Gays Serving in the U.S. Military - Who should decide?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
I have no problem at all with civilians questioning military policy. Hell, I encourage it. DECIDING it is another matter. Then again, I have problems with anyone without a womb or a medical degree making decisions regarding abortion.
If you haven't walked in the shoes and will never walk in the shoes, I don't think you're better qualified to decide than those who have.
Find out who Christine O'Donnell is...
I'm on the case!
Hmm, first impressions suggest that she needs to get laid and that maybe that would lighten her up a bit. Wouldn't get around her quite impressive ignorance, though.
Joking apart, you have some trouble coming with her and her ilk and I just hope it won't spill over onto the rest of us.
Have a nice day, y'all.
:D
by maecuff
I just hope that people get out there and vote next month.
I would like to believe that there are more reasonable people than not..but I have my doubts.
by ansugisalas
"L-aid" is more to the point.
Always overcompensating, those in-denial closet cases :D
As max pointed out, there are several behaviors that are legal for civilians but prohibited to the military.
Many of these exist because of the potential damage to morale. Service people must live and work together in dangerous situations; in deployment situations there is rarely any 'going home at the end of the day'. When you're stuck with the same people CONSTANTLY, you have to be able to at least get along together. Many legal civilian behaviors such as adultery, insubordination, or dating subordinates are against the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), the military law for all branches of US service.
Others laws are intended to ensure the military remembers it is subordinate to civilian leadership. While the military is expected to provide input and options to those leaders (President, Sect'y of Defense, assorted service branch secretaries, other elected officals), once those officials reach a decision, it is expect to be executed without question. Criticism of the capabilities of those officials is also prohibited. Wearing a uniform to certain activities is against the UCMJ, since it may imply the military endorses certain positions or parties.
You don't lose your citizenship when you enlist, but you are agreeing to have certain of your rights suspended. The US military has been an all-volunteer force since not long after the end of our involvement in Vietnam, you're agreeing to those suspensions of your own volition.
by jamesrl
I don't live in Toronto, I work there though, and the municipal election was last night.
The choice was between a right winger who promised to slash spending, and a middle of the road guy who promised to do the same.
The right winger has said some racist things in the past, been convicted of DUI (in Florida), had a marijauna charge dropped, been charged twice with assault, once when he was 18, another time more recently his wife filed charges and then withdrew them.
The middle of the road guy was an Ontario cabinet minister in charge of the ministry of health and under his watch the government wasted 1 billion dollars on an electronic health records scheme where nothing much was accomplished except the creation of a huge bill for consulting fees.
So I'm glad in the burbs, I had a sane choice to make.
by maecuff
like having to choose the lesser between two evils.
Unfortunately, that seems to happen more often than not.
by delbertpgh
First: I've served in the military with gay men, lived in barracks with them, shared community showers with them. I was never gay myself, and no gay guy ever made a move on me, not even when I was glistening wet and soapy, naked and at the peak of my youthful vigor, in the comon shower. If I had gotten propositioned, I would have simply said, "No thanks, a**hole, what do you think I look like? Now, pass the bong and forget it." (Not that we ever passed the bong in the shower. That was in other rooms.) I never had the opportunity to share a foxhole with a gay guy under fire, which seems to be the situation that silly people like to bring up as the Ultimate Dreadful Moment of Sexual Vulnerability, but I doubt it would drive me homo, or drive him to rape.
I guess you could compare all this weird handkerchief-wringing on the part of our generals and conservative thinkers to what they thought about the integration of blacks into the armed forces in 1948, which was done not by Congress or courts, but by Truman's executive order. What about the massive prejudice in the country? Was the military supposed to take the lead in overcoming that, ahead of the civilians? Would forcing ("forcing," damn it?) men to serve and bunk with negroes cause dissension, harm morale, reduce effectiveness, and adversely impact reenlistment? If you took a poll of white soldiers in 1948, and asked it they would want to share bunk rooms, toilets, showers, mess tables, and every minute of the day with colored soldiers, what do you think the opinion would be? If there had been no integration in 1948 and you asked the same question in 1965 or 1970, what do you think the opinion would be? If they asked the generals instead of the men? Answer: the same, at all times, in all cases. "No, not now, why change, why hurry?"
It was done, and the military survived, and the country outlasted the communists in the cold war. And, we're better for it, though there will always be some who disagree. (Check out stormfront.com and amren.com.)
Congress should open service to open gays, but it won't, because Republicans will sell out justice for the reactionary vote every time. So, that's my answer to your question, "Who should decide?" Congress should, but they won't, even if most of the country thinks it's a decent idea. Somebody should, because it's justice, and there's no worthy objection to it, let alone one that should override justice.
I've seen no evidence that queer G.I.s reduce military effectiveness. I just see "experts" afraid to advocate change. The country as a whole has come to accept homosexuals as valid citizens, just as they have learned that Jews, Mormons, Indians, blacks, and women are entitled to the everyday rituals and privileges of citizenship.
by ansugisalas
Chalking up one more brewup to DelbertPGH ;)
On a different note; this whole thing got me thinking about resistance to change in general.
As I see it, Conservatism has to be smart. Conservatism has to be "not changing without reason".
"Not changing for reasons of We Don't Do That" isn't conservatism; it's Stagnatism, and that's a surefire road to decline.
My own ideal is dynamic equilibrium though; the image is that of balancing on top of a ball. Thinking "I'm not going to move" will lead to a simple fall. To stay put you have to keep your feet lively. The ball represents "life", it's predictable unpredictability and it's unpredictable predictability.
by delbertpgh
The "don't ask/don't tell" license to serve, which means it's okay so long as nobody tells your commander you're gay, was passed by Congress. Congress should therefore repeal it.
Courts have overturned the law, because (in our evolving conception of justice and citizenship, which changes over time) they believe it is unconstitutional, under terms of the equal protection guaranteed by the 14th amendment. Civil law once divided homosexuals from the full rights of citizenship, just as it still divides criminals from full citizenship. Civil law and the public imagination have moved.
The President is obliged to defend the laws that Congress passes. That's why Obama's Justice Department is busy making court cases and filing to stay execution of that judge's decision, because the President is not at liberty to ignore the nation's laws. Until the case is affirmed by the Supreme Court, or until Congress liquidates its existing law, he's stuck defending something he wants to overturn.
by delbertpgh
Except, apparently, immigration laws - and specifically in the state of Arizona, where that state's governor pleaded with him to enforce those very laws.
And, apparently, voter intimidation laws - and specifically in the state of Pennsylvania where activities of Black Panther activists were swept under the rug.
by delbertpgh
Immigration laws are enforced by the INS and Border Patrol, within the budget allotted by Congress to that purpose, and consistent with their policies of enforcement over the years. In an election year, Arizona's governor chooses to stamp her feet and tell Barack Obama how he should be enforcing laws. Well, she's got that right. Admittedly, Arizona has a bigger illegal immigrant problem than other states. They do like to dramatize it, I notice.
The Black Panther voter intimidation case was two guys who showed up at one Philadelphia polling station on election day in 2008, one of them carrying a night stick, who both shot off their mouths for a while while wearing urban militia costume. A cop was called, the guy with the night stick was told to leave, and did. The other one stayed for a while. Although some peripheral figures said this was part of a national Black Panther initiative, it doesn't look as there was ever more that two guys at one polling place in Philadelphia. Charges were filed by the Department of Justice, then dropped. There has apparently been some sort of investigation:
http://www.mainjustice.com/2010/10/25/civil-rights-commission-spent-almost-175000-in-black-panthers-probe/
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203550604574361071968458430.html
The Tea Panthers at work:
http://www.redstate.com/anitamoncrief/2010/10/21/uncle-sam-funds-acorn-poll-workers-but-tea-party-group-investigated/
My guess is that a few blockheads went out in both cases, trying to be important and intimidate some voters. Voters refused to cooperate; nobody was intimidated. Nobody will be prosecuted. A lot of partisans will feel just terrible about that, and will keep yakking on and on. Ho, hum. Doesn't seem like much of anything real happened.
by delbertpgh
The President is not free to abrogate acts of Congress. It's been done, as when Truman refused to build out the Air Force to congressionally authorized levels, but it's rare.
Only the courts can rule an act of Congress illegal.
An overused platitude being thrown around, not only by drowningnotwaving, but others as well, is [i]the people[/i] should decide this or that.
First of all, we live in a representative republic, not - thankfully - a pure democracy.
Secondly, [i]the people[/i] do not speak with a single voice - never have, and never will. Thus, the brilliant design of a representative republic that operates under a specific set of rules.
Too many people think with their emotions, not with their heads. Because I dare to suggest there are other people more qualified than I to make certain decisions, I'm suddenly painted as negligent in my duties as one of [i]the people[/i]! That's simply ludicrous.
Personally, I made my position quite clear: I have no problem with anyone, regardless of sexual orientation and/or preference, I have no problem interacting with that general group of folks, either professionally or socially, and I don't judge them. But when it comes to managing and structuring a military machine the size and scope of the US military, and considering its purpose, I don't believe social engineering should trump overall effectiveness, and that consideration of such is best left to those who are more savvy and experienced in that regard. To suggest that I know better than General Petraeus, or some other such person, on how to run an effective military machine is not only silly, but it's rather stupid.
On one hand, The Joint Chiefs of Staff advise the president on all matters concerning the military. On the other hand, the president is accountable to the citizens of the United States and has to work with Congress. It's his decision, and his alone, to balance the two, or to place more emphasis on one over the other. As such, I would have absolutely no criticism at all of the current president if he, as Commander in Chief, ordered all branches of the military to open its ranks to openly gay people. Just do it and put an end to the debate; it's about as simple as that. And if any president would be inclined to issue such an order, one would think it's this one. Why he's not doing it is one of the proverbial $64,000 questions.
But quite frankly, an issue like this pales in comparison to other issues we face right now. Another person asked, why is it even an issue? That's really a good question. While our republican house (small r, not large R) is burning down all around us, people are arguing over who gets which bedroom.
You really have to define the purpose of the military before you can truly decide who has the right to define the structure.
If your military is solely to be used for the defense of your country (as yours so obviously is not) then social engineering should not trump effectiveness. Although I'm not sure how those - very few - few gays who want to serve in such a homophobic environment so reduce the effectiveness in any measurable way.
However, your Secretary of Defense stated "Army soldiers can expect to be tasked with reviving public services, rebuilding infrastructure and promoting good governance. All these so-called nontraditional capabilities have moved into the mainstream of military thinking, planning, and strategy - where they must stay."
So, if you're going to have your military perform all of those functions that would normally be within the scope of non-military organisations, don't you think that "effectiveness" need not be limited to the "fox-hole" argument and that - perhaps - generals [b]aren't[/b] the right people to define the structure?
As for "promoting good governance", that was pretty much the role of the military in the Roman Empire. And in any good military dictatorship.
I've got to be honest, although I'm deliberately stirring, I do have enormous misgivings about the activities of the US military machine. I can't be the only one who sees the Orwellian Newspeak where the Department of Defense oversees a military machine that hasn't defended you against anyone since the name change from the "The War Department". OK, so you've defended South Vietnam, Israel and Saudia Arabia, but that doesn't count
:)
Yeah, I know, I'm a "perfidious foreigner" and I have no right to poke my nose in, etc, etc. But you can't stop me. So there!
..... change the size, scope, and mission of the United States military, what would it look like? Since you have [i]enormous misgivings about the activities of the US military machine[/i], you surely have a picture of what it should look like.
P.S. Points to ponder:
I've never made any such [i]fox hole[/i] argument.
[i]Homophobic[/i] is, all too often, unfairly and/or inaccurately thrown into any number of debates - it only tugs at pulling one's emotions over one's reason. Any-phobic is considered an irrational fear of something, and various [i]phobic[/i] charges are often levied against an argument that's neither irrational nor based on fear. It's more often than not, just another one of those overused platitudes people toss around.
While you might be a [i]perfidious foreigner[/i], you're OUR [i]perfidious foreigner[/i]!
"...reviving public services, rebuilding infrastructure and promoting good governance."
And here I thought that was the Peace Corps' mission.
