Presumably bad guys can get US guns pretty easily too?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jamesrl
I worked at a 7-11, late shift. Two young guys, one jumped the counter, put his fist in my stomach and pretended he had a knife. I didn't believe he had one, but my response was the same. He could have the till. Corporate policy at that time was to let that happen, resisters were fired. I could have easily hurt him badly as he came over the counter, but since there were two, I knew the odds of accomplishing that and getting the drop on the second one were low.
They never seriously were a threat to me. They took the money from the till, didn't take my wallet. They left.
Because I stayed calm I was able to describe them very well and that eventually lead to their arrest. I testified at their trial. I had heard that they had threatened to kill me when they got out, but I was off to university anyways, many miles away. If I had seen them in a dark alley after their sentance, I would have presumed the worst and defended myself with force.
I take exception only to, "They never seriously were a threat to me."
I would correct your account to say, [i]you[/i] may not have perceived a serious threat.
All three elements of ability, means, and opportunity were ongoing for real -- "Condition Black", as they say: lethal assault, right now, in superior number, no less.
I probably would have soiled myself.
by hal 9000
The beauty of a well concealed Hand Gun is that the possibility of any person having one is a open opportunity for the Police to shoot first and then think about asking questions latter.
Officer :- I pulled the Posh car up on a minor traffic offense and shot the occupants.
Judge :- Why did you shoot the occupants.
Officer :- With the new laws I was in fear of my life as there is the possibility the the occupants of the car had concealed hand guns and could shoot me.
Judge :- Did they in fact turn out to have any weapons at all int he car.
Officer :- Yes your Honor they had a Ball Point Pen and Car Keys.
Judge :- Case Dismissed the officer acted properly to maintain his life.
Yea right I think not but it's always a possibility. :p
Col :^0
by jamesrl
There was no point at which I perceived a threat, that is true.
There was a flash of a moment when my training almost kicked in and I almost nailed the guy as he came over the counter. I had the opportunity.
My perception was they were clearly focussed on the money. Back then, in 1979, the max in the cash register was $40. I think I had more in my wallet.
If I had thought they had intent to harm me when they approached, I would have handled it differently. We had a piece of steel under the counter used in shelving that was over a foot long that made a decent club.
by ansugisalas
but I think soiling oneself is counterproductive, at least in that situation.
I'm pretty sure it makes it harder to run, for instance.
by ansugisalas
by ansugisalas
by delbertpgh
by ansugisalas
I am over here, Lion is over there. Context.
Signs came a bit later. First unintentional signs : *sound of scuffle in dark outside*
Then intentional signs.
A gun too is sometimes a sign : it has a form, and it has a meaning. It is a sign when the meaning doesn't derive 1:1 from its form.
by delbertpgh
I suppose that if you meet a dangerous situation, with no weapon, where your liberty, your property, and your pride would be spoiled a bit by just turning tail and leaving, you'd do that if it meant saving your life and your health. Or maybe you'd just stand and fight because life to you, in that moment, is not worth living with such humiliation. Probably you'd choose safety.
Put a gun in your pocket. Would you behave differently? Would you find yourself, as you say, "someone lacking in basic human decency (who) would take the fact that he or she is carrying a firearm to meet physical confrontation head-on?"
Here's something else to stew on, if you've got a few seconds to think hard. Pull out a gun to control a situation. Somebody six feet away from you does not accept your control, believes that you will not shoot, believes that by talking and moving toward you he can disarm you. What is your one choice here? Shoot, as soon as he misbehaves, before he has your gun, and shoot immediately. At the instant you wield a firearm in close quarters, where if anything goes wrong it can be turned against you by a lawless man whom you have just threatened with deadly force, you have given up your freedom to not kill somebody. If he chooses not to do the right thing, if he behaves in a way that carries the potential of greater risk, you can only pull the trigger. You have made absent your basic human decency; you can only behave like a calculating machine measuring a threat.
That's the case, if you plan to survive the situation you're in, with a gun in hand.
Been there -- less than a second to go, the one time.
A seeming million times in my mind beforehand. A million times practicing live. A million times asking myself, "Why?"
It didn't go down the way you dream from the armchair.
by apotheon
Check suicide rates for violent criminals in prison.
Hint: Outside of specific, limited subcategories of criminal, it's pretty low.
by apotheon
To grasp what AnsuGisalas means, it generally helps to know that he's a linguist.
To grasp what santeewelding means, it generally helps to know that he's trying to be difficult to nail down to meaning anything at all (though I half-expect him to say something cryptic and vague in response to this that seems to dispute what I say in a hand-wavy manner).
by slayer_
If that is what you are saying, then I agree with you, looking to the prison population makes sense.
Has anyone ever surveyed a prison to see how many inmates are suicidal?
The entire discussion about carrying firearms is interesting. As mentioned in this thread is the need for a person to be mentally prepared to defend himself. No weapon can help if you are not ready, able and understand that the process of defending oneself will be a life changing event no matter what the outcome.
I have carried concealed and openly for more than 20 years. Concealed where the sheeple tend to freak out if they see a gun, and open the rest of the time.
I am always armed and most of the time with a 1911/45ACP on my hip and a 32ACP in my pocket. As for the benefit of open or concealed...if concealed was the deterrent then I would expect police to carry concealed. Of course they need to have rapid access and concealed slows deployment.
Open carry is often discussed as giving the criminal the knowledge of who needs to be taken out first. I believe that few criminals actually want to get into a conflict with an armed person so they avoid open carrying people. Others, like Dave Workman, believe it just attracts unneeded attention to the gun toting person.
Fortunately I live in a state and county where open carry is common and most people don't notice or don't seem to. In the Seattle area, open carry creates some amazing expressions on peoples faces. We open-carried there in an attempt to help people understand that carrying a gun is legal and in Washington state does not require a permit (only concealed carry requires a permit.)
If you want to learn more about open carry in your state visit opencarry.org. There are lots of discussion items on both concealed and open carry.
by ansugisalas
Police. The ones you see, our deputies.
Except for those who have it turned around in their heads.
by papa_bill
One of the most interesting statistics is "11% of police shootings kill an innocent person - about 2% of shootings by citizens kill an innocent person."
http://gunfacts.info/pdfs/gun-facts/6.0/Gun-Facts-v6.0-screen.pdf
by ansugisalas
by apotheon
by apotheon
> "You can carry and use a gun for any legal purpose."
The simple elegance of that statement is a beautiful thing to behold, and makes the stupidity of highly complex firearms laws quite obvious.
by slayer_
by apotheon
by slayer_
by ansugisalas
by apotheon
by ansugisalas
It went a bit like this:
The statement above seems superfluous (for people in the US).
The first part "you can carry a gun" is already in the 2nd amendment.
The second part is vague, since it leaves undefined what is a legal use. So if legal use has to be defined somewhere, it means that this "law X" defining legal use of firearms, or legal use of force in general, or even legal actions in general - together with the 2nd amendment will already cover all of the above statement.
But please explain if I'm wrong.
And what the fluck is up with all the disappearing posts?
by papa_bill
by papa_bill
by apotheon
The legal purpose is any use of a firearm that does not break a law. Thus, using a firearm to plink at targets is legal, because there is no law against that. Using a firearm to murder someone is illegal, because there is a law against murder.
I don't see how one needs firearms laws per se to arrive at the same conclusion.
re: disappearing posts
TR is broken. It always has been, and always will be, as far as I can tell. It just gets more broken over time.
This business of law and guns and simplicity looks about to go over a cliff.
Such as when Apotheon tells us about "a law against murder". I know of none. I do know of descriptive and prescriptive laws. They take the form of, "if...then..." I don't know of any proscriptive ones.
Easy to go over the cliff with slippery pronouncements and make us all pay.
by apotheon
Descriptive is what you do before you get to "murder"; not, "regarding" murder. Prescriptive is then what you do with regard to your finding of murder, and not in theory.
I [i]am[/i] taking part in your so-called productive discussion of actuality. Excuse my deplorable manners, though, for chewing your fat and spitting the gristle out into your face.
by slayer_
by papa_bill
for everyone applying for our police academy. Anyone who has an attitude like that would be denied entrance.
Unfortunately, they often apply at small towns, who don't have the resources to screen applicants closely. Of course, in these towns, the opportunity to shoot someone is pretty limited (think Barney Fife and his *one bullet*).
by apotheon
by apotheon
I understood your statement just fine, but I treated it as all trolling insults deserve to be treated:
. . .
by slayer_
by apotheon
Slayer_ . . .
That's pretty much the whole point. I find people whose only discernible purpose here is to destroy discussion pretty unpalatable sometimes.
by papa_bill
Since Hernando De Soto.Since the Indian Wars. Since the Revolution. Since the Wawah of Northern Aggression. Since WWI, WWII, Korea, Cold War, Viet Nam,. Desert Storm, All those. But we were right in the middle of most of them, like it or not.
.We sent our best soldiers, sailors and airmen. Many didn't come come back, many did, but worse for wear.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending