Discussion Locked

Tidiness and the Techie

0 helpful
124 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

124 replies

by inkling

is that you would stay and clean with them.

I started my IT career in the Marine Corps, where cleanliness = Godliness.

Bottom line is, if you aren't willing to inconvenience YOURSELF to get things done, your team most certainly won't be bothered to inconvenience themselves.

by grimshiire

What the FREAKN HELL IS A DESKTOP ENGINEER? I can not believe how absurd these titles are becoming. The person in charge needs to have them clean it & keep it professional looking or have them clean the data center floor with a toothbrush & THEIR TONGUES!

by 2rs

Shellbot, thanks for taking the time to itemize my daily responsibilites. Item 10 is at the top of my excuse list & probably takes 50% of my time, especially when a new employee arrives, complete with "Knowledge of commonly used software". I need to work on tidying up after completing each task, true. Since when is an IT person bestowed the capability to use EVERY feature of EVERY software program used within the company? Is there a dust-flinging fairy that I need to meet? Happy Holidaze!

by 2rs

I find it comforting to know that other IT folks have "Clean my office" as a yearly Goal!

by 2rs

I am so grateful that there really are others wired this way. I've spent my entire working life "proving" that I can find something because I can remember which pile it's in. At home, too. My S.O. goes nuts because everything is in piles and "helps" me by organizing.......

by rhomp20029

After working in the IT field for over 40 years, I have seen neat people who could not think their way out of a wet paper bag and total slobs who could find exactly what they needed from a pile in less time than you could find it in a file.

What you are doing is trying to do behavior modification on people who will then neaten up and work less. If you demand their being neat when it hurts their work, then just get yourself someone else to pester.

by nicknielsen

Once I figured out that you meant freecycle.ORG and found the site, I checked it out. I will keep it in mind next time I clean house. In my current job, though, the client provides all parts and equipment and requires that I return everything to them so they can dispose of it. There will also be a great deal less of it after their recent changeover to Neoware thin clients.

by nicknielsen

At two of my previous work locations, we tried to get a biweekly IT Friday going where we could shut down and clean up, responding only to emergency calls. We initially got management approval, but that approval was rescinded when management realized that IT actually meant to stick to the definition of "emergency" as "network down, server down or network printer down." Apparently, management didn't like the idea that salesmen were coming to IT at 4pm on a Friday to get VPN issues fixed and being told no. "I haven't been able to connect all month. No, it can't wait until Monday, I'm flying to xxx on Sunday." Instead of management telling sales to report outages when they occurred, IT was told to return to normal call response.

Needless to say, they just didn't understand why the IT benches never quite made it to immaculate...

by roaming

Having to drag stuff from one floor to another is probably what is putting them off.

by john.fisher

Seriously, you guys must wear ties and shiny shoes or some such. Your job is not to "give them a talking to" your job is to insulate them from the stupid corporate flak, make sure they have what they need, and provide policy on important things, like customers.

In short a manager's job is to keep all the paperwork, corporate politics, and dumb VP's ideas away from the people who actually do productive work so they can get their job done.

Start by reading the US comic Dilbert, yes its based on real stories people send him. Try not to be the pointy-haired boss. Then rent The Office, UK or US edition. Then rent Office Space too. If you don't laugh ruefully, you are in the wrong job. really.

Look if you've got a safety issue like fire-aisles, then just get a big cart and go around and pick up the stuff from everybody.

hope things improve for you,
JF

by bitboss

1. Constantly remind the techs that their workshop represents a health hazard. When that fails (as it will) plant some rats (really big ones) in the workshop.
2. Post an email informing techs that on every Friday all unsecured equipment will be dumped by the maintenance crew - techies can't stand throwing anything remotely electronic away.
3. At the monthly staff get together - sacrifice a techie to the tidiness god over an open cooking pit and inform remaining techs that they must consume their former colleague to appease the wrath of the tidiness god (they're an incredibly gullible lot - just look at Microsoft products).

by zlitocook

If they can not keep their desk tops clean how will they keep any thing they do clean? If they can not keep up with what is on their desk how will they keep up with new projects?

by hlhowell9

I am one of the "untidy". However I am also one of the more creative of my group. My mind works in a different way than the people with great organization do. Not better, not faster, just different. I quit one job over this issue, and would quit just as fast the next time. The company I quit lost a lot of business to the company I joined.

It's a choice.

If their workspace bothers you, don't go there, if their productivity is what you need.

Otherwise you take your shot and take your chances. Good engineers, good software folks are not cheap, or common.

If you want tidy, become an accountant or a product rep. It's a different skillset.

On the otherhand, I worked a number of years in a highly secure environment, when cleanliness was more important that creativity. I lost creativity, but I did keep the space spotless. Wouldn't do that again either.

Now I'm retired. But my home and my boat are neat. My worksapces are messy but they are mine. I'm the boss. If you don't like it, don't visit.

Regards,
Les H

by rhomp20029

Could not have said it better. I too am now retired and I too worked for years with a mess on my desk. Never lost a paper and could find anything needed when needed.

I was the one that people came to to get things fixed in a hurry because I could do it. I was then they came to when they got errors they could not understand and I found what the problem was and either told them how to fix it or fixed the problem myself. All the neatniks spent their time straightening things up and trying to figure out which file they put it in while I got on with the job.

I guess the managers have to decide what they want. Do they want the job done or do they want a spotless desk. Most times you can't have both and meet your deadlines. You decide.

by shellbot

a) Work Area Neatness & Tidyness 60 %
b) Work Attitude & Ability 25%
c) Punctuality & Attire 5 %
d) Other 10 %

so you put tidyness above being a team player, knowing how to do thier sh*t and doing a good job?

must be a great place to work, full of clean people who can't do anything..

personally..i'd reararnge them as such:
a) Work Attitude & Ability 85%
b) Desire to learn 10%
c) Trustworthiness 5 %

Ya know what, a team of people like that might not look pretty and might have a messy desk, but they'd be like gold to me and i'd treasure every one of them.
To have a team of competent trustworthy and reliable people who have a drive to learn ...a tech managers wet dream

by w2ktechman

Next time I am looking for work, I'll see you first....
Do you pay for training too?

I do have to agree, that many a time I would prefer that the tech's clean up sometimes. But other than rag on them about it, I let it go and pointed it out once in a while as a problem if anyone else enters the area.
So, they did clean, but rarely. And I didnt have to spend all of my time complaining about it.
I valued their knowledge and troubleshooting skills much more than cleanliness. That is the way that I had found to have a good team.

by cris_garcia

The way i have it is:

1. I have a storage room where i keep all new/old equipment (helps me keep inventory control).

2. Same room has enough room so i can use a table for setups/diagnostics/cleaning equipment.

3. My server room has a metal case where i keep/safeguard my backups tapes. Also i have a file cabinet where all CD's are kept. And a nother one for keeping supplies (toners, blank cds, etc). (All this is inventorized).

4. At my desk i only keep papers (important ones) on my drawers. And we always clean and avoid eating at our desks.

by w2ktechman

by imagining it.
Or maybe we need those D&D bags of holding?

Not everyone has extra space that they can just 'use' at their will.

by jwm.mckay

Nobody said empty but you're so prejudiced you didn't get the picture! Tidy in the sense someone can walk in and find the current software cut without firing up the pile of old versions; tidy in the sense of redundant job sheets put in the bin or filed; tidy in the sense that I can pick up a DIMM without wondering if it works.

Read the detail next time please.

by sarge62436

My team carries a responsibility that involves making sure our laptop-based diagnostic systems are capable of providing automotive technicians with the data and functionality required to accurately diagnose and repair customer vehicles. It is not unusual for us to scatter laptops, cables, interfaces, AND vehicle control units/wiring harnesses across more than one desk.
To some, this is not tidy. However, if we did not diagnose, disassemble, repair, and verify, then our dealer techs would have a hard time keeping customer cars on the road.
We reinforce the concept of accounting for items and putting them away in designated, secured areas when we are finished.
In short, put it back together and put the tools away when you are done with it.....

by coopster

The fire marshall came by and said we can't have misc stuff stacked in corners, etc. Not an impediment to escape, just "too much" stuff.

Nope, no room in any building for us to have storage. So fine. Where to store it? At a retail store: ie., throw it away, when we need another- buy it. Hmm. Old unit, new repair parts unavailable? Too bad. Time to upgrade! Sure, it's pretty expensive, but the room looks fairly tidy!

by gooder

I got fed up with one desk in my dept, so I've just set an objective for that person to keep their area clear. We are part of the main office so it doesn't make us look good.

They said they'd rather take the hit and lose the small percentage of the bonus I'd assigned to the objective. So I doubled it, reducing other objectives to suit.

I'm now waiting to see what happens...

This discussion is closed to new replies.