Discussion Locked

The "Myth" of Israel

0 helpful
210 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

From time to time I come across a news item or article which might provide a basis for a discussion. The article below is from Foreign Policy magazine. [Unfortunately I cannot just post a link to the article as it is available only to subscribers]

I will not respond to petty personal insults addressed to me.

[b]?Israel Is a Successful Democracy?[/b]

Sort of. From what began as an impoverished and war-ravaged country flooded with Jewish refugees from Europe and the Arab world, Israel has grown into a regional military power with a per capita GDP that exceeds all its neighbors. Unusual among post-World War II states, it has also managed to maintain an uninterrupted parliamentary regime for 60 years. Israel?s status as the Middle East?s only credible democracy plays a major role in its close alliance with the United States and its generally warm relations with Europe.

But how well is that democracy working? Israel elects its leaders, and its vigorous free press sometimes publishes criticism that might be considered anti-Israel elsewhere. Much of that criticism is aimed at the undemocratic regime in the West Bank: Jewish settlers enjoy the full rights of Israeli citizens, while Palestinian self-rule is limited to enclaves.

Within Israel proper, democracy is functioning but fragile. The lack of a written constitution has left the creation of civil rights to an activist Supreme Court?from a landmark 1953 decision that kept the government from closing newspapers, to last year?s ruling that enshrines the right of same-sex couples to adopt children. But the court?s position is tenuous. Some in Israel want the Knesset, Israel?s parliament, to restrict its powers to overturn laws, rule on security matters, or accept human rights cases.
Another critical weakness is the status of the Arab minority, one fifth of the population. Officially, Arabs have equal rights. But they?re scarce in the civil service. Arab towns and cities get less funding from the central government than Jewish municipalities. Roughly an eighth of the country?s land is owned by the Jewish National Fund, whose policy of leasing land only to Jews is at the center of a long legal battle.

Arab parties, which hold only 10 out of the Knesset?s 120 seats, have been consistently left out of government coalitions. Not only does that exclude Arabs from power but it also makes forming a majority coalition much more difficult?a central, and rarely noticed, reason for the chronic instability of Israeli governments.

The crumbling of the major parties that once dominated Israeli politics has made coalition government a shaky proposition. Labor, Likud, and Kadima?a centrist breakaway from the Likud?now hold only 60 Knesset seats between them. Labor leader Ehud Barak and Likud chief Benjamin Netanyahu are both ex-prime ministers who lost their jobs in landslides, reflecting their parties? failure to attract new leadership and the public?s disgust with politics. Solving the diplomatic impasse with the Palestinians?the country?s key challenge?is made much more difficult as a result. Israeli democracy is alive, but it needs an infusion of new blood.

[b]?Israel Is a Jewish State?[/b]

Not in the way you think. In Western countries, ?Jewish? is usually considered a religious category, parallel to ?Catholic? or ?Muslim.? So ?Jewish state? sounds akin to ?Islamic republic.?

But Zionism?the political movement that created Israel?was born of 19th-century nationalism, and it defined Jews as an ethnic group, a nationality like ?Russian? or ?French.? Inspired by other contemporary nationalist movements, early Zionists transformed the traditional Jewish aspiration to return to the Land of Israel (a.k.a. Palestine) into a modern nationalistic program. Jews needed to revive their historical language, but religion was a relic of the past, an obsolete vehicle for maintaining ethnic identity in exile.

Israel?s secular Jewish majority is heir to that conception. For Israel?s secular elite, being a Jew means speaking Hebrew, living in the Jewish homeland, and belonging to Israeli society. Jewish holidays are national holidays?to be spent hiking, at the beach, or overseas, not in a synagogue.

The theocratic side of the Israeli polity is largely a relic leftover from Ottoman law. Marriage and divorce are controlled by religious authorities, so Jews can only wed through the state-run rabbinate. Catholics must marry through the church, and they can?t divorce at all.

Otherwise, the clergy has little power. Completely secularizing the state would not end the real divide in society, which is an ethnic split between Jews and Arabs. As a key example, universal military service is central to civic identity?but Arabs are exempt. Arabs tend to regard themselves as Palestinian citizens of Israel, but not as ?Israelis.? Unless an overarching Israeli identity can be created and Arabs can be integrated into the mainstream, Arab demands for rights as a national minority will only grow.

[b]?Israel Was Born of the Holocaust?[/b]

No. Israel was born despite the Holocaust. Every visiting foreign dignitary is taken to Yad Vashem, the official Holocaust memorial. The route proceeds from exhibits on the horrors of the death camps to the establishment of the Jewish state. The stress on the Holocaust reflects the emotional trauma that the horror still inflicts on Jews. It also underpins the political message that Jews can only be safe in their own state.

But an additional message is that Israel was created as a response to the genocide perpetrated against Jews in Europe. That?s a historical mistake, and promoting it is politically costly for Israel. As an organized political movement, Zionism began in 1897, decades before the Nazis took power in Germany. Modern Jewish migration to Palestine began even earlier, not just from Europe but also from Yemen, Central Asia, and other parts of the Muslim world. Early Zionists did see anti-Semitism as proof that in an age of nation-states, Jews needed one of their own. But they built their plans on Europe?s Jews moving to Palestine. Those numbers would ensure that Jews would grow from a small minority to an overwhelming majority in the country.

In 1939, there were 8.3 million Jews in the territory that would come under Axis rule. Six million were murdered. The Holocaust orphaned the Jewish independence movement, whose largest source of support and immigrants was wiped out. The state that was established was much weaker than it would have been.

When Israel bases its public relations on the Holocaust, it unintentionally lends support to the Arab argument that Palestinians are paying for Europe?s sins, a talking point intended to undercut Israel?s legitimacy as a Jewish home and shift Western support to the Palestinians.
There?s one sense, though, in which the Holocaust formed Israel: Psychologically, it created the feeling that Jews stand in constant threat of annihilation.

[b]?Israel?s Existence Is in Danger?[/b]

Not anymore. When Israel declared independence on May 14, 1948, its Arab neighbors responded by invading. ?It does not matter how many [Jews] there are,? said Arab League Secretary-General Abdul Rahman Azzam. ?We will sweep them into the sea.?

Instead, disorganized and inexperienced Arab armies quickly crumbled before them. By the war?s end, Israel held more land than the United Nations had allocated it. Before the June 1967 Six Day War, as Arab states massed their forces on Israel?s borders, Israelis feared a second Holocaust. Israel?s astonishing victory showed that it had become the regional superpower, a status confirmed when it repulsed Egypt and Syria?s surprise attack in October 1973.

Five-and-a-half years later, the peace agreement with Egyptian President Anwar Sadat neutralized Israel?s most formidable foe.
Today, there is no conventional military threat that remotely compares with the alliance led by Egypt. Left isolated by the Israeli-Egyptian peace, Syria has carefully observed a cease-fire since 1974. Afraid to risk full confrontation, Damascus has supported substate forces such as Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in the Palestinian territories. Along with other guerrilla groups, they employ terrorist tactics and rocket fire. Those methods have claimed many Israeli civilians? lives. But on a national level, they?re equivalent to a chronic illness, not a fatal disease.

[b]?A Nuclear Iran Would Destroy Israel?[/b]

No. If conventional armies don?t endanger Israel?s very existence, then what of an Iranian bomb? Benjamin Netanyahu, now leader of Israel?s right-wing opposition, said in a typical speech, ?It?s 1938, and Iran is Germany.? Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has made similar comments. The 2007 U.S. National Intelligence Estimate?s assertion that Iran has stopped its nuclear weapons program has done little to reassure Israeli leaders or citizens.

Although all nuclear proliferation is dangerous, the rhetoric ignores the regional power balance. Israel does not normally say it has nuclear arms. But Olmert slipped in 2006, classifying Israel as a nuclear power. Foreign reports sometimes refer to Israel?s presumed
second-strike capability, the ability to destroy an enemy even if the enemy were to strike first. Such deterrence kept the Soviet Union and the United States from using nuclear weapons during the Cold War.

A common argument is that deterrence won?t work as it did with the Soviets. Iran?s fundamentalist leaders would supposedly be willing to commit national suicide to fulfill their irrational ideology. Experience shows, however, that Iranian leaders share the Soviets? caution. Iran agreed to a cease-fire in the war with Iraq once Iraqi missiles began falling on Tehran. The ayatollahs were willing to sacrifice soldiers?but not to pay a higher price. The threat of mushroom clouds will concentrate their thinking about Israel wonderfully.

It?s true that Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad?s extreme anti-Israel rhetoric and Holocaust denials are perfectly pitched to frighten Jews. But when Mohammad Khatami was president of Iran, we were told that his moderation made little difference because real power lay with the ayatollahs. For the same reason, one should avoid overestimating Ahmadinejad?s clout.

Iran?s underlying reason for wanting nukes is nationalist and fairly pragmatic: It seeks to assert its role as a regional power and to deter other nuclear powers. The real risk is that it will set off a regional race for the bomb. The more fingers there are on more buttons, the greater the chance of a mistake. Complacency would be a mistake?but so is panic.
?Hamas Seeks Israel?s Destruction?

