Discussion Locked

Pros and Cons of Windows

0 helpful
476 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

476 replies

by hal 9000

She asks the exact same question but at the same time finds it totally acceptable to turn on & off her TV & VCR with the same button on the remote. :)

Yes I know it's silly but who has ever accused M$ of even being close to sensible? :D

Col ]:)

by glenvdb

Microsoft is my bread and butter, If it worked 100% then I would be out of a job, but that being said, I actually like the ease of use, the fact that "everybody" has the same OS, makes my job a heck of a lot easier to troubleshoot and fix. Remember 90% of the time, the problem is with crappy software, not with Windows itself. Poorly written DLL's and just plain Borgware, that wants to change Windows (AOL and Norton are prime examples).
Linux on the other hand, has gotten so much bad press lately for the badly written code, I am glad I have NOTHING to do with it. Windows (and Mirosoft)will always create employment, and give people the chance to feed their families. Linux will take a while, but it WILL die, and be replaced by another form of Unix.

by apotheon

Bad press for badly written code . . . ?

What the heck are you talking about?

If you really think Linux is going to die any time soon to be replaced by "another form of Unix", you probably don't know much about A) economic forces, B) open source licensing, or C) both. I mean, sure, all things come to an end, but the same could be said of the planet.

by gphoto45

XP boots faster, and is far more compatible that Linux copies of it. If Linux was so great, why do they just copy Windows apps. As for compatiblity, try running Mepis, or Knoppix with Debian machines. I just replaces 11 Linux machines with WIndowns XP and the company productivity shot thru the roof. As for security holes, check on the linux security leaks before you start making statement. Linux is not much more secure. A simple Fork attack will drop almost all versions of linux to its knees. (Expection if Debian!) Like the Mac users, it is a Elitist attitude that is hurting Linux. On the subject of viruses, Linux does have viruses. But you don't make a tire that is 29" tall, when only one car uses it. Linux is just too obscure yet to be a target.
I use Linux and Windows, but since the cost of using Linux is far higher than Windows, Companies are not impressed. In reference to one of the earlire comments, Windows is offering Distrubited Software, not going to it.

by rwitschger

I am a systems administrator of many years now. I happen to like MS Windows for a number of reasons. Keep in mind I will list these from a business perspective instead of a home based user.

First, it's easy. User like it since it's hat they know. With so many users running a windows box at home, they have become somewhat comforatable with it.

It's easy to find help. The new genereation of out of college IT Specialists don't really know Linux or Unix very well. You can get someone to support Windows alot more readily and cheap.

While Freeware is great, support is better. As with all that is Microsoft, you have to pay to call them, but when you do, you get an english speaking and knowledgeable person to help you through your problem. Also, you can take the free approached and get answers to really complicated problems quickly by googling Microsoft's site.

Application support. Once you *have* the newest version of Windows, any reasonable windows application will run. Most of those vendor specific Apps that all of us Systems admins *love* will run on Windows 95, so you can feel fairly confident that they will run in Windows XP. I am yet to find a single vendor that will give you a Linux application.

I want to make a point about Active Directory (AD). I know that many do not support AD, but I am a firm believer. Between group policy and third party application integration, AD is simply the most beautiful thing that Linux lacks. Sure there is Samba, wich does a pitiful AD simulation at best, and there is LDAP, which works well when you get it working, but AD beats them both.

As a counterpoint to many of the arguments against Windows that I saw above. Windows is not free, no; however, when you are a business, neither is Linux. Redhat AS3 costs money, we have to pay for each and every server to simply auto update itself. And why is it auto updating? Security holes and the like. Now, this is alot like Windows yes, but I am paying to license Windows, not to patch it. Moreover, all of those really great free Linux based software packs like Apache and Spamassassin have FREE WINDOWS counterparts. People are porting these programs over to Windows quite consistantly now. So, minus the audits, you don't gain that much with a Linux system.

Windows XP is pretty good for a business once you have it setup. It can be givien a theme based on your company, it's stable and esy to support. Once you have a Windows computer on a Windows Domain, you can easily support that system.

Windows 2003 Server is great.

And security holes? That's the best argument against windows? If you are afraid of security holes at the OS level, you are doing something wrong. The perimeter of your network is where security comes from, not the OS!!

I won't be checking back here, so persoanl attacks because I tend to support a Windows Domain will get you no where.

Spelling and grammar are not checked, sorry.

by apotheon

You make some good points, but I think you make some unsupportable points based on ignorance as well. not your fault. I'll see if I can help enlighten you.

"[i]While Freeware is great, support is better. As with all that is Microsoft, you have to pay to call them, but when you do, you get an english speaking and knowledgeable person to help you through your problem. Also, you can take the free approached and get answers to really complicated problems quickly by googling Microsoft's site.[/i]"

You're probably not aware of this, but the Linux community has actually won awards for being the "best" technical support available. Much of this is because of the quality and quantity of free, helpful support you can get by participating in LUG mailing lists, which are just awesome. Every new Linux user should join two.

"[i]Application support. Once you *have* the newest version of Windows, any reasonable windows application will run.[/i]"

Linux is even more broadly software compatible. New versions of Windows do actually break older software, and more often than new Linux versions will break older versions of software, to say nothing of how friggin' easy it is to upgrade software to newer versions in Linux. Even better, though, is the fact that you don't necessarily have to upgrade your Linux version to use newer software, but it's almost impossible to get a brand-new application to run on a Windows version that is two revisions old. Best of all, upgrading your Linux version is about as easy as can be, and in Debian (for instance) can be accomplished with nothing more complicated than typing "aptitude install [kernel version]". That's it.

"[i]I am paying to license Windows, not to patch it.[/i]"

Then, of course, you have to pay separately to upgrade your Windows version every time you decide you want to stay with the times. Besides, RHEL isn't the only distribution available, and you can get Linux perfectly free for business use if you want it. RHEL isn't the only commercially viable Linux version available. I'd even say it's not the best, generally speaking.

"[i]all of those really great free Linux based software packs like Apache and Spamassassin have FREE WINDOWS counterparts[/i]"

Your use of the word "all" in that sentence is a pretty significant bit of exaggeration.

by rzimmerman

In the corporate world we don't have much to say about what we prefer. We are stuck with Windows. We use XP and Windows 2000 server. The faults have already been reported by others ad nuseaum. The pluses are that many developers write application code for Windows, so there is a high liklihood you will be able to find an application to support your budget. Also there are millions of trained technicians that can support Windows, and of course we need them all since it requires a lot of support.
We will be looking seriously at Linux this year but I doubt we will go down that path, since that would require our key vendors to also support Linux which just won't happen. Fortunately in the personal computing world I am not stuck with Windows, so I have a nice new Apple IMAC with a fabulous OS called Tiger.

by Member 28898618

The guy wanted comparison of windows versions, not your timid complaint about non windows OSes which you obviously dont have much knowledge of. Execs are using Microsoft because they are less interested in the pangs of semi-competent techies, than in having a successful business. The capabilities of the MS products lines go far beyond the needs of developers, or of isolated nerdgs sitting behind their favorit C++ routines. This is why the techie community should not be selecting tools for the business. They would make the business infrastructure a tatter of hacks, and kludges. A favorite tool here and another their is not how a cohesive infrastructure gets built. It is done using a critical mass of interconnected capability, like that which Microsoft offers. If you are a lone coder, have fun with Linux, if you are working in IT for a company of any size, with a user base consisting of Finance, Shipping, Manufacturing, Legal, Human Resources, Logistics etc, then you will provide them with a working environment and tools that let them talk to each other.

by rzimmerman

You obviously haven't worked in business for very long. If I missed the point then so did the hundreds of other responders. I have an MBA in Economics and have managed in IT for many years. I came from the non-tech side of the business which is why I realize how many billions of dollars IT wastes every year supporting Windows OS, whether desktop or server. I don't want to get into a pissing contest, since all of us are stuck with Windows in Corporate American whether we like it or not. I also know a good OS from a mediocre one, which Windows is.

by apotheon

He or she did not necessarily miss the point. The original post asked for the benefits and detriments of Windows. Several versions were listed. It was not clear whether the question pertained to comparing all those versions to each other or simply comparing them as a whole line of OSes to other options.

As for the rest of your post, you make a great bit of marketing for vertically integrated single-vendor hostageware. Aside from that, I don't see any value in it.

by Member 18971163

I would like to reply to a few of your slanted comments if I may.

"First thing to remember about MS Windows is it is aimed at the lowest common denominator - a user who knows nothing - and it achieves the goal."

-The user of a computer is just that. A USER. A user does not want to know how to configure DFS or set up an ACL. They just want their friggin spreadsheets to work. Microsoft gets this, and makes one of the most user-friendly Operating Systems, in my opinion. Of course there are more advanced features (tons of them actually), but these should be left to the Administrators of the systems.

"Best Workstation is XP Pro with SP1 not 2, best server is 2000 Advanced Server."

-XP Pro is excellent, but why not SP2? Are you just showing your inability to correctly configure Windows Firewall? We have SP2 runnning on 150 desktops with NO problems, with the firewall turned on. Folks, don't believe the drivel that SP2 is unstable, because it is not by any means. Also, why dismiss Windows Server 2003? It has tons more command-line tools and has made drastic improvements on Active-Directory. Unless, you are used to dealing with mom and pop shops that do not use such mind bogglingly advanced features as Active-Directory (sarcasm intended).

"Major cons not mentioned above - default configurations waste too much space (drive reserves - 10% recycle bin, 12% restore)"

-Again, this is to save beginning users from themselves. What is wrong with that? If you don't like this, it is easily changed. Either manually or through scripting or Group Policy.

"Cost much more than most alternatives (not the case originally). "

-Have you seen what Red Hat Linux charges for support? Sure the alternative Operating Systems may cost less for the installation files, but you will pay much more for lack of support and non-standardization. Of course, if you had any business sense you would have thought of this already, right?

"After 20 years of using MS I am in the process of going to Linux with WINE to run my applications because most of my old 98 apps wont run in XP, thus I need a dual boot XP/98 where as Linux wiuth WINE will run them all without a reboot."

-Have you tried compatibility mode with your 98 apps? The fact that you have been dual booting shows your lack of experience in IT. Even if the programs will not run in compatibility mode why not just run VMWare Workstation or Microsoft Virtual PC to run your 98 OS in a Virtual Machine. This is a much more stable solution than WINE will ever be.

Your short list of pros for Windows just shows your lack of experience with the Operating System. There are many advanced features that can be found with a little education and research.

by nmeyer

A couple of posts from people that use Macs instaed of talking smack on them. I made a living on PC's and how they were so tough to network and support. I made a lot of money and know a LOT about PC's. I came home to a Mac - and am a loyal fan. I don't want to fix my computer at home - I just want it to work.

Hardware and software is not an issue. There is plenty of both.

While PC's have some open features - the OS is a big black box - OSX less so.

Find me a windows computer that can run:
1. most major pre OSX apple software
2. OSX software
3. Windows software
4. X-Window applications
5. BSD command shell applications
And we'll talk.
And the CPU is typicaly classified as a low end supercomuter to boot.

Windows fans can talk smack when they have a close to equal product. Until then - patch your OS and complain about inturrupts block your viruses spyware and and go away.

I have work to do. :)

by dkt999

First and foremost, I'm making the assumption that you are actually looking for some objective discussion on this topic and not simple Windows, UNIX and or Linux "bashing" or "love-fest".

Given this, the 1st and most important question that needs to be answered is, "what is the purpose of your report?"

If this report is for some type of class project, then I hope you get a good grade. If on the other hand this report is for an actual business purpose, then there are several other really important questions / issues (e.g. business, not just IT) you should address that are related to this topic and not simply "is Windows good or bad". Such as:

1. What are the business need, requirements, drivers, etc. behind this report?

2. Who will be affected by this decision?

3. How with the O/S be used and what will it have to support?
(e.g. If you are running a high-volume, 24x7 application tied to a terra-byte / clustered database & OLAP data-warehouse, etc., etc. then Windows probably isn't the best choice. On the other hand, if this is for a small office of 5-20 people with needs for a small, effective COTS applications running on SQL Server or the like, then Windows probably is a good choice. Again, depends on the "need")

4. Consider the $$ costs. If you are a complete Windows based organization now, would it be worth the cost / effort to introduce UNIX or Linux, something you & the rest of your IT staff have no experience? Conversely, if you already support more than 1 O/S, then what is $$ cost difference between a good UNIX box vs. a good Windows or Linux box?

5. What types of applications does your organization need / require? If you build them yourself, no problem. If you have to purchase, then what O/S' do they run on?

Answer these questions first and whether or not Windows has some issues (which it does) may very well be a moot point.

Simply, if your organization needs software X and software X only runs on Windows, you run Windows. Or if your organization is only made up of 5-20 people, do you purchase high $$ UNIX boxes met to support 100's of people?

by hal 9000

In every case where I've had to ring M$ for support and bear in mind I'm a Certified Partner and are supposed to get preferential treatment it has been a total mess up which has required at least 4 total reloads from scratch and even after hours on the phone I've never got a correct answer. SO M$ support isn't all it's cracked up to be and the customer pays in most instances so it isn't free either.

Now take a company like IBM who has their own Linux Development Staff who Liaise with both RedHat and Novel if they are unable to solve a problem on the phone for you they take the problem away and get back to you within 24 hours with a solution. When you have a big Server fall over it's far easier to get support on a Linux OS and have it up and running properly than it is on a M$ OS sure you might get it back up but it will not be running right until you have fixed the bug that has taken it out. My biggest bugbear was the patches being released which did a lot more damage that they where supposed to cure and I've had to pull a Backup HDD out of the safe more times than I care to think about to get a system up and running again in very short order as yet on Unix/Linux/BSD I have not as yet had this problem but I've only been using Unix since 1972. :)

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

And replacing them with PC's right?

Mac's have their place but it's the people who sell them and use them that drive me nuts as they are constantly telling everyone just how bad their systems are in the work place and wanting PC's and I'll bet that when they get their PC's they'll be thinking just how good the Mac's where.

But with only 5% of the market Apple is nothing more than a Bit Player no matter how technically advanced their products are. My Brother in Law bought a new Power Mac or whatever the Notebook version is now called and was sold a Windows version of Norton's AV by the same people who sold him the NB since even the sellers can not get their act together they do not engender a lot of confidence in their products.

I supposes that as a group of Apple dealers got together to make one massive Apple seller and promptly went broke within 3 months as well tends to make me wary of their business practices. It's one thing to have to pay through the nose for support but it is a totally different thing to have nothing more than a boat anchor when the hardware breaks and you can not get it repaired/replaced.

Col ]:)

by Member 28898618

Microsoft is powerful, and successful...This makes those with small penises, or inferiority feel threatened. The Open Source community, conspiracy types like jdclyde, wannabeez like hackers, and naysayers like Mac lovers. Those who want something for nothing, like the European Union, and the worst of all, those who compete with Microsoft using the courts and lawsuits, like Sun and IBM all share one thing - they blame their lot on the rise and presence of Microsoft.

They are all wrong.

by hal 9000

But didn't IBM make Microsoft?

I was working for IBM when they released PC's and granted I was working mainframes so I didn't really see too much of the Play Toys that where being sold to the general public but I believe that they all where loaded with MS stuff.

If it had not been for IBM MS would never have the current Market Penetration that it has today which God Gates was quite happy to go along with while it suited him and then he wet his pants when he saw Xerox's Prototype and had to start to develop Windblows which has been a massive backward step as it as yet has still to reach the same levels of security that Unix had all those years ago.

Col ]:)

by Member 28898618

You arent much of a security guy if this is the extent of your understanding of the difference between Solaris (an obsolete and beaten OS), and MS Windows Server. Both OSes listen on ports, ALL ports can be closed, but if you dont know what you are doing, you could disable critical services and thus make the OS inoperable. Windows AND Unix have security vulnerabilities, Windows gets more press for obvious reasons, it is the most pervasive, and guess what? Many of the hackers out there are Open Source fanatics. The browser is NOT embedded in the OS, this is an Uban myth. But then you really dont speak from expertise, you are an obvious low level tech who exposes your minimal knowledge repeating such myth.

by hal 9000

Banks, Government Departments or big Financial Agencies are running Windows anything as a front door to the Internet or for that matter which Windows OS is capable of running a 1,000 CPU Blade?

The bulk of the Internet is built on Linux and Apache and that is the way it has been for ever and by the way things are going the way things will remain. The big Financial institutions continue to run Large Unix Main Frames or Blades depending on how old their hardware is and it has proven almost unbreakable so far which is a lot more than can be said for any form of Windows.

Col ]:)

by jaguariuna1

I do belief Windows is, and remains, a necessavy Evil...... Like there is nothing in Linux yet to substitue for programs like Nero, Winamp, and the likes........ Linux remains hard for installing new programs, (which are a Cinch for Windows)..... One's grandmother would have troubles with that!!...... Also, ultimately, one must give credit to Windows, for basically creating the Internet, as we know it.... Most Linux OS' are downloaded using Windows, even though the Windows copy may ultimately be bootlegged, as they do in Asia, and everywhere else!! Moral of the story: Windows to me is still a necessary Evil!!... I, and some of my friends, double boot..... It will make one use the best of the two Worlds: Windows AND Linux!! Use and Abuse, please!!

by jaqui

k3d and nero for linux.

xine, among others are actually better than winamp... and there is a winamp look and feel media player with linux.

installing a package like an rpm or deb is click and go, type in admin password.
dead easy, just as easy as windows.. since with windows, if set up right, you actually have to log out and log in as administrator to install programs.

why is linux, freebsd, openbsd usually downloaded with windows? because the pc is shipped with the virus installed. if the local vendors would carry them with other os options then people would buy them with the os they want installed.

by Member 28898618

Huh? Standard? Oxymoron... Windows takes a licenses and trained tech to support it properly because it is filled with so much capability..sorta like a fighter jet. You dont put a car mechanic ( a unix hack) in a windows environment and expect them to understand what to do. Note that those who think they can compare Windows with other OSes are always barely knowledgeable in regard to Windows. They are like French school kid taught to hate America.

by jmgarvin

So you are saying:
a) *nix is a kluged together OS
b) Windows is far more efficient and capable as a server
c) Windows and *nix cannot be compared because ???

The essense of your posts sounds like something the underpants gnomes would come up with.

by apotheon

You must come from the Bizarro universe where everything is backwards. Are you being funny? Is this sarcasm?

Take it from someone that started out as a Microsoft certified IT professional and gradually migrated to Linux: you've mostly got it backwards, chum. I'm somewhat expert with both, still more expert with Windows than Linux, and in pretty much complete disagreement with your post.

Hell, I've been schooling Windows system and network administrators in Windows system architecture and network management here in TR for months. Considering the necessities of technology familiarity for consulting, and my experience as an IT consultant, I'd say that this post of yours combined with your profile's statement that you're an IT consultant pretty much adds up to an advertisement for anyone but you unless what's really wanted is a Windows salesman.

by liberty&justice

Not coming from a multi-tasking environment, Windows has made considerable practical adjustments. But even XP Pro still has some troubles. I have noticed it "pausing" other processing especially when doing something related to networks and CD/DVD stuff.

Some of this could be poor drivers, etc. However, I suspect that much of it is simply a reflection of it's parents. In some other OSs, it is much harder to override multi-tasking than to implement it - again parentage.

The OS I use the most is AMOS - almost 30 years old with DEC parentage. From the assembly language up, all was designed with multi-tasking as a primary goal. I suspect the same is true for UNIX/Linux. But with the huge amount of "bad" code that exists and has plenty of usually "happy" users, Windows has thus far failed to keep up with 30 years ago but is still the most popular.

So good code does not, alone, make a winner.

by Member 28898618

The brief history is this: IBM was an oppressive monopoly during the 60s and 70s. THe government broke them up (long story here). Gates and others were writing software for the PC long before IBM got into it. Gates wrote software originally for the Altair and later even for Apple. Gates put out the FIRST commercial version of Unix, called XENIX back in the 70s. When IBM came out with their PC (apple owned the market at the time), they had two OSes. One was theirs, PCDOS, the other was Gates, MSDOS. Gates was brilliant charging less for his product and thus took the market early.

Today, we see IBM, bitter and beaten, trying to knowk MS out by taking over the Open Source community. IBM did not procude the best PC, they did not p roduce the best OS for it, and today, they really can claim little in regard to real progress in the software industry, other than the 360 project many years ago.

by mswanberg

Here are my opinions on your takes, and a few more of my own...

1. Avoid the current because of one potential future? Sounds narrowminded to me. And off-topic.

2. And Linux does not have these same potential issues? The only reason the majority of these attacks target Windows machines is that the vast majority of PCs run Windows. If and when Linux is the OS on the majority of machines, all a hacker has to do is pour through the EASILY DOWNLOADED source code!

3. To me, the main reason that Windows machines are considered unstable is that people install and uninstall tons of software on them. I am a well-versed bright experienced computer user and I FREQUENTLY throw up my hands at trying to install Linux apps. It's like a game the OS plays just to get stuff installed. VERY frequently, I find a Windows equivalent of what I'm looking for, that works, doesn't require fifty pre-requisites, and installs and configures in about 5 minutes. Perhaps it is this plethora of software that is available for the Windows OS, coupled with the easy install features (and incomplete uninstall features) that makes Windows PCs unstable overall. In the end, I have 4 Windows boxes and 2 Linux boxes at home. The Windows machines run 24/7 with a few hiccups here and there. The Linux boxes, even though they don't crash, they don't work, can't recognize simple hardware configs such as USB keyboards and mice, and when I try to upgrade or install anything, it's a bloody nightmare. And then I try 45 different flavors of Linux to see if any will give me what I want (something more than an email and www client out-of-the-box would be nice, please), 42 of them don't set up X right and then I have no GUI. So, yes, of course Linux is stable, because it just sits there, few people can install stuff properly, and then it takes hours upon hours to read manuals and search the net to figure out how to config a file somewhere only to find that file doesn't exist! It's maddening. And I'm experienced! Think of what might happen in the hands of an average PC user.

Here's an example. I installed RedHat clean, choosing to install EVERYTHING! I consulted one of my several RedHat books (not even generic Linux books, but specifically RedHat books). There would be, for example, "Step 1: edit the blah-blah file looking for these entries." Well, either the blah-blah file doesn't exist, or else the entries mentioned do not exist in the file! Frequently this happens! And that's from a fresh install!

I have never had anything like that happen on a Windows box. I have never had, for instance, "edit the registry" only to find there IS no registry.

4. There are generally alternatives to MS' apps. OpenOffice runs on Windows, for instance. Don't hate the OS because the apps aren't to your liking.

5. Again, that's apps, not OS.

All in all, I think Microsoft has done a wonderful job of making PCs accesible to the layperson. Unfortunately, a handful of enterprising twerps have made the experience horrible, with virii, spyware, adware, and other hacks. Is Windows perfect? Of course not. But Linux is hardly a solution either.

And to blame Windows for the security holes is like blaming the rape victim for the rape. People are attacking, doing illegal things to try and subvert other people's equipment. Unless Microsoft has these hackers and virus authors on the payroll, I find it hard to believe that they could be at fault.

I am reminded of a quote from the FreeBSD folks (BTW, FreeBSD couldn't get X configged right on my machines either): "We do what we do because we love Unix. Linux people do what they do because they hate Windows."

by apotheon

I'm finding it difficult to believe your post wasn't made in jest, particularly considering your statement about "hackers" (incorrect usage of the term, by the way) and source code availability. Perhaps you're not familiar with the "many eyes" principle of software security.

"[i]The only reason the majority of these attacks target Windows machines is that the vast majority of PCs run Windows. If and when Linux is the OS on the majority of machines, all a hacker has to do is pour through the EASILY DOWNLOADED source code![/i]"

First, no, that's not the only reason. Windows is an easier target for reasons that are clear to anyone with an understanding of the basic architecture of both OS designs. Something as simple as true multi-user design has a significant effect on OS security.

Second, no. Reading source code doesn't magically impart upon one the ability to violate system security. Reverse-engineering tactics are the most effective for finding security holes in software, because it's not the code that determines a system's vulnerabilities, but its behavior, and usually at the points where one program communicates with another. In fact, access to the source code even makes it easier to write secure software, for the OS, since you are better able to properly make use of the API when writing code to interface with the OS. On the other hand, access to source code does allow one the ability to improve the source code. I would think someone whose profile describes him/her as a developer would know this.

"[i]To me, the main reason that Windows machines are considered unstable is that people install and uninstall tons of software on them.[/i]"

Interesting. Yes, it's true that refraining from installing and uninstalling software all the time helps keep Windows more stable. On the other hand, I install and uninstall software on my Linux systems [b]all the friggin' time[/b] and that [b]never[/b] produces system stability problems as a result. Seems to me that Windows has stability issues, based on that.

"[i]I am a well-versed bright experienced computer user and I FREQUENTLY throw up my hands at trying to install Linux apps.[/i]"

I can only guess at how you're trying to accomplish installation of software. You might be doing it wrong. Maybe you should try using a dependency tracking software management system, like aptitude, which is standard on Debian, or YaST2 on SuSE, or emerge on Gentoo, or YUM on Yellow Dog, or any of a number of others. What are you doing, "installing" from source tarballs? There's nothing wrong with doing that, if that's how you want to do it, but complaining about dependency tracking if that's your methodology is a little like complaining that it's taking too long to get to work in the mornings because you refuse to use your car, or even your bicycle, or for that matter your shoes.

"[i]Perhaps it is this plethora of software that is available for the Windows OS[/i]"

Let's see here . . .
It seems there are about 15,000 unique software packages in the x86 stable distribution of Debian, in the Main archives alone (not counting Non-Free or Contrib archives). That only includes stuff you can download and install with nothing more complex than a single one-line aptitude command (such as "aptitude install package-name"), or an apt command if you prefer ("apt-get install package-name"). There's also Synaptic, the acclaimed GUI front-end for that software management system. Windows doesn't even provide anything anywhere near as simple and easy, let alone anything that offers 15,000 unique software packages. None of this in any way precludes you from installing additional software that isn't available in the Debian apt archives (or on the full install CD set), though in all the time I've used Debian I've never had need to install software that wasn't available using apt or aptitude (both do the same thing, just in slightly different ways). Having gotten used to using the Debian software archives, I find the selection of software available for Windows to be anemic at best, to say nothing of the inconvenience of having to go to the store or order installation CDs for major applications rather than typing "aptitude install package-name" at the command line and waiting about fifteen or twenty seconds for it to finish.

"[i]they don't work, can't recognize simple hardware configs such as USB keyboards and mice, and when I try to upgrade or install anything, it's a bloody nightmare[/i]"

What the heck distro are you using? Is this something like Red Hat 6? The problems you're having aren't even familiar to me with modern Linux distributions. As for being a bloody nightmare to upgrade or install hardware: When was the last time you swapped out a part in a Linux system and had it tell you that you would have to call the software vendor to get a new OS key?

"[i]something more than an email and www client out-of-the-box would be nice, please[/i]"

What else do you need that isn't provided "out-of-the-box" in Linux but is provided by Windows "out-of-the-box"? Seriously. A standard install with KDE or Gnome usually includes several each of office suites, web browsers, groupware applications, database managers, integrated development environments, revision control systems, media players, image editors, network traffic analyzers, advanced partitioning systems, IM clients, IRC clients, email clients, software management systems, system resource monitors, games, desktop kitsch, CD burning programs, and a number of other things that don't occur to me off the top of my head. In fact, it's in part because of the glut of "standard" software with KDE and Gnome (the two most popular desktop environments) that I prefer lighter, leaner window managers.

"[i]I have never had anything like that happen on a Windows box. I have never had, for instance, 'edit the registry' only to find there IS no registry.[/i]"

Linux doesn't have a registry. It has separate configuration files. If you don't want to deal with config files, use GUI or Curses-based configuration editing utilities. If you really, really want a registry, use Gnome, which now has a registry of its own.

"[i]There are generally alternatives to MS' apps. OpenOffice runs on Windows, for instance. Don't hate the OS because the apps aren't to your liking.[/i]"

Don't tell me you don't know that OpenOffice.org runs on Linux. In fact, that's where it started. Some kind soul ported it to Windows to help wean people off that rat's-nest of software Microsoft is churning out. As for alternatives, you should see the long list of alternatives that show up when I type "apt-cache search office".

"[i]And to blame Windows for the security holes is like blaming the rape victim for the rape.[/i]"

No, blaming Windows for a specific virus would be like blaming the victim for the rape. Blaming Windows for security holes would be like blaming the victim for walking into a maximum security prison sporting a shirt that says "rapists are pussies that can't get it up".

There might be some truth in that quote from the FreeBSD camp (and I've seen it before). After all, I'm a Microsoft-certified IT professional that used Windows for years before trying Linux on for size. It's my in-depth knowledge of Windows that made a Linux lover of me.

by jmgarvin

"1. Avoid the current because of one potential future? Sounds narrowminded to me. And off-topic."

Ok, sure...but one needs to look to the future to PLAN how their organization will work in 5 years.

"2. And Linux does not have these same potential issues? The only reason the majority of these attacks target Windows machines is that the vast majority of PCs run Windows. If and when Linux is the OS on the majority of machines, all a hacker has to do is pour through the EASILY DOWNLOADED source code!"

NONONONONONONO! *nix is a true multiuser environment. Windows fakes the funk. What this means that in every *nix install each users has their own user space. However, in Windows I have user space and "other" space that I can use. I have too much power to change the whole OS as a user in Windows, I just can't do this very easily in *nix.

As for the source code argument, it doesn't hold water. The problem here is that source code != vulnerability. Attacks focus on how the software operates rather than the underlying code. Sure, I might be able to dig up an obscure vulnerability here and there, but for the most part it really doesn't matter if I have the source or not.

"3. To me, the main reason that Windows machines are considered unstable is that people install and uninstall tons of software on them. I am a well-versed bright experienced computer user and I FREQUENTLY throw up my hands at trying to install Linux apps. It's like a game the OS plays just to get stuff installed. VERY frequently, I find a Windows equivalent of what I'm looking for, that works, doesn't require fifty pre-requisites, and installs and configures in about 5 minutes. Perhaps it is this plethora of software that is available for the Windows OS, coupled with the easy install features (and incomplete uninstall features) that makes Windows PCs unstable overall. In the end, I have 4 Windows boxes and 2 Linux boxes at home. The Windows machines run 24/7 with a few hiccups here and there. The Linux boxes, even though they don't crash, they don't work, can't recognize simple hardware configs such as USB keyboards and mice, and when I try to upgrade or install anything, it's a bloody nightmare. And then I try 45 different flavors of Linux to see if any will give me what I want (something more than an email and www client out-of-the-box would be nice, please), 42 of them don't set up X right and then I have no GUI. So, yes, of course Linux is stable, because it just sits there, few people can install stuff properly, and then it takes hours upon hours to read manuals and search the net to figure out how to config a file somewhere only to find that file doesn't exist! It's maddening. And I'm experienced! Think of what might happen in the hands of an average PC user."

This is just FUD. If you are using Gnome or KDE you can install many packages by double clicking on them. Also a TON of packages are now coming with install scripts, so it is even easier! I don't understand what the hassle is with installing stuff in Linux. The hardest install is a ./configure && make && make install. For the most part, this is rare and you can use various package managers to just get the package for you! With Red Hat likes, the rpms are easy to deal with and you have cool tools like up2date, yum, and apt-get. You just point and click!

"Here's an example. I installed RedHat clean, choosing to install EVERYTHING! I consulted one of my several RedHat books (not even generic Linux books, but specifically RedHat books). There would be, for example, "Step 1: edit the blah-blah file looking for these entries." Well, either the blah-blah file doesn't exist, or else the entries mentioned do not exist in the file! Frequently this happens! And that's from a fresh install!"

What are you talking about? What files do you need to edit and why? What is so hard about CREATING a file if it doesn't exist?

Also in many window managers you have nice little search tools AND you can just double click on what you want to edit and a handy text editor opens!!

"I have never had anything like that happen on a Windows box. I have never had, for instance, "edit the registry" only to find there IS no registry."

How about find this reg key? I've tried to edit a reg key that doesn't exist...loads of fun. Or when Active Directory doesn't change the reg keys so it isn't actually running, but looks like it is. Tons o' fun.

"4. There are generally alternatives to MS' apps. OpenOffice runs on Windows, for instance. Don't hate the OS because the apps aren't to your liking."

Ok...I use Windows at home for some things like gaming, but Windows is clunky. I don't like using the apps in the OS...

"All in all, I think Microsoft has done a wonderful job of making PCs accesible to the layperson."

Sort of. The problem is when you get a BSoD, the layperson freaks out and turns off their computer in fear of doing something. They then call the helpdesk and waste everyones time. When this happens multiple times a DAY, you have to ask, is this really a good thing?

"Unfortunately, a handful of enterprising twerps have made the experience horrible, with virii, spyware, adware, and other hacks. Is Windows perfect? Of course not. But Linux is hardly a solution either."

Why not? Linux is more secure out of the box than Windows. Plus, Linux has a ton of features that Windows is just NOW starting to implement. A big thing is that more and more stuff is integrated into the Windows OS and that leads to more and more security holes.

"And to blame Windows for the security holes is like blaming the rape victim for the rape."

Not quite. Blaming Windows for the security holes is like blaming Yugo for making an unreliable car. Windows is made insecure because MS doesn't care about security. They are finally starting to care, but it may be too late. Win2k3 is a good step forward, but it still has strange issues and SP1 BREAKS the server...nice...

"People are attacking, doing illegal things to try and subvert other people's equipment. Unless Microsoft has these hackers and virus authors on the payroll, I find it hard to believe that they could be at fault."

How could they not be? If they made their OS secure, than it wouldn't be an issue.

"I am reminded of a quote from the FreeBSD folks (BTW, FreeBSD couldn't get X configged right on my machines either): 'We do what we do because we love Unix. Linux people do what they do because they hate Windows.'"

De Raadt is a little nutty. He lives in a very black and white world and sees Linux as a threat to the "clarity" of Unix. The problem is that De Raadt is wrong and he is taking the whole Linux community out of context.

by Member 28898618

My post was in reference to the internal organization of most corporations, that is a Finance dept. an HR dept. etc. These business users dont care what the OS is...

In regard to your industry perspective. Banks and Finance orgs use IBM mainframes still, aging, obsolete, but left over from mainframe days. Solaris, HP/Ux and Linux do not run the Internet, there is no such thing as "the internet" as if it were some backroom in a company. The internet is an abstracdt of zillions of machines running everything under the sun and back. If you want to really get specific, the internet is the set of routers and switches...this gear is run by microcoded routnes running in ROM, Cisco has a properetary OS in their boxes, if you want to say they run it mostly, then its not windows or unix. however, linux is making inroads there...still, the number of machines running Windows is FAR greather than all others combined (must include clients as well as servers). If you dont understand that, they you arent in the discussion.

by jaqui

uses embedded linux on thier devices, as do linksys, dlink and 90% of the other manufacturers.

75% of cell phones are using embedded linux
75% of gps units..embedded linux.

m$' palm os won't condense enough for these devices. and the routers, switched etc are using linux for the security and stability.

by jaqui

since when has a virus been an os?
( since widers 95 it has been a virus, and all good virus scanning toold will say so, after all the bios based virus on the 486 were smart enough to lock the computer against windoze )

by shorne

Jaqui
If you can't make anything past Win2K run in a stable manner you don't belong in the biz.
By the way anyone who is still referring to Microsoft as M$ and Windows as windoze is immediately assumed to be a 15 year old running Linux in his bedroom.

by apotheon

I'd place more faith in a 15 year old running Linux in his bedroom than in an "IT professional" using Windows in the workplace that thinks Linux is "too hard".

by jmgarvin

I don't care WHAT type of hardware you are using, Windows servers aren't stable. The workstations aren't much better. The problem is that Windows doesn't play well with others AND it has internal issues that have yet to be resolved.

You comment about the 15 year old is not only pedantic, but a pointless tangent that has nothing interesting to add to the conversation.

by hal 9000

That people who refer to MS as M$ and Windows as Windose or Windblows or whatever else is used just might have been around before Windows and know what was available then.

I'm constantly being told by MS Representatives that because I was working Mainframes before the DOS days I'm expecting far too much from Windows as their product is not capable of doing what is required on a High End Server you can read that as a Mainframe or Blade Array.

The M$ came about because of the amount of money that Microsoft was raking in per second and when Windows was originally released it was considered by every IT professional as "Valium for your computer" and while fine for Home Use had no place in the business environment. When MS stopped supporting DOS the market had to move to Windows even though it may not have been the best option for the job but it did save training costs for the staff who used it at home on their low budget/performance computers so it saved companies heaps in training but even with Windows 95 there was still the Novel Networking suite underlying most business installations to actually allow Windows to work part way properly.

What you also have to remember that way back when Bill Gates was one of those 15 year old Nerds/Geeks who was using DOS in their bedroom and look where he is today. With a bit of Ruthless Business practices the next big OS development will probably come from someone like that and not the Big Guys who have far too much time and money tied up in their current products. Since NT Windows hasn't really changed that much the basic Kernel is still the same WINFS still doesn't work and other than Eye Candy Windows has not developed very much either all that has been done is to add more layers of code onto the base code in an attempt to secure it and make it more user friendly even ES 2003 isn't all that great in the way new code that was supposedly built from the ground up as there is a lot of the older code still residing in it.

Col ]:)

by mj_mcgrann

I am one that resisted Windows for a while but realized that it is like fighting City Hall. I believe IBM had Microsoft beaten with OS/2 Version 2, but IBM just did not market the Operating System properly. In its day, OS/2 would out-perform any Windows platform on any system! I hope Linux can hang in there to give Microsoft some competition.

I would be very interested to read your final report.

by jaqui

I hotkeyed ALT Z to kill the xserver.

though I would never buy overpriced proprietary machines in extremely ugly boxes.
( aka mac )

by worm22

Pros:

1) Winbloze is easy to use so there is little to no training required.

2) Industry standards (here's to hoping that this one changes sooner rather than later). Most of the software packages that are considered industry standart are made for winbloze. Many of them have counterparts in linux, but there are incompatabilities that make it ... difficult to go with pure a linux environment.

3) Video Games. (main reason I have any winbloze installs, so I couldn't leave it out ;) )

Cons:

1) Instability (blue screen of death anyone?).

2) Most hacks, viruses, spyware, and malware are aimed at winbloze.

3) Simplicity (yes, I know I put this in both categories). When used as a development platform, the simplicity of winbloze leads to sub-standard products because developers do not have to understand how everything works, and so develop inefficient products.

I'll stop there 3 in each category. personal preferance would be linux (in case that wasn't obvious).

by jmgarvin

Neverwinter Nights will run natively in Linux. You can get plenty of other games like Counter Strike and WoW running just fine.

More and more games are being ported or "emulated" via Wine (since it isn't an emulator what do you call it when it is running Windows games in Linux?)

by jaqui

after 3.1.1, m$ have not released anything close to resembling an os, they have released viruses.
windoze itself is a virus.

and no version if the user interface is meant for professional use, all versions show the foundation purpose... to play video games.

by jaqui

this is actually a bad thing.
the bad coding in the apps, the requirement that they run as administrator, the heavy use of activex and vbscript all make this integration more destructive.

everything should be segregated.. so that a fault with an app doesn't bring down the entire system.

by ngreed

The only pro that I can give to windows is that it is plug and pray most of the time, other then that, if I had the choice, I would not use it

by dells

95, 98, and ME aren't worth the time or the money. In the late '90s I had a workstation with 95 which I would regularly lock up 3-4 times per day running and testing in my programming IDE. I switched to a more powerful laptop that had 98 and I would lock that up 7-8 times per day to the point where I had to unplug the power AND the battery to be able to reboot it. I then moved to a new laptop with NT 4.0 on it and never had any problems with it. I've since used 2000 Pro and I'm currently using XP Pro without any major issues.

-Dell

by jaqui

on my wife's system win xp pro destroyed her hard drive.. after complete system failure once a week for a month.

I did slavage that drive.. by making it a dual boot system with linux.

seems windows bootloader destroys boot sector of western digital drives.. it won't allow the bios to run the drive with windows bootloader there...not the xp pro bootloader.

by sfc byte

From a technical standpoint I have to agree with a lot of people that Windows, the OS, is pretty lame but functional. Microsoft has the history of knowingly implementing incomplete OS with known problems. Their attitude seems to be "What the hell, we'll fix it later in a SP or SR." It's like getting a new car and finding out changing the radio stations turns on your emergency lights.

I think the issue is that the majority of computer users, not computer professionals/geeks/freeks/specialists, are comfortable with windows. They simply love GUIs and are comfortable with them. The majority of my friends, computer geeks all, prefer LINUX. It has GUI and command line. It also doesn't break...like windows. Throw a baseball at a window and it breaks. Throw one at a penguin and it gets made and pecks the crap out of you!

by hal 9000

Phone line for the dial up modem connection and the power lead to make the Windows Box totally secure. :D

Col ]:)

by apotheon

People still use modems?

I was talking about network security, y'know, not stability or physical security. It's all good.

Of course, there should probably be a sneeze guard over it so it doesn't catch a cold. You know how susceptible Windows is to virus infections.

by rashid breedy

Windows is ok. Maybe one flavors are better than others; but at the end, everybody uses them for better or worse, for play or for work, curse or thanks. But we use them! So, if ther is some one that can build a better OS do it and stop whining!!! Sooner, we'll see Microsoft jumping from spaceship from spaceship, space station from space station, planet from planet. So, deal with it.

by shorne

Who said anything about Linux being too hard. Many shops are running both Windows and Linux and find it to be a great mix. The point is that if you can't configure a modern Windows box to run without crashing all the time, your in the wrong biz (or you're just buying bargain basement hardware).
Hey I've got an idea, why don't you post something calling me asinine and pointless to display you're maturity.

by chilango02

You're quite right when you state that technincal merits are inmmaterial to personal preference.

And, it sounds okay to prefer technical merit.

But since both Windows and Linux work reasonably fine as server OS, then the cost starts to be a major issue. And that's where the licensing fees (actual and planned) of Microsoft really become a barrier adoption.

I much clearly prefer put money on our project's needs, rather than giving it to Redmond --alredy rich rich-- folks!!

by pr6

Three reasons -

It may not be the latest / best etc, but it is perfectly capable of doing what I require. Therefore, on principle, I see no reason to upgrade just for the sake of it.

Second, the next upgrade would be to XP, which unfortunately I have on my laptop. I detest the way M'Sopft changes the user interface to do exactly the same as W98 did, for no good reason that I can see. It seems a case of change for change sake - the bain of serious IT work, IMHO.

Thirdly - I am paranoid (!) about the steps M'Soft are taking to try and log exactly what one does. So before even getting embedded into that world, I am stopping at W98!

I hope this is helpful....

Peter Robson

by apotheon

My point is that your comment about fifteen year olds is asinine and, well, pointless.

by apotheon

When you can tell me how to install a three-button pointing device in a Powerbook, we'll talk.

by apotheon

You act like you're responding to Windows fans. There are other OSes that run on PCs. The strengths of MacOS X are pretty much the same strengths of Linux, which is what several of us here prefer to use, and usually on PCs.

I'd definitely choose a Mac over a machine with Windows on it, all else being equal. I'd likewise choose Linux over MacOS X.

by apotheon

It's funny, I don't have that problem with Linux. Perhaps you're using a kernel 1.0 version of Linux, circa 1993.

by shorne

I'll give you that the 15 year old comment didn't come across right and I'll withdraw it. What I don't buy is that Windows isn't stable. We manage to run lots of Windows servers and desktops without any great anquish and I know we aren't alone. But don't misunderstand, I'm not arguing AGAINST Linux. We have Linux too. I'm just saying that I have found most Windows versions past the 9x's to be very useable. I have found that many stability problems in the past have traced back to either troubled hardware or misbehaving third party software. That's all I'm sayin'

by rm3mpc

Pros:

Lots of people use it.

Some software won't run in other environments, and you MAY
need that particular software in your business environment.

Cons:

Unstable.

Performance deteriorates.

Viruses, worms, trojans.

Spyware.

Planned obsolescence.

Takes expert knowledge to keep it alive, much less running
efficiently. This is a particularly sticky point, as it's a form of job
security for the techies, and defeats the purpose of a "personal
computer." Users shouldn't have to worry about what's under the
hood, nor should they have to pay for hired guns to keep them
going from one week to the other. Every place I've worked at or
consulted for had more support personnel and costs per user
base than any other environment.

Costs to defend it from invasion.

Windows needs to be thrown out and started all over again, but
that won't happen because of legacy software and vested
interests. It's a patchwork full of holes, and it's going to stay that
way.

I vote for the Mac OS with its built-in Unix first, Linux second.
Windows comes in a far-distant last.

by daavid.turnbull

Try using the file open widget when you have a large number of mapped drives. If some of those mapped locations have slow connectivity you may have to wait a couple of minutes before then next step can be performed. It does not matter that you are trying to open a file local to you machine. It does not matter that you are running the fastest machine available with resources such as memory to burn the app will lock up as soon as you click the drop down to select a path. Almost every app depends on this widget to open files.

There is something fundamentally wrong with an OS that assumes that all resources have high availabilty. In most environments the opposite is true.

An example of this philosopy that allows comparision is Internet Explorer which can be compared to something like FireFox. One is lean, fairly straight forward and as a result fairly resistant to virus's and other hacks and the other large, complex, has complex interelationships with other apps and the OS and generally tries to run your life for you.

by apotheon

Yeah, you'd think all this bad press would be noticed by those of us who actually follow Linux news pretty closely. Why haven't I seen a glut of press coverage of badly written code issues pertaining to Linux? I don't even follow Windows news as much any longer, and I'm still seeing more Windows issues than Linux issues.

by jaqui

requireing the gcc "extentions" for the kernel is badly written code.
those extentions are the bugs in gcc.

the press, I've never heard any bad press about linux, unless it's in microsoft advertising, which is all fud anyways, as they never really look at linux.

by apotheon

"[i]De Raadt is a little nutty.[/i]"

Only a little?!

Besides, he's OpenBSD, not FreeBSD. Heh. I think you're right about the quote originating with him, but the person to whom you respond seems to have been referring to some FreeBSD enthusiast that repeated the quote (perhaps without knowing where it originated).

by apotheon

I've gotta wonder what your definition of "reasonably fine" is with regards to how Windows operates as a server. There's so much wrong with Windows as a server that I tend to think people who choose Windows servers over unix servers to be somewhere seven leagues south of nutty.

by billwalt10

XP sucks. I put XP on 3 older computers, one not so old. It wouldn't recognise several cards on the newest one and no drivers were available for them. It also made the 2 older ones run slower. With a good GO-Back program of any type, give me 2000ME any day. It loads faster and shuts down faster, sleeps better too! XP liked to hang up when sleeping too long.
billwalt10@yahoo.com

by hcream

It all depends on other factors such as hardware, applications, environment and users:

How old is the majority of hardware? Do you have application that has to be run on older platform? Is the PC stand alone, or on a network? Is the user an experienced Windows user? Do they require training to use a new OS?

For user who needs wireless connection, XP is the perfect choice. It integrates well with the latest hardware.

Win2000 is not as resource demanding as XP. It may be a better pick if your hardware is 3~4 years old. If you have a Volume License version of XP, MS allows the OS to be downgraded to 2000.

Win98 Second Edition is a good pick for 4~6 years old hardware. It is very stable & easy to implement. When equiped with firewall, antivirus & antispam software, it's still a rather secure system to use.

Forget about ME. It's slow & most users don't like it anyway.

NT is stable but hard to implement. Once setup, it doesn't like to be bothered again. We still use it on a few File/Terminal servers, but not on any workstation.

To cut down paper & toner usage on our aging office Fax machince, we use an old Win95 PC to intercept incoming fax messages & distribute them using Outlook. It works great for us.

by jennyn

I went to an MS pre-release marketing demo of NT back in 19.... they were selling it strong on its new "multi-threading" technology - that is why the NT logo shows interweaving threads, and that is the "New Technology" the operating system offered.

Rather than relying on time slicing to create the impression of multi-tasking (as prior versions of windows did - sharing a single processor thread back and forth between processes - slowing them all down), New Technology, they said, genuinely multi-tasked making full use of the processor power... anyway that's what they told me!

by gcollatz

Before Windows, every application needed its own printer driver for almost everything. If your new program did not support your hardware, you were out of luck. The original concept of Windows was to provide the programmer with an environment devoid of driver worries and provided easy(er) creation of a GUI. Windows also standardized the user interface to a large degree, so that familiarization with one program promoted instant familiarization. This spawned a flood of software for windows and third party improvements to the GUI prompted Microsoft to do more for the user interface. Plug and play applications in large variety. That is what I like. No editing of complicated Unix scripts or configuaration files. What I do not like; High prices, an arogent attitude, constant hack attacks and harassing atipiracy measures. Part of this is Microsofts fault and partly our (the user community's) fault. Under the bottom line, what good is a perfect OS if one can not find the applications one needs to run on it.

by gphoto45

I agree wholeheartedly. I remember when Hp, Compaq, Ibm, Apricot and others all had thier own OS's. Windows has to be given credit for creating the compatiblities between manufacturers. I feel this is the one issue That is hurting Linux. As for the Windows servers being unstable, NT 4.0 -7 years -24/7- only planned shutdowns, 2K server - 4 years - 24/7 - only planned shutdowns, SBS2003 - 2 years - 24/7 - Only planned shutdowns. Sounds like the people who are having server problems forgot the rule, those that fail to plan, plan to fail.

by richman316

What a bunch of sour grapes. I've been using Windows since 3.1, my company that I work for uses nothing but Windows yet we thrive. Yes windows has it's con's but so does every other OS out there. I've used linux, Unix and others and always run back to MSW. Since MSW is at the top it makes sence for virus/malware writers to try to break it. I would gurantee you that any other OS that gets up ther will deal with the same headaches. Bottom line is MSW is more productive to the average user and that carries a lot of weight.

by hal 9000

While the desktop might be the Windows domain the high end servers certainly are not nor are the big Server farms/Blade Arrays/ Mainframes that the banks and other financial institutions use. Then there is the Internet that is built in Unix/Linux and Apache.

Whenever there is a Denial of Service Attack why do you think it is possible to get the message that such and such a site is unavailable if the majority of machines actually did run Windows of some flavor the Internet would be crashing on a daily basis your ISP would be unavailable most of the time and you wouldn't expect to receive E-Mail before Snail Mail if at all.

The fact of the matter is that all the big end of town who have the money and the secrets do run Unix/Linux and have done since time began well at least Computer Time and they are rock solid.

The only reason that MSW is more productive to the "Adverage User" is that they use it at home so the company doesn't have to pay for training the staff so of course productivity will be better but would you go to a brain surgeon because he did a lot of operations or because he was trained and knew what he was doing. Windows users fall into the first group IT professionals are supposed to fall into the second group. Apparently that is no longer the case so we are allowing the continued Dumbing Down of the industry that we work in and then wonder why jobs get outsourced.

Col ]:)

by bamillikan

I think you should not include 95/98/98SE or Me in your comparison because these were considered to be for non-workstation (personal computer) systems. At work, our development was always on a Sun UltraSPARC or HP Worstation running their own UN*X flavors (System V).

PROS of Windows 2k/NT/XP
1) Windows really bridged the "gap" between computer "geeks" and business/home users unlike any other OS (including Amiga,Atari & Apple). People can pick using a computer in a very short period of time (unlike the HP, Sun, Silicon Graphics and even IBM-RISC flavors of UN*X). I think when Microsoft got in on the "ground floor" with MS-DOS with IBM and IBM really started taking off, they had the "base" with which to build Windows 3.1 (which was the first widely-used MS Windows release). It acted as a "shell" to MS-DOS and was run automatically by being called from the "autoexec.bat" file.

2) Windows designed the whole "pluggable" hardware module computer base or Hardware Abstraction Layer (HAL). They viewed a computer "system" as being "dynamic". Windows introduced their Windows Driver Model in Windows NT (the latest version) and Windows 98 (but, it was up to the developer to use it or not). It is enforced now from 2k on. They brought in "layered" drivers which allowed certain devices to have a common interface (video card, audio cards, etc).

3) Market share. Microsoft has, by far, the largest market share in operating system distribution that anyone (or anything) else. That is Microsoft's weapon. Most companies realize that 90% of systems out there are running Windows and that it is really not cost effective to develop hardware (and drivers) or software for any other platform. By creating Visual C++ and Visual Basic, the separated themselves (pretty well) from other OSes. It certainly does not follow any ANSI or IEEE standards. So, they made it very cumbersome to port an application to another platform.

Cons
1) Security. It's a last thought at Microsoft. Our company got hit hard by the RPC virus. It's a cool idea to have remote process calling and execution on another PC, but opens a WIDE door to virus writers! Now, you can buy plug-in software that can make Windows more secure. But, it's just more $$$ on top of the OS cost itself and (I think) it's just better not to have a Windows machine even on the open Web. That's just my personal opinion because Security was an afterthought and not really built into the OS.

2) Cost is a HUGE problem. With their new licensing structure, they leave small businesses with little or no choice. They just can't afford it. As an OEM system builder, I think it's the dumbest thing to think of a software OS as part of the hardware "system" itself. I'm going to end up with a bunch of OEM licenses for Windows XP that are going to be useless when new OSes come out. In addition, I cannot transfer a license to another computer (and maybe load another OS on that computer). I have to buy a new license. For the home user, that really hurts the pocketbook! They can't compete with free in the server market with an OS that was built upon another OS (UN*X) which had security in mind since inception.

3) No 'open source' flexibility. Having open source drivers and kernel software gives me, the developer, the tools I need to change or "tweak" the functionality of a device to fit my specific needs. The User-level in Windows does NOT do well in a Real-Time environment where timing (better than 10ms) is key. The only workaround is a driver, but the device drivers from vendors are all (or mostly) proprietary and won't be distributed to third parties for modification. Not a problem with open source!

by jaqui

is available, and almost every distro has a page on doing it for thier distro.

problem with that is, how do you know what apps I want on my system and will use?

the options for linux make oem a tricky one.. for those that know it.

for newbies, that's where xandros is targeted, complete moron at keyboard windows install.
insane desktop design ( based on kde on debian linux ). like install software is under networking not system admin tools?!?!?!

there are a few shops that sell systems with oem linux.

by itmanager

I believe the greatest advantage windows has for both technical and non technical people stems from the market share it has.

For business people (and I include home users, gamers, not for profit organisations, etc), this ensures a common platform that enables interaction (dare I say it - interoperability).

For technical people, by and large, market share determines where the external support will be provided, where the development effort will contribute to, and what the innovation will be applied to. At the end of the day, people must eat, have shelter and clothing ? this takes money; individuals, and by extension company shareholders, pursue money because individuals people want to survive.

Many technically great products have fallen during the battle for market share. The video Beta ? VHS format is an infamous example. Sometimes products win because they are superior, but sometimes then win because they have a superior marketing strategy. Forget the technical arguments ? perception is the reality.

Like most contributors to this thread, I?ve used and supported a myriad of operating systems, from PCs through to mid range machines, over the last two decades. At the end of the day, it has been market share that has determined for the majority where the users (business) want to go and what is easiest for the techs to support.

by jm22

Briefly, 2 points:
* its an OS that has standardized the world so that everyone can find an application that fits their needs and runs on their computer and they can share their data. I personally hate microsofts products, they dont do a lot of the things well but at the end of the day its about being standard and compatible.
* and Secure. Everyone overlooks this because Microsoft gets slammed for their security holes. But the key point is that they have many fewer holes and have put a huge emphasis and resources on making a secure OS. Apple skates by without addressing security and for a long time Linux also skated because the hacker community targets Microsoft and turn a blind eye to Linux and Apple because they are the 'white hats' and Bill Gates is the villain. so give Windows credit for seriously addressing a very serious issue.

by skontos

Each iteration of Windows incurs a premium, in that, in every major release, part of what we pay for are cumulative fixes and ancillary updates.

It's a great business. We pay for bug-ridden software and we pay again to have it fixed.

Windows95 is no longer supported, acording to http://www.theosfiles.com/os_windows/ospg_w95.htm

Yet, it essentially has the same look and feel as Windows XP. It has the same kernel.

Windows98, WindowsME, Windows2000 and now yet another release later, we have paid through the nose for essentially the same OS.

This is like buying a car, forcing me to pay for the built in obsolescense, and then making me buy a newer model at a higher price.

If it was any other business, we would not stand for it.

by daavid.turnbull

On more than one occassion I have accidently shut my machine down because some automatic update widget has popped unexpectedly and the text I was typing gave it the right instructions to reboot the computer.

This is probably a worst case scenario but incidents where input goes to the wrong app because it has grabbed focus without warning are an all to frequent occurence. At least allowing focus follow the mouse cursor such as X allows would be a vast improvement.

Yes I know there used to be, or maybe still is, a registry setting that allowed something like this but it did not work well because the OS was not designed with this in mind.

There is something fundamentally wrong with software, including OS, that thinks it knows how and what you want to do better than you.

by hal 9000

Until IBM entered the PC market Apple was still only a very small company and it was IBM with their idea of Open Architecture which made PC's accessible to the masses and it was IBM who got Billy Boy to buy Sun Micro systems Dirty Operating System and re badge it as MS DOS as Garry Killian's wife threw the IBM reps out of the office when they insisted that she sign a waive insisting that she would not discuss their approach outside of DR DOS before they would even tell her where they where from.

Prior to that MS only wrote applications and not an OS. I looked it up in the company Brainwashing material that they provided to all the staff at the time last night. I knew it would eventually come in handy at some time and the bit about the SUN DOS is from a Goggle Search that was done last night as well.

As for IBM being bitter and beaten they never actually expected the PC market to take off the way that it did and I was eventually pulled out of the mainframe side to the PC side when sales exploded and had to learn MS DOS which I immediately dumped from my company supplied system and replaced it with DR DOS and then with the then industry standard Lotus 123 and Word Perfect 3 I think but I eventually ended up with WP 5 and all the training material for that as I still have it here. Word never made any sort of impact on the PC Market until they bundled it with all their other second rate Office Applications into Office and made it possible to share data between different applications which was not all that easy previously.

Back in those days I had several PC's all with different OS's on them I even had one running the company Unix just to keep my hand in and when I was transfered to the PC side of things it was only for a 6 month period to teach the techs there and then I went back to the real business of IBM and that was the mainframes.

Today I still know a few people at IBM and they are anything but bitter at MS as they see it for what MS is and do not consider it as competition but a complementary thing to their current products which it really is. Even then MS doesn't offer a product for the big Blades and the like ES 2003 just is not scalable enough to run on the 1K + CPU Blades that are currently available the same applies to the current crop of mainframes as well.

Sure IBM stuffed up with OS Warp but again that was all IBM and their way of doing business like Corel today they seem to think that they have a better product so they do not need to promote it they have done exactly the same thing since they acquired Lotus as well which now days is non existent in the industry but in its day was a lot better and was being promoted was a far better suite than Office ever could hope to be.

Today IBM is getting on with their CORE BUSINESS which are large Blades and Mainframes and they still offer a very good Note Book which if anything is way ahead of the others on the market as far as the M'Board goes. Some of the specialist products that they have designed for places like the DOD are brilliant as well.

But from being on the inside at the beginning of the PC I can tell you that it was never expected to take off the way that it did and in all honesty if IBM had not gone with the Open Architecture idea in all likely hood we would have two distinct camps Apple and IBM with all propriety hardware and none of what where once known as IBM clones which are the common PC today. But I still think that Xerox made the biggest blunder possible when they dropped their prototype Lidia and returned to their Photocopying business that was the biggest mistake that I've ever seen and it was what spurred both Apple and MS to develop a GUI. Currently Apple has sort of got it right with OSX but Windows is still so far behind the leading edge that it isn't funny. But even today both companies have yet to reach the net workability that Xerox had all those years ago.

Col ]:)

by dbarto

I got so tired of the fragility of Windows, especially in the area of
the Registry, that I bought my wife an iMac, and myself a PowerMac
Dual 2.0 GHz. Windows XP is still pretty fragile. If you never install
an application on a fresh Windows XP box, there is a chance that it
won't need the registry repaired in the future, but that's about it.

At work I have both a Windows box and a Linux box. The Windows
box had to be rebooted three times in the past 30 days. The Linux
box was rebooted on 7/29/04 (almost a year ago).

by hal 9000

They just honestly know no better and if they have a Nix box as a server they are most likely rebooting it on a weekly/monthly basis just because they believe that the Windows Boxes need it so the Nix boxes must too.

Most of these places don't even have their units running 24/7 so they are reliable for them after all how many problems can you experience on a Windows Box that is constantly being turned off? You'll never have problems with memory being tied up and not released when an application is finished or any of the other problems that are associated with Windows as the things are just not running long enough to actually run into problems.

These people believe that things should work this way so they act accordingly not because they think that things are just this way but because they where taught to do things like this and just do not know any better.

The number of times that I've received looks of disbelief when I say my Nix box has been running for X number of days is just funny now I've long since given up on attempting to try to explain why it is so and just leave them to their own devices. At one small business I snuck in a Linux Gateway and they don't even know that it isn't a Windows Box it just runs in an out of the way spot and chugs away unattended and I'm constantly told by this company what a brilliant box it is and just how Good that the Version of Windows on it is. The rest of the machines are turned off on a daily basis so really unless they do something way out of line they just do not run into problems that are rampant in Windows.

Col ]:)

by yanipen

Pros.

During the desktop revolution, Bill envisioned that MS will become a household name. This is due to the expensive OS's out there, which was in purpose, is for the the server types. There was the MAC's of course but it was intended fot the office. And there are a bunch of other pc's

So they created an OS that is suitable for the home/office use. It is fairly on the budget of any household. And the public accepted it. You can say that it has a major impact on the pc revolution.

So, when the public accepted it, so then came the applications that you can use with the OS. And mind you, there is a lot of applications out there.

Cons.

Since it was widely accepted, and used. Then came the abuse. Then comes the scrutiny. Not to mention the discontent among the MS employees.

Since they need to meet deadlines, most of the products then comes out not fully tested. May I mention the Blue Screen of Death? Ask MS about that. You can blame the guys who sets the deadlines. But they promised to be vigilant about the patches and fixes that need be ( PROS. ). But things should be better.

And comes the flaws because of meeting the deadline. Then comes the viruses, security issues. And a lot other things that comes with it.

This is because of the way MS does things on its products. Partly due to its attitude, how its employess being treated and the discontent.

Heheh, what I gave you is the general idea on what it really is, without diving to the technicalities. My suggestion then? Use windows on typical home pc use. But for really serious computing, use Linux instead of windows family on servers. Anyway, there still a lot of things to consider. In example, if your company uses Autocad a lot, then consider windows on workstations. I have not heard yet of this product with equivalent to Linux.

Anyway, I have said my piece. You asked for the pros and cons, so I gave you from a common user's perspective.

I hope this helps.

by hal 9000

I saw and I've read the material where the Product Development Manager of MS has stated the need to go to dumb terminals all with an Internet connection and you then lease the software and OS from that company which just happens to be MS.

No it hasn't happened yet and it will not happen in the short term either just because Windows is still incapable of running on Server Farms and the like do you remember the fiasco when MS acquired Hot Mail? But that is what they are working cowards.

It is MS way of staying the market leader as even today they have to take into account Linux when reporting their expected earnings for the coming year so at least the person in charge of Product Development can see the writing on the wall so in an attempt to keep their place they are attempting to make PC even cheaper to acquire and then worry about running costs latter. Currently unless you are buying a high end business machine the cost of the software just about always exceeds the cost of the hardware involved and I don't ever consider using Celeron CPU's or all in 1 M'Boards to keep costs down like the big boys do.

Incidentally do you know who is in charge of Product Development at MS?

Col ]:)

by shorne

Ya I know all that (except remember that Bill predates DOS). I came up in the industry on the Novell side as a happy CNE and remain sad that they blew their franchise (they went side ways with 4.x then blew up with version 5). And like you say in your other post, I agree our linux boxes are up way longer than any of the Windows boxes. Look, I'm not an apologist for MS or Windows. All I'm saying is it doesn't crash every day, and anyone who tells you it does has a problem that they aren't addressing properly. I have several Windows servers that have been chugging aways for months now and another that would have except its UPS stopped giving it power. And yes I have a couple of linux boxes that have been running for more than a year. Hope that clarifies what I'm saying.

by hal 9000

Aren't you applying the monthly MS Patches?

I know that MS doesn't expect business to before they have tested these patches but I also know that most of the infections are now occurring from the time that MS releases a patch and before it is deployed by someone. MS told me so at the last Partners Meeting and went to great lengths to try to get people to deploy patches as soon as they become available. At lest now they don't break as much as they used to which is a great improvement and when MS has WUS working it will be even better but even Office Patches require rebooting to actually work most of the time.

Don't get me wrong MS has its place but I just get worked up when I'm told they are the answer to everything which even MS doesn't claim.

Col ]:)

by bluron

Tho I am not an IT expert, I have used all listed OS. The only one had problems with was ME. Kept crashing every other day.

by ivan chan

MS changed their windows version very often, But nothing useful features (end users) was provided. Windows 2000 is better than XP, Windows 2000 is stable but eats less memory.

Pro: Windows is easy to use

by taliesinn17

the tr=hree finger salute is the easy fix, what your supervisor shold be doing is taking all the info you are doing on the front lines -- and trend whether your problem is software, hardware or basic user training to the corporate environment . . you can't just blame any operating system -- this coming from a mainframe guy making things work between that and ALL sorts of operating systems and networks -- Cheers and best thoughts!

by tsantanamm

I'm a Novell Admin. But I must say, some of your claims are way out of target in regards to Windows. I have been running windows side-by-side with Novell 6 and I haven't had a single major problem with it. Most of the viruses ad/spyware that affect windows, are made by conspirators against the MS Empire.

There's no other platform out there with such a huge library of software that run on windows. You're all just a whole bunch of cheap, pissed off open source admins that are scavenging for a nickle mad at the fact that you cannot find descent software to run on your systems without actually having to pay for it.

Windows ROCKS. Case Closed damn it!

by hal 9000

There are many systems that MS just doesn't address out in the real world. Even MS admit this so I find it laughable that you are going way beyond what even MS is willing to claim that they have a product for everything computer related or even an OS that will work on every configuration.

I'll give you a challenge Use a 1000 CPU Blade and you try to get any commercially available form of Windows to work on it using every one of the CPU's.

Col ]:)

by jaqui

you'll wake the sleeping monkey up.
after all it's well known that no ms virus will work on major hardware, only real os will. ;)

by jaqui

a universe of software for *x

that's the best answer to the software options, ms' own ad campaign that only tells one part of the story.

and it's on average 20 thousand separate applications available from a 3 cd install.

get windows, 1 cd
get office 1 cd
get web server 1 cd
get sql server 1 cd
get dvd playback/burning software
get graphics apps
get more multimedia apps.
already you have spent far longer getting and installing and configuring software for windows and nowhere near the amount of software installed.

these windows guys really don't understand the power and flexibility or choice options of linux do they?

by edjcox

I'm doing a report and I expect others to write it for me by responding to my posting. It will be easy to cut and paste your responses and fashion a report. I have sucessfully garnered all manner of report fodder this way and find it the easy way out.

Please write my report for me and respond completly and succinctly. I will plagerize all who respond and will give no credit for autership to any of you.

Thanks for supporting me..

by jaqui

microsoft certified sales executive.
for majority of them, it has no meaning on technical ability or knowledge.
4 hours repair a cpu damaged by one mcse, that a second called garbage and wouldn't touch.

5 years later that cpu is still working great.

okay four hours, 2 pots of coffee and a pack of smokes to straighten out every single pin on the cpu.

by alashhar

Hello all!

My opinion the price of the Microsoft operating system (2000,XP, 2003) also the licenses are too expensive, and I think if I want to make upgrade from 2000 server to 2003 server I have to pay. So I have to pay always to get the power of Microsoft O.S. in other side I believe if you configure the windows well or you know how to configure it, it will be very reliable and security. And don?t forget that about 90 % of the users in world are using windows O.S. so that the reason to make many people attack the Microsoft O.S., few months I read that red hat Linux has big numbers of attacks which may be more that the windows has. The last thing the windows is very easy to use and has a lot of tools or servers such as DNS, Active Directory, DHCP, IIS, Share point server.

Best regards

by bwallan

We're running HP Pavilion 753 desktops. We're also currently on our third attempt to install SP2. At present we have no communications, explorer will not run, Internet Explorer bombs on about half its starts. And this attempt has had fewer problems than the previous two attempts!

As far as I'm concerned SP2 has caused far more problems, damage and lost $$$ than we would have ever had with viruses, spyware, etc.

If this is the best Microsoft can offer in the way of system upgrades, please go find someone else to test them!