Discussion Locked

Is It OUTRAGEOUS or is it just ME?

0 helpful
330 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

330 replies

by apotheon

That's a fact of life -- sometimes, you simply cannot escape a particular OS (or OS family). While the reasons for this necessity are often asinine and absurd (in short, they are [i]bad reasons[/i]), that's not the fault of the people who are required to use that specific OS in order to effectively participate in the business niche they call home. I'd never consider deriding someone's choice of using a given OS for reasons of such a limitation, assuming that limitation is actually a practical one in that case.

As far as I'm aware, there are cases where standardizing on MS Windows for AutoCAD and related applications qualify as such a situation. Nobody's stupid for making the choice to use MS Windows for AutoCAD, that being the case. Of course, the point where that's still a [i]bad reason[/i] is the point where Autodesk does not support more platforms than MS Windows. It doesn't matter what platform is needed for an application, what OS it calls home, if the application in question isn't designed for a purpose specific to that OS (such as a Microsoft Windows specific system cleanup utility, or a Unix specific network layer stateful firewall), limiting your application to a single platform/OS is a piss-poor choice. Autodesk make that kind of piss-poor choice, clearly. The same would be true if AutoCAD were a Linux-only application, or a FreeBSD-only application, or a MacOS-only application.

"[i]Why don't you tap into your vast Anti-Microsoft knowledge base and enlighten me as to which operating system will better support MY application (any Autodesk product) than Microsoft.[/i]"

None, as far as I know. That has (almost) nothing to do with what I said before. I think you're reading a bit more into what I said previously than was actually there, and for the extent to which that was the fault of the way I phrased things I apologize. I see now that I did take a rather fast and loose approach to composing my initial response to you. On the other hand, you probably shouldn't be surprised at the tone of my initial response, considering I was replying to statements of yours that essentially imply that Microsoft is all good, and those of us who disagree with that must be dumb or malevolent.

"[i]A big difference between other "IT Professionals" and me is that I don't consider technology (or an operating system) the ends in itself, but rather the means to an end.[/i]"

Same here. It just happens to be a means I prefer to enjoy the experience of employing. It's also worth noting that one can employ the means of a technology such as an operating system toward more than one end at the same time.

"[i]And quite frankly, I've come to see the "Linux-Type Gurus" (the ONLY Microsoft alternative) in a similar light as I see the liberal elitist snobs who think they're more "enlightened" than the rest of the population. Well, you can take your elitist attitude and shove it![/i]"

The fact that they have different preferences in OS don't make them Democrats. In fact, I'm inclined to think that open source software is a more purely free market capitalist thing in either a libertarian or anarchist (depending on your perspective) sense, and the very socialism-reminiscent culture of the Free Software Foundation is equivalent in open source circles to the way the Left in US politics has "stolen" the term "liberal" from those who once did the term credit. Unfortunately, the term "liberal" in this country is now so thoroughly tainted that even people who would once have been considered liberals (and, at best, might be described as embodying "classical liberalism" now) use the term "liberal" to refer to the collectivist Left, which in turn considers such "classical liberals" to be ultra-conservative. Similarly, the Free Software Foundation and its strong lunatic fringe is trying to eclipse the positive aspects of the "natural" and free (in the sense of liberty) state of software with its own twisted left-wingnut ideology.

If the software industry is an information economy, open source software is free market capitalism within that economy, the FSF is the pack of social democrats at the door, and Microsoft is the totalitarian fascist[1] establishment. I'd appreciate it if you were able to differentiate between free market capitalists like myself and social democrats like Richard Stallman.

"[i](And if you thought I was "smarter than that", well, too friggin' bad -- up yours, you snob.)[/i]"

I referred specifically to your suggestion that Microsoft is the be-all and end-all of virtuous IT industry success when I said that. It always strikes me as odd that someone (like yourself) who clearly has his heart in the right place as regards free market capitalism is apparently unaware that corporatism in the US market economy is in fact a pervasive and corrupting influence by "managed economy" regulators in government that feeds upon itself as a vicious cycle of spreading corruption in the market. The words "business" and "corporation" should never be conflated, but at least 98% of the US is unable to separate the two concepts -- it's a cultural bias that would surely prove immensely difficult for [i]anyone[/i] to overcome.

