Discussion Locked

Presumably bad guys can get US guns pretty easily too?

0 helpful
150 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
article root

150 replies

by darjon-lorne

The beauty of a concealed handgun is that (if concealed properly) the would be offender is not aware that his "victim" is armed. Obviously, the possibility of assaulting an armed man makes the idea far less pleasant, and therefore less likely. As such, legal concealed weapons benefit the law abiding citizenry to a far greater extent than they do the criminal faction.

by apotheon

The benefit of concealed carry is not to the individual carrying, but to society as a whole. If concealed carry becomes a common practice (as it is in some areas), the criminal element is less likely to directly confront and threaten people in general, because the would-be predators do not know who's armed and who isn't. Open carry only protects the guy carrying openly; concealed carry adds an element of protective uncertainty for everyone.

by taphilo

Actually that was the case in "The Old West" and there WAS less violence - seeing that the other person ALSO has a gun - and not knowing how good they are with it - is a deterrant. Actual documented "gunfights" in the old west were less than 60.
Parts of the US still allow open carry and people there think nothing of it, but with the general population of the US being trained to panic when they see ANYONE but a law officer with a gun and report them as a criminal - ensures that doing so a person outside those few areas of the US where this is normal is apt to be stopped 10 to 20 times for doing so in a week.
By law ANYTHING can be considered a weapon and treated as such in any US court. Firearms, again over the years, has been singled out to have extra special punishments when used. If someone used a baseball bat to kill someone they may get 8 years, but if you use a pistol it is considered "special" and you will get at least 15 - the person is still dead but using a pistol in our courts punishes the person more. (At least in Oregon, and likely elsewhere).
The best way to think about owning a weapon is that 99.9999 you will never have to use it at all. But in tht .0001 time that you can to save yourself or someone else and you don't have it - while you wait the 10 minutes for the police to arrive and the guy / gal is only 10 seconds from you then not having it makes a big difference.
Remember: most police officers go through their whole career and NEVER fire their weapons. So should we not then take theirs away too since they had never used it against anyone?

by mariah10

Unfortunately, people like you or the anti-gun people, would be terrified, not realizing that we are law abiding citizens. Including store clerks, restaurants, etc.

Actually in Missouri, there is an antique law on the books that DOES allow one to carry a weapon on their side - you see, it's not concealed then, is it? We also have another old law on the books - OPEN RANGE. Insurance companies do not want people to know about it becaues if you hit livestock on the road, generally consensus is the animal owner is at fault....NOT. Had it happen - kids cut the fence, horse got out, lady was not watching the road (her admission) and hit and killed my horse. She had to pay. now if my fences were in poor condition - that's a different story.

by ansugisalas

Having a concealed weapon means that a criminal can't decide not to mug you, because he can't know that you're armed.
How is that a good thing?
The "surprise surprise" moment when you whip it out is extremely dangerous to all concerned. A mugger is likely to be rather desperate to begin with, so what are the odds that they'll do something stupid when a gun appears in the hands of their victims?
A struggle for the firearm can be lethal to either participant.

I don't see how it helps things.

by apotheon

Knowledge of the prevalence of firearms helps to dissuade would-be criminals who fear for their lives. Knowledge of the legality of concealed carry suggests that more people are likely to be carrying. The fact it is concealed might slightly increase the danger to the person carrying by giving a (mugger|rapist|whatever) some hope that you don't happen to be carrying, but it also introduces a significant element of uncertainty about the safety of the act of carrying out a confrontational crime against even those who, it might turn out, are not armed.

. . . and if the guy does something stupid, there's a pretty good chance he'll get shot for it. That's one dangerous criminal fewer in the world. Loss of life is tragic, but less so than the likely alternatives.

. . . and, honestly, the odds that he'll do anything at first other than give up, run, or just generally try to buy time are pretty damned slim.

Please, please tell me that was an honest question, and that you don't come back with a trolling response. Please?

by mariah10

Because the 'bad' people don't know what they are confronting. A little old lady they see as an easy target or very adept professionally trained marksman.

by apotheon

No, not the way "security through obscurity" is technically used. "Security through obscurity" is used to refer to the practice of hiding information about one's security procedures in an attempt to increase one's security against a threat that, at some point in the future, may be in the progress of being realized. Thus, it would mean "If everybody who carries must do so concealed, I will be more secure if someone attacks me because that person will not know whether I am carrying."

The societal effect of the common case of concealed carry is more like "Peace through uncertainty." The widespread incidence of attacks is reduced by the knowledge of widespread carry as a practice coupled with the uncertainty about who is actually carrying. It does not in any way protect a given individual against an attack any better. In fact, on an individual basis, the specific effect of the "obscurity" condition (someone carrying who hides the fact he or she is carrying) is more likely to be a reduction in security. Remember -- only someone with something to hide can hide it, thus practicing security through obscurity.

by mariah10

IF your lifestyle is such that it puts you in inaccessible or hard to find areas with no cell phone access, then a gun is the only thing between you and harm....either animal (which I would never kill unless it was attacking me or the people I was with) or human.

by papa_bill

OK, dial 911, if you can, then ask your attacker to please wait for the Police to arrive.
A cellphone will be handy *after the fact* (we hope).

by slayer_

Well, its meant to, statistics prove that it does not. Apparently violence criminals aren't afraid of dying, so it stands to reason, they don't care if their victim may be armed.

But trying to predict what goes on in a persons head... that seems the problem to me.

But, is the risk higher that, an armed criminal will attack you, or that your child will find that neat gun you carry everywhere, and try it out for himself?

And let's not forget to mention society as a whole, as its important. But why do you feel unsafe, most have never been involved in a violent crime. Maybe its a population thing, more people in a small area, the ratio of crime may stay the same but the number of occurrences increases, you hear more about, people become scared.
But the ratios are still the same.

And finally, if we assume our criminals think logically (unlikely, but what the hell). Then if a criminal assumes their victim is not dangerous to them, they are less likely to injure or kill their victim.

Everyone knows you can't prevent criminals, but maybe we can make them less dangerous. Bring the level of violence down. To me this seems like an attainable goal.

by santeewelding

Fine-tune what you have to say about all this and maybe you find -- nothing.

For instance: "criminal".

The only judicious way I see to say, "criminal", comes after conviction by due process. In your screed, I see (7) mentions of "crime" and "criminal". I have no idea (I do; but I am reluctant to characterize your thinking) of what you're talking about. Has to be, though, something about taking law into your own hands, much in the way that you denigrate doing so with a gun.

by slayer_

Since we have a max of 25 year penalty for the most violent of crimes, and most get out before that. Most criminals are repeat offenders, criminal in my world is correct in that case.
Its practically a coming of age for some groups to steal a car and run down a few pedestrians. And as long as they are underage offenders, they get away with a slap on their hand.
http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/canada/breakingnews/34500124.html

by papa_bill

When I get mugged (planning on this weekend) I'll think of what you said. Bring the level of violence down. Yeah, good idea, why hasn't anyone thought of that?

by slayer_

Just probably not in Alabama.

Move to some other country if you want to experience it.

by apotheon

> When I get mugged (planning on this weekend) I'll think of what you said.

Thank you. I needed a laugh.

by apotheon

> Well, its meant to, statistics prove that it does not. Apparently violence criminals aren't afraid of dying, so it stands to reason, they don't care if their victim may be armed.

There is far more certainty of dying at the hands of an armed "victim" than due process and execution. That's why the death penalty doesn't work.

by slayer_

Life in prison, or death by hand gun?

I wonder if the violent criminals ask that question to themselves...

by papa_bill

Most illegally held weapons were stolen from legitimate owners. Thus responsible owners must keep their weapons inaccessible when not being carried. No argument, this is a well known fact.
And gun store thefts are quite common.
And you will probably assume that this is a good reason for the total elimination of guns from within our borders.
But what you don't realize is that the *importance* of guns in the hands of private citizens is is not so much for individual defense as is it is for defense from a possible takeover of our government by tyrants or dictators. This fact seems to be little understood by Americans as well as many others, and the resulting misunderstanding risks the loss of this right, which is so important to our personal as well as national security.

by ansugisalas

not everyone can throw a surprise party.
It takes a steel sprung spine, and you that have those are not in majority.

by papa_bill

The advantage of concealed carry predicates on a general assumption that anyone you meet may be carrying. Thus assaults are reduced from the fear that the victim might be able to mount a real defense. The point is not that you can surprise an attacker but that you are simply less likely to be attacked.

by ansugisalas

Especially if concealed carry license was an option, too.
Strange that open carry is even subject to legislation... isn't that bearing arms in a nutshell?

Hey, BTW, since you carry, have you ever thought about what you do if you're attacked in closed quarters? Like, if someone jumps you in an elevator, that's a tricky place to draw, let alone use a gun.

by delbertpgh

A lot of calculus goes into whether "given uncertainty, will a criminal do this." Actually, what governs most criminals (at least the ones who get caught) is stupidity, and stupid trumps all behavioral calculations. People who commit small-money crime usually do so because of besetting emotional issues, and financial problems that they get into because they haven't got the patience to reason a way out or the steadiness to stick with it. Some of them seem to discover the pleasures of cold-hearted sadism once they hold a gun in their hands, as in the case of store clerks who get executed after handing the money over. There's no profit in over-thinking the motives of people who kill like that.

by delbertpgh

I used to own firearms. I may buy one again and do target shooting, once I get college bills out of the way. I enjoyed putting holes in paper. I don't think I'd ever consider a gun a tool for self protection, unless I get myself into a business where I'm carrying precious commodities around routinely, or take up drug dealing or pimping as a post-retirement career.

Information I picked up about guns when they were my hobby convinced me I'd be more dangerous to myself and my friends if I carried a gun, than to the target bad guys. It takes repeated practice to draw, aim, and fire accurately; and civil combat demands instantaneous intelligent judgements be made. Without the skill and the mentality, I'd be just a halfwit amateur trying to become town sheriff in an instant. Wives are killed in domestic arguments with guns; suicides paint ceilings with guns; kids pick them up out of the drawer for play and kill each other; people burglarize your house and steal guns and use them for further crime. More people are killed inadvertently than in actual defense.

And, I would not feel safer in a world where I could expect half the people in the restaurant or at the bus stop were packing. Lots of my fellow men are angry and unstable already.

by robo_dev

surely ya'all aint from 'round here :)

A gun is a tool, and like any tool, there is a time and a place where it's needed. The difference, of course, is that most tools don't have the capacity for instantly ending a life at the push of a button, so there are inherent risks in leaving this tool laying around where kids, drug addicts, or mentally unstable folks can get to them.

Personally, I like guns, and understand that guns can be an effective self defense tool.

But consider that a police officer, while armed, also has years of training, a radio, a baton, chemical mace, a taser, and a gun (or two). He has a layered security approach that happens to include a gun.

by apotheon

> A gun is a tool, and like any tool, there is a time and a place where it's needed. The difference, of course, is that most tools don't have the capacity for instantly ending a life at the push of a button, so there are inherent risks in leaving this tool laying around where kids, drug addicts, or mentally unstable folks can get to them.

We should treat rat poison, cleaning chemicals, gardening shears, electric chainsaws, car keys, and any kitsch that happens to be heavy and hard like a crystal owl someone gave me for my birthday a couple decades or so ago, all with the same care as a firearm -- with the exception of legal liability, which is much greater for firearms than other tools and accessories that can very easily end a life. Safely operating a motor vehicle requires more attention to detail and forethought than carrying a firearm for self defense (and most people don't drive very safely).

by papa_bill

You simply explained without yelling your personal choice. Thanks.

I won't waste your time by repeating what I have stated elsewhere, but will point out that most municipalities *try* to eliminate the licensing of firearms to to mentally of emotionally unstable. for obvious reasons. They also will not knowingly permit felons to carry. These attempts at pre-empting the potential violence are only partly successful, but do represent the general concern we have with these issues. Hopefully better answers will come, not just for licensing but the reduction of violence in general.

by apotheon

Recognizing your limitations is great, but please don't assume yours are also mine (or anyone else's).

> More people are killed inadvertently than in actual defense.

More cases of defense with a firearm occur where no shot is fired than where someone is killed (and let's not forget the in-between cases, where an assailant is wounded). Accidents and suicides with firearms are nowhere near the most common cases of use outside of practice.

> And, I would not feel safer in a world where I could expect half the people in the restaurant or at the bus stop were packing. Lots of my fellow men are angry and unstable already.

I would -- because being "angry and unstable" in the prevalent sense is not enough to trigger a tragedy.

by delbertpgh

Some times I've seen possible trouble coming, and if I had a gun, I might have stuck around to face it. Instead, I've stepped out of its way. Have I lost something by doing so? Maybe. Armed, would I have made myself safer? Considering my actual life, probably not. I've already found, and chosen, the safer alternatives available in difficult moments, and managed to arrive un-beaten and un-robbed at this age.

by delbertpgh

You point out that most police never fire a weapon in their careers, and that you don't need one 99.9999% of the time; it's only useful for that .0001%. Well, cops have a lot of training in combat and decision making and self control; they are trained as much to not shoot as they are to use a gun effectively. If you arm a bunch of civilians, maybe they'll use a gun more often... maybe, .0033% of the time. Still seems like a small number, except 33 times more people are pulling guns.

In your example you've got somebody 10 seconds from you, and you need a gun. Usually a guy is closer than that when he becomes a danger... one or two seconds. That's the time you have to recognize your problem, get your head together, pull your weapon out of your pants or purse (where it will probably get snagged on something), aim, fire, and hope you're right. Or, if your opponent is armed and more ready, get shot first. Have you made yourself safer?

Or, try a scenario where somebody is actually 10 seconds away. Early evening, you hear a shot and a woman screaming, see some guy running down the street toward you carrying a shopping bag. You pull your gun and yell "Freeze!" like in the movies, and he stops. And then somebody else runs up behind him with a gun and shoots him in the back. Oops. You've just facilitated a murder. Well, your heart was in the right place.

In The Shootist, John Wayne plays gunfighter who is idolized by a young man, who asks him what it takes to be so great. Wayne says, "It's not always being fast or even accurate that counts, it's being willing. I found out early that most men, regardless of cause or need, aren't willing. They blink an eye or draw a breath before they pull the trigger--and I won't." Somebody who wants to be Mr. Impromptu Self Defense needs to recognize he's taking on a big commitment, a commitment that will make him a different person, when he carries the gun and if he tries to be real about it.

by taphilo

From the news reports and offical training standards (national standards? I think so, all training seem to have to meet the basic same requirements) the officers are trained to shoot whenever someone is less than 20 feet and they start coming at them - if even if they THINK they have a weapon, course as I mentioned ANYTHING can be considered a weapon. The reason is that at 20' a determined person can get to you in less than 2 seconds and that is how long it takes a well trained (and as you stated lots of practice) to pull aim and fire at somneone. Course most of the times the officers already have their pistol out and pointed so it takes maybe 1/2 second. They are also trained to keep firing till the person is on the ground.
They are also taught to avoid shooting. Course whenever a PO stops someone they have their weapon, have armor on, and you KNOW they are willing and capable of killing you so the intimidation factor for any law abiding person is high. Means nothing if you break the law and so those people don't care and are willing to confront them.
Always some bad apples in any community.
Last month a PO shot a person after confronting him and the person was really just talking to people, but just in a manner that made people nervous. A PO told that person to stop sit down and stay there - even though he had really done nothing illegial. When he asked why the PO stated "Because I told you to." The person, started walking away and the PO then grabbed a beanbag shotgun and shot him 5 times. The only problem was that he had loaded it with REAL shotgun shells. Only after the person was down, 3 others PO had gone to him, he was moaning, and then after a few minutes they turned him over and saw him bleeding did they realize he was shot.
Here the person was not a real threat and they shot him anyway - going away from them after not committing ANY crime - unless walking away from a PO is now considered a crime and they can shoot you for that.
Well, at least in Portland they can!

by apotheon

It is rapidly getting to the point where, any time a police officer talks to you, it's probably best to just hold up your hands and say "don't shoot" over and over until he lets you go.

Okay, so I exaggerate -- slightly.

by papa_bill

and from day one it was an eye-opener.
Most old timer officers would tell you they never fire their gun *in anger*, meaning they have never fired *at anyone*.

by hal 9000

Who get scared of new recruits who openly say to the Old Timers who have never had to resort to drawing a firearm.

[b]I want to see what it feels like to shoot someone.[/b]

They are the ones who scare me and I might add all of the Old Timers that I know. ;)

Col

by delbertpgh

Sorry, becabill. The right to hold guns is an important part of American identity, for lots of reasons. Mostly it boils down to each American wanting to be an independent force on his own plot of ground, and many choose to own guns to underline the fact. However, the idea that a bunch of pot-bellied guys with M-16s huffing around the suburbs will be effective against the organized military is a libertarian opium dream. It's not a reassuring idea to think that there are some, survivalists and anarchist cranks, who are already prepared and eager to see the baloon go up so they can bust loose and start shootin'.

by papa_bill

Our greatest chance would be for certain troops to side with us, and that's not an impossibility. Even our troops (most of them) have their own stake on the "civilian" side of life. And yes, our troops are sworn to defend the Republic. Don't forget, though, that *we* has the same responsibility.
I'm not one of those idiots who lives in some secluded valley with a dozen guard dogs, surrounded by "no trespassing" signs and bristling with illegal military weapons. Despite all our government's continued screw-ups, I still support it. It's still the best the world has seen (objection overruled). There's lots of room for improvement, and we're working on it. It's a long way off.
What I fear is a government that has completely lost it's way and reverses course completely. Unlikely, but not impossible. At that point, we would *have* to take over, and by force. Theoretically, we're in charge now. If we continue to elect *mostly* responsible leaders on all levels, including party leaders (and I may be in trouble here), we'll be OK.
If we abdicate our responsibilities, our civil liberties will come crashing down around us.
The best answer is to take care of the government we have. Change the oil. Rotate the tires. Drive carefully, lest we have to buy a new one with our blood..

by ansugisalas

most campus shooting-spree'ers seem to be not so much criminals as they are severely unhinged, suicidal nutcases with delusions of grandeur.
Hard to predict.

One thing to take into account is the criminal subculture. It matters how they see others, and themselves. Just because they are criminals doesn't mean they have to be completely immoral, but their culture can take them there, as it seems to be in some gang cultures.

by apotheon

> Strange that open carry is even subject to legislation... isn't that bearing arms in a nutshell?

You're starting to see the point of view of a lot of people who object to "gun control" politics in the US, I see. There's a nontrivial number of states that at least nominally allow open carry by law, by the way. Mine is one of them. Despite this, there are reasons to choose concealed carry, such as not tempting some fruit-basket left-wingnut frozen yogurt shop owner to freak the hell out. Frankly, hoplophobes are more dangerous than any gun, and are far more likely to escalate a dangerous situation than even the criminals threatening them.

. . . but somehow, because I carry a firearm for self-defense, there are people in this world who see me as a sociopathic killer. This is why, after all this trolling and/or freaking out he does, SinisterSlay is awfully close to getting on my last nerve with all his BS.

> Hey, BTW, since you carry, have you ever thought about what you do if you're attacked in closed quarters? Like, if someone jumps you in an elevator, that's a tricky place to draw, let alone use a gun.

I'd probably fight back without using the gun, at least until I could be sure I had enough control over the situation to use it responsibly. Short of getting bushwhacked with a tire iron, there's likely to be such an opportunity, and being too eager is probably not the best option. The mind is my most effective weapon, after all; the gun's just a force multiplier.

by apotheon

AnsuGisalas appears to be someone who realizes he hasn't thought about it as much as some others, and thus asked a question. You, however, haven't thought anything through at all, but think you know it all and refuse to actually discuss anything.

Please stop holding up your ignorance as some kind of reason to be proud. "I don't know anything about the subject, and that makes me a good person!" doesn't cut it.

by apotheon

Your language has officially gotten cruder than anything else said on this subject at TR without getting the censorship treatment.

by apotheon

> And gun store thefts are quite common.

news to me

Edit: How exactly does pointing out that I hadn't heard about this warrant a downvote? I'd love to hear more about it. I can only imagine this downvote was the act of a troll like SinisterSlay.

by ansugisalas

That's the BIG stick - Your mind.

The biggest reason I'm talking at all about this subject is that I'd just like to try and make sure that people remember to use their heads, think about possible situations aforehand, do some visualization practice perhaps. Whether they prefer to carry or not.

by ansugisalas

I've seen trouble coming and chosen to stand firmly in it's way.
Met it with a smile and laughter in my eyes...
The bad guy found that highly disconcerting and after shaking my hand (I insisted), beat a hasty retreat...

Not sure I could have pulled it off with a gun in my pocket (ok, not the best place to put it!). But I am not fool enough to dictate to others how they deal with trouble. Especially since I don't know the environs in which they live.

by ansugisalas

by the trail of dead.

We can't all be fecky like you... the world would be a charnel house.

EDIT: Fixed the wrong form for fecky

by apotheon

I once talked myself out of a mugging and/or beating at the hands of two young gang members/inductees (not sure their specific status) in Southern California. In essence, I talked circles around the one who did all the talking. I think he was confused for the twenty minutes (give or take) it took for someone else to show up. With a witness on the scene -- one that I knew -- he turned his demands for my "jacket" into a request for "a light". I told him I didn't smoke, and the two of them left.

Even better, when I was in the Army I knew a guy who went home to New York City on leave. He had, like most infantrymen, taken up the habit of wearing something on his belt -- a knife or multitool. In his case, it was a Gerber multiplier, the kind with a gravity knife style plier that slide out of the handle with a flick of the wrist. He was riding on the subway, and someone threatened him with a knife. He pulled out his Gerber and flicked the pliers out, then held it out in front of him as though he meant to do battle (or perhaps remove teeth). The confrontation ended with the other guy retreating from the subway train's car into the adjacent (and empty) car.

Both he and I, in our respective circumstances, would probably not have done anything different under the circumstances if we had been carrying guns -- unless the other party did something different and more aggressive. If that had happened, we would both surely have been happier to have the option to defend ourselves effectively without getting cut open or pulped in the process.

by ansugisalas

As unfortunate as those happenings were, to have taken place in the first place, they are a good read.

The problem for me would be that getting full effect of showing that one's body does not fear harm can require getting to a range where the gun is less than optimal.

If living in areas with organized crime one might suggest that the best policy is to ALWAYS draw steel - with all that that entails, including always using it to full effect if given reason to.

But if your police is crooked, you'd better make sure you've got a movement of the people with you.

by jamesrl

Back in my younger days, my sifu (kung fu instructor) instilled in us some very valuable life lessons, and made sure we understood them before he taught us any techniques.

If at all possible, avoid violence. Run if you must.
Don't let your ego get you into fights.
Even the best fighter can have a momentary lapse and get hurt or killed by someone with lesser skills.
If an idiot insults you, and you take it seriously, there are now two idiots.
The best way to avoid violence on the street is to neither look like a victim or an aggressor. Project quiet confidence, but don't confront.
If violence comes to you, defeat your opponent as quickly as possible.

When we became students we made a pact with our Sifu. If we ever had cause to use what we've learned on a fellow human being, we had to arrange a face to face with him to discuss. Twenty five years later, I've never had to do that.

by jamesrl

I don't think I had the self control and patience I had when I was training back then.

But I do try. I fail sometimes, but I keep on trying.

by slayer_

You are now claiming a sarcasm message is trolling, you are so far under the bridge you can't see anything.

by apotheon

> Some times I've seen possible trouble coming, and if I had a gun, I might have stuck around to face it.

That's definitely a personal failing, if it's true. Every concealed carry permit holder and open carry advocate I've ever met has, when the subject came up, said that he or she is less likely to stand and face a threat now that he or she carries. There is, it seems, a naturally arising culture of responsibility for all but the most dangerous types -- sociopaths, for instance -- when they find themselves in regular possession of lethal force for purposes of self defense. If you're the rare guy who would be more likely to invite confrontation just because he's better able to defend himself with lethal force, you're probably someone who shouldn't have access to car keys, baseball bats, and kitchen knives.

There are a number of reasons for the natural rise of such a culture for that subset of the populace. One is of course a simple greater awareness of the responsibility that rests with someone who consciously chooses to arm himself or herself for self defense. Another is the fact that, on one hand, one would always prefer to come out of a confrontation unscathed, thus making the defensive display of a firearm preferable to a fistfight (all else being equal) -- and on the other hand, knowing that the consequences of having to resort to the final purpose of a firearm has far greater consequences that should weigh on the conscience of any thinking person than a few punches. Only someone lacking in basic human decency would take the fact he or she is carrying a firearm as encouragement to meet physical confrontation head-on, and while "willfully ignorant jackass" is probably an accurate description for about 98% of the people in the world, almost all of even them have at least some slim shred of human decency. If you don't -- if you would actually be more likely to stand your ground just because you could kill someone -- you should definitely exempt yourself, of your own free will, from practicing the right to keep and bear arms.

by ansugisalas

He is saying things between the lines that are so not what the point is.
Just because he's advocating something that I am not opposed to, it doesn't mean that I'll stand for him advocating it in a potentially harmful way.

by delbertpgh

People + difficult situation + gun = high stakes situation + confusion

Once you're walking around with a gun, it has a potential for use. A gun can turn you into a person who uses a gun. If you think you know who you'll be after it starts to happen, then congratulations. You must have spent a long, long time thinking about everything that could happen.

by apotheon

> A gun can turn you into a person who uses a gun.

Utter poppycock and drivel. Inanimate objects do not control me -- period. I own knives, cars, alcohol, campfire lighters, and computer power cables, too. These things do not turn me into a stabber, a drunk driver, an arsonist, or a strangler. The fact I own a laptop certainly does not turn me into a criminal security cracker, either. This "argument" of yours is beyond ridiculous.

by papa_bill

The potential for eliminating a life from this earth is not a pleasant one. I will always say "better him than me", and at this point, that is my position. I will, more than likely, hesitate at the critical moment, and may die as a result of my indecision. Few people outside a combat zone have actually shot anyone, and of those I have known, none have ever taken it lightly. Some have come back suicidal. Others came back fearing their own shadow. I don't like the idea, I don't want to be in that position. But my fists aren't good at all, and I don't thing running would work for me. I don't want to die, but I am also incredibly stubborn, and anger easily if someone is taking unfair advantage of me. So, like it or not, stupid or brave, I will use whatever I can get my hands on to "win to contest". I hope to have a viable weapon available. That's not a knife, or a rock. It would preferably be a gun. Regrets will be there either way.

by apotheon

I guess maybe residents of SoCal can bring a printout of that story with them when pleading their case for concealed carry permits if they're prone to use of social networks and criticizing dangerous criminals.

by apotheon

> Its practically a coming of age for some groups to steal a car and run down a few pedestrians.

Maybe tougher gun laws would prevent that. Oh, wait. . . .

by delbertpgh

"Knowledge of the prevalence of firearms helps to dissuade would-be criminals who fear for their lives." Back in high school, in cowboy country, I knew a number of young men who didn't seem to give a damn about their lives at all. In my hippie days, I knew some dopers and especially some dope dealers who didn't care about their lives. They were people who loved to fight, loved it more than their chances of survival.

Like I said before, stupid trumps rational. You can pile up gram weights on either side of the balance, so that it's obvious to anyone with a brain that choice A weighs superior to choice B, and then along comes a ton of stupid, and the obvious no longers matters at all.

by apotheon

Not everyone fears for his/her life. That's a given.

Not everyone is able reason his way out of a wet paper bag, either.

Not everyone is able to read an entire argument, and thus misses things like ". . . and if the guy does something stupid, there's a pretty good chance he'll get shot for it."

Not everything that glitters is gold.

Moving right along. . . .

by slayer_

But instead they use baseball bats, and fire bombs.
Last year they lit a guy on fire to take his beer.

Fortunately, no one died, unlike if guns were involved.

by slayer_

You are the only one making stupid comments at me in this discussion.

You are purposely finding my posts, neg voting them without even reading them (as obvious by your comments on posts with no text at all) and then leaving asinine comments about how stupid I am.
You sir, are the very definition of a troll.

by ansugisalas

about not judging people's choices without knowing their living conditions.

Of course, there's no guarantee the bodies aren't of disloyal or under-achieving pushers, but with that level of organized crime there's really nothing anyone can do except assume the body of stone and fight back with anything they can lay their hands on - and barring that - with claw, fist, elbow, knee, shoulder, forehead and tooth.

For that stuff, only thing to remember is that however they word their threats they'll kill you anyway. Put the price of your corpse as high as you can, and the bonus is that maybe they'll have to kill you before they start carving your flesh.

by ansugisalas

If the police is bent, an upstanding citizen may find his family targeted for revenge, since names and personal information will be purchased from loose tongues.

It takes a clear message from the people that any "coincidences" will be met with extreme belligerence and dogged pursuit to make certain that police brass takes leaks seriously.

Even then, who wants to be the one whose fate changed the system?

by ansugisalas

I can only say that I honestly felt that his "not exactly saying so" were a tendentious and intentional series of attempts to invoke the very "so", which he didn't say, exactly.

There are times when I smell a rat, and there isn't one.
There are also times when I smell a rat and it's the size of a bus.
Usually the way the target responds lets me know which it will be, and what I found doesn't put my mind at ease at all.

by papa_bill

Most people, including myself, wouldn't carry "open" even if they could. A useful gun is heavy and bulky. I know lots of deputies, detectives and other non-uniformed persons who *have* to carry on the job, but most lock it away off-duty. Those I know who do carry and don't have to carry a gun I would consider too small.
As for close quarters, no plan will cover all scenarios.

by papa_bill

But if that's the case, then you probably weren't in as much trouble as you thought.
I'll face the fact that very few people on the whole are actually attacked and robbed in their entire lives. Most people aren't often exposed to the potential threat. I was, and on three occasions the threat became all too real. Once my attacker happened to see a cruising cop slow down and take a look. Attacker fled. The second time he saw my gun sitting on the console of my van. He left quickly.
The third time I really thought might be my last day on earth. Fortunately, the police department, sherriff's department and and number of federal officers were watching very closely, and my call for help on my police radio brought them all running and fifty of so over-active members of the African Peoples' Socialist Party (most of whom were already wanted, therefore all the brass) disappeared *very* rapidly. If the law enforced people hadn't been tipped off (as I *wasn't), I might have had to shoot while running.

by ansugisalas

If the gun is your "plan" for being safe from harm, then you have a problem.
The tactically prepared mind is like your hand. Without a hand, the gun does nothing. But a hand can be useful even without a gun.
So, I'm NOT saying that you should rely only upon a readied mind, but I [u]am[/u] saying that without a readied mind, even the most powerful handgun in the world might not keep you.

by apotheon

It's not thin. It's precise. It may not look like a big difference to someone who doesn't deal with the effects of security through obscurity as a normal job function, but for me the difference is pretty significant. I can only (reasonably) assume by your attitude about it that you are lucky enough to avoid those effects the majority of the time.

by apotheon

Sometimes -- especially with some people -- putting someone on the defensive about a given comment by misreading into it can lead to the person reacting similarly to how he'd react if that were actually how he intended it to be read.

Sometimes, a person can even be led into defending something he did not intend to say by the misreadings of others, if those others cleverly enough tie things together so that they superficially appear to be logically indivisible (even if, in fact, that's only a fallacious connection).

It's often best to argue against what you think he might be implying by questioning it in a way that indicates you think that's a full-of-garbage interpretation, and the person couldn't reasonably mean that.

by ansugisalas

I have gotten into trouble trying to pull that off... I have surmised that I have accidentally given off a very condescending tone trying to explain how a person couldn't possibly have meant what I thought that persons' writing would mean.

I just go on instinct anymore, at least then when I screw up, I know it's because I was wrong, and not because maybe I was right the first time around.

Anyway, I feel that Rick wants to win an argument, and he can do that with someone else. I have better things to do.

You helped me disengage and back off, thanks. There are enough futilities in the world.

by santeewelding

...how you divine security "attitude" in my two posts above is beyond me. You got yourself a magical dowsing rod, or something? And, why trifle with attitude of another in the first place?

by apotheon

1. Your words online are the only way we have to judge attitude -- so you're either making mocking statements about it or misrepresenting yourself. I suppose I might have said "apparent" there, but given the context of assumption I thought that part was perfectly obvious.

2. Who's trifling with your attitude? You can keep it, if you like.

by apotheon

Anyone who says that should probably have his badge taken away for at least twenty years. There's a fair bit of maturing left to do, there.

by santeewelding

You can see both sides at once.

Again: what compels your preoccupation with attitude? In re, do you go bottom up: harvesting words online pointing you in a direction? Or, top down: harvesting those that justify pre-existing suspicion?

I say, [i]suspicion[/i], because that's the strongest word I'll use. It's as far as I can personally go. It is not a thing worth getting out in front of, preemptively, for me.

You?
.

by apotheon

Sometimes, I think you just dislike it when people address the actual topic at hand.