Cyberbullying versus free speech
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
adults are something like children in that they learn not to do things that bring bad or painful results, so after "just talking to the parents like they are adults", and getting responses like:
"So?", or
"She's not your kid. Mind your own damned business."
It's easy to see why some people quit trying.
by jdclyde
when one of the teachers finally stands up to the kids and has this happen though.
There are a lot of things I will tolerate in life, but my children will keep a respectful tone while they live in my house.
They have learned, they can disagree and discuss it, and have a hope of changing my mind. As soon as the attitude/tone starts, discussion is over, and now it isn't only "no" for this accasion, but we are working on a premade "no" for the next week and we can go from there. B-)
by oz_media
Actually, harassment would be ONE of the stupulations that PROVES that free speech is NOT an ABSOLUTE right.
If there are 'if' or 'buts' that surround a right, then it is NOT an absolute right.
Example, free speech does not protect you when you are harassing somebody.
Free speech does not protect you when you are not protesting peacefully.
Free speech does not protect you when speaking out in a private place.
Free speech does not protect you when it is a case of character defamation, libel or slander.
There are 'conditions' in order for you to be protected by free speech, therefore it is NOT an absolute right.
Your comment as quoted: "Free speech is an absolute right". INCORRECT.
by oz_media
Unfortunately that is the most common misperception of what free speech really is.
Free speech does NOT mean you can say what yuo want when you want, it merely prevents teh government from passing a law to restrict your freedom of choice in religion, government and grants you a right to protest against such peacefully.
Other than that, you can't say what you choos ein my home, it's MY home and you have no freedom of speech guarantees there, nor at work. Schools fall into gray area as they are government funded, if the GOVERNMENT fund it then it becomes an issue sthat requries agovernment law to stop it, which is what the first ammendments assures you they cannot do. BUT, in the case of harassment, sexual or racial discrimination, or when bvreaking other laws such as Defamation of Character, in this case Libel, Free Speech does not apply (and that's exact;y why it isn't considered an ABSOLUTE right, as it can be negated under certain conditions.
Unfortunately too many poepl eactually think Free Speech IS an absolute law, as did these school kids.
by jdclyde
your rights end where the next persons begin.
Of course, rights are easier to take away in a secular society than in one founded under Christian principles. We have what is called "Unalienable rights". They are not given by the government, so can not be taken away by the government.
[i]"that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights"[/i]
Those of us with a creator are endowed, while the rest of you are monkeyboys... :p
by jamesrl
But when I went to school, we had very few disciplinary problems, and I have no reason to think your experience is any more representative of "Canadian" education than mine.
My high school was perhaps exceptional - we won a national math contest and provincial football championship the same year. We were a disciplined bunch and skipping classes or acting out were treated swiftly and harshly.
I've got three kids in school, one starting high school, two in senior public/middle school, and I've met some excellent teachers. Of course not all of them are. We actually worked to get a new teacher fired because she had anger management issues and abused the kids.
When I started they still had the strap. In high school, they counted strap you, but they could and did yell all they want. One math teacher used his yardstick on your desk if you weren't paying attention and gave a wrong answer.
James
by oz_media
Fom what I know yuo have a few years on me.
High School here was an unruly gang turf issue. We had East Van, vs West Van, schools within eact end were against each other. acid/LSD was in, weed was a given, alcohol was part of school.
We had the winning football team and excelled in academic programs but most of the school was still just an uruly place to waste your day away. Classes were something where if you wanted to go, you went; if not, you didn't. Teachers were laughed at and ignored, should have seen the stuff we did to the VP's car in auto shop, LOL.
But the same actions in England would have had me in serious shite. I would have felt teh teachers wrath, got a nice caning or strap afterwards from the headmaster and would have had it at home too.
Today, Vancouver schools are far more academically focused than before, it was sports or shops then, and the students seem to be far mroe interested in actually going to school.
We had it pretty easy in Canada back then though, you could be anybody and build a career of your choice and get paid well for it. Today its a lot tougher for kids to break out into teh market I think.
But there is simply no discpline in schools, the teachers will toss you out if you are too hard to handle, but they certaonly don't address teh issue and give you a strap or cane, my god the parents would have a field day today, protecting poor little Timmy from that horrible teacher who beat on him.
I couldn't even imagine what would happen if a teacher caned a kid these days.
by tink!
Oh did we talk about teachers when we weren't in class! And if any adult had gotten a hold of the book we wrote - we (the writers) would most likely have been expelled, that is, if they managed to figure out the code names for the teachers. That book was the most filthy piece of trash I'd ever seen/written/read in my life! Nothing but sex, violence and gore. :D No wonder I like horror movies.
[edit: Actually, now that I think of it, I don't think we code named the teachers at all. That was the fun of the book - doing whatever you wanted to them in fiction. We did, however, have our own individual pen names to disguise the writers just in case it did fall into the wrong hands.]
by oz_media
by jdclyde
by neon samurai
but one does not have the right to be protected from such hostility?
If one agrees to a code of conduct there by agreeing that one's freedom of speech is too remain within that code of conduct, should they not expect to be held accountable for there actions in breach of that agreement?
by jdclyde
see, I had the "RIGHT" to be blatantly hostile towards you. :D
You have the "RIGHT" to either sit down, STFU and cry about it, or you have the "RIGHT" to be hostile back.
B-)
One can not threaten, but one CAN belittle someone else. :D
If the kids would have not implied partaking in a homosexual act, but kept it to "he is a dootyhead for taking my phone away", none of this would be happening.
Disparaging of ones character is a no-no.
A sane person would not listen to what Loc has to say
Oz is listening to Loc (and replying).
Ergo?
If I call you a jerk, that is not harassment.
If I call your cell phone 100 times a day and call you a jerk, that *is* harassment.
again, the action, not the word.
by jdclyde
don't write anything down, no pictures, not video tape, and nothing that can be used in court.
deny deny deny! B-)
I learned my lesson that you NEVER "accept responsibility for your actions". Getting punished by the school/government will NOT make you feel better about anything you have done.
I have told my boys, if they EVER get busted, shut their traps and call me ASAP.
Saw a guy "step up" and instead of NOTHING happening to him like everyone else, he almost didn't graduate. All because one dumb kid left an empty whiskey bottle in the dark room. So WHAT that the cops came and were trying to scare everyone because they were going to "fingerprint". I was SUPPOSE to be in there everyday, so my hands were on EVERYTHING in there, and if she was cute, someones..... ]:)
One little all day party in the darkroom and you would think it was the end of the world...... ;\ Music, dancing, drinking....
ah, the good ol' daze... B-)
by neon samurai
.. though I would differentiate a bit between one or two random opinions and an ongoing attack of one's character and moral. I don't know if this case falls into the more extreme classification though.
Now, on the matter of the second point; if one agrees to a code of conduct which defines what speech is acceptable and what isn't, do they still get to give an outcry when they break that code of conduct in a blatantly unsubstatiated and hostile manner then are held accountable for those actions?
by neon samurai
by jdclyde
first, you are trespassing. A crime you can get arrested for.
Second, if the person feels threatened, they have the right to remove that threat, permanently.
I can call you a poopyhead and get away with it. I can not call you a crook and get away with it.
by jdclyde
A small town is more likely to take you out behind the woodshed if the law won't remove you.
In the bigger cities, they pretty much expect that everyone is an a$$hole. It will be dealt with quickly by them, or not at all unless there are plenty of witnesses or video.
I don't think there is a set line anywhere. You have to take offense, press charges, and then win in court. Courts are a real crap shoot, because a jury of your peers is rarely a good thing.
by oz_media
There is verbal harrassment (calling people 'names' such as Jerk), calling somebody more than the allowable 3 times per day (yes you can call 3 times IF there is no answer on the first 2), sexual harassment, etc.
Don't confuse stalking with harassing.
YEs you cited ONE exmaple/form of harassment, but we were nto talking about that. We were SPECIFICALLY referring to teh exmaple fo using the WORD FIRE in a public place in order to incite mayhem. THAT law is clearly defined and teh ONLY factor that makes it illegal is teh use of teh WORD FIRE, as described quite clearly in the law and teh specific case in which it is used to refer to.
It's not something with grey area, as you are trying to point out, it is not something to do with harassment, as you are now tryign to twist teh topic to meet your thoughts, it is one comment and one comment only.
FIRE, as used in your example orginally quoted, is the ENTIRE and WHOLE issue behind the law as applied here. That is exactly why it is referred to by judges worldwide now, it was ONE statement, ONE case and ONE result that is used, not the examples you are trying to make it.
