Discussion Locked

To those who voted for Democrats two years ago

0 helpful
279 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

You contributed to adding more debt onto the shoulders of future generations than everyone else over the past 200 years! AND, you contributed to the impending total collapse of the U.S economy more than everyone else over the past 200 years!

http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/111th-congress-added-more-debt-first-100

Go ahead, blame Bush. It's all you seem to do. But you only have yourselves to blame. Your day of reckoning WILL come, and you will have dragged others down with you.

What will you do when the Dollar collapses and the United States defaults on both its debt obligations and promises to its citizens? What will you do when the Dollar is devalued? What will you do when the World Reserve Currency is no longer the Dollar? It will happen, you know; it's just a matter of time. And it will happen sooner rather than later. (And why is George Soros, Democrat's favorite billionaire, buying up all the gold and silver he can get his hands on - all the while, advocating MORE government spending and debt accumulation?)

When will people realize that America's credit card is WAY over the limit? And it's actually too late to fix it. I've been sounding the warning for twenty-plus years. But no, my detractors claim; I'm just mean-spirited and selfish.

In short, the American people have elected themselves out of the best thing that's ever happened in the history of the world. They've killed the Golden Goose in exchange for their own (selfish) basket of eggs.

P.S. I also blame the weasel and spineless Republicans who were sucked into the Democrats' games, and were, themselves, no more than Baby Democrats. But whatever it takes to get elected, I suppose.

Do you belive such a thing? Do you share such an outlook? If so, what will you do to prepare yourself? If not, why not?

279 replies

by santeewelding

The assault overwhelms an individual on many other fronts. Debt and default, however, [i]will[/i] grab and spin violently around anyone who has not been paying attention.

Past time to complain about it.

by maxwell edison

That's a great description, Santee.

It is - and has been - an assault. It's been an assault on liberty, an assault on freedom, an assault on individual rights, and an assault on the very fabric of what made America great in the first place.

But I'm not complaining about it - at least not any more. I used to, I suppose, but that time has long passed. Instead, I'm starting to plan for the inevitable - although that presents quite the challenge.

Anyone who doesn't believe that the American economy and the American Dollar is on the road of collapse - a road of no return - is simply ignorant or in denial.

by delbertpgh

The way you talk makes me wonder if you're stocking up on canned food, ammunition, and Krugerrands. "An assault" on liberty, freedom, indiviualism, and the sinews of American greatness. Sounds like somebody has declared war against you. But nobody has. No war. Relax a little. Worry about the real problem.

The U.S. has gotten into a financial mess because of a lot of mistakes, but mostly by wishful thinking (house prices can go up forever, bankers' salaries can go up forever, jobs can disappear overseas forever, taxes can be cut forever, and we all will be better because of it.) We had a huge asset bubble that popped, and now we are left with a shrunken economy, mortgages that will never get above water, and no confidence. If you study depression economics, you know that if government spending is slashed to match our lowered government income, then confidence and business activity will fall further. It could potentially increase red ink more than the crazy stop gap spending you hate so much now, once unemployment runs to 20%.

It is going to take years for our 10% unemployment to get back to the 5% level. Probably about five years. We have a special problem right now because businesses, sitting on a trillion dollars in profits, don't see any reason to put it at risk by investing in job-creating projects. Private equity (i.e., American rich guy money in limited partnership investment clubs) is putting its tax-cut savings into foreign investment, because they don't want to risk it here. The private institutions with cash and the power to put it to work behave like they don't believe in this country.

Economic dogma says that lower interest rates should produce higher economic activity, but rates are near zero for short term money and 3% for long term, and the economy has not reacted. Traditional economics says that crazy low interest rates cause inflation, but it's not happening now. Conservative economists say that if taxes are lowered (note: deficit thereby raised) we will automatically see more investment, but it hasn't happened lately. In fact, taxes have been low since 2002 and all we got was anemic growth and a huge bubble. All the things we were sure of about our economy seem the be false today. Economic truths are on a holiday, until the economy comes back.

Economics is not like physics; it's a behavioral science, and right now America is a frightened mob. All it wants to do is conserve its savings and get rid of its stifling mortgages, and it does not invest, no matter how sweet the inducement. If government does not do its job and force economic action, by various forms of stimulus, our economy can and will collapse, until you have 20%-plus unemployment, people dying in front of hospitals that can't afford to admit them, and a generation of kids who won't get a college education. Because, like in the 1930s, when it gets that bad, it stays stuck at the bottom for a decade. Maybe if it gets really bad, you get a revolution. Check the politics of the Depression: Huey Long, Norman Thomas, Father Coughlin, Americal First, fascist clubs.

One last thought: what was it that ended the Great Depression in America? Why, it was the biggest, most wasteful government spending program of all: we paid ten million Americans to dress in funny suits and march in circles, and ten million more to build planes and vehicles that smashed into the ground or burnt or got blown up. It was the Second World War, and we put it on credit.

by santeewelding

Let me know if you get a handle on it. The only thing I sense at the moment, is to remain alert for tipping points.

The Tucson thing doesn't look like it. Close, but no cigar; unless we're in for a spate of them.

by ansugisalas

are the ones giving solace to the ones giving fuel to the ones that go popping caps in people...

You people, for all the good you have, also have one of the most fiicked up political discourses outside of fiicking 1980 Cambodia!
No wonder you have assassinations every now and then. Max - they're politicians.
They're all bad.
There are no heroes in porkville.

So get over it, breathe deeply counting backwards from ten, and get over it some more.
It's not like the other side would have done any better, they'd just have pardoned some more CEOs with that money.

by maxwell edison

Are you friggin' serious? I'm witnessing the demise of my own country, and you tell me to get over it?????

P.S. It illustrates - and supports - my basic premise. Less government is the best government. (Due credit given to T.J.)

P.P.S. What's the difference between those who would steal money from another, one by vote and the other by gun?

by ansugisalas

for how long now?
It can't be good for you to have a blood pressure that high all the time.

At the PPS: The former is not theft, and is not in violation of those natural rights you talk about. Nor is it your place to deny the right of another to give their vote according to their rights - so stop whining about it.

Instead of contributing to near-extremist word-warring, thus contributing to the smokescreen that allows the leeches of porkville to have their way with your country and everything in it's reach, you should contribute to a constructive effort to get people to agree to realistic goals.
*None of that "no social security" crap, coz there are people who will have to kill you for food if it goes away.
:Instead help your fellows create a discourse where the actions of government are viewed in a realistic, nonpartizan, nonzealot light. Keep it real.
Or keep having steam come out of your ears like in the OP, whatever.

by maxwell edison

..... some guy from Finland tries to come across as an expert on Americans. I don't know about you, but he just rubs me the wrong way. (Of course, from his perspective, it's probably my short-coming, not his.)

by dogknees

ever think that perhaps the country in question deserves to go down the tubes? If they can't manage their affairs better than this, ....

by maxwell edison

I've been fighting against these things for twenty-plus years, and I deserve to go down with the ship?

Whatever......

by smartacew0lf

why exactly do you feel this way about America and its citizens? How long have you felt this way and what precipitated this feeling? All I ask for is your honesty. Actually, I feel I probably already know the answer.

by nicknielsen

There is no other currency with the strength to step in and carry the load if the US$ crumbles. As it stands now, if the US economy tanks, the world economy collapses with it.

by jamesrl

Canada is in relatively good shape economically; Canada didn't have the bank issues that the US and many European countries had, we didn't do any bailouts except for GM and Chrysler, our housing market is strong, unemployment is improving and the oil/gas market is very strong again. Our government is running a deficit, but we should be back to surplus and paying down the long term debt again in 5 years.

Having said all that, we cannot have a vigourous economy in Canada without a strong US economy.

by ansugisalas

Not that it matters.
And I don't try to come across as an expert on Americans.

I know language, and I know meaning.

The way you people use language in political subjects is highly unstable, making it a small step for a madman to go from the normal(1) "They're destroying our country" to the completely postal "I've gotta kill those [Party of Choice] congressmen".
After all, if someone is literally destroying the country, killing them is the usual response, is it not?

(1:normal in your political discourse - not normal in the sense of non-pathological)

by santeewelding

Is what kills you, vaunted language expertise, or not.

Step carefully. Others of us have a handle on language, too.

by ansugisalas

is a property of a society or community as a whole, a collective.
It's the sum of the standard ways the people of that collective speak about the various things they speak about.
I criticize that discourse; specifically the way Mr. Edison contributes to it, a way that seems to me (subjectively, and subject to faulty sampling) to be a widespread phenomenon.
And I can't, for the life of me, find a better way to address the people that make up a collective - specifically as members of that collective - than "you people".
I don't think it to mean "every single one of you people" - on the contrary; I intend it to mean "the resulting, de-facto output of the lot of you taken as a whole".

But I guess I should mind my business, and not talk so much.

by ansugisalas

too close.

And pointing a gun is pointless.

Pointing a gun and pulling the trigger, that's something.

Short of that, it's just holding your dick in public.

by Member 25348569

is the natural state.

It happened to us. And to the Romans, Ottomans, the Soviet Union...

Yes, Bush has contributed to the decline. On his watch you continued your bad habit of being militarily over-stretched (and I don't just mean the two ridiculous wars that we are currently engaged in).

The UK has been in a state of more or less steady decline since the 1880s, challenged by Germany, the US, Germany again, plus France, Italy and Japan and more recently by China, Brazil and India. Sterling ceased long ago to be the world's trading and reserve currency. The Empire is gone. Most of our utilities, car industry, the City, even chocolate factories, are owned by foreigners. But life goes on.

by maxwell edison

What the United States spends on all things military pales in comparison to everything else. The U.S. could have spent zero on military for the past ten years, and the Dollar's woes would still exist, perhaps delayed just a bit.

In 1960, the U.S. spent something like 60 percent of its budget on military. Today, it's more like 20 percent of a much larger budget.

The U.S. military has absolutely nothing to do with the decline and eventual fall of the U.S. Dollar and the U.S. economy. Run away social spending has everything to do with it.

But the military will have something to do with keeping order when the eventual fall will, most likely, cause civil unrest the likes of which haven't been seen in the United States since our own Civil War.

Although I will agree that we spread our military too far. I would have preferred that we pulled them all out of Europe 20, 30, maybe 40 years ago years ago, out of South Korea, etc. Let the Europeans deal with their own defense.

And to those smug know-it-alls who say stupid things like we (the U.S.) [i]deserve it[/i] won't be so smug when they realize what will happen to the world economies when the Dollar does collapse. It will be the mother of all economic domino effects!

P.S. another easy target to blame in addition to military spending is those [i]greedy rich people[/i] who don't pay enough in taxes. We could cut military spending to zero AND tax EVERYONE in the U.S. 100 percent of their income, and it would STILL not be enough to pay our debt and keep the promises on all the obligations of the U.S. Government.

by Member 25348569

It's just that it's generally been the first pointer to imperial decline. So I thought I'd start there.

As an aside, compared to his British sheeple counterpart, the average US citizen is an optimistic, forward-looking person. This means that when the cruch really does come, the likelihood of serious civil unrest is greater. We will just sit around at 'tut' at the price of petrol (which is now 7.53 USD per US gallon)...

One economic problem that I believe that we share, is an obsession with property. Successive governments have encouraged home ownership through incentives. You own your own home, you feel good, you continue to vote for the people you believe gave you this chance. If you look at the thirty years between 1950 to 1980, the world was pretty closed and protectionist and the US was at the height of its primacy. Compare this to 1980 to the present day and the growth rates of economies in these two periods have been roughly the same. But real wages didn't rise for the majority of people as much as they should have and globalisation may not have been as beneficial to the average Westerner as we were promised. Many economists believe that housing is probably one of the main reasons we are seeing this. All that happened is that the people just got more access to debt and larege amounts of that debt was diverted towards housing, generating a property bubble.

Pop...

The beneficiaries from globalisation are the ones that hold capital, not the holders of labour.

All of our successive governments have failed to address, through stupidity or just classic political and economic short-term thinking, that labour is a global commodity. American and British workers now directly compete for jobs with those making pittance wages in China and India. The fact that millions of our jobs are being offshored and outsourced does not bother advocates of globalism at all because it is supposedly a beneficial thing for the overall global economy. But, as I said above, it isn't working that way.

More later...

:)

by Member 25348569

700 billion USD per annum up front figures.

During the Bush Presidency, after correcting for inflation, military spending rose at an average rate of 8.1 percent per year. During the same period, the overall US economy grew at an average annual rate of 2.4 percent.

Plus all of the 'extras'. Interest on the money borrowed to finance this. The necessary treatment costs for US wounded in your (mostly unnecessary) wars. Those costs are just going to keep on going UP.

The GDP of Afghanistan, before the invasion, was around 5 billion USD with half of that coming from opium sales. You are spending ten times that figure per annum to get absolutely nowhere.

Neil :)

I'll get on to the "greedy rich", later.

by maxwell edison

I suspect you simply have a problem with my use of the word [i]fighting[/i]. I also suspect you take it too literal, not as being synonymous with opposing.

But okay, I'll play along. What should I - personally - have done that I didn't do?

by ansugisalas

Did you oppose ALL of the leeches, both left and right?
Did you call BS on superfluous war efforts, too?
Did you set aside patriotic conditioning when the US military - too - showed signs of corruption?
What did you do?
It's obvious that you alone could have done everything right, and still not have succeeded... but the Maxwell Edison I've seen here is not one I would suspect of choosing an efficient strategy over an idealistically approvable one.

by maxwell edison

You think you understand me, but you don't. I also don't think you understand squat about the U.S. budget. And it's obvious you don't understand the concept of [i]American Democracy[/i] - as it was intended.

Re: [i]the right of another to give their vote according to their rights[/i].

A democracy is not three wolves and a sheep [i]voting[/i] on what's for dinner. So stop whining about trying to make it so.

by ansugisalas

Goes all the way through, terminus : China.

Did I get that right?

Three wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner? And let me guess; the republican-backed corporate rule is the "sheep"... and the "wellfare mothers" are the wolves?

You're dumbing yourself down way too much. This is that "fighting" you've been doing, right? No wonder you're up shit creek with a paddle up your ass - sideways.
You should have done something useful, not ranted uselessly - like you do here, now.

I've yet to hear you say something constructive that doesn't concern pre-19th-century events.

Why don't you let your own history inform you on how to deal with crises? And no, Booth is not what I'm talking about.

by Member 25348569

Is about where you're at in the process.

Fast food and reality television.

:(

The fundamental causes for the fall of Rome:

Over-militarisation and military over-extension

Widespread indebtness

A widening gap between rich and poor

The imposition of religious fundamentalism as the state religion

The denigration of rational thought in favour of faith

The moral decay epitomised by Bread and Circus within the Roman Empire.

Recognise any of these?

by dwdino

Max,

While you do present a valid point about this point in time, it is only and indicator of a graver root cause.

This nation, for at least 5 decades has been developing a resistance to what is right. As another has posted, all other "kingdoms" have risen and fell. I therefore propose that this downfall is the just rewards for an amoral people. Throughout history, the internal degradation of the people has led to the demise of the society and nation.

Is it possible to correct course and recover? Yes. Is it likely? Doubtful. Societies are built from the ground up. A strong people will throw off a radical government. A weak society will allow its trespasses to be replayed in its government.

Overspending? This has been the norm for the majority for some time. Now the government is caught in the same crisis.

Moral relativism? See above.

Lack of self-control? See above.

by dwdino

And as I have history, known to you, I see no need to revisit my stance.

Let me return the volley in this manner. Find a nation having completed this cycle, ancient Rome perhaps. Define its height and the change leading to its demise.

Similiarly, our nations founding and its general base in comparison to today, yields a few astounding contrasts. Some support my premise.

So, can you, on the other hand, defend that a switch from one base to another will not topple the tower?

by jellimonsta

[q]Overspending? This has been the norm for the majority for some time. Now the government is caught in the same crisis.[/q]

I would argue that overspending has been the crux of governmental issues for a long time, and is not a recent development. Granted under the current administration, the issue has become paramount, regardless of the detractors.

by smartacew0lf

Someone up for a fight or what? Honestly, Max, your post smacks of exactly what we have all slowly began to absorb as a normal and reasonable way of doing things. I.E. Just as it is done in the news media and even in Congress. No one is accountable for anything anymore. It's the other sides fault.

There is an old saying that goes like this, "Remember, when pointing fingers at others, there are 3 times as many fingers pointing back at you on the same hand" Nowhere have I witnessed this to be more self-evident than it is in present day idealogical arguments. My first choice of words to end the previous sentence with was "discussions". But the plain and simple fact of the matter is that there is so little actually being discussed these days its pathetic. All looks like a Bill O'Reilly show where he suckers someone from the opposing faction and stacks at least 4 more people holding views close to his own up against them. And then none of the 5 against the individual will even give the person the opportunity to speak!

Excuse the sh1t out of me for voting Democrat in our presidential election 2 years ago. But quite simply, after the exploitation of the international support we had after 911 in using it to pillage and loot another country for their wealth there was no way in hell I could vote for another Republican. Not that year anyway.

But perhaps you truly believe in what we are doing in Iraq. Perhaps it doesn't bother you that we let Bin Laden slip away from our grasp as some "politician" defies all known military strategy with his foolishness.

The eyes of the world are and have been on US. Perhaps you aren't paying attention. Our closest of Allies are beginning to distance themselves. Personally, I don't blame them.

by Member 25348569

The reasons given for the fall of Rome are many and some are disputed. One of the reasons given to which I subscribe is the adoption of an overconfident and intolerant Christianity as the State Religion (Gibbon, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire). I'm not setting this up as a precursor to a religious debate (Yet. I'm still working through my original list and this comes in at #4) but I did want to question - and still do - your use of "amoral" and see if it came from a religious perspective and if it reinforced my belief in the way your society is going.

If you choose not to tell me what you think I already know (I don't), then I'll move on. Life is too short.

:)

by dwdino

Amoral - having no moral standards, restraints, or principles; unaware of or indifferent to questions of right or wrong

A nation disposed to its own pleasures above all else is destined to destruction.

"intolerant Christianity" is the fault in your premise. There are numerous examples in history of perversion of the source for a specific gain. But I digress...

by nicknielsen

Who defines them? Do they extend further than "Thou shalt not kill" and "Thou shalt not steal"? Some apparently wish to progress to "Thou shalt not think differently."

Even better, what does "moral" mean?

"Intolerant Christianity" is a redundancy and has been so almost since the birth of the religion.

by jamesrl

Do you accept that those of other faiths and creeds can be moral?

If I recall my history, the American founding fathers were opposed to following the principle of am official state religion as existed in England.

by maxwell edison

..... that I don't singularly blame the current crop of Democrats or President Obama - although they did put the economic disaster plan on steroids. (Side Note: If you were to actually design an economic disaster plan for a nation, just look at what the United States is doing and has been doing for the past 40-50 years, and you have the perfect blueprint from which to copy.)

This trend has been maintained and fed with both major parties in control of both Houses of Congress and/or the White House. I've been harping and warning about the same thing for two or three decades. Those who've been around TR as long as I have can recall the myriad discussions I've started and/or comments made on the subject.

When did it start, and who do I blame?

It started in 1865 when the Confederate States of America were militarily prevented from seceding from the Union. Abraham Lincoln was the most instrumental person in American history in squashing individual state's rights. The one thing that could be most instrumental in keeping the federal government in check is strong and independent state governments - something long lost.

If a territory can voluntarily join the union, then it - or the states carved from that territory - should be able to voluntarily leave if the federal government gets too powerful and tyrannical.

I can actually envision the day when a good number of states actually attempt to secede from the United States. But instead of taking up arms, I would envision the taking back of resources, the refusal to send money and representatives to Congress; and if the federal military is sent in to put down the peaceful rebellion, instead of armed resistance, we'd probably see the proverbial lone soul standing in front of the tank in the town square.

I blame the people who crafted, presented, and passed the 17th Amendment to the United States Constitution, something that further eroded individual states' rights. (Note: Originally, the members of the U.S. House of Representatives were elected by direct vote of the people of their respective state, while the members of the U.S. Senate were elected by the members of the individual state legislatures.)

I blame the people who crafted, presented, and passed the 16th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which, in essence, financially enslaved the entire U.S. population. Taxes are certainly necessary to maintain a strong and effective government, but when the collection of such is also used to control - and punish - the population, we have tyranny.

Americans certainly love rags to riches stories, but they then like to see the rich and affluent come crashing back down. And giving government the power to seize the fruits of one's labor IS tyranny. And in the process, we've indirectly given one citizen the power to vote himself the fruits of another person's labor. That, too, is tyranny.

I blame FDR and his merry band of Socialists who rammed through Congress and the Courts what soon became the roots of Socialism in America.

I blame LBJ and his Great Society Programs, along with the Congress that passed them, and later ones that refused to repeal them. LBJ was probably the one person most instrumental in giving people a reason to shirk their own personal responsibility.

I blame Republicans, in general, since 1964, who then started to run scared from their libertarian roots in favor of seeking votes. In general, Republicans since 1964 have been behaving more and more like Democrats and Socialists (but I repeat myself), and less like true Republicans.

I blame the population that refuses to accept responsibility for their own lives. And I blame the voters who figured out that they could actually vote themselves gifts from the treasury. Moreover, these same voters seem to approach elections like they would American Idol. Principle and policy be dammed! They only want the best looking and the best sounding people with no figurative warts - a shallow and ignorant approach to one's civic duty.

I blame the public educational system for systematically doing away with teaching true American ideals, accurate American History, and the true intent of the Constitution.

I blame the mainstream news media - e.g. AP, NY Times, Washington Post, CBS, ABC, NBS, et al - who've lost their objectivity in favor of advancing social agendas. Moreover, they've failed in their watch-dog role in seeking out and exposing corruption in, and mismanagement of government.

I could go on, but that's enough for now.

by delbertpgh

I've often said that a thoughtful man can't be wrong about everything, and you have again proved my point. Perhaps you are surprised that I share your view on anything. If you have paid attention to my posts, you know I am basically conservative. I may stand in the shallow end of the conservative pool, but I'm there, not somewhere else sentimentalizing Castro and 1960s Swedish socialism and believing that all people need is the right government-administered therapy to be their best.

Like you, I'm disappointed in American education, because it has lost rigor and relevance. I am especially disappointed in what passes for history textbooks these days. (I suspect you favor a history I might consider indoctrination.) The high school texts I've seen are bad because they abjure almost any narrative at all, and replace it with a collage of short sidebar articles about random topics with no context, designed to uplift the spirt of any and every minor group of Americans, and to offend no group major or minor, save the ones with actively working critical brains.

I don't think the press (or your "mainstream media") is working very well in keeping the citizens advised of what's important, or keeping the hot bright lights on government. They do a lot better than Fox, which is outright dishonest on a number of accounts and is little more than a shill for the Republican party, but the mainstream still does a lousy job.

The people have definitely lost track of what they need from government, along with their willingness to pay for what they demand. I'd agree that democracy has not functioned as well as it has at times in the past, with representatives afraid to tell a consistent story (or vote a consistent line) if it means any pain or sacrifice. The people want a happy face, and the elected bodies try to provide it.

However, this sort of ends our sunny interlude of shared opinion. I'll put my critiques of your position in a few other short posts. That way, it won't mar this moment of golden harmony that we share.

by delbertpgh

Lincoln, our greatest president, held the union together, and we have been more prosperous and more free because of it. (He originally did nothing when Southern states seceded, until South Carolina went and started the war by shelling a Federal fort. Still, I give him the credit.) Lincoln foresaw an American continent fractured in pieces, each piece obsessed with defense (or war) against the others, each using tariffs and trade restrictions to build its wealth at the expense of others. Being split in pieces would have been expensive and tragic, with generation after generation facing the cost of going to war with other Americans.

What greater freedom would have it promised, even if you were to disregard the suffering of a fragmented people? The states that seceded were interested only in the freedom of white people to deny dark people their rights. If you permitted secession (or nullification of Federal law by states) these days, would it lead to greater freedom for individuals in their daily lives, or just to some theoretical freedom exercised by a geographically-defined polity, which they could experience only through their legislature? Reading about the freedom your state government enjoys is to me less enabling than having freedom in my personal life.

In the 20th century there has been a great expansion of equality, which is to say freedom, at the instigation of the Federal government over the reluctance of some of the states. Blacks, women, Catholics, Jews, Chinese, Japanese, and Hispanics have all gained titular equality in the places where white men alone had freedom. It's part of a great story, one that is not finished and improves over time.

by delbertpgh

I don't understand the sentimentalization of the pre-17th amendment era. (For people not up on the U.S. constitution: the 17th amendment required that Senators, like members of the House of Representatives, be elected by vote of the people of their state, and not just be appointed by the state legislature.) When senators were elected by legislatures, they were much more in the pocket of financial interests, especially banking, mining, and railroads. Half the Senate was bought and paid for by capitalists. The old system was just an open invitation to crooks. The 17th amendment was honestly a reform.

The 16th legalized the Federal income tax as a means of funding the government. Prior to this, virtually all Federal revenues were raised from import tariffs, with a little more from various fees. You simply could not have a government large enough to run the 20th century United States paid only out of tariffs and user fees.

Had the 16th not been passed, the Federal government would probably have had to finance itself by a national sales tax (probably in the area of 20%), or by ingenious and nefarious other techniques to confiscate wealth. The government would not, sorry to tell the conservatives, have faded away or even failed to grow had this juicy tax been abolished.

The graduated income tax is fairer than many other taxes would have been. It's unnecessarily complex, but it does the job. The country needs government, and the income tax assures it will be financed.

by ansugisalas

Maxwell just poses as a libertarian, and is actually working for corporate rule.
He doesn't seem to be ranting against monopolies, nor against corporate-owned politicians and he doesn't seem worried about the military behaving like a state within the state. But then, the military is all chummy with the corporates, since yellowfruit.

by delbertpgh

Conservatives deplore Franklin Roosevelt because he expanded government, and legitimized intervention in society by government. However, in 1932, a lot of Americans were ready to give up on what had once worked in favor of any alternative, and for some, that meant the wilder, the better. There had been three full years of progressive economic collapse: banks failed by the thousands, and depositors' money had simply disappeared when they closed; unemployment was at 20% nation wide; the stock market had fallen 90% from its peak. Nobody had confidence. Nobody was hiring or investing. Money, if it had not been lost, sat idle in deposits.

Without a new activist force in government, Americans were ready for one of the European ideologies that seemed to be successful at staving off the chaos of modernism: communism, or fascism. Both are today repellent to us. In the 1930s, they weren't as repellent as watching your children go hungry.

Franklin saved American life. There would have been a much darker period without his leadership.

Incidentally, in 1932, Republicans lost control of the house, senate, and presidency: 101 house seats (plus 14 more in 1934;) 12 senate seats (plus 9 more in 1934;) and Roosevelt over Hoover, 57% to 40%. Norman Thomas, a socialist, got 2%. The country was emphatic in its decision, way more than we have seen in recent decades.

by keighlar

... you have a way of saying what I am thinking in such a way that it makes me wonder if you sometimes you sit and take lunch in my brain. I know that my presence here is mostly that of the lurker, but all my wanderings make me feel that I know most of the regulars here like those in my neighborhood. So, even knowing that I am likely to get scourged, I have to stand strongly on the side of Max's points.

This once great country is in its death throes and we, its citizens, are lashed to its every roiling convulsion. Since I had voice to speak I have spoken against the onslaught of governmental control in our personal lives. It's gotten me nowhere but bitter and jaded.

Even now, we give way in the smallest things and wonder why we have no backbone as a populace in the larger things. My daughter's school showed a very controversial film in her Science class last week without notifying the parents of the children. She asked me to keep silent; my fiance asked me to keep silent. It's no big deal. Leave it alone. Don't stir the pot. Don't create waves.

There lies the beginning of complacency. I cannot keep silent and sleep at night even if my voice echoes in the dark. "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." [Edmund Burke]

We have done nothing for so long that only tattered vestiges of the Spirit of America remain. Until we are ready to take responsibility for ourselves, to ourselves, I see no hope of deliverance.

by jackofalltech

Reading so many negative comments from people who just don't get it.

I really don't think, outside of Divine intervention, that there is any hope for my beloved country.

by ansugisalas

You do realize that nations have gotten back on their feet even after the bankruptcy was a fact, right?

You're not even there, yet, and still some are already skipping forward to the "let's place the blame, now that we're all confined to hell for eternity" -game.

There's a two step program for getting back on your feet.
Step one: Spend wisely.
Step two: Work your ass off.
:Repeat as needed.

It works.

by maxwell edison

Re: [i]The way you talk makes me wonder if you're stocking up on canned food, ammunition, and Krugerrands.[/i]

People should have individual disaster plans in place, or at least in mind, to prepare themselves for any number of disasters so they DON'T have to rely on government to do it for them. All one has to do is look at the debacle called Katrina as an illustration.

People should be prepared for medical emergencies by at least having a First Aid Kit, and know how to administer it. For all too many people, the only First Aid they need to know is 911.

People should be prepared in case of massive power outages.

People should be prepared for weather emergencies.

And yes, people should be prepared for some degree of civil unrest and/or social collapse. It can't happen here, you say? Yea, right.

But it's your smug and condescending attitude that exacerbates the problem. And it presupposes that people should not be prepared to take responsibility for themselves. Just wait until we have the nation-wide economic version of Hurricane Katrina. People might wish they were better prepared and relied less on government and more on themselves.

by delbertpgh

I'm paying down debt, and losing weight. Leaves me less susceptible to two kinds of potential economic misery. Although I'm not building up a year's supply of canned food (like a Mormon), I buy extra when it's cheap. Lots of people like me, holding back on our spending and being very careful of what we do spend it on, contribute to the slow growth of our economy and to the near-zero rates of inflation.

What I'd really like to see is my government get a proper stimulus working, (preferably something that rebuilt our infrastructure so we'd have something lasting and useful to show for the borrowed money,) so we could get the hell out of this panicked recessionary mindset. Then, all of a sudden we'd have inflation and the budget deficit to worry about, which we'd be able to fix, because we'd be rich Americans again.

by santeewelding

Meaning, that, at the moment, you are not prepared for immediate and personal adversity? You look to the kindness of strangers, themselves beset?

by jellimonsta

But do you, really? Or do you just think you know what's right for you, in a moment of incorrect judgement? :p :D

by maxwell edison

You know [i]what's right[/i] for you, I know [i]what's right[/i] for me, and John and Jane Doe know best [i]what's right[/i] for them.

None of the aforementioned people should force their definition of [i]what's right[/i] onto others - the very thing that's necessary in any collective social system. And likewise, government shouldn't define [i]what's right[/i].

That's precisely why I'm adamantly opposed to it - collectivism, socialism, government nannyism, etc. I'm baffled as to why more people don't agree.

Well, no I'm not. I know why. It's because when people define [i]what's right[/i] for themselves, it means they must also accept responsibility for themselves - something all too many people either don't want to do or are afraid to do. The right to define [i]what's right[/i] for you is only one side of the coin; on the other side is responsibility. You can't have one without accepting the other; and when you give one away one, you lose the other.

by dwdino

"their definition of what's right" - while this often comes into play, there is a third, outside definer of right.

More acurrately, you are free to choose to align with right or wrong, but both have been long since defined.

by hannibb74

The laws of economics are the same, no matter where you are. When you print too much money and don't care about deficits, you destroy your currency!
That day will arrive if nothing is done, the worst part is that in Latin america people are used to be poor and suffer, but in the USA people will suffer a lot more, because the standard of living will be lowered tremendously.

by delbertpgh

The current level of military spending is higher, in inflation-adjusted current dollars, than at any point in our history, except the 2nd World War. Higher than Viet Nam, higher than the cold war.

When you talk about boots on the ground, it costs now about $500,000 per pair of boots, including soldier, excluding some other costs. Got to hope they are at least 100 times more effective than the cheaper shoes that oppose them.

by jamesrl

The Navy and Air Force, where many of the big ticket items go.

From what I read on Wikipedia, the cost of new equipment is almost as high as the salary cost of the US military. And some of those programs are questionable in temrs of cost effectiveness.

by maxwell edison

One could certainly - and legitimately - argue that none of the military budget comes from borrowed money. Throughout the history of the United States, national defense was the primary role of the U.S. government, and, with the possible exception of WWII, it was financed without accumulating massive budget deficits.

The huge budget deficits didn't really start until the 1960s, 1970s range - immediately following the massive social programs implemented under LBJ. Military spending has been a constant throughout our history; social spending has not.

Therefore, one could very reasonably - and more accurately - argue that it's the social spending, not military spending, that is the root cause of our deficits, debt, interest payments on said debt, and current economic woes.

by dwdino

Christianity teaches that there are many paths and many who will find them, but only one that leads to restoration and satisfaction.

Intolerance dictates that "no other can exist". This creates a dichotomy as the two words are opposed.

by dwdino

Yes, moral is a human measurement of a persons choices. Often this measurement is aligned with a given set.

You are the first to attempt to intertwine (sp) the two subjects. The morality of a people and the enslavement by a government has now been raised by you.

by nexs

If the person you don't like gets voted in, you yell at all the voters who voted against your choice.

Just classy. ;)

But in your defense, America's financial situation affects many countries around the world. Whether it be negative or positive, there's no doubt that the USA still has a great effect on the world.

by maxwell edison

It's their policy positions and their agendas that I don't like.

In a nutshell, I want government to get the hell out of my life and not infringe upon my right to take responsibility for my own life. And there are tens/hundreds of millions of people with that same attitude.

Unfortunately for us, there are other people, both in and out of government, who simply will not allow that to happen. That's not what America is supposed to be about. In fact, the role of government is to PROTECT and GUARANTEE that right, not infringe upon it.

People simply say, screw you dude; you got out-voted. You have to do what the majority wants you to do. Tyranny of the majority.

And in the process of doing all this, they have created a financial mess for the United States that will be very difficult - if not impossible - to correct before we experience an economic collapse.

by ansugisalas

They had to suffer through the eight years of Elmer Fudd and his various military escapades and massive loanings and ... [i]screwing up the economy on purpose to help his rich friends get richer[/i].
So, now you're having the same ride, with less of the stone-crazy, and you can't handle it?

by Member 25348569

Are you saying that those of us on the outside, looking in, aren't allow to tell it as we see it?

Well, you can ignore us, but stop me or the "guy from Finland", if you can.

:D

by Member 25348569

Even when I deliberately step (throw myself) over the line?

:D

Bedtime, here. We haven't had a good discussion for AGES so it will be nice to see what has become of this thread by my morning. I just may have to brush up on recent US economic policy.

by jamesrl

But our economy is intergrated tightly with the US. We have a free trade agreement, we have many cross border companies, transportation costs are low and shipping is fast, the list goes on and on.

We have ticked off China by standing up for human rights. And we have been slow to warm up to opportunities in India.

by maxwell edison

..... that you won't comment on the discussion.

I absolutely LOVE your take and opinion on my discussions. Just like I love eggs with bacon; pancakes with maple syrup; biscuits with gravy; movies with popcorn; peanut butter with jelly; golf with beer; gasoline with a 400 HP engine; cheese with crackers; coffee with a muffin; scotch with ....... ice - and more scotch.

Not even a tease?

by santeewelding

Is that anything like, ronkedoor?

Oh, and, did you ever get a forward of the article by Orson Welles? Whorfian Hypothesis, and all; like your post.

by ansugisalas

I've had a busy schedule lately, but I am reading it.

I don't follow the hardcore Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, but I do follow the later refined versions - language has an impact on thinking, but it does not categorically define thinking.

This is yellowfruit, I know, there's older stuff too.

Edited for order.

by ansugisalas

show that you have no sense of continuum.
How will you make a change if you say "Democrats"?
That's the smoke-screen I'm talking about.
You're not only buying into this supposed "difference", you're selling it on, with a markup!
There is no difference! Stop bickering about the "vote", and start building the flucking alternative.

If you're not part of the solution - you're a part of the smoke-screen.

Sorry for shouting ;)