Say no to Free "IT Advice"
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by spidershrek
by gus
I've been in this business for almost 30 years. I work for a school district with about 1500 computers. I get questions asked many times all day long. Look at it this way . They respect you enough to ask you. You don't have to be ugly . I don't work on machines for free either. I always send them to the local computer company. It helps his business and gets them out of my hair.
Like the show road house "Be Nice" it pays off in the long run. Not everyone can be as smart as a young IT. The cost of an education is expensive and it's human nature to try to get information for free. You young fellows hang in there . Always remember "Youth and Strength are no match for Whit and Experience
by tonez1
by sheldonmoss
by alxnsc9
by wvcomment
I too have faced the issue of free tech support for home computers. I used to go to peoples home's (some I considered very good friends) to fix problems or troubleshoot their computers, but it soon got to the point were it was expected. Anytime someone had a problem they just dumped it on me. I got lots of invitations for dinner but always at a price. Finally I stopped. People asked and I told them flat out NO!! I told them why.. because I felt I was being taken advantage of.
Now I freely give advice, people ask questions, I will try to get answers, but I will not touch their home computers. They ask my opinion on systems to purchase, or what to do if they have a virus.
It has taken time but now my relationship with friends and co-workers is much better. Funny though how those invitations for dinner stopped coming..
by info
I get bombarded with "quick questions" and requests for help.
I try to determine as rapidly as possible whether the request will translate into billable work within the next six months or year or so.
My door is open to anyone who wants to share the problem they are experiencing.
I do not want to waste an opportunity to match my services (I package help and advice as a service) with people who are willing to pay for them.
At the same time, I do not wish to jeopardise a long-term relationship for the sake of short-term opportunism.
I believe I would never accept work that is detrimental to my primary client. I don't want to let small stuff become obstacles to continued relationships which are much more valuable.
Frankly, unless an individual has a high net-worth, it is very difficult to provide services to them that are valued more by them than the sum of the monetary cost of the service.
Usually, but not necessarily, a business group or an individual operating a business has much more "use" value for what you can offer and will have no problems paying you for any help and advice which will enable them to better do what they already do as an extension of their existing goals and objectives.
After considering all these issues and related issues on a case by case basis, I eventually determine whether or not I will do what is requested of me and what I will do it in exchange for.
Pro bono can pay a lot. Many times I have done pro bono work to the point where the person requesting the work became so guilt-wracked they paid me twice over for the services rendered. And refused a refund of the extra money claiming it was my bonus. This kind of thing can more than adequately compensate for the leaner times.
I you don't help them, then they will set up an informal self help group around the "IT GURU".
Perhaps form a local LUG, swap software, pirate ware, perhaps even swap viruses!
eventually you will find that this grooup at work no longer bothers to come to you.
by sbrooks
I don't find it a problem giving free advice, it's only when the advice turns into unpaid work that it becomes a problem. Like when someone wants help re-installing windows, I'll jot down the basics like how to boot from the windows CD and etc. But then some people start pushing the concept.
Like when I get asked over the phone to talk someone through installing windows, this is no longer free advice, they basically want me to sit at the other end of the phone telling them what to do at every step of the way, something I usually get paid a lot of money for. I don't mind them "having a go" and then asking for help at a sticky bit and etc, but there are limits to what "free advice" should cover, each person needs to sort out what these limits are to them, because they are different for each person.
Now the other problem with free advice is, if it's free some people simply don't take it as seriously as they should. If I give a person free advice, it is exactly what I would do if I was standing there in person charging them $70+ an hour myself.
An example, I got called for help with an internet connection, it wasn't working, all the computers were still networked but the internet wasn't working, so I ask for the status of the lights on the modem, and sure enough the dsl light is indicating a loss of sync. So I ask them if they have called their ISP and checked for problems, no they haven't, rather they had, but there was as a queue, so can I come and look at it. So I give them some quick free advice, call the ISP. But no, they want me to look at it personally, so I tell them if I do all I will be doing is sitting on the chair and waiting for their ISP to reply, and finally convince them to call their ISP, and I was busy on another job so by the time I got there it could be sorted out.
They didn't call back, so it either worked, or I lost a customer, but he point is, a lot of people don't really appreciate advice given for free, so I give it out sparingly, because a rare item retains its value.
Steve
Advice is free, service cost, tho if advice comes down to, how to do, in many cases, which turns into hours of talking, then it too, comes with a price.
Out Of The Inner Circle
by hermit47
I work locally for an electronics service that targets home, personal, and small business users bill@ expresses how I need to cope with family and friends perefectly.
Family and close frinds always ask for the "Quick solution" to problems. I am always placed in positions of evaluating the need to charge for time or count it as help "off the cuff" so to speak. The line I draw is verbal advice counts as an advertising tool, or hook to draw the client relationship. If I am asked to do the work I make sure people realize that I am on the clock at that point. Family gets a discounted rate, which creates the impression of a win win situation to them. I get to be the hero, they get the help they need at a discount.
Those who work in IT departments could help themselves by remembering that since their time and education is valuable, it is only right to expect fair pay for it. Doctors regularly give advice and sometimes sample medications to those in real need, knowing that when the real emergency comes, they will be the one called for the work to be done. So decide on a fair price structure, that either would appeal to the querents if you like helping; or discourage if you want some down time. Make it known to all, and if the boss thinks you are moonlighting? Explain exactly why it is necessary to do it.
by rubendlct
by kurdon
First, we shouldn't feel 'privileged' because that is a state of 'aboveness'in disguise, and that's not the point but the same as I read in posts before, it depends ALOT in the kind of people asking for yout help.
When you work in an environment where you deal with alot of people, yo can esaily say if:
1. They're just bugging people, who messes up because they give a shit about breaking equipment. You help them, and they break it again and again and again.
2. They don't have enough knowledge into using equipmente, because surely they are normal people wic spent hundreds of dollars in specialization in their areas which have nothing to do with computer, but here it splits to:
2.a. This people want to learn, this people deserve our time if possible, because tey will probably not bug us anymore in the future, the're interested and doing things right
2.b. This people just don't want to get along with technology, and it doesn't matter if you try to explaining how not to mess up in common tasks with apples and oranges (simple tast as prnting, email, etc), so they mess up again and again too and don't care.
3. There's people who FIRST TRY TO DO SOMETHING as esay as chehing if the printer doesnt print because maybe is disconnected from the computer, disconnected from the power, that the mouse is not working correctly because is dirty and they first clean it, that the email bouced back after sent because they wrote the adress wrong and many oher BEFORE asking any advice because they are conscience that it takes away our time, but at certain point, they ask you for an advice, Since you know that thi people try first, you know that they will pay alot of atention and what you will sggest and remember it the next time it happens again.
Whatever, it's tru that this is a dad horse yeah, but is not a 'matter of principle' only, it's very important when you get to know the people requesting help.
Everyone willing to tryly LEARS is wort our time and teaching wenever possible of course.
And about charging, tottaly agred when it comes to actual work, because it's work and we all studied to work in it as a way to sustain orserlves, besides, it's not ok to make people comfortable with getting things for free that's damage for them :)
by mikemerch1
With family and close friends I say if you are still running Win 98 I can no longer help you MS not longer maintains it. I will help you upgrade...
XP I will tell them first before I will even look at their PC. Update XP, Update Virus scanner and Anti Spware.Run them . Call me if they still have problems.
Friends of friends and the milkman's brother in law ...sorry
by coyotenm
I've found that where you work, that may gain you some goodwill--as long as everything you do works well, but not advancement. In fact, in some weird twist of logic, it may do the opposite. Your superiors will think you are a nice person, but somehow it says you are not management material. They aren't looking for nice. So if IT help is your way of doing good for the world, go for it. But it won't get you much in the way of promotions.
One exception: if you volunteer IT work for an organization, that's a great reference, a way to build professional contacts, and a great way for a beginner to get needed experience for a full IT job.
I am used to finding out answers myself BEFORE I ask for help. At least that way I am not dependent on others.
I help a person to be self-sufficient without the person isolating his/herself.
-swg
by framey
by master3bs
by pastwalker
by fehrle_sa
yeah, thats a stupid policy, making yourself look like an idiot to get out of helping someone. It's just silly.
Okay so my company has only 150 users, so I give out free advise more than some. But most often people come to me describing some problem they're having... I just say the same thing car mechanics tell drivers when they bring in their autos.
ie:
"My car is really sluggish. What could it be?"
"That problem could be caused by a number of different things."
And so it goes....
by htos1
by bcftw
by nttn
I am new to the .Net world, and the biggest problem I faced at the beginning was finding out how to get my hands on the learning material I needed to learn the basics.
I found this site by accident and have been telling all my friends about it, and they have thanked me for the advice.
Didn't cost me anything to give it, but the thank you reward was a great feeling.
Jerome
by wadeedward
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending