Say no to Free "IT Advice"
As an IT Adminstrator I get a lot of staff members asking for advice on their home computers.
What will be a nice way to say "No" to free advice.
At present it is involving some staff members and a partner.
Thanks
IT Employment
As an IT Adminstrator I get a lot of staff members asking for advice on their home computers.
What will be a nice way to say "No" to free advice.
At present it is involving some staff members and a partner.
Thanks
by jaqui
hand them the heaviest, thickest, most technically complex manual on computers you can lay your hands on.
then say, look it up youself.
by lwebb
...then tell them you read it and that's why you charge $100/hour without guaranteeing squat...and GET IT.
P.S. You don't take checks or CC. CASH Only, half up front.
by tmcal
by ddissent
by bfilmfan
We can set up a database with a phone listing of peers. When they want some free advice, have them call one of us. When we answer, it's $3.95 a minute for all the hot nerd brain action they can stand and we could pay you a finder's fee.
Most people in life are looking for something free. My advice is to provide no more than a 30-second answer for free. If they want more, quote them your rates. They usually disappear real fast then.
by dr dij
by ramrod
by the admiral
The correct answer is:
"Unfortunately, I don't have experience with your particular setup, so it would be a complete shot in the dark as to how to fix your problem. You might have better luck by having a person come to your house who is licensed and bonded who can take a look at your setup and make the appropriate recommendations. I don't want to give you the wrong information without knowing the entire picture, sort of like an automechanic pulling out the engine in your car just to plug a hole in your tire."
by tagmarkman
by mickster269
The Admiral summed it up quite nicely. We aren't psychics, and we aren't omnipotent.
But we also don't want to dent our relations with our co-workers.
The diplomatic way out is the best way.
by aceskaraoke
by mollenhourb9
The Admiral has it right (maybe that's why he's the Admiral?). You don't need to get belligerent, as some film critics do. Quoting rates could actually violate company policy with regard to moonlighting. These are usually decent people just trying to get a straight answer from somebody they trust. Give them the benefit of the doubt and treat them with respect. Someday you may need their help with something in the office, and you don't want them to think you are a jerk (unless of course you ARE a jerk and LIKE being thought of that way).
Treat people as you would like to be treated.
by tj8
by jarodbee
by admin
by zen37
One of my friends had a neat idea.
He shows his MCSE card and tells them that the MCSE rules obligates him to charge for any and all work he does at an acceptable minimum rate.
So far, he hasn't been busy all that much outside of work!!!
I don't do that anymore. What i hated the most is when people would ask for pirated copies of software and they would look at you funny when you told then it was illegal and you couldn't do that. Like all IT people are expected to be thieves or something. geez!
by beads
Short of wearing one of those: "No, I won't fix your computer..." shirts around the office. You might be tempted to put a small, sign on your desk or what not. Just large enough for people to see but not explosively so. Yes, someone really does make a T-shirt with those words printed on it. Thought about wearing one to the next family get together where I am usually barraged worse than anything at work.
No, the PC (Politically Correct) thing to do would be to follow Admiral's advice. That is without a doubt the most succint way I have ever heard to avoid the perils of the 'free advice' dilema. Of course if they get really upset I remind them that the advice I could give would cost them many years of training and learning for the privilidge. So, even for us, its not at all free now is it?
- beads
by jaqui
all suposed to be thieves.
after all how else are they supposed to get free software?
ignore the fact it's us that create it so we are stealing from ourselves ( in a sense )
we should support piracy of software....
[/sarcasm]
since I'm open source, I just say go download the sources and compile it.
if it's a commercial app, why does the company need it?
I ain't spending money I don't have to.
by mjd420nova
This is a problem for all IT souls. I'm slanted towards hardware and will give it all for free.
As much advice as anyone doing it by osmosis.
I refer to it as the "laying on of hands". To
truly bless the needy, they must bring it to
my presence and say the magic words. I will
do "work" for friends and agree ahead of time that no money passes hands, as the blessing are to be repaid inkind. BARTER I gain many services I could otherwise not afford. I barter
with my auto mechanic, dentist, doctor, babysitter, and grocer. My regular rates are
$125. arrival and $95. an hour with one hour minimum. I do everything from printers to
monitors and systems. Many things are dependent
upon the age of the machine and available parts.
So far, the best customer I have is the dentist
as I feel I'm getting the best side of the deal,
but I would never have suggested Barter, He brought it up...
by fbeechwood
As a school Technology specialist and Computer repair teacher I have a solution
Tell them what I say, " I will be happy to have one of my student assistants to assist you."
They usually recoil in horror and beat a hasty retreat!
This is not the nicest way tro handle the problem but it is effective
by knightheart
Whenever coworkers ask me to look at their systems, it's usually the same thing: Spyware. I wipe out as much as possible, and then put their hard drives (as slaves) in a system I have specifically for eliminating spyware, and clean it up all the way. It usually doesn't take that long, so I give them a REALLY reasonable price, and I haven't had any complaints. No one has expected anything for free....yet.
I worked on my boss's machine and didn't charge, but she gave me a couple gift certificates for a restaurant I liked anyway. And since it was her machine, I didn't have a problem doing it during work.
One thing I do steer away from, and that's building machines for people. As soon as Windows crashes once, even if it's because they've stupidly installed a ton of spyware and have no anti-virus or anything, they complain that the machine isn't right. So now if they ask, I tell them to get either Alienware or Dell (feh), for no other reason than if they have a problem, they can call tech support.
Of course, I've had people buy the Dell and then ask me for help when something goes wrong with it. That's when I can say "sorry, but I didn't build the machine, and since you've paid for Dell's warranty, you should ask them." Sometimes when reminded that they paid for something, they tend to want to get their "money's worth."
Never do it for free once, because then it's expected forever. People will get a lot more offended having to pay for something after it was free then if that's how it's been all along.
by choppit
by mrshickman
VMS are they using.
It's quite easy to let yourself get dragged into this sort of thing. If it's a mate I'll go round try and help and sink a few beers. If it' the missus' sister best friends mother in law then Ill book atime to do it and then be unfortunatley too busy
I allways tell people who ask for "free" computer support, YES I can certainly help them for free, just as soon as they can put me onto a Plumber who can sort my plumbing for free. Oh and by the way when did they last go to their work for "Free".
PS. Check out the rates and call out charges of Plumbers. Are we not the same ? Electron plumbing in a precise manner.
by aceskaraoke
by jdclyde
By helping people higher up the food chain, this helps you get friends in high places.
this can only be good news when it comes to raises and advancement.
by aceskaraoke
by jdclyde
it really can be as simple as saying yes and making a friend in a high position and saying no and making bad feelings with someone in a high position.
I prefer the friends.
by dmambo
C'mon, we can help those who might not be "higher up the food chain". In reality, the help most people need doesn't take too long to give. As long as nobody's taking advantage of my good nature, I'll usually help them out regardless of their social/work position.
Most of us geeks spend a significant amount of our free time pursuing geek activities anyway. Why not let that time benefit someone who needs the help? :) (That doesn't mean you have to be a doormat. Everything has its limits.)
by rdover
What if you gave verbal advice and they didn't follow your verbal advice and did something wrong and messed up their PC?
Or what if you go to their house and in attempting to fix it, something unrelated happens and their machine crashes, or two days later it crashes? Their going to say "You came over to my house and broke my computer." It can get real ugly real quickly!
by gary
by dmambo
by hugh_vagn
by aceskaraoke
by winkyx
by jmgarvin
You are there for free advice and help. They think you WANT to constantly work and give out free advice. They think you don't want a weekend or time off....
Aren't you ALWAYS thinking about these things? Aren't you ALWAYS wanting to work for hours on end at someones house (or on their home computer in your house) trying to figure out WHAT they really want and need?
by davemori
We post recommendations to an internal user group discussion page on our intranet, with links to various vendor sites, and Q&A type stuff with huge legal disclaimers on each page.
Whenever someone asks, we point them there.
by paul
by mswanberg
Just say, "well, I usually charge my friends $100 an hour to work on their stuff... but I tell you what, I'll do it for you for $90..."
:-)
by lwebb
I think all IT people have this problem at some point.
So do what I do:
Act like they're imposing on you (body language, tone of voice etc...shouldn't be hard to do because they ARE)
Tell them you normally charge $100/hour for consulting and off-site jobs.
OR:
Repeat after me:
"You know dude, I'd like to help you but I've already been through this a million times already. If I give you advice, then suddenly I'm responsible for every little thing that goes wrong with your machine and all of a sudden I'm roped into driving 40min to your house at 10pm on a Saturday night because you fat-fingered your password and it's somehow my fault...
Dude, your FRIENDSHIP,...and my Marriage... are far too important to me than giving you free computer advice. Here's a number of a guy I know in the Valley..."
Works EVERY time.
by legalalien
by bkl.thomas
by the hard way
by johnshell
by tekdoc
"Prescription without Diagnosis is Malpractice."
That usually gets them laughing.
Then hand them your card, or the card of someone who makes house visits.
For executives and managers in your company, you should look for agreement that this is part of your job. Home computers are extensions of their job, and you need to keep them realtively safe. Of course you are compensated for the time involved.
Remember now, if you are going to be this mean spirited and petty you forfeit the right to ask anyone anything about anything you don't know (without payment) ever again. That mechanic friend of yours ? Forget it. And the guy that works at the garden place and knows plants ? No chance. That guy down the street that is a tax person. No, that's it. No cash, no help. You said it.
Nope, you are on your own now pal. Whatever happened to being a nice person and applying a little Karma to your life ?? Jeez.
The Merchant.
by dugga6
by dmambo
by ddissent
I like you - YOU get it - The rest of these greedy idiots surely don't. That's ok because you and I? we can look at ourselves in the mirror and actually LIKE what we see. These other "people" get to live their lives picking up every penny they find on the sidewalk ... wishing it were a dime.
- greed is the gas that fuels the car of the lonely
DVD
by wdeckert
What's the problem with helping people? I get asked for help on a fairly regular basis; co-workers and friends mostly, and family sometimes too. I have no problem lending a hand, and in return I get help if and when needed.
Don't you earn a good enough living? I simply don't see the need to ask for money in return for helping a friend.
I did not have time to read all the posts, but the first 10 I read were all negative. You sound like a bunch of immature egotistical spoiled brats. I sure hope that many of the posts were positive, and that I simpyl missed them.
Lastly, I would like to point out that many of us, and probably even many of the complainers, offer *free* advice here online to people in need, so what exactly is your problem???
Teamwork, folks. Teamwork. Don't be so cheap.
by jb1
by haylocks
Why would you not want to help out colleagues?
I had so much support from tecchies when I was tech-ignorant in sales in DEC that I now run my own PC support company.
I help out my colleagues who are in the state I was 25 years ago - I usually, smilingly, ensure that I receive an untaxable bottle or two of Shiraz. And it's nice to know they prefer my help rather than some others of my colleagues!
Staff who work together for their common benefit give their company a performance boost. If you're you're a curmugeon, don't expect anything from them either.
by carterdn
by jeffh
by karenc
Tell the partner you are starting a home business dispensing IT to the needy for a small fee, outside of work and won't affect work in any way of course.
Then as the partner has had all this free help from you it's only fair the partner helps you run your business by giving you advice and solving your problems.
Once the partner decides this is a bad idea you can legitemately do the same and further you can apply it to the other 'customers' with the partners backing.
by arkous
by jez
All situations are different, but i think it is good for our (IT peps) reputation to be approachable and offer basic advice...
I try and be helpful and if people get too probing the geek in me comes out and i tell them
"of course you wouldnt have this problem with linux". ;-)
Also any mention of home visits is met with "so your going to cook for me", or "that'll cost you few beers".
The bottom line is be honest. If something is going to take me 2 hours (OS install) then i tell them it is a big job and i can / cant fit it in.
We are all only human and people will respect you more for your honesty.
by lsa
by shuubz
by neokinetic
by gauravbahal
Probably you need to be an entreprenuer now. Get a buddy. As soon as someone asks for advice say " Gee, I wish I could help. But hey, I know a great guy who can help you out. Simply Brilliant fellow, he has his own business and runs a small company (that indicates money will be charged)" :-)) Give your buddy's number. Who ofcourse charges for work and splits the proceeds with you.
Bingo. You will rake in some moolah and those who dont wanna pay will seek advice some place else. Two birds with one stone.
Also, you can decide on who to help and who not to. There are times when help goes a long way. Remember most of our work as human beings is done because we network, because we know people who know people who can help us in times of need. So use the above ploy sparingly.
Zakaku
by dstahl
My experience is that quite a few of these people are using home-computers for work purposes (As the cost of USB-data keys has declined causing the weight of company issued laptops with proper VPN clients have increased to the point where employees will sometimes elect not to take the laptop home).
My point here is that frequently the home computers of the employees become a defacto extension of your computing environment. Wouldn't you like to make certain these devices are at least 'virus free' before that USB-key returns to the office and gets plugged back in?
My policy has been:
*IT will clean/debug/reload home PCs for employees during work-hours on a lowered priority basis.
*IT staff WILL NOT under any circumstances make a house call to an employees home (this made our lawyer very happy).
*The company purchased additional anti-virus CALS for every employee to use at home.
*When IT works on a home user's PC, the AV software is installed/updated/configured, a personal firewall is downloaded/installed/configured, SpyBOT S&D installed and, of course the Microsoft Update service turned on and brought current.
The results of this kind of approach seem to be terrific.
First, employees gain access to IT staff in a non-emergency/non-project scenario - get some free advice and learn all about each other's family ("It all started after my son installed something called bitTorrent and...."). That kind of social interaction pays dividends later on.
Second, employees are being gently educated and in some cases better able to deal with the 'kid/computer' relationship at home since many of the children are felt to be more knowledgable about computures than they are.
Lastly, you've done a good thing as an IT professional by helping control insecure PC's in the always-on home environment. Altruistic? Nope! You've also reduced the risk that your corporate LAN environment is going to be infected from the 'inside' (saving those all important egress security elements that we all have from failure).
So, my advice is just say yes. Manage their expectations properly, give them more value than they bargined for and you'll increase your customer satisfaction in a huge way.
/djs
by ronbirch
by cleanjoe
what a bunch of mean spirited people we are. we don't help if it doesn't benefit us in some fashion. that is really sad.
based upon the majority of replies, does this mean i can't ask my neighbor for advice on hiring a contractor to do constuction work when my neighbor just went through the same process? or talk to a family member who owns an automoble that i am considering purchasing? how about talking to a coworker who has vacationed in a country that i would like to visit? what about asking a fellow runner about the brand of running shoe they are using?
each of those folks have domain knowledge (aka advice) that i'd like them to share with me for free.
we all need to lighten up. take a day off. we are all so stressed out that we can't think like a 'normal' human, a good friend, a family member, a nice neighbor.
by mill3502
by pete1978
First, analyze the politics. If the person asking for the advice is in a position of influence (such as a partner), giving the advice may help your career or allow your department to get things the department wants later. Always give the advice to political powers as you will often get something in return later.
For the people who are not in such power political positions, make a referal. Tell them, the people over at ______________ PC store are very reliable. Check with them. They'll have time to look at the problem and give you an answer based on what they find. I don't have the time to look at the PC and without looking at it, I'd just be guessing.
by wondercat
by crazijoe
by genes89
I have caved in on this issue and bill friends for my time working on their stuff. I give a "family" discount ($95 v. $125) and so far it has been OK. No one has been dissatisfied, I don't feel like a sucker, and I have picked up sime business from the companies who employ them.
Has anyone heard how the Geek Squad at Best Buy is doing? As an independant, I worry that they will take my SMB clients away.
by curtisyerger
by soulman918
by gnorton100
Produce an extra income stream. Verify that it is their home computer and then remind them that home computers are outside your job scope so you can't help them during working hours, however, you could work on it as an after hours job or they could take it to a local shop. Then give them your pricing: X dollars per hour + one way travel. (Half an hour travel one way = half an hour pay.)
I've had a couple of people balk at the price and some that try to press for the information for free. I simply restate the top paragraph and ask them to call me if they want the job done after hours and tactfully hang up.
by etco
I know the pressure IT Pro's can be put under by co-workers looking for solutions to tech problems at home and ...yes..it is cheeky and presumptious of them to expect IT help on tap. The issue doesn't have to be about whether or not to charge for helping them. Myself and my team are currently drafting self help materials (PPoint, Viewlets, Docs etc) covering a variety of common in-house issues eg.NDS login, email/intranet login etc, which will be delivered during a 'drop-in clinic' event targeted at all non-IT staff. Beyond this initial clinic, we anticipate future clinic agendas being driven by the demands of the attendees which will almost certainly involve offering advice and information on avoiding and, to an extent repairing common home PC problems.
All materials will be made available through our staff intranet and actively promoted by our team whenever we are approached for unofficial help.
by skorekeep
...when I post answers in the forum I work on, because I take on a surly, contrary attitude on purpose. Ya'll take the cake. With an attitude like that you can kiss goodbye any chance of ever becoming an entrepreneur; the best thing for bringing people in to see your wares is free advice on your common problems. You want to be an island, then I hope you pay your kid a living wage for mowing the yard, and keep a spreadsheet to account for every penny.
The worst aspect of trade unions and guilds is the "lets keep it a secret" attitude. Try to find out how a surveyor does his job by searching on the web, for instance. y'all sound like a bunch of 16th century craft-masters.
Then, of course, there's always the possibility you're simply scared silly by not knowing the answer...
by dfox138
by mshi
I usually 'misunderstand' their request for help and answer by giving them some advice - maybe the address for spybot s&d or a local geek squad type service. When I lived in a different state, I had a friend who would do that kind of thing on the side - he had cards and everything, and I'd just give them one of those.
I also get a lot of 'what kind of computer should I buy' questions, and I usually probe a little and end up recommending they shop around and make sure they get enough memory and hard drive space and a good anti-virus program. I'll give them a quick rundown on the main things they need to look for.
And occasionally I've managed to impress them by looking up a specific error message in google and telling them what to do about it.
Partners/owners - I'll fix their machines, but on company time. If they're paying my salary, they can have me work on whatever machine they want. If it's a bad time, I'll just make clear what project is being delayed so I can fix their printer.
I'd think the goal is to be nice enough not to really piss off your coworkers unnecessarily, but not so nice you get taken advantage of. Most people I've dealt with have been understanding.
by tony.savoie
I get this all the time. I dont like doing it, but cant say no without offending people. I dont feel right about charging friends/family/coworkers so I barter with them. I trade them 1 hour of computer work for 1 hour of whatever they can offer.
One persons husband runs a landscaping business....8 hours of fixing thier home pc got me out of taking care of my lawn for a month!
My mechanic's pc was acting up....couple hours of spyware removal and applying patches got me 3 free oil changes.
Kid down the streets mother approached me cause the kids laptop was farked up and he uses it for school. I fixed the laptop, kid came to clean the gutters on the house.
It gives the people a little perspective too. They dont like cutting my grass on thier own time, I dont like fixing thier computers on mine. They are less apt to call with "Oh, my icon moved to a different spot on my screen. How do I put it back?" type problems...
by roadman1007
by jb1
Wow. I can't believe the number of negative posts on this topic. What kind of egos have all of you developed? Have you never been in the same position? Have you never asked anyone a question related to their career specialty? Or are you different and don't hold yourself to the same standard you expect others to live at?
On top of that, you said these people "ask you for advice on their HOME computers". They ask for advice. They didn't ask you to come work on it, they asked you for direction with a particular issue. Try getting off your high-horse, become a human being again and answer their question to the best of your ability. If it's a difficult, in-depth issue that logically can't be answered easily, just tell them.
It is internally fullfilling when someone comes back and is beaming all over the place about how they did exactly what you told them and it worked! They feel so good about themselves and are very thankful to you. It often ends up with a homemade cake, them buying you lunch or some small token of thanks for helping them out.
It's egotistical, self-absorbed "techies" like the bunch of you that bring down America and neighborhoods. "Horay for me and screw you.". Nice attitude to have. I suppose you'll want us to feel sorry for you when life throws you a curve and isn't going your way. Just remember not to ask anyone for free advice or help at that time. Call a professional egotist and pay them to do something a good friend would be willing to do just to help you out...
by mikefromco
I agree. It's as if none of us have ever asked for free advice from co-workers?
So if you work in the IT department of a hospital and ask a doctor or nurse a question, their answer should be "Make an appointment"? Would you really appreciate that response?
And JB is also right; there's usually some token of thanks or maybe better a return of the favor.
by i,technician
Dear Freeozraelised,
You may have forgotten the law of sowing and reaping. While you give advise for free, you are being paid in the valuable currency of knowledge. Every time you solve a problem, you have to think. You hone your skills, for FREE. Put another way; it costs you nothing now to become the most knowledgeable, well-rounded technician your company has in the future. The law of sowing and reaping in action. If you feel you are losing time away from real work to give free advice and that is what is really bothering you simply let your co-workers know that ?free? advice will be secondary to work. Ask politely if they could get back with you later. Better yet, consider talking to your supervisor about organizing one or two lunch break home computer Q & A sessions a month. This shows your willing to assist your compatriots, demonstrates and enhances your skills and everyone will learn something. Oh, and it will probably be a lot of fun. Sow, then reap.
by jmiguy
I get multiple co-workers stopping me in my tracks many times during a day to ask for free tech support. I get non-stop calls at home and at work from friends, family, aquaintances, and co-workers asking for free tech support.
I've spent thousands of dollars on schooling and I've spent many years of my life learning this trade.
For anyone to assume they should get free tech support just because they know me is extremely rude and un-thoughtful. These people need to be set straight right away, even if the same rude behavior has to be thrown right back at them.
IT workers are specialists and should be treated as such. If any of my co-workers can provide a valuable service or valuable advice, I'm more than happy to compensate them, and would never consider asking them for free help.
The next time you go to the doctor, why don't you try and ask for some free medical help! Ask your doctor if he or she thinks he or she is above everyone else.
Doctors shouldn't charge people either for giving medical advice in you world. Please get real!
by mhambrecht
by jnoonan
by horell
by gary-knight
by btitus
I deal with this on a case by case situation.
For the occasional advice seeker with a simple problem, I listen to the issue and offer a couple quick solutions. I can afford a minute or two out of my day to be nice to the people I work with. For problems that seem more in depth I usually tell them to send me an email with detailed description and if possible a screen shot of the error message and when I get a chance I'll look into it. Most of the time I never receive that email so I'm off the hook. Hey, I offered, they elected not to follow through, not my problem. On the rare occasion that I do get an email, many times I have learned something in the process of helping them resolve their issue so it becomes a gain for me.
I do have some users that almost daily are asking me to resolve issues with their home PCs. With these people I eventually draw the line and tell them they need to spend some money on a professional service because the company is paying me to attend to it's systems not employee's personal PCs.
by saintgeorge
by portypicker
Hi,
I'm with those that don't quite see what the problem is? If you just tell people that you you 'don't have the time' then pretty soon you'll be known as the guy who doesn't have time - for work colleagues, for friends, for his/her partner(!! You really don't like helping your partner??! Ouch!) - and the problem will go away.
Personally, it's a little ego-boost for me when folks ask for my help/advice. And generally most are pretty generous when it comes to paying me back (one or two insist on paying properly, with invoices and that (I give a 'discount' rate!), but most give me some wine or malt whisky or maybe a 'techie' gift they know I'll like). But even those that don't give something material (like my Mum!) do 'give' in other ways... helpful advice in other areas, may just being 'good company' (and 'bigging me up' to their friends...).
If anyone does get to be a real hassle and takes advantage, then it's really down to your interpersonal skills to 'dissuade' them without them wanting to slap/kill you! That may vary from person to person - the 'no time' excuse generally works though. (Or fall back on the 'helpdesk' mantra of 'reboot/reload/reinstall').
But always remember, people will always remember what you did for them, when you were 'there' for them... They also remember when you weren't! You get what you give in this world (eventually!). The choice is yours.
by crowell
Sort by Trending