Discussion Locked

Should government be allowed to regulate. . . . . . .

0 helpful
303 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

303 replies

by tonythetiger

THEN they can also do (that).

Nowadays it seems that a lot of people vote to ban something simply in the hopes of making other people as miserable as they are. They can't control what's important to them in their own sorry lives, so they'll damned well control something in someone else's. In other words, misery loves company!

Most of laws now in existence are the result of control freaks banding together to "out-regulate" each others behaviors. Back and forth and back and forth. "They" take "this" away from "us", so next time "we" retaliate by taking "that" away from "them". Back and forth and back and forth and pretty soon nobody will be able to do anything... and nobody will be able to be happy.

People REALLY need to read some history. Read about past democracies and [b]why they failed![/b] Take a long hard look in THAT mirror! Try to understand something past your miserable little selves. As I've said before, the constitution is to protect US from the government. It wasn't intended to be a bludgeon to beat each other over the head with!

by tonythetiger

more often than not... but nearly always for different reasons. It's frustrating to see them lose... not because their cause is wrong... but because their argument is...

I'm not sure [b]the[/b] end is nigh, but I'm pretty sure [b]an[/b] end is. And end to what? I don't know yet... but whatever it is, I'm pretty sure violence will be involved.

by jdclyde

the places Christians "lose" the most are typically turned into shitholes that spiral downward quickly. Think NY city before Giuliani cracked down on decadence.

There is a need for restraint, though. Don't want to turn into the town in "Footloose", ya know.... ;\

by tonythetiger

People arguing that a student should be allowed to say a prayer at school graduation is because the community is overwhelmingly Christian...

Yes, a student (who is scheduled to speak at graduation) SHOULD be allowed to offer a prayer, but no, not because the community is Christian, because the student has freedom of speech!

And no, the government does not have to offer "equal time" to other faiths... the student speaker wasn't selected because of his faith, he was selected because of his academic achievements, and if that student had been Muslim, or Wiccan, or Atheist,I would back his free speech rights to say a prayer of his choosing!)

Too often this "wrong argument" torpedoes good intentions... to EVERYONE'S detriment, in my opinion.

by delbertpgh

Seems like great grounds for regulation.

How about requiring that fat, vitamin, and calorie content be posted on food? Lets the consumer know what he's getting, lets him make informed choices more easily. You could say that the consumer gains freedom of action by these intricate labeling mechanisms. Anybody interested in promoting that kind of freedom, which trespasses on the freedom and self-interest of the food manufacturers?

by jamesrl

I am all for the government having regulations to ensure food safety, particularly in areas like meat. One of the cleanest meat processors in the country just had an outbreak that killed 40 people. Smilarly the was the peanut plant in Georgia that caused hundreds to get sick.

I know the courts exist and that we could sue, but frankly a lawsuit is cold comfort, and money doesn't bring a loved one back.

I'm not though for banning of food, or rezoning or whatever. I don't mind school boards taking pop/soda out of the vending machines, if that is the school board's choice. But if you want to stop your kids from having junk food, you have to teach them, cause they can find junk food at every corner store.

And I think junk food in moderation is ok.

James

by delbertpgh

Sure. Insurance companies can make payout terms so restrictive that insuring somebody's life, health, or property is scarcely different from theft.

And don't even get me started on the credit card business, or the banking industry, or any industry that concentrates money and makes loans.

by tonythetiger

people had a bad experience with something, so they gang up and vote to ban it, or restrict it so heavily that it's all but useless for most people, when all they would have had to do is to avoid the thing they want to ban.

People put themselves in other people's business way too much. I'd like to see a law where any proposed law be required to go through testing to see if it could conceivably interfere with anyone's personal liberty, and if so whether a legitimate government interest is served by violating that person's liberty, and if so does that government interest OVERRIDE the liberty interest... and do this BEFORE enacting the law!

by delbertpgh

Once in a while, the country's bankers and financiers stop being stolid, conservative, fussy accounting types, and go wild. In this latest turn, they took the whole world economic system over a cliff, and it's costing us a trillion dollars to keep ourselves out of a depression.

Banks and major lending institutions that work like banks (insurance companies, brokers, hedge funds) manage our savings and pipe money to borrowers who can use it profitably, and make the economy grow. When banks get unprofitable they stop lending, and when lending stops millions go out of work. Banking is a business, but it's not like manufacturing or freight. When the banks are screwed, everybody suffers.

You don't want government running the banks, for sure. But you don't want fools and scoundrels turning the national economy into a private casino, rigged in their favor. It's an arena where you don't want government telling business what to do, but you definitely need it to tell business what NOT to do. It needs proper regulation.

by notsochiguy

...that's almost as bad as waiting outside a Nymphomaniacs Anonymous meeting with a bouquet of flowers and box of chocolates and shouting "who's tonight's lucky winner" when the meeting concludes!!!

]:)

by deadly ernest

I won' t say much, except my son calls her 'a dumb super bitch' now that he' s finally got out from under her thumb, and refuses to answer her phone calls. She' s very controlling. Walked out in Feb 1994, divorced 16 July 1995 (her birthday), and still calls trying to tell me what to do.

by jdclyde

A weight watchers meeting, yelling "I have fudge! Hershies chocolate kisses!" :D

by jack8beans2

Yeah - it is crazy - we want regulation, but it sucks when they get too involved. Yikes 0 it's kind of a double edged sword.

by gadgetgirl

Healing. Mostly done, but left with a few permanent reminders. Won't be able to "cut loose" as much as I'd have liked to, but you know fine well, I'll make the most of my trip!

STILL on with paperwork thanks to the cops tardiness and lack of follow up. I have more than enough to sink a battleship, and I still ain't getting anywhere!!

Still wish you were going, babz.... :(

:x

GG

by notsochiguy

At a former employer, they were trying to setup a weight watchers meeting. They were meeting in the cafeteria.

They were running some sort of contest/campaign to get people to join. As I walked past them, they tried to get me to join.

I said something along the lines that if I joined, I'd win the competition, and they'd all have to average more points than Michael Jordan to keep pace.

Sufficed to say, they were not amused.

Honestly, I didn't know it was like golf, where the lower the score, the better.

OOPSY!!! ;)

by jdclyde

Simple regulations like not allowing the withholding of information from investors or lying to them, is a good thing.

The "poor me" group is also a part of "we". it isn't fair that people who work hard have so much, while they sit around, drinking cheap beer, watching Opra, doing a whole lot of nothing useful.

by jdclyde

that political agenda opened the door to this, and turned into a license to thrill after that?

If the government would not have gotten into the "house for everyone" business, the lending practices would have stayed on the business smart side because "the government" wasn't agreeing to back up all the risky loans.

by nicknielsen

From what I understand the trading in essentially valueless paper (mortgage derivatives) was a strong contributor. Had those derivatives not existed, only the holders of the defaulted mortgages would have been in trouble. The derivatives (and greed) spread the loss across the entire financial sector.

by jdclyde

that pulled the rug out, as there WAS value to that point.

Think of the politics causing bad business decisions as the first domino.

by delbertpgh

The idea of spreading home ownership among the poor, and thus raising their expectations and improving their behavior, had appeal not only to liberals but conservatives as well. But the dollar value of dubious loans extended under governmental protection wasn't nearly enough to explain the mess that we got into.

Home values just kept rising and rising, 7% to 20% per year, and bankers found that if they just believed values would rise continuously and forever, then they could loan any amount of money to anybody with or without proof of employment, and keep raking in fees for placing and securitizing the loans. And that's just what they did. Other bankers found they could insure the bonds against default, and in the "rational" expectation that there would be no problem of default, they insured a trillion bucks for chump change, and called it all free money.

Bankers behaved like children who chased mom & dad out of the house, smoked crack, and went apesh|t. That explains the credit crisis, and not some pleasing little fable about government making them do it.

by jdclyde

The table was set for them, the rules had been thrown away, and it became a feeding frenzy.

Irresponsible to ignore the fault of politicians and social agendas that started the whole thing. And then when it was clear we were heading for disaster, politicians again stopped anything from being done until after the crash, and then the blame game started. Throw all the bums out.

by delbertpgh

Who can say what a house is really worth? You have to weigh its value against everything else you can do with your income and your savings. Somewhere, where you find a rational balance, you have a "real" value. The deal with a bubble is, when you know you are paying too much for it, you believe you can sell it off and make a profit (or refinance the loan) when the value rises in 18 months or so. This bubble got so crappy because the Fed and the Chinese and the Arabs and everybody else made dollars available real estate loans, and the banks made it easy to channel the money to the borrowers, all in the name of making fat fees. So long as values rose without end, nobody would lose, and everybody would gain.

Here's a little cartoon showing how it actually worked.
http://docs.google.com/TeamPresent?revision=_latest&fs=true&docID=ddv7hj34_03774hsc7&skipauth=true

by evilkillerwhale

CEO's can be fired. If they aren't doing a good job, they are gotten rid of. The government should keep it's fat nose out of my business. Shareholders can sell their stock if they don't like the way a company works. That's capitalism. Stay over in Australia where you're required to vote. What a stupid system

by evilkillerwhale

has a friggin' clue how much is actually spit out by humans. No one knows how it will affect the Earth. That's the entire idea of the butterfly effect. The system is just too big to model. The latest band wagon is global cooling (as it was back in the 1970's).

Furthermore: The US stopping it's pollution does NOT stop other countries. Other countries, on the other hand, take our resources. So isn't it better for us to take certain resources in the name of the environment? The oil deposit off the coast of Florida that environmentalists 'saved' is now being drilled by the Chinese. And their systems are not NEARLY as advanced as ours, nor can they handle spills. Nice save, idiots.

by delbertpgh

As much as I love banking, and as much as I love investment management, I have not refused to acknowledge that bankers can be greedy dodos.

They don't need to be "enabled" by bad examples set forth by government. All you have to do is slip the reins, and their horses go charging.

I guess that repealing regulatory structures is enabling. But it's not what you meant by the term.

by maxwell edison

..... throw around can be proven, nor can they withstand being scrutinized. It's all based on faith, someone else's [i]word[/i], or flawed and incomplete computer models.

[i]Prove it[/i] is something they've never done - over the past 25 years - nor will they ever be able to do. You should read Al Gore's 1980s book, [i]Earth in the Balance[/i]. It makes Star Trek look like reality TV.

A new slogan for the MM-GW-CC zealots should be, [i]Don't let the facts cloud the agenda.

by Member 25348569

For a given value of "proof". If you demand "absolute proof" then then you are being deliberately naive.

We have long passed the point where any intelligent person can examine the evidence and fail to come to the conclusion that the climate is changing, that we are the cause of a significant part of that change, that ecosystems have a limited capacity to adapt to climate change and that reducing the rate of that change is the most important thing that we can do.

Neil :)

Please, enlighten me on which particular computer models are "flawed" - and how?

As for "Earth in the Balance", a quote...

To warn of the dangers is not to despair of the solutions. Most of all, this book is a call to action and hope. Whether our purpose is to preserve the simple pleasure of fishing in a mountain stream on an autumn morning or the simple security of knowing that our children's drinking water is safe - to save an endangered species, an endangered wilderness, or an endangered earth - we have it in our power to restore the earth's balance before the growing imbalance inflicts its greatest potential damage on our children and grandchildren. Today the human species is the only one with the self-knowledge and the capacity to protect its own future.

You really, REALLY need to put aside your prejudice.

by dr dij

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co2

most of these can be verified elsewhere but it is a good quick summary.

CO2 has been at 280-300ppm for last 10,000 years. is now 387ppm.

we are emitting 27 to 35 gigatons a year, increasing to 39gigatons in a few years.

nature cycles 220 gigatons into and out of atmosphere a year.

This is another source of imbalance and warming, mainly because, since the start of the industrial age, many of those gigatons would have been absorbed by forests. BUt 50% of the world's forest had been cut down since even early in the industrial age.

The 30 gigatons a year is 1% of the amount in the atmosphere, 3 teratons (3,000 gigatons)

(sorry, my previous post did say 10%, that is wrong, the amount is not)

so in the last 50 years we have emitted close to 50% of the total 3 teratons in the atmosphere, exacerbated by cutting down forests and jungles that would have absorbed much of the excess and contributed even more not included in this total.

by tonythetiger

[i]I think the government should have a hand in regulating the pay of people who have an exceedingly large say in what they get paid. The government should be able to set a cap in such cases.[/i]

that anyone else doesn't have? (with the exception of Congress, of course)

by jamesrl

And one of the rules is: The more you are paid, the more is expected of you, and the more your performance is monitored.

James

by jdclyde

so Politicians removing the restrictions and later preventing oversight being put back in, had NOTHING to do with all this.

Whatever. Toe that line.....

The bankers were enabled, and nothing was done to stop the train from going off the cliff despite having YEARS warning. See ya at the bottom of the cliff.

Now, thanks to The Obama, we not only have major deficit but national debt we will never get out from under.

by delbertpgh

Presidents Reagan, Clinton, and the second Bush all worked to loosen or repeal banking regulations. The political "social agenda" that led to the disaster was the one of government is the problem, not the solution. Guess we know now how well that philosophy works, at least with respect to big-time finance.

In fairness to the lame brain politicians who let it all happen to us, it's unlikely that American voters would have let the politicians get away with fixing the approaching problem. It would have meant trying to drive down house prices and making money harder to borrow. In a democracy, the nurse who delivers bitter medicine gets voted out of a job.

The deficits will take us 20 years to work off, as did the deficits of World War 2. However, the alternative to the crazy spending we have done would be a depression, a dozen years of 15% unemployment, or worse. Like the last one. Come to think of it, it was only the crazy deficit spending of World War 2 that got us out of that last depression.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Intent is virtually unprovable. Remarkably, intent supposedly to the contrary, the minimum isn't livable.

This is not to say that I think government should regulate wages, at the high or low end.

by maxwell edison

[i]Enablers, dependents, and codependents[/i] - that defines America today.

How about 90 percent of American Social Programs - which accounts for close to 50 percent of the federal budget? ENABLERS, DEPENDENTS, and CODEPENDENTS!

Enablers, indeed!

DOWN WITH THEM ALL!

I would support an immediately and permanent discontinuation of ALL government programs that create or support [i]enablers, dependents, and codependents[/i] - corporate, personal, or otherwise.

Do you agree or disagree, and why?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]I wonder what will happen to the national debt when the nation no longer exists.[/i]

I think it will belong to China.

by maxwell edison

.....it's an unsecured loan - so they'll get left holding an empty bag.

What are they gonna' do? Repossess California? (One could only hope!)

by jdclyde

and GIVE California away. After all, wouldn't want to hurt anyones feelings in this nation of muslums, as he put it. And with his nominee that thinks a Latina woman can make better decisions than white men, who knows how low he can take the country?

by delbertpgh

"How about 90 percent of American Social Programs - which accounts for close to 50 percent of the federal budget? ENABLERS, DEPENDENTS, and CODEPENDENTS!" That 90 percent includes payments to the elderly, government retirees, veterans, and the disabled; as well as medical programs for the elderly and poor. The whole if-theyre-broke-let-em-suffer rationale doesn't appeal to me. It misses justice. There's more to justice than one taxpayer getting to keep every cent that comes his way.

Looks like we'll never agree on that.

by maxwell edison

.....the clause in the constitution that grants government to power to distribute tax dollars for the purpose of charity. If you can find it, I'll concede that it really is a role of government.

And since when is [i]justice[/i] defined by taking dollars from those who earn them, and distributing those dollars to those who didn't earn them?

by tonythetiger

[i]The whole if-theyre-broke-let-em-suffer rationale doesn't appeal to me.[/i]

You have every right to do something about that... with YOUR earnings...

[i]It misses justice.[/i]

What is just about taking my earnings away from me against my will?

What principle obligates me to support someone else who I had no input into determining their existence? (and if there is such a principle, what obligates me to a greater or lesser extent than another who is supposed to be "equal in the eyes of the law"? In other words, if we're all supposed to be treated equally, shouldn't our tax bills be equal?)

Is it just because I was (accidentally... I certainly had no choice in the matter) born here? Was there a contract I signed? What?

by delbertpgh

Max:

The preamble of the Constitution includes the text, "in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity". The preamble, in its scholarly 18th-century mode of writing, lays out the reasons we bothered to get together and establish a union and a government, in addition to the restrictions and powers it enumerates later. Purposes, prohibitions, and powers are all of a flexible but unitary piece. The Constitution also presumes that most of life goes on beyond its reach, and outside the scope of any law: ?civil society,? and the Constitution must live in service to that society?s needs and ideals.

Since America and the problems of life and government have been transformed by the past 200 years, the Constitution has to be interpreted over and over to keep it relevant and to allow the government to actually function. It is not in the character of America or its establishing document to prohibit policies of government, when they would promote freedom, stability, and prosperity. Look at regulation of the radio spectrum: is this in any way imagined by the framers of the Constitution, and apart from the preamble, does it even metaphorically allocate any powers to deal with it? Nope. But we'd be a country that missed the opportunity to make use of cell phones, broadcast entertainment, military radar, and GPS if freedom to exploit the radio spectrum were not taken away from the inventors, entrepreneurs, and crazy coots, American citizens all, who would otherwise dominate it. The freedom, and the wealth, we gained from its regulation outweighs the rights lost by its original proprietors.

There are a few reasons why justice commands that the Federal government collect money from some citizens and spend it, in part, for the benefit of others. One is practical: ends could not be served by the individual states. If a retirement benefit (Social Security) were to be funded and distributed by the states, then the states with the lowest taxation and least ability to pay out would capture the economic activity, while the states that paid the best benefits would get all the retirees. Another practical reason: people would be at the point of revolt if a wealthy society used them for a lifetime or until they were unable to work, and then said, ?you go die, or live like a rat until you die, because unless you?re earning you?re not worth anything.? You?d have to set up machine guns in the streets to enforce an Ayn Rand social ethic. People won?t tolerate destitution leading to death when they?re surrounded everywhere by wealth, comfort, and amusement. If you don?t want to spend your life in armed suppression of your own population, you do what needs done to insure domestic tranquility.

There?s another call to justice in redistribution. Society consists of a lot of layers and classes, and people who fall into them tend to get stuck there. Their kids tend to stay there, too. A free economy is also free to set a value to their compensation, which can rise or fall. (Lately the lower classes have seen more fall than rise.) In general terms, wealth is freedom, and poverty is prison. If these persons are to have their freedom largely determined by a market system, they need some relent from its consequences, so that they or their kids can otherwise experience some opportunity.

And, here?s the last call for justice. Suppose you make $100,000 per year as a programmer. Maybe you make more or less, but it?s not an unreasonable amount. You don?t make this all on your own, though. There?s a network of economic activity that makes your swell income a possibility. That means that when you do great, you do so in part because of the contributions of lots of others, some richer than you, and many poorer. They are owed a measure of the freedom that American society promises every naked infant can grow to enjoy, and you owe it, because in part you earn yours out of their sweat.

Del

by tonythetiger

[i]That means that when you do great, you do so in part because of the contributions of lots of others, some richer than you, and many poorer. They are owed a measure of the freedom that American society promises every naked infant can grow to enjoy, and you owe it, because in part you earn yours out of their sweat.[/i]

And it is because of them that there is even a market for my sweat... it's called opportunity... and if I do not make the effort to take it when it is offered, I do not have a rightful claim on its rewards.

When people have the right to place burdens on others without consequence, the downfall begins.

by maxwell edison

..... interpretation of the constitution, and in finding ways and words to justify your desired end conclusion by changing those powers truly enumerated within, and ignoring what it's really intended to protect.

Personally, I would rather rely on the words of James Madison, considered to be the father of the Constitution.

Taken from various Madison writings:

[i]I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on the objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.

If Congress can employ money indefinitely to the general welfare, and are the sole and supreme judges of the general welfare, they may take the care of religion into their own hands; they may appoint teachers in every State, county and parish and pay them out of their public treasury; they may take into their own hands the education of children, establishing in like manner schools throughout the Union; they may assume the provision of the poor; they may undertake the regulation of all roads other than post-roads; in short, everything, from the highest object of state legislation down to the most minute object of police, would be thrown under the power of Congress.... Were the power of Congress to be established in the latitude contended for, it would subvert the very foundations, and transmute the very nature of the limited Government established by the people of America.

With respect to the words general welfare, I have always regarded them as qualified by the detail of powers connected with them. To take them in a literal and unlimited sense would be a metamorphosis of the Constitution into a character which there is a host of proofs was not contemplated by its creators.

Wherever the real power in a Government lies, there is the danger of oppression. In our Governments the real power lies in the majority of the community, and the invasion of private rights is chiefly to be apprehended, not from acts of Government contrary to the sense of its constituents, but from acts in which the Government is the mere instrument of the major number of the Constituents.[/i]

I don't disagree, Delbert, that there's financial injustice in our nation; and that, just perhaps, the people who earn the most have an obligation to care for those who cannot care for themselves; and that those higher on the financial ladder can help those on lower rungs. What I do disagree with, however, is trampling on the Constitution and its intended purpose of protecting - and guaranteeing - the principle of individual liberty in order to do it.

Government does not provide the only solutions to the problems you describe. Turning to government is not the best solution to the problems you describe. In fact, it's probably the worst solution - especially considering the inevitable long-term disastrous outcome. All governments that tried to provide for all the social needs and wants of its citizens have eventually collapsed under the weight of its own obligations, and the United States will become the next victim.

Not only does the redistributionist agenda violate the true underlying purpose of the constitution - which is to guarantee and protect individual liberty - but it will lead to the downfall of a great nation.

You, Delbert, are killing the proverbial goose that laid the golden egg because it doesn't lay enough eggs to be redistributed in the manner you think necessary and appropriate. Redistributionists are killing our country, and James Madison would surely disapprove.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]And with his nominee that thinks a Latina woman can make better decisions than white men, who knows how low he can take the country?[/i]

The last 50 years or so, at least, white men been making crapass decisions.
Down, boy.

by jdclyde

And that fact that she has a latina vagina enables her to make better decisions than a white man? Please tell me you are joking.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Miss the point much?

[i]And with his nominee that thinks a Latina woman can make better decisions than white men, who knows how low he can take the country?[/i]

[i]And that fact that she has a latina vagina enables her to make better decisions than a white man?[/i]

Two in a row. Sexist, and bigoted. Because she's female, and Latina, she's incapable of making better decisions than have been made by white men bearing p3ck3rs? Or at least decisions that are equally as bad?

Call her on her record, not her sex or ethnicity. I think way better of you than that...

edit: P3ck3rs doesn't make it past the filters? What about pickle p3ck3rs? :0

by delbertpgh

I am not a "redistributionist"; I don't think everybody ought to equally enjoy the benefits of our common enterprise. I believe in differential outcomes, and differential compensation. I think there are people who are more valuable to society than I am, who make intelligent gambles with their wealth, and I think they ought to be paid a lot more than I am. But I am a pragmatist, and I know that our society would be a lot more cruel and ugly, a lot more dangerous, and a lot less rich if we let the market and misfortune be the sole determiners of how low the poor would sink.

I'm not driven by compassion, but there is an element of that in there, too. I'm also pretty cynical about a lot of things: I don't believe the poor are often susceptible to "improvement"; I think that the poor are usually where they are because they don't have the studiousness, work ethic, or the patience to do better; I don't think there is enough human charity to match the job that tax dollars and bureaucrats are doing; I don't think that society would work well without the poor around to do the jobs they do; and I don't believe the labor of the poor is worth much more than they're typically paid. I'm not impressed with the great bulk of the poor.

Here's a little fable of redistribution for you: a man has a knack for organization and getting people to trust him, borrows money to open a factory, gets hundreds of Americans to work for him, sells lots of things to other Americans, and every year puts millions of dollars in his personal pockets until he sells the business to a group of American investors for a $50 million profit. Now, be honest: did he work 100 times harder than his employess who were paid 100 times less? Did he make 100 times more things with his hands? No; he didn't; he made money because he could organize the labor of others to make things that would cause dollars to jump out of consumers' products, and kept the profits for himself; and he was the beneficiary of a system of incorporation and ownership and transferrability of property rights, enforcable by government courts, police, and offices, that facilitated the sale of the company he founded. Capitalism is a system of redistribution. So, redistribution by itself is not a sin.

Here's another fable of redistribution: my dearest old friend died recently of a brain tumor. She worked diligently as a newspaper reporter, paying her own way at age 80, until the tumor announced itself by destroying her ability to find words (aphasia,) and she passed away five months later, a total physical cripple. She stayed with friends the first couple months, but then her deterioration became so profound that she could only be cared for in an institution. She spent her final 80 days in a hospice, where the rooms were beautiful and clean, the staff was generous and respectful, and the ending of life was more bearable than it would have been if she were stuffed into a cot in a urine-stinking hallway in a charity nursing home. What made the difference? Maxwell Edison, J.D., and Tony did, with their contributions to Medicare and Medicaid, which met the bills. I'm glad you were there for us. I loved her like a mother. Thanks, boys.

by Member 25348569

Isn't it awfully nice to have a penis?
Isn't it frightfully good to have a dong?
It's swell to have a stiffy,
It's divine to own a dick.
From the tiniest little tadger
To the world's biggest prick!
So three cheers for your willy or John Thomas.
Hooray for your one-eyed trousers snake.
Your piece of pork, your wife's best friend,
Your Percy or your cock.
You can wrap it up in ribbons,
You can slip it in your sock.
Just don't take it out in public,
Or they will put you in the dock
...And you won't
come
back.

Hmm... Failed on only one. You should be OK from here on, Boxie.

Neil :)

Provided free of charge by NITS(tm) because the combination of Python and Pubic Service was too good to miss.

by delbertpgh

Not everybody who finds himself poor started out on a route of stupid or careless behavior.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20090604/hl_nm/us_healthcare_bankruptcy
(In case you don't want to click the link, the article begins, "(Reuters) ? Medical bills are behind more than 60 percent of U.S. personal bankruptcies, U.S. researchers reported on Thursday in a report they said demonstrates that healthcare reform is on the wrong track.
More than 75 percent of these bankrupt families had health insurance but still were overwhelmed by their medical debts, the team at Harvard Law School, Harvard Medical School and Ohio University reported in the American Journal of Medicine.")

Also, although I can't find articles on the specific point right now, I have read that a significant percentage of people who take early retirement do so because of disability. Suddenly becoming unable to work often wrecks plans for getting finances into shape for retirement, and leaves the retired person with extra obligations and on the brink of insolvency.

by maxwell edison

In my opinion, we surpassed [i]a measure of redistribution[/i] a long time ago - and about 10 trillion dollars ago.

Without the anecdotes intended to get a person's emotion to trump his reason, how would you define your [i]measure of redistribution[/i]? What percent of the federal budget, for example, do you believe should be redistribution dollars? Or as a percentage of the GDP? Or in percentages of population? Or anything at all to show that you actually do believe it should be [i]a measure[/i], and not a bottomless trough. Define your [i]measure[/i].

By the way, did you know that from the end of the Civil War all the way to the 1960s, the percentage of Americans living [i]in poverty[/i] declined each and every decade (with the exception of the Great Depression decade)? It would appear that when the [i]War on Poverty[/i] started, the downward trend ended. Why do you think that is? (If I were a conspiracy theorist, I might think it was an intentional ploy to keep a certain segment of the population IN poverty.)

Some other thought-provoking questions:

When did medical costs really begin to skyrocket? The answer is, when people other than the consumer started being responsible to pay for them.

How, then, might we get medical costs to start spiraling downward? (This should really be a no-brainer.)

When did the number of single-parent families and out-of-wedlock births begin to skyrocket - especially among the young black population?

Why do the government schools that spend the most money per pupil generally have worse academic records than the private schools that spend much less per pupil?

I could go on with the questions, but.....

by maxwell edison

If you were given an assignment to devise a plan that would keep the largest percentage of a nation's population financially dependent on government, and to keep a large percentage of a certain segment (or segments) of the population in perpetual poverty, what would be some of the strategies of the plan?

How would you do it if you intentionally set-out to do it?

Edited addition:

And the trick is, you want to do it without them even realizing it!

by maxwell edison

- Tax a person's income.

- Create a mandatory government run retirement system.

- Create a mandatory government run health care system.

- Create compulsory education in government schools.

- Pay the poor and uneducated to have babies.

- Provide free food and housing.

- Create envy among the classes.

- Discourage and excuse the taking of personal responsibility.

- Control the media.

by Member 25348569

You ask, "When did medical costs really begin to skyrocket?"

Well, when your doctors caught on to the fact that they could charge you all whatever they wanted.

Regardless of when it started, you pay, when compared to the rest of the world's developed nations regardless of their "social medicine" status:

Higher prices for the same health care goods and services than are paid elsewhere.

Significantly higher administrative overhead costs than are incurred in other countries.

More widespread use of high-cost, high-technology equipment and procedures than are used in other countries.

Higher treatment costs courtesy of your unique legal system which forces a style of "defensive medicine" where you prescribe tests and procedures as a defence against the chance of a malpractice suit instead of a purely clinical purpose.

These have got worse over the past couple of decades.

Neil :)

by maxwell edison

[i]Well, when your doctors caught on to the fact that they could charge you all whatever they wanted.[/i]

That's not at all true. In fact, the opposite is true - when doctors were told (by either insurance companies and/or government) what they had to charge, and when the aforementioned entities became the third party paying for the care. And when people realized they could go to the doctor (and someone else would pay for it) for every little scrape and sniffle.

If we could snap our magic wand (or is it wave our magic fingers?) and eliminate ALL insurance companies and government involvement in health care, and ALL medical care was totally consumer-driven, the costs would indeed spiral fast and furious downward.

by delbertpgh

Just to give you something to chew on.

"Without the anecdotes intended to get a person's emotion to trump his reason, how would you define your measure of redistribution?" This raises an extra issue for me. If one never allows emotion to trump reason, how does one know one is alive, or admit to enjoying it?

Anyway, a "measure of redistribution" would be whatever it takes to meet necessary societal aims, allowing that some goals can be ridiculous or unachievable, and should never have a dime spent on them.

"How, then, might we get medical costs to start spiraling downward? (This should really be a no-brainer.)" Why, by withholding medical treatment from anybody who can't pay for it, silly! When lots of consumers die off, demand falls, and the medical profession just gives up on lots of expensive treatments, like dialysis and transplants and clotbuster drugs, as well as firing lots of nurses and doctors. Maybe the cost of some treatments would drop, too. Boy. Is no-brainer synonomous with brainless, by any chance?

"When did the number of single-parent families and out-of-wedlock births begin to skyrocket?" About 1960 or so, continuing for the next 50 years. About the time a lot of other stuff started happening. It happens to poor people, middle-class people, and rich people. If it makes you feel good to blame it on Lyndon Johnson, then feel that way, but I suspect it has a lot more to do with the way wealth and modern life break down old social patterns.

"Why do the government schools that spend the most money per pupil generally have worse academic records than the private schools that spend much less per pupil?" This is really asking multiple questions about cost and achievement, and has tricky hidden assumptions. It neglects expensive private schools, like the one I send my son to ($21k/year), which have by far the best academic records in town. It neglects special education, which private schools generally refuse to offer, leaving the expense and the low-achiever spec ed kids on public schools. It ignores places like DC, Pittsburgh, and New York, where any parent with any kind of good income either moves out of town or puts his kid in private ed, leaving the poor kids and the working class in public school with the special ed bunch. It's really a question of the sort, "Why do Catholic schools get better academic results than public schools, and often cost less?" Part of it is that special ed and handicapped kids don't attend, and part of it is they pay their teachers half of what public school teachers get, and very importantly, parents who pay to send their kids to any private school don't let them get away with as much crap. It's a style of parenting that leverages the school experience.

Somewhere in you there's a conservative argument that doesn't rest on false comparisons.

by tonythetiger

Charge people who don't have insurance 50 or more percent less than people who have insurance... Local hospitals charge 30 to 40% less.

And then there's the problem that most employers who offer to pay for health insurance (they don't really... they just take it from money they COULD be giving you) contract with just one carrier, making those employees, essentially, captive customers.

I think that insurance would be much less expensive if employers wouldn't pay for health insurance... instead giving the employee the money and letting them shop on the open market.

by jdclyde

Those were HER words, not mine.

I am willing to accept people of different ethnic backgrounds or genders as my equal based upon their efforts, but NEVER my superior based upon their gender or ethnic background as she has claimed.

So, I accept your apology based upon you not following the issue to know it wasn't ME putting her down based upon her gender/ethnicity, but her claiming to be better than "white men" based upon the same stupid reasons. Note, she never claimed to be AS good, but BETTER.

by delbertpgh

Hospitals usually charge people without insurance 50 to 100% MORE than those with. The hospital has a standard price for procedures, and the insurance companies negotiate that down to a discounted rate. If you come in uninsured, you get slammed with the full rate.

Why anybody thinks this is just, I don't know.

by tonythetiger

what is merely value for tax paid... That's entirely different from suckling at the government teat!

by tonythetiger

[i]It neglects expensive private schools, like the one I send my son to ($21k/year), which have by far the best academic records in town.[/i]

If they don't perform to your expectations, you can withhold payment, or in some cases demand it be returned. Try THAT with the government! :)

by Member 25348569

The problem with healthcare is that ill-health usually cannot be foreseen. There has to a mechanism - in any society that I'd like to live in - where the child that contracts leukaemia can be unconditionally treated.

You haven't answered my points about the cost of defensive medicine and the overly technical nature of US medicine. These are unaffected by insurance companies and the government.

The high costs in the US made higher by excessive administration, I agree, but you need to ponder on the fact that nearly half of US citizens have no insurance. These people inevitably remain untreated for conditions that could be remedied at relatively little cost - relatively is the key word - until emergency room treatment is required, pushing up costs for everyone.

Really, Maxwell, the US healthcare system is one of the puzzles of the Western world. How can you spend so much on healthcare and yet not treat all of your citizens? This is only matched by South Africa and they spend a LOT less.

by delbertpgh

I believe that decent health care in a rich society (like ours) is a human right. That's the zinger.

I believe it also is not in the interests of business or individuals to have health care paid for by business as an employee benefit. Good insurance winds up costing more, and makes a business less competitive. Makes no sense to me. There should be a different means of funding it all.

I don't know how our country manages to spend so much on health care, as Neil points out, yet get such inferior results. France does better, has more choice, more satisfaction, for less money. You can admire those guys for more than cheese, wine, and welcoming women.

About a quarter of America's costs are associated with payment. That is, all the insurance companies and all the ladies in doctors' offices who fill out insurance forms. A quarter of our medical bill is not associated with the delivery of care, in other words.

by maxwell edison

..... it comes at the expense of another.

How can health care (or any goods or services) be a [i]human right[/i] if the delivery of such has to come at the expense of another? In its simplest form, if YOU have a RIGHT to health care, then by definition you have to either force another person to provide it or pay for it.

You certainly have a right to pay for it yourself, but you have no such right to force another person to either provide it or pay for it. You have a warped sense of of the word [i]rights[/i] - what you suggest is either forced labor or robbery.

The scary thing, Delbert, is that a lot of people are now advancing the [i]health care is a right[/i] argument.

I have one question. Where are we going, and why am I in this handbasket?

by Member 25348569

So, what you're saying - as I read it - is that in modern US society health care is to be considered a privilege and not a right to be respected for everyone.

So, if it isn't a right then who will receive healthcare who won't and what are the criteria.

Just asking. Let's get down to the nitty gritty; what do you do with those who are injured or ill and have no health provisions?

:)

I'll pick up your answer tomorrow.

by maxwell edison

..... of the 1980s.

In the early 1980s, the MM-GW zealots (who are now the MM-GW-CC zealots) predicted:

..... an increase in average global temperature of between 4.5 and 6.0 degrees Celsius. The prediction today is only between 0.5 and 1.5 degrees Celsius (not accounting for any margin of error, of course, which is somewhere between 0.5 and 1.5 degrees Celsius). They were wrong - drastically wrong.

..... increases in sea levels in the range of 30 feet. The prediction today is only 12 inches. And I haven't heard of ANY sea level rise over the past 25 years, only predictions for a future beyond our lifetimes. One would think that a rise would be gradual, and some significant increase would have occurred over the past 25 years. But no, nary an inch, other than the constant 1mm rise per year that's been measured every year over the past 200.

..... that the polar ice caps were melting. The reality, however, is that over the past 25 years, the polar ice caps have been both melting and growing, depending on the year - just like they've been doing over the past 25 million years. (Or over the past 5,000 years for the strict creationists.)

..... nothing about climate change, only global warming. But when the GW prediction fell embarrassingly short, they changed the disaster-of-the-day to climate change. The climate is changing and there's no denying it, you say? Well, the earth also revolves around the sun, and there's no denying it. The climate's ALWAYS been changing, and it ALWAYS will. To state with certainly (or even speculation) that human activity is causing it is pure nonsense. And I don't need definite proof. All I know is that it's more likely that human activity IS NOT the cause of climate change - since it's ALWAYS been happening. And even if it is, who's to say that the climate won't improve for the better?

Over the past 25 years, Neil, since [i]Earth in the Balance[/i] politicized scientific studies, NONE of the predictions have come true, and ALL of the predictions have been downgraded from hurricane strength to a light drizzle. So quit your worrying and buy an umbrella.

by jdclyde

THAT is why health care costs so much. The people that DO pay for their health care are picking up the bill for those that are unable to.

Don't believe the BS you have heard, the poor and uninsured do NOT get turned away.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]Those were HER words, not mine.[/i]

Well, whythefuck didn't you just say so in the first place? :0

by jdclyde

Because you didn't ask?

Besides, I thought EVERYONE had heard her comments by now?

How about her comment about setting policy from the bench? Someone needs to tell that bitch and her benefactor Nobama that there is something called Separation of power.

Funny how liberal nutcases go crazy about Separation of Church and State as if it were actually a part of our government, but then pretend that Separation of power isn't. Well, not funny at all. Pathetic actually. Talk about dishonest.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Been busy as hell with the garden, our annual audit at The Center, and setting up for the semester that starts Monday. I have three extra classes to teach over summer.

I'll check her out when I have a little time, after the semester gets underway and the audit is finished. Not like I have any immediate say in the matter... @ssholes.

by maxwell edison

Health care is a commodity - it's either a good or a service. You either buy something or pay for someone else's service to you. It's no more, no less.

You pay a mechanic to service your automobile. You pay for parts, materials, and for the service provider's labor.

You pay a computer technician to service your computer. You pay for parts, materials, and for the service provider's labor.

You pay a carpenter (or mason, or plumber, or electrician, etc.) to service your house. You pay for parts, materials, and for the service provider's labor.

You pay a doctor to service your body. You pay for parts, materials, and for the service provider's labor. It's no more, no less.

Richer people can pay for more and better service - regardless of the type of service. That's a fact of life. Get over it. Some people have a better-functioning body than others. It's a fact of life. Get over it.

It's an emotional block people have that leads them to consider health care something different. Get over it. When purchasing health care, a person buys either a good or a service - PERIOD.

I'm amazed that you - an Atheist - might consider health care a [i]human right[/i]. You're someone to whom life is no more than a bunch of biological parts working together to make a person. It has no soul, no meaning, no purpose. Life is the search for that thing which will kill you - and then you're dust. But yet you advocate FORCING another person to pay for the care of YOUR body? Who appointed you God?

Edit: P.S - I anxiously await your argument that will justify your desired conclusion.

by maxwell edison

If a white male had interjected race into ANY comment, in ANY context, and in ANY way, he would be history.

Let's discard all double-standards.

Lady Justice is blindfolded for a reason.

http://www.scalesofjustice.org/images/scales_of_justice/scales_of_justice_385x261.jpg

This is a nomination for only one of nine positions on the bench of the highest court in the land.

If she were a Conservative Republican, her reputation would have been totally trashed by now, and her nomination would be in the trash bin - AND withdrawn.

That's the point.

She does not deserve the position - and the American people deserve better. The American people deserve a status-blind, race-blind, and gender-blind justice to interpret our constitution.

by jdclyde

by Democrats to the last few "minority" nominations by Republicans?

Handled a very different way.

But the disgraceful cult of Obama will march on, trampling everyone in it's path.

by nicknielsen

What kind of crap is this? Veterans' benefits and retirement are "social" programs?

I spent 24 years offering the US a blank check for "up to and including my life" and it's a f*cking "social program"?

My rosy red butt! What mental midget came up with that?

by santeewelding

Yours, as was mine, was membership in a "faction". The old white guys who put it together in the first place mentioned that word once or twice. Been on just about everybody's lips since.

by delbertpgh

I spent four years in the Air Force, (ready to defend my desk against the red hordes, to the death, if necessary,) and I never saw anywhere else in American life employees wrapped in such a womb of care and minor comforts. It was like the ultimate socialist paradise. Cheap bars, discount groceries, 27 cent smokes, the PX, the hobby shop, golf courses, pools, library, free unlimited medical care (for the family, too), therapy and substance abuse counseling, dorms, housing allowance, base housing for the fam, free standby on military flights, special discounted charter flights, university classes free on base at night, four weeks paid vacation per year, pay for vacation you didn't use... it just went on and on. Including the neat retirement bennie, 20 years and half pay and veterans' hospitals for life. Of course the pay was mediocre, and you might have to kill people, and risk your life, but we were compensated for it like no other working class guys on earth. Anyhow, now that you're retired, what gets spent on you is no longer a defense expenditure; it's a retirement benefit, where you're paid for nothing. It isn't far from a social program, you've gotta admit. Even if you've earned it. (You might say that old people have earned their Social Security and Medicare, too.)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]I never saw anywhere else in American life employees wrapped in such a womb of care and minor comforts.[/i]

Ain't too many job descriptions I know of that include 'willingness to die'. Or, 'willingness to die in strange and inhospitable places'.

A womb of care and minor comforts ain't schit in the face of a job description like that. I consider that an element in the disrespectful level of pay my servicemen receive.

etfdu

by jdclyde

from his attack on our petroleum based economy to bowing to Muslim Kings.

He doesn't realize or care that attacking petroleum will devastate an already devastated economy.

Of course his war on petroleum didn't stop him from taking AF1 out for a joy ride for "date night".

We can not afford to let him destroy our economy and country.

by santeewelding

About anybody doing that. You are part of the country. I am part of the country. I, for one, have to be destroyed before anyone can say the country has been destroyed.

by dr dij

we are emitting 27 billion tons of CO2 yearly.

We also know that temperature is almost exactly following emission peaks and valleys straight up.

And we also know that CO2 has been at 280-300ppm for last 10,000 years and is now heading way above that now.

Just because you are in IT doesn't mean that because YOU don't "have a friggin idea" that someone else doesn't know that. That really sounds like you are ignorant of the issue.

We have networks of monitoring stations, satellites, terabytes of data on a vast # of climate related topics over many years in many locations, plus industrial complex data so we know how many cars, how many power plants, etc are out there.

It is TRUE that the US stopping our pollution does not stop other countries. However the developing worlds are way less likely to even put in pollution controls or cut back if we don't. However many of those other countries including Europe and yes, even some of China tho they are now becoming the biggest polluter, are putting in alternative energy sources.

by Member 25348569

is perhaps a little harsh. You know, the belief in an Imaginary Friend isn't a prerequisite for empathy. Quite the opposite, I generally observe. Still, let's leave that aside for the moment.

Your definition of healthcare as a commodity, in the most economically successful country on Earth, then requires an answer to the conundrum that Americans spend more per capita than anyone else in the world on healthcare, and yet have less access to it than almost any other nation in the developed world. When healthcare is seen as a commodity, then for doctors and hospitals, treating sick and injured people is a more viable business strategy than preventive care - profiting from suffering. For your insurance companies, the less medical care they allow, the more money they make. Your lawyers feed in this trough of money when they pursue the malpractice cases and, in this, doctors must bear some of the responsibility as well, since lawyers can?t build cases without doctors on their side acting as expert witnesses. Yes, it's a commodity all right...

You know, if you created a public healthcare system, you would SAVE money if you could tie it all together.

Neil :)

More later...

by delbertpgh

Health care is often life itself, or the difference that makes one able to enjoy life and experience other liberties, or just the ability to endure life with dignity. I don't believe that because I label somebody as undeserving (and I do, a lot) they should be refused health care. Although everything is a commodity to somebody, from A-Pos blood to communion wine, to the general public being able to live and escape bodily and financial ruin means more than an exchange of goods.

JD says that the poor can be treated in emergency rooms "for free", but it isn't really free at all. We, insurers, and the hospitals pay for it. E.R. care is the most expensive way to treat problems, and middling health issues are often allowed to become bigger and more expensive because no care was offered when it could be fixed cheaply. It's a piece of why our life expectancy is lower than other modern countries', and why our medical bill is so much higher.

Besides, Max, I think you are talking about removing access to even this care as a legal entitlement, which it is, now. You'd turn it over to charity, and if there wasn't enough charity to cover the suffering, you'd let the suffering magnify. Am I wrong about you?

by delbertpgh

Military benefits are all compensations for a unique and nasty job, but I confess to no opinion about what you call servicemen's "disrespectful" pay. It was a whole lot crappier in 1970, when I started at $60 a month, plus all I could eat (which included fruit cocktail, baked as a pie.) Anyway, is there a suitable level of pay for the job description that includes dying violently in a strange place? Above which you'd be paying too much? You have to offer compensations necessary to fill the ranks, and apparently our military has a formula for it.

I guess part of the reason the long card of caring benefits the servicemen receive intrigues me so is that the military is the home of so many committed right wingers, guys who eat up Limbaugh with a spoon and splash on Hannity after shaving. Yet, these guys with a straight face expect and receive (and often whine about) the most comprehensive set of goodies available to any American worker. It is downright socialistic in its conception of a community that works together and mutually supports itself and cares for every member's every need. Not that I'm complaining. I'm just amused, is all.

It would be a worker's paradise, except for the killing, mutilation, and dying. But I was in the Air Force, and pretty much only a small cadre of pilots and aircrew took the big risks. The rest of us just hung out on base and tried not to be bored.