In its dreams. Hamas?s founding charter, issued in 1988, defines Palestine as ?an Islamic waqf??sacred trust??consecrated for future Muslim generations.? That includes pre-1967 Israel. All of Palestine, says the charter, must be liberated by jihad. Diplomacy is a ?vain endeavor.? The document turns the goals of radical Palestinian nationalism into timeless religious truths.

Yet with time, Hamas has indeed changed. It hasn?t renounced its charter, but has stopped referring to it. The movement has gradually morphed into a hard-line but more pragmatic Islamist organization. A milestone was its decision to participate in Palestinian Authority elections, even though the Authority was born of the Oslo agreements with Israel. In its 2006 election platform, Hamas stressed liberating the land that Israel occupied in 1967, even while insisting that it would not renounce the claim to pre-1948 Israel or Palestinians? right of return.

This balancing act looks much like the change that the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) underwent a generation ago, when it adopted its 1974 ?phased strategy??willingness to establish a state in part of Palestine while maintaining a claim to the rest. For the PLO, that was a way to justify participating in diplomacy on the future of the occupied territories, and it was a step toward recognizing Israel. Today, there are disagreements within Hamas over whether to negotiate directly with Israel. However, the organization appears willing to accept a de facto two-state solution and long-term cease-fire, as long as it doesn?t have to recognize Israel outright.

Not that Hamas has turned moderate. It hasn?t renounced ?armed struggle,? including attacks on civilians. It may be willing to put up with Israel?s existence, but it still hasn?t negotiated with itself the way to say so publicly. Nonetheless, an eventual agreement with Israel is within the realm of the possible.

[b]?The Israel Lobby Controls U.S. Policy?[/b]

Never. In their book The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt hold the lobby largely responsible for U.S. policy not only toward Israel but toward the rest of the Middle East. The book?s greatest flaw may be that it serves as an unintended advertisement for the central lobbying group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), which is eager to play up its own influence.

Although AIPAC does lobby the U.S. Congress effectively, its influence on policy has limits. Under former President Ronald Reagan, it lost its fight to prevent the sale of AWACS surveillance planes to Saudi Arabia. It could not prevent Bush Sr. from using loan guarantees as a means of pressuring Israel on West Bank settlement. Under Bill Clinton, AIPAC helped push through legislation aimed at moving the U.S. Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, despite the potential for upsetting peace talks. But the victory was hollow: As passed, the law contained a presidential waiver that Clinton and George W. Bush have repeatedly invoked to avoid the move. In 2006, despite AIPAC?s efforts to pass a version of the Palestinian Anti-Terrorism Act that would have virtually cut off U.S.-Palestinian relations, the U.S. Congress opted for a more moderate bill.

Attributing U.S. policy solely to AIPAC has the advantage of great simplicity. That is also precisely what?s wrong with it. The constraints on U.S. policy in the Middle East were laid out after the Six Day War, in a memo to then President Lyndon Johnson written by McGeorge Bundy, his former national security advisor. The United States is committed to Israel?s survival, Bundy wrote, but also to good relations with pro-Western Arab states that want Washington to tilt against Israel. Keeping Israel strong saves the United States the headache of defending it directly. But in the long run, Bundy implied, getting Arabs and Israelis to make peace was the only way to resolve the contradictions in U.S. policy. American administrations have oscillated between these conflicting concerns ever since.
At 60, Israel is neither a perfect democracy, nor a Jewish ghetto imperiled by Iranian Nazis, nor a puppet master indirectly controlling Washington. It is more democratic than its neighbors, more reliably pro-Western, and more successful economically and militarily. Nonetheless, it faces the classic dilemmas of a nation-state dealing with minorities, borders, and neighbors. In other
words, it is best understood as a real place, not a country of myth.

[i]Gershom Gorenberg is author of The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967?1977 (New York: Times Books, 2006) and a senior correspondent for The American Prospect. He blogs at southjerusalem.com. [/i]

210 replies

by john.a.wills

There are 5 million Israeli citizens in enforced disenfranchised exile. The Israeli state is therefore no more a democracy than, say, late-apartheid South Africa, where only a third of the citizenry had full voting rights.

by john.a.wills

No-one else is responding, so I thought I'd try a second response.
"ethnos" is Greek for "nation", as "goy" is Hebrew. Nm 23:9 tells us that Israel is a people which does not count itself among the nations. With a few exceptions, when the Bible calls Israel, or part of it, a nation, God is annoyed with us. Israel is a church (Hebrew: qahal; Greek: ekklesia). This church a long time ago split into the Jewish and Samaritan churches. At the beginning of the Common Era the Jewish church split into the Rabbinical Jewish church and the Christian church. To call Rabbinical Jews a nation or ethnos or goy is unbiblical, and to erect a national state for them is to construct an oxymoron.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

perhaps no one else responds because at the moment we are sick and tired of discussion that polarizes. It was an unpleasant weekend around here. Timing for this may be not so good.

by jardinier

Alleged human caused global warming polarises and yet everyone seems keen to discuss it ad infinitum, ad nauseam.

In the past I have started discussions here about Israel but it appears that no-one wants to know about it.

by jardinier

Who are the bad guys -- the Israelis or the Palestinians? Which group has the most legitimate claim to the region?

by charliespencer

Perhaps people are more willing to discuss global warming for a couple of reasons. One, it's something they can personally effect, and that personally effects them. Perhaps they weren't willing to wade through that Master's thesis you opened with; I know I wasn't. They may think they already know what they need to discuss global warming. Global warming is at least a semi-technical, scientific discussion; it's more likely to be of interest to the membership of a tech site than political or religious discussions.

Me, I find this particular topic of no interest at all. Actually, I've made it a habit to avoid any topic you open. I've learned that you toss out subjects then let others fight it out while you disappear for days at a time, apparently unwilling to respond promptly to questions asked of you. (Note the four-day lag between the boxfiddler's post and your response. We're not playing chess by mail here.) I'm only responding this time because I noticed Boxy had contributed and agreed with her.

I also notice you rarely contribute to a technical or IT topic, so I'm not sure why you're a member of this particular forum at all. If you want to discuss religion or politics, why not participate in forums dedicated to those subjects? You're more likely to find others interested in your topics, and they're more likely to be better informed. I'm not implying you should go away, only that you can't expect to get a large number of responses to a topic this far removed from this web site's core subject.

No insults are intended. I can like you personally (as personally as anyone can with only a web connection between them) but find your topics of conversation boring.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

taps of the page down button. If I want to read a book, I've a few waiting in the wings.

by jardinier

I see that you have been a member here longer than I have. But obviously you have a defective memory. Once upon a time "off-topic" meant just that -- non technical -- and the threads were for the greater part about politics, social issues, religion (yes there have been many threads on religion which were always popular).

Perhaps you have forgotten the EL monster which when I last checked had run to about 2,500 posts. I believe that was very much in the area of religion.

There were discussions about technical issues also but they were in a minority.

And why did I wait four days before checking the forum? Because I deliberately did not subscribe to it because the thread I started immediately before that was largely composed of insults to myself.

Another reason is that I spend most of my time posting to a Christian website, primarily because people stick to the topic and do not go off on tangents, cluttering up the discussion with childish repartee.

As for my technical status, before the website was redesigned I was a TR Insider. Go figure. You might also note the figure "8" beside the thumb at my profile. This indicates that I have participated in Technical Q & A's to a modest degree.

by jdclyde

Off-topic, as long as within the bounds of taste and acceptability for a professional website to hose, means just about anything goes.

Being techie or not is not a requirement of this site.

[b]On the same side, crying because people go off-topic in an off-topic post is rather childish in it's self.

by charliespencer

But I don't see how you can expect intelligent responses to a discussion this far off the core topic. Would you go to a religious site and expect informed responses on the pending 802.11n wireless standards?

Maybe it's just me, but I regard starting a topic and then intentionally not participating as rude at best. If you don't subscribe because you suspect your topic will draw insults, why post it at all? Either develop a thicker skin or don't post, but don't start a controversial discussion and then sit back. That's nothing but trolling.

by Member 25348569

but not about Israel.

No-one is going to read your cut-and-paste. It's too long. Given that, no-one is going to respond.

With the exception, that is, of John.A.Mills whose views on Israel are well known (well, I know them) who I would have expected to see leaping in and bumping the thread a couple of times. Not disappointed in my prediction, am I? :)

If you want to get your name on another long discussion, Julian, then ANY subject has to be something that people want to post about and one where views are not SO polarised that no-one except the committed care to post.

:)

Anyway, given the "new improved" TR discussions, you ain't [b]ever[/b] going to get any long threads with your name on them any more.

by jdclyde

Been seeing the woman for several months now, but as it is still pretty close to the breakup of her marriage, I have been insisting on taking things very slow.

[i](no Mae, 31 is NOT robbing the cradle!)[/i]

so, does she rate one of my home made (from scratch) carrot cakes? It is using my grandma's recipe, which calls for "Oleo". :D

Going to have to think this over carefully, because this cake is to good for just any old occasion! :p

by charliespencer

You've been crying on our shoulders a lot longer than hers. Where's OUR carrot cake? Please tell me you don't pollute it with coconut.

by jdclyde

only got a few minutes before it comes out of the oven, so don't have time to post recipe now (as neil is asking for).

will get it up this evening, but you have to keep it between the several thousand of us.... :D

by Member 25348569

I can't get to grips with carrot cake. I can't see what advantages it holds over Mum's fruit cake but I'm willing to be convinced otherwise. I usually find that there's too much icing (frosting to you folks) and I'm not a fan.

Neil :D

Unless, of course, it is a family recipe handed down the generations and not to be divulged.

And, yes, she does deserve your bloody carrot cake. "Several months" and you haven't even given the poor girl carrot cake because you're "taking things very slow". There are faster glaciers. And warmer... (joke!)

by jdclyde

I think the recipe in a peer mail would be more appropriate as this is an old recipe that means a lot to me.

I have NEVER had anyone (besides me) make a cake as good as gram! :x

Side note, I will be scamming some of the cake back to take up to grams in the nursing home. She gets some EVERYtime I make one. :x :x

by maecuff

That's just weird.

Carrot cake is the sh*t, Neil. And if it's made right, then the icing is made with cream cheese.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

always rate special home-made carrot cake, if for no other reason than we put up with boyfriends! :D

Post the recipe, and don't even think that coconut goes with carrot cake. Thanks for that reminder, Palmetto.

by jdclyde

WTF have you people been smoking to even get the idea to ASK me about coconut?????

you people are messed up! :p

by w2ktechman

is this taking it to the next step. You need to 'drug' her into going farther :0

Just what IS in the cake that makes it sooo special :0

by maecuff

between you. Cradle robber.

And yes, I'd go ahead and make her the cake. That's very sweet.

by charliespencer

Hey, baby; how you doin'? You log on here often? What's your OS? You must be a 64-bit system 'cause my performance is rising, if you know what I mean.

<>

by jdclyde

a decade in the right direction.... :D

made the cake, but it wasn't cooled in time for her to take it with her.

she came over to play, but it turned out her mom is having a surprise party that she just found out about that she had to get back to. Of course NOW all she wants to do is take a nap, but what can you do, right?

she will just have to come back later to get the cake after it cools the rest of the way.

even had a birthday card sitting on my pillow for her to find! Ain't I just the romantic? B-)

by jdclyde

cake is made and frosted. (sitting in the fridge)

of course it wasn't done in time to give her before she had to get back to her "surprise" party.

tomorrow will be a good time to give it to her though, right? B-)

Was going to try that curry chicken tonight, but thingone had his girl friend over and she isn't into spicy. I WILL be trying it tomorrow though. has anyone else given it a shot?

by jardinier

that the usual people, especially jdclyde and neilb, would prefer to exchange trivial repartee rather than attempt to address the topic.

Well I guess it is back to the Christians.

Off-topic discussions at TR USED TO BE very meaty, composed mainly of posts which actually addressed the topic. But they have become so silly that I don't know why I bother to keep trying to get a serious discussion going.

I MAY consider addressing any posts which relate to the topic. I happen to feel very strongly about the Israel/Palestine situation. Not surprisingly it comes up at the Christian website also.

They have a forum for political discussions and I don't mind telling you that the American Christians have VERY DEFINITE opinions about politics and STICK TO THE TOPIC and generally show more insight into American politics than what I read here.

OK, back to your Fox news where you can learn what is happening in the real world (as defined by GWB and co)

by w2ktechman

thread hijacking seems so much more fun!

Fox news - How did you know?? :0
That is where I learned about everything that I know.

dem Christians must not have JD's carrot cake recipe, so they are staying on-topic. Hmm, are they eating the store bought spice cake with some carrot stuffs added??? -- LOL

Sorry, GWB brought to me by Fox made me say it..

Oops, I meant my religion made me say it!n

by Member 25348569

is OUR choice whether we post or not.

Quite probably if anyone else, Maxwell for instance, had started a thread discussing the Israelis then I MIGHT have posted. Probably not, though, as I have fairly extreme views about the Israelis from a US perspective and this is not the place to repeatedly air them on the whim of someone whose only motive seems to be that of a troublemaker.

Not only that, you posted an indigestible cut-and-paste which was well beyond my patience to read to the end. In addition, it was not well-written in that it failed to address other than in a superficial way the real issue of which is the organ grinder and which is the monkey in the Israel-US situation.

You then invite comment.

Had you posted one or two ideas about what YOU think and reasoned why YOU think so and invited answer, you might have got a thread. Because you did not do this, those of us who know you of old yawned and turned away. Jdclyde's subsequent hijacking of the thread was no more than you and it deserved.

Neil :)

So, you say "I happen to feel very strongly about the Israel/Palestine situation". So, WHAT do you feel and WHY? Don't post three and a half pages of material cut from some online mag, post your thoughts. I'll debate with you if you do that but otherwise not.

I wonder if your American Christian friends go "OH, no. Not HIM again." We do - and perhaps you should take that on board.

p.s. Not being an "American Christian", I personally reserve the inalienable right to show less insight into "American politics" than them.

by jdclyde

Just go away.

You are an amusing little troll to snivel that your off-topic discussion didn't stay on-topic.

Fine, tell us in YOUR OWN WORDS why YOU feel "very strongly" about Israel/Palestine. What is YOUR axe to grind against the Israelis?

Historically speaking, since they were there before the muslum nations, is there anything valid to the claims against them?

Make your case or run off to a different sandbox, the call is yours.

[i]
Side note, it is amusing how simpletons attempt to use Fox news watching as some kind of insult.

by charliespencer

"...I don't know why I bother to keep trying to get a serious discussion going."

I don't either. More specifically, why try HERE with material better suited to other sites?

"I happen to feel very strongly about the Israel/Palestine situation. Not surprisingly it comes up at the Christian website also."

I'm not surprised it comes up there. I happen to feel very strongly about NASCAR, but I don't expect anyone at TR to give a rip. If I were to start a serious discussion on the topic here, I certainly wouldn't expect the same level of response I'd get on a racing-specific site.

"They have a forum for political discussions and I don't mind telling you that the American Christians have VERY DEFINITE opinions about politics and STICK TO THE TOPIC and generally show more insight into American politics than what I read here."

Great. How are they're discussions on TCP/IP, Linux, Java, Blu-ray, solid state drives, or AMD vs. Intel? Pretty poor, I'll bet, because that isn't their focus.

Again, I'm not saying you shouldn't post non-technical content here. Just don't be surprised if you can't find an audience. Oh, and I get my news from NPR, about as liberal an outlet as you'll find in the U.S.

by charliespencer

But I've seen coconut, raisins, and even pineapple. (Seen, not eaten.) When you get around to peer-mailing the recipe, I'd like to be on the distribution list. And if anybody wants my curried chicken salad, let me know.

Say, what was that thing terrorists used to do when they'd redirect a plane to an airport other than it's original destination? It's right on the tip of my tongue...

by charliespencer

Curried Chunky Chicken Salad

4 c cubed chicken (appx. two large or three small breasts; turkey may be substituted)
1/2 c diced celery (appx. two stalks)
1/4 c diced carrot (appx. one medium carrot)
1/2 c diced grapes, any color (appx 25-35 grapes)
1/2 c chopped walnuts or pecans (appx. one 2 oz. bag)
2 minced jalapenos, seeds and membrane removed (optional)

1/2 c diced apple (appx. one medium apple)
1 tbls lemon juice

1 c mayo or fat free substitute (appx. one 8 oz. jar)
2 tsp apple cider vinegar
1/2 tsp plus 1/4 tsp curry powder
1/4 tsp cayenne pepper

Combine first six ingredients. Dice the apple and coat immediately with the lemon juice to prevent apple from turning brown. Add apple to the mixed chicken and veggies. Combine remaining ingredients well, then add to chicken and veggies and stir to coat well. Makes appx. 6 cups.

I like to use this to fill warm pita bread; great for tailgating. I like my chicken salad chunkier than the typical Southern style; that looks like it's been through a blender so toothless Grandpa can eat it. I've got other variations but the basic proportions remain 4 parts chicken, 2 parts veggies / other, 1 part mayo.

by jdclyde

if you get a "carrot cake" from a store, it is almost always a SPICE cake with a few carrots thrown in. not sure what they do to the carrots, but they are horrible.

in a REAL carrot cake, you never actually bite into a chunk of carrot because it just becomes a part of it.

by w2ktechman

what is the big deal???
We all know it's used as the same thing, so wtf?

However, if I go to the store and look in the 'icing' aisle, I will not find any 'icing', instead I will find lots and lots of 'frosting'...

by jdclyde

all you will find is ice.

if you go to the cake and frosting section though, I know exactly what you will find. B-)

by Member 25348569

WHATEVER it's called!

:D

Obviously the US programmes that we get over here are screwing up the NITS(tm) Culinary Department Database. I'll correct it.

by jdclyde

with powdered sugar (confectioners), butter, cream cheese, crushed walnuts, and vanilla.

although I have always known it as frosting. will have to look on grams recipe to see if it is listed as icing or frosting...

I got my copy back in 97.

by w2ktechman

just as good, it requires 4-6 cubes of butter (melted)... On second thought, that is the heart attack express recipe -- better leave it alone....

by jdclyde

because most people can't HANDLE big pieces.

it is NOT the best thing for people that put themselves on restrictive diets.

I also only make it about two times a year, so it is ALWAYS a special treat when I do. Not going to allow it to ever be "oh, more carrot cake". B-)

cup and a half of cooking oil, so you don't need to oil or flower the pan... ;\

by boxfiddler Hot topic

but that's just me. Nuts in the icing just frosts my @ss. Ok, bad, but irresistible.

etu

by jdclyde

I told the ex I was going to trade my 36 in for two 18's (this was a few years back).

For some reason, she wasn't as amused as I was. B-)

And yes, this was after I knew she was leaving.

by jdclyde

I could not eat the whole cake before it would go bad. :0 It is VERY rich.

And stuffing that much in again takes away how special it is! B-)

by jdclyde

I have heard icing, I have heard frosting, but I have never heard of icing honey.

heck, I have made frostings with a whip cream base, butter base, cream cheese, or sugar, but never honey! :p

The sugar is for when you are decorating the cakes because it is the easiest to work with. Yes, I can make the little roses and such. B-)

by jdclyde

interesting.

What I have become fond of doing is after cutting up hot peppers, use the same knife to cut up some cheese. mmmmmmm.

I got my boys hooked on that! :D

[i]
(a sharp cheddar)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

NEVER give me tequila! I get oooogly and rabid. Really. I mean really. No, really.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

But really. Last time I drank takillya I tried to run down my ex in a parking lot. In my defense, only barely, he brought a sweet YOUNG thing into my bar and made out with her all over the place. Hence ex. Fortunately for me, not dead ex. The beginning of my move to getting clean.

Really, you do not want to give me tequila.

by w2ktechman

Interesting, I thought this used more butter....

Butter Dips

1 + 1/2 cubes butter (melted)
1/2 cube melted butter
4 1/2 cups flour
3 tablespoons sugar
1 tablespoon salt
2 tablespoons + 1 teaspoon baking powder
2 cups milk

sift in dry ingredients, add milk and 1/2 cube melted butter. Stir slowly until the dough 'jus clings' together. Turn onto well floured board and roll over to seal lightly (about 4 turns).
Roll out to about 1/2 inch thick and cut into strips.
Dip each strip into the melted butter to cover all sides, then place them in a pan very close together. pour remaining butter on top.
Bake at 400-450 degrees for 15-20 minutes (light brown).

Alternatives -- add a little parmesan cheese on top.
add garlic.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

can't do carrot cake [i][b]right[/b][/i] without cream cheese icing. Definitely not.

by tearat

Politics and religion should not be discussed at the same time
It becomes too confusing for most

If you want an answer to a question

Limit the discussion to that question
Also asking the question will help
Posting a statement, which appears to be third party then waiting to see what happens, is not discussing the subject

What was the subject?

Was it the reposting of other people opinions?
Or was it the opinions that you reposted?
Or was it something else?

by Member 25348569

Carrot cake specifically but digression to pastries or desserts (NOT deserts!) is acceptable. It would seem it's also acceptable to post public service announcements such as "Boxfiddler gets mariticidal urges when fed Tequila so feed her Bourbon instead".

Hopefully, Julian will come back, see what we think of his deliberate attempt to start what would probably have been quite a nasty argument, and bugger off again.

:D

He does have a habit of trying to start acrimonious debates despite the fact that his own debating skills are crap.

by Member 19291532

I expected an anti-Zionist rant full of pro-Palestinian, holocaust denial propoaganda.

I'd point out that many nations do not have a written constitution, including the U.K., and they would argue that it gives them a broader interpetation of civil rights - not that I necessarily agree with this.

And just because there was a Zionist movement that wished to establish a State in Israel (seems like that has been going on for a LOT longer than since the late 1800s), doesn't mean this is what caused the genesis of Israel. Expand this argument logically, and the Hebrews have been wanting to call Israel (and more importantly, Juresalem) home for at least the last 2000 years or so.

Is it Religious or is it Secular? Is it Religious or is it Ethnic? I think that is a little too muddy at this point to say where one influence ends and another begins. You could also argue that for more than 2000 years, *other* races have been defining the Jewish religion as an ethnic identity. The State of Israel certainly operates as a secular State identifying people by ethnicity - but that ethnicity springs from a religious identity that is a critical part of Israel's self identity. The concepts are all married in Israel.

Ultimately, it is a State ran by a people that have been besieged from all sides since the Pharoah's ruled the known world, who have been run out of their settlements time after time, who faced a fairly effective modern genocide, and now find themselves surrounded by militant extremist religious fundamentalists.

It is no wonder they're a little damned jumpy.

by jardinier

Someone actually addressed the initial post with a serious and well thought out reply.

Thank you dcolbert. It is encouraging to know that at least one person here has something more than carrot cake between their ears. :)

by charliespencer

If we have carrot cake between our ears (and technically having it in my mouth is having it between my ears), why hang out here?

As I asked earlier, wouldn't you get more informed responses if you posted these questions on a political- or religious-oriented site? Why do you expect your non-technical topics to be treated seriously on a technical web site, especially since you've -never- started a topic that could be considered 'on-topic' for this site?

by jdclyde

she likes to "fiddle" with computers, which are widely accepted as "boxes".

got to admit, I like the visual you are drawing much better.... ]:)

Add a little frosting and.... :p

by jdclyde

I must say that Julian should be able to post what he wants, regardless of what many of us see as the reason for his post.

I spend as much time(if not more) in the off-topic as I do the on-topic. I blame a lot of that for the lack of relevant on-topic tech that I give a rip about.

If Julian wants to post intentionally argumentative posts and sit back and see what happens, that is find by me.

It is telling of both his intentions and his character of how he handles people not scampering to his post AND his crying about side discussions.

He forgets that just because he starts a discussion, no one is obligated to stay "on-topic" about his off-topic topic, nor are they obligated to come in and act like the stirred up hornets nest he was so gleefully hoping for.

He also lied, or at least changed his mind. [i]"I will not respond to petty personal insults addressed to me."[/i]

If he wants to try to get an anti-Israel rant going, whatever. It just means a subject has become his ever negative focus instead of the US for a little while.

by charliespencer

Just because I find them boring doesn't mean I object to him starting them. I just don't understand why he expects to get either interest in, or informed responses to, these topics at this site.

by jdclyde

Cake. I like cake. I CAN have it AND eat it too. When it is gone, I can make more.

He is a troll trying to get things all worked up, and is just pissed that no one cared enough to get worked up like he was hoping. That, or the fact that many of us know him enough to see through it.

I saw this when it first started, and would NEVER have posted in here, and was content to let it die a quiet death. Then it was acknowledged by a few, but not in the way he had hoped. his problem, not mine.

Besides, all he said was he wouldn't reply to personal insults, he didn't say ANYTHING about side conversations people actually care about. B-)

gunna have chicken tonight! :D Will let you know how it goes over.

by Member 25348569

(no, I KNOW my problem with Julian) is that he doesn't seem to start a thread with his own views and reasoning and generally doesn't come back with any subsequent post that are truly debating the subject that the raised. There is never a debate with him, only with others.

It is my view that that is dishonest and my tolerance of Julian has dropped steadily over the years that he and I have been posting here.

Just my tuppence worth.

Neil :)

His first fire-starter was a cut-and-paste screed and his only other on-topic post was an ambiguously worded question. His other half-dozen posts were whining that no-one wanted to play in his muddy pond.

As we both noted, if Max had started the thread, he would have contributed from the start.

by jdclyde

when I think of an American Christian, would quite possibly be you, Neil... :D

As for American Politics, you have shown a greater understanding than Julian has ever been willing to undertake.

by Member 25348569

That was the point I was trying to make to Julian. That the membership here is a lot less predictable than his "Meet Christians" which, I guess, is full of Christians with the odd annoying Australian.

The membership here is varied in both nationality and religion - with the odd annoying Australian.

Neil :D

I hasten to add that the "odd" annoying Australian is not, of course, Colin, who I would describe as "unique" and far from annoying...

by charliespencer

I'm an annual contributor and I don't even drive a Volvo. Now, if you'll excuse me, there are some trees outside that are obviously in need of some hugs.

by charliespencer

He'd participate on a regular basis, not just lob out a grenade and then walk away for several days because he was afraid he'd be insulted.

by Member 25348569

This is a CAKE thread. And an Israel thread and a b:tch at Julian thread. The only way that you can introduce a FOURTH topic in under 100 posts without the fabric of TR unravelling is if the chicken is a Jewish recipe.

Edit to add: forget it. Go ahead. I forgot that this is also a "Things that make Boxie homicidal" thread.

by santeewelding

I'm going to hang that one on the wall by the front door in case I get too serious with the next person who walks into my life.