Is IT degenerating into a field where idiots rule?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by ibanezoo
Same here... 3 guys (well 2 really) to handle 800-900 people spread across 15 locations in a 300 mile radius. We lost count of the computers... who has time to count them?! :) Develop, test, and release this new enterprize tracking app, roll out a domain in that new department, add these 50 email accounts, oh yeah these ones need forwarding but we don't know where yet, fix the CEOs email again because he doesn't know how to use a mouse and folders "are gone damnit! Im the CEO, get them back NOW!", get in the crawlspace and run this cable, we opened 3 more shops so we need VPNs in place until we can get perminant WAN connections set up, 10 computers are dinosaurs and need replacing, why isn't that massive Xerox printer that we never told you about not set up on the network-we need to print!, uninstall the spyware from the sales teams laptops, reboot the windows servers, patch up the Linux servers, make sure your SUS is up to date, purge the mysql databases, 4 shops need new storage servers as they maxed out now, Hey why can't I log in? Do you remember my password? Give Joe a new keyboard because he dumped a coke in the last one, did you know our webpage is out of date-go fix it, write us a program that converts any customer supplied file to a GroupIV TIF automatically from our web forms, save that cat stuck in the tree, go help the government auditors.... Oh yeah, can you have this all done by noon, and don't spend any money!
asdfg eghsdn AAS&>Tqwehy7rhy7quwhehilabnsdfkl
^^^^ Head hits keyboard
At least the paycheck is good and you get to wear the super cape when you pull everything off an hour early ;-)
The real Problem as I see it is that usually and in ordinary circumstances, {Outside the tech World} the boss knows far more than you do and there's very little you can get away with. The other side to that is that if you run into a problem you can turn to your Boss for help and he'll know what you're talking about and help you solve whatever is wrong. Not So in the IT Tech World, unfortunately.
Usually we will have Superiors who are far less knowledgeable than we are and when it hit's the fan, they are looking at us, and we have nowhere to go because we're not qualified enough or experienced enough.
The reason for this is because we sold ourselves too high in the first place. We wanted the job, so we really poured it on. The boss didn't know any better went ahead and hired someone who looked good but technically should have been better qualified. This is not be true in all cases but I dare say in most.
Then we kill ourselves trying to catch up on what we don't know, so that no one will notice our deficiencies or differences. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't work, depending on the situation and the depth of the problem.
So the real problem as I see it is that it is the Boss who's lack of knowledge that forbids him from asking the proper questions that would help him determine if this individual is really this good or just blowing smoke.
This is not a put down on the Bosses either :) , Man, the information moves so fast and hard that it's hard to keep up so we can't expect a Boss to know everything, however, sometimes, a little more knowledge can be quite revealing.
This is where the problem lie's, The unknowing good hearted "Give em a break" Boss hiring a greenhorn and it takes off from there.
Better to just be up front with everything, that way there are no surprises when it hits the fan and all can pitch in to help stop a storm that can become a Tornado or worse yet. :)
Thank You.
Aaron
by bobjorg
by pz0r56
by b8zs49
by b8zs49
I work for a large IT Services company that also is world known for it's line of computers. As a support person I see a lot of what goes on and have a good handle on what skills or lack of skills people in our organization have. We have managers who refuse to deal with employees they know don't have the skills but send them out to do work on the customers equipment anyway. I've seen technicians go out and turn customers machines into vegatables resulting in lost data and lost productivity for the customer. All that management seems to do is make excuses instead of fixing the problem.
We have sales people who write bad services contracts. They want the business so bad they offer a contract at a low ball price and then to make it profitable we can only use low skill level technicians for high skill level work.
We have so many layers of management which also adds to the price we must charge the customer to make a profit. We need to trim the fat, get rid of the many layers of management, bad sales people, and the dead wood technicians who don't want to better themselves.
There are a lot of highly skilled people out of work. It is time to give them shot.
Since I am the only one in the IT dept and my company. I take offence at your observation. :)
But I have heard horror stories on larger busineses and businesses with no IT infrastructure--they out source it.
i've ridden the wave of IT for the past 10 years. when it was the "wild west" 10 years ago things got done, solutions were crafty and innovative and the rate of growth of technology was exponential. without skills and trained staff companies couldn't get by.
now IT is run by people trying to climb the executive ladder. if IT fails they have the company by the short and curlies. IT holds companies hostage and most that run IT departments don't know a megabyte from a hole in the ground. they've become part of infrastructure and cost centres rather than solving problems.
by b8zs49
How many famous entrepreneurs don?t have collage degrees? I have a B.S. and an M.B.A. and it doesn?t mean crap. My sister is a PhD and she?s not as good with people as my friend who?s a high school dropout and runs his own construction company! He clears four times my annual salary (yes, he must be a lousy business man without a piece of paper that says he knows what they taught him). I know at least 30 managers in my own environment that are managers simply because they have a degree and they can?t do their own job and find others to do it for them. They can't motivate anyone further than their own bonus.
You?re typical management. I can tell by your dumb post.
by db0
by pete1978
You seem to mention having a degree in IT vs/ a certification (such as MCSE) as some measure by which a person is either not-an-idiot (IT degree) or an idiot (certification).
I've been in the IT business for 20 years. I've met many people with IT degrees and many people who held certifications. Trust me that both groups have more than their share of idiots and both have some people who are brilliant.
Don't ever assume that someone with a degree is intelligent just because they have a degree. Getting a degree requires taking classes and passing tests. High IQ isn't a requirement.
Don't ever assume that someone who holds a certificate is an idiot just because the are, in your view, only certified. Getting certified requires passing tests. Low IQ isn't a requirement.
What you are discussing is not a degree vs/ certification issue. It is a QA issue. It is only an issue of whether the person (degreed or certified) cares to make certain that the answer they give is the best answer.
I personally know a person who has an IT engineering degree who advises against a particular, very popular, CD Burning software package. When I asked him why, his reason is that he doesn't like the package. When I asked why he doesn't like it, it turns out that his first ever attempt to burn a CD was with that program and he made five coasters in his first 10 attempts at burning a CD. In his IT engineering degree mind, this was the fault of the software and had nothing to do with the fact that he had never burned a CD before in his life and had not read the manual to learn what to do/not do while buring CDs. Is that intelligence? No! Is it poor QA? Yes!
As for IT going to the idiots ... the intelligence of the planet is a constant, the population is rising.
by pete1978
Actually, much of what is being discussed in this thread is an IT Management issue. The average IT person is too busy to have time to discuss what is being done, why, how, and when it will be complete.
Unfortunately, too often IT management is too busy dealing with projects and budgets to deal with the discussion of what, why, how, and when.
This means that there is nobody in IT telling the rest of the company what IT is doing for them.
On the other side, the average non-IT person believes that, because they know where the power button is on their PC, they must be a power user. When they talk to the IT people and hear the true tech-speak, they have no idea what was said and believe, therefore, that it is jibberish. They see the IT people disappear into rooms that are locked off from the rest of the organization.
All of this leaves them with an information void. So they fill the void with the belief that IT is doing nothing. After all, the IT folks probably only lock the server room door so that the rest of the company doesn't know what PC games they are using, right?!?!
IT Management, in spite of their schedules, must take the time to inform the rest of the company on what IT does for them. Sure, they know that IT does a file backup every night. Do they know that IT used the backup to manually recover 1000 files last month saving the company tons of money and preventing end users from having to recreate the files (thus saving time)? Do they know that IT updated the corporate AV package and, as a result, prevented the virus breakout that they all heard about in the news last night? Do they know ...
No, they don't know. IT workers don't have the time or the vehicle to give this information out to the whole organization. IT Management must start informing the organization about what IT does for them behind that locked door. If IT Management doesn't step up to this plate, IT departments are doomed to outsourcing.
by mwebster
by big scoddie
I dislike the myriad low-end IT dweebs that think that because they can fix a few desktop issues on a network they are qualified to do just about anything.
I know a few that will freelance jobs in areas that they have never had any experience or exposure. Say, setting up a VPN, cabling out a building or trying to develop a POS web site.
They invariably make a complete mess of it, but bluff their way with a barrage of tech-speak. Their inexperience means they also end up charging for many more hours than are reasonable but the customer has no idea of what is reasonable. This often stems from the misguided assumption by the customer that if you know any IT, you know everything.
The end result is a "solution" that falls over, is a severe security risk or just doesn't work. The customer ends up angry and the real professionals suffer a bad name.
There should be some better accreditation system for IT people. Setting up the World's smallest domain in your bedroom does not make you a network engineer!
I have read quite a lot of these posts and i find a lot of them so spot on. Agreed, a certain level of not-so-smart ppl are dominating the IT sphere. THe reasons have been quite well documented in the posts.
Now, while i agree with the spirit in which the author wrote, i must underscore that it can be an equal hindrance to the IT sphere, allowing the same 'idiots' to overrun the profession. The author obviously loves assembly programming. But the reality is that RAD is the future. Using notepad to construct enterprise level web applications is pointless and not-so-smart. I feel where he is coming from, but as IT professionals, we must continually adapt and change, while maintaining a high standard of development.
And as a young aspiring java programmer, i put the same effort into producing optimized and secure code as i would, if using C.
Point is, by refusing or being too slow to adapt to new technologies, IT professionals allow IT Aspirants to flash their qualifications in these new technologies, and gain preference over what may be perceived as obsolete or less productive software tools.
I agree 100% though that RAD has created a new breed of programmers, who have a peripheral knowledge of programming paradigms. This is inevitable. Don't hate the concept though, embrace it and with your knowledge and experience, take it to a new level and stand head and shoulders above the rest.
As much as core IT pros would despise the "bogus" IT pros, they are doing what they must to survive. Real IT Pros must continually adapt, even in the face of obvious crap. Agendas beyond IT, drive the processes that IT pros work within.
Its a hard hussle.
by rayjeff
"But why does everyone who has read the "Chip Chat" section of the sunday paper think they have the answers and are more than willing to try and trump the IT guy at the next meeting?
(In another life) a director of a major manufacturing company told me I didn't have to explain a complex financial model as he had taken the four-hour course "Finance for Non-Financial Managers." My MBA in Finance was worthless against his four hour course. The issue came up as he had just totally misinterpreted what the numbers meant."
In my relatively short career of being in IT (5+ years)I've worked with/under 4 directors/managers. And out of the 4, the current on I have a working relationship with (not directly because I'm not in the IT dept)has the least amount of experience. I've taken a look at his resume and his B.S. is in Mathematics and he has an MBA. He got his undergrad degree in the early 80s and his MBA in the early 90s. He got his MBA while at his current joib, which is where I work. In the previous life beofre being the IT "god", he was a systems analyst.
I say all of that to say with my true life situation. The division I work in (non-IT) just finished a big three year project (I was hired during year 2). I was charge by sheer luck of the responsibity to setup an electronic assesement system to include a database. Needless to say, I accomplished the task. Unfortunately, I needed the assistance (after going through twists and turns for over an year) of the IT director to gain access to much needed data. Little did I know it was going to be the start of something awful.
The database was created in Access XP. I already had a prototype database and a "production" copy running. They both worked well and I was able to incorporate many modifications into the production model; They were in operation for two years. By the time the IT director came onboard, he took the work I did and created a whole new database from it. The probelm was because he was never a part of the original design and didn't understand the requirements of my division, the database he designed was flawed. Queries that needed to be used could not be used because of the design. I had to use some of the methods in the database I design as a workaround. Even ideas I had to solve the issues with his design, he didn't even entertain them.
My catch phrase again...I say all of this to say that his background isn't in IT (even though he was a systems analyst), yet he gives the image to the organization that he knows everything in which clearly he doesn't. And because of such, when someone whose knowledge maybe more extensive than his, he balks.
by rayjeff
"But why does everyone who has read the "Chip Chat" section of the sunday paper think they have the answers and are more than willing to try and trump the IT guy at the next meeting?
(In another life) a director of a major manufacturing company told me I didn't have to explain a complex financial model as he had taken the four-hour course "Finance for Non-Financial Managers." My MBA in Finance was worthless against his four hour course. The issue came up as he had just totally misinterpreted what the numbers meant."
In my relatively short career of being in IT (5+ years)I've worked with/under 4 directors/managers. And out of the 4, the current on I have a working relationship with (not directly because I'm not in the IT dept)has the least amount of experience. I've taken a look at his resume and his B.S. is in Mathematics and he has an MBA. He got his undergrad degree in the early 80s and his MBA in the early 90s. He got his MBA while at his current joib, which is where I work. In the previous life beofre being the IT "god", he was a systems analyst.
I say all of that to say with my true life situation. The division I work in (non-IT) just finished a big three year project (I was hired during year 2). I was charge by sheer luck of the responsibity to setup an electronic assesement system to include a database. Needless to say, I accomplished the task. Unfortunately, I needed the assistance (after going through twists and turns for over an year) of the IT director to gain access to much needed data. Little did I know it was going to be the start of something awful.
The database was created in Access XP. I already had a prototype database and a "production" copy running. They both worked well and I was able to incorporate many modifications into the production model; They were in operation for two years. By the time the IT director came onboard, he took the work I did and created a whole new database from it. The probelm was because he was never a part of the original design and didn't understand the requirements of my division, the database he designed was flawed. Queries that needed to be used could not be used because of the design. I had to use some of the methods in the database I design as a workaround. Even ideas I had to solve the issues with his design, he didn't even entertain them.
My catch phrase again...I say all of this to say that his background isn't in IT (even though he was a systems analyst), yet he gives the image to the organization that he knows everything in which clearly he doesn't. And because of such, when someone whose knowledge maybe more extensive than his, he balks. My issue is why should be so afraid of knowledge that others have when he's the one with the "high up" position of IT director for the entire organization? Why be afraid to share your own knowledge with others?
by rayjeff
I've been lucky that through my academic career to have REAL IT jobs while still being in college. I'm sampling a little of everything. It is definately going to help me to be a better student of computer science (the undergrad degree i'm working on).
SO, there are a few of us out there in the U.S. IT world that are getting the experience to go along with academia. it makes for a better IT person because the choices are just that broader and open.
by mkelley_25
I have worked on computers since the age of 13. I have been a help desk tech, computer tech, network tech, network admin, networking instructor (at the post-secondary level), and now, for the first time, at age 38, I am an IT Manager.
I am now in a position to rectify all the "wrongs" that were thrust upon me during my time in the field. I am in a position to rectify all the "make it work with what you have because we're not spending extra money" projects; all the "learn it yourself, on your own time, because we're not paying for you to go to classes to be taught" technologies; all the "we MUST go with the cheapest bid given up front, even though it will end up costing us three times more in the end" mindsets.
I am trying to keep all of the "bonehead" decisions my former managers made in mind so that I don't end up making the same or similar mistakes. I am also trying to keep the "good" decisions my former managers made in mind also; hoping to emulate those.
However, in trying to keep all of this in mind, AND trying to learn a whole new skill set required to be a manager; I am also learning first-hand that the view from "this side of the desk" is completely different. I attend more meetings than you can shake a stick at; I am a member of roughly half-a-dozen committees; AND I am getting a real taste of "office politics" from a whole new perspective.
Yes, I agree that there are "idiot" managers out there in EVERY field. In fact, I used to be the guy who thought his former manager was a "complete waste of good oxygen, who wasn't qualified to carry my toolkit." I still feel that way, BUT in the last three months, I have gained a whole new respect for him...
by rayjeff
by rayjeff
Is is this always the case? When will the hiring folks grow a REAL brain and have competent knowledge of IT so to hire competent people?Q??@?@???!??!@#?!@#?
@#?%@|?#%?@#$?%#?^$?@#^?#@?
I got into computers because I enjoyed them. I did not get into it because I was told they were high paying. That does not mean I want to be low paid though.
My experience started with hands on. It was the 80s. You had to open the box up and dig deep to get them to work.
Then it was a trade school followed by college.
Something happened midway through my college. Certifications. They became a hot ticket. I could not afford them. What pissed me off even more was that those who got laid off due to NAFTA were eligible for voc rehab. Guess where they went? You got it, those cert mills that taught you how to take and pass a test but not retain any practical knowledge.
For those who have them I am not knocking them in their entirety but a condition that happened. So as I was looking for a job I was not being selected. Recruiters did not care for my college courses or degree. Microsoft told them that only an MCSE could work phones and do field support.
I was told by one recruiter who I do not even think could spell computer that an MCSE is like a college degree. I just stared at her. Um, yeah. That is why a lot of them cannot write a memo or know how to use a spellchecker.
So the market got flooded with all these so called techs who had these certs. Others will tell you yeah but they had to perform once they had the job. Sure they did but far too many of them could fake the funk and learned enough to stay afloat while those who had far better practical knowledge could not even get an interview because they could not get past recruiter's scanning machines who were looking for those industry buzzwords.
Every job where I got the opportunity to talk to the manager I would be working for I have gotten the job. Every job that I did not get that opportunity I have not since I had to go through a recruiter.
The cert thing is not as bad as it used to be but still these schools that are still in the cert mill business are telling people that you can make mad money out the gate. So they honestly believe that with no practical experience they are going to get 65K.
It is extremely annoying to see other techs make as much as you if not more who you can out tech. It is frustrating as well. I have known far too many who line their walls with certs who can't put most of that if any of it to practical use. That is sad but I am not exaggerating.
I went through a bad experience of one such who walked up my back into management and then supervising me and then blacklisting me. He learned just enough to where he thought he knew everything.
What is worse is that IT is not even governed by IT anymore. It is straight business who think they know IT. I understand IT is a service. It is a CUSTOMER service but they want to increase that bottomline and reduce everything to zero touch but then pay at walmart wages. They have this very SciFi Channel look of things that everything is just a magic button and do not understand the amount of grey matter needed for honest troubleshooting. They think that a monkey could install a hard drive and then go out and hire a monkey. The monkey that is now making 10 an hour that is more than his burger flipping job he used to have literally just sticks the hard drive in. If any troubleshooting is done you are lucky. Data transfer? Ha. Hell was your hard drive even bad in the first place?
I am old school. I am a doctor visit. These blokes forget that is an important part of IT, customer interaction. Instead they want to reduce it down to IT being like the phone company or the cable company and think that is interaction. They think remoting in is as well interaction.
I save this company's name so much. I put a face on the company that the client can talk to. I build trust. They vent to me. I facilitate their issue into a pleasant experience. And it is not like we do not relay the complaints we here of our helpdesk and remote team. We are 100s of years of combined experience who get sidestepped about our see of things. We get told the client really wants the issue to be taken care of. Well yes but their complaint is that it is not being taken care of on the first call and they know if they can call one of us we can do that for them.
In a year I expect to be outsourced to a magic button machine. 10+ year career down the drain. I have been watching pay scales backslide since most eveyone is going through some contractor agent who then wants to pay bottom dollar but expect maximum knowledge.
What is worse is that I am already working for an outsourcer since our client outsourced most of its IT off to various companies. My company then outsources pieces that it does.
How can you effectively integrate IT into business units to best serve them when you outsource it. That just creates more red tape as now you have these levels of private govts competing for their bottomline.
Everyone is looking for that damn easy button that does not exist. I see far too many of my clients though who still in 2008 do not even know how to use basic functions on a computer.
Well this is depressing. I am going to go something more uplifting.
by jiminpa
a little closer... a bit closer...
THIS POST IS 3 YEARS OLD!!! HELLO MCFLY!!!
?:|
So why did you reply? The info is still pertinent to today's climate. I did not go hunting for this McFly. I simply opened up the link in my email and there the topic was to click on. I did no searching.
If there is a statute of limitations to what we can reply to then by all means take it up with Tech Republic and tell them to purge their data every 15 minutes.
I would had made the same damn near speech 3 years ago. It would be nice to hear from all those who posted then to post again and tell us what changes have happened since.
It used to be that colleges were years behind current tech but many of them have incorporated classes that prepare for certifications as well.
In fact I went to Cisco Academy at a college and taught by a professor of that college who was certified.
And this was back in 2003.
Lord of the Rings as well as King Kong are American films. New Line (formerly Time Warner) is Lord of the Rings and King Kong is Universal. They are born American Film Studio companies.
A lot of American film studios have directors and producers from all over the world. I saw an American film recently that was directed by a chinese director. Does that mean that is a chinese movie now?
The latter two Matrix movies sucked balls.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending