Pros and Cons of Windows
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by abel46
when I read all that people that says that Windows is unstable. OK if you refer to win9x family then I agree, but NT, 2000, 2003 and XP?
I have worked for different companys runing from one to 30 Windows servers. And I can't remember a single time when a Windows server has crashed.
They are stopped from time to time to upgrade or maintainance but that an other story.
I have used Win XP with SP2 for some months now, and I can't understand why some varn abut this. For me it's rock solid anyway.
I use CA antivirus and MS anti spyware.
by mw_azhar
This biggest problem i have faced in any WIN based OS is, its very prone to virus attacks, drawback being you dont need user intervention for an executable to run on win os, there are many auto start methods with which an exe can be started eg:registry and others, wht i wanna convey is WIN OS very vulnerable to virus attacks due to its architecture where as when u compare any *nix OS you need human intervention for executing a file i.e file permissions needs to assigned though i agree there are many *nix based viruses aswell but *nix OS has proved to be less prone to virus attacks.
If you want more detials on auto start methods used by viruses/bad guys to execute a file on win OS plz contact me may be i could provide u with an whitepaper.
by apotheon
by apotheon
Have you ever spent more than half an hour with a running Linux system? Really?
This is asinine. It gets really, really old spending so much time disabusing people of their blatant misunderstandings based on ignorance.
I have a very difficult time taking any comparisons between Windows and Linux seriously when they come from people that have significant experience on one platform and roughly zero on the other.
by apotheon
XP, given the same installation functionality and the same hardware, does not boot faster. I have personal, extensive experience that belies your little fib.
Linux does not "just copy Windows apps". Try looking at examples like Sendmail, BIND, Apache, Ethereal, irssi, netcat, perl, apt, Mserv, Squid, gcc, Vim, iptables, Subversion, grep, wget, and the X Window Server, to name just a few that, at best, Windows (and third-party application developers for Windows) copied, and at worst Windows can't yet duplicate no matter what you install.
The "simple fork attack" bugbear gets tossed out every once in a while, and it rarely gets answered. Would you like to know why? I'll tell you: It doesn't get answered because recent Linux users have never heard of it. The reason they've never heard of it is that recent Linux versions (say, up to ten years old) are effectively immune due to system security. You can stop talking about "a simple fork attack" now, really you can.
Yes, there are Linux viruses. Unfortunately for your argument, they are of two types:
1. It's a genuine Linux-effective virus but, because executables don't just randomly run on Linux the way they do on Windows, it won't have system-wide access and cause any real damage unless you log in as root and choose to execute it of your own free will.
2. It's actually an email that contains text similar to "This is the Linux email virus. To spread this virus, forward this email to ten people. To execute the virus payload, log in as root, navigate to /, and execute 'rm -r *' as soon as you're done forwarding it to ten people." Too bad for your argument, this virus works on the honor system.
Linux isn't obscure at all: it runs a significant percentage of the webservers currently in operation. 30% of my current support clients have Linux fileservers in their offices. The city of Munich runs on Linux. Wal-Mart sells preinstalled Linux laptops.
Cost of using Linux higher than Windows . . . ? Okay, now I [b]know[/b] you're just trolling. How ridiculous can you get?
by afhavemann9
We use primarily Novell servers, some Linux and Windows 2003 severs as well. The Novell servers are the mainstay with Linux and Windows filling necessary gaps. All of these are quite but Novell is the king. Our Novell servers don't go down unless we shut them down...period. After that, Linux gets the award followed by the Windows servers.
This is a bit unfair to the Windows servers because neither the Novell nor Linux servers are used for anything else. Unless their getting a patch, upgrade or similar, no one touches them. The Windows boxes on the other hand, by virtue of their software availability get used for quite a few other jobs. Many of our apps have no Linux or Novell equivalent so the Windows servers have to run far more tasks than either Linux or Novell; and as such they're subject to much more abuse from the software loaded on them. That fact alone, counts for most of the problems they experience.
For instance, we use our copy machines as high speed scanners and network faxes, the routing and processing software only runs on a windows server box and once a month or so it [the routing software] craps out forcing a re-boot. As I said, Windows servers get used (and abused) much more often because of the software availability. We have one Windows server that has only one small app running on it and it?s completely stable. Day in, day out, it just runs without attention, the same reliability as the Novell and Linux boxes.
I have close to 25 years in this business. On the left on my desk is a XP machine, on the right is a Linux box. I'm happy using either; I grew up on DEC, PDP, DOS, CPM, u-name-it OS's of every different flavor, though mostly CLI?s. I can configure a Linux, Novell or Windows box with equal capability and it?s my observation that any of these can be setup to be extremely stable.
As an aside, I have to admit, I too really hate to see someone typing ?M$?, ?micro****? and other crappy terminology; it simply looks childish; sorry if you don?t like that, but it?s true. I see someone typing like that and my opinion of them drops.
I also have to agree with some of the other posts that XP boxes can be as stable as Linux provided the admin takes the time to learn how to properly configure one. Our environment of hundreds of XP systems require very little attention once configured to the corporate standard. True, we have a SUS server which handles the patching for critical fixes, which relieves us of that chore, but that?s much better than we have for Linux or Novell. When Novell issues a point upgrade, it hundreds of megs, hours to install and often causes incredibly difficult to solve problems that can bog down the upgrade for weeks. Add to that a massive workstation client that often screws up so badly that it must be stripped and reloaded to get it working again. And Linux is no joy either, without real central control, it?s a wasteland for proper documentation and patch/upgrade management.
But it really doesn?t matter; you get a Linux, Novell or Windows box configured properly and it runs fine. And frankly, anyone who can?t do that really needs to stop whining and begin learning. Either you?re a true professional who can do the job regardless of the OS or a whiner with limited ability.
by masteraaron
by jaqui
at urpmi from mandriva.
to install apache on a system that doesn't have it in console:
urpmi apache2
it will list all dependancies, then ask okay to continue.
if you did network install it will look for the packages from there. if cd install it will ask for the cds it needs, opening the cdrom as needed.
no earching for deps, no issues when removing, as it tells you what the deps are.
( if you remove an app, that had a dep that requires it, and a third app requires the second, it even lists that third app )
It must be very nice to be in your position, but personally I'd cease patting myself on the back for my technical skills and start patting the back of whoever provided you with such an environment.
Who gets to choose which of your platforms perform a function ?
by afhavemann9
I fail to understand your reply.
No offense intended, but you?re making assumptions without knowledge. When I came to my current employer many years ago, they had nothing but a few stand-alone 6 mhz IBM pc's. The state of the art then in networking was cabled 10mb Ethernet, 10BaseT had yet to make an appearance and it would be years before Microsoft introduced Windows 3.11. They had something called ?Windows?, but nobody really knew what it was for (I still have a set of those original disks). Everyone worked in DOS and WordPerfect (for DOS) was as good as it got with software. At that point I had already been a programmer and support tech for almost 10 years.
We have a small museum here for obsolete computers and equipment; it contains my first micro, an IMSI, serial #13, hand built with 256 bytes of memory. A Radio Shack model 1 and 3, my first IBM PC, all 6 mhz of it with 8? outboard floppy drives, A PCAT, my first Apple and so on. I donated most of it because I no longer have space for it at home; by the way, it all still works.
I designed the network environment for my organization, every bit of it., and implemented it in over 40 offices across the US (now 125). I chose what would do what, then and now. A DEC Vax mini running VMS served as the original network server in 1987. Eight years ago I planned and implemented a nation wide managed WAN, bringing over 3600 nodes and 125 offices into it, it serves us well now.
I have a relatively small staff and I insist each and every one of them understand hardware, software, protocols, diagnostics and all the rest. I have a reasonable training budget and use all of it every year. I attend those same training classes and some of them I teach.
Who provides this environment?, my employer of course. And as for patting myself on the back, don?t be silly; you do that when you think you?ve something to prove, I left that behind many years ago, it no longer matters.
The fact is, I can do anything any of my well trained staff can do and I do it often, I?m not just a ?Glass Wall? manager, I work every day in the field doing the same jobs my people do, I just happen to be the boss as well because I started it all here.
by hal 9000
That here I'm not needing to sell myself or my skill set. But if you go back to even the DOS days the end users did know how to create a Spread Sheet DBase or whatever.
Today they do not and at a recent visit to a Computer School that specialized in teaching Advanced Office usage they didn't consider the need to show their students how to perform a Mail Merge. Now pardon me if I'm way out of line here but wasn't one of the arguments when the PC hit the office that it would do away with informal form letters and personalize them all? This used to happen but it doesn't now days why is it so?
Anyway when I sell a system it doesn't matter if it is a workstation or a complete network my staff and myself teach the end users how to work the system and we spend a lot of time doing this so they are far more productive, instead of like most others just dumping the hardware in the place and running as fast as our legs will carry us. It's called SERVICE which is something that I find sadly lacking in almost all of the so called Professional places that I run across they are all out to make as much money in as short a time as possible.
The way that we work ensures follow up business and currently we have not lost a single client that has stayed solvent to other sources.
Most of the customers have their favorite Tech as well and they want these same people to continue to return there whenever they have a problem. I think it is known as "Good Will" which is something that isn't thought about today. :D
While it's true that I don't want to be the next Bill Gates I am making enough money for my needs and whats more I don't have to advertise as my customers do this for me by passing on my business to all the companies that they deal with. I've been there earning several K per hour and I'm now quite happy to do the real work and help the customers out by working with them instead of just selling them what it is that they think they need and then moving on to the next one and promptly forget about the last one. It may also be a small part of the reason why I do so much insurance work.
But if you want to see someone who's lazy you need go no further than me but I firmly believe if you do it right the first time you don't have to go back and do it all over again, so while we do work a bit differently to the current industry we have our clients and a growing base of them as well and what's even better is that they are genuinely glad to see us when we arrive there and are thankful for our efforts.
As I keep saying IT is a service industry where we are a means to an end rather than the end itself, this is something that many do not want to understand!
Just a side note here while IT isn't "Brain Surgery" there are still quite a few fields where if we do stuff up it cost lives, this could be from not maintaining a Medical DBase correctly and the patient files get messed up or a CAD program spits out the wrong data and something is made that places peoples lives in danger because the system wasn't working correctly so while you are correct that IT isn't Brain Surgery you can not forget that peoples lives still hang in the balance in quite a few of the industries that we support so we have to get it right and keep getting it right.
Incidentally have you actually worked in a OR? I have and quite a lot of the equipment used for Brain Surgery is computer or microprocessor controlled so we have to treat that a lot more carefully than what we do a desktop workstation for the secretary in a Sales Office. Just do not forget just how much of the current technology relies on Silicon!
Col ]:)
Asinine, blatant, ignorance? You are supercilious apotheon and there seems to be little more point to your posts at this stage in the thread than gratifying your own evident ego, perhaps to make the 'kiddies' believe in you.
The point of the post was intuitively given away in the title. If you have such a very difficult time taking any comparisons between Windows and Linux seriously then refrain from posting your inane, offtopic, irrelevant and 'asinine' comments. Save them for a relevant thread or even better start your own thread where you can be at the top. Arrogant tosspot (that's English mate, not sure how it translates into american).
by hal 9000
I don't remember seeing a single post about the topic by you here.
Was that just an oversight on my part?
Col ]:)
by jclambert
I remember the days of Netware quite fondly. It just worked. I don't remember any server problems aside from hardware issues with Netware servers. Too bad programmers found it much easier to write for Windows.
Then again being able to write for it more easily makes it easier for more people to write software - and many of those should almost NEVER write any (myself included).
by jmgarvin
but when you figure out how to generically do that for every company, let me know...I want to invest.
How do we maximize productivity? How do we NOT impact profitability? How do we maintain incoming cash flow via web services?
by jmgarvin
The way MS chose to succeed in the market has proliferated all the way through IT.
Quality is regularly the first casualty of IT business.
They led the way, all the dumbass lemmings in sheeps clothing followed them right off the edge of the cliff.
Watching them attempting to fly before they go splat would be quite funny if they weren't carrying my livelyhood. Designing a safe landing for my current employer at the moment.
It's not a ms specific or even IT specific problem, but business nowadays is dominated not by maximising productivity or profitability but by maximising shareholder value through short term gains.
When you hear crap like. Lets sack half of our infra-structure support types because everything is running smoothly, you know the guy's responsible for that decision have a collective IQ below 30.
Short term solutions = long term problems
As soon as cost cutting(profit enhancing) measures cut quality you are on the path to extinction and just as a propeller head isn't qualified to run a business, a bean counter isn't qualified to judge technical quality.
by jaqui
"bean counter" should be kept out of the decision loop also, unless it is a bean counting business.
the bean counter's are the ones that make the real bonehead cost cutting to maximise profits short term decisions.
by apotheon
by jmgarvin
by banyangod
and Linux isn't,
Right now Linux is not easy to use for the "novice user" which means that in a business enviroment, you mostly need Windows for your employees.
by hal 9000
and Windows isn't,
Right now Windows is not easy to use for the "novice user" which means that in a business environment, you mostly need Training for your employees. Which costs money so we leave them on Windows and hope that they muddle their way through.
Col ]:)
by blarman
Just because 90%+ of other people do something doesn't mean I should also blindly do the same. That's a pretty lame argument (insert blue-screen joke here). And the argument that majority opinion declares techonological superiority as absurd to say the least. Where is Microsoft's true expertise? Marketing. Always has been. But *nix is superior in security. The business trade off is in what is more important - security or a particular application. I think if you look at it objectively, it is the application that determines the operating system, not vice-versa.
After just writing several MBA papers on relevant topics, here's an objective opinion of both strengths and weaknesses of both platforms. Just for your information, my background is as a Windows Admin (Oracle 9i Cluster on Win2K and Win2K3 for global company). At home I have a laptop running Win2K and my games box dual-booting between Mandriva 2005 and WinXP Pro. That box boots to either OS quickly, but NeverWinter Nights plays better in Linux, even though the driver install (Radeon 9600 Pro) is an absolute nightmare.
Comparisons
Software ubiquity - almost all software is written to run on a Windows client. On the server side, things change substantially. But look at games. Until *nix gets a decent graphics package or re-writes X, Windows will be the target of choice.
Graphical interface - Linux has made HUGE strides in this arena and arguably has a graphical interface almost as good as Windows now. But programming apps for Windows with a good GUI is easier than for Linux due to lack of good hooks for X. *nix has a host of free and open-source applications, but the interfaces often differ so much that they require significant learning time. Microsoft's close coupling of the OS and the windowing interface is a double-edged sword, however, as poorly written applications (and even some not-so-poorly written ones) can then take down the entire operating system. This can't happen on *nix. An app might crash X, but can't take down the OS.
Command line interface - seriously, anyone who even bats an eyelash before saying *nix wins this no-contest battle is braindead. As for the use of the command line for average Joe User... probably not a good idea. Besides, who doesn't like to man woman? ;) (*nix joke)
Hardware - This one is dead even. Windows has an easier interface and typically better driver support for hardware, but the hardware that has drivers/software in *nix is typically more solid. So, the stuff you get for *nix is solid, but of a smaller selection than the stuff for Windows. I've had drivers crash Windows, but never Linux - and on the same box. What do you want? Quality or variety?
Applications - again, I see this as the main crux of the discussion. If you just need to do a little Internet browsing, some minor productivity stuff like documents and spreadsheets, then both will function just fine - but at different costs. You can pay $300+ for Windows XP + Office, or go and download your favorite flavor of Linux + OpenOffice for free. I've used both, and unless you need to use some of the serious data analysis packages in Excel, Open Office has no complaints from me.
The main reason a lot of businesses use Windows is because that is what they started with and that is what the application was built for. And if that application is critical to your business, end of debate.
Software installation - The winner here is Windows and Linux both, but for different reasons. The Windows installer is slick. Linux has significantly improved their installers (the take source, make, then install is too complicated for most users) but it does provide some tweaking that can be very nice. The major criticism of software installation on Windows deals with the land mine also known as the Registry. Potentially, apps can hose just about any portion of a Windows box with a bad registry write. Again, this can't happen on *nix. You can point out dll Hell vs Dependency Heck, but most modern Linux installers take care of these, while Windows' System Restore can at least help you recover, even if it doesn't fix the problem.
The main avenue where *nix wins hands down is security during install. There has been progress, but the profligation of viruses, etc. point to the myriad of problems still prevalent in Redmond-ware.
Conclusion? What do you need the computer to do? If a specific application drives your business information systems, Windows will often be the selection. If security (like for web-based apps) is paramount, *nix is hard to argue against. If not - there is an open debate involving rollout, support, and user training. You have to weigh the factors and their costs and make a business decision.
by blarman
"Where do all these people get the impression that there's a lot more software available for Windows? Nothing could be further from the truth."
Marketing, of which Microsoft is undisputably king. There is a lot of software out there - but most people only know about the Windows software and the source sites for it - ergo the perception. To change the perception, you have to market the products and inform the users. Just like in a Presendential election - it's often the one that spends the most money to get the name recognition that gets elected.
Standard Marketing 101 - customers have to know about a product, then be informed of its benefits in terms of competitors, before making the choice to buy. If they only know about one product that will fit their needs - a Windows-based one - then the decision is settled because they don't know about the alternatives.
Oh, and though I respect Linux a lot, it doesn't have the necessary support for high-end games. Rogue Spear anyone? World of WarCraft? Not on Linux. Fix this problem and Linux becomes a competitor to Windows in a lot more households, because - let's be honest - the real reason most people have a computer is to PLAY GAMES!!!!!
by apotheon
That's actually an extremely good run-down, as far as it goes. There's obviously a lot more that can be said, but for a beginning, that's great.
Nice job.
by apotheon
Yeah, it was a rhetorical question. Clearly, the lion's share of marketing clout is on the Microsoft side of the tracks: you hit the nail on the head. Windows platform applications also benefit from the ubiquity of Windows itself, which provides them with greater visibility thusly. Windows, meanwhile, owes a lot of its ubiquity to the fact that it was the natural upgrade path from DOS, which was available for home use on cheap home hardware long before any killer-app-supporting unix was available on cheap home hardware, thus giving the Microsoft marketing machine its initial user base as a captive audience.
re: games
I've actually run across some mention of rabid Linux devotees playing WoW, so I'm not sure WoW isn't capable of being run on Linux, perhaps by way of WINE or Cedega. TR user jmgarvin would be better informed on that subject than I am, though: I don't really follow the gaming news at all.
by rm3mpc
I take issue with crediting Windows standardizing the user
interface. As in so many other respects, Windows is a cheeesy
knockoff of the Mac OS. Nobody thinks about it any more, but
go back and read old reviews of software on the Mac; major
points got deducted for not following the standards. Windows
didn't even exist.
by hal 9000
Wasn't both the Mac GUI and Windows a direct copy of Xerox Unix GUI?
But without the security as at the time it wasn't considered as important?
Col ]:)
by afhavemann9
We bought several HP?s for evaluation and I have to agree that they can be difficult to work with. I'm unsure exactly why because that very difficulty earned them a "don't buy" score in our tests. They run Red Hat fine though -- go figure.
We finally got them to load XP-SP2 by pushing a fully configured, non-machine specific (machine dependencies removed) image (XP-SP2 with SYSPREP) onto them and allowing the discovery process to cleanup the hardware after the fact. This worked OK but they still seem to have more problems than any of our Dell boxes. Part of the problem seems to lie with the bios. On each of the machines we had to upgrade the bios before discovery would complete without crashing out.
I don't know all the details of what's needed to produce an HP that's as stable as on the Dell machines, but there is a distinct difference, and since the OS is identical, it's got to be the hardware environment.
I suggest you try SYSPREP - it can be a bit hard to master but works well with just about any system and the big advantage is being able to drop a fully configured (to the corporate desktop) image on any platform and have the install complete without having to maintain separate images for every different piece of hardware in the house. There are other methods (Ghost,etc.) but SYSPREP is there, and it works.
by davidfacer
Which bit, you coming across as an arrogant tosspot or your girlfriend jumping to your defence?
If the former is aff. then good for you. If the latter is the case then QED.
by apotheon
by travisfx
I'm just catching up on the thread.. a good one though.
I'd say Shorne's comment about the 15 year old is very relavent. I'm so sick and tired of people putting in these stupid MS jabs, trying to be clever... Its old, people, cliche.. Stop it.
Secondly, you can't make blanket statements about, well almost anything. So saying MS is unstable, period etc is wrong. 2k, xp etc on good hardware is very stable. I hope these threads get better and get beyond this kind of nonsense. Maybe that's why I almost quit reading them..
by apotheon
by pmdoyle65
I wouldn't necessarily agree.
However I would omit if I were reading through for the first time again. Afterall it isn't against the law to change ones mind.
I'm comfortable and I'm happy that you are too.
by mrivera
You are kidding, right?!?!?!
WIN and OPERATING SYSTEM??!?!? Pleeeeaassseeee.....
Windows, regardeless of how you dress it is an A P P L I C A T I O N.... It is not an operating system. Please! Start reading on DOS, OS/2 and WIN3.x and then you tell me if you still think win crap is an Oper Sys...
by mrivera
by jmgarvin
"I'd say Shorne's comment about the 15 year old is very relavent. I'm so sick and tired of people putting in these stupid MS jabs, trying to be clever... Its old, people, cliche.. Stop it."
The "jabs" at MS are mission critical flaws that MS still hasn't addressed. How is talking about them a bad thing?
It is kind of like Cisco pulling the Cisco IOS vulnerability presentation from Black Hat...It just looks bad when you don't own up to your vulnerabilities.
"Secondly, you can't make blanket statements about, well almost anything. So saying MS is unstable, period etc is wrong."
First you say making blanket statements is wrong, but then you run off and do so.
"2k, xp etc on good hardware is very stable. I hope these threads get better and get beyond this kind of nonsense. Maybe that's why I almost quit reading them.."
So this is metric by which we guage our OS...that it runs only on "good" hardware. 'Tis a sad day indeed.
by jan.witschge
Microsoft has acted as the 'de facto standardisation' institute for desktop ICT and desktop productivity tools. It will probably do the same for data centre ICT.
It has succeeded to be the 'democratic ICT platform' because:
1) they combined all good ideas in the 80-ies and 90-ies into their products, without being held back by the legal systems on monopoly issues.
2) they were very visible to the end user
3)They also won from other proprietary and 'open' product philosophies of other companies or communities, because of better marketing (and portfolio mgt), better lawyers, and not neccessarily better but certainly more accessible technology.
I have been am ICT- techie, using and building all types of systems from the mid 70-ies onward and know what's in there.
by pjfromottawa
Looking at your first sentence got me to thinking about how Vista would be abbreviated in your list. So I guess the most obvious is Windows VI which would also mean version 6.0 (if that's what they're internally versioning it as).
It's just about 10:20am here and I think I just maxed out my creativity for the day. Good thing I'm a drone.
by apotheon
That'd put a whole new spin on the vi vs. emacs religious war in the Linux trenches.
I think it's more likely to get called WinV, or Win[foo], where foo == whatever MS prints on the packaging.
by msgale
by apotheon
1. 2000, NT 4, 98, and even 95 were more stable than ME, and 2000 more stable than XP. So much for stability and age being directly related. In fact, since Windows is a direct evolutionary descendant of DOS, you might note that 3.x was more stable than any Windows from 95 on, and DOS without Windows 3.x tended to be even more stable than that (a couple of crap versions notwithstanding).
2. Linux isn't playing catch-up with Windows due to some notion that proprietary OSes supporting nonproprietary hardware are the only worthy OSes. Linux isn't a proprietary OS. You're comparing apples and nerfherders.
by hal 9000
"Microsoft Windows (note the spelling) was the first proprietary operating system to support non-propriety hardware."
Perhaps you would like to inform me just what "Propriety Hardware" was not available for DOS? God it didn't even have printer drivers let alone any thing to drive Video, Sound, a lot of controller cards yes back before the IDE Controller was built onto the M'Board we had to load drivers for everything. Back in those days we used to use Vesa plug in Cards for better Data Transfer rates remember those things?
As for Linux not having driver support for a lot of things perhaps you would like to inform me what it is that you couldn't drive, I've just loaded Debian Woody onto a old 200 MMX Intel Box with a Multi media keyboard an unknown Video Card and a Creative Sound Card and everything was recognized and works even the extra keys on the keyboard.
Currently I'm playing with a copy of Ubuntu which is on a 2100 AMD and ASUS M'Board with network, video, SCSI add in cards and on-board sound and everything works straight from a clean install without any tweaking. The only thing that I did have to specify during the install was the type of monitor and the resolutions I could drive it to.
This thing has picked up the network plays DVDs and does everything including using every key on the multi media keyboard attached.
What exactly did you do wrong loading Red Hat 9? That installs easily and if anything is easier to install than Windows Maybe you didn't expect it to default install some software as well as the OS was that the problem? Just about every ISP that I know uses Red Hat 7 which is a breeze to install straight off the Cd's and 9 is even easier.
About the only real problem that I've ruin across installing Linux is onto a Boot Drive that is a SCSI as for some reason the boot loaders don't seem to like the idea of using a SCSI Drive to boot from but then again there are not too many machines in use that are using SCSI HDD's and when you run across one that does you use the right version of the product to meet your needs and not the free to download copy or the one that you buy at the newsagents for a few dollars.
If you actually bother to use the proper tool for the job you don't have a problem.
As for your 2003 ES Servers just how good do you think that OS would run on a 500 CPU Blade Array? Even if you could afford the license fee. Lets face it Windows Server products are only for small servers and are just not suited for the large ones that control entire systems but they do make excellent Domain Controllers.
Col
by tomsal
Yeah its a shame that all the *VERY* important stuff of our modern technology driven society is handled by Unix (or Unix variant) machines though huh?
;)
Guess those "irritating" Unix guys were on to something...
by sgilman
I have Windows servers that stay up and only go down when we do regular maintenance on them, which is our decision to have the servers go down.
I'm not a Windows fan at all, but it bugs me when people say "Windows servers suck, they always break" when it's not true, they don't ALWAYS break.
by theroyala9
pros and cons
I originally intended to install windows xp on 4
new p4 desktops for an office environment (law
office).
I purchased the copies of oem software, os and
office pro suite. Part way into the
installations I did do "security updates." This
altered the software in such a way that it was
difficult to control the systems. Eventually I
lost a system to trying to customize the user
accounts. Nothing illegal, nothing but try and
fit the one size fits all to my needs.
What troubled me and lead to my throwing $1000 of
software licences in the trash was the fact that
it wasn't a corruption in the file system or
programing -- it was the microsoft corporation
that was so willing to take a system by the
ankles and bash its brains in. The work on these
computers is the livelyhood of several families.
I took on the challenge of linux and I sleep well
knowing that I can control the the systems and
that they are working for me. It take work and
patience and a good supporting community but I
can say that I enjoy it and my worries are far
few and more appropriate.
I know there are administrative ways to solve
problems on windows. I prefer a more straight
forward approach. Users are born and raised w/
microsoft (educational lic.) and so they dont
always take to linux. I worked management before
and i can tell when im getting shafted. I
fortunately have the ability to move people along
as well so my troubles are few and windows
systems 0.
by hal 9000
Windows Server to run unattended connected directly to the Internet?
No disregarding power outages and things like that which are beyond our control mostly I'm betting that you couldn't expect one to run more that somewhere approaching 1 month the time between MS Patches being released.
Of course if you don't patch them they will run longer but then they are more likely to break. :D
Col ]:)
by jaqui
we are on to something. ;)
stable, fairly secure operatring system. :D
by hal 9000
In just one thread I've been called a MS Zombie and a Linux Bigot. :D
I really think that this thread is going to take some beating for all the opinionated people who have posted. ;)
Col ]:)
by ip_fresh9
Notice the bold 'exploited'. I'm not saying Microsoft has any more or less vulnerabilities than Linux, or anything else like that. Hackers want to do the most damage possible. If the most popular product is Windows, they will tailor their viruses to destroy Windows machines. If it's Linux, they'll tailor them to Linux machines.
by hal 9000
If you look at the very first recorded case of hacking in the world it was a spoofed account at Melbourne Uni that allowed the naughty little boys with their 300 Baud modems access to the entire worlds computers back in the mainframe days. Did they do damage hell yes but the reality of the situation was that they could only attack user accounts and delete data from them so they had the room to play around in and do whatever it was that they wanted to do.
Windows Servers and desktops just made it so much easier for them when the time came even though by then it was illegal that only made it more fun for them. It was like 20 - 30 years ago sneaking a cigarette or bottle of beer when you where to young to smoke or drink most of us did things like this not because we wanted to but because we where told not to!
Computers just gave some the ability to create more damage and havoc in a shorter time frame that what we used to be able to do. What was the last guess that it took 24 minutes for a virus to spread around the world?
That is why there is an IT industry to try to prevent things like this from occurring not to wet nurse a bunch of Window boxes to keep them running we are supposed to prevent intrusions and plug any holes before they happen but today we are spending all of our precious time holding the Windows Boxes HDD's to keep them running that we now have precious little time left to do our real work and instead of being proactive in this area we are now running around cleaning up the mess after the event.
There is something very wrong when we not only see this happening but accept it as the way things are.
Col ]:)
by htos1
by techrepublic
I would imagine the users will not just want to boot up an operating system and play Minesweeper. The stability, compatibility, and cost of the required applications should be considered.
Anyway, Microsoft apps make use of undocumented hooks in Windows to improve applicatons performance, so they are very closely linked and should be considered together.
Let's see the hardware compatability list of most Linux OS's or Unix for that matter is about 2 inches long. Of course they don't tell you about that they just keep piping their evangelistic refrain "stable, stable, stable".
What about RAID 1 cards or SATA RAID cards ?
Do you consider the support for these devices stable ?
I'm interested to know what you mean by stable. How would you measure it ? How would you verify it ? It's just another meaningless word that the pundits use as they are FUDDIN along trying to influence the influensable. Both sides do it.
Linux has some use but please stop piping about stability it really is meaningless.
The hardware support for Linux is and always has been pitiful and well behind windows.
by awolfe_ii
Microsoft never designed security into Windows and the torrent
of viruses, worms, spyware, rootkits and all have gone beyond
the point of acceptability. At this point it is a hazard to run
Windows, especially with Outlook or Internet Explorer. Microsoft
is only now beginning to implement default security for users
that is _below_ superuser level.
In contrast, Unix-based OSes (Linux, Mac OS X, Solaris, AIX) have
a system model based on secure government computing
research (Multics). Fifteen years ago (!) Unix System V achieved
a B2 rating, whereas Windows never made it past C.
You can debate a lot of pros and cons. For myself, the security
problem with Windows has grown so large and threatening that
it completely dwarfs all other concerns. After ten years on
Windows, I bought a Mac PowerBook and use it daily at work --
no viruses, no scans, no worms, no spyware -- NOTHING.
If the Mac were as porous as Windows, there would be at least
some viruses or worms around. But ZERO is a very small
number compared with hundreds of thousands of viruses,
thousands of trojan horses. It demonstrates clearly that
Windows problems are not due to its market share making it an
appealing target -- the security problems are due to its inferior
system architecture.
by habrazie
the os depends on what you need to do and the equipment needed also depends on what your need is. The other factor is Who is going to be doing it.
Every network is different as to what it must do with who.
The os depends on your use of it.
The os that does one job well may not do another.
The best os depends on the whole situation.
If security is a major issue then use an os that focuses on security. If security is not an issue then use an os that focuses on the issues you have.
Or use more than one os.
by awolfe_ii
jm2 - Windows has essentially no security architecture and hasn't
caught up in 2005 with where Unix operating systems were in
1990. If you haven't used Linux or Mac OS X or other Unix variants,
I will excuse your comments as being uninformed. But you should
try harder to inform yourself.
by alacrity
I too have had Netware boxes run forever, but I have NT4 server and SBS 2003 that never go down either. I firmly believe that the security and stability are "all in the wrist" There is still some art to computer configuration. Some have it, and some don't. I support more than 250 computers and ALL are stable (except when the inevitable PEBCaK error shows up) All run Windows OS's and MS applications. Most workstations are re-booted monthly for patch installs, older win98 systems run for several months without re-boots. My "best" server was only rebooted after continous "up time" of 2 years 11 months and 14 days. That reboot was for adding RAM. MS bashers are (usually) just not good enough techs OR (get this) so DAMN good they tweek where they should not.
Just my $.02
by alacrity
In a post further down this branch (where it can't be replied to) I read :
So this is metric by which we guage our OS...that it runs only on "good" hardware. 'Tis a sad day indeed
I firmly disagree with this. Look at cars. The Yugo and the Benz are both cars. Both have 4 wheels and a seat. but $4000 for one and $40,000 for the other? Why? "It shouild run on whatever hardware we put it on!"
But we all know that the only reason the Yugo had a rear window de-froster was to keep your hands warm while you pushed it back to the dealer!
Buy cheep crap and you have an unstable system. A GREAT chipset, CPU, VIDEO, etc, etc placed into bottom-of-the-barrel mobo and you STILL have crap. the motherboard designer has to worry about signal propagation, delay, cross-talk, Time-domain reflectometry, etc, etc. Many good companies have boards that just don't work well, and most people can blame it on Windows, but the problem is really a design flaw. I once traced a battery drain problem to a mis-labled board that had the onboard battery hard wired in reverse. (anyone remember NexGen??) A Simple +/- reversal and the CMOS battery died within 3 weeks. Now imagine a CPU vector spitting out complex results to the RAM and the chipset opens the gate but the motherboard messed up the trace lines and the data gets one bit wrong in RAM. System says "Hey. can't have this. I quit for now" and Windows gets another smudge on its record.
Hardware matters.
by hal 9000
But then we all see the junk that is sold by so many companies to cut corners and keep the price down.
I've even seen Dual & Quad Processor Boards that I wouldn't wast the time of throwing them into the sea being sold by a major maker as a server system. While the insides where junk the sale price didn't reflect the cost of the internals it was all to make as much money as possible and don't worry about support.
Even one particular model of IBM PC had a 100% M'Board failure rate a couple of years ago. This unit came preloaded with the basic software & OS and sold for just over the 1K AU mark. Really at the time I couldn't have bought the hardware to do a decent job for that amount and then I would have had to add on the MS Software and even though it would have been OEM it would have been the proper Application for the job with XP Pro and Office not Works. But most people just buy the cheapest that they can get and think that they have got a Great Deal and all the other builders are thieves who are out to Rip Them Off at every opportunity.
Sadly that is how many used to be, in same cases still are and something that we have yet to get past.
But that Designed for XP sticker that MS allows to be placed upon the boxes should be better policed as MS is way too easy in handing them out and for that MS can be held responsible.
Col ]:)
by apotheon
by swilk67
Gentlemen please, my title point has been illustrated on this thread alone, I don't usually partake in IT banter, but the wanton - pseudo- professional backlash, (I feel confident enough in my chosen profession to NOT to list my accreditations or experience) and you know who you are! - The ?I?ve more credits to my name than you and my parents have too? argument is, frankly utterly juvenile.
Please stop arguing the pro and cons, but work towards harmonisation, standardisation, and utilisation of hardware regardless of x platform ? Do not use your time on this site, deriding each other about ms vs. nix, or some petty argument, but talk constructively on how to bring it together. Don't forget, if the IT industry were the car industry, we'd still be producing Ford model 'T's at this stage. My apologies to you Sirs, but please do not denounce anybodies knowledge of x platform over y platform ? this illuminates perfectly what I meant about intellectual snobbery found on this site and within the industry itself.
Thanks to parsnipfingers and jwitschge for the understanding.
by apotheon
swilk67: It's kinda funny to see you trying to play the "mature" card, lamenting the flame wars et cetera, considering your every post here has been a defense of Windows, an indictment of unix/Linux, and generally derisive toward anyone that doesn't favor Windows. Even when you try to appear somewhat balanced in opinions, your remarks about the various unices are punctuated by "but it still sucks" addenda. Now you're continuing the trend by calling everyone that doesn't agree with you some kind of immature brats.
Meanwhile, you single out a couple of fellow Microsoft-philes as your paragons of maturity and professionalism, people who have if anything been even more anti-anything-not-MS than you have. Parsnipfingers in particular has shown anything [b]but[/b] maturity and professionalism in most of his/her posts here.
What the hell are you smoking, that you think nobody's going to call you on that BS post of yours?
I've been supporting both MS and Linux, alone and in hybrid networks, for years. I'm moving to another state to become the netadmin for a company that runs a hybrid network with both platforms running both as servers and as desktops. I don't have a vested interest in either platform, financial or in any other manner professional, for the sake of its branding. When you can truthfully say the same, maybe your dismissive attitude toward unix/Linux and the people who like it will improve.
by hal 9000
Some people do particularly those with a MS only background.
It is these people who are scared of the developments in the IT industry and the quick movement away from MS Windows on the server side at the very least as if MS ever had a proper Server platform anyway. :^O
MS make some very nice useful products that keep me busy and the money rolling in so I'm not complaining too much but honestly I would much rather prefer to be doing routine maintenance rather than constantly running around on mercy missions to my customers to fix something that has broken in Windows. At least then I wouldn't be feeling that I'm getting money under false pretenses.
Like one customer that I have which I sort of inherited one day when I was very drunk he is driving me nuts with his constant complaints about an old backup machine with 98SE on it. Currently it will not run Defrag or Norton's Speed Disk so he has spoken to a few people that he works with and come up with the solution the CPU must be replaced an old AMD 450 mind you then when he decided a day latter that it didn't have enough RAM installed he wanted it changed.
Of course I've left it running doing diagnostics and found not a single hardware problem but a whole bunch of errors in the Windows Registry which is causing the problem. Of course having the date set to 2008 didn't help either. :D
So he is now on my back to reload the thing but only after I save his data and he wants it done now but at the same time the only USB 3.5 inch caddy I have around here has another one of his HDD's in it formatting up so I can recover some data off it and it has only been at 75% complete since Friday it's now Monday morning so I think that his chances of getting his data recovered are slim to say the least. But he doesn't want me to stop the try until the Format option spits the dummy and fails. ;)
Of course that drive came out of his main unit and he didn't follow my advice and BACK IT UP! He only backed up his company Data and none of his other files which now seem so important. At least some people are good for a laugh. :D
Col ]:)
True Yes
Right No
Was the word democratic chosen to distance yourself from the oppressive communist oppostition ?
Need I say more ?
Don't worry once someone can't find better to say they will attack you on that point. I as French Canadian got use to that.
If what I am saying make sens and they don't like it wheter I am for or against Windows they will attack me on my spelling. So who care the one that love debate do not give you the spelling crap the one that are just "Emerite Professor" will alwalys look at your creditential I guess it is the new "Elite" class of today world.
For myself if I could get rid of MS I would but having to choose between building my "box" and buying a Mac I choose to built one. I would probably buy the Mac OS if I could only buy the OS and not their "candy" <> wrapping.
Maybe in a kioske it could make sens to buy a computer that have the monitor integrated or a PC Keyboard by itself but for me it is open the case and open hardware so for me it is MS because I can't find all the correct software to support my AIW 9800 and my Creative Audigy2 Platinium and other stuff like that, if it existed and supported by the hardware vendor I would go Linux but because only Microsoft offer that now I guess for now it is XP for me as it was before for 98SE and Me after that.
Have a great day.
by unni_kcpm
Pros :
1. User Friendly.
2. Large User Base & Answer/Help banks for
various problems.
Cons :
1. Buggy due to add-on features and available
softwares.
2. Nexus(Virus & Exploitations) against it.
by unni_kcpm
Pros :
1. User Friendly.
2. Large User Base & Answer/Help banks for
various problems.
Cons :
1. Buggy due to add-on features and available
softwares.
2. Nexus(Virus & Exploitations) against it.
by paul
Agree here. And one more thing, how many of you would have a job if we running UNNIX on all systems? Very few in deed. So be thankful we have it. Besides on workstations all other OS are simply not yet ready for the end user. Never forget the end user please. They are the people we all work for. Without them we can all go home.
Paul
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending