Discussion Locked

Gays Serving in the U.S. Military - Who should decide?

0 helpful
412 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Disclaimer: My personal position is two-fold:

One: A person's sexual preference and/or practice is his/her own business. I don't know whether sexual orientation is a matter of choice or birth, nor do I care. It's not my business what you do; it's not your business what I do.

Two: Serving in the military IS NOT a Constitutional right. The military can indeed [i]discriminate[/i] for a variety of reasons (sorry, you have flat-foot), all of which are implemented for the purpose of maintaining the most effective military force possible. If you disagree, please show me the exact article of the Constitution that shows me to be wrong. The mission of the military is to be the most effective fighting force - no more, no less.

Having said that, whether or not gays are allowed to serve in the military is a question that I would pass on to the military experts; I'd yield to their opinion.

What's yours?

Edited to change the title and add the following content:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=337373&messageID=3376274&tag=content;leftCol

412 replies

by jamesrl

Quote from one of Canada's former Prime Minister, Pierre Eliot Trudeau.

I'm sure there have been many gay people who have honorably served in the military throughout history. Alexander the Great was one example. I'm sure there are many others.

The argument that it may cause dissension in the ranks, I think should be behind us. Similar arguments were made about Blacks in the military and women in the military and yet many militaries around the world have coped, as have many effective militaries that allow gay people to serve.

In the Canadian Constition's Charter of Rights and Freedoms, discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation is not allowed. I know that the US hasn't reached that stage yet. Perhaps its time it should.

by charliespencer

In terms of legal protection, yes. No one has a choice in either, or about a physical handicap; and current psychological thought is that sexual orientation isn't voluntary either.

We bar discrimination on the basis of religion, a 100% voluntary choice. We should certainly extend that protection to those areas where no choice is involved. Obviously, physical requirements of a job may dictate some level of 'discrimination' on the basis of a person's inability to perform; if the job legitimately requires lifting 300 pounds onto a 7" shelf, I'm out.

by kevaburg

The problem with gays in the military (and I have served for a considerable amount of time in the British military to now be able to form an objective opinion) is the same as the problem with having both sexes serving in the same forces.

Where these people work together in high risk environments, a high risk also exists of forming/establishing relationships at whatever level.

If the time comes whereby one half of a partnership has to make a decision for the greater good, could that person make the decision to the detriment of the partner?

Furthermore, could both partners be relied upon not to make decisions that could endanger their comrades?

This of course, is purely hypothetical, but does raise problems of relationships within the forces. The American forces have a "no relationship" rule whereby serving members cannot form relationships with other serving colleagues, but women are still allowed to serve. So why not gays?

Could the problem be that the American forces are full of sexual homophobics that feel there is quite simply no place for homosexuality as a priciple? If so, then they are practising a discrimination that I am sure is against something in their constitution. If not, then why not?

I am not homosexual. It simply does nothing for me. I am however, aware that there are people that are. Is it up to me to marginalise these people for their beliefs or opinions? We are not allowed to discriminate against people for religion (a personal preference) and we are not allowed to discriminate against people that have a polical opinion different to ours (against our rules of democracy) and to that end, even the Neo-Nazis have a party that is allowed to rally and vie for parliamentary seats. So why disciminate against gays?

Great minds, such a Alan Turing, have been lost thanks to societies complete lack of understanding for people that want to simply live their lives the way they want to.

Lets accept that not everyone wants what we want and get on with living and give everyone the same rights.

by ansugisalas

They want to pre-emptively shut up the recruits, so they don't start shooting off their mouthes about the readings on their "gay radars". :p ;)
Well, it's as good an explanation as any, right?

by charliespencer

"If the time comes whereby one half of a partnership has to make a decision for the greater good, could that person make the decision to the detriment of the partner? Furthermore, could both partners be relied upon not to make decisions that could endanger their comrades?"

The same questions could be asked of married heterosexual soldiers with civilian spouses, (regardless of the soldiers' genders).

"The American forces have a "no relationship" rule whereby serving members cannot form relationships with other serving colleagues,"

Where did you get that? I know plenty of US service members who are married to other service personnel. I have two pairs of in-laws with both spouses having been on active duty while married. What they can't be is in each other's chain of command.

"Could the problem be that the American forces are full of sexual homophobics that feel there is quite simply no place for homosexuality as a priciple?"

Possibly. It's also possible the members of Congress who passed DADT (only a handful of which have been in the military) are the homophobes.

by av .

They just weren't open about it because of repercussions.

We need to get past this issue in the military because there are a lot of gay people that want to serve their country and they should be welcome.

Its a matter of tolerance and the onus, to me, is on the people that don't like it. Its time for them to learn to tolerate and accept gay people that have the same goals as them.

I don't know what the military experts think and I would defer to them too, but I would find it hard to believe that they would exclude people based on their sexual orientation.

AV

by drowningnotwaving

To suggest otherwise is ignorant.

Widespread acceptance of homosexuality has moved on somewhat from the time of Edward II.

by ansugisalas

What would Osama say?
One has to ask, if not being *with* the US is being against them, isn't agreeing with Osama also being unamerican? :p

by charliespencer

Due to the current overseas deployments, it is difficult for the military to retain trained soldiers. This has driven a documented lowering of recruiting standards. Legal and educational backgrounds that previously would have barred enlistment have been lowered or waived.

In short, we've started accepting ignorant criminals. Barring better qualified applicants simply because of what they do in their off-hours is a bad policy. If I'm stuck in a muddy foxhole, I'm more concerned with another soldier's ability to kill the enemy than whether he's eyeballing me in the shower. Heterosexual servicemen have been able to control themselves around females for decades; gay ones can too.

by jamesrl

And it isn't just restricted to those who got in due to lower standards. I just have to reflect on the Russ Williams case in Canada, a top student who became a trusted pilot (flew the Queen and Prime Minister) who became the commander of the largest air force base in Canada, and yet is capable of shameful and despicable acts. He was a rising star, funny, charming and .....evil.

I am a little confused over the need for an act of Congress. Wasn't it Truman himself, as Commander in Chief, who ended descrimination/segregation of blacks in the US armed services?

by maxwell edison

Or the need for a court decision, for that matter.

The president is also the Commander in Chief of the U.S. military. If a military issue does spill over into the civilian and/or political realm, let the president make the call, just as President Truman did. But keep Congress and the courts out of it.

At least that's my opinion.

by charliespencer

Discrimination against blacks was a DOD policy, strictly under the control of the Executive branch, not a law passed by Congress. I believe "Don't ask, don't tell" (hereafter DADT) is a federal law passed by Congress, hence Obama's (and any other president's) inability to override it on his own.

by charliespencer

I agree that is SHOULD be the chief exec., but since Congress passed the law and the pres. (Clinton?) didn't veto it, he ceded the authority to make that decision.

I'm from a state where the governor can't break wind without legislative position. If you the US chief exec has limits on his authority, try this place. Every cabinet-level office in the Exec. branch is elected; the Gov. doesn't appoint any of them, or run as a ticket with the Lt. Gov. Budget decisions? He has a seat on a committee of five; the other four are the party leaders from both houses. Compared to this place, the 'DADT' decision is kindergarten art show.

by drowningnotwaving

... rest easy - homosexuals do not check you out in the showers.

At least, no more nor less than your straight friends check you out.

If you looked like me you can rest assured that it's simple - no-one is checking you out ! :)

by charliespencer

I never had much appeal to women; now you're telling me I completely out of luck. :(

Seriously, I included the 'shower' comment because that's the type so many raise in opposition to gays in the military. "What about in the barracks, or the latrine? Will straight soldiers be comfortable with gays in those settings?" I'd rather share barracks with an intelligent, motivated homosexual soldier than a heterosexual with a stack of waivers to his legal record and a bad attitude who barely passed the entrance test. We're enlisting too many of the latter and discharged too many of the former.

by ansugisalas

A "straight" ignorant criminal is more likely to rape a fellow than a gay one. Just look at high security prisons.

by jamesrl

I am not one who is of the opinion that sexual orientation is a choice. Sexual behaviour is a choice, but I think you are born with an orientation.

But all are protected under our Charter in Canada, and in most of the "western democracies".

by maxwell edison

You make a good point with your first sentence:

"[i]I agree that is SHOULD be the chief exec., but since Congress passed the law and the pres. (Clinton?) didn't veto it, he ceded the authority to make that decision.[/i]"

But I might guess that President Clinton didn't necessarily [i]cede the authority[/i], per se, but rather politically structure the issue so that he could have it both ways - and have an outlet to blame Congress, not letting the buck stop at his desk, as Truman did.

by seanferd

Why is there even an idea called "gays in the military"? Why is it something to be considered?

I rather suspect that there is no military reason for this topic. It is more likely that it is a point of contention due to the demography of the U.S. military containing loads of fundamentalist Christians.

by maxwell edison

It's not I who dubbed the word [i]gay[/i]. It was actually those very folks of the homosexual persuasion who wanted to wear their sexual preference on their sleeve for all to see. (It guess it made them happy - yuk yuk.)

For decades, certain behavior was (and is) forbidden in the military, including, but not limited to, engaging in homosexual behavior. Engaging in such restricted behavior was cause to be dismissed from the military.

It was those who proudly wear that tag on their sleeve who openly challenged the military's stance on forbidding such behavior, and it is they who are advancing the [i]idea[/i] of which you speak.

by seanferd

It's not I who dubbed the word gay.

OK, who said you did?

It was actually those very folks of the homosexual persuasion who wanted to wear their sexual preference on their sleeve for all to see.

Citations needed.

For decades, certain behavior was (and is) forbidden in the military, including, but not limited to, engaging in homosexual behavior. Engaging in such restricted behavior was cause to be dismissed from the military.

And the all-wise military surely has some sort of reason for this. I have yet to hear any sort of valid reason.

It was those who proudly wear that tag on their sleeve who openly challenged the military's stance on forbidding such behavior, and it is they who are advancing the idea of which you speak.

This sounds reasonable. However, someone had to make being gay against the rules in the first place. There is your starting point.

by charliespencer

I don't think seanferd is questioning the word 'gay' itself, as max seems to think. It appears to me he's questioning why the concept of gays in the military is anymore of an issue than redheads, Iowans, or fans of the Dallas Cowboys.

by john.a.wills

is a book by G. K. Chesterton in which he opines, among much else, that soldiers do not go to war for economic reasons nor because their governments send them (because if all the soldiers refused to go to the front there would be nothing the government could do to force them). Also, there is a significant degree of democracy in many states, including the ancient Roman Republic, so there must have been some popular reason for the destruction of Carthage and the conquest of Greece. Chesterton opines that Carthage was destroyed because it practised human sacrifice and Greece was conquered because of its sexual perversion, repulsion to which is perfectly natural. He admits that things are more complicated than that.

As to the modern U.S. armed forces, I'd rather have a few perverts in them than people like Edmund Calley. But are those the alternatives?

by drowningnotwaving

for your endorsement! :)

Perverts abound and always have, throughout history. See Abu Grab for most recent evidence, but they are not in any way alone in their perversions.

So you're happy with [b]perverts[/b].

What about gay folk?

by john.a.wills

are not the ones I was thinking of - I'd put them more on the Edmund Calley side. But I wasn't restricting myself to gays either: think of Bill and Monica. If gays are excluded as such from the military, a fortiori B & M should be too.

by maxwell edison

..... is the one word that trumps everything else you said, and it paints both you and your message accordingly.

Why did you even bother to post more than that one word?

by ansugisalas

#1: if he'd have written just "perverts n/t" them some might think he was talking about participants in the discussion in general.

#2: What he wrote before that one word already painted his message all over him, in mile-high letters. I find that the "perverts" bit was far less virulent than the agitprop that preceded.

by ansugisalas

Doesn't your antizionist viewpoints teach you anything?

Who wrote the histories? Victors did.
Carthage was destroyed because of the machinations and propaganda of Cicero and his like-minded, who wished to remove a potential rival. Whatever they may have practiced, we can't tell. The romans removed all trace.

Another thing that there's no trace of, is this "institutionalized homosexuality" of ancient greece. We know that in some circles there was little stigma (aristotle may have disagreed, or Plato), and yet, we all know this myth. And then, rome was no different. Go and search for poems by Catullus, in translation online, and you will be enlightened.

What is said of a culture by those that will destroy it, or have already destroyed it, is seldom the reason why they did it. It's a bandaid on a guilty conscience, a shine on a tarnished halo.

by maxwell edison

Me: It's not I who dubbed the word gay.

You: OK, who said you did?

I simply replied to the following comment that you made:

[i]I can't understand why this is even considered. Why is there even an idea called "gays in the military"? [/i]

???????

Me: It was actually those very folks of the homosexual persuasion who wanted to wear their sexual preference on their sleeve for all to see.

You: Citations needed.

Give me a friggin' break. Are you blind? Gay Pride Parade, all the gay organizations, etc.

Me: For decades, certain behavior was (and is) forbidden in the military, including, but not limited to, engaging in homosexual behavior. Engaging in such restricted behavior was cause to be dismissed from the military.

You: And the all-wise military surely has some sort of reason for this. I have yet to hear any sort of valid reason.

Scores of reasons have been advanced by military experts, but whether or not you consider them [i]valid[/i] is your deal, not mine.

Me: It was those who proudly wear that tag on their sleeve who openly challenged the military's stance on forbidding such behavior, and it is they who are advancing the idea of which you speak.

You: This sounds reasonable. However, someone had to make being gay against the rules in the first place. There is your starting point.

Well, it started sometime in the past. Why does the starting point matter? Twenty years or two hundred? Somewhere along the line, it was made policy. It doesn't matter to me when that was. If it matters to you, then you figure out when it was, and then make whatever point it is you're struggling to make.

by seanferd

And the multiple question marks is a dead give-away that you are a complete loon. I'm tired of you, your always-unsupported BS on any topic you like to bring up, and the way you think facts should bend to your political beliefs. Grow up.

You call that a point-by-point response?
I simply replied to the following comment that you made:

I asked why such a concept existed, not why you brought it up. I thought it fairly obvious that I was not claiming you created the idea. As always, it is blatantly obvious why you post anything you do: You are one of those whiny "conservative" buffoons.

So, again, why is it of interest to anyone why there are gay people anywhere? What is the draw to this idea? What are you and the people to whom this is a thing to be considered afraid of?

Give me a friggin' break. Are you blind? Gay Pride Parade, all the gay organizations, etc.

In the military? Yeah, I suppose if teh gheys spend all their time in service having parades instead of training and fighting, there might be a problem. If this isn't what you mean, your point is what?

Scores of reasons have been advanced by military experts, but whether or not you consider them valid is your deal, not mine.

Well, I figured you would want to support your position since you raised the topic. Even the mere mention of one of these reasons would be a start. Put up or shut up.

Why does the starting point matter?

It only matters because you state this as if the military reacted to some danger brought about by homosexuals. The policy was in place first, men serving in the military were discovered to be gay, and the military made a big deal out of it. Since we now live in a time where homosexuals do not have to fear instant death or mutilation at the hands of crazy people, and these gay men want to serve their country in the military, there is a fight for the right to serve.

If it matters to you, then you figure out when it was, and then make whatever point it is you're struggling to make.

I'm not trying to make a point, I'm asking questions of the person who started the conversation as to what he actually thinks, and whether he will ever get around to making his point. Your disingenuous rhetorical tactics are lost on me, bud. If I want to deal with this level of stupid, I'll go debate creationists or something.

I'm done with your intellectual dishonesty. Maybe I'll be able to discuss music or something with you in one of those types of threads, but otherwise, so long. No point in having a conversation when it really isn't a conversation at all, but some weird game you like to play.

[Note to Sonja or other mod: Delete this if you must. Yes, I did just read today what was written about attacking ideas, not people. This is generally something I follow. But "Maxwell Edison" is just the obvious front for an obvious class of ideas, never having a solid argument or evidence to back up the claims, always playing games and running in circles, subjecting the forum to these sophomoric "discussions": A troll.]

edited to close tag

by maxwell edison

I actually stated my position in the opening dialogue.

In your previous message, you said, [i]One of us is misunderstanding something.[/i]

Well, I don't disagree with that.

And for one not trying to make a point, you sure used a lot of words to not do it.

By the way, I'm actually more of a libertarian rather than a conservative.

by nexs

It's what makes these discussions interesting, if nothing else.
;)

I'm going to but my nose halfway into a discussion with my tuppence on the matter.

Gay men should not have to hide who they are, and most of them don't. Most of them, of course, don't parade around in frills and fishnets, dancing and spitting with their lisped sentences everywhere. That is a stereotype that is probably more fabricated than anything else.
Note that I've said 'gay men'. The main problem that I could imagine would be men with a fear/dislike of gay men - those types men would welcome lesbians, I'm sure.)

That being said, it is inevitable that homophobic others (men or women), would make a point to disorient those in question.

But my take on the matter is, as long as is doesn't affect their actions in battle (which it most likely wouldn't), what could the problem possibly be? Other than those who have a problem with homosexuality in the very essence of the word.

by ansugisalas

I guess, as an exonym, it had derogatory intent. In commandeering it for themselves, they made of it a vessel for empowerment.

by .martin.

if they want to fight (and they have no problems with them), they should be allowed to fight.

by pser

'We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal.'

This 'Declaration' ... has been used by many, FOR many, to amend the Constitution. Abe being the most well known, in his Gettysburg Address.

I would also look closely at the fourteenth amendment, section 1: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."

Also, being 4F'd, due to physical disabilities, is understandably good cause for the military to "discriminate". I myself was rejected by the military because of a disability. However, being 'gay' ... is NOT a disability.

Pretty simple really ...

by santeewelding

Is not good enough. I lived through that. I was a member of the U.S. Military at the time. Your off-hand mention, erroneous as it was, did not float.

You bring crap up like that, you best be punctilious in every detail when it comes to women, children, and old men shot to death in a ditch. And, me, assigned general responsibility for it.

Spat upon.

And, don't let me ever hear again of you assigning the word, "pervert", to any soul upon the face of this earth.

You do, and I will report you to Jason, that he may do to you what he did asymmetrically to me -- shot dead in a ditch.

by tonythetiger

has nothing to do with its status as a law and everything to do with what's in the hearts and minds of men.

Frankly, if you can't "handle" being around someone who's different from you, that's YOUR problem.

by the maverick phantom wanderer (formerly macoza, nodice, kp, etc.)

I fully agree with your first point (I would say the apocalypse is coming, but I'm starting to think that it already hit a long time ago- the effects unraveling themselves slowly).

Responses to the second point by sentence:
1. True
2. Never understood the flat-foot thing.
4. As it should be.

Response to the 3rd paragraph:
They should know what's best for the military; however, what one should know is not what one knows, or what one practices.