If I jump up and down in a theatre and yell, OMG RUN! RUN! I will get a lot of shushes, some really nasty looks and perhaps a couple of people squirming around to see what is going on. The act of yelling teh specific WORD 'FIRE' reults in hysteria, people learn to deal with most people's hysteria by sussing up what is going on, they will often ignroe people's cries for an amblance and ESPECIALLY 'HEEEEEEELP'! But yell 'FIRE' and it starts panic. The difference, in the case cited, the case noted and commonly referred to in courts when discussing free speech and the case as used here is the specific word 'FIRE' as much as you'd like to to meet your goals and make yourself seem correct, you cannot change the law to suit your own ideals, it simply does not fly.
[b][u]Clear and present danger law[/b][/u]
Commonly used to nullify use of the First Ammendment.
[i]"Future of Freedom Foundation, a libertarian think tank, has stated [1] that in most cases free speech issues in the U.S. depend upon whose property one is on at the time. If someone falsely shouted "fire" and created a stampede which was clearly against the wishes of a theatre owner's policy of conduct, then the theatre owner would be within his rights to prepare charges against the agitator. If, however, the theatre owner decided it would be good for business to have patrons yell "Fire! Fire!" whenever they felt like it, then he would be within his rights to do so.[/i]
It is the word that creates he 'stampede', not the act of yelling. If I stand in a theatre and yell HELP, STOP HIM, OUCH!, MY GOD LOOK AT THAT, LOOK OUT BEHIND YOU!, nobody does anything but get annoyed, yet add the word FIRE into it and the theatre will empty in a stampede. FIRE being teh operative word in the sentence.
by tink!
I was NEVER that wild.
The wildest thing I ever did was throw a cast party at my house when my dad was out of town. It was completely innocent though - no alcohol or drugs and I made everyone smoke outside. The only thing wild about it was the game of Truth or Dare - in which myself and another girl had to go upstairs and come down in nothing but towels. LOL!
Otherwise, I only smoked cigarrettes and drank wine coolers behind my dad's back.
by oz_media
Just because you don't THINK you are wrong, it doesn't mean you are NOT wrong, wheras in this case yuo clearly are.
Law is my pet, I can play this game all day and night, in this case it is black and white, as linked to and descibed above.
again though, if you think you are right, you may feel you are right but it isn't necessarily so.
by oz_media
we actually had our 'new' teacher throw in teh towel and go back to teching grade 3 after us.
At recess we would stay behind and turn all of teh furmiture backwards, put his desk at teh opposite end of teh room, hang th eguinnea pig cage from teh lights and take his fish bowl turn it upside down (with a piece of card on top while we flipped it, and then slide teh card out so as to leave a bowl of water (and his prize fish) upside down on his desk.
We'd hand a string of books out the window (3rd floor) and drop it in passers by, he would wind up collectign all the books from the grounds at lunch.
We'd get up literally in teh middle of class and walk out, go to 7-11 buy a Big Gulp and return to class with it when we were ready.
He just gave up and left crying one day, so we got a sub ot torment until year end and he was back to kiddie grades the year after.
In high school the VP asked us to change her tires, at 2:30PM. When 3PM rolled around, she found her car in the parking lot, with the rotors sitting on the rims which were laying on their sides without tires on them. Wheels flat on ground, car on top. LOL
by oz_media
It teaches me patience with even the most ridiculous, though I think even they would se efact before adding their guess to it instead.
This is a matter of having you understand the clear and concise amendments to the US Constituion, there's no possibility of adding Locrians law to it, no possible way at all.
by oz_media
You have a computer can you not simply Google it and find the countless examples and instances that prove clearly that FREE SPEECH IS NOT AN ABSOLUTE RIGHT.
How can it be an absolute right if there are limitations to its aplication? Simple, it CAN'T. DUH!
by oz_media
This ones a real nutter I know, but you would think that with the information available that the density would diminish, but nooooooo.
"they have the right to remove that threat, permanently."
I assume you are referring to shooting the person. There are also a LOT of 'BUT' surrounding that common claim to, but you wouldn't understand them, they are legal facts and that doesn't seem to have any effet on your understanding of your rights.
So what if someone was in your home, unarmed and you wanted them to leave and tehy didn't, do you think you could shoot them?
How about if you caught a robber, armed, as he was runnign out teh door, can you shoot him too?
And lets say you catually stopped a criminal in your home, you knocked his gun out of his hands and stuggled on the floor, can you shoot him then?
I suppose this is all subject to Locrians Law and not actual US law, but that's okay too, actual US laws don't seem to apply in your case anyway.
by jdclyde
I was the wild long hair, traveling with the local rock-n-roll bands since I was 16. With the band you drink free. bonus.
Did I mention I do NOT share most of these stories with my boys? They know I was no angel, but no reason to give them ideas.
All I DO tell them is while what I did wasn't right, the rules and punishments have changed since then. Things that would (and did) get me a stern talking to by a cop would get them thrown in jail today.
We drank a lot, regularly. I had even taken rum and cokes into class on more than one occasion. The instructor knew, but didn't care. I was getting my "A" and I never disrupted class, so he let me be. He would just look at me, shake his head, and go back to teaching.... ;\
He was kind of nuts. World history. There was the day he starting going on about the "damn gooks in the rice patties".... Can you say "unresolved issues"? :p
As for Oz, back in 8th grade, we turned the principles car sideways in his one car driveway. A driveway lined with rail road ties that his little car would/could not drive across.... B-)
Other than that, I found in high school, if you were on good terms with the administration, you got away with a lot more, while the people they didn't like got busted for every little thing. People liked me, as long as I wasn't there to pick up their daughter.... ]:)
I WAS/AM the person your mother warned you about.... ;\
by tonythetiger
[i]Disparaging of ones character is a no-no. [/i]
The disparaging remark is [b]true[/b]?
by jdclyde
you had better be able to prove it....
Knowing something and being able to prove something are not the same thing.
by jdclyde
Ok Oz, wasn't really looking to get into a discussion about shooting people, but if you asked..... I was just being sarcastic before... :p
It is a State by State issue on what you can and can not do. HERE, if you feel threatened, you can use the force required to remove that threat.
If someone has your TV and are running out the front door with it, NO, you can not shoot them. They are not a threat. If he points his weapon at you, you drop him. If the weapon is in a pocket or waistband, he is not a threat with his hands full. Insurance will buy you a new TV.
If you just want someone to leave but they won't, (but are not violent or threatening) you call a cop and about a half hour later you can have them removed. (cops are intentionally slow to respond to domestic style disputes as parties involved are often emotional and will BOTH turn on the cops when they get there)
If you are foolish/stupid enough to physically confront a robber [i](as I once did)[/i] and take their gun away [i](as I once did)[/i], no, you don't get to shoot them, [i](as I once didn't)[/i].
It all comes down to what is a threat to you. In the US, you have a real right to be free from threat in your own home. Someone breaks in, you do not have to make sure they are armed, or do any of the TV crap like yelling "freeze". They are a threat, that can be legally removed. Make sure you have insurance and a lawyer, because you will end up in court over it in many of the cases, but it often comes down on the side of the home owner defending themselves. Home owners do not have to be tough guys that can/will beat up the intruder.
Edit to add: I went through personal protection classes, where they teach you both the proper safe handling of firearms AND the legal issues with defending yourself with that firearm. They teach you if you are victim of a home invasion, try to get your firearm, get your family safe, and stay put. You are recommended AGAINST "clearing the house" because it makes YOU a target for the intruder and is more hollywood BS. If they come to you, well.....
I can not vouch for the other states, although I know Texas gives even more lea-way on this where you can protect property as well as yourself and family.
Other places, [i](like Chicago and New York)[/i] well, the cops will make a nice pretty chalk line around you when they show up.
I know you don't agree, but it is NOT as blood thirsty as many portray it to be.
I own several handguns and rifles. NONE of them are laying around my house for personal protection, but instead are ALL locked up in my gun safe, with the key on my keyring, in my pocket. They are not for personal protection. That is why I have golf clubs and baseball bats all over the house. B-)
by tonythetiger
[i]So what if someone was in your home, unarmed and you wanted them to leave and tehy didn't, do you think you could shoot them?
How about if you caught a robber, armed, as he was runnign out teh door, can you shoot him too?
And lets say you catually stopped a criminal in your home, you knocked his gun out of his hands and stuggled on the floor, can you shoot him then?
I suppose this is all subject to Locrians Law and not actual US law, but that's okay too, actual US laws don't seem to apply in your case anyway. [/i]
In Texas, you can shoot someone running AWAY from your neighbor's house after they broke in or tried to :)
In most other states, you cannot kill or attempt to kill someone who is not a threat to your person or to the person of another. In some cases, however, you MAY intentionally wound them :)
by jdclyde
They can still be a threat, and if they accidentally live, they can try to sue you.
If your dog attacks them while they are breaking into your home, they can sue you. Is that a crock of sheet or what?
No winging someone. No shooting the gun out of their hand. Full clip, center of mass. Threat eliminated. You do not give them a
"fair chance" or wait until you are fired upon. Just make sure you properly identify your target. Rounds that will not penetrate a wall is also a good idea for home protection, that way only the person that is suppose to die, does.
Any word on the civil trial for the guy from Texas that took out the two illegals that were breaking into his neighbors house?
by oz_media
THAT is teh point I was gettign at. Too many people think that if an intruder is in their home, they can legally shoot away, as demonstrated so many ties in comments we've seenhere. But that just isn't so, the THREAT is the key issue.
As you said, you can't shoot someone leaving or trying to leave, or someone who is unable to access a gun to pose a leathal threat upon you.
The level of threat is key also, if it is a gun, a knife, fists etc. makes a world of difference. This applies in Canada too, you are alowed ot own guns here, in fact there is a higher percentage of Canadians with legal firearms than in the USA.
We just don't make a big deal out of it and use it in a threatening way all the time, ie. "If someone breaks into my house, my Glock is under the pillow and I'll shoot them on sight." It is THAT mentality that gives gun owners a bad rap. I am NOT opposed to gun ownership, I am simply opposed to how EASY it is to legally obtain a firearm in the USA as opposed to other parts of the world that excerise greater gun control/discrepancy.
I fully understand home invasion laws and have taught the courses similar to the safety course you speak of, as a security Foreman and manager of concert security teams (who find they have a LOT of similar 'force' issues to deal with at most major shows). It was my life for a good 12 years (security and legal boundaries) so I can understand exactly what you are getting at.
You seem to have confused my post though, my intent was not to get into a gun ownership issue but to iterate exactly what yuo have said above, lethal force is not something to be taken lightly, which it too often is by Joe public, as you very well know yourself.
by oz_media
The Castle Doctrine Law was only just passed in Texas last year to allow such use of force. Prior to that it was handled with the same scrutiny as any other state.
even now it is still not as cut and dry as you may think.
[i][b]"LAREDO ? "A man who shot and killed a 13-year-old breaking into his mobile home has been indicted for murder[/b] in a case that could test a new law giving Texans more leeway to defend themselves with deadly force.
Jose Luis Gonzalez, 63, was indicted Friday in the July killing of a teenager who sneaked into his home with three friends to steal drinks and snacks. Francisco Anguiano was shot in the back and later died at a Laredo hospital.
Gonzalez was indicted by a grand jury for first-degree murder.[/i]
http://shootingmessengers.blogspot.com/2008/04/texas-man-indicted-in-13-year-old.html
The law is being scrutinized on a regular basis and I doubt it will last more than a few years before being ousted, too many Texans are against it (if you can believe THAT).
Then again, Texas is not really part of Earth, is it?
Texas is another planet for most people, it simply si far too different than any otherplace on Earth for people to accept it as being American or even human.
I mean, they produced people like George Lee Harvey Oswald, Bonnie Parker (of Bonnie & Clyde fame), Charles Albright and of course Ross Perot and both Bush presidents.
I think that says it all for Texas: Serial killers, mass murderers and Presidents that had thousands killed during their time in office.
Yup, Texas, what a place!
by jdclyde
As for regulations, again, that is state by state.
Here I have to go to the local cop-shop where they will do a criminal background check. If there is nothing in my past, I get my purchase permit that is good for 15 days.
It is a far cry from just anyone walking into a store and walking out with a weapon.
Even to get a rifle, there is again a criminal background check.
Only point of contention, an intruder does not have to be armed to be considered a threat.
The problem is, the anti-gunner crowds that run the media intentionally put on the toothless hick that is gunna shoot ya if you step on his property! It is an intentional and dishonest attempt to make all gun owners seem like nutcases.
You will hear the same about the NRA, even though the NRA has ALWAYS been for tougher enforcement of existing laws, and for proper training for all gun owners. The dumb and dishonest still think the NRA is "anything goes" as far as gun ownership.
If you poses an illegal firearm, lock them up.
If you use a firearm illegally, lock them up.
A simple idea.
by oz_media
Horne was not threatened, and he was urged to not go outside and confront them by the 911 dispatcher. another officer was out front of teh house and saw him shoot both guys IN THE BACK.
He said he feared for his life and that the man had lunged at him witha crowbar.
First of all, both of them were shot in the back.
Secondly, he was safe in hsi home and could have stayed there, gun loaded in case they came to HIS home, and he HAD spoken with police who were arriving on scene. He told teh police dispatcher that he was going to shoot them, walked outside, confronted them and shot them. That is NOT the action of someon in fear of hisown life, not at all.
