The rude employee
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by mc_user
The chicken that clucks the loudest, is the one most likely to go to the steam fitters picnic.
Banacek
getting a contract where BOTH parties have some obligations ?
How do you get loyalty or respect, that bit extra effort out of a person on such a contract.
Offer nothing, get nothing in return, damn stupid.
Anyone on such a contract is a serf, pure and simple, at the complete mercy of their landlord. Probably the only reason it sort of works, is you are allowed to have guns.
by whitede25
I had a similar problem employee. I spoke with the employee about the need for professionals to adjust their communication style in order to communicate with others. I required the employee to attend communication training. When training was completed I required them to set up 10-15 minutes to explain to me what they learned from the training and how they planned to incorporate it into their daily activities. I continued to monitor the employee and solicit feedback from those they interacted with. When the employee realized that I was serious about their changing or losing their job, they responded. "After all," I explained, "I am trying to give you tools that will help you be successful no matter where you work or whom you work for."
Don't back down, don't coddle and by all means - document, document, document!
by johnny bee
by bob_steel
I posted below on this topic and you guys are right.
Managed correctly by well-trained staff you may find he's not actually rude at all. I have an aspergers member of staff who has this problem. I have an agreed hand signal I use with him to let him know when his behaviour isn't acceptable. Without it he is unaware - and obviously can't do anything about it.
He's the best member of staff I've ever had or probably ever will have.
by uplinkspider
by vnguyen
I would agree with Chaz. Ask yourself why this is happening. Look behind the behavior to find a possible cause. See a bigger picture.
Many years ago, I was in the position of being that employees with the rudeness problem. I was short with people and had a low tolerance for what I thought of as "user stupidity".
My employer sent me to a class to learn better people skills. (The fact was that I already had the skills, but did not use them) The class did not help.
But it did make me think about my behavior and I looked for patterns in it. I discovered that my "instability" was caused by my eating habits. As a thin person, I did not have much reserves, and although I was not a diabetic, my moods would swing wildly depending on what time of day it was and what and how much I had eaten. (sugar levels, etc.)
Once I straightened out my eating habits, the problem went away.
So the point is:
1. That there may be other issues causing the behavior.
2. Even though we are all adults, NO, we cannot always see our own behavior from the "inside".
by lienshen
The generalizations and assumptions in your post are so grossly negligent I am hoping that you are not in a supervisory position of any kind at all.
Your entire post is rude, condescending and completely off base in it's assumptions and it's conclusions based on those assumptions. Instead of showing them some compassion to help them tailor their behaviour, you continued to look down your nose at them. How very un-Jesuslike of you. People sometimes are just ignorant on how their behaviour effects others, yourself included. I am disgusted by your behaviour here, by your comments and think you are rude and probably not as social adept as your make yourself out to be. You are the kind of guy in high school that girls dated just for status, and that people hung out with for material value... have you ever stopped to think that maybe "nerds" don't socialize to avoid all these generalizations and assumptions?
by jdclyde
Argueing with your boss will only mean you will be looking for a new boss.
Some arguements are just not worth winning, and if you are going to make someone look bad, they will get rid of you ASAP.
You learned a hard lesson. sit down and shut up.
Point out politely possible problems, but remember that you are not the only person in the world with an answer that would/could work. Add input, but in the end, shut up and do your job.
I would bet there is a clause in your contract that allows them to fire you on these grounds. Better go back and re-read it.
Best bet is to move on as you already burned that bridge to the ground. Going to court would take years and cost you a lot of money and time.
by bvanloon
I know the reasons for telling people the positive points first. I do that but it strikes me as a little manipulative. Build them up just to knock them down a notch? While I understand the goal of accentuating the positive, it's not this person who needs positive feedback. The people who need positive feedback are the staff he is destroying.
It's the velvet-covered iron fist and most people know it, especially if they have reason to believe the news isn't good. You know that you have some heavy bad news to deliver. Why not just come out with it? Not in a brash way. There are ways to deliver bad news or critique so as not to destroy a person. But don't play games. Most people aren't stupid.
This person doesn't need manipulation. He needs motivation.
by x-marcap
I send an email documenting the fix. I send the person an email letting them know it is fixed. I used to go to their desk to demonstrate the fix, now I email or call.
I used to investigate their PCs now I pass it back to the helpdesk. That peeves off the helpdesk as they need to keep their problem queues clear...
