Discussion Locked

To those who voted for Democrats two years ago

0 helpful
279 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

279 replies

by delbertpgh

Nobody's politics can run in a straight line, not without making one look somewhat extreme. Neither Max nor me.

Although I believe government and other broad-shouldered institutions should be limited and should stay the hell out of my life as much as possible, I feel the same way about large companies, too. Powerful corporations under the control of greedy men can strip the liberty from your American life, much as a bunch of socialist do-gooders can, but they will do it for the sake of power and wealth. Theodore Roosevelt (maybe our 5th greatest president) recognized this, and saw that government had to stand between the people and business in the 20th century. I'm pretty much of the same mind with Teddy on that.

by ansugisalas

That's why I'm against tendentious politics. If it doesn't have a specific goal, non-directional and discrete, I won't have it.

But it always seems to be "less foreigners" or "less taxes" or "less government" or "more welfare" or "better education" or "more efficient education"... nobody dares say "We want an educational system exactly this big, with these specs", or "We believe our nation can cope with, and benefit from approximately [b]this[/b] rate of foreign-to-native inhabitants" or "We want a government that can handle [b]these[/b] tasks"...
When everybody has a "more" or "less" directional goal, there's no true room for consensus.
If everybody is clear about their goals they can go measure the distances, and see where the compromises can be found.
And then people on both political wings will find that there are people on their own sides with which they have nothing in common.

by jamesrl

Even a political party as small as two people will eventually find an issue that divides it.

Political Parties often subscribe to large scale vague principles, but differe sharply on how to achieve short or even long term goals.

When you are a member of a political party, you have to agree that you can't always get everything you want, but by supporting the party, you can get some of what you want, and that your party is closer to your values, ideals and goals than another party.

In systems like the US and Canada, were a small number of parties exist, you will get broad coalition parties. Thats just human nature. So setting a specific goal is just not that easy. You can say less foreigners, but members will have different ideas and priorities about what would bring that about in the best manner.

by delbertpgh

That crazy boy who shot 20 people was schizophrenic, not political. He had some political ideas, but any information or theory in his head was overwhelmed by the crazy.

As much as I blame today's "conservatives" for embittering political talk, I can't assign them the slightest responsibility for this murdering crackpot.

by maxwell edison

Re: [i]... today's "conservatives" for embittering political talk[/i]

We hear that claim all the time, but never accompanied with specific examples. Do you care to post some specific examples of such [i]embittering political talk[/i]? Specific examples means full quotes in full context, either written or video.

I'd like to know just exactly what you mean by that. Perhaps others would as well.

by jamesrl

I don't think that conservatives are the only ones throwing out nutty talk.

But if you want examples of what I consider to be wacky speach that stirs up hate and divides the country, here goes.

"I hope that's not where we're going, but you know if this Congress keeps going the way it is, people are really looking toward those Second Amendment remedies and saying my goodness what can we do to turn this country around? I'll tell you the first thing we need to do is take Harry Reid out." Nevada GOP Senate candidate Sharron Angle, floating the possibility of armed insurrection in a radio interview, Jan. 2010

"This is what Hitler did with the SS. He had his own people. He had the brownshirts and then the SS. This is what Saddam Hussein so but you are comparing that. And I , I mean, I think America would have a really hard time getting their arms around that.''
Glenn Beck, claiming Obama's 'civilian national security force' is the same as what Hitler and Saddam Hussein did, Glenn Beck, FOX News' Glenn Beck show, Aug. 27, 2009"

"We Came Unarmed ? This Time" from a list of 'favorite' signs at Tea Party rallies.

"He has no place in any station of government and we need to realize that he is an enemy of humanity," said Rep. Trent Franks about Obama.

"Our nation was founded on violence. The option is on the table. I don't think that we should ever remove anything from the table as it relates to our liberties and our freedoms." Tea Party-backed Texas GOP congressional candidate Stephen Broden, suggesting the violent overthrow of the U.S. government if Republicans don't win at the ballot box, interview with Dallas's WFAA-TV, Oct. 21, 2010

And let me be clear, I don't think that this kind of talk, however reprehensible, is responsible for a nut job with a gun shooting a congresswoman. But there is clearly evidence of embittering talk, on both sides of the aisle.

by tonythetiger

"If they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun" - Barack Obama

"I don?t sit around just talking to experts because this is a college seminar, we talk to these folks because they potentially have the best answers, so I know whose ass to kick." - Barack Obama

"That Scott down there that's running for governor of Florida. Instead of running for governor of Florida, they ought to have him and shoot him. Put him against the wall and shoot him." - U.S. Rep. Paul E. Kanjorski

"If I hear one more Republican tell me about balancing the budget, I am going to strangle them." - Joe Biden

"You guys see Live and Let Die, the great Bond film with Yaphet Kotto as the bad guy, Mr. Big? In the end they jam a big CO2 pellet in his face and he blew up. I have to tell you, Rush Limbaugh is looking more and more like Mr. Big, and at some point somebody?s going to jam a CO2 pellet into his head and he?s going to explode like a giant blimp. That day may come. Not yet. But we?ll be there to watch. I think he?s Mr. Big, I think Yaphet Kotto. Are you watching, Rush?" - Chris Matthews

by delbertpgh

I mean that the tone of politics has become nastier. There are far more cases of politicians, and particularly of commentators with access to broadcast media, who paint opponents as not just wrong on policy, but as treasonous or revenge-driven evil spawn, who want to do nothing but destroy wealth, blacken the future, and sow despair among good people so that America will never prosper again.

Republican-allied forces seem to be making the most of this tactic. If you don't hear it, I imagine your concern about other issues has left you deaf to these tones, and no appeal to reason or evidence would convince you otherwise.

As for specific examples, James has documented a few. Tony has provided opposing material. For every quote, there's a counter-quote. I won't bother, because there's no way to demonstrate what the climate of discourse is by plucking a dozen words from here or there. I've watched enough of Hannity, Palin, Issa, and others to spot that the basic strategy is to get people pissed off.

by smartacew0lf

as citizens of this country we have lost not only the support of citizens around the world in other countries, but their respect as well. Indeed we do get what we deserve.

by Member 25348569

I had read a few excerpts and there was no way that I could believe that the book had been written by - or was even about - the bumbling idiot that was Bush. But that's a purely subjective conclusion...

I do remember that the book prompted Gerhard Schroeder to call Bush a liar.

:)

by Member 25348569

"national defense was the primary role of the U.S. government" is one of those statements that has me muttering "theoretically, yes" and it would translate into reality if it were not for the fact that I don't actually see your military [b]defending[/b] anything at the moment. Nor have they done so for quite a while.

Obviously, I'm not an expert in US military history so I invite suggestions as to where and when this [b]national defense[/b] happened.

The last half century will do...

by nicknielsen

The case being made through the collapse of the Berlin Wall was that by defending Europe and the Far East from further Communist 'encroachment' (isn't that just a less offensive word for invasion?), we were defending ourselves. The domino effect, and all that.

The problem was, of course, our leaders had (and still do have) a regrettable tendency to allow ideological rigidity to trump common sense. They very consistently chose to back people simply because they were anti-communist (or said they were). This led to the backing of repressive rightist dictators over leftist democratic reformers, while preaching "people's choice" and "rule of law" to the world.

This distressing hypocrisy probably contributed more to the anti-Americanism prevalent over the last century than any other factor.

by maxwell edison

The cost of the U.S. military - for whatever purpose, right or wrong, it was being used for - has historically been paid for without creating budget deficits. Budget deficits didn't really exist in significant numbers until we got ourselves on the road to financing myriad social programs.

Therefore, my point that military spending today does not cause the current budget deficits, but rather social spending causes them, is a very legitimate argument that you've conveniently side-stepped around.

by delbertpgh

It's clear that the memoirs are sort of a historical dramatization, written by people who had talked to someone who was there, but had based substantial portions on articles and interviews written by other people. Quite a bit of dialog, including Bush's own, was plagiarised from other works, and as you mentioned, some of the actors testify it's simply not true.

It's more of a historical novel than history.

by Member 25348569

Sorry, but budgets is budgets. Everything is the cause - too much of everything. If military spending had been going down over the past few years then I would grant you your point.

Has it? According to my sources, military expenditure as a percentage of GDP rose every year that Bush was President.

Oh, and fell, year on year, during Clinton's watch.

by maxwell edison

I'm quite happy looking at the numbers - ALL OF THEM - and letting them speak for themselves.

I'll acknowledge that military spending, as a percentage of GDP, rose from about 4 percent to 6 percent between 2000 and 2010.

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/downchart_gs.php?title=Military_Industrial_Complex&year=1960_2013&units=p&chart=30-total

I'll also point out that TOTAL government spending, as a percentage of GDP, rose from about 33 percent to about 44 percent during that same period.

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/downchart_gs.php?year=1900_2010&units=p&title=Spending%20as%20percent%20of%20GDP

2 percent additional for the military versus 9 percent additional for all the rest. However, I didn't limit my sights on only the past ten years, I looked at the past 50 years - a more accurate indicator of the overall trend.

In 1962, when military spending was at 11 percent of the GDP, since the military consumed 60 percent of all government spending, all other government spending was only about 5 percent of the GDP. Run-away social spending started in the 1960s. Today, total military spending is ONLY 6 percent of the GDP and 20 percent of the budget, while all other government spending is 38 percent of the GDP and 80 percent of the budget.

In a nutshell (repeating myself, I suppose):

From 1962 to 2010, military spending, as a percentage of GDP, went from 11 percent to 6 percent - down 46 percent.

From 1962 to 2010, all other government spending, as a percentage of GDP, went from 5 percent to 38 percent. What is that? An increase of almost 800 percent?

Nonetheless, the United States needs to go on a serious spending diet. Your diet plan, Neil, calls for eating less of the comparative very small piece of pie. My plan, on the other hand, calls for eating less of the much bigger piece of pie. But most Americans think like you do, Neil; and our financial obesity problem not only continues, but it gets worse every year because too many Government Big Mac Meals are being handed out - Super Sized ones at that.

Cut BOTH of those pieces by 50 percent, and I'd be tickled to death!

But whatever; I won't push you anymore. If you don't want to acknowledge the obvious, then you won't acknowledge the obvious.

by ansugisalas

of what is called a political wing.
With "...nothing in common..." I meant that they'll actually look at the others, actually see them - and simply go "WTF?!? What in the ... Srsly, WTF!?!"

But nothing else is good too... except it makes me think "Nothing else than what? Bipedal motility? Dependency on drawing breath? What?"

by jamesrl

We are having a competition at work and I'm down nearly three pounds the first week.

I hear you on the first resolution, I'm not posting to his general premise. I think its ground we've been over before.

by jamesrl

"The Ghost Writer" that is - its pretty transparently supposed to remind you of Blair and his memoirs, though clearly the plot slips into territory that is creative fiction. Still interesting.

by ansugisalas

It means that each member is effectively resonating the least common denominator on all issues that member doesn't care intensely about. It can never work well.
Ideally a no-party parliament would be best; just the elected individuals following their own minds.
Ideally. In practice it'd be too ineffective, could be a weimar mkII. It would require some seriously innovative decision processing to keep it moving.
Perhaps a major game theory or connectivist theory breakthrough away?

by maxwell edison

..... not from the quote itself:

[i].... floating the possibility of armed insurrection in a radio interview, Jan. 2010[/i]

She didn't float the possibility of an armed insurrection!

[i].... Glenn Beck, claiming Obama's 'civilian national security force' is the same as what Hitler and Saddam Hussein did[/i]

Big friggin' deal! How many times was Bush compared to Hitler?

[i].... suggesting the violent overthrow of the U.S. government if Republicans don't win at the ballot box[/i]

That quote didn't suggest the violent overthrow of the U.S. government!

NONE of those words are direct quotes.

But these are:

http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0608/Obama_brings_a_gun_to_a_knife_fight.html

http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/obama-latinos-punish-your-enemies-voting-booth_511932.html

http://teresamerica.blogspot.com/2009/10/chris-matthews-wishes-rush-limbaugh.html

I could go on, but I won't.

Besides, I've said many times in these threads that wars are caused by those who take away individual freedom and liberty. Is that also inciting violence? And is it a false statement? When was the last war waged by a people to restore freedom and liberty? When was the last war waged by a people who wanted to give up their freedom and liberty? The former question has many answers. The answer to the latter question is never.

People can - and do - reach a breaking point, as history has proven time and again, when their freedom and liberty is taken away. People have never reached a breaking point with more freedom, only with less.

Are people reaching such a breaking point? You're damn right they are! (Oh my! Is that violent speech?) I've even suggested that the day might come when some states want to secede from the union. Is that suggesting a Civil War? There are those in the media who would add that suggestion after reporting my original comment.

Example:

"..... the day might come when some states want to secede from the union", said Maxwell Edison suggesting the possibility of a second American Civil War. (Of course, I never suggested a Civil War.)

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=340147&messageID=3406784&tag=content;leftCol

Nonetheless, it's not the angry tone of the language that should be condemned, but rather what's causing it. All too many people want to stifle the language as a means to advance an ever-increasing encroachment on individual freedom and liberty.

Thomas Jefferson even noted (I'm paraphrasing) that a rebellion now and then was a good thing to keep government in check.

(I kind of rambled all over the place, but what the heck!)

by jamesrl

With regards to Sharron Angle, to me when you suggest second amendment remedies to what Congress is doing and "Taking Harry Reid out" in the same breath, its clear to me what she means.

As to Bush and Hitler, when do two wrongs make a right? Do you believe Obama can be equated to Hitler?

Enemy of humanity? Thats just outrageous inflamatory rhetoric. I would feel the same if someone said it of Bush.

I am well aware of TJ's famous quote. And personally I think in the case of a Hitler, it might be justified. But clearly, the US is not at that point. The US democracy has some huge issues, but it isn't dead yet. Similarly the economy is in bad shape, but can recover. The debt is an issue, but it can be dealt with.

by delbertpgh

At www.usgovernmentspending.com, you can get some historical series, on debt, deficits, and categories of spending, either in nominal or inflation-adjusted (year 2005) dollars.

If you try to fill an eight-ounce glass with nine ounces of water, then you can reasonably blame the last ounce for the spillage. However, it seems a little false to me to be saying the bottom four ounces are a different and more virtuous kind of water than the last five. It's all water.

In 1945, with ten million men and women under arms, the defense budget was $846 billion (2005 dollars.) In 1962, Kennedy's first budget year, it was $330; 1969, Viet Nam's peak, $410; 1977, Ford's last year, $322; 1982, Reagan's first budget, $420; 1989, communism's collapse, $494; 2001, Clinton's last year, $404; 2005, the peak of Iraq, $600; 2009, the current year, $723. It's projected to rise in two years to $823 billion, before beginning a decline of about 10% as Afghanistan winds down and 75,000 Army and Marine troops are cut.

No way around it, we're paying for a lot more military than we are accustomed to.

by maxwell edison

Jefferson, Madison, Washington, Mason, Franklin, et al would not recognize this country as the United States. And I would venture to guess, that without exception, every person who signed the Declaration of Independence, and every person who signed the Constitution, and every person who supported both documents, would not stand for the government we have today and would actually rebel against it - armed or otherwise.

by maxwell edison

The Web site you mentioned was the same one I used to get my numbers. Perhaps you didn't bother to notice or follow the link.

Now using that Web site, since you did your exercise on military spending, do the very same thing for non-military spending. Will you come to the same conclusion?

[i]No way around it, we're paying for a lot more[/i] (non-military government) [i]than we are accustomed to.[/i]

by nicknielsen

You chose, however, to focus not on the quotes but on the (obvious, to me) interpretations.

I'm disappointed.

by delbertpgh

I can not dispute that we're paying a lot more for social services than we ever did before. Of course, we have over 300 million people today; in 1960, I think we had about 180 million, and in 1940, about 135 million. Social service expenses properly trend upward as population increases. Particularly, it will increase even faster as our proportion of elderly citizens rises, because they absorb more in the way of Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. (By the way, half of Medicaid payments, which are intended to help the poor, go to keep elderly patients in nursing homes.)

Without saying what an appropriate level of military expenditure would be, I would have to note that the threats to our security have not increased over the last 30 years. If anything, they've decreased. No more Soviet bloc, etc. On the other hand, stuff costs more these days: an F-22 costs $150 million, and an F-35 Joint Strike Fighter costs $130 million, whereas a 1975 F-16 cost about $15 million, a 1960 F-4, about $2.4 million, and a 1950 F-86, about $220,000. It kind of raises questions about value for cost: is one F-22 as capable as 10 F-16s? In any case, the cost of keeping up our military has doubled since Clinton left the scene, and I suspect there's a lot of luxury spending in that budget. (The Presidential helicopter fleet: the new set of Marine One choppers, commissioned after Bush couldn't keep in full communication on 9/11, will break all records. The VXX program will cost $11 billion for 28 craft, about $400 million per helicopter.)

However, all that's beside the point. You may feel that the military, the courts, public roads, and the police are the only proper things for which government ought to pay and for which we ought to be taxed. That's not my opinion. I don't go to that church.

by nicknielsen

The current political aim of the more vocal members of the Republican party appears to be to achieve political homogeneity by ejecting all the RINOs (Republicans in name only), those who are not conservative enough and those who dare to admit that the opposition may have valid points of view. I don't think they realize that if they succeed, they will have limited their appeal to a much smaller proportion of American voters than they expect.

I am one of those independent 'swing' voters. I vote based on who I feel is the best candidate for the office in question. I have voted for both Democratic and Republican candidates in the past. If, in the future, I am continually presented with candidates such as Christine O'Donnell, Sharron Angle, or even Jim DeMint, I can't see myself ever voting for a Republican again. Of course, if the Democrats start continually presenting candidates such as Alvin Green, I can't see me voting for a Democrat again, either.

by tonythetiger

I think it's an outlet... people let off steam so they WON'T do something stupid or insane.

How many more incidents such as this occur in places where such rhetoric is restricted... where there IS no outlet for frustration?

by oz_media

I was just thinking today that I hadn't heard much from you lately, I then realised that the political spotlight has gone pretty quiet so you didn't really have any democratic slagging to illustrate your intense foresight into such matters.

Lo and behold, Maxwell raises his silver hammer once again. Haven't even read the post yet, just thought it was hilarious to see a new bash dems thread (I just assume that's what it is, how clever you were to vote for another party, as always)and then to realize you had started it.

Classic and so true to form.

EDIT: Okay I read it now, but have to ask, while you ask so many rhetorical questions.

[i]What will you do when the Dollar collapses and the United States defaults on both its debt obligations and promises to its citizens? What will you do when the Dollar is devalued? What will you do when the World Reserve Currency is no longer the Dollar? It will happen, you know; it's just a matter of time. And it will happen sooner rather than later. (And why is George Soros, Democrat's favorite billionaire, buying up all the gold and silver he can get his hands on - all the while, advocating MORE government spending and debt accumulation?)[/i]

What will you do? Finally give up and leave for another nation or stick around and moan about how the majority of US voters don't know what they are doing?

I don't think it's all about Bush, I don't think many do, nor is it all about dems or Obama either. You complain that nobody has listened to you for the last 20 years, however you have had a lot of different people in office all contributing to the state of affasirs you are in today, you've never questioned spending trillions on war, just programs to support yoru own citizens.
Do you feel a different party would have prevented this or do you concede that Americans, as a society on a whole, have put themselves in this mess and really it is only the fault of government for encouraging such unresourceful actions?

What will I do? Buy more gas over the border, once they settle down and start encouraging Canadian visitors and revenue instead of making them so resentful of horrific security measures that they don't even want to cross a border.

I may begin to shop more stateside where our dollar is worth at least a dollar and roll with the punches, as society has done since the dawn of time.

by oz_media

[b]SMUG:[/b] [i] I've been sounding the warning for twenty-plus years. But no, my detractors claim; I'm just mean-spirited and selfish.[/i]

[b]CONDESCENDING:[/b] [i]You contributed to adding more debt onto the shoulders of future generations than everyone else over the past 200 years! AND, you contributed to the impending total collapse of the U.S economy more than everyone else over the past 200 years!
...
Your day of reckoning WILL come, and you will have dragged others down with you.
...
[/i]
Three words, POT, KETTLE, BLACK, I won't call you the 'H word' though, it's just too obvious.

by oz_media

As Maxwell always indicates, you must look out for number one (yourself and/or your loved ones...your immediate loved ones anyway).

So when you go to the store to buy a $10.00 can of corn and they are out of stock because the country can't afford to import more from the nations you rely on, go and knock on Maxwell's bomb shelter door, it's all his fault for hoarding it. :D

Not to worry, we;ll send down some bags of food and aid as needed. Maybe those poor folks in Iraq will help out as thanks for all the good you did for them or maybe having the biggest military force in the world will help.

by oz_media

You have seen it coming for 20 years and yet remained to see it come to fruition, merely complaining about other people's actions in the process instead of planning your escape route. Nowhere else to go? That's because maybe you see that every other nation on the planet with any history behind it, eventually separates into classes of rich and poor. American's dreams of every man being wealthy had to end one day, some people will eventually have to live on less and in harder times, again just like every other nation on the planet. A super power never remains a super power and you know that very well too.

Sop what does that leave you with? A nation that you love anyway, home.

Th sun still rises and sets in the most downtrodden places on Earth, people still wake up and live their lives regardless of economic or political situations.

If you find no satisfaction in life itself, then perhaps you should shut yourself in a bomb shelter and simply wait for the end while waving your fists and cursing your fellowman.

But to think that America will always remain a prosperous and financially stable nation where all men can enjoy wealth and success, in a world where you rely on so many for your day to day existence, is simply blind.

That's not 20 years of foresight at all. It;s ignoring the state of the rest of the world. You always say how referring to history offers guidance, in the sense of quoting your founders, however you seem to have ignored the state of other nations with any history.

You constantly comment about how people rely on others and are not self sufficient (which I don't contest at all), yet you seem to ignore the fact that AMERICA relies on others and isn't self sufficient.

How did you hope it was going to work out for you? Everyone prospers, everyone is rich or successful in their own way? Yet everyone still depends on 'something' from others.

It's a given, if you follow history show me where it has been different anywhere else in the world, even for those who have such plentiful lands that they provide America's resources.

So yeah, get over it already, or move somewhere else where you can say how great America is in comparison, a reality check if you will.

by jamesrl

We had something similar in the 80s, a "ultra" movement started in the Progressive Conservative Party, and eventually they broke away and formed their own party, the Reform Party. They did ensure the Liberals won for a while, but clearly could not see themselves winning a majority.

Eventually they merged with the Progressive Conservatives and became the Conservative Party, and they have been governing with a minority since 2006.

I have always voted for the Conservative party as the best choice, though at times I've held my nose. But thats not guarenteed. They have to earn it every time in my books.

by Member 25348569

How and as what was Bin Laden perceived by either the American public or administration in 1996? I'd be interested to know if the US had any legal grounds for detaining bin Laden at that time. Certainly, in the UK, we'd scarcely heard of him.

Neil :)

by jamesrl

From Wikipedia:

Several sources dispute Ijaz's claim, including the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks on the U.S. (the 9?11 Commission), which concluded in part:

Sudan's minister of defense, Fatih Erwa, has claimed that Sudan offered to hand Bin Ladin over to the U.S. The Commission has found no credible evidence that this was so. Ambassador Carney had instructions only to push the Sudanese to expel Bin Ladin. Ambassador Carney had no legal basis to ask for more from the Sudanese since, at the time, there was no indictment out-standing

by jamesrl

First off, Oz is not a Canadian citizen.

Secondly, by using my nationality or anyone's nationality as an insulting term, you simply do what you accuse Oz and others of doing. It nullifies your argument and puts you into the catgory of schoolyard bullies.

by delbertpgh

In 96 Bin Laden planned an assassination of Bill Clinton, who was visiting Manila. The plot and the bomb on a bridge were discovered and no attempt was actually put into action. Also, in 96 the Khobar Towers military barracks in Arabia was blown up, killing 19 US soldiers. Al Qaeda gained a certain amount of attention.

After the African embassy bombings in 1998 the Clinton team got a little more activist, and launched cruise missiles against a drug factory in Sudan (which had kicked Bin Laden out in 1996, under Saudi pressure), and against an Al Qaeda training camp in Khost province in Afghanistan.

There was a reluctance under both the Clinton and Bush administrations to believe that terrorists not affiliated with a state could be effective in any large way. Our experience with Palestinians always demonstrated that the real troublemakers were the ones with a base in a country and friends in its government. Once Bin Laden was chased out of Afghanistan, the Bush team considered the problem solved, and moved its focus to Iraq.

Bin Laden showed us that times have changed.

by jamesrl

If I look at the myriad of facts and figures on Wikipedia, most from reliable US government sources, there are a few takeaways.

One, if you look at the "Recent additions to Public Debt" chart, you can see that during the late 90s, the increases in the debt went from 4% in 1994 to .2% in the year 2000. They subsequently go up.

But that should give us some hope that those types of reduction can happen again. Yes Clinton reduced spending in many areas, but the country did not fall apart, and the direction was headed towards a budget surplus.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_public_debt#cite_note-67

I will also note that there are countries who are in a better position, and those with a worse position. Japan is particularly hard hit.

by maxwell edison

The population increase as justification for spending a greater percentage of GDP on social programs? Are you really serious?

The population was also increasing, on average, every year for the 150 years preceding your time-frame, but there was no increase during that time.

Moreover, an increase in population - especially productive population - will, in itself, increase the GDP; which, in turn, will automatically increase the tax revenues to government; which, therefore, would pay for the additional services, if any, provided by government to and/or for that increase in population.

Collect the same percentage of GDP, and total revenues increase all by itself. An increase in population is no reason to increase the percentage collected - unless the role of government is expanded for reasons other than just an increase in population.

Do you really believe some of the stuff you post? Or do you just spew it out without thinking it through?

by ansugisalas

There are people who use inflammatory rethoric to create an illusion of opinion.
They have no opinions. They don't agree or disagree. They just want the votes and the pork and the screwing over the nation some more, from the other end.

And if the common man doesn't smell the stink and turn on, and tear limb from limb, these parasites... well, then the common man has himself to blame for getting screwed over some more.

That's my take on it. They're not wolves, just scabby dogs.
And people are only sheep until they wake up... they are the real wolves, then.

by jamesrl

Seriously they hire people to scare them off. I met someone who did it at Newark, they use dogs, in other places they use guns or flares that whistle like fireworks.

Coincidentally, there was a situation in Kelowna, B.C. this week with the police. They received a report that a man had been firing a gun at the local golf course. They found the man, put him on all fours, and the arresting officer wound up and kicked him straight to the face. Turns out the guy had a job scaring Canada Geese off the golf course. He had been trying to tell the officers that he had a license but they didn't stop to ask questions before kicking him in the face. A non involved party had a camera phone and made a video which made it to youtube.

by delbertpgh

Again, looking at usgovernmentspending.com, percentages this time, total government spending in these years was this % of GDP:
1900 3
1916 2
1919 24
1925 4
1939 10
1944 46
1947 17
1949 15
1952 20
And, from there, it pretty much stays put going forward, fluctuating between 18% and 21% most years, hitting 22% several years in a row under Reagan, once dropping to 16.4% in 1965 (under LBJ). GWB drove the percentage up, and under Obama, it gets to 25%.

Population grew: about 76 million in 1900; 132 million in 1940; 180 in 1960; 227 in 1980; 272 in 1999; 310 today. Percent 65 and older in 1960 was 9.2; in 2009, 12.9.

Defense numbers are all over the map, fluctuating from 6% to 11% through the cold war, 4% to 5% thereafter. (Before the New Deal, it was between 1% and 2%, usually closer to 1%.)

Deficits were pretty much under control until 1970, under 1% most years, often negative. 1979 (Carter) was the last year a deficit was under 2% of GDP, until 1996 (Clinton.) GWB proceded to borrow a ton for his wars, and slashed revenues to create tax cuts; Obama's borrowing looks to be close to 10% of GDP, approaching war time budget dimensions.

What does this tell us?

Well, tax-and-spend Democrats appear to be better than borrow-and-spend Republicans on the deficit. However, the total budget goes up each year, and nobody bothers to revisit the effectiveness of existing programs. So, nothing much gets cut.

There are a lot more Americans, and even more needing Social Security and Medicare.

The defense budget, currently at 5.5%, is high for peace time. Once wars wind down, the war budget needs to back off, too. One thing worth bringing up, on the nation's financing of wars: traditionally, we have raised taxes so that we won't have to deficit-finance our complete war. We did that for WW1, WW2, Korea, and Viet Nam. (I, who paid income tax in 1968, remember computing the whole form 1040, and at the bottom, adding an extra 10% of the amount due.) For Afghanistan/Iraq, we cut taxes. It's the opposite of how we approached all other wars.

The numbers suggest that total government spending is within the band of normal spending that has endured since Korea. Are you suggesting we go back to Warren Harding days (and 1.5% defense) to get back to where we should be? To "normalcy", as Harding put it?

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/downloadmult_gs.php?year=1890_2015&view=1&expand=&units=p&fy=fy11&chart=G0-fed_H0-fed_F0-fed_00-fed_30-fed_10-fed&bar=1&stack=1&size=m&title=&state=US&color=c&local=s

by maxwell edison

The massive spending is being funded by the accumulation of debt, not by the collection of revenue. You could eliminate ALL military spending, and there would still be debt accumulation necessary to pay for the rest . You could tax people - rich or otherwise - to their maximum possible breaking point, and there would still be debt accumulation.

Our national debt is rapidly approaching 100 percent of our GDP. It's simply not sustainable. It's destroying the value of the dollar on the world currency market, and it's put our economy on track for a massive financial train wreck.

If you disagree with any of that, you're either not paying attention or you have your head in the sand.

The freedom and individual liberty arguments are secondary to that financial reality.

And in that regard, I find it extremely sad to realize that while our founders gave their fortunes and their lives in the quest for more freedom and liberty, today's crop of the [i]"me first - what's in it for me"[/i] generations won't even give up a free visit to the emergency room to get rid of a pimple on their a$$!

by maxwell edison

(Not that either Nick or I lives to please the other.)

For reference, James's message - the one to which I replied:

[i]I don't think that conservatives are the only ones throwing out nutty talk.

But if you want examples of what I consider to be wacky speech that stirs up hate and divides the country, here goes.

"I hope that's not where we're going, but you know if this Congress keeps going the way it is, people are really looking toward those Second Amendment remedies and saying my goodness what can we do to turn this country around? I'll tell you the first thing we need to do is take Harry Reid out." Nevada GOP Senate candidate Sharron Angle, floating the possibility of armed insurrection in a radio interview, Jan. 2010

"This is what Hitler did with the SS. He had his own people. He had the brownshirts and then the SS. This is what Saddam Hussein so but you are comparing that. And I , I mean, I think America would have a really hard time getting their arms around that.''
Glenn Beck, claiming Obama's 'civilian national security force' is the same as what Hitler and Saddam Hussein did, Glenn Beck, FOX News' Glenn Beck show, Aug. 27, 2009"

"We Came Unarmed - This Time" from a list of 'favorite' signs at Tea Party rallies.

"He has no place in any station of government and we need to realize that he is an enemy of humanity," said Rep. Trent Franks about Obama.

"Our nation was founded on violence. The option is on the table. I don't think that we should ever remove anything from the table as it relates to our liberties and our freedoms." Tea Party-backed Texas GOP congressional candidate Stephen Broden, suggesting the violent overthrow of the U.S. government if Republicans don't win at the ballot box, interview with Dallas's WFAA-TV, Oct. 21, 2010

And let me be clear, I don't think that this kind of talk, however reprehensible, is responsible for a nut job with a gun shooting a congresswoman. But there is clearly evidence of embittering talk, on both sides of the aisle.[/i]

----------------------------------------

And these are the direct quotes he posted:

[i]"I hope that's not where we're going, but you know if this Congress keeps going the way it is, people are really looking toward those Second Amendment remedies and saying my goodness what can we do to turn this country around? I'll tell you the first thing we need to do is take Harry Reid out."[/i]

and

[i]"This is what Hitler did with the SS. He had his own people. He had the brownshirts and then the SS. This is what Saddam Hussein so but you are comparing that. And I , I mean, I think America would have a really hard time getting their arms around that."[/i]

and

[i]"We Came Unarmed - This Time"[/i]

and

[i]"He has no place in any station of government and we need to realize that he is an enemy of humanity," [/i]

and

[i]"Our nation was founded on violence. The option is on the table. I don't think that we should ever remove anything from the table as it relates to our liberties and our freedoms." [/i]

End of quotes.

----------------------------------------

First of all, James started his message saying, [i]"But if you want examples of what I consider to be wacky speech that stirs up hate and divides the country..."[/i]

Okay, [i]wacky speech that stirs up hate and divides the country[/i] is, at best, a stretch, considering the exact quotes he posted. And that's what we're looking for.

First of all, a pet-peeve of mine is the term, [i]divides the country[/i], as if all of the sudden, all people can agree on all things at all times. It's a silly and meaningless platitude, at best, and with the rarest of exceptions (if ever), this country always has been, and always will be, [i]divided[/i] in many regards and/or to some degree. There's absolutely no way around it. There are simply too many [i]Conflicts of Visions[/i] (due credit given to Thomas Sowell) among the population.

(That's one of the beauties of individualism, by the way, at least in my opinion (my vision), since it's more conducive for people to live and pursue their own visions without infringing on another's.)

So I dismiss this [i]divides the country[/i] nonsense. It's nothing but a tactic used against one's opponent when one does not want to address and/or discuss the REAL underlying issue.

Okay, so now let's try to target those things in his message that [i]stirs up hate[/i].

Oh my, but first, I used a forbidden word, myself! I used the word, [i]target[/i] - [b]AS IN GUNS!!!!!!!!![/b] OH MY! Am I using [i]wacky speech[/i] that [i]stirs up hate[/i] and [i]divides the country[/i]?

But I digress.

What exactly is in those quotes that specifically [i]stirs up hate[/i]? I hear them and I don't feel hateful towards anyone. Do you feel hateful, Nick (or James) when you hear (or read) them? Heck, using the greeting [i]Merry Christmas[/i] stirs up hatred in some people - those who just want to hate someone and/or something in the first place. Hatred is an emotion generated from within, not from without.

So there's nothing hateful in any of those quotes.

Okay, and finally, let's look for anything that might be considered [i]wacky[/i]. Well, that's pretty subjective, don't you think? What exactly constitutes [i]wacky[/i] anyway?

Personally, I think, like, teenagers, you know, talk, like, you know, kind of, like, wacky; you know, he was, like ...... and she was, you know, like, wacky.

Heck, I also remember when we used to smoke wacky!

Okay, I'll give you that one. Those quotes might fall under the wacky category. And I'll also admit that when I hear people whose policy positions I might support use those kinds of terms, I cringe - not because they use them, per se, but because it only feeds ammunition to their political opponents who will only use it against them, thereby side-stepping the underlying issues.

OH MY!!!!! I DID IT AGAIN!!!!! I used the word [i]ammunition[/i] - [b]AS IN GUNS!!!!!!!!![/b] OH MY! Am I using [i]wacky speech[/i] that [i]stirs up hate[/i] and [i]divides the country[/i]?

My guess is that some wacky thinker out there will try to use it against me in a hateful way that will only serve to further divide the country.

And there's probably a joke in here somewhere about a comparison to how Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr settled their political disagreements; but then I'd probably be accused in inciting violence.

by ansugisalas

Some people take out their brains when they put on uniform...
Maybe they don't want it to dribble and stain the crisp fabric?

by ansugisalas

but then I realized: it's Max - he put me on "ignore" a year ago already... :p

Because he so loves constructive discussion ;)

But people blaming "democrats" instead of "politicians" are contributing to the problem. They just help the Republicons get their turn of robbing the grave pre-emptively (after the Democrumms are done with theirs).
All the time spent bickering uselessly is time not spent figuring out how to fix a broken system.

There may be (theoretically) honest members of both parties, maybe even representatives... but they're caught up in the broken mechanics of a system best suited for pork distribution.

by maxwell edison

I want government out of my life. Democrat or Republican, I don't give a rat's a$$.

Is that too much to ask? Really! Is that too much to ask?

On a scale of 1-10, Republicans are a 7, Democrats are a 10 - give or take whatever.

Do you really not get it? Big government is destroying our economy, our way of life, our freedom, and our future.

Just GTFO!

P.S. Quit trying to be a "moderate". TAKE A STAND!!!!!!!

P.P.S. And those who take the opposing position are BANKRUPTING our country. I want to leave more than a mere shell of freedom to my kids. What about you?

Perhaps I should say nothing, and leave a bankrupt country, a dollar that has no value, a future that's bleak, no freedom, no liberty.

I shake my head in disbelief.

P.P.P.S. People are AFRAID to take a stand, because they don't want to deal with the onslaught of criticism. TAKE A !@#$%^&* STAND!

by oz_media

Finland, Finland, Finland,
The country where I want to be,
Pony trekking or camping,
Or just watching TV.
Finland, Finland, Finland.
It's the country for me.

You're so near to Russia,
So far from Japan,
Quite a long way from Cairo,
Lots of miles from Vietnam.

Finland, Finland, Finland,
The country where I want to be,
Eating breakfast or dinner,
Or snack lunch in the hall.
Finland, Finland, Finland.
Finland has it all.
You're so sadly neglected
And often ignored,
A poor second to Belgium,
When going abroad.

Finland, Finland, Finland,
The country where I quite want to be,
Your mountains so lofty,
Your treetops so tall.
Finland, Finland, Finland.
Finland has it all.

Finland, Finland, Finland,
The country where I quite want to be,
Your mountains so lofty,
Your treetops so tall.
Finland, Finland, Finland.
Finland has it all.

Finland has it all.

Written and performed by
-Michael Palin

(Gorgeous country, well I've seen Helsinki and thought it was pretty awesome anway)

by mike.pulaski

Heres your choices to vote: extreme liberal Democrats or ultra conservative Republicans. Both suck, yet you sit here and point your fingers at the voters as if its their fault.

There are no easy solutions to the problems, but over spending by the Democrats is not the way to fix it, nor are your ultra conservative ways of doing nothing and saying "let the market police itself".

Too many windbags in politics and experts telling us how we voted the Democrats in. Did you ever stop to think that if we voted the Republicans out in a landslide, maybe...just maybe the Republicans did an awful job leading up to that with their agenda? So lets vote them all back in!!

We need moderates...not political affiliations to get us back on track. The All or Nothing approach is ludicrous.

by maxwell edison

Since you're so new around here, you obviously haven't read a lot of my stuff. Considering as much, however, I have to wonder why you decided to extract a pound of speculation from a mere gram of content.

Nonetheless, suffice it to say, you missed the target.

Your next assignment, should you decide to accept: Read one page (out of 273 pages) of Thomas Sowell's book, [i]A Conflict of Visions[/i] and write a thorough and complete book report on it.

by maxwell edison

How do political "moderates" view the U.S. Constitution?

What's a political "moderate's" stance on abortion?

What's a political "moderate's" view of individual liberty and self-responsibility?

In short, what are some of the philosophies, ideologies, and convictions of political "moderates"?

And who represents one of the great ideological moderates of our time and/or all time?

Enough for now.....

by smartacew0lf

Democrats, fancy themselves conservatives. They are not. Much less Ultra-Conservative. The purpose behind all of this bickering will reveal itself soon. I suspect it isn't going to be a pretty sight. And here we set, practicing our own little renditions of Fox News with each other while there is an enemy at the gate. People better start using their minds again and "think" about the things they are being told. It may already be too late. After more than 200 years of liberty, if we let this slip down the tubes so easily, we never deserved it to begin with.

The line isn't drawn across party lines. Those fools on Capitol Hill, the ones telling you that you are either one or the other, no in between, they aren't going to be down in the trenches with you when the sh1t hits the fan. And you can take that figuratively or literally. It isn't their table that will be bare during dinner time. Isn't members of their families who won't be able to afford Health Care. Just as it isn't them that go to jail for the crimes they commit.

And until they are held personally accountable for everything they do on that Hill, comfortable in the knowledge that, that which they set forth for others to live by, applies equally to them as well, nothing will change here. At least not in a reasonable manner.

by mike.pulaski

I might need stitches from falling out of my chair while laughing at your statement. Those kinds of statements are made by clueless fearful politicians or money hungry clergy who want to control mindless robots.

What assault on liberty and freedom? Please tell me ONE freedom or liberty you have personally lost since Obama was President? I assume this is who you direct it at. And I'm not a Obama backer. I expected better, but I certainly don't see any of my freedoms and/or liberties going away because of him.

Bush signed the Patriot Act. Cheney flat out revealed the name of a CIA spy, had his staff lie about it, get convicted in court, AND THEN COMMUTED THE SENTENCE!!! Here's someone protecting the US in a certain death situation, and that MF reveals her name simply becuase her husband wrote an unflattering article about the Iraq War!! NOW THAT is losing liberty and freedoms!

They started warrantless wiretaps and actually tried to appoint their personal attorney to the Supreme Court!!! What's your feelings on that?

And the best part of all that, they came off smug and acted like us, the people, should realize they are above us and we simply don't understand that they are protecting the country. Uh...HELLO?? From the people, of the people, by the people? But I guess Lincoln didnt know what he was talking about when he said that.

You want to know who are jeopardizing our freedoms and liberties? Terrorists, not politicians. What do you suggest we do? Nothing since you have already lost tons and tons of your freedoms and liberties?

by oz_media

You're not going to accuse me of bashing FInland and tell me that Canada sucks even worse! LOL.

Right, you have a sense of humour, I get it now. It's just rare here sometimes. ;)

by maxwell edison

You assume too much. You speculate too much. You know too little about me to make an informed opinion about me.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=340147&messageID=3408388&tag=content;leftCol

Nonetheless, to answer your question regarding the Obama Administration.

[i]Please tell me ONE freedom or liberty you have personally lost since Obama was President? [/i]

Establishing (and/or supporting) a medical care system that FORCES people to buy medical insurance IS INDEED a direct infringement on individual freedom and liberty. Do you disagree?

And if you fail to answer my replies - as you have up to now - you paint yourself an intellectual coward.

P.S.

Re your comment: [i]I might need stitches from falling out of my chair while laughing at your statement.[/i]

Are you going to pay for those stiches out of your own pocket, or do you expect other people to pay for them for you? I say that you should pay for them yourself. But Obama wants the "collective" to pay for them.

by ansugisalas

an exercise in Xtreme Futility :)
"You don't like my hat? Well your hat sucks bigtime!"
"What?!? My hat sucks? Are you gay?!?"
"Doood, I just said your hat sucks donkey's balls - no need to get personal!"
"Oh, how you gonna stop me? Throw your gayhat at me?"
etc. etc. :p

by ansugisalas

need to either.
It's not like it's difficult to see what you mean, it's just difficult to see why you can't see through it yourself.
You have the posturing of an independent thinker but the habits of a wooden puppet.

by santeewelding

Is a minuet, compared to a grind.

Should you go up against anyone, not that Max is a dance master, pay complete attention to every of your devices.

It's the old song: have your ducks precisely in row, else somebody like me says, "Erm..."

by nicknielsen

That you don't agree with it is obvious.

That you feel anybody who doesn't agree with you hasn't taken a stand is even more obvious.

I've also noticed that each new discussion becomes less moderate (read: rational) and more extreme (read: emotional) as time passes.

by maxwell edison

I couldn't define what it is.

Moreover, you've neither agreed nor disagreed with me on anything, at least that I can recall. Take a stand, Nick - specifically agree or disagree with ANYTHING I might espouse. I'll respect either one. But you've done neither.

And [i]moderate[/i] is not taking a stand. It's NOT taking a stand. Moderate is being afraid to take a stand, probably the fear of being challenged for taking it.

Moderate is a cop-out.

by nicknielsen

[i]I want government out of my life.[/i]

If you wish to live in a society of any kind, you will have government of one form or another. The only way to get government out of your life is to move to where there are no other people.

You want a stand, Max? Okay, here it is. I want my government to:
- provide defense
- support commerce
- provide for the general welfare. This includes:
-- ensuring everybody has the same opportunities in education and health,
-- protecting the public from business misconduct (the much-maligned "regulation"),
-- food and product safety
-- encourage innovation and support research

There's more, but that's a nutshell.

Unlike some here, [b]I'm willing to help pay for it[/b]. Otherwise, I want it to leave me alone, without passing stupid, intrusive laws like the Patriot or Defense of Marriage Acts.

There's your phucking stand. Put it where it will do you the most good.

by jamesrl

Of course Max moderate is a relative thing.

John Adams was a moderate, often forging a path between the more radical federalists and the Jeffersonians. I would argue it was harder for him to be a moderate than to have joined one of the other 2 camps.

In his time, Teddy Roosevelt was a moderate. A republican who railled against the corrupt alliance between governments and business, the "invisible" government. Wise man, and that fight needs a champion today. It was certainly harder for him to strike out on his own and form his own party than it would have been for him to bow to the pressures of his party.

Truman was a moderate Democrat. More Liberal democrats wanted him out, and Republicans painted him as another New Dealer.

John Anderson, who ran for President in 1980 was a moderate Republican(didn't get the nomination and left the party), someone who I identified with at the time. He didn't chose an easy path, he could have stayed a comfortable senator and remained a leader within the party, but chose to fight the more difficult fight, and strike out on his own.

I am a moderate.

Being moderate is far from "not taking a stand". Thats a simplistic facile argument that assumes that every thing is black and white, with me or against me, for big government or for individual liberties.

Life is not that simple and never was. It is often easier to look at life as black and white and its easier to put yourself in one camp or the other. Being a political moderate at times is to be demeaned by many or even most. It often takes courage to tell both major camps they are both more wrong than right. It comes at a cost.

When I started my political involvement, I came to find myself most allied to a political movement called "Red Tories". These were conservatives, in a tradition going back to England centuries before, who believed in fiscal convervatism and individual rights, but who also believed that the state had a role in balancing the interests of businesses and individuals. I share many similar beliefs with our first Prime Minister, Sir John A MacDonald, who is probably the individual who did the most to move Canada from a colony to an independant nation. While it was the dominant political philosophy for many years, its now taken a back seat to a more American style conservatism, and there is a stigma to being considered a red tory. It would be easy for me to deny or downplay that today, but I wouldn't be true to myself, so I remain proud to be what I am, even if it limits my involvement in the party.

Do you wonder why people refrain from engaging you when you call people cowards or cop outs, or "forgive" someone who doesn't agree with you? Perhaps thats why people don't challenge you, because they are tired of being dismissed as wrong headed, cowardly, indecisive.

Perhaps Palmetto has the right idea.

by fregeus

...one-dimensional you are. Left or right and nothing else. Dem or rep, American or not, etc, etc, etc.

I TOTALLY disagree with most of what you propose and disagree with the examples you put forth to support your views.

I, on the other hand, am not one-dimensional. I'm not even bi-dimensional. I am multidimensional. I don't see black and white. I see a great deal of shade of those colors. I see a whole slew of other colors. Each of those creates unimaginable number of shades. I also know that there are colors I cannot see myself, which creates a whole new slew of other shades.

Moderate is not cowardly or not taking a stand. Moderate is a different direction all together.

You are entitled to your views Max. You are even entitled to take them to the extreme. But what you are not entitled to is to treat anyone who views differently as weak, cowardly, stupid, ignorant, and delusional or any other negative qualifier you can think of.

A little civility please.

Thank you

TCB
Edited for grammar

by ansugisalas

is one-dimensional... two-, or god forbid, three-dimensional persons cannot fit there, only potentially be bi- or intersected by it.

Unless they happen to be entirely above or entirely below it, which isn't that difficult.

by ansugisalas

to the barbarian's fault.
But - if you show me how my ducks are out of quack, you will be appreciated.

by jck

- There are idiots on both sides.
- There are people who value themselves way too much.
- There are people who think God values them, where they live, and their choices more than anyone else.

The fix:

Get the corrupt scum out of Washington.

Republicans can whine all day about "liberals", but they have spent for the past decade.

Democrats can whine about "conservatives" blocking progress when they spent 20 months in Congress stopping any effort to make efforts bipartisan rather than one sided.

The majority up there are a bunch of selfish, self-serving ninnies.

I say get rid of the whole bunch of them, and do it draft style. Send farmers, barbers, housewives, garbagemen, teachers and secretaries to create the laws in this country...rather than a bunch of spoon-fed, closed-society aristocrats.

Until you do that, you can hate whoever til you're blue in the face.

You turn your face to keep one side from screwing you, the other side is gonna screw you twice as hard.

Welcome to America...land of the greed, home of the depraved.

by jamesrl

I think if you managed to do what you suggest, it would start off well, but within a few elections, you'd be back to square one.

I've mentioned before, the thing that strikes me about US politics is the freewheeling funding and political spending that goes on. To the extent that a politician must decide to represent the people who elected him or the people who funded his/her election campaign (and we know who usually wins). Political Action Comittees, large corporations etc have undue influence on US lawmakers. It shows up in pork barrel legislation and bad decision making. You can bet the people make $200 hammers for the airforce spend millions of dollars lobbying those who make the decisions on defense spending.

Limit what people can spend so that there can be a level playing field. Limit what people can donate to elminate undue influence. Publish every cent that comes in, and every expense a congressperson spends. Separate out what is an expense the government should pay as part of the job, and what is a political task which should not be paid for by government funds.

Make them accountable. Have strongly enforced ethical guidelines.

by nicknielsen

My preferred campaign finance rules:

1. You may contribute as much money as you like, but you can only contribute to a candidate if your residence allows you to vote for that candidate.

2. If you are not eligible to vote, you do not have the right to political speech.

3. A candidate may spend no more than $1 per registered voter for a primary or general election. The count of registered voters will be as of the last legal date for voters to register for the election in question.

I think these rules would have the effect of limiting the bulk of political advertising to the last few weeks before an election. As written, though, they would have the effect of allowing a Senate candidate in California to spend $14 million-plus and limiting Senate candidates in the least-populous states to less than $500,000. A properly-worded exceptions for Senate campaigns might be appropriate.

All I need to do is convince Congress to cut its own throat and the Supreme Court to apply some common sense.

.
.
.

Hey, everybody needs a dream.

by oz_media

When merely focused on being a drama queen, specific political blame game opens the floodgates.

by maxwell edison

As it pertains to the topic of my initial message, of course.

Imagine that a jet plane represents the forward progress of a nation and a society. It can't stop, nor can it land. It must remain moving, and it must remain moving forward.

Now further imagine that this jet has historically been cruising at an air speed of around 600 knots and an altitude of about 40,000 feet. It's been cruising in the jet stream, traveling west to east, with very little resistance, having a lot of success moving forward.

Over time, however, this jet has taken on board more and more people, as well as more and more cargo. Eventually, the jet reached a point where it's actually taken on more weight than it was designed to carry. Moreover, there's even more people and cargo waiting - and being promised - to be beamed aboard. (Hey, they did it in Star Trek!)

As a result and over time, this jet has been losing both speed and altitude, but it's still, somehow, plugging along. However, warning bells have been sounding in the cockpit! Controllers on the ground have been urging caution! But alas, all the warnings have been ignored. In fact, the crew has turned off the radio so they can't hear the ground controllers, and they've turned off the volume of the cockpit alarms so they can't hear them either.

We suddenly find our jet over the middle of Utah traveling due east at a speed of only 250 knots and at an altitude of only 6,000 feet above sea level. The engines are very close to stalling because of both the lack of air speed and as a result of being over loaded. But worse yet, directly in its current path are the Rocky Mountains and its 14,000 foot peaks - rapidly closing in with each passing moment.

The pilots - one in the right seat, the other in the left - are debating over which way to turn the jet so as to avoid a collision with the Rocky Mountains. (Both pilots, it might be noted, are not considering the excess weight which is still causing a loss of altitude.) The debate is getting quite nasty. The Navigator, the person in the jump seat, is advocating no change in bearing at all. Full speed ahead, he suggests, and just pull back on the controls to regain our previous altitude (also ignoring the weight problem that would prevent such a solution).

The passengers, meanwhile, hearing all of the debate going on in the cockpit over the speakers, are getting tired of all the bickering and divisiveness going on around them, and they're tired of the warnings being sounded. As such, they turn off the speakers so they can no longer hear it, and they close their window shades so they can no longer see where they're headed.

Can't they all just get along, they ask?

Finally, the moderate among the group steps up and suggests a compromise. Come on, guys, he says. Let's work together. Let's go back and forth between a heading that falls between either 5 degrees to the left or 5 degrees to the right. That way you will show the passengers that you're willing to compromise and work together. Wouldn't that be nice?

Back to reality, and the [i]moderate[/i] choices at hand:

1. Go straight ahead, and the jet will crash into the Rocky Mountains in western Colorado.

2. Turn 5-10 degrees to the left, and the jet crashes into the Rocky Mountains in western Wyoming.

3. Turn 5-10 degrees to the right, and the jet crashes into the Rocky Mountains in Southern Colorado.

The REAL solution, however, is to stop taking aboard more people and cargo - and even to jettison much of the weight that caused the loss of altitude and jet speed in the first place, so it might find its way back into the jet stream, thereby regaining its optimal cruising speed and altitude.

But no, the [i]moderates[/i] will have none of that nonsense! Moreover, the [i]moderates[/i] are relentlessly criticizing those people who are actually heeding the warnings.

by maxwell edison

No I don't.

I have to wonder, however, why you don't criticize those other people who consider ME the one who is [i]wrong headed, cowardly, and indecisive. [/i]

by maxwell edison

That was done with a chuckle. Apparently you missed it.

That person is a new member (according to the date on his alias), and he made assertions about me that simply were not true or accurate. Therefore, I "forgive him" for not being privy to all I have said.

You present an assertion (a false one), and argue against it - just like that new member did. That straw-man don't hunt.

by nicknielsen

Dispose of half the cargo and the loudest 10 percent of those screaming to turn the plane. From each side.

Piece of cake.

Outside that, your analogy fails, both in your choice of vehicle and your estimation of moderates.

by maxwell edison

Re: [i]Dispose of half the cargo and the loudest 10 percent of those screaming to turn the plane. From each side.[/i]

I'm actually good with that.

In other words, cut the size, scope, and cost of government by 50 percent, and figure out how to render that 10 percent who bich impotent.

That's what I've been suggesting all along!!!!