But the Texas Castle Doctrine Law doesn' trealy protect him either as THTA is only effective if the shooting is at NIGHT, not when the shooting/invasion was conducted.
IN his case, he's just really 'kin lucky he's in Texas, or else he wouldn't have a hope in hell of getting through without a 1st degree manslaughter charge (at best).
Read and listen to teh call he made to 911 here, as well as the follow up call after he shot them, against the dispatchers pleadings. THEN he has teh gaul to say they came into his yard and he had no choice. HE CONFRONTD THEMAnd here's a similar incident wher ethey have ciled charges, the guy shot someone driving AWAY from the scene.
Just goes to show, you pass one law and out come the cowboys, freaks, yahoos or whatever idiotic phrase describes these paranoid lunatics properly.
Personally I say it is Texas, why not just strap them in the chair them move on, you execute people for much less.
by oz_media
You get 10 days to buy your pistol, long guns do not require a permit (which is bad).
That is not the issue, the ease and speed at which it is issued is a problem. Private sale is of course exempt from this need also.
If you don't have a prior criminal record and no KNOWN mental health issues, you can get your gun simply by walking in, havign a background check in a computer while you wait and walking out with a permit to go and buy a pistol just about anywhere. Done deal.
That is not any form if discouragement to a guy who just got really PO'd with somemone and is going to kill him or ANY criminal for that matter. Gangs and criminals are made up of new members who are clean and innocent. You want in? Go buy me a gun, domne deal, legal and all. That night someone else is shot.
You see, in Canada it takes time. a criminal background check is conducted thoroughly and takes a couple fo weeks, not hours. It is also up to teh discrepamcy of the shop owner, who have been proven to simply take gansters money for firearms and leave it at that.
Michigan laws are as slack as any in the USA, I aam not opposed ot guns, I am opposed to screening and buying on the same day or even the same week. Rage that gets peopls to buys guns to kill with is usually vented in a few weeks, whereas in the USA, they can rage, buy and kill in the same weekend, if not same day.
For more on Michgans gun legislation: http://www.legislature.mi.gov/documents/publications/firearms.pdf
That's the full meal deal, no ifs ands or buts about it, those are the slack assed state laws as they apply in YOUR state.
by oz_media
When I was younger I had been told MANY times by girls parents, "You are a really great guy and all that but I just wouldn't want you to date my daughter." word for word, no lie.
We like you but don't trust you as far as we could kick your sorry but. Why didn't they understand why that offended me?
I always found that "I really like you guys too but sure am glad you aren't MY parents" was a good comeback.
Or else, "Don't you trust your daughter to make her own decisions yet?" The trust word always gets them as they want to defend the fact that they raised her properly and she is smart enough to know better herelf.
Or else, just grin and bear it, drink all their liquor and wreck the house with a good bash of a party anyway.
by oz_media
That's funny, to this day I still don' let peopl etake my picture, not that its a big deal anymroe though.
I used to be adamant about people NOT taking my picture at parties, bat events, backstage etc. I have literally torn film out of a girls camera who took a picture of me at a party, after a whiel people learned to simply not take MY photo, all others are fine by me.
I was ALWAYS doing something I shouldn't, with my label involvement growing and band representation contracts, I got really sticky about it for a good 10 years. Today it just pisses me off and I still don't let people take my picture or take pictures with me, its a no no, however there is little to hide nowdays, compared to back then...boy what a ride it has been!
by neon samurai
So, instead of visiting your home. Granted, I question lethal response where only threat of insult is experienced. Let's take it to the local pub or park even. If I aproach you and your significant other in the local pub or the local park and share my freedom of speach through blatantly insulting and intentionally costic opinions. That is still ok? I'm not in your home or, in the case of the park, not even in a private place with nice big bouncers.
When you inevitably take a swing at me, I'm perfectly within my rights to claim freedom of speech and charge you with physical assault in response too my verbal assault? I should have no responsability for what I say because it is my right to do so and you can't do anyting in response but express your freedom of speech? Why does that right to free speech outweight the targets well being?
Why does considering one's freedom of speech always have to be done without considering the consiquences or target of that speech?
Granted, I'm not the type that would come find someone a park just to talk smack to them nor do I intentionally express opinions I'm not willing to support. This is really just posed as an example. At what point is practicing one's right to free speech incrouch on the rights and well being of another person?
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending