Discussion Locked

How to convince users to use their computers only for business related work

0 helpful
192 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

192 replies

by nzbn

Lock everything out through group policy, dont let them have access to anything they dont need. Then at your firewall perimeter only let out what services/ports need to go out, most commonly 80, 25, 110, 20, 21, 3389, etc then block everything else out. that then natively stops any p2p networks, messaging and chat programs etc, block access to any media players, dont let them install anything. Do it all through software and if they pack a stink tell em tough shite. Time to get hard

by kd5mid

Let the title guide you. Give users only access to business items. Don't let them change anything or install any programs. When they ask how to do it , tell them there is a WORK-ONLY policy and you have to follow it.

by sdj30

Network security is key to protecting your network infrastructure and the data within. Alot of the stuff that people download is just not games and programs that rob cpu and memory. Alot of it may contain key loggers and other virus traffic that can sniff out passwords and other data that is integral to the security of your network. SO my answer is lock them down. If you are part of a domain take the ability to write to the c: drive right away. Give the appropriate applications folders permissions to run but allow them to olny write to their My Documents folder using security groups and adding your domain local security groups to your local security groups on the individual computers. Another method if you are using a Windows 2000 domain is to enforce restrictions on how much space thay have on the hard drive to copy to using disk quotas. At some point and time some end users will just defy the nice guy or gal in you to the point where you have no choice but to take charge of your end user environment or they will take charge of you.

Steve

by falling burrito brother

My employer does this also (altho' clients don't get admin rights to PCs, thus can't install whatever they want. If a bone-fide software install requires admin rights, we grant it for the duration of the install, then once the app has run, revoke the admin access). Plus the employee has to (read and) sign an Internet Usage policy document. We generate internet usage reports & send to departmental managers so that any untoward usage is dealt with as the local manager sees fit. If the manager is happy with his\her staff browsing , then all well & good. It's the manager's call, we in IT just give them the information (or ammunition, depends on which way U look at it). Obviously we have policies which block access to certain websites etc. (who doesn't). We run an SOE, so all users are created equal - VIP users get increased email & home directory allowances (space-wise). This seems to work well - the only clients who get miffed by lack of 'rights' seem to be the usual suspects who would abuse any way. Cool.

by tonythetiger

was, in the login script, scan for .mp3s and other known problem files on the hard drive and simply delete them. They already can't install programs that write to the program files directory or modify the registry. If they ask me to install something, I tell them the request has to come from their supervisor.

by oko

What a nuisance...and that with seven (7!) laptops at the same time...
I suppose you know enough about computer-malfunctioning and ways to get a finger behind the reasons, but still:
- did you try and see what happens when you disable the networkcards?
- if you do not start Outlook (why not use Mozilla btw), do they function okay?
- you see anything strange running in the background?

etc etc, you know what I mean...

In the end it is also possible Dell (isn't it?) put some murky system on your machines (by accident of course!); check them out...

Good luck

by virtualwolf

You could also try this. Right Click C: drive, choose "Properties", Uncheck "Allow Indexing Service to index this disk for fast file searching". This may allow fast file searching, but it will slow down Windows too.

by gnx

I just delete the non-business related stuff when they complain the new pc is running slow. If they have a complaint they can take it up with management. I have 2 or 3 users constantly downloading stuff that doesn't belong. Unfortunately I can't take the internet away from them because they need it when they do some work. I just refuse to repair any programs that I don't install when the PC is put on the desk. If someone leaves I usually will write zeroes and format the hard drive instead of trying to delete all this stuff. It is a constant battle of wills and the user will ultimately lose. I don't think you can convince those users about what they can't download until they get written up or something like that.

by pkr9

You put yourself on the defensive. You let it happen, and remedy later.
Be proactive instead. Set-up barriers, block users.
Go to the extent of partitioning local drive to Windows minimum, and store ALL userfiles on central server with limitations on size. Additonally run an hourly batch job removing unwanted files.
Scrap their PC's and give them diskless thin clients.
Take it up with management. You might end up on the frontpage on papers with charges of copyright infringements or stoles SW. Very bad PR!

Try to get a new job, after being responsible for you latest company going to court sued for stealing SW and music....

by mconiegs

Thanks for the idea of Deep freeze.

The reason for the heading is how many staff would come to work with sandpaper and paint and start re-decorating, especially in rented office space? Yet the same staff consider it ok to "re-decorate" there main work tool, normally at huge expense in support costs. The support costs are then normally made up by other staff, or lower wages to all staff.

by pwalters9

Having been botha business owner and a company employee, I find this issue to be misunderstood by many. Many employees abuse company assets while many companies abuse their employees.

Here's what I do. If you use your PC for "non-business" items (e.g. listening to MP3s offline from the Internet), then you are responsibile for local admin and maintenance of your PC. If your activities impact my network infastructure, we talk. If you can't do your work, we talk. Obviously, don't do stuff that is illegal or would compromise the company (e.g. porn or gambling). But, if you work through lunch to meet a deadline in the office and elect to shop online vs. leaving the office, I'm cool with that. Just be a safe surfer. Be smart and let's work together. Need to check your bank balance on payday, cool. Want to watch that 500Kb streaming video of some cheesy pop star, no. Save that for your dial-up connection at home.

by sendbux

Probably would be better to get someone else to "write . . . some usage policies".

by whamii

At the company I work for we use a product called Surf Control. It allows you to add the websites you only want your users to access. It also trakc were users go and logs it for you. This gives you proof for management. Once we rolled out this program all we had to do was mention to our users that they are being tracked. This has cut our virus reports down from 5 pages to 1 page.Just the thought that they are being watched has kept our users company friendly but it also made IT a bad word among users. Our policy states that computer use is for "Business" related use only. If users are caught surfing sites they should not be on they are disciplined.

by bfelts

The only way to get any traction on this issue is with management buy-in. Otherwise, you are whistling in the dark. No amount of reasoning will sway users if your management is resisting the very policies you need to implement. I know folks that have lost their job because management will not back them on something as unpopular as a reasonable AUP, but still hold IT accountable for upholding virus, piracy, e-mail compliance, and other issues. Heck, folks have lost their jobs for trying to implement something as simple as a password policy, due to user outcry. Look to the management, and you will see their attitudes replicated down to the shipping dock guy. If they (your management) won't support you, you don't stand a chance.

Good luck!

by jkratzer

I did not have managment support for my policies at first. I implemented them anyway. I implemented strong password policies and even stronger windows policy's.

Now that managment can see the benifit, I have there support. (And a promotion to Technology Manager)

Sometimes you have to go against the grain to get the job done and realy show management the results. Just reporting users, in most companies, is wasting your time.

Stand firm on what you believe to be right and follow through. If the company does not like the results, then it is not the right company for you.

by dclay2112

First you buy the software. Then let everyone know you're monitoring them. Bingo! Problem solved immediately. When they think things have blown over and no one is checking on them - you got'em!!

Go to http://www.spectorsoft.com/

by pickleman

Sounds like you're working for a bunch of morons. You can either put up with the continued idiocy, or you can start looking for a new place to work.

Those are the only two options available to you if nobody in upper management cares about the problem.

by beoweolf

First you need a company policy, written, discussed and enforced. You will need backup from your manager and his mangager to make things stick.

Then take a system image of what is authorised on each machine, it helps if you do it by department or workgroup. Nothing personal should be on the "C", system drive...if it has nothing to do with business, PC system operations, networking, etc. then lock it down.

setup a token partition for user descrestion, set a quota thru system or group policy that allows "x" disc space for misc.

The hard one: When the system is running slow, has problems or is infected....just format the "C" drive and reinstall the image. Anything else is up to the user.

If you wish to be kind, then set up space on the file server and allocate space for users to upload anything that is important, pertains to their job...and maintain backups from there. Again, anything on the local disk is subject to being deleted.

A bit draconian, but it works.

by macghee

that's not draconian. Maybe I'm a bit spoiled where I'm at, but I thought that constituted "Best Practices" as well as due dilligence.

by timw

We are now in the happy situation where 95% of our desktops are a standard configuration. We've written policies on how databases should operate (storing temporary files in a named folder, etc) and users run with normal User rights.

We provide C:\TEMP where people can put files if they want, but anything in that folder will not be backed up if we have to re-image the PC.

by deadly ernest

I worked in an organisation that had policies on these issues and the staff routinely ignored the policy. We had another policy was that any call re problems with the OS performance were dealt with quickly and simply.

Take special 2 disc cd set to PC, boot from CD running first a virus checker, using the latest definitions on the network server, then adware and spyware programs. Check performance, if still bad.

Boot second CD which did a format C and reimaged the operating system.

Since all corporate local data storage was pointed to D drive by the corporate image, no corporate data was lost but all extras were. After a few incidents of this most users limited what extras they did put on.

Another organisation had their systems set to have them boot over the network with the registry settings and start up programs reimaged at each boot. Anything set up just never got a chance to restart.

by macghee

If this user is spending that much time downloading and listening to music and watching movies, management might be interested in knowing where the money that they are spending is actually going. Further, the issue of stolen copyrighted material and liability for it comes up. Not something that your management would want to get blindsided by. I don't know how big your firm is, but if it's small the litigation costs could seriously hurt the business, and thereby hurt you.

Speak to the employee's manager after clearing it with your boss, as this situation will undoubtedly be of interest to him or her. The employee is stealing time from the company by not performing the assigned work. Spending the time he is being paid for by downloading movies and music is nowhere in his job description. I sincerely doubt that he is whipping out a credit card to pay for any of the movies or music, which brings up the second issue: theft of copyrighted material. It doesn't matter where you or I stand on the copyright infringement / theft issue. What matters here is company liability for the actions of one of its employees that it failed to properly supervise. The company's assets (computers, network, servers, internet access) have been used to illegally obtain the copyrighted materials. You can bet your severance pay that the holders of the copyrighted material would love to sue for major bucks over this. The headlines have been full of such cases. It would be enough to make a Temple Law School lawyer salivate. If the company takes a hit, the company has way less money to put into interesting things such as employee compensation, profit sharing (no profit, no sharing) and retirement accounts. So it is in your best interest to perform the due diligence needed by to prevent the company from taking a hit that would vaporize your next raise.

I'm not going to go into all the various moral and ethical aspects of this, as others here have, or will do that sufficiently.

Cover your ass: go to your boss.

Pete

by dcbowiemd

Well .. Sadly those morons are being paid by the tax payers of America. Plus I make far too much money right now and I got 9 years before retirement. So I'll play the game. I do a very good covering my bum and keep archives of emails that I can go back several years with.

I document everything, then when someone starts raising cain and asking why, I pull out my archives, forward the emails and say, here is what meeting was on what the, the attendees, what was discussed and agreed upon, etc.

Because I keep such excellent 'notes' I have pissed off some because in time people forget what was discussed and agreed upon, etc. Then those shakers and movers want to change the rules of what they made, which is fine, just don't blame someone else, such as the network group.

It's not all bad, because I put in a Windows 2003 network early part of 2003, got the latest and greatest servers and slowly began the movement over. Then it's the xp systems too.

Yes, there are drawbacks, but because I 'play' the game with them, they will help. Even in times of tight money, someone always wants to do in some department a new thing and they have money and will fund us.

We have upgraded to the latest and greatest routers, been to schools to keep up with our skills and been paid well.

That is what we get back for putting up with users who can trash their system on a whim and decide they can't work because their computer is down.

I've checked out places and they don't pay nearly as much as I get. I would take a 20k cut just to switch jobs. Ain't worth it. I'll stay with the morons and wear the many hats and continue to document myself.

by macghee

You're out of line flaming him for that post. And if your strongest argument is regarding some spelling mistakes, then you are pretty lame.