My opinion, let them show us evidence proving that gays in the military reduce the effectiveness of the military, otherwise stop what (without said proof) is a stupid practice that limits our fighting strength unnecessarily.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

what people do in their bedrooms, or their other rooms for that matter. I do give a rats what they do in foxholes.
My only criteria...

by ansugisalas

Well, have you?
I'm not talking about just any reservist officer or drill sarge.
Military expert, someone with expertise on matters military... someone who knows what things are detrimental to military efficiency, which things are beneficial and which things are irrelevant. And not simply doing "business as usual" or "upholding proud military traditions", regardless of whether they're beneficial.

Hazing, for instance... Beneficial? Detrimental?
Women soldiers... Beneficial? Detrimental?
Women officers... Beneficial? Detrimental?
40000$ Toilet seats? Beneficial?

See, the thingymajig is, Maxwell, that forty years ago they said the exact same thing about women. And they were wrong.
So, "they" were the wrong experts.

by drowningnotwaving

There is no correlation - none, zero, zilch, zip - between your note and the one to which you respond, on at least two occassions in this blog alone.

This particular note, not the least.

Is there a reason for such demonstrative feeling of inadequacy?

by ansugisalas

I'm being tolerant.
Replying to agitprop, even though I'm allergic ;)
Of who do you think I'm intolerant? Prejudiced people who prefer to do things like they always have, regardless of a need to adapt? That's not intolerance; that's well-founded disdain. Dinosaurs can get off the bus already.
Srsly; you underestimate my capacity for communication:
Ping
Pong
Your court still.

by ansugisalas

Must have been an ordeal, crawling out of the ditch, out from under the countless faceless corpses there, the ones not fortunate enough to have the gumption to shake it off and get on with it.
You do know your mail-service is perverted, right? Keeps summoning up Mailer-Daemons!

by ansugisalas

You're against people having sex in other ways than the missionary position?

I'm sure Pope Drachenfels XVI would be charmed, tickled pink, in fact.

by drowningnotwaving

[i]- homosexuals do not check you out in the showers.

At least, no more nor less than your straight friends check you out.[/i]

The qualifying sentence, IMHO, joins the first sentence. If it didn't seem to do so, blame my poor lay-out of the written response and then please consider it as such qualification.

Having been involved in many sporting teams throughout my years, many of which included people who are gay, I'll happily stand by that comment. In fact, I'd go further to say that, in my experience, I am far more likely to be checked out by the straight folk than then gay.

Two reasons - straights outnumber gays, is first. And, just as David Bowie observed, "other boys check you out".

Second, most gay folk have their 'gaydars' in strong operation and as a rule this tends to work for them.

Speak to gay people about this. They will discuss it happily and reasonably, if you are not asking simply to take the mickey out of them.

And funnily enough, I am assured [b][i]they do not bite. [/b][/i]

by drowningnotwaving

Given the note had a total of three sentences - one of which was a (no doubt) poor attempt at self deprecation - the only person that sees the "game" is you.

I suggest, given your three most recent replies (two to me and one to Ansug.), that other readers may draw a somewhat inverse conclusion to your own spiteful, yet factless, missives.

The ball, Max - just play the ball.

by drowningnotwaving

Your comment:

[i]I'd rather share barracks with an intelligent, motivated homosexual soldier than a heterosexual with a stack of waivers to his legal record and a bad attitude who barely passed the entrance test.[/i]

... is so spot on.

It's not sexual orientation that makes people dangerous. It never has been.

by drowningnotwaving

To suggest that we, the people, have to [i]Yield to the opinion[/i] of the Military is not the smartest thing you have ever written.

It is also somewhat dismissive of your own responsibility in such things, if you take your own responsibility seriously.

PS I suggest this in a non-nationalist manner - looking at the topic in general as it applies in many different countries.

by maxwell edison

I think a person's sex life is pretty personal. I don't share the details of mine with anyone, and I don't care to be privy to the details of another's.

By definition, those who wear their homosexual life style on their sleeves for all the world to see, is - to me - sharing too much.

You've done nothing but criticize me and attack me ever since you first came to this site. But in reality, you really know NOTHING about me.

In reality, I'm more tolerant of other people than 99 percent of the world's population - but they can't take my tolerance.

by drowningnotwaving

My response, to your post, was specific.

The title and subsequent text of my message were directed to your comments around the subject of "Yield to the Opinion" of the military leadership.

To quote:

[i]Having said that, whether or not gays are allowed to serve in the military is a question that I would pass on to the military experts; I'd yield to their opinion.[/i]

Simply "yielding to the opinion" of someone in public authority, over a policy that discriminates against any subset of the population - I don't think that is consistent with your espoused libertarian views or (without the high-fallutin title) the responsibility of us, as mature and engaging adults.

I said nothing of people wearing their sexual habits on their sleaves, whatsoever.

Don't really know what the heck you are talking about, on that particular front. It bears no relation to anything I wrote.

You did put the comment out there for, one assumes, comment.

by nexs

Would be the key criteria here.

If their sleeves say "Hello, I'm gay!", then that should be fine. It would be the same as a straight man's sleeves that say "Hello, I'm straight!", or, perhaps, even the same as a wedding ring.

In all honesty, if a gay person is too camp to be of any use on the battlefield, then be rid of them. Equally, if a straight person cannot bear to be near a gay person (even, if their actions are a battle-central as they should be), to the point that it interferes with their battle savvy, then be rid of them, also.

Edited for clarity.

by ansugisalas

don't say it.

Are you having a bad time or something? You seem to be far from at ease with yourself.
You used to be more calm about opposition.

Take care.

by ansugisalas

Cato, then. I mixed up my [i]Praeterea censeo[/i] with my [i]Quousque tandem[/i]. My point, thus amended, still takes a ploppy dump down the neck of yours.

by ansugisalas

Dame Edna in Ranger School...
But srsly, I don't think anyone's arguing for the right to be stylish... just for the right to pursue a normal career without having to lie about their private lives.

by nexs

And if you look on the other side of the 'coin', the straights would go around bragging on the girls they'd bedded.

Bit of a double standard, don't you think?
;)

by ansugisalas

"Sir, No Sir!!! I don't feel comfortable pooping when I think there might be openly gay people around!!"
"I have homophobic sphincter syndrome, no can go!"
:D
What Maxwell didn't say about his discussion is, that it isn't about "there be gays" or "there be no gays"... because "there be gays" alright. Just not openly at present.

And men check out each other in the shower on account of "does that guy have a bigger dong than I?" not on account of "will you look at that juicy-fruit butt right there?" ;) :D :D

by charliespencer

One man's perversion is another man's enjoyment. Or another pair of men's.

What's the difference between kinky and perverted? Kinky is tickling your partner with a feather duster; perverted is using a live chicken.

by kevaburg

I didn't word what I said about the "no relationship" rule very well did I? I see your point there but I wasn't referring to service personnel with a civilian spouse. I was referring to a situation whereby both partners are involved in the same conflict and fighting alongside each other. This happened in the first Gulf War where a soldier fell for a medic in his section. One of them knew where their duty lay but the other was more concerned about the partner. That isn't a situation you would encounter with a civilian spouse.

A policy of DADT is about as ignorant as a policy can get. Instead of discriminating against someone directly, we will tell people that it is OK as long as we don't know anything about it.

And as far as I can tell, most Americans seem to think that is acceptable!

by maxwell edison

Very few people, if any, understood the intent of this discussion. Therefore, I slightly changed the title and added this new message.

For those who may not know, there have been some relevant court cases of late brought by advocates of those who want to change military policy through the courts. The decision was appealed in a higher court's decision.

I've outlined my position in the opening discussion as follows:

[i]One: A person's sexual preference and/or practice is his/her own business. I don't know whether sexual orientation is a matter of choice or birth, nor do I care. It's not my business what you do; it's not your business what I do.

Two: Serving in the military IS NOT a Constitutional right. The military can indeed discriminate for a variety of reasons (sorry, you have flat-foot), all of which are implemented for the purpose of maintaining the most effective military force possible. If you disagree, please show me the exact article of the Constitution that shows me to be wrong. The mission of the military is to be the most effective fighting force - no more, no less.

Having said that, whether or not gays are allowed to serve in the military is a question that I would pass on to the military experts; I'd yield to their opinion.[/i]

For that I've been attacked by some as being intolerant, ant-gay, etc. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Individual issue aside, the underlying question is this. Who decides military policy? The voters? Congress by passing laws? The courts by hearing cases brought forth? Or the military itself - including the designed civilian and elected leader of the military - the president.

My answer is the military itself - including the designed civilian and elected leader of the military - the president.

If military policy regarding one issue is allowed to be decided in the courts and/or the halls of congress, then we open the door to have all military issues decided in the courts and/or the halls of congress.

Many people have cited the instance in which President Truman desegregated the military as support for allowing gays to serve openly in the military. I agree 100 percent, in as much as it was the President of the United States - the Commander in Chief of the U.S. military - who made the decision; the voters did not decide; congress did not decide; and certainly, the courts did not decide.

The courts in the United States were not designed to ride roughshod over the military; and the United States military was not designed to be overseen by the courts.

The question that few - if any - really picked up on isn't whether or not they should serve, but who should decide?

by jamesrl

I assume that the leader of the military, that being the President of the US should decide.

In the past, Presidents implemented "Don't ask, Don't tell", cut bases, even de-segregated the US Military (Truman).

From my poli sci background, courts don't write laws, they interpret them. Sometimes they have to interpret them in the context of a consitution or other over arching document. But they don't write laws, and I've often seen references in supreme court decision , both in Canada and US, for the need for a law to be re-written to make it more clear.

by maxwell edison

Reading through the messages, most (not yours, James) are simply ones expressing personal opinion on an issue - if that person could decide, here's the reasoning; or here's why it should be one way or the other.

SO MANY PEOPLE in the United States fail to consider an underlying premise, an underlying principle, or an underlying authority on which an opinion should be based. Our system of government was established the way it was for a reason. And if the system, per se, becomes outdated, then there's even a designed way to change it - through a constitutional amendment process.

As a simple illustration, people will debate the merits and/or faults of legalizing marijuana all day long, and few will give-in to another's opinion if it differs with theirs. But while one might be personally opposed to it, nowhere in the constitution has the federal government been endowed with the power to decide. Therefore, if a person wants to disallow the sale and consumption of marijuana (on a national level), it should NOT be done by the passing of federal law by legislators elected by voters who want to impose their will onto others; instead it should be done by the passage of a constitutional amendment, not unlike the eighteenth amendment.

Likewise, it matters not whether or not an individual (except the president) believes gays should be allowed to openly serve in the military, but what's the correct process to address the issue? The courts? No. The office of the president is designed to make such a decision. The closest the voters get to making such a decision is voting for the person who will ultimately decide the issue.

Too many people want to impose their personal will onto others, and they use the voting booth to do it. Personally, I don't want to impose my will on anyone. And there are many TR peers who will literally laugh at me for saying such a thing. But it's those same TR peers who don't fully understand our constitutional process. (And imposing my will on others is not defined by trying to prevent others from imposing their will onto me.)

P.S. And then we have people from other countries making their comments - oftentimes snide in nature - but they are totally oblivious to our constitutional intent and process.

by ansugisalas

Is belonging to a military organization something that replaces wholesale the basic citizen liberties?
Or is the reduction of liberties a specific and goal-based one, one delineated by law?

If it's the former then the military can do whatever the hell they like, and then the militias out in the woods start to make a lot more sense.
If it's the latter, then the decision lies within the government of law; and that's a triune one; legislative, judicial, executive.
Be they forever kept seperate and independent of each other *ahem*.

by maxwell edison

[i]Superior[/i] is not the right word. [i]Different[/i] would be more applicable.

[i]Is belonging to a military organization something that replaces wholesale the basic citizen liberties?[/i]

Remove the word [i]wholesale[/i] and replace it with [i]some of[/i], and I would answer with a definite yes. Anyone who's served in the military, including yours truly for six years, knows that to be true. There are scores of things a civilian can do that a soldier can't. The military (in the U.S.) even has its own justice system (UCMJ).

The rest of your message is just nonsense based on the flawed foundation you established in those first two comments - rather those first two comments disguised as questions.

by maxwell edison

Of course it doesn't. But it does redefine a GI's citizenship.

One small example: The right to vote does not change, of course, but participate in a political rally in military uniform and face possible disciplinary action under articles of the UCMJ. A private company may or may not have similar rules, but it is not law for a private citizen like it is for a military citizen.

Moreover, a GI may not agree with the president's politics, but he/she is still obligated to follow that Commander in Chief's orders. A civilian has no such obligation.

I'm guessing that you've never served in the military - especially the US military. Your messages are simply dripping with ignorance.

by slayer_

The military is just a job like any other, just mysteriously in America they are allowed to discriminate.

There are a shit load of examples of countries with militaries that allow gays, non of them have any issues.
If the USA wants to block segments of its people, in a time of war no less, that's their own damn stupidity.

The Canadian military blocked my high school friend from joining, claiming he was overweight. The dude could pick me up and hold me over his head if he wanted, tones of muscle and a very square frame. Apparently that was overweight. Now I consider that stupid, especially since many people would join the military to get in shape (the reserves anyone?).

by maxwell edison

One: The military IS NOT [i]just a job like any other[/i]. To the contrary, it's a job unlike any other.

Two: The President of the United States should decide (at least in the United States). My reasons can be found in previous messages.

by maxwell edison

Stupid, ignorant, and uninformed (or ill-informed) people have no business deciding issues with far-reaching implications. Although I acknowledge that they are part of the process by casting a vote.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_askamerica/20101025/pl_yblog_askamerica/who-is-the-vice-president-ask-america-stumps-voters

It's why we have certain rules for our republic - rules outlined in our constitution.

It avoids "people deciding" all issues.

As a wise man once said, democracy is not two wolves and a sheep deciding on what's for dinner.

by slayer_

This isn't a kingship, the military exists to protect the people, why then, is the military not controlled by the people?

by charliespencer

then there's the possibility of the policy changing every 4 - 8 years. Obviously that hasn't happened with Truman's desegregation decision, but many policies are changed with each new administration.

by maxwell edison

But in a case like this, I strongly doubt it would change, unless there were terrible problems with its implementation. Something like segregation, gays, etc. is an evolving process, not likely to go back to the way it was.

Heck, Obama hasn't even changed Bush military policy regarding two wars, warrantless wire-taps, the Patriot Act, and Guantanamo - even though he vowed to change all of the above while he was campaigning.

by slayer_

Our PM's are even worse, they not only do they lie, cheat and steal, they get caught!

by charliespencer

By the Constitutionally appointed civilian leadership, as chosen by the people. Ask Gen. McChrystal.

Would you have the people directly setting the hiring policies of all government agencies? Would you have them directly setting all military policies, not just the eligibility ones?

I'll back you on the people making military decisions as soon as each completes his term of service. Peace Corps or other form of public service is an acceptable alternative.

by bettylaverne

you may think this is a jump, but I believe the hate crimes against gays are fueled in part by this publicly sanctioned discrimination. Gays do not choose to be gay, and they serve, and have always served in our armed forces, just as heterosexuals do. I was in the military, saw gays serve well, and saw some heterosexuals whom I would not want to go to war with. It is time to end the gay-bashing in this country, and time to end the hate crimes and the horrible events like the recent suicides by gays. it is also time to fund research in genetics which will prove that gays are genetically predisposed to homsexuality, and it is not an evil "sin" as some so-called Christians purport.

by maecuff

I don't understand why this is even an issue. If an American is physically capable of being soldier, if they are emotionally stable enough to handle fighting and they desire to serve their country, then what's the freaking hold up? Serve if you want to serve.

Gender, sexual orientation, religeous views, etc. shouldn't come in to play.

We are way too wrapped up in other people's private lives.

by drowningnotwaving

... to question ANY sector of our government or citizenry with regards any policy that negatively discriminates a section of the community.

To say "I'll leave it to someone else to decide" negates the individual responsibility to stand up and fight for the rights of people.

We absolutely have the right (and I'd argue duty) to demand answers from the Military on why such discrimination occurs, and why it is in our better interest to have such discriminatory policies in place.

If the department / military cannot field appropriate answers then we have an expectation that such policies will be amended to reflect a path more reflective of societal views.

Same as women. Same as indigenous folk in countries around the world.

Further, the premise that only those who have served in the military are allowed to question military practise and policy is simply ludicrous. In any country on the planet.

by Member 25348569

will make absolutely no difference to those who who use the word "sin" to describe anything.

Why the assumption that the studies will prove what you want? Given that the posessor of a "gay gene" wouldn't pass this on to offspring, you're going to have to jump through quite a few hoops to explain why it exists. :)

What is needed is social change. But if your Religious Right is gaining ascendancy - as it looks from over here - with such as Sarah Palin wanting to base your county's law on the Ten Comandments, it isn't going to happen for a while.

by maecuff

I didn't think it possible, but I finally found something nice to say about Sarah Palin. She's not as bad as Christine O'Donnell.

by jamesrl

If Obama sincerely believed he could and would be able to acomplish those things, and then couldn't deliver, it wouldn't be lying.

If he made more promises than anyone could possibly keep, then he'd be very naive. But in my experience most politicans are, and I know many of them personally.

You don't want a leader who does things blindly either. You are probably too young to remember the helicopter deal. Mulroney's tories had committed to a 5.5 billion dollar deal to buy new helicopters for search and rescue and for Canada's ships. Our existing ones were very worn out and experiencing catastrophic failures. The Liberals said they were too expensive and promised to scrap them no matter what. When they got in power they found out that it would cost them 2 billion in penalties to cancel the contract, and running the selection process would cost another 500 million. The correct response would be, the most cost effective thing to do was buy the ones with the deal they had. Instead they broke the deal. It took years to buy some of the copters for search and rescue. They ended up buying a slightly cheaper version of the same one they cancelled.

I think you elect people to make good decisions, and sometimes that means breaking a promise when you find out it was a bad one.

Neither Chretien nor Mulroney have been caught stealing BTW.

by maxwell edison

I would call it blowing smoke in the direction of the current (at the time) political wind, and insight into the ignorance and cluelessness of the person blowing said smoke.

You may or may not remember, but I predicted that Obama would not live up to any of those political promises.

by santeewelding

Until our Our Glorious Leader suffers another attack of petulance.

My email is vetted by no less than the U.S. National Bureau of Standards. Has to be something awry at your end. I am pure.

Maybe, it's your missing sash weights.

by charliespencer

I think it a case of overestimating what a candidate thinks he can accomplish vs. the reality of being president. I think every one who's ever sat in the Oval Office gets a big, fat reality check when their a$$es hit the chair.