Discussion Locked

The rude employee

0 helpful
158 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a new job at a small state agency. It's a good job. All the users need is a little planning guidance. My problem is that I have an employee who has good work habits and adequate computer skills. He is out-right rude with some of the agency management and staff. I have had some verbal complaints that staff refuse to go the rude guy for help. I understand that he had the same problem at his previous job.

Any thoughts?

158 replies

by mjd420nova

Sounds like someone has to sit down with this person and be straight forward and explain what's going on. If that doesn't work, try putting to shoe on the other foot and reverse the situation. Maybe then they'll see the light. If that doesn't work then show him the door. It needs to be impressed on this individual that this type of behavior is unacceptable and will not be tolerated. PERIOD I've encountered the same with some people and reversing the tables was enough to make them get their affairs in order. However if it doesn't work, termination is the only resort unless you have a position where they aren't in contact with others, thereby avoiding the possible conflicts.

by stress junkie

I don't see the point of talking to a misbehaving employee. We're all adults. This person already knows that he is misbehaving. And I don't see the point of putting a misbehaving employee in a position where you can hide his malfeasant behavior. I do give an allowance for a single instance of misbehavior if it is out of character for the person. We all have a bad day now and then.

I say if the person makes a habit of misbehaving, if misbehavior is a normal part of their character, then just get rid of him. No coddling is required. No warnings are needed. That's like telling someone that they shouldn't write graffitti on the office walls. I think that we all already know that. It is stupid to have a meeting with the person and say stop doing this when everyone knows that the action is wrong. Show some leadership and just get rid of him.

by mjgunther

Well, there are often business regulations regarding dismissing an employee, both for fairness and to protect the employer from legal reprisals (getting their pants sued off for unfair dismissal).

I absolutely agree that that you and your company should not have to put up with or pay a salary to an employee who does not realize that courtesy is a job requirement. But *first*, the employee must be made explicitly aware of the courtesy expectations. CONSULT WITH YOUR HR/PERSONNEL GROUP for their requirements about verbal notice, written warnings, and your responsibilities for documenting them. This gives the misbehaving employee a final chance to shape up (hah!), and solid evidence that you have done your best to encourage improvement. (If the jerk is still within a probationary period, it's clear sailing!)

Cut this creep loose, but protect yourself, your department, and your company while doing so.

by tech.dan

[quote]No warnings are needed[/quote]
Wrong! Todays labor laws tell us we simply can not let someone go for this kind of attitude without any kind of previous warning. At least 3 warnings have to be given formally and in writing and signed by supervisor and employee. Even though your rude employee is being a jerk he still has many rights

by dallae7c

I have dealt with this type of situation, and the one recommendation I can make is document, document, document. If you can show that you have made multiple attempts to help this employee improve their disposition, you'll find it easier to get rid of them. Also, show how this employee is depleting the morale of the rest of the team. It's tough when you have someone who is talented technically, or does their job well, but its a package deal. You need to have a good balance. Good luck!

by sendbux

[quote] I don't see the point of talking to a misbehaving employee. We're all adults. [/quote]

Welp. Maybe I don't understand all of this, but I've been doing HR for a while:

1. "The point of talking to a misbehaving employee", if nothing else, is the investment YOUR EMPLOYER has in that employee, which is uniformly considerable. We don't throw away assets (there's a reason we call it "human RESOURCES") without at least having a good reason.

2. Didn't he say he was employed by some government? They have civil service rules tht would choke a horse. I hope never to have to cope with HR in that environment, where the civil servant's job is actually considered a PROPERTY RIGHT that can be enforced!

3. If I can take a misbehaving employee and make him or her into a good employee, then I have done my job. If I can't, I try to learn from the experience so as to do better next time.

4. If the situation is hopeless, and there are no civil service considerations, then as others have said, document, document, document. Then fire. In California, at least, in this situation the employer is going to have to pay into their unemployment insurance account on this one, documented or not.

by uglycelt

We spend too much time concerned with keeping ppl happy.
Warn him, then dump him

by wayne m.

I can't say it better than mjd420nova did. To reiterate:

1) Immediately sit down and talk to the problem employee. Explain the situation and the consequences if it continues. Define an action plan and a date for a re-evaluation.

2) Monitor the situation and discuss changes with the employee. Early on, this may need to be daily. Be sure to acknowledge all postivie changes. Expect that, as with any newly learned behavior, there will be some backsliding. Acknowledge these incidents as well.

3) At the stated review date, if there has not been substansive improvement, follow through with the state consequences, i.e., transfer or termination. If there has been noticeable improvement, establish a new plan and review date for continued improvement. At this point, however, less day-to-day oversight is necessary, though any significant and prolonged backsliding will need to be dealt with.

As a supervisor/manager you have responsibilities to both your staff and whomever your staff interacts with. You cannot ignore either one. It is not enough to say that your staff are adults and to let them go if they fail to meet your standards, but it is also not enough to ignore their actions. Dealing with a difficult employee is never enjoyable, but it is a necessary, high priority task. Good luck.

by uplinkspider

Great advice - here's my take.

In my many years of management experience I have as of yet come across a rude employee (by nature) that was able to be successfully rehabilitated. On occasion you may have an employee loose grip of her/his composure (it happens) but the employee in question here is the habitual abuser. Much like a malicious code embedded into a program at the very least (by keeping her/him in check) it will rob your system of resources and if you?re the one damned to approach this individual you?re definitely inviting eternal resentment which will lead to counter politicking and maybe even sabotage and if you?re able to keep her/him in check think of the continued investment in resources spent over time ? not worth it. At the very least this person may be a stumbling block and at worst case scenario cost you your position or career. There are three basic triggers that justify termination; 1) Stupidity 2) incompetence and 3) corruption. The first two, stupidity and incompetence, may be effectively managed without termination if the recourses are available ? stupidity can be contained; there are many people with prized skills and work ethics that simply make stupid decisions but if we are able to contain them and safe guard them from hurting themselves and the company then you?re able to continue benefiting from their knowledge base and skill sets. As stupidity - incompetence can also be dealt with with education and training, again if the resources and time are available. On the other hand corruptibility is what the corrupt does and without a personal life changing experience the corrupt will remain corrupt. You can try containing the corrupt and the corrupt will seek ways of working around, under, over or through the containment ? you can try education and training and the corrupt will find an antidote. If you?re in the position of authority and have the support of HR and management then elect to terminate. On the other hand if you can?t stomach termination or an underlining conflict exist (the boss?s bother) then, to avoid a potential land mine, push for a collective intervention. Upon seeing that there?s a unified front this individual will find it difficult to seek support from peers (real or perceived) and won?t be able to single you out as the enemy - frustrated she/he may leave on his own accord.

Best of luck,

/\o/\

by blue-knight

I had an employee that was good technically but passive-aggressive rude. The little 'digs' etc. After being put on notice, I had him in is own words write - "What are the rights of a computer user. What can a user expect when the computer guy comes by". His responce supplied enough to get him fired. (I had tried to fire him and HR down graded it to a probation.)

