Discussion Locked

How to convince users to use their computers only for business related work

0 helpful
192 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I always get impressed when i receive a help request from a user that said : " My computer is very slow, i need to wait 5 minutes to open any application"

Although he has a P4 computer with 60GB HDD and 512MB of RAM, it looks like there is somthing serious happing, checking viurs monitoring log on the server, checking updates, every thing works fine , but finally you go to the user look at his computer then be happy or get made you fined thousands of MP3s songs, handrads of Moives and quit few games mostly not more than 10 - 15, and finally up to 13 -15 startup programs such as chatting programs, messengers, picture views, calenders !!! Now can any one tell me How to convince users to use their computers only for business related work specially if those users in upper managment levels ?

192 replies

by gadgetgirl

You desperately need to write and ratify some usage policies!

If you don't tell the users what they can and can't do, they will just go ahead and do anything they wish - especially if they work from home, use a laptop etc.

I work in the health service in the UK, and I am currently manufacturing an ISMS (Information Security Management System) which is based on a framework of policies which users are bound to abide by through their terms and conditions of working.

If you google Usage Policies, you'll get my drift. You can also find lots of justification for applying policies, too - again, just look for Information Security Incidents, and you'll have enough bullets for your gun!

Best of luck, you'll need it.

GG

by creative8008

Thanks for your replay, but i have set kots of rules and policies , the problem comes when i tell a user why you break the rules, i always got the same answer " why you don't tell my manager" and the most funny thing that his manager is doing the same thing, even if i goes to higher level than a manager, know body care they all said " a good computer can handle any type of usage". !!!!

by bfilmfan

Document the issue each time you find it.

When they download a virus or trojan and it knocks out their system and a multitude of others, you will have some lovely documentation to assist them in finding new opportunities.

by manuel.amaro

I believe you have to bring your top manager to your team.
You have to start showing him/her the time spent on recovering from problems caused by bad use of the computer and the security problem the company could get with spyware or viruses.
Remember him that time is money and a bad virus could stop the entire company.
Than you should start writing a security/using computer policy to apply and make them signed by all employees.

by w2ktechman

If you really want to do the work, create some computer software policies to ban the install and/or use of many programs. It will not get them all, but it may work for the most common ones.

by hubejo

We elliminated this issue with Strong IT Management. IS policies are reviewed by a VP, and the VP chosen to be in charge of IS has an IT background (he understands). The policy approved for situations like yours is when a user had ANY issue with their PC, the moment IS discovers anything on their PC that breaks the rules we ghost it. All we backup / restore is the users documents folder (and the rules also say that anything you need to keep, you need to have it in your documents folder because IS can reprep your PC at any time without any advanced notice). Repeat offenders get their PC reprepped automatically when they have an issue, virus alert pointing to their PC, etc.

Addendum: After reading the replies I'd like to explain how we have kept the attitude towards our department good, overall.
For every policy we have an explanation that comes across as helpful not only to our department and the network, but first and foremost to the user. Our job is to guide and keep them as productive as possible; we are the ones educated/the experts on how to do this- so at times out "guidance" does include locking down the desktop, taking CD ROMs away from the user etc.
As much as we respect the expertise of users in THEIR field of expertise, it is in their best interest to respect ours (or at least in the best interest of the company- and we are all here to help the company progress- right?
It has also been proven that when users take ownership of their systems, they are better motivated and equipped to handle issues with their software. Although IS can mandate how and when software is upgraded, it is no different then when administration mandates policies for departments without taking ownership of that department. Sometimes it helps to explain at the users level in parallel (if the user is unreasonable be careful not to stoop down to a lower level); many things are regulated- fences are everywhere- IT just has their own version. Other people have their fields of expertise and can do more in their field than we can do, just as we can do more on our PCs than most people. That does not mean we should do their software-related work for them just because we are the software experts; that would almost be like telling the Accounting Dept. they have to do your taxes because they are the experts, and they are the ones that got you into this mess by reporting your tax information to the government.

by ibanezoo

You have to prove what they are doing is bad for the company. For example, we recently got a call from payroll saying that they couldn't do their work because the website they were trying to get to was going so slow it was timing out. Well, I like to get paid, and so does everyone else I assume.... so, it was easy to see a few users flooding the T1 with streaming audio and video and provide that information to management. Needless to say, those bandwidth wasters were terminated and the websites they were going to were added to the blacklist.

by dcbowiemd

I'm an old timer. Been in the business since the early 1980's (ya'll know how old that makes me in computer age) ....

I support top level execs and their secretaries. Because of politics these people have full rights to the computers in use which are W2k and Wxp. I even had a lady once who decided to clean up her workstation, deleting whatever files she felt were not needed in the windows directory. (don't ask ... people wanted access to everything) ...

So we just learned how to work with the system. Oh, we documented the reasons why having admin rights to their systems was not good, how it caused problems, cost, etc., and they upper level managers agreed we were right but they weighed it against their need to feel they have 100% rights to their workstations.

So we protected our servers and the switches/hubs/routers, etc. We worked with those who were willing to work with us and we educated many people. Those who wanted the ills and pains of the downloadable programs, we would take the autostart features off, remove it from the run area of the registry, startup, msconfig, wherever we found it starting up and let the user run it when they felt like it. Call it a compromise.

The fun part is when a secretary went on vacation and had to hand over her password to a temp. We got to where we were allowed to create guest accounts such as 'secretary1' 2, 3 .. and that went over well.

Sometimes you can give all the reasons and you can be 100% accurate, but remember it is politics. The games people play and the control they insist they need.

We also kept a couple of loaner pc's for swapout while we rebuilt systems. The users were always told if they want any data to be sure and save it on the network because we could not give them a 100% guarantee that we could recover anything off of their harddrives if and when they crashed it.

For those users coming in via Metaframe it is much better. :}} However if they are coming in via Metaframe that by extension means we have to support via phone their home systems unless they are willing to bring their system in. Some do, some don't.

Again, a game of politics.

by t-cally

I normally send out helpful "what to do at home" to get your pc back the way it was. I give links like Trendmicro, Spybot, Zonealarm, ?how to clean your mouse?, which are all user friendly and effect. The objective here is to educate them, help them out, and establish a ground of trust so that you aren?t the IT Gestapo, even though that is probably part of your job. It may take a sexual harassment clam due to inappropriate material or the network being knocked down due to one of those friendly sites before ?someone cares?. To cover your ?end?, email everyone or higher management the factual risk factors as well as reason why their pc aren't working as they use to. Also, consider the man hours lost from cleaning up end user created problems, which could have been avoided. Perhaps any attorneys that might work there have seen or dwelt with financial lost due to inappropriate computer use.

by realgem

If you lock the computer down so that only admins can download and install, then you will solve most of the problem.

If they want you to support the users with a reasonable level of service, there has to be some compromise. I would escalate this problem to your manager. Or, lower your expectations.

by baketown83

At my job many policies are put into effect as well as a user agreement. When we find a computer that has tons of "crap" on it. We immediately report to management and the users are dealt with accordingly. This even applies for the "higher ups" within the work place. After all there is always someone in charge of someone else who is in charge.

by absolutely

You can either write a bunch of documents full of rules that will become your responsibility to enforce, or you can use information technology to solve the problem at the user's expense instead of yours. It appears that the main problem is hard drive clutter, plus some inappropriate or just unnecessary programs. If the luser has installed programs, the luser has been granted admin status on that PC, for whatever reason. Maybe you can solve your issue with a simple FYI document explaining (to employees who have the privilege) that if they spend their breaks downloading files that aren't prohibited by company policy, the downloads should all go to a "pt" directory, and they are responsible for ensuring that if that directory exceeds 0.??? TB or whatever, they move their personal files to an external hard drive that they purchase at their expense. I just bet that takes a lot less of your time, and if the downloaded files aren't illegal, indecent or offensive, why restrict your happy employees' use of their personal time?

by ebeck

I agree - let technology solve these issues where possible. But still enact an Acceptable Usage Policy (AUP) to safegaurd against the really stupid things. Bottom line, you want to get them to buy-in and find value to technology, even distored values (entertainment, etc.). As long as you can minimize the harm done, and avoid legal or other big issues (covered by AUP), then this becomes less of an issue.

by creative8008

Its not my idea to be a police offcer that just want to annoy "Happy Employees" but a part of my job is to insure safty and more utilized busniess time, if the employees are having their personal time during the duty time plus the idea which says " No warry we have IT" i beleave that controling such employees to keep them in-line specially with computer usage is better that to let them do what ever they want and at the end it will be IT problem, and in my opinion IT work is more that just fixing systems damaged by " employees who have happy personal time"

Regards.

by lseikkula

Except it never seems to apply to users. Or, they don't think it does! I had one fellow complain that he had ebay set up as his home page and it keeps switching to our company's web page every time he rebooted! I kept telling him our standard image was to bring up OUR company's web page, he argued and argued with me. I finally just gave up!

by ungle

If you can't get policy, walk away.

However, policy are powerful tools, not that you will necessarily always enforce them but in situations like this you have the tools necessary to deal with the problem. Again, you are not IT police, but well publicised IT usage policy will allow you to say 'I'm sorry, but installing these applications violate the company usage policy. I'll have to rebuild your machine'. You don't use these policies to run around slapping hands and uninstalling apps. They're there for the situation you've described - or to stop users installing spyware.

But...without senior management buy-in, policies are...not!

So how do you get policies in place? Best approach is during the SLA negotiations. At this point you take the SLAs to the management and tell them 'The SLAs look great, I'd like to meet them, but to do so we need to establish usage rules'. You'll probably need to explain why it's important :-)

Once you've got senior management buy in, the abusive users have lost, you have won!

Good luck

by mjd420nova

I have had to talk to each user who is plowed
under with messengers, cursor and veiwer
programs that load on start up. I explain that each one slows the machine down a little bit, after time and more added programs that this
can be substantial and even create lockups
and hangs. Make it the users decision if they
need all the happy stuff or want a quick
machine.. I use the task manager to even
illustrate this to some users, the response
so far has been positive. I'm trying to check
out if I can use two versions running at the same time, one user and the other for work.
Two machines is the cure, we have one desktop
just for games and browsing, as the others
can't even get to the internet.

by wayne m.

mjd420nova has it exactly right. What the user chooses to do on his computer is not your problem. Show the user how his choices have affected his performance and recommend clean up steps, but go no further.

If the person is getting his job done, then don't worry about what he has on his machine. If he isn't getting his job done, then it is an issue between him and his supervisor. Just provide an accurate report to the affected user about what is degrading his system's performance.

Managing the work habits of the staff is not your responsibility. Focus on addressing the issue at hand: slow system performance.

by manuel.amaro

That could be the best approach if that isnt really your problem. In fact, if you have to manage an help desk team and you're responsable for the good work of the IT infraestructure, you have to be worried with what are your users doing with the system you've distributed them.
If they complain they couldn't work because the computer is too slow, their manager will ask you why that is happening. If you block them, you have less trouble then wait the trouble get's you.

by jkaras

Disable the cd rom drive and lock down the pc from certain programs. That way they cant load any programs or files, blame it on security against viruses or trojan attacks. Issue a usage policy that spells out deviation, and remotely connect to their pc and delete anything that is on there that you mentioned for all employees. That way nobody is blamed and all are given the same expectations. It is company property, not theirs. You can examine your equipment, there is no breach of privacy. If they want to listen to music they can get a radio or an mp3 player. Some companies use chat programs to converse with other departments for support. Mostly it is just used for flirting and joking with other employees, but it helps people be more happy in their position even though it lowers productivity. If it isnt used for business purposes take it away and lock it down with a policy. You can site network bottle necking that is costing company bandwidth lowering productivity. No manager will argue unless the top dog says I want it, I'm ok with that.

by amberhaze

lately I have been using a new / old approach. In conjuntion with a product called deep freeze, I have been locking machines down so no matter what is installed, etc, when the users reboot, they are back to the way our IT department configured them, after a short while, they pretty much give up.

The best part is, we haven't had a virus or trojan infection in almost 2 years now. (And no more complaints of "my computer is so slow")

It just takes a bit of planning with regards to Well developed roaming profiles and a set of complimentary policies.

The only complaints we get now are from users who broke the rules and d/l a 1Gig movie, hid it on the local drive only to discover the next morning it is totally gone, as well as the tool they used to get it.

While not suitable for all situations, it is far preferable than the usual fighting with users about accepted use policies.

by creative8008

what is that tool ? or how did you do that ? is it automaticlly or manual can you please give more details ...

regards.

by murso

If you have a W200x server domain, this is an easy fix. GPO is a godsend to any admin. I had an issue with people using MSN Messanger, so I created a GPO to block that program from running on all workstations. It was easy, they get a nice little "you can't do that Dave" type message, and no one complains.

As to the why Admin the user on the box - for some things this is needed. For instance, my auto virus updates will only run when the box is in Admin mode because it changes files. These updates take place all times of days, so I'm not running around locking and unlocking users just to get them installed.
I do wish the update would run in Power User mode, but for now, I let GPO handle what I do not what people to do, but keep the system open enough to let background things run.

by jesc

Use one of the tools that scans the PC and updates a central database with what it contains, like SMS. Compare the installed software with your licenses. Then automate a notification that unlicensed software is installed when there is a mismatch.

I wrote an application in Access to do this in about a week. We loaded up our software licenses with the currently installed software, and then looked for differences. The guy in Michigan was really surprised when he and his boss got an email the day after he installed Age of Empires on his work computer.

by amberhaze

The product is called deep freeze and it is produced by Faronics.

http://www.faronics.com/index.asp

It is perfect for school or public access situations, however I have started using it in the business setting as well with fantastic results....

It is well worth taking a look at.

You can even schedule a automated network "thaw" at a predeturmined time for performing updates.

On the down side, it is not very forgiving of a poorly designed set of network policies.

by cgoeckel

We use Deepfreeze here on some of the public stations.
We especially use it on the stations that are used by kids and have games on them. At least once a day a child has managed to get the pc to lock up somehow by hitting keys of some sort and doing a reboot clears it all up.

It has its pros and its cons.

Pros
--If someone alters a program or installs something without permission you just reboot and it will go back to what it was before.
--Users cannot alter the file structure in anyway
--Less time spent troubleshooting if there is an error
Cons
--Personally I have run into where Deepfreeze has caused a corruption
--IF you don't set the network "thaw" correctly and you apply updates...start all over again. The updates never happened.
--If users add network drives or printers that they need and they reboot...guess what, they are gone.

by kensmith

I've used DeepFreeze in school settings. Microsoft has developed their own version, called "Windows Disk Protection", which is free - offered at part of the "Shared Computer Resource Kit". Windows Disk Protection protects the Windows partition (typically drive C) that contains the Windows operating system and other programs from being modified without administrator approval. Disk changes made are cleared with each restart unless the administrator chooses to save them.

by bhawkins

We had trouble in our computer training rooms with people putting on programs of all kinds. Put Deep Freeze on and no more troubles. They can install anything they want but on the next boot its back to ground zero.

by jhultberg

Just as a warning, I foutunately did this on a tested imaged computer where I was testing deep freeze on it. But be sure to put in a Thaw time on the computer because if you screw up on one of the settings and not have thaw time on it, you will not be able to uninstall the deep freeze configuration on the computer that it is installed on. Write down a note of when you set the Thaw time to be set, and uninstall then if you are just doing a testing of the program before you go main stream and install it on everyones computer.

Good luck!

by tmansops

We had a similar issue. Luckily I reported to the CFO. I gave him hard evidence of what was going on, but more importantly the cost to support/fix these issues. When he saw the weekly tally he pushed it to the other Sr. Managers and it was reduced. It also justified software to monitor and block these items. Use Sr. Management as a tool...show the lost cost.

by stargazerr

We got 7 new Laptops for 7 new guys in the office. Dell Inspiron 6000. The damn things came pre-installed with so much crap.

I uninstalled everything. Uninstalled the pre-installed anti-virus Mc Afee. Did a defrag. Even optimised XP.

The computers are still running very slow. Any ideas?

]:)

P.S Only thing I can think of now is spyware ... But these computers have only been running for 2 days ...

by manuel.amaro

You forgot to mention the capacities of those laptops. Anyway, in my company, we always install computers from scratch. Format everything and install it again with our own software and crap ;-))

by stargazerr

My boss wont let me.

The Laptops are 80 GB HDD, 1 Gig Ram Intel Pentium M 1.70 GHz Processor.

]:)

by eddie.limoncelli

It takes some time, but it pays off in the end. I always reformat new machines and give them a clean OS install. Uninstalling the preloaded crap still leaves a lot of crap on the system, so a reformat is the bet way to go.

by dv5033

Reformat and build your own "clean" image. Have a couple if you want and one with the base image.
I am considering Deep Freeze, just not sure if this will be applicable to my environment - we'll see.

by creative8008

Reformatting and cloneing is one of system fixing ideas that always be the last option in my opinion, and lets think how long ot the IT time will be consumed by reformatting computers if he work with a 300 - 400 computer, it looks easy but in my opinion pervention is better and more time saving than go to the last choice

Regards

by crabbyabby86

As a poor college student in cramped student housing, I'm at a point where my Inspiron 6000 has become my primary machine. Obviously that means I had to do all the wonderful optimization you did with your new 6000s and pitch most of my music and games, and I too have some slowness issues.

But I'm pretty certain I've narrowed it down to the antivirus. Something about every antivirus I ever try (including McAfee--which was the biggest hog--and several free ones I've come across) just rapes my system resources. I've had to more or less turn off the auto-protect in my Norton and focus more on full weekly scans, and I've gotten used to protected webmail so that I don't have to even consider Outlook's threat.

Whenever I'm offline I shut Norton down completely and my performance goes back to how I imagine it should be.

Pretty crazy. And awkwardly frustrating. I guess I've never felt the need to do anything about it--poor college students can only hope for good enough--but I thought I'd share my experience in case it might help.

by jamesrl

Back in the 80s and early 90s, I used to love Norton products. They were the best tools for fixing HD problems (Disk Doctor) and other utility uses.

I bought system tools in the late 90s, and ended up uninstalling it because it was a resourse pig.

I've bought a couple of systems that were refurbs of mainstream manufacturers home type PCs that had Norton pre-installed - I uninstall it.

Currently I use AVG free at home. Its much less resource intense. I also use MS antispyware, which is moderate.

Once upon a time I spent hundreds of thousands of dollars of my employers money on Norton Anti-Virus. I wouldn't now, under any circumstances.

James

by mr. tinker

Client of mine purchased 9 workstations from Gateway, all with XP-Pro. Thel ALL came preconfigured with Google-Toobar and Desktop, and the final straw... MSN messenger configured to run at startup, AND even if you deleted through ADD/Remove it got re-installed. (Yes, I killed-off the system restore and it still got re-installed.) I found 3 Data/Mining cookies were present even though the PC had NEVER been hooked up to any network straight out of the box. Even re-installing from the "OEM-Restore" disks put back everything I manually removed. Solution: Format and Install the XP-Pro software from a Store-bought-Vanilla XP-Pro disk, then load in the needed drivers.
All spyware and startup issues completely bypassed. Lesson learned: People need to: STOP BUYING THE "CHEAP" HARDWARE SOLUTIONS. They aren't cheap in the long run. It's cheaper in the long-run to build the systems to your needs from the ground up and not rely on the "Big-Name" brands who bundle-in garbage software to make it "cheaper to buy" up front.

by rknrlkid

I've had to do this exact same thing to a Toshiba laptop and to a Compaq desktop. The "restore disk" restored stuff that most ad-ware/spyware programs alert on, plus I don't need AOL, Compuserve, AIM, MSN Messenger, Online Games, Yahoo Messenger, etc etc. My solution was about the same as stated before. I reformatted, then reinstalled the version of generic OS. The only problem I had was with drivers, and that was only a problem because I had to download them from the manufacturer. (An annoyance, really).

I am convinced that "cheap" computers are as inexpensive as they are because they are filled with software that is really sponsor-ware.

by cgoeckel

When you get XP installed, have you tried going into MSCONFIG and removing apps from starting up?

If you aren't sure what each program is....go to this site and type in the file and it tells you if its needed or not. Yes, No or Up to user. These guys do a great job of keeping up with new stuff as it appears. The website is out of the UK.

http://www.sysinfo.org/startupinfo.html

With XP you will have to download the msconfig file and save it to the System32 folder.

I use that on all the computers when we reload them with Non vendor CDs (Dell, GW). It cuts down the startups.

by oko

Hello Stargazer(r)!

Could you please explain the slowness of these laptops? I mean: what are you trying to do, when you notice they're slow (internet/office/graphics)?

I bought an Inspiron a few weeks ago, dropped all the crap (especially the anti-virus stuff!! Geez, talking about crap!) and the machine is running XP home fluently.
BTW I put up a few Linuxes also; use these mainly...

by stargazerr

Jumping windows ... starting Outlook. The computer is behaving as if it has 32 MB of RAM or something ... Internet as such is fine. Its the computers that are slow ...

I removed all the crap, but I saw a few entries in the registry for the crap I deleted. I am going to try cleaning th registry and see what happens.

]:)

by manuel.amaro

Anyway, I dont know how your company work but my boss only want things working and I decide what has to be formatted and what it isn't.
If things dont work well, that's my and my team's fault, so I have to fix it.
Anyway you have several pages that tell you how to troubleshoot a slow windows xp.
Techrepublic for instance published several articles about those services we can disable.

by jaqui

one: no sound system, hardware or software for the computer.

two, make then work on a linux box in console only when you catch them doing things they shouldn't.

guarantee, being presentd with nothing but console will scare any windows wanker boss into not wasting time with mp3s and having no sound system at all will drive the point home.

by johanv

some Microsoft bashing from a Linux fanatic.

My advice to you about AUP is easily achieved.
1. Block users from installing applications on their computers. Something that can be achieved irrespective of platform.
2. Enforce a central file storage location. This will ensure users can only store files in a central location and also allow you to write scrips to scan for unwanted files.
3. You mentioned chat programs which infers internet connectivity. Unless IM is a core part of your business, you can block IM's on your firewall.
4. You can also invest in content filtering software which will strip out any *.exe files (etc.) as it enters your environment via the internet.
5. I have to agree with Jaqui, do not purchase systems without any multimedia capabilities (unless required by the type of business).
6. Invest in defragmentation tools. Not only will they contribute to a better performing computer but also show that you are being proactive in what you do.
7. As for start-up programs, introduce computer policies which resets any changes made to the system. User can go crazy putting shortcuts all over the place, etc, etc but after each session the desktop environment is returned to its original state.

by johanv

some Microsoft bashing from a Linux fanatic.

My advice to you about AUP is easily achieved.
1. Block users from installing applications on their computers. Something that can be achieved irrespective of platform.
2. Enforce a central file storage location. This will ensure users can only store files in a central location and also allow you to write scrips to scan for unwanted files.
3. You mentioned chat programs which infers internet connectivity. Unless IM is a core part of your business, you can block IM's on your firewall.
4. You can also invest in content filtering software which will strip out any *.exe files (etc.) as it enters your environment via the internet.
5. I have to agree with Jaqui, do not purchase systems without any multimedia capabilities (unless required by the type of business).
6. Invest in defragmentation tools. Not only will they contribute to a better performing computer but also show that you are being proactive in what you do.
7. As for start-up programs, introduce computer policies which resets any changes made to the system. User can go crazy putting shortcuts all over the place, etc, etc but after each session the desktop environment is returned to its original state.

by manuel.amaro

Anyway I've forgot to comment those computer capacities.
1 Gb memory it's enough to make an ordinary windows xp work fine with most applications, even so, some graphic ones need a good grafic card with its own memory. Is that your case?

by the admiral

What you have a problem with, and it is common if it is not enforced at the beginning of employment is an Internet Usage Policy.

While I do look at TechRepublic and eBay items, there is no P2P sharing programs allowed on the network, and it has been made abundantly clear through policies and software (we have an item that is installed that reports back the asset and who has it, and if there is any P2P or other illegal software installed) that if any item that has been proven to violate copyrights or is not licensed, your are met at your office by the securty team who takes your badge and escorts you to the door.

It is plain and simple. Employees are there to do a job, not to further their life experiences with illegal downloads, chat with friends, or other non-work related item.

I would mention to the upper management levels that if a BSA audit walked through the door that the entire corporation would not pass.

In fact, many of things have been done by me mentioning that you remember a former colleague who had mp3's and movies and the like is still working through the legal system and he might get away with a 2 million fine and 10 years in prison.

by ravesh

Well I guess that might be a question we all would really love to have a definite answer for but it is more complex than that but on the other there are policies that can be set in place;
1. Setup an IT policy - each user must sign.
2. Group policies - Lock 'em down - I love those windows group policies where you control every aspect of the system...great stuff.
3. Monitor installed software on network pcs - good open source software out there.
4. There are more alternatives to lock 'em down.
5. After advising all staff of the new policies and telling them that they have been warned, setup up a script where you can run it at a scheduled time to delete any prohibited file extensions, eq. mp3s, wav, mov, .....etc.

Works for me.

by creative8008

well as per as what i understand that you are apsoltly right, using your power as an administrator insequence with system controlling priviliges is an effective way, but my point is to "Convence" make users understand and accept the idea of uitilizing besiness time in besiness work and activities, it is also a part of team work idea which is you "the user" your part and i do mine to achive maximum corporating and reach to beyond suceed point.

regards.

by pkr9

The error you(?) made was to let users log-on with administrative rights. As others have pointed out, one of the measures is policies, which only really work with XP pro and 2003 servers.

Another very good approach is to skip the PC's generally - yes it is possible - and let the big majority run on thin clients. This wil give you the benefit of minimizing maintenance, just think of changing hundres of PC's with a handfull of servers. It will also ensure that malware attacks are kept to a minimum, everybody runs same version of SW, malware protection is ALWAYS on top, noice and heat emmissions in the officer are markedly reduced,and the user gui is the same wherever they log-on.
I tried it, and I would never even dreamof giving the ordinary office user a PC.

Also tell users that the compaby PC is just like the company car:
Don't tune the engine.
Don't install blowers, nitro or other stuff.
Don't fit fat big slicks.
Don't paint it pink (or whatever your fav color is).
Don't fit spoilers.
In short - it is a tool provided by the company for company work.

/Peter

by grandpa4

Write down the fix needed - give one copy to the employee and one to his manager with a request for permission to fix the computer. That way both the employee and the manager know what is happening and it is their choice as to the result. If they choose to keep the junk they also choose to take the slowness and related liabilities. You have done your job until you get their direction. That way you don't have to revisit the problem.

by ebeck

I didn't mean to imply it was your intent, rather to say that you might end up being the police if policies are the sole method to get users to stick to biz only. You should be thankful if you users do say "don't worry we have IT"!!! Try "oh god I'd rather not call IT for help...". You should focus on fostering support from the business unit heads in understanding the value IT & technology brings, and how other uses can bring down that value. If they are worth anything in your org, they'll line up behind you right away when it comes to users wasting time. Also, last time I checked, IT was not responsible for oversight of employee productivity. IT is a part of the business, run by management & leaders that have that duty. Use technology to control your destiny, i.e. safegaurd as mentioned by all means, and make it easy to recover from problems, i.e. imaging, enterprise backup/restore/migration tools, monitoring devices, and network management tools. Sell the investment in these tools to senior management, and then keep them informed on what activity is causing problems, and the undesired activity will become a decision issue for management. If they want to allow it, then you will need to work around that. If they don't want it to take place on company systems, you've then got their backing to systematically eliminate it. Hope this clarifies my post.
Regards

by absolutely

Where I live, employees are entitled by law to stop working for 15 minutes twice a day, plus eat lunch for at least 30 minutes, if they work 8 hours. During these "breaks" the employees' time is for them to use as they please, for their "personal" enjoyment. Since you "beleave that controling such employees to keep them in-line", I judge from the spelling that English is not your first language, and from the sentiment that freedom is not your preference. Fine, you pathetic tyrant, "keep them in-line", but don't you come near me!

by techniquephreak

While they can do whatever they want during their breaks, if they are using company property they still have to adhere to the company computer use policies...

Even if they bring their own notebook or PocketPC, if they are using company resources such as the T1 line or wifi, they have to adhere to company polciies...

Unless, of course, your company allows you to break policy during your breaks. If that's the case, do you enjoy sexually harassing your admin assistants when you are on break? Do you wander around the breakroom in the buff?

by quagmire

i do....well not really BUT i hear that i prance around in a tutu, little IT fairy wings and rollerblades...according to my users...that do not get to play on the AOL/MSN/Yahoo/IRC and download crap all day...or the ones that break a mouse or keyboard just to get a new one only because the new employee has recieved a brand new one...gah i say block everything but the local intranet from the users....but that can't happen cause 75% - 85% rely on certian web sites to complete their jobs....blah you really can not win for loosing.

by crewr

Take a few laps and a cold shower man.

Why not just let your employees take joy rides on the forklift or surf on the conveyor belts during their personal time? These are company owned machines bought and maintained for a purpose. There are policies that govern their use for good reason.

Computers are no different. Sure, you're not going to lose a leg if you screw up but you might open the door to a virus attack or a hacker. You *will* waste hours or days of IT time cleaning up after the messes made by these policy breaking users. There are valid reasons for keeping personal software off of business machines.

by pkr9

They can do whatever they want to during breaks, paid by companby or not. They can not use office equipment - including PC's - as a private item. Especially not in a way that endangers you vital IT system.

by mtucker

You must first have corporate policies and procedures for acceptable computer use and that spell out the possible penalties including and up to to terminain.

More importantly you must explain to the why they should not do these things telling them about viruses, worms, spyware, etc.. talk to them about about legal issues including copy write laws and how their actions could cause a compant wide problem disabling numerous computers and causing work stoppage and slowdowns for many others too.

Remeber you must bet management buy in, but scare the living *&^%^%$&^% out of them.

by jerryfr

Policies and rationale, consequences for transgression and visibility are all necessary. Realistic service levels are also vital.
Ex: My wife was a tax manager for a large public acctg firm. The call response time agreed to with their outsourced vendor was 72 hours! So she did what needed to be done; sweettalked a Jr. tech out of the admin p'word and figured out how to resolve issues herself. She's taken that attitude with her to her new employer, who has the same service vendor (hmmm, who could that be?).
Imagine, a cubicle full of $100k pin-striped CPA's sitting around for 72 hours waiting for a 20 yr old technogeek to leave his DOOM game and install some software. All while under IRS deadlines.
IT, outsourced or not, must be responsive to prevent users from taking things into their own hands.

by wannabegates

That is so simple it isn't even funny. Why would you ever want to make a user an admin on a corporate machine? Just install the apps they need to use and let them have the machine. As long as they are not a Domain Admin you are good to go. They will get the, "You need to be an Adiminstrator to install this Application" dialogue every time they try to install anything.

Problem Solved

by oldbag

Whenever I setup a machine, I do not give admin to users unless there is a very specific reason. The problem is that there are many apps found on the internet that will load even if the user does not have admin. Google Earth anyone?

by starderup

When I worked for Novartis, the end users didn't have authority to install software. There was no 'Run' option on the start menu.
If users know that their systems are remotely scanned for unauthorized software and that any self installed software can result in termination, they usually will stick to business.
If you can't get support from upper management, then your problems are bigger than you are going to be able to deal with.
If they knew how much this is costing them in support, they might be more receptive.
I'd change jobs.

by mavmin2

We seem to have a lot of fear about how the union will feel about standardized desktops, lock downs, Net use, mail monitoring, etc. We need to do these things because most of our Net use has nothing to do with the job and if I sign on to a machine and the e-mail is up 85% of what I see are jokes and personal e-mails.

Our brand new machines started getting cussed about being slow in less than three months. We were getting reqest for more RAM and bigger HDs. Go to the machine and like the original message it would be loaded with all sorts of junk.

The users think that the PC is THEIR machine not the corporation's. Tell them waht to do and not do to keep their machine speedy and they will ignore you. I have even been called a Nazi because I will delete junk and lock down applications.

I want to pull what little hair I have left.

by lock'emdown

You are not alone... My former last name is Hahn...some of my nicknames include: Ghengis Hahn, Attila the Hahn, the Wrath of Hahn (for you trekkies out there), and Network Nazi. There are others but they are unfit for posting.

by operations

In my company I'm known as the Network Nazi - I'm proud of the fact our users very rarely open or go to a website that isn't business related - they're afraid I'll take everything away. So if you have to be the Network Nazi do it - up to this point in time our company has not been hit with a virus or trojan.

by james speed

I am in Healthcare IT. These type of things not only cause issues with the user, but could conceivably affect patient care in a very REAL way. I do not allow anyone to install ANYTHING on ANY PC unless IT approves it....which is usually denied unless its absolutely critical. My domain policy is so tight that users cannot even save files to desktops. If they want files saved they must put them in "My Documents" which is pathed to the file server (and backed up). They cannot even open a command prompt....WHY WOULD THEY? There is absolutely no reason!

I have taken everything out of the control panel...WHY DO THEY NEED TO GET TO IT? They dont... Because of this policy my days are filled with NORMAL IT tasks instead of strangling stupid users who install the latest version of US NAVY SEALS to play at lunch... Aint happening on my watch :)

Yea, I know, some of you will say I'm a Network Nazi, but thats ok. My network is secure, I'm not wasting time trying to figure out what any number of "LUSERS" has done to "MY" PC's.

This is a hospital - it is NOT an extension of their home PC. It is a tool to ensure our patients are taken care of by providing the best and latest technology. Most of you are aware that many Healthcare systems are now totally "electronic medical Records" - so, without the systems, a patient could conceivably suffer harm or even die because their patient data wasnt available to nurses or doctors.

Yep, I'm a Hard A**, but I do it for my patients...my users know without a shadow of a doubt these are "MY" PC's - NOT theirs. Yea, I also do sweeps on the file server for MP'3.... wham - Bam - gone. Unless... its some I dont have :) (Hey, thats the benefit of being IT!)

Ok, who's gonna take the first shot at me for being so mean :)

Jim S.

by kascee

Your approach is actually quite understandable, a little belligerant maybe, but quite justified. I understand the frustration these kinds of users cause, but smooth IT doesn't let that get in the way of doing the job. For others, one possibility in a Windows environment is to create a user group with policies which lock down their rights. Make someone a member of that group when the issues of use come up. Reprep the machine and then lock them down to business only functions. An earlier post spoke to being IT and not police. It is crucial that IT never take a public side in establishing and determining application of corporate directives.

by geektx

I am with you 100%. I am an independent consultant and maintain about 30 different networks that go from 5 seats to 300 seats and I have found that the "Nazi" approach is the right way for me and my networks.
Typically I deal with the top level management/business owners and they are behind me completely. Even if they are the source of the problem.
Some of my networks started the same as creative's and when I took the issues to the big boys they asked what we could do about it. The answer was simple and the users have had no choice but to accept it.
If they want to spend their personal time at work surfing or downloading ... go home or starbucks or wherever but _do_not_ do it at work! I even had one company that would charge the department for any user caused issues. The charges came out of bonuses and such for the affected department. When the perks of a job are affected for a group of people they tend to police each other. The flipside is they tend to be reluctant to call for help. Its a viscous cycle but it works out for the greater good in the end.

The easy way to win is show the big boys your bills/costs and they will agree to just about anything that will reduce those costs or use that expense in a more productive manner.

I have told every tech that has worked under or for me one thing they must always remember. You are in charge! You may not be at the top of the food chain in your orginization but without the support of IT no one can do anything. You are in control of everyones ability to be productive. If they are suffering from their own stupidity, then it is your goal to never let them get to a point to be able to make the stupid descissions they do.

"I don't know what happened. I clicked on this icon and everything went crazy."
If you are maintaining your network properly and in the best interest of the company, the user should not have the option to open any app that could be dangerous. Make it personal. When they are destroying your network they are affecting not only their productivity but your livelihood.
Consider the network as your children just as management considers their department their baby.

Some people find themselves in a position where this doesn't work for them ... then you are in the wrong end of this industry. You can not be passive nor too aggresive, just know how to pick your battles to win the war on stupidity.

