SSID Broadcast, MAC Filtering, WEP, etc) then you have opened it to the public, for public use.

If you ever want to claim that the network is/was private, you MUST make some effort to secure it. Even if it's as simple a method as turning off the SSID broadcast. It's my understanding (IANAL) that if you don't protect an asset with at least minimal means, they you cannot claim loss/trespass in a Court of Law. (YMMV)

by dboundscpa

If I leave my doors open while I am away and someone enters my home, I can't have them charged with breaking and entering and probably not even with trespassing since I gave my IMPLIED CONSENT by leaving the door open.

In the same way, an unsecured network, broadcasting its SSID, is like an open door.

It is not trespassing to connect to an available wireless network if you did nothing to access it other than a basic search for available networks. On the contrary, it is negligence on the part of the network administrator to allow the network to be exposed if it shouldn't be.

by smorty71

I think this whole thing gets a little more complicated when you consider where you are in relation to the access point.

For example, Ned was in his company's building. What if the network was from a nearby building. How much responsibility should the network owner have for the range of the network equipment?

I often get irritated that my neighbors in the houses on either side of mine both have wirless networks that are received by my wireless NIC. While I don't access those networks, I would prefer that they keep their networks on their property.

I know that sounds kind of wacky; however, everyone who has responded seems to think Ned was trespassing. Couldn't the same argument be made the other way, too?

by jdmercha

Let's say your neighbors wireless router interferes with your cordless phone. (Which is very possible.) You can file a complaint with the FCC. Your neighbor will then have to take steps to eliminate that interference. (Or be fined.)

by mrafrohead

Responsibility for range...

I know that you can control the output of the AP's... Less output means less broadcast.

In case of business though, I think that that's different than home.

What I would recommend for your home problem with your wonderful neighbors. One of two things.

Change their SSID, or screw with all of the settings... That all depends on how you feel with that type of thing. After all, they are violating your space, IMHO...

OR - Change the channel that your NIC listens to by default, and tighten down what your NIC will listen to (speed settings). Customize it strictly for your home network. That will also help and then you won't be interfering with others rudeness...

To me it doesn't sound wacky at all. I see it as you come through my house and it's mine. And if they catch me on the wrong day, and my network is interefered with by theirs, (and theirs are completely unsecured, i've checked) I may possibly flash their firmware... That would permanently fix the problem... ;p

Mrafrohead

by Member 29327465

I think that the point made earlier, along the lines of "if you think it's wrong, it is wrong", sums up my feeling about this morning. Being technical, I strongly suspect the WAP was inadvertantly setup without security. I knew better.

But imagine this scenario: I (or a less geeky version of me) turn my laptop on, sign in and walk away to get a cup of coffee.

My computer boots up, connects automatically to any available network, and any apps that auto-start, come online (for me, YIM and webshots, as well as probably a bunch of other apps I'm not aware of). Technically my computer has just hijacked an account, without any active knowledge on my part. My less geeky alter ego would just start using the computer and be thankful that the wireless magic works so well.

Second point...what about the many intentionally free hotspots out there? Are users supposed to try to guess about the validity of access point based on the SSID name alone? That's pretty ridiculous.

In summary, I do agree with most people: it was a sketchy thing to do for me...but the state of technology makes an open access point tantamount to an invitation to use it. In fact the way most laptops are setup it's actually more difficult to NOT connect than it is to connect.

by cactus pete

The example you showed where you walk away is allowed for in terms of intent. However, jsut because you're unaware of having violated something doesn't mean it's right.

Of course, you can set your machine up to not automatically connect to any wireless network. That is as equally hard as not allowing any laptop to connect to your network, too.

But no, you shouldn't think of yourself as having committed some heinous crime. Your intent was not malicious. There was certainly a chance that the node was there jsut for that purpose, too.

Out of curiousity, what was the SSID name? What were the others? Did you simply choose the strongest signal, the one on the top of the list... Or did you actually pick one that looked like it was intended for that use?

We, as technology professionals, have a duty to use others' resources in a professional manner. We should not hijack someone else's connection ofr malicious needs.

We also have a duty, some might say, to inform others when they have erred and set up a HUGE security hole [not that you checked that far, I'm sure].

Then, we, as cohabitating citizens of a kind and sensible world, can also understand you didn't really do anything all that bad.

You weren't in Harris County, though, right?

by choppit

If you have concerns about cyber-trespass, why would you allow your laptop to connect to any available network?

by mrafrohead

There's a difference if you find a network in a business district that is open. If you REALLY are curious if you should be on it or not. Check to see if the AP is locked down. If it is, it is safe to assume that it's open for a reason. And more than likely has port blocking enabled and maybe even AV running to control spread of virii.

On the flipside, as you connect to these networks, beware what you do, because you really never know who is watching YOU... ;p

I've left my network wide open before to see who will connect to it. I have 400 Yards of broadcast strength. I intended on watching who did what on my stuff... To my sadness, no one connected, not once... **sniff** **sniff**

by kmhs_sa

If you are to try and notify that the AP is unsecured, how are you supposed to notify who it is.

My wireless LAN has the SSID of SALAD. Given that, how are you supposed to determine it is mine. Then it goes on, if you can access those details, what about someone who wishes to specifically target that network.

by mich-a-billy

It has been my experience that Windows doesn't connect to a SSID that it hasn't incountered before as a default. It only informs the user that a Wireless connection is availiable. After the user allows it to connect, Windows will connect to the SSID every time it sees it.

by mrafrohead

If not, then I would assume it public domain...

If you are given a warning that specifically states, DO NOT CONNECT UNLESS... then you should be fine.

Worse comes to worse, you're connected wirelessly. They can't find you if you don't want them to.

by mrafrohead

No, not so much that it's okay if they don't catch you.

It's okay if they don't secure it...

If someone can't take the time to read the 20 page instruction manual that comes with it, then it's their own fault for their own negligence.

Just to add a little spice to this thread, what I do when I find an open network:

I change the SSID to "secure_your_router". They all lose their connection and then have to go in and figure out what happened. I figure that in doing that, it forces them into the Admin program and once in there, they're mor elikely to change it and secure their stuff... Specially since it's been changed on them once, they don't want it to happen to them. And since it's nothing that hurts anything, I think that in the long run, it helps them. I don't think it's appropriate to do anything malicious with it though...

Running insecure networks is negligent and hte rest of us pay for it. Spammers getting to do what they want, fraud and ID theft. Remember, every stolen credit card, you and I pay for in higher rates and all of that jazz...

Insecure open networks are a bad thing for all of us, and they shouldn't be allowed. Those that run them should get into trouble for doing it, as well as those for "illegally" connecting...

Secure open networks are fine though, as then you're running a community service ;p

mrafrohead

by maxwell edison

.
Not to point fingers at anybody, but for Pete's sake, some people come across as taking the moral high-ground over something as harmless and innocent as accessing a wide-open network connection while sitting in the lobby of an office building. I suppose these are the same people who drive EXACTLY the speed limit in the left lane of the freeway.

If anybody thinks this is wrong, then I suppose they've never recorded a friend's CD so they could listen to it on a road trip. I suppose they've never recorded a television program to view at a later time. I suppose they've never gone even one mile over the speed limit. I suppose they've never sneaked into a private party. (Try it sometime. Especially a wedding party where everyone will assume you're with the "other" side.) I suppose they've never parked on the side of the road to watch the movie at the local drive-in theater. (Okay, I'm old enough to have seen movies at drive-in theaters -- lots of them.) Geesh, if it's not illegal, and if the "no harm no foul" rule can apply, what the heck does it matter?

Besides, who's to say that whoever "owns" that network connection didn't consider this possibility when it was configured, and just didn't care enough about it to make the effort to secure it? sMoRtY made a good point about his neighbor infringing on HIS air space. Yea, and turn down your stereo while you're at it. Besides, I don't want the RIAA to come down on me for listening to your music without a license.

No, Ned was not "hijacking". Heck, to even call it "trespassing" is a real stretch. All he was doing was listening to someone else's music because THEY had the volume turned up high enough for him to hear.

To make anything sinister out of this is like making a mountain out of a molehill. In fact, this isn't even up to a molehill.

by dafe2

One - You forgot to mention seatbelts. Two - Did you REALLY watch the movie at the drive-in?
Three - I still remember getting through in the trunk on a few occasions as I'm sure you do too.

Anyway, there's a big diference between free surfing and malicious intent.

You mentioned putting out access points knowing they were insecure. We do exactly that.(honeypots) It seems to keep the scumbags busy surfing and away from the 'real' thing. LOL

If someone happens upon them (an honest person) & it proves usefull/helpfull to them......well, no harm done.

by maxwell edison

.
Whether or not I watched the movie depended on who I drove into the drive-in with. And being the trunk-guy wasn't that bad, was it? A cold (or maybe hot) beer that we bought illegally in the HUGE trunk of someone's parent's 65' Buick was quite an adventure.

by cactus pete

Did I come across that way?

All I'm trying to convey, I suppose, is yea, shouldn't relly do that sort of thing - but hell, I do it, too.

Maybe it's more wrong when it's intended to be more wrong - but I'm not really willing to draw the line and enforce it.

by gralfus

If the person using the access is not bothering the company/gov't who provided the open link, then they probably don't give a rip that you are on their network. If they do care, then they need to get a real network admin who regularly scans for open portals. Either way, if you aren't messing with their stuff and only going to the internet, then you are probably safe. If they don't know there is on open access point, they probably won't notice your use of it either.

by thechas

Max,

I OFTEN drive in the left lane at or below the posted speed limit.

We have a large number of left lane on and off ramps here.

I have the choice of being a criminal for driving faster than the posted speed, or following the law and making the lawbreakers mad.
Of course, with traffic being as it is, I often end up needing to get into the left lane several miles ahead of my exit since fast traffic will not allow a driver at the speed limit to merge.

The left lane should be for those who wish to travel at the posted speed limit.
The right lane for those who wish to drive slower.

P.S. Yes, I am a reformed speeder. I have trained myself to NOT drive faster than the posted speed limit on nearly every road.

P.P.S. We have a few 2 lane roads around here with speed limits much lower than the average driver wants to follow. I truly love driving just below the posted speed limit with 15 or 20 cars backed up behind me.

My point, if we are a nation of laws, why don't we follow the laws we have?

If everyone choose to follow instead of stretch the laws, we would not have the litigation problems and large corporate legal staffs that we have.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
There's a new law in Colorado that will ticket people who block the "normal flow of traffic" while travelling in the left lane, regardless of the speed limit and/or the speed at which that driver is traveling.

http://www.truckflix.com/news_article.php?newsid=818

http://motortrend.com/features/news/112_news29/

And it really doesn't pay:

http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/3593570/detail.html

My "left lane" comment was not intended to apply to left-lane exits. Of course that would require left-lane driving; that goes without saying. It was intended to apply to those who presume to be the "almighty enforcer", forcing those behind them to drive slower than they desire, or forcing them to pass on the right.

The right lane is for driving at or below the speed limit. The left lane is for passing. Personally, I think that people who, on open Interstate highways, drive in the left lane are not only extremely rude, but are extremely dangerous as well.

You may disagree with Colorado's new law and/or the notion that left-lane driving is for passing. But who was behind it? The Colorado State Patrol.

http://www.9news.com/storyfull.aspx?storyid=22138

You should really consider being a safer driver instead of the enforcer of how you would like other people to live.

by maxwell edison

.
But I'm also a realist, and I know that not all people will obey the speed limit. And if I happened to be in the left lane, and one of them approaches me at a rate of speed higher than what I'm travelling, I'll show a little courtesy, instead of contempt, and move over to let them safely pass.

by montgomery gator

On the Interstate Highways, there are signs that say "Slower Traffic Keep Right", which means that if there is someone coming up behind you going faster, and you can get over to the right lane safely, then you need to get over. Even if you are going at the speed limit, I interpret that to mean you need to get over. People who drive in the left lane and do not let people pass are known as "Left Lane Vigilantes" (Do a Google Search), and create a road hazard by bottling up traffic that otherwise would be flowing freely. The left lane is for faster traffic. The right lane is for those driving slower than the left lane traffic. One thing that really puzzles me is that on highways with 3 lanes, some people use the middle lane as the slow lane instead of the right lane (which is often open), and I find it easier to pass on the right. In this case, the middle lane should be used for traffic faster than right lane traffic, but slower than left lane traffic.

If there is a left lane exit ahead I need to take and I move to the left lane to take it, I speed up to the speed of the traffic flow in the left lane instead of tying up traffic, and use the exit ramp to slow down, not the highway.

by mrafrohead

Chas, I'm sorry to read this...

Hopefully I won't come up on your butt. I have no problems kissing the jerk that wants to go slow in the fast lane...

Some call it road rage. I call it "forcing sensibility".

If you don't want to go with the flow of traffic then you are causing a jam. Move over a lane. It's not too hard. When I feel slow, I chill in the slow lane. Nothing wrong with it.

BUT slow in the fast lane, not cool. It's not fair to make everyone else take there time just because you aren't in a hurry.

As for following the laws. There is a law against blocking the flow of traffic. If the speed limit is 70 and the flow is 78 and you want to go 65, you are breaking the law too... Just something to think about....

Another thing I noticed:
"I truly love driving just below the posted speed limit with 15 or 20 cars backed up behind me."

This is just some advice, I don't mean it threateningly...

I would really think twice about doing that too... I have followed people home for doing that, and run them off of the road. (I have some days that I am a VERY bad person to be around (though not for about 6 months) and if I do it, I'm sure there are others). I'm only telling you this to hopefully prevent you from experiencing a true a$$hole.

by zczc23119

I make reference to a recent article in The Washington Post ? Tec news ? in which it was reveled a small town in North America was the first to grant each and every one of it citizens the right and facility to connect to the whole town wireless network. So far this debate has been centered into a corporate situation and I would like to inform you that now a whole small city town offered this service. I do not want to discuss the right nor wrongs of wireless networking in any sense now as after reading this informed article of late I now realized that the fact that you can connect to a wireless network goes far beyond the scope of a corporate office.

Certainly we enter a Brave New World now this context, with an open mind I am not sure I even want to examine the merits of wireless networking but the fact remains if you do not want it you can always disable the service, although power that be initiate the service by default on a default new installation.

I wish every administrator of a network, whether it be home, corporate or now township a full and long life for their decisions will dictate who can see what and what they can change or connect to and in the respect to Data security and in the current direction taken by PC applications we again examine and revisit a Main Frame/PC client situation where it is deemed necessary to clearly define the role of the user, their access and permissions.

by mrafrohead

Maxwell, I never knew you had it in you!!!

This one caught me totally off guard ;p

I see your comment about smorty, so I guess I will read the rest of this thread to see what was said. I have only read the original post and my side thread, and now your post... So I'm sure I"ll pollute the rest of this shortly.. ;p

But I just had to drop a note about what you said!

I can't believe you've snuck into weddings, I'da never guessed it.

I see it as this. If a network is open, and you attempt to access the admin part and it's locked, then its open on purpose. That's a different story than a AP that is pulled out of hte box and you can type in 192.168.1.1/100 admin and get in...

That just makes my blood boil because you know that smuck is running boxes probably with no AV, common sense, etc.... But at the same time, gives me the ability to download my Kazaa on someone elses dime (and Ip).. ;p So in the long run, maybe they aren't as bad as I think... ;p

wocka wocka

Oh and I'll send you some earplugs so you dont' have to worry about that Pesky RIAA. I'm sure after they hear that you've heard music that you didn't pay for, you'll be getting a bill. Even if you weren't the one that was "playing" the music... you still heard it... ;o)

by choppit

Don't get me wrong, I neither agree nor disagree with this practice. If you can convince yourself something is right, then it must be.....

by maxwell edison

.
Just because something may not be "right", it doesn't necessarily make it "wrong".

I heard a story about a guy who had an old couch that he didn't want. It was in very good condition, but he just didn't want to fool around with selling it. So he put it out on at the end his driveway and placed a sign on it that simply said, "FREE". After a week, the couch was still sitting there. But the guy had, what we might call, a very interesting idea. He removed the "FREE" sign, and replaced it with one that said "$100 - Inquire Within". The next day, the couch was gone.

Since he did this to entice someone to "steal" something of value, rather than drag off something that was worthless, did the new owner of the couch really do something "wrong"? Was it "wrong" in one way, but not "wrong" in another? How could that be? Moreover, could he be prosecuted for it?

Don't you just love those "moral dilemma" type questions?

by dafe2

You could get a LOT of beer & a few bodies in the truck of an Olds Delta '88 too!

And how about driving arround all night on about 5 bucks worth of gas........or two weeks in a Mini Austin LOL

by house

I access certain utilities that are work related from home. If I need to switch the device that I have directly attached to the internet, I clear my own host address (public IP) so that I don't have to wait for the lease to refresh. I don't know if that's right or wrong.

We assign a host address to a device (hardware)... we need to clear the entry in the UBR in order to force the new request immediately. I don't see a problem with that, but I'll ask the admin next time (to cover my butt).

by choppit

Do you think it would therfore be a sensible step for wireless AP manufacturers to default settings to secure with no SSID broadcast (perhaps even a random SSID), then show a warning if these settings are changed?

by maxwell edison

.
Instead of playing, what seems to be, a devils advocate roll, what's your opinion on it? Out of the many messages you've posted in this discussion, it's not clear what you really think.

by choppit

I don't do it, for the same reason I don't plug my appliances into mains outlets in public areas. However, when I travel (not often) and I have time to kill, I sometimes set out to find wireless networks, secure or otherwise. I don't however connect to them. If I find insecure APs, if possible, I'll inform the owners.

by mrafrohead

Personally, if they wanted to really do it right, they would force a user to configure the router BEFORE it would start to operate.

Something simple. On first boot, or reset, they would have to go through a basic config to set an SSID - choose whether or not to broadcast. Choose whether or not they wanted and open or closed network. Give the ability to add a logon advert (something to say whether the network is public or private). Give the ability to encrypt. THEN it should start.

But that would be too easy, and the users might get confused.

WE are ALL effected by dillhole users that pull crap out of the box and run it open. And it should NOT be allowed. If you aren't competant enough to read an instruction manual, then **poof** you should not have the rights to connect your network to the rest of ours.

Mrafrohead

by thechas

As I understand this, you entered a building that you normally work at and accessed wireless networks within the building. Correct?

If so, my first question is what are company policies about network usage?

Next, were these wireless networks set up by IT departments, or users?
If set up by users are they in compliance with company policies?

I see this situation as being a LOT different than other threads on the topic of "war-driving".

I do not condone or agree with the concept of war-driving.
Nor do I agree with people who park near an office building at night and use the wireless LAN for their Internet connection.

You on the other hand were in a business for a legitimate reason.
If you normally connect to the company network with a wireless connection, it is not your fault that you were able to make other connections while in the building.

The only action that I feel you are obligated to take is to inform building security, or the IT department that people have open wireless networks accessible to the public.

Chas

by cactus pete

Perhaps we'll get this clarified for us, but I don't think the building was for only one company. So I suspect the connection was made to a company with offices on the lower floors...

by Member 29327465

sorry for the silence, i have been busy enjoying our blizzard. (2+ feet at my house).

CNet rents one floor of a building with probably 20 other small clients. CNet's policy is quite buttoned down: we definitely don't have open access points, we periodically sweep for unauthorized ones, etc.

However, we are on a high floor and when i tried to connect from the lobby I didn't see ours, but I was connected automatically to this other SSID. Incidentally it wasn't casually obvious which company it belonged to.

(I can hear it now: "excuse me, where is linksys located"?)

As one other followup, I setup a wireless network for my friend this weekend. From her house there were over 5 unsecured networks visible, and one was called 'linksys'. And yes, I did secure her network :>.

This is a case where the equipment manufacterers (heck, isn't it just linksys?) really need to address this by setting up reasonable defaults.

by titssni

Secure vs unsecured
Moral vs immoral
Hijacking vs using
right vs wrong
your ideas vs mine
laws and legislation vs your beliefs

In situations like this one has to ask questions like those and it boils down to,

what do you (i) think is thr right thing to do?

A person setting up a hotspot should know the reason behind doing so an dif they do it and leave it unsecured they should know the consequences for doing so.

It's now up to you as the individual who comes across that unsecured network to decide whether or not you will access it and for what reason. At that point it becomes another issue of now that I have access and is using the service how do I react with it. Do I use it usefully or do I screw around and do some messes up stuff.

Keep in mind that wireless technology was made for that same reason, having access wirelessly from any location within range. If you don't knw how to setup and configure the tool leave it alone.

Another way to look at it.

If I left my house open and the doors open and went for a walk does that tell people i'm giving them access and they can walk in and out as they please?

This comes down to morals and your personal views as well. It also depends on the situation and location you are in.

All these point and issues came across in all the posts but it boils down to you the individual and how you decide on how to proceed when you hit that point.

I have 2 network and I leave one unsecure and secure he other for personal internal use, the unsecured is for anyone who wants to be around the block and need access while outside. his is just because of the area I live in and the people I know in the area. I wouldn't do this for most areas :-).

The Suite

by dafe2

We leave a few 'open' here and there............

It keeps less honest people away from the secure side. From time to time consultants use the connections as well.

Every once in a while it generates a lot of IM's about 'what stupid admin set this up' as they wack away at nothing more than an internet pipe.....fine by me....it seems to keep them busy and amused.

by jdclyde

Do you see someone broadcasting an open signal over public airwaves, out into a public area as the same as walking into their house? If I am in my yard and can detect an open signal, is it really illegal to use that signal?

I would never advocate the use of this to do your downloads or try to "explore" their computers.

Does anyone know if there is actually a law against this?

by mrafrohead

well, where I'm from, and open door, is a legal invitation. Whether you meant it or not.

For example, you knock on my door, I open it to see what you want, you walk in my house. You are legally allowed to be there. Granted I may physically throw you out, but then I am in the wrong, as I commited battery AND you entered legally through my "invitation" of opening the door.

Scary huh???....

by thechas

In Michigan, the rule of the left lane is for passing ONLY applies to road with only 2 lanes in each direction.

If there are 3 or more lanes for your side of the road, you can use whichever lane you desire.
Of course, this results in drivers who weave through traffic continuously. It can be very tricky to judge if the driver behind you is going to allow you to change lanes or swoop around you.

In traffic, from a left lane on-ramp, it can be several miles before I have a safe opening to move to the right while driving at a safe speed. Let alone the speed limit.

I don't mind the concept of ticketing drivers who hog the left lane so long as it is coupled with increased enforcement of both the speed limit and the basic speed law.

On the main North South highway here, it is problematic to use the right lane except just before your exit.
The on-ramps are just too short for anything less than a Viper to reach traffic speed before they need to merge.

If you remember the precision driving teams that frequented county fairs in the 60's, the aggressive drivers around here would be bored by the large safety margins those teams used.

Just as I prefer to set up a PC for stable rather than fastest performance, I choose following the law and making safe maneuvers on the road rather then trying to see just how many cars I can pass.

Chas

by thechas

I find it interesting that the typical response to road rage is to place more restrictions on law abiding motorists.

By making laws that open up the roads for aggressive drivers all we do is embolden them to be much more aggressive.

If we continue down this path, we will end up limiting responsible drivers to off hour travel only. Just so the aggressive drivers can break as many traffic laws as they desire without being inconvenienced by having to follow a driver who has the nerve to drive in a safe and legal manner.

Instead of attempting to control the dangerous aggressive driver, we take the easy path of placing tighter restrictions on those drivers who responsibly obey the traffic laws.

Chas

by mrafrohead

I compare the jerkoff cellphone talking, latte sipping, SUV driving, 58 in a 60 in the left lane punks where I'm from to the great drivers of MI... It makes me feel better to know that in MI there are people who really know how to drive... But you post what you posted and you're throwing me for a loop...

I'm from Michigan BTW... Hence my thoughts...

Whenever I've been in Michigan all I have observed are a normal flow of traffic. Slower users in the middle and right lanes. Faster drivers in the left lane. When someone comes up behind you going faster, the slower driver gets over to let the faster one by and then continues on their way... I think I only saw maybe two or three exceptions to the rule...

Dude, you sound RUDE...

Did you ever think that it's drivers like you that START road rage??? Consider that for a second.

Think of this, you are playing holier than though and telling ME I can't do what I WANT to do. You aren't my boss. It's my risk to drive fast. It's my cat and mouse game with the cops. You have NO say in the matter.

By you driving slow and holding up 15-20 cars, have you ever considered that doing that creates an unsafe driver that just wants to get around the asshole in the front so they can continue on?

The speed limit where I'm at is 60. I usually go 64-65. But if I see a jerk holding up traffic, I will go 90-130 just to get the chance to cut them off and ruin their day as much as they are ruining mine.

The flow of traffic is one thing, but being that "one person" is unfair to the rest of the world. You want to go slow (exiting and entering are different) get your ass OVER...

It's not about going after aggressive drivers. You are making drivers aggressive by your rude behavior. Start to show a little common courtesy. Do you like being treated like crap? Then why would you do it to others? I'll bet when people do let you in, you don't even wave to say thank you do you? You just expect it as your right...

Else, you may see me cut you off one day and then slam on my brakes and make you follow ME at 35 MPH until I feel like we've gone slow long enough and then I'll stop you and confront you... And if it's not me, it'll be someone else, I think you get the point I'm making here... (more of example).

by jdclyde

If they are publishing this out without any attempt to conceal or lock it down then it can't be any more illegal than listening to the radio.

Now, if you try to access their server, you are talking a whole new ball game.

Many people are setting up the open access points as a good will, to share bandwidth they aren't using. Businesses will do this at night, broadcast a signal into a local park. It is running on a DMZ, so there isn't a real threat to them and they aren't using the bandwidth.

If you are walking through the woods, you can keep on walking as long as someone hasn't clearly posted that it is private property and to stay out. Many security "experts" even claim if you do not have such a "no trespassing" on your logins on your server, anyone trying to get in can.

The law hasn't kept up with covering this.

Be a good neighbor and you shouldn't have anything to worry about as far as legalities or ettiquitte.

by cactus pete

People who drive in the middle lane of a three lane [one way] highway are usually being safe by staying out of the on/off merge lane. Those people find it is much easier to stay in the middle lane than to constantly move over to allow traffic to merge.

The idea is that merging traffic will be slower than the speed limit.

Passing on the right is then an additional hazard, as you should always attempt to pass on the left [in the US and likewise configured countries, of course]. In additional to surprizing the drivers not expecting you to pass on the right, you cut off the merge lane.

Should someone be a left lane vigilante, the rule is, I believe, to flash your lights at them - from a safe distance. Becoming a left-lane-enforcer by tailgating a left-lane-vigilante does more than just compound the problem...

by montgomery gator

I agree, one should avoid passing on the right, even on 3 lanes. However, when the left lane is clogged up by someone going slower than the flow of traffic, and the middle lane is full, then the right lane is the only option. I do not flash "left lane vigilantes", because they will get even more obstinate and less likely to move over. Same with tailgating them (being a "left-lane enforcer" as you put it, which has its own hazards. Only option is to be patient, and hope either they get a clue and move over, or wait for a safe break in traffic and pass on the right, which I would rather avoid, but have to do, occasionally, due to clueless people in the left lane.

Regarding merging traffic, people should use the ramp to get up to speed, not wait until they get on the highway. That is what the ramps are intendend for, unless my high school drivers ed teacher was wrong. It is the responsibility of people getting on the highway to match speeds, not the other way around. Of course, I do move from the right to the center (or left as the case may be) if there is room to do it safely to let someone onto the highway.

by cactus pete

Yeah, but those ramps are designed for a mustang to get up to the speed limit - not a yugo to the speed of traffic ;)

by jdclyde

It is one thing if you can be in a public area and pick up and use an unsecured access point.

It is another if you start making system changes to someone's personal property. This is an illegal intrusion and should never be condoneded.

Just like if someone does secure their access point but you hack it anyways. That would be wrong too.

I would say there is a big difference between each.

by mrafrohead

BUT - I can tell you that I don't intend to stand by and allow some ignorant jerk increase my chance of receiving virii and spam.

Nope, not gonna do it.

Now, is it right to change the stuff. Probably not. If it was a secure network, then it is completely wrong. That line I won't cross. Because at least there was attempt there. That would be the point I would attempt to contact an admin of the network.

But I see it as this. Once your radio waves cross into my path, they belong to me. What I do with them from that point on is the users fault for giving me their signal. If they didn't want me to have it, they should have done something to prevent it.

I can tell you this much. My router, not an expensive one, has options to prevent wireless changes. Therefore, if MY router has it, and it's not that great of a router, then I'm SURE that there are plenty other users out there that have that also... 2 mouse clicks and you're safe...

But that was on page 18 of the manual... Most people don't want to get past the "quick install" card... If that...

by cactus pete

"But I see it as this. Once your radio waves cross into my path, they belong to me."

That would be for read only. Sending requests back onto their hardware would then be violating your own rule, using that logic.

by jdclyde

from the back pannel in the car so you could reach into the cooler in the trunk without having to keep popping the trunk?

Am I only one to put Jack Daniels into a ziplock baggie and stick it in my pants to get booze into a concert? Yeah, I got a package for you baby...

I doubt it.

And the point was well made, that it is your intent on what you do with that access.

by thechas

What we need to both stop road rage and eliminate the reason for left lane vigilantes is ZERO tolerance enforcement of the traffic laws.

When I first started driving, the sheriff in a neighboring county was known for strict enforcement of the speed limit.
Nobody from the area drove even 1 MPH over the speed limit in his county.

An interesting side effect of the high visibility of the road patrol officers was that this county also had one of the lowest crime rates in the area.

I would love to see every US city, county and state institute a zero tolerance traffic law enforcement protocol.

Otherwise, if you are not going to enforce your laws, repeal them.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
With all due respect, Chas, you seem to have zero tolerance for people who don't live up to your notion of how people should live. You have voiced so much opinion about how you think government should be exerting control over individuals in so many areas of their lives, that I have to wonder about your real desires for America.

You have zero tolerance for people who drive even one mile over the speed limit, but show a boat-load of tolerance for terrorists.

How about supporting a world-wide ZERO TOLERANCE policy towards terrorism?

by thechas

Max,

I look at a speeding motorist much as you do a government social program.

The speeding motorist is taking money out of my pocket!

First, because a speeding car uses more fuel per mile, speeding wastes precious resources and raises the price of fuel. And worsens the trade balance.

Second, when a speeding driver has a collision, the resulting damage is worse than it would have been at a slower speed. This raises my car insurance rates. True, it raises their rates more than mine. But, part of the rate is based on regional loses. Fewer, lower speed collisions in an area result in lower rates for everyone.
Also, in many states you pay into a catastrophic fund that pays the ongoing costs for disabled victims.
Then there is the cost for emergency services.

Third, a speeding motorist increases wear on the public road system. Not from going fast in itself but from panic stops and radical lane changes.

I have seen zero tolerance programs improve traffic safety.

Zero tolerance against terrorists has worked well for Israel hasn't it!
But, that should be a discussion for another thread.

Chas

by montgomery gator

My 4-cylinder Saturn SL2 has no problem getting up to speed on Interstate ramps, and it is not a muscle car in any way :-)

by mrafrohead

I guess then I can rationalize this. Your waves pass into my house. Your waves belong to me. So in essense, so does your router. So if I screw with it, I feel better now as I'm only screwing with my stuff anyhow...

Thanks for allowing me the chance to rationalize that to myself. :)

by mrafrohead

What max posted is a HUGE example of that.

That's all it is. Nothing more. It's treat others as you wish to be treated!

by mrafrohead

As well as my Hyundai Elantra 2.0L 4Cyl...

I almost have a small enough engine to be powered by girbles, but it does me just fine...

Just remember, it's the right peddle, the accelerator. Magikal things happen when you press it down... ;p

by mrafrohead

As well as my Hyundai Elantra 2.0L 4Cyl...

I almost have a small enough engine to be powered by girbles, but it does me just fine...

Just remember, it's the right peddle, the accelerator. Magikal things happen when you press it down... ;p

by mrafrohead

As well as my Hyundai Elantra 2.0L 4Cyl...

I almost have a small enough engine to be powered by girbles, but it does me just fine...

Just remember, it's the right peddle, the accelerator. Magikal things happen when you press it down... ;p

by mrafrohead

I don't know what happened, but I have three of the one that I tried to post.

I don't think I did it, but if I did, I apologize for the nastiness...

by mrafrohead

Usually the speeding accidents come from the speeder having to do something out of the norm to get around the person who is holding up the traffic...

At least from all of the accidents that I have witnessed... There's usually a catalyst to the accidents.

And if I'm not mistaken, I read somewhere that the optimal speed to drive to maintain the best fuel efficiency is 65MPH...

by mrafrohead

I also see dlink router through my house occasionally... ;p

Though after that last time it's been a few months...

by clmoran

The air waves in the US are free and if someone has an unsecured wireless connection available, it is free to use. I just wouldn't recommend calling the homeowner for technical support! =:o)

by thechas

Interesting comments.

When someone parks on my bumper, I follow what I was taught in drivers training and slow down.

I do try my best to drive at or just below the posted speed limit. If treated respectfully, I will go up to 5 MPH over when I need to use the left lane.

I have done such a good job at training myself to drive the speed limit that I now need to watch the needle so I don't go too slow!

Anyhow, I think my comments and the responses have corrupted this thread enough.

Here is a link to a new thread for those who wish to pursue this subject further.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=167266&start=0

Looking forward to more interesting comments.

Chas

by thechas

I know why the home networking companies leave the defaults open.

It's the same reason that Microsoft continues to dummy down Windows.

Users just refuse to read the documentation to find the default password and then set up their network.

In order to control support costs they make the decision to set up the routers so they just plug and play.

Gee, I wonder if we could start a class action suit because the wireless network companies are leaving so many people open to identity theft?

(Just kidding)

Besides, it would never go anywhere. The class would loose their identities to a phishing scheme looking to start a class action.

Chas

by brian.harwood

Anyone call "Breaker Breaker" on a private CB radioconversation lately? If the frequency is free and unsecured then the door ia open. Maybe we should politely ignore it but legally, if you leave your door open then it's not beraking and entering. If you lock your backup tapes in the safe, then why don't you secure you wifi too.

by billds

If you are not using tools to circumvent security measures in order to gain access and given that anyone setting up an access point should know the consequences of broadcasting the SSID I feel that the responsibility lies with the person that set up the access point.

In the end if you want to be protected and there is no law to protect you then you must protect yourself.

From the perspective of the person 'intruding', if they aren't breaking any law then it has to come down to their own conscience.

by robin_graves

I have been installing wireless routers for some time, since the word is out to "AVERAGE JOE" that
every 12 year old is scanning hundreds of computers
24 hours a day to see who is open on the web. It used to be nothing short of ridiculous for Ma and Pa to purchase a firewall router and try to read the manuals and go online to read the FAQs for HELP and
SUPPORT, and now, with wireless, the situation is worse. There are thousands upon thousands of wireless routers out there, and judging by the huge array on the store shelves, the trend will mushroom - no one wants ethernet cables snaking all over the place...

Here is my earlier email to DLINK, who supplies thousands of stores with their wireless equipment,
and the email, although about the wire ethernet,
is completely applicable...

I helped one person who put in a DLINK, and then,
after weeks of frustration, ripped it out, put back a wireless. I can't imagine how many customers are lost by the manufacturer's stupidity.

EMAIL to DLINK:

_______________________________________________

After carefully reading thru the CD MANUAL on the
DI-604, it occured to me that the technical writer
has his head up his fatty acids.

The "END USER" of the typical DLINK router is
a family, with 2.4 kids, 3.1 cars, and 2.7
computers on cable or ADSL High-Speed....

All the way thru your "Helpful" manual, you
list things like:

RN&t*d Settings :
" If you WANT your TCMP246 turned on, you MUST
make sure that the 9J4H*#G settings is
set to your ICMP56HtR request number."

How the hell does Mom and Pop Joe computer user know if they
" WANT " the TCMP246 turned on?

Telling them that the TCMP246 is a subnet request
modifier delimiting protocol packet enhancement filter
with subnet gateway filters to accept or prevent
IRT46IEEE router pings, only makes the stupidity of
your so called " HELP " read me's in the manual even more
cryptic.

Ma and Pa have 3 computers.
They want administrative control on their main computer.
They want Billy to connect to your DLINK hub, from
his computer in his room. How do they do this? In Eeengleesh?
They want Salley to connect to your DLINK router, from
her computer in her room. How do they do this? In Eeengleesh?

They want to block all outside access, including PING requests
from getting into their system.
They want to know IMMEDIATELY, how to put in the longest,
most secure PASSWORDS possible, to prevent anyone,
(like Billy's computer hacker friends) on the inside
of the network, or outside on the web, from getting
into their home computer system. How do they do this? In Eeenglish?
Pleeeeze?

If you are trying to show off how technically advanced you are to your
collegues in the Communications business, you are doing a fine job.
If you believe for even a moment that your so called "MANUAL ",
is helping John Q. Public, you are so full of yourself, that
you are blinded by your own arrogance.

A good example of your clearly arrogant, self-serving,
missleading, even fraudulent behaviour is your coverage of one
of the most important topics in the entire process - that of
changing the stupid DEFAULT PASSWORDS.

There is a general principal of JUSTICE used in the United States
of America :
truth is definded as:

The truth, the whole truth, and nothing BUT the truth.

Your coverage of PASSWORDS, fails on 2 out of 3 counts of
this definition. You do not " LIE " per se, you just
just do NOT tell the whole truth, avoiding details of the correct
parameters of the legal passwords, like they were the plague,
and showing PASSWORDS which are SOMETHING BESIDES THE TRUTH,
clearly demonstrating to the users, excellent, 31 character
password fields, which, if the user types in, YOUR SOFTWARE
ACCEPTS, in fact, not only does your software allow 31 bit
entries, IT ASKS THE USER TO CONFIRM a second time !!!

While your LEGAL department may point out that this deception
is " NOT A LIE ", in ordinary English, this is fraudulent,
deceptive, false advertising, and you clearly show a level of security
in password length that you have no intention of supporting.

I will be watching your advertising, your website manuals,
and your installation CD's in the near future, for clear
changes in this fraudulent practise. ...

I have installed a few of these units over the years, but
until now, never analysed the stupidities of your INSTRUCTIONS,
READ-ME's, Manuals, DIAGRAMS, and Examples...

In the past, helping other people set up your typical
"HOME USER" D LINK routers, I always used simple, easy
to remember passwords, which I asked the " HOME USER" to
choose, and being short, and simple, they accidentally
fit the stupid, narrow parameter, short requirements
of your " UNDISCLOSED", " UNMENTIONED", " UNDOCUMENTED",
" CLEARLY AVOIDED REFERENCE ", programming.

However, since every 12 year old in the country has access
to clear instructions on the web on how to set up snoop programs
to monitor thousands on on-line users, and clear instructions
on how to break simple passwords, I MYSELF followed your
clearly documented, clearly printed, 31 field length password
examples, and after re-entering them, was locked out of my
own DLINK unit, forcing me to reset the damned thing
and re- initializing the hardware and software repeatedly,
until I realized that your Clearly printed Examples were
a LIE. False Advertising. False Security.

CONCLUSION:

You are NOT giving any instructions at all to the many thousands
of " HOME USERS" on how to set up the router and Firewall,
connect Billy's and Salley's computer, and change passwords and
settings IMMEDIATELY, to give the highest level of security,
which they falsely believe that they are getting...

In fact, the DEFAULT settings of the unit, as shipped are a total
JOKE, with wide open options and passwords that any 12 year
old can defeat. Emphasis in the manuals on the ABSOLUTE NEED
to IMMEDIATELY change default settings and passwords, is totally
missing, and obsucured with mumbo-jumbo technicaleeze, which
is as clear as mud.

Choosing to populate your CD's and Manuals and Examples, and
leaflets, and Demonstrations with TECHNOSPEAK is not against
the law.
It is stupid, and arrogant, and hurts your SALES, but, not illegal.

However, the deliberate AVOIDANCE of password parameters, coupled
with CLEARLY printed examples of 31 digit PASSWORD fields,
which your own software accepts, ( twice), likely IS false
advertising, making the USER believe that 31 digit, high- security
passwords are possible, when in fact, they are not.

I will pass around JPGs of your manuals, your set up wizards, your
CD pages, your online manuals, your instructions, etc. all
regarding PASSWORDS, to see if others agree that this is
fraudulent advertising...

I will be watching the next revision of your software, and your
packaging to see if this FRAUD is corrected.

It would be wonderful as well, to see clear instructions in
English, on how to connect Billy's and Salley's computer to
your equipment. In English.

ROBIN

Dec 16th 2K4

__________________________________________________

Since this email, above, to DLINK, I have analysed
their manuals further, and have discovered the
deliberate use of OBFUSCATED sentence structure to
deliberately confuse users - " If you do not want
the Armt39.Vb3.n not active, then you must not
choose to not allow the ISP/ntr/34%3:49 activity"
SETTINGS : Allow, Dissable

Given the sentence structure, what do you click on? How many users happen to have another computer online beside them, to PING the resulting choice to determine if it is valid? For that matter, how many users would know how to PING what address in the first place. Finally, If someone has 384 computers to look after, and does know how to PING, would they bother to take the time to PING to verify the setting?

Setting the wireless routers is really simple.
Understanding the deliberate obfuscation provided by the Manufacturers is a nightmare. And it is getting worse.

There is not a single person with a mobile wireless unit, that I know of, that does not
get dozens of connections wherever they go. There
is not a single person in a home or SOHO environment that does not pick up neighbouring signals, and the occurances are getting more frequent.

Blame the manufacturers for arrogance, obfuscation, and shipping units with all security OFF, and all PORTS open, - this means that the
users will not phone in, asking "why won't this work", - and therefore a cheap way to decrease costs in SUPPORT, while maintaining an arrogant posture of "ONLY we, know what we are doing"...

ROBIN

by graeme

Our local Staples told me that they get 20-25% returns on networking products that "don't work" - meaning "too hard for end user to set up". So you can understand why home and small office products come "open" if the neophyte user is to have success in setting up.

We take the view that an unsecured network telss you eveything you need to know about the owner's sense of security and that you are likely to catch something if you take the free ride. WE simply avoid them.

by adent888

Hijacking implies taking over the network. As long as you do not attempt to connect to other computers on the network or try to gain access to services not meant for you, I have no problem with using an available signal. However you bring up an interesting question. Do IT professionals have a social responsibility to let people know when they are at risk?

by giltrotman

I found this thread quite interesting (especially the diversions from the topic were highly entertaining) (I always found the non-commisioned highway cop, called left lane vigilante here a peculiar beast who feels that since they obey the letter of the law, they'l be damned if they are going to standby and watch you flaunt it even if it means backing up traffic from here to Timbuktu) and perhaps the all-out attempt to avoid the obvious--why is the orignal author trying to take responsibility for the owner of the wireless signal, I think one of the first replies kind of answered that one, equating the author to a never drive over the speed limit, by the book type of person? Now while I do appreciate conscientiousness, I am not going to lie awake at nights or post a ? to a Tech-Republic forum or for that matter the AP's owner to say "Hey there is an unsecured AP here are you aware of this?" In fact, to get to the point I don't think using an unsecured AP to check your email, browse Kazaa, or whatever immoral or illegal? In fact, the manufacturers who make and sell these dumbed-up, wide open APs (with intentionally obfuscated manuals) are within their rights to do so. I believe it is up to the buyer to beware of what he is buying, if Linksys or D-Link sells all their w-routers opened-up DON'T BUY THEM and as a technical consultant advise your customers that in your professional opinion Linksys does not pay enough attention to security. To further my point, it is up to the buyer to be ware of what he is buying, or to put it more specifically, if I buy a w-router that is opened-up and then install it at my workplace or residence I cannot sue the manufacturer because not only did somebody use my internet access, but they also stole copies of my Turbotax return, any lawyer I went to would promptly advise me that it was up to me to determine how to secure it, by reading the manual or purchasing a different product that was more secure. To further illustrate my point in a different way, if I go down to the mall and purchase a new HDTV and bring my new TV out to the parking lot and realize it won't fit in my vehicle, am I going to say to myself well larceny is illegal so my TV is safe here, while I run home and come back with a pick-up truck, which by the way, I leave unattended at home with the keys in it because grand theft auto is also illegal and expect to come back and find my TV sitting there and if I should happen to know the TVs serial number and see it in soebodies house next week can I really claim it stolen, no abandoned is more like it, given away perhaps. Now, that doesn't mean that if I leave my front door to my house unlocked I should expect to come home from work finding strangers eating my dinner, watching my TV with their feet up on my table and my wife under their arm, but if I did can I blame them or should I shoulder the responsibility for locking my own damn door. (BTW: I'm from NYC where locked-down is the norm and security is priority A1). Yes In the latter example I may be able to charge them with trespassing, but a halfway decent defense lawyer would probably be able to convince a jury that their client weary, hungry and lonely found my door open and thought the place abandoned. My wife would probably testify on their behalf because I didn't care enough about her safety to lock the damn door.

by danag429

I live in a building where there are one or two unsecured wireless networks. It means I can sit on the couch and go online from my laptop, without having to drill a hole and run a cable through the wall.

If someone leaves their wireless access point unsecured, then they obviously don't care if someone uses it. It doesn't cost them any more, and if they are using password protected accounts on their machines, nobody can get in and hurt them.

If I were to set up a WLAN, I'd simply protect all of my machines and if anyone wants to get online, what do I care? As long as they can't see my machines' innards, it's no skin off my nose!!

One of the wireless networks in my building has a machine with an unsecured guest account. And guess what? I decided to be evil and look at their machine.

BOOOOOR-ING! They had one accessable music file from some hack who shouldn't have veen allowed in a recording studio.

So as long as you're not doing anything mean to their machines, they probably will never know you're there. And if they password protected the user and guest accounts on their machines, then they obviously know someone could get on the network. Like I said, it costs them nothing and is a good will gesture to the neigbors.

by scottvolkert

If you don't ask to permission to hunt private lands in Wisconsin, you just violated the law. The lack of "signs" does not give you permission to enjoy the land I paid for.

And you better have it writing, in case you make the land owner mad and he denies permission!

by bronzemouse2003

You purchased the land, stocked it as a private preserve (fish or game?) and fail to put in the proper barrier to prevent the stock from leaving the property.

When the stock leaves your property, it's open season on a public asset - your loss!

Do it right the first time.

by bill.greenleaf

It's like a freeway vs a turnpike... thumbing a ride vs taking a taxi or bus.

As long as you are not a "hacker" looking for a "freeway" to spread your malicious ways.

Access to the Internet for legitimate resons on an available link should not be regarded as "hijacking". All the manuals tell you how to secure your wireless access points so, if you leave your doors open, whether for good or bad reasons, someone is going to come in.

by nobby57

Have read nearly all the posts but still find myself in muddy waters -- which is the nature of this kind of question, I guess.

Here is my situation (and reason why I was interested in this thread): I am a tugboat captain for a company which docks ships in a large east coast port. Got a wireless PC card for my laptop for Christmas. As soon as it was installed I discovered that the hotel across the street from the pier was putting out a strong signal that I could even get from the end of the pier, hundreds of feet from the hotel. The signal is so strong that it is the default for my laptop out of a dozen (mostly secured) signals, as soon as I power up. The hotel page loads, then and I have unlimited high speed internet access. I love it -- we have dialup at home -- but I wonder about the ethical question, too.

Sure they haven't secured it. But this is more than just overhearing someone playing loud music. I am using part of their bandwidth, right? I would be paying $40/Mo for that service at home. So I am recieving something of value. On the other hand, it is not costing them much, if anything; I imagine that the hotel would have to be full of avid internet users to soak up all their bandwidth, to the point where my access would constitute any real interference.

I guess the real question is how I view it. Having read most of the posts and thought it over, my view now is that I should go to the hotel management, let them know the situation, and see what they have to say. Probably they don't know they are providing high speed internet access to the neighborhood at large; in that case they can get it secured. But maybe they are cognizant of it and intend it as a public service -- there is a square in front of the hotel with trees and benches, etc. Unlikely but possible.

Anyway, it seems to me now that I have to let them know. Then if they continue to leave it unsecured, that will be their lookout.

I'm not an IT professional, just an avid hobbyist -- I have a couple of basic certifications I got just for the interest of it. But I think even that level of expertise involves some responsibility.

Thanks to all for the thoughts!

by dlstaats

While on vacation last fall we stopped at a bakery/sandwich shop which advertised internet access ($1.00us/half hour). We bought lunch and proceeded to plug in the rj45 cord to my wife's laptop to check our e-mails and the program venue at a location we wanted to visit later that day and the next. We had no problem getting on and doing so. The other couple who were trying to check on airline flights were having major problems so I said "here we're done with this port and it's working fine" - he plugged it into his laptop and no go - I then realized that I had left the default wireless coneection in the laptop enable and I was on wirelessly - this shop did not have wireless. I scanned and there were 3 sites available - 1 was locked down (signal strength 3), another ssid=linksys (signal strength 2) was not, and the 1 I had hit on was ssid=d-link (signal strength 10). I checked with the Real Estate office next door and the motel next to it and they denied having a wireless access point. I checked again 2 and 3 days later (didn't use it at that point) and the site was still there and wide open.

by paul

The way I see it, if somebody hacks into my wireless network, I have every right to mine the data on their computer, copy it to my hard disk, and use it however I see fit.

by Member 29327465

couple questions

If you left your wap unsecured and broadcast the SSID, would you consider any foreign machines connecting as having 'hacked' into your network?

question 2: in practice how easy can the connecting machine be compromised? (I assume that if the client has folder sharing enabled without security, then anyone on the network could connect). But barring something like this, what service on a typical windows laptop would allow the server to obtain file access?

I may be opening myself up to ridicule here but my impression is that windows is pretty secure, especially since the introduction of sp2 with the built in firewall.

The most i've seen references to is 'evil twin' waps (http://news.com.com/Evil+twin+could+pose+Wi-Fi+threat/2100-7349_3-5545355.html), but this technique is basically eavesdropping on network traffic, which I *think* can go on on just about any network by using products like ethereal.

by ex-military nut

Obviously you were there for a reason other than surfing an unprotected wireless network. I agree with the post about bringing the unsecured access point to the "owner's" attention. If they reply that it is there for that express reason - the honey pot - then no harm; you've gained information on a useful access point AND another contact for your personal (people) network.

Boil it down: Every action should involve a little common sense. It's like the warnings about cruise controls and electric hair dryers - cruise control is not synonomous with auto-pilot and if you use an electric hair dryer in the shower, you deserve what you get.

by larry3500

Every single-family home I've ever seen has one or more garden hose connectors in front of the house; anyone walking by can get water by going to an unsecured hose bib and turning it on. Many homes even leave a garden hose connected at all times.

Does anyone boldly walk up and take a drink?

Does anyone rinse their car off?

NO. NO. Social etiquette seems to protect a homeowner's water from interlopers.

Does anyone stop by to read your unsecured newspaper between the time it is delivered and the time you retrieve it (in your pajamas and slippers)? NO.

by jevans4949

In the UK, the Computer Misuse Act, passed about 15-20 years ago as I recollect, might apply in this case. Its original intention was anti-hacking, but it is drawn in fairly broad terms, to forbid unauthorised use of a computer, even if no harm done. As I recall from discussion at the time, it would certainly apply to unauthorised use of a dial-up connection. Similar legislation might apply elsewhere. This is in the criminal law, so would require the Police / Crown Prosecution Service to action it.

Trespass? In the UK we don't normally have exemplary damages, so in a civil law case the owner of the system which was "hacked" would have to show the losses which he suffered. The most obvious would be if he was paying a per-megabyte rate for his connection, or if you were signifcantly slowing his business process.

by bronzemouse2003

You purchase limited service from your cable TV provider. You have the option of purchasing your own Cable Decoder box.

Now the service provider scrambles channels you are not purchasing, but sends them into your home.

Your decoder is capable of descrambling those stations.

Who's at fault provider or end user? (Remember, the service provider has the capability to filter out signals into your home.)

If you don't want someone to access the service, don't provide it to them.