Discussion Locked

Freedom of speech is nonexisten here on TR from what I see.

0 helpful
461 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

461 replies

by gadgetgirl

Stef, I thought it would have taken more than two.....

Having said that, there are two people on this board who could "name that tune in one!"

:D :p

GG

]:)

by jdclyde

You sound like you have backed into too many door knobs for your own good....

And why is it you choose to be a poor copy instead of standing up as your own account?

by jdclyde

Know your audience and speak in terms that they can understand. It is the first rule they teach you about public speaking!

by jdclyde

After he spent all of his lunch money on "member enlargement" products that he gets in his email, and still has to wait till the stream starts to know where to grab.....

by jdclyde

He must be knocked just about senseless after the troll feeding that has been going on in here..... :0

by Member 25348569

WhyMeWorry had been around for over a year as a normal peer (whatever THAT means for THIS site!) :p

He's not been reamed before now but he just seems to have fallen over the edge one day, got his main account canned by Beth for racist comments and then got his new account jumped all over by the Usual Suspects when he came back for a moan about it.

Seems that H-1B visas for Indians is his blue touchpaper.

Just goes to show that there are times when you need to back off, chill, have a curry and a pint of Cobra!

Neil :D

I know I gave him a bit of a kicking back up aways but I think that he's one of those people with a real blind spot for how he comes over at times. It is possible to resurrect yourself on here but he has got to tone down the racism and - maybe - crawl a bit.

I suspect that I won't lose sleep over it.

By the way, I never asked. I knew that Dwarf and Blackadder would go down well but how did you and the Things get on with the League of Gentlemen?

by locrian_lyric

Just a bunch of people enjoying berating an individual.

It's funny.

Given the fact that most of us in IT are introverts, and many of us were the subject of 'dogpiles' growing up, it amazes me that a little more lattitude not be granted towards folks who mispeak.

We've probably got a few folks in here with Asperger's syndrome as well. Some people with AS make Rosie O'Donnel look like the poster girl for tact and taste.

(now before anyone gets all over MY backside, I have AS myself)

C'mon now.

The response to WMW has been WAAAAAAAAAAAAAY out of preportion, which leads me to believe that some folks in here are just enjoying the opportunity to attack someone.

by absolutely

[i]Just goes to show that there are times when you need to back off, chill, have a curry and a pint of Cobra![/i]

Enjoying foreign cuisine is an excellent way of beginning to appreciate foreign cultures. Except for British cuisine. You pretty much have to like British culture without any assistance from the 'cuisine'.

:p

by charliespencer

Maybe he really was trolling, but I remembered my Kevlar brain-bucket this morning. I notice he hasn't posted anything today, on this or any other topic. He still has a profile, so I assume Ms. Beth didn't have to drop the bomb on him again.

by jdclyde

when gg gets a XdaytiTs going.... ]:)

And one correction, she doesn't sound like she is suffering at all, butt rather enjoying herself [i](bzzzzz)[/i] :0

by sleepin'dawg

I can't help calling them [b][i]"Fun Bags"[/b][/i]. I must be getting way too old but in my defence; while some guys are real[b]Titt Idiots[/b] I'm kinda [b]Bum Dumb[/b] :^0

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by tony hopkinson

Attack people for fun on TR.

Surely not.

You'll be suggesting some people continue to make contentious posts on the same off topic in order to rant at them next. :D

by beth blakely

You very obviously didn't see what he wrote before it was edited. I have utter faith that if you had you would gladly feed him to the dogs.

I've been dealing with this joker for over a month now. I tried to handle the matter privately to avoid this very situation. Unfortunately, WMW couldn't be persuaded to behave by my very professional private email.

He chose instead to up the ante by wreaking havoc on the community under several (like 20 or so) assumed identities and to insult a particular race of people over and over and over. It was hate speech, pure and simple.

Now I've alerted "the regulars" by entering into this discussion to help me combat this sucker. Why? Because it's YOUR community that he's affecting.

I suggest that if you don't like what's going on here you just take your own advice and quit beating a dead horse. We understand your perspective.

Or not. Whatever!

by faradhi

He was jumped on pretty quickly and viciously because of a post that was considered insensitive by others. The response may have been disproportionate to the offense but he hit a nerve on others and myself.

by locrian_lyric

That matter is over, as far as I'm concerned.

What I am concerned with is where this community is heading as a whole.

