Discussion Locked

Seagate refuses to honor drive warranty

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have a Seagate Baracuda 120GB SATA drive that failed in early November. According to Seagate the drive was purchased by the distributor in Aug 2003, and we purchased it from the distributor Nov 26, 2003.
Seagate's website clearly states that certain models, this one included, and sold on or after June 28, 2003, are now covered by a 5 year warranty.
E-mails and faxes have gotten no response from Seagate. Direct phone calls result in "Duhhhhhh".
My distributor has taken the challange and is trying to resolve the matter because they agree with us that the drive is clearly in warranty.
This kind of treatment is usually an indication of a business in severe financial problems.
We have removed Seagate from our approved vendors list.

10 replies

by hal 9000

Seagate USA or Seagate International?

On every occasion where I've had to return a faulty drive I've just logged onto the Companies web site and gone to the RA section filled in the necessary fields been given an RA number and address and sent the drive away and had it replaced. Simple straight forward no problems.

However there is one downside the replacement drive doesn't have a warranty.

However because of the area that I work in faulty drives are not usually considered as viable for warranty as we loose control of the data on them and it is cheaper for us to destroy the drive than run the risk of the data getting loose and causing untold damage to the company. At the same time when we dispose of old computers they have the drives pulled and a new drive fitted and left blank. It is far cheaper to do this than run the risk of data theft.

Col

by bruceand

Yes, we've done this many times before, but when the serial number is entered it comes back out-of-warranty. Complained to tech support they advised me to fax copy of distributor's invoice to an individual in Seagate. We did this twice with no acknowledgement that it was ever received.
Phone call resulted in talking to someone who barely spoke english, and suggested we contact the distributor.
Data security is not one of our problems.
Thanks anyhow.

by hal 9000

Do exactly as MAX suggested.

I'll bet you get a satisfactory response very quickly.

Unless the drive had a Re-Manufactured sticker on it you should have the full 5 year warranty and Seagate should honor it without exception.

Col

by house

Media is a good way for Seagate to look bad in this business. Just the fact that you posted this threrad brings back a few concerns of my own about Seagate.

Keep the pressure on your distributor so that he knows you are serious. He has more contacts than you when it comes to an individual manufacturer. Your middle man does not want to lose his client (you), but might not follow through with an initial request.

Not honoring the warranty is a definite sign of financial issues, but this seems like a different case. In my point of view, the dist should honor your claim and fight it himself.

PS - If you ever get a hold of someone at Seagate, ask them why their drive utility is so fat with graphics that it takes up two 1.44 disks.

by bruceand

I know what you mean about Seagate's diagnostics. I also have had cases where the latest version wouldn't run and had to resort to last year's version. This year they also have "bin" version to make a self booting CD copy which is easier to use.
Both the Floppy and the CD versions have bugs.
However before I would trust either to test drives of other manufacturers I would run the manufacturer's own diagnostics first.

by maxwell edison

.
November 20, 2004

Mr. William Watkins
President, Chief Executive Officer and Director
Seagate Technologies
920 Disc Drive
Scotts Valley, California 95066

Dear Mr. Watkins,

I have a Seagate Baracuda 120GB SATA drive that failed in early November. According to Seagate records, my drive was purchased by the distributor in Aug 2003, and we purchased it from the distributor on November 26, 2003. Seagate's Web site clearly states that certain models, this one included, sold on or after June 28, 2003, are now covered by a 5 year warranty. After several attempts, Seagate refuses to honor the warranty and replace this faulty product.

You may or may not want to get personally involved in resolving my dispute, but will you please answer one question for me. Is there any reason why I should not buy Maxtor hard drives from now on?

Warmest Regards,

Signature here

Your name here
Your address here
Your phone number here.

by bruceand

Thanks for the information. Actually we did replace the defective drive with a new Maxtor unit, as this machine belongs to one of our customer's and I don't feel our problems with Seagate should become his problems too, and he needs his computer for his business.
Will send the letter to Seagate next week.
Thanks again.

by bfilmfan

I'd also check with the local consumer laws on warranties and see if you and the distributor could get their attention that way.

No company wants a state attorney on their case threatening nasty things like seizing all assets of organization and such...

by bruceand

Will wait to see if we hear from the CEO, then will go to consumer protection people both state and federal as well as warranty violation laws.
Lots of good advice, thanks.

by bruceand

Not sure which action prompted it, but I got a phone call from Seagate today with an RMA number to return the defective drive.
Unfortunately I was out of the office so didn't get to talk to the individual, but we can write finis to this current problem.
Thanks to all for your suggestions.

This discussion is closed to new replies.