You forgot our 'defenses' of Panama and Grenada.
by pser
?I have no problem with anyone, regardless of sexual orientation and/or preference, I have no problem interacting with that general group of folks, either professionally or socially, and I don't judge them.? - Max
Is that the same stance you take/have in regards to the B.S.A.? Do you ?advocate? with such vigor, your support of ?inclusion?? Or, do you, with your actions and money support a group who DOES discriminate against ?Gays??
This is simply, ANOTHER, not so thinly veiled attempt to trash President Obama and or anything ?Dem./Lib.??
If he were to pull a ?Truman? and 'make it so'... I?d bet dollars to doughnuts you?d be railing against his audacity to "issue such an order" without Congressional and or Judicial involvement. Pfffttt!
The ONLY reason this is an issue at all is because of ? as neilb would put it ? ?Religious Nutters?, both past and present ... PERIOD
Yeah, Yeah, ?the debate NOT the debater? but come on?!?! It's this debater's "debates" that insight such reactions! Gahhhh!
The BSA is a private organization. As such, just like any private organization, it has the right to association; and the courts have upheld such arguments, not only with regards to the BSA, but regarding other private organizations as well - men's only golf clubs, for example.
Whether or not a person associates himself (or herself) with the BSA is a matter of choice. If someone doesn't like the rules, they don't have to join. The same holds true with the Girl Scouts.
There's nothing preventing a group of people from creating a GSA - Gay Scouts of America - I suppose, one for which an exclusion of heterosexual persons is among the bylaws.
Is the Catholic Church (or some other church, for that matter) justified in choosing to disassociate themselves with those who openly question the existence of God?
Would the National Black Panthers be justified in keeping some white guy out?
Would the KKK be justified in keeping some Black guy out?
Would a nude female yoga club be justified in keeping men out?
I'm a libertarian. I may not agree with someone's behavior, their choices, or their lifestyle - and I may even choose to not associate with them - but I defend their right to behave as they please, as long as they don't infringe on the choices and rights of others.
I might also choose to not associate with roving gangs, or goths, or white supremacists, or people who always preach Christianity to others, or.........
You presume that [i]discrimination[/i] is always a bad thing. Well, I'll discriminate against smokers who want to light-up in my home. Is that wrong?
A person with very discriminating taste once said that the right to association is often confused with discrimination.
It does, at the moment that someone makes a discriminate call with no fact or evidence.
Based upon their heart, to use your words, and clearly not their head.
You've got your head so far stuck up your butt with regards 'due process' that your ability to actually see the issue has gone to zero.
Oh, and nice dodge on 'changing the title' and having a special little meaning to your whole post that you only choose to reveal later on in the discussion.
Word games? You wanker!! At least you're good for a laff.
by oz_media
if anyone wants to serve their country they should well and rightly be able to do so. What person in their most insane mind would stop someone from defending their nation?
Of course, just like anyone else, they would be expected to complete the standard training, medical clearance etc. That aside, what else would possibly stop a military branch from deploying anyone ?
The only reason to stop them or anyone for that matter, would be the inability to complete training, physical disability etc.
Why would they even be singled out to begin with? Why not just ask "Should men and women be allowed to join the military?"
Sexual relations, even heterosexual, are not supposed to take place anyway. They are all just soldiers, women or men, no difference at that point.
by slayer_
by oz_media
As usual, trends are determined by media and marketing. They can make ANYONE look good or bad in US media as it is so untrained. I don't mean regulated, as in freedom of speech should be removed but it seems the people just gobble up the Enquirer style new reports they air Stateside. Then again, that's what they are used to and are force fed, once again by the media.
The US media controls the outcome of presidential elections. The Us media decides if and when the US goes to war (based on creating or removing public support). The president says something and people turn to the media to find out the details. Again, this is just a common and expected mindset of a public that has grown up immersed in such media spins. It get's to the point that you can't determine fact from fiction.
Unfortunately, this has also stemmed into the inacceptance/acceptance of soft drugs, public views toward other nations people and governments, racism, political correctness run amok, presidential scandals etc.
No I don't think all Americans are drones, sucked into the media, but SO MANY are. If they are not, they are often steered in one direction or another by others who are just as radical one way or another. Spins, trends, headlines and fear seem to fuel the American way, unfortunately.
Again, and I add this only because SOMEONE will get the wrong idea,this does not pertain to all Americans, but a great deal who don't spend time looking at the rest of the world through different channels. They simply rely on what the media spins, what is hip to follow and the 'trend' that has been set.
by oz_media
by oz_media
Discriminating based on skin colour, should be as adversely opposed as discriminating based on shoe size, sexuality, eye colour or any other stupid reason to stop someone serving their country.
If they discriminate against gay's, there will still be and always has been, gays in the military. They just won't say anything about it, as always.
However, show me where personal sexual preference, specifically gay sexuality, has stopped a military body from operating effectively.
I don't mean soldiers getting PO's and not wanting to share quarters or fight beside them, that has nothing to do with the gay soldiers at all but the ignorance of others fighting with them.
Perhaps they should screen out members who can not accept the gay lifestyle instead?
by delbertpgh
by ansugisalas
these things are also "illegal" under many other forms of employment.
Specifically under the kind of employments that constitute many desireable careers.
So, flipping burgers at mickey D's; you're allowed to slip boogers into the special sauce (right?!?), but if you're a corporate or federal or state career officer, then lots of things are out, because your employer says so. That's similar enough to the military limitations to illustrate my point.
Similarly; everyone can buy stock - but if you happen to have inside information to motivate the buying or selling of stock - presto - it's a crime.
Liberties are reducable by law.
Laws govern the military too.
What would it even be without it? Think about this: a military not governed by law... don't think the US military isn't, it is governed to a large degree.
Heck - even black ops turn up on fiscal bills once in a while!
"these things are also "illegal" under many other forms of employment."
No. None of the things I listed are civilian crimes. They may get you fired, but if not specifically spelled out as violations of company policy, they may not even result in termination. They won't result in a trial, prison sentence, criminal record, or potential loss of retirement funds like a UCMJ violation. When a civilian job fires you, your relationship is over. When you're convicted of violating the UCMJ, you're still in the military while serving time, often at the lowest rank, still subject to the UCMJ and military regulation.
by ansugisalas
I agree that the military contract is a very tight one.
But I look at it as a set of 1) Contract, 2) Code of conduct, 3) Penalties for breach of code/contract.
Different jobs have different settings in the various parts of the set; from near-zero to prohibitively severe.
The military employment set is pretty severe in all parts.
Some jobs are more severly delineated though, like, some positions in criminal organizations. To say nothing of us in the Bavarian Ill*ghurrrkh*
by oz_media
From what I understand, campaign promises unless specified to date, are a list of objectives the candidate will seek to impart during a four year term in office.
If I am not wrong, he is almost halfway through that term now (Nov. 2008, right?)
In the first half of his term, did he not finish implementing national health care and start reallocating troops from Iraq to Afghanistan (and a bunch of other stuff I am sure some oppose and some support)?
My point is, from what I understand he still has two years to make good on campaign promises, or is he supposed to have it all sorted in the first year or two then just surprise everyone with his actions for the next two years?
The president can indeed overturn congressional legislation through the veto process. Yes, I know that Congress can override a presidential veto, but it takes 2/3 majority, not a simple majority.
Moreover, when it comes to the armed forces, the president, as I've repeatedly said, is the Commander in Chief. Congress is not the Commander in Chief, the president is. As such, I might believe that in the case of military matters, the president could indeed override congressional legislation. If Congress was intended to be the Commander in Chief Panel, then it would have been written into the Constitution as such; instead, the president is given that role.
And as you, yourself, pointed out, only the courts can declare something illegal. Just because you say something would be illegal, it doesn't mean it would be. Acknowledging, of course, that neither of us is a legal scholar.
by oz_media
I knew there was a period of a few month before they were actually "handed the keys" so to speak. But doesn't that make his time actually IN office even shorter so far?
So he's been in less than 2 years, yet is expected to have upheld all campaign promises already? Is this the way all presidents are viewed? "You said you'd get it done so do it already!"
When I give an employer a time frame that I will reach a goal, I usually do it within that time frame but not in the first few weeks or even first few months.
under my rule. And it wouldn't go gallivanting around the world, righting wrongs. Or wronging rights as it has occasionally done in the past.
It's big enough - and then some - to do what it ought to be doing and that is defend your country against all-comers. You know my thoughts about the Iraq war and all of your other forays into gunboat diplomacy. It wouldn't be so bad if any of them had been successful!
(So, what are you going to do about Iran? Tony Blair wants you to whip their asses.)
I wasn't accusing [b]you[/b] of the fox-hole argument. I'm simply making the suggestion that, if the purpose of the US army is broader than simply defending your shores against an invading army, the fox-hole argument - that relationships between soldiers might cause inappropriate reactions under fire - is almost totally specious. And it's the only argument that I've ever seen against women troops or gays.
Homophobia? Well, there's no other reason that I can see for society to feel threatened by homosexuals whilst I can see many reasons why the reverse might be true - here and where you are. And yet your vast military machine sees some sort of threat in gays.
Oh, I'm not really perfidious. The perfidious will stab you in the back. I will stab you in the front.
When you're not looking, anyway.
Or if you're shorter or weaker than me...
Neil
Obama continued the Bush strategy, almost to the letter, regarding Iraq and Afghanistan.
Obama promised to close Guantanamo in his first year. I predicted that he would not; and he has not.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2010/07/obama-guantanamo.html
I will suggest, however, that he made the promise under a cloud of ignorance and cluelessness. He would if he could, but once in the position, he discovered that he just couldn't. But even I knew that. Why didn't he know it?
[i]"Sorry, American people,"[/i] he should say. [i]"I didn't know what I was talking about when I made the promise to close Guantanamo. Once I got into this office, I came to discover that the Bush policy regarding Guantanamo wasn't that bad after all."[/i]
by oz_media
by ansugisalas
by oz_media
by oz_media
that's the great thing about our government, well it's not bad anyway, and about all that it's got going for it. The minority party keeps the majority in check and the majority KNOWS they will be toppled in a heartbeat if they screw up.
Other than that, they are all bullspit politicians who don't merit a moment's credibility. But at least we all know it and don't defend the creepy baystards, no matter what party we voted for.
by oz_media
Which one of you is playing Arthur? :D
DENNIS I told you. We?re an anarcho-syndicalist commune. We take it in turns to act as a sort of executive officer for the week.
ARTHUR Yes.
DENNIS But all the decisions of that officer have to be ratified at a special biweekly meeting.
ARTHUR Yes, I see.
DENNIS By a simple majority in the case of purely internal affairs?
ARTHUR Be quiet!
DENNIS ?but by a two-thirds majority in the case of more?
ARTHUR Be quiet! I order you to be quiet!
WOMAN Order, eh?who does he think he is?
ARTHUR I am your king!
WOMAN Well, I didn?t vote for you.
by ansugisalas
for other federal employees of certain levels.
Ping.
P.S. Your guess that I have not served in the US military speaks volumes.
by oz_media
It is amazing how you know hat the president doesn't, given the teams of people he has that are supposed to know better. How your wisdom has not been imparted on the millions of Americans already is beyond me. Simply put, the world, erm, America, would be a better place tomorrow if they'd only give you the keys.
I know you would change it all in a few days, sure people would be wearing white wigs and knickers, carrying jewel adorned snuff boxes while peasants dumped their soiled toilet bowl into the streets each morning but it would be a better place for many.
by delbertpgh
Although the President can veto Congress's law, that is only possible within the ten days following Congress's vote. After that time elapses, it's settled law.
I think the only time the President could get away with overriding legislation in his capacity as commander in chief would be in an outright emergency, in which national security was at immediate risk.
Of course, there are plenty of points where the President will somewhat fudge execution of a law, knowing that Congress will not impeach over the small stuff; and Congress would in some cases be happy not to have to debate and be held accountable for a law.
by ansugisalas
ask the experts. Is there a good reason?
What are the benefits?
There are drawbacks alright, that's a given.
The present rules do not actually bar homosexuals, it only forces them to be fundamentally dishonest in their dealings with the military. Now, that can't be good.
by slayer_
by oz_media
by oz_media
While church and state are not supposed to cross paths that way, I think it's clear to all that the right wing has a VERY Christian focused demographic and leadership. Well Bush even used his faith to address his reasons for denying gay marriage, though that is not Constitutional and as thus was not his real reason, I'm sure.
That's not to say the left doesn't include people with religious faith, in fact I think from a citizenship standpoint, it's probably even keeled.
Religion is still very strong in the US, compared to many other countries that have seen a decline in religious 'attendance' (as far as Sunday church is concerned).
So while there has been a noticeable change in the US being based on Christian faith, it is still there in one form or another and I feel will always influence their leadership stronger than in most other Western nations.
You are correct in that, as long as it is deemed a SIN, it will always be contested. Unfortunately while it seems times are changing, they just aren't changing fast enough or just enough period.
This religious focus of US politicians, makes them seem so out of touch, out of date, separated from the realities of the rest of the world. It's almost like talking to cavemen.
While I accept ANYONE'S right and reasoning for their chosen faith, without question, it simply cannot be used as a reasoning for political decisions that effect citizens of all faiths.
I watched a show the other day, Undercover Boss. (I think te hUK started that one so you know how it goes). A c-level employee goes undercover to find out what's really going on in the company. they had the CEO of a hotel chain, who is VERY religious and feels God guides his every move, which is all fine and dandy if that's what gets you by. but he made a comment that threw me for a loop.
He said: There are two types of people. Those in that turn to God and will always find his help, and those who turn away from him and will never find peace.
THAT'S the kind of complete ignorance the right wing fuels and thrives on. his FAITH doesn't bother me, his dismissal of anyone who doesn't follow HIS God will never find peace bothers me.
by oz_media
And then the PM grabs the guy, who pied him in the face, by the throat and threatens him. LOL :D
You's better not be tikin' aboot doin that again ya-noo!?
by oz_media
Sorry to jump in Max but don't you think that's a bit harsh?
Last I checked, Finland was not a state.
I'll assume by the use of ignorance you didn't mean it to be derogatory toward Ansu's intelligence but meant it in it's true form of merely being uninformed.
After reading quite a few of Ansu's posts, I think it's fair to say that a lack of intelligence is not the issue at play here.
Again though, sorry to jump in but that seemed a bit rash coming from you, you generally show a little more restraint and patience, toward most others anyway.
Personally speaking, I usually try not to comment on things about which I know nothing - things about which I'm totally ignorant - like serving in the Finnish military.
I said, [i]"I'm guessing that you've never served in the military - especially the US military. Your messages are simply dripping with ignorance.[/i]"
Currently there are upwards of 16,000 non-citizens serving in the U.S. Armed Forces. About 8,000 join each and every year.
[i]Finland was not a state?[/i] What's that all about?
P.S. In my book, AnsuGisalas doesn't deserve too much, at least from me. I can't recall many of his comments to me that weren't snide or otherwise condescending in nature. We usually have a couple of back-and-forths, after which I ignore him. Maybe he doesn't intend to come across that way, but he sure appears to from my perspective. If I'm quick to pull the impatience trigger, I've been given reason.
(The same applies to the guy from Australia.)
by oz_media
Well I don't disagree with your view toward drowningnotwaving, I've been there too and the level of intelligence often drops pretty low at that point.
I have tossed it around with ansu too, but for the most part have found that a language barrier is the general problem. not that the language is poor, but perhaps some of the phrasing leave a bit to be desired and can be taken wrong. I try to read one or two times, with a break in between to ensure that there is not double meaning and false implication.
I am certainly not about to tell you how to read posts or what to think of people though, you don't need my help there.
As for the Finland comment, it just seemed that you hadn't taken into account that he's not American. I often don't pay any attention to where people are from or what they do, I couldn't care less half the time either. I reflect on the comments and often that is telling enough.
Ignorance, I had a feelign that's what you meant, the literal definition and not a slur, but the way it was out forth, and coming from anyone else, I would have thought otherwise.
by ansugisalas
I don't mind you, and my snide remarks aren't aimed at you, as such. I'm aiming at that soap-box under your feet.
I see through you: You're an OK sort, and you'd be an interesting one to converse with. Except - you keep that box tied to the bottom of your shoes and it keeps you from using footwork. It makes you very dull.
I'm not in your flock, and you will never convince me of anything from on top of that box. But if you come one down I'll lend you an ear, at least enough to give you a run for your money. That's what keeps a person young, you know?
Footwork - That, and talking to people one does not necessarily initially understand.
I have no problem with people of faith, so to speak, regardless of the flavor of said faith. But wearing it on one's sleeve for all to see, and to proudly proclaim for all to hear! No thanks. (Not unlike a few other things people [i]wear on their sleeve for all to see![/i])
I saw that episode of Undercover Boss, and that kind of stuff turns me off as well. In fact, I even [i]discriminate[/i] against them by choosing to not associate with them.
However, not all right-wing (or Conservative or Republicans) fit the mold you describe, although all are usually painted with the same wide brush.
Conservatives, generally speaking, can be either fiscal conservatives, or social conservatives, or both. George Will or the late Willim F. Buckly (fiscal) versus Mike Huckabee and his ilk (both), for example. And I know some conservatives who are actually agnostic and/or atheist, but their fiscal conservative convictions are strong enough to pull them into, and keep them in the Republican Party. They, like me, strive to bring more libertarian principles into play from within one of the two major parties instead of being out of the arena by way of a minor party that will never win anything.
by oz_media
I too accept anyone's faith, what right have I to deny you belief and hope?
In that same sense, what right has a devout Christian to deny me the right to choose my own faith or beliefs? Who are they to tell me I am a sinner or will suffer eternally? It's the hypocrisy that gets me riled.
"Have respect for our faith....sinner."
I also understand that not all Republicans are hard core Christians, but you cannot deny that the majority are. A lot of the principles they instill as "truly American" are merely principles based on their Christian faith. When they say it is unAmerican, they could often say it is unChristian and mean the same thing, but that wouldn't be prudent.
There is also no question that there are still a greater number of Americans actively practicing and preaching Christian faith, compared to other western democracies. Whereas many others have since "modernized" (for lack of a better word) and started to follow more realistic paths through life than the simplistic, faith based solutions to all that is hard, bad or wrong.
"God leads me" Well you may feel hi guides you and watches over you but every circumstance you face and overcome is entirely your doing. Sorry but I just don't know how anyone can TRULY believe otherwise. We aren't puppets after all.
But I digress, it is not people's right to faith I question. It is people of faith that deny others the right to NOT follow such paths of faith that really gets to me.
Back to the Undercover Boss, he was a great guy, saw some reality made positive changes, even if rather superficial, but his denial of someone without Christian faith to guide themselves was just really off-putting.
reporting to the people, that decision can be influenced by the people, or the person removed.
Whether or not this happens is moot.
Palmetto, your comment re abortions and the influence due on decision makers (predominantly males and predominantly without medical degrees), actually says it all.
To think that the citizenry (rightfully or wrongfully) cannot or will not force decisions is simply untrue. It happens in all walks of life. The military don't get a special right to say 'sorry hands off', and in my opinion of course they do not deserve it.
You should be ashamed of yourself, Delbert.
Two extremist right-wing white supremacists dressed in military garb, carrying night sticks, pounding them into their palms, who, by their very presence and demeanor, were attempting to intimidate voters - and you call it [i]Ho Hum[/i]?
Are you serious? You should be ashamed of yourself!
Oh my, did I get my colors mixed up; and did I confuse left and right?
P.S. Who else shares Delbert's [i]Ho Hum[/i] attitude about this obvious voter intimidation case?
Changing black to white and left to right seems to paint a different picture, don't you think?
In reality, however, one's the print and the other is the negative, but both exposing the same thing.
You are no slouch.
You land on your feet.
by herlizness
<< Two: Serving in the military IS NOT a Constitutional right. The military can indeed discriminate for a variety of reasons (sorry, you have flat-foot), all of which are implemented for the purpose of maintaining the most effective military force possible. If you disagree, please show me the exact article of the Constitution that shows me to be wrong >>
See Amendment XIV.
For the reasoning on the issue, read the opinion of the Supreme Court in Lawrence vs. Texas. I think the logic of the case compels the conclusion that gays cannot be excluded from military service consistent with equal protection under the law guaranteed by the amendment.
Just to be clear, however, I am not saying that homosexual conduct while on active duty is constitutionally protected; it most probably is not. There is a world of difference between discrimination based on status and discrimation based on conduct.
[i]Section 1.
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Section 2.
Representatives shall be apportioned among the several states according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons in each state, excluding Indians not taxed. But when the right to vote at any election for the choice of electors for President and Vice President of the United States, Representatives in Congress, the executive and judicial officers of a state, or the members of the legislature thereof, is denied to any of the male inhabitants of such state, being twenty-one years of age, and citizens of the United States, or in any way abridged, except for participation in rebellion, or other crime, the basis of representation therein shall be reduced in the proportion which the number of such male citizens shall bear to the whole number of male citizens twenty-one years of age in such state.
Section 3.
No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any state, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any state legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any state, to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. But Congress may by a vote of two-thirds of each House, remove such disability.
Section 4.
The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned. But neither the United States nor any state shall assume or pay any debt or obligation incurred in aid of insurrection or rebellion against the United States, or any claim for the loss or emancipation of any slave; but all such debts, obligations and claims shall be held illegal and void.
Section 5.
The Congress shall have power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.[/i]
Please be specific?
To what are you referring?
Regarding Lawrence vs. Texas, military rules and regulation is not the same as state law.
[i]No state shall make or enforce any law ....... [/i]
The military is not a state.
I will say this, however. Yours is one of the best replies.
by herlizness
<< I assume you're referring to Section 1 of Amendment 14 ... Please be specific? ... To what are you referring? >>
of course I refer to Section 1
<< Regarding Lawrence vs. Texas, military rules and regulation is not the same as state law >>
yes, but without a long-winded discussion of the UCMJ here, the relevant law to most observers is DADT, which is US Federal law codified at 10 USC 654, and it has been held since 1954, in Bolling v. Sharpe, that the equal protection clause of Amend. XIV applies to acts of the federal government via the doctrine of reverse incorporation
please note that while 10 USC 654 does enunciate your original premise that there is "no constitutional right to serve in the armed forces," such provision has yet to be fully tested and is subject to judicial review; it should be clear that Congress may not, by fiat, pass upon the constitutionality of its own enactments
<< The military is not a state >>
see above
<< I will say this, however. Yours is one of the best replies >>
thank you
by herlizness
<< But I do agree - the U.S. Constitution decides. And as such, it's the president's call >>
not really; see Article III, U.S. Constitution and Marbury v. Madison; it is the province of the court to say what the law is .. and of course the province of the legislature to make the law in the first instance
the complication here of course is that the president is also commander in chief, which presumably gives him some measure of authority on the issue. Presently, the issue is largely academic, though, since President Obama believes that Congress should be the branch to change the law, for what I think are fairly sound reasons.
..... considering the fact that no legal challenge has been presented on such a basis. Or if it has, it couldn't stand up under legal scrutiny.
If it had merit, some legal scholar would have surely pursued it by now.
It's the president's call - period.
by delbertpgh
In Log Cabin Republicans v. United States, the Federal Circuit Court ruled that DADT violated the 1st amendment, in that the restrictions of expression it imposed by servicemen was not justified by a pressing security need... that the ban against homosexuality on grounds of maintaining military readiness was not demonstrated, and appeared to be bogus. Also, there was some rationale about self-incrimination (the 5th amendment.)
Legal language was entered in the 1994 Defense Authorization Act which stated that homosexual activity was incompatible with military service. Clinton responded by inventing the "Don't Ask/Don't Tell", implemented as an executive order. Obama can revoke the DADT executive order, but that leaves him with law saying gays can't serve, period. DADT is a policy that limits investigation of possible homosexuality; it does not legitimate or de-legitimate it.
The House of Representative in 2010 passed a new authorization bill, which includes the "Murphy Amendment" that will void the language of the 1994 authorization, subsequent to a review by the Secretary of Defense. It was passed by the Senate Armed Services Committee, but was filibustered by John McCain and others. The authorization is still stalled.
There's another case in another court where a similar judgement was passed on Sept 25th. I don't know anything about that one.
Until I researched it, I assumed that the case would have been made based on the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. Turns out they chose to argue it on the 1st, as a free expression issue.
by herlizness
Mr. Edison, I've provided you with the constitutional, statutory and case law rationale for my position ... and expanded it somewhat in my most recent reply to DelbertPGH, who has actually done a bit of homework on the issues presented by DADT.
If you have a cogent legal argument to rebut mine, please go ahead and make it. Saying the some legal scholar would have made the argument is to say nothing at all. In all events, as I have noted, counsel in Log Cabin Republicans v. US did assert an equal protection claim, which is given vitality through the 14th Amendment, not merely via the 5th standing alone.
Moreover, your continued insistence that "it's the president's call - period" is wholly and completely inaccurate. If you've ever bothered to read Article I, Section 8 of the US Constitution, surely you've noticed that one of the enumerated powers specifically committed to the Congress is "To make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces."
In my opinion, the president likely has authority under Article II to issue an executive order suspending enforcement of the policies prescribed by Congress in 10 USC 654 but he surely does not have the authority to repeal the act itself using some sort of post facto veto power. At the moment, the issue is moot as President Obama has decided, as a prudential matter and not a legal or constitutional matter, to leave the decision where it is explicitly committed, apparently upon the belief that it will be a more durable policy if so done. I agree. Congressional authority on the matter is explicit; presidential authority is implied and derivative.
I take it that you are not a lawyer and accordingly find it a bit peculiar that you should become so doctrinaire on legal issues, particularly with regard to complex and nuanced legal issues.
by delbertpgh
If there was some actual voter intimidation going on, I'd be upset about it.
What you have in Philadelphia is two clowns who wanted to seem tough and intimidate voters. They dressed the part, talked the lines, and one of them carried a stick, and acted scary, but I haven't got information that they actually scared anyone, or impeded or influenced anyone's vote. The guy with the stick went quietly away when a cop told him to leave. Unless I'm misinformed, the rest of the day proceded without incident.
The DoJ evidently considered bringing charges against these bums and/or the Black Panther organization, and then dropped it. Black guys who want to get black people agitated would probably like to see them charged and hauled around by cops. White guys who want to get white people agitated are happy to see them not prosecuted at all, so they can complain about prejudice. "We white/black folks are being stomped upon and having our rights violated by a conspiracy of black/white criminals at the highest levels of government!" If you want to play the game, just repeat the preceding sentence to yourself, selecting your racial preference as appropriate.
The option to prosecute may have seemed like a non-starter for Justice. If some voter got hit with the stick, if somebody got pushed or threatened, if there was some defining action (instead of a malefactor who just "seemed threatening" and belonged to a militant group,) then you'd have a felony or major misdemeanor issue with jail time attached. Instead, there were two guys wearing beret caps, one stick, some words, and a man who left when asked. Try and make a case with that. A good defense attorney could make that look like half of nothing. The Civil Rights Commission has investigated the failure of the government to prosecute. It will be mildly interesting to see what fault they find.
by delbertpgh
He thinks that perversion is nearly normal, impossible to avoid if you've got it, and the source of fun. He welcomes it, providing it is not abusive. "Pervert" fails to be the condemnation it once was.
Oral used to be something that perverts liked. Some churchmen still rail against it, but now oral is pretty much mainstream, a third date kind of thing. If you were ahead of your time and liked oral in 1965, you were a perv. Gay men will always and all be perverts, because they are out of the mainstream. They don't want what everybody is supposed to want, whoever the hell "everybody" is. That makes them pervs.
by oz_media
by delbertpgh
He's also gay. He is funny, extremely candid, profane, and writes very well. He answers all kinds of questions from all kinds of people of all different gradations of perviness. He married his partner and adopted a kid with him. The column is called Savage Love, and it appears weekly in a San Francisco alternative newspaper.
by oz_media
AlQaeda, 'nuff said I guess.
If you can equate the US military to Middle Eastern terrorism, it falls right into place.
If not, then I suppose one must frown upon such actions, regardless of who did it or IF they actually scared anyone. It's no different to me than standing outside a church trying to intimidate people of faith.
I may have issues with the US government but I sure as hell respect democracy and equal treatment of all citizens.
by oz_media
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=neGbKHyGuHU
You know, maybe you or I would not be intimidated by them, in broad daylight in front of a public building, with other people/witnesses around.
But a mother with her children in tow may very well be intimidated. Sure she may have even entered and cast a vote, but will she return again?
Why someone wouldn't be prosecuted for hefting a bat outside a public polling place is beyond me.
He didn't have a baseball and mitt with him, the bat was to used to instill fear and impose opposition, is that not illegal?
by delbertpgh
I've watched two videos. One showed two guys from the University of Pennsylvania talking to the thug with the nightstick. (It was a nightstick, or policeman's billy club, not a baseball bat.) The guy with the stick certainly LOOKED intimidating. However, he did nothing.
The other video was a recording of a Fox News report. They showed up after the guy had been asked by the police to leave, which he did. They didn't draw guns, or arrest him; he didn't resist. He apparently spent about one hour in front of the polling station before being ejected. The Fox interviewers were very concerned that white people might be being oppressed by scary militant black guys in some episode of reverse racism, but they could summon up no report of anybody being pushed away, or who was too frightened to enter. A white poll worker said on camera that the two of them stood close together in front of the door after he spoke to them, and he walked between them and entered the building, and called the cops.
These two were pulling their trick in an overwhelmingly black neighborhood, and it is very possible that the only white people who approached the building in that hour were the poll workers. Perhaps they were what you might call "smart" black guys. Smart enough to realize that if they tried this stunt in a majority white neighborhood, it would take a lot less time for a half dozen angry white husbands and brothers to show up than it would for the cops to arrive, and when they did arrive, they would wonder why a black guy was lying in front of the entrance with a nightstick up his butt. I know a little bit about Philadelphia, and it works like that in many neighborhoods. There's a LOT of strong racial feeling in the town. Most of it never gets prosecuted.
So, here's the deal. Pretend you are a Federal prosecutor. Rush Limbaugh is indignannt. Sean Hannity is indignant. Every white guy with a chip on his shoulder and a microphone in his hand is indignant. The facts of the case seem indisputable: a guy was trying to intimidate anti-Obama voters, which probably means white ones. A clear case of racial discrimination. All you need is an intimidated white guy to prove your case. But, you can't find anybody who was actually there who says he was intimidated. All you can find is indignant Fox reporters, whose alter egos were vicariously intimidated. It's like the guy threw a brick through a window with no glass in it. Maybe you can charge him with vandalism, because he was TRYING to break the window, but the window failed to cooperate. In light of that, is it worth it to prosecute? Knowing that if you did he'd probably be defended by Johnny Cochrane, and that Al Sharpton and the leadership of the Black Panthers would get hours of free television exposure, and it would cost the taxpayers a couple million dollars, and race relations in Philadelphia would get a little worse? For the sake of throwing one punk in jail for three months, or maybe losing the case?
Quoting from the Washington Post, July 15 2010:
The controversy will continue to play out before the Commission on Civil Rights, which plans to issue a report in September. Members of the commission, who have heard hours of testimony, are divided on the merits of the case.
Abigail Thernstrom, a commission member and a senior fellow at the conservative Manhattan Institute, called it "small potatoes" and said conservatives should pursue more important issues against the Obama administration. The case, she pointed out, invokes a narrow and rarely used provision of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, which has been used successfully to prosecute only three times since its passage.
"If you want to criticize [Attorney General] Eric Holder, there are lots of grounds on which to criticize him," she said. "Why waste your breath on this one?"
Thernstrom said that she did not find (former Justice Department lawyer) Adams's testimony convincing and that the facts of the case raised doubts in her mind, noting that the Black Panthers were standing in front of a majority-black precinct that had voted overwhelmingly for Democrats in previous elections -- not a prime spot for intimidating white voters.
by jamesrl
Palmie has used that reply a number of times, so I was pointedly directing it to him.
While I am no Dan Savage guru, I have read his column in a Toronto alternative paper. I'm not offended by what he writes, but its clearly for an adult audience. He can be funny sometimes. I wouldn't have been able to point you to his website or his home paper without using a search engine.
by herlizness
<< Until I researched it, I assumed that the case would have been made based on the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. Turns out they chose to argue it on the 1st, as a free expression issue >>
well, as you indicated in your caption, this case was decided on 1st and 5th amendment grounds; the 5th Amendment claim was, in part, an equal protection claim; as you likely know, there is no equal protection language in Amendment V; however, if you read the cases beginning with Bolling in 1954, you see that there is an interplay between the 5th and 14th amendments which eseentially makes the original bill of rights applicable to the states ("incorporation") and the equal protection guarantee of the 14th amendment applicable to actions of the Federal government ("reverse incorporation").
That is the substance of the law and of the decision; how the issue is pleaded and framed by counsel is of considerably lesser significance.
by ansugisalas
self-modifying too.
That always impresses me.
A bit like how DNA works. A gene can code for the transcription of a molecule with the sole and specific effect of lodging itself between the DNA strands to bend it into a shape that helps the Ribosome DNA parser latch on to a specific other gene... that's called an accelerator, but when you consider how it's been hacked into shape trial and error - without other guiding influence than the incidental survival and procreation of the carriers of such hacks... it's stunning.
As a revolutionary at heart. I've told you before, that lawyers make lousy revolutionaries. You make for a lousy revolutionary.
Keep your nose buried in your annotated version of the constitution, until gunfire rings you awake.
by ansugisalas
You know that.
If you don't keep your system healthy, don't stop malware, don't clean up using the apps made for that... that's when the reinstall becomes necessary. But you don't do that with your computer, so why'd you do that with your nation?
Stay awake, exert influence during critical periods, using legal and constitutional means. Avert the need for revolutions.
Keeping the armed forces in step with the parent culture is prudent. Not forcing people to enter into an armed force contract on a dishonest basis is prudent. Alea iacta est - that's where you get if you don't.
And then all of us will have to consider our capacity for revolt, given the instability that would ensue, and the neighbourhoods we live in.
A comma in your title.
I don't never lighten up when it comes to these things.
by ansugisalas
ambiguous with a comma. Opens the door for ellipsis.
Without a comma ellipsis is not a very likely interpretation... though I grant, it's not correct according to norm.
You realize the rules are to be broken, among friends.
I have pacts with others about this. I make my pact with you, young sir.
by ansugisalas
I hold that there are no breakable rules of languag... they flex too readily and too far for that ;)
I wouldn't use the full flexibility with enemies of course, so I see what you mean.
by ansugisalas
the pr0n industry is putting in a lot of effort to proffer number two as a candidate for depervification.
But that's another can of worms, as I can't see how what pr0n use does to a person can be healthy, not personally, and not societally.
Not that I'm a prude. I just see how people get their expectations so twisted out of bounds that they end up not being able to enjoy a normal relationship.
Names are rarely unique. 'Eccentrica Gallumbits', maybe. I want to be sure the poster and I are discussing the same person.
There are also cases where the posted name is incorrect; see the 'Edmund Calley' mistake in this same discussion.
One of the reasons US haven't sunk to the level of the rather small and too liberal nation of Canada could be that in USA there are still a good number of normal people who do not defy The National Order of Things. I find amazing to read this trendy expression called 'sexual orientation' invented by the liberals. Gender/Sex is not an 'orientation' but well defined physical and psychological structure, which is absolutely not subject to trendy liberal orientations, liberals cannot remake according to their distorted vision of human physiology and nature.
By the way, homosexuals too were born of a man copulating with a woman during Her ovulation days, women being subjected by nature to monthly menstruation. Both humans different in nature but equal in dignity were created with specific sexual organs, which become in time perfectly in harmony to copulate with each other. Also great geniuses can be mildly or heavily neurotics!
by jamesrl
If you want to look to nature, then are you trying to tell me that no other animals other then humans have same sex relations? Really? Care to think that through?
I'd like nothing better than to not define people by ANY singular charecteristics. But as long as people descriminate against others based on those charecteristics, then we need to define them. I look forward to the day when no one cares about what two consenting adults do behind closed doors.
BTW, I'm not a liberal. As a Canadian I'm definately not a Liberal.
by jasonhiner
until you forget the lessons you learned in grade school about playing nice with others. :-)
You are the master of your own destiny here. If you avoid personal attacks and foul language you can stick around.
Of course, people around here also like it a lot more if you actually post useful thoughts and analysis rather than perpetually diverging off topic and posting obtuse nonsense. Take that as a recommendation.
Sort by Trending