I've been around (mostly lurking until somewhat recently) since before the date on my account. This is my second account. I created it after I forgot the login name of my first one. I remember the original interface of this site....

What I see as of late is a GENERAL hostility that I don't recall.

I saw some of WMW's posts and they were over the top...some by alot.

Fine.

Ignore him, ban him, but DON'T FEED THE TROLLS.

He's got folks in here so whipped up that many are sinking to pretty low level, and not just with him. The bad attitude is infecting the community in general.

It's that attitude that I would like to see corrected.

If it means banning WMW or anyone else who is disruptive, so be it.

But seriously, do you think that keeping him around to be used as a punching bag is GOOD for the community?

by locrian_lyric

I am not saying that his posts should not have been edited or that his account should not have been fragged. You'll not find a single instance of me defending word one of his posts.

What I don't understand is that if you KNOW he's causing problems, why is he not being banned on site every time he pops up?

Is it because it's more 'fun' to attack him?

But at least I get to sit back and watch the crowd with pitchforks and torches storm the next castle.

with all due respect to you, madam; this is not the community I joined in 2002, nor it's previous incarnation I had joined earlier than that.

by beth blakely

For your information, he IS banned every time he starts causing problems. And if he chooses to create a new identity and behave himself then he can be a part of the community.

You're entitled to your opinion about the community and free to participate or not.

by beth blakely

If you'd like to compare our dedication and concern for this community, bring it on. I've been with TR for over seven years and I love it.

When I said "with all due respect," I meant it. I was trying to explain my point of view. When you said "with all due respect, MADAM," it read as quite sarcastic and condescending. Further, you assumed I wasn't doing my job by getting rid of the idiot, but you were wrong. Both of those things ticked me off.

When I said you could choose to participate or not, I meant it. You're free to do either. We'd be happy if you stayed, but hey: This is the community, warts and all.

I work hard every day to try and make it the best it can be. Most people here know that. You are cordially invited to believe that or not.

I'm finished going back and forth with you. You get the last word, so go for it!

Peace be with you!

by deepsand

What summary action(s) would you have TR take to both predict & control one's future behavior here?

by faradhi

Unless they deserved it. I did not read dude's posts but I am confident that the group is not overreacting.

I myself have engaged my mouth before my brain in some discussions and have been berated. What I have not done is whine about it like this guy. Neither, have I created alternate personalities and stoke the flames sort of speak.

For the most part, the people on this board are reasonable. However, they do tend to react harshly to a lack of respect towards the community.

by faradhi

that is used to define Pornography.

It can't be defined, but you know it when you see it.

by tony hopkinson

an opinion, or an interpretation of fact, or even an outright lie, on this site if you don't want a response?

Someone disagrees in a response, 'you' disagree back.

Get into it a few other's join in....

You should see what happens when I start airing my socialist principles. I get nailed by several of the regulars, if it bothered me , I'd keep my gob shut.

by jdclyde

I think he missed the part about this not being a single incident, but, as you said, going on for a month with multiple accounts AND attempts by you to let him know what is and isn't acceptable in this community.

It is a slightly different case when you actually know something?

AttaGirl. Keep up the good work. We see and appreciate it. :x

by jdclyde

that this is far from the first account of his that she has disabled, yet he just keeps making new accounts and coming back.

by absolutely

You're welcome to object to my ruling of course, but the OWNERS will decide whose objections they care to consider. It's their property, not ours.

:p

by jdclyde

you would be a part of "anyone", and having objected, your objecting yourself? Ohh, the tangled web we weave!

Don't you just hate people that hate? B-)

by mslamen

I can see in your post's that you are one of the level headed ones in this forum.

Till we meet again my brother

by wayne m.

I prefer moderated sites. Although I wish everyone was able to discuss issues civilly and we did not have content edited, the reality is that some are unable to, or unwilling to, meet this simple standard.

I continue to trust the staff at Tech Republic to excericse appropriate editorial control. I am grateful for this and Beth and staff have my support in continuing to maintain a site that is both informative and fun.

by ontheropes

in just a matter of a few hours while...

Nevermind.

(cue in the violin music)(cue in the fire)

by Member 25348569

I won't take criticism of British food from the Yanks! You've taken all of the World's best foods and morphed them into your own image and I'm not sure that too many of them have benefited!

I would offer the cheeseburger, Pizza Hut and the hot dog as examples of the Americanisation of something good. There are many, many more!

The most notable culinary lesson from my trips to the States is to say - trust me in this - it does not make food any closer to haute cuisine if you melt crap cheese all over it!

:D

by locrian_lyric

Go after American Beer....

It's a much easier target than our cusine.

Though I do agree on Pizza hut.

Still, the cheeseburger, especially the confection from that great establishment "White Castle", is an artform in and of itself.

by tig2

I can hardly stand to drive down a street with a White Castle on it. When I first moved to the Midwest, a friend insisted that White Castle was the perfect food. Yeesh!!! It was awful!

In later discussion we concluded that it likely has much to do with where I was raised. White Castle was an adult experience, while Midwesterners have had access to this commodity since childhood.

Now the In N Out Burger is truly a masterpiece!

by maecuff

Melted cheese product on anything is not only good, but good FOR you. Have you HAD a croissan'wich lately?? Hmmm??

by jamesrl

What microwaves do to croissant's is a sin against nature.

Couple of datapoints:
1) Heard on the news a survey showed the favorite food of Britains is....currie.

2)The epic "Harold and Kumar go to White Castle" was primarily filmed in and around Toronto. There are no White Castles here.

3) What Americans and Canadians often put on fast food (burgers and croissanwhich) is commercially known as cheese food, because it is so processed they can't call it cheese any longer.

Melted real cheddar makes many things taste good.

James

by absolutely

How ya doin?

Guess what? I've never even been to Britain, just heard the jokes about your food and decided to see what you'd reply. You're a very witty chap.

Cheers.

by Member 25348569

I would like to treat you to some traditional British food.

It had better be a curry. :D

And a beer or two to wash it down.

Soapbox warning!

Actually, until just a twenty or so years ago, the jokes were totslly justified on the whole as British restaurant food was mostly rubbish - poorly cooked "French" or "Italian" missing the point of both in that that good ingredients are needed for good food.

Home-cooked food tended to be mostly bland with overcooked vegetables.

The last couple of decades we have become hugely food-conscious and the quality of restaurant and home-cooked food has gone up across the board and the number of international cuisines that we get right is now what it should be.

We still do damn good curries though.

by beth blakely

Richard, I could not agree with you more on this point. And no, I don't think bashing--generally speaking--is good for the community. My point to you was, believe it or not, this jerk had it coming.

If you've noticed, though, this thread has already moved to other topics... Like the health of the community and Warner Bros. cartoons! ;-) The rage is generally short lived and the nature of the beast.

And, may I say, thanks for being a reasonable human being during this discussion. It's so refreshing.

by neon samurai

We've got more than a few OS bigots floating around TR also. I only mention it because the definitial clarified it so well.

As for the H1B thing that pops up; I find politics distastefull in general but fully admit I haven't the understanding of the H1B situation required to make any comments.

by deepsand

Most are unaware that the primary definition of bigotry is class agnostic.

As for the H1B debate, it is necessary that one [i]always[/i] make the distinction between the companies who use such & similar visas to obtain employees & the employees who are so obtained.

Unfortunately, too many ignore that distinction, and visit the sins of the father on the children.

by crashoverider

I believe in total freedom of speech but when you are on TR website you are on private property just as if you walked in to someones home. The owner of the home can and most likely will set rules and if you violate those rules you will be subject to the consequences.

So what can you do? Well in a free market you can set up your own competing business and set your own rules for that business if your business is better i.e. no moderation total freedom of speech people may choose your business over your competitors business. I am not condoning the actions that the moderators take but it is their right because they have been entrusted with that power by the owner.

I also believe that the same rights should be given to the TV or radio station owners but mommy government does not see it that way in the current political climate. This is one reason why the radio and TV stations are hurting because back years ago they did not stand up for their rights and fight when they should have.

by absolutely

The 'issue' is failure to understand, recognize, and fully respect that one party's property rights (TechRepublic, here) are not equivalent to the other party's free speech rights (WMW, in this case, but this argument will be played out a couple more times before it's settled & well-understood). WMW & its cronies argue as if they really believe they have a [u]right[/u] to speak freely on TR's property.

They are mistaken.

[i]I am not condoning the actions that the moderators take but it is their right because they have been entrusted with that power by the owner.[/i]

You don't need to 'condone' anything. It is their property to use by their standards, not ours. The moderators are employees, doing a job for money. The owners assigned them that responsibility because it's in their financial interests to do so. Professionals don't want a forum littered with racist diatribes because it's not only a waste of our time, it's insulting to our hard work to suggest that we should exclude other races from free competition.

by jamesrl

And its Steffi who has shown a particularly vicious manhating streak. Poor Dmambo had to leave, and Palmetto suffers headaches.

James

by steffi28

I love good old British food!! In fact sometimes I would cut off my own arm for a pub lunch, or a nice pan of Scouse!

Them Americans don't know what they're talking about!! ;)

by maecuff

I'd probably rather eat your tongue than some of the crap that comes out of fast food restaurants.

by jdclyde

on how it is prepared and the seasonings used.

I will NOT eat at mcdonalds. ewwwwww!

by Member 25348569

I'm still reeling over the prospect of Mae eating my tongue

Even if it's just so she doesn't have to eat McDonald's

by locrian_lyric

...nor am I threatening to take my ball and go home.

I find both to be a total waste of time, effort, and energy. In return, I'd like to be spared subtle (or blatant) invitations to leave when I mention something I believe to be harmful to the community.

But please, don't call me Mr. It makes me feel old, and I'm dealing with that enough already.

I mentioned this to someone else, but back in the days of Usenet (and the BBSes) we treated folks like that with what was called a PISS, or a Passive Ignore, Simultaneous Strike.

It's good that you are taking care of the disruptive individuals, it makes the community far more enjoyable, and certainly a far better resource.

The cold sholder always works better than bringing out the flames. If you're dealing with a real troll, he gets bored. If you're dealing with someone who just gets carried away, they moderate their tone when they see that the behavior results in their being ostricised.

All anyone can really do in here is post words on a screen. I've had far worse than that done to me and I seriously doubt that I am alone in that regard.

We are professionals, we've all handled worse than the worst online troll. Ignore them and they do go away.

That is not to say that the moderators and owners of TR should not act according to their interests with regards to banning, moderating et al. I am simply saying that it does no good to feed the trolls.

Trolls want one thing: attention.

If one attacks a troll, one gives said troll attention, albeit negative attention.

What a troll can not stand is being ignored. When he is, he usually resorts to extremely outlandish behavior in the hopes to get an avalanche of attention once more.

I'm not making any demands or threats, nor am I being snippy or sarcastic. If It comes out that way, I apologize and can assure you it is not intentional.

by locrian_lyric

1)I live and work in the areas they supposedly drove through on their quest to find White Castles...

If the movie had occured where they said it did, the whole thing would have been ten minutes long.

2)Microwaved Croissants are slightly less palattable than wet cardboard

3)Cheese-food is SKEEEEERY! I always wondered "Cheese food, is that what Cheese eats?"

Given point #3, what do you suppose Cheese WHIZ is?

by neon samurai

It seems that there was a liberal party long before the latest and previous up swells in PC. I'm not really concerned about your political views keeping in mind that there is no difference between a hard liberal or conservative hater. I just find it hard to believe that the Liberal party sprang forth from the politically correct movement.

(Ah, those days of wonder when someone was a "waste reciprocal janitorial engineer" not "toilet cleaner". At least that over-reaction is done with.)

by captbilly1eye

I couldn't tag this response to Steffi's last comment 'cause no one has shown me how to get past the Max Message thing and I haven't figured it out yet :(

Anyway... Steffi, I think what you meant was that you are an 'Angel'.
...and that is true by any 'angle.' :)

by captbilly1eye

gotta confess, tho...
I didn't do it on my own. ;)

anyway.... I changed my icon. You like?

I was reading the discussion the other day and thought about friends i've lost. ... the least I can do. for now.

by captbilly1eye

I feel so toopid.
I didn't think it worked at first so I ended up making two duplicates. too funny.
...now I need to have a way to delete. :D

by deepsand

1) PC knows no exclusivity.

2) PC pre-dates its having been so named.

3) The term "Liberal" as here used is [b]not[/b] in accord with the correct definition of such.

by jamesrl

Many of the "west of Toronto" locations.

The scene where they are on the cliff wityh the hanglider, I know that actual spot. And from that spot you can see the road where the mythical White Castle is. There is actually a gas station there.

The first White Castle I've seen was in San Diego. I could be mistaken but I think I saw one in Vancouver. We don't have anything like them in Toronto.

James

by locrian_lyric

which is of course my point.

Once again if my tone seems sarcastic, I apologize, it is quite unintentional.

I mentioned before that I have Asperger's Syndrome, and while I have made great strides with regards to communication, I do have a problem with coming accross as sarcastic or condescending when I am not attempting to be either.

I respect the work you do and am not belittling it in any way. I made no assumptions about your duties or whether or not you are derelict in them, as I assume that you are not the only moderator.

If my posts led you to believe otherwise, then again, I apologize. My use of the term 'madam' was also not intended to be offensive. I simply have not engaged you prior to this, and as such did not presume to adress you by your given name absent a screen name.

Perhaps I should go back to lurking, as it seems that I have not progressed quite so far with my social skills as I had hoped.

Peace to you as well.

I do believe that you and the rest of the folk at TR are doing a fine job. I have enjoyed my tenure here, the recent exchanges notwithstanding.

by absolutely

How many people remember that 'liberal' and 'liberty' derive from the same Latin root? How fewer understand that only a subset of the agenda of today's left wing is truly 'liberal', and/or that only a subset of today's right wing is consistent with the liberties [b]guaranteed[/b] by the Constitution? In my experience, the answer to all those questions is "damn few".

How many are surprised by the phrase that Republicans are (on some issues, such as occasionally tax rates) more 'liberal' than Democrats? It's true, but only if you consider the literal, rather than the colloquial, meaning of 'liberal'.

by deepsand

His above reply to me makes it clear that he neither knows the correct definitions of Liberla & Conservative, nor understands that PC is simply old wine in a new bottle.

by mslamen

Very well, I will leave my views out in my responses to you.

Conservative haters! Thats a good one.

by locrian_lyric

yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup
yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup
yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup
yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup yup

:D

by absolutely

'Political Correctness' is the modern name for a particular variety of tyranny, which I'm sure is older than organized systems of law.

'Politically Correct' is also used as a 'straw man' to falsely impugn many legitimate claims for civil rights.

by absolutely

And not one comparable epithet for those who infringe on the liberty of individuals. ('Tyrant' applies only to those with formal, recognized political power, though infringement on personal liberty is hardly the exclusive pastime of tyrants.)

How sad.

by deepsand

Do not ascribe to others those traits which you see in yourself.

Kindly refrain from presuming to speak for others.

by absolutely

Buy your own web server.

This is not your forum or WMW's forum, and if any of your opinions are [b]not[/b] deleted, you may thank the owners for that. You just make yourself look like a 'whiny little titty baby' when you complain about the owners of TechRepublic refusing to waste their resources on opinions you like. There's a vast Internet, and you have the right to waste [b]your[/b] resources, not anybody else's, on expressing your worthless opinion.

by beth blakely

LOL
Richard, this has been a bizarre conversation for me. I think you're doing fine

I believe we've been victims of trying to have an emotional conversation in print. Some things just don't translate. I think you're trying to be a smart aleck because I'm a smart aleck! Classic projection.

Don't get paranoid about your social skills based on me, for Pete's sake! Stick around! Keep posting! You'll get used to the crew and they'll get used to you. It's a really great group once you get to know them.

Right gang? Right? Now, let's put on a show to save the old Mill!

by deepsand

This gives the impression that you deliberately seek to atrract attention to yourself.

by deepsand

The presence of a formal or recognized authority is not requisite for being a tyrant.

Main Entry: tyrant

Function: noun

Etymology: Middle English tyraunt, from Anglo-French tyran, tyrant, from Latin tyrannus, from Greek tyrannos

[b]1 a :[/b] an absolute ruler unrestrained by law or constitution [b]b :[/b] [u]a usurper of sovereignty[/u]
[b]2 a :[/b] a ruler who exercises absolute power oppressively or brutally [b]b :[/b] one resembling an oppressive ruler in the harsh use of authority or power

Our Founding Fathers did not speak of "tyrannies of the majority" without a clear understanding of the meaning of "tyranny."

by absolutely

[i]Let me ask you something.

If Imus had called your wife or your daughter a "Ho" on national radio, would you be upset?[/i]

Uncomfortable with the fit of his own shoe on the opposite foot I suppose. Well done, James.

by captbilly1eye

...and being mean :(
what did I do ta deserve dat?

Man! I was just goin' by the SP pic.

If you are an angle, you definitely are not right. Perhaps obtuse... :)

by tig2

I think that this qualifies you for something but I surely don't know what yet.

Changed your icon??? Still the multiple flags to me.

Your friends remain alive and vibrant as long as your memory lasts and you can pass them on to others. Part of the joy of living.