[1] By "fascist" I mean the denotative meaning of the term -- an intermingling of authoritarian governmental and economic power, where private business interests and government are interwoven to produce the dominant power structure. That is, in essence, the very definition of a corporatist state.

(edit: I forgot to add the footnote the first time.)

by apotheon

When a given business centers around a given application, it's sometimes for a very good reason. AutoCAD is one of those applications that is typically linked with a very good reason for building the business around a single application.

The problem is that, having made the decision to build a business model around it, most people then continue to extend the necessary software for that application into every aspect of business without even thinking about it. It's actually the case that most companies whose entire business model is dependent upon AutoCAD could probably realize huge improvements in profitability and efficiency by using MS Windows for AutoCAD and certain other specific functions, but other OSes for the rest of their IT infrastructure. People really don't seem inclined by nature to consider the possibility of a heterogeneous platforms infrastructure, however, and as such completely miss the benefits of unixlike OSes for tool development, file serving, routers and firewalls, mail servers, and so on -- and even the benefits of something like MacOS X for design work.

Even worse, they fail to realize that a certain amount of diversification may be valuable even in their core business application choices. While AutoCAD may be the only application that provides precisely the benefits a company needs for its main business niche, that in no way prevents the company from diversifying the application choices for related, but somewhat different, tasks that may exist on the fringes of that niche when other applications may be better suited to the task. While this is in many cases unlikely to yield immediate benefits, it usually doesn't introduce real difficulties either, and may in some worst-case scenario future circumstance provide the company with greater resiliency (such as in response to Autodesk ceasing to provide exactly what the company needs, or Microsoft's platform ceasing to be a viable option).

Since corporate business models are based around the near-term quarterly performance metric, however, rather than a continuous and complete picture of advancement of the business model, that's only to be expected.

(edit: This was posted from FreeBSD 6.2 -- neither MS Windows nor a Linux distribution.)

by maxwell edison

.....that I saw "Linux-Type Gurus" as "Democrats", but rather their attitude as a "know better than everybody else" paints them in a similar light as elitist snobs. I see them with similar attitudes; their political preference is irrelevant.

by rkuhn040172

I'm in the engineering and construction business too, like Maxwell, and for you to say that there "may" be something else out there is a joke.

You say we "may" find something. Good luck!

Try replacing AutoDesk products, Vertex or our ERP software. Try replacing the tight integration we have between our ERP software and AutoDesk products.

Try converting all those thousands upon thousands of files for compatibility, try telling all of our contractors that we've changed software so now they must too.

Dude, you live in a dream world! While many of your technical arguments may be sound, you are delusional and simply underestimate the complexity of the real world.

by w2ktechman

that I know nothing about autodesk suite. I pointed out that you 'may find' an alternate product to work, not that you 'would' find it , or that there was a better one for your needs. That is what research is for. But the point was merely that options are not a bad thing. And that being 'stuck' on 1 company for everything can be a problem in itself.

I'll also agree to Rickks point that conversions suck. And switching can be a real hassle. And while switching, lots of 'conversion problems' appear. That is why researching is also important. But, sometime down the road an option may work out. But if you dont look around or browse, then you truly are stuck.

Maybe I did not post it well, or get the point across well enough. I did not tell you to change anything, just pointed out my opinion. Since you did not like it, fine. I really dont care. but your last post DID sound a lot like Rickk's posts, which are usually a cry of desparation to get anyone to listen to him.

posted from pclinuxos

by maxwell edison

By the tone of your message, you seemed to assume two things: one, that I have not done any (or enough) research into available applications for my industry, and two, that I would actually find something as a suitable substitute for what I currently support. Both assumptions are incorrect. If anything, you should have assumed the exact opposite. But then again, you also suggested that you didn't think I was very smart. In this case, I'd bet a dollar to dirt that I know just a little more about it than you.

by maxwell edison

I think you took my message differently than I intended. Perhaps it was my poor writing, or my poor choice of words, or my failure to write pages upon pages to clarify everything I said. But I never suggested (or intended to suggest) that Microsoft (either the company or its products) was the greatest thing since the preverbal slice of bread. I only suggested that the bad things about Microsoft pale in comparison to the good things that have come about as a result of the company's success -- at least in my opinion.

I've discovered that it's an effort in futility to discuss religion or atheism with either type of fanatic; and it's equally futile to discuss Microsoft with one who simply hates the company. Some idiot in a message above asked (I'm paraphrasing) when Bill Gates would have enough money! Like he's doing it for the money! Discussing Microsoft with such ignorance is something I should probably avoid, just like I won't discuss religion with the likes of Mr. Miami.

Anyway, let me use an analogy to illustrate one of my points. To the millions upon millions of "global warming" fanatics who want to force the auto industry to change its oil burning ways, so to speak, I simply tell them that they are such a huge force, that if it was possible, that they, themselves, should just STFU and create a whole new type of auto industry to compete with the "Big Three". (Of course, they then launch into some conspiracy theory argument!) Likewise, if Microsoft is SO BAD, then the people complaining about it should come up with a viable product to compete with them. But they don't. (And they, too, then launch into their own version of a conspiracy theory.)

Do I think Microsoft is perfect? No, of course not. Do I have to jump through some hoops from time to time? Sure I do. But it's the nature of the industry. And I'd have to do those things REGARDLESS of which product I used for whatever purpose. It's just the way it is. Some people simply focus on complaining about problems. Others focus on resolving them. And the more focus spent on complaining, the less is spent on resolving. And personally speaking, I believe that on balance, Microsoft has been a positive force for our industry, and a positive force for our economy. And I actually do hope a viable alternative does surface. Competition is a good thing. In the meantime, I'm using the best product(s) available to achieve my own desired ends. And to spend even one second "complaining" about what I have to do to make it happen is counterproductive. So why do it?

by w2ktechman

"I thought that you were smarter than that
Although I dont agree with you too often, you seem knowledgeable. But this last post was a cry of desparation, something I would have more expected from, say, Rickk!"

Did I say that I thought you were not smart?
Honestly, I have read many of your posts, and although I oft. disagree with you, you usually do a good job of it and think it out well. Sorry, I did not mean to imply anything else about your intelligence other than that rant of a post that I did not expect from you.

As for the "assumption", you are again incorrect. I never assumed that you had not, I was just explaining my previous post better. What I said was
"I'll admit that I know nothing about autodesk suite. I pointed out that you 'may find' an alternate product to work, not that you 'would' find it"
and
"I'll also agree to Rickks point that conversions suck. And switching can be a real hassle. And while switching, lots of 'conversion problems' appear. That is why researching is also important. But, sometime down the road an option may work out. But if you dont look around or browse, then you truly are stuck."

These were explanations of my previous post. I do not see 'tone' in them, just some typed words to correct my point that I was intending, that apparently was stated poorly enough for mis-communucation.

I also do not doubt that you do know more about your business than I do, so I am not going to go there at all. If you think that I was just trying to attack you, you are mistaken, I was just trying to point out a few things, like the unusual post by you, but apparently failed miserably. So, in this case, I will stop posting comments on this issue completely.

by maxwell edison

[i] ?So, in this case, I will stop posting comments on this issue completely?[/i]

Perhaps I should follow your lead.

Like I said to apotheon, there?s no point in discussing a difference of opinion and/or a difference of perspective on subjects of religion, evolution versus creationism, or Microsoft bashing. I crashed their pity party in a lame attempt to show the positive light in which Microsoft ?could? be seen, but to no avail. If people don?t want to see it, then they won?t see it. There?s absolutely no point in me trying to convince them that Microsoft is not the devil they loath. Some people pursue some beliefs religiously ? religion, global warming, and Microsoft loathing. I should learn to leave them alone when they throw a pity party.

by apotheon

Your use of the term "pity party" is as likely to make people think you have good intentions and ability to reason about anything objectively about as much as rickk's ridiculous abuse of the term "zealot".

by apotheon

Sometimes, you just have to get out of your comfortable old butt-molded office chair if you want to improve your health. Don't get stuck in a Microsoft rut, believing you're living in the best of all possible worlds just because it seemed like the best of all possible worlds when you first moved into it.

"[i]I've discovered that it's an effort in futility to discuss religion or atheism with either type of fanatic; and it's equally futile to discuss Microsoft with one who simply hates the company.[/i]"

Perhaps people who have a problem with the way Microsoft does business have problems with the way you talk about it not just because they're "fanatics" who disagree with you, but because you say things that lump everyone together, compares them with fanatics, and implies that they "simply hate" Microsoft. There are very real, very reasonable reasons to object to Microsoft's business practices, but you dismiss them by generalizing about people who find Microsoft objectionable, just as you dismiss their complaints about the quality of MS software, without bothering to find out anything much about the reasons for their dislike.

I don't "simply hate" Microsoft, for instance. I find the ethical basis for Microsoft's business model reprehensible at best, but it's sort of a default way of doing business under the current mixed economy circumstances -- that alone is not enough to make me decide that Microsoft is the Devil (or whatever religious analogy you're trying to fit to my thoughts on the matter today). Sometimes, we just have to live in the world in which we find ourselves, and as long as you don't actively make things worse, participation in the ongoing problems of the system in place isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Of course, that's not what Microsoft does. Microsoft is up to its elbows in actively making things worse. It gets better, though: the way Microsoft handles bug reports, security vulnerabilities, new product roll-outs, marketing, and essentially everything else it does is pretty unpleasant for us as its customer base, and many of us have simply decided to cease lowering our standards every time Microsoft (implicitly) asks us to do so.

Sometimes, people like you imply that the only reason some of us dislike Microsoft is its success as a corporate business enterprise, as though we're acting out of envy or some bizarre left-wingnut "hate the bourgeois corporate masters" ideology. It's a little like the whole "they envy our way of life" attempt to explain away Muslim terrorism -- facile, overly general, and inaccurate. Oh, sure, there are probably a few people like that (in fact, I've met a couple), but in general that's not the problem people have with Microsoft. By the same token, I might claim that you just worship business success at all costs, but I don't do so because I refuse to make the same mistakes with regard to generalizing your motivations that you do with regard to mine and others who choose to avoid Microsoft software, or who simply prefer some alternative to it and try to explain that in a discussion like this.

. . . and if all that isn't your intent when you start using terms like "pity party" and "fanatic", you should [b]stop talking as though that is your intent[/b].

"[i]Some idiot in a message above asked (I'm paraphrasing) when Bill Gates would have enough money! Like he's doing it for the money![/i]"

I found that a little silly, too. Notice I've never used that "argument", and have never agreed with it. I generally choose to avoid responding to it at all, just as I often choose to avoid many of the more insipid comments made by pro-Microsoft fanboys. Unlike you, however, I do my reasonable utmost to avoid giving any impression that I'm generalizing from the single example of someone saying something like "Doesn't Bill have enough money yet?" to encompass everyone with whom I disagree.

"Likewise, if Microsoft is SO BAD, then the people complaining about it should come up with a viable product to compete with them. But they don't. (And they, too, then launch into their own version of a conspiracy theory.)[/i]"

Actually, people have come up with viable alternatives already. I'm using one right now, called FreeBSD. An interesting thing about these viable alternatives is that they were not created as alternatives -- they were created for their own sake, and they worked out excellently well. There are reasons that Microsoft's offerings have come to dominate certain market niches, and those reasons are largely unrelated to the fitness of MS software for the needs of those market niches. The fact that certain corporations standardize their product lines on a Microsoft platform is unfortunate and sometimes unavoidable as a result of Microsoft's dominance of those market niches -- market dominance tends to be self-supporting, and is a difficult nut to crack. That doesn't mean viable alternatives do not exist in the general case, or that viable alternatives in the specific case of something like AutoCAD will never arise.

"[i]Some people simply focus on complaining about problems. Others focus on resolving them.[/i]"

Some of us prefer to focus on solving problems, but have to point out the problem at great, and exhaustive, length before anyone will admit that there's a problem to be solved.

"[i]And personally speaking, I believe that on balance, Microsoft has been a positive force for our industry, and a positive force for our economy.[/i]"

Even if that was true at one time -- which is a dubious claim, but not one that is necessarily false -- it certainly isn't any longer. Failing to take notice of the "big picture" enough to recognize this fact because of a long tradition of seeing the world through Microsoft colored lenses is not the same as examining and analyzing circumstances clearly and with attention to detail only to find that Microsoft is a great benefit. By the same token, while Richard Stallman did a great service for ideas of liberation of the developer and end user from overly restrictive copyright law by putting them on the map, he did so through radical, extreme practices that have come to be considerably less beneficial, and even actively detrimental. This happened because Stallman was wrong about some things from the very start, and with great zeal and commitment refuses to recognize that fact. Bill Gates, similarly, was wrong to pursue certain business practices -- ethically wrong. If those practices initially led to positive outcomes, that doesn't excuse the practices, nor does it guarantee that they'll always lead to positive outcomes (and, in fact, their outcomes just get worse with every passing year).

by absolutely

"New & Improved" is so often a misnomer that its primary role in the popular lexicon is satirical.

[i]If many people had their way, or so it seems, we'd still be computing with an 8086 processor with 64 KB of RAM running DOS version 4.0. Moreover, look at the all the industries and companies (including CNet and TechRepublic) that have thrived as a result, offering support, information, training, and such.[/i]

OK, I'm looking, and I'm not saying that IT is terrible across the boards as it is. But, I am saying that there are numerous legitimate cases to be made that both the hardware and the software technologies might have been more advantageously leveraged in a market less dominated by one entity. Should the government cause such a change? Probably not. Should the government [i]allow[/i] such a change, by leaving well enough alone wherever possible? That would be enjoyable to see.

My perspective on the last 15 years of the IT industry is that it has been geared excessively to video games, causing important advances in materials science, and probably also in intelligent coding algorithms, to be ignored in favor of fps. What a friggin' waste!

by absolutely

color you want -- as long as it's black!

Crap, this joke is so obvious, methinks Bill did that on purpose, as a sort of middle finger to us all, as he begins his retirement.

by absolutely

Of course. Like any customer, you purchase what is best for your intended purpose, which you know best.

I'm thinking back to DOS 6.0, and my vague recollection that I could use DOS 6.0 on the same system that ran Windows 3.11 for Workgroups. It occurs to me that at least one option was available to Microsoft, at that time, which wasn't taken, which is to "pick one" -- DOS with a GUI interface, or the path that eventually [i]was[/i] chosen, to the NT kernel.

Other things being assumed equal, a fundamentally sound operating system would only need to be slightly extended, say to include Universal Serial Bus, Firewire, Fast Ethernet and wireless protocols. Linux/Unix fits this description. On the other hand, a fundamentally [i]flawed[/i] operating system, with essentially nothing going for it other than what had been lifted from Xerox, would need to be overhauled, repeatedly. Microsoft fits [b]this[/b] description. [As merely a casual observer of Apple, their use of varying kernels, combined with pioneering the GUI for home/workstation PCs defies description!]

My estimate is that your applications Absolutely Required hardware advances, but that any of the three major players in the operating system market (Apple, Microsoft, Unix/Linux/GNU -- maybe that's 4+ ?) have/had the [i]potential[/i] to accomodate those applications. If Microsoft is the only provider of the environment for the CAD software you Absolutely Require, then your decision is made. But realistically, if that is the case, it is so because Microsoft first dominated the OS market, then CAD software makers focused on MS, not because MS is the only maker of an operating system with the [i]potential[/i] to accommodate the algorithms required for computer aided drafting. Any operating system can use floating point arithmetic, and provide the same end result to you. This leaves us with an interesting abstract discussion, with more concrete socioeconomic implications, about different operating system models. Modularity built around a robust, minimalistic kernel has a lot going for it.

I have no plans to storm into your shop and format your Windows partitions and install my favorite open source operating system. But, IT pros with our eyes on the Absolute Fullest utilization of the existing hardware and software for maximum productive value see some shortcomings in Windows operating systems, and ask legitimate questions about how such a kludge comes to control > 50% of its market. They are interesting questions. Nobody is holding a gun to your head and forcing you to consider them.

by rkuhn040172

Thanks for the "abstract discussion, with more concrete socioeconomic implications", but everything you said doesn't change the situation at hand.

You may have the time and get paid to sit around and contemplate the history of the PC industry, the socioeconomic implications, and other abstraction discussions.

But I spend my time and get paid to come up with solutions for problems. Thanks for the history lesson though :)

by travisfx

a question. Yes. And it very well may be the key to the survival of debate such as this, It is:
Is it correct to say;

"I couldn't give a r@ts @ss"

OR

"I could give a r@ts @ss"

I'm sure for millenia, this has been pondered, debated upon and quite likely shelved due to general lack of consensus.

I vote for the first;
"I couldn't give a r@ts @ss"
It just sounds better, doesn't it?
How could you "GIVE a r@ts @ss" anyway?
How incredibly rare might one be to obtain?

But then again, in order for the first to be valid, you would have to have a r@ts @ss in the first place in order for you to profess that the issue is not even worthy of this useless, disgusting item! Wow eh?
You see the problem?
I admit, its not easy. And so it remains.
What do you think? :)

by deadly ernest

gathering of politicians and you'll be knee deep in rats of various breeds, or you can go to a major garbage dump to find some cleaner types of rats, the cleanest are at your nearest drug testing lab.

by maxwell edison

.....and the answer is couldn't. You couldn't give.....

You can't give that which you do not have. You could give something you do have. If you have no interest in an issue, you have no interest to give -- you couldn't care less.

In this case, unless you do have an ample supply of rat's asses, you couldn't give any of those either.

by w2ktechman

then you 'could' give it. As in
I could give a rats a$$, but I will not
or
I could give a ras a$$, but I do not care enough

But then again, your way sounds better

by absolutely

[i]Thanks for the "abstract discussion, with more concrete socioeconomic implications", but everything you said doesn't change the situation at hand.

You may have the time and get paid to sit around and contemplate the history of the PC industry, the socioeconomic implications, and other abstraction discussions.

But I spend my time and get paid to come up with solutions for problems.[/i]

Were you standing when you posted that, or do you, in fact, also have plenty of time to "sit around and contemplate the history of the PC industry, the socioeconomic implications, and other abstraction discussions"? If your time is truly devoted to profitable pursuit of solutions to problems, by all means, prove it: go away. If, on the other hand, you continue posting, you disprove your own assertion. That's your choice.

by absolutely

I lean toward apotheon's perspective, although my use of the computer is more similar to maxwell edison's. Oh well.

[i]Perhaps people who have a problem with the way Microsoft does business have problems with the way you talk about it not just because they're "fanatics" who disagree with you, but because you say things that lump everyone together, compares them with fanatics, and implies that they "simply hate" Microsoft. There are very real, very reasonable reasons to object to Microsoft's business practices, but you dismiss them by generalizing about people who find Microsoft objectionable, just as you dismiss their complaints about the quality of MS software, without bothering to find out anything much about the reasons for their dislike.[/i]

As an end user, I would find Windows useful, if it didn't break at the drop of a hat.

by gwa

Hi, I have just bought new Toshiba laptop for work and found problems with Vista immidiatelly. Spent 8hrs trying to sort out with Microsoft Update etc and then ran out of time and patience. I dropped the machine off at specialsist to see if they could put XP on the machine but it seems that these new machines have been made in such a way that this is very difficult, mainly as the drivers which would make this possible are either no longer available or seem not to work ??.
My only option now is to put this new machine on ebay and buy older XP laptop or Macbook. I've had it with Microsoft.

by deadly ernest

of Ubuntu or Kubuntu Linux as they have many generic drivers that often work. No guarantees, but it may save you losing money on the deal.

This discussion is closed to new replies.