Discussion Locked

The "Myth" of Israel

0 helpful
210 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

210 replies

by charliespencer

That may be the closest I've seen you come to harsh. Nothing ambiguous or open to interpretation about that.

by santeewelding

The "closer" I "come" to that which involves everything the more ambiguous and open to interpretation I must seem.

The difficulty, and I admit to it, is a direct function of none but my articulative failure. Thus do I pay attention to those who do manage clarity so often; who do speak quietly, yet clearly, such as yourself, and some few others.

Thank you.

Richard

by jdclyde

why is Julian all of a sudden sporting "wood"?

look'en for luv in all the wrong places? :0

by jdclyde

and like it, whether you like it or not! :p

And we are officially over 100 posts! B-)

I won't bore anyone with the count of how many are actually on-topic, vs cake vs discussing off-topic. Lets just say, we are officially off the on-topic. :D

by gadgetgirl

but I was actually implying that I needed a hug.....

:(

still haven't got one.........

:(

GG

by charliespencer

It isn't Christian, Jewish, or Israeli. It certainly doesn't belong in carrot cake and shouldn't be frosted with cream cheese.

Oh, wait; you can marinade it in either tequila or bourbon. Never mind.

by charliespencer

Better late than never. The apparent topic is "Hijacking a Discussion". Discuss the moral implications as they relate to Israel, Christian web sites, carrot cake, chicken, and distilled spirits. All contributions must be in black ink, double spaced, white Letter or A4 size paper, 1.5-inch / 4 cm margins on all sides. All lower-case 'i' must be dotted with hearts or smiley faces.

by jdclyde

to be off-topic from the off-topic topic? :0

tequila marinade? I don't think so! Tequila belongs in a glass, neat. B-)

by jdclyde

do you really see the original post as "politics"?

Next thing you know, John will be trying to sell his Anti-Israel book again.....

by neon samurai

I guess political does not mean an inherently divisive toppic though.

(He's tried to hock a book on religious theories around these parts? Where's that unsubscribe link, I'm going to see if what's happening in the technology related topics ;) )

by Member 25348569

125 ml tequila - about half a cup
Juice of one lime
Two finely chopped or crushed garlic cloves
Handful of finely chopped coriander leaf (half a cup of chopped cilantro)
2 tablespoons brown sugar (2 tablespoons of brown sugar)
Half teaspoon of salt
Freshly ground black pepper

Combine all of the ingredients and marinate chicken pieces for around an hour. Easiest way is in a plastic bag.

Barbecue or, if it's still bloody raining, cook the chicken on foil in a pre-heated oven, as hot as you can get it, 500F, for a few minutes, ten at most, turning once so that the pieces [b]begin[/b] to char on both sides (watch carefully!). Reduce heat to medium (375F) and cook for another fifteen minutes. Cry at the waste of alcohol as it evaporates into the air.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

where the h3ll is that freaking carrot cake recipe???? I want it, and I want it now. Got that? :D

by boxfiddler Hot topic

than PC's.

Breaking them apart and flattening them for recycling is fun. And big ones need to be carved up pretty good if they're going to fit in the recycling bin.

I like wrapping prezzies too. :D

by jdclyde

His copy/paste OP, which from what I have been able to get through, does not support that anything is a myth except maybe the idea that he is looking to have a discussion.

by Member 19291532

A one stop shop, where I can flex my mind in various ways, not just on technical topics. I don't mind multi-dimensional conversations, even if the conversation is not on-topic for this particular site.

There are two sides to this argument. I think my response makes it clear who I side with - but there are a LOT of people in the other camp. Just to blindly assign it as anti-semitic propaganda in every case is not a sound or rational approach, either.

The problem is, if I go to a politically oriented site, I get responses from people who are primarily interested in politics. This doesn't necessarily give me an accurate sample of opinion. On the other hand, here I get to see what my professional peers think on this topic - which is an interesting insight into the people I work with on a daily basis. So... why not?

by Member 25348569

this thread was started by someone who I think makes a habit of starting controversial threads without contributing much further. He has done this for some time - a year or two at least. He pops in occasionally, fires off a couple of disputatious "thoughts" - never his own - and then buggers off for a couple of days or so before coming back to view the results. I - and most of the peers as you can see - choose not to get drawn in any more for his amusement. I will debate with him but, failing that opportunity. I'll insult him until he goes away. If I can even be bothered to do THAT these days.

Feel free to start a thread yourself, posting [b]your[/b] thoughts on a subject that interests [b]you[/b] and you will almost certainly get a response and we can have a proper debate. Hell, if you don't get a debate, you'll at least get a recipe!

Neil :D

by the scummy one

JD was put in the Girl Scouts instead of the Boy Scouts. That
is why he does all of these things that no real man would
ever know (or admit to knowing) :^0 :^0

by locrian_lyric

It's been too heated in here as of late.

This 'article' pushes just about every button there is to push, the author obviously has an agenda, and while I could argue with him until I'm blue in the face, I defer to Loc's law #17: Never argue with idiots, they drag you down to their level, then beat you with experience.

How did this place get so political?

by the scummy one

By JD's own admission it is a blow up doll. So he has a 31 Yr. old blow up doll that was too tired to satisfy him over the weekend :0
Maybe a bit underinflated :0

:^0 :^0

My religion made me say it!!!

by tearat

You?re on your own if you upset her

?Add a little frosting and?

I have no idea what you are talking about
(Safe answer)

Lets see a frosty box would be an icebox

I cannot see how frosting would
Make the cardboard or plastic or steel taste any better
But the teeth marks could be a difficult thing to explain

Well teeth marks on any box could be a difficult to explain

But being a rat I have no problem with boxes
I nibble here and a nibble there
Run away and leave someone else to clean up the mess

by jdclyde

although some are more valid than others.

With everything going on in the middle east, people that hate Israel figure this is the perfect time to turn opinion while people are tired of war. The people that forget peace is not free, and that you can not reason with unreasonable people, such as the current government in Iran.

by locrian_lyric

It is a VERY clever way of removing all non-jews in Israel from the discussion, while using a prejorative at the same time.

What to see them do a tapdance? Ask them what Zionist means.

by tearat

Many people are not comfortable talking about others in public
A lot of them think it is rude

I for one do not like to discuss the politics of other nations unless it directly affects me

It is not my place to influence the vote of anyone but the other citizens of the nation I am a citizen of

I also am sceptical of the opinions of people who do not live within the borders of the nation they are citizens of
How can you fully understand what is going on if you do not live there?

Discussing someone else?s religion unless you are a practicing follower of that religion will always end up offending those who practice
The same applies to morels

One of the biggest problems is language
Since we are speaking English
Which is the most logical and accurate language on the planet
We should have no problems

Yeah right
You guys never have any trouble understanding each other do you?
Nope not me

Why don?t you believe me?

Or is that
Why?
Don?t you believe me?

by ontheropes

I'll have to try that. I had my first morels ever this spring and they were deep fried. Yummers.

Back to the topic-

Here's a seemingly unrelated picture but, in my little mind, I think it's somehow fitting. :)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is excellent. I use a marinade of olive oil, basil, garlic, and sherry (or very dry red wine). Yum!

You almost got me with that... Until I realized it looked rather like a morel. :D

by jellimonsta

I am not familiar with that region. It appears to be close to Niamey, but I do not recall seeing it on a map. ?:|

by ontheropes



I'm a pretty simple guy though. Deep fried mushrooms with ketchup suit me just fine. Now I have a craving for them. I should've just ignored the whole thing. Dammit!

by charliespencer

The original content of this post should have been in response to puppybreath's comment above. jdclyde's response to the original content makes more sense if read in that context.

jd, I apologize for missing the intended target.

by jdclyde

more likely either another copy and paste of someone elses work, or just ignore that post all together, just like he has puppies inquiry as to Julians opinions on the whole issue that he claims to "feel deeply about".

by jdclyde

wonder if there is a way to have arrows on the screen pointing to where the other post should be? :D

by jdclyde

and the more liberal leaning you are, the more condescending you are allowed to be to anyone that isn't as "enlightened" as yourself.

Maybe even the sheep have been saying "no" to Julian lately, and that is what is making him so pissy?

by charliespencer

jardinier shows up on this, his own discussion, on average once every four days. That means you shouldn't expect a reply until Thursday, June 26th. This assumes at that time he'll actually share an opinion on the subject instead of just posing another question like he did on his visit of the 22nd.

by puppybreath

I thought it was the best way to prove to any doubters out there that he is nothing more than a troll, and a poor one at that.

by jdclyde

hope people will prove you wrong, and that they aren't as bad as you thought?

Today would have been a good day to have been wrong, sorry that didn't work out though. :(

by jardinier

that he just a twit with nothing more useful to fill his time than post trivial chit-chat at TR.

You also have a serious memory problem. Perhaps you need to upgrade to some more RAM.

The comments you have posted here are total rubbish because obviously you [b]CANNOT REMEMBER [/b] the threads I used to start for the first several years of my membership at TR.

The various religious ones which you obviously enjoyed were all started with a post in my own words. No doubt you also cannot remember the various political and other threads which I started with my own words.

I started posting here in November 2002. Up until about two years ago at the most, I was very active in discussions, including more than 120 which I started WITH MY OWN WORDS.

At one point I was running at 20 - 30 from the top in site activity, and most of that was associated with forums because I have never bothered too much with the Tech Q & A because TheChas always got there first.

During my period of several years of quite intense activity at TR, I used to post to discussions several times a day according to where I happened to be. That included from home, from my place of work, and from a coffee shop.

This also coincided with my hands-on activity with computers. It would be a good two years now since I stopped messing around with computers, and so my interest has dropped correspondingly.

Another reason I spent less time at the forums was because I was building and updating my various websites.

Perhaps you remember Gret, or is that stretching your memory too hard. We both used to post intensely at TR and also later at meetchristians.com

This quick "copy and paste" phase only started AFTER I found no reason to visit TR regularly, hence also the time delays between my posts. Whenever I come across some article that I think might stimulate discussion I post it. I don't give fig whether anyone is interested in posting to it.

What a pathetic excuse for a human being you are -- with a memory span of less than two years.

So your tolerance of me has dropped steadily over the years that you and I have been posting here. Once again, you are showing signs of dementia with your memory span of less than two years. You used to be very polite to me and actually like me I think.

As the quality of discussions deteriorated at TR -- mainly because of the ever increasing time wasted with petty personal chit-chat -- I started to post more to the Christian forums. At least they stick to the topic.

I will not start any more threads at TR because I am simply not interested in wading through all the irrelevant off-topic crap that is becoming the most recognisable feature of the forums.

I like and respect Maxwell. I do not like or respect you. You are just a wanker who apparently has such an empty life that you have to pass countless hours posting mostly off-topic nonsense here. I suggested to Jeff Clyde that he get a wife. Perhaps you also need to find some activity involving your penis other than playing with it.

I have much better uses for my genitals as you can see here with my fiancee Kidist. We plan to marry in about four months time. I may even make a baby with her.

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Kidist_7_75.jpg

by charliespencer

"I will not respond to petty personal insults addressed to me."

Apparently it's okay for you to use them but not for others. Do as you say, not as you do?

"I will not start any more threads at TR ..."

Since it looks like no one is interested (your "Vote Nader" topic died a quick and unresponded death), everyone involved should be happier. You won't waste your time on an unappreciative audience, and we won't have to figure out why you think anyone is interested.

by jdclyde

so you can meet in person for the first time?

What country is THIS one from?

Will she be bringing her sister with her?

Hope this one doesn't turn out to be a scam like the rest.

How funny, as that seems to be your answer standard answer, "find a wife". Clearly you are thinking about it a lot more than I am. Some of use have more in our lives, so we don't need a mail order bride.

by locrian_lyric

and there never was.

But I *DO* know that the jews aren't blowing up school busess and targetting children for destruction.

They also aren't setting bombs with nails dipped in rat poison, so it has anti-coagulant properties.

Yeah, the Palestinians are REAL heros, aren't they?

by santeewelding

So I looked up "political", and every variation thereof I could find.

I guess you did, too, before using it.

by ontheropes

Bets? Anyone? I'm good for a couple of bucks on it. I'll bet that he does post more, after all, to me he looks like, "a twit with nothing more useful to fill his time than post trivial chit-chat at TR."

Julian, I'm a messed up dude. I'll admit it. I could go on at length about myself but I don't think anyone wants to hear me appear to be whining. You, however, pretend to have your shlt all of the way together, in fact you flaunt it and all you succeed in doing is make me feel better about myself in comparison to you. That's an accomplishment. Thank you.

Oh, and thanks for the laugh. Neil and dementia. :^0 :^0 That was a good one. Why didn't you just call him a poopyhead and be done with it? :^0

I don't have anything better to do with my time right now than to post trivial chit-chat. Sue me. I see you're still here too.

by jdclyde

and you won't find any takers.

He has said this before, the last time he and the Dawg played. Can't remember if it was one or two months that it lasted.

He had a young fiance at that time too, but he never did get to actually meet that one either. (19?)

by ontheropes

You're right, it'd be a suckers bet.

I don't really 'get' what happened to Julian. I used to like him and now he just creeps me out. Maybe it's the fact that I didn't really know him and was a noob to TR at the time. Time changes things doesn't it?

The 'discussions' he has are just too predictable as has been pointed out at length so well in this one but I don't think that Julian sees it yet. According to him we should all go to meetchristians.com, his website if I'm not mistaken, and have some uplifting and intense discussions where everyone conducts themselves as adults. If he's representative of what you'll find just shoot me if you ever see me going over there, would you please? I just don't want to live like that.

I see he's sucking up to OZ yesterday and now Max. Maybe he's trying to get a few people on his 'side' so that'll mean that he has worth and value. Okey doke. That's what it looks like to me but I'm basically a non-interested, casual observer. I could be wrong.

He'll be back and post more BS 'discussions' nobody cares about. It might take awhile but he'll be back.

by jdclyde

People always revert back to who they are.

They can put on a show for a while, but sooner or later, they slip back into who they truly are.

He stopped trying to be nice and let everyone see who he really is, and it isn't a pretty sight.

Uplifting? When is the last positive thing that Julian has posted (besides the time his lips were suctioned on to The Mighty Oz's a$$? I am sure you saw from Oz's reply, he was as surprised as anyone by it, and didn't return the complement. Talk about awkward...

He has already let it slip he goes to the Christian sites to poke and prod, not to find any truth for himself.

He is not the person I once thought he was, and you picked the correct word, "creepy".

He doesn't start anything positive, because he is not a positive person. THAT is what everyone has learned about his "discussions". They are just him going off against Bush, America, the Jews, or Christians.

I am sure there are others, but those seem to be the main focus of his hate, which is a miserable way to spend his days that there is nothing more pressing that for him to rant against things half a world away.

I think he comes back here when they get sick of his negativity on the religion web sites.

Maybe he should make a new site, www.IhateEverything.com

What a sad, lonely life.

by jellimonsta

JD, Morels are pretty darn good. I think I do prefer portobello or shitake though. :D

Edited cuz I evidentally can't spell :0

by the scummy one

I dont like Fungi, it should not be food... I kill it in the yard, I kill it everywhere I find it.
If I found it on a pizza, likely I would eat it anyways, after picking at it a bit, however any other foods with it, I would need to dose in fungicide (then toss out)..

by ontheropes

Whew that's good stuff!

My wife is taking a vacation day tomorrow. Maybe I can talk her into my treat someplace nice for lunch, someplace that has mushrooms.

I almost called in an order for some deep-fried mushrooms. If I'd had some other reason to go into town today I would've done it. I've got a mushroom jones going on.

by puppybreath

It's always interesting to hear other points of view. But I can't remember him sharing any insights at all except for his rants against America/Americans.

As mentioned earlier, he seems to enjoy posting a piece of wacko journalism and then runs and hides, hoping that a flame war will start. I wonder if he does the same thing at his precious Christian sites.

by jellimonsta

just like any other fungus, they sure grow on you! :p
Wow... I should boo myself for that one. :D

by Member 25348569

If you would READ my post you would understand my point. I haven't called you any names - yet - but, if I so choose, I surely can do better than "twit". Oh, my. That cuts me to the outer layer of dead epidermal cells...

When you were a regular contributor to TR I don't remember that we had any particular problems other than that caused by the simple disagreements that happen in a good discussion. You still had the habit of starting threads on contentious issues and stepping back out of the firing line. You rarely pulled your weight but were always good for a pompous post on religion and your "search for truth" although, even then, it was difficult to work out what you actually THOUGHT.

Some time ago you started to frequent your Christian site and your involvement at TR diminished. That's OK, you can do what you want. What happened, though was that you morphed into the seagull poster that we all have commented - fly in, sh:t on something, fly out. You wander in, post something in the hope of starting an argument - NOT a discussion - and drop back to see if your "chums" at TR have generated some amusement for you.

You're a TROLL, Julian. You KNOW what we all think of trolls.

No need to say it.

Neil :)

by jardinier

A typical discussion at TR:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Revelation12_7_90.jpg

A typical discussion at meetchristians:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/LakeOfFire_80.jpg

I am not the least bit interested in the opinions of people who have nothing better to do with their time than make continual gibes at me. In fact this says more about the gibers than myself.

I am interested in the opinions of people who count, like Jay Garman who invited me to be a TR Insider based on his assessment of the overall quality of my threads and posts, or Jaqui who invited me to join a select group of people aiming to build a better mouse trap.

I have met (in cyberspace) many nice people at TR. These friendships are enduring and are based on mutual respect.

I have met some wankers who seem now to have joined together to form a new incestuous group of gibers.

I also have friends and foes at meetchristians.com Many people appreciate my threads and posts. I believe that I am making a positive contribution to that website by challenging people to examine more closely doctrines and views which they have perhaps taken for granted as being true.

As I have previously said, the discussions are far more constructive than many threads here at TR because the people stick to the topic.

TR, and the respectful members, have made a great contribution to my life. As for the gibers, well, gibe away if that is the only way you can get your rocks off.

by Member 25348569

The thoughts of a "wanker". Alas not even a unique "wanker" but just one "wanker" of an "incestuous group of gibers" that includes jdclyde! Oh! Oh! How the truth hurts.

O-kay...

"Gibe", the word of the day, is only a single syllable. Should we not ramp it up a bit to match the calibre of the "overall quality" of your threads and posts - and websites?

Can you spell "plagiarise", "copyright", "intellectual property"? No? OK, back it down a bit. Perhaps "pirate"? Maybe? "Rights", "steal"? Surely?

Certainly "word-for-word" is something that you understand. "Original"? Not that one.

Perhaps you don't like it when someone comes along and challenges YOU to "examine more closely doctrines and views which" you have perhaps "taken for granted as being true". Like the one that you are truly welcome on those Christian sites. Maybe, when all is said and done, they are just more tolerant than we are.

Neil :)

"Smug git" would be a good starting point for your comeback but I don't think you have the balls to mix it one on one. You certainly don't have the smarts.

Edit because my favourite Security person reckoned (correctly) that the second sentence didn't make sense (grammatically).

by Member 25348569

Do you KNOW how you come over?

