Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Every two years a new OS comes out. Every two years a new crop of young freshly studied certs show up and underbid the the entire industry. I live in Boise. I just saw an ad in the paper here for a lan tech for $12/hour! When I first started in this industry I was making very good money. I had a new cert and a master's degree. Microsoft has promised the industry captains that the cost of doing business will go down. It's because Microsoft has trained way too many MCSE's and/or we are letting people into the industry without MCSE's. They haven't earned their space. I say we unionize the IT sphere!
I say we apply rules of work that apply to a 40 hour work week and serious overtime. I say we demand $50/hr for any IT related work, as a minimum. If we join together we have the power to run this world!

725 replies

by bfilmfan

I've noticed that salaries in Iowa tend to be very low. I am sure it costs less to live there than in a number of other places.

My advice is to relocate.

by propellerheadus

What exactly would unionizing IT accomplish? If its more money you want, try consulting (but that is pretty hard work and not everybody can hack it, trust me).

You have to pay your dues before you can sing the blues. Work five years or so, be good at it, get noticed, keep learning, and you will find success. That's the IT game in a nutshell.

by tonyackerman

"Work five years or so, be good at it, get noticed, keep learning, and you will find success."

Simple response, no offense intended:

Bullshit.

By the time you've spent enough time learning the niche that you service, some muddle manager will determine that you're now too expensive and the same work can be done by two headcount at Wipro India for half the cost. You'll be out on your ear faster than a single bit down an empty fiber pipe.

Read the writing on the wall folks. The work is being offshored faster than it's being created. Like any other decent paying industry that had it's roots in this country, we've mananged to export this industry also, tho' the turnaround time on this was remarkably short. If you think it's going to stop, you better take a good long hard look at the economics of this industry and realize the bottom line is all that counts. In short, anyone worth a damn is going to be too damn expensive.

There's a reason why companies want the H1B visa cap lifted and it's not because they can't find qualified people here, there are plenty! The folks from overseas are cheap and end up essentially as indentured servants. If they don't like the way they're being treated, worked or payed, the sponsorship for their visa can always be yanked and they can go back home (and don't tell me it can't happen, it does, I was on the sidelines watching it happen ).

There will always be some degree of IT work onshore, but unless you think working for Geek squad is a real career, these are difficult times for our line of work. Forget trying to find a new position if you're over 45 in this business unless you're Mark Lucovsky. Forget about the halcyon days of the dot com era, it's gone.

Do we need to unionize? Absolutely! If for no other reason than to establish a political front where we can influence the machinery that has some modicom of control over how much of our industry does and does NOT get exported. Maybe, just maybe we can exert some influence how the poor bastards in India are being treated and make it better for them, and in the process level the playing field. It's too late to stop it, all we can do now is try to slow it down and influence how it develops from here.

Otherwise, you want to work in the business? Start packing your bags and head to India.

(I've been in the business since '86, degrees in CS, Physic and Mathematics, worked at some of the biggest names in the industry. I have the street creds so don't even think it.)

by cactus pete

Go ahead, unionize, then see you get $16/hr and pay 25% of that to your union dues... Then you have to strike, because someone told you to. At which time you're not working. Oh, that person demands you get paid more per hour, so the dues also rise...

How about you don't take that job for $12/hr because it doesn't pay what you think you're worth? That's what we call a free market. Supply and demand work it out...

What can a union do for you (other than wages related) in the IT field? If it's just wages you're wanting, then find something that pays more.

Do what you love. Work hard at it. The money will follow.

by questor1

The real reason Unions get a start in companies with employees is that workers feel they are being unfairly treated by that company. I have no idea where you get a 25% cut in pay that goes to union membership. You're unsubstantiated threat of 25% union membership fees only amounts to fear and loathing of Unions which is unfair.

I view Unions as a form of insurance for employees... a standardized set of rules, work hours, and compensation are negotiated by the Union with the company to arrive at a fair wage and working conditions for the employee-union member.

Your idea of a free market allows these jobs to be abruptly taken away to outsourcing companies (often overseas) with lower wages. There is no competitive advantage other than a temporary reduction in wages for outsourcing. These abrupt changes cause absolute havoc with families when IT is outsourced, I have experienced it several times. Perhaps you want to move overseas for an IT job in your twisted view of "free market", I prefer to work in the USA where real value is created from union IT jobs.

The real advantage of Unions is fair treatment of union members. If a company unfairly treats a union member, they are permitted by the Union to voice they complaint for a negotiated agreement. Most companies do not permit this for employees without union membership.

Unions foster social stability where "free market" IT outsourcing causes chaos.

by blead3

In a manufacturing economy, where work was tied to capital and equipment, unions allowed workers to bargain for better conditions/pay/etc.

In a knowledge economy, where work is tied to ideas and the Internet can transmit those ideas across the world, unions are a relic that would only be worked around by the corporation (whatever the size). Read Thomas Friedman's "The World is Flat." The Internet has changed everything, especially for knowledge workers. Trying to put up barriers and organizing unions to combat it would be like building a sand castle wall to keep away the tide-all the effort would quickly wash away.

Those economies that put up fewer barriers to trade (and outsourcing) in the end become stronger because they grow more jobs and become more diverse. Witness the difference between the US, the EU, and Japan. The US economy has grown at a healthier rate in the past 10 years than the EU and Japan, where trade barriers are high. Millions of jobs were added in both the Bush/Clinton administrations because US trade barriers are relatively low (but still here) compared to the other two. These new jobs weren't just low end (i.e. burger-flipping), but were a combination of low, medium, and high end work. Now the employment rate is below 5% (and shrinking), you'll see salaries rise in order to fulfill the classic supply/demand tension that always exists.

Do unions foster social stability when teacher's unions fight ANY education reform to link pay for performance?

Do unions foster social stability when police unions draw a 'blue wall of silence' when it comes to rogue cops?

Do unions foster social stability when GM and Ford have to lay off thousands because their workforce makes them uncompetitive w.r.t. foreign auto makers?

Union membership has shrunk as a % of the total workforce in the US economy, and we're stronger for it.

by mikeetemple

There is no "free market" when it comes to wages without a Union. Only the Union has an interest in establishing a balanced salary. CEO's and CFO's from the employer market get togother and agree to set salaries without a union is what is going on now.

We need to have our concerns "heard" in the Market place. We cannot do it as individuals any differently than the CEO's and CFO's.

by cartermofgurnee

Unions foster social stability - yes. The stability of the lowest common denominator. It does provide a sort of 'insurance' - insurance that if you're an idiot, a bungler or just plain lazy you can still, for a short period of time, get a paycheck and use the club of the state to keep out competition. Unions are the last resort of the incompetent.

by hangin_online

There is a couple of points here to be made. Your reason for unions getting started is only half true. If you work for a large corporation and don't have the ability articulate what your needs/wants are to management, then maybe yes, you need someone to speak for you. I work for a non-union company and negotiate my working conditions for myself. Key word NEGOTIATE. When you got hired for the job you do, you made an agreement to work in x conditions for x dollars. if you or the company can not live with those conditions any longer, you renegotiate terms or you go your separate ways. i don't want someone else talking for me and especially not negotiating for my $$$.
And by the way, a union will not stop outsourcing over seas. there is always a clause that can break a union, corporate america isn't that stupid.
Keep your knowledge and abilities up to speed and keep yourself valuable to your company. this way you have bargining power.

by davew

Creating an IT Union is very likely the worst idea that I have ever heard.

Unions are great for say Coal Miners but in an industry with such a broad base it would be almost impossible to manage union classifications.

Also, Why should I make the same amount of money as the guy down the hall that has a paper MCSE and plays solitaire all day? Why would you want your salary dictated by a union rather than your personal performance?????

Sure it's great for the schmuck who is below the curve but what about the guys that go above and beyond? Why should I pay part of someone else's salary?!!?

In my book working in a union is like living in a communist country. Think about it, I live in the USA for a reason...

by icubub

Yep, look at how well unions have helped the auto industry. Jobs aplenty!

Unions were good arounbd the turn of last century to help institute change in working conditions, fair wages, decent hours. We've done a lot of this with legislation, and as some people have pointed out, fair market conditions.

Find a specialty, something you enjoy. Don't go advocating something stupid like unions! They will only help commoditize (real word?) IT even more! IT people are professionals, like doctors, lawyers, engineers. Unionizing IT would put us more in the class of laborers, machine-shop workers, factory personnel.

Let's not cheapen our image even more so...

by johnnysacks

Be careful what you ask for. The easy perspective is to view unions as insuring that the hard working backbone of any profitable company is adequately compensated rather that treated like animals by the corporate machinery running this country (world). Look at Verizon, benefits galore, time and a half for overtime, double on Sunday, striking because they work too much overtime. Try a job at Wal-Mart on for size please.

The reality of any old school union shop is that a significant percentage of the workers are protected by seniority. The utter lack of motivation and competiveness of some of these people with regard to their primary jobs is mind boggling.
Their highest motivation is involvement in labor negotiations to obtain as much compensation as possible for performing as little extra work as possible.
Every single task has a negotiated time allocated to it and the goal of the union is to maximize this allocation.
I've seen young workers come in from the real world and knock out 3 hour jobs in under an hour without breaking a sweat and with ABSOLUTELY no reduction in quality, even going so far as to point out problems and areas of improvement. Needless to say they are quickly instructed that that's not the way things are done.
The pipe-fitter needs a helper to hold up the other end of a couple pipes for an hour - don't you DARE ask the floor sweeper to give him a hand, need to hire an apprentice pipefitter. Every single insignificant task you and I take for granted is mired down in this ridiculous beaurocratic morass.

The problem is that there is nothing more deserving of unions than the incompetent narcissistic sociopaths in corporate management.
Look at GM - management and engineering can't put together a car that people want to save their sorry assed lives. Every police department and taxi fleet in the country buying Caprices, what do they do, cancel production. (A big thank you from Ford) Every bell and whistle piece of bling turns to malfunctioning crap after three years with Honda and Toyota dancing around them in the end zone. What was their flaming a-hole in charge Roger Smith doing when small cars were killing us? Re-engineering the biggest car maker in the world to produce the highest quality cars in the world... No, buying GI-Joe action adventure toy companies during the Reagan years.

by 50kilroy

When you say, "Do what you love. Work hard at it. The money will follow", you are absolutely, 100% WRONG.
I was in the I.T. field since 1975 and only last year grew onions enough to move on to electronics research, which pays what the job is worth.
In my 25 years in I.T., I have been paid what the job is worth (up through about 1985), then the Windows babies took over. With the advent of Windows, every Tom, Dick, and Harry began to think that he was a computer expert, which thought was reinforced by the toilet-paper MCSE programs. I have heard so many times from a 16 year old 'hi skooler' that he/she was an 'engineer' and therefore should be paid as an engineer.
Back to your question, YES, $12/hour is bad. Bad, bad, bad. An I.T. professional should be paid a minimum of $35.00/hour, but that isn't going to happen; not without organization.
What a union could do for I.T. is to strenghen the field and exclude those 'engineers' with the Microsoft toilet-paper certs in favor of us who have hard experience.
Sure, the tests have tough questions, and there are many MCSE 'boot camps' which will, for about $1500, drill a kid in the answers.
Answers do NOT make an engineer.

by richard

The big problem is that those who need a Union the most are those that don't want it.

When I say union I mean an organization similar to a trade union. I see so much reinventing of the wheel, this not only holds back and individual it holds back the industry...

by acavasin

First read dpetrak's reply. Even though he doesn't articulate it as well as he could, he gets it.

Sure, go union and jack the wages up to $50.00/hr. demand double time for overtine, no- hell- demand triple time for overtime. Then you can start bitching about working conditions, idiots behind the keyboards, dust on the server, whatever. Management will piss you off and then you can go out on strike. Three weeks later the first boatload of Indian or Pakistani or Malaysian IT replacements will arrive....

Check out the auto industry, the steel industry, the rubber industry and the construciton industry,
then make your decision about unions...

by ed woychowsky

Two words: Bethlehem Steel.

Look what the unions did for those employees. Where are they now? The last one that I spoke to was stocking shelves in a supermarket for $8.50 an hour.

Alright, that's more than two words.

by techiemikee

Paper MCSE's are like interns so don't compare an entire industry to someone just trying to get their foot in the door.

If you were around the industry during the late 90's then you are familiar with how over inflated the salaries were, and then what became of those over inflated salaries.

Don't assume all companies are low balling people. If the company or region you live in is under compensating then move on, that is the most effective way to get the message across. A union puppet walks the line and the employer has someone to negotiate with but if an employer leaves and finds a company they are better suited for, there is no negotiation and the former employer is forced to make drastic changes to keep the rest of the employees or to attract new ones.

I personally welcome $12-$16 hour folks into the industry cause when they screw up--and they will screw up--then it usually wakes the management up to how much money down time costs them and the will gladly pay the premium rates it takes to get a veterans in there who can avoid the costly mistakes made by the rookies. $12-$16hr job listing means to me that I need to follow up with that company in 3 ? 6 months, because it will take 3-6 months for either the employer to get fed up with their new hire or the new hire to find better compensation elsewhere.

by cathleen301

Which unions are you referring to that take 25% of your earnings for dues? My union takes 2% of my earnings - a small price to pay. Especially since our contract, which has expired, mandates that we keep the same standards until a new contract is agreed upon.

What do you think you're worth? If everyone who does the same type of work that you do accepts $12/hour maybe your employer will decide not to increase your salary and because no one else is paid more than $12/hour maybe he'll feel that he's paying you too much - how much of a pay cut are you willing to take to do the same job that you are doing now and then some?

Or, maybe your employer will freeze your wages yet double or triple your insurance co-pay and deductibles and weekly contributions. What percentage of your earnings are you paying or losing to your employer for health coverage? A union contract can protect you in that area.

Maybe your employer will decide that IT "professionals" should work 50, 60, or 70 hours per week and aren't eligible for overtime. What if your $12/hour is derived from a set 40 hour per work week salary, and your employer keeps the salary the same yet increases the number of hours to 50, 60, 70 per week?

With a union contract your employer can not do this to you on a whim. The contract ensures a standard, and changes to that standard would have to be negotiated by BOTH parties. A union contract protects your self-respect and your right to fairly negotiate your value to your employer. A union contract will also establish a safe working environment, protects your job if a family member is ill and you are their caregiver; or need a maternity or paternit leave.

Is a union contract perfect? No. For instance, there is work that I know how to do, have gone back to school to learn how to do - yet it is work that is in a higher classification than my job. The company will not train me to do that job, because I would have to be paid that classification's rate of pay. But at negotiations, I can bring this to the attention of the negotiation committee and maybe the new contract can be tweaked. At the very least, I can try to make a change, I don't have to just sit there and stew in frustration.

For me, the union contract has more benefits than drawbacks. The job, wage, safety and working conditions protection that it gives me allows me to focus on being a productive employee.

There are still a lot of unions out there, I'm sure IT workers can fine one that will meet the criteria that they establish.

by richard

or perhaps inexperienced.
you should abide by your logo.

You can through stones if you want but.. this is what happened to me in the past.
I as a member of a trade union, I was a forman, I liked running jobs but the pay was not keeping up with inflation.
Others in my trade did not support the union, they did not want to work together and did not want to pay dues. At a uninon meeting I tried to tell the those who speak lik you that they need guys like me and they needed their union. They did not listen and when the last company in our trade, in Miami, Fl went non union, I had to sit in the office for 3 days, I was the only one on strike.
As a forman I made $1 over the rest. I was on strike to another $1 for going non union. After 3 days I got the measly $1 and went to work. I watched as their were no more raises and others worked for what I would not. Well the $2 over scale was not enough and I went into IT make $90k a year and the kind of benifits package that you hope for.... I have not always made this much, it is demanding, and sometimes I wish I could find another way. I have no job security and am racing toward retirement hoping I will be able to continue live on what I have.
Not only do you need a Union to help you, those of you who think you don't need it the most. I am an over producer, If need be I will pay a large sum to learn what your employeer needs and build it in my $100,000 computer lab. When times are tight I may take your job!....
I think there is a better way, I would like to have more of a life other then IT. I would like to have some kind of working conditions other then reactive poor planning overtime. I put my job on the line often when told what I will do, when and for how much. I don't think employers owe me anything other then a fair deal and my fair cut of the pie. I know that I will always give more then the minimum that I am required. That's how you make a win win.
Bring on a Union NOW, We all need it, perhaps you more then me.

by jamesrl

I'm an experienced IT Manager and Project Leader with 20 years in IT, and with the market in my big expensive city, I can't charge the equivalent of $50 US an Hour.

If you want your salary to go up, provide more value to the company you work for, or find a company who will appreciate your skillset and hard work.

I know that if my workspace unionized, the company would simply move the work to a non-union area.

And don't think you rule the world because you have an MCSE. I have a couple of staff members with 20 years experience each, who support a bunch of MCSEs. Neither of them has an MCSE. Both of them are far better at the ins and outs of MS servers/networking etc, than the MCSEs that they support. They provide docs and training to the MCSEs.

Microsoft clearly makes money from the Certification process - how do you think a union would be able to get them to change their process?

James

by whistl3r

"If you want your salary to go up, provide more value to the company you work for, or find a company who will appreciate your skillset and hard work."

I hear this every day, colleagues complaining of poor management and the skills and knowledge management lacks. Simply put, ANYONE with a master's degree "SHOULD" be making six figure at least, regardless of what effort is being placed into the company, chances are they are the backbone anyhow.

The NUMBER 1 problem is, most corporation's and business' hire unintellectual people and follow a bureaucratic process. Case in point... two people apply for an IS/IT engineering position; one of which holds a graduates degree, the other 20 different certifications, no formal education AND a minority, who will get the pick of the draw? Chances look good for the minority.

Second problem is, management needs to remove there head from their rear side and hire compitent employees providing exceptional benefits. Management also needs to LEARN to keep their employee's happy... after all THESE employee's whom you hire make YOU the money. Companis do not make money just because they exist, companies exist becuase of your dedicated employee's who sweat and bleed while the executives sit in their padded leather chairs, believe me I know (I own my own business).

Sooner or later all IT will walk out the same door they walked in.

You think outsourcing will resolve your issue... incorrect. The market would severly panic, there would be a likelihood of a 500% salary spike.

I guess you are not aware that hiring your copmlete IT staff offshore to replace the American labor market is illegal and will most likely land you below the curb.

However, i do agree with the rest of your points... just because you have a cert does not mean you know anything. What do some companies expect for these assembly line certified techs, 2weeks of training and they already know how to setup a server, heh. You can blame management on that one.

by jamesrl

And I take issue with your idea about legality. Dell is one example where they took entire groups offshore, and I worked for a Fortune 100 company which entirely outsourced their IT department of thousands of people. Outsourcing is not necessarily offshoring.

Personally I don't think that outsourcing is the answer in most cases. My point was that unionization often rewards the mediocre, and I can tell you that I managed two teams, one unionized, one non-unionized, that did the same job. The morale, competancy and performance of the non-unionized group was far better. The union made it almost (but not quite) impossible to get rid of the dead wood.

James

by sita999_2000

I fully support your view point, especially to put an end to the practice of non-payment of salaries to IT professionals in India - Chennai where I know of a software outfit with only 4 or 5 programmers extracting work from them but paying only a pittance with a promise of paying the arrears in due course, keeping them on tenterhooks! The employer knows very well that if they go to court, it will drag on and the younsters would not venture to do so asthey will be either busy programming or looking for a break elesewhere.

by daveinla

Want more money? Provide unique skills for an employer who needs and appreciates them. You're competing in a world market for skills. Good for you that you got that degree and certificate, but did they tell you in MCSE school that you had some kind of entitlement to a particular wage level because of them? By the way, if you can form a union that can guarantee employers at least $50/hour of value for members' services, you'll have some takers.

by aa8vs

If you find that kind of a deal, I am sure there are several [union] Delphi folks that would be interested.......

by mobill122

That's what people seem to continue to overlook. Today we operate in a WORLD MARKET, it is no longer a USA market.
If anything, if you read a little world economics, you will find out China is the upcoming big player in the world, just as Japan was years ago.
The US is fast approaching a $trillion dollar debt... and guess what... China will soon have a $trillion dollar CASH SURPLUS in... you guessed it... US DOLLARS.
We continue to BUY every toy we desire and build huge houses we can't afford. Overlooking the fact, that due to world market leverage, our wages are falling.
We scream about Mexican's, etc taking our jobs.. but here on the gulf coast.. there are signs posted all down the streets.. NOW HIRING, but no one applies for those lowend service jobs.
Personally, I'm thinking of taking Chinese language classes, as they will soon be buying up everything in this country, like the Japanese did 20 years ago ! lol

Oh...and for those who don't know... Ft Knox no longer holds gold to back the value of our dollar.

by golfloon

Businesses exist to make a profit not to employ you. If it costs your boss $50/hr in Boise and $5/hr in Bangalore where is the most cost effective place to put his data centre? As for Unions I personally saw them destroy the UK's manufacturing industry through unrealistic wage demands and strike action in the late 80's. If you want more money learn more valuable skills.

by rodney_scul

bottom line thinking that many in the US share, and will ultimately cause a severe economic trauma to occur in the US.

Money is not the only thing to consider when making such decisions as you suggest. There are security issues as well. Talk to some of the companies who sent thier work offshore only to find an almost identical competing software product only 6 months after they sent the work to India.

Many people also forget about the impact of culture on business. The culture in the rest of the world is radically different than in the US. Also, many cultures actually hate the US and use our own greed against us.

I don't think Unions are the answer, but this offshoring crap - if it continues to grow into an even bigger beast this time - will result in a severe depression of the knowledge industry in the US in the least, and at the worst a shift of the US IT industry OUT of the US.

by jardinier

The Australian Journalists' Association, I know from long experience that white collar unions have almost no power against the employers.

When journalists strike, management and non-union staff always manage to produce a newspaper.

I can't think of any white collar union which was ever able to wield any power.

To get better wages and/or conditions, you have to be able to bring the country to a halt. In Australia it has been the petrol tanker drivers and waterside workers who KNOW they will get what they ask for because they are in a position to hold the country (or state) to ransom.

If garbos go on strike, all hell breaks loose. If clerical workers go on strike, nothing happens.

I have heard (although I have not checked this out) that if doctors go on strike, fewer people die.

It's kind of like economist Thorstein Veblen's theory in reverse: [see "The Theory of the Leisure Class" (1899]

He postulated -- quite validly I consider -- that a person's level in the social pecking order could be seen by the way they dressed and the fineness of their skin.

Thus the lowly labourer had calloused hands and wore overalls, while the managerial class had tender skin and wore fine clothes.

So it works the opposite way in the supply-and-demand labour market. The lowliest person can cause the most disruption to society.

I would suggest that individual IT Pros should seek private contracts with management to ensure an appropriate income.

by percywa

jardinier says "I can't think of any white collar union which was ever able to wield any power."
Well, I have heard that many times, mainly from "union Members" who believe that the union should be able to get what the members want, without having to do anything themselves.
Quite clearly, any organisation draws its strength from its members.
When a unions members are not prepared to put up fair resistance to unfair conditions, then, obviously, their union has no power, and knowing this, the perpetrator of the unfair conditions will take advantage of that weakness.
So, yes, historically, in Australia, so called "white collar" unions have not had the sort of power that the likes of the MUA, AMWA, CFMEU, have had, but with members taking more responsibility, more so called "white collar unions" are now achieving far improved outcomes.
So if you want the AJA to have more power, get some strength and responsibility into the AJA members.
Or you could always join another union that covers IT workers.

by rcohen58

Not to belittle your experience, (unfortunately almost everyone thinks they write well or are real journalists, and we know that is not the case) but if the IT staff of a large paper (or any other business for that matter) went on strike and the managers and other non IT people tried to run the systems I would give them 3 days till the whole thing came crashing down. Think of what would happen if the press operators walked off, and the managers tried to run the presses.

Years ago I worked for a communications company where they decided that they didnt need to pay overtime to get a large contract out the door. We would come in every Monday morning to find our entire work area in complete disarray. The managers who didnt receive overtime were coming in on Saturdays to do the work of the lowly, ignorant technical people. It usually took us half the day to clean up the visible mess and six months to fix the stuff that wasnt visible.

by revnum9

Unionization should be available for every type of shop in which the workers are not owner-managers, and perhaps even excluding any managerial level.

by malcolm_pattison

I agree with James, an MCSE certification means nothing to some organisations, and will not employ MCSE?s within the UK because of individual?s fast tracking the MCSE syllabus. As James, we have MCSE?s on site, who have to take a lead from the more experienced technicians who are not MCSE certified.

And $50 per hour some techs dont even get that a day dream on. Company?s could not afford to sustain that kind of wage as IT already sucks up most of a companies profits as it is.

I believe that the working conditions for IT people need to be addressed for sure and a bit of respect shown for their efforts and the unrecognised work that goes on behind the scenes of any company IT infrastructure.

Unions unite people sometimes for all the wrong reasons trust me I live and work in the UK, Unions within IT I do not think so.

Malcolm

by rcohen58

Malcom:

I dont think that IT "sucks up" that much of a companies profits. Most of the time the IT budgets are the first to be slashed (well before the CEO's yearly bonus). I agree that there are a whole lot of IT people to whom $50 a day would be a raise but I think that is a sysmptom of how little control we have over our own situations.

by clmoran

Do you really think that unionizing IT will help that much? After all, look where you have to call to get a new cert code for XP: INDIA.

Unionization doesn't help that much as I work in an industry that is highly unionized and I see our work going to Japan, Mexico, and now China is on the horizon. In a year I will be looking for a new career as the company is closing the door in my face--even after approving concessions.

I could see a guild that actually raises the standards of IT. Companies will pay for quality and if a guild raises the bar of excellence with training and updates, then you will have the protections and success you want. A "labor" union is the wrong way to go (the voice of experience talking here).

Have a wonderful day!

by deburca

In Europe I've experienced this problem for quite some time. I'm an independent contractor, and I've frequently seen my quoted rates undercut by some guy who is willing to work for a very low rate. The company that hires these low-rate workers normally comes short in the end, when they discover that they are getting just what they pay for. I try to resist cutting my rates, but ultimately the market rules.

I don't see the logic of your proposed unionizing anyway. Your $12/hour LAN tech would just charge the new minimum ($50 or whatever).

by 2manycerts

You can be the president. You just listed the reason we cannot unionize. Every two years a new crop of...

Idiot.

by van helsing

Good for you, you earn the respect of getting that MCSE and that good ol' Masters degree.

Do you think the $12/hour is still small, try getting the feedback from your Asian peers and see how little they earn and yet they can also get the respect you're looking for.

The industry does not live on certs and degree alone, it has its own "circle of life" which also consists of non-MCSEs and yet have valuable contributions to the industry.

I am myself a non-cert but is currently managing a number of MCSE staff and can work very well with my peers from our offices around the world with minimal effort. Ever heard of the phrase "equivalent experience"?

Love the job, the respect and incentives will follow.

by a_greiner

Those who cannot remember the past are doomed to repeat it -Santayana

How about you just go ahead and move overseas and learn to speak bad english, then you would have all of the benefits your union would earn you now, instead of in ten or fifteen years.

by jrwooton

and I have to say that is not such a bad Idea. then we woulldn't be so screwed by the dogs of the management echelon everytime that they need a scapegoat to send to the cost cutting machine...I am so tired of loosing work that way...

by ggenus

I agree that we I.T. people could benefit from unionization, but I've been in the business since 1992 and do not have an MCSE. Does this mean I "haven't earned" my space.

by gfz660

Squaredge: Iam retired from the teamsters union. There is good and bad in everthing. If the IT were to be in the union. In my opinion, that would be good. But like everthing else wages would have to be regulated. Under a contract. But as you say there is a lot of competition out there. I was a shop stewart for 15 years on & off. So i understand how the system works. These were just some of my thought,s. Sincerly Zeeman

by cptnemo2

In a time of supply glut, prices fall as do options. There is a story: Once upon a time, a major airline carrier named Eastern had to negotiate with their pilot's union. The pilots believed themselves underpaid and ill-used. It so happened that there was a glut of pilots in the market at the time and airlines were suffering from an upstart, not expected to last long, called 'Southwest Airlines.' Eastern tried to reason with the pilots, but they had none of that, and struck the management. This was a mortal blow to the airline, which went belly-up and no longer exists. The pilots? They became IT people because that was the only growth market at the time...

by qzh00k

Write your representatives, no more H1B visas, or no increase in the number. I (US itguy) am now outnumbered by offshore recruits in many tech meetings I attend. I have seen this trend in the last five years go exponential.
The knowledge transfer going on will eventually help the rest of the world match our capabilities in manufacturing sysems, with cheap labor to finish the blow. I consider it a matter of national security.

by dougprechtl

I would have to point out that the purpose of a union is to fight for better wages and benifits for its members and that there is a highly sucessful model for this based on a knowlege commodity rather than labor: The American Medical Association. The while not a union per se, has been the most sucessfull union that I believe has ever existed. It controls the number of new members by controlling the number of doctors that are graduated, lobbies on behalf of the medical profession to prevent regulation by the government, and prevents forign doctors from practicing without going through AMA controlled redidencies. Further, fees are set through AMA publications that provide average fees per procedure.

This model can be utilized by any knowlege based profession including IT. It would require a tremendous organization, and years to implement but it would work.

Preaching free market is a disservice to the profession. We do not want a free market, and no business wants a free market. You want a market that you control, and until we all realize this we will continue to work for $12/hour while Doctors and Lawyers make $200-$600/hr.

by dougl4

Only a very small percentage of doctors and lawyers make what you suggest, and then not for every hour of the work day, so their annual comp. is much less than you suggest. I know a number of successful examples of each profession, and their numbers were never that big. Additionally, most doctor salaries have been shrinking significantly over the past decade, and lawyers are becoming a dime a dozen.

The beauty of our US labor market, is that if you are unsatisfied with anything, you can go somewhere else. I happen to be working on a project in the heart of auto country. Around me, I see very healthy IT wages being paid, and thousands of auto union workers in absolute fear for their work and finanical future.

by dougprechtl

Based on working for 2 doctors practices, these are conservative numbers for my area (NY Metro). I should not have compared it the IT guy's hourly rate of $12/hr from the midwest. A guy here should expect about $30 an hour on salary for the same position. My point is that the AMA and ABA provide "Guidelines" for these fees, and the Doctors and Lawyers stick to them. In this area, a low end lawyer is $150 per hour. Call any lawyer and none go lower. Doctor's office visits are a minimum of $85. None go lower.

We would all do well to do the same.

by rgoode

I don't know who said it, but "our arrogance will be our downfall". There are too many dynamics that go into IT salaries to think that we can demand anything. I work for a company that is driven by what our customer is willing to pay. Economics and demand drive our salaries and the best we can do is to give the customer our best. Furthermore, go ask a Ford employee what the Union has done for them and you will get a better perspective. Those who wish to live in an ivory tower of titles and certs go ahead. It will make more jobs for the less arrogant ones.

by simplyshaman

there's always one in a bunch.. but here's my question. do you realize just why it is that people complain so much about outsourcing american jobs to the rest of the world. it is because of unions driving wages through the roof, which in turn drives prices through the roof. eventually we'll outprice our entire right to an "american way of life".

unions are a bad idea, they breed more strife than they help. and more companies are willing to pay higher wages and give better benefits to non union employees than those who succumb to this guerrilla tactic employing institution of the american economy.

my advice, just say no to unions

by odee100

I agree that a union would benefit the IT world. I, myself, am not MCSE certified, but do have a Masters degree and several years experience. I live in Billings, MT and am forced to work as a tech for the local cable company. The wages are barely above poverty level. I am not sure the local economy would support a $50/hr wage, but it should be a lot more than it is currently supporting now.

It is true that there are too many people in the industry that haven't earned their space. I believe it is due to the numerous companies that offer the "canned answer" type of MCSE classes. That is the reason I went to school and earned my degree. I have the knowledge. I have the experience. Now, lets join together and create the decent jobs so we can afford to live.

by trwright

There is already a union for IT, it is under the Teamsters umbrella. Do you really want your life controlled by a bunch of people that really only want your union dues paid on time so that they can vacation in a better place than last year?

by architect

You need to read a book on the best seller's list entitled "The World is Flat" by Thomas L. Friedman". It dives into the technological changes that have been affecting IT including outsourcing to India, China, etc.. thanks to the internet and the world wide laying of an over abundance of fiber optic cable, hence the title.

by epollnac

We are NOT union, BUT would love to see it happen.

I started in the IT world about 20 years ago. I worked for a contractor at that time as their System Administrator... their work force was entirely union. I started at 6.15/hour (about 12,500/year). My 9th year there, making a whopping 18K/year, I started some research. I found that persons doing the same work as I were getting paid at least 2 times what I was getting. I brought this up to the owners of the company and requested a substantial raise, only requesting 28K/yr. They thought taking me to 22K/yr was good enough. At the time of their "good enough" raise, I put in my two week notice and accepted a position making 36K/yr. I am still with that company and am making a little over 65K. I have seen this company I?m with not let technicians go (GOOD technicians I might add?) and hire younger techs at much lower rates, like at the $12.00 to $15.00 per hour? it just wrong.

by srrattech

What type of employer would provide the best opportunity for advancement & achievement as well as just compensation. Employers with a policy providing annual performance reviews for advancement and/or increased compensation allow an open opportunity to succeed. However, unionization removes any advancement or compensation on individual performance. Job Description, Title, Seniority, pay scale is all that matters. The freshly studied cert will earn just as much as the senior cert if they hold the same Job Title/Grade. Seniority would count for little unless the union mandates tiered pay scale based on years of service to the union and not ability to perform. Remember, all members to a newly organized union have the same seniority level: new member.
I'd rather be judged for my own performance. Shop around for the employer with the suitable cmpensation package. Also, an individuals compensation is based on value to the employer. I would take the $12.00/hr job if it is with an employer of sufficient size. All I need is the foot in the door. If there is no performance level that provides the compensation desired then one must consider themselves a dime a dozen, as well as working in the wrong field.

by weld387

I am currently a Union Worker. I mainly work for the rail road. Used to be a Union Iron Worker before 9/11. IT stuff is just a hobby for me at this point. If the industry were Union I would sign up in a heart beat. The only problem I can see is all the work going to Foriegn places like say "INDIA" were some cat named Winston is doing the work for like two dollars an hour!!! How are you going too offer the same IT service's and justify to a share holder that your pay should be fifty an hour? I truly wish you luck.

by jabamonte

If you want to see the results of unionization, just look at the automobile industry. Unions blame the company, but when your union contract states that a forklift driver makes 18.00 per hour or that a person who installs the shocks makes 25.00 per hour it isn't the company, it is the unions that have driven car domestic companies towards extinction.(no pun intended)

What makes the domestic car industry a pandemic is the fact that union workers believe that a forklift driver should make 18.00 vice 8.00 per hour. In a market driven society, the market decides what a fair wage should be, not the union.

All that being said, the car companies are not blameless, the contracts the car companies agreed to were crafted when domestic car companies held 87% market share. Domestic car companies are short sighted and had a "you take what we give you and like it" attitude. They forgot that consumers are the final vote and that consumers vote with their wallets.

If you unionize IT, you would put us on a slippery slope. Ours is a market driven economy. If you are unhappy with the wage you earn, move to a place where you can earn more.

by woodwurker

Money isn't every thing in a job! (Although we're not at $50.00/hour we're close with the benifit package and all the overtime.)

Our I.T. dept. has been unionized since the late 70's. Having been in the union at that time, the only reason we certified was because Managements incompetency. I've now "crossed" over to I.T. Manager and have taken with me all the negative experiences from the Union days. Even though the staff are still Unionized, they enjoy many more perks than their peers in other departments. The staff know this and keep things to themselves.Treat your staff as you would want to be treated. Believe me, it really pays off! We have had zero turnover in I.T. for the last 15 years.

by codebubba

Oh yeah ... that's just what we need, more reason for the businesses in this country to send the work overseas. Brilliant.

Have you never observed what unionization does to an industry in this country? It results in over-priced merchandize that is lower in quality and creates a generation of lazy workers who expect everything to be given to them. No thanks.

I don't support abuse of employees either - but unionization does more harm than good these days.

-CB

by earl keith

I have worked in union environments from several perspectives, and I have never seen them benefit anybody in the long run.

Sure, some employees make better wages now. But just as many have to accept a wage lower than their qualifications.

Unions also tend to make a business an adveserial place to work. When the "whole" business team is not smooth, the consumer has to pay higher prices for services and goods.

I know you do not but goods and services that do not give you the best value.

I have never joined a union because I see it as giving up my rights to stand on my own merits. I have always felt that if my employer is to stay in business, he cannot pay me what I am worth today. The moment I am worth less to the company than I am being compensated, I will be out of a job one way or another.

I work for a contractor. One of our major clients picked up and moved 1300 jobs because of the Union. Wages were not the issue. A lack of productivity and 12-14% absentee rates were.

If you unionize IT, you will see the drive for excellence diminish, and you will see the cost of services for things you buy go up.

by jmail

Ford. GM. Chrysler. Look at the economy in and around metro-Detroit.

I worked with a company that had unionized IT employees and being a member of the union was mandatory. Ironically enough, I was brought in because they didn't have the "time" to implement changes to their IT architecture and infrastructure. They were required to meet hourly requirements and couldn't work past certain times due to union constraints. In this case, most of the IT guys wanted to finish what they were working on, but received pressure from their union to comply with the hourly guidelines. Overtime could not be approved to finish these projects because the company could not afford the overtime salary rates. It was cheaper to bring me in as a consultant...

by tpsman

I think Microsoft has done a great job of selling the MCSE cert to the corporate world. In my view its experience that counts and that certs are just paper.

In regards to you idea of demanding $50/hr. Thats just silly. I have several friends who have returned to India and now work in IT there. They get around $10/hr. I met a guy the other day who was bragging about how he dumped all of his U.S. IT people and hired a group in Pakistan to do his .NET development. He pays $9/Day/person!

So forget the Union idea and spend time trying to think of a new career outside of IT. But make sure your new job isn't one that can be outsourced as well. Try plumbing, they already have a union!

by cklondon

Unions are great for unskilled, semi-skilled, or more manual trades (this is a generalization, I realize this is not 100% accurate, read on before flaming). In these areas (like plants, warehouses, and government centers), employers try and get away with paying as low as possible and working them long, hard hours. The contracts are negotiated to force employers to pay their employees in identified steps or scales, set up acceptable minimum and maximum conditions, and ensure job progression is dictated by the negotiated contracts.

In contrast, IT is a collection of highly skilled trades. If you are good at it and/or have a lot of experience, there is a lot of demand for your skills. In the case of highly skilled workers, unions can be a hindrance. They tend to protect people who are out of touch with modern practices, limit the ability to progress, and force you to work within a set range of variables with regards to pay, pension, benefits, etc. Most IT people with any experience can negotiate conditions on their own, and if the company doesn't treat them right, they can walk to the competition.

As a skilled IT worker, you have an inherent responsibility to keep up with your skills, much the same as health care and other areas have required numbers of hours on professional development each year in order to stay relevant.

Even in most smaller areas, there are several options for IT that include (if all else fails) relocation to a larger center or even working as a consultant (if you can handle the pressure).

by johnaaaaaa16

The problem with such a plan is that everyone is treated as equal. Having been in IT for over a decade I have learned that there are people at all different levels.

For example, if I can produce a application that meets the customer's/boss's needs in 4 weeks and you require 8 weeks and we both work 40 hours per week, are you worth the same as I am? Likewise, if two people both take the same time to produce a given result (in any area of IT) but one person's solution requires less maintenance, then there is a difference in value.

Until the IT world has a way to truly measure value produced then there is no point of trying unionize.

Why should people of vastly different skill levels be paid the same? Certification tests are fine but they don't measure value. With luck, we will find a way in the future.

by cbny01

I am suspicious of anyone that writes the out of hand, knee jerk reactions both for or against unions here. The fact is that unions have caused great good and great harm, just as business owners have. There are no good guys or bad guys here, just people all trying to get a bigger piece of the pie from a certain angle. I have worked as an IT contractor for 13 years with clients that had both union and non-union employees. It is obvious that abuse runs in both directions. I have seen a unionized employee that makes $50/hr with incredible amounts of vacation time complain about his job for an hour while on the clock. An hour. In essence his employer paid to receive insults. However, I have also seen management spend time to convince their non-union employees that they are all "a big family", only to toss them at will later, or demand pay cuts while their sky-high bonuses remain the same. The fact is it that it is a much more complex issue than "unions bad" or "mgmt bad". Plus how could you do it - the field is so varied and complex. We still can't figure out if it's a software or hardware problem...

by roberts184

I agree anything can be abused or mismanaged. But you do need to look at the power structure to understand where it is more likely to be abused. Corporations are organized, do have a lobby, influence laws to favor their position, share information on worker's salaries in order to minimize their cost, black ball people who act out, and have their own agenda. Contrast this with the disorganization you see in these posts when you look at labor. It quickly becomes clear who is winning this battle.

ps. I have opted out of IT and I am a few months away from a masters degree in education where i will join my unionized friends in teaching.

by cbny01

organized labor also has a very powerful lobby. Hence, the organized. If they didn't unions would have been busted a long time ago. Personally I sympathize with labor for the most part based on the impersonal nature of a "corporation". I cannot remember who said it or the quote exactly, but basically the entity we call a corporation allows many to share the profits while none accept any blame. I also have little faith in economic "laws". These are not laws like gravity where compliance is moot. People can decide what to do with their resources, and their motives are almost certainly more complicated than a simple model could predict, as anyone familiar with supply and demand knows. For example, I read a post on here that said if you offer low wages you get crappy workers. Assuming a crappy worker is someone that knows little about IT, my personal experience has been otherwise. I have seen "crappy" IT workers at every pay scale. I got underbid by someone from another country b/c what I considered to be an unreasonable rate was his fortune...and he was good. I still stand by my earlier comment though. Even if you wanted to unionize "IT" where would you even begin...

by lightspeed555

I've read most of the responses, not all. No one it seems has mentioned that there is a real disparity in how IT services are quoted/billed or otherwise. A lot of "industry captains" really don't have a clue (had a librarian in charge of IT dept) of how much work IT's do or are responsible for. Don't know if there is a standardized charge per job - it would go a long way though to "normalizing" salaries which it sounds like everyone wants. (the auto industry has such a thing for repairs). I've worked on systems since vaccuum tube days and find that the way the industry has evolved "frustrating" at the very least because of this. Hopefully, IT's could "pull together" or at least agree to some accord for their own sakes as well as the industry..

by ludedude25

Ok say you get rid of all Unions, Now who's left to set your wages? Do you really believe that all the big corperations will give there employee's fair wages and benifits? Ha now that's joke.

A union was designed to give the workers power. It's only major downfall is too much power which can lead to it's demise. Only Union members who abuse their power destroy the union name.

by nacromancer

Corporate America will leave this country when the bottom line is no longer profitable. The self interests of Corporate America has been the bane of Politicians who fear their own jobs will be at stake each election when their constituents start seeing jobs and local Government revenues generated by those jobs move over seas to a cheap, often oppressed, labor force. Anyone can teach a dog tricks, but people are not dogs. We learn things...
Everyone wants more, that is the bottom line. There is no such thing as loyalty when it comes to a Share holders demands when a bottom line fails to show an expected profit margin.
The lines are being drawn in the world of knowledge for hire vs a profit margin. No National Standards or structures are set to guarantee a corporations investment in a persons unproven abilties. Unionization could at least in part set the standards for guarranteeing an IT's compentancy and qualifications. Therefore ensurring the Corporate world a tried and tested, worthy of their investment asset. And prove to the Corporate World that they do not have to worry about whether or not their investment is being wasted.
An IT Union could provide the means to keep everyone who claims to be what they claim to be a place in the work field comensorate with their tested and proven capabilities. There by ensuring to the corporate world they are going to get what they are paying for. Also the Union could also provide an opportunity to further and extend the capabilities of it's members as they choose to increase their IT specialties by learning from those who are much more advanced and experienced in areas they themselves are not. That is the way to sell the Union Ideaology to Corporate America. We will ensure you get what you are willing to pay for. And by these standards and guidelines, tried and tested, by our best experts, their investment in one of our members becomes more secure. If the Company does not have the budget for a $50. / hour IT, then they must be made to understand the net worth of the experience they are requiring verses their budget and bottom line.
I do not think any Corporation will be willing to give an IT Union so much as a return call or concern. As long as there is no structure or standard in place. This is what happens when in a world so highly competitive, people refuse to stand together. Damed if you do, Damed if you don't. With every battle there is victums, and I think everyone is afraid in todays economy they will not measure up to even the basic standards comensorate with their positions. While others who do, and are kept from proving it, suffer. Such is the basis of this discussion. Those who feel they would measure up want a standard and provide protection by those standards for others. For you, I stand. A standard tried true and tested needs to be set for all levels of IT expertise and experience. This of course will not happen over night.
There is much to learn and planning for a war against those who are already entrenched. I hope you all of have done your homework prior to raising your flag? For as we speak those who are entrenched already, forewarned is forearmed. Let the posturing begin.

by wizardb9

You have a very inflated view of yourself.What makes you think that your contribution to the bottom line of whatever company you work justifies paying you $50.00/hr. Get real you are living in the dotcom past.

by myrdhrin

Unions kills your chances of moving quickly
Unions kills your changes or going high as fast as your qualified
Unions gets the old crapy not evolving but with more seniority guys in front of you no matter what you do because he was there first
Unions stops really protecting they workforce as soon as they realize they can make more money out if it

If you're not up to the field go somewhere else. If you want a union go in a workshop and start building cars (no pun intented on that industry)

by 35rjt

If you want to watch your co-workers sit around while you produce, go for it!

Once the Union gets in, you will never get rid of the marginal IT Techs.

With our current World trade philosophies your job will get shipped off-shore as soon as it can be done cheaper. The Union can't help.

by jcritch

Face the facts:

Computers are no longer viewed as a mystical wonder, heck 8 year old kids are creating their own web pages.

50.00 a hour, hmmm has Iowa legalized dope smoking? Oh and you want benefits too?

Unions are a joke, they allow unproductive scabs to be paid the same amount as those who give 110%, yet the brotherhood/sisterhood protect the scabs if they are fired.

by michael.nixon

Well,

Here in the State of Kansas we have a union for State Employees called Kansas Association of Public Employees. Inside of that union, IT employees have their own bargaining unit. Now for the bad news, as state employees, that doesn't give us much power, and the average salary is around $17.00 an hour. Now for some areas, out in the sticks, that is good pay. In the cities like Kansas City, Lawrence, Wichita, Topeka, that is not a good hourly pay.

I look at the other job postings and I see that even where I work, IT pay for the state is about half of what the outside non-state employees get.

I say, LETS UNIONIZE!!

by mitchschultz

I have to agree with with your statement. That is the story where I work. The most common phrases I hear on a regular basis is "Its not my job", "It isn't in my job description", or "I don't know". I am the only employee in my department that is not a member of the union. This is only because I am classified as Professional (eventhough I am paid hourly) and the others are classified as Support. It is me against them. I have no desire to be a part of a union that promotes laziness.

by tech

And there you have the reason I would never live in the USA. Too many of you have the most misguided view of unions, and this underlying concept that your way is the only right way. No concept of the responsibility of the society to support the individuals who make up that society. Its every man for himself. Pathetic and sad. You need a social conscience as a country. You need to look at the peopel who are starving in the wealthiest country and supposedly the leader of the free world. Heck - just look at the travest that New Orleans disaster exposed to the rest of the world. You need unions more than anyone I think.

Yep - I know this is inflamatory - but open your eyes people and look at the reality.

by techiemikee

Enormous distruction in the gulf region but I think the expectations of the releaf effort were unrealistic not that the releaf was inadequate. A normal human reaction in a crisis situation is to fight or flight the danger not simply wait for releaf. Sure some are incapable but there were far too many able and capable people taxing the time and resources of the releaf efforts which meant releaf was unavailable to those who truly needed them.

by stan20

I couldn't stand the pay cut.

Want "one size fits all" salaries? Unions are great for the below average. I'll negotiate my own deal.

by ludedude25

I belong to a union. I make a Hourly Rate of 27.10hr. My bring home is $754.64 for a standard 40 hour week.

Dues deducted for that week are a mere $54.20. That is not after bring home, that's from gross.

I pay more in county taxes, federal withholding, social security etc.

Some pay cut for being able to have a group of people help Negotiate my wages and benifits huh.

by stan20

Unions prevent free market salaries. If a company isn't willing to pay my price, I won't work for them.

by sjwilliams

Lets take a quick look at recent history and how unions have affected it shall we?

Steel Unions....Most of the larger mills have gone out of business already, those that haven't are having real difficulties.

Auto unions....American auto companies haven't had a truly good year in decades.

Why are these industry dieing in the US? UNIONS. Don't get me wrong I am all for fair wages and safe working environments but Unions have a detrimental effect on business. Here is how. Nearly every union regires companies to maintain health care and pension funds for thier retirees. So what happens, when, after 25 or 30 years of work everyone retires? You fall into a situation where the revenue generated by a company is less than what it 'owes' to it's retirees (sounds a bit like Social Security don't it?)

A business can only do that for so long before it's product is priced beyond the means of its consumers and looks for other alternatives. For example before LTV went under they were buying steel from Asia for cheaper than they themselves could produce it.

Now, as far as impact on these unionized IT workers. Inovation will die, because you now have to ask Guido if its ok for you to run Cat6 instead of Cat5e. Money would remain unchanged because the contract would be negotiated such that the hourly rate increases but the take home would be about the same, where does the rest of that money go? To Guido. While the take home is the same however your taxes go up, because you earn more.

There are IT unions out there. Most of us in IT who do the research into those unions find that the bennefits of a union are not as valuable as you might thing.

Besides they Unions are Socialist anyway.

by awforrest

Organized labor is the key to better life for everyone. You could try contacting SEIU - the service employees union - the are actively seeking new members and groups of workers. This will be a tough task though considering the anti union climate created by the Bu$h Crime Family.

by techrepublic

A company answers to its owners, who have risked their money to run a business. If you're valuable to that business, you'll be paid commensurately. If you're not, you won't. And that's fair: you're not owed a position at a particular wage any more than you're owed a good price on Pop-Tarts from the grocery store.

Yes, everybody and their shoe-shine boy got an MCSE in the last decade, and yes, now you're a dime-a-dozen. Welcome to supply and demand.

by tobagoman

I have been in I.T. for 20 years. The nature of I.T. is that it is a moving target. You become an expert in one area, learning everything to be the best at what you do. The problem is that the technology changes and what you worked so hard to gain is now useless. Companies don't care about what you did the past 20 years, they want to know what you did today. Unions just take your money for dues, and put you out of a job and piss off the company that pays you. To really make it in I.T. you need to be part of a shop that adopts a structured approach to I.T.
Example: The ITIL model. http://www.itil.co.uk/

Most companies in the U.S. don't want the overhead of ITIL. And do not understant that it will save them in the long run. The result is that young, hungry IT Geeks will work all hours and sacrafice there lives to live for the company. "Been there, done that" When you decide to have a life outside of work, here comes the problem. You cannot demand what you want to be paid, unless you are the best at what you do at that second. It is harder to compete due to the international market being full of well educated young hungery people who are willing to do it for less. I feel your pain and insecurity with this career path! Conclusion: You need to get into a structured shop and stay at the top of your game. It is your life! Control your future. I tell people looking to get into I.T. that it is a cool and fun job. To make it, you need to specialize in one area and become the best at it. Unions were designed to protect people and served a great purpose. They cannot make it in the globalized I.T. industry. We would be the only place following the rules, and business would move out of the U.S. Look at how many big U.S. I.T. companies are foreign owned now.
Thanks;

Bob Drake
GTECH Corporation

by ludedude25

A union is nor has never been a bad thing. Unions were made to help protect the American worker!

Unions work quite well, yes you can make a lot of money but that comes with Greed. The Main problem with Unions is that the workers have too much say and put themselves into their own predicaments.

The American Auto industry is a bad example to use on Unions part. When times were good the Union members were the ones that voted on all their wages, perks, etc. After it peaked out there Greed sticks them up there with high wages which they won't give up. Now comes the non unions Undercutting them big time. Union members could easily vote themselves a pay decrease to be more competitive but will they? NO. Now you have to factor in the Greed of the people own GM, Ford, etc. You think there going to cut there pay to make a car price more competitive for you? NO . Now what does the big time company's do to cut cost's. You guessed it. Lay off's and shut down plants. Now they sneak around and open a bunch of tiny non union plants, Pay their employees what they want and the employee's now have no say it's either work here or quit.

Look at all the foreign countrys that have no say in their wages. Look at what there people make on the hour. Now look at what minimum wage is in the US. There wouldn't be a minimum wage if it weren't for unions.

It all boils down to Greed is what has Torn this Country and it's business's apart not unions. I'd like to see someone prove me otherwise.

by jtakiwi

The horror, the madness, to hire someone who actually knows what they are doing vs. one who paid a few grand to pass some tests. I know quite a few MCES's (and CIS grads for that matter) who aren't worth $10/hr. to perform IT work without significant experience. So, I guess in a union world that would equal paying a newbie $28/hr. to sweep the shop floor.

by mike_goff

I am the Vice President of a small Plumbers and Pipefitters Local Union. I also help take care of our small LAN when I am lucky enough to work in town. While I can't claim to have the education that most of you have, I have taken online courses, bought several hundreds of dollars worth of books, spent countless hours online on tech sites and get tech newsletters via email almost daily. I mention this to let you know that I have at least a basic idea what you have to go through. The education, which doesn't stop when you graduate since technologies advance every day. You have to learn and advance with it or fall to the wayside. Having to deal with clients and their employees, some of which are clueless or "hack and wackers" that do more damage than good, and its your job to fix their screw ups. The sometimes convoluted hours trying to save someones business when their system does a crash and burn and they "forgot" to backup for a week or two. The point I'm trying to get at is.... What is your education worth? What is your ablility to save their company worth? What is your ability to create, deploy and maintain a streamlined system that saves them thousands of dollars a year or more worth? If left to corporate america everyone would work for minimum wage or less. I feel that you should unite, negotiate a contract and benefit package and have a say in your future in the workplace. If you don't band together it will soon get to the point that you'll see the walmart way of thinking hit you hard too...."yeah I know you've been doing this for only $15.00 an hour but I need you to take less" "Billy Bob putertech said he'll do it for $14.50, so if you'll take $14.00 I'll keep you"..... Before it gets to the point that you start cutting each others throats to get or keep work maybe you should think about uniting for the overall good of everyone involved. Better to have a level playing field, at least until they figure out how to outsource your "hands on" work.

by alisak20009

Hello,

I am probably shooting myself in the foot with this answer but I must say that I agree. The part where I shoot myself in the foot is the fact that I work for the Geek Squad which is owned by Best Buy. I earn an hourly rate of less than $20 an hour which is a rip off. I should be earning at least $25 to $30 an hour. I don't have any certifications (because I am working on getting treated for ADD and I can't get through a text book). I started as an Admin. Asst. (glorified name for a secretary) and when I lost that job I found there were no AA jobs in my area paying what level I was at. I did have computer repair skills and went running to my local GS when I heard they were finally in BB. So, by your standards I should be blacked out of IT not working in it. But if there were a union I would be first in line to join it as there is strength in numbers. The down side is that if there were a strike of any sort the corporations would just hire some competent non-certs to take our places at a severely reduced rate of pay. It is a big world out there and we are but goldfish in the ocean.

by cptnemo2

A sample size of 2 practices is simply insufficient to make the conclusion you have, especially when talking about such an inflated area as NYC.

The reality of Union activity is present for all to see...in education, unions have 'dumbed down' America so that excellent teachers are often forced out to keep 'union' teachers from looking bad (read Linda Chavez's book...that is Cesar Chavez's daughter and co-founder of the United Farms Worker's Union). Unions are now either big business or organized crime rackets. But don't believe me...read about Jimmy Hoffa...

by still_rockin

Being in a union didn't help the Air Traffic Controllers did it? (Maybe you're too young to remember, gotta go back to the 80's...) They just all got fired by no less than the President of the United States. It pains me to say that there are serious problems with business/economic mindset/conduct in this country which have only been spiraling us down further and further over the last 25 years, with no end in sight...

by noo-yawker

A lot of emotion surfaces when the idea of unionization is discussed. It's important to reflect on the "what" and the "why" that cause labor unions to be considered in the first place. While workers create labor unions it's working conditions that create the need for unions.

When individual workers are unable to bargain effectively with their employer about the terms of their employment then they have a need to form a union so they can bargain collectively. Typically this happens when a particular labor supply is greater than its demand. It doesn't matter whether that worker is a coal miner, textile worker, truck driver, ER physician, or IT professional.

IT workers who have been around for about 10 years have seen the circumstances of their larger work environments change greatly. There are more workers in the available pool, domestically and internationally; many former specialized skills have been commodified; the way work is done enables decentralized development; and the overall trend towards mergers and acquisitions have reduced the number of available jobs. The accelerated growth in IT during the period from the 1970s through the 1990s has tapered off. This means there are more people but fewer jobs.

The conflict is between workers, who believe that they should not be treated as a commodity and their past loyalty means they do not deserve to be treated as such, and employers who are looking at current and future P&L and see salary and benefits as an expense that must be reduced as much as possible.

In many cases, unfortunately, both employer and employees become so hardened in their own positions that they lose the ability to communicate and compromise. This takes the focus away from the important goal of maintaining the viability and growth of the enterprise itself as a source of jobs which also has social responsibilities to the workers who help it grow and thrive.

One can't blame unions for the failure of a business segment. Detroit isn't selling cars because of unions; it is not selling cars because management failed to offer well-made cars that potential customers would want to buy while their competitors have succeeded because they understand their market better. The cost of labor is not the major issue in the automotive industry but is an easier issue on which to cast blame than management having to find fault with itself.

by evisscerator

You pose a great question, but there is plenty of recent events that would prevent this idea from reachng fruition. Take a very long hard look at FORD Motor Co and General Motors. The fact that they are now closing plants in North America and laying off 30,000 workers is a solid indication that they are now "UNION BUSTING". This is something that they have been wanting to do for a very long time. I must say I agree with their view of the matter .... Cars cost too dang much. I just bought a new car and paid 1/2 of what I paid for my house for it (that is ridiculous).

As far as Unionizing IT, I would rather see a movement to start an "Apprenticeship" based IT world than one dominated by uncertifiable CERTIFICATION standards that we now have. The only people who "PROFIT" from "Certifications" are Microsoft, Novell, Red Hat and others. The time has come to steal their thunder and start making IT a bit harder to get into. We need to cut out the cancerous "Neighborhood Wanna Be Computer Guru's" who end up screwing up more than they fix. These closet computer hacks need real jobs and stop profiting at the expense of other people doing legitimate business.

.... I relenquish my SoapBox to someone else now ....

by styehimba

You have my vote on that. I am tired of all these so called wannabes' coming into the IT field underbidding those of us that have been here for 2 decades at least. It is maddening. However, this is the mentality that people have these days. However, they don't understand that they will get what they pay for............ So I say Unionize this mother and let's get paid what we are worth and make all those who think they know study as we did and get certified like we did and then just like everything else, start at the bottom and work and prove their way up.

by gbennett

Get real... unions will be the death of America. Union people never studied economics and don't have a clue about the concepts of supply and demand. Smoking dope instead.