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
Of course you have rights. Anything in your employment contract is enforcable (read and agree before you sign). They also cannot fire you for a legally discriminatory reason (because you reached 40, because you became pregnant, etc.). Otherwise, yes; unless your employment contract says they must have just cause to terminate you, they can fire you because you wore an ugly tie, because you have bad breath, because they don't like the political bumper sticker on your car, etc.
Of course, people who do their job to the best of their ability and maintain a friendly air with their co-workers normally don't have to worry about it.
by tonythetiger
Sorry, nobody is forcing you to work there.
"...getting a contract where BOTH parties have some obligations"
You produce usable work, the employer produces usable money. Those are the main obligations (there are some things that may be subject to state and federal laws that are also obligations).
If you want something else, negotiate it and get it put into the contract. This is normally done before employment begins but if you are particularly good at what you do, you can probably do it anytime.
by scatts
Has she sworn or been overtly demeaning to junior staff? If so explain very politely to her, and then if she ignores you to her Boss, you will not accept her talking to your staff that way. Make sure senior management & HR are involved. Force her to apologise to the member of staff. The longer it goes on the more she thinks she can get away with it.
If she persists and HR / Management refuse to deal with it then apologise whenever she calls and say unfortunately due to her behaviour none of your staff are willing to deal with her. You will of course attend to her personally but you are right in the middle of a server upgrade/ fixing an important system etc. you can deal with it tomorrow.
Pop by at 6pm (or if you feel brave 2 minutes before she goes home) and drop a note on her desk that you looked at it, but as she wasn't there you couldn't resolve it. You will pop back tomorrow after the you have resolved the other XYZ problems. Alternatively wait until you know she is busy with deadlines and pounce.
Keep this up for a few days, reminding her politely the published SLA for resolving minor problems is 3 days, make sure you just manage to fix it before the SLA expires.
Make sure she always books a call on the system and you keep it well updated to show how hard you tried to resolve it.
She will either realise she is stuck and start being nice or she will complain and you can explain why your staff refuse to support her to HR and point out to her boss how hard you tried to resolve it.
Remote control such as VNC or similar is also a godsend, you just ring her up on handsfree, take over the machine and start a conversation with someone else about a suitably urgent and important matter, ignore her as you are too busy to talk to someone so rude.
Of course have a peek round her machine for any banned software or files while you are on it. Mail asking her to remove them, copy in her boss & HR. If she caused the original problem by loading 'My Little Kitten' screensaver etc note it on the call.
by absolutely
by bschaettle
by scatts
Managers should manage people, if you fire him without trying you aren't doing your job.
His work is good, his attitude bad.
Find out what the problem is and try to resolve it, if you can't resolve it at least you have gone through the motions and documented it to mitigate unfair dismissal claims.
When I left school, real unemployment was running at about 5 million in the UK. I started my career at 18 on a welfare to work program, it gave me and extra sixty pence a week.
So save the capitalist 'morality' play for someone else, I know who gets both sides of their bread buttered with deals like at will employment.
Serfdom, been there, done that, didn't like it.
by absolutely
Or is he the best in the office?
Does he know enough that the value added by his labor exceeds the cost in productivity to the rest of the office of his rudeness? Also, if his job description includes IT support, he should be fired if others are intimidated to ask him to do his job duties. But if he is so knowledgeable that the office cannot function without him, he is probably just gruff because he isn't being paid appropriately.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by wje_jr
I'm a technician in a business. A twenty year co-worker I'll call "gravy boat Larry" GBL.
GBL would always puts his two cents in and acts omnicient. Other co-workers were afraid of him, until I came along. I also have a good secondary investment income and don't really depend on my technician job for economic sustinance but I love the work and really look forward to it.
I was doing a routine repair as directed by a technical service bulletin. I was ready for GBL.
GBL looked at me and asked me "what in sam hell are you doing?" I exploded! and yelled so everyone heard me " I am following the directions of a mother fu*k*ng cock su*k**g engineer who makes a 100K a year more than you do, has a wife and three mistresses with a teenage male twink he is banging on the side, so kiss my a** you son of a bi**ch and go fu** yourself.
I did not get fired for that emotional outburst, my manager only replied "I heard this project is eating you up" Thats all they said, my co-workes loved the drama and gravy boat Larry is polite to me every single day.
You have to weigh your situation and the risks of going off like I did. I don't recommend it unless you can afford getting fired.
The emotional release felt so good!!!!
by sinclairp
of the sweat off our brows. Who made the rule that 5% of the population could benefit from 95% of that accumulation.
They did didn't they.
I wouldn't cite communism particularly the russian and chinese experiments as an alternative to capitalism. I had democracy in mind.
Take the blinkers off for a minute, and think about what it would be like if you got rewarded for the value you add, not a split of what slops out the trough when the providers of capital have had a good wallow.
by 50kilroy
In reading the several replies, I have noticed a trend toward the heartless. Many say "dump him".
You really should find out _why_ this person has a rudeness issue. He may be under tremendous stress at work or in other areas of his life.
Does the employer have the 'never enough' attitude? i.e., never good enough, never fast enough, never inexpensive enough, etc., etc.
I have been in that situation and it is extremely difficult to maintain a 'honey-sweet' attitude when your company considers you to be less than dog-doo under its heel.
Investigate this person and help him to overcome.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by retailnet1
assumptions of yours.
Nobody owes me employment. They owe me money for my labour and respect for my ability.
But if you want respect, you show it
If you want dedication you reward it
and if you want loyalty you give it.
An at will contract implies non of these things, yet you find the c***s who write them up, expect all of these things in return for mere money.
Value is indicated by them wanting you to stay, not by them passing up the opportunity to let you go !
The price you guys are willing to pay for the american dream is flat out scary sometimes.
by tonythetiger
by rfraysier
you'd have a real hard time with an attempt to do it in the UK.
Do it in France and they'd bring back Madame Guillotine.
Maybe both you and the french are extremists.
Only a successful person could make it in such an environment, that's the price, every one fails sometime.
by sully
This is all great but... The most important things are:
1. Document the case
2. Follow up with HR
3. Write the employee up and if he doesn't sign, have a witness do it. All they're signing for is that he received his warning - not that he agrees to it.
4. Write up an action plan that results in success, yet, include a statement regarding dismisal.
5. Follow up with the employee and with HR regarding this action plan, make sure things are getting done.
6. Follow up with the co-workers who claim he is rude and make sure they are being coached to allow him to change.
7. Commend the employee for ALL efforts to change behavior and point out where he is staying on task and where he is not.
8. Document everything.
9. Leave your stress at work.
10. Pick up a good 1st person shooter game and have havok on his virtual arse! (j/k) but really 1-9 are all about managing risk and opportunity. I know this might be a bit off topic but in Chinese writing their character for crisis is made up of two characters; Danger and Opportunity. You are in a crisis my friend manage it by eliminating the danger and capitolizing on the opportunity.
by sully
by sully
Document everything she does and says. Tell her to leave the room if she is distracting you from doing your job. Consult with HR above her supervisors head and file a formal complaint. Document everything that she and her managers do and say to you that is offensive and file a harrassment suit against the company if they do not comply with a performance eval and conduct action plan. The bottom line is that you need to be professional. You need to quit worrying about whether or not you're wrong. You need to just do your job and coordinate the direction of stress to its proper corporate recepticle - the HR department. Don't give in to the bullies at work, you are protected by Federal Laws if in the US so even a right to work state has no precidence over a harrassment suit. Support your claim with dates, times, quotes, etc and show her that you are documenting it because it is interfering with your work and with the company's payroll/productivity. Root out the trash in your company by just not letting these things get in your way.
Now, if this is not possible, i.e. you are unwilling, then just suck it up. Bring her chocolates, lay on your best BS for her and smootch up cuz she owns you and so does her boss. Then if you get a chance put a keylogger on her machine and track what she does; find any emails or memos that are offensive and allow copies of that stuff to get to the upper management or better yet post them in a public place for everyone to see. These two will stand out like sore thumbs after a while of this. Use your technical skills to thwart their bullish psudo-feministic behavior. A real feminist has talent and a competitive spirit; yet she is still a nurturing woman. These two are just bulls who need to go back to square one and learn how to play nice in the play ground.
by i didn't do it- it broke on it's own
You say he is a "State" employee. Can't fire a State employee. IMPOSSIBLE to get rid of them. The only way a State employee leaves is when they drop dead.
Go to ANY State Agency, they're all rude. The more rude you are, the faster you move up the ladder.
Just put up with it. Nothing else you can do.
by absolutely
"The price you guys are willing to pay for the american dream is flat out scary sometimes."
What scares you is the price I am [b]not[/b] willing to pay, and to whom I am unwilling to pay it: you. I exist by right, not by your favor, and I'm not helping you to pretend otherwise.
by scatts
According to the post She is a problem (first hand experience), she is protected by her manager.
All you can do is make sure you protect yourself and encourage her to change or expose herself.
If she had intimidated my staff I would make sure it had happened and I would deal with it, thats what I get paid the big bucks for. No way a decent boss would ask their staff to tackle someone like this alone, if it were between just two I might try using mediation and bring the two together in front of me.
But my suggestions above have worked very well for me before.
by absolutely
However, with an attitude like the one displayed here, I doubt that even I would pass your prerequisites for being helped along.
As a Superior, I will do whatever I can to encourage and coach a new person until they get the idea and meld in with everybody. Having said that, let it be known that have very little patience for arrogance and rudeness, regardless of which side of the fence it comes from.
While it is true that a Manager, or Team Leader is responsible for the eventual outcome of the given projects, it is also true that this gives him/her absolutely no rights to berate or in any way ride roughshod over a new employee.
If "As a Boss" you are not prepare to take the time, with out all the preconceived notions that seem ready to jump into gear as soon as this poor shmuck makes a mistake, I would venture to say that I would be most reluctant to accept your thinking or attitude as my Superior.
Having been in Business for well over 35 Years, I can state categorically that regardless of profession, People are still People and ALL like and Need to be treated with kindness and respect.
Oh by th way, I've brought back some really great Program That I was sure were dead in the water.
All it took was a little more patience and kindness than Usual.
No exceptions.
Regards
Aaron
Well said indeed.
Much better to be Dumb only for a little while than to live out your life in Darkness.
I really like the way this is put and have made note of it.
Thanks for the Post.
Regards
Aaron
by adegachi
It is rare to find a human being who is both competent and sociable. The time and skills required to socialize often exlude the time and skills required to become competent. Those who become more competent also often are not pleased at others rising faster than them in the social ladder or even having an equal position. This they see as some sort of lack of appreciation or even double standard. On the other hand, those who are less qualified feel slighted (and even jealous) by the very knowledge/skills of the more competent, which s/he acquired to gain self-esteem and appreciation by others in the first place and are also afraid to acknowledge not knowing something, which they are afraid would be perceived as weakness and would lead eventually to rejection/loss of the job.
In order to proactively resolve this kind of undercurrent in a small enterprise, I would
(1) informally get to know the real person behind the "rude" employee, see if s/he feels somehow unappreciated and publically lavish some sincere appreciation and recognition on him/her (not necessarily by promotion or assignment of official responsiblity but also moral/verbal recognition in front of his/her colleagues).
(2) Organize informal social get-togethers for all the team from the small company once a week around any game, sport, or activity enjoyed by the majority, which can also be changed from time to time to break the routine.
(3) Organize some work-relations/best practices workshops at the enterprise.
(4) Award Employee of the Month on a rotating basis to all co-workers.
Remember a "rude" human being is just a mask, and a more "obvious" way of getting attention. This employee is obviously crying out for attention and acceptance by the group, although s/he is sending out signs to reject others before they reject him/her (for fear of rejection). His/her competence is his/her way of saying to the world it ought to be enough to accept him/her; so that deep inside, the employee does not accept himself/herself easily. Hence:
(5) If possible indirectly make available to this employee some form of counselling or hire a counsellor to come to the social gatherings and become part of the business.
(6) Avoid any direct counter"rude" measures (personalization of the issue). These would be perceived as such and would always be counterproductive.
Compassion: please give him/her another chance. Once s/he is accepted, s/he will be happier and so will give you very good productivity.
With honey, you can catch a lot more bees.
"Don't Sweat the Small Stuff at Work: Simple Ways to Minimize Stress and Conflict While Bringing Out the Best in Yourself and Others (Don't Sweat the Small Stuff Series) (Paperback" by Richard Carlson. ... No promotion intended: I just love this writer.
Hope this helps.
Sincerely,
Majid.
by 50kilroy
I've dealt with all kinds of different people from all walks of life in my time and have always found the time to be courteous. Sometimes, I was the Boss, in other situations, it was they who were in charge.
It's been my observation that most people who "Do Not" feel a need to prove themselves on a continuous basis usually make much better bosses and co workers.
I would like to think that we haven't reached the point as human beings that we now have to go and read books on how to live? That would be truly sad.
The Rules are simple and they apply to both sides.
"Treat other as you would have them treat you". I don't have to into any big analogy about what this means. We're all smart enough to know.
But if a person actually has to go and read what should be second nature out of a book, I suggest that much more than a book is what is needed here.
Rudeness,arrogance and a need to Dominate, have always been signs that the person had a very low opinion of "themselves" and used every opportunity to "Show" just how good they were. Especially in front of the Boss, if at all possible. Problem was, they used the wrong method.
So next Time take a good look at the person in front of you and just before you open your mouth, remember this, he/she too, has feelings and can be deeply, hurt, damaged by your words and actions, just like you can. Because of your need to Feel like your "Worth Something"
Look at them, then speak and you'll find you won't need books.
