connecting to unsecured wireless: is it hijacking?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by ktc
I was under the impression that "Hijacking" was ANY unauthorized use of a wireless network. As an IT consultant, I can "sniff" around to find wireless nodes and to see if they are secure or not but, once I've "jumped onto" an unsecure wireless network, I have broken the law.
If you are unsure whether its a public node or not, it is your responsibility to find out if you can use it or not.
It is up to a company to make a node secure, if they wish. But, if they want to make it secure and didn't, that falls under the category of stupidity and negligence. I believe that from a legal standpoint, it's not up to the company to keep you off, its up to you to stay off.
Just because IBM and Microsoft have pretty lawns out in front of their buildings doesn't give me the autority to spread out a blanket and have a picnic, even if there are no "no trespassing" signs.
by ktc
I beg to differ on this comparison. At least in the state of Michigan, specific laws are on the books about hunting. They, in part, state that if "no hunting" signs are NOT posted, it is fair game to hunt.
But, there is not a law on the books addressing the network posting of "no squatting" signs and thus the legality of squatting.
by beoweolf
Especially the one about a newspaper. If I purchase a newspaper, have paid for the service and have a reasonable expectation that it is mine to use as I wish. On occasion, people have taken an unread newspaper from my desk...when caught; they would say I thought you were through with it. Three salient points were ignored. First, it was on the desk, not in the lobby. Second, it was obviously unopened. Third and most important, they didn?t purchase it. The test for cyber trespass could be the same, is it available? Can you access it? Was it provided for your explicit use? In a public space, advertised as such?an open ?hot spot? would be O.K. to use, otherwise it is trespass.
Same case with a book or magazine. Availability or opportunity; does not automatically confer privilege. Someone purchased the service or product; they shouldn't have to defend it constantly. However; I do concede one point mentioned, give the climate of entitlement so pervasive today...you should take at least minimal steps to discourage non-intentional abuse. Example, a good citizen should have a fence on his yard if he has territorial pets...if only as a "demarcation zone" of where trespass starts. Not that this is any real protection from litigation, but it does establish a reasonable expectation of privacy.
by bmcombrw
by rallison
I have been dabling and implementing WLAN system over the last 5 years. In the beginning I felt the same, "if the WLAN was unsecure, its like offering a public service". But after my experience in the hospitatlity industry I have learned that an unsecure WLAN with public access is a revenue loser.
Although we are all aware that the "cost" associated with WLAN is not significant when compared to the IT budget, there is a cost associated for Internet access via 3rd party ISP or corporate resources. The Back end connectivity is limited for the business needs and priced accordingly, when the connection is "hijacked" by a client user across the unsecure WLAN the internet resources and connection is used more than as planned by the business.
I would encourage that WLAN itegrators, implementors and planners adopt a minimum security strategy to ensure "hijacks" of sessions or access could not occur.
As to the individual who may be tempted to hijack, think of the open WLAN as someones telephone. When you're a guest at their house. Would you just make a call, or ask first?
Commen courtesy is to ask, because that phone is not yours and you don't pay the bill.
Just my two cents.
--- Rick L. Allison
Sr. Network Architect
Acela Technologies
by erich1010
Yes, I agree with you totally.
People can build houses with doors or without doors. If they build them without doors, they can expect that, from time to time, someone might wander in. Of course, if someone is in someone else's house, doors or no doors, you must respect their property. And even if they have no doors, if they have just a sign saying, "Stay out", that should be respected, too.
I have a wireless network, and I leave it wide open. My computers are secure enough, that any passerby probably isn't going to mess with much. If it helps someone, hey great! Though, I would expect that they don't mess with my computers or try screwing with the routers. Also, I think it would be rude of someone using it on a permanent basis without asking me.
I've roamed other people's networks. I have a laptop with a wireless connection and find it useful for accessing the net. One time it really came in handy was when looking for a new place to live. I could go into a neighborhood, bring up the listings near there, then check the houses out. Of course, I never did anything bad to the network of the person kind enough to leave it open for me. If there was a way of thanking the person who left it open for me, I would have.
If people are leaving their wireless networks open because they are generous, that's great. If they are leaving their wireless networks open because they don't know better, they probably should learn more about what they are using. In any case, others should respect the property of others and not abuse it. However, using the network for what it was built for is not considered abuse, in my book.
The Internet is not the real world. It is a different environment and it runs under different rules. In a sense, it is much safer in some ways and much more dangerous in others. On one hand, you have much information that is just given away freely. On the other hand, if you have information you wish to protect, you must be diligent, because all the thieves in the world are at your door. In real life, you can't hang out in a store and chat about its merchandise without some clerk eventually shooing you away. On the Internet, you are welcomed to do so, and you might even have access to people in the store who can really do something about your suggestions and requests. In real life, trespassing is very straightforward. There are definite property lines and you know when you are on someone else's property. In the Internet, this concept is much more abstract. In real life, where you are welcomed and not welcomed on a property is visible. You probably won't get shot using the walkway up to the door, but you might get in trouble walking around a fenced yard. On the Internet, you might wander into private property without knowing it.
Right now, there is no real way to know if an open wireless site was put there on purpose unless the owner goes out of their way to state so. However, it is fairly easy for an owner to say "Stay Out". All it takes is a switch to turn on the wireless security features. Therefore, I use the wireless networks, silently thanking those who leave them open on purpose and trying not to hurt those too ignorant of computers to know either way. Either way, I try not to use too much of the bandwidth and don't mess with their computers.
by kobrak1
by rmorrison
by dcperich
If I set some chairs out in front of my house, can anyone walking down the street leagaly sit in one? Its the same question.
Unless there is a law that defines who can sit where, its just a matter of opinion.
If it is illegal to connect to an unsecured Wi-Fi, I would think signs (physical or digital) would have to be posted warning potential users not to use that connection. How else is one to determine which connections are private and which are public?
If I set my own chairs in the building lobby (a common area) then clearly anyone can sit in them.
Hijacking suggests that one has taken something for their own exclusive use. What was actually done was to piggyback on the open network. If a butterfly lands on your shoulder then it gets a free ride without impairing your ability to walk. If a user is using IM for simple communication, it is unlikely that the WLAN will be bogged down. Certainly a large download would be another story.
I also don't see a practical way to identify the physical location of the open WLAN. If there are four unsecured nets in a large office building, how do you know to whom to report the unsecured net?
by placidair
by bmcombrw
If I set some chairs out in front of my house - within the boundaries of my lot, which defines my property - no one has the legal right to take or use those chairs without my permission. If I set out another chair on the public sidewalk, outside the boundaries of my lot, anyone has the legal right to assume I don't want that chair anymore and they can take it or use it. Even though it would be common courtesy to knock on my door and ask if I meant to leave this chair out in the public domain, I could not have someone who merely took it away arrested for theft. I routinely put old furniture and such out to the curb in front of my house, to be removed as rubbish, and sometimes people like what they see and cart it off for themselves. If those items were on my lawn instead, I would be outraged if those people carted them away - and legally entitled to have law enforcement on their tails.
If you don't want to bother knowing where your lot ends and public property begins, to actively ensure that you place your chairs on your property, then you can tie the chairs to your house with long chains.
by bhlang
by stltech
by acmbruch
With City plans of offering public WIFI the thought comes to mind:
That in a public place the WIFI is public and private WIFI needs to not interfere in public places. Not having your WIFI in check is no excuse for getting mad at a user, as the user is in PUBLIC airspace.
Who was in the wrong place, the user or the WIFI?
by vze2hjtw
I work for a communication as a field tech and were recently giving a wireless laptop and was amazed as to the amount of open access point there is out there. 1 out of 5 will be secure.
Who do you blame, the vendor, the ISP or the customer? I will put it this way 10% to the vendor, 50% to the ISP and 40% to the customer.
The vendor need to give more information on securing the wireless access point. The ISP must stress the important securing the access point and give instruction on doing it (I recently received a westell 327w modem/router from my ISP and there was no documentation with it after numerous call no one seem to be able to tell me how to secure the wireless access). And finally the customer need to learn the important of a secure network. Just don't buy a wireless network because the salesperson tell you it easy to set up and no need for wires.
Maybe if you shut down a unsecure wireless access then the person will take the time to learn about securing them (Only a suggestion)
by djj
by rrosca
I leave my wi-i connection unsecured because I want people to have access to it.
This whole debate gets more interesting when we start to consider who do we want to police the actions of people who piggyback unsecure wireless connections. Personally, I do not want to call the police when someone hops on my connection. I left it unsecure so that people can use it. If I did not want people to use it, I would have secured it.
Now, you use the word "hijacking". I certainly don't want people to abuse the connection I simply want them to use it for normal computing.
This obvioulsy gets more complex in the days of bit torrents and mpaa lawsuits and virus attacks (I certainly don't want to get in trouble in someone uses my connection to do anyting illegal but...it's a possibility I have to consider).
by rnw
by dcperich
by dcperich
by danag429
When I was a child, our house served as a shortcut to another road. We installed a gate in the back yard, so the kids could go through and not have to walk around.
There was no sign saying "shortcut". If the kids found it, then what was the harm in their walking across the property?
The same way, if there's an unsecured wireless network, you're not hurting the owners by using it. If you hack into their machines, then you've crossed the line, but if they have password protected the accounts on their machines, they probably won't even notice someone using their wireless setup. The airwaves are public territory, and if you don't want anyone using your network, you can secrue it.
In my opinion, that's kind of mean. Why not let people connect if they are in the lobby? Is it costing you anything?
by jamesrl
There is a law in Ontario that you cannot do things which impede the flow of traffic, including sitting in the left hand lane at the speed limit when other want to overtake(Overtaking on the right is also illegal but rarely enforced).
There was a case where in a protest, a couple of drivers drove side by side down a divided highway(2 lanes each direction) at the speed limit intentionally to block traffic. They were charged, convicted, appealled and lost the appeal.
Every year there is a blitz where the police look for "left lane bandits" instead of speeders. And yes they can be charged, even though they are doing the speed limit or less. Why do we have these laws? Because its safer to allow some speeding than to force people to pass on the right. I will note that its rare to have left lanes in Ontarion that turn into exits.
In Ontario, the highways were built to a standard which allows safe operation at a higher speed than the speed limit. And the police do not enforce the speed laws on multilane divided highways until you are substantially over the limit of 100 KMs per hour. 120 is safe, 130 is risky, 140 you will be ticketed.
There are times when speeding is accepted here - if you need to speed up to pass a truck who blocks your visibility or whose wake is buffeting your car, you won't get stopped.
I think there are other practises that warrant more close police attention, like unsafe lane changes, and following too close. I'd rather be on the road with speeders who pay attention than slow drivers on cell phones who absent mindedly change lanes without checking their blind spot.
James
If your neighbor's fruit tree grows over your common fence into your yard, it is legal to pick the fruit that is on you side of the fence. Moreover, you can trim back the branches on your side. The possible limit to this is that you can't trim the tree so severely that it dies.
This individual did not go into the property of the WLAN owner. The WLAN came into a common area and was used (apparently) without harm to the WLAN.
by tekdoc
This is very interesting. I'm not a lawyer, but there are legal and ethical decisions.
1. You don't have any idea what is going on in that network. If their business is defense, medical, etc. you took a wrong step in my opinion. They may have a heightened sense of security for many reasons, and you could become a test case. A real situation follows. A doctor brought his notebook into a small office building. One day he discovered that he could connect thru next door tech company's WAP. Okay, would you hire that company to build your apps? Forget that for a moment. Eventually they secured the WAP, and that was that. The problem I have with this is that the doctor exposed proprietary information.
2. I can't quote law, but if you access a company's property without permission, you are exposing yourself, innocently enough, to being accused of theft, trespassing, etc. What is the likelihood of getting "caught?" Don't allow that to sway your judgment. If I leave my door unlocked on a very hot day, and you enter my house for a cool drink of water... What if I leave my door ajar slightly? What if I leave a bottle of water on my front step? The point is that each situation is different. Whether or not something is right or wrong depends on the observer, the value of the property, the extent of intrusion, and I'm sure other factors I don't consider, but a judge would.
What is more interesting than the legal and technical aspects, is your co-worker's response to what you did. I can't characterize it for you, but definitely worth thinking about.
With 20-25% return rate, it is no wonder that manufacturers have reduced "quick install" cards to the lowest common denominator (which just happens to be unsecure).
Robin is also correct in that the manuals, often written in Engrish, seem to require a technical background to understand and follow. Once it works the average consumer figures they don't need to read the rest of the manual.
The manufactures need to put this on each quick install guide card:
Quick Installation Guide
- Use these instructions to get your network runing quickly, unsecured and publically accessible.
- Information on security settings available at the end of this guide.
After all, maybe some people really don't care if you use it. Perhaps they even want this.
End of Quick Guide
- Securing you router is recommended. -
- See pages X onward in the User's Manual for directions -
- If you require assistance, call us at 1-900-XXXXXXX for $Y.YY/minute for consultation.
The 1-900 number would pay for the service, the manufacture would reduce "doesn't work" returns and the consumers get better education and guidence.
In the mean time, I will connect to my neighbours open networks so that I can approach them to help them out. That's what a good neighbour does. (Much like warning them that their car windows are down when it starts to rain.)
by ernestm
Here's the real problem. There are many, many open wireless networks out there. Many are specifically intended to allow public access - in my city, a large number of restaurants, etc. provide public access points. Even businesses do - the business I work for specifically has a multi-tier wireless setup where you need VPN access to get into the corporate network but any visitor can connect and get Internet access freely.
Connecting wirelessly, you very, very seldom get any kind of message saying "Welcome! I'm public" or "Quit it! I'm private." So if a user opens their laptop and sees several wireless networks - how are they legitimately supposed to know whether they can use it or not? Especially because most of the public's interaction is with "ok to use" public access points.
It seems to me a lot like trespassing. If you fail to mark your property, you can say someone shouldn't be there but legally you are in a very weak position.
Now, you can say "well, if you don't know if it's public or not, don't connect! Just to be sure!" But ethics in the real world don't require that, any more than they require you to not wander through that tree line near the river because ut "might" be unmarked private property. There are enough laws on enough things that if you defaulted to no use when you weren't "sure" you'd be stuck in your home all day.
With the proliferation of public access points, and with not just users but IT professionals and everyone knowing how automatic wireless connection is in today's technology, in my opinion if you have a publicly accessible wireless network you should expect that it be considered fair game. If you don't like it - fix t, it's easy. But to claim that people using it are hijacking is neither fair nor tenable.
by cactus pete
Which is more reasonable to expect:
A) The average person knows even HOW to secure their new wireless setup [or even that it should be]
B) If an access point doesn't specify that it's open intentionally for you specifically to use, it isn't.
by bossford
by danag429
I live in Massachusetts. I was driving along at the usual traffic speed of around 75 miles per hour in the left lane. I was daydreaming and didn't notice the cop behind me.
So he put on his lights, rolled down the window, and yelled at me for being rude and not paying attention to my surroundings. No ticket, just a dressing-down for not being courteous.
The speed limit is 65. On a sunny dry day, the culture seems to accept 70 to 75 miles per hour as acceptable. If the police were really concerned about the speed limit, they'd go around giving lots of tickets.
So, it seems that if I were to set up a wireless network, and protect the machines, I could leave it open for anyone to use without it making the slightest difference to me.
by jdclyde
think for a minute. If it wasn't for all the people out there that are on AOL without a clue in the world, there wouldn't be as much call for trained professionals to sell, fix, fix again and fix again their equipment.
They are creating an bottomless pool of opportunity for techs to thrive and be able to afford all the cool toys.
Next time you see a "dumb user", instead of snorting down on them, say "thank you". It is the "dumb user" who PAYS to have things done for him.
by paul
Hi Ned, my example actually comes from my home network... I have a basic Netgear router which another person from the apartment block managed to circumvent the security (not sure how exactly). Sad thing was, he left his C drive root shared and completely open... It was through browsing that drive, and finding his resume that I was able to work out who it was. I am on broadband with unlimited usage and only have a PDA and laptop connected to the network so not concerned really if people connect - the only thing that worries me is then conducting searches on illegal topics that would point back to me.
I personally think that connecting to an access point without permission is tantamount to hacking. Getting into a car with unlocked doors and keys in the ignition is still theft after all.
Cheers,
Paul
by dave.schutz
If you put up an unsecured wireless network and my computer finds it with no effort on my part, that's your fault. As long as I don't use for illegal activity than I don't see a problem with it.
If you don't want others to connect to your wireless network then secure it!!
As network admins we spend lots of time securing our wired networks and I believe it is a resonable expectation we should do the same for our wireless networks. I know I do.
by manningda
Likewise, I couldn't talk intelligently about the legal issues, however I think there may be an obvious comparison here...
What do you do when you leave your home... your car... your office??? You probably lock them; but sometimes aren't you in too big a hurry.
(ex: quick errand to the corner store = house unlocked... quick trip into the post office = car unlocked ... lunch break during the day = office unlocked)
When this happens, how would you react to someone driving off in your car for a couple of hours... or someone coming in and making long-distance calls on your office phone... or someone coming into your home and watching pay-per-view on your cable/satellite system?
I suspect you would consider it a violation.
I am certain there are many domain administrators who do not consider an intermittent "rogue" connection a serious problem; but ask yourself honestly...
"Would I expect someone else to respect my "territory" if this situation was reversed?"
If your answer is yes, then I say...
"...let your conscience be your guide."
If you answer no, I suspect you may find yourself invited to fewer and fewer LAN parties.
Honestly, who wants to hang out with a party crasher?
Well, I found my self at Kennedy Airport Terminal 4 and while at the bar by security gates found 6 or more networks from the airline lounges at my disposal. Used of coures. I have a WiFi network in my house so if you are in Parioli district of Rome and can get the signal from the street you are welcome to log in. If a network is unsecured then it seems more or less open season if you are not trying to steal anything.
Stephen
Rome, Italy
by sverbil
802.11x devices operate under Part 15 of the FCC
rules. There is *no* right to freedom from
interference, or more exactly, "no expectation
of protection." That's the quid pro pro in
exchange for being allowed to use unlicensed
devices. You can't prevent 802.11 signals from
"Floating" into your space, and more than you
prevent interfering 2.4 GHz emissions from your
Microwave oven (operating under Part 18 rules in
the *same* spectrum) from floating across the
hallway and interfering with your neighbor's
wireless AP. You *would* be responsible if your
microwave oven was faulty and operating outside
of the specifications (and it would be a healthy
thing for you to fix!) but... as long as you're
operating in spec, you don't need to refrain
from operating your microwave oven. Take a look
at the dispute from 2001 over Fusion lights
RF-powered lighting systems to see where this is
going:
http://www.bwianews.com/2001/11/part-18-rf-lighting-potential.html
by mstrauss
by wwwebster
by nbpqsecofr
by cwoolley
by caryxander
by unixwolf.edu
Okay... we have lots of analogies to reading unused newspapers, sneaking into drive-thru theatres and hunting on unposted land. I can think of others, like watching TV through a neighbour's windows, having to fence in your yard (i.e. implementing security) to avoid liability with a backyard pool. The list goes on... All interesting and conscience provoking, but is "WLAN piggybacking illegal"?
Mentioned were the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (18 United States Code ? 1030) and the UK's Computer Misuse Act. Have these ever been used against unauthorized WLAN users?
Has anyone ever been caught and charged? (Yes, I realise this is new territory without a great deal of precedence.)
As far as I know, there has only been one case were a WiFi piggy-backer was charged. I believe it was in the Toronto (Canada) area, where police officer patrolling a residential area noticed that a man in parked car using a laptop wasn't wearing pants. (I can't find a URL to this story... if you have please post!)
If you want people like this in your neighbourhood, leave your routers unsecured!
by wwwebster
Oh, yeah, now I know...
substitute 'gun owner' for every instance of 'driver' (in your post), and you are parroting what (we) law-abiding, gun owners have been saying for years.
You are correct, of course.
by notoriousdog
If you saw a car unlocked (with the keys in it - for a more accurate analogy), would it be alright to take it for a spin? If you leave the house unlocked, the trespasser is not excused. You may not be doing anything malicious, but you still don't have permission to be there.
Most people don't understand what we take for granted. The network you used most likely belongs to someone who doesn't know what they're doing. You shouldn't take advantage of that. An unsecured WLAN is not a free public access point.
by bmcombrw
by cactus pete
by bmcombrw
There was at least one case in the old days of the Internet where someone found a telnet service open, connected to the host, and actually did some kind of damage. The perpetrator got off scot free because the owner of the telnet site did not specify in their login banner that access to the site was limited to authorized users only.
If your car breaks down in the boonies and land owner boundaries are not clearly marked nor are there any No Trespassing signs about, I doubt you could be prosecuted for taking a shortcut to a service station across ground that could be, for all you know, public land. And, since my little walk will likely not affect the land I'm traveling through, I don't even think there is a moral obligation to track down the nearest land owner's house (assuming I can tell that the land I want to traverse relates to the house) to let someone know what I'm doing. (Might be smart, though - it might be illegal for the land owner to shoot me in these circumstances, but that doesn't help me if I'm dead.)
by cactus pete
It is entirely possible that you are illegally trapsing through public land when your car broke down. Ignorance of a local ordinance is no excuse for having violated it. A public land might be deemed offlimits, say, during the mating season of an endangered species that lives there. No signs are necessary...
Now, just because it's illegal doesn't mean that you'll be prosecuted, either. Every once in a while, common sense about an issue or circumstance trumps regulations and even if you're caught, you don't get charged.
So what does that mean? Not much, I suppose.
by bywhatnow
by cactus pete
by bmcombrw
by joekool24601
by todd
The answer is no, you are not doing anything wrong.
Every server used on the internet, allows pass through traffic (Information that is meant for someone else?s server but still goes through yours ?remember why/how the internet came to be), even if that information is secured (encrypted/VPN). Actually that?s why business use encryption to prevent other server operators that like to ?ease drop? on the line from finding out the information being transmitted through their systems etc...
IF there is no security or authentication for a wireless access point, it would be the same as plugging your computer into an internet connection that was wired. IF they want to charge for it, or make money on it (ISP) then they should have security or authentication active, that would prevent you from connecting to their server, without security or authentication it is not trespassing, it?s rightaway.
by mhasf
Ok, you are using someone's property and possibly bandwidth that they pay for. So it is tantamount to stealing. Think of the old cable service where they only used filters that were easily removed, and thus opened up services you were not paying for.
So you say, "well... if the guy (or gal) is stupid enough to leave his net unsecured, then he/she deserves what they get!"
OK, so you walk buy someone's house and notice that they have some really cool potted plants in front. They are not chained to the concrete so you figure they are now community property.
Having said that, there are a few issues here:
1. Damn the Wireless Hardware companies for not including an auto-secure feature for the less technical. Even a capability to ask for a simple key during install, like your drivers license number, or something like that.
2. Those of us in the know should, if we can, let that person know that their front door is wide open.
by bhunsinger
How fast you are going on a road affects everyone on it! It may be you God and the Cops when there's no traffic but every driver has a responisiblity to avoid colloisions. I drive 5 miles over the speed limit to pass trucks in the left lane. Am I being 'rude' to those who want to drive 80 mph? I think its rude when they hover 10 feet behind me.
Oof, that button was the one inserted by the manager of the Driving school I work at part time.
by myndkrime
In the words of Dennis Miller " I hate to get on to a rant here but".......
From what I have read on the subject there are NO laws barring you from doing this, so you are not breaking the law. As long as you are just using their AP and not trying to break their WLAN or their systems. I have experimented and did a little wardriving, with just a laptop and a Cisco 350 external wireless card, no additional antenna, I am able to pick up APs galore with no security settings, even more disturbing it that a majority of them have ALL the DEFAULT settings intact. I read in a previous post who is responsible for these, and splitting the percentage of blame on vendor, ISP, and user. Let's put it in simple terms...IT IS THE USERS FAULT. If you purchase a car drive it then leave the keys when you leave it, would you be surprised if your car was stolen? Take personal responsibility, if you purchase the equipment you should know what the implications are if it is not setup correctly. Received a wireless AP from an ISP, did they stick a gun to your head to install it? NO you chose to install it, same with all the other users who think there is nothing to it and that have the mentality " That won't happen to me" when see accounts of people hacking into systems.....How do you think they are getting into these systems? YES UNSECURE NETWORKS..
Is is legal, NO LAW AGAINST IT
Should you use it, If they don't secure it is open range....
Should you notify the person? You can inform them if you would like but it seems that most of the time the good samaritan trying to advise of network weaknesses is often the person who is getting charged or arrested for bringing this to light.......
Bob:
This is, apparently, being done. The folks mentioned in the report below are comitting fraud. If I were to do this in my home, which is not an advertised WiFi Hot Spot, and you were to use it... I suppose you are transmitting your information (willingly and uninvited) into my home. I suppose I could sniff away. (If I did anything with it, that would definitely be a crime.)
Interesting...
http://news.com.com/2100-7349_3-5545355.html
'Evil twin' could pose Wi-Fi threat
Published: January 21, 2005, 10:51 AM PST
By Dan Ilett
Special to CNET News.com
TrackBack Print E-mail TalkBack
Researchers at Cranfield University are warning that "evil twin" hot spots, networks set up by hackers to resemble legitimate Wi-Fi hot spots, present the latest security threat to Web users.
Attackers interfere with a connection to the legitimate network by sending a stronger signal from a base station close to the wireless client, turning the fake access point into a so-called evil twin.
by mmoran3180
by cactus pete
But let's say that tomorrow there is a parade in front of your house. You put out the lawn furniture at the sidewalk to reserve you rightful place in front of your own home.
I'm from out of town, and don't know about the parade, and you're the first person to have put out the chairs... At the moment, you're just on your way back to the house for more stuff to put out, and I can't see you.
So I take these very nice looking chairs - practically brand new!
But you wouldn't blame me, would you, even if you saw me driving away with your next load of chairs... I found them where they don't belong...
So the analogy doesn't quite hold. If you don't have any strong evidence that it is likely to be free, you shouldn't take it.
by geoffnathan
by cactus pete
Your example is for reading what is broadcast.
That's it.
When you reply to it and use the service back through the owner's property, you have then violated the law.
That would be like shooting the dear [non-fatally] off of the property, then following it back onto the property to finish it off.
by jtakiwi
by djunia
just a whole lot less visible.
There are security standards published all over the place as well as IT audit/control requirements. They make this situation much clearer.
The reason security folk require log in banners is that they identify both your wired and wireless networks are private and that you will (or won't) prosecute. You cannot pass most IT audits without findings if you don't use these. In most states, you cannot prosecute if you don't use these. There are arguments in the security/audit community over whether the identity of the network owner should be in the banner, since that can help the bad guys, but the banner is essential.
When I work with companies that have wireless networks, I recommend that wireless services be tied to their VPN. That makes it simplest to keep wanderers out.
I would not log in to an unknown network, wired or wireless. There are folk out there setting up trap networks that will capture all of your activity. Not a lot and not likely in an office building, but it is something to consider. Also, the folk who own the wireless (and, eventually, wired) network can also capture everything you do over their connection. They pay for the bandwidth and the internet connectivity, so you are "borrowing" a cup of internet without permission. For everyone who has had to deal with bandwidth limitations, that can be significant.
It is wrong to use someone else's network without permission. Your connection from the lobby was wireless, but that becomes wired very quickly. You would not step into their office and pick up the phone without asking.
Finally, if they are that poorly secured, I would worry about what sort of malware is floating around their net. Good security goes both ways.
by caryxander
by jtakiwi
by andypiesse9
by ron.riley
Your right, the FCC says you can LISTEN or RECEIVE unsecured radio freq's. BUT YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO TRANSMIT ON THEM WITHOUT A LEGAL LIC.
If you use the unsecured wireless net to so much as connect to the unsecured network, YOUR DEVICE IS TRANSMITTING. Which is Illegal.
See my other comment: "How is this different" below.
by buschman_007
I know it's no excuse, but I'd bet a good chunk of those unsecured networks are coming from the homes and offices of those unaware of the danger. Perhaps they don't understand the risk involved in wireless networking. Many think Wi-Fi is as harmless as their TV remote. Just a way to get internet access without wires.
So in this respect hijacking is somewhat like taking candy from a a baby. ;)
Mike
by foulere
by andypiesse9
by mikercol
Looking only at the ethical side of this qustion I'll propse a hypothetical situation.
I'm an IT Director with 500 people reporting to me through 15 Managers. I'm interviewing you for a position filling an open Network Admin Manager postion. My 3rd question during the interview is a hypotheical question.
"You were waiting in the lobby because you had arrived 15 minutes early for the interview. You opened your laptop computer to check some notes you had made in your preinterview research and find that your computer has found an unsecured AP. Is it ok for you to use the AP for your own personal needs."
If your answer dose not match up with the posts you have made previously you might want to reevaluate some of your choices.
by cactus pete
by buschman_007
I agree this is an interesting moral/ethical dilemma.
You can think of hundreds or somewhat relavent anaolgies for hijacking. The field(w or w/o tresspassing sign) is a good one. What about a dollar bill? I mean legal tender is publically traded. But if I see a dollar bill on the ground that doesn't mean it's my dollar. legally is it stealing? I don't think so. Are you morally obligated to try and find it's owner? Is it ethical to take it?
Very much a grey area.
Personally I don't have a huge problem with it. When my cable modem was down, I used my neigherbors unsecured access point. Just simple surfing, nothing devious. But I did feel guilty while doing it. So I guess somewhere down deep I don't feel it's right. Even though I didn't misuse, I did somewhat take advantage of their ignorance. Or at least that's my assumption. Maybe they are aware of the risks and just don't care if others use their bandwidth.
No clear answer for this one.
Mike
by jeremys
It is still theft, no matter where you leave you chair(s). Just like your car, even when it is on the other side of the city, it is still your property.
I still think hijacking implies a malicious act. There is a difference between sitting in their lobby talking to a friend on MSN and parked in an alley behind the company downloading DVDs. Personally I think it has more to do with intent.
by tradergeorge
In general, I agree with your philosophy on theft. But who decides where to draw the line? You say it is okay to IM or email, but not okay to download DVDs. That is kind of like saying that it is okay to steal $100 but not $1 mil........The line will differ with different people.
I do not think you would appreciate 1000 people all instant messaging on your network when you are trying to download, but by your philosophy, none of them individually would be doing anything wrong.
The best way to test a theory is to carry it to its worst case scenario and see if the premise is still valid. Here you can see, it is not.
I don't think it's hijacking per se but I don't think it's the right thing to do either. Hijacking to me (IMO) usually means that the connection has been taken over and the owner locked out.
When I find an unsecure WLAN I make an effort to educate the owner of that connection about the dangers of an unsecure & open connection.
by cactus pete
by buschman_007
It's called being inconsiderate! I'm all for you obeying the law to the letter. But to sit in the left lane for miles before your "left exit" *rolleyes* is purely inconsiderate. You don't care if you inconvenience others. I think your indifference to your fellow man is more of a disservice to those around you than breaking the speed limit by 5 mph.
Mike
p.s. It feels so good to finally say that to a person like yourself. :)
by cactus pete
Breaking does, in fact, affect the road.
Ever notice the bumpiness of a street just where the traffic light is? This is usually caused by trucks breaking for lights - their weight pushes the asphalt into ripples.
by dcperich
by buschman_007
Fuel efficency is not based solely on speed. At reasonable speeds gearing and an engines power curve play a much bigger role in fuel efficiency than speed. At higher speeds(like over 100mph) wind resistance plays a much bigger role in mpg do to the eingine wasting a lot of power to just push through the wind. But at speeds under 70 mph it's all about the engine/gearing configuration.
Acceleration wastes far more gas than maintaining speed. So in essence, you driving at or below the speed limit, forcing drives to slow down and then quickly accelerate around you... is wasting more gas than if you politely moved over and let them by.
Mike
by dcperich
by ron.riley
How is this different then:
1) Your neighbor plugging his electric lawn mover into your outdoor outlet to cut his lawn. Because the outlet doesn't have a lock.
2) Someone coming into your house to get warm or use the bathroom because you left the door open.
3) People coming into your back yard and eating food you are growing on fruit trees or a garden, because you didn't lock the gate.
4) Your neighbor using your garden hose to water his lawn or wash his car. Because the spiket wasn't locked.
If it's illegal for the Govt. to tap your phone line without a court order. What makes you think it IS legal to tap into a wireless network just because you can.
This reasoning says, if I can BREAK INTO a network, through some means that the owner hasn't been able to protect themselves againest. Either due to lack of knowledge or $$$ to buy security software/hardware. Then it's OK!
Then it must be OK for a crook to break into your house or rob you, because HE CAN and you didn't do everything possible to prevent it. Same thought process. But when YOU are the Victim, it will be a totally different story. A thief is a thief. The amount and how it's done doesn't matter.
Anyone that has setup a wireless network knows that by default the security items are TURNED OFF in the network devices. The average home user too cheap to pay someone knowledgeable to perform the setup, is going to get others connecting to their network. But probably won't even know it.
They could have hired ME, but........
by unclerob
From a personal point of view (point of view? what's that? nothing like that ever pops up around here!) I don't think accessing the internet using access provided by an unsecured WLAN is illegal. The access point is providing a signal which it's owner hasn't secured and therefore he isn't restricting access to outside users. When you setup a WLAN, the onus of responsibility to ensure that your wireless network is secure is placed on you since the equipment is yours, you set it up & maintain it, pay for the electricity that powers it, purchased the equipment that uses it (wlan cards for you & your users, wireless access point to distribute the signal, and the internet access service you pay for). Security is a form of insurance and it's a choice you have to make, if you're not willing to insure yourself & your users from would-be users that accidentally discover that they can access your WLAN and it's resources (one of which being internet access) than the fault is yours alone. Ethics is the real question here, is it ethical to use someone else's wireless internet access? Things tend to be more concrete & finite when the resources are tangible. In this case people can argue all day long that a wireless signal is tangible or it isn't. If it's a tangible resource, then you can argue it's stealing but you could also argue the point of why it's not secure to begin with and why should unsecure wireless signals be broadcast in a public place - maybe that could be viewed as an invasion of your personal privacy (being bombarded by wireless signals in the 802.11b-g range - of course I'm being facetious). But if you argue that it's an intangible resource than there's no harm done in accessing the internet using someone else's WLAN.
I read a post by someone at softwarelaw that quotes that this type of access could be construed as unlawful but I doubt you could get a charge like that to stick. The internet is a global resource and as such a specific country's laws may not always be applicable. Give you an example, DirectTV satelite service is broadcast to U.S. subscribers who pay for the service, but the service is broadcast globally because it's provided by satelite and as such anyone who buys a directtv dish and pirates an access card can get the service for free, people in Canada have been doing it for years. DirectTV found that it was losing money because of all this unauthorized use of it's service and attempted to sue canadians who were selling DirectTV hardware in Canada. From what I remember they weren't all that successful because even though their signals were being broadcast into another country and people were pirating the service, they didn't have a license to operate and sell that service in Canada and couldn't contain the service to the continental U.S. and as such couldn't doing anything about stopping the pirating of it's service. What do they do then, they zap everyone's machine with a signal to bring down the pirater's machines, both legit & non-legit users. Legit users have to call DirectTV to get the service running again. Although this example deals with a signal reaching another country which is another ball of wax, the bottom line is this, they broadcast a signal to everyone not just their intended subscribed users and people took advantage of that.
There's a lot of people that don't pay for cable either because they're cheap or poor or whatever and have a tv with antenna and watch whatever tv signals they can get a hold of, don't think it's illegal although they could technically be construed as stealing tv service without paying for it. But why bother, these people just took advantage of a resource that was available.
What if someone (again I'm being smart a$$ here) invents a fresh air machine for their personal area and you walk by and breath in some of this fresh air, did you steal that service without paying for it or did you just take advantage of an intangible resource and didn't hurt anyone in the process.
I tend to be verbose and everyone fell asleep after reading this I'm sure. I don't think it's illegal if you kept your use restricted to internet access and didn't try to hack into their network and destroy or steal data, keep your use ethical (the pundits will cry out that this is unethical) and don't worry too much about it.
Maybe one day they'll discover that all of these radio waves floating about unrestricted had some bad effect on everyone's health and at that point you'll be able to sue someone/everyone for the health problems it caused.
Bottom line, if you have a WLAN and didn't secure it from unauthorized outside access then you have provided free internet access to those that discovered it was available and shouldn't be mad at those people that made use of your resource. If you don't want to be an impromptu wireless ISP for strangers, secure your WLAN and be done with it.
Who knows maybe one day in the future people will look back and laugh at a discussion on this issue because in the end accessing the internet on someone's WLAN isn't really that big a deal. I wish people would make a bigger deal about all the spam we get in our inboxes, and hackers that break into banks and steal peoples money. Get the lawmakers to crack down on those types of issues.
This was a good discussion, I welcome any replies for or against my points but please keep it clean and don't attack me for my opinions - one guy went ape on me for my "liberal" point of view in another TR discussion and that's not good for anyone. CHEERS!
by cactus pete
Not having bought insurance against theft does not permit the theft. So that analogy doesn't work for me.
[That leaves you to have to prove it was a theft of something in the first place in order to say someone wronged you.]
Likewise, your DirecTV analogy doesn't work. By your logic, anyone can read the SSID all they want, capture any packets that are broadcast and read them to their hearts' content. However, once you reply back and request specific use and information, you have crossed the line.
by eramos
To avoid the "who do you think I am, insulting my intelligence" attitude, try going to them to thank them for providing wifi in the lobby as a service to visitors.
If it was intentional they'll say thanks, if it wasn't, they shouldn't feel you thought them negligent.
by mike fahey
OK, let's accept the notion of the frequencies in question being free for public use, and think of it as a national park. However, the park has to be accessed by some means, either a trail, road or land owned by a public entity [local, state or federal] or over private property contingent to it.
The public entity can set restrictions on access or use through regulations, and generally posts signs to inform potential users of the limits of use. Private landowners can choose to permit or not permit the public to access the park, and have the same right and responsibility to do so, including giving notice.
In fact, in real estate law, if a landowner makes no effort to post the limits of use, and the public establishes a path, trail or road for access across the property and uses it for a specified length of time [15 years in some states], without objection from the landowner, a public easement is created under law, and the land owner loses the right to limit access to the easement. Now depending on the state, and how strongly property rights are viewed, especially in rural areas, if a property owner puts up a fence 15 years later and a sign prohibiting use, the public must appeal his action in court to protect the easement as a permanent feature.
To trespass for the sole purpose of access to public facilities is not generally considered an enforceable misdemeanor unless the property owner specifically posts the land. Since the primary issue Ned raises is access, not theft or harm of physical or intellectual property, the biggest issue is the cost of use, which the owner of the system bears. It can be argued that that owner [business or personal] should protect his/her/its interests by limiting use to control the cost, or charging a fee for use, but if they do not, then it is free, albeit a potentially unintended gift. No harm, no foul, and no ethical issue unless the system is otherwise misused by the person who connects to it.
In summary, every right under law carries with it a responsibility that is inseparable. Failure for whatever reason to exercise that responsibility [negligence] can and will reduce the value of the granted right accordingly, and can create a liability when misused. A similar burden is placed on the owner and the user. Fair and equitable, best kind of law there is.
Of course, this all hangs on enforcement, which is a separate issue of power to assert and protect rights granted, which is really another discussion...
by cactus pete
Your argument requires that there be no posted usage limits prior to the publicly established path.
here's where i see a difference in what you see:
The SSID is a fence. It is reasonable to expect that a fence denotes a limit of use. For the publc to hop the fence, they must do so knowingly. No single, permenant path is contructed that all the public follow.
The SSID says "this is the beginning of my property" even though it does not say "You cannot use it" you nevertheless must knowingly chose to ignore the established parameters.
by blarman
Given that the spectrum is in the public domain, and that it is accessible via the lobby (a public portion of a company's premises), and that no efforts have been made to secure it from public use, the proper legal assumption is that the access is there for public use or as a service to the customer/public. If one had any doubts, they could be relayed to the front-desk. But I don't think I'd have any ethical compulsions about invasion of someone else's network.
I would very much liken it to if the lobby provided a network in the lobby for potential clients to plug into which gave them access. You would know that these were explicitly set up for this purpose - or at least be highly justified in the assumption. I would feel comfortable making that same assumption here as well.
by cactus pete
Generally speaking, hotels charge you for everything. And a lot. Once in a whilethey provide an amenity for their patrons to invite them to stay there as opposed to a competitor - something like free internet access.
You aren't the intended target, but it is free, andthey undoubtedly know it. [A hotel always makes decisions first by saying "What can I charge for this?"]
True, it's not 100% ethical, but they knowingly made this decision, so I doubt they mind.
And just curious, what does the access page state?
by tradergeorge
To me, this is a relatively simple question.
If you walk into almost any hotel/motel in the morning, you can usually (with exceptions)walk unmolested into the breakfast buffet and eat your fill. You could justify this in a lot of ways, perhaps by saying that it was their fault for being "unsecure", or that the buffet was there for "visiting guests".
The only real question here is whether YOU were authorized to use the network, or would have been if the owner were asked before you accessed it.
Even if all you are stealing is a little bit of bandwidth, it is still theft.
by cactus pete
by mintond
I was in London last week on business and a friend of mine asked me to come over and take a look at her system and see if I could fix it. When I went over I found her dsl was down and I had a few technical questions that could only be answered if I could get on line. So I powered up my laptop and I started using the good old modem and a land line to connect to the net. Well low and behold my laptop connected to a wireless network without even trying I looked and the network and noticed it was a linksys system and just for s and g's used the default IP and password and I was in the router. I then looked at the DHCP client list and found the names of the computers which matched the next door neighbors name. So what did I do. I did the honest thing and knocked on the door and informed them what they needed to do to close the open door they left open. The main reason if someone decided to use that connection to set up a kiddy porn site then they would be responsible. Most people just love the plug and play and don't realize how opened there systems are. So I just did some education.
DM
Sort by Trending