Discussion Locked

Should government be allowed to regulate. . . . . . .

0 helpful
303 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

...... (fill in the blank)

Treat this like a Friday Night Music. In other words, post a new reply with a different [i]fill in the blank[/i] example, or comment on one already posted.

I illustrated with a few starter threads.

Post your [i]issue[/i], answer yes or no, and make your own comments on the issue. Be brief or go into detail, whichever is appropriate.

Let's see where it goes.

303 replies

by maxwell edison

That's a hot potato.

As it relates to air traffic control, government functions, national defense, the power grids, etc., I might say yes. But if we allow those things, what else do we [i]invite[/i] the government to regulate?

To the aforementioned (and similar) things, I say yes. To all else, I say no. How can both of those things happen at the same time?

by deadly ernest

The government should not have any say or regulatory control of the internet at all.

Sure, have government organisations using the net to chase down criminals involved in cyber attacks and other criminal activity over the physical network, but not the internet or the data or it's access.

Traffic control and other government functions should NOT be accessible via the internet, if they are it's because the organisation has NOT done it's job right in keeping such security required functions segregated from the internet. This should be a physical segregation, not an electronic one.

It's an indictment of governments and their organisations that people can use the internet to access such systems as the air traffic control system, the rail network, the road traffic control systems. They should NOT be on a system that's connected to the internet at all.

get the infrastructure controls out of the internet accessible network.

by maxwell edison

Is this a no-brainer, or what?

NO - NO - NO - NO - NO

It's the epitome of violating the First Amendment.

Do you disagree?

by maxwell edison

Is this a no-brainer, or what?

NO - NO - NO - NO - NO

It's the epitome of violating the First Amendment.

Do you disagree?

Yes, in case you're wondering, my previous newspaper example was a set-up for this one.

by deadly ernest

First, I'm extending this to any elected government and it's citizens.

As a general rule I agree - especially in regards to waged staff, the majority or workers.

I think the government should have a hand in regulating the pay of people who have an exceedingly large say in what they get paid. The government should be able to set a cap in such cases.

In this I'm thinking mostly of members of boards of directors and CEOs. In the majority of cases they get to decide the bulk of their salary package and the share holders, who technically have final say, rarely get a chance to object and reject the salary. This is especially so where the company started as a private firm and the original owner, or descendant, is now the CEO and still owns 51% of the shares. They can give themselves huge salaries, and often do, and the other share holders can't say a thing.

by maxwell edison

Why? And to what extent? And where does it stop?

Example: Government says, [i]"Ernest, you're salary should be capped at $$$"[/i]

If we (the government) can cap your CEO's salary, then we (the government) can cap yours.

by jdclyde

Other than in a dictatorship, I don't know of anything in a "free" nations laws that would allow anyone outside the company to have a say in what anyone inside the company makes.

We already have the misplaced intentions of minimum wage so Democrats can pretend to be doing something to help, which it doesn't.

by maxwell edison

.....suggest that YOU (through a government broker) can dictate what another person earns - CEO or otherwise.

If you try to justify for one, you try to justify for all.

by maxwell edison

My answer - a resounding NO, NO, NO, and NO FRIGGIN' WAY - exhaled or otherwise.

(You knew that would touch a nerve, didn't you?)

by dr dij

I'll just bring a fleet of 20 buses and park them surrounding Max's place, run them night and day,

Then build a couple unscrubbed coal plants upwind of Max's place. The chinese are building one new coal plant a week, and they don't have scrubbing like american plants.

maybe then you'll figure out is not a victimless crime.

instead is something that we have 'socialized' the right to spew gaseous crud into the atmosphere, and like we once thought the ocean was unlimited, the atmosphere likewise has limits to the cr*p we can spew into it and remain health as a race.

just to put into proportion, we now exceed 10% of the total atmospheric CO2 is added again each year by humans worldwide.

by Member 25348569

have farts that smell so bad that they can use them as a form of defensive weapon.

Not a lot of people know that.

by deadly ernest

already getting some schools to send kids home at lunch time if their lunch doesn't meet their healthy food requirements list. Some are even confiscating food they class as wrong for the children, I'd like to see them sued.

by maxwell edison

She's not a [i]white male[/i].

What would have happened if she was quoted as not being a [i]black male[/i]?

It's racism run amok, and it's being given a free pass.

by deadly ernest

"...regulating the pay of people who have an exceedingly large say in what they get paid."

The government regulates how much an owner can take out of an owner operate business, similar regulations should apply to incorporated businesses.

The key is who has the most say in the decision.

If I can say how much I get paid and I'm managing a business in which others have a strong vested interest (ie shareholders, partners) then there should be a control system to stop me robbing the business blind as has been happening with some CEO jobs for a couple of decades. If the business is big enough to warrant paying a million dollar salary to the CEO, then make it dependent upon performance and tie it to post tax revenue as a percentage, or something similar.

Too often do we see a business goes bust and some workers miss out on a several thousands of dollars of entitlements each, the shareholders lose their investment, yet the CEO has been banking a few million a year in salary while the business has been struggling and going down hill. A control system would stop that from happening.

I'd also like to see a system where the CEO on a huge salary can be forced to payout unpaid staff entitlements from their own savings where their salaries have been outrageously high in comparison to the rest of the staff.

BTW that was a quick response.

by deadly ernest

but it should be one to limit the CEO ripping off the shareholders and other staff simply because he has the power to make those decision. In a fully owner operated company it shouldn't apply as they can only rip themselves off, I speak of where they play with other people's money.

The point here is we are talking about people making decision on what they get paid by others. Often to the fiscal detriment of others.

Bonuses etc can be set in relation to performance. The best way would be to set a CEO wage as a percentage of post tax income, you may have the percentage vary with the company size a little to balance things out for the smaller companies.

But say you set the CEO salary of big business to 3% of post tax income. The business makes a profit of 100 million dollars and he gets three million, but if it makes a loss he gets zip. This would encourage the CEO to perform better and to notify quicker of adverse trading situations. At present we see many cases where the CEO gets paid millions while the companies make losses and go bust.

by deadly ernest

laws on company operations and industrial relations.

It's outright theft for a CEO to set his own salary at half a million or more while the company is struggling, yet many do. In these cases they're stealing from the shareholders and the employees as they usually don't alert the authorities to bad performance until it's too late to save the company, but after they've milked it dry. Yet this theft is legal at the moment.

by maxwell edison

..... that you charge so much for your services. What you charge isn't the point. But WE ALL get to decide what's too much.

Is that right?

by deadly ernest

he's playing with have a say. The current system encourages CEOs to delay reporting operating difficulties until it's so late the company can't be saved, yet while this is happening they still walk away with huge salaries, often leaving the company with insufficient money to pay out worker entitlements like owed leave etc.

The laws need to be amended to make them more responsive and responsible, but more importantly the CEOs and Board Members should NOT be in a position of setting their own pay; which is what currently happens.

by nicknielsen

He submits a compensation proposal to the Board of Directors for approval. Recently, though, as long as the stock price kept going up, the boards have essentially been rubber stamps for the CEO's proposals.

I see the problem as a combination of entitlement mentality and corporate incest, where the same group of individuals serves as directors in some companies and as executives at another. Both factors lead to a compensation [i]quid pro quo[/i], where the directors at company A set executive compensation at the level they wish to receive from their fellow director/executives.

Government has no business in business other than those regulations intended to protect the consumer from unsafe products or unethical business practices.

by deadly ernest

The point here is we are talking about people making decision on what they get paid by others. Often to the fiscal detriment of others.

Bonuses etc can be set in relation to performance. The best way would be to set a CEO wage as a percentage of post tax income, you may have the percentage vary with the company size a little to balance things out for the smaller companies.

But say you set the CEO salary of big business to 3% of post tax income. The business makes a profit of 100 million dollars and he gets three million, but if it makes a loss he gets zip. This would encourage the CEO to perform better and to notify quicker of adverse trading situations. At present we see many cases where the CEO gets paid millions while the companies make losses and go bust.

by maxwell edison

That corporations - or ANY business, for that matter - should operate outside the financial control of government.

YOUR VOTE SHOULD NOT dictate what a corporate CEO earns, or what ANYONE earns - PERIOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What a pompous and self-righteous attitude you're displaying. Get off your high-horse, and stop dictating to others how to live.

(I'm taking a break. Attitudes like yours just piss me off to no end.)

by deadly ernest

what they must pay him each year instead of asking them to nominate a figure?

It's all to do with who decides what happens with someone else's money. In every other situation the one who owns the money makes the final decision, but not with CEO salaries.

by deadly ernest

profit he can take from me as a share holder.

If he's worth the millions, let him set up an owner operated business and make it, or go buy all the other shares and make it all his.

by deadly ernest

Which I think it is. If the government has the right to interfere with all the other industrial relations and business laws placing controls on how people work etc, no reason to exempt this,

by maxwell edison

.....telling a CEO what to do?

I'm a [i]non-share holder[/i] in your life, Ernest. Now get on the ball and do what I TELL YOU to do.

by deadly ernest

I'd also like to see similar rules to control how the politicians' remunerations as well.

If the CEO sits down and negotiates a contract to which 75% or more of the share holders agree, then they've had a hand in the decision. But many companies are such the CEO sets his own salary and the shareholders only get to approve it without being able to object to it. This is especially true of annual raises etc.

It comes back to who make the decision as against who owns the money.

by dr dij

Ignore the problem and it might go away!

:)

My comment didn't predict doom and gloom, however you can see that changing the atmosphere 10% a year that might well happen.

My point is that capitalism includes valuing resources. That means taking care of them.

Instead, globally we treat the atmosphere as if no one owns it (socialism).

So, if it makes you happy, socialism is the cause of global warming? (answer tailord to make max happy, may not co-incide with actual reality, no facts of max's were checked in this answer because he normally ignores them, no warranty expressed or implied, your mileage may vary)

by maxwell edison

How about, ignore the fabricated problem and those advancing it might go away!

MM-GW-CC is a hoax, a scam, a lie, a con, a deceit, a farce, a racket, a fraud, a swindle..... anything but a problem. Those advancing it, however, therein lies the real problem.

by maxwell edison

..... the unjustifiable. And keep trying to explain the inexplicable. And keep painting yourself into a Marxist corner. (Although you'll never admit it - Marxist = Government control over business, as well as other things.)

Give it up, Ernest, and rephrase your entire argument.

In the meantime, I'm done. You've made your position quite clear.

I want nothing to do with either your argument or the high-horse on which it rides.

by deadly ernest

agree to disagree.

At the moment there are many corporate and industrial relations laws that control just about everything else.

If I run a private business the government has the right, under the corporate laws to review what I'm charging and make me reduce my profit margin if they think it's too excessive, despite me giving people the right to chose between paying me for my goods or not. How is their right to do that any different to putting a cap on CEO salaries?

The government puts all sorts of limitations on most corporations and workers through the industrial relations laws and corporations laws - how does this one aspect differ from them?

Hell, what gives the law makers any right to make laws on any industry they don't have any direct personal experience with?

Right and fairness doesn't come into most laws.

If the CEOs were acting ethically, they wouldn't be setting themselves such extremely high salaries to begin with.

by deadly ernest

instead of just setting physical and safety performance requirements and limits.

We've the ability to make safe cars out of composites but most laws on vehicles require various gauges of steel instead of setting minimum performance characteristics. The same with housing materials and other goods. The laws focus on the how and not the outcome.

Hell, over sixty percent of the heritage buildings around the world can not be legally constructed today as they do not meet the current laws on materials etc as most of the laws specify materials and not performance standards.

by deadly ernest

decider. The owner of the body should be making the decision, the owner of the money should be making the decision; and in advance in both cases.

I know you have a problem with seeing the ownership relationship at times, but that's the case.

by maxwell edison

....I presume to neither tell a person what to eat or how to live - or how to conduct his business. But you do - period.

It's a difference you can't possibly justify without the presumption of superiority over others. I make no presumption. You do.

It's called the underlying premise, Ernest. You should back-up and examine yours, decide what it is, and just let the chips fall where they may.

Your opinion of convenience or circumstance is a dog that just doesn't hunt, as far as I'm concerned. Define the underlying premise, Ernest, and just let the chips fall where they may - PERIOD. You may not like it, but that's a consequence of living in a free society.

by deadly ernest

to the shareholders months in advance of them knowing about. You accept all the other laws the government has about conducting business, including those that give the CEO the control over the company assets and the ability to dictate his salary.

I allow that if they have the right to dictate the other laws, then this is just as good an area to make laws. Either they can make them all or they should be making none of them. Once you step off the black and white and have a grey line, then where you go in the grey is all open for discussion. You accept most of the grey but not this part.

As I said, we'll have to agree to disagree.

by santeewelding

Or, Ernest and Max, race on into a relative wilderness.

My eye settled initially on just the one term of the proposition(s):

"Government".

May we all concede that what we carelessly call "government" has also shoved its own head up its ass? I know in California it has. They now ceaselessly rearrange pieces on the board without questioning the board.

I broached this once with Max. Max was unwilling. You, Ernest, I take to have raced further and irretrievably more than Max into the wilderness.

Probably -- for some of us -- it will take not words, but gunfire to upend the board.

by deadly ernest

with a major earthquake removing the state from existence.

As to bullets, I expect we shall see a lot flying around the world in the not too distant future due to some major culture clashes overflowing their boarders.

I personally don't think people should have control without ownership, but since we have some government laws allowing that in some places, then there should be laws to regulate the extent of the control.

by the scummy one

that an earthquake could be strong enough for that task :(

And I think the majority of people here are true dumba$$es, that would rebuild any damaged area exactly as it was :(

by maxwell edison

I'm a libertarian. I'm an individualist. I believe in the least amount of government control over the individual as possible. I believe (as Jefferson did) that the best government governs least. I realize that in a free society that some people will do things with which I disagree, but that's better than having a less-free society.

I believe these things, and regardless of the individual issue, I stand-pat on the underlying principle and just let the chips fall where they may.

Some people simply can't admit their own [i]underlying premise[/i]. Or, they can't tolerate the fact that others might disagree with them; they try to control others into their own way of thinking.

Bullets will indeed eventually fly when enough people have realized that too many of their freedoms have been taken away by those riding on a high-horse presuming to dictate how their lives should be lived.

Ernest is a smart guy, but he's an issues driven guy, not a principled driven guy. And he apparently can't tolerate that other people live in a way with which he disagrees - and he advocates FORCING them to comply to his preferred way of living.

I mean, really. Look at two or more dozen messages of his - he thinks CEOs make too much money and that government (him and his votes) should control them. How pompous is that?

P.S. Ernest has lost this debate. But he won't admit it. He's lost it because I've made it clear that the underlying premise on which his argument is based is not consistent with maintaining a free society. And he won't admit that he advocates a less-free society. If he admits that he advocates Marxism, which he won't do, then his argument is consistent with an underlying principle. Thus, he's painted himself into a corner.

by santeewelding

I was fly on the wall while Libertarian theoreticians wrangled and struggled with the notion of, "prisoner".

So far as I know, it goes unresolved. Principle doesn't hack it, in spite of their pie chart.

Something deeper swims here, which neither of you acknowledge.

by deadly ernest

without the blinkers. It's not the money they make, but the way they set it with other people's money and then rip other people off by not doing their job right.

All along I said the criteria is 'who has the say over the setting and who's money they're spending.' Then come show they run the company.

Two principles involved in this.

1. The government is already making laws that say how much people can earn and how businesses operate. So either they should have full say or get right off the playing field. Not exempt controls on the guys who give the government politicians the campaign money.

2. The people making the decision on the rate are not the people whose money's being spent. I believe that you need ownership before you have control, but this violates that rule.

You accept the government rules on everyone else, but not this one group and you deny the owners of the money the right to make the decision in advance by supporting the current process.

The core of the whole thing is the decision makers - who are they. If it's the CEOs and the Board, then there should be external controls as it's not their money.

by jdclyde

is increasing the speed at which we are heading over the cliff.

There is a run on ammunition at this moment. People see a huge crash coming, and when all the cultists of hope lose even that, it will turn to riot and theft.

by jardinier

Is that I serious prediction jd? I ask because the American Christians at the website to which I post are very much pro-gun and predict that America is, as you say, "heading over the cliff."

Many strongly believe that the "end times" are nigh.

They know that I also post to TR and so I would like to hear the opinions of Americans who are not necessarily strongly aligned with any religious group.

by deadly ernest

What I find funny about this is I'm usually accused of being a rapid right wing extremist in favour of big business and against the unions. This is the first time I've been accused of being a socialist. The whole socialist agenda fails once you get above a community of a few hundred, but can be made to work wonders below that level.

I believe in getting value for measure and ownership equals control. I'm against any uncontrolled ownership, but if you must have it, then it should be regulated.

Anyway, the weather is outside of all our control, at the moment.

by jardinier

In an exhaustive discussion at meetchristians.com no Scriptural evidence could be found to support the notion that monogamy was a requirement for either Jews or Christians.

Hence by making monogamy a civil law, the Government went against Biblical teaching.

However we are so conditioned to accept that monogamy is a religious rather than a civil law, that bigamy or polygamy have become "dirty" words.

King Solomon who is noted for his wisdom had 700 official wives and 300 concubines. God was cranky with him not because of the number of wives and concubines he had, but because he turned to the pagan religions followed by these women.

If three (insert any number) women are happy to share me, and I can afford to keep them and any progeny that might result, what right has the government telling me that I have behaved unlawfully?

by maxwell edison

Other than defining, what I might call, [i]a national age of emancipation[/i] - an age at which people are legally responsible for themselves and can make all personal decisions for themselves - my answer to your question would be no.

P.S. Any anyone who wants three wives, gets exactly what he deserves - including financially supporting any and all children that come from it.

by deadly ernest

than they do any other business contract. From a civil perspective marriage is a business contract and the government should deal with it as such. Leave the religious aspects to the churches and outside of the laws.

The current mainstream Christian churches practice many doctrine that have no support in the Bible or Tora. they came into being as part of the Church hierarchy efforts to control the people from about the 4th century through to the middle ages. Monogamy is one such aspect, just like celibacy and non marriage for priests and nuns.

by deadly ernest

the government should have either no involvement at all or be fully involved, not a three quarter way place that exempts the CEOs who hand them campaign funds.

Either remove all the restrictions they have on the others and get off the field, or finish the job properly; not another half arsed measure.

by jdclyde

If to aggressively file fraud charges against a CEO that intentionally misleads the share holders.

As for what is paid out and to who, you make it sound like the CEO decides to write himself a huge check and no one can say anything about it, and most wouldn't even know? Not quite how it works.

by nicknielsen

[i]...10% of the total atmospheric CO2 is added again each year by humans worldwide.[/i]

Really? Somehow I doubt that. What's your source?

edit: runaway [i]italics[/i]

by jdclyde

One, Obama is taking us towards major financial ruin. He can't just keep printing and borrowing money to continue to buy support.

He is going to be raising our costs everywhere he can, the last thing any intellegent person would suggest during a slow economy while people are hurting. From the time he declared war on Petroleum our fuel prices have shot up about $.60 per gallon.

I know of a couple places that are hiring now. It seems the black techs that worked there quit because they think Obama is going to "take care of them".

While I don't see a revolution, I do see riots in the streets again.

I also know of neighbors making pacts. If mobs come in and go for one or the other, there will be a crossfire to take care of the problem.

I fully expect things to get ugly, but hopefully only in places that deserve it, like New York and California.

And no, this has nothing to do with religion.

by santeewelding

That we could see.

Meantime, there are importances, like the boys.

Conduct yourself in and by the highest, so that those boys may see what I see.

by jdclyde

I am more mature around the boys. Well, "some" is probably a better word, as I am not at all here.... :D

Lead by example.

Boys are 17 and have [b]never[/b] seen me toasted.

Have always stressed responsible firearm ownership/usage.

Have always stressed personal responsibility.

by jardinier

for confirming the comments that have been made at the Christian website about what Obama is doing.

No, it has nothing to do with religion. If you inferred that from my post, I apologize if I gave a wrong impression.

by jdclyde

So I wanted to make sure it was understood it is not a Christian movement.

Did you hear about the "Tea Parties" a month back? People that are a part of the CultObama try to push it off as just a few greedy racist Republicans, but in reality it was hundreds of thousands of people from all political and ethnical backgrounds.

by jamesrl

I very much think the government has a role in protecting its citizens from air pollution. Air pollution from cars and factories does negatively impact people's health, but individually there isn't much we can do, so it is in my humble opinon something the government can and should regulate. On of the problems though is that air and water don't know about boundaries, so the government of Canada and Ontario can only try to moderate the 50% of air pollution that comes from Canada, but the 50% from the US requires our government to try and influence the US and thats not so easy.

I would see clean air as part of "Life" in terms of a right.

James

by maxwell edison

..... and a shame that our U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that our EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) can indeed classify CO2 a pollutant.

[i]"I think this is one of the most important environmental decisions in the past quarter-century," said Norman Dean, executive director of Friends of the Earth, one of the original plaintiffs in the suit.[/i]

Silly me. I always thought our Supreme Court was created to rule on the constitutionality of issues, not to decide what may or may not be a pollutant.

This is what people mean when they refer to an [i]activist Supreme Court[/i].

Liberal Justices, Stevens, Souter, Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kennedy voted to overstep the court's intended boundary, and they transformed themselves from lawyers and judges to play scientists and activists for a day.

Conservative Justices, Scalia, Thomas, and Alito, as well as Chief Justice John Roberts, respected the constitutional limits placed on the Court and dissented.

[i]"Aside from a single conclusory statement, there is nothing in petitioners' 43 standing declarations and accompanying exhibits to support an inference of actual loss of Massachusetts coastal land from 20th century global sea level increases," writes Chief Justice John Roberts in his dissent. "It is pure conjecture."[/i]

Activist Court indeed!

http://judicialnetwork.com/cgi-data/in_the_news/files/160.shtml

by santeewelding

As how the chasm would be so big that it would suck so much ocean in that Australia would be dragged next to California. Their government could help with our budgetary problems.

by deadly ernest

you can kill a house and one in ten is equal to near total destruction. My older print edition of the normal webster doesn't recognise the term. So I wonder where they got it from, along with the historical reference.

next you'll tell me they recognise ethician.

by Member 25348569

Probably not jd, either...

If you put in an NT and we're reading it with "Print/View all posts", the joke doesn't work!

by gadgetgirl

let me play.

This is all I can play with.....

:0 ;)

And I KNOW you didn't mean jd or Santee.... :p

:x

GG

by jdclyde

he seems to think government SHOULD be regulating business contracts. Didn't you hear about the punitive tax Democrats put in place to stop the bonuses they knew about months in advance?

Or how The Obama is dictating to GM how to run their business?

Thanks to Liberals, government is taking MORE control of our lives, not less.