Discussion Locked

Cyberbullying versus free speech

0 helpful
142 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2007/02/12/school-facebook.html

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20070213.FACEBOOK13/TPStory/TPNational/Ontario/

This is juts 30km north of me...

Long story short - students get upset at ban of cells/pagers/other devices in school and blame principal of school (school board policy BTW).

Kids go onto social networking site and make comments, turning into something pretty nasty (some of the comments suggest he should suck some part of the male anatomy). Kids get suspended, though their punishment is less than if they had said the same things about a fellow student(board cyberbullying policy).

The kids have been all over the news saying this isn't fair, that they have the right to free speech and since it wasn't posted from school grounds the school has no right to interfere.

To me this is the classic free speech/responsibility challenge. The students are wrong to think that something that they do outside of school, but that affects the atmosphere of the school, cannot be held against them. If I slander my employer from my home, they can fire me. The students somehow think that they have the right to say whatever they want without consequences.

Now some students may have been caught in a wide net because the school board doesn't understand the technology. The student council president was a member of the group(he was invited by others) but did not post anything at all, and was suspended with the rest.

Frankly I think these kids are the enemies of free speech and fair comment. If they had used the forum to debate the fairness of the cell phone ban, I'd be all for it(though I agree with the ban, I like open debate). But their personal abusive attacks cannot be let pass.

James

142 replies

by stress junkie

Placing libel and slander outside of the scope of free speech is generally accepted.

The debatable issue here is whether the school had any jurisdiction to impose punishment. On the one hand I don't think that the school has jurisdiction but on the other hand no other authority would do anything if the issue was brought to them. So are we going to grant the school jurisdiction for convenience or practicality? Yes, I think so. We should understand the precedent that's being established though. We are saying that the civil authority that has jurisdiction would probably not respond so we find a more convenient and accommodating authority that does not have jurisdiction to punish the offenders.

Let me be clear about my own position. I am very happy that the school board took punitive action in this case.

by jamesrl

They have in the past done automatic 20 day suspensions. What they are suggesting is what is going on in cyberspace is an extension of whats going on in school and vice versa. The bullying may start in school and continue in cyberspace.

Its a tricky issue. Libel and slander aren't always part of the bullying. The bullying may be something like " Debbie is ugly and stupid and has no friends" - that may be bullying but not libel/slanderous. But if you say it on school grounds you can and will be suspended (my kids are in this school board and I've read the rules).

The school is a catholic school and has a code of conduct for its students.

James

by neon samurai

The students proved that they could not responsibly carry mobile phones too and from class so mobiles phones where banned.

They responded by behaving in a way that no parent or professional setting would tolorate (or hopefully wouldn't anyhow).

They then go to the media with an outcry because they are held accountable for there actions.

They seem to think that freedom of speech somehow outweighs the other person's freedom from hurrassment.

Now, the part that puts a grin on my face; it's out there. They will push the issue, get publicity and generally over-dramatise the situation. They can't take it back. They can't delete it. And, they are drawing attention too it so the news and there names attached to it become publicised on other websites. I think they should be held accountable and I expect they won't remember the stupid decision fondly when it starts effecting there futures. Students who have done the same are already having stupid highschool decisions haunt them in future job and school applications.

As for the school. I think they need to based punishments on factual evidence of who was involved not just the linked list of names for the overall groups. Unfortunately, school is a political organization focused on manufacturing not a place of education. The parents will push from one side and the school board may cave. The board will push from the other side and over-react with too large a net and too heavy a hammer.

No one is going to truly win this one.

by inkling

If you support free speech that means you have to suffer the things you do not like/want to hear along with the things you do like/want to hear. I served in the military and consider myself to be very patriotic, but I am against the banning of flag burning, etc, even though I find it distasteful.

I don't think the school has any right to punish these students regardless of how vulgar the comments are. If school resources were not used, or if this was not done on school time then tough.

If threats were made that is a different story, but vulgarities are not in and of themselves threatening. I personally find it absurd that anyone gets offended by "curse words" anyway. What is the difference between me saying the "f-word" or saying "CRAP"? The meaning is the same when used in the right context aren't they? And is it not the meaning of the word that is offensive?

I would expect that the principal would alert the parents of these children to what their kids were doing, but that is about the extent of their legal recourse in my opinion.

I don't think kids should be using any of the banned devices in school, but unless the school offers telephones for their children to call home if they need to (after sports, etc. - I personally had to use a pay phone when I was in High School) then I don't think cell phones should be banned altogether.

The day a school tries to parent my child will be the day my child starts home schooling.

by deepsand

In fact, parents have not only demanded such, but sued schools for failing to so act! Given the choice between pissing off the students vs the parents, the choice for the schools is clearly obvious.

And, for those too young to have experienced it, most colleges had official [i]in loco parentis[/i] policies until the end of the '60s and early '70s.

by jdclyde

Sorry, but individuals do NOT have a free right to say anything they want.

Freedom of speech is to keep unpopular political speech from being silenced.

This is not free speech that is protected.

People give up certain rights in a civilized society, and crude/abusive expression such as in this case is one such thing that is given up in CIVILIZED nations.

You CAN say it, but you are not free from retribution, such as getting fired from your job or suspended from school.

by dumphrey

is the defining characteristic of any freedom.

"Sorry, but individuals do NOT have a free right to say anything they want."

Well, we do have a right to say what we want, we do not have a right to be immune from consequences of said speech. (Which is what you stated in your last sentance).

Seems to me it comes down to the "harm principle", meaning we have a right to say what we wish (in the sense that its impossible to remove the ability without violating many other rights), but that right is only protected in as much as our words do not cause harm to another. This is where it gets tricky. What does harm mean? A bruised ego? Financial loss? Hurt feelings?
This is where I get stuck on the issue.

by locrian_lyric

The only places it can be restricted is when it is part of another act, such as shouting "FIRE" in a crowded theater if you are not an actor on stage or there is no fire.

by tonythetiger

that this was a Catholic school, which I assume means not run by the government. The "free speech" laws don't necessarily apply, though there may be some contractual issues.

by oz_media

The school is not playing parent, they are protecting their own best interests.

The Crime:
They are liable for defamation of character, in this case the principal is tamtamaount to the school's ability to encourage new student and is a key part in how the school is seen from the outside.

Acceptance: (if this was was in the USA)
First Ammendment:
Free speech does NOT entitle you to say what you want, when you want. It merely stops the government from passing a law against you excercising your freedoms of expression and religious faith.

"...that expressly prohibits the United States Congress from making laws "respecting an establishment of religion" (the Establishment Clause) or that prohibit the free exercise of religion (the Free Exercise Clause), laws that infringe the freedom of speech, infringe the freedom of the press, limit the right to peaceably assemble, or limit the right to petition the government for a redress of grievances."

In other words, you can call Bush a prick and as long as you don't stop traffic or cause any harm to anyone, it's okay.

Nothing in there says you can say what you want, where you want, it's just that the government can't pass a law in order to shut you up.

Hate speech, and defamation of character are still punishable crimes, while this is not really HATE SPEECH, I'll agree with you there, it IS defamation of character, in written form thus Libel.

It is a crime, and they should rightly be punished for it. The measely few days out of school is no punishment for most kids, but I suppose these kids will say how much they stand to lose from it and try to play the big man role before losing.

We had many pay phones in school and if you parent needs you to check in after classes, (a ridiculous claim to begin with) then the school office, with a note from the parent, will gladly oblige.

There is no reason a child needs a teleohone in school, there are adminstrative staff that will help in the case of emergency.

There is no reason for a kid to be able to text while in school, none at all.

There is no reason for a kid to need a PDA to organize his day in school, they provide schedules and if you can't leaarn what classes to go to and when, then you will need ot be on the short bus and will get help accordingly.

When you were in school, there were payphones, how many times was it imperative taht you used one? Not for buying dope or finding out where teh party was that night, or checkign in to see what's for dinner but actual need to contact your parents, where anoter phone was not available to you?

Ever?

Yeah, we don't need phones.

As is demonstrated by these morons, who are supposedly good students, they need to focus a lot mroe on learning than calling. They don' teven understand teh difference between the US Bill of Rights and the Canada's adherence to the International Human Rights Act.

My only argument is that they shouldn't be suspended, the 'kin morons should have to attend school overtime until they are not so stupid.

by tink!

[i]the 'kin morons should have to attend school overtime until they are not so stupid. [/i]

I agree with that Oz. Since when is Suspension a bad thing to bad kids? They don't have to go to school? Oh no!

Suspensions hurt kids who are good students, and work hard on attendance records and such.

Whatever happened to detentions and making the bad kids do extra school work? Or do community service with the janitor? Is it because the adults don't want to have to spend the extra time supervising them in this type of punishment anymore?

by neon samurai

Suspension is the worst that happened too them? That's lucky I figure.

The school had a code of conduct which was agreed too and broken by the students. They chose to attend the school provided by the catholic school board instead of the school provided by the public school board. Anywhere I've seen a catholic school, there has been a public school also available for all us non-catholic heathons.

Suspension is definately getting off easy. In a work environment it would have been expulsion; here's your last pay, that's the door.

I know for my kid, time off for bad behavior wouldn't result in sitting around home on vacation until allowed back into school; Especially after drawing that kind of shame through clearly unacceptable behavior.

by now left tr

"their personal abusive attacks cannot be let pass"

I can cite / read / been involved in a few TR momments when this kind of behaviour was allowed to pass, with no person taking action. Perhaps we should all take heed here!

by jamesrl

Here at TR we can all have our moments and move on - you can chose to stay or leave.

But the postings from those students are about people, teachers, that they see and interact with every day. Would that not change the tone a little around the school.

If some of your work collegues did the same thing, posted vulgar obscenities about you, non-anonymously, would that change how you work with them? Is that not a much different thing to insults traded here?

You don't need to come here. You could happily live without the place. But if you poison someone's workplace, thats a different story. Its not so easy to get a new job.

James

by inkling

The same could be said of Facebook James.

The principal didn't have to go look at what was said on the Facebook site.

If, as the Principal of a school, you haven't come to the realization that some of the students won't like you for some of the rules that are enforced, then he needs a serious dose of reality.

What is the principal or any employee of the school doing visiting the Facebook profiles of these children anyway?

Assuming the principal was told of the existence of this discussion...he should have been an adult, realized kids will be kids and not bothered to even look at it.

by jdclyde

can give you a pass or fail.

Schools have to keep discipline and order, or they will not be able to maintain a learning environment.

The schools with the least amount of discipline are also the schools with the least amount of academic success.

Would YOU be allowed to do such against your boss, and still hope to keep your job? [b]Think[/b] about it, instead of reacting on emotion.

by jamesrl

The principal was told by other staff.
Presumably the staff found out from students, not all of whom agreed with the tone of the site.

I think what it might help you to know is that each student has to sign a code of conduct to be registered at the school. The school has the right to deny access to the child if they don't sign - its a Catholic school. The postings clearly violate the code of conduct.

Free speech is not unlimited. I don't have the right to slander or libel, incite a riot, promote violent hatred (in Canada at least). What we are balancing here is the right of the school to enforce a code of conduct versus the right of the kids to free speech.

And its a little more than a group of profiles on Facebook - they created a group specifically with the principals name in it, to denegrate the principal. That goes beyond an individual's musings.

James

by inkling

If it's a private school and the children and parents sign a code of conduct that governs behavior outside of school...then the kids knew full well they could get in trouble for it and deserve to be punished.

Still, if I were a teacher or staff member of a high school and one of the students came to me about this, I seriously doubt I would even bother to give it a look.

While it may be inappropriate for the kids to act in this manner, kids WILL be kids, and if no threats were made then it is a non-issue in my opinion.

by nicknielsen

Would kids then still "be kids" or would you recommend appropriate punishment?

Would you rethink your attitude if you thought that such a group could possibly incite an individual to violence? Even if unintentionally?

At the very least such postings would be prejudicial to good order and discipline, even in a public school

by side_ally

im a student and i came upon this site after researching the topic

but come on ... free speech is Voicing your opinions ? like we are now ? and I think you?ve all forgot how crippling teen life is ? I think this form of bullying is a way of releasing the pressure of teen life ? if bagging out a teacher or a principal gives you a sense of security or power then so be it ? if they care about what a student thinks of them then they really are in the wrong career ? think of where the students are coming from or what they might be feeling ? I think the youth needs away of blowing of steam and getting it off there chest ? I would rather have offended teachers than emotionally challenged students

by homusonline

I have actually heard that from people regarding these situations. Scary part is they were serious, and questioned nothing about it.

In my area, we have dealt with hazings of all sorts as well as postings on MySpace, Facebook, and others. These things tend to be a balancing act at best, perspective ignorance in others.

I have actually seen the media come out and chastise schools in my area for doing what this school did. Schools range from public to private, but usually the same story. The schools have come out like this and punished students for what they post. These were threats, cyberbullying, and other things directly related to the school. The school was fried in the public eye for infringing on the students right to free speech. And all the students, parents and lawyers stated the school had no business reading these or punishing anyone because of such postings.

Then there have been stories where students have posted about these hazing rituals and cyberbullying. The school was not aware of these postings. The parents and media immediately fried the school again, stating that they have a responsibility to the kids and their safety. The public clearly felt that the schools were negligent for not stopping these things from happening. They have also said that threats and other postings, whether made on campus or not, that directly relate to the school should be dealt with.

No matter what seems to come of these, the school is the big loser every time. For some unknown reason, everyone shifts responsibility from the children and parents onto the school, both for action or inaction. And thanks to the holy power of the lawsuit in the US, most of these people act without remorse or responsibility, and this is a direct result of it. My favorite was a kid who was expelled for "finding" a pellet gun in a garbage can. He hid the gun, and was caught with it. The parents, student and of course the legal team, all claimed that the student was going to bring it to the attention of the school (but he did hide the gun). That he did not warrant expulsion as he was, of course, in the process of doing the right thing, and that the school was at fault for not understanding that. Even the reporter did not buy it. I figure pretty shortly, I should be able to do any illegal thing I want, so long as I think about doing the right thing at the time.

I remember getting detentions and Saturday schools for intercepted notes and various things that were found and read by the school. These kids are posting these thoughts and expressions on a public web-site. If they believe it is private enough that the school has no right to it, do not post it on a public web page. These kids do have the right to free speech, and as such can enjoy the responsibility inherant in freedom.

I do believe the school has the right to check MySpace, facebook, and any other blog and webspace. These may be private thoughts, but are published in a public place, and are therefore public domain. The school should set about boundaries, though, and have policy for handling these situations. Both to protect the children, and the school itself. These websites should be handled no differently than a note that was intercepted in class. When informed or these situations are discovered, the school should act. Threats dealt with in kind. Inciting violence or illegal actions outside of school resulting in contacting the parents. And the "principal is a poopy-pants" or "my teacher smells like old cheese" be dismissed as an immature mind attempting to deal with a hormone spike and the over-inflated expections laid upon them.

by netman1958

on the following:
"and I think you?ve all forgot how crippling teen life is"

"I would rather have offended teachers than emotionally challenged students"

It's been a long time since I was a teen, but I don't remember it being that hard at all. In fact, I would jump at the chance to re-live my teen years.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is still bullying.

Split wood. Beat the feathers out of a pillow. Work out. Swim laps.

The behavioral habits you acquire now, in your 'crippling teen years', will follow you into the rest of your life, which, believe it or not, can be equally 'crippling'.

Further, emotionally challenged applies to adults as well as students. Life is a nightmare of an emotional challenge. Get used to it.

by jdclyde

fill in the blank yourself.

It is completely the fault of the parents that came out of the same system that do not know THEIR rights, and so are passing on bad information to their perfect little copies of themselves that they have created.

They don't FEEL it is fair, so it must not be.

I think the parents should be made to sit in the corner, nose to the wall.

by tink!

Yes I know that comes from the Spiderman movies. But hey, it's true. If you are going to have the right (power) to speak as you will, then you must face the fact that responsibility goes hand in hand with that power.

If you are going to say something or do something, then you must realize that there will be reactions to it. Just like physics - for every action there is a reaction. Therefore whomever creates the initial "action" must be prepared to face the "reaction" that follows.

by jdclyde

Did you know you have a RIGHT to free health care? Bah!

They teach people have RIGHTS, but it is not their fault for the responsibilities.

by jck

You sore about that corner. Did they make you wear the dunce cap too? :^0

I went to therapy for my aggression. That's why I advocate sending the parents and kids together to day workcamps so the kids can see how good they have it.

And if they don't work at the camp? Jail.

Sometimes when you wanna ween the baby, ya gotta sour the milk.

Sitting in the corner means being lazy. Make em swing a sledgehammer!! :^0

by jdclyde

and no sitting either.

Face the wall, nose touching it,
hands clasped behind your back,
and stand there......
and stand there......
and stand there......
and stand there......
and stand there......

talk about time standing still.....

The single most influential teacher in my life was my sixth grade teacher. He never used it on me, (he didn't need to) but he had one of those old rubber hot wheels race tracks. You remember, the orange pieces? Whack across the back of your leg got your attention, real quick.

He was two years away from teaching my boys before he retired, or he would have taught three generations.

I had blown off my math homework assignment. So what, give me the "f", what do I care? Well, he made me stay after to finish it. We had pictures that night for basketball, (he was the coach/teacher/principle) so he called my mom and informed her I was staying after, and to pick me up after pictures/practice.

AFTER I did my homework, he took me back to his place where his wife tried to kill me with seconds and thirds of the food before their son pointed out that I had already said "no thank you" to the previous helping she had put on my plate..... :D

Every other teacher before or after didn't care if I got that F or not. He knew I was better than that, and made me step up and BE better than that.

Math is now my easiest subject.

by jamesrl

Many students at a high school will not go on to college or university and will instead commence life in the working world. What a rude shock awaits them if they find they've been coddled and sheltered from real life consequences through their school years.

You can't have it both ways, if you want to be treated like an adult, you have to accept responsibility for you actions, like an adult.

I'm all for voicing an opinion, but bullying is bullying, whether the victim is a teacher or a student. I don't want my kids to learn that bullying is ok if the victim is a teacher.

James

by dumphrey

facebook pages. The details in the links you provided were to vague for me to say if it was bullying or just kids being d!c|

by jamesrl

The principal was called someone who performed oral sex on male genitalia "$#@!sucker".

A spokesperson for the schoolboard called the comments demeaning and "extremely vulgar and very profane".

"Campbell said the comments violated the school's code of conduct, calling the situation "a case of cyber-bullying."

He said if the incident had involved students posting comments about a classmate, it would have been dealt with in the same way."

I'm afraid thats all I could dig up.

James

by dumphrey

since there was no way Facebook would leave them up in the PR storm. But it would be interesting to see if they said he was a *&*&* or if they thought he was a *(&(*^.

In my opinion...
I think...
I feel...

All these make it hard to press libel/slander since you are exressing a belief admittedly your own and not a statement of fact. This is why I was interested in their wording.

But, all that aside, it does seem they violated the terms of their contract with the school, which they ahd the right to refuse, and to find anoher school.

by jdclyde

Heck, we used to have sex. You know, with girls. Real girls. Try it sometime, you might like it.... ;\

Someday, if you work at it, you to can say "I like girls!" B-)

by dumphrey

its not protected under such circumstances rather then restricted. But thats me being picky.

by locrian_lyric

It's not the speech, but the action.

You can shout "FIRE" if you are an actor shouting "Ready, Aim, FIRE!"

You can shout "FIRE" if there is a fire.

So, it's not the word FIRE that's the issue, it's inciting a riot/panic

by oz_media

"The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent."

It is the CONTEXT the WORD is used in that is the issue. If the context is of a nature known to incite a riot, then it is not protected under the first ammendment.

The reason the word is so importasnt is that the example you are referring to was tantamount in determining exactly HOW freedom of speech cannot be applied.

Now THERE's a nitpick for you!

by wayoutinva

needs to do is pull out the signed agreements and get the students & parents who disagree with the punishment to spell out why they should be given a free pass on the breaking of the agreement when everyone else as seen fit to abide by it. What makes them so special..And do it in a public arena..so we can all hear the whinning and flimsy reasoning that will be used to justify their actions. But hey thats just what I would do..

by jdclyde

have them repeat and explain everything they posted.

Then have them explain how it is relevant.

If it is not true, then there is possible liable.

by jdclyde

you do not have a right to not be insulted. The student CAN speak out against the staff, but there are slander laws as well as obscenity laws that they will be subject to, for starters.

by jamesrl

If the student called the teacher a "Bad name" in public, but outside of the school grounds, there isn't much the teacher can do, short of talkingt o the student or parents - no legal recourse.

But publishing it in Facebook is somewhat akin to saying it in the newspaper. Its published, not verbal, carries more weight and potentially more harm.

The school has a right to decide what the rules are for attending the school. The students had to agree in writing to those rules when they signed the agreement, including a no bullying clause. The school then has the right to enforce that contract, up to and including suspensions or expulsions.

James

by tink!

I think you are right in your point here James. Being that these comments are being [b][i]published[/b][/i] upon a public website gives a whole lot more meaning to them.

If these comments were in a chat room between the students, it would not hold so much weight as that is a passing conversation. But when it is posted to a public forum where the posts remain on the site for any and all to see, then you are indeed "publishing" your words and imprinting them as if you were to put them in an ad in the newspaper. It then can be covered by slander laws.

The school should also review its choices of suspendees. If there were people signed up to the forum, but did not post slanderous comments, they should not be considered a part of the guilty. Only the ones who actually made the slandersou comments should be punished.

by tonythetiger

How can they be sure the people listed actually did the deed?

I mean, if I have someone else's picture, I can create a page, say I'm them, then post all kinds of nasty stuff to get them into trouble. This can be caught, by tracing IP addresses, etc., but is the school actually verifying this information?

by oz_media

First of all, it never ceases to amaze me how teh Internet has made so many lawyers out of the unknowing. People in Canada speak with people in America and then start going on about the right to free speech and , this one slays me, pleading the fifth. Not growing up in a politically concious society, Canadians learn abotu politics form Americans and they then assume that US constutional ammendments effect Canadaians. While we DO have a similar bill of rights, we do not base our laws on US Contitutional Ammendments.

As for this case, you are correct that they have been found guilty of defamation of character. But in this case it is considered libel; libel is written defamation, slander is verbal.

IN the case of libel defamation, the damages are assumed, whereas with slander, it is up to the person who has been defamed ot show clearly just how much of a financial loss has been incurred and show specific damages that the verbal assult has put upon him.

Libel is an easier suit because written word, especially on th einternet is quickly absorbed and transferred, the assumed cost is deemed based on the amount of public who has viewed the information.

I say these kids SHOULD be made and example of but a lot more focus should be placed on these laws and how they are applied exactly, and why.

In the couple of issues I've had here with libel defamation, it stands to cost the guy quite a bit in a court room, as this site has a HUGE membership and many peopl efrom all over the world view it, thankfully TR has been very cooperative and went well out of their way to appease the cease and desist requests. I truly thank TR staff for their quick help in resolving these issues.

In Canada our freedom of speech is guaranteed by our adherence to Article 19 of the International Human Rights Law.

While teh US ammendment is focused on how teh government cannot pass a law denying you your freedoms, the IHRL pertains more towards freedoms of thought and expression (though somewhat different than free speech itself).

These kids just got into the mentality that they could say whatever, whenever and it would be protected by a US Ammendment.

As with many US citizens, they also feel that free speech entitles them to say whatever, whenever.

so now that I get this far, I have another question, 'Doesn't it just lok bad for teh school that some of their more honorable students all seem to not udnerstand these basics of Canadian/Human Rights?"

If I was the principal, I think I'd be more embarassed that they were so clueless than what they had actually said about me.

Good ejumakashun! Maybe its a goo dthing that they put away PDA's and cell phones and start paying attention in class instead.

by oz_media

When I was younger you wouldn't DREAM of acting out in class. Mind you, when I hit high school in Canada, it was a joke, people just didn't give a toss about school and the students ran the teachers and classes.

I think teachers should have the ability to knock the little bastards out, that'd change the way they are treated in a hurry. It sure does back in England.

Out here it seems parents send kids to school and teh teachers are slaves who are just paid to baby sit their snot nosed brats and put up with their crap. Gotta love North America, nobody accepts responsibility, kids do what they want and parents get pissed off when their kid is disciplined. No wonder our countries are full of morons that graduate.

by locrian_lyric

It's the attempt to incite a riot/panic.

You can do it with things other than words. If you had five people point, scream and run from a place, chances are you'd have the same result.

by oz_media

First off all, feedom of speech is NOT an absolute right.

Secondly,this takes place in Canada and no first ammendment rights can be applied anyway.

But it doesn't apply in the USA either.

Have you actually read and understood the First ammendment ?

[i]"The First Amendment to the United States Constitution is part of the United States Bill of Rights that [b]expressly prohibits the United States Congress from making laws[/b] "respecting an establishment of religion" (the Establishment Clause) [b]or that prohibit the free exercise of religion (the Free Exercise Clause), laws that infringe the freedom of speech [/b], infringe the freedom of the press, [b]limit the right to peaceably assemble, or limit the right to petition the government for a redress of grievances."[/b]

What laws have been placed upon him that stop him from speaking out about the government? People just keep assuming free speech mans you can say what you want, when you want, it does NOT.

It has NOTHING to do with saying whatever you want, NOTHING AT ALL. Freedom of expression is a different animal altogether and also falls under the same limitations. The fact that there ARE limitations ensures that people cannot assume that freedom of speech is an absolute right.

The fact that it is subject to other limitations means precicesly that Freedom of Speech and freedom of Expression are NOT absolute rights in ANY country.

Time for you to do some learnin I think. it's not just you, millions of Americans and Canadians think the same thing, only to be somewhat dumbfounded when they are fined or jailed for what THEY consider free speech.

by locrian_lyric

The fact that government oppression tramples on rights is irrelevant.

Read the federalist papers some time, VERY enlightening on the subject of rights, liberty, et cetera

by oz_media

Read your own legal system's guidelines regarding the appliication of the first ammedndment in US law. RIGHTS ARE NOT ASSUMED.

Or just give up, you have nothing to say that any sane person should listen to anyway.

You make an incorrect comment, it is corrected with proof and fact from the main source and yet you continue to remble on with your little panty waste replies to the contrary. You even contradicted your original comment with your reply this time, just to make SOMETHING you have said seem SOMEWHAT correct.

by oz_media

Right on teh money wit hthe publish comments but PUBLISHED content is considered LIBEL defamation of character.

Slander if oral or vocal defamation of character, Libel is written.

Libel is FAR easier to punish for and can easily be taken care of with the award being assumed. Slander is much harder to take to court, there needs to be a lot more proof of the exact amount of personal financial loss.

But these kids just got suspended and want it to be an issue because they actually THINK they are right. Just goes to show that they either don't get instructed properly at that school or these kids are too interestd in text and phone calls than they are in learning the most basic of human rights.

by oz_media

I think it is a result of too many prents whining about theur kids being held behind after school and how the school has no right to do that.

Maybe its time we let the schools satrp and cane kids again, perhaps both parents AND students would get the picture that the school is an institution for people to learn, not a playground for kids to learn how to constantly push the limits and complain about their rights being infringed upon.

if I had done that when I was a kid, the world would have stopped spinning. My parents would have been the first people to waltx me down to teh school to apologize for my behaviour and would have let the school deal with it accordingly.

Then again, we learned things when I went to school, that's what we were there for. There was no free ride in life, you needed school, unless your career choice was to empty outhouses by siphoning through straw.

I just want to beat the snot out of most of the baggy pant wearing, slack jawed morons they call students these days. They wouldn't have lasted 5 minutes in our high schools, without being thrown to the curb with a few boot prints on them.

Pansy arsed tossers, should all be condemned to a life of working at MacDonalds and WalMart.

by neon samurai

They may be with all the publicity they are getting. A job involving "j'want fries with that?" may be the only thing they can get hired for with how common background checks are becoming and how purmanent the internet is. ;)

by neon samurai

hehe.. who doesn't have a few stupid highschool decisions they'd like a chance to rethink. At least in our, or my, day we didn't document them ourselves on a permanent medium.

A while back there was discussion around if there should be a "children's internet" that could expunge kid's history when they hit adult age. The idea is that kids get a sandbox to be stupid in but don't end up with the documented history. The theory is also that it could also keep adults off the children's internet hopefully limiting predatory attacks. I don't know about the second as someone will figure out how to get access but I think th first intention is worth considering.

We where all stupid highschool kids once but self-documenting that in a perminent medium is the new twist.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"children's Internet".

Boy. I think that would be a bad idea. We have already invented myriad ways to avoid holding our children - and ourselves - accountable.

For those of us who were near complete idiots in our teen years, we couldn't have gotten away with it if we hadn't been enabled. That same particular bunch of us - if we wake up - will pay for that level of idiocy until we die. A level of accountability that is near obscene for the simple fact that accountability in the moment would have taught us.
(Maybe beyond, but no one knows about that.)

etu

by jck

And Conservatives believe in what? Privatizing everything?

Listen to your candidate when he pseudo-quoted Teddy R.:

"Unfettered capitalism breeds corruption."

Conservative motives to make private enterprise independent from government regulation and oversight means businessmen are allowed to pursue corrupt and unrestrained practices.

Kind of like oil companies are doing now. Oil goes up based on damage that *might* have happened to refiners.

3 days later "Oh...the damage isn't that bad."

If someone doesn't keep things within a nominal means, all people that are along for the ride...being the American people...begin to suffer...excepting those that are "pushing the car over the cliff".

Besides, I have to ask this of you:

Have you ever taken a free thing from the system in your life? I have. Free tetanus shots from the county. Free testing from the county. That's free medical care. Guess I'm a pig for that.

Oh, and btw. I believe the liberals propose that everyone has a right to free basic medical care...not all health care. That is, it's not like they will get free plastic surgery or boob implants.

by jdclyde

I don't recall there being anything that gives you anything more than the "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness"?

You do not have a RIGHT to happiness, just the ability to pursuit it.

You do not have a RIGHT to take something from one person to give it to another.

You have a right to ACCESS quality health care. This can not be denied. Nothing gives you a right to it for free.

Like any other service that costs money, where do you see this should be "free"? It is not one of the necessities of life.

Food IS a necessity of life, so it should be free.

Shelter IS a necessity of life, so it should be free.

Clothing IS a necessity of life, so it should be free.

Health insurance is NOT a necessity of life, yet you would have the government rip money away from people who work, to pay for someone else to have their "free" healthcare?

Of course you will not be honest enough to admit how hypocritical that is of you and any/everyone that "feels" that health care should be "free".

Just how basic is basic? Do I get a "free" kidney transplant or hearth surgery?

Before you buy into the BS about how grand the welfare medical states are, talk to the people in Canada and the UK about how "free" it really is, and the waiting periods and such. Was a very interesting link Neil posted last week of their meetings going on about how failed their medical system is. I will see if I can find it.... It was a real circus...

Never confuse people being compasionate enough to help others, with another person having ANY "rights" to such help.

Stop feeling and start thinking.

by jck

[i]I don't recall there being anything that gives you anything more than the "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness"?[/i]

Go back and read the Bill of Rights, then. You'll find a right to peacable assembly, bear arms, of the press, etc.

[i]You do not have a RIGHT to happiness, just the ability to pursuit it.[/i]

Yep, and any fettering of your right means what? Someone gets a slap on the wrist? You're not even guaranteed that right either.

[i]You do not have a RIGHT to take something from one person to give it to another.[/i]

No, but your government does. And, you can't do anything about it...can you? lol

[i]You have a right to ACCESS quality health care. This can not be denied. Nothing gives you a right to it for free.[/i]

And depending by state, you also have the right to free healthcare by law. Public health facilities, by law, can not deny critical care to patients who are in mortal danger.

[i]Like any other service that costs money, where do you see this should be "free"? It is not one of the necessities of life. [/i]

I see that things like flu shots, basic checkups, etc., should be free. Because, this kind of service means if someone who can't afford a doctor is found by public health service to have tuberculosis or something that can endanger the public that the government is informed immediately, rather than the person wandering the streets and passing it to an untold number of others.

Does it excite you to know that your kid could be going to school with another kid whose dad has TB and hasn't gotten any meds or anything cause he doesn't have the money to go?

[i]Food IS a necessity of life, so it should be free.

Shelter IS a necessity of life, so it should be free.

Clothing IS a necessity of life, so it should be free.[/i]

Clothing is NOT a necessity. Natives have lived without clothing for 1000s of years. Civilization expects that of you, not nature or need.

[i]Health insurance is NOT a necessity of life, yet you would have the government rip money away from people who work, to pay for someone else to have their "free" healthcare?[/i]

Health insurance is [b]NOT[/b] basic healthcare.

And if the government would stop sucking up to people for votes (both sides do it), they'd make welfare people go work at McDonalds or pickin up trash along a highway for that welfare check.

[i]Of course you will not be honest enough to admit how hypocritical that is of you and any/everyone that "feels" that health care should be "free".[/i]

Basic healthcare is best for the country, jd. It is a stop-gap measure to prevent/curtail the transmission of disease among the populous.

Or, do you feel it's right for your children to be in more chance of medical peril cause you want more of your paycheck?

[i]Just how basic is basic? Do I get a "free" kidney transplant or hearth surgery?[/i]

I've lined out what basic is above.

If they would reform welfare and make it "workfare", yeah. I think all non-elective procedures should be included, so long as the person did not bring on the condition voluntarily to their body. (Surgery for deep tissue infection for piercings, lung transplants for former smokers, etc.)

[i]Before you buy into the BS about how grand the welfare medical states are, talk to the people in Canada and the UK about how "free" it really is, and the waiting periods and such. Was a very interesting link Neil posted last week of their meetings going on about how failed their medical system is. I will see if I can find it.... It was a real circus...[/i]

That's because they've let it get out of control. Of course, we're not doing much better here. I waited 3 hours to get into my doctor just a few weeks ago, and I had an appointment. And to get that appointment for a simple check I had to wait 2 weeks.

Is that any better? And I have insurance! And I pay! And I work! So, what's so great about the system here, jd? What makes it so good?

BTW, check out Australia's healthcare system.

[i]Never confuse people being compasionate enough to help others, with another person having ANY "rights" to such help. [/i]

So, you're going to be compassionate and go to medical school to donate your services?

[i]Stop feeling and start thinking. [/i]

Oh, I think. I just think about more than what I get in my check. I look for a solution to the overall problem, not just what benefits me most.

Maybe most of your problem is not all because of how the system works, but because of yours and others approach to patchwork solutions?

[i]?If you could kick the person in the pants responsible for most of your trouble, you wouldn't sit for a month.?[/i] - Theodore Roosevelt

Gotta love Teddy.

by tonythetiger

[i]And Conservatives believe in what? Privatizing everything? [/i]

.... through contracts with private businesses. Why not cut out the middle-man?

[i]Listen to your candidate when he pseudo-quoted Teddy R.:

"Unfettered capitalism breeds corruption."[/i]

It CAN, but doesn't always. Prosecute those cases where it does, and leave the people who aren't doing anything wrong alone (goes for citizens too)!

[i]Oh, and btw. I believe the liberals propose that everyone has a right to free basic medical care...not all health care. [/i]

Problem is, they are LYING to you! It's not "free"!

All social(ist) programs violate the spirit of the Declaration of Independence and our Constitution. We are all created equal, and the government should protect our liberties equally. The cost of government should also be divided equally. If the government does something for one person and not another, that is preferential treatment, and should be disallowed. While some exceptions can be made in times of emergency, those exceptions should be treated as loans, and the recipients should be expected to pay it back with interest.

by dumphrey

but its another good point. But that moves us from freedom of speech into freedom of expresssion, and even more vague.

by jck

Nah, he just gave you reason to want not to have to do something undesirable each time you F up.

I think teachers are held back from putting kids in their place...both by law and by fear that the kid will bring a gun in and shoot them the next day.

Part of that blame goes on the system...part on the parents.

The system for not standing up to legal crap and saying "If you think you can do better, Mr. Lawyer...you pay to put them in the private school of your choice. We won't ruin other childrens' educations for one, unruly, miscreant child."

The parents for not being parents...letting their kids run around and not teaching them responsibility.

Hell...I feared my dad coming home and knowing I didn't behave. That kept me in line til I was 17. lol :^0

by jdclyde

works for me... B-)

One of the big problems I see are[b] pathetic [/b]people that are more concerned with being cool than being a parent. Being a parent means you will be unpopular with your kids because you tell them "no" when it is required and in their best interest.

Was at a store the other day, and these kids were such brats. running around, getting into everything, and their parent just looked on in admiration. I looked at my boys and said "Thank you". They asked why, and I said it was for not being like these children, and that I appreciated them for the fine young adults they are turning into. The proud parents glared at me, while everyone else was a combination of horror that I would dare say that in front of proud mommy/daddy, and admiration that I would dare say that in front of proud mommy/daddy.... :D

Frickem.

by bizzo

They're all over the place.

Although a few weeks ago I saw something that I could hardly believe. Again, in a shop. Walking around was a young mother with her boy, about 5 years old. The boy was doing what normal boys do, running around picking things up saying "I want", and mother saying "No".

She gets to the checkout, and I'm stood behind in line. She says "Alex, come here", he says, "Mum, can I have this". In a little sterner voice she says (not shouts) "Alex". He goes, "But mum ..."

At this point I thought it was going to go the usual way of things, a screaming match between mother and child, but no. She starts to count "1 ... 2 ...". She doesn't even get to 3, when the boy runs up to her, stands by her side, looks up and says "Sorry Mum".

Like yourself, some parents know how to bring up children, but unfortunately some don't.

by jck

[i]One of the big problems I see are pathetic people that are more concerned with being cool than being a parent. Being a parent means you will be unpopular with your kids because you tell them "no" when it is required and in their best interest.[/i]

BAH! Let's talk about pathetic.

That is a mongering sentiment.

I practically raised my niece. I have never been unpopular with her. I never took the piggish attitude "I'm your elder and you'll do what I say because I said it."

That kind of attitude is antiquated, bullish, and only for those who are mentally incapable of dealing with communicating to a child who is of age to be reasoned with.

Every time I told my niece not to do something, I would explain why if she asked why not. I never treated her like an idiot, or that she was incapable of comprehending it, or that i was too good to explain something to her.

You do [b]not[/b] have to be a bully monger or unpopular with your child to be a good parent. You are absolutely wrong.

[i]Was at a store the other day, and these kids were such brats. running around, getting into everything, and their parent just looked on in admiration. I looked at my boys and said "Thank you". They asked why, and I said it was for not being like these children, and that I appreciated them for the fine young adults they are turning into. The proud parents glared at me, while everyone else was a combination of horror that I would dare say that in front of proud mommy/daddy, and admiration that I would dare say that in front of proud mommy/daddy.... [/i]

You must have double jointed shoulders... patting yourself on the back like that. What a good dad I am...I did so well raising you right...YAY ME! BOO YOU!

Real tactful there. Maybe instead of making a belittling comment about them as parents, you could have just talked to the parents...you know...like an adult?

Way to think there.

by locrian_lyric

Makes me proud every time folks tell me how happy and well behaved she is.

I'm not out to be my daughter's fried, I'm out to be her father.

Anyone can be a friend.

by tonythetiger

I heard, from the mouth of another girl about 12, "Give me a f****ing cigarette, mom." The mom fished one out for her. I wanted to slap both of them...

by neon samurai

I think that's why it never went further than inital discussion. I'd like to see some way someone's childhood idiocy online could be expunged at the same time as other children's juvi records (age 19 here I believe) but implementation is the real challenge and how long will it take kids to figure out how to break out into the grown'ups networks?

by jdclyde

clothing is more than just a decoration or for modesties sake. It gets COLD here. Ask someone that spent the two coldest months last year without a furnace....

Patchwork solution? Tell people that the gravy train has come into station, everybody off!

The DO workfare in Michigan. Fatboy demonizes it in Bowling for Columbine, when he blames Dick Clark for the 5 year old for taking the gun he found living in his uncles crack house to school and shooting a little girl. Poor woman had to actually WORK like the rest of us. What could people be thinking????

And shots/immunizations is NOT what is being talked about by "The One" and his party.

And in ALL hospitals, it is illegal to turn someone away with a life threatening injury/illness, regardless of their income/insurance/nationality. It is the braindead Dems that paint the picture of people being turned away from life saving treatment after an accident, but like most of what they say, it is just not true.

by jdclyde

Just because I say no doesn't mean I don't have a reason AND share that reason with them.

What it comes down to, it the kids will either not agree with your reason or not CARE about your reason. Guess you would have to be there full time to run into a time when a child will disobey you after you say no about something? I smile at how simplistic you really think it is.

And yes, sometimes it TAKES being belittled for people to "get it" about how pathetic they are. You can not have a reasonable conversation with unreasonable people, and anyone that raises their kids like that are not reasonable people. Go watch "the nanny" and you will see some monsters of kids, but worse is the parents that created the monsters.

Ask any parent on here how it works out when their 3 year old insists they want that toy in the store, or they want that candy. Ask them how it works out when the teenager wants to go do something that you know is not a good idea, or they can't go because their homework isn't done or it is a school night. You know less than you think.

Any parents want to chime in here? Ever have your kid say something hateful to you because they were not allowed something? How did "reasoning" work out with irrational, self-centered children?

My boys are VERY well behaved, and I still deal with that.

by jdclyde

mum better not reach "3" or something bad will happen.....

How many times have you seen someone repeatedly say "I'm not going to tell you again!", and then about a minute later they say the same thing? Kids know how much they can push, and know which parent they can push.

I have seen a 2nd grader tell his mother to shut up, and she did.

by jck

[i]Here in Michigan clothing is more than just a decoration or for modesties sake. It gets COLD here. Ask someone that spent the two coldest months last year without a furnace....[/i]

I believe...you make a choice to live there. It's not required. You could move. You can get a job somewhere else. You CHOOSE to live somewhere that is not hospitable to human existence in the winter without clothing. So you choose to live where it's needed.

That is your choice. Don't blame me for your choice to stay there where you have to have clothes.

You can move where it's not required...just like the welfare unemployed can move where there are jobs.

Remember that arguement you made? :)

So clothing is not required. Stop being hypocritical and admit it. (remember that line?) :^0

[i]Patchwork solution? Tell people that the gravy train has come into station, everybody off![/i]

Elect me president, and I will. Any welfare person who doesn't take a job assigned to them by Job Corps or the Unemployment Office...has gotten their last check.

I've said it before...I'm an advocate of the Jamestown, VA model of living. If you're able to perform some job function for which you can be hired...and you refuse to work...if your family won't feed you...you're gonna starve and die.

You're preaching to the choir on that one.

[i]The DO workfare in Michigan. Fatboy demonizes it in Bowling for Columbine, when he blames Dick Clark for the 5 year old for taking the gun he found living in his uncles crack house to school and shooting a little girl. Poor woman had to actually WORK like the rest of us. What could people be thinking????[/i]

What was the child doing alone in a house by himself to where he could have time to find a gun? That's negligence by his mother, not the system.

[i]And shots/immunizations is NOT what is being talked about by "The One" and his party.[/i]

Basic medical care has been discussed since Clinton was in office for everyone. The privatization of medical care has only led to higher insurance costs adn worsening treatment.

For God's sake, jd. Let me give you another real life example.

I went to a hospital ER in July with a pulse over 100. My normal pulse is about 44-56 beats per minute.

Do you know how long it was before I saw an ER doctor? 8 damn hours. And, I was having some kind of heart issue. I suppose if I'd have dropped dead on the floor, I would have got some medical attention.

But, how good is our medical system again? What benefit has the privatization of medical care done for this country? NOTHING. PERIOD. I could have died, and the hospital probably would have sued my estate for the money for the EKG and blood test.

[i]And in ALL hospitals, it is illegal to turn someone away with a life threatening injury/illness, regardless of their income/insurance/nationality. It is the braindead Dems that paint the picture of people being turned away from life saving treatment after an accident, but like most of what they say, it is just not true.[/i]

Not true. Private facilities (there was one in Oklahoma City when I grew up, but I can't remember the name of it) in most states are not required to deliver care. Only public accessible medical facilities have to do that.

I know Minnesota is different, because of a "Good Samaritan" law.

And btw...I have seen people turned away from private clinics here. I used to go to one, and later worked for the company as their programmer. They don't have to accept patients like a public facility does.

by locrian_lyric

If a person shouts "FIRE" in a crowded theater and there is no fire BUT the person shouting it *THINKS* there is, he will not be in legal trouble, or on the chance that he does, would be able to mitigate it quickly.

by locrian_lyric

Also, learn about John Adams, the architect of the constitution.

He argued STRONGLY against the bill or rights, not because he didn't believe that our rights should be protected, but because he KNEW idiot pinheads would come along and make ludicrous assertions about what rights really are.

by jck

I have been through all of that, and then some, JD.

See, I have a sister who is a pig. She and her husband would rather have bought cigarettes and beer than pay for my niece's clothes and dance lessons and a car to get her to school in.

I picked up the ball, cause I realized there was no reason for my niece to be punished for being born. And, I did it with a girl child. Ever had to have talks with a 10 year old girl you're raising about menstrual cycles?

I've done everything from being in the delivery room the day she was born, to paying for half my niece's wedding because my sister is a cheap bi+ch.

I've had condom talks.
I've paid for lunches.
I've driven my niece to lessons.
I've made time out of work to go to recitals/games/events.
I've changed diapers and been peed and puked on.
I've had discussions about why she couldn't have something when she was a child.
I've talked with my niece about drugs and alcohol.
I've been the person to drive her and her friends to the movies and mall.
I've been the one throwing her birthday party.

I've been there for it all.

Just because I didn't get someone pregnant yet doesn't mean I don't know all about it. I had to be a dad to my niece, and I wasn't the dad. I had to make up for my sister being a lazy ass, and some guy being a deadbeat. I stepped up.

Again, you assume you know more just because you made your kids.

That just means you procreated. Doesn't mean I haven't been in your shoes having to take care of and raise a child.

Oh, and about the fulltime thing you mentioned?

There was a time that my niece was staying with me pretty much fulltime when I lived on the other coast of FL, because i didn't make her cook me dinner and do my laundry and clean up after me like my sister and her husband.

And, she stayed at my mother and fathers house as a child most of the time when I took care of her because my mother worked almost 24/7 and my sister and her first deadbeat husband were out being partiers. I was attending college and taking care of a child.

So I've been on the fulltime ride thing too. Don't kid yourself.

At least I'm prepared for being a parent now. And, I thanked my niece for it too...and not in front of my sister to make her feel like the bi+ch she is.

by locrian_lyric

Mr Woodside.

Mr Woodside would hand out tests and quizzes in descending order of grade.

He would also announce to the class if you did particularly poorly.

He frightened the HELL out of me, but boy did my grades improve.

He was the best teacher I ever had, and gave me the tools to succeed in life.

He did not coddle me because of my disabilities, but worked me like a dog, and gave me some of the 'can do' attitude I still have today.

by jdclyde

hurt your poor little feelings....

he should have given you a big hug and told you it wasn't your fault..... right? ;\

by locrian_lyric

He hurt my feelings, ALOT.

Guess what, he hurt them enough so that I never EVER wanted to go through that again.

I remember the last day of school, he didn't tell us our grades, but told us if they were the same as the last marking period.

I had gotten a "B" in the third quarter, and when he got to me he said "no".

I was almost broken hearted....

until I saw my report card and saw I had gotten an "A".

I ended up getting a "B" for the year, after getting a "D" in the first marking period.

Yeah, my feelings got hurt for a little while, but I don't remember that, but I *do* remember the feeling of getting that "A". :D

by neon samurai

This is the bit I don't get. One's right to free speech is great. Say what you like, support it and repeat it if you feel it is correct. The part I don't get is how one's right to free speech should outweigh one's right to freedom from abuse. This isn't the best wording but I think it gets the idea across.

What the kids did was intentionally malicious. They where abusively expressed unsupported opinions against someone for doing there job. If the tables where turned and the kids where the target of abusive writing, would they be so interested in free speech rights? Does free speech mean I can target and harass whom I like for whatever personal justification I choose?

In the end, this is basically all over a bunch of school kids being told they can't bring there blankie or dolly to school with them and responding by throwing tantertantrums then self-righteously throwing another tantertantrum when they are held accountable for the first. If I where one of there parents, I would be shamed by my child?s behavior. If one's right to free speech does somehow outweigh one's freedom from personal attack, how should the school respond to these kids?

by jdclyde

"fried" your daughter....

[i]

I don't care about spelling, but typos crack me up..... :p

by jdclyde

you told her no and explained it, she was just fine with it, huh? Yeah, right. Now, about that swamp land....

My point about the "full time" was that kids will act differently for someone that isn't there all the time. Tell me you have never seen that? Had nothing to do with dipping the wick or anything.

by oz_media

You are not wrong, couldn't possibly be wrong, it would result in a four week rant going in circles until you finally changed the subject enough to make a point.

I simply took what is written and specified in the Law Library at our local University.

I assumed that a legal definition of the term, as applied in a court of law (that's where it originated) would suffice, I suppose you are right and they are wrong though.

Damn, so bloody clever, and yet you are in IT?

A waste of superiority for sure!

I bow to you gracefully, I guess I'll ditch my membership to the law library and start sending you money for your infinite wisdom instead.

Now go give you head a good shake and put on some cartoons until mom calls you for supper.

To be more concise, you can jump up and down and yell and point and it rarely gets much attention, yell "FIRE" and its the [i]word[/i] itself that creates hysteria, not the action.

Just like they tell you to do in emergencies to get attention of strangers, say for a woman being raped, a child being snatched etc. Yell "FIRE" and it gets instant attention, the WORD is key. Nobody cares about someone jumping up and down and making noise, but "FIRE" is instant alarm and gets everyone's attention right away.

But I suppose you can write to the BC Supreme Court and set them straight on it too. Just tell them you are a computer nerd and know better, they'll buy it.

by jck

[i]And everytime you told her no and explained it, she was just fine with it, huh?[/i]

Just fine with it? Maybe not. But, I was never unpopular with my niece, as you asserted a parent HAS to be with children they raise.

She always understood why I made a decision, whether it was what she wanted or not.

And in fact, her friends all thought I was cool too. Why? Cause, I didn't talk to them like they were stupid just because they were 12 or 13. I'd hang with them at the mall, take them places their parents didn't want to take the time to do, etc.

I treated them like equals. I talked to them like they were just like me. I listened to what they had to say.

And, they (according to my niece) thought I was the coolest adult for that.

[i]Yeah, right. Now, about that swamp land....[/i]

Call the FL Dept. of Agriculture for that. I have regular land :p

[i]My point about the "full time" was that kids will act differently for someone that isn't there all the time.[/i]

And as I told you, I have been there fulltime in my niece's life. More than my sister, who is her mother.

And even when my sister would run off and drag her along (and my niece even pondered applying for legal emancipation from my sister to stay and live with me in FL at age 13), my niece and I always talk and still do to this day. I have flown up to see her several times, and been up when she needed me (like in April when her husband's father was killed).

Pretty much all of her life, it was either me or my parents paying for anything she got, including once when my father paid for carpet for her room because my sister didn't want to pay for it but did the rest of the house.

And guess who went to Missouri and put the carpet in? Not my dad. Not my sister. Me.

Nah, I don't know anything about taking care of a child and being there for her and doing things for her...required, needed, or wanted.

[i]Tell me you have never seen that? [/i]

Did my niece act differently toward me? Yeah, she actually did. She talked to me more, and respects me more to this day. Why? Cause I didn't take the "I'm the parental unit and you'll do what I say!" attitude.

I taught her why the decision was made. I explained to her possibilities, consequences, ramifications, etc. I did not act like it was my God-blessed right to unquestionable judgement or decision. I didn't treat her like a retard or like she was unworthy of being told why.

I treated her like a sentient, understanding human being with a brain.

But it was [b]not[/b] because I wasn't there for her...it's because I [b]was[/b] there.

[i]Had nothing to do with dipping the wick or anything.[/i]

I guess not. I did pretty well (along with my parents) at raising her. She's 20 now, and runs an office, is attending college full time on a scholarship, and taking care of two children.

So, I guess being "the donor" has nothing to do with anyone being able to be a good influence on kids you raise.

by jck

pulled out the cell phone, snapped a photo, and emailed it to social services.