Do you wonder why you find yourself attacked on all sides on this site? I suspect you ARE puzzled. I think that you feel aggrieved that you, your wonderful web sites and your Ethiopian "fianc?es" don't attract the recognition and acclamation that you think you deserve. I think that you are incandescent that you find yourself attracting the reverse.

If you were even half as good as you seem to think you are then some kudos might indeed attach to you. The problem is that if anyone chooses - and most do not - to dig deeper, you are not even half as good as you think you are.

Not even close.

Even being insulted by you is like being attacked by a dead sheep.

Neil :)

Allow me to quote Oscar Wilde "Some cause happiness wherever they go; others whenever they go."

Go.

by jdclyde

matter of fact, it wouldn't surprise me if the took things Neil posts here and copies them over to the Christian sites, pushing it off as his own work.

For his lack of being able to come up with ideas and then support them, it is amusing that he still considers himself a "journalist". But then again, journalists aren't what they used to be.

by jdclyde

Are the two words for people in Julians age bracket that selfishly even think about having a baby.

Will you be there when they graduate?

Will you be there when they get married?

Will you be there when they have their first kid?

A very selfish thing to do, bringing a child into the world that you will not be there for, just for your amusement and vanity.

I am quite a bit younger, but would never consider starting over with another child because children are not toys or trophies of attempts to prove your manhood, and if you are not there for them, it is a crime.

How sad, and slightly disturbing....

by charliespencer

She said it was about time, and maybe I'd quit whining at her.

Shouldn't there be some sort of wanker song? "I'm a wanker, he's a wanker, wouldn't you like to be a wanker too?" Oh, that's Dr. Pepper, isn't it?

by charliespencer

I just cleaned Monday and now I have to do it again. I hope you're happy.

Jackson Browne's 'Running on Empty' album was released around 1979 when I was 20. I didn't get the significance of the track 'Rosie' until last year.

by jellimonsta

I haven't heard that song since I was a kid. I always liked his song's, they are pretty damn funny when you are 10 years old I tell ya. Have you ever heard his song 'My Brothers Magazine'?

by jdclyde

and hadn't even heard the last few I posted until I went looking for a theme song for us! B-)

by john.a.wills

Come now, be honest, the Palestinians are one of the oldest nations around - they are referred to as a nation in the Gospel of John, they were the first majority-Jewish nation and, so far as I know, the first majority-Christian nation (the date is approximate, 200 AD, as it was by individual conversion that the nation changed, not by some king's ukase, as happened in Armenia in 301 AD).
And as for killing children, what do you think is going on in the West Bank?

by the scummy one

Palastine was never a nation -- Although Israel was.
Palastine was a name for a region, that had many different
controlling parties from Europeans to Egyptians. But the
Palestinian people have never had their own country/nation.

by john.a.wills

I think you are confusing different meanings of Israel, and in particular confusing the very distinct derivatives "Israel" and "Israelite".
Furthermore, the national rights of the Palestinians are independent of their current religion (they were majority-Christian for about a thousand years), and so are their personal property rights. I do not, by the way, believe very strongly in national rights, but they are bantered about.

by jamesrl

Google "alt.folklore.urban" and "songs about mast*&^%$!@#" and you find a list, including Rosie.

I knew about Rosie about 6 months after first hearing the album.

James

by john.a.wills

When the Romans sacked Jerusalem and destroyed the Temple, the Patriarch, or Chief Priest, received prmission from the Emperor to rebuild the Temple. But instead of setting up tents in Jerusalem and collecting money to rebuild the Temple brick by brick, as one might have expected, the Patriarchate stuck in Jamnia/Jabneh/Yavne for decades. The great council which formulated the list of books in the Rabbinical Jewish and crystallized the Rabbinical Jewish church (as opposed to the growing Christian church) was held at Jamnia, not Jerusalem, about 90 AD. Later the Patriarchate moved to various places in already-Christian Galilee, until a new Emperor dissolved it some time around 240 AD. So the Rabbinical Jewish interest in claim of the physical Jerusalem must have come later.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I was innocent once. That or so fried only half the brain was working in any given moment.