The personal time of the employees while on break and lunch does not extend the right to do whatever they wish with company assets, such as the computer or the internet. Numerous US court cases have shown that very clearly.

by macghee

Quagmire,

If you really want to torque up their stress-o-meters, allow access only to the sites that they need to access for performance of their jobs, but deny everything else! Also, given the volume of trojans delivered (see www.sans.org for statistics on this one) via instant messaging, deny all access to all chat protocols at the gateway. Your headaches will decrease. When they whine that they can't chat with whoever online anymore, ask that the request be sent via email and explain the business need for this connection. If they are stupid enought to do this, forward it to their manager for some sort of clarification as you "don't understand how it ties in with business objectives." Ought to be fun as long as the lusers are minions. If they're higher up, some sort of explanation about incompatibility with the business software might suffice.

by ornerdoug

I don't work in an environment as serious as health care, but I have the same views as you. Those computers are for work only, if they try to go to a domain or subdomain I feel is not for work, bam-o, they are redirected to a webpage that says "This website has been deemed unuseful for your line of work, please do not visit it again". Really upsets those who wanted to play online games and listen to internet radio and suck up system resources.

by macghee

Creative,

If you come up with standard desktop loads (perhaps one for supervisors, one for lusers) and have master copies on hand, all you have to do is format and ghost it. Intially, getting all the boxes set with the "standard load" will be a bit time consuming, but after it's done life will be easier. Any serious problem comes in, just format and ghost the drive. Figure about half an hour per box. While it's running, go have a cup of coffee or work another machine.

by macghee

Abby,

Try this to see how wellit stacks up. Replace the Norton A/V with the free copy of AVG. Install and run Spybot and Ad Aware. Run them at least once a week, along with a full system scan with AVG. I'm pretty sure that you'll have less junk invading your lapbox and more system resources available. One other program that you may find useful for getting resources back is called Maxmem from AnalogX. It's free, too.
For download source for the ones I listed above, try either www.download.com or www.majorgeeks.com and good luck.

Oh yeah, download and run CCleaner - think I got it from Majorgeeks. It cleans out all the junk files, freeing up a lot of hard drive space. Also free.

Pete

by bg6638

I hate to be ruthless, however firing one is what it took for users where I last worked to get the message that company computers AND time are for company business. Although, it helps when they cause a problem which holds processing payroll checks up for a day! Nobody wants to be responsible for that again, as you become public enemy number 1!

by raelayne

Lots of great ideas and some hare-brained ones.

I think there's no perfect solution here; there are competing values that cannot be resolved.

Too much restriction and regulation breeds employee discontent.

Too little regulation breeds support costs that are astronomical, and fosters poor performance.

IT wants RULES and ENFORCEMENT and PUNISHMENT because the support folks get really sick of dealing with the problem. User WANT FREEDOM -- do just get their jobs done, or in unfortunate situations, to just screw around and "have fun." Whether you're willing to put up with the baby behavior is, of course, a matter of how desperate you are to hang on to the employee -- I'm never that desperate myself.

The computing resources belong to the company, and the company has the right to dictate how those resources will be used. Where did "I can do anything I want with corporate assets" come from?

If you work someplace where you have a "right" to a break every couple of hours and a lunch hour (those jobs still exist?), then you have the right to the break, not to do whatever you want with company equipment during the break.

As a manager, I try to balance the different concerns; I try not to get in the way of people doing their jobs, but I draw the line at the illegal, at copyright violations, etc. I don't think anyone in my department believes he or she has a "right" to do whatever he or she wants, and I expect employees to exercise judgment. I let them know when they've gone too far, so there is an ongoing series of course corrections going on. Yes, it's annoying, but it beats the Nazi approach.

It is sometimes amazing to me what employees think they're entitled to. One fellow called his broker once every 7 minutes for an entire month, something that showed up in phone logs I received at month end. He thought he had the right to do this, and told me that if he had to leave to use a pay phone he'd lose even more more work time. He's gone, of course, and lost his shirt in the derivatives market, which was gratifying. So I can relate to people's frustration, and their desire to become the Network Nazi.

But we should beware of a solution that's worse than the problem. In my department, people do their banking, send personal messages, etc. while they're at work. They exchange jokes. They print things for their kids' school projects. But the time they spend on this kind of stuff is very limited. It's just a matter of being professional.

In short, I really think the Nazi approach is over-kill for most work environments. A set of policies, enforced when things that shouldn't happen do, and continual education works best.

Get executive buy-in by showing them the dollars. Come up with a reasonable set of policies (buy them -- that way you can make the "industry standard" argument, deflecting the charge that you are a control freak). Enforce them reasonably, when you need to. Enforce the serious ones more vigorously -- downloading music not paid for, or installing copies of software without a license, etc., should be prevented. Stay cool about the minor stuff.

by helpusobiwan

You will be able to do nothing about it (except buy mucho more RAM) until Management decides THEY wish to do something about it. Perhaps the bill for more memory will make the point. But probably not. As long as the work of the company appears to be getting done and management is playing the same games, then there is nothing to be done about it actually. Consider this your opportunity to learn how to make really hot gaming machines (because that seems to be the preferred usage, eh?). We ahve policies also. For example, if porn is found on your computer, you are fired. Period. Fired. Well ... unless you are mid-level or upper management. Then the IT guy will smirk and look the other way (he knows who signs his check all right).

If you have any idea that someone way up in the administration might some day attempt to blame the whole mess on you, (1) develop a record of the software each user requires to do their job [NOTE "requires", not "likes to play with"], on the next hardware and/or system upgrade install only those applications, then (2) in the name of security, install antivirus software (if you haven't), install anti-spyware (if you haven't) and keep them up-to-date. I don't mean the retail variety we buy at Walmart or download free from "freesoftware.net" ... I mean centrally-managed, commercial / industrial applications (like Symantec or CA or someone really big and well known). Lock them down so the users cannot bypass them, then (3) install a content manager (like WebMarshall) on the incoming Internet access line; then (4) issue memos to department heads & staff (ie, anyone with an email address at your company) stating the typical company boilerplate about not having non-company programs on the computer and that Internet access is provided for company business use only and that company email addresses are provided for business only and that company phones are provided for business only ... feel free to throw in "reasonable personal use" whereever you are comfortable ... you get the idea [we have to sign, date and return ours when these come out periodically]; then (5) document abuses in a contemporaneous record based on personal observation, browser history logging, content manager reports, etc., etc., etc. (do _NOT_ advertise you are doing this).

Voil?! Now, if anyone ever complains that you are not "fixing" the garbageware on the users computers, you can say that (1) the systems were "standardized" and (2) the users were provided with the standard suite of company software required to do their jobs and informed of their responsibilities in regard to computer/Internet/email usage; and (3) you've got the data to prove it and you are more than willing to share it with any manager interested. If you're still in "trouble" with the company, quit and go somewhere they are interested in working instead of playing all day!! YOu will be happier and probably better off!!

Just my 2 cents.

by swlchris

I work in a fairly busy computer shop and have had to service some small business setups from time to time.
I ceased to be amazed at all that crap I found in msconfig, start menu and task bars...
We use a few tools, cc cleaner, hitman pro and a bunch of various anti-virus goodies..
As long as the admin password is by passed those problems are going to appear sometime in the very near future.
There doesn't necessarily have to be P2P on the machine, or Yahoo Games or wahtever. The very existence of popups and click here's that install goodies is rampant on the Internet.
I do like the deep freeze best though in the shop, keeps the massive 3d games off the network hehehheheheh. Works great in an internet cafe setting too.
If all all else fails , there is the evil option of typing in format C: watching it go bye bye and sticking in a Linux cdrom :)

by support

A few steps ->
(a) Get a policy, there are a tonne of them on the web, adjust it so it suits your company, with statements like -> only tech support can install software, and only company data is to be kept on company machines, and any non-company data/programs can be deleted without warning
(b) Get it approved by management -> by management as a group, so the odd single manager who won't like it can't tell you no - a simple justification to use is to bring up a single user who has wasted company money and time by doing something like what you describe - and tell them how much it cost in $$$$, and ask if they want to keep spending those $$$$ on things like this - or would they rather have their company cars - and see if you can find similar incidents in company history so the $$$$ amount is higher
(c) create an image (or images, if necessary) which doesn't allow any users to install software, only administrators -> use something like ghost or
if your smart enough, ghostforunix (free and easy) to roll it out
(d) roll out the image to all company boxes, making sure no standard users have admin access to the image of course

I did this about 4 years ago, and it has saved so much money and time for my company, in not having to deal with problems like you describe above. It also saves money on the training angle for your staff, as they know all machines are exactly the same, and can teach and support each other without too much resort to tech support for individual customised computers.

by avinesan

This is true however policies are just but a mechanism to curb this problem. I've done my Research on "email in the workplace" and found that by taking preventive measures like monitoring application usage, installing cameras, restricting access to applications and explaining - NOW THIS IS A BIG ONE - the productivity that is lost in terms of man hours lost which directly equates to large sums of money. On the same token if all these measures are taken and if staff is aware of whose responsible for this - you'll be able to sense the hostility.

Remember what ever the descision, take note of its ramification.

by blue-knight

It depends on how narrow you define company business. I have been in field since 73. When first training users who had never seen a computer before, using solataire was more effective than anything else in teaching how to use a mouse. So do you consider playing solataire theft?

I prefer users to 1> Get their job done. 2> Be efficient 3> Be easier to adapt to new changes 4> Suggest ways that the processes and programs be improved. All of these are core business concepts. You do not reach All of these goals with box of regs around your users. Yes, abuses have to be stopped. And Yes, getting the current job can be also be done. But in stopping abuses, you do not want to stop the adaptability and suggestions. You do not want a climate of fear either. Fear can be ok for the short term, but it is like a acid on long term productivity and growth.

I have requests for tighter policies from my staff from time to time. There are a few very valid reasons for some (no porn), but most I turn down. But many are about increasing control or sensibility of the IS and not the core business reasons. Limiting what the users can do means they can do less. Making users fearful in general degrades performace.

by tprattbp

Agreed! We have a strict Acceptable Use Policy that clearly spells out what is acceptable and the sanctions if not followed. No one, including the owner, is allowed to install software on company computers. That puts the ownership, license compliance & support fully on the IT dept. We also require all users to attend a Safe Networking presentation before they log on the first time. We follow up by periodically providing training on how to best use the electronic tools the company has provided them.

by mdpetrel

1st of all: STOP BLAMING USERS!

We exist to serve them ... and THEY DO NOT KNOW ANYTHING AT ALL ABOUT OUR WORK

If they don't understand something it IS UP TO US TO EXPLAIN IN PLAIN LANGUAGE

2nd: BLOCK THE POP-UPS THAT THEY SEE WHICH TRICK THEM INTO INSTALLING AND DOWNLOADING ALL THESE EXTRAS

.......

Bottom line: IT IS UP TO US TO BE PRO-ACTIVE

Do not get mad at them, they truly do not know what they are doing.

by jim.danvers

I just start deleting / un-installing. I don't care - I know that my boss and his/her boss(es) will back me up. Our users know the rules, they know what is and isn't allowed on company owned hardware. I will just (w/out any warning to the user) will just start un-installing out of add/remove programs until I get the machine cleaned.

When I'm done - I will then announce to the user - "ok - machine should run better now..." and I'll pretty much leave it at that. If (and they frequently do) the user asks what might have been the problem - then I'll just tel them that I found all sorts of weird s/w on the machine that shouldn't have been on it - so I un-installed it. I rarely get resistance.... and when I do - I tell them who to talk to (my boss).

-=- jd -=-

by jamesrl

I used to work at a Fortune 100 company and they came up with an interesting policy. If there a PC related problem and there was software on the PC that may be business related but not on the approved list, they would do "best efforts" to resolve the problem(assuming the problem was with supported software or the OS). If best efforts fail, the next step was to back up the data and reimage the PC to the original supported and test again. If the problem no longer existed, the user was not allowed to re-install the non-supported software(or if they did they were on their own for support on any issue).

James

by rob mekel

Were they allowed to have company data on their company's pc? Didn't they have to put it on the file-server? What would have happened if the pc-disk crashed irreparably, with vital company data on it?
Oh my there is a lot to learn I think.

Rob

by iron111

Version 10.0 of Symantec Anti-Virus Corp Edition includes spyware protection. RTVSCAN.EXE found in processes consumed between 50 and 55K of system resources. Symantec soon after came out with a release of 10.0.01 which only consumes 35K which is still alot, but doesn't bring a 2.4Ghz - 500MB Ram machine to it's knees.

In addition to Symantec, we use the free Beta M$ Antispyware, as well as XPSP2. We utilize policies within active directory that prevents any unauthorized software installations.

by kiltie

May I quote you "Absolutely"....

vvvvvvv vvvvvvvvvv
Quote
"Since you "beleave that controling such employees to keep them in-line", I judge from the spelling that English is not your first language...."
End Quote

Hmmmmm, best not to flame, doesn't achieve anything really..... all I would comment is that English seems not to be your first language either.

re the coffee breaks, as an employee of a very large UK Civil Service department, I worked straight through them...... my "extra time" was a few hours before anyone arrived for work, and some hours afterwards.
I was still working, but with batch processing (at that time Windows didn't exist) and there was a 30 minute wait between submitting a job to the mainframe system and getting results back

by r3d

I agree wholeheartedly with your decision at a hospital.

Unfortunately not every business is a hospital or has the same requirements as such. what about a business where you have developers that need local admin rights to do their job? what about execs that hold power over your position and tell you to let them install a certain application you deem unworthy of installing? what about custom/proprietary applications that require administrative rights in order to run properly? What about project managers that know enough about computers to be dangerous?

I had one project manager take a guy's system (minus the HDD) in order to install and run a server in his workgroup. The guy let his manager do it and then requested a new system. I thought I had already given him a system and confirmed it and took it to my 2nd line manager who was extremely upset that a project manager had the gall to do something like this. He gave me the authority to take the server and swap it all back the way it was, and unfortunately the server no longer worked, but the guy got his system back at least. when the PM complained to a different high level manager, he was told to deal with it and that all the managers had knowledge of what he did and that it was frowned upon.

anyways, people try to get away with all kinds of crap regardless of the consequences. i try to circumvent this by warning them in advance and appeasing at least a few of thier requests. I had a MP3 server setup so that the company could listen (not copy) to music of their choice as they worked.

I like the gestapo tactics you describe, but it jsut doesn't fly for all types of business...

*sigh...

by ltsmith39

ah - how about since '63 - back then - this wasn't a problem - the problem was getting people to use computers. no - playing solitare is not theft unless solitare happens to be the only thing you do all day and it's strictly for personal enjoyment(i've seen this really happen). it's not what you do, but the purpose. company business is company business and personal business is personal business. I know it's tuff to seperate the two (i have the same problem), but unless we call it what it really is (in my opinion) people will have a tendancy to minimize it. you're right on with the rest. PS - i have had to look at porn just to validate what was going on and "police" it. only once. and not by my choosing.

by jjlucero

Boy I couldn't agree more, we replace more stolen and physically damaged laptops abused by users than you can possibly imagine. Some are even frozen because they not only abuse them physically but add their own image to them, just replaced LCD and most of the plastics to a laptop that was ran over by a car...still trying to figure this one out.

by jjlucero

You have my sympothy, I do feel your pain but sometimes the best approach is to just let them live with it until they can suck it up and admit they made a their own bed that they have to lie in.

I deal with it everyday, my laptop is to slow, why do you people bother giving us one? Its Useles!!! And then they call you every thing from IT/Computer Nazi's to PC Police, make claims that you've spied on their e=mail but as stated in earlier post...this isn't YOUR machine it belongs to the company you work for and was given to them to do their job, don't pull your hair out, it's not worth it, you have to have support from your IT manager, good luck with that, but in the mean time, if they are forced to work with it "AS IS" until you can undo their self inflicted damage... they will certainly appreciate it more, union or no union, they aren't IT and can make all the accusations they want but if parts aren't available or some other more pressing issue is the problem like you don't feel like fixing it today, well seems they could have a problem proving it to be an intentional delay, we justify stuff all the time to our self inflicted victims and it seems to work pretty well.

by deadly ernest

Back in 1997 a colleague ask how you could manage something like this and I gave him a set up that I had dreamed up for a IT Network Management assignment, he later implemented it at his work. A big company with over 5,000 PCs across the country.

PC has 2 hard drives, C drive is the corporate system and D drive is for local data. My Documents and Favorites are pointed to folders on D drive as part of the corporate image, as is a folder called 'Personal' in the email client. All corporate data is stored on servers, with all but the Personal folder in the email on the mail server.

The corporate image is such that no additional folders can be added to the mail client no data storage pointers can be changed. All log on profiles are on the servers.

Every Wednesday night ALL computers are to be left on so that IT can roll out patches and updates etc. This is done by making a new image and then it is placed on every PC during the night. Thus every Wednesday night sees any new applications vanish. The people can do anything that they wish.

If an individual needs a special application it is loaded onto the D drive with a link in the favorites.

Gateway is set up so that all ports but those needed for corporate usage are closed off (chat and IM within the network works but not with the world) and some software to lock out inappropriate websites.

The corproate IT policies refelct all this and no one cares about what they want to do with the D drive as the main system works well and gets FIXED each week.

by arnonllanes

I don't think they have to be told that during work hours, they're supposed to be working (unless they're going there for fun and not getting paid). To answer your question: Group Policies (or local computer policies for that matter). Question for you: Why on earth are they allowed to install software on the local machines?

by bfelts

I have management insisting on each desktop user having Admin privlieges. Luckily, some of the senior management at my company understands why this is not allowable. It is still (after a year) in the balances if our management will insist on global admin for all users. All the arguments have been placed on why admin should be locked down, but some of our managers feel that a users ability to install a random program at an instants whim is more important than any security or possible licensing issues. In addition, some of our programs will *ONLY* work if it is run by an admin user....

by oook!

..of giving some leeway, and yet protecting everything. Most employees like to check email / travel / banking during their 'break' time. Where I work, is a 30 minute limit per day of surfing to most sites (not including chat etc) with special permission for other limited sites. It seems to work pretty well - they check their own stuff quickly - first thing in the morning & at lunchtime usually - but don't complain as they are allowed to do the things they need.

As for spelling... whilst I was typing this on my tiny little laptop, I mis-spelled loads! I had to go back & re-read it!

by rob mekel

if y're having trouble convincing upper management of the need to imply those polices (rules) then make sure you have a financial overview of what it will cost extra if they want all of those programs to run as nice as they would as if just 1 or the normal company programs are running.

I'm sure that will convince them as they are triggered on profit and not spending money on fun of the employee including themselves.

Rob

by your mom 2.0

If your company uses Active Directory, why not just create a GPO that locks down the users' permissions so they can't install anything?

by oldbag

I have found and documented cases of objectionable material but to date, the employees involved have only been 'lettered'. I really think that the only way to get users attention on this is for someone to actually lose their job over it. We do have written policies but they are being ignored. The topic has come up again with management and I hope to get this into our employee handbooks.

I was working on a system today that had spyware and viruses and found some naughty stuff. I did my documentation and backed up the files in question on my external hard drive. Unfortunately, the user of the system is the older brother of the young man that I am training as my assistant! I did inform my manager of what I found but I didn't like doing it this time.

by r3d

Two things come to mind about naughty stuff appearing on a system.

One, it may not be that person's complete fault. i have seen some people leave their systems logged on and "others" go onto their systems and cause the naughtyness to appear. i even had a problem with a security guard getting on user systems that have been left logged on and doing some "weird" stuff.

Two, you could have just notified the user and get his input as to what happened and warn him verbally that he either needs to logoff or not go to those types of sites, or you will be forced to report his activities. You could also just say these things get logged as to the sites each user goes to and it's beyond your control. Most users have no clue as to how that works anyways, lol. Truth be told, it can be monitored, but most companies don't bother with it.

anyways, reporting him to a manager could jeapordize his position and it's something you want to resort to as a last ditch effort. I wouldn't want to get anyone fired over something so trivial, and I would at least like to give the user the benefit of the doubt or at least a chance to not screw up like that again. Besides, it's fun seeing them squirm knowing you are aware of what strange activities they are up to, heheh...

by sikkerhed

Lockem down man! No one needs local admin rights.
Give them only the access they need, not want. Forget the politics, and do what is right for the network.

by deadly ernest

Our church computers all have local admin locked down and are used almost daily on the Internet for searching out records. They all have anti-virus programs installed and are set to update the AV definitions daily. Yet the AV definitions are still at the point they were when shipped 18 months ago. Why you ask? Because the local admin rights are locked down and we do not have them and the AV defintions will only update in full admin mode - we cannot change any of the system files or settings.

So each day we spend a long time downloading AV updates that we can not install and we cannot stop because some idiot wen overboard in their lockdown.

You have to look at what can be done while still maintaining reasonable usability levels and total lockdown is not one such option. If a total lockdown was a totally reasonable wortk solution then you should be using older equipment and using thin client as you will get by with less resources and faster responses and ensure data is always stored in the right place.

by rob mekel

I guess your systems are in a LAN environment.
Did you ever try to have the AV updates at login-time? This way the local security-settings can be overruled by the netadmin and install the AV updates. Don't ask me how exactly that this is done, as I am not a system/netadmin, I just know that it can be done.

Success

Rob

by kaogle

I went to a training class last week and they gave me this advice:

1> Do not enforce the policy yourself, have HR *the check signers* enforce it.
2> Make an example out of somebody. Somebody has to be the example of what happens if you defy the rules.
3> Make sure everybody knows that the enviroment is a "No expectation of privacy" enviroment. Meaning there IS a big brother in this area.
4> If all else fails, take away their computer. Its not theirs, typicly in an enviroment, it is actually the "property" of the IT department.

by oko

O yeah, it's so utmost simple to tell what to do in a classroom; and indeed, the advices look healthy.
But, about the rules in practice:
1. HR-people generally don't know anything about 'policies'...and will not be interested either
2. That's the way to make an eternal ennemy
3. Who is going to do the checking? You? You got nothing else to do?
4. Taking away their computer? Good plan! But, where is this organization, where THAT will be allowed??

In short: LOL!

by deadly ernest

admin access out on site so we cannot make changes. The AV upgrade is run form 'Start Up' when you log on and does not activate as you need to be log on as Administrator for the update to install. We are not and cannot log on as Administrator.

I have worked in a place where the system had a special script to run the AV update and install it between when you clicked to activate a user log on and when the log on was activated by the system. That worked just as you say. So did one where it ran a script upon boot up but prior to the screen with the choice of log on ID options. Neither of these apply here.

by r3d

Do you have a manaement utility or a server side component that manages the updates?

Symantec Corporate uses a mangement utility to update all clients without interactive required responses from the end user. It's all automatic and behind the scenes, but it has to be setup by an administrator.

You could also create a script that can "run as" a different user, say a local admin. You would need the local admin to set it up though.

You could also setup the update service to run as a different user as well, so that when the update took place it would automatically run as the local admin or any other account that had authority to do so...

Hope these suggestions help.

by deadly ernest

I know there are a number of ways this could be done. The AV program that is installed can be made to work properly with a basic user IF it is installed as the basic user - but NO - HO installed it as Administrator and ship them around the country and no local staff are given the Administrator password. And you get in huge trouble if you make any changes to it at all.

Bloody half trained gorillas who read a manual somewhere one day about locking down a PC. Total lockdown is the most stupid way to go for security.

by r3d

I like that commercial too, I got a big kick out of it when I saw it... I don't doubt that a scenario such as that could happen, but I find what is more likely is freemail aaccounts. The ones like hotmail, Yahoo Mail and any others that do not scan for virii, that users subscribe to are the worst enemy of the IT profesion. People email all kinds of crap and do this in the corporate world as well. The proliferation of crap is astounding and when one person gts a worm and his system starts spamming any available ports and email addys from the first users address book, the propagation gets a little ridiculous.

How do you shutdown or even enforce external email like that? Besides having a solution that works on the firewall...???

by ltilley1

How to tell the CEO to not send email with blank subject lines, or how to tell the CFO that they really do not need 3 years of email retained, or perhaps just to tell the Marketing Director that the delited items folder should not be considered as a filing cabinet.
ON the other hand I have found buying them a bigger and better computer, gets me some great hand me downs that have more than enough capicity for what this lowley tech needs.

by footlessrabbit

...when my IT manager installs two different versions of SQL on my SQL server. Thus, bringing my DTS packages, remote connections and what not to it's knees.

Seems my eyes would be looking in the wrong place.

by virtualwolf

Install a fresh copy of Windows and image it. Then put that image on all the other laptops. It never seems to work that good if you just uninstall what you don't want. I like to wipe the drive, install fresh copy of windows, install what I do want, and make image.

by sarge62436

Heavy-Handed policies simply generate animosity and are counterproductive. Try an honest, non-tech speak seminar that shows the merits of using a workstation for business. Show the users an example of what can happen when virus, fungus, and plague gets into a workstation. Make them accountable (and deny access where it makes sense), but give users valid reasons. "Because I said so" is a excuse, not a reason.
Remember, you (the IT person) should also abide by the same policies that you set. "Do as I say, not as I do" methods will cause much more harm than good.

by rob mekel

Then make damn sure that your NOT hold responsible if any damage is done, it either be your company or your clients damage. So make sure that your IT dep. at headquarters is held responsible for any mal function/damage due to viruses, spyware or anything else that can damage your dep. our your dep. clients.

Maybe their not half trained but don't know what customers need (as you are their internal customer). ]:)
But then again don't they test an image like that first? And then not only as being an admin but as a normal user? ?:)

([i] f***ing nerts, living in an ivory/electronical environment/tower, dunno anything about real business. oh boy this can apply to a lot of us, can?t it [/i]) :D :^0 ;)

Rob

by ian gardocki

Our strategy is multi-headed.

The first part is to realize that this strategy has to not only be the rules on the computer, but how the user thinks of it. If the user stops thinking of the computer as theirs (even just a little) then a lot of your job is already done. Most users will only try so hard when it comes to these things so make their life difficult and they will give up (most of the time anyway).

First thing we do is block the downloading of .exe .zip .rar .ace at our proxy. If they don?t have a way to get new programs easily they probably won?t install them. I would also recommend blocking streaming content, music and movie files extensions as well. Users have no need to be downloading these things at work and blocking this will help cut down on all that extra bandwidth wasting. Obviously there will be some people who need these things for their job, primarily multimedia people (and execs if you are forced to believe them).

The second thing we do is implement a good set of group policies. Think of your policies like you think about a firewall. Don?t just block the programs you know you don?t want. Instead allow only the ones you know you do want, and block ALL others. If your users don?t have permission to run "Yahoo_Messenger_installer.exe" then it becomes much harder for them to install the program.

This last thing is actually more psychological, and will get you hated, but it works. Disable the ability to change the wallpaper/screensaver/Browser start page. Standardizing these things to the "company wallpaper" and your intranet page will really hammer home to the user that this is NOT their machine.

Realize that doing these things will make you the enemy though. You do need cooperation at some level from the users in order to do their job. People are driven to make the things they work with theirs. Here are some things you can do to help get at least a bit of respect from them. Some of these things use network resources and do bend the rules above, but they are being sanctioned by you and are being used in a controlled environment so are "safe".

Make the screensaver a slideshow of their "my pictures" folder and allow them to put the images they want in there.

Set up a streaming music redirection server that plays the top 5 requested internet radio stations. This is not that hard. Set up a weekly vote on your intranet page where people vote on the genre of music they want to listen to and or the station names you are already providing. Based on the top 5 picks find streams that provide what the users want. Open a hole in the firewall to one machine and allow it to stream music from an internet radio station. Use streaming software on that machine to re-stream the content out to your network in multicast. This way you only use a small bit of bandwidth getting the 5 streams in (as opposed to a few hundred if the users do it on their own) and your internal network usage is used efficiently because you are multicasting it.

If you REALY want to work on your IT/user relations, set the wallpaper to a web page that allows them to constantly have a little slideshow in one corner that displays their pictures. Allow them to submit requests for RSS feeds to also be displayed on their new "Dashboard" wallpaper.

Remember. It is important to think of both the networks security AND the users morale. Just remember to make all your rules exceptions to a global NO rather than trying to block specific things.

(By the way, just incase you don?t think this works large scale, I am one of 10 people in our IT department responsible for about 10,000 machines. We deal with workload by having "power users" who are part of the normal workforce that are assigned from within each section, to do the "easy" stuff. Helpdesk is our level 2 support and policy says that they only talk to our power users. We are level 3 and we only talk to the helpdesk.)

by rob mekel

How much time/proces capacity do they take?

And so on from there you can get an idea of what is wrong with those damn things.

Have fun

Rob

ps check on the swap-file sometimes it isn't installed, but then you did know that, didn't you!

by aaron a baker

When the employee applies for the position, it is made crystal clear that ICQ, MSMessenger, Pal Talk and all those other "wonderful" programs will not be tolerated on Company machines,end of story.
Then it's up to the firm to decide which of these is appropriate to use etc.
No Multi_GBs of Music allowed, no crap games that have nothing to do with business.
No online gaming etc.
Decide what is and what is not appropriate for your Firm's Computers and make up and agreement form whereby the potential employee MUST understand and sign before he/she is even considered for employment.
Control is the only way to monitor such a situation.
When you consider the enormous cost of maintenance on these things, IT's don't come cheap, even if they are working for you, then throw in the down time because the dunderhead got virused or wormed while playing a stupid game, of worse yet, these horrendous Music downloads that take up incredible amounts of space and then the user complains that the computer is slow?
The Computer is No Good??
That's when you show him the affidavit that he/she signed coming in and remind him/her that the next time, it will be a fee to be paid or termination.
A Laptop is company property, not their own and it should be treated in the same manner as a business accessory.
Bored? Go have a Pizza or something but leave the Computer alone, unless you want to be charged for the repairs.
There's the answer.
Accountability and Responsibity for one's own actions.
Regards
Aaron ;)

by rob mekel

The problem with this comes in when upper management want to bend the rules just for their own sake. And worse tell their workers they have to get those "nice" programs to.

In fact they are undermining their own set of company rules. Then the complaints come in about bad response times on the local/company's LAN/WAN.

So every now and then you have to make upper management aware of the issues/problems they get the company into if not staying with good company rules.
[i] best done when ever upper management feels the urge to let slip the rules to their own "benefit". [/i]

Rob

by vandoorninck

Log the time you spend working on sluggish PCs and be sure you can demonstrate to the user and his accomodating boss exactly what's slowing it down. It they still resist usage policies then you can assume their investment in IT support is meant to cover a relaxed environment. It this gets in the way of other, more pressing projects, show the reasons why you'll need to augment your staff.

by oldbag

Sorry, but I need my backup of my management on this and the only way to get it is to inform them. Also, what I found was mail messages in an Outlook folder named 'keepers'. This indicates to me that saving these was intentional.

I have pointed out to users many times that they are responsible for what occurs under their userid. They have been told that their best protection is to log off their computer at the end of the day and not to reveal their password to anyone.

By the way, pornography is not trivial. It is offensive and could result in lawsuits against my employer. The same follows with racist or other types of offensive material. If I find it, it gets reported. This has been made very clear to me by my management. I know that this particular employee is being lettered (a warning, not fired).

As systems professionals, we all need to recognise that this type of material has NO BUSINESS on a user's system. Please do not make excuses for those people that consume this type of garbage. If you want to look at this, DO SO ON YOUR HOME COMPUTER, NOT ONE THAT I HAVE TO SUPPORT!

by rob mekel

As misusage of your company?s property and time is theft. Let alone the harm that can be done to your company?s image what can result in sales loss.

I wouldn't take it that lightly as trivial.

I agree to give the user a chance to improve behavior

Rob

by oldbag

The letter that this employee is about to receive should help improve his behaviour. Since this is a smaller company, I am hoping that the word will get out that I will report ANYBODY I find misusing company equipment.

I have been accused of being "out to get" a certain manager. People think that the PC on their desk is a personal toy and they should be allowed to 'play around' when things are slow. I am attempting to force the old boys network to clean up their act and need any help I can get from management. In order to get their support, I need to report this type of misuse.

by rob mekel

For sure if the word gets out that measures are taken and consequences will follow the other mis-users will back down.

But ... (there always is a but, isn't there)

Will it give you a nice and comfortable working environment, will company atmosphere improve? I guess not.
On the other hand if you give them the reasons why these rules are ... and if their sensible to logic ... then maybe it doesn't has to come to a repercussion/ fear frightening company (don't say that it is now but the risk is there.)

Maybe these links will give you an idea.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=191169&messageID=1978356
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=191169&messageID=1983264

Rob

by maxchowhk

Yes, I will back up all those song into a DVD and return to the user, at the same time I will mention it is the corporate policy of not allow any personal infromation in the system or use the system as personal use. Will note the user inform management if found next time.

by dr_zinj

First make sure you have documentation/logs of all the work you've done to fix user-caused problems. And have a list of the associated costs to the company.
Now go see the CEO and convince him/her that these are behaviors that departments are choosing to allow to happen; and that logically, the cost to correct those problems should be docked from their annual budgets and reassigned to the I.S. department.

by bmwwaterman

We started using local Group Policy on the XP PC's to limit what can and can't be run. When you know what the excuteable is, then you can keep it froming running. We also install Spybot and Adaware. So when we found some new programs, excuteables, etc. that we want to block, we throw those into the "Do Not Run" list in Group Policy. Now if you are in Microsoft shop, you can push it out through Group Policy after they log in. If you are in a non-MS shop, then you'll have to use the local group policy on the client machine. It's a little more of a pain to do, but you can do it. We did.

The politics of management is they don't understand what the problem is, let alone the solution. How many times do we encounter problems, and scratch our heads our selves. And we work with this stuff all day, every day. They basically expect you to fix whatever the problem is. Don't you hear, after you start explaining what the problem is, them say, "Oh... just fix!" I love the dumb looks sometimes also.

Don't give up. Find that little crack so you can do what needs done. Help to protect themselves from their own actions. Start out slowly at first. Then it'll get accepted and be expanded even more.

by khamis.abulani

I suggest you to have policy in your domain that you can limit users from doing what you do not want.

Also you should spend in getting solutions, such webcontent filter and email content filter, and concentrate in your security, you will have better and controller environment.

Khamis Awadh
Infrastructure Specilist
Team Leader DSS
Injazat Data Systems

This discussion is closed to new replies.