ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
I know that you expend far too many rounds on our friend, meaning, instead, to address the larger community.
I know, also, that you need to address your avatar in your newish role. I mean, duct tape?
No longer appropriate.
One of the items that opponents of the current bill wanted addressed - in addition to a slew of others - was to eliminate the mandated coverage that policies had to include (which differs state to state).
Pregnancy isn't the only one. Perhaps you don't drink or do drugs. But in case you ever do, you're covered for chemical dependency treatment as well, thanks to state and/or federal mandates.
Well, he supports Obama, the democrats in Congress, and you.
Birds of a feather, or so it's said, makes this look an awful lot like socialism.
Yep, Fidel sure knows what top-notch medical care should be like - and it's free! And they get to drive all those neat classic cars to the clinics.
The US attitude to the Cuban regime is about as intelligent as the US's attitude to Israel.
And that's not very.
.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WgKDyNPM9M
I actually agree with President Obama that insurance companies shouldn't be put in the driver's seat. I've been saying that all along.
But I also don't want government in the driver's seat.
I want the consumer to be back in the driver's seat.
Who do you want driving?
by jck
Your state or local government already collects all that money for those plans?
Seriously, Tony. Google it sometime how many claims the people of the State of Ohio files with Medicare and Medicaid per year, the disbursements the federal government has to handle, etc.
Your state, and no one else's state, is going to just throw all that work on their current infrastructure.
And, it's too much of a workload for any one director/czar/secretary to oversee along with another department.
They will be forced to create a new division or branch of your government, and put a whole hierarchy of management in above the workers needed to actually process the work.
So, yours and every other state that would do that would be participating in a voluntarily wasteful act by creating unnecessary, broader management level positions for each state and still disbursing and handling the work that a single entity with a single management structure does now.
Your idea...would be incredibly wasteful.
Sorry. But if you're so about saving tax dollars, you'd be against something that creates unnecessary bureaucracy and expenditure.
by jck
If someone's participation in Medicaid to get healthcare is forcing you to participate, then your driving on interstate highways and US Government funded highways is just as much.
You haven't paid for all the infrastructure that you use.
And before you go saying medical infrastructure isn't a necessary part of the system, remember places like the CDC and NIH are part of that.
If it's not necessary to give someone a flu vaccine or check them for a heart attack or do an emergency appendectomy to them, then it's unnecessary to provide you with the security of knowing someone keeps vaccines for haunta, smallpox, measels, etc., on the ready and watches for communicable outbreaks.
And really as others have said recently: if you're not happy with the system, you can always leave and go somewhere else where you are more facilitated in your beliefs.
Personally? I've tried to leave America. I've worked since I was 11. I have worked enough that I can file at 67 and get a full SSA pension. I'd be better off going to another country, working 20 years, and retiring with a 2nd pension and live comfortably after that.
But, companies in other countries don't want to wait 2-3 months for me to arrive. Hence, I'm still stuck here.
But, I'm not leaving because I pay my share like everyone else (except the impoverished, or the wealthy who buy their way out of paying) to contribute to the system.
I want to leave because government gives industry and the wealthy power to manipulate the working class, and force upon them ethics and standards that they themselves refuse to conform to or simply ignore.
I want to go somewhere that, when I work a 10 hour day to get a project implemented without taking 40 people offline that it's appreciated.
Here? It's not. And, I have proof of that now from the last 3 jobs I've had. Co-workers appreciated me, but my bosses always asked more from me even when I'd gone to great lengths to give them their desired results.
Sorry, but there's only so much sleep I will go without and so much effort I'll do for a set amount of compensation.
Talk about being treated like a slave.
by jck
[i]"A greater good" is an illusory concept. It is an imaginary creature, conjured up by a spoiled child who jumps up and down screaming until it gets its way.[/i]
I'm sure that's how King George III saw the American colonists who revolted.
by jascc1
....is that this is not some IT Project that you should 'phase' out over time.
There are people who are dying everyday. You should not take life/death matters in a 'phased' approach if there is a very valid way to help NOW.
Obama is making a very valid attempt to help people NOW.
I'm sure most of the folks against his plan are already insured in some way, so of course it is of no consequence to you all.
Please show me one person who does NOT have healthcare who is complaining about this.
by jck
A) Obama is not writing the legislation, including the earmarks that were so ridiculously attempted.
B) Yes, his promise of getting healthcare for everyone was important. But, so was his promise of "total transparency" which has usually happened with his White House, but not with his party members in Congress. He should have chided Pelosi, Reed, and their ranks for not following his lead to discuss things openly.
C) The shenanigans that go on with politics in government: The longer that it draws out, the more time the special interests, big business, and other politicos have to get access to members of Congress and convince them (one way or the other) to do their "bidding".
I still think the best thing we could do is vote in your local farmer, barber, trash guy, housewife, auto mechanic, etc., and get all the lawyers out of there and put working-class Americans in office for a change.
by tonythetiger
[i]Obama is making a very valid attempt to help people NOW. [/i]
of the rules don't start for 4 years? There is no valid health-related reason to wait, so why? It's not money, they can always just print some more, so why?
Could it be that he knows the negative consequences will outweigh the positive ones and wants to make sure he's out of the line of shrapnel range when the bomb goes off?
I overheard someone say that Joe Biden was two-thirds right when he said it was a "big f-ing deal".
by jascc1
....or do you know someone who can't get treated because of lack of insurance?
I would like to hear someone who DOES not have health insurance complain about how this new plan is unfair, un-constituional, blah blah.
Clearly you naysayers take for granted the fact that you don't have to worry about not having medical insurance.
Maybe it's not 100% perfect but it's 100% in the right direction.
Tell me what National Law/Policy that is 100% perfect and in which no one in this nation has some gripe about.
This is life or death people. Unfortunately, you naysayers only see the financials involved.
by puppybreath
And using your reasoning only people in the military or with family in the military should discuss military spending or policies.
That would eiminate quite a few naysayers, don't you think?
by jmgarvin
You should never call the fire department, the police, use public roads, or go to the doctor in you are unemployed.
The argument is silly...the socialism crap has to go...Why aren't you complaining about the VA or medicare?
I can go to the VA if I need to. That's socialized medicine. As a matter of fact, my dad goes to the VA (socialized medicine) to get care for things that medicare (socialized medicine) doesn't cover. He gets free pills (socialized medicine) and had free podiatric surgery (socialized medicine), but nobody is complaining about that.
You can't pick on this bill without picking on all the socialized medicine we already have. However, that is EXACTLY what you are doing.
by jascc1
by tonythetiger
there are millions of different ones, all of them starting with, "The way I see it,"
The truth is, it cannot be defined, because we cannot see the future. We can see what doesn't work without truly understanding why, and think some sort of "opposite" is the way to fix it. Since the opposite of the opposite ends up being the same, history repeats.
by jck
No state is forced to participate. Period.
Federal medical subsidizing is like playing baseball. You play by the rules and you get to participate.
So, your issue should be at the state level since your state *chooses* to participate. Shame on you for spending all those tax dollars!
But have no fear! Your worries are over in Ohio.
Medicaid/Medicare will take care of the sick and infirmed nationally, and the US government can (by heeding your request) cut off all your state medical program funds and you can have about another 12,000 unemployed state medical workers too and no medical funding from the US government to vaccinate, treat, and maintain the weak, elderly, and poor.
Sound good? If not, think of it this way. Cheap, local-style burial in a cheap casket 1 time is cheaper than paying for their treatment...right?
*rolls eyes*
by jck
Is that the London Bridge, The Bridges of Madison County, or the Bridge over the River Kwai?
Please have title ready for the property. I'm interested. I'm going to live under the bridge and troll around. :^0
Just wait and see. It saves money, you should write a written apology to Democrats in Congress by hand, and deliver a copy to each of them.
Well, all except Pelosi. She irks me. She's 180'ed since she became speaker.
by tonythetiger
[i]No longer appropriate. [/i]
"the way I see it," it fits now as much as ever. My role is that of a fixer. It's a lifetime gig.
by jck
Max would NEVER exaggerate things he comments on...
Like how medical reform will:
Take away rights of the individual...
Setup "death panels"...
Force the country into "disaster"...
You go back and look in 1993, they said the same things about the "socialist" things Bill Clinton did to improve the economy.
Of course, that "socialism" lowered unemployment, created more new jobs than in decades, brought the cost of living down, etc.
So, I guess a capitalist, free-enterprise system that doubles your fuel prices in 7 years, off-shores jobs en masse, and pays bonuses out to executives even though they bankrupted their corporation...is all okay with Max and those who think like him.
If socialism means that people have as much power as establishment, then I am a socialist.
I guess "Of the people, by the people, and for the people" is Socialism too.
Abe Lincoln was such a bad guy.
by jmgarvin
You seem to think that I could possibly afford insurance without a group policy.
Do you get insurance through your job or do you pay for it all by yourself?
by jck
Some forms of prescription drugs are free in Canada, much like how you can get generic antibiotics for nothing in some states.
It's subsidized pharmacological distribution.
So, Oz is technically right. The hospital gets certain things free, and are expected to pass that on to qualifying patients who need it.
As for itemized billing, I got mine for my past hospital visit a couple weeks ago:
1 fish oil capsule = $2.30 (I get a bottle of 250 for $10)
1 multivitamin = $1.80 (I get a bottle of 200 for $8)
Now, you tell me....
Is the hospital billing that to get more reimbursement from insurance, making a higher profit, or both?
Actually, I can tell you it's most prevalently the first choice. I worked in multi-practice medical operation. They 2-3x bill cost to insurance to make enough after the contractual percentage reduction to make ends meet.
So insurance getting 70% fee cuts from doctors/hospitals under group plans means the cost you see in the bill is most likely inflated to make up for that.
It's just pathetic. Hospitals and doctors have to struggle to do well enough to provide good care, they have to ask insurance reps who have little-to-no medical training if a procedure is "okay", and the insurance company sits there every year and figures out what benefit they can cut, what cost under contract they can decrease, and push their profits higher for what?
It's not for the betterment of their participants...I assure you that.
by tonythetiger
[i]Some forms of prescription drugs are free in Canada, much like how you can get generic antibiotics for nothing in some states.
It's subsidized pharmacological distribution.[/i]
It's not "free".
by the 'g-man.'
by jck
If things don't work out like I want in the next few years, I am going to make a push to relocate to the EU.
If I have no reason to stay here in America, why bother staying...right?
by jck
by jmgarvin
*The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.*
So sorry the Founding Father don't fit with your Ditto Head world view.
by jck
Since when?
Every policy I've ever seen (I had a time when I contacted over a dozen companies to get a policy on my own) had a right to termination clause.
If you can get one, it would be so exorbitant and probably would only go to those who are in perfect physical condition.
If you are so sure you can get it, I would suggest then Tony that you pursue that sort of policy and give up what you have now.
I think you'll find it far more difficult (if not impossible) to acquire that sort of custom-developed policy.
by jck
I can negotiate my rate?
Hm. That's funny. I don't negotiate my plan...my employer does...and I can not get the money from them for it to purchase my own.
2nd: I tried getting insurance myself. No one would underwrite me, let alone "negotiate" with me.
I think you're fooling yourself about what you can actually get and what is available to you on the current market.
I even had an insurance rep tell me one of his companies denied a fitness instructor/bodybuilder coverage in the Tampa metro...simply based on body weight. He was 3 percent fat, but he was so muscular that his weight didn't fall within "acceptable limits" even though he was a specimen of health.
That's how that great industry works giving people a fair shake.
So, when are you going to go acquire your own custom policy that you get to negotiate the price down on your own?
by tonythetiger
[i]f someone's participation in Medicaid to get healthcare is forcing you to participate, then your driving on interstate highways and US Government funded highways is just as much.[/i]
I am not forced to drive. If I don't buy fuel, I don't pay fuel tax. I DO pay for it in the sense that goods and services delivered using that infrastructure include the taxes those providers paid...
[i]You haven't paid for all the infrastructure that you use.[/i]
I'm sure I have...
[i]And before you go saying medical infrastructure isn't a necessary part of the system, remember places like the CDC and NIH are part of that.[/i]
Medical infrastructure and medical services are different things. CDC and NIH are not unlike guardrail. Medicaid is more like the car. The government doesn't pay for my car, why should it pay for anyone else's?
[i]If it's not necessary to give someone a flu vaccine[/i]
I've only had one, in 1976 in basic training. I was forced to take it. It put me in the hospital... never again! I'd rather have the flu.
[i]And really as others have said recently: if you're not happy with the system, you can always leave and go somewhere else where you are more facilitated in your beliefs.[/i]
Isn't that somewhat disingenuous? If it's OK for you to stay and strive to change the system in a way someone else doesn't agree with, why isn't it OK for anyone else to stay and strive to change it in a way you don't agree with?
I think the only thing right about the "us vs. them" mentality is the "vs.". I don't think the government should be forcing us to pay for personal benefit of anyone. You don't think the government should be paying for "an unnecessary middle-east war". [b]I think we're both on the same side of the "vs."[/b]
If it's what people voted for?
I could have put quotes round socialist but, as you say, if Fidel's for it...
..... what the United States is supposed to do.
Democracy is not (or should not be) two wolves and a lamb voting on what's for dinner.
Tyranny of the majority is still tyranny.
by tonythetiger
[i]If man was more selfless socialism would/will work. [/i]
if my uncle had a vagina she'd have been my aunt.
Everybody has their own view of the way things should be. Everybody [b]does not have[/b] the right to force others into their mold (unless you're willing to admit that some people should have more rights than others).
There's also the theory that "I can't be good for anyone else unless I'm good for myself, and what's best for others is that I be best for myself". It's true of business, and the wealthy. If they think they're not the best for themselves, they're going to go into "protection mode" to the detriment of all.
by tonythetiger
is nine years greater than the current US male life expectancy. AND, "nearly" or not, he's still alive.
:|
.....it's 12 years greater than the current Cuban life expectancy.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but any life expectancy statistics have less to do with the quality and/or availability of medical care, and more to do with life style choices, diet, bad habits, rebels in the back yard, etc. People who over-eat, smoke, drink, are couch potatoes, etc, with the best medical care are probably doomed to an earlier death than others who don't do those things. Agree or disagree?
http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/indicators/92.html
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2102rank.html
And George Burns lived to 100 - cigars and all. (I wonder if they were Cuban cigars, like the ones Fidel smokes?) When asked what his doctors thought about his smoking cigars, he said, I don't know. They're all dead.
My mother is alive kicking at 91, and shows no signs of stopping. Her secret? A piece of dark chocolate every day.
by tonythetiger
[i]Hm. That's funny. I don't negotiate my plan...my employer does...and I can not get the money from them for it to purchase my own.[/i]
and you blame the insurance companies for that???
I just paid for my son (not on my insurance) to have his wisdom teeth removed (two impacted). What was originally quoted at over $2000 I negotiated to less than $1500. That's less than I paid 30 years ago when I had the same condition.
[i]I even had an insurance rep tell me one of his companies denied a fitness instructor/bodybuilder coverage in the Tampa metro...simply based on body weight. He was 3 percent fat, but he was so muscular that his weight didn't fall within "acceptable limits" even though he was a specimen of health.[/i]
Scary. What's next, are you going to expect medical insurance to pay for foam bumpers on the trees on the ski-run, to keep you from breaking your face? And you think people who don't ski should be forced to share in the cost? Wow!
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
is to put consumers, not companies, in charge. You THINK they're paying for your insurance, but they're not. They're taking the cost out of what they could be paying you. If you had control of that money, you'd have the contract negotiating power. Get it!
Oh, that reminds me... Since part of the mandate is to put the amount the employer "paid" for health insurance on your W-2, how long do you think it will be before it's taxed as income?
I predict it will be the day after the next president is sworn in, no matter who the next one is, or how Congress is divided politically.
by tonythetiger
that a state would choose to continue those programs. (and they already handle all medicaid... the only thing the fed does is pay for part of it (from money they got from the state's citizens in the first place)... they are the ultimate middleman! "Here, give me some money so I can take part of it and give the rest back to you". There's no "value added" service that they perform in exchange for their cut, so what the hell good are they? Oh, that's right... they FORCE one to PAY for another. What a racket.
[added:]
[i]Your state or local government already collects all that money for those plans?[/i]
They collect ALL the money, they send some of it to Washington, Washington sends money back (sometimes more than what the state sent, sometimes less), the state pays the claims. The only thing the fed does is collect from states, (take their cut) and send money back to states.
by jmgarvin
Just because insurance is denied, it doesn't mean medical care is denied. People don't need insurance, per se; in fact they NEVER [i]need[/i] insurance. They [i]need[/i] medical care, and insurance is nothing but a middle-man third-party payer.
Cook Children's Medical Center in Fort Worth, the facility at which the child is being cared for, is one on many Children's hospitals that will not deny care to such children, regardless of their ability to pay.
What you fail to remember is that I don't deny our medical care delivery system is, in many ways, screwed up. (It also works pretty well in many ways.) I don't deny that the insurance industry is screwed up. But like I said a previous message, I want neither the insurance industry OR the government in the driver's seat of providing medical care. I want the consumers in the driver's seat. Doing more of the very things that screwed it up to begin with is not a viable solution.
Speaking of free market at work (and those [i]greedy rich people[/i] who hoard all their money):
[i]Fort Worth Children's Hospital (currently called, Cook Children's Medical Center), began with the organization of the Fort Worth Free Baby Hospital on March 21, 1918, under the leadership of Mrs. Ida L. Turner, a former postmistress. The hospital was first located at 2400 Winton Terrace West, near the present campus of Texas Christian University. All of the building materials and furnishings for the hospital were donated.....[/i]
Tens of millions of dollars are donated each and every year to Cook Children's Medical Center to provide medical care for those who cannot afford it. Those tens of millions of dollars are applied to provided care each year for those who cannot afford it. Cook Children's Medical Center currently has over $100 million in funds available in its Cook Children's Health Foundation - all of which came from charitable donations, and all of which will be used to provide care for those who cannot afford it.
Hundreds of volunteers work tens of thousands of hours each and every providing care at Cook Children's Medical Center.
Every major community has such medical centers.
Your story went on to say, [i]A five-hour surgery to correct the defect was performed Friday, and Houston is doing well.[/i]
I'd be willing to wager you $100 - payable to the Cook Children's Health Foundation - that the child in your story WILL continue to receive the necessary care, and the parents will not be billed.
https://www.cookchildrens.org/giving/healthfoundation/Pages/default.aspx
by jck
It's wrong for other people to expect you to cough up $50 in extra taxes...
But, it's okay to expect that hospital to have mercy on that child's family and give it $10,000s of dollars in medical treatment.
Are you kidding? Seriously?
You don't want to sacrifice, but you think it's okay for that hospital to have to?
BTW, what's this with quoting how much money they have? That shouldn't matter, remember? Are you hating on the wealthy medical establishment now and expecting them to give because they accumulated wealth?
I thought you were against that.
Donations should not matter. Their equity and holdings should not matter.
If you had $100M, would it be then okay for me to expect you to donate $200k to that child's care??
Give me a break. This is the type of hypocrisy that I don't understand you can have and not realize.
Max having to contribute = bad
Someone else having to contribute = okay
Amazing.
Oh, I hope you never have to face that situation in your lifetime, and I hope that karma doesn't come back to bite you in the arse for calling someone caring about an infirmed child a "Typical emotional reaction".
That's real humane of you.
by jmgarvin
Max you just keep shuffling cost.
Good for you for donating. However, that $100 only offsets, what, 1% of the cost of the operation for the child. Where will the hospital make up the other 99%? Oh, that's right, they'll pass the costs along to the consumer, thus increasing health care costs in an ever lasting cost shuffle...which you seem to prefer...
You must have been the book keeper at Enron.
by puppybreath
what I'm doing is responding to someone who commented on people with insurance discussing the issue rather than people without insurance. Implying that people with insurance shouldn't be involved in the discussion.
Nothing more, nothing less.
by jascc1
That was my point. It's easy for those with insurance (me included) to criticize something that won't have a direct impact on them.
Please spare me any "my taxes or insurance bills will go up" crap.
by bdskp
You said
"You can't pick on this bill without picking on all the socialized medicine we already have. "
That's just silly. Even if this bill was EXACTLY like what we have now doesn't mean I can't single this bill out.
It's like saying "You can't be against a new tax on gasoline because there are already other taxes on gasoline!"
Just because we may or may not already have X amount of something doesn't mean I can't rise up against more of the same stuff.
by jmgarvin
by jascc1
by tonythetiger
by jck
Congress made everyone wait about a year for it.
What's 4 more gonna hurt, right?
Besides, you can save that $50 a year increase...and go negotiate for a 120GB PS3! :p
by puppybreath
being in the military has nothing to do with life or death situations.
Do you want to rethink that last comment?
by jascc1
How far did you have to reach back to pull that one out?
Let me summise quickly for you: The law, while maybe not perfect, is a grand step in helping HELP the millions of Americans who did not have health insurance and thus do not have the basic RIGHT of healthcare that you and I have.
Why you dragged the military into this discussion still bewilders me. But for the record - if there are laws that could help save military personnel lives, then I'm all for it!!
by puppybreath
I have a RIGHT to health care because I paid for it. You have a RIGHT to healthcare because you paid for it. But neither of us has a RIGHT to force someone else to pay for it for us.
Your original post referred to only wanting reponses from uninsured people. Since this bill affects everyone and not just the uninsured, everyone should be involved in the discussion. I tried to point that out with my military reference but it was obviously way over your head.
BTW, in your post you wrote "or do you know someone who can't get treated because of lack of insurance?".
Thats' a main point with many of us "naysayers" as you like to call us. You don't need insurance to get treated. You never had to. Just go into any emergency room in Arizona or California and look at all of the illegals getting treated without insurance.
The bill should have been about controlling the cost of healthcare, not trying to take over the insurance industry.
...... [i]rights[/i] (a word he used) are bestowed upon a person by another person.
We don't have Kings and Queens in the USA. And we don't have (or at least shouldn't have) people who presume to be the elite noblemen with the power to [i]bestow rights[/i] upon others.
(Of course, we've had this discussion before.)
Before I posted that link, I donated $100 to Cook Children's Health Foundation.
I challenge you to do the same thing. (Or to any Children's Hospital.)
As much as you spout, you really know nothing about me. But I know this about you: You're just dripping with mean-spiritedness. Your messages prove it.
by jck
[i][b]Hm. That's funny. I don't negotiate my plan...my employer does...and I can not get the money from them for it to purchase my own.[/b]
and you blame the insurance companies for that???[/i]
You said that I could negotiate my rate. Being that I am not the policy holder, I can not. I am a named group member, not the group that has the policy.
It was not a point blaming the insurance companies, but showing you that your "you can negotiate" supposition is false.
I don't have the option of taking the value of my policy, bankrolling it, and using it to pay for medical at my discretion.
It's not a given option, Tony.
[i]I just paid for my son (not on my insurance) to have his wisdom teeth removed (two impacted). What was originally quoted at over $2000 I negotiated to less than $1500. That's less than I paid 30 years ago when I had the same condition.[/i]
You negotiated with the provider, not the insurance.
BTW...I could have got you a better rate than that. You should have looked around more.
[i]Scary. What's next, are you going to expect medical insurance to pay for foam bumpers on the trees on the ski-run, to keep you from breaking your face? And you think people who don't ski should be forced to share in the cost? Wow![/i]
Hm. Medical insurance = safety measures?
I think not.
Well, you expect people not to expect you to share in the cost of coverage that does benefit you.
Besides, there's a big difference in being born with a heart defect, and some novice skiing dumbarse running into a tree because they went down the novice slope and now decide they're Albert Tomba and wanting to take on a black diamond run.
Self payment makes the most sense?
Hm. Okay. Easy to say when you haven't had 7 figures of medical expenses pile up on you in less than a year and you have no insurance.
Hell, I just got out of the hospital last week. I have no idea what was being covered or not. I'll get a bill, and it'll probably be for $1000.
Do I have $1000 cash to dish out? No. I am not dipping into my retirement funds, so I will have to pay them off over time.
And, I have what is considered good insurance.
I can't imagine having $500k in expenses and no insurance.
BTW...one other thing...
Self payment only makes sense if you can afford it.
Not everyone has money.
by jck
you're a dittohead.
http://www.rushlimbaugh.com/home/daily/site_032510/content/01125117.guest.html
Fair and balanced, are we?
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]No state is forced to participate. Period.[/i]
Just like they weren't "forced" to change the BAC level to .08.
Fed says "I'm going to steal a lot of money from the people of your state. If you play by my rules, I'll give some of it back."
Nah, that's not force...
by tonythetiger
[i]I'm going to live under the bridge and troll around.[/i]
my ex :)
[i]Well, all except Pelosi. She irks me. She's 180'ed since she became speaker. [/i]
Yeah, she hasn't been the same since that house fell on her sister.
You've proven that you're nothing but a fool and and idiot - and a mean-spirited one at that.
I'm through with you. You're not worthy of my time or attention. Not only will I not reply to your messages, but I won't read them either.
by puppybreath
He's planning on leaving the country.
So support a bad bill that you know will never affect you. Sounds a lot like Congress who pushes this through knowing that they are covered differently than the common folk.
by jck
When the government does it, that's force.
When a business does it, it's just doing business?
It's coercion either way.
Just you'll excuse it if there's someone making a profit.
Besides, I still have to ask:
Why is it that you think establishing 50 seperate managing organizations (1 for each state) is more time/money/personnel efficient than having a central, single office do it?
Personally? I think a system where standard medical care is overseen and managed by government is smart.
I think then that private physicians and insurances can offer treatment and coverage for non-necessary things (nose jobs, breast augmentation, removal of a 6th toe, etc.).
But, there really is no reason anyone in this country shouldn't have a flu shot, shouldn't be able to get a free once a year checkup, shouldn't be able to be tested for a suspected TB or hepatitis infection, etc.
That kinda thing prevents spread of communicable disease, makes the society as a whole more efficient, and leads to less loss of productivity for business with contributes to financial gain.
So rather than having a system that will allow business to screw people for being sick, why not have a system that helps keep them well and in turn that helps business prosper without screwing someone?
Boob implants don't make people healthier, but preventative shot sure can.
by jck
[i]my ex[/i]
...into women who are retirement age :p
Yes, I'm 41.
And, the woman I've been involved with is 26.
Yay me! :D
by jck
I can say that you didn't get a drawing from your kid from school free, because some poor underprivileged worker who made the crayon in China got screwed on his pay...so someone sacrificed for you back down the line too.
The point was:
It was free at the point of distribution to the last recipient.
Even going to the bathroom in some places is not free anymore.
by dwdino
by tonythetiger
[i]And George Burns lived to 100[/i]
Some of his years should have been taken away from him and given to someone else so they can live longer.
Reminds me of the joke about the college grades :)
by jmgarvin
by tonythetiger
[i]You said that I could negotiate my rate. Being that I am not the policy holder, I can not.[/i]
Maybe you should get a job that doesn't force you into a particular insurance plan (or did that employer kidnap you and force you to work for him too?). It's certainly preferable than having the government hamstring everybody else due to your shortcomings!
[i]It was not a point blaming the insurance companies, but showing you that your "you can negotiate" supposition is false[/i].
You certainly can! In fact, you're the ONLY ONE who can, because you're the only one who knows what you want!
If a store only has mint flavored toothpaste but you want cinnamon, do you just buy the mint and be happy with it? Do you let others make ALL of your decisions for you? Why? Is it laziness, or cowardice,...
[i]I don't have the option of taking the value of my policy, bankrolling it, and using it to pay for medical at my discretion.
It's not a given option, Tony.
[/i]
... or do you just accept the decisions of others because it gives you a reason to bitch?
[i]You negotiated with the provider, not the insurance.
BTW...I could have got you a better rate than that. You should have looked around more.
[/i]
It was a decision based on more than just money... there's quality of work (I asked friends), how long he'd have had to wait for an appointment (while writhing in pain), driving distance, etc.
[i]Hm. Medical insurance = safety measures?
I think not. [/i]
What's a checkup?
by jmgarvin
You cannot remove LIFE from me (you know like LIFE, LIBERTY, AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS?) just because you feel I don't have that right.
If you want to bandy about the Constitution, fine...but be ready to face the fact the Constitution is quite clear that you cannot deny your fellow citizens LIFE simply because you choose.
..... doesn't appear in the Constitution. It appears in the Declaration of Independence (from the British Crown).
You are the one who cited the Ninth Amendment to the Constitution.
[i]The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.[/i]
Stay focused on that, and only that, break it down word-for-word if you'd like, but please explain to us what it means to you - and what it meant to James Madison - and how it supports your position as described in this discussion.
Feel free to take some time and do some research.
by jmgarvin
I just replied comparing their bookkeeping methods to those of the US Government.
If my post was pointless, so was yours. In fact, since you introduced Enron, yours was even more pointless.
And if you keep playing these silly games, I?ll send you to the same corner I sent jck.
[i].....they'll pass the costs along to the consumer, thus increasing health care costs in an everlasting cost shuffle...which you seem to prefer...[/i]
Absolutely I prefer that. It's better than adding an additional cost of a middle-man, whether that middle-man be an insurance company or the United States government - debate on the true role of government aside.
Nonetheless, you must not have read my message. That hospital was created in the first place to provide free medical care for needy children. It was the free market finding a solution for a problem. And it's worked quite well. Moreover the funds aren't necessarily always passed onto the consumer, as you claimed, but rather are paid for by donations, and much of the care is administered by volunteer doctors and nurses.
Why don't you admit that the article was misleading? Like I said before, no insurance doesn't mean no care - and that's the impression you were trying to give.
P.S. While it's true many people can't afford either medical care or insurance, having to always go through the middle-man called the insurance industry will, without a doubt, increase the overall and ultimate cost of receiving medical care. Any middle-man ALWAYS increases the cost of anything. It's naive to believe otherwise.
by jmgarvin
That hospital is a special case and not the norm.
no insurance normally means no care since you cannot afford it.
by jascc1
HUH???? You and I are only able to pay for it, because we have employment of some kind (or savings, etc.). Not everyone is employed or they work somewhere that it is not offered.
Sooooooo....they are just sh*t out of luck, huh? Better hurry up and find a job, so you won't DIE, huh? Oh that's right - if you're sick, just go to the ER. It's just like it's portrayed on TV.
Do you go to the ER for your medical services? Why not? Because you pay for heath insurance that gets you 'better' heathcare, maybe?
"Your original post referred to only wanting reponses from uninsured people. "
That was called a rhetorical question - to prove a point. The point that those who have an issue with the bill HAVE healthcare - and thus are taking it for granted by saying it's not right.
"Just go into any emergency room in Arizona or California and look at all of the illegals getting treated without insurance."
REALLY??? Man - you need a wake-up call bad. You, like many other who are in opposition, live a closed world. Have you ever been to those ER's? Do you know what the doctor/patient ratio is? Do you know those hospitals are PUBLIC , which are UNDERFUNDED, which means they don't have everything they need to help everybody. You like many others are oblivious to what is happening around then and WHY.
So basically you have solidified why you are opposed to the bill. You live on 123 Dream St, Bubble City, USA.
by tonythetiger
by puppybreath
and they need to be controlled by the Government. And because they're so bad, we're going to force everyone to buy insurance through them rather than working on ways to control health care costs which are way out of control.
Because forcing everyone to buy insurance from these bad companies is going to make them good, caring companies.
So reward the bad companies with more business while the actual problem still exists and is not being addressed.
And this is a smart move in your opinion?
and her secret is to answer any question about her longevity with "Well, I suppose it's because I am not dead yet". Cantankerous old biddy...
I'm not sure that George Burns is anything nut a statistical outlier, famous though he might be.
The Cuban life expectancy is so close to your own that it's too close too call.
Therefore what?
by jmgarvin
Max, when you don't have an answer, you try to redirect the conversation.
When you keep on talking about shuffling around payment, yet don't have any real answer, you resort to the same old trick of strawmen and redirection.
[i]The Cuban life expectancy is so close to your own that it's too close to call. Therefore what? [/i]
Well, you brought up life expectancy in the first place, so I guess I could have asked you the same question.
Moreover, The British, Canadian, et al, life expectancy is so close to our own that it's too close to call. Therefore what?
Therefore, I guess it gives us something that may or may not be meaningless to use as support for whatever we're trying to prove or disprove; and it provides jobs for some statisticians who come up with these numbers.
And, of course, it might provide a general time-frame in which payment for a steak dinner must fall. The clock is ticking.....
P.S. Should we include our mums/moms?
by puppybreath
that in the future a Republican will be controlling your health care?
Sure, you're all gung ho now with Obama and the Democrats controlling the Government, but what about when the tide changes?
Are you really going to be excited to have someone like Bush control your healthcare for 4 or 8 years?
Be careful what you wish for, you just may get it.
I'm simply shaking my head in disbelief.
I would say that debating/discussing things with jmgarvin is like conversing with a six year old, but I don't want to insult six year olds.
I know what it is. Apparently, we don't speak the same language. Yea, that's it.
Someone - ANYONE (except for the loony-tune, jck) - please step-in and either get jmgarvin - or me - on the right track. Who is missing what? Why does jmgarvin make absolutely no sense to me?
by jmgarvin
But either way, my point stands.
I know what is what, my post was unclear.
However, that is beside the point.
The 9th Amendment is quite clear. You cannot deny me my God given right to LIFE. Which you are clearly doing be declaring health care is only for the privileged few.
But it would be harsh.
I'd have to kill you both.
by tonythetiger
[i]When the government does it, that's force.
When a business does it, it's just doing business?[/i]
to patronize a different business than it is a different government. If the store I'm in doesn't have cinnamon toothpaste, I don't buy mint, I go to a different store. If the first store wants me to buy toothpaste there, they'll start carrying the kind I like. Insurance is just like toothpaste. If you don't like the offerings at one, you go to another. It's YOUR responsibility to buy what you want. If you "accept" what someone offers, it's not anybody else's fault.
[i]Why is it that you think establishing 50 seperate managing organizations (1 for each state) is more time/money/personnel efficient than having a central, single office do it?[/i]
You stilll don't understand. ALL states have almost all of those managing organizations ALREADY IN PLACE. The only thing the fed equivalents do is shuffle money and impose rules (which they have to change constantly to make it appear as though they are actually DOING something). Those federal equivalents (DOE and DOT for two examples) add no value to the service that the state departments provide, but they DO absorb some of the resources.
[i]Personally? I think a system where standard medical care is overseen and managed by government is smart.[/i]
And personally I don't. The difference is your way makes demands on me (property and/or liberty) while mine makes absolutely no demands on you.
[i]I think then that private physicians and insurances can offer treatment and coverage for non-necessary things (nose jobs, breast augmentation, removal of a 6th toe, etc.).[/i]
Magnanimous of you to decide for another what is and isn't "necessary".
The US spend on healthcare is more than twice ours and far in excess of the Cuban spend - more than ten times higher per capita - and yet it seems not to benefit you at all. Canada seem to do a few years better than you or us with half of your per capita spend.
Therefore your healthcare "Industry" is woefully inefficient in delivering its product and hugely overpriced. It doesn't deliver at all to a significant part of your community although I'd guess that you would say that its their fault for not making provision.
Given that you, the US, can't go on as you are then some reform is obviously needed. What would YOU do?
unless you opt out of society completely, that society seems to have the power to take from you whatever they want. Whether they have the right is a debatable point but they are YOUR government, state or whatever other level.
If you accept they have the right to take ANY of your money for ANY reason, you buy into whatever else they choose to do with your money.
Feel free to build your own roads.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]unless you opt out of society completely, that society seems to have the power to take from you whatever they want.[/i]
Might makes right. It doesn't, however, make ethics.
Sort by Trending