Being fired can help people to change and I hope he improves as a result.

by nohablapc

We work in a government agency too and their a thing called seniority! When you get to a certain point in your career you're pretty much untoucable. The supervisor has to document exactly what is happening and discuss the issues with the employee and also include HR. It's very touchy situation. It has to be done and documented over time before any action can be taken. Our situation is improving....on some days. We wish you luck!

by vivekgana

I was hired as a consultant in one of the top Newyork financial firm named after New York mayor. On a first day Project manager introduced other consultant who is a tech lead for a particular project. I was given a first assignment on open source project, tech lead did not even know basis of open source library and showing some crappy solutions to fix issues on a second day, I engaged in technical argument and proved him he wasn't right several times, told him problem is very tough, need more time. On a contrary he told project lead that I was competent, arguable and hard to deal. They did not even talk to talk to me to discuss and fired me on 4th day of assignment? Can I take any legal action against this team?

by gralfus

She is openly rude, confrontational, demeaning, and generally a pain in the sphincter. But the boss (also a female) likes her. She has threatened to sue if she is fired, and I don't think upper mgmt really cares about her attitude as long as she does her job. I get to support her computer problems. Not that the computer really has problems, but she is so monolithically bullheaded that a minor misunderstanding of MS Word gets blown into apocalyptic proportions, and I'm an idiot that can't understand the issue and why isn't it fixed already, and why am I wasting her time with this crap, and get her someone who knows what he's doing.

Whee. Want fries with that, you stupid b#tch? I swear, there is no one around here that even approaches her level of offensiveness. I hate working with "golden children" that can't be fired.

by stress junkie

Everybody likes to talk about filing a lawsuit if this or that happens. I remember when I was a little kid we would threaten a lawsuit whenever something happened that we didn't like. Either that or we'd put the other person in the hospital. Neither threat ever happened. I wonder how those ideas even occurred to eight year olds. Must've gotten it from someplace. Probably some idiot parents.

The theory that has been expressed to me many times behind large bureaucratic organizations hesistating to get rid of bad employees is the threat of a lawsuit. What a load of c--p. Actually I've got a theory. I call it The Theory of The Hired Gun. This applies to your situation, gralfus.

You see, there are some managers that would like to be mean and rude, but don't want to be considered mean and rude. So, they hire someone that will do their dirty work. They get to see people being treated badly without being blamed. Everyone always says something like "I don't know why the manager puts up with . The manager is such a nice person." Well, maybe the manager is really a sociopath that exercises his/her dysfunction by proxy through the bad employee.

I've seen this in numerous situations. It is too common to think that it is just a coincidence. So, gralfus, your real problem is the manager that "likes" the rude employee. She is really on the same team as the employee that causes problems. They work together to create a hostile work environment.

Systems analysis doesn't just apply to computers.Social groups are also systems.

by projectcoach

Sadly "unfair dismissal" laws in the UK mean that you need to be very careful when sacking someone. There is a formal sequence of steps you need to go with if you are not to run the risk of a claim for unfair dismissal.

One of my friends, a Senior HR sepcialist, recommends clients pay off a claimant up to ?4-6000 to end potential legal action, as this will be cheaper than the cost of even a successful defence.

Some employees can claim legal aid or get no-win no-fee assistance. It usually costs very little to make a claim. There have been recent attempts to charge costs to claimants who launch what are called "vexatious" claims I believe, but I'm not sure how they went.

And this is no urban myth. I personally know of a sales rep who was called in to a disciplinary interview for fiddling her expenses. She waited in the car park afterwards and attempted to run over her manager in the company car.

She was of course dismissed, but won a claim and compensation for unfair dismissal because the company had not followed correct procedure.

It's a mad, sad but true world sometimes.

by irogerk

In Gov,yes is common.
(not usually found in the private sector),
Rudeness is a tool used to coverup activitie's one should not be doing.
Is sad, but iv'e seen this many times.
Best you "hunker down" and CYA til he's cought, cought he will, just takes time/persistance.
Hang in there, retirement benifments are best to keep.

by j.g.camp

I don't know whether it's a real situation or not, that is are the one's complaining, are they the one's that are trying to get the "rude" employee to do their work for them ? You'd be surprised who doesn't know how to use MS Office beyond simple data entry skills. In that case, I don't blame the guy for being rude, he's probably just standing firm and making the complainer/whiner try to do something on their own for a change. There's an awful lot of people that'll watch the clock for you too, even though they aren't your supervisor or boss.

by chaz chance#

If you want to change this person's behaviour, you must find out what is behind it.

Nobody wants people to dislike them, so nobody deliberately behaves in a way that will cause dislike. Behaviour like this is caused by something that is making them so unhappy, which they feel powerless to do something about, that the unhappiness leaks out in their interactions with other people. If you get to know them, you may be able to get them to open up to you. Then you may be able to help them deal with it.

If you can't be bothered doing that, but you just want to get on with them, you must behave like an adult. When they are rude to you, say clearly and firmly "That's very rude" or "Don't be so rude to me". If they are agressive say "Stop bullying me". When they realise that they are having an effect on other people, it makes them stop and re-assess their behaviour.

Putting up with their behaviour makes you a victim. Complaining to their boss makes you a whiner and a victim. Retaliating makes you a child and a victim.

When a boss, who had haressed a colleague so much that he took early retirement to get away, became my line manager, I was really worried. I had been really badly bullied at school, and for all I knew I was still an easy mark for bullys. The first time the guy had a go at me, I looked directly in his eyes and said in a loud, firm voice, "don't bully me". His attitude changed at once. He began treating everyone better, with respect. From that point on he treated me as a friend, right up to the day he left.

And I guess I was a friend to him, by pointing out the thing he needed to know, where change was needed. Only a friend would do that.

by maevinn

I don't know tha no one wants to be disliked or though poorly of, but I do know that a number of people simply lack the social skills required to manuever through a work environment without coming across as unpleasant. Some people can learn the social skills, some people can not.

However--I heartily agree that identifying the behavior and not accepting it is a good move. Both from the boss and the co-workers. I try those approaches before resorting to work-arounds. If the co-workers don't confront this individual about his behavior, the manager is going to be hard pressed doing so successfully.

by gentlerf

Something I have seen here is a lack of awareness of a possible disability. There is a disabling condition called Asperger's Syndrome which affects primarily male humans and was once called "High functioning Autism". Asperger's does affect social skills learning as the sufferer does not know or understand the social cues for a "socially responsible" response. It just might be cheaper in the long run for this individual to have a company sponsered screening for the syndrome. In fact, Wired Magazine had a 50 question test in the December 2001 issue which could be a pre-screen for diagnosis. A neuro-typical (normal) will score on average a 16 on the test. Many diagnosed and undiagnosed Asperger's sufferers score over 32. If the individual who inspired the initial article in this thread could be challenged to take the Wired test, it might wake him up to smell the coffee.

by jennya_d

I agree completely with Wayne M.

So my advice is, please as a manager try to understand the character of other people and the reasons they don?t feel comfortable or rude. Of course if the character is rude nothing could be done, than to explain that you keep other kind of treatment between each other. Other case it is much easier because it is a question of misunderstandings and it is better to clarify it on time.

by problemsolversolutionseeker

I had the, um, privilege of telling someone in a design meeting yesterday to 'back off, you are being offensive'. Went over like a lead balloon. Got pulled into the office later by my manager; thought I was going to get a lecture, but instead received support.

Anyway...
It is possible that someone is going on in that person's life. Get to know him a little.

Having said that - if you are level headed, punch back! If not, remember, there is more than one way to skin a cat. Drunken Monkey, kindness, alternating passive and aggressive responses, prayer, confusion, Jedi, may the force be with you, mind meld, donuts, have lunches but forget to invite him, sic a couple of catty women on him. My wife calls them 'my bag of tricks'.

Oops. I am in a mood. Oh, yes, I forgot. Smile and have a great sense of humor!

by homer4598

I don't think the person was saying that it is an Urban Myth that an employee will sue, but rather that the "fear of lawsuit" was just an excuse by a manager who really likes (and backs) the abusive employee.

The U.S. has laws too, which is why one of the replies correctly stated to speak with the employee, set a plan to correct the problem, monitor, document, then fire if necessary. I've seen companies sued many times. In fact, one an employee I terminated sued the company stating that I was discriminating against her because she was pregnant. Unfortunately for her, I documented the problems AND one of her co-workers was pregnant as well -- I didn't terminate that person.

by greg o

Even though the US has quite a few federal laws, this type of scenario is usually handled at the state level. Here in Florida "at-will" employment is common, meaning when you're hired, you usually sign a statement saying there is no binding contract of employment and either side can terminate the employment "without cause" as long as its not done discriminately. The boss can walk up to you any day & just say "This isn't working out. We're letting you go." He does not have to justify himself or the company. No documentation is required saying why you're fired, or that you've been counseled and given opportunities to improve, etc. You can still sue the employer for wrongful termination, but the burden of proof to even get it heard in court is totally on you. You would have to show overt discrimination, an extremely hostile work environment, or similar. Very tough but seems to work quite well here.

On the flip side, as an HR & IT manager, I know what it costs to terminate & replace an employee. I almost always recommend trying to correct an employee's performance instead of replacing them, due to the costs involved. If supervisors and mid-level managers are doing their jobs of giving feedback to employees on how they're doing on a regular basis, not on an annual evaluation, then these scenarios a very rare. When they do, its almost always a management problem. Co-workers often compound the situation by NOT talking to management enough about it, or going to the next level if the problem is mid-level. If a manager hears enough complaints from enough people, eventually it will sink in there is a real problem that needs attention. Just my $.02 as every company has its own environment & culture.

by aj051804

So you are saying at-will employees have no rights and that employer decided one day that she does not like you and she can just terminates you?

by tony hopkinson

How, I've never heard something so stupid in all my life.

What do they call leaving places like this manumission?

by homer4598

I work in one too. However, you still need to document everything so that you aren't sued for some kind of discrimination. Every company that I've worked for has required the documentation before terminating an employee. I've seen many people sue the company claiming some kind of discrimination. In every case where there was not enough documentation of the poor performance, attempts at corrective action, etc., the company settled out of court to save themselves the hassle.

by riotsquirrl

The rude behavior may be a sign of current or developing mental illness. I worked with a young man who was so rude to callers on our help desk that I'd cringe every time he got a call. He point-blank refused to learn the skills I'd been assigned to teach him. I was dismayed, but this was a "body shop" government contract and management was more concerned about replacing him than how he treated the customers. After all, they always doctored the numbers so the customer looked satisfied.

Finally he sought help for his mental problems. He informed HR, and from then on the contracting company was terrified to do anything as it was already a frequent defendent in a number of high-profile employment-related lawsuits (partly due to its size and partly due to its exploitative and greedy practices). Finally the young man left for another job where he was promptly dismissed after his probationary period.

by dsusysmgr

It does not take long until the tendency to not work with Mr Rude, extends to general dissatisfaction with you and your department. Save your self! Either stick him where he can do his job with out interacting with the users, or follow your HR procedures to get rid of him, while it can still make a difference in the way users relate to you and the dept.

by jdclyde

The guy had no social skills, poor hygene, and really creeped the women out the way he would look at them.

He found himself locked in a room all day. A computer would break, someone would go grab it and give it to mr. anti-socal who would then fix it. When it was done, someone would take the system back.

He was eventually let go because the bosses finally decided they didn't need to take abuse from an employee either.

Distance yourself from this person!

by vwest1

Have you verbally discussed his problem? If yes, & no improvement then the next step is to make him verbally apologize to the individual(s) to which he was rude & a written apologize. Once he has to face up to his faults, he will soon find that he doesn't like doing that & will quit the job or will try to quit being rude or you'll have to write him up till he's terminated. You can't help those that don't want to help themselves. Either work together or get out. Good Luck.

by tony

Unfortunately most managers tend to sweep things like this under the rug due to long time loyalty, affordable pay or talent niche. What they don't realize (choose to ignore) are the negative effects that ripple throughout the team and company.

by leonard j rivera sr.

It's time for a sit down. Almost a psuedo interview. You don't want to accuse the employee of anything, what you do want to get is this employee to tell you basically what they like and dislike about their job. Find out if something is bothering them. If the employee brings up the topic or if you feel the need, you can discuss the reports of "rudeness" without naming anyone.

Whether or not your emplyee accepts it as fact or fiction, you can exaplain that it is the perception of your customer base that is causing this and you need this employee to adjust.

Perhaps give some pointers yourself without targeting actual flaws. Use your best communications skills to get this person to understand that there is a negative image people are experiencing and it is having a negative impact on the environment.

Be clear, be factual, be precise but most of all be nice. If this person exhibits the same "rudeness" towards you, then you can use that as a "classic example" scenario.

The end goal is to come to a working agreement with this employee, a career goal or path to improved performance. Set your expectations clearly and come to an agreement on how to meet them. Don't forget to let this person know that you require a change.

You'll have to surf this one according to your own management skills to see where you can lean a little harder and where you need to let up a little but the end result needs to be what your expectations are for this person to perform their duties and what the consequences are. Then make a deal and stick to your guns. this doesn't have to be a do or die situation, give it an escalation path with the absolute end (no improvement shown after amount of reports or amount of months or what ever) then casually follow up with the user community to see if there is progress, schedule regular meetings along the way with this employee to see how they are doing.

Encourage the positive, and on the negative, remind this individual of "The Deal" and "The consequences." In the end, you will end up with the type of employee you really want or really don't want and you can take it from there.

Hope that helps, this isn't a golden rule, just some advise, take it for what it's worth, you may agree with some of this or not or all of it. Either way, different people need different management in different cases, ultimately it's up to you to get this person to improve if that is indeed your desire. Give it a shot, it won't hurt and if not for anything else, you should come out knowing a bit more about this person and what you really need to do.

by tony

I see this with a lot of companies I work with and it has forever been a mystery. Coping with people like this is merely a bandaid to what the real decision is - three strikes and you're out. I don't care how good an employee is, if he or she can't get along with others and is miserable to work with, why can't they just be let go? It boggles the mind...there will be other employees to fill the void, ones that can be embraced and genuinely liked by others.

by beoweolf

The difference may be minor, but could explain the complaints.

I have been in situations where some staff members had come to expect concessions (in use of employee time, skills or attention) which were not part of the job skill neither set nor offered to all staff. While it may be a fact of office politics that a little butt-kissing is offered, it still sets a bad precedent when some follows guidelines and enforces documented policy. A strict interpretation of policy may be inconvenient, as well as easily mis-interpreted as being "rude".

It is good to have a smooth running office, workplace ... but to characterize efficiency or possibly reserved character traits as rudeness is unfair. I trust, as the manager of this individual, you have listened to "both" sides of the complaint? There are few Neanderthals still roaming the earth, example: some men who were chivalrous, open doors, lift heavy packages, offer complements to females - have become confused in how to react to current unwritten aspects of social interaction. As such the niceties have become a casualty of casual day-to-day interaction.

So, the question is whether the "rudeness" rises to the level of "hostility" or aura of refusal to perform within the guidelines of his positions. The issue "may" not be the employee. Your intervention may be an attempt to apply pressure, force the employee to bend the rules or operate outside his own comfort zone.

Be careful how you react; facts are actionable, perceptions are or can be/ should be managed. In documented cases where the employee is hostile, you should intervene; have HR suggest anger management classes or you take the time to explain how his current behavior is being perceived. At the same time, get to the bottom of why they feel he is being rude, is this a common perception; or is it localized to a certain definable groups of employees? The answer to that question may lead you to what actions, if any, you should take as well as where the actual problem lies.

by webwrkr

The existence of the rude employee isn't new to business.
They've been around since the beginning of business itself.
When you have to deal with a person who is openly rude or
hostile to others, make a plan on how to deal with it and ensure
that you are being fair to all parties involved. There are always
two sides to the story.

Prior to beginning this process it's a good idea to speak with
your HR department to get up to date information on what
options you have within the scope of your company's policies.
Aside from clarification in your plan of action, also determine
how much time you can appropriately spend on this issue. You
don't want to be consumed with one issue as you probably have
tons of other obligations as well. A rude employee shouldn't
dominate all of your mental time or the time you need to spend
doing your other tasks or dealings with your non-problematic
employees.

Part of this plan should include speaking to the employee in a
non-threatening way and also speaking to his/her coworkers to
see if they are experiencing the same issues. I have found in
several cases that one employee reports another as rude or
hostile, but that they are the only one that sees it this way.
Again, be fair and do your research. Let the chips fall where
they may.

When you meet with the allegedly hostile employee, document
what you discussed, document your recommendations and be
sure that the employee understands what you're asking them to
do. Set a review date to follow up with the employee and
monitor the behavior in the office/department to see if you can
observe any changes.

At the review, document whether the employee has made
progress or not, give them some recommendations and set
another review date. Your goal is to do this enough times that
you either assist the employee in modifying their behavior or
satisfy your HR depertment's documentation requirements for
termination.

Finally, don't allow the "threat" of a lawsuit dissuade you from
doing the right thing. The right thing in this case is to identify
the problem, help the employee take corrective action or
terminate him/her and fill the seat with someone who wants to
do the job and can get along with others. If you've followed
your HR department guidelines there is no real "threat" in a
lawsuit.

by newby7718

Most companies or agencies have policies that promote a productive workplace free of harassment which includes shouting and abusive language and demands respect for authority by following the established chain of command. Learn to use the policy.

I inherited an employee that fits the personality and skills that you described. He constantly lost his temper and angered our Director's, bringing discredit to my department and other staff members. He also tried to micromanage and intimidate his peers.

To regain control, I had to use our progressive discipline plan which gives him a verbal notice of policy violation and insubordination -- documented in writing -- and a written notice with an improvement plan agreement. The next step was suspension without pay and finally termination.

After the written notice, our employee realized that he was wrong and started complying with the improvement plan. All I had to do is monitor his actions and work with him to let him know his progress -- or lack thereof.

Today, a year later, you can tell by his expression that he is still angered occassionally, but he has amazingly learned to control his actions. His anger quickly turns to a smile and cooperative mode.

It is amazing what good policy, a little counciling, and lot of effort on a manager's part can do make a problem employee a great employee.
If the employee is as skilled and concensious as you indicate, that employee is worth the time and effort it takes to mentor the employee through anger management.

by jck

No people skills on the job.

When asked a question, he would answer rudely if he thought it was stupid.

Yep...warn and give a chance to clean up his act...document any other infractions...dump if he persists....good plan someone mentioned.

by tig2

Misinterpret my technical team's approach as "rude". In working through that, I discovered that "rude" was defined as "talking down" or "acting superior". What I knew about the person was that it was a self defense mechanism.

I talked with both parties. We all agreed that it was important to maintain positive behaviour in the workplace. We also agreed that personal traits are exactly that- personal. My tech agreed to make an effort to try a better interpersonal approach, the other staff person was willing to provide positive feedback and be more understanding. In the end, that staff person became a real advocate for the technical staff.

When i hear complaints of rudeness, I have to ask myself what is REALLY happening. If I see rudeness displayed, I take the offending person into a private space and discuss how they are coming across. In most cases, the individual simply has no idea of how they are being perceived.

Of course, if it is a continuing issue, more definitive action is required.

by vjbrown6925

Joe, The Labor Laws differ from state to state. As Op Mgr of a large employee leasing company, I have the priviledge of working with a variety of personalities. Most state agencies have a protocol that is to be followed when dealing with it's worker's. Regardless, they should follow the State Labor Laws. Private employers sometimes have more latitude than state agencies is terminating employees. Check with your state labor commissioner or the HR department for your rules. In my experience as a former state worker and manager, sometimes the rude behavior is not work related at all, it comes from personal issues. Stick to the facts of the case and keep any personal feelings out of the issue. Good Luck.

by tchard

Most Governmental agencies will have personnel policies in-place for dealing with employees whose personalities don't 'mesh' with the rest of the crew, or your customers.
Work ethic and habits notwithstanding, if someone's in a 'customer-facing' position, courtesy and respect are almost equally important as technical skills.
"Plays-well-with-others" comes to mind here. It's time this person got a "report card" of his/her performance, and has the offense(s) documented.
When you've gathered the requisite amount of documentation, cut'im loose!

by menace65

Hrm, that's a very telling statement right there. Seems to me this is more of the same behaviour by someone who doesn't want to change. Obviously, it does need to be researched further, to ascertain exactly what the issues are. If the same complaints were lodged, and he had been spoken to previously about this same behaviour, it's time for him to hit the bricks. I have seen one person's behaviour bring down the morale of a whole department because it was tolerated by management. Good luck.

by stress junkie

Regarding the investment of the employer in the employee, you fail to take into account the same investment times five or ten or twenty in the employees who work with the malfeasant person. The bad employee brings everyone else down. People hesitate to approach the rude employee when business tasks require it. That adds inefficiency. The rude employee demoralises the people around them. That creates situations where people sit around thinking about how they have to do something with this rude employee rather than actually doing the job. The other employees in the department are subjected to unnecessary stress just by having to deal with this employee. The entire operation of the department suffers because of this one person.

That's not even taking into consideration the human element of the other employees. The rude employee creates confusion with the good employees. They see this malfeasant jerk apparently getting away with their behavior and feel that there is an injustice being pertetrated on them. They wonder if their own contribution of being approachable and team oriented is a mistake.

And, people do not change. You cannot reform a bad employee. You're letting your messianic ego cloud your decisions. You want to feel like Jesus in the work place, redeeming the unredeemable, healing the unhealable, and basically thinking of yourself as a god. You are just as much a liability as the rude employee because you are an enabler. You permit the rude employee to continue in his behavior while you try to work your redemptive magic. You will fail. Even if you initially appear to have succeeded the bad employee will, over time, backslide to the point that they think that they can get away with their sociopathic behavior. They know that managers get tired of trying to redeem them. Eventually the good employees that complain about the bad one will be considered 'persona non gratis' for continuing to complain. Your approach only entrenches the bad employee and secures their place in the organization.

by jupiter9

You seem to want a ten-second solution to a twenty-year problem. That doesn't happen very often in real life.

I've seen things that don't jibe with your view of problem employees. People go from good to bad and vice versa. People who work with bad employees sometimes do like them personally and wish they would straighten up. People who go from bad employee to good employee often feel better about themselves and don't backslide -- if they're not allowed to.

And few managers think they are gods; mostly we think we're imperfect, struggling with difficult situations and hoping we don't screw up too badly when we have to make a decision.

The points of the previous posts have been:

1. It may not be legal or wise to fire someone without warning. This means you have to DOCUMENT the person's shortcomings. If previous managers haven't been doing this, that was their failing.

2. You must give people a chance to reform. This is only fair. When the person's job is on the line, s/he may change. I have seen it happen both ways.

3. If the person does not reform, *the person is then dismissed.* That is in total contradiction to your statement that the procedure only "entrenches the bad employee."

The previous posters were not saying never get rid of the person. Just that you have to follow a procedure.

