Discussion Locked

Wardriving - Legal or not?

0 helpful
557 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has the law caught up with Technology yet?

In a recent discussion telling dumb user stories, I had a handful of members jump me because I had used someones WiFi connection for a few days for email and a quick TR fix.

Some claimed anyone doing this is a thief, while others tried to make it a moral issue of ethics.

I did a search, and found nothing specifically stating this is illegal although I did find two cases in process right now. One in the UK and one in the US.

http://news.com.com/FAQ+Wi-Fi+mooching+and+the+law/2100-7351_3-5778822.html?tag=nl.caro
http://www.infoworld.com/article/05/08/08/HNwifi_1.html

Wording stating unauthorized access to a computer or a network was as close as I could come to an actual law.

I think most people that do this (myself included) would not if it was clear that there actually is a law against it. How close do you think we are to that?

If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical? Based on what? The person that left their open access point is missing what at the end of the day? They have been harmed in no way and nothing has been taken from them.

And I am not talking about some clown that is hacking, or sucking up massive amounts of bandwidth so please don't waste anyones time with that angle.

I guess I would also not include a home user that doesn't have their own connection and goes off a neighbor full time.

557 replies

by gadgetgirl

The infoworld link needs membership....

If you can tell me which Act is referred to in the UK case, I can check it out for you.

GG

by michael_orton9

You shouldn't really bother about legalaties.
The realpoint is if you can wardrive successfully, so can others with malicious intent.
Its just like leaving your keys in the new Jaguar, in a public carpark.
If there is a way into a system, someone will use it, legal or not.
There are no (effective) policemen on the Information Superhighway!

by jdclyde

joe-user with their home network and open access point.

They probably had heard from someone that they needed a router to secure their home network and got this, not realizing they locked the door but then installed a dog access that a rat could come in.

If these home users AND MANY business users don't take care of their systems, what can be done about it?

It only leaves the question, if you will use some of their bandwidth too. Hopefully with all the trojans and spyware on their systems, there will be some bandwidth left over to use!

by jaqui

it is recognised at a Criminal Offense under section 243 of the Criminal Code of Canada, as un-authorised access of a computer system or network, unless the w.a.p. had a public name, as in it clearly indicated it was a public access point.
( high priced Hotels, most Starbucks have public access points here. )

by too old for it

... that if you just hook up the wireless router, and (a) don't secure it and (b) don't change the name to something other than "linksys" "netgear" or "SMC", what you have is a public access point.

by bp7226

Is it the sender? The receiver? The ISP? The User? If a radio wave is in my space do I not have a right to use it? If that answer is no, then shut down the Radio Stations and the TV Stations and take away all Ham and CB Radios and Cell Phones. While I have never used wireless from anywhere except my own office, I have yet to actually see a reason why it should not be both legal and ethical. If I can receive the radio signal, I am entitled to use it!

by stargazerr

:D I dont go off a neighbor full time anyway ... That was the first and last time

I am not really familiar with the UK laws (having lived here only 6 months) .. but I would most certainly like to know (GG ??)

In India,however, I know that there is no law as of 6 months ago ... Dont know, if they have drafted one since ...

The reason for this being that wireless connections and access points are not as popular ..

I dont suppose that the person with the open access point is really missing anything at the end of the day ... but ethically, using something without the knowledge of the owner cannot exactly be termed, borrowing ...

]:)

by jdclyde

if you use something that takes NOTHING away from someone else, can it really be concidered stealing?

Like I said, this is only assuming the casual user, not the downloading fools that need their MP3 or porn fix.

If there isn't a law saying otherwise and the owner of the access point is out nothing, I personally see no ethical discussion provided it is an open access point.

by sleepin'dawg

Imagine if you will, you're in bed and your car is in the driveway with the keys tucked in the visor and it's 4 AM; you're sound asleep. Your neighbour's car won't start but he knows your habits and he knows you won't be awake till 6. He jumps in your car, drives to the convenience store and on the way back he puts 10 bucks of gas in your car. The amount of gas he puts in is far in excess of what he has consumed on his little trip. You are actually gaining something by this. He arrives back in your driveway just as you wake up and he tells you what he has done. How do you feel about what he has done??? You have lost [b]NOTHING[/b] so can it be considered stealing???

The law clearly states that unauthorized use of an automobile without the owner's consent is car theft but he has returned it with more gas in it than it had previously and you have actually gained a bit by his act. [b]You[/b] were not using the car, he didn't want to wake you for something so trivial and you were not even aware of your car being missing while you were asleep. So,how do do you feel about this??? You have lost nothing!!! Yet the law states he stole your car regardless of the circumstances and the fact he returned it with more gas in it than previously. So, what are your feelings about this??? Has he really stolen something from you??? You paid for the car and all the upkeep on it; it's your car and nobody else's. So, was your car stolen or not??? What do you call unauthorised borrowing??? Imagine if he was someone you didn't or barely knew. How do you feel??? How will you feel when you find someone using something you paid for without asking your permission. If you hadn't woken when you did you would probably never have known. Apparently you have lost nothing but how do you feel??? Do you feel violated, a sense of loss, perhaps??? Have something been stolen from you and if so what exactly??? I'm just asking but if it were me, I might have shot the guy and regardless of his explanation, might have called the cops. Note: I said might, because [b]I[/b] don't know what I'd do in that situation but I do know I will feel [b]something[/b], no matter how intangible, has been stolen from me.
BTW if you were going to shoot him, make sure you do it while he is sitting behind the wheel in the car.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by stargazerr

When we say ethically speaking ... it really means something which cannot be put under positive or negative, however, considering our social habits, we know what we are doing is "Not Right"

It may not exactly be labeled stealing ... We culd call it .. "Freeloading" :)

]:)

by dr dij

I don't think wireless is as fast as broadband, and dialup is pretty cruddy slow. Any use of the bandwidth is taking away from someone elses speed (presuming they're even using it at the time).

I'd love to say 'if you don't secure your wireless then you have no protection from the law' but then criminals in companies would live wireless points open on purpose like thieves leave doors or windows unlocked at companies to come back later and steal.

by noyoki

Did they leave it open on purpose? I know of some people that leave their WiFi open with the intent of sharing. How do you know that this person didn't have the same idea and was actually glad to help? I'm fairly certain, that if you knocked on their door and said, "Hey, I can connect to your wireless router from next door, would you mind if I checked my messages for the next couple of days? I'm not from around here.", that they would say "Oh sure, go right ahead."

by sleepin'dawg

Several months ago I read an article on Wi-Fi security that had a side-bar on wardriving. Being somewhat insatiable in curiosity and having a brand new laptop c/w 802.11a/g capability I decided to test out the claims of the article. I wasn't so much surprised at how easy it was but shocked at the number and types of open access points I found within a few blocks of my home. Absolutely incredible. Included in the list were several banks, car dealers, fast food outlets, home renovation companies, big-box stores, restaurants and bars, and scads of private users, all of whom I assumed were too stupid, too dumb, too careless or too computer illiterate to have set or reset password protection on their equipment. Of course I do not include the users who are deliberately setup as "public access" points such as McDonalds, Burger King, Starbucks, Best Western Hotels, Ramada, Holiday Inn, etc., etc. I was shocked somewhat to find the accounting department of a large retailer wide open not only to Wi-Fi access but to their whole system. Back in 1977-1981 when Apples and IBM-XT computers were just becoming generally available, and security concerns were not what they are today, those of us who were a bit more technically inclined were going on line with 300-1200 baud modems and it was great fun to hook up with BBSs and then taking that extra step to see how easy it would be to gain access to other things. Does anyone still remember accoustic connection devices???? Does anyone still use them??? :^O This particular retailer was notorious for being so readily "easy to crack". Its my guess they still are after 28 years. But that is getting away from the point. Back in those days a lot of access points required use of long distance connections and if one did not wish to incur huge long distance charges on their phone bills, one learned to hack the phone companies. There was a hot market in "blue" or "black" boxes just as there is a hot market today for black market cable and satellite descramblers. Software piracy was rampant; still is for that matter.

True blue IBM machines came with BASICA on a set of 4 proms and the bios on another prom. Clones didn't come with BASICA and their bios would be supplied by some company like Phoenix Technologies. Clones were only 98-99% compatable with the IBM but those of us who worked in high tech companies were not hindered by this. IBM, for some reason did not solder its proms or CPUs to the mother board so, if one had access to a chip burner, it was an easy matter to purchase some e-proms, hoik the bios and BASICA chips from an employers real IBM machine and burn yourself a set of chips. IBM soon brought out the AT, the originals running at 6Hz and later that went up to 8Hz. These machines were being sold for approximately $3000-$3500 at the time and left us clone drivers with our 8086/8088s in the dust, so to speak. We got around that by pulling our 808X chips and replacing them with NEC V20s or NEC V30s running at 10-12Hz. It was a similar mentality to the souping up of an ordinary car to outperform something more expensive and jazzier. In 1981 my personal machine, a clone with a 20 megabyte hard drive and 100% compatability, could boot faster than an AT and proudly proclaim itself to be a "true blue" IBM machine.

People would group together, everyone chipping in, to buy expensive programs of which every contributor would get a copy. Some companies like Autodesk would try to protect themselves by including hardware locks with their software but we could circumvent that by cracking the hardware codes with software. The hardware locks were only a temporary, minor, inconvenience. Very few people saw anything wrong with this at the time. The view was this was knowledge and knowledge was/is meant to be shared. BTW During those times a lot of companies saw their photocopy costs reach stratospheric heights what with all the photocopying of manuals and IBs. LOL :^O We see something like this today with the P2P music sharing crowd. It's not ethical maybe but it's only illegal if you get caught. A lot of this is still going on but you seldom hear of it because the practitioners are good enough to have never been caught; either that or been damn lucky.

The same mentality is still operative today, only now it's around Wi-Fi. Back in my army days I remember a soldier being caught pilferring another soldiers locker which had been inadvertently improperly locked. What still registers with me to this day is, that while the thief got a BCD, the soldier whose locker had been rifled was fined on the grounds that he was culpable in having created the conditions by which his locker could be broken into. Maybe users who leave themselves open and do not take precautions should also be considered culpable. I think the same should apply to anyone who has not taken the proper precautions in protecting themselves or their equipment. There will always be curious people out there who are going to push the envelope whether to test their capabilities or out of a streak of larceny. It's sort of like the old joke where a man asks a woman if she would sleep with him for $10,000. She agrees but then he asks her if she would sleep with him for $10. She is astounded and asks him, "What kind of woman do you think I am???" He replies, "We've already established that. Now we are haggling over the price." ;)

While we are on the subject of Wi-Fi anyone who has something like a Palm Pilot and uses its Blue Tooth connection to access the web through their cell or to connect a keyboard, should take a walk through an air terminal or any other establishment with lots of terminals within line of sight. You might find your results informative and interesting to say the least. Now think of working in an office where your co-workers may be using Blue Tooth. A bit of paranoia in those circumstances might not be totally out of place under those conditions.

Is wardriving legal or illegal. the answer for now appears to be maybe yes, maybe no but think about this. If the authorities set out to catch someone and make an example of them; they will catch someone. If you are one of the unfortunate ones to get caught; you will be spending large sums in legal fees and time in defending yourself and there will be no defense against the notoriety you will have gained even though you might be found innocent. You have to ask yourself, "Is it worth the risk???"

For whatever it's worth; I still get a kick out of taking one or two remotes with me when I'm out walking my dog. When I walk by a house where I can see a TV through the window, I hit the remotes. A lot of times nothing happens but a lot of times you get to see someone jumping to their feet, pointing thier remotes at the TV, pushing buttons and then going over and hammering away on the top of their TV. Too funny for words!!! :^O I guess I'm still a big kid at heart. Remember there are a lot of kids out there. You might want to think about who programs the VCR or TiVo in your house.

Sorry about the diatribe; put it down to Sunday morning boredom while waiting for Sunday kick off time. Hey jd, think the Lions have a chance this weekend playing at Green Bay??? LOL ROTFLMAO

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by mjd420nova

In the beginning---- Yup, Acoustic couplers, 300 baud it was called and BBS was wide open to anyone with right phone number. Many large
companies only had dumb terminals (Televideo-
Hazeltine ETC) that could hook up to mainframes
and no one thought about if some hacker got into
their systems. Then the REAL computers hit the
market, IBM PC and APPLE IIE and modem speeds
got faster along with faster processors, and the
rest is history as they say. Wireless is very
prolific, almost every home has one and none
are protected. Hospitals, schools, doughnut
shops, and motels can be easily accessed and
hassle free. But beware, I will cut you off
if I catch you on my wireless router, if you persist, look out, I'll lock you up and leave
you hanging. Try bending or laying flat the
antennas, this limits range and quality unless
you are really close(ten feet).

by too old for it

Hindsight being 20-20

However, having grown up in Green Bay, I can tell you that foorball at Lambeau in December is always a interesting exercise.

by gadgetgirl

I've done a bit of digging by the back door, and where the US may prosecute offenders under the Anti Hacking Laws which are now in place, it would appear that the UK is still basing any WiFi trials on the Communications Act of 2003.

(and they STILL haven't put plans in place for an Act which will cover hacking in its' own right!)

Our first legal case appears to have been in July 2005, and was against a persistent offender. Basic overview is here...

http://www.pcw.co.uk/vnunet/news/2140329/wi-leach-gets-suspended

Basically, he got let off....a conditional discharge means that he doesn't serve time/community sentence if he doesn't commit any further crime within the 12 month period. Still, his WiFi access hasn't come cheap, they did fine him ?500 (~$880)

I've been told there is to be an amendement to the Comms Act in the near future, so I'll keep an eye on it.

Incidentally, jd, it was a guy from Michigan who was done under the Anti Hacking Laws (it WAS you, wasn't it!!!)

No, couldn't have been, that guy got nine years in the clink!!

GG

by tonythetiger

find my wireless network in the middle of BFE, you are welcome to access it. It's only good for half a block or so though :)

by m_a_r_k

The owner of the network has the option to secure it. You're not trespassing like going into someone's unlocked house. I'd say it's only stealing if you hack into a secured network.

by stargazerr

He has the option to secure it, but the person is either very gullible or does not know the rules ...

In such a case, taking advantage of someone's lack of knowledge isnt good either .. If the person chooses to keep the network open even after knowing that he has the option to secure it .... well, in that case, he asked for it :D

]:)

by m_a_r_k

that most people are very tech unsasvvy and don't know how to secure their wireless network and don't even know anything about the security risks. Somewhere here on TR there was a recent article discussion about how so many home users have security holes in their computers. I wonder where that went to. I'd like to read it. Maybe a wardriver stole it.

by joe_t

What if someone got on your LAN via an improperly configured firewall? Would that be a problem for you?

And hey, what about spam? You left port 25 open, after all.

And viruses? You allow people to receive email and surf the web, right?

If you hold that accessing a WiFi network that is not secured is legal, you are standing on the top of a slippery slope, indeed...

by m_a_r_k

that would stealing or hacking.

What about spam? It's entirely legal. Just like telephone solicitors if you're not a do-not-call list or door-to-door salesman.

I think the discussion focused on HOME networks, not corporate. So your question about allowing people to receive email or surf the web is irrelevant.

I'll take my chances on your siippery slope. I stated my opinion on the legality of it. You have your opinion. That's fine. Show me a law against it and I will say it is illegal. No law = not illegal.

by methos7997

So would you mind if I walk around your backyard when your not around. I won't steal anything, just play in your pool, swingset or whatever.
Try to portscan any gov't site for a while and see what happens?

by dmambo

It's probably not stealing, but it is trespassing. If you find trespassing unethical, then so is wardriving. I would not want strangers in my yard even if they have no malicious intentions, but I do not put up a fence. On the other hand, I do have a fence around my wireless network.

by beads

So your saying that if I were to secure a door with a cheap lock a locksmith of low calibre should feel free to pick the lock to gain entry? Even if the lock is sitting in an open field with access to nothing? Its still ethically questionable even when the law is nebulous.

- beads

by stargazerr

That it is not correct to use something that belongs to someone else, without their knowledge ..

It isnt about how much knowledge a person has. It is about ethics. Even if a person is less knowledgeable, I expect him to have enough common sense not to hack a less secure network.

]:)

by jeasterlingtech9

picking the lock = BAD
if your house is glass you realy can't scream "peeping tom" now can you? if you don't want to put on a show don't ... if you don't want to share wifi connection, don't

to anyone borrowing a wifi connection use courtisy no muddy footprints no stealing no embarising emails , downloads, or IM

by jman.org

For casual use, I'd have to say it's legal.

The feed is being broadcast into public space, so if you can tap into it, it's yours to use.

That being said, I would say that the home user who taps into a neighbor full-time is not breaking the law, but is certainly being a leech. Morally they should offer to pay a portion of the usage fee the broadcaster is incurring.

The flip side of that arguement is that the person broadcasting could (and is encouraged to, if they so feel) "lock down" their transmission to keep it private.

Should a "zero tolerance" law get passed, it would be just another example of our Congress having too much free time on their hands. We are evolving into a wireless society (perhaps when HDTV broadcast finally kicks in full time, the old UHF & VHF frequencies can be dedicated to local net transmissions), and it would cost more than it was worth to track & fine everyone who ever got a little free bandwidth now and again.

Just my .02

by dwdsr

While I agree that folks that have open WAP's should be aware that they have the option to close it via WEP, I choose to leave mine open so that someone that might have a need to get their e-mail (or send one to a prospective employer) can do so. I've been on the down-side of not being able to afford an internet connection, so I can appreciate the relief you feel when a neighbor (or someone completely anonymous) leaves a WAP open so that you can connect with the world. It's not been my experience that there are THAT many malicious people out there. Sure, there are some, but if I can help someone out that really needs it, I'll take the chance that some a**hole will take advantage of me...

by tlea

This is wrong, plain and simple. The quantity does not make it any more or less so, just more or less irritating to the person and the ISP being ripped off.

The right thing to do, if possible, would be to find the person and ask for their permission. You may find that they left the access point open intentionally, then you're good to go (though the subscriber may be violating his/her terms of use). You may also find they didn't know that their AP was public, and they are VERY thankful that you pointed it out. They might also tell you to shove off and mind your own business. Either way, you shouldn't use it without their permission. (I understand that finding the person who has the open AP may not be easy, but if you don't want to put forth the effort maybe you shouldn't be using it.)

You would think that people concerned about security, which I hope most IT people are, would do what they can to help those who may not be as savvy, instead of taking advantage of their ignorance. That's what malicious hacking is all about, taking advantage of people?s good nature and ignorance.

As far as the "no one gets hurt" philosophy goes, this is BS. The person may be using all of their bandwidth to watch a movie, use a video phone, play a game like UT2004 (one of my favorite), or to download some 300MB service pack. They are paying to have access to that bandwidth, and someone downloading email, which could contain large attachments, or accessing web sites, or even downloading a small patch can cause the game or video to perform poorly for a period of time. Whether that seems important to you is immaterial, because I bet you it is important to the owner of the AP.

Also, imagine if ten other people think it's OK to ride this poor sap's network because he was just too "stupid" to secure it properly. This will most likely cause a noticeable degradation in his connections performance.

One other thing that keeps getting mentioned is acceptable use. What are the guidelines for acceptable use? From what I can tell it is whatever the bandwidth barnacle deems acceptable for his or her purposes. What if you need to download a 30MB patch that will solve a VPN issue you are experiencing? Is this OK because it's not porn or an MP3?

Using other people's stuff without their permission (permission could include labeling an AP as public) is at the very least just plain rude if not downright wrong.

by jgarcia102066

The other important thing that people tend to forget about is integrity. Just because you have the capability of doing something, doesn't mean that you should do it.

This is just like the people that climb the telephone pole, find the cable system box unlocked and proceed to hook-up cable to their house. This of course is old technology but it also did not hurt anybody. Now laws exist to protect the cable providers against this kind of piracy. Hopefully, there will be laws soon to protect against this wireless piracy as well.

by jdclyde

first of all, anyone that would be downloading a 300MB patch would know enough about computers to not have left that access point open on accident.

Next, the usage. If your just looking to be arguemenative knock your self out. If your looking for a rational discussion, and hopefully having someone step forward that actually KNOWS about the issue then hop on board.

The examples I gave were to show bandwidth usage, and anyone looking to discuss the issue should have seen that.

The next thing it, anyone that has a laptop good enough to play UT2004 and is still dumb enough to go wireless instead of hard wired seems odd. With the extra network overhead of wireless, you are only getting about 1/3rd the bandwidth you get with a cable. This also adds to processing time, adding latency on both the send and recieve. This equates to one, lag, and two, frags (of you).

by tlea

I love it when people make assumptions like, "If you patch your system, you MUST know how to configure your router." Windows update will download and install large patches, whether or not the user is savvy enough to configure their wireless router properly. This is a bad assumption on your part. My mom just bought a computer, and Windows update was enabled by default, though her router is wide open by default. So, by default, she can update her computer by downloading large patches without having a secure wireless connection.

As far as usage, is concerned you mentioned email, which can involve large attachments. Maybe you don't get large attachments in your email. That I do not know. But since were on the subject of bandwidth, what is the specific acceptable limit for usage? How many Mbits / second should we be allowed to consume and over what period of time? What if 5 or 10 other people have decided to use the same open connection because its OK?

Why are you assuming the UT2004 machine is connected via wireless? My gaming desktop is attached to my wireless router / 5 port switch via a cable, but the WAN bandwitdh is still shared between all wired and wireless connections. As far as being dumb is concerned, you may want to think things through before telling people they are dumb based upon false assumptions.

I believe that my contribution to this "rational" discussion were justified based on the original article. I stand by my original statements and add that just because something isn't iilegal doesn't make it ethical.

In the end it sounds like you had a need to do something, you took the easiest, least expensive route, and are trying to justify your behavior in a public forum, and I don't agree with you. It really is that simple.

by andrew.moore

How about this angle- I find that someone outside of my organisation is using an open access WiFi connection without permission. Is it okay for me to intercept their TCP/IP packets and graft out usernames, passwords etc???

by jdclyde

no one up to this point was discussing anything but low bandwidth internet access on a non-regular basis.

To start sniffing traffic is completely a different story.

But if it is your network, I would bet you could legally sniff your own network provided it is not INTENDED for free use. Something like a hotel that gives it out to customers would get in a world of problems if they tried the same thing.

by generalist

We could always reverse the equation. If YOUR wireless signal is intruding upon MY space, could that be considered to be electronic trespassing?

While this happens all the time with TV and radio signals, you run into problems when the communications is two way. Receiving a wireless signal is unavoidable. Sending data to the wireless device is a bit more controllable.

I sometimes wonder how much trouble a person could get into if a neighbor sets up a wireless network without a password and you accidentally access it because you are in the habit of clicking on the first, and once upon a time only, wireless node in your area.

by unclerob

Someone uses your car without your consent and puts $10 to cover the gas and you feel that you're ahead. How about wear & tear on the vehicle itself, sure it was a short joy ride but the engine did run so you did exact a small/minute amount of wear on the engine depending on your driving habits. Plus maybe you adjusted the seat the and the tilt steering and changed the radio station - obviously I'm being a bit ridiculous with this scenario but I figure wear & tear on the vehicle's engine even for the short jaunt you took it on would cost more that $10 (especially considering a taxi would have cost you far more than $10 for the same ride I'm sure). Where's the wear & tear on the wireless access point? If anything let's consider the wear & tear on your body being bombarded by those uncontrolled radio waves coming from the access point - ok now I'm really being stupid here but let's just say that you can't compare the two, one is an actual physical, tangible resource where as the other is not. I'm not sure the cops or any lawyers are going to be making any money fighting a case where someone is piggybacking on his neighbor's wireless signals. Theft, probably not, freeloading, yeah I'd call it that.

Since we're talking about neighbors here, why not do the neighborly thing, tell him that the signal is of decent strength that you can use it from your place and that he should either enable wep or implement some other security feature or offer to help him do this or tell him you will use his wireless signal whenever you see that it's available.

Ethics are always different depending on what side of the fence your standing on. I'm not promoting either side, heck I might take advantage of the wireless access if it was available to me and then again maybe I wouldn't.

But then again, maybe you should also ask your neighbor before you go into his house and open his fridge and help yourself to a beer and a sandwich, just because you would want his permission before taking something of his for free..... Just a thought.

...my 0.02 cents cdn

by jdclyde

that the thought was kind of short. He is paying in Canadian! Talk about theft! :D

Ethics are a funny thing, as they are not consistant as we have been finding in the Christmas, religious, and political discussions of late. Some blame culture, some religious upbringing, and others that it is all an accident.

Too subjective to try to play the "ethics" card, in my 0.02 cent [b]US dollar.

by jdclyde

Your car situation isn't QUITE the same thing as their is much more involved with physically removing something. There is the wear and tear, there is the chance of an accident, they came and took something.

In the case of WiFi, it is your neighbor that is assulting you with their signals. If they choose to continue to assult me in such a fashion, I will be forced to put up something to absorb the signals so they don't interfere with the control signals from the aliens.

In the case of WiFi, they are sending it to you, your not going out and getting it (unless you use the setup I mentioned in the "What is your best and great user" discussion.

http://tinyurl.com/8uvjl

If you leave your bedroom window open while servicing your wife and I choose to not look away from the safety of my telescope inside my own home, who is to blame?

by unclerob

Wow, these TR discussions have come a long way!
Not bad. What kind of service are we talking about since we're on the topic:
1. oil change
2. lube job
3. working on those uv joints
4. front end/rear end inspection
5. changing the tranny fluid
6. timing adjustment
7. testing the shocks
8. tuneup job

Sorry I couldn't resist.
If I had a telescope I might also help myself to those wife servicing signals too! Until my wife smacks me upside the head and closes the window & blinds and lets me know that I'm not supposed to be interested in that kind of stuff anymore since I'm married. OY VAY!!!

by jdclyde

As for the specific service, I guess it would depend on the day and HER mood, now wouldn't it? ;\

A good'ol fashion rotation is always called for though! B-)

by cortech

How was JD's instance and different than for example:

I walk out of my office, across the Wal-mart parking lot to McDonalds. I then walk back across the Wal-mart parking lot with my lunch to my office.

Therfore, I used up some of Wal-marts parking space (WiFi bandwidth) to go to another site (website) and brought back my lunch (minor download).

Technically, I tresspassed by using their property for something other than visiting their business but realistically the space I used up in their parking lot had no effect on the number of cars they can park. Should I go ask the manager next time if I may walk across their parking lot, or should I tell them to put a fence up if they don't want me to.

No harm, no foul. Just a thought. Comments?

by jdclyde

don't try to be logical here. ;\

It is interesting the people that want to compare this to physically invading someone elses space and doing something compared to you sitting in your own home and them broadcasting it to you. You aren't going to get it, it is coming to you.

So most of the counter-arguments just do not wash.

by sleepin'dawg

you imply actively going out, seeking open sites. It is one thing if you encounter a site passively, it is a whole different ball of wax when you jump in your car with your laptop and [b]actively[/b] drive around seeking access points. You are not being a victim here, you are being very much an agressor. So far there are few if any laws specifically against it but there are some ambiguous laws that could be brought into play here. An example might be the theft of satellite service. Anyway if you did get caught can you afford the time and money necessary to vindicate yourself. You might win or you might lose. Everything about the courts can become a crap shoot. Assuming you won; you'd be out huge amounts in legal fees and then there is court time. You could cop a plea but how about the accompanying notoriety??? Best thing is if you are going to do it don't make a habit of hitting any one site too frequently; keep moving around. ;) You notice I don't go on record as to actively doing it or not doing it; although there was that time I tested the findings of an article.
I would advise if you are doing it; keep quiet about it. BTW for what it was worth the article was in a Ziff/Davis publication, which one I can't remember but I've always wondered how many new wardrivers it inspired. After all, anyone who can walk and chew gum at the same time and knows where the on switch is, can learn how to do it.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by m_a_r_k

yet ?:|

But didn't we have this discussion before where I pointed out to the jokesters like you that a sheep is a lamb, and a lamb is a girl? :D

by jdclyde

could be called "drafting" as well, but it isn't.

Freeloading. Gee, it is almost what is expected of people today, isn't it?

If the government can do something as immoral as "redistribution of wealth", why can't I do "redistribution of bandwidth"? I am being discriminated against because I am bandwidth challenged at the time!

by stargazerr

I cannot argue with ... but that wont stop me from trying :D

I re-phrase .. free loading is something that is offered for free ... Personal open access points apparantely aren't

]:)

by m_a_r_k

Cows [i]are[/i] female, you know... And, mind you, it takes quite a he-man to wrestle down a 9000-lb animal with horns as pointy as needles that'll gore your innards if you get within 5 feet of the things.

by m_a_r_k

If I find an Internet access point and it doesn't require me to log in, or I don't get a message telling me it's for private use, I'm going to assume that the owner doesn't give a rip if I use it.

It's just like with cable/satellite TV. If you flip on your TV and you suddenly find that you're getting Pay-Per-View or HBO or any other premium service, are you gonna be a good little boy and complain to your cable provider that you're getting free service? Or are you NOT gonna watch any of the heretofore pay-access channels?

by sleepin'dawg

but it is another thing entirely if you actively hook up an unauthorized signal decoder or descrambler. If you get caught; it's going to cost you, big time.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

can you throw in one sentence?

No law = LEGAL.

Next you will start saying that is no not none of noneones business what is not done with the not illegal access? B-)

by antuck

Personally, I have set up quite a few wireless networks in offices and homes. I always set some kind of wireless security in place for this reason alone. Not to allow other access to the network.

When setting up these networks, I have seen other wireless networks around. I always thought about clicking and just seeing if I could connect but never have. Why? because to me it's not right to. It is not my wireless network. So I have no business siging into there network unless it was approved. To me it is irregardless if the signal was not secured. I think it is like someones front door that is not locked. Is because the door is not locked ok for me to enter the house or car? I personally don't think so.

Also, do the ISP regulate how many computers may have access to the internet? I know Comcast here in IL allows for five computers. I think SBC does the same but can't say for sure. How many computers were connected when you were? I realize it would be hard for the ISP to determine how many computers are on. But the fact does remain there is a limit to five (again here with Comcast.)

I don't know the legalities of this. You mentioned you couldn't find anything. That's not surprising given this is all new technology. They're still trying to write laws for spy-ware. Ethically - that is a big debate I suppose. I mentioned my thoughts. I also feel as a person in IT I should know better.

by beilstwh

making the statement that "If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical" is not true. Lets take only one example (there are many). You are married and you are having sex with her sister and she doesn't know. Legal, sure... Ethical, no way.

by raven2

In most areas of the US and in many other countries it is technically illegal to have sex out side of marrige. Adultery statues are still in many legal codes.

Legality is the function of interpertation of the law, or as Ambroise Bierce says, "Lawyers are those skilled in the circumvention of the law."

Ethics is a different branch of thought.

What Rosa Parks did was technically illegal but unquestionably ethical. What George Wallace did was technically legal but definitely unethical.

by aryeh

Hi I think this is a great issue of concern.I think that most IT people would be respectful of home users networks but on the other hand I agree that it
is big security concern because most people do not understand they are putting themselves and there privacy in the open and you are not paying for the service.

by maxwell edison

.
If you (or anybody) can't show that it's illegal, then it's not. And if it's not illegal, then by default and by definition, it's perfectly legal.

Consider this. EVERYTHING is legal until some law is passed to prevent (or reduce) it. Show me the law and the court case test, or concede that it's legal.

Is it ethical? Is it nice? Is it taking advantage? Well, those questions will be answered in as many different ways as there are people. Personally, I don't think it's very nice for one citizen to vote himself the property of another citizen. So it's all perspective, I suppose. However, how many people will be (or are) on their soapbox about not taking something (Internet connection) that doesn't belong to them, but they espouse and take advantage of tax and give-away social programs?

by wordworker

I am shocked no one from the "I'll download any darn song/movie/software I can get, legal or not" crowd has weighed in on this subject. Maybe it's okay to steal bits and bytes if you're using your own connection, but not if you're piggybacking on someone else's bandwidth.

by jmgarvin

The idea is this:

Is it legal to split the coax from your neighbor's cable box? Is it legal to tap into their phone line to get phone service?

Would it be legal to split the coax from the neighbor's house and use their broadband?

No. This is no different. While your neighbor's at technologically stupid, you are stealing bandwidth and service from the broadband provider.

It is unethical and (from the looks of it) illegal.

by nedg

your neighbour dint leave a phone or cable point for you out in the street, and you would be taking it upon your self to cut into or brake into the service to use it there for it is stealing.

also there are many public hotspots that people use evryday.

and you a wrong in asuming your neighbour is an idiot leaving his AP open what makes you think he didnt leave it open on purpose.

by jmgarvin

I honestly don't understand your first sentence. As for people using "free" hot spots, this is up to the business and it usually advertised.

Most TOSs are pretty clear on the point that sharing bandwidth is service theft. As for the neighbor leaving the AP open to let his neighbor's use the bandwidth, not only is he stupid (security risks ad nausium), but he is probably also in violation of the TOS.

by jdclyde

When you don't want people in your house, you lock the doors. You don't want them in your car, you lock the doors. You don't want them in your yard, you put up a fence and maybe a "no trasspassing" sign.

Why should your wireless network be any different?

by el guapo

Is it my fault that my technologically inept neighbor did not employ security on his wireless signal to keep other people from using his bandwidth?

Is it my fault that my wireless lan-enabled laptop keeps picking up his signal everytime I boot up my pc? If people are going to employ this type of technology in their home, they should also be responsible of maintaining, researching, and securing it. If they don't want other people from using their bandwidth, configure it that way!

Take your house, for example. You built your house for you to live in it and feel secure in it while you live there. Therefore you will install an alarm system and deadbolts so no one else can enter your home but you. You don't leave your doors open at night so that you can share your house with other people.

As for the tapping to get free cable, this is a different story. You physically alter the cable to get free cable (I haven't done this so I don't know the process). The cable company installed the cable fixture so no one can tap it; the wire tapper comes along and hacks the scured cable fixture and there, free cable.

by stargazerr

Switch off wireless on you laptop in that case ... Dont connect to it..

If a neighbor is technologically inept...It doesnt give you the right to connect to his wireless network.

For example: If you left a window open in your house, or have a lock which is easy to jimmy (not physically change it, but unlock it with a hair pin) .... will you appreciate someone jumping in and having a look around, even if they dont steal??

]:)

by unclerob

Nobody left a window open, we don't have a lock that's easy to "jimmy", no one is physically entering anyone's house to look around and not steal stuff.

We're in our own home, wireless signals are coming into our house. That is actually the very first act of trespassing in the original scenario since we haven't left our home, something is coming into it and you can't tell me that I can't make use of a wireless signal that's coming into my home, if you're saying that I can't make use of these signals then you make every required effort to stop their broadcast into my home plain & simple and please don't give me anymore examples of breaking into cars & "jimmy'ing" house locks with a hair pin or some other such nonsense - those are actual physical acts requiring physical effort and actual physical actions to effect these changes.

In the first place, we didn't ask for the wireless signals to come into our house and unfortunately if those signals come into our house we're going to use them.
Secondly, radio, tv stations, satellite service providers, etc. need licenses to transmit signals that our radios, tv's, phones, systems, etc. can make use of. If this person made no attempt to enable WEP and/or any other form of security so that those wireless signals could not be used by others than I'm not going to feel bad about riding those signals in my own home.

Thirdly, giving me examples of stealing cars, breaking into a home, stealing cable by tying into the neighbors cable, stealing phone service by tapping into the phone line, stealing electricity by running an extension cord, walking through someone else's home without stealing anything, swimming in someone's pool, pee'ing on someone's fence, etc, etc, etc. still does not equal making use of a wireless signal coming into your home. All of the other items are physical, tangible objects and all require you to make a physical effort to trespass/steal these items while making use of an intangible resource such as a wireless signal that's being broadcast into your own home without your consent is not comparable. That is why your example is flawed.

Years from now we'll unfortunately find out that these wireless signals along with everything else on our planet causes some form of cancer (please heaven forbid this, I have to much to worry about now as it is) in which case right now I won't worry or feel too bad about using this "technologically inept" neighbor's wireless internet access or question any morality or ethics issues that arise from making use of a signal that technically is trespassing into my home.

- Don't hate the player, hate the game.

just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree ;-)

by unclerob

Technically we're not trespassing - No one is in this person's yard, we're in our own home. If anything, how about that person trespassing against us, we didn't ask for a signal to be broadcast into our own homes from this person's wap. In fact if a law is needed it should be to acquire some sort of license before operating this type of wireless equipment so that all the necessary safe guards are in place which includes enabling wep and any other security safeguard.

If you want to get technical, I can listen to the radio to my heart's content, why - because I'm receiving a signal that's being broadcast strong enough that my radio can receive it. The radio station is licensed to broadcast that signal out to the public where others can receive it. This person probably doesn't have a license to broadcast his wireless internet signal so technically he should be required to secure his signal so no one else can receive it.

If he doesn't secure his wireless access point and the signal is strong enough that I can make use of it than I'm not doing anything wrong and I'm certainly not trespassing if I'm inside my own home.

I don't think you're analogy works, try again with a better example.

...just my 0.02 cents cdn. ;-)

by waity85

I agree, if I'm sitting in MY house using MY computer why can't I use unsecured signals that enter MY property. Notice I said unsecured, protected signals are a different matter, if using them isn't illegal, it should be.

Not sure bought the licensing side of it though, sounds like your giving gov's another opportunity for a stealth tax.

by dkeefe

What this discussion needs is a definition

War Driving ? The act of activity looking for unguarded WiFi hot spots to use without the owners consent or knowledge, and without any compensation to the ISP who provided the connection to the internet.

Some will have said that it is a user beware world out there. We are supposed to be IT PROFESSIONALS. That means we should set a standard for the rest of society, where it concerns IT. Some will say that it is neither illegal nor un-ethical to use those connections. Just because it is not expressly illegal does not make ethical. I say it is very un-ethical to use those connections. We as IT Professionals have advanced knowledge of these types of systems. We should not be using it to gain access to the internet at the cost of others. To sit outside in you car and use the unguarded hot spot should make you feel cheep epically when there are several ways to gain ligament, and free access to the internet. What are you doing out in you car? Certainly not research on a paper, or responding to a call from work. No you doing things you would be ashamed of otherwise you would be doing them at home or at a ligament connection.

by dkeefe

What this discussion needs is a definition

War Driving ? The act of activity looking for unguarded WiFi hot spots to use without the owners consent or knowledge, and without any compensation to the ISP who provided the connection to the internet.

Some will have said that it is a user beware world out there. We are supposed to be IT PROFESSIONALS. That means we should set a standard for the rest of society, where it concerns IT. Some will say that it is neither illegal nor un-ethical to use those connections. Just because it is not expressly illegal does not make ethical. I say it is very un-ethical to use those connections. We as IT Professionals have advanced knowledge of these types of systems. We should not be using it to gain access to the internet at the cost of others. To sit outside in you car and use the unguarded hot spot should make you feel cheep epically when there are several ways to gain ligament, and free access to the internet. What are you doing out in you car? Certainly not research on a paper, or responding to a call from work. No you doing things you would be ashamed of otherwise you would be doing them at home or at a ligament connection.

by dc guy

It's like being thirsty and lost on a hot summer day and helping yourself to a drink of water out of some homeowner's garden hose.

If the person were home and you asked them, would they allow you? Almost certainly yes, and most people would invite you in for a glass of ice water and a rest and to help you find your way home.

The difference here is that you might not be able to find the person whose network you're using. I assume that if you could, you WOULD have asked. You seem like a decent person.

You were in a jam, you needed help, you assumed that the person would not mind if you had the ability to ask.

If it were me I would hope that was your thinking.

Just don't make a habit of it. And meanwhile I'll be improving my firewall. (Actually I have a really good firewall: No wireless access in my house.)

by unclerob

I saw this link posted on one TR's pages:

http://jefatech.com/product/WARDRIVINGKIT

Apparently it's a war driving kit which allows you to search for & make use of open access points to the full legal limit

Does this mean that war driving is currently legal in the U.S. ?
Reading this ad leads me to assume so, let me know if I'm wrong.

by jdclyde

doesn't mean you can use it.

I can go buy a switch-blade, but I can't carry that same blade.

It is even legal in some states to own a gun silencer/supressor, but not always to USE that supressor.

Did you know in the US, if you get the permit, it is even legal to MAKE a HOME MADE MACHINE GUN? If you make it yourself, then the feds can't use the Interstate Commerce clause to ban this.

It really is amazing what you can buy. Just don't get caught using it!

by sleepin'dawg

There are no set precedents as yet regarding wardriving. However there are laws on the books, with precedents, regarding theft of service in respect to satellite and cable service. Maybe, or maybe not, these laws could be applicable to wardriving. But right now, in the current situation, do you want to be the test case for this??? Think of what it would cost you in time and money, never mind agravation, if you were to become the test case in this matter. Losing is not an option and winning could bring you levels of notoriety you may not care to deal with.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

because I doubt if MS has EVER sent a 300 Meg patch through Auto Update, as the specific size WAS mentioned in the previous post that I had responded to. I feel very comfortable with this particular ASSUMPTION.

Also, as the one who both started this discussion AND "borrowed" someones open access point for two days, I can clearly state that when I say "just email" I am not sending and recieving attachments. My usage? You playing your little game would not have even known I was there.

And you may believe that, but that isn't what determines what is ethical to other people.

Easiest, least expensive route? What other route would have been available on a two day basis? You must have never had to pay for your own cable modem or you would know that they take almost a week to install from the time you order it, and they do not install service for two days. Clue time.

Justify? Nothing in this discussion was asking for justification or your approval. It was asking what people have heard about the legal aspects of this, not for someone to tell what they "believe" to be true, but about FACTS of LAW.

So in the end, the only thing that was simple, was you.

by cactus pete

Did you check the local institutions? Many libraries have open access. Many hotel lobbies have open access. Starbucks, Panera Bread, Barnes & Noble, McDonalds all have various levels of for-purchase access, from two hours to a day, to a month.

Have you ever seen those sorts of sites before? (Please don't read any inflection into the question, it's an honest inquiry.)

by stargazerr

You can tell when McDonalds or starbucks and the sort provide open access ... Either the connection name or the fact that there is a starbucks nearby, gives it away ...

]:)

by tlea

You will note that in your original post you mentioned ethics in regard to legality. In fact you said if something isn't illegal, then how can it be unethical. If you didn't want to discuss the ethical implication you should have never brought it up. (Just for the record, just because something isn?t illegal, does not mean it's ethical.) Ethics and law go hand in hand by the way.

As far as usage is concerned, lets say it?s a 30Meg patch (the size was meant as an extreme case to demonstrate my position, but you seem to miss the point), or even a 3Meg patch. What is the acceptable size? Once again, this seems to be up to the person "borrowing" (without permission) the connection. You still haven't given me what you think are acceptable limits?

Now about PUBLIC access points. There are access points out there that you can use, without having the cable company come out and install a connection (and you thought my 300MB patch was a stretch). Some are free, some require payment. McDonalds, Starbucks, Panera, the local library, just to name a few. There was no need to borrow this person?s connection. As I said, you chose the easiest, least expensive solution. You may want to educate yourself as to the availability public wireless access before going on the road again.

You did make one assumption that was correct. I have never paid for a cable modem, this is true. But I DO pay for my own DSL line and equipment, as I am not a big fan of our cable company.

As far as legality is concerned, check out this article, it raises some interesting questions.

http://reviews-zdnet.com.com/4520-7297_16-5509700.html

Whether you meant to or not, you came across as trying to justify your position in your original article.

by deborah.kellock

Speaking of ethics (or is that morals?), you would shoot someone for stealing your car? shoot and perhaps kill them? for stealing your car. Only in the USA...

by nedg

If you go onto somones propert that has a fence but no lock it is not trespassing, but if you maliciously damage or take somthing without permision that is against the law.

if the perimiter has a form of lock or security on it and you enter the property that is trespassing.

Laws are based on ethics but are not normaly ethical.

A good ethical rule of thumb is do unto uters as you would want them to do to you.

so in my opinion if the person left hi AP unsecured open to the public, you are welcome to come in and use it and have a look around without causing any damage or taking somthing that is not yours to take within reason ofcourse.

by joetechsupport

I understand the definition of legal but I have trouble with ethical although I've queried it a few times.

My opinion is based on my sense of right and wrong, which as I may well misunderstand, is actually a more a question of my personal morality than ethics per se if I have this correct.

As I understand it very bad things may be done on fully ethical grounds and according to the infinite types of morality wee all hold. Same for law. Slavery remains legal in some jurisdictions and was in all empires and many democracies. Theft and killing are fully legal in a military context. Military theft and killing may be ethical as well but as I've said I'm unsure because people talk of just wars and unjust or ambiguous wars.

My cynical side likes to think "ethics" were created to justify otherwise abhorrent or disagreeable acts - I know cases where this is true, I know cases where it is false. At their best ethics as I understand are intended to guide rational, "correct," "best" or "lesser of two evil" decisions free from unequal, unjust, unfair and/or innapropriate varying moral and/or religious standards. Slavery and torture are the best examples for me because these are clearly "wrong" yet are frequently through history considered a moral and religious obligation.

To me, it comes down to this, wardriving or anything:

1) Have I been given express permission to do said act?

2) Would I appreciate the act being done to me or those I care for? Might others I don't know feel differently about such an act?

3)Do I have to tell myself I'm not doing anything wrong or that it doesn't hurt? This is always dead givaway. I call this the "hand in the cookie jar."

4)If it is wrong, a bad, illegal is there to myself a proper justifying extenuating circumstance, not just an excuse?

5)After considering all these, I make the choice. I don't always make the "right" choice.

That's about it. The process can happen in a flash. I like to think this is what most of us do.

by waity85

I personally feel that if the access point has no form of encryption, security or authorisation, then using it from your own private property or public property shouldn't be illegal.

Why do we keep asking the public sector to legislate to protect stupid users? Just turn on WEP or similar. I know these standards are easy to bypass; but if your bypassing them it IS illegal (or should be).

Anyway, there's my two-pence worth....

by jkaras

This has been debated in the past here on another thread. Basically put it is not illegal, but it is unethical. If you are not paying for a service and you get it free knowing full well it's no accident, then you are stealing. You are just justifying your actions by saying it's their fault for not protecting themselves properly. If you are receiving a signal from a free web cafe then it's ok because it is understood that it's free like library. Yeah yeah yeah you should be a customer but that is a free provided service for all not someone paying for a service that you are piggy backing on.

by eteller

... if nothing else, this is "Theft of service or Denial of service." Surely, a gray issue, nobody is hurt or out anything, it's still wrong.

by stargazerr

The neighbors' hen (or duck) wanders into your yard and you kill it and eat it ... the neighbor has a right to (at least) shout at you ...

Note: In this case, you didnt physically do anything except kill the hen ... same as when you physically dont do anything but click on the browser and start exploring ...

I hope thats a bit more helpful

]:)

by unclerob

because we're talking about another physical, tangible resource - something you can physically touch, taste, feel, smell, etc.

Wireless signals are not physically tangible resources: you could walk by them, through them, around them and not know of their existence. You need special equipment to even know that they exist in your immediate location and what the signal strength & quality is, and if it's secured or not.

Clicking, browsing, exploring would all be done on my home computer for which I have full, unfettered access to in the first place without infringing on anyone's rights.

Here's the deal so we don't have to go through examples because to tell the truth I've been trying to think of examples myself and can't come up with any that are comparable because you can't ideally compare physical items with intangible radio signals. I'm not a bum, if my neighbor was broadcasting unsecured wireless signals strong enough that I could surf on his connection, I would let him know and offer to help him enable wep, install a decent firewall, download the latest & greatest windows updates, update his av & spyware software and let him know that if he's going to use this kind of technology he needs to be careful because if I can access his WLAN chances are that others can too. I don't think you can talk about legalities or ethics because there are decent arguments on both sides of this one. All I can do is be a decent neighbor because it's the neighborly thing to do, not because of ethics or legalities because we don't have concrete laws that define what's right/wrong in this situation. But not everyone is a good neighbor and everyone needs to realize that being one isn't the law either so I can't be mad if someone is going to make use of my wireless network if I'm throwing my signals out there for the world to access.

The latest crop of 802.11g wireless routers/ap's doesn't make this problem any easier to deal with since they provide greater range, faster access, etc. Someone could unknowingly provide internet access to several neighbors and not know it either. I recently installed one for a friend and we took his laptop outside of the house just to test the range of the ap connected to a dsl connection that was installed his basement, we were getting decent wireless access from both of his neighbor's yards on each side of his house, the sidewalk infront of his house, the street infront of his house, the detached garage in his backyard (which he liked alot), his backlane, etc. If you have a clue you will secure your wireless access point, but for most people, once they get past the 2 minute setup wizard that comes with these access points, that's all they want and they put the boxes & cd's away and never fuss with it again afterwards.

again, this is just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree/disagree

;-)

by jeasterlingtech9

if i leave my keys in the car unlocked and let my neighbour know about it about the only thing i would do is eather thank him for the gas or tell him not to do it again and lock the car
most users don't know about locking down wifi or don't know the consquences of not locking their wifi
i've checked my email on an open wifi (jump in download the mail or grab a webpage and get out) but i would not poke around in a network without permission
in the USA there is a presumed permission in any thing that is not obviously harmful and not against the law (breaking a lock to get something BAD, selling something overpriced {gougeing on gas ect} not nearly so bad)

by mickey6

BACKGROUND:
About 25 years plus ago when the first satelite TV came out the hackers decryipted the signal before they started their sales.

When the trials made the Supreme Court of the USA, they ruled that a signal sent in free air (cable is a private carrier)was fair game as long as it was not re-broadcast or reproduced and basicly no law was broken.
----
That said 802.11 AKA wifi is in the public sector of the FCC and open territory.

While hacking someone elses computer is a felony, tapping an open internet signal is not. Just remember, if you try connecting to another computer on said network without permission, you may be looking at up to 20 years under the commercial espionage laws.

Some think you are stealing from the ISP, not so, the bandwidth is already being paid for by the access point owner.

RESPONABILIY:
The owner of the network has the reasponsibility to secure their network or leave it open for public use as called for.

If you use the connection so be it, but don't under any reason try to hack it or you will be violating the law. Wardriving is not hacking onder the law. It is simply finding the open points.
----
As to the question of ethics and morality, remember that morality is a standard by which we measure right and wrong, ethics need not be good to be ethics. The Mafia has ethics.

Remember, coffee shops and businesses are often offering FREE wifi internet.

If you want to wardrive try sticking to the ones you know allow access. Then no one will complain.
----

On my companies network we have 2 access points. One is highly secured behind the firewall for access to company info and the other in front of the firewall is open to free internet use. I even named it FREE_WEB.

It only added about 5% extra traffic and costs the same anyway. So who cares.

Have fun ...

by antuck

You mentioned about stealing cars, breaking into houses ect... as taking a physical effort to do. Then you stated that an intangible resource like the wireless signal being broadcast into your home is not comparable. But that is actually flawed. Sure the wireless signal is coming into your home or where ever. But, you must physically look for this signal and physically make the connection to this wireless signal. Granted this is only mouse clicks and generally, the wireless connection SW you are using will automaticlly sign you in the next time you are within range. You still must do something physical to make the connection the first time.

by sleepin'dawg

and we weren't implying anything like that. We said cows. See we never implied there was anything queer about good ol' M_a_r_k. :^O

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)