Discussion Locked

Is IT degenerating into a field where idiots rule?

0 helpful
329 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

329 replies

by joetechsupport

Your reply, I believe, mirrors my thoughts exactly. Allow me to expand on why they left:

IT before it got that name was a lab where things were designed to current and future needs and maintained. This environment attracts bright and creative minds.

IT has degenerated into just another corporate department where the goal is to keep your boss happy at best, screw thy neighbour at worst and your function is an intrusion into office politics. This environment attracts tedious dullards.

Not all professional managers and companies operate so, but the fact that most do puts everyone on an even keel and that is why nobody disintegrates from incompetence since it is the status quo.

What self-respecting intelligent person will work where the ability to think for ones' self is viewed as dangerous and career-limiting?

The smart fish swam away to other oceans. The benthos remains. They're schooling organisms, I mean team players after all.

by dean

I agree with what you are saying but I cannot agree that NZQA is a valid qualification. I am a self taught techie. And I consider mself to be as good as someone with a degree. I am just a young guy with 2 years Active director, Linux, MS Server 2k3. And a small amount of novell know how. But NZQA is a laugh. I think the only way to learn computers is to do computers. Not study NZQA papers..

by jacktel

Idiots rule? You got that right! Of idiots, by idiots, and for idiots and it ain't just in IT. I haven't read all the posts but I've read enough of them to get a good idea. ApolloCDR said it good, that most management thinks this stuff is all magic and it just "works" and that "anybody can do it". We are a service company and I can't even tell you how many times I have heard "so and so's high school kid can do this" or "I have a degree in computer science and I know a lot about computers" from people that think that anybody that can install a modem or MS Office can setup and run a network. We see this every day, we fight it every day and I for one am about at the point that I'd just say to hell with it and let them all fend for themselves but the sad thing is they are all connected to the internet and what they do effects us all in one way or another. The sad fact is that most of them want something for nothing, real life doesn't work that way, it never has, you get what you pay for (sometimes). If you want to go out and hire know nothings with half the alphabet after their name well then that is what you get and when your e-mail doesn't work, you just lost all your company files, and half the world is using your server to operate their porn site from well that's what you deserve. And you know the worst thing about the above worst case scenario? The "victim" will defend their "expert" to the death no matter how many ways you show them what they did was not only wrong but completely incompetent!! Are our company's engineers and technicians experts? No, and we don't claim to be!! Are we good at what we do? Damn right! Anybody that claims to be an expert makes me suspicious right off the bat because I know better than that, ain't nobody an expert at this stuff and anybody that says they are is lying and the more letters in the alphabet they have after their name makes me that much more suspicious of their competence.

Jackie McCracken
President and CEO
JackTel, Inc.

by deesy58

I teach IT at a major private university, and I can tell you that the students are not being taught the foundational skills needed for successful performance within the IT professions. Some students want to learn, but the curriculum is so bad that they can't learn. Some students just want a degree, and don't care how they get it. Most of them wind up employed in the IT field, many as "idiot" managers. We should no longer be surprised at the inanity we see all around us.

by jacktel

Boy did you hit the nail on the head!!! We've been trying to hire a tech for the past three months and had just about given up until one just "fell in our lap" about a week ago. I can not tell you how many "degreed" types we talked to that didn't know anything and I do mean anything, basic things like what DNS or DHCP are much less the purpose of them and then to find somebody that knew what a Windows Server looked like or what Group Policy is...

The schools need to start teaching the basics, that we can work with. I know from experience that the schools can't teach you everything and a lot of training is still required and I accept that because every real life situation is different but a good foundation in the basics would be extremely helpful from our perspective.

Jackie McCracken
President and CEO
JackTel, Inc.

by sheldonmoss

I totally agree with your comment. I am in that situation right now, and to add to that my boss is steady loading my plate with stuff he wants me to learn, remind you I am also the only consultant in the field going to different client sites meaning different networks and user habits that I have to take into consideration. This is really burning me out. I think it is because management do not see us running around like chickens with our heads cut off, so they don't think that we are doing anything but costing them money; however, if most administrators that I know of including myself was to stop keeping up with their companies network and technology it would cost these companies would have to pay much more than they are paying now, trust me I have seen it happen.

by sheldonmoss

Well said - it is hard enough to stay on top of technology than to try to explain it to someone that can care less anyway.

by aidplus

With profit being king, the cheaper the better. Rockets are built to standards, and the lowest price. Software has kickbacks and profit margins to preserve. Corperations dont care as long as they make a Dollar. Gues what, we have the ISO standard. If the software does not adhere to these standards its only management to blame. (If you can make it stick)

by surflover

exactly

this post is a response to JDmercha on "here's how it cheaper"

...for some reason, my replys are not attaching to the thread where I respond, theyre all going to the root of the discussion... this just started about an hour ago...

by rtracy7

Back in 1997 I watched a "new IT manager" destroy an R&D organization. He was from the parent company that had just purchased our R&D outfit. He told all the scienists and engineers that the VAX 8800 and FPS 164 were too expensive to maintain and that they would be replaced with networked IBM PCs.

Well all new work or research came to a dead halt while everyone re-wrote Fortran and C code that would run on the new array.... After a year, while most codes were still being de-bugged - the IT manager pulled the plug on the big-iron. The result was a total distaster, we lost contracts right and left as "trusted outputs" no longer were there, manufacturing was making products that could not meet spec because of math or logic errors still in the material properties specification and design optiumizing routines. It was all downhill from there as management backed him up.... saying this was the wave of the future and we were going to be on it..... right.... the company ended up very downsized and moved out of state. So, in this case both the IT manager and upper management.... all got themselves "laid-off" as the company downsided as the parent company replaced almost all of them as a result. Now that takes a real set of idiots, to do that to yourself. But, hey, he played Golf with the rest of the Upper Hallway Guys.... So, his opinion carried the most weight..... right!

by rpepper

I'm an old codger from the States, but I still remember the old rule of thumb for IT back in the 60's and 70's, "No one every got fired for buying IBM". In other words, many IT people are so afraid of their upper management, that they will go with the big boy on the block or whoever upper management thinks is best, no matter what they really believe or know to be true.

by bpedler

Having a degree in anything is not necessarily a precursor to having extensive knowledge in a subject. In fact look at engineers. Not many have an ounce of nous when it comes to making real world decisions. Lack of common sense is a big issue in any field but IT in particular. Any network not running LAN monitoring software is open to invasion and misuse but i have to ask.
Why the hell haven't we written a virus to take out other viruses???
Why the hell haven't we written code to take down porn sites???
Not all of the IT world believes in Open Source either. Linux is NOT the be all and end all some would have us believe.

by cpetrosky

Idiots come with lots of variations:
Salespeople who sell products and services they don't have the capacity to understand to your management who doesn't understand either..... Also, there are other dynamics at work which make the "best" result subject to interpretation, i.e. a best result might be: "it uses hardware and software we understand", or "we're buying the solution from a friend of mine", or, your I.T. managment having "religion" about what a best solution results from. (for example, who the hell would choose Siebel over ANY other database solution, including flat file). See what I mean? If you aren't prepared to bite it and play along, then you need to look for another sandbox.
You'll sleep better when you do, and you can be someone else's idiot. "-)

by jasoncctc

they made too much money and didn't really contribute to the short-term bottom line anyway.

*sarcasm off*

by cobaltlake

This sounds so familiar... like eating my lunch after throwing it up several times. Sorry for being so crude; but after 17 years in the IT business and working in many different countries, in many different environments --> from the Director of IT all the way down to the lowliest BOFH graveyard shift tech, I have experienced numerous examples of vendors and sales persons outright LYING to management of the company I was employed at about the service or software of that particular salesperson?s intent to sell us, hyping my bosses up with all that flashy sales pitch crap, or offering amazing pricing on T-1?s, only to find out that you cant use the product between the hours of? and try calling customer service about it to complain? HA! RTFM (and the fine print of the LSA?)

?IT? seems as though a person?s (or companies) word these days can be bought and sold like a used car. After the sale? all is forgotten. What ever happened to the days when a man?s (or woman?s for that matter!) word was his or her reputation and was the foundation upon which was built business relationships and a successful enterprise? Is it really all about the $$$? After successfully building a thriving consulting business (working 20 hours a day) where if I gave my word, the customer could be damn sure that they would be delivered what I promised ? OR I WOULD NOT ACCEPT PAYMENT!

I recently accepted a position at a non-profit org so I would have time for a family, and am definitely seeing the business from a different light, not to mention a different stress level! Sure the money is not enough to pay for the new baby?s doctor?s bills, but I can still rest easy to know that I am not working for a company that is screwing anyone over and I still get to sharpen my vendor accountability skills, not to mention my fine-print mumbo-jumbo legal ease translations! Remember, you have the option, no you have the RIGHT to decent business practices ESPECIALLY as the client. Do your homework first, ask too many questions, go ahead? piss people off if you have to! YOU ARE THE CUSTOMER! Don?t get mad. Get even! The answer you seek might very well be right there in the small print.

VENT | dev\null

Wow, that felt good.

by andrew_ockrim

Like a lot of other techies I have moved away from front line IT in Australia due to the exact same reasons as the rest of this post.

I can report a few of my TOP IT Guys are now doing the following: Coffee Shop owners, Strata Management, Trainers, Gardening buisness, Mobile Phone retailers, etc.

It seems that some of the best and brightest (I know) are sick of getting zero respect, long hours, no thanks for a decade plus of expert industry knowledge and having to compete with freash foreign candidates willing to work for peanuts.

The work ethic and pride has gone from IT - Particularly in Australia. The value of quality emnployees has degraded to the point that the most valuable staff I used to have working for me are now no longer in IT. One guy who was one of the hottest developers i had ever seen is now more than happy running a small removals business and earning more money shifting refrigerators than he was competing with the offshores for development contracts.

Its a sad state and i cant see the brain drain subsiding....

by rain city bob

But why does everyone who has read the "Chip Chat" section of the sunday paper think they have the answers and are more than willing to try and trump the IT guy at the next meeting?

(In another life) a director of a major manufacturing company told me I didn't have to explain a complex financial model as he had taken the four-hour course "Finance for Non-Financial Managers." My MBA in Finance was worthless against his four hour course. The issue came up as he had just totally misinterpreted what the numbers meant.

(In yet another life) I was a US Navy pilot; I often took an F-4 Phantom to civilian airshows for static display. Many citizens at these shows would tell me why the plane really couldn't fly (it held almost every world record for performance at the time), how it was mis-designed, etc. Seems only the 10 to 12 year-old boys knew anything, and were certainly more fun to talk to than a 50 year-old taxpayer with 32 hours of flight lessons.

(And waaaay back) in a frosh chem course, a bunch of students argued with the prof (PhD) that electrons orbit the nucleus of their atom and that even AEC logo clearly showed orbiting electrons. QED.

So, I guess I would say it happens in other professions. It's part of the intelligent design, I guess.

Be polite to the fools; encourage the kids.

by too old for it

We had the Phantom II in the Marines. It wasn't so much that it wouldn't fly (it flew extremely well).

It just wouldn't glide. Everyone from the CO of the Marine Air Wing to the GSE tech knew that when the lights went out, you got outta the way.

by nzbn

I have never claimed to know it all nor will I ever put claim to that,
What I will say is what do you think you have to have to get a tech job at microsoft or ibm? It sure as hang aint MCSE no matter how much experience you have. Every successful large company has used people with degrees to get them ahead.

A degree is far more than a foot in the door it teaches you far more than just experience or experience + MCSE, People with MCSE know about the features that some of microsofts products offer, people with a degree can evaluate each vendor on thier merits and fitness to the organisation and provide a workable solution that is both cost-effective and non biased because this forms a part of thier extensive training.

I started mine with 30 people and there are only 3 left I dont know anyone who has failed MCSE! I'm not saying hire them just because they have a degree because there are other qualities that must be included in the package as well.

by mr_dobby

Sorry, still don,t agree.

I have a BSc in computing, I have an mcse, ccna,cna & security+. I have benefitted from all of them. With regard to my degree, although I learned many fundamental items, I have still learned far more from my work experience (with regards to getting the job done).

I would recommend to anyone that a degree is definately worth completing and is more important than certification. It is however still only a starting point (as are many certifications). Without on the job work experience one is definatley not qualified to manage a network (and any company who hires a graduate without experience to run their network is asking for trouble in my opinion).

With regards to an mcse not being a real qualification. Your assumption is based on what? Your bad experience with certain mcse qualified technicians I presume? I agree that many mcse's are not worth the paper they are written on, there are however very many who are good! Furthermore, i have seen many job positions in NZ where the employers are looking for an mcse. And if the mcse is that easy (without all the cheatsheets, etc) then have a go. You will find the exams actually are very difficult if you don,t cheat your way through them.

by dashx

Actually, I work for one of these companies so to answer your question, NOT a degree. From what I have observed, apptitude and passion for technology will serve you much better than a degree in IT/CS. In fact, when I first started (less than ten years ago)I had neither degree nor cert and I did just fine. Having seen other people both with and without degrees come in the door, I have found that there is very rarly much to choose between the two (so long as the person without the degree WANTS to learn). If a person demonstrates reliability, commitment, apptitude and a passion for technology, it's not that hard to get alot of employers to pay for your education while you gain valueable experience.

by kp58

Why should we have to market our selves?
MS tell us the simplest way to solve the problem is their network software but the cost and infrastructure make life hell for techs and the budget.
Why? So we go out and buy more Intel Products which are "tailored" (Used to be) to MS software. So now we have to spend $1000's to maintain our competences so we have to attend MS approved training centres to comply with their standards which they changed to ensure more sales and more profits and to make sure the sales statistics make them look good.
Why? So the Decision Makers are blind sided by MARKETING.

WHY CAN?T THE FACTS SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES

I have done the research to tailor systems and their 3-5yr development plans for a number of organisations in SE QLD Aust. The majority took the cheapest option whether mine or not and the rest bought the medias hype at a cost of 3-5 times my most expensive recommendation for the level of implementation they chose, because their IT staff knew they would not have to extend themselves at all. I.e. Buy MS software and Dell gear and the system will chug along and he can blame undocumented upgrades for the slowness and not get called out too often because he has trained the organisation to accept mediocre IT operations, supported by the belief of the Discission Makers that they chose the BEST, because of marketing mistruths.

If a CPU runs
Full duplex data transfers with simultaneous departmentalised operations, centrally managed at twice the byte size
As
A half duplex, serial operation, decentralised management system 20yrs old.

Why would you buy the former when it is cheaper to buy and operate?

Because of MARKETING.

When you discuss the IT Solutions and write the recommendations include a reminder
The big companies do the same things as we a smaller company does when it comes to spending the advertising dollar but only so much more because they are so much bigger. Do you believe your own adverts? So why believe them. You cut out the truths that hurt, so do they. Your wordsmiths turn a phrase so do theirs??.

Ah sorry they?re the facts and we need MARKETING. Like a hole in the head.

(95% of my research time is wasted getting through the marketing and getting to the facts. Even then there are no standards to go by; I have to sort out the data like
Speakers ?A?
98dβ(spl) 1W1M, 10W(mpl) SNR 90dβ ?0.005%@15W

Speakers ?B?
50Watts not documented but this is actually (pmp)

Speakers ?C?
100Watts Max rec o/p
Which would you buy? (spl Sound pressure level, mpl ? mean power level, SNR ? Signal to Noise Ratio, pmp ? Peak music power)

By the way ?A? may = ?C?

by jmgarvin

Why would I want to keep the half duplex? I have to wait for in/out operations because I only have half duplex.

Now you example says they are the same, but that typically isn't true when you migrate to a CPU with more horsepower.

by nzbn

people in the org know it better than anyone outside the org especially the lowly workers sweating on the floor they know more about the company than the CEO

by nzbn

Lets look at the big picture,

There may in your opinion only $10.00 difference between two say AV's per licence so your ROI is right then and there why research it take the cheaper one, BUT if you make the wrong choice here say hello to viruses, spyware, malware, downtime then work out how much that is going to cost you, if its a large org you could easily be looking at millions,

IT needs to be researched because the cost is not now its in the future when the s**t hits the fan where well researched products save thousands if not millions.

by old timer

Spot on - we should all be concerned. I have always felt the rot started to set in with the proliferation of the PC in to business in the late 1980?s. This is when the big end of town mainframe professionalism started to become diluted and management were sold a crock of ?. by overly rewarded sales people. Most of whom had no understanding or experience of how to run an IT shop and how to build and roll-out decent working applications. Then we had an influx of partially or underqualified people in the 1990?s as the IT Industry exploded and we shifted into systems integration and later outsourcing. Those firms expanded to meet demand by hiring anyone they could but at a low price and resorted to contractors rather than by improving the skills base they had. How many times have you heard a big transnational outsourcer or systems integration firm say ?our people are our biggest asset? but how many do you know who actually invest in building the real competence and professionalism of that asset. They certainly won?t invest in training their contractors.

Large IT shops then started to fall into the same hole, i.e. relying on contracting rather than on hiring and ?developing? people. This is what boosted the rise (in Australia anyway) of the contract labour hire firms. The contract labour firms seem to be staffed by enthusiastic people, but most lack a deep experience of our industry and they certainly don?t invest in their ?assets? either. Add to this mix the fact that Universities are 5 years behind the real world and you have one reasons for the current situation. The other reason is a lack of real professional IT leaders who have served an "apprenticeship". It?s no wonder that so many of the newer, and not so new, folks in our industry are so disillusioned. Its to their credit they stay at all.

by nzbn

NZQA is the New Zealand Qualification Authority which is the legal body that decides what constitutes a qualification and what does not.

I have met many MCSE's and the like that know Jack about Microsoft products and how they work so I dont see how your statement of "proficiency with a particular product" stands up.

Sour grapes? LOL only when they arn't ripe.

He who trusts soley a salesmans tounge is welcome to the trouble it brings.

Since when did spelling have anything to do with what this topic is about? Nice try at discrediting but stick to the facts here! Whats right fi or endif - it depends

This is no MS bashing statement and why should it be that? Its about people and incompetence , and I think I will continue on with a masters rather than MCSE next, thanks for the sales pitch though.

by mark

I didnt see where you said you have met many qualified MCSE's, whose skills and knowledge you respect...Yes you mentioned certification in a broad statement, then you focused on MCSE's as an example...

by mark

I didn't see where you said that you have met many qualified MCSE's, whose skills and knowledge you respect...Yes you mentioned certification in a broad statement, then you focused on MCSE's as an example...

You are trying to juxtapose having a degree versus having a cert...It is not an "either/or" proposition.

Let me ask you, if you manufactured a product, who would you want to employ to service and rep the product...since I mentioned Cars before, lets use the same analogy....

Lets say I own a Ford Dealership, In the US, mechanics are ASE Certified. Does that mean the mechanic is automatically qualified to work on Fords? BMW's? How about Land Rovers? Maseratis?

The ASE certification is analogous to your higher degree....

Of course the answer is that these manufacturers have special training seminars, manuals, certifications and tools that are particular to their product. The mechanics who work on these products are REQUIRED (by the dealership, ie, the employer) to successfully complete the product certification in order to remain employed. Why do you seem to have such a hard time with this concept?

Instead, you seem to go after the very people who have achieved their product certification saying that they are "Idiots" who rule IT.

I say in response that YOU are NOT qualified to make that assessment. These are people who completed the manufacturers requirements for DEMONSTRATING proficiency in the product to the MANUFACTURER or the TESTING AUTHORITY - No one had to prove anything to YOU nor are you in a position to judge the skills of others, in the vacuum of making the same acheivement (note by the way the simple rule employed..."i before e except after c." thus making me appear to be literate.)

The final note to this sad complaint of yours is that I have no sympathy for whiners and complainers, You are simply part of the solution or part of the problem and judging by the negative energy, derision and condecension that was literally dripping off of your original post, I have a hard time believing (there's that i,e thing again, holy cow it works!)that you are a positive contributor to your IT dept.

Too bad

by nzbn

teach and troubleshoot? thats two entirely different fields and your pay should be doubled accordingly :)

She would probably never understand anyway, use lots of TLA's and watch it all wash over her vacant expression, she will eventually give up pestering you and let you get on with your job.

Get stuck into those lazy bulls and if they want you to teach them make them work 3 times as hard as you are

by nzbn

when you had that exec breathing down your neck wanting to know where all of his other stuff went

by tony hopkinson

The main chance, choose your career based on the market people jumped ship just after they scuttled it.
Me I'm still here

by fast586

I own a small computer business in New Jersey. I never recommend a product that hasn't been tested and that I wouldn't use on any of my own machines. I see however, a lot in the way of political plays in the IT field, related to using a certain product or products, instead of using what really works.

I used to be part of AT&T's IT support team until a few years back, when I was laid off. While I was there I would test antivirus and other products and make recommendations on my findings. Even though most of the software I tested was must better than what AT&T was using, they would not use it because it wasn't on their recommended or corporate list. So when a virus outbreak would occur, the other IT folks would run around like crazy to try and figure out what to do because what they were using didn't work. I was able to obliterate the problem on some of these machines on my own, by using what I had previously tested and found to be a better solution.

I don't agree with your remark about MCSEs however. I was on AT&T's server team while I was there. I can't tell you how much I went through to get my MCSE and it came down to both practical on the job experience and multiple books and training materials. I worked very hard to achieve MCSE status. I did it all myself and I'm proud to call myself an MCSE. I am not a "Paper MCSE". I'm the real thing.

fast586

by samuel leung

Although I had the choice of University Degree, I chose to take a 2 Year Trainee Position on Cert 4 Network Management. I am now the head of IT for my workplace of 260+ PC's and 10 Servers, growing rapidly.
My workplace is in a way a subnet of a bigger organisation, say like a School within Education Department. The Education Department decided to take on a IT Uni graduate who had adequate industry experience or so we all thought.
Turned out first day on the job I had to explain what a Patch Panel was, then how it connects to a switch, then what a switch was and how it relates to the backbone of the network and then the rest of the world... He still didn't get it. I was scared, very scared. This guy earns almost twice what I do, is in a higher position with more authority all because of a Uni Degree.. but what does he know... Nothing... he even took the time to write down EVERYTHING "I" ever TAUGHT him.
He resigned a few months later after a review of his knowledge and understanding, and numberous complaints about his personal skills from the other 'Schools' within the 'Department'.
University may be good for some but for the majority of people I see come out with Uni Degrees, they know far less about the real world after being stuck in text books and programing for three or more years.
After all, I live with an IT Uni Graduate and clearly remember him asking when he finished "Is it hard to install a CD-Rom".. and I thought he was kidding.
Uni graduates seem to like the long hard and complicated solution which no other profesional will be able to understand when they leave. It's like "Lets make it in Java C" when I would say "few line Batch file will be adequate enough".
- Simple yet Effective

by mcollis

A number of years ago I was shortlisted for a techie job with another tech type and someone who had a uni degree in Egyptian Mythology. He got the job because he proved, by his qualifications, he could understand things better than us tech types!

by nzbn

Does not recognise other countries degrees and the likes mainly because there are too many differing degrees and methods world wide to validate them all, the other is legal, can you imagine an accountant trained in one side of the world looking after the accounts of a company in another country - CHAOS unless trained in NZ many professional fields lack the knowledge they need to practice in the NZ market just as an accountant from here would lack the working knowledge of American accountancy, -- different laws.

Thankfully IT is pretty cross boundary in this sense so you would be pretty much safe in the knowledge that your quals will be recognised in the industry as they should be.

by nzbn

Pity Lord of the rings made more sales, money and fame than that American movie The Matrix aye :P

Look out for KING KONG yet another NZ made movie, or perhaps HalfLife another Peter Jackson (New Zealander) piece of brilliance! :) :P

by anniemae46

Just because you disagree with a choice of any solution, doesn't say it's an uneducated one. (Or, is this an underlying Unix vs. Windows issue?) Bad solutions don't necessarily point to idiotic IT people. IT is a fast-paced environment - that's an issue. Many problems (i.e., Antivirus, network monitoring, etc.) you have addressed, are more related to policies and understanding business requirements first. Here is where a well-working team is crucial. I think that's more often the problem.

by sm

I wud attribute this trend to IT not being passion (which was earlier) but becoming another earning medium. With wizards ruling the day in all software development IDEs or Application packages the logic development takes a back seat. The boys and gurls get a pay package for being street smart than being more logical.

by tony85

I work supporting a number of small businesses in my area. In one case, the months it has taken to persuade them that they need someothing like arcserve for their backups, instead of the free stuff that came with their tape drive, which doesn't back up Exchange (I support a lot of SBS). Why do we need to backup Exchange, they ask. We can copy stuff into PST files.

Someone complained that for a large company only 1% of budget went on IT. In some smaller companies, it is higher, but they forget that the costs are mostly for server and infrastructure support, much less per desk support.

At least some are slowly coming to realise that their business actually relies on IT.

by raskew

I worked for an Idiot Manager and told him that his knowledge was not good enough to give me a truthful answer to several problems that occurred! When the opportunityy came about I was canned and now (4 years later )the company is in bankruptcy. By the way they sent their help desk to India!!!

by somebozo

managers in the field of IT are mostly stupid school drop outs like bill gates who couldnt get into engneering so they choose IT, which was by that time a worthless faculity

IT managers act kiddish and have no sense of making decision. Heck most of the IT managers i have seen have 50 times less knowledge than me but salaries and fringe benefits 50 times more than me. This has given me such depressing feelings that i have thought many times to start fixing cars for living rather than IT. Atleast in cars u make better money and get respected for your expertise. lets see what happens in future, im still looking forward for ASE certs

by noly_big_boy

I think this would apply to our company where the manager himself doesn't have any knowledge on how our software works. We bought an expensive database and application software without consulting the professionals before implementation. He has recommended to the management to invest on wireless comm overlooking the amount for this kind of setup. He neglegted a good investment on IT guys to manage the work and as a result, the database software is running on 1 region only, the rest of the regions are paying the communication expenses for the wireless connectivity and no one to manage the other regions' requirements if they would start implementing the same software. IT Dept. expenses for this year is 3x the expeses last year. You may be asking how did he do that? Simple, he was just hired by the general manager of the company from other country and it would be shameful if he will be terminated just like the previous one who did the same thing.

What a complete shame!

by Member 25348569

You have an organisation which exists in order to rationalise standards between NZ and the rest of the world - a worthwhile cause. However, if this is the case then I would at least expect them to be cognisant of the standard of degrees issued by the most prestigious university in Britain (sorry, Cambridge). If they can't manage that then what use are they?

Answer: None!

Neil :)

ps. I like Kiwis. You are [b]not[//b] Australian and that counts for a lot! Though, being Welsh, I'm a bit p:ssed at the hammering your guys gave mine at Rugby.

by nzbn

for thier reason of not doing everything, budgets, management and time, They serve thier purpose here but I definitly agree there needs to be a body that is capable of corrolating degrees for countries into a equivelant standard so that we can all cross borders and have our qualifications recognised.

I think we all got p:ssed that night :)
We have a common pet hate, the aussies :) I could go on for days with sheep harrassing jokes directed at those decendants of criminals but thats another topic all together :) Ruggers is our national sport so I would hope we were good at it :)

by d_cay

I'm graduating this Dec. AS/CNS (tech school)
I'm going for my A+ soon & studying for my CCNA.
1 year ago I got my first job in tech support in a outsourcing co. for a major ISP. What a valuable lesson! The main problem I saw was the people they hired to "train" didn't have a clue how basic networks work, let alone how to get customers PC's to connect & stay connected. And they didn't care! All they wanted was a job. These new so called "techs" created more work for the real techs, along with tension.I just kept plugging along, kept my mouth shut, taking callbacks, sometimes a customer was calling for the fourth/fifth time, and resolving problems. I get satisfaction from problem solving and my supervisor saw that. W/I 6 months I was put in a special queue.
My point is if you like what you do, get really good at it(it takes time). Then go to the next level. I want to make more money and work at a place that I can gain more experience, and now am,but I also realize that patience, studying to gain new skills, and focusing on MY job performance will eventually lead to that. Stay positive, learn new skills and it'll come!

by tony hopkinson

I also know who bunch of proper business people who despite all information to the contrary from the IT professionals they hired, went ahead and bought a pile of crap because it was 'cheaper', to watch it turn into an outright disaster for all the reasons they were warned of in the first place. Still what do propeller heads know anyway, if they were clever they'd be managing business' ?

by ddobert

I have been in the IT field for over 20 years.

I have witnessed the IT profession rise from a 'geeky eccentric interest' to professionals making significant contributions to the 'bottom line' to just another budget line item that needs to be trimmed.

Some of my peers that have fallen victim to 'rifs' and other cost cutting activities ended up in other professions. Generally, they are happier in those occupations (retail/medical/construction) although not compensated as well intially, some of them are coming back and some of them have surpassed me.

They have shed the page and cell phone calls at 2:00 AM on a Saturday morning because some senior executive can't get to his email account because the server is down because it got infected by a virus because the A/V license expired because the invoice was not paid because the bean counter told management the IT department didn't state that this was mission critical and therefore wasn't going to be paid until the company really, really, really needed it. (I am joking of course, no one has ever seen anything like this happen, huh?)

Seriously, though, IT is so inexorably woven within our business and personal lives the distinction between where it begins and ends has become vague. As professionals, I believe it is encumbant upon us to communicate to the best of our ability to those 'IT challenged' decision makers just how important technology is to their success (as well as our own).

In the end, it really doesn't matter who made a bad decision that impacts a company negatively...the whole company gets the black eye.

by tomaaa19

The problem starts in the boardrooms and executive suites where often uninformed/disinterested management makes decisions based on what will make them look good for the next quarter, next review etc and to hell with the long term implications.

In the 90s the BIG THING was massive cuts in staff and somehow everthing will be fine. Now it is cut internal functions and outsource it.

When will these twits realize that there is no one size fit all solution.

To turn this around the entire food chain from stockholders on down needs to rid itself of the short term mentality and think about long term, planning, growth and sustainability.

If you take the narrowing of focus that some companies are practicing to an extreme they could become so dependent on a small set of customers for their narrow range of products and services that they could vanish overnight when a competitor one ups their product/service.

Selling off a profit making product line/division is a short term solution to a long term problem, once that bump in profit is gone so is the revenue stream that the sold off asset provided.

As to what the techs sell/promote, they are told what the company is pushing, which may not be the best choice for the customer.

In closing the idiocy rolls downhill, the IT shop it near the bottom and gets the full impact.

(sorry for the long rant)

by placidair

Wasn't this theory proven years ago when firms ran like lemmings to MSWord from Wordperfect (the superior product)? The MicroSoft juggernaut is what it is, and most don't bother to do their own research and testing of anything. They get a copy of some "best practices" list from a geek pundit and are off and running. Why? Because if they have it in writing as "the best way" and still have problems, they still have their butt covered. If they make their own decision, after their own evaluation, and something goes awry (and let's face it technology is not perfect and something, no matter how small, ALWAYS goes awry -- at least from the perspective of the enduser), then it's their butt in a sling because they can't pass it off on someone else's advice. I think that's also why there's so much outsourcing in the first place -- got a problem?.... blame the vendor.

by placidair

we're all still here -- we're just forced to sit on our thumbs and make monkey sounds by management.

by halibut

The face of IT has changed. It used to be the UNIX hacker type fasade ruled IT, with the thick glasses poor hygene and fashion. IT was distant to the average corporate person, a proverbial fog, a scary area, like trying to fix your car or hot water tank.

As Computer use increased, the interface between the systems and the people needed to change and that's where the MCSE came in. They filled the gap. But the problem is that with that came a lot of people that didn't have a clue about the actual backend troubleshooting and with that the NT 4 MCSE exam was a simple memorization of facts and procedures. The market is slowly evening out, people with no experience are leaving and the companies are finally starting to realize that certification without experience is not a good hire.

My only beef is that there are numerous individuals with no experience and skill peddling their skills in the market at $20 / hour at the expense of the remainder of us skilled and experienced individuals in the market.

by sschafir

Those of us that are knowledgeable (smart) were forced to go underground because of the young upstarts that believe they know a lot more than they do. They market themselves as knowledgeable and tell employers, customers, clients, etc. many myths and untruths and pass them off as facts. We come along at higher rates and everyone cries because these young people "sell" at a lower rate. The clients, etc. say they can get it for cheaper and I point out that you get what you pay for. They always end up paying them more in the end for having to do things over and over. Also having to "force" us to get certifications when we know what we are doing is ridiculous. It is just a way for Microsoft to make money while really not adding any value to our knowledge. I have been in the computer field for 22 years. Managed to dodge these bullets by starting out as a programmer, moved to IT and networks and now do technical support for a custom written software package. I don't mind learning but didn't sign up to go back to school every 2 or 3 years to take tests. You go to college once and are finished. It is up to the individual to keep up with the current trends and information but they should not be forced to do so. Because of this and the job market many smart people have left the field to do something that isn't so stressful. I am thinking of following suit and am working on building a non-computer related business now so I can also leave this field. It was great until the mid-90s and has now gone by the wayside. Even colleges state that accounting is the new #1 degree being sought.

by helloparminder

until u take a step to inform n update ppl on the technical front. they seem to believe every lip service given by a sea shell programmer ;) the young shall pick up the facts faster. inform the edu consuls on this domian so dat u guys have a scope for improvemnt.

by peteh

Yep ApolloCDR you're so right!

So often IT management are looking at costs, costs of servers, ditching backup solutions always going for cheap options. It does seem that anyone who has a home PC is fully qualified to not only discuss but to set IT policy for hundreds of users because they used it once at home (or their twelve year old did.

It's funny how the HR department get shirty if IT people go sick too often but conveniently forget how often they work late unpaid, it's odd how the Sales guys don't drive around in Ford Fiestas and don't like the suggestion that they should... and yet they all know exacly how IT should work, what they should be allowed to do and install and we're all just killjoys who want to stop the efficient running of the business by evaluating and testing first.

by nzbn

I have no problem with extra training ie MCSE what I have a problem with is idiots that don?t have a clue, don?t do research, don?t further themselves, and generally make an absolute c@@k up of everything.

Note also these mechanics must already have their highest level of qualification before being allowed on these courses so I fail to see how this lends any credit to your argument.

In NZ these precious people who make out they are so great because they have MCSE, and NOTHING ELSE by the way, are tearing companies to pieces, costing schools and non-profits thousands more than they need to and generally not providing anything decent in the way of IT support because they are so caught up in only giving what Microsoft or any other large vendor for that matter tells them to give.

I once had some fool (Who ran an IT company) tell me that Linux/Unix was an amateur?s operating system... This guy obviously has no clue as to what runs some of the world?s most high powered super computers... Every OS has its place, every PD course has its place but it?s a matter of perspective and how you use and further your skills that counts.

But as one person above pointed out they are the reason myself and many others make allot of money so hay.

In Addition:
1. Imagine the potential that many IT pros could climb to if they got the proper training and used it appropriately, but sadly many are happy to sit in their own world hoping no-one will ask them to further themselves. - Perhaps this pertains to you?

2. By the way before you criticize my spelling take a look at your own Mr. "condecension" the correct spelling is "condescension" - Like I said find something a little more substantial to argue your point with next time, your wasting my time with trivial arguments.

3. And... Your precious I before the e except after c rule does not always work in NZ, not every country spells everything the same in the English language. Not to mention a pathetic point to try and pick up on - try something a little better next time

by tokpatiman

Ya that's exactly what's happening in most organisations but I wonder if they have all the time to handle all these IT staff besides there professions then again I think about the risk they're taking in their own hands...Information in these days is very vital so live to the professionals...It is the same with other professions anybody can do anything but...!!

by wellpaid

Those of us that are not idiots, are well paid and holding great jobs that are challenging and ejoyable. We are sought out for our knowledge and call our own shots and select the jobs we like...

Anyone who is complaining falls in the idiots category.

by grimshiire

Killing the HR dept will only make them stronger. The last post from wellpaid shows a typical consultant puke who gets to run other clients networks into the ground just to keep a paycheck. When you get a real job, come talk to us in the trenches. Consultants are a necessary evil, but they would be the absolute last ones I would call. I would rather take my chances with the India help desk & believe me, I have seen my share of stupid rent-a-techs.

by wellpaid

Actually I am not a consultant. I have selected my job chnages based on career growth, geographic location and compensation. I have not failed to get a "real" job offer during each ingterview with prospective employers and typically spend anywhere from 2 to 9 years with a single employer big and small. In 30 years I have made the choice to enjoy my job and do what is appropriate in each and every situation.

Again, those most frustrated, loud and obnoxious underscore their lack of polish, business knowledge and technical apptitude. If this idea really upsets you, your are in the class being spoken about by this thread.

by indrajit020177

According to me the technology are changing so fast the people are not getting enough scope to do their research thoroughly. every other day a new version with new protocols are in market.
So to keep this in momentum they are not able to keep the track what should be in and the cost wise also it is low . So big doenst care for that nowdays for the thorough research before implementing something bcos they know if that doenst click they will get some alterenative on the second day.

by nzbn

You have obviously done all that you can to further your education which is great and should be applauded as there are many that do not.

True one does need experience before they can effectively manage a network by themselves once they have completed thier degree, I dont see MCSE or other certs as a no go but too many people use them like they are degrees.

From last count MCSE here is only 22 days in total training for the course so it would be good to attend in that you can learn about more MS stuff, but I think for someone to use it to say "Im a system engineer" because they just have MCSE is a bit of a joke.

Yes there are no doubt many people who have just MCSE that are talented people but imagine what value they could bring to themselves and an organisation if they but gave themselves the highest possible training!!

I myself have good friends who are not degree qualified that do programming for local govt etc. They are extremely bright intelligent guys but if they furthered themselves through proper education thier talent could truly be let forth.

by mr_dobby

I agree, these mcse bootcamps (get yout mcse in 2weeks or your money back) are definatley what is giving the mcse a bad rep. Even somebody who works full time in IT (and is well experienced)should take their time when studying for a certification. Simply passing as quickly as possible to earn more cash (but not actually knowing anything) can only end negatively. I took a year to pass my mcse.

By the way, my better half and I are heading to NZ for 4 weeks in December on holiday:-)Should be fun!!

by nzbn

Are you visiting Mount Maunganui? Best place to be in summer - smokin hot :)

by stargazerr

All our companies sail in the same boat....and all off us live the same hair raising (or is the word plucking off???) lives....

and people go about asking...What do techie guys do all day anyway ?? :o)

by maelorin

If we don't tell our 'clients'/'consumers' (whatever the new _in_ word is) what we do for them, how will they ever know?

We *cannot* rely on management to tell them. This thread is about the cluelessness of most management.

We have to be our own PR agents. I don't mean bore them senseless with technical details. We need to talk to the people we are working with/for and treat *their* problems just as seriously as we do our own.

I'm not suggesting we don't already do this, but all too often I walk into a workplace and discover it's practically ICT v Everyone in a smackdown contest.

If something cannot be done in ten minutes, tell them why - what you have to do and how long it will _probably_ take. Double emphasis if you have to leave something before it's finished to deal with another problem. Tell them why, make sure they know you consider their problem important, and try to give them an idea of when you'll be back - or how they can find out.

by jamesrl

I'd like to apply for an IT managers job there.

I am an IT manager, and its clear by your tenuous grasp on reality (50 times more salaries and benefits than you...) and math, I'm glad you don't work for me.

Just for fun, lets do the math. If you make 40,000 a year, then if your manager makes 50 times that it would be $2,000,000 a year. And here I thought basic math was a pre-requisite to good computing ability. By the way, because my staff can charge overtime and I can't, some of my staff will make more money than me this year. And other than the bonus plan, we all get exactly the same benefits.

Your generalizations about IT management are so one sided that no one can take you seriously. You may have a bad manager, but there are bad managers and bad employees in many industries. There are also good manager and good employees in many industries.

By all means, become an auto mechanic. If you aren't careful you could get a bad boss there too.

James

by ireche

This is the main problem with most big companies. They have somebody...for example, IT Admins who are brilliant at their job. So what does the company do?? They see this person who does their job well and decide that they could be moved to another position and make a success of that role too. Unfortunately, what generally happens is that people are moved out of positions they know and understand, to positions where they are uncomfortable and no where near as productive.

So all the smart people got moved and you can't tell that they are the smart ones anymore because they are sitting in jobs they don't enjoy and have no motivation for. It's about time companies starting paying people more for being good at what they do rather than paying people more for doing jobs they know nothing about.

by chris meacher

Could be worse - the other day I found out why my P4 3000 was running a VBA script slower than my Athlon 2000 at home.

The old 3-fingered-salute brought the answer straight to me - urmmm why are there 2 boxes for processor usage - oh s##t - it's pretending it's got 2 x 1.5GHz chips and NOT USING ONE OF THEM ! ! !

Okay so VBA isn't the most efficient language to code in, but it's a hell of a lot easier to format data in Excel than having to write my own report handler - but if I'm closing everything else down to run it I expect it to use the whole processor.

A BIOS tweak later and I have the processor working properly. My home computer still runs quicker - but having 1.5GB of ram will do that for you.

And then there's annoying adverts coming up to Crimbo advertising HT as a 'feature'??? It's all I can do not to smash my telly in rage. At least I'm in charge of IT purchasing mow and can design some 'decent' systems (i.e. no Intel, and only has Windows because we use propreity software that'll only run under it).

by mgordon

Please oh please give me just one day's income of that stupid school drop out, Bill Gates!

so if u r smart u wont trie 2 command a comp the same way u rite :-)

< better English > My managers have typically possessed BIS (Business Information Systems) degrees; partly technical and mostly business. It is not the job of a manager to be a technical expert. In fact, it is better if he is not; for if he were, he should be employed in the field of his technical expertise, not merely managing. Many do both -- I manage a helpdesk but I am also a server admin and network engineer for a five-state company. Using Cisco systems and self-starting employees produces reliability in hardware and human resources.

Charles Darwin would like you to understand that anything that continues to exist is "fit", more fit than what one might suppose. From this we can conclude that superior technicians are not particularly useful as managers; either because they cannot manage (frequently the case), or because their talents are needed on the equipment rather than assigning who is "on call" this weekend.

by mgordon

J. Burya at the young age of barely 20 was tinkering with the operating system of Control Data mainframe computers. Now he works at a bank. When I was just barely 30 I was writing modules and interacting with the kernel of the Honeywell DPS 8 mainframe -- probably a "lost art" since you had exactly 512 words of "program prefix area" to write your interface code -- a block of privileged code that interfaced between the kernel and the user program. It required not only assembly language, but a sixth sense to realize highly optimized floating code (code that works no matter where in memory it is placed, and without rewriting addresses via linking loader). Now I manage a helpdesk, sometimes program Cisco routers and I'm pretty good with type 66 and type 110 punchdown tools. I still write programs but I do not try to market them. My helpdesk tracker is 6,000 lines of "C" with MySQL on the back end, Apache web server in the middle and web clients on the front end. Nothing spins, blinks or requires Java or Flash.

So what happened? RAD, mostly (Rapid Application Development). When computers ship with a gigabyte of memory and run at gigahertz speed and programming is "drag and drop", what need is there for anyone that can squeeze a utility into 1/2 kilobyte? NASA for sure can use such people but that's about the end of the list.

I still write elegant little programs but it is mostly a hobby. Besides, who wants to go back to the days of staying up all day and all night trying to debug some nasty little function? Borland's debuggers were awesome. Now, with 99 percent of your code hidden away in libraries, debuggers aren't terribly useful especially when you realize the bug is in the library.

by ratatat62b

Mister NZBN has had a few Canadian beers.

Take two Canadian size aspirin in the morning & call me when you get a new attitude.

by mr_dobby

Yep, thats on our itinery (as a LOR fan I am also looking forward to Hobbiton even if there isn't much left of it to see).

by sysgoddess

Some of us are still here plugging away as consultants since most companies laid us off to bring in naifs who don't know the different between ethernet and token ring and are willing to work for $10 an hour.

by sysgoddess

"So all the smart people got moved and you can't tell that they are the smart ones anymore because they are sitting in jobs they don't enjoy and have no motivation for."

I can't think of a single instance where this has occurred in any company I've worked for. In fact, the inverse has been true where they've brought in some brown-noser from another department who knew nothing whatsoever about I.T. who proceeded to cut a swath through the department either through ignorance or because they were put there as a hatchet man to do what the prior manager lacked the skills or balls to do in the first place.

by sysgoddess

"A person with a degree often feels they deserve to be treated better than someone without one. Persons without degrees have an incentive to prove themselves and tend to be self-motivated."

Being a non-degreed I.T. person I have to somewhat agree with your assessment. I've been in I.T. for 20-21 years now and in the past few years have seen all the kids with their shiny new diplomas whose eyes glaze over when I've asked them to do something as simple as change an EIO card out of a network printer, exchange a token ring card for an ethernet card during a cutover (the only tokens any of them had ever heard of was for a bus, the subway or was something they hoped they wouldn't b e tested for).
I've had a couple of these fine young degreed fellows call to ask me how to find the Program ID key on a Win95 or Win98 machine or ask how to get the USB to work on an NT box and other equally stupid things and then bemoan the fact that their "talents" were wasted making a mere $14.00 an hour when most of them should have been sacked and sent back to school to demand a refund of their parent's hard earned money.

by hagar3

Most IT Professionals still aren't bright enough to recognize their function in producing revenues for the company. Rather than assisting revenue producers in doing thier jobs easier and more efficiently. They are constantly looking for ways to make it harder for others to communicate or other functions that would increase revenues.

by tony hopkinson

If you work in a IT business then by definition if you have a successful product you are generating revenue. If you are supporting a non IT business then you should contribute to revenue by reducing costs.
I've worked in both and been hindered and helped by management, I can assure you I knew what I was there for. It was obvious to me at least.

You talk like a manager so standard situation.
Approaching a deadline, you geta emssage from on high and a new feature gets brough into scope. You ask and get told that it will take three weeks work, that's too long so you ask for an alternative. The willing business oriented developer says well I could bodge it in four days but it's a less than ideal solution and anything we build on it after that will need to be reworked.
So a simple question, should you award yourself big pats on the back for
Saving your firm 9 days development time, getting the feature in and on time. Then for the simple expedient of crossing your fingers behind your back, save all that future rework cost when you promise to get it in scope for the next release ?

by hagar3

Cost reduction is not necessarily the best solution. You confirmed what I meant. Most IT departments do not understand that they are tool to enhance production. They seem to think that IT is an end unto itself. The don't see themselves as enabling communication with customers and employees on the road. They put themselves in the place of eliminating that service in the name security or some other high sounding goal. They don,t understand their mission nor do they know who their customers are.

by jkameleon

You completely missed the point here.

Years ago, European car industry put the money together, and financed & built this entire synchrotron lab

http://www.elettra.trieste.it/index.php

for one sole purpose: to precisely explore the properties of materials in order to insure, that cars fail in predictable manner. Car industry managers, who started the projects are not idiots, researchers who work there are not idiots. They are just adapting themselves to the market demands, that's all.

The "predictable failure" logic is applied for software & other IT solutions as well by Microsoft and other vendors, as well as anyone trying to make a living off IT.

by jkameleon

Once upon a time, a year or two after dotcom crash that is, there was a dairy in my town, managed by a couple of orthodox bottom line freaks. IT cost were kept strictly in check. Wages were minimal, turnover was enormous, but with tons of layed off techies wandering around, firm's IT job positions could be easily filled. IT appeared to run smoothly, but there was a problem brewing under the surface: Backups were made, but because of configuration error, nothing was ever written on that tapes. Problem remained undetected, because for minimum wage, while furiously searching for a decent job, nobody cared to engage into system's operation any deeper than strictly necessary. And then, one beautiful day, hard drive on the database server crashed. Operations had to be suspended. It took months to partially recover business data from paper. Damages run into millions. Management put the blame on IT department, shareholders accepted their arguments, as well as financial loss. IT scapegoats were fired, another batch of losers hired, and the show went on, the old stupid way.

by james speed

I have been an IT Manager - I surely wasnt an Idiot or School Drop out. I thought I was a good and decent & fair Manager. Not to mention I knew more than Any/All my employees because I have worked with computers since the mid 1970's.

I sense that you are upset by your Manager and are taking it out on ALL Managers - this is not a good thing. At any one time thousands of IT Managers are on this board and will most definately take offense - you arent "Winning friends and influencing people for the good".

The vast Majority of them are probably Top Notch guys/gals. Making blanket statments such as this show that you are NOT ready to be an IT Manager anytime soon.

If you have a beef with your Manager, suck it up, go in and talk with Him/Her and get whats REALLY bugging you off your chest. Then you will at least be happier and hopefully a little more productive.

Jim S.

by renwarb

Although I have had the terrible displeasure of working for some very poor managers, I am able to recognize that many managers have reached their current professional level by proving their skills/worth.

However, some of my complaints from experience have been:
- Inability to grasp basic technical details concerning products/services which are being managed. (I.E. Setting a deadline without understanding the amount of time required to complete a project)

- Committing to providing a service/implementing a solution that your staff does not have adequate knowledge. (Unless providing training, or time for Self-Study)

- Failure to consult the staff involved about the merits/drawbacks of any particular implementation.

- Having a "Hair-on-Fire" approach to issue resolution. (It is understood that time is of the essence when dealing with critical outages, but it is better to remain focused and make rational decisions, instead of panicking and creating a larger problem due to hasty decisions.

- The "Are-we-there-yet?" phone calls. (When I am resolving a major issue, it wastes critical time, and disturbs my focus to answer calls from my manager asking for details at 10 minute intervals.)

**This is a non-management peeve**
- Consistently selling/bidding services that we are unable to provide.

Now, I have been in the field for 5 yrs. I have done helpdesk, desktop support, Novell Admin, Linux Admin, and currently handle COTS implementations/support. I get frustrated by low pay, a company who does not wish to invest in me (in terms of education), managers who throw me into an implementation-in-progress without giving me background information, having my vacation requests denied without justification, lack of raises/salary adjustments, etc.

However, IT is my life...this is my career. I know that there will be better days. (Maybe when I move to India...lol) Honestly, though, I'm 23...I talk to my peers. Most do not see IT as a viable career choice. Mechanics are respected...Roofers are respected...Officers are respected...Plumbers are respected...Electricians are respected...IT Geeks are crapped on.

Sorry for ranting...so much that I could say, but never enough time. Just the thoughts of a 23 yr old trying to make the right choices in a very dangerous field.

by rickydoo

When I moved to Alberta, Canada four years ago I expected to find a few nitwits in my field of tech services for joe average, but I have so far met two people who claim to be techs who are not morons.
One dipstick told a customer that he could not make his Dlink NIC work in his older Compaq, and you can not return the old NIC to the computer once its been pulled. He should have known not to try and put a Dlink in an old Presario to begin with.
Another told a customer on wireless Internet service that the slow connection problem she was having would be solved when the company installed a DNS server on the tower to restrict the usage of a bandwidth hog on the network.
When I go to buy product retail I ignore salespeople unless absolutely necessary. They sometimes attempt to impress the customer with their knowledge, and when I correct them or disparage the brand they're trying to push on me they waste even more of my time trying to defend their ignorance.
If this thread is any indication of the level of competence in the corporate world these days, I guess I got out just in time.

by cheesel

If someone down the hall has a problem they have to call in a ticket. Where do they call? Banglore, India. Eventually, the ticket gets routed to me, 20 feet away. NUTS!

by wdbray

I'm in charge of three locations two in the US and one in China(I know don't Say it) butWhen I need help on a situation I seem to find people in the support field with all these so called titles that don't know anything that they should and in retrospect I end up fixing or finding a way to make things work along with getting a bill for nothing. I now make the companies that want to do business with me sign a contract that they understand the problem and have solutions or the cost is on them. China is another problem I usually fly there to do the work my self since I really can't even trust someone there. Good luck to all.

by squaredge

One of the reasons IT has degenerated into folly is because any knucklehead gamer who can assemble a pc thinks he can run an it department. Management assumes to their folly that anybody can do it. Microsoft has created so many MCSE's that we are a dime a dozen. Having an MCSE is a good start but it should only get you into the door. Without a degree you shouldn't get promoted, period. You haven't paid your dues. I don't care if you've been a loyal employee for 30 years with the same company, no degree, no promotion. But management doesn't care because they can pay the unexposed and inexperienced less. What we need are Unions in IT.

by kuchelj

Degeneration is in the eye of the beholder. I've trained a lot of Interns and new hires that were fresh out of college and I haven't found their degree's to be very useful when it comes to administering an IT Infrastructure. An MCSE certificate holder assures me, to some degree, that the candidate has an understanding of the fundamental architecture that is running the business. In the MCSE?s case, I only need to focus on the 'way' that we deployed the technology and they are up to speed. The college degree doesn't assure me of any of this.

Most college graduates don't have a working understanding of DNS, Active Directory, Proxy Servers, etc, so it takes me twice as long to train him or her. In the end, the theory of college and the theory of certifications are very similar. You read a book and you take a test when you know the material. When you get to the workplace you put your knowledge to the test. If you don't know the material, you get fired.

Also, your 'Case in example' is a little flawed. You mention that your service provider used 'Windows servers where Linux/Unix would have done the job better' but that's a very narrow view. Are you considering all of the ramifications of introducing a new OS? Administrators know Windows or they know *nix but they almost never know both extremely well.

If the service provider followed your suggestion, they would need to hire additional head count to maintain the *nix servers. They would also need to worry about building and maintaining a new backup, patch management, monitoring, and auditing infrastructure to support the new operating system(s). That's a ton of money for a questionable amount of optimization. There are also hardware considerations that come into play when introducing a new operating system.

You also need to consider how much funding you (the client) gave to the service provider and what the provider was contracted to do. If you didn't give the provider the money that they needed to implement QoS, monitoring, etc, then you can't blame the provider. If you asked the provider for a service and they didn't live up to the SLA, then you have several legal options at your disposal for recouping some or all of your financial expenditures.

by Former member

... and renamed the profession IT. That explains why the current trend leans towards new technology gadgets to do the job and damn the service - we'll just throw it out when it fails.
Manufacturers picked up on this and decided to forego the quality since it is a throw-away society. Used-car-dealers-turned-HR-managers went one furhter, chosing to downsize the importance of good Information Services and Support and turn a department they could not understand into one they can throw away.
Someday, it will all come back on them when the new breed of overnight IT "pros" suddenly discover the next instant success job; like CEO in a can.

by maelorin

Back when I was doing end-user support, I realised that the best answer for this kind of question was to tell them who was responsible for the decision. As a lowly techie, my job was to fix things and try to keep stuff running. Making decisions was the reason _the boss_tm got paid the extra money.

By *who*, I mean the position. Jake may have made the decision, but he made it as Head of IT or whatever. He might not be in the chair by the time the poor sufferer asks me they're stuck with something that doesn't work, or whatever.

The most common question I was asked was actually not about why any particular software, but why they couldn't change their background, or whatever. I got my answer down to a few dozen words.

They want to understand why they are not allowed, not what we've done to prevent it or whatever. Explain the reason for the policy. *Especially* if it's in their Policies and Procedure Manual - and then tell them where it is in the damn thing.

by maelorin

The communication problem is an old one, and there is no excuse for it. Nevertheless, it is a reality.

A while back I noticed a subtle but interesting change, IT is now more commonly referred to as ICT - obstensibly to bundle in the communications technologies that were part of IT all along. Having an ICT manager who can't communicate is sad, but still not uncommon.

I have worked in a school environement, indeed as a teacher in a ICT rich school. And two thirds of the students are *still* ICT illiterate *despite* having had laptops since they could walk. They are quite ahppy to walk about with a mobile phone attached to their ears (sometimes literally) but getting a grip on the computer is 'too hard'.

I agree with you regarding communication within businesses. All too often people expect the *other* person to do the explaining.

At the end of the day, the average person is still quite average. And by far the most common.

by maelorin

The issue is not that marketing is a waste of money.

The issue is whether the company considers its investment in ICT is adequate or productive. That is a matter for ICT management to address with the rest of the management.

Bean counters can see whether marketing has an effect on the bottom line quite quickly. They are often less clear about how ICT infuences profitability. ICT management need to be able to make that clear to those who allocate resources.

ICT is usually considered to be an operational expense, rather than a combination of operational expense and strategic investment. If your management cannot see that, perhaps you need to find a way to do it. Or move to a company where management does.

One of the things I do in my consulting work is show how decisons affecting ICT ultimately affect the _big_picture_tm.

Usually, just drawing attention to the way dollars invested in effective ICT _and_ effective ICT training can produce a tangible return. Not only through improved 'effiency' but also as a strategic investment itself. Reducing long term overheads, or spreading costs over longer periods or more efficiently across the whole enterprise can have remarkable effects.

At the end of the day, this is what 'outsourcing' and 'internal markets' are really about.