Chances are that the problem has been around for a while and the person never got challenged on the problem behavior. Managers generally don't enjoy firing people.

The employee's expectations have been implicitly set by the manager and the workplace. If the employee has not been warned or reprimanded, his or her performance is deemed acceptable by the employer by default.

by londongal

First time I've ever posted a reply here - I was 'inspired' by this tale that is very close to home for me.

I agree that too often managers forget that the rude person is just one employee and they have to think about everyone else forced to put up with this person. I have been in a situation where I had to work with a rude bully and was told by my (and his) boss to just swear back at him. The bully was very smart technically and used this to scare management so they didn't dare get rid of him in case they lost vital information. So before you get rid of your problem, make sure he isn't hoarding information that you'll miss when he's gone. If you can't do this, I'm sure it will still be easier to pick up the pieces than to handle the mass unrest in your area.

Saying that, it might be worth asking what is frustrating this person, because rudeness doesn't come from nowhere. Most likely they are just frustrated in life generally and you won't be able to change that, but there may be some issues that can be tackled that will leave them happier in themselves. As others have said though, you can't afford to spend all your time focusing on this one person, and while trying to help them I think you have to make clear that their behaviour is unacceptable.

by stress junkie

Everyone here is always happy to hear a new voice. :-)

One thing that I really like about the TR discussions is that you can say things here that you want to say in work. And, having said something you can see what other people think. I find it very therapeutic and occassionally educational. :-)

by uglycelt

Most of us don't have time to analyse employees let alone to try to help them (espec. if they are rude !! )
Easier in the long run to dismiss

by aaron a baker

Of welcoming you to our Tech Republic Family.
There are a lot of really great people here and as you go along, you'll get to know them better and better. The beauty is the more you discover about them, the more you like them. I sure do.
We are truly good hearted individuals and cover a wide range of Computer interests, from Rebuilding to Programming to IT Work.
If I may, I would suggest the following.
"Never" allow yourself to feel that your question might be to immature or silly to ask for fear of being laughed at. Rest assured, that is Not our way.
No question is trivial and neither are the people who write in. We hold no one cheaply.
We take the questions very seriously and answer in accordance.
So Please;
Be Welcome and come back often.
Welcome Home Londongal. ;)
May your stay be a lengthy one.
Regards
Aaron :)

by uplinkspider

Yes! Somebody who knows what he?s talking about. As supervisors and managers it is not our job to reform employees. We orientate, we train, we set standards and enforce policy, which most are set in place for mutual wellbeing, we monitor, report, etc but we are not physiologists, we don?t psycho analyses employees and we?re not redeemers. This has been a common fault among many supervisors and managers and not once have I seen it work. As I mentioned in a previous post, the stupid and incompetent you can contain and educate but a bad program you have to delete.

by jrh300

I work for state government (not in IL, though), and we have a program for free counseling services for all employees. I would imagine that Illinois has something similar. If the original poster is the supervisor, he can suggest the counseling services to the employee. There should also be letters of expectation that are given to the employee, and signed by both supervisor and employee. If the position is union, good luck! At times, it takes an act of Congress to fire sometimes! As others have said, document, document, document.

by x-marcap

I record many service calls on my MP3 palyer to document my activities for weekend support. After enduring flying F bombs from a construction supervisor in the field, I told him I was forwarding him on to my Supervisor. I had him on tape and I let him know exactly what was going on.

If I hadn't had my MP3 player, I would have been fired. I was professional and had just told someone something they didn't want to hear. "It's a PC, you need to reboot." (I can't reboot I won't be able to commit my time report). "You have lost your wireless connection, You should re-establish connection, and to do that you will need to reboot." (@)(*#$)(*@# You!!!)

I was told that it was illegal to record this fellow without telling him. I pointed out I am in Ohio and there was no need to tell him, and that I could record the conversation legally. I was asked to destroy the .wav file, which I did from my Company PC, but not from my personal MP3 player. When the complaint came up at my review, I tagged the file to the review and returned it to upper management.

Without evidence, I would have taken the pipe up alongside the noggin. As it was, I substituted someone else's head for mine in the path of the swing...

by stress junkie

I think that joe.woodward@... is talking about someone whose default everyday behavior is to be verbally violent to everyone. In your case you were not guilty of the accusation. But, more importantly to this conversation, even if you had been guilty of one incident that would not put you in the class of people that we're talking about. Everyone has a bad day. Employers are wise to overlook an uncharacteristic incident and in my experience they generally do. That's good for everyone and for the business itself. It is good for employee morale if they know that a single indiscrete act will not cost them their job. And if someone does have a bad moment in business and it is not held against them then that person will often be somewhat grateful that the business management allows for people to be human.

This conversation is really about sociopaths. People who are vicious to everyone every day with no provocation.

So, you weren't guilty in the first place and even if you were it would have been unreasonable for your employer to terminate your employment for uncharacteristic behavior. Unless you punch the CEO in the nose. That might not be overlooked so easily. :-)

by x-marcap

Emphasis on the mean. I had 36 hours at 10:00 A.M.
We routinely work 10 -15 hour days on Salary. Older people have been forced out of the company (involuntary retirement) as soon as they hit ~50. If you don't have 30 years with the company where thsy will cover retirement bennies to age 65. 75 points is mandatory for retirement 1 for each year of age and two for each year of service. At 55 with 10 years of service you get 15% anual salary for example. at 30 years you get 40% salary.

The company is very close to systematically eliminating those who will be qualified to get the 75 points but be more than 5 years away from retirement.

I took a lower paying job to get the better retirement. I see the pattern, I keep my head low. I try to keep a low profile...

I see the blood in the water, but I keep my skills sharp and make ertain I am on everything new that comes out if I can help it...

by hendry_betts

Dan, et al.

There are states in which work is a privilege and not a right. In Georgia (in particular and others I am aware of) you can be terminated at any time for any reason as long as it is not a proven issue of discrimination. It is a "right-to-work" state. Having said that, government agencies are different from the states themselves because they are just that, government. Everyone so far has given sound advice. I will just restate

Counsel, Document, Counsel, Document, Counsel, Document and then if nothing changes -- dismiss.

Cheers

by rndmacts

You are a new manager and you have an employee who people complain is rude. Are these same people willing to put their complaint in writing so that you can bring it to his attention.

In the 80's I was probably considered the rude guy in a government agency, my job was to usher in personal computers to the staff. Most of the staff was using VT100 terminals at the time and as they received a personal computer were required to attend a training session for half a day to learn the differences. Most of the secretaries and the clerical staff came in and picked up the booklet provided and then proceeded to use the systems without training or reading the booklet. Then in the following weeks would barrage me with problems that they created by not reading the information or attending the sessions. At that time IT support was low man on the totem pole not much more than the mail delivery guy. I had two secretaries that would constantly call that they had lost their documents, no matter how many times I tried to show them how to save to the central server, they would misfile their documents. I got tired of dropping something else more important to run to their aid and locate the missing documents and again show them how to file.

At last my manager called me in to tell me that I was recieving complaints, and when he listened to my side of the story went to the two secretaries bosses to reveal how they were repeatedly calling for the same issue and disrupting our rollout of new PCs to other employees.

My advice to you is talk to the employee and apprise him of the fact that you are receiving complaints. Get his side of the story to explain his surliness. If he can not give a good accounting for his behavior inform him that you are going to document the discussion and place it on his personnel file. Usually this entails a letter signed by both you and the employee with a review period set. If the employee does not improve his behavior then you have the right to approach HR and request councelling for the employee, with the beginnings for dismall for just cause being filed.

As I have been a Union officer, I can tell you these are the proper steps under any Union agreement or state agreement to terminate an employee for just cause.

My biggest point to you is not to get stressed about this employee but to talk to him and get his side of the complaint. Many managers will transfer an employee as being rude without finding out that the complainant might be the one who is the problem. You say the employee has good work habits, what is it about him that leads you to believe that he is intentionally rude. I know that to a lot of people I appear standoffish and rude but it is not my fault, I do suffer from a physical disability that makes it difficult for me to read body language in others and not know how to respond (I don't smile naturally) I am also painfully shy in public situations. I have had bosses who have understood this and others who didn't, so my career in the public service was up and down. Most of my bosses also realised that I didn't suffer fools lightly, so didn't send me on call dealing with them.

by colonel panijk

Definitely have a chat with him in a NON-THREATENING manner. Discover what makes him tick. It's entirely possible that he has a condition like Asperger Syndrome (a form of High Function Autism). People like that have a very difficult time picking up on verbal and non-verbal social cues given by other people. They're technically brilliant but socially clueless. He may be trampling all over other people's boundaries and not have the faintest idea that he's doing it. He may not realize that he's offending other people with what seems to him to be perfectly reasonable and rational behavior.

So, try the carrot before you try the stick. Of course, this guy may simply be an S.O.B. prick, and you'll be unable to reform his behavior and will have to eventually get rid of him (after following due procedure). Good Luck!

by x-marcap

He has a medical issue at that point, the technical needs must be balanced. (I have a 9 year old with Autism. My seven year old was talking at one- 14 months and eventually 9 year old started talking at 3 & 1/2...)

He also, if medical condition may be put on SSI...

I would have him evaluated by competent medical personnel.

by mc_user

At a former company I worked for I expereinced two examples of this problem.

The first was an executive secretary who had an attitude a foul mouth and a lot of contact with the public. She was also good at her job. The company owners and HR were able to openly discuss the problem with her and eventually sent her to a classes on protocol and manners. This was enough to maker her realize there was a problem. She came out of it a better secretary and a pleasent voice on the phone. She sometimes reverts back to her her old ways, but only in private and amongst close freinds and workers.

The second was an african american lady we hired for IT. I trained her to work the midnight shift maintaining a mainframe. Duties were easy, spend most of time printing large reports from programs that run all night long and then start the automated backups. She was a nightmare, constantly late for her shift and a couple of times not showing up at all. Not even a call in sick. Work that should have been completed in the middle of the night did not get done. We knew she had a problem but she was a female minority working in IT. The company did not want to let her go. I spend a week with her at her shift on the pretense of training for some new procedures. It did not help. She was finally fired when a upper level manager came in one morning to look for a report he needed and found her sleeping. Not just sleeping at her desk but, streched out on a table with a pillow. As a final blow she said she would file a discrimination lawsuit for being let go. It never happened. (we later found out she was stealing lunches from the company fridge, items from their desks and even used the owners private bathroom.)

I guess the moral is that if you value the employee give them every chance to change. You could get a bettter employee for it. Don't automatically go to the firing option until you have exhausted all options.

by x-marcap

A wise man once stated: Once you eliminate the impossible, the result, no matter how improbable is all that is left.

by egeezer

It sounds like at least part of the employee's job is supporting internal customers. I'd make sure the job description included, in addition to providing support, maintaining customer satisfaction.

Then I'd make sure the employee had customer sat in his performance plan, and communicate to him that complaints would negatively impact evaluations and resulting compensation and career opportunities.

by achen2

As a student in management you need to follow standard protocol. Sit down and talk to him about his situation. After each discussion DOCUMENT what you have discussed in your conversation. Next you hand down a documented FINAL verbal warning with termination as the last resort. This will in turn make him wake up in the situation so that he can not do this to others.

Should you terminate the employee ensure that you document on his employee record for the state about his performance management. Thus in turn can deny his unemployment insurance from the state.

by mich2isa

Joe,
At times in society we have such individuals who are always a pain in the. Suprisingly you may find these very charaters do not realise whatever they can be doing unless you talk to them.

I feel you should try approaching that individual and elt him know of the stupid things he is doing that are not right.

Otherwise congratulations upon your new job

by wvbladel

It's true. They often don't realise they are being rude. Maybe it's a lack in their upbringing. That's why the confrontation approach often works.

by mdhealy

I notice many posters suggest variations on the same theme: threaten this person with termination. I wonder how many of them have ever worked at a state agency? I haven't, but I did spend some years at a university where it was extremely difficult to fire somebody. We once had a new programmer who never to my knowledge completed a single project from the day he arrived to the day we finally got rid of him: from the moment our boss began building a case to this guy's last day was nearly a year.

by tomjedrz

Joe -

Formalities aside, you should pay some attention and figure out what is really going on. Perhaps it is a strategy to not get bothered by people. Perhaps he has no idea that he is being perceived as rude. Perhaps he is arrogant. In any case, he probably does not know that you consider it a problem.

First, if you haven't already, get to HR and review this persons file. You should have a right to see it. You should review the rest of your staff's files while you are there.

Second, discuss the situation with your boss. There may be history you don't know about. Your boss should be able to fill you in on the counseling/discipline protocol.

Third, you need to begin catching this person being rude, and telling him that it is not acceptable. Then note the discussion on a piece of paper and put it in your own file for this guy. You can't get lazy; keep at it. You need to catch him over and over. Either he gets the message and straightens out, or he will not be surprised when the formal process starts.

If you are not willing to have these conversations, then you shouldn't be a supervisor.

Good luck.

by aaron a baker

Starting with establishing if this guy is actually being rude and/or obnoxious or is he being interpreted as such. There is a difference. In a case like your, the weight of balance must by definition be with the employees. surely they wouldn't complain for no reason at all.
With that in mind I would have a private meet with this individual and inform him of the discontent and discord that he is causing by his rudeness and obvious lack of consideration.
Although stated politely and nicely, the message would be crystal, get it together or get out.
Nobody and I mean NOBODY is deserving of the kind of treatment this creep doles out in order to feel better about himself. Thisis the year 2006, we know how to live and i would quite forcefully inform him of such.
And remember something else, this type of behavior can also be interpreted as harassment, and abuse, neither of which are tolerated in civilized society, let alone at work.
If he refuses, then Dump him, Nobody is that Good, I don't care who he is, it give's him no special privileges of abuse and riding roughshod over others.
If it were me?, he'd be gone, for offenses past.
Regards
Aaron. ;)

by fanchant

I was "wished the best of luck" from a job where I too had complaints of being rude to others, some justified, some not. What I found, however, was that once I left that company, my stress level dropped dramatically. I'm now working in front line customer service again with great success. Sometimes it's just the job fit, not the employee himself.

by ian

I've only read a few of the responses so far but I have to say that it appears that dumping the individual comes up most. STOP, do they have the technical ability that you need, if so arrange an Interpersonal Skills Course for both of you, that way they won't think your ganging up on them and you'll probably get something out of it yourself.

by rmcguire

A rude person is very hard to deal with especially when they need the help desk person, which is me. I work for a large school distrct in Kansas, my job is the schools library person for deyployment, repairs, help desk, a one person show. The users I deal with are mostly women with somewhat of a higher education level in their field of teacher, librarian. There is one person that has been rude to everyone and asked to leave two schools already. How does one deal with this, I don't know the correct answer. I have to rearange my schedule to be at her site when she is not there. Just press the ignor button is not correct but being a whipping post is not correct either.
Rudeness is a character defect which reflects the way a person feels when they are not being taken serious. I've tried everything to help the situation, this has failed so for now I give them the information they need and nothing more. If I have to visit the site its on a wednesday when they are not there. libtech@hotmail.com

by jdobbins

This kind of behavior is typical of someone with an overinflated opinion of himself and his worth, and considers everyone else on the "B" team. You need to have a talk with him, fast, and update his performance evaluation criteria so that helping others, with generosity and not condecension, is a major part of his evaluation.

by bvanloon

Joe,

I am sorry to hear you have this problem. Having been a manager and having to deal with this same thing in the past, I sympathize. Here are some guidlines that might help and I think the others have supplied them but may bear repeating.

First, understand your agency's/states rules regarding corrective action and office discipline. If they are not followed, law suits can occur (harrasment, wrongful dismissal, etc.).

Second, be a leader. This person needs to know the score. He/She is affecting the morale of your other staff in a negative fashion. He may know his stuff but his people skills are absolutely deplorable and he needs to know it. he needs to know that others are complaining. Be very specific about the offenses. Vagueness is not going to serve you well. Verify and quantify.

Third, the workplace is not a place for rehabilitation. Don't attempt to rehabilitate. If the problem w/ rudeness is due to other issues (substance abuse, domestic problems, sickness, etc.) part of the corrective action must be that the person seek help. This person needs to understand personal responsibility and accountability.

Fourth, while I agree w/ one of your respondents about all the negative attention this person receives at the expense of the other staff members, it's almost unavoidable. Make sure you make extra effort to reward the good and mature behavior of your other staff members and be public about it. This person is holding you and your staff hostage. Being somewhat demonstrative of positive feedback for the others may improve their morale and will clearly show your support of them.

Fifth, this person needs to know he/she is looking at the door. Continued rudeness and behavior that does not improve will be met w/ dismissal. But this person needs to know this now, not later. There is a price to pay for lousy unprofessional behavior and the rest of your staff doesn't need to pay it.

by km8295

Tact and good manners were once taught across our society. Nowadays, you can't rely on that. Does this person want to be kind and tactful? If so, you may be the teacher, remediating the lack of basic skills. Also, there is a moral component: does this person consider others as having value and worth? In other words, does this employee respect others or consider them somehow lesser beings? You may find morals hard to teach! So, what are you up for?

by minstrel mike

The reason for talking to someone is that if no one says anything and then he's fired, it's a shock. I would recommend suing if you've gotten good performance evaluations and then are suddenly let go.
The documentation is just to demonstrate you performed _your_ job as manager well. Often, a simple talk or even minimal direct action works wonders. My brother took over an engineering dept on a ship in the Navy (US--good govt job) that was doing poorly. After two weeks, he put 20 of the 28 sailors on PIPs--performance improvement plans. Nineteen of them, all older, resigned their commissions when he called them in. The one guy who didn't was 18 years old and just going along with gang.
Having that talk is difficult, but there's a 90% chance you'll only have to do it once.

For co-workers, it's much harder. I've had a dysfunctional one for 4 years. The milquetoast boss gave her the same performance rating she gives everyone and tried to appease people. The developer has never delivered a single thing that actually works. It never passes my testing but I was forced by the boss to put it on production. I make the boss handle all complaints about the code the wacko writes. She used to curse at us in meetings. I finally told the boss that this is a "fighting words" town and since the boss ain't doing anything about the situation, I will, that the next time I was cursed at, I was going to deck the b**ch and call security. We have separate "team" meetings now. That was two years ago.
My boss finally hired another manager in-between us and her and it took him just 3 weeks to identify the problem (after implementing lots of b.s. reporting that has since been discarded).
All he did was not let me release any code that wasn't fully tested--a procedure we had in place but that wasn't enforced in her case. She flipped out, lots of self-incriminating e-mails, saw the writing on the wall, and is now burning all her sick leave (you don't get paid for it when you quit) before trying to get medical disability and early retirement and anything else she can legally steal.
We've fired other people (and this is a US Federal Agency with a boatload of rules) before and gotten sued. The normal payout is $200,000. We'd have saved money firing her after the first 6 months and paying off a lawsuit and our morale and output would be higher now.
My boss thinks everything is fine now, but all of the employees remind her and her boss that we only blame the coworker for the first year of problems. The three+ years after is completely the boss' fault. I suspect she'll be gone next.

by adeal

You should keep a log. Of course, it will always go in this persons performance review. But in a state position (which I'm assuming is union), there is nothing you can do. I have horror stories about these types, and a simple reprimand had the union calling and going after the supervisor! And these aren't even good workers. Lazy, incompetent, negative, use up all of their sick leave, and complain about having to actually do what they're paid to do. Be careful if it's with a union position. There is little you can do, and even reporting it could backfire.

by tutor4pc

Rude people are sad cases. Rudeness is a form of violence. A rude person needs to be made aware of their behaviour and the fact that honey gets you farther than mustard. Rudeness may also be a form of lack of self confidence and therefor a shield to keep the danger of being exposed out. No matter what, the rude person needs education. If that does not help - OK, then a different job may be the right thing. I once had a rude supervisor - a miserable creature. I fought back but she had someone protecting her. Nevertheless I found a way to strip her of her power position and later she was moved into a position that was suitable for her, working in a store room with little contact to people.

Hope this helps.

Jo

by ckl_13

It has been my experience that employees who are purposefully rude are simply carrying out their own agenda to put in 8 hours go home and collect a check. They know their behavior will assist in isolating them from fellow workers and people they are actually hired to provide help. A common sense sit down pointing out that their attitude is being percieved to be negative and directly inquire as to whether or not that is their intent. Being a state or gov. agency doesn't give much room to hold demotion or termination over their head but even those agencies have reviews and raise evaluations that can be used to get the point across. This is all to say that you can't force everyone to be cheery and gleeful on the job but you can enforce at the very minimum a neutral environment such that this individuals behaviour doesn't negatively impact the work and attitude of others.

by bigbigboss

Ever heard of "Unacceptable Behaviour". This is you weapon.

There are a few rules you must know about dealing with this kind of problems.

1. You cannot fix attitude, you can only deal with behaviour. And specific behaviour.

2. You have to lay down the law before exercise the law.

3. You need specific incidences to exercise that law, and the incidence must happen after you lay down the law.

The law you may want to consider is "unacceptable behaviour". You can come up with this yourself, or, even better, do it in a staff meeting, and let all staff member help with defining what is unacceptable. You have to define the penalties as well. The key word is: up to and including dismissal.

You don't have to say who can lay the complain. It can be hear say, customers, clients, colleaques, management, or your own observation. But you need to have witness - not whether the behaviour is acceptable or not, but that the behaviour has been committed.

When you are awared of an incident, you talk to the offender, in an unthreatening manner, to get him/her to admit to the act. Document the meeting and all that was said, including date, time, location, who was present (get some third person in it, so that you don't need the guy's signature on the document). Next, you interview the witness, and document, as above.

Now you have the weapon to act. You can shoot to kill, or just to maim. That's up to you.

By the way, for sexual harrassment behaviour, it is the acceptance of the person in the receiving end that counts, not that of the offender. If you feel offended, you are.

by jterry

It is more important to have harmony in the work place than his expertise no matter how good he is. With all the IT poeple looking for work you shouldn't have a hard time finding someone to fill his position.

by sg1962

In NY state employees have the benefit of a relatively strong union. You need to follow the rules - counsel and document, etc. The personnel unit can be vital for advice because the union can and will get involved making sure that the supervisor did everything neccessary before dismissal. Hopefully, counselling and frequent feedback will improve the situation but if not.... You should be able to get a solution to your problem within two years.

by itguyy

When an otherwise good tech turned the receptionist into a bitchy pile of tears I took him aside and mentioned this:

"Personally while I may think that 'What do you mean you don't know how this happened? Do you think fairy's come down and change settings on you computer at night...' is freaking hilarious and probably somewhat deserved, its no way to treat users and It needs to stop or I'm going to have to let you go."

by jterry

IN every company I have worked in only there to protect the company, not the employees. Your concern for this individual is how much the company has invested in him or the liability of the company if you fire him. There is no concern for the employees who have to work with him.

by mcannon400

A few years ago, I had the opportunity to lead a team of programmers in a "large" integration project. Our small group was working with 5 seperate companies.

One of our team was the consumate "techno-bluff". He bullied and belittled users (not to mention the fact that he was incredibly rude). He had multiple users in tears quite frequently.

Some department heads cornered me in a meeting one day and DEMANDED that I do something. My solution was to give him a benign little system to be all his own... he quit within three weeks and went to work for WalMart.

by douglasjohnledet

At one job, I was considered the "rude" employee.

Why was it that I was considered "rude".

Because I didnot know how to say "No" properly.

I was given guidelines and mandates by the executives at the firm.

Managers, Supervisors, Assistants, Administrative and everyone else in the corporation believed that their "project" was the ONLY item of consideration.

When their "project" clashed with the guidelines and mandates, I would say "No".

But I didn't "Sugar" coat the "No" enough. And after the tenth time saying "No" to same person, I would sometimes become very direct with my "No".

Now, if I have to say "No", I agreed that their project is very important, explain to the person my "restrictions" and volunteer to accompany the individual to the issuing authority to get an override.

This works 99% of the time.

Unfortunately, I developed this too late for that job, but it has saved me many times since.

Doug

by doogal123

In this kind of situation you can escalate this external request issue to your supervisor and have him handle the politics of load balancing too many requests with not enough people.

by pscottc

Simply stated, there is no binding contract between the employee and the company that states the duration of the employment. I think that this type of arrangement forces employers and employees to talk to each other. If an employee doesn't feel empowered to talk to his manager, he should talk to his HR representative.

by jake707

We've had the same thing where I work. Two guys I work with have pretty much no social skills. One was in the same room with me, and when he left we all breathed a sigh of relief until he was replaced by someone just as bad. Oddly enough, they both have the same annoying habits. They like working in complete darkness, they talk very loudly on the phone, and when they eat (and they always eat in their cubes) it sounds like a dog licking its butt. (This is what happens when guys don't date in high school.) They even type loudly.

The best course of action is direct confrontation. SUBLETY DOES NOT WORK. Men like this, and yes it's nearly always men, can't, won't or don't pick up on subtle social cues. They missed out on normal social interaction in those crucial years of 12-18. While their peers were dating, hanging out at the mall and going to parties, they were playing D&D or sitting at their computers. You must be direct. For example... We will turn on the lights. Please talk softly on the telephone. Eat in the break room, not at your desk. The accompanying false arrogance that these guys have will never go away. I think for truly annoying nerdy guys it's their way of lashing out a world that rejected them.

by blarman

Rudeness is not a protected status like race, color, religion, etc.

Give the guy a frank review with a warning that if his behavior does not improve to acceptable levels, he will be let go.

In his current state, this employee is not worth having around.

by charles1nagler1

Irrespective of how good he is at his job, there is no justified reason for rudeness. I would tell him that his days are numberd if he does not shape up. Tell him the old expression "Shape up or ship out".

by tbmay

We could possibly give better insights if we had a little more detail. Perhaps an example of how the employee is rude. I notice most posters either are ready to term the guy or they feel like they are being called rude themselves. There are most definitely rude employees AND there are users who will ACCUSE an employee of being rude if she/he doesn't bend/break rules for them or otherwise give them special treatment.

I'd like a little more information.

by aaron a baker

That's the reason we all went through puberty, that's the reason we spent so many painful years growing up, some of us harder than others. To learn how to behave in public!!
I was raised with a given set of rules and regulation. In our home, they simply weren't broken. At least not without paying the price.
That's the purpose of parental upbringing, to teach yu how to behave,walk and talk in a socially acceptable manner. But this takes place in the formative years, so anybody acting this way in their 18s to mid twenties simply has no excuse.
Most of the time, you'll find that staff are more than easy to get along with and always willing to help the novice, because the faster he/she can get on line with the rest of the gang, the faster and better the work get's done. It becomes a form of Family and if well maintained, a joy in which to work.
It can be a happy environment.
So I for one, fail to see the need for anybody to be purposely rude,abrasive and/or abusive.
Just talking with all the different Techs, male and Female here at Tech Republic, has given me some insight as to just how truly generous and giving these people can be. So now we are asked to believe that this putridity is doing all this unawares?
Sorry, doesn't wash, he knows all right and he just doesn't give a damn, for him it's an attention getter.
Rest assured, he'd my attention and a lot more than he wouldn't expect. Maybe somebody should deliver him back to his parents and say "Here Dear Mom and Dad, do this one over, you missed the part about manners and civility." ;)
Regards
Aaron

by jstin466

Always do a job background check by doing this it could tell you how many jobs this guy has had in the last two to three years. Find out were he work before he came your way. If the people on his last job say what a great worker got along with everyone.Then go to were he worked chance's are there will be someone who really knows him.If not chance's are you may lose some really great worker's. I would get rid of one bad apple than take a chance on losing alot of good ones.

by bob_steel

You have to find out and understand WHY this guy is rude.

One of my best employees is aspergers - very socially inept and VERY rude. I've had to educate the other staff about his condition and I have to spend much time clearing up the mess and working with him to help him work in a team.

We all have a laugh together and now he's loved and valued. Hard work yields results. Don't just take the easy route, because it could be a massive mistake.

by nawaz.marican

Hi... just a note... I think there is a need to address the issue very swiftly but more imporantly do it professionally and strategically. His/her action is a reflection of how you run your unit and you character is in scrutiny by your peers, staffs and perhaps even management.

typcially, i'll give two verbal warnings... the first is typically counselling/advice (try to find out what's his problem) while the second can be a reprimand... These verbal commuincation must be done in private and not for the rest of the staff to see or hear. You still need to ensure his privacy is secured.

the third one will be a written memo ordering him change his ways and note the conversations i had before... and indicate that any such uncivil behaviour will not be tolerated and drastics steps will be taken to rectify the situation...

But before you head on doing this... consult with your HR practitioners ... perhaps they may have some corporate guidelines and before a written note is made have the company legal counsel vet it through...

you need to ensure that you have conducted yorself according to the guidelines set by your org and ensure that actions are not beyond the legal limits of the environment you are practicing in.

Hope this helps. Gd luck!!!

by farooqjawaid

just to carry ur thoughts..i just remembered a very good phrase taught to me when I was in college....
A Chinese proverb "One who asks a question is a fool for five minutes; one who does not ask a question remains a fool forever"

So one should go ahead and have the Courage to know & Dare to ask

by chandu_ch

Dear joe,

I feel that people require feedback to perform better in their work.

In your word i was able to understand that his results are good but behaviour aspects are bad.

So with out delay fix a meeting with that employee and explain all postive points first.

Then you straight away put about his rude behaviour and how it is affecting hia career and departmental work culture.

Suggest sertain ways to control his emotions.

I think he will understand and perform better.

I expereinced this type of situations with so many people and able to chaneg them.

I am sure he

by pikeman6669

Fire his ass NOW!
There are many fine people OUT OF WORK in the IT field who would be soooo happy to have this job.
Seriously, this guy should go work at WalMart or Home Depot. My struggling IT friends need the work.