This kind of mentality has worked well for me for 20 years.

by crash84

Hey why would I want to take a shot at you, I agree 100%. My machines are imagined with what they need to do thier jobs and they are users only on their machines. We even hide the USB from them. It will say it installs but won't showup as a device so as far as the user is concerned his camera or thumb drive don't work. I may be a hard a** but at least I can sleep at night nowing that my machines and network is secure.

by Former member

There are certainly people who waste company time with personal stuff. But there are also people who 'waste' as much or more personal time with company stuff.

So they want to watch a movie on their comapny Laptop during a long flight, or maybe listen to some music, orm,aybe even play a game or work on their personal finances. Why not try to accommodate them?

We have a solution that works pretty well. ALl systems are built forma golden image. Policy establishes that all company data is to be stored/backed up to a network drive (which is swept, by policy for .mp3,.mov,etc...).

If the user's PC is having problems, we generally reimage if it takes more than about 5-10 minutes to troubleshoot. The user gets it back the way it was pre their non-comapny related stuff.

Not a perfect solution perhaps, but one that helps manage the problem users without crippling the power users.

by petraje

I love your way of doing things. That is the way IT should be performed. LOCK EM DOWN!!

by spinner of websites

of management (your boss or supervisor) that really don't want to work. It makes it very difficult to say or suggest that he takes off the games, movies, mp3s, IMs, etc, even when there are board approved policies that police such actions. If you say anything to HR or his manager, you get canned with his denials, even if you do document this situation. If it's your boss or senior management, just make a suggestion after you fix it. If it is a joe blow regular worker, just document it and consult your IT manager and let him/her handle it with HR and the worker's manager or supervisor.

by whistl3r

GPO's!

If management blatently disregards these rules; then you need to document and start charging these departments more for their negligence; until they ratify the problem.

by Former member

First off, do you have a Computer Utilization Policy in place? If so enforce if not put one in place; delete all non-business related files.

Change user access to Limited user; I am assuming the the PC files being consumed are all local and network drives are not affected.

You need management support for any and all restrictions to work. They must be applied across the entire workforce.

JoBriKa

by jwc120

While working for a Comercial Calibration laboratory as Network Administrator I rolled in early one morning to find a very unhappy technician who'd been there for hours attempting to get caught up with the work load. He cannot access the network, the server broadcasts a message every few minutes that the server is running out of disk space. I knew that was impossible because I monitor the disks regularly. I discovered the problem was a jpeg file that had been saved to that little partitian drive that holds all of the Novel Command Codes and rarely changes size. I moved this to file and all was running fine. When I opened the file, after a virus scan I found a found a large, rich color photo of a Flyers Hockey Player. When the rest of the employees arrived I went around asking about this picture. I finally met an angry technician who was ticked off because he wasn't able to load his new 'screensaver', so had saved it to a network drive.
The follow day all management and employees recieved notice from I.T. that no personal screensavers were permitted, the company Web Page was locked in and none of the employees or management was able to change it. Also, they were all locked out of all network drives except for the space alloted for their documents and they were reminded thatf failure to clean out their documents would result in new documents nots being able to be saved.

by slsb

If the rule breakers are in upper management, you will not be
able to just lay down gestopo type rules unless the people above
them are on your side and even that makes bigger enemies.
Instead the best way to win them is to show them the impact to
the bottom line. Show them what it costs in time, money, lost
productivity, cost of opportunity -- theirs and yours (and
perhaps others). Make sure that you are logging all of your
hours -- what are you doing all hours of the workday (minus
lunch and breaks, of course)? How much time is taken from
other more important duties and stragetic projects that improve
the company and its bottom line? Bill your hours to each
department -- even if it is not in terms of really $$ coming to
the IT account, you can at least show a monthly report of where
all of your time is going.

by rcabrera

Although you say them, they will ignored you. In my company we found that 45% of the help desk reports originated by this type of situations. We decided to emit restrictive rules and enunciating sanctions, nevertheless also we blocked the users to install, to share and to chnage some folders. This reduced 45% of this.

by blarman

They are the ones affected by the performance. Publish a message out to all users and tell them the results of their actions. Then tell them they can either ask before installing garbage and violating the company's computer-use policy (you DO have one, right?) or they can deal with poor performance.

by ibanezoo

...fire them. Once the other employees actually see people getting fired, then tend to stop doing whatever bad stuff it was that got their buddies canned. When you have a company that survives by the computers working properly, everything from production to payroll, you can't afford downtime from (L)users screwing around on their computers. Not to mention paying people to sit there screwing around instead of doing their jobs.

When we find computers like that we make alot of noise about it to embarrass the (L)user among their peers and make sure their manager takes notice, %99 of the time resulting in that employees termination.

I used to be nice about it.... but when I get called in on a weekend or late at night to fix something because someone has been using their computer in a manner it was not authorized to be used.... I tend to be a real A-hole

by blue-knight

Big Picture First:
People at home are using their computers for a significant amount of work. Some companies are starting to send the W-2 electronically, workers are doing email, after hour support is sometimes done from home, research on business problems, training, etc.

This is not a non-trivial aspect. The siode effect of companies putting increasingly repressive policies is that users will do work(only) on the company computers. And they will do less work on their home computers. The overall impact has been a significant loss for companies that track both the work and non-work computers.

Morale, productivity, adaptability to change are all lessened.

If someone abuses this is just like someone who spends the entire day chatting at the office coffee pot. Do not get rid of the coffee pot, but their manager should be worried about productivity. Is the person in your example one of the most productive users? IE if Mary never does non-work on her computer, but also does not accomplish as much as Sally who does other actions, then it is Mary not Sally that needs to be looked at.

Blue

by ltsmith39

ANY use of any company resource for other than company business is stealing. I suppose you could argue that no one else is using it, but would you ask the boss's secretary to type up your resume if they weren't doing anything at the moment? Does your company let you use the executive limo to take you to lunch if it's not being used at the moment? Besides how many people use company resources for personal use ONLY on personal time? I also suppose you could allow stealing - it happens more than most people would like to admit. In retail 75% of theft is internal.

by cber505

"If they complain they couldn't work because the computer is too slow, their manager will ask you why that is happening."

That is when you tell the manager what the problem is. Let the manager mange their employees. If you are the manager then deal with the problem employee. Too many mangers take the EASY way out and create a policy instead of addressing the individual. If the problem is bandwidth then inform the mangers of the issue and let them decide. Mange the IT and let the people managers manage their people.

by bhaven23

I sent the guy on break and said I'd fix it while he was gone. I simply deleted all the things the clown had installed. A note was left that the more junk he put on the PC, the slower it would run. Leave it alone. It has been awhile and he hasn't complained about a slow system since....
I'm not really a mean person, trust me.

by bg6638

I had several "maverick" users who thought that the computer provided by the company was THEIR property, and as such, could do anything they wanted with it provided that they did the work required of them. I established a company policy working with the HR dept., and still abuses such as selling on eBay, visiting joke sites, chain e-mails, etc. on *company time* kept up on a daily basis! How did we change it? One of them was dumb enough to launch a virus that cost a full day's work for the company, including holding up payroll checks! They became VERY popular in the plant for that, and we rewarded their action by terminating them on the spot. End of troubles, as the other "mavericks" more than received the message!

by mgomez25

you know sooner or later all that troubleshooting is going to add up to over time and constantly fixing the same issue over and over again...if not on the same machine or on different machines with the same issue about there system running slow or taking forever to boot-up....this happen to me and i was questioned by my manager....and then had to explain why i am always having to go back and fix the same issue over and over....when that happens you can best bet that there will be some serious policy changes in computer usage on the job.

by praetorpal9

Policies and standards that are not enforceable are not worth much.

Work stations should be set up with least privileges, separation of duties and user provisioning for the purpose of doing one's job, and nothing else. Internet privilges are not needed on the loading dock, for example.

Trusted operating systems track all that is done on a system and prevents abuses by authorized users. If you rely on policies, you have grounds to fire someone for non-compliance, but infractions will continue to occur, causing downtime, loss and expense.

A few public systems could be set up separately in a separate network for employees to use on break, answer personal emails etc., if necessary to keep morale up.

by eaglewolf

Agreed .. Norton *used* to be good. But what I find on most machines now, it IS the cause of the problem. They've gone seriously astray.

I use AVG-7 at home, too, with no problems. There is a new one for anti-spyware/malware/etc. you might want to try:

http://www.ewido.net/en/

I purchased it and consider it worthwhile. It catches things no other anti-spyware s/w does .. including my SpySweeper.

by r3d

have you checked the system cache to see if it is somehow adversely affected? You might try setting it to a managed size of 1024 or something to that effect.

Also, I know these systems are relatively new, but you may want to check the "prefetch" area and delete everything up to about a week ago; if there is are a lot of files in the first place. This may not be an isue really, but if there are a ot of files, then it could very well be helping the problem.

One more thing, you could also go into "folder Options" - "View" - "Advanced Settings" and remove the tick from the "Automatically search for network folders and printers" selection if that is what is causing your problem. i find it can be annoying at times; especially if the AD is screwed up and bloated with bad entries.

by thumper1

I worked as the Network Admin at a law firm that made policies and actually enforced them. The standing rule is if you wanted to install something on one of the firms computers, it had to go through me. Peroid. No games, no MP3's, No JPG's unless they were case related. No screen savers or wall paper, actually no nothing I didn't OK. Anyone who broke that rule was subject to termination as stated in the employment manual under "Computer Usage". These people did not tolerate any BS from secretaries, and some Attorneys. Had one instance of a secretary who went out of her way to make life miserable for me. She was very religious and one day, I saw a Bible passages screen saver on her system. I asked her how it came to be installed. She said one of the other secretaries installed it for her, and since it was religious it couldn't be any problem. I didn't say anything, just walked away. When I got back to my office, my phone was ringing. It was the office manager, The secretary in question called to make her case first. The office manager reminded her about policy and had a little talk with the secretary who installed the screen saver. Didn't have any problems from anyone after that.

I changed jobs, the new firm has the same policy, but does not enforce it. I have some problems with unauthorized programs, I guess it will take a disaster to make them take notice.

by kujo1us

1st off you need to refer to all computers used in a work environment as workstations and all home computers as PCs and explain the difference to your users, Personal computers are exactly that, personelized for the user, owned by the use, by its very definition "workstation" means that it is used for work, not personel (but sometimes funny) emails, or chat programs or my favorite free casino card games(cant seem to convince users that free means spyware), but for work only, I find it takes a combination of talking to Sr management, implementing group policy and in general being a network nazi to accomplish the task :)

by daffyd

The Public Library in Waterloo, Ontario uses this tool for open PCs. When re-booted as instructed after use -- clean as a whistle! Marvelous software.

by logos-systems

Fire a couple of the user that are violating company policy, by using the computer system, network, and internet access for non-business use. The word will quickly get around and very few others will want to take the chance.

by lymon1

I know this will not help the problem. But I love the comercial where an IT employee screams; We have a virus!! Then a few IT's gather and ask HOW did it get in, we had everything secure. The bosses' daughter comes out of his office saying, "You should see the coolest game I downloaded from the internet." Even office managers do not understand that ONE trip to wrong site and the network is down..I will not even start on an intranet.

by m_johnson

We have a simple policy that says all computer equipment and everything on them is the company's property. Any software not on the approved list may be deleted with or without warning. We do allow for personal software installs if approved by administration. Everyone with computer access signs this policy acknowledgement - if they don't sign, their account gets disabled. It's also part of new employee orientation so everyone gets the word.

by just watching now

As a older dude (who's send a lot of wierdness go by the board) I'm impressed with the amount of thought and the good ideas you guys have come up with. I've seen most of them implemented, and almost anything works, from stricter policies to the "network nazi" approach.

I see the biggest problem as the lack of distinction in today's world between "I'm at work" and "I'm not at work." I work at work, and play at home. But too many times, I'm not sure where I am. If I'm at home, working on a cut-over of new software on a remote server at one o'clock in the morning, and I have a one hour dead time until the next step, am I at work? Or am I at home, and free to play a WOW session on the side?

On a personal note, I have a bunch of computers and home and reserve one for work, but not everybody has these resources.

Personally, I think the problem is going to get worse as more portable information devices are added, people started working from more venues, and crossover viruses become common.

Good Luck to us all.