Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

725 replies

by flowahpla

I have to chuckle at anyone who thinks that labor laws alone are going to protect them, or that governments even care.
Just ask a temp. They are predominant way to get around labor laws.

by matthew.procter

Of course the one option everyone has missed is MOVING. If you don't like where you are, move. Its simple. I know that Australia is crying out for SAP skills, as well as anyone who knows which end of a mouse goes where.

New Zealand has some similar trends too, with about a third of our IT team being imports from the UK.

Wages may be less, but the cost of living is too. And ther lifestyle is much better.

IT already gets a bad rap becuase of bugs, viruses and idiots who think they know what they are doing; do we really want to add "stevador' also?

After 8 years I get ~NZ$25 per hour. And its moer than enough.

by vlpresher

Not on your life. The day of the union is over. The focus of the union now is how can we increase the fee's to our members so the union officals can get a big raise.

Unions force companies to pay pay administrative staff salaries way out of line with what it take sto do the work. Example: 125k a year for walking around a loading dock writing bar code #'s. This is one reason why companies have layoff and why prices of goods skyrocket.

Union's today are the highway robbers of yesterday.

by frankmon

I have been involved with 4 different unions during my career and I have to say that not once did I get any real benefit from them. Let me step back a bit and look into the history of organized labor a bit. The following is very simplified but I don't think anybody wants to read a treatise on the labor movement in America ;).

In the early 20th century, companies were under no rules or laws that kept working hours to a minimum, a person could be fired because the foreman didn't "like" them, there was no minimum work age, and many other insufferable conditions existed. On the other hand unskilled workers were holding down positions that they were unqualified for, possibly creating dangerous conditions.

At some point some workers decided to organize in order to force owners to provide a fair wage, decent working conditions and proper equipment (this is somewhat simplified but you get the point). The organizers realized they needed to provide something from their end so they made sure that if someone was a journeyman level in their trade that they could be trusted to perform their tasks well with fewer errors.

So, after many violent confrontations and many murders and threats, unions came to be. When they first started out they were good. They kept labor management somewhat fair and improved wages and benefits. In turn the unions promised that they would provide skilled workers.

This all worked out for a while even going so far as to making some union rules federal law so even non-union workers began to be given fair conditions. There were always contradictions to this but for the most part the workplace was a much better place to be in by the 1940's then they were at the turn of the century.

By the late 40's and 50's most of the union rules were now federal labor laws making the unions somewhat anachronistic. Unions then shifted their focus and began promising that a union worker would be loyal and well skilled. In effect they were trying to operate more like guilds than unions.

Then the greed set in. Union management felt that lining their own pockets was a far better thing to do than protect the labor force. If a union decided they didn't like someone because they spoke out against their "brothers" (in reality the person was speaking out against unfair union rules) they could be fired (or worse) with impunity.

The unions then started practicing cronyism and nepotism to the nth degree. To this day there are some very strong unions that you pretty much have to have a stamp on your birth certificate in order to ever become a member. This practice began to decay the supposed skill level of the workers. Men and Women who were very skilled were denied membership because if they were too good, they would make the other members look bad. with laws now keeping wages and conditions somewhat fair (not always, but better than back in 1900) the only thing the unions could provide was a highly skilled workforce and with cronyism and nepotism that was even going away.

These practices not only lock out potential skilled workers but can cause dangerous conditions as well. In one firm I worked at, the master electrician was the brother of the union president. He was also a heroin addict, alcoholic, and semi-illiterate. He cause 4 accidents that I know of that hurt a total of 13 people. Yet he kept his job because the union protected him.

That's where organized labor is now. They have, for the most part, outlived their original purpose and have refused to change with the times. I'll get into what unions should be doing now a bit later.
During my career (which is in the entertainment field) I have been involved with 4 different unions and each one left me feeling that my needs were not met (or even considered) as the union management is now more concerned with keeping their personal bank accounts fat.

Some of my experience with unions include- being reprimanded for "sweating" because I was working too hard. Working too fast because I made the rest of the crew look bad. I was fined for picking up something that was 6' long without help; it was a piece of 1x3 pine which weighed < 4.5lbs. I was also fined for trying to negotiate my own wage rater than go through the union.

Then there were the other "things". Rampant alcoholism. You were a "man" if you went to lunch and had 3 beers and 2 shots. Crystal meth usage was almost required in order to try and function while drunk. Anyone who complained about it or did any whistle blowing were soon let go or laid off.

Anyhow the above are some of the more egregious activities that organized labor is involved in today and I believe in order to survive, they need to reinvent themselves. They need to be more like a guild.

I would love to see unions become guilds where you have to have a certain amount of education (say an A.A. degree) with plenty of education in your chosen feild. I would love to see these guildmembers not be forced to use feather bedding(where more people are on the job than needed) and can aslo negotiate their own wage and benefits. But it should not be easy to get into the giuld just because you know somebody. It should be based on your skill level and experience so that a comapny can hire a guild member and know they are getting the best in their field, not some alcoholic who can barely write hs /her own name.

Once I moved into "scab" shops I made more money, had better benefits, and what would have been my dues are now going into a mutual fund. Because of my skill level, I have never been laid off as I strive to make myself a valuable employee. I spend at leat 3 months a year taking classes to expand my knowledge.

Anyhow, like I said the above is from my own experience and there are some folks who love the union system as it exists.
The unions have a choice, evolve or stagnate. I feel that if they continue to stagnate then they will be forced out of the workplace eventually leading back to the early 20th century practice of every person for themselves.

by frankmon

I guess my education is lacking somewhat in grammer and spelling. Sorry, I was in a hurry.

I want to sum up by saying that I'm not anti-union in the least. I am vehemently anti-stupidity with regards to organized labor and believe that if the unions get their act together and join the rest of us in the 21st century they could be a good thing.

As they exist now though, they are holding labor back and giving management a good excuse to break them rather than work with them.

The AMA comments I've read do make some sense. That org acts like a guild. The mebers all have to be educated and "certified" and continued education, while not mandated, is rewarded. The last time I had something really wrong with my health, I sought out the physician with the most initials after their name (that is somewhat glib as I did research further).

There is no reason that a model based on the AMA could not be created for the IT field and it should.

by jaredh

I found your history of unions very interesting and informative.
Here are the reasons that I am "unhappy" in my IT job:
1) unrealistic expectations regarding hours & pay.
I currently work in public education. Is the pay great? Heavens no! But it is enough to support my family. That is what really matters. But when all of these expectations of unrealistic deadlines and providing solutions with little or no resources are thrown on my shoulders, I would love to just walk away because it is "unfair".
I currently work 40 hours a week. If a project is left undone, then oh well because I am not paid to get the job done just put in my time. Now that itself is not bad but I take pride in my work and I want to do it right, but I am not given the resources to do it right. If Unions could make this happen, then I am all for it.
However, I saw a IT working who joined a union and it took over a year to get him fired! This guy was getting complaints from all of his customers & from fellow employees. He was constantly late he even stole, yes stole computer parts. The last I heard was that stealing is a crime. He should have been terminated right then for committing a cime against his employer. But no, the Union protected his sorry butt. If this is what Union's do, then forget it.
If they do both, then what is the greater good? Fighting for fairness, or over doing it and creating unfairness?

by flowahpla

You seem to be malinformed, or perhaps fearmongering?
Even worse case scenario, any union I have ever heard of doesn't operate at that level with respect to dues!
There are dues, of course, but most are in the low single digits with respect to percentages.
As far as strikes go, there is no way around it. They suck.
But they suck for the employer as well, and in most cases serve as a deterent to both parties involved. There is strike pay, but it is minimal to say the least.
Unions have their pros and cons, just like anything else, but to be taken seriously, you need to first get real.

by cactus pete

That's the point. I'm not going to quote a specific number for dues (as everyone will vary) so I came up with a number that was obviously not accurate. This was intended to make the point without committing to an actual number.

If I said 5%, people at 2% would be mad. If I said 2%, people at 1.5% would yell.

So try to reread it again - jsut add your own numbers where appropriate.

by bitswapper

If you're going to work someplace, and the first thing they ask is if you have CERT_XYZ, consider that a mark against that employer. Try to talk directly to the person who manages the area you're looking to work in. You may be able to tell the degree of cluefullness present. If it seems too low, then they'll likely outsource in the future, or get carried away with their desire to fill the ranks with people carrying certifications. Oh, and by the way, MCSE stands for *Musn't *Configure *Servers *Ever.

by rowdydave

I didn't expect to get rich when I took an IT job. I make a living and pay my bills. That's what I expect. If I'm not satisfied with what I get from my employer, I can look elsewhere for employment or go into business for myself. I don't need a union telling me, or my employer, what to do.

Unions were formed when workers were being abused, both mentally and physically, in sweatshops and labor mills. With a few fringe, illegal exceptions, no one is being abused today. However, many are crying that "the man" doesn't pay them enough for what they do. Did you expect to get rich working for someone else? Get a clue.

With the exception of some high-ranking executives, no one who is an 'employee' is going to get rich. That's just the way it works. It's possible for an 'employee' to get there, but the opportunities are few and far between. The more quickly you realize that, the more quickly you can prepare yourself to make the tough choices to either accept what you've chosen, or choose otherwise and make things happen for yourself.

Unions are just as oppressive as companies; moreso in some cases. The restrictions a union can impose on my ability to be flexible and practice multiple skills would make my job boring and unfulfilling. The one term I hate the most is "That's not my job." I could go on about altruism (which is sorely missing in our world these days), but there are good arguments on both sides of that employer/employee fence.

Do comanies need to consider sharing a little more of the pie with their employees, instead of giving the CEO that 85% raise? Yes. Will unionizing make that happen? Absolutely not!

If "the man" isn't paying you enough, perhaps you should look within first. Then, if you're satisfied within yourself, look elsewhere for work. Maybe you desserve better, but if they're not offering it where you are, perhaps some other place will.

by buzzwizard

Oh yeah, lets kill the goose that layed the golden egg the same way that UAW is killing the American auto industry. They're already outsourcing or jobs to India. Are you trying to speed up the process?

Buzz

by cactus pete

My wife is a temp at a place for about 7 years. She makes about a third more than the average worker there...

That's just a headcount issue. Hiring a temp is a different type of accounting cost, so it actually works out more in the company's, and our, favor.

Win win for us both.

Naive not, indeed.

by cactus pete

I feel like I could get another job almost anywhere. I might or might not be able to make as much money. But that also depends on the industry, teh location, and how good a fit my skills are to their needs.

I don't think a union would help me find another job. I think that a union ould hire less than qualified people to fill spots, just to fill spots (whether needed for the operation of the firm or not).

by cathleen301

I'm happy for you that you work for a company that cares about its employees!

I'm also above average and expect a wage commensurate with my abilities. What if the "set union wage" you are talking about is something you negotiated?

When we ratify a contract, we know for the next 3 or 4 years just what our wages will be and when to expect our raises. You see, we negotiate the pay rates, raises and benefits with the company. If we are not happy with the proposed rates or benefits, we don't ratify the contract!

I'm glad you don't mind working for less than your true value. You're lucky that you have an employer that won't take advantage of that, or else what's to stop them from deciding that the less you are so willing to work for is your true value? I?m glad you get paid enough to enjoy what you do outside of work. Does that include all the necessities for your children, grandchildren and retirement?

I, too, find the intangible rewards very important. I love what I do for work and I?m good at it! I also help others by participating in my Union as a steward, or executive board member, or officer or just by going to the membership meetings to be the voice of those members who aren't able to attend.

Who would pay someone to tell them to strike? Do you even know what goes on before there is even the thought of a strike? Our union works hard to negotiate contracts - we haven't had a strike in the 19 years I've worked there. No one would prefer to strike than to do their job. We take pride in the excellent work we do - which is why we can negotiate contracts without striking.

I, too, do not like not being able to do all the work that I am capable of doing. So, rather than whining about it I work to make changes in the contract. Just as I?m sure you?ve made some tweaks to the computer stuff that you love to do. Unions aren?t perfect. But the people who are union members have the option of working to make them better.

Let me know when you are 50-70 years old how mobile you are; how easy it is for you to just up and leave if your employer takes advantage of you. And, what about your pension? Family members that depend on you?

by cactus pete

I've never had a company tell me they would pay a pension. I get 401k contributions, but that's it.

Here's a newflash for you: Anyone who works in a capitalistic society works for less money than they are worth. Else, the employer wouldn't make a profit.

I negotiate my own salary. I chose a company that offers benefits I like.

I believe that my good decisions now will allow me to work until I chose to stop working, and by then I will have enough money for everything mportant to me.

And if you think your pension is safe, you haven't seen anything in the news for the last few years.

by flowahpla

This is true and I have seen it.
Perhaps not in IT, but in the manufacturing sector.
Some people wrap themselves in the blanket of union protection, and become complacent.
The onus for them to perform, and their job depending on it is not there in the conventional sense.
Seniority can also ply a role in that an individual who is the best fit for a position may not necessarily get the job, as someone else with senority who is "trainable" in that position will take it.
As pros and cons go, this is definately just a couple of serious cons.

by startech

That's some pretty steep insurance to keep your job. Did you know that you're paying somebody nearly $3000 a year just to keep your job? What was your last pay raise? +$5.00/hr? + $10.00/hr? And how many people are in your union? Multiply that by the number $3000/year and somebody's making a boat load of money.

You'd be better off finding a job elsewhere!

by rka

Finally someone with sense! People obviously have not learned a lesson from what the UAW has been going through. "Why is my job going overseas?" they say. They just don't understand that there are people willing to do the jobs for less!

Better wake up those of you suggesting union representation. If you demand too much, there are others who would be more than happy to take your place and employers won't hesitate to hire them.

by evisscerator

People don't realize that GM/FORD Union Employee's make a minimum of $45.00 per hour for the jobs they do, but those costs are passed on to all of us who aren't UNION by making us pay 1/3 more in the price of a cheaply made automobile.

What kills me is the TeleCommunications Union (SWBELL, AT&T, MCI, VERIZON, and more)also have lost many jobs all the while the CEO's of these corporations make astoundingly huge BONUS's .... SWBELL CEO made a $10 Million dollar bonus last year, that YOU and I paid for and that UNIONS lost employee's over.

The Days of the UNION are gone and over .... Their Jobs are outsourced to 3rd world countries because the COST of their LABOR is cheaper.

Perhaps if we didn't want so much for pay, and price of our cost of living went down 33% or more, it might equal out. But, where most of the companies profits go is toward the upper management for the little work those people do.

Honestly, for every CEO out there, there are at least 3 other people making him look good by doing their job (he's given them his work to do).

by gometrics

No one starved, the poor were fed, clothed and provided shelter. The looting was stopped within two weeks. The jobs here are plentiful and the pay is fine...including IT. You can make $15 per hour flipping burgers in some places. Housing is still a problem but KATRINA WAS the worst NATURAL disaster in U.S. history. It has been less than six months. How long did it take to rebuild Europe after WWII? Wasn't it years with some friendly help from the USA? That same helping hand is in N.O. too though not all appreciate it. We hardly live in a country where everyone is out for himself. The U.S. is #1 in charitable giving last I checked. Real poverty is having no food, no shelter, and no hope. That does not describe any place in the U.S.A.

by jamesrl

With respect, not by the numbers.

In terms of Government assistance, the US ranked 22 out of 23 countries in terms of giving as a percentage of Gross National Product. Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Norway give far more of their wealth away.

Its is true that US citizens are very generous privately, but even when you factor that into account, the US on the whole is not #1 as a percentage basis. In absolute numbers it is the largest, but it is one of the largest economies and a fairly large population as well.

http://www.globalissues.org/TradeRelated/Debt/USAid.asp#Sidenoteonprivatecontributions

James

by jamesrl

You may have read my other posts about the place where I managed two desktop teams, one unionized, one non unionized. They both had access to the same amount of training. They both had the same opportunity to be productive. The unionized group was less productive. Why you should ask? Because it was difficult yo get rid of the deadwood in the union shop, and that made those who would normally work hard slack off, because they were upset we were forced to carry the deadwood. The non-unionized group worked hard because they knew that their own personal performance would impact the raise they received.

Is there a lesson somewhere in there?

James

by questor1

It seems that your company does not have control of its IT staff if slackers pass off the work to others. Your company likely needs to develop better metrics to measure and compare workers in the same area(s).

Employees (both union and non-union) need to know what management expectations are for the quality and quantity of work, as well as hiw their performance is reliably measured. These results need to be regularly shared with both employees and staff so they know where they are.

I once worked for the US EPA as a help desk manager for contractors and was tasked with clearing out deadwood staff and improving contractor response to EPA clients. The prior contracting company tried to pack as many unneeded contractors as possible into the contract to jack up billing rates. We started daily 5 minute update meetings, better time to open and time to close statistics and a staff rating system that was updated weekly. No system is perfect for emplyees or managers, but I was able to fairly and completely show staff where improvements needed to be made. If a staff member did not improve, they were put on notice and given a 2 month period to improve.

Some improved and some did not. Those who did not were regularly shown the ratings results and eventually the exit door from the contract. Our 40 person staff was cut in half within 1 year, but there was a very noticable improvement in staff morale and customer satisfaction once the deadwood was cut loose due to their lack of action...

When employees are motivated, satisfied, and doing a good job that shows up in results - relations between management and staff are much easier regardless if the staff is union or non-union.

by cactus pete

The answer was to switch companies, not unionize?

I had a little trouble following the last bit, I wasn't sure if you were complaining about the current employer or not.

by mot_esach

WOW! Are the techies irratable today?

I have seen both sides of this issue (the union part). I was a job steward and a union local President as well as a member of the local barganing team. I moved into managment and was part of the barganing team for contract renewal due to my experience on the "other side."

If you want to ruin the IT field just unionize. Every "junkie tech" out there will celebrate with you, then shove it down your throat.

Unionization does not guarantee any employement, it does not guarantee any representation nor does it guarantee any wage, bebefit or job security. Oh they will tell you it does - but the truth of the matter is it will not.

What it will guarantee is poor workmanship from a very few that will reflect on a majority and those very few will be protected. The majority will have to support them because they are union members regardless of their opinion about their technical capabilities.

If you are being overworked on the job or not being compensated correctly for work or overtime, then you need to do some research into the Fair Labor Standards Act and explore your respective state statutes regarding reasonable and fair compensation. That is the first avenue for requiring compliance by the employer. If they don't meet what you want, but are in compliance, then move- its still a free country. To require a salary minimum will eventually defeat your purpose. Outsourcing will be the result and tnat means no matter what you want to charge - no one is going to pay it.

I think we pay a lot of occupations way to much money for the products they give including a lot of techies. I do free lance work and freely admit to my clients (in advance) that I may not have the answers - but I will send them to someone who I know won't put the screws to them to get their answers. In my local area there are six shops that frequently and intentionally don't warrantee their work nor do they offer any real solutions. I don't send anyone to them and they know it. I also do work for several companies whose deadwood problem in the "techie" field scares me. I don't believe the "certification" process helps and I tell my clients that fact.

If you want to be paid well - then do a good job. If your company is too small to offer "glorius compensation" then move on to someone who will. Whatever you do don't insult the "90 day wonders" comming out of the tech schools. Many of them are great - some are fantastic and still others are idiots. What one produces is the measure. Maybe that is a point you need to examine. You also are not entitled to the "top of the mountain" until you pay for the trip. I think managers can figure it out quickly enough. I think grousing over compensation is really a process of expressing disatisfaction with an employer. That is a different subject than compensation.

The important thing to understand is that pay scales quite often reflect the local economy or the general state of economic well being for the company or the local community. If you live in an area that can support $50/hour then more power to you. But to unionize and set broad scale employment rates will keep expansion from occuring. Lack of expansion means lack of promotional or even basic employment opportunities. It certainly stifles personal creativity which is what, in my opinion, drives the IT field to having the quality that I have seen.

If you don't want to work for $12/hr don't. But ask yourself who is going to pay the bills. If you are in an area where your wages won't pay the bills, then leave - after a process of poor techs who will work for those wages, with associated down time and consulting costs, managers will figure it out and wages will go up.

The important thing to understand is that it is possible to price yourself right out of the market - then how do you pay the bills?? All the technical experience in the world isn't going to help you if there are no jobs for you.

To sum up - a union is not the answer. It will ultimately only lead to more problems than solutions

by ibanezoo

... hah... we have enough of those mafias ruining everything else in this country.... why ruin IT? Why do people complain so much about their IT jobs in these discussions? Find another line of work if it sucks so bad. You get paid what you are worth and if you don't produce there is someone else who will and for cheaper. Maybe you can start your own company and pay your IT staff whatever you think is fair.

by apotheon

Collective entities are what got us into this mess in the first place, and now you want to "fix" it by creating more collective entities. There hasn't been an industry improved by unions in at least thirty years. Unions, like minimum wage laws, increase unemployment by forcing business to consolidate talent, and increase unemployment by destroying businesses. People who advocate unionization typically want something for nothing.

I'm not saying you necessarily don't deserve to get paid more: I'm saying that demanding higher wages doesn't come without a price. If you think entry-level IT is tough to find now, try it after unionization. The domestic IT workforce will be decimated inside a few years if the industry gets unionized. It'll be prohibitively expensive just to get into this line of work, too. There will be no room left for people who [b]enjoy[/b] the work, ensuring that people who care more about their paychecks than about their work rule the industry.

Screw that noise. I prefer opportunity over strongarmed handouts.

by it survivor

Your comments make me think of a time when we had no unions. The Standard oil Trust dominated the land and JP Morgan ran the country. We had 12 year olds works 12 hour days for $1.00 day. People need to study the economic history of this country. We had better wake up before we are the next 3rd world country with a working class that is condemmed to poverty and working conditions that replicate the beginning of the last century.

by noyoki

We now have laws preventing 12 yr olds from working, laws preventing 12 hr shifts, and a law stating the minimum wage.

Sure, Unions were great when the people needed them, but they have outlived their usefulness imo.

by justanotherguy

It can bad enough answering to the boss you have now. Imagine now you have to kiss some union steward's arse just to keep your job. Unionism leads to cronyism, retired in place (teacher's unions for example).

Is there anything wrong with unions per se? No. But like any other human-centered group, it provides a place for power grabbing and complacency. And who needs more BS (and that's not Bachelor of Science) in IT anyway?

by tonythetiger

to that would be to change the way everyone is compensated... by defining a unit of work output besides time. It would probably be unpopular in some circles though ;)

by halibut

I can't agree more at Apotheon's reply. Unions are great for certain industries. Industries that require certain safety and workplace needs but unionizing for the money is the wrong reason and will backfire to the industry. Would this union include the offshore IT industry or not? If not how would this change a company's view of the inhouse IT staff?

I currently work for a company that uses outsourced IT support in Malaysia and India, and our support it has been an absolute nightmare when dealing with them. No local support for this infrastructure has proved problematic, and as the industry sees issues the whole setup will change.

As for the $12/hour tech, don't be too worried, there is always bound to be someone that under charges to get the work and as their skill increases their price will go up.

by montgomery gator

Think things are bad now, if this happens, all the good jobs will be outsourced to Bangalore (unless we can get our IT brethren in India and other countries to go along with the plan).

by edwards

Look at GM, Ford, United Airlines. High priced
union labor is sinking those companies. There is
a big pool of cheap IT labor available in India.
Go ahead a unionize. Demand big wages. The Indians
will be happy to undercut you. So will non-union
people who prefer employment to unemployment. Look
at Winchester (U.S. Repeating Arms Corporation).
They are closing up shop. They can't make a profit with high union wages. Socialism does
not work in government or the workplace. Make
yourself more valuable and your paycheck will
reflect the consequences. Resort to collectivist
union thuggery and you can join the unemployed.

I have more computer science, electrical
engineering and embedded systems development work
on my plate than I can handle. I've had to put
some requests in abeyance. My hourly rate as an
employee works out to around $62/hour. I don't
have to demand it. My employer is happy to have
my services at that rate. They bill my labor out
at $250/hour (loaded rate).

by mot_esach

If you want a controlled market - try China. They have a very well controlled market.

Not one I would want to be in - but tightly controlled. Good luck on "asking" for a wage increase.

by startech

Just some themes in this thread in case you union-mongers missed them:

Say no to unions!

Unions are a bad idea!

Unions do nothing for you!

Unions cost YOU money (is that racketeering?)

Unions give you a false sense of security!

Unions are the cause of the downfall of this country!

Unions lead to faster overseas outsourcing!

You make less money with a union!

Unions stifle creativity and innovation.

Unions are for the weak.

You're better off negotiating for yourself than letting a union rep do it for you!

Unions promote weakness, lazyness, and complacency.

Unions are old tools for an ancient society.

Unions are DEAD!

Now let's stop whining! If you want $50/hr. -- go earn it!

by it mgr/packer fan

It is unfortunate, but folks-- our field is just like any other-- there are new kids, fresh out of college, applying for jobs at YOUR workplace every day! Your only recourse is to do a great job, make yourself valuable, learn new things, even if you are not directly paid to do so, and go the extra mile. In IT, expect to work evenings, weekends and holidays-- expect to change with the times, and do so as rapidly as possible, and that means keeping your THOUGHTS young and flexible, too. As for those huge salaries that a lot of IT people seem to think they command-- well, if the company can get the same work cheaper, they will- look around you, companies are going bankrupt, and this is no kidding-- they MUST stay competitive, and to do so, must watch the bottom line. As for unions-- why do you suppose all those darn GM plants are closing? I can tell you, because I was a contractor at AC Sparkplug, early in my IT career- they are closing because uneducated Kentucky men and women felt they could hold the company for ransom, and demand $25 an hour, in the 80's, for putting a widget on a car body as it went by. Things MUST equalize, that is not right, and that is what is happening with IT- if it is easy enough to get an MCSE that so many people, CHILDREN are doing it, then perhaps it isn't worth $100,000 a year to hire one. And I have managed and built servers in Europe, from my home in Wisconsin-- your competition is worldwide. The solution? Get specialized, be smarter than the average bear- or do get into another field, that will guarantee you the big bucks-- and let us know what field that would be!

by sailor39

dopetrk, I will answer each of your allegations/misconceptions with my knowledge of unions.
First, a union does not hire people, the company with the union contract does. If the union wishes to keep the contract, it will send as many qualified IT applicants as it can find.

Secondly, no union I am aware of charges dues of 25%.
The norm is more like 3% to 5%, and it is certainly worth it because not only hourly wages will be great, but more importantly, you are protected from unfair work rules like 50 to 60 hours/week with no overtime, late nights after midnight and early calls the next morning, even to protecting you from "outsourcing". I can see a tremendous need in the IT field for the able assistance of a union.

Oh Yes, if a union wishes to strike, one of the things needed is a majority vote of the membership in the venue in favor of the strikeIf you stop and think about, there are very, very few strikes these days. Just abolut everyone agrees that a strike is absolutely the final resort.

Disclaimer - I currently do not work in the IT field, but as the old saying goes...I know many who do. jack

by cactus pete

"First, a union does not hire people..."

Actually, they negotiate how many people work there. The negotiate the necessary standards for the hired personnel. They, in effect, do the hiring. (Granted, contracts vary.)

"Secondly, no union I am aware of charges dues of 25%."

Me neither. The number, as I've explained a few other times, was meant to be outrageous enough to not be taken literally, but easy enough to make the point. Feel free to read the other posts.

"...not only hourly wages will be great, but more importantly, you are protected from unfair work rules like 50 to 60 hours/week with no overtime, late nights after midnight and early calls the next morning, even to protecting you from "outsourcing"."

My hourly wages are great. I work overtime and get paid for it. (They try to make sure no one abuses this, actually.)

It's my company. I take responsibility for it. I work hard and I'm compensated accordingly. I would hate a union boss to tell me I can't work if I want to. That I can't let a 15 minute call slide if I want to.

I take care of my company, and my company takes care of me. A union would simply get in the way of that.

If you work for a place that doesn't treat you properly, leave it. If they break the law, report them.

And as for being protected from outsourcing - At the rate we're adding remote offices, I am more of an outsource to the remote sites sometimes than I am a local worker.

If I couldn't do my job, I'd be fired. When the company can't pay me or be flexible enough for my life, I'll fire them.

by rka

Socialism is dead. It is a system which supports ineffective and unproductive ways. Socialism props up the status quo with bureaucratic protections instead of looking for better ways to do things. That is why many inventors from outside the US leave their country to pursue their dreams in the US.

You obviously have never been to the USA or you would NEVER say it's "every man for himself". This country and it's people give more to humanitarian causes both home and abroad more than all other countries combined! The problem with you and those like you are that you choose to believe the liberal crap which is published in most main stream newspapers. The New Orleans disaster was due more to mismanagement than a lack of concern for the people affected. Get your facts straight.

Get out from behind your newspaper and find out what real Americans are like. You might just find out we are not so bad.

by ibanezoo

You guys crack me up. You can't force businesses to do anything. If someone is willing to work for less and can perform acceptably to the company, you bet your ass that person will get the job over you. Companies do not owe you anything. *You* must provide the incentive for more money/benefits/whatever.

Unions aren't all they're cracked up to be, at least not these days.

by maryacats20

sounds like the boss either likes the person or is to LAZY to fire a that person ,the right way . I am a retired (27 years UFCW local 1000 ) union member. I worked in retail I can see where you guys could use a Union too; you have input as to wages, benefits,vacations , & holidays.Your UNION will only be as strong as YOU the members will make it . Been there done that . good luck organizing . I read your tech site to learn from you .
Mary

by jdclyde

Go ask the 30,000 FORD Union employees that will be out of a job in the next few years how stable the Union made their lives.

By demanding more money than the job is worth, they priced cars out of competition with imports.

Have you ever worked union? I have, and the only thing lazier than a Union employee is a government employee. that is why they can't compete.

I will NEVER work union again.

by greentwig

Sorry, but if you can't bargain your own enterprise agreement you probably aren't in the right industry...

by edwards

I worked at PacBell for 11 1/2 years. The unions
really screwed the non-union, non-management
employees by confiscating union dues from their
paychecks and preventing them from moving freely
between various departments in the company.

When the contracts expired every 3 years, the CWA
employees routinely lost 2 to 3 weeks of pay while
walking the picket lines. Much more lost than was
ever recovered in the new contract. The union
bosses drove past the picket lines in big
Cadillacs. The "strike benefits" were a very small
return of the union dues extracted.

Unions are attractive to the inept and the incapable who hope that collective bargaining will
get them a better deal than their own paltry
performance warrants.

The cost of employee retirement benefits built
into the cost of every GM automobile exceeds the
cost of the steel required to build it. The
non-union produced automobiles easily undercut
the price of union made vehicles. GM and Ford
are both in the toilet as a consequence.

Unions are an anachronism that flourished when the
United States was the only global manufacturing
power on earth. It isn't that way anymore. There
is plenty of competition around the globe. The
days of being able to make demands at the
bargaining table that can't be financially
supported in the marketplace are over.

by logos-systems

After being in this industry for over 35 years now, I can tell you that there has been a national debate for the Unionization IT Workers has happened at least 3 times that I know of. It didn't happen then and I doubt if it will happen now.

If you don't want to work all of those unpaid hours above 40 hours, I strongly suggest you move into consulting. At least you get paid for every hour you do work. Of course you don't get paid if you are sick or on vacation, but that is the trade-off.

If you don't want to work hard, constantly keep learning the new technologies as they come out, I would strongly suggest that you get a job with the New York Transit Workers union.

If your IT skills are mediocre, and you want to get paid what another person does that has exceptional IT skill, who is willing to do what is necessary to themselves ahead in their particular specialty, then a union may be the only way to accomplish your goal. But you will find that most of the mediocre IT personnel will be laid off, with little hope of finding another position anywhere! Just remember in this global economy if an IT worker cannot show an employer that the company can get a better Return On Investment (ROI) by hiring them, than any other IT worker in this country, or by outsourcing the work to some overseas IT Shop then the chance of that IT work be hired is minimum at best. Even if IT workers could form the strongest possible union in history, there is no way US write a law that would prevent any company, US based or foreign based, from going overseas and hiring someone else.

by mot_esach

Don't blame the boss! I had a guy just like this and fired him for misuse of sick leave and lying to me.

The union could not find a contract problem but they supported a lawsuit. The judge told me I had to hire hime back. Not because I didn't have grounds for dismissal - he agreed I had that justification - but because his ethnic origins didn't provide him with an adequate work ethic - and I had to make allowance for that or I was discriminating.

It is not always managements fault.

by riverrat1

Come on now, you really think a MCSE is earning your way? All you have to do is buy a cram exam, memorize it, lay down $100 the next day and take a test. I know people who only knew how to turn on a computer and surf the internet who asked me how to get in the industry. I told em get a MCSE and guess what, in one month they had an IT job.

by rgoode

The only thing that Union involvement insures is that big companies will find any way possible to outsource the jobs to avoid their involvement. Workers can watch out for themselves through class action when a labor issue arises, but I do not want the involvement of a loose cannon with an agenda when it comes to my representation. I have been a part of class action representation which has successfully watched after my coworkers, and it didn't cost me a monthly payment. Furthermore I never had to worry about my money going to political candidates I did not approve of.

A free market means that an employee or prospect has the right to represent himself. If he or she does not like the salary or terms they can go look elsewhere. Unions typically have fostered resentment and confusion with an occasional success story, but they are a bad idea in the modern IT world.

by spitfed

but lack of trade barriers to the US were. Once preferential access to US markets were offered to Japan and other 'Tiger economies' (in exchange for military bases with which to fight the cold war which the Pentagon insist on still fighting) imports flooded in, leading to a hollowing out of US manufacturing. No amount of unionisation would save US jobs.

Read 'Blowback' by Chalmers Johnson for a fuller account rather than my crude summary.

I'd like to know what sectors these new jobs (" a combination of low, medium, and high end work") are in. Call-center work perhaps?

Just like to add that unionisation would probably have a negative effect on my sector, Games software development, where start-up struggle to pay salaries, have insane deadlines to meet and are expected to meet most of the risks.

My 2 euros worth.

by tink!

Perhaps a union would work for the larger companies with large IT departments. But for those of us who work with smaller companies, I think it would hurt us more than help.

Yes unions often get employees great benefits and huge flexibility (especially for families with kdis). But small companies are often family run and therefore have that understanding anyway.
To make it required by union law would simply antagonize the company and make them feel like they are being yanked by the throat. Whereas if you allow them the freedom of offering the benefits and flexibility on their own, they are more agreeable to deal with and more willing to be flexible with the employee(s).

This I say because I've worked for mostly smaller family run companies, and they've been wonderfully flexible for me and my kids.

by ralford100

NO WAY TO UNIONS. Things are bad now, with outsourcing to India, China, Mexico, etc; Unions would make the situation much, much, worse!

by budziaszek

What do you think IBM went Global for, here on a contract to Air Canada they layed off over 300 developers and sent the work to India. So do you feel safe anymore while flying on this carrier?
Rather than hiring resources here in Quebec I was sending work also to Bulgaria. So you tell me what makes you so special (rhetorical)? Anyone can be replaced!

by startech

Of course, I've had meals that look great and tasted like SH*T. Which would you rather have?

by whistl3r

And... new technology is born into the market on a daily basis, it's not only the fastest growing market in the world it's the most crucial market in the industry.

So, Who's responsibility is it to keep up with the times? Who devotes their time for such businesses to continue floating?

by whistl3r

Never too late. People who believe this are either too lazy or just have no care in the world.

It is illegal to fully outsource your IT / IS department's offshore, which is why corporations split departments in half (half american workforce and the other offshore).

by whistl3r

AND that's the problem... Management throwinig a wet towel around "thinking" they know how to properly staff the IT department then wonder why they have sooo much downtime. With these incompetent cert boy's floating around you are bound to have problems.

IT / IS involves an individual with a formal (college) education, not someone who took a two week crash course. We don't see two week crash course surgeon's do we, now?!

by raintree

You need to think this through. Unions have done some very good things but your last statement is scary. Wanting the power to run the world has caused more damage than anything else I can think of.

Some of us have been around for awhile (early 60s for me), don't have a cert because we don't need on (you might call decades of experience a cert). Please don't tell us we are now to be excluded from the IT industry because we don't have an MCSE or a Masters Degree.

If you don't like the place your working you are always free to seek other employment.

by raintree

Sure, unionize. Like the auto industry. How many jobs are left there? And, let me see, we all know that jobs there are increasing every month, right?

by e_196

>But for those of us that understand what real I.T. means, we're not the least bit worried about outsourcing because we perform REAL work that our clients can't possibly outsource no matter how much they may want to.

You should be worried if you don't know the difference between outsourcing and offshoring.

by tech

You seriously think the way collective bargaining and unions are run in the US is how it is done in the rest of the world? That yours is the ONLY system out there? That YOU have the best place to live on the planet?

I dont know whether to laugh or cry at the complete lack of understanding of the world beyond your borders that shows through in so many people's posts here.

Your automobile industry isnt in trouble because the workers were paid too much. Its in trouble because your cars frankly arent worth buying. I suppose theres a view that if everyone were given a bowl of gruel a day in exchange for working themselves to death then the US auto industry would be flourishing?

I maintain that each person in a society has a mutual obligation to the others in the society. Thats why we have shared infrastructure. Thats why we don't kill and eat the guy who lives next door. The principles are the same in both cases.

But then - how many of you vote? If you don't vote, frankly you have no right to complain about what your Govt is doing. You have no right to complain how they are spending your taxes. Because obviously you dont care enough to participate in the process in the first place.

Democracy (NOT a US invention, which may come as a shock to some of you it seems) is a wonderful thing - a country gets the sort of government it deserves for the amount of interest it shows in selecting that government.

Unions are no different. They are a social institution created by people for the benefit of people. They can be good or bad depending on the people who are in them and how those people take them. I'm proud to have been in a related union in whatever job I've been in for all my life.

My employer does well from my work. And I do well from the salary they pay me. They don't own me though. If they choose to ship my job OS, then so be it. If I choose to leave, then so be it too. It seems to me the ones who are making the most noise about jobs going overseas are those who are opposed to unions anyhow.

It must be terrible for them to live in a constant state of fear of their futures - whether it be if they will have a job, or how will they survive post retirement.

by startech

When you look in the mirror, are you brown? Does your shit stink?

It's people like you that give the US a bad name. Are you really so envious of the way this country has come to be that the only thing you can do is bash? For crying out loud, there's still room for you here -- come on over -- and stop bitchin'.

Our cars do stink -- not all -- but most. If you want one that doesn't, you have to pay for it throught the nose. You're right! They're not worth buying. That's because they cost too *^&^%$* much due to an a-hole on the assembly line asking for 45.00/hr for doing nothing.

You're right again. Each person in a society should have obligation to the others. That's why we (the US) help ourselves and _others_ throughout the world when in need. That's why we sacrifice our lives so you can live freely. That's why we give more per capita than all the countries in the world combined.

I completely agree with you that if you don't vote, you don't have a right to complain about what happens to you or what the Gov't is doing. BTW, I bet 99% of the people on this post are voters. Don't go making vague generalizations.

Maybe in your country you need a union. Are the labor conditions really all that bad there that you need a union?

My employer too does well from my work and I'm very well compensated for it. I ask for no more even if I do think I'm worth more. And if they do ship my job elsewhere, I have more than enough experience and fortitude to be able to land on my feet anywhere. I don't need a union to protect me.

What you don't seem to realize is that the US is made up of innovators and realists. What scares us most is people like you that want to stifle innovation and put everyone on the same playing field. I do live in a constant state of fear -- that unions will continue to evolve and erode the very fabric that's kept this country together.

Honestly, there's still room over here. Stop whining and buy a plane ticket!

by bms

Unions are for laborors and professional associations are for professionals. What are you people. If you are professionals then start an association like other profesionals ie. doctors and lawyers but not teachers. Professionals set their own wages but collectively agree on minimum standards. They are self policing like AMA. If you want to organize then someone take the lead and begin the American Information Technology Association (AITA). not to be confused with Alabama association or the truckers association.

by delaaguilerae

I am the Recording Secretary for AFSCME Local 199 and I work for Miami-Dade County ETSD Enterprise Technology Services Department. (Senior Telecomm. Tech.) Several IT classifications are listed in our Bargaining Unit they are as follows: Computer Technician 1,Programmer Assistant, Programmer1,Programmer2, System Analyst Programmer1, Sys. Analyst Programmer2, Sys. Analyst Technician and Telecomm. Techs working for the Hardware and Depot Divisions doing computer repair and wired or wireless networks.

By Florida Statues Public Employees have the right to unionize. The good thing about having a Union contract with classifications, a pay scale and the concept of "Seniority" is that it helps the worker and like you say anything thing beyond 40 hrs on many classifications that are not Job Basis is Overtime ( time and a half pay) and if you get called back to work after hours you earn a minimun of 4 hrs overtime.
We have On Call pay for Programmers they get 2 extra pay steps for being on call and beeper. (The County is trying to take that away from us in contract negotiations.)
Also the Federal Fair Labor Standards Act specifies that in many job functions or classifications anything above 40 hrs a week is OVERTIME.

by jardinier

Thank you for validating the general theme of my post.

The "more lowly" the trade, the more power they wield.

by apotheon

1. The members have the power, not the unions. As such, they don't need the unions.

2. Members give their power to others by supporting unions, thus removing that power from themselves. Because they just lay down and take it, there's nobody to actually stand up for the rights of the members, rather than the privileges of the union bosses, and because they pay exhorbitant dues merely for the "right" to work, unions have great gobs of money for lobbying in favor of consolidating power in unions, thus perpetuating the problem.

by jaqui

1) every 6 months there is a new os, not every 2 years [ Linux has new versions on a 6 month schedule ]

2) Unions are the worst thing to do.
they promote employee incompetence.
they promote laziness
they take money from you
they interfere with getting the job done

If I had my employees unionise, then I would simply close the business down, citing "employee incompetence, they went and unionised" as the reason.

I worked in a union shop, as union member. won't make that mistake again.

by gbennett

Joining a Union is saying I'm too stupid and I I'm going to give someone my hard earned money to think and do for me because I'm too lame.

by apotheon

When your employees unionize, you can take one of four approaches:

1. Knuckle under. Take it in your tender places. Let them rob you.

2. Fire everyone, close down the business, and go get a real job.

3. Fire everyone and hire people that aren't in the union.

4. Sell the business.

Exactly one of those doesn't result in (almost) everyone in the union effort getting canned. Even that one is going to result in reduced employment, as the employer is going to have to cut costs, which means not hiring more people later at the very least.

If I was running a business and all the employees decided to unionize, I would suddenly stop giving a damn about their welfare. If they want to make an enemy of me, they can damned well look to someone else for support than me. Screw 'em.

by jaqui

fire everyone, close down the business, and start a new one.
is an option.

by malazaba

As a member of the teamsters Union (Local 111) I understand that Union organization has many benefits. Collective bargaining is the best way to attain a group's goals. However, saying "lets form a union!" and doing it are two entirely separate things. The best advice I can give you is try to work with an existing union to help organize your workspace. Local 111 is a Telecommunications Union and is always looking to help those that are downtrodden.

by startech

In other words: Bring us your lame; those who can't speak for themselves; who don't have any negotiating ability with their employer; who are lazy and weak; who want something for nothing; who want to make $50.00/hr. without earning it.

P-L-E-A-S-E!

by mitchschultz

The union employees where I work are not better trained. I have more certifications and training than they do, and 95% of that I obtained prior to this job - on my own and out of my own pocket. It seems training is not a necessity in our IT department. Their productivity leaves a lot to be desired. I don't need to understand economics to know that I am the only employee in my department who has worked several 20 hour days and comes in and works on holidays in order to get my work done and they wouldn't think twice about working overtime - they will, however, sit at their desks after-hours to claim the time and a half.

by toby.peterson

Most other indusrties have a union and for good reason, overtime, breaks and conditions are spelled out for employers and employees. Then both groups would know where we stand.

by dj

I got out of the immediate IT industry as the only IT work I could get was at a Clerical award wage - pethetic! I also agree there should be certain set levels of pay across the industry, this will assist both employers and IT employees of what they need to expect when dealing with each other.
Wageline was pethetic cause they got no idea, and employers in the past have taken advantage of that.
Enterprise barganing is one thing - but is only of use if your barganing skills are better than your employers... or if your have been working for the same organisation for more than a year. Most IT ppl that I know tend to move around between organisations to pickup diverse skills.

by technicallyright

Well said Tony and although I agree with what you are saying I also agree with Apotheon.

The IT world is definitely changing and I can't say for the better.

I don't think many people are saying unionize for more money but perhaps to keep the jobs and the money they are currently getting. I don't think I have ever seen before an industry where the salaries are declining.

Having said that I don't think unionizing is the way to go, the auto industry is an excellent example.

by tech

You seriously think the way collective bargaining and unions are run in the US is how it is done in the rest of the world? That yours is the ONLY system out there? That YOU have the best place to live on the planet?

I dont know whether to laugh or cry at the complete lack of understanding of the world beyond your borders that shows through in so many people's posts here.

Your automobile industry isnt in trouble because the workers were paid too much. Its in trouble because your cars frankly arent worth buying. I suppose theres a view that if everyone were given a bowl of gruel a day in exchange for working themselves to death then the US auto industry would be flourishing?

I maintain that each person in a society has a mutual obligation to the others in the society. Thats why we have shared infrastructure. Thats why we don't kill and eat the guy who lives next door. The principles are the same in both cases.

But then - how many of you vote? If you don't vote, frankly you have no right to complain about what your Govt is doing. You have no right to complain how they are spending your taxes. Because obviously you dont care enough to participate in the process in the first place.

Democracy (NOT a US invention, which may come as a shock to some of you it seems) is a wonderful thing - a country gets the sort of government it deserves for the amount of interest it shows in selecting that government.

Unions are no different. They are a social institution created by people for the benefit of people. They can be good or bad depending on the people who are in them and how those people take them. I'm proud to have been in a related union in whatever job I've been in for all my life.

My employer does well from my work. And I do well from the salary they pay me. They don't own me though. If they choose to ship my job OS, then so be it. If I choose to leave, then so be it too. It seems to me the ones who are making the most noise about jobs going overseas are those who are opposed to unions anyhow.

It must be terrible for them to live in a constant state of fear of their futures - whether it be if they will have a job, or how will they survive post retirement.

by roberts184

with only 5 to 10 percent of folks working in private sector unionized, I would have to disagree with your strength of organized labor argument compared to the strength of organized business. If you want to begin to unionize IT, you begin as every labor movement ever has, at the bottom, organizing the union. This, above all, has been the weakness of the American labor movement for the last fifty years.

by davea05111

No way in the world my IT company will be part of a Union. People hire us because we do things efficiently for reasonable prices, using technology the rest of you are afraid of. The IT world is changing, and if you think you can hole up in a Union, think again.

Adapt or die. Unionizing is the opposite of adapting. It will never work in the IT field.

Prove me wrong... so we can grow our business.

by peter.kelly

Depends on what you mean by fair. A free market has no concept of fair, only in supply and demand. If your skills are in high demand then you get high pay. Is that fair?

Is it fair that production jobs have dried up or that 55 year old metal worker is no longer employable, because his trained for a job no longer exists?

I don't know, but I think the questions are worth thinking about.

by dumbquestions

1000 x yes. Any and all groups/communities must unite around common needs and interests to keep from become enslaved by the master corporations

by apotheon

. . . but not in the same industry. Industries that have been unionized are pretty much closed to entrepreneurship.

by nyitdude

The concepts of a Union are good. Protect the worker from harm, decent hours and pay, etc. But here? They suck. I was in a union many years ago, they never helped anyone with what they said they would. But they sure loved robbing our paychecks every week. In Europe, what is the unemployment rate? 20%??? Well here it is under 5%.

Now I WILL say that even in the IT field many are underpaid. Most of the jobs available are the likes of Wallmart, Home Depot, etc. But where else can you get a part time job with health insurance and still only pay around 2.50 per gallon of gas? In Europe you pay HOW MUCH???

I love this country, I would not want to live ANYWHERE else. This is and always will be the greatest nation ever. Dont like that comment? Too bad. This still one of the only places where if someone works hard, stays honest, and really cares, good things will happen.

I think people who put us down just because, are jealous. Yes we have problems, yes we are not perfect, but there is nowhere else I would rather live.

Our problems? Stop illegal immigration, stop overtaxing the working class, and most of all stop liberalism... Just my 2 cents, no intention fo offending anyone.

NYITdude

by dusterman

Just exactly where could you possibly be living in the USA , and not realize that the guvernment ... once again .... has lied to you ?
I'll only do this one point as the list is really too long ........
POINT : The reported unemployment [ to the media , so that they will "verify" the guvments stats ] is a blatant lie and has been for a very long time [ there are those here that can probably tell you exactly when they started using the "favorable" system ] .
A brief about the system ..... simple ..... when someone is no longer on the unemployment rolls ..... poof ! ! ...... they mysteriously are no longer unemployed ....... what a wonderful and magical system !
When I questioned a person [ from the guvment ] at length and got as loud as him ] the result was for me to be asked to leave ...... for asking him for the truth .........
FYI ....... later I was asked by someone [ still trying to convince me that I was wrong and to "preach" the wrong good news ] ...... "how could you undermine the guvernment ..... they have been there for you and the other needy citizens for the hard times ? Why would you then tell a slanted tale such as yours ......... Hmmmm.
Can you say subversion .........
Please take your over paid [just guessing here ], over sized ass [ just guessing here ] to the rural counties in your own state [ NY ] and start asking how many people are really out of work and how many are working "day labor" just to put food on the table ...... this doesn't hold true for the wonderful NYC counties as much as the very , very rural ones ..........
OH yea ...... I grew up in one of those "poor" counties ..... hello , hello ..... is the miracle worker Hillary in the house ???
Let me invite her to some folks houses where the meat of the day , week , month is venison ..... nothing wrong with that ..... I grew up to be a tall 6'2" SWM 225lbs with a 56L jacket and a size 40 waist even at 55 yo ....... and still think that all you liberal wonderchildren need to be stranded in the "country" for a few weeks .......
I personally guarantee that you will come back to your "wonder world" with a new slant on reality ....... the real one ....that there are millions of unreported poor .... some living in your area ..... people that will work [ not panhandle ] and work hard and only ask for a reasonable wage ...... Hmmmmmmmm .....what's that mr. employer ...... oh you have an illegal that works under the table for $4/hr and if I want the job what will I work for ??????
Hmmmmmmmm
.
Unions { most } have had their time , it has come and went for the most part .
They too ..... lie to their members [ voters ] they cheat their members [ voters ] and finally they too act in morally irresponsible ways [ citizens ].
EX....... IBEW ...... worthless in the early 70's ..... God only knows if "he" let any of their worthless souls into heaven since !
.
Sorry all ..... this guy just makes me realize what the guvernment has really baffeled most of our fellow country men into believing ........

by jamesrl

If I weren't mature I might feel insulted.

I inherited the unionized group, and when I arrived they were somewhat demoralized. There was a performance review program in place, and though on the outside it looked the same for both union and non-unionized employees, the union's collective agreement put some mighty bog handcuffs on what we could say and how we were to rate their employees.

Nevertheless, I did clean house, it was just far more difficult. I convinced the union president's wife, one of the worst slackers, that she should take early retirement.

We did make major productivity improvments over the course of a year. But the point was and is, that it waqs much harder to do so in a unionized environment and that was as hard on the staff as it was on management.

James

by ralford100

Are you kidding? THEY LOVE IT! Some H1's are going home so they can make more money (relatively speaking).

No.. Access to alternate work via exter-national outsourcing is always going to be cheaper and easier. The solution is to provide quality work in shorter time, something that the American industry has been lacking mostly due to greed, greed, and more greed. And... Unions propogate greed even more.

by ontheropes

I spent 6 months in New Delhi and the surrounding cities working with Engineering staff and management for Whirlpool of India. I can tell you that the vast majority of Indians don't have a clue of the things we take for granted. Simple things like electricity, clean, drinkable running water, gas heat, air conditioning, clean working conditions... I could go on.
I paid more for my hotel room for a one night stay than the senior engineers made in a month. Sure they love IT. It's a job that might keep them warm by burning cow dung and sheltered in a dirt floor packing crate for a family of 6.

If they're really successful they might be able to buy a scooter.
Unionize? No. Change the way our government allows the trade deficits to continue? Good luck! We're living in a service oriented country. The manufacturing base has long ago gone byebye. $50.00 an hour? Sure. Earn it. The Indians work for $50.00 a month! That's before THEIR union dues are taken out.

by mollenhourb9

Good idea. You can do for the IT industry what the UAW has done to the US auto industry. How do you feel about moving to China?

by mollenhourb9

Your rant shows why IT types aren't taken seriously in the rest of the business world. If all you know is technology and not business processes or who the company functions (not how the LAN, WAN, etc. passes information around the company), then you are "just a tech" in the eyes of the organization. The sad truth is that a trained monkey can learn technical skills, and India (and soon China) have the best trained monkeys in the business. It is no different than what happened to the auto industry, the accounting industry, etc.

As any job becomes mature, the gut level work becomes less skilled and more "factory" oriented. Declining wages are inevitable. Unionizing will only serve to further isolate you from the rest of the business world and give the big-wigs more reason to outsource your job. Find a different career. I had to.

by fred123456

I work in a union shop, I was forced to pay union dues, I have employees working with me who know nothing about IT and the systems they support. And why are they still here??? Because its literally impossible to get fired because of the union.
I was actually witness to direct insubordination when the IT Div Mgr asked an employee to move a PC and the employee said no. What happen? Nothing, because according to the union contract IT people are not supposed to "move" PCs.

If you want knowledgable professionals in IT, do not even think union. In IT it only causes headaches.

by jaybofma

Unions were so very important towards worker rights and protections in the early 20th Century. But since then, global competition has rendered US manufacturing to a position where manufacturing jobs are lost every day. Unions are too focused on the here and now. Not one union is truly making headway towards protecting workers futures!

I've worked in a union shop. While fighting over bid-lists, seniority and the next contract, the union totally missed the big picture and several manufacturing sites are now laid waste in the shadow of Bunker Hill. Even then those union members constantly chatted around the lunch tables about the problems faced by their auto-worker ?brothers?, all the while the scene through those lunch-rooms windows was of scrap steel being loaded onto ships on the opposing shore of the river, bound for reclamation outside of the US for use in the manufacture of the real threat to those auto-worker brothers around the Pacific rim.

My wife is a teacher. She isn't necessarily inclined to be a union member, but if she were not, she would still have to pay a stiff fee to the union for some supposed benefit to her through their hard work at contract negition. So she has opted to pay the substantial fee; at least she does get a few discount cards at some local merchants out of it. Sure she gets some good benefits: no real need for stress in the annual review (although that?s not my wife); a seven hour day (although that too is not my wife); a pretty good pension; etc. But her insurance offering is only mediocre compared to what I experience in an open and private industry.

When have you last sought hardware support and not found yourself talking to an outsourced provider in some unknown offshore location? (I?m sure a Union would have prevented that!) When is the last time you called your land-line telephone service provider and actually had "customer service"? (But they are unionized, aren?t they?) When is the last time you were satisfied with the service provided by your cell-phone provider? Lets see? up my wage (not salary for a Union) to $50/hr for the two years that it takes the company to negotiate a long-term contract to outsource the service! Then it?s 26-weeks at whatever the Unemployment Rate is while you look for a new career, because you won?t find one in IT!

When was the last time you were an owner of an American-made car? I've never owned one, Eagle Scout, public-school reared, flag waving Patriot, husband of a Union teacher that I may be.

Use your "knowledge"-based career traits to take a step back and find a better perspective.

by bfilmfan

Thanks for pointing out that I misread the city and increased the size of Iowas to include North and South Dakota, Montana and Wyoming as part of the state.

That being said, my advice still stands. The salaries in Idaho aren't great since companies like HP have down-sized a great deal to overseas locations.

by ejbag

The answer is simple. Organize with the only Union that will take on Employers who outsource or move jobs to foriegn countries. The Teamsters Union is 1.4 million workers from Doctors to Zoo Keepers.
Ed

by dkirkham

Laws preventing 12 hr shifts?
Man what planet are you from?
There are lots of industries/companies that use a rotating 12 1/2 hour shift, and if you don't want to work 12 1/2 hours a day then your working for minimum wage.

by mareshg

If you have real talent in IT someone will pay you what you want. If you are like most of the new certs you have not developed any real skills yet and yes they go for cheap. Look at India and other countries where $5.00 is a great living wage because the cost of living is so cheap. I can pay 3 programmers to work on a project and cross check each other for the price of one in the US. I believe in 2 heads are better than one. It's kind of like getting a second opinion from a doctor with out paying more, and if the first 2 don't agree a third isn't that much more expensive.

Companies pay for talent and skills that are difficult to obtain on the cheap. So it is up to YOU to get a very unique skill set that companies will pay for. A union will restrict that education because they always serve the lowest common denominator the unskilled worker. That is where their largest support base comes from, and their largest income.

Unions also price their labor force out of the world market. Look at Ford and General Motors, and the airlines. They have great paying jobs and benefits but the companies are broke, the jobs are gone! Would like to get paid more than you are worth and not have a job or get paid what you are worth and have a job. Make yourself more valuable educate yourself leave that job and negotiate yourself better pay in the next position. Union or no union no one cares about YOU except YOU.

by cactus pete

Perhaps it would have been better stated:

Laws preventing 12 hr shifts without being appropriately compensated and with adequate breaks.