And in the process, you will become a better team [ Led by You ] and you could end up working with Friends, instead of Competitive Cuthroats.
I'll take Friends, any day.
Regards
Aaron
by gsg
It was Holmes who uttered this line and well put it was too. ;)
Regards
Aaron
by 50kilroy
You have seen a lot of bad and good advice here. I do wonder how you found about his problem at a former job. That would be grounds for him to bring a lawsuit. I hope that he does and I also hope that he ends up owning BOTH that former company (for revealing 'secure' information) and YOUR company (for asking and then revealing that same info).
Your company needs a union!
by dr.phil
We had a woman like that and she was equally hated by everyone (at that was consistant he chuckles). A certain unnamed employee kinda sturred the pot until the level of hostility finally went over the edge.
She was staying after hours alledgedly to get more work done on a Friday and was accompanied by a temporary (also a lady) when the temporary decided she had enough.
This temp took care of what all the other employees only did in their dreams and imaginations-- the temp beat the living hell out of her. (the room where the beating took place looked like it had been ransacked and there was the greasy shape of a face with makeup and lipstick on the door glass)
Monday morning Miss Rudeness didn't come it (too many bruises and scapes) and the temp had ditched the temp company. Miss Rudeness came in the following Monday still bruised, swollen and both eyes black. We all laughed our butts off and Miss Rudeness was fired that day.
We all wanted to buy the temp dinner but we couldn't locate her. :)
People will take just so much crap.
by cioupdates
I have read a lot of interesting and intellegent suggestions to this thread.
Its a very very serious issue and the Manager have to act very promptly to these type of situations. My suggestion would be as follows:
1. Confirm the validity of complaints and write up the employee for unprofessional problems without any further delays.
2. Provide HR information about employees behavioural issues and request help.
3. Ask HR to provide him professional training (pl. don't try yourself) Training should be immediately completed after the write up.
4. After succesful training strictly monitor the employee for any behaviour issues. If the employee is interested in the job his behaviour will change. Keep monitoring the change and make sure it is permanent change. If the employee goes back to his usual behaviour dont waste your time immediately make the right decision in showing him the way out of the door. I strongly believe if you take this course of action your problem will be resolved and you will gain the confidence of your employees and management.
Good luck!
by waltenshaung
by dr.phil
Since this is a state agency (no matter what size) there is ALWAYS a procedure that must be adhered to if the offending employee is a civil servant. In this case you must document, coach, note improvement, document. The previous usually must be performed three (3) times to satisfy the HR office and whatever union may be involved. This will protect you against inclusion to any lawsuit that takes place naming you *with* the agency name. If you name is left out of the lawsuit target you're ok. If not then you better get a lawyer that specializes in civil service actions.
If this louse is a contractor then complain to the contract administrator and that persons boss.
by uplinkspider
A different face of rudeness - I too just acquired a job with a government agency and though I shied from accepting a managerial position management insisted. Unemployed for 9 months and when not under employed I accepted. I was given charge over a small field team and one of the members is constant trouble. She is a high maintenance personality and exercises zero tolerance towards her team members and me alike while demanding a wide range of tolerance for herself. She has a propensity to play cutesy around males, constantly demands, when in conversations or meetings, for people to repeat themselves. She also has the annoying habit of speaking out of place and out of turn, hijacking a conversation or a meeting and redirecting it to impertinent subject matters. If she?s not given center stage she will pout and when addressed she?ll reply with sharp rudeness. The fact that this employee is a female who believes that her internal acquaintances (connections) and her flirtatiousness with male figures of management afford her job security makes for a volatile situation. Fortunately members of management are not blind. I was asked if the team could tolerate her until the end of the year when her contract comes to term, I answered yes. Her contract is not going to be renewed.
In your case you?re new to your post, distance yourself a little and allow for time to reveal more about the personal dynamics in play. The fact that you know he had this problem at his previous job means that you?ve done some investigating or somebody told you about it and if that?s the case rest assured that others know it too. Wait and root yourself first before pursuing a resolution perhaps by then somebody in management will flick the switch and terminate him without you having to risk getting hurt or worse loose your job due to him.
Best of luck
Now in my case, what if she wasn?t a contractor, what if she did have internal patronage?
by grp9892
Hi
I have received an inquiry for life insurance give me call if any body in your family is interested .
I am living in Edison NJ
I am also Engineer and MBA so you can expect Best rate and Value of your money
Shyam Patel
You can reach me @732-735-3625
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending