Discussion Locked

If this isn?t lunacy, I don?t know what is

0 helpful
832 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post

832 replies

by nicknielsen

Does not equal "already backed it up."

This is old news; anybody that's been paying attention already knew about it. There was a major flap several years ago, but Congress didn't have the 'nads to change the law when people called bullsh1t. Sound familiar?

And if SUV drivers knew what was good for them, they wouldn't have SUVs, would they?

by $$$$$$$$$$

I'm bored with the subject of TonytheTiger.
Had his question and his approach to this
subject been "valid" my answer to him would
have reflected that. Instead, I reply to
him in the spirit of his participation
here: belligerence. I'm just
better-informed than he.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I "already" explained the comment you
challenged, and as it is common knowledge
["old news" in your own words], that DOES
= "already backed it up."

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2484267

[i]And to claim that special exemptions for
the manufacturers of SUVs does not benefit
the purchasers of same is to say that those
purchasers don't know what is good for
them.[/i]

Well? Does the benefit to manufacturers
from selective legislation also benefit the
purchasers, or not? Do you disagree with
any part of that? What part? Why? Present
your argument. Your claim that I haven't
backed up my statement is foolish.

by deepsand

Reaching equilibrium between levels of CO2 inputs and outputs will not serve to reduce existing levels of either atmospheric CO2 or oceanic acidification.

Only a [b]reduction of [u]net[/u] output[/b] of CO2 can accomplish such.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]The original is that 'the love of money
is the root of all evil.'[/i]

... but your own expressed views ...

[i]placing value on an intermediary thing -
whether currency, gold, labor hours, pretty
flowers - is at the root of our human
problems[/i]

... are an even broader assertion.

by deepsand

from a different sub-thread.

I've been trying, to no avail, to keep the 2 issues separated.

by deepsand

When I've evidence that you've read and understand other reading material that I've placed before you, then I'll consider new requests.

by deepsand

Money - tactical tool - is not the issue.

Long term survivability - strategic goal - is.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Though the very combining would serve to make the old, if not new at least very different. Is late and my thoughts are elsewhere, but will be back with an edit. This sort of thing usually takes me a bit of pen and paper 'juggling' in order to say exactly what I want to say. Of course that doesn't necessarily mean it will make sense to anyone else. ;)

edit 4/26:
I am not as eloquent, or even such a stickler for logic as several of you. Logic holds only to prove validity in reasoning and I am really just attempting to get people thinking in another direction ? at least for a bit. The facts of things only say so much about life and being. So bear with me, please. Then blast me if you must. ;)

Defined terms:
Intermediary value ? that thing which distracts our assignment of value from the person whose skill and intelligence created the thing or provided the service.
Community ? a relatively small and intimate group of people acting in concert with one another and with the natural world to promote their own and each other?s health and well-being.

Actually, I think that I revise my initial answer to say that we need a completely new paradigm. We need to stop assigning value to intermediary, impersonal things (yes, my post above Facts, schmacts?) We need to value people, the skills and knowledge that people hold. Even the most stupid or foolish of us can serve a community in some fashion and be respected for that service if we choose to value people. Currently, I frankly don?t see that as a society we value people. Certainly some people here and there value people in general or at least particular people, a lot of people think and/or claim that they value people, but as a whole we appear to be a long way from behaving in that fashion on any kind of consistent basis. Our race in fact has a long, long history of not valuing people in spite of what we proclaim and/or have proclaimed in the past. If in fact we valued people above all, I believe that war, slavery and all the various and sundry other physical, mental, and emotional abuses we propagate as a species would be nonexistent.

We need to honestly see and value our place in the natural world. In fact, we are at its mercy and even the most technologically rich and proficient of us get regular lessons in just that. But as far as I can see we learn little to nothing in relation to our utter dependence on the natural world at the foot of those regular lessons. Rather, we go out of our way to dream up new ways to try to avoid the lessons. What arrogance.

We are completely dependent on something not of our making for our survival. All the things we invent, while useful to us, distract us from the real and true understanding that we are at the mercy of the same forces as are the ?lesser? inhabitants of this planet. We delude ourselves with our distraction and this has brought us to the position in which we find ourselves today ? unable due to lack of what I will call primary knowledge to fend for ourselves. We have set corporate agriculture and food processing in place, most likely because it is quite convenient not to have to scrabble in the dirt, forest, and lakes for our food. We purchase our water from a water company that is more than willing to cut off our supply if we don?t pay the bill. These are primary survival needs and we have sloughed off the responsibility for meeting these needs personally for ourselves to those who have distracted us with the lure of convenience.

I would consider this new paradigm to be one in which money ? or any other form of intermediary value ? is nonexistent. Communities function as a unit, each member providing according to skill and inclination (I do not mean willingness with the use of this word) that which the community needs to survive and thrive. I?m none too certain that this has ever been the human condition, though before the advent of money in the form of standardized coinage or mayhap even commodity money, there had to be some form of unitary community function that placed value on personal skill, knowledge, and service rather than impersonal things, or it is likely that we would not be here today.

How do we accomplish a paradigm shift to that which is in direct opposition to that from which we currently operate? Gads. Generally speaking we humans appear loathe to alter our worldview without first being dumped to the bottom of an endless pit of despair. Those of us who do elect to work at altering our worldview spend our entire lives overcoming the perceptual habits that we acquired during childhood and adolescence.

It strikes me that our only hope is to live through whatever disaster we foist upon ourselves with intent that is focused enough to not let go of or misinterpret the lesson/s that could be learned via hindsight.

A few more days and this would likely improve, but I don't have that kind of time at the moment; being directly engaged in fulfilling the requirements of the current paradigm to a necessary degree. ;)

edit typo

by deepsand

1) They get a vehicle intended to be and almost exclusively used as a passenger vehicle without having to meet the same fuel economy (and emissions?) standards that are applied to automobiles; and,

2) They can arrange the purchase so as to gain a tax credit that is unavailable to buyers of automobiles.

These advantages are only slightly offest by the amusement value that they provide the rest of us during Winter, when they oft times end up upside down on the side of the road. :^0 :^0 :^0

by deepsand

Do some research re. the properties of plastics vs those of other materials, consider the ease or difficulty with which suitable substitutes might be found, consider [u]all[/u] of the costs of switching to substitutes where possible, consider [u]all[/u] of the costs of the loss of those items for which no suitable substitutes are available, consider the total effect on humanity as we now know it, and then return and, with a straight face, tell us that your suggestion is a viable one.

by deepsand

Plastics, unlike combustion byproducts, are eminently recyclable.

Even if simply discard, plastics, unlike exhaust fumes, do no end up in our lungs and the atmosphere.

Courtesy of "[i]Science for Dummies[/i]."

by boxfiddler Hot topic

and I am curious as to why you say this?

"but your own expressed views ...

placing value on an intermediary thing -
whether currency, gold, labor hours, pretty
flowers - is at the root of our human
problems

... are an even broader assertion."

by Member 25348569

but I will still argue the point.

If we do halt production of fossil fuel CO2 completely, the level of atmospheric CO2 will decrease as the oceanic sinks take out the excess. We can't stop that and the only way we can mitigate the reduction in oceanic alkalinity is to set up carbon sinks on land.

The effect of the changes in oceanic pH are really not very well understood, not really manageable by humans and something we will willy-nilly find out.

The effect of using land that we could use for carbon-sink forests to grow plants for biofuels instead does increase the amount of CO2 that we produce compared with what we actively remove from the atmosphere. However, the same applies for crops grown for food which are just biofuels for animals.

The effect of using desert-sited bioreactor farms to grow oil-producing algae is as carbon-neutral as any nuclear reactor or solar mirror array and probably a lot cheaper to build! Certainly, a lot cheaper to decommission than the nuclear option.

Neil :D

Ah, hmm. After being ticked off by Absolutely, I'm running a bit scared now. Can you confirm that this is the point you are disagreeing with? I have a tendency to type whatever comes into my head regardless of whether it's EXACTLY right... :(

by $$$$$$$$$$

"and I am curious as to why you say this?"

Because it's so, yet not so indicated by your own comments. But, this doesn't really answer the question, does it? So, can you re-phrase your question, more precisely?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Ah, hmm. After being ticked off by Absolutely, I'm running a bit scared now.[/i]

Any digs or taunts [recently, anyway, certainly any in this thread, or for that matter with "!" in my alias] at you were intended entirely tongue-in-cheek. Whichever ones amused you less than they did me, I take back.

"I don't have a problem if you disagree but I will still argue the point."

B-)

by $$$$$$$$$$

I think that [b]corn[/b] ethanol's relative inefficiency is the easiest fallacy in Big Petrol's argument to expose & discredit. I humbly request your assistance. I've provided a couple relevant links already in this thread, but another perspective, with the same basic agenda, would be nice. Thanks in advance.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]How does the threat of using up something you would not have us use in the first place pose a problem?[/i]

The choice to use up by burning something [petroleum] which is not renewable, [b]is stupid[/b] because
1. another use of petroleum, plastics, is more important in the same global economy
2. suitable substitutes to petroleum for fuel exist, but suitable substitutes to petroleum for plastics do not.

It's a no-brainer, no-brain.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Why do you say that my own expressed views are an even broader assertion than is 'money is the root of all evil' (as you originally put it)?

I can see why - sort of - my own expressed view appears to be a broader assertion than is 'the love of money is the root of all evil'.

by nicknielsen

And so arrogant.

I don't disagree with your assertions about stupid useless vehicles. The demand for SUVs is artificially increased by both the tax break given businesses and by the exemption from the more stringent automotive CAFE standards. In most cases, SUVs are a waste of space and a blot on the landscape, and people stupid enough to use them purely as day-to-day transport deserve the $100-plus tab at the fuel pump.

To be honest, whenever you post more than a single paragraph, I don't read your posts in depth unless your first paragraph grabs me. The tone of your posts and the fact that you seem unable to write simple declarative sentences without a multitude of convoluted (and, on the surface, contradictory) clauses always reminds me that I have better things to do with my time.

But it sure is fun to pull your chain.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I didn't mean to say that you were making an even broader statement than that, but that your statement was [b]as broad[/b] as the way I first stated it, and broader than the original, complete quote, that "the [i]love[/i] of money is the root of all evil."

So, backing up to where we got out of synch:

[i]The original is that 'the love of money is the root of all evil.'[/i]

I know that, but I used only the latter part of the quote because your own expressed views are better-described without the opening disclaimer. I was pretty much just noting that, because it seems the noteworthy aspect of what you've said: you don't only agree with the original saying in its entirety, your attitude is "yes, but moreso."

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]To be honest, whenever you post more than a single paragraph, I don't read your posts in depth unless your first paragraph grabs me.[/i]

So, just like Tony, you don't know what the hell you're talking about.

[i]The tone of your posts and the fact that you seem unable to write simple declarative sentences without a multitude of convoluted (and, on the surface, contradictory) clauses always reminds me that I have better things to do with my time.[/i]

Critique my writing without reading it, and make sure you claim that what I write is "on the surface, contradictory" while everything you say about me is contradictory to the discussion in this thread. Good dog! Posting such obviously hypocritical garbage saves me a lot of effort in rebuttal. You might not know how out of line you are if you're skimming [b]everybody's[/b] messages, or you might be just a lazy trash-talker who doesn't know anything about anything. We won't know until you get on-topic.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

After awhile this having to respond to a post that isn't the post I'm really responding to gets to me. Thanks for the clarification.

And the conversation! You are one of those who push me to think with more definition than is normally required by my daily routine. Probably why I hang about here...

by nicknielsen

I [u]no longer[/u] read the complete post unless the first paragraph grabs me. I gave it up when finding the primary clause started taking longer than reading the sentence.

The topic in this discussion is the lunacy of consuming food crops to create fuel. I think it goes beyond lunacy to complete idiocy. Stop subsidizing farmers, stop subsidizing oil companies, stop subsidizing ethanol production, stop subsidizing [u]consumption[/u] either directly or through the tax code. Take some of the money saved and fund pure research on alternative energy; put the rest toward the national debt.

Edit: formatting

by $$$$$$$$$$

By the way, how do you expect to have both?

[i]I have better things to do with my time.

But it sure is fun to pull your chain.[/i]

You might have better things to do with your time than read my post, or have nothing better to do than pull my chain, but not both.

by $$$$$$$$$$

But, how to do so without helping you make
your case that I am cantankerous seems more
trouble than it's worth. I'll just thank
you for the compliment, and admit that it
went to my head long ago. The Attitude is
part of The Package.

by nicknielsen

The original topic of this discussion? Just did that.

Plastics? We can't stop using them. They have become so embedded in our everyday lives society would probably tank without them. Best alternative? Recycle, recycle, recycle. In my area, the recycling centers only take #1 and #2 plastics; grocery stores collect plastic bags. No idea how to keep the rest from ending up in landfills except to expand the recycling. Research money would help.

Drilling for oil? Until we find an alternative, we don't have a choice. We need to drill and we need to find new sources. Open the coastal waters, open the ANWR. Enforce the hell out of existing laws to protect the environment at these sites.

Nuclear power plants? Start building. NIMBY? No problem. I'd rather have a nuclear power plant next door than a pig farm; smells a lot better and fewer flies.

Enviro-nutz publicly screaming we need to change while also doing anything and everything they can to obstruct change in any direction but the one they want? Point them out for the hypocrites they are and ridicule them into silence. Make those that want to live the agrarian ?dream? of a century ago do so. Put them out with [u]exactly[/u] the technology of a century ago. Make them grow or gather their own food and slaughter their own meat. Give them century-old medical or dental care, if any. They want clothes, they can grow the flax or cotton, pick, comb, card, spin, weave, and sew or trap, kill and skin. If they need something, they make it or barter for it. Too hot? Sorry, no A/C, find some shade. Too cold? Put another log on the fire. Most of them will come to their senses within weeks; the rest will die young, and good riddance.

Edit: [i]You might have better things to do with your time than read my post, or have nothing better to do than pull my chain, but not both.[/i] Why not? Better things to do with my time can include, but not be limited to, pulling your chain. Anybody seen the ysis? I know where the anal is...

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Enviro-nutz publicly screaming we need
to change while also doing anything and
everything they can to obstruct change in
any direction but the one they want?[/i]

First, you have to propose a specific
course of action. Then, you have to defend
its merits against the merits of competing
proposals. Then, and only then, can your
critique of such discussion be sensible.
So, where do you want a nuclear plant,
exactly, and who has obstructed it? Why?
And why would nuclear plants in general be
better than a sufficient investment in
solar power to satisfy all residential
electric needs, exactly?

by spam.mailbox

We can talk about credit card companies here, but I feel that a new thread should be started to discuss that subject. Here's a tidbit to hold you over, though...

Credit card companies have pretty much all moved their operations to be based in states that have no usuary protection laws for consumers. This is so that they can charge whatever the heck they can squeeze out of the consumer.

Granted, the consumer signs an agreement with the card grantor, but the card companies have a "buyer-beware" attidude because nobody really reads the 10 page-long fine print ("legalese") concerning their cards, do they?. That is why the mortgage industry is hurting right now- because they lent money to borrowers who really shouldn't have been lent the money to begin with.

[url=http://www.bankrate.com/brm/news/cc/20020320a.asp]http://www.bankrate.com/brm/news/cc/20020320a.asp[/url]

I don't have any credit cards, never will have one... I either get a signer loan, credit line, or use my debit card. Credit cards are much too "convenient" and get people in debt fast because quite a few people only pay the minimum monthly payment, which will take years to pay off the principal.

by spam.mailbox

"Re-pube-icans", since none of the "Conservatives" this election cycle have anything hanging underneath their "other" brains...

That's Rush's moniker, by the way. I didn't want to steal his thunder...

Oh, and Abs, that was a great link to that article regarding the Corporate welfare. Long, but very informative...

by spam.mailbox

...when you take the refinery's margin divided by [b][u]their[/u][/b] cost to buy a bbl of oil on the market, the right edge of that chart still only shows a margin of about 11%.

($11.75 margin divided by $102.00 price of a bbl of oil)

P.S.
One small correction they need to post on their chart:

I'm sure that is an unintended mis-labeling of the top of the chart showing "$/gallon" instead of "$/bbl", because their margin on a gallon of gas is obviously not $12...

by $$$$$$$$$$

I hadn't decided whether I'd start one or two threads about predatory credit card practices and Bernanke's immoral bailout of predatory lenders but not of the preyed-upon borrowers. Reading the way you just related the two, I think it will be just one thread, which I promised "week after next" elsewhere in this thread, on a date that gives me just a week to gather material. I plan to post what I have by 8am Eastern next Monday.

by Member 25348569

As far as I read the story, the University are finding it difficult to cope with the feedback from the Prof's outspoken views with the staffing level that they currently have.

The piece states "Colorado State University officials say handling media inquiries related to Gray's forecasting requires too much time and detracts from efforts to promote other professors' work."

Now that's either true or it isn't.

He cries "conspiracy to silence", you cry "conspiracy to silence". If I employed someone who was mouthing off about "brainwashing our children", I'd want to tell him to get his own media answering service as well.

Neil :)

by tonythetiger

is silence all the ones who don't believe what we believe, leaving as a majority those who DO believe as we do. That'll make us right, right?

by Member 25348569

Get a grip on reality - you and Maxwell, both.

Read the article. "Colorado State University officials say handling media inquiries related to Gray's forecasting requires too much time and detracts from efforts to promote other professors' work." Where are they "silencing" him? They have just said that they aren't going to handle his publicity because they don't have the personnel - as is their right.

They aren't stopping him from shooting his mouth off, they just aren't going to help him.

You need to stop and read before you go off on one.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i] It seems that the only right thing to do is silence all the ones who don't believe what we believe, leaving as a majority those who DO believe as we do.[/i]

Will you mind answering as many questions about this claim as you ask about climate change? Will you mind doing all the research yourself, while I contribute nothing but more questions?

by maxwell edison

Well, I do believe that the university has decided to stop providing him the means to be heard. As one of the nation's top forecasters and experts in climatology, the university has, indirectly, provided a forum for his position. Even though that's been a positive for the university over the years, I believe that they'd prefer not to be the university associated with an out-spoken critic of the notion of human-induced global warming - especially considering the fact that Dr. Gray is not some nut-job, but rather a very qualified and formidable expert - a REAL expert.

I believe there's a culture that permeates through our institutions of higher learning, and in this case it's one that advances the notion of human induced global warming and/or climate change. The university would like to believe there's a consensus; that's what the other (non-expert) nut-job professors keep saying; but Dr. Gray - a REAL expert - is proof that a consensus is far from reached.

There are, I'm convinced, plenty of dissenters in the scientific community. However, if they speak-out, they'll be shunned by their colleagues, denied promotions or the good positions, denied funding for their pet projects, and so on. In Dr. Gray's case, if he was an outspoken advocate of human-caused global warming, and he had such exposure as one of the country's foremost climate forecasters, there's no way in hell the University would stop supporting that media connection.

And you have to understand, this is Colorado State University - the proverbial red-headed step child who, as a state university (both on the national level and within the state of Colorado itself), has lived in the large shadow of the state's darling, the University of Colorado in Boulder - the People's Republic of Boulder as it's often referred. Colorado State is being put in the spotlight by Dr. Gray's outspoken stance against the notion of human-induced global warming. Spotlights are good for universities, aren't they? However, in their eyes, and in their culture, it makes them embarrassed; it's not the spotlight they want.

Out here in know-nothing land, we have the pundits on the local evening news advancing everything green - Earth Day this, Global Warming that, Climate Change is all around, and on it goes. In elementary Schools it's ridiculous - kids ARE being brainwashed! Politicians who don't know the first thing about such things are advancing the notion only to advance their own self-serving desire for power, position, and control. Businesses are jumping on the band wagon to sell, so-called, green products. And then all around us we have people like you, deepsand, and Neil, who all claim to know the science, when in fact you couldn't carry water compared to Dr. Gray's expertise.

Like I've asked before. What makes you right and Dr. Gray wrong? I'm sure your answer will border on a lame attempt to discredit him. Colorado State's answer is to do what they can to keep him from being heard in the first place.

To answer your question: You're darn right I believe they're really doing it to silence Dr. Gray. But what does it matter? People like you won't listen to him anyway.

Relevent links:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=261291&messageID=2481152

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=261291&messageID=2481459

(By the way, are you the original Absolutely, or are you a different person who assumed a similar alias after the original was asked to leave TR?)

by jdclyde

is we regularly see the same colleges stand firmly behind liberal professors for as long as they can. Ward Churchil was one such nutter.

Even after finding he has plagerized his research, they had to decide if they would terminate his employment with them.

Even after finding he lied about his Indian (native american) heritiage to GET the job, they had to decide if they would terminate his employment with them.

Fraud on his resume is NOT grounds for dismissal?

There is a very different way that you get treated, and we are close enough to see it. Based on JUST the one story, I could see your point.

The following report came only after nationwide outcry over this bastard.

http://www.colorado.edu/news/reports/churchill/report.html
[i]
Professor Churchill has outraged the Colorado and national communities as a result of profoundly offensive, abusive, and misguided statements relating to the victims of the horrific 9/11 terrorist attacks on America.

As repugnant as his statements are to many in the University community, however, they are protected by the First Amendment.

Allegations have been made that Professor Churchill has engaged in research misconduct; specifically, that he has engaged in plagiarism, misuse of others' work, falsification and fabrication of authority.

These allegations have sufficient merit to warrant referral to the University of Colorado at Boulder Standing Committee on Research Misconduct for further inquiry in accordance with prescribed procedures. The research misconduct procedures afford Professor Churchill an opportunity to review and to respond to the allegations before any determination is made. If the Committee determines that Professor Churchill engaged in research misconduct, the Committee is to make recommendations regarding dismissal or other disciplinary action.

Also referred to the Committee is the question of whether Churchill committed research misconduct by misrepresenting himself to be American Indian to gain credibility, authority, and an audience by using an Indian voice for his scholarly writings and speeches.

Other issues brought to the attention of the reviewers, such as teaching misconduct, were not found to warrant action.

by Member 25348569

as I don't know what colleges in the US are "Liberal", which aren't (what IS the opposite?) and which are "Mouth-Frothing Christian Fundamentalist" or really even what "Liberal" means in relation to a University.

In this case, Maxwell posted a link and a conclusion. I reached a different conclusion [b]from the link[/b]. TonyTheTiger reached a conclusion of conspiracy theory standards by whatever means - some form of drugs, I have to assume.

You are posting about someone of whom I have never heard (now I have, I'd have shot the git) and I don't know if this conduct is typical. "Two swallows doth not a Summer make" so I don't really have much more to say.

So I'll stop.

:D

by jdclyde

to show the WHY. This is very common of how the anti-war, anti-republican, anti-government, anti-industry, anti-anti..... are treated, by being greeted with open arms, while if you don't fall into the anti crowd, you are on your own.

There have been Conservative speakers that have been allowed to be attacked by protesters (yes, physically attacked) while security stood by.

THEIR right to free speech is not important, because it doesn't fall in line with the liberal agenda in the US.

No, I don't have time to link to this. ThingOne has a track meet, so I am out of here! yeah, leaving early so I can get there, but gotta have your priorites, ya know?

by tonythetiger

there's this overwhelming compulsion to let (or force) the tail wag the dog. I am not a slave to technology, nor to science. I may [b]use[/b] these tools to help me decide something or I may not; but ultimately, I make my own decisions. Those who wish to use their tools to force a different decision might want to keep Newton's Laws of Motion in mind (especially the third one) :)

by tonythetiger

[i]What's the basis of that assumption?[/i]

God told me.

[i]Will you mind answering as many questions about this claim as you ask about climate change?[/i]

No.

[i]Will you mind doing all the research yourself, while I contribute nothing but more questions?[/i]

Yes. I'm farming all the research out to God. I'll post to you all of His replies.

[added: There may be an occasional delay, because sometimes He speaks to me in a language I do not understand. In those cases I will use a translating service.]

by Member 25348569

that as an "IT person", I am a slave to technology or science - whatever that actually means. Maybe I am! I've not always been an IT person, I have spent more than half of my working life as a non-IT person, as one of the scientists that you seem willing to vilify separately and as a group.

I also make my own decisions based on the available evidence. I firmly believe that I have assessed more of that evidence and for a longer period than you although I can't prove it - and don't really care to, anyway.

Suffice to say that I find mildly offensive your "holier than me" attitude. Especially given that you've not to my knowledge posted a single scientific fact in any of the Climate threads.

:)

Newton? Hmm, a scientist wasn't he?

"For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction" is a law of Physics, isn't it? What's it got to do with anything here? Personally, for those who just want things to go on as they are, the first Law is much more appropriate.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i] I've noticed that, particularly among IT people there's this overwhelming compulsion to let (or force) the tail wag the dog. I am not a slave to technology, nor to science.[/i]

Nobody is a slave to science. Science is a method, and you have shown no aptitude in its use. Your complaints are meaningless as long as that continues to be the case.

[i]I may use these tools to help me decide something or I may not; but ultimately, I make my own decisions.[/i]

That is not what you said earlier.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2482256
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2486604

[i]Those who wish to use their tools [b]to force[/b] a different decision might want to keep Newton's Laws of Motion in mind (especially the third one)[/i]

Nobody here is trying to force you to believe anything. I just don't silently endure your attempts to obfuscate matters, nor your expectations of being respected after earning contempt.

by tonythetiger

[i]Suffice to say that I find mildly offensive your "holier than me" attitude.[/i]

to some extent or other, though few of us will admit to it. Call it a survival instinct.

[i]Especially given that you've not to my knowledge posted a single scientific fact in any of the Climate threads.[/i]

Do you honestly expect me to be beholden to incomplete information?

by Member 25348569

Again, what I expect from you is exactly what I get. Nothing of substance, just carping one-liners with no evidence to back anything up.

As for "Call it a survival instinct." Call WHAT a survival instinct?

by tonythetiger

[i]Call WHAT a survival instinct?[/i]

The "holier than thou" attitude. If I think something "helps you but hurts me", I'm going to naturally be against it. Imagine we're in a boat in the ocean, and it disintegrates. There is one life preserver. I state here and now that I would try to take it from you.

by tonythetiger

[i]Looks more like suggesting or inciting violence against people who disagree[/i]

and only in the amount necessary to cancel the force (subject to an upper limit of availability, of course).

Oh, I forgot. I'm not talking to you.

by cactus pete

I think it was clear what you meant by elitism, and who you felt were the elitists.

I thought it was clear I was challenging who were the more elite.

by maxwell edison

Why do people exaggerate and/or misrepresent another's position? We both know the answer. Please don't exaggerate and/or misrepresent what I said.

Part of my reply to you lies within this message:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2487178

Like I said, if Dr. Gray was an outspoken advocate of the notion of human-(whatever) Global Warming - or in other words, a Global Warming Alarmist - there's no way in hell the university would stop supporting that media connection. He PROVES there is no consensus, and he's at an institution with a large population of other professors who are claiming that very thing.

And like I said, there's not a university in the whole country that would not embrace such media attention - unless, of course, it's not the kind of attention they want.

Duke University wins yet another national championship = good media attention, and the university will do everything it can to embrace it.

Duke University ruins the lives of its students by throwing them under the bus of false accusation = bad media attention, and the university will do everything it can to squelch it.

Colorado State University Professor challenges the notion of human-(whatever) Global Warming = bad media attention............

I think it's the Global Warming Alarmists, and especially those sheep who blindly follow them, who need to get a grip on reality.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Hypocrite!

[i]Why do people exaggerate and/or misrepresent another's position? We both know the answer. Please don't exaggerate and/or misrepresent what I said.
...
I think it's the Global Warming Alarmists, and especially those sheep who blindly follow them, who need to get a grip on reality.[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2487345

[i]Out here in know-nothing land, we have the pundits on the local evening news advancing everything green - Earth Day this, Global Warming that, Climate Change is all around, and on it goes. In elementary Schools it's ridiculous - kids ARE being brainwashed! Politicians who don't know the first thing about such things are advancing the notion only to advance their own self-serving desire for power, position, and control.[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2487178

If "a politician says so" is good enough to brainwash [b]your[/b] kids, it's because you have taught them not to think for themselves and to always submit to authority without question. Your frequent attempts to debate by appeal to authority in fact suggest this is so.

by $$$$$$$$$$

That is at least a factor, if not the whole story:

[i]There also seems to be little question that prominent climate scientists have complained to CSU about Gray, who has become more involved in the global warming debate. His comments toward adversaries often have been biting.

In 2005, when Georgia Tech scientist Peter Webster co-authored a paper suggesting global warming had caused a spike in major hurricanes, for instance, Gray labeled him and others "medicine men" who were misleading the public.[/i]
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/5736103.html

By the way, the way you rephrased I'd almost agree "that the university has decided to stop providing him the means to be heard." Just because anyone who fires any employee can be said to no longer provide them the means to do anything. But, Dr. Gray can still publish his opinions in retirement the same way you and I are publishing ours. Will he?

[i]Colorado State is being put in the spotlight by Dr. Gray's outspoken stance against the notion of human-induced global warming. Spotlights are good for universities, aren't they? However, in their eyes, and in their culture, it makes them embarrassed; it's not the spotlight they want.[/i]

That's certainly possible; whether one phrases his termination as caused by his bad manners or his non-conformity or non-compliance to institutional hegemony, I know people have been fired for less. If Dr. Gray is right, I'd be very interested to know. I'd stop using public transit, and be very happy about it.

[i]To answer your question: You're darn right I believe they're really doing it to silence Dr. Gray. But what does it matter? People like you won't listen to him anyway.[/i]

As a matter of [b]fact[/b] I've downloaded a 28-page .pdf containing his predictions of Atlantic hurricane activity for 2008. Unfortunately, although that is his primary responsibility to the University and I'd enjoy reviewing his predictions from previous years and comparing to NOAA records, that isn't the reason he's being dismissed. His claims about global warming are the primary subject of disagreement, and so far I haven't located any of his claims on that, backed up by anything but his bluster. In his profession,

data = evidence

[i]And then all around us we have people like you, deepsand, and Neil, who all claim to know the science, when in fact you couldn't carry water compared to Dr. Gray's expertise.[/i]

Them's strong words, pardner. Ready to back 'em up yet?

[i]To answer your question: You're darn right I believe they're really doing it to silence Dr. Gray. But what does it matter? People like you won't listen to him anyway.[/i]

That there is absolutely false. I haven't seen data and reasoning from him to back up his claims. On the other hand, I can pick up a copy of [i]Nature[/i] at random, and as often as not, find an article either confirming a prediction of anthropogenic climate destabilization, or revising a part of it. The necessary revisions, from my reading, are minor compared to the consistency of the predictions to results. For example, I see no rebuttal when I point out that comparing subsequent temperatures to 1998 is cherry-picking, because 1998 was the hottest year on record. But global warming naysayers keep trying to pull that, I suppose because often enough they're not called on it, that they can continue to appeal to a vocal minority, including yourself.

[i]By the way, are you the original Absolutely[/i]

It's still me, only more so.

[i]Like I've asked before. What makes you right and Dr. Gray wrong? I'm sure your answer will border on a lame attempt to discredit him.[/i]

What a gem. I'm tempted to make up some deviant sexual preferences just to help you save face, but I'm not that generous. You've declined previously to debate the science of global warming. What about Dr. Gray's criticisms of global warming, only? Would you be willing to defend Gray's claim that "Hansen?s alarmism is exaggerated because the models he uses to predict the increase in global warming count on too much water vapor in the atmosphere"?
http://www.businessandmedia.org/printer/2008/20080304113132.aspx

If you can't even do that, you really have no place comparing Neil's scientific talent or mine to Dr. Gray's. If you can't defend the merits of Dr. Gray's work, you can't claim to be qualified to judge the merits of his work, nor compare that to others.

by maxwell edison

I simply won?t engage a hostile person (with this one exception).

Moreover, as far as debating the science, as you (and deepsand) have both invited, that?s a silly thing to suggest. I?m not a qualified scientist; you?re not a qualified scientist; I assume deepsand is not a qualified scientist (even though he presents himself as a qualified expert on all things); and our audience is not populated by anyone who could discern fact from fiction.

Edit:

That was a terrible choice of words, but I'll leave it so everything that follows makes sense, and out of respect to those who've already read it.

I should have said:

I?m not a qualified scientist; you?re not a qualified scientist; I assume deepsand is not a qualified scientist (even though he presents himself as a qualified expert on all things); and no one in our audience is a qualified scientist, at least not that I know of

End of edit.

As such, it?s just not possible to debate the science in any meaningful way. And the fact that normal people out here in know-nothing land cannot debate the science is precisely my point ? they?re expected to blindly follow like brainwashed sheep, which most of them are doing.

I find it shockingly sad that most people just won?t admit that, in reality, they know absolutely nothing about the science behind the claim of human-(whatever) global warming. They can?t possibly form a meaningful scientific conclusion. Instead, whether they admit it or not, they?ve simply decided who to believe.

That angle of the issue is what we (out here in know-nothing land) should really be debating - the merits of deciding who to believe and why. That?s an offer I?ve extended, but it?s you and deepsand who refuse.

Besides, like I said, you?re just too hostile.

Edit: Admitting you?re not an expert on something isn?t so bad. But trying to pass yourself off as one?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Fact: maxwell edison is not a qualified scientist;

Fiction: "you?re" not a qualified scientist; I assume deepsand is not a qualified scientist

As such, it?s just not possible to debate the science in any meaningful way. And the fact that normal people out here in know-nothing land cannot debate the science is precisely my point ? they?re expected to blindly follow like brainwashed sheep, which most of them are doing.

I find it shockingly sad that most people just won?t admit that, in reality, they know absolutely nothing about the science behind the claim of human-(whatever) global warming. They can?t possibly form a meaningful scientific conclusion. Instead, whether they admit it or not, they?ve simply decided who to believe.

[i]That angle of the issue is what we (out here in know-nothing land) should really be debating - the merits of deciding who to believe and why. That?s an offer I?ve extended, but it?s you and deepsand who refuse.[/i]

Oh, we've been doing that, all along.

[i]and our audience is not populated by anyone who could discern fact from fiction.[/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2488380

It appears to be working about as predicted, by the "human dignity" school of psychology.

by $$$$$$$$$$

... and some other relevant statistical approaches to validation of assertions, via data analysis.

[i]I find it shockingly sad that most people just won?t admit that, in reality, they know absolutely nothing about the science behind the claim of human-(whatever) global warming. They can?t possibly form a meaningful scientific conclusion.[/i]

It would be interesting to watch you attempt to quantify your assertions of others' ignorance. You're trying to begin a conversation on a leap of faith.

[i]Instead, whether they admit it or not, they?ve simply decided who to believe.[/i]

That is an unprovable, unfalsifiable assertion; it's logically and scientifically invalid.

by Member 25348569

and it's SUCH a big 'but' and there's a few of them as well.

Gray's particular field of expertise is hurricane prediction and he's very good at it, no doubt, although we don't have hurricanes over here so we've never actually heard of him. The background to his meteorological specialism gives him, possibly (you would say probably), some significant advantages when assessing the work of those whose particular specialist areas are climatological rather than meteorological.

The two subjects, although both being branches of atmospheric science, are quite different, meteorology being concerned with short-term weather systems and climatology dealing with patterns over decades and longer.

"But since you brought it up, who?s more qualified to have a more expert opinion on human-(whatever) global warming and/or climate change? You or Dr. William Gray?" is not really the question.

The question is who should I believe, Dr. William Gray or these guys?

http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/myths/index.html

No contest!

:D

Oh, and UKMET does hurricane predictions, too, for our Caribbean chums.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Not too much hostility.

You're just lying, and I'm not cooperating.

Global warming denial is political, not global warming
research. You claim scientific research into climate is
corrupt, based only on exaggerations of what Al Gore and
the mainstream media say. I've been far more patient
than your cynical lies deserve. For that, I apologize to any
honest people reading.

Bite me, max.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Only in defense and only in the amount necessary to cancel the force (subject to an upper limit of availability, of course).[/i]

Nobody here has used or threatened force against you. You brought it up, falsely portraying yourself as victim, when you implied the use of force by citing Newton's Third Law, for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.

An equal and opposite reaction to being called on your utter ignorance of the subjects on which you so eagerly opine would be to inform yourself. Don't bring up "force" against me again. Threats of force are not protected by the First Amendment, and will be prosecuted.

[i]Oh, I forgot. I'm not talking to you.[/i]

That would be best.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Elitism (noun): The belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect, social status, or financial resources.[/i]

1. Who perceives environmentalists as superior?

2. Are they perceived as superior in one or more of those three categories? Which one(s)? What is the basis of that perception?

3. By refusing to debate the science, do you believe you are effectively refuting or validating the perception of the superiority in the first of those three qualities?

intellect
social status
financial resources

by tonythetiger

but perhaps I slightly overestimated your comprehension skills.

If you think I was threatening YOU over some meaningless words, I maybe could look up a therapist in the phone book for you, because you have a paranoia complex.

The "force" I was referring to that will be reacted against was that that will be brought to bear on ALL of us to get us to comply with the left-inspired policies relating to the climate change hoax. Now, you can kiss their asses for a bite to eat or a place to lay your head or for permission to keep a couple of your rights from being trampled on if you like, but I will not.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Global warming is not a scam.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/04/080402100001.htm

maxwell's 3-part def'n of the "perceiveed superiority" of environmentalists
Elitism (noun): The belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect, social status, or financial resources.

1. Who perceives environmentalists as superior?

2. Are they perceived as superior in one or more of those three categories? Which one(s)? What is the basis of that perception?

3. By refusing to debate the science, do you believe you are effectively refuting or validating the perception of the superiority in the first of those three qualities?

intellect
social status
financial resources
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2487480

by maxwell edison

How about this:

I?m not a qualified scientist; you?re not a qualified scientist; I assume deepsand is not a qualified scientist (even though he presents himself as a qualified expert on all things); and no one in our audience is a qualified scientist, at least not that I know of.

It was actually a poor choice of words for either side of the argument. As such, I?ll leave my original comment because I deserved the slap you just gave me.

by Member 25348569

Not, admittedly, a climatologist but a "qualified scientist" for many years. Whatever you think that means, I think it makes me quite good at assessing research data and the conclusions drawn from it.

:D

by jamesrl

including statistical methods. I used that knowledge working for a polling firm.

I also studied Macro and Micro economics.

So I have a fair familiarity with scientific method and proof using statistics.

Notice I haven't weighed in on either side, at least in any significant way. I need some time to do the reading.

I have read enough to think we are going through climate change. I think there is a strong possibility that humans have done something which may have impacted that change. There is a difference between causing the change, and being an agent to accelerating the change, or just being coincident to the change.

I am aware that there is a great body of information out there, as well as a body of hype(on both sides of the argument).

Of course even if we scientifically prove that climate change is not man made or impacted, that doesn't mean we don't have to deal with it.

Pollution is an issue even without climate change. And oil will not last forever. Oil was created over millions of years, and we aren't "making" any new oil, just pumping old stuff out of the ground, it has to end sometime.

James

by maxwell edison

Believe it or not, I thought about you when I made that comment. You were a biochemist, weren't you?

The ones most qualified to study and draw subsequent conclusions would be those scientists who have an educational background, internships, positions, and years of experience studying the atmospheric and astronomical (the Sun) sciences. I have no doubt that your mind is trained in the sciences more than others, but it?s simply not your specialty.

Just because a structural engineer may be qualified to determine stress loads on a bridge, and there may be a common basis in early engineering study, but it doesn?t mean that he (or she) would know very much in the area of aeronautical engineering and building a spacecraft that could travel to Mars. Both are engineers, but their specialties are quite different.

Your science background probably used a microscope in your field of expertise. Study of the Earth, the Sun, the atmosphere, and weather patterns require viewing on a scale a bit larger than a microscope.

But since you brought it up, who?s more qualified to have a more expert opinion on human-(whatever) global warming and/or climate change? You or Dr. William Gray?

by maxwell edison

.....I might suggest that you are extremely qualified (especially considering your additional life?s experience) to comment on the real movement behind the claim of human-(whatever) Global Warming!

I've maintained all along, it's a political issue, not a scientific issue.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I haven't seen any data supporting his claims. I found one video that showed him celebrating a small correction to somebody else's model, in a convention of global warming naysayers of some sort. Crap, we're such a bunch of collectivists in this country, we band together over the most inane things. Doesn't anybody want to just know the truth of the matter?

by tonythetiger

[i]I've maintained all along, it's a political issue, not a scientific issue.[/i]

We can know it to a (infinitely small amount less than 100%) certainty. We can even say it. But for them to actually admit it would be political suicide.... this is the basket they've put all their chips in. If they lost it, they (and those who aligned with them) would stop having those orgasms they get whenever they force someone to submit to their will.

[edit: fixed sentence]

by $$$$$$$$$$

That is libel.

[i]We can know it to a (infinitely small amount less than
100%) certainty. We can even say it. But for them to
actually admit it would be political suicide.... this is the
basket they've put all their chips in. If they lost it, they
(and those who aligned with them) would stop having
those orgasms they get whenever they force someone to
submit to their will.[/i]

by $$$$$$$$$$

You can bet I will.

If I thought your opinion of my qualifications was important, you'd have been summoned to appear in court already.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

that 'arbitrary, unaccountable power' maintains itself via money and a variety of other desirable commodities.

Alongside an uninformed and needful populace.

etu

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]How does 'arbitrary, unaccountable power' maintain itself?[/i]

Arbitrarily.

Rotten people will misuse whatever tool(s) they have. I just don't believe that money itself is a problem, nor the root of systemic problems. I'm still looking for more information, especially on specific corporate laws, but I strongly suspect that the current body of statute protects offending individuals from prosecution for "corporate" actions, and vice-versa. The collapse of Enron suggests that nobody is held fully responsible for the total sum defrauded from Californians.

by tonythetiger

In order to claim to be an aggrieved party, one would have to admit to being "one of them who..." which would make the statement true... therefore no libel was committed. Qualifications aren't relevant. Same game, different pieces.

by tonythetiger

There's no way around it. Who pays, for example, when a company loses a lawsuit? It's just another cost of business that is added into the cost of the product or service, so the consumer always pays.

We might as well immunize companies from lawsuits and instead increase the criminal penalties for the [b]individual[/b] wrongdoings of company officials. The lower prices will likely more than make up for the cost of incarcerations.