Discussion Locked

quick q

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
all hypothetical...but what would happen if you had a software IDE raid array (RAID 5, with 4 disks) that was supporting both your operating system, and your data (two seperate drive letters). You blue screen when it's starting up (win2k server)and decide that maybe its a bad ide controller, and unplug two drives, then power on. Say it does the EXACT same blue screen. Would you have broken the RAID array up by unplugging two drives at once? I don't think so because 1)it's software and the os didn't even start up and 2)it didn't give a different error msg when starting up. What do you think? I hope this garbled mess makes sense :D

3 replies

by jdmercha

There are no garantees with software raid. But if you are getting an immedaite blue screen then the software raid hasn't kicked in yet. So I would agree with you. And in a perfect world, you could just plug the two drives back in and restore the raid even if it was broken.

by advancedgeek

I thought that if you unplug two drives from a RAID 5 array, and start the pc running the RAID, that this would make it unrepairable.

by senior program analyst

I agree that in most cases once the Raid is fired up it would be broken with 2 or more drives down). But in some cases it can be repairable. In this case though, since its software raid, then the original boot of the machine isnt using any raid - the boot is stored just like any PC on the first drive. Once the boot has loaded the raid and the raid drives are active then you may be back to a broken array, but since the blue screen is coming up before the boot has completed then likely it still had not initialized the raid so nothing would happen to the data yet.

This discussion is closed to new replies.