Discussion Locked

Is It OUTRAGEOUS or is it just ME?

0 helpful
330 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

330 replies

by tufop

How long after 2002 can you buy a brand new 2002 Toyota?

Microsoft has long stated it's goal is 1 new OS a year. I don't know if that includes Server OS's but it's like anything else. Eventually it's obsoleted by the manufacturer.

by hal 9000

Where did you get the 1 year figure from? Certainly not M$ as they are currently saying that every 2 years they expect to provide a SP similar to SP2 for XP and then every 4 years a new OS that is a development of the current Vista and that Vista is the basis of the next 10 years of M$ Development.

That is what M$ was saying as of February 2007 and it was said several times prior to the last Partners meeting so if they can stick to the stated timetable which not even the M$ presenters are certain of that should mean that sometime in 2009 there will be a Vista Service Pack Released and then sometime around the latter part of 2011 there will be the next progression of Vista.

But if I bought any new car I would certainly expect to be able to buy parts for it for quite some time after the initial purchase so it could be kept on the road. I don't expect to take delivery of a new car with a sealed Fuel Tank which requires replacing the car when the fuel runs out.

Col

by daveo2000

Why should you expect to be able to go to a store and buy parts for the engine of a car manufactured over 30 years ago? Certainly the manufacturer would make sure that you couldn't get any parts; and, more importantly, if you lose your keys you won't be able to get replacement keys. That would just make no sense! How will car manufacturers feel about you taking away the consumer's incentive to buy a new car?

Once a new model of car is on the market, the manufacturer goes out and tries to get all of last year's unsold models back from the dealerships so they can provide the dealer with the new models.

I thought, for sure, you knew this! :0

BTW, if we ever get (gods forbid) a Windows OS as part of a car, do you think that MS will support a car OS that is over 10 years old? Or will you be forced to upgrade your car at that point?

by stevenmoulden

Just pull a new OEM code (never activated of course) from the side of the case since everyone knows that the volume license is the one that's the original legal one!

Or just become an auto mechanic...they don't mind as much when they have to work on the cars...even on newer ones; they get paid whether you drive a 1985 Isuzu or a 2007 Mustang....

by tufop

Couldn't have said it better myself. I was at the same event but had to leave about an hour before it ended and never got the copy of Vista I went for. I guess you got to play by the rules. I can't go into a Toyota showroom and say give me a brand new 2002 whatever.

by travisfx

Yeahh kill all functionality. Very good MS. Baracade all the doors, windows, throw away the key. There! ( slap hands together). Now she's secure. Wait a minute... Doh!
I can't imagine that's the idea of Vistas improved security. What a bunch of idiots.

by daveo2000

MS is so quick to throw things out on the market that the first release that they sell is really what we called, back in the old days, BETA (at best). SP1 is really RC1 and SP2 is the first that you should consider to be commercially viable.

A friend of mine changed some hardware on his XP-SP1 machine and got locked out. It wouldn't even let him put in a new activation key. He finally worked it out with an MS tech support guy... it was a bug in SP1. Go figure.

by why me worry?

and slept all night outside of Best Buy and other stores. MS is targeting these idiots who needs to have the "latest & greatest" yet know absolutely nothing about the problems with the product they are all mindlessly flocking to buy.

by daveo2000

The guy I referred to above (or was it below?) that had a couple of hundred PCs that had unlicensed versions of 98 on them. He wanted to buy Win98 licenses for them but MS was only offering XP Home to him.

Again, you are the magic man!

by daveo2000

Some of the most informed folks are right here and have already experienced the issues you asked about. Col (HAL9000) has been answering questions about Vista for quite a few months now and has direct lines into MS (even if he doesn't want to talk about it) :)

I'd say that by asking the question, you have started your research. Plus you are doing it in a place where people can defend or argue the points instead of leaving you to figure out if it is just FUD.

by daveo2000

Oh, yeah. I think that was NT 3.51 and only when it wasn't connected to a network.

Col, what do you remember about this?

by deadly ernest

admin networks without extra encryption as long as they had a good public gateway. The network was only allowed to handle things up to the confidential - Commercial-in-confidence - highly protected level. Nothing that was heavy national security stuff, that required extra encryption on a separate NT 4 network.

by why me worry?

The same DOD that allowed some Navy commander to replace a battleship's Unix based navigation systems with Windows NT4, causing the ship's systems to crash and requiring that the battleship get towed back to port?

I'm sure we've all hear of this story back in the 90s', and yes, it did happen contrary to what people think may be an urban legend.

by dt6string

Copies of XP are getting harder to find at retail outlets. SUPPLY AND DEMAND. If more people are looking for Vista, thats what they're gonna find more of on the shelves. As retailers see the demand for new XP licenses dwindle, they stop buying it, PERIOD. A retailer's most valuable commodity is FLOORSPACE. Don't waste it on a product with greatly reduced demand.

It will take a while for Vista to get smoothed out. We saw this with 95, 98, Me (was that really an OS?), 2000 and XP. A few months down the road and all this over-reaction will die down.

I'm advising my customers to stay with XP until at least SP1 if not SP2. If they just have to have the newest and greatest, then I set them up as a dual boot. When an app isn't functioning in Vista, boot to XP and keep searching till you find the upgrades to make apps compatible with Vista. Some will never be compatible. Thats just the way it goes. In every industry.

From the look of some posts here, it sounds like we should just put a stop to all progress so a few complainers aren't inconvenienced.

I always felt that a great part of the fun of this field is hunting down or creating the workarounds to make something work that most people say isn't working or will never work. I've met some incredibly ingenious and tenacious individuals in the IT field who just get it done. Who just get it period.

No more conspiracy crap. Microsoft is a corporation. They never claimed that they were a non profit organization. Many of us owe our incomes, our jobs and careers to them. I've bashed them quite a few times myself, but as time goes by and I grow my own business, I'm looking at the ROI. How quickly will my current business practices and products give me a return on investment, just like MS, IBM, Exxon, and all the rest.

And besides, just think of all the new business we will be getting because of the problems with Vista upgrades. These are the times of opportunity for us all. Its not that we're taking advantage of others poor fortune, we are providing a much needed service to frustrated users and this is when we stand to gain the most. Right now.

by tony hopkinson

criticise MS business's practices because that would make you a hypocrite? ;\

If so I admire your honesty. :D

Do note before we can fix problems in vista we have to buy it, possibly a box to run it on, learn it, find the tools we need to do our jobs on it, while holding down our current markets. That's a lot of disruption and extra effort and outlay for a potential return.

Depends on what you do, but if I was still contracting in the UK, upgrading my desktop, (no way vista will run on it) buying two vista licenses one for my portable and I might need the XP), VS2005, Office 2007? SQL Server 2005?, Delphi upgrade...
We are looking at up to 50% of what used to be my gross here, still it's prettier so I feel much better about it.

I don't owe my income to MS, I was writing commercial programs while he was thinking frames, doors , squares, windows !

You don't owe your income to MS, in fact no one does, without us, he would have been selling fridges door to door, of be churning out bad code for ibm.
We are his market, and he keeps doing us in the ass.

Could you go to your customers, and say buy this or you get no support? Could you say no we don't sell that any more here's our new version which works with naff all else, you'll have to buy new hardware to run it, oh and it costs more?

I can see why you'd like to be in that position, expecting your customer's to be grateful for it, is a bit much though isn't it?

by dt6string

Its nice to be admired for something as simple as not being a hypocrite! Glad i don't resemble that remark.

True, in you're position, you are looking at possibly a large outlay of dollars. I did mention that I look closely at ROI, which for me is primarily equipment (hardware), software, advertising especially, and training and education. Some areas of support are going to be harder hit than others.

But I strongly disagree with you on owing income to MS. You may not like it, but they have the lions share of the market of business desktops and certainly home PC's.

Now, thats not to say that another software innovator (whether MS is an innovator is a topic for another discussion) that developed a better and more widely adopted OS wouldn't gain my appreciation just as deeply or more so. I'm not beholden to MS, but as they OWN the desktop market, I do owe my income to them. If IBM had gotten there, I would recieve most of my income from their designs, efforts, and, more so, flaws. But the businesses I support use Windows Desktops, and Servers (though not exclusively) so at this point in time, its MS, plain and simple.

by why me worry?

and finding the bugs in it? I am not being paid by Bill Gates to fix his product, nor is it my intention or obligation to. MS is relying on the sucker end user to find all the bugs and report them instead of having the actual coders do their jobs of proper QA before releasing a product that has not been fully tested.

by david.mclaughlan

When Ford, or any motor vehicle manufacturer for that matter, brings out their new models for the year do you go down to the showroom and rant about them not continuing to manufacture the previous years model. Of course you don?t ? there again maybe you do. Most reasonable people ask the dealer to describe the differences and decide if you want to upgrade to the new years model.
If you want to buy a second car and you really like last years model you look for the best possible buy in the second hand market for that model. If the warranty on the second hand model has run out do you bitch to Ford ? no I think not, but there again maybe you do.
Why do you expect anything different from the computer industry?
If you were running DOS 3.1, and there are occasionally valid reasons for doing this would you demand support for that as well?
To use the car analogy again if I have Model T I don?t think I would expect that I would be able to get ford original parts. In fact I think I might expect that I might have to have some parts specially manufactured. That?s the price I choose to pay if I want to drive a classic.
Just like other industries IT moves on and develops new products, user groups form around certain collections of technologies where enthusiasts gather and support each others need to freeze time and not move on.

by hal 9000

Particularly as Henry Ford said that he would give everyone a car if they would have it serviced and the necessary parts supplied by him meaning his company. Servicing is where the real money is in any industry is not in New Sales.

Look at any business and ask where they make the bulk of their money from and you'll find that it's the Service Department who have an ongoing supply of work where as Sales are a one off profit with very little chance of a second buy unless something drastic happens.

While I am into Classic Cars I would expect the Car Makers to supply parts for their Old cars as that is where the real money is so under that guise Mercedes Benz has it's own Classic Car Devission that supplies parts for all Classic Mercedes. I have a 1959 Ducati that there where 5 made of and guess what Ducati still supplies parts for that and I don't mean the easy bits that are in common use but things like Gear Clusters where instead of having the Dogs cast onto the sides of the gears the square holes are cut into the gear face below the teeth. Standard for racing but unusual for road bikes or cars for that matter.

Even My 1982 Ducati the only part that I'm currently unable to buy is a new Gear Lever but when the next batch gets made in a couple of months time I'll be getting a couple so that I have a few spare ones just in case anything happens to the one currently on the bike. God a few years ago I could buy new parts for a 1930 BSA without any problems not sure about that now as I have sold that bike and sidecar off so I haven't looked for those type of parts for a long time now. Even my VW Beetle is easy & Cheap to buy parts for but they are chossy on what they sell as the lasttime I went in there I asked for a Master Cylinder Brake Kit only to be told that they don't sell them I would have to buy a complete new Master Cylinder but at $28.00 AU I was more than happy to spend the money as it saved me quite a lot that I was expecting to pay for a stainless Sleve to be fitted to the master Cylinder and then a new Kit to be set into the Modified Master Cylinder. I can buy any panel that is needed new off the shelf for my 1965 Beetle. To me that is Service.

Col

by daveo2000

After all, that seems to be the only one being supplied here even though it is really a lame analogy.

by deadly ernest

runs KDE as default, it also has some easier access to the more commonly used administrator functions. Security wise, it's slightly better as it asks you set set up a different password for the root access during the install.

SimplyMEPIS even uses the Ubuntu repositories for many of the package updates.

edited to add.

The KDE interface is more Windows style than the Gnome and I find people used to Windows can migrate to KDE relatively easily, but sometimes have trouble with moving to Gnome.

by tig2

Also have a look at PC Linux OS for people who are accustomed to Windows look and feel and are not technical.

SimplyMEPIS is also a good one. There are many more based on what you want to do.

by deadly ernest

Over the last 12 months, I've tried a lot of Linux packages, and in SimplyMEPIS the only command line function I've used in the last f our months is to run a PING command, and you have to do that in the command line in Windows. I know one of the Linux packages for network management is all GUI and does it from the GUI, so I don't have to use the command line, but I prefer to do it from the command.

Most Linux distribution also support a lot of the older hardware, and if they don't any driver written for earlier versions of the same Linux branch will work, in every case I've tried they have.

by deadly ernest

they didn't care about XP, maybe my phone enquiry was one of those that upset them and caused them to change their minds.

by deadly ernest

Steff, their marketing guy is mega MS supporter. He puts Vista on his machine and the tech guys refuse to touch it, next the activation says it's a pirate, next day the MS guy on the phone tells him to buy a legal copy (which he already has), yesterday's he gets upset because the MS tech is now examining his hard drive by remote access without getting permission. Can't wait for today's (Friday here) installment.

by hal 9000

How did you get back inside the airlock when you didn't have a spacesuit? :D

Would you like a Game of Chess? :^0

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

I've earned just as good money doing it for other platforms as I have with windows.
I started my career in manufacturing doing main frame (well mini really) admin and coding. So in real terms MS replaced my market or had no affect on it at all.

Having my own affordable PC with my broadband so I can converse with my peers, play online poker etc is nice. There's no doubt that MS success expanded the home market to the point where PCs had to become affordable for the home user. I pay for that and MS among others, make a tidy profit out of it.

But my career achievements are dependant on my talent, must be, because I'd been coding 11 years before I touched a PC, and that was a state of the art IBM XT 286 with dos 3 on it.

Given you are into the elimination of BS, how could you possibly be a hyprocrite. :D

by hal 9000

[b]MICROSOFT = Most Intelligent Customers Realise Our Software Only Fools Teenagers.[/b]

Sounds about right for the Vista Release after all how many adults where in the ques outside the shops come midnight when Vista went on sale?

Col

by hal 9000

And I even buy copies of M$ DOS only a couple a month but M$ is still selling them with absolutely No support. A couple of years ago they tried to switch the sales of DOS over to buy a OEM Copy of XP Pro and use the backward License so you can install M$ DOS. Lets see $60.00 AU for a DOS License as apposed to a couple of hundred $ AU for an OEM copy of XP Pro. When that idea was rejected by the customers M$ went back to selling DOS at $60.00 AU a pop. Currently they are selling about 50 copies per month in AU. But here is the funny thing the Sales Guy at a Partners Meeting said that he couldn't understand why people actually still continued to buy copies of DOS when they could just install from the Floppies and no one would be any the wiser. You should have seen the look that he got from the Head of M$ Legal as he said this. If looks could kill he would have been incinerated on the spot. I assume that when the Roadshow moved on from Brisbane that was changed. :D

The DOS goes onto Computer Controlled Machines like Lathes, Milling Machines, Armature Winders and the like that are used in the Power Generation Industry well the ones that I work with are anyway and the NT4 Client is used extensively in the Earthmoving Industry as they have a Program that currently has no plans to upgrade available that allows them to get their earthworks to within 2mm of specification so it saves them lots of money and on big jobs the computer isn't expected to last the distance or be of any use on the next job depending on the job in question.

Col

by hal 9000

I can still buy parts for my 1959 250 Ducati and they only made 5 of these things as the Factory GP Bikes which where never raced by the factory. Granted there are slight differences between these and latter models so things like Gear Clusters are different and Con rods but I'm still able to buy new stock of these parts without a problem.

Then I've just bought a complete interior for a 1972 Mercedes Coupe so that's High Back Seats front the rear seats and Door and internal skins. Even Mercedes has it's own Dedicated Classic Car Devision which specialises in providing parts for any of the customers needs.

As for the seals that you need Honda never made them in the first place so you can always look to the original maker and I'll bet that they still have them available. Actually the Biggest problem that I ever ran across was a Moto Guzzi that bent an exhaust Valve when it was less than a week old we couldn't replace the Valve with anything from Guzzi so we took measurements and found that a Toyota Valve had the same dimensions and we used those ever since. But replacing Oil Seals are the easy things. Honda had a practise of supplying a gasket set without the Oil Hole in the Crankcase Gasket which was interesting to say the least particularly when you managed to seize new engines within a couple of hundred feet. :D

Col

by hal 9000

M$ Legal pays him a visit and hands him a subpoena to appear in court for Pirating their New OS and he gets to defend himself for only a few hundred K to prove that he actually did have a Real M$ Provided copy of Vista but as the legal system here doesn't support scurrilous prosecutions he doesn't get awarded costs so that $400.00 AU OS ends up costing him close to half a million and it still doesn't work. :D

Col ]:)

by stevenmoulden

Makes me wonder if Bill and the Gang will next go after free speech in addition to their piracy campaign....drive the rest of IT to underground support centers!!!

by hal 9000

That if it wasn't for people like you M$ would be dead and buried for supplying the junk that they do supply.

I don't owe M$ a single cent and they don't put a single cent in my hip pocket but their shoddy products do and the fact that M$ is incapable of supplying fixes that the average End User can apply is what makes money for me. M$ inability to do anything correctly so I have a saying that I use to every customer [b]Don't blame me I only fix the mess I didn't design it,[/b] if you have a need to complain about the shoddy product take it up with either M$ or the Government Authorities that are in charge of Fair Trading. As I'm unable to help you I can not even look at the Source Code to fix problems that have been designed into the Windows Kernel.

But it's nice to see someone who really thinks that they owe their livelihood to M$ when it's actually the other way around. :D

Col

by dt6string

I think you misread what I had to say, or misinterpreted it.

Yes, we clean up their mess. But mostly we clean up the mess of the end users. They are the ones who open infected attachments in their email from senders with names like Gun A Junkya, don't update and patch their OS, tell me on a service call that they think their AV is fine, but it expired a year ago. Most that I know don't try to educate themselves on best practices.

Hell, there are two sides to every story. Everyone here has pro's and con's. All I'm saying is that I got out of the Corp IT world and coudn't be happier for it. Most of my business is not from home PC users, but its still a good portion. I appreciate that I am very good at what I do, both technically and as PR/Sales and that MS products or mistakes, whatever you want to refer to it as, produces an income for me. OK, I see your point. I produce my own income but its because of the same thing. MS helped create a huge market where individuals like us are needed and in that sense, I owe much of my income to them, to their poor design or planning or whatever.

So, simply put: IF you recieve an income working on MS OS's, you make money because of their efforts and marketing, good or bad. You capitalize on it, Period. You can't really think that you put money in their pocket, that I have it wrong and its the other way around. Thats a slightly inflated view of oneself. How much money do you think you could put in their pockets? Insignificant is how much. We could ban together and say we have power and $'s in our numbers, but we could leave today and tomorrow the void would be filled by newbies and on it would go.

Tony Hopkins situation is different. He isn't beholden to MS in his line of work. More power to the man, although he's still a smart ass.... :-)

I supported 20,000+ users worldwide (thankfully not alone) and the only system with a near flawless record was the corp mainframe. And even then, most problems revolved around emulation software. Thats reliability that Unix or Widows Servers will never match.

As for the parasite remark, daveo2000, would you consider a physician a parasite? Of course not and neither are you or I. We didn't invent the disease, we're just providing the cure. Till the next outbreak...

by daveo2000

I see what you are saying and understand that much of what we do is actually creative, but it bothers me that so much of what we do is making up for software that could be so much better.

Most of us have some pride in what we do. Sure, sometimes some folks might let something slide because the client is a real jerk; but, those are limited cases. MS isn't dealing with individuals, they are selling en masse. Why was it that the same IP stack problem that caused BSOD in earlier versions of Windows was still there in 2k and, if I remember correctly, in XP? Why do they spend more time trying to kill cooperation (like Samba) than they do trying to fix bugs?

As for the doctors analogy, why didn't you choose lawyers? ;) I think they fit much more closely (since, after all, MS uses so many of them!) ]:)

Yes, some doctors are parasites. I put many (but not all) plastic surgeons in this category. All you have to do is listen to news reports (and some of the gun lobby folks here) to hear about what some doctors do badly for their patients.

But that wasn't your point. The good doctors treat the problems that their patients have gotten themselves into. So, in that, I think you have a very good parallel (for this aspect of it) in comparing MS with cigarette companies.

by deadly ernest

and later withdrew that allows you to run Win 3.11 as a 32 bit system. And don't forget my copies of Dos 5, 6, 6.2.

With Win 95 did your want 95B, 95C or 95D. My copy of 95A is corrupt now.

by anin_26

can anybody tell me why we should upgrade to vista? xp is a full fledged os. its stable, rock solid, its good looking, it's secured. so why vista? is it legitimate to upgrade to an os only 4 graphical purpose, which needs further massive hardware upgrade. i think microsoft should go 4 their further os security not 4 new, costly os which make negetive impact within people who like, who use windows since long time. and outshelfing XP.....!!, i'm afraid. i think bill gates should rethink his business strategy....

byeeeeee........

by hal 9000

That will be in about 18 months time when we actually have Mission Critical Business Software that will run on Vista currently we do not have this so it's a non issue.

It's just the same as when XP was released very little actually worked on it as M$ had changed the rules again for third party software houses so they all had to rush back to the drawing Board and recode their applications to make them work with XP.

As for Vista I'm not personally supporting it yet and have no plans to do so in the immediate future either. I got caught out quite badly by supporting XP from the very beginning and I'm still hurting from that mistake.

The fact of the matter is yes Vista needs more in the way of Hardware but again it's already here so there is no big deal over that as we are only using what is already available so if you where to install Vista Today it should work as well as it can on the currently available hardware. The real problems are the third Parts Software that will not currently run on Vista and until this changes I'm not interested in even attempting to have a serious look at it and I have a Volume License set since November last year. I wanted to test the RTM version and I'm now satisfied that it not working properly yet so I'm not supporting it till it does.

Besides because I've taken on this policy I've lost a Government Department who has Implemented Vista and I can finally escape the bickering and false accusations of me or my company selling Pirate Software to them. I don't need the BS that comes along with doing their work and then after they abuse me and my staff they then have already Rung M$ to report us for selling the Pirate Software and then tell me that they have finished me off for my Illegal activities. They also don't pay in any reasonable time so I'm personally glad to be rid of them. You know that you have a real problem when the Governments Own IT section refuse to deal with this Branch of the Government they just supply what they are told to and put the hardware in place and then walk out the door and let them mess it up even more. They are not interested and now nor am I as I've had 3 complaints about selling a Government Department Pirate Software in the form of a 2,500 Site License for XP Pro which is just ridiculous and they then get nasty when you prove to them that they are wrong. That and the massive staff turnover makes this place not worth supporting no matter what!

Col

by myg33ks

How about tell you why you should not? As many have pointed out, Vista is alot like XP was when it was released. I waited a year to install XP as I was fully satisfied with Win2k Pro.

Why the wait? MS continues to put the cart before the horse and releases Vista before it was ready and uses the retail market as guinea pigs.

The real issue lies in the "4 year Life" of an operating system policy. MS will focus on all the eggs in the Vista basket and it will become a decent system at some point.

Check the benchmarks:
hxxp://www.tomshardware.com/2007/01/29/xp-vs-vista/

Conclusion: K.O. For Windows Vista?

Windows Vista clearly is not a great new performer when it comes to executing single applications at maximum speed. Although we only looked at the 32-bit version of Windows Vista Enterprise, we do not expect the 64-bit edition to be faster (at least not with 32-bit applications).

Overall, applications performed as expected, or executed slightly slower than under Windows XP. The synthetic benchmarks such as Everest, PCMark05 or Sandra 2007 show that differences are non-existent on a component level. We also found some programs that refused to work, and others that seem to cause problems at first but eventually ran properly. In any case, we recommend watching for Vista-related software upgrades from your software vendors.

There are some programs that showed deeply disappointing performance. Unreal Tournament 2004 and the professional graphics benchmarking suite SPECviewperf 9.03 suffered heavily from the lack of support for the OpenGL graphics library under Windows Vista. This is something we expected, and we clearly advise against replacing Windows XP with Windows Vista if you need to run professional graphics applications. Both ATI and Nvidia will offer OpenGL support in upcoming driver releases, but it remains to be seen if and how other graphics vendors or Microsoft may offer it.

We are disappointed that CPU-intensive applications such as video transcoding with XviD (DVD to XviD MPEG4) or the MainConcept H.264 Encoder performed 18% to nearly 24% slower in our standard benchmark scenarios. Both benchmarks finished much quicker under Windows XP. There aren't newer versions available, and we don't see immediate solutions to this issue.

by w2ktechman

Are yours connected to a network? Have you ever installed anything?
I will admit, I like XP a lot, but it is not rock solid and can be broken even without intent.

by daveo2000

I remember that even NT4 still had the problem where if you had a faulty network cable you would get the BSOD on boot. I used to keep a faulty cable that I knew would crash the system just to test new releases to see if they every bothered to fix it. I can't remember if I ever tried it on XP.

And then there was that bit where Intel could never fix the math bug in the x86 ROM because MS had programmed to the bug instead of around it.

by so.cal guy

any OS can be broken xp is rock solid yes our network workstations have xp installed.

and about the only problems we have are from the partition drones who try to install some crap they downloaded at home and brought to work on a jump drive.

and try to infect the network with spy-ware or some other crap

by mjwx

I almost didnt beleive it, I had to check it myself, but of course the XP machine costs $150 more and doesn't come with the HDD upgrade.

Even when I called our Dell rep he was reluctant to agree to give us XP, instead trying to sell us vista. He only stopped when I asked for a new account rep (I didn't think I asked nicely either, I have a bad habit of yelling at suppliers).

by daveo2000

I have always been under the impression that yelling at suppliers was the industry standard way of letting them know that you actually do have an opinion and they should belive it. ]:)

by tony hopkinson

Place I was working at had a tensile frame pulls a piece of steel wire in half, and measures the force required.

The software was third party, no source
the PC and XT 286 with DOS . No hard drive and two 5.25 floppies. All the slots were used up so they had a combination video and printer card. The printer side of the card stopped working and the the software was hard coded to make low level calls to it's graphic hardware and it's obsolete.
Buggered, new pc, new software package, new interfacing, ?25k for a video card.

by brokeneagle

I let my status as a Registered Parter and my Action Pack expire last month.

My homebuilt computers will be replaced by Macs when they die, if not sooner.

by daveo2000

For those of us that work in bleeding edge IT shops, we expect to get screwed by MS every 18 months or so. Plus all of the recent high-school grads or script-kiddies looking for work always want to get the latest beta release of MS's latest replacement for the last "be all / end all" technological buzzy/whistler/flasher toys.

However, there are a lot of people out there (most of the world?) that just need to get their work done. At some point, they buy something that has a computer built in or as part of the package. They may not have wanted it that way but that is what they were sold. Not all that long ago, you only upgraded a computer system when it no longer performed what you needed it to perform. Remember the phrase "If it ain't broke, don't fix it"?

Now, we in IT are in the mindset of "If you haven't fixed it lately, it must be broke." Those other folks that just want to do their jobs just keep getting frustrated about this mindless vicious circle of upgrading and intentional obsolescence.

by hal 9000

Granted I work Business and we work to a Tax Cycle of about 4 years where everything gets replaced with new stuff because the Tax has written the value of the computers and related hardware down to such a level that there is no longer a viable Tax Deduction in having the old Hardware there so it gets replaced. :p

So my attitude has always been when the Accountant tells you to buy something new I'm going to be the one who supplies it. Granted along the way quite a few printers and the like get replaced when they break as it's not worth attempting to get them repaired and whatever Backup Solution that is in place needs to be regularly tested and certified that it's working properly but otherwise it's all routine maintenance for this little black duck. :D

There is a problem arising right now for me as by June this year I have several companies who are due for a complete replacement of all their hardware. I'll be deploying XP Pro again as currently there is no advantage to move to Vista Ultimate except from a Profit Margin point of view and lots of reasons not to make the move the main one being that the [b]Mission Critical Business Systems Don't work with Vista.[/b] so that makes it easy not to sell. :^0

Col

by why me worry?

And any IT dept that blindly follows what MS and Gartner tells them are not doing what's best for the company. It takes good IT managers, CEOs', and directors to say "NO" to Vista because they realize of the impact that Vista will have on getting work accomplished. I've worked for a NYC based law firm in which they boast about running "bleeding edge" technology, but in the end, the IT dept has to deal with the nonsense and users are lawyers are screaming about not benig able to get work done.

At my level in my career, I can easily weed out newbies and tech wannabes, because as you said, they are the ones who need to have the leatest and greatest because they have little to no knowledge of the underlying problems that these poducts introduce and how it will affect business productivity.

by daveo2000

I feel that I am becoming more and more of a dinosaur in my feelings about how business should work. Maybe I have been infected with that Open Source bug that makes a person think that they should try to provide a good product and after that people will want to use it.

Many of our jobs exist because of MS. I don't think anyone will argue about this. But I think you will also have to agree that a lot of those jobs are there because of MS screwups or outright lack of concern.

Why didn't Unix take over the world instead of MS? Because most of the people that were working with Unix wanted to get a job done well and not have to keep going back to the OS to fix stupid bugs. It was designed to get the job done.

Why did MS "take over the world"? Well, "long ago" they saw a new market and jumped in. That market had lower expectations of computers and that is just what MS gave them. The "buzzers, bells and whistles" mentality kicked in with steroids and a bit of cough syrup.

by hal 9000

They wanted a second rate cheap alternative for their Open Architecture Computers that they where about to start building so they went to a struggling almost bankrupt company called Microsoft and gave them a [b]Golden Handshake[/b] which Bill G simply couldn't refuse.

If IBM had of gone with another OS & Software M$ would have died a natural death taking quite a lot of money and staff entitlements along to the grave with it. MS once they got way too big for their boots turned around and [b]Bit the Hand That Feed Them[/b] as IBM wanted to develop OS2 which would have been the end of M$ or at least removed them from the OS side of the market but as Bill and Steve had seen Xerox's Prototype Unix running a fully integrated Network with a GUI on Unix they just had to race each other to develop this technology but on their own propriety platforms.

Apple won that race and look what happened to them so this is a perfect example of being first to market doesn't guarantee you sales or even any form of Continued Customer Support. Though when Apple went to the Bean Counters they nearly killed it off so that might not be such a fair comparison.

Col

by tony hopkinson

He put cheap pc and any 'eejit' can use it interface together and he made it work.
Right place, right time, right network, won big. It could have all gone badly wrong on him.
Since then he's played that initial genius, luck, sleight of hand, whatever you want to call it like a master, business wise.

Quality wise most of his stuff still sucks, ISAPI, .NET being a couple of exceptions, but I'm pretty sure he doesn't give a toss what I think though. :D

by hal 9000

Has EFI and it's a true Electronic Fuel Injection system not one of those manifold pressure sensors that alters the amount of fuel being dispensed through a Fuel Distributer and with the fuel injectors constantly on. The 6 Cylinder Car had 2 X Banks of 3 Injectors that open together as they do in a modern car or if you are looking at one of the V8's they have two blocks of four that do the same thing. It's a Bosch System and by no means the first Bosch Fuel Injection System.

Personally I can not ever see M$ convincing Bosch to ever use a single M$ product and if they where to M$ would want to back out as Bosch would demand at the very least a 30 year Service Cycle for their products. That's what they have now and in all likelihood will continue with. So with all the non Japanese and Korean cars taken care of there is no reason for the Japanese and Korean Car Companies to move to a M$ supplied Embedded OS. These also use standard off the shelf parts that are made by third parties so M$ would need to try very hard to get those Manufactures to take them up on a M$ Embedded system to use when everyone else is refusing to touch that type of thing.

Actually much more importantly there is a lot of Medical Equipment currently in use that uses Embedded M$ OS's and they are what will be interesting to see what happens. Things like Ultra Sound Machines are typical of this and as they have a relatively long life they will have to be supported by M$ even if they produce a new OS that replaces the XP Embedded systems and moves them to Vista Embedded OS which will increase the life expediency of the machine as it will improve it's usefulness and diagnostic abilities. :D

Some How I don't think that's what M$ had in mind when the did the deal with Siemens Medical but that's what will be happening. The places using these could possibly end up spending more on conductive Jell than the cost of the Ultrasound machine if M$ replaces the OS with a new one that gives the unit a greater flexibility to do more with the same hardware. :^0

Not sure just how many CAT, MRI & PET Scanners run on M$ OS's mainly because I avoid Medical work like the plague I've done my time in hell and don't need to repeat it but it would be interesting to know just how many of these Computer Aided Diagnostic Machines actually use an Embedded version of XP. There is currently [b]No Way Known[/b] that something as expensive as a CAT, MRI or PET Scanner will be ripped out because the Embedded OS is no longer supported. I know that the European Governments would be straight at M$ through trying to rip out the Jugglers and I'm betting that most other Governments including the US would be in line to do the same thing. :p

Medical Diagnostic technology is already expensive and we don't need the prices of these machines and procedures being ramped up just because M$ decides to stop producing different Embedded OS's that drive them.

Col

by tony hopkinson

they roll all our cash up and stuff it in their ears.
Fish hooking them and taking it back is even more effective.
Never found one yet who doesn't start co-operating when they see the money going back in my pocket. A little ear wax never hurt anyone.

by w2ktechman

I have run into bad cables, but not ones that would BSOD an NT4 system (that I can recall at least).

Maybe Mae's new hammer has altered my memory a bit. lol

by why me worry?

I've had bad cables plugged into NICs' on both XP and 2003 and they did not blue screen. What would cause a BSOD is if the NIC isn't firmy seated in the PCI slot, as I have seen because I didn't want to be a brutal maniac when inserting a $1500 Gigabit NIC into a $30,000 server.

by danglingwrangler9

First, I am independently employed in the IT industry as a consultant from 14 years experience all the way to CIO, before striking out on my own, (due to layoff like most others). I would request repliers clarify your vested interest in Microsoft or others, so everyone knows where everyone is coming in this discussion, without naming company names.
Lets take the blinders off and let the frank discussion ensue about Microsoft "Vista" - it "requires" a brand new machine almost as the cheap dells and all the other cheap (under $700.00) boxes store bought just won't take a Vista upgrade! It take a minimum 1GB of memory just to run Vista adequately, another Direct9x Video card (under $150.00) shares 256 MB more of memory. You spend more than $200.00 on Direct 9x video card and the memory usually comes on-board (so there is no addt'l share requirement), in most cases.

Now this is before your machine is running "ANYTHING" else. Adobe Photoshop or Intuit Quickbooks Premier would boost the computer requirements at least another 256 - 500 MB of memory.

So lets review so far the expense of upgrading the insecure Vista OS just to see brilliant image rendering when you open your text based email (for security reasons) - Basic Vista Home Edition with "Aero Glass image rendering $299.00, Direct 9x video card required to run Vista 9x with Aero Glass $200.00, most likely memory upgrade of at least 1 GB (if older Bios is capable) $99.00. So you will spend most likely $500- $600.00 for Vista upgrade.
Is there any wonder there is an underground software industry? The middle class is being squeezed right out of this consumer category, just like the numerous other ones where the middle-class just has to go home empty handed.

Do you think Microsoft is in cahoots with any any kind of conspiracy with all the Computer Manufacturers it partners with to force people to buy new computers vs spend in the neighborhood of $500- $600.00 to upgrade an old computer to run the the basic stripped down version of Vista????????

Are we seeing the beginning of a class structure - the middle class that no longer will be able to afford to have a new computer or at least wisely justify that kind of expense just to enrich the billionaires Bill and Michael and keep their bank accounts flush????

It is my opinion that the answer is YES to the above questions and the IT techs that stand up to this sort of malarkey get out-sourced off-shore.

Maybe it is time to unionize. They can not take all the jobs off-shore... and to think that this situation will change or that Bill and Michael are NOT sitting around thinking how they can accelerate this scenario to prevent this very thing in the IT community - unionization I frankly am surprised if hasn't started already - unionization in IT. It really is heading toward critical mass fellas....and gals. Anyone got another scenario ??????????

by why me worry?

Unions won't do much for the IT industry, but annoying the crap out of congress to put a plug on this out of hand H1-B fiasco will. Bill Gates just made a bullshiit speach to congress regarding a so called "shortage" of skilled IT workers here in the USA and asked to expand the H1-B program. Perhaps if this greedy pig paid decent wages us Americans can live on instead of outsourcing to 3rd world crapholes where they pay pennies on the dollar to people who can't even speak proper English, there wouldn't be a so called "shortage".

Screw Bill Gates! He calls himself a "philanphropist", yet he is quick to sellout the USA to some 3rd world craphole. Perhaps he forgot thjat is was the USA and people like us that made him a billionaire and not India or China.

by deadly ernest

and this will cost me clients as I've already told them I won't work on a Vista machine. Some are smart enough to wonder why and looking at other options, others just ignore me thinking they can talk me into it later.

by hal 9000

In taking up the battle to support M$ dropping support for XP that is embedded into Medical Diagnostic Equipment like Ultra Sound Machines CAT, MRI & PET Scanners.? :D

I wounder why that could be Hum? :^0

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

In about 2 years time but only on the Original Version and not the SP included version which will take another 2 years to fully test. :D

Then when that is ready for you to start working on it there will be a New Windows about to be released again. Some how I think that M$ actions on this one will be the start of people looking for some form of substitute as they are by now sick & tired of the M$ Drug Dependency and will start looking for something that doesn't treat them all like criminals and actually works. :^0

Col

by thechas

I work with a lot of systems that run legacy code. We are still running hardware that predates the IBM PC and DOS!

We cannot get funding to convert the elaborate custom applications over to run on new operating systems.

Right now, new applications are being written on XP systems. Some of these will need to be in service at least 20 years from now. Should we need to rebuild a hard drive, or make a duplicate system for increased capacity, we will need to be able to install XP!

I don't make the decisions as to what OS to use, I just get to implement and support it.

Chas

by mikemajor3

1. yeah, I remember the XP and 2000 releases - and I was one of the ones telling everybody to wait. Happily, I was right that time - after SP2, the system got pretty good for most folks.
2. I've done four laptops on dual boot with XP and Ubuntu 6.06 LTS; seems to meet most folks needs. Interesting sidenote that most folks don't seem to know - ubuntu has a feature that allows re-partitioning of a hard drive (after defrag) without trashing all the contents of the drive... highly overdue, in my opinion.
3. I went Ubuntu after the fourth time in a month that Microsux demanded I re-register my XP. Only time I miss it, is when some of my friends send me .wmv's in my email.
4. Read an article about two years ago, that basically stated that the only thing that could release Microsux's "stranglehold" on the industry, was them... looks to me like they're in the process of that. I do some consulting work on the side, and in the last three months, have had at least five companies, that I set up with XP, ask me for proposals for sending them totally open-source... none of them want anything to do with Vista's new licensing/disabling scheme. Wake up, Microsoft; you lose the business sector, the X-Box better start taking more market share than it is.
5. By popular demand, I'm gonna shut up now
hagar

by neon samurai

Who Microsoft? Manipulative? Anticonsumer? Anticompetitive? Say it isn't so!

Hehe.. just yet another example in the long long history of Microsoft employing every dirty trick to manipulate the market and retain it's monopoly.

Here's my theory based on some ideas new to me; if I read correctly, 64bit hardware is now pretty much standard pending the market's natural selection of a software platform standard (once Dos, then win98, now winXP). Currently the contenders are Windows Vista in it's conveluted versions, osX or Linux. osX is starting to get alot more notice and is a very real contender in the race to become the 64bit standard OS. Linux came out of no where and continues to outpace osX and Vista in development evolution but may not yet be enough to take the average user's desktop/laptop market. Vista has launched to less than stellar acceptace with prohibitive end user license and software taxes. Microsoft is no stranger to using anything but product quality to compete though so we can expect a series of similar tricks along with at least a few more FUD marketing pushes in the next year or so.

- When MS Dos was king, win3.0 was only accepted as a pre-install as a way to get the underlying Dos at a discount.
- When Win3.11 was king, win95 was slow to catch on and that was after MS locked software vendors into a win95 explicit development contract then delayed win95 for a few years killing the smaller locked-in software developers that they had no interest in buying.
- WinXP was a fight again to get people off win98/winNT2k

That's just the major Windows versions excluding the increadable market successes like Microsoft BOB. Now, don't also forget that there is a huge winXP user base out there now who've paid there one time product purchase and expect ongoing tech support. A single sale product does not inspire ongoing technical support (outside of purchases support contracts). Last, in the eyes of a consumer, an older version is not worth buying when a newer shinny version is available. (I was given the example of the discount bind at any local software store.)

I suspect, Microsoft will do quite a bit of passive-agressive "curtailing" of winXP sales to premote Vista and try to reduce a long user base conversion period. I suspect also that they are in a hurry to leave the WindowsXP support desk business since winXP they won't be pushing sales of the OS for that initial big bang of income to cover ongoing support.

by brian.crawford

grow up, no difference than any business, when a products done it's done. when was the last time you could order/buy a new year 2000 vehicle or a 5year old TV

by bart99gt

I'm actually running Ubuntu as we speak.

I'm technically savvy enough to use Linux. I've gotten fairly comfortable with it so far as basic computer usage is concerned. However, there's no way I could hand a computer loaded with Linux to most of my family members though, and most of them aren't technically ignorant by any stretch.

Linux isn't ready for prime time yet. Its a heck of a lot better than it was even 2-3 years ago, but there are some important aspects of it that are still way over the head of your average computer user.

by jmgarvin

What is way over the head of average users?

I'm curious because the install is cake (Ubuntu installs from CD while your OS is still running) and everything is setup out of the box, including and office suite.

by deadly ernest

both have a very Windowsie like look and feel. Ubuntu uses the Gnome desktop by default, while SimplyMEPIS uses the KDE desktop by default. I've installed this on a few machines for some very tech illiterate people, and they've had no trouble switching over. Just ensure their commonly used programs are easy to find, ie desktop icons if possible - clicking on an icon is all they need to know.

by xnnyl76

RIGHT BEFORE XP CAME OUT I SAW WIN 98 AND ME ON THE SHELVES,BUT IMMEDIATELY AFTER XP CAME OUT,COULDNT FIND 98 OR ME ANYWHERE.I BELIEVE ITS ALL PART OF THE MS MONOPOLY.

by lalicea1

That's the Detail! That's why Mr. Gates has 47B reasons to be happy and to say "Because it's worth it."

by tig2

I always thought it was a "chick thing".

I simply politely observe that they have mistakenly shoved their head up their arses and offer reasonable assistance with the problem.

And call another vendor from the conference room. While they are still there.

But I am ALWAYS polite. No yelling.

by hal 9000

I continue to day to buy M$ DOS without a problem. Apparently M$ AU is selling about 50 copies per month without any support so actually M$ is still offering DOS as a product that they are selling and their Legal Department is encouraging this practise to continue.

As for the other Big dead OS that I support from M$ NT4 I'm forced to buy a copy of XP Pro and use the Backward License to install it though to be fair to M$ they did give me a CD & Product Key for NT4 when I pointed out that I needed this product for a specialised application that doesn't run on anything newer than NT4.

Provided that I keep buying XP Pro Licenses M$ doesn't give a dam how many times that I use the NT4 Install CD.

But I'm wondering what will happen when Vista finally becomes the Norm and what version I'll be forced to buy to install NT4 then and much more importantly How Much will it cost?

Col

by hal 9000

They charge you for the Laser Sighting equipment that goes on the Plant and all around the work site and then [b]Give You the Software[/b] that enables you to get the earthworks to within 2 cm's of the design.

Apparently this is for such a small market that they are no longer interested in supporting the software so maybe when I have the time I could Port it to Linux or something like that.

Or take the easy way out and just forget to tell M$ about it any more. :D

After all this is [b]On Site[/b] without any Internet Access so there are no security risks as it only drives the Laser equipment. The software now is a [b]Give Away[/b] to allow the continued sale of the laser equipment. The problem here is you can not buy what isn't made. :^0

But I would just love to be there when some Legal Git for M$ arrives to audit their software, being earthmover's they are likely to deck the guy then run over him in his car with a Big Excavator or Bulldozer and that's when they are being nice. If they get upset I'm sure they would want to see what was stronger 2 D10 Cats going in opposite directions or the Legal Git for M$ tied between the two dozer's. :0

At one of these places I was asked to look at a computer to repair it and it wasn't in the Site Office apparently the person who used it got slightly upset with it and parked a 40 ton excavator track on top of the tower. Of course they just said that they threw it out an failed to mention that there was this [b]Bloody Great Big Excavator[/b] currently sitting on top of it. :D

Col

by lalicea1

Since Windows became the most used OS in 1990's, I have always said that it's worthless to upgrade it. After it substituted DOS 6.22, one user yelled "GIVE ME MY DOS BACK!!". From Win95 to 98, it caused problems, from 98 to ME, it caused problems, from ME to XP, it caused problems.

Always, upgrade Windows have caused problems.

My Policy: NEVER UPGRADE WINDOWS. In my case, I bought a PIV 2.66G PC w/XP three yrs ago. I will keep it till my PC falls into "comma". Also I have no plans to upgrade Office XP Pro.

by w2ktechman

and mostly it is due to 3rd party programs, I agree completely. But it doesnt take only spyware/virus to break them either.

I was just pointing out that XP is not 'rock solid' unless sandstone was the solid rock tested.

that is true with all apps and OS's. Sorry about the misrepresent there.

by mjwx

:)

Maybe that's the problem, you're too polite. It might help if you yelled at your suppliers little bit.

by absolutely

[i]6 months later, those same folks were going on about how [b]XP really wasn't all that bad. [/b] Now its regarded to be probably the best OS MS has ever released.[/i]

The smallest turd that your neighbor's cat ever shat on your front doorstep is still no better than a turd, shat by [b]your neighbor's[/b] cat, on [b]your doorstep[/b].

When you factor in patches, including [b]"Critical Updates"[/b] -- aptly named, given the security breaches the original shipped versions of MS operating systems have all contained since 95 -- it's perfectly fair to say that "the Windows operating system [b]is delivered broken[/b]".

by hal 9000

It would be much better to say that M$ is still developing their product line known as Windows & Office and while still in the early Beta Stage will eventually manage to get it to work unless all their Beta Testers Desert them first and go with something that just works and stop paying M$ for the Beta Product and then for the Technical Support to fix the Broken Software. :p

Col
[i]Edited[/i] because the MS Keyboard needs new batteries again and refuses to put the letter SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS s up when I want it to Upper case No Problems but Lower Case if works maybe one in 10 attempts. :(

by w2ktechman

just wireless.
I have an HP wireless keyboard and it refuses to type E or r (upper case E lower case r) without several attempts. I think it is just a wireless issue with them. It also happens randomly on other letters, and it will always delay the n when typing 'and' (it will always show as adn) and the h the 'the' (shows as teh). I have slowed these words down and paid close attention, and I do type it correctly. Considering it is not a problem on my non-wireless keyboard, I just attributed it to an issue with that wireless keyboard.

by hal 9000

It's was given to me by M$ for being such a nice person and for once not wearing the T Shirt that Reads [i]"In a World without Walls or Fences who needs Windows & Gates"[/i] to a Partners meeting. Or something like that anyway, it's actually the fourth one that I've had because they keep breaking well the first 2 times the mouse was the problem then the Keyboard broke a couple of times so in the last year it's been replaced 4 times now.

Actually it's a pity that Rickk's not around because I could say that M$ doesn't have any Vista Drivers for this product which is the current model or for the Fingerprint reader that I have on the NB again another Microsoft Branded product that comes with a M$ Branded driver CD. :D

Actually if it did the same thing all the time it wouldn't be quite so bad but as it's an interment it drives me crazy. It also adds the wrong letter as I go along and I quite often see adn instead of and or teh instead of the. Things like that which it does itself. Of course when I want to type Teh it spits up the as that is a Surgeons name that I go to and do some work for and the sod insists that if it's not his name on the invoice he doesn't need to pay, but when his own computer spits out an invoice with his name spelt wrong and replaced with the instead of Teh he still wants to get paid. :^0

Col

by absolutely

Their 'Wireless Desktop Elite' keyboard + mouse has been much more reliable for me than Logitech's competing set, which I returned because:
(1) the mouse would not work more than about 30cm from the wireless receiver
(2) the wireless receiver, although nifty in re-charging the mouse while not in use, was an annoying, clunky monstrosity that I didn't want on my desk
(3) Logitech's forum was full of even worse complaints than I experienced while owning that set for ~1 month.

That said, I think that Microsoft has a demonstrated track record of using their enormous financial resources to provide products that are [b]just barely[/b] better in performance than their nearest competitor, squishing that competitor, then providing TOTAL CRAP to The Market. I feel guilty for spending [b]any[/b] of my $$ on Microsoft whenever there is a competitor to Microsoft in the same market.

Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts,

by stanj.miranda9

Where have you looked,because i just checked newegg.com and they have it,as well as tiger direct,zipzoomfly, & mwave.This is XP Pro,and they have the full versions ,and they also have the OEMs.You couldn't have looked to hard.

by deiceray

No, when I looked, there was no XP on tiger, or many others, including Circuit City, Best Buy, etc.. I think MS persuaded vendors to clear the shelves for vi$ta; things may have changed since the release, maybe a few people at MS came to their senses and realized a wider product selection made for a much more receptive marketplace. We'll see. So I guess you came into the discussion a little late. I'm glad to hear one way or the other some improvement has been made.

by w2ktechman

They started showing up again recently. Right after Vista was released, XP was hard to come by except the OEM versions.
After about a week, the OEM's got easier to find, but it took some time for the full versions to appear again, except on the microsoft.com website, where XP in all forms was still available.

by keith

Micrsoft has little to do with the disappearance of XP other than developing a newer version. The decision to suddenly quit stocking XP is up to the dealers. There is still stock out there (now NOS)all you need to do is look for it.

by deiceray

I would suggest that the ONLY entity that can influence the presence or absence of MS's products is Microsoft. The American system of commerce has never been and isn't based on restricting the consumer's choices. If that were the case, we'd have no need for labeling or branding; there'd be one Milk, one Bread, and one Beer. There may be an issue with shelf availability, but let's be real about this, the free market demands that as many products as are available to display for sale ARE displayed. No, it was MS; read back through the thread and you'll see others saying exactly the same thing.

by deadly ernest

at one point they weren't shipping copies of XP to fill orders, as they wanted the stores to run out and sell only Vista. To support this they stopped providing a lot of the special quantity discounts they used to give with XP, as they now apply them to Vista only. All part of their campaign to get shops to stop selling XP.

DELL and HP had no XP models available when Vista was first released. They had large numbers of calls and Internet requests where people wanted new boxes with XP. They said 'Sorry Vista only.' The clients said 'Sorry, no sale, we go elsewhere.' Only then did they push MS to allow them to use the XP disc to sell XP machines. But you can't buy an XP machines from their resellers, only off their Internet site.

by deiceray

Thanks for the confirmation! I knew that was the case, but what would the world be without the doubting Thomases? I've taken that role myself; it's a social lesson - whether you believe what you read or not. Sometimes I wonder just how "free" the free market system is. I think this is just a small example of the distortions that can occur in this economy, and it may be one of the last, as the world economy continues to exert increasing and real pressure on the economic behemoths that are used to dominating. Technology will continue to accelerate faster than economic systems can adapt to them. It's a fascinating time, eh?

by deadly ernest

In the past strong regional economies could buffer a monopolist against wider economic trends, but that buffer is weakening daily. Also, more of the bigger players are starting to learn a world wide economy means a major issue in another part of the world will affect them directly, where as it didn't used to.

MS is currently suffering from financial downturns in Europe and Asia, so they're using the old style system to try and tie their older markets closer to them. When what they should be doing is loosening the strings and wooing new markets. They're making the very same mistakes the people they were in opposition to when they started did, and forgetting the very practices that made them grow in the first place.

The question may well come down to how many USA congressmen and senators the USA Big Business can buy and how well they can pressure other countries into accepting their business rules. Time will tell.

by apotheon

"[i]Microsoft doesn't call the shots, and if said retailers really want to sell XP, Microsoft will gladly sell them more licenses.[/i]"

Imagine for a moment that Microsoft wants to sell Vista, instead of XP (this is obviously the case). Now imagine for a moment that you're a retailer. Where are you going to get copies of XP to sell if you want to sell them, but Microsoft doesn't want you to do so? What are you going to do about shrinking profits on Vista, as well, if Microsoft doesn't give you the same (lower) wholesale prices because you won't replace the XP stock on your shelves with Vista?

Are you entirely unaware of how the software industry actually works (particularly when dealing with the major software vendors, like Microsot)?