Wardriving - Legal or not?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by mickster269
"In what prosecutors say is likely the first criminal conviction for wardriving in the US, a Michigan man plead guilty Wednesday to a federal misdemeanor for using the Internet through an open Wi-Fi access point at a Lowe's home improvement store in suburban Detroit."
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/06/michigan_wardrivers_guilty/
(if this has already been posted, mea culpa)
by unclerob
But if you're inside your own home and your computer's wireless nic grabs hold of an unsecured wireless signal strong enough to announce itself to your nic, how is that comparable to stealing a car or breaking into a house?
How do I physically look for the signal if I'm within my own home, I don't know about your specific windows setup but my pc will alert me to any wireless network signals that are strong enough to announce their presence to my pc (and any IR signals that are close enough to my pc's IR port). Plus I'm using my computer anyways, I didn't leave home to make use of this signal, I didn't go into my neighbor's yard or house to make use of this signal.
If using my computer inside my own home to make an automatic network connection using an unsecured wireless signal that was broadcast into my house without my consent is comparable to stealing a car then I'm at a loss to see the how they are the same or similar - because they're not!
Plus using your analogy, you might also say that radio signals picked up by my radio automatically could be comparable as well.
There is a big difference, you can't compare an intangible resource (like wireless signals) to a physical resource like a car or house. If you can't recognize the difference between these items then you don't understand the concept & scope of this conversation.
Also please don't send any cars crashing into my house for me to use, I don't know of what use they'll be good (spare parts maybe?) for considering the damages an all. Intangible vs. Tangible. Simple as that.
;-)
by antuck
You have to physically tell Windows to make the connection. When it alerts you a wireless connection is near, it does not automaticaly make that connection. Unless you have configured it to do so.
Bottom line to me is, it is not my network I don't belong on it. I have no right jumping in to there network just because they don't know how to secure it. Much like the car or house it is not mine I don't belong thier. I don't need someone telling me I don't belong thier.
I do understand the concept and scope of this conversation. Another reason I don't sign onto anybodys wireless connection, if they do not know how or why they should secure there wireless connection, what is to make me think they have a secure and patched computer. When I see the unsecured wireless networks, I always wonder what kind of virus or garbage ware do they have on there system. And, is it one of the network searching worms that as soon as I connect zaps me. No Thanks!
by stargazerr
No Argument :D
I only argue with people who are gits and dont realize or maybe dont want to realize that what they are doing is legally or ethically wrong
]:)
by jalefevre
A long standing principal in US law is that of prescriptive easements (see http://www.escrowhelp.com/articles/20031104.html). If you trespass long enough, it becomes legal. "The legal test to acquire a prescriptive easement of another owner is that the use must be open, not secret, notorious, clearly observable, hostile, without the landowner's consent and continuous without interruption for the number of years required by state law. For example, the minimum hostile use varies from 5 years in California to 30 years in Texas."
This seems bassed on the 'no harm, no foul' rule.
by m_a_r_k
by unclerob
as per my original post:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=82&threadID=185931&messageID=1904304
by sealife
I have an AP that is listed on the consume.net site as open for anyone to use. My transfers are not capped so I have no issue with anyone using my connection if it helps them. It gets used sporadically.
If I had a capped account then it might be different. If I wanted to keep my WiFi connection private then I ought to use the link encryption not so much for security but as a notice that it's private.
I suggest that if an AP is not protected then the owner should not be able to go to law as they are guilty of contributory negligence by not using the very simple tools available.
by tony85
I too faced the problem recently. I was in a hotel for a week with no internet access other than dial up at about $1 per minute. Nature of job prevented me gaining access elsewhere during the day.
However, at night, it was obvious that there was an unsecured wireless network around. I have to confess that I did briefly make use of it. If there had been enough to identify it, I would have gone and knocked on the door, and explained to them (if we had a common language) about their exposed network and offered them some Euros for the use of it.
There is the opposite side to this - if your laptop is set to connect automatically to a network, then it may connect itself to an unsecured network when you thought it was connecting to a different network. In my case, at first glance, it was not obvious that this was not a free network in the hotel (quite common in some hotels) and it was only because I was there for several nights and it switched off around midnight that I then began to wonder about the source.
What we have is a technology that is being installed by many people who have no concept of what they are doing - they plug it in and set it up. When I do this for people, I secure their network and explain to them why I am doing it. One way of making it clear to them is to point out that if a guy in his car in the street was downloading child pornography through their connection, they would not know, and when the police came knocking on their door, it would be difficult to show that it wasn't them. At this point, they usually understand why they should spend the extra few minutes setting up security, or having someone do this for them.
by lederhoden
"If I can receive the radio signal, I am entitled to use it!"
To receive a signal, maybe, but NOT to transmit over that signal. At that point, you are actively taking bandwidth away from someone who is paying for the use of that bandwidth. You are depriving him of something for which he is paying - ergo you are stealing from him.
by mccmike45
In the US, we have the right to receive any radio wave, unscrambled. Thus, we have free TV and radio. We do not have the right to circumvent a scrambled signal and we do not have the right to send radio signals because the sending is regulated, thus the FCC. This is why it is illegal to have an anti-radar device that transmit a false tone to the cops radar device telling them that you were driving at 55mph when you were actually driving 70mpg.
With all of this said, you have the right to receive the Wi-Fi signal, but you cannot transmit on it unless it is a public resource. If you don't use some minor amount of protection for your device, is it considered public? I don't know.
Legal and ethics are not the same thing as we have seen (i.e. "I did not have sex with that woman, Ms. Lewinskey") and we all know that in a legal sense, definitions of terms is always up for debate.
by drew17
Sad to point out that you are incorrect.
It is illegal to intentionally receive unscrambled cordless telephone signals and analog 'cell' phone signals.
I doubt they even sell 46mhz cordless phones any more but when they were the standard they could easily be monitored with any scanner from Radio Shack.
Electronics Communications Principles Act of 1986 outlawed the monitoring of cordless phone conversations. It was ammended in the early 90s to become even more restrictive and close some loop holes. Monitoring any 'over the air' telephone conversation is a violation of Title 18, Section 2511 USC.
by redcell
Although broadcasting or transmitting is regulated if you purchase a device that can broadcast you either have also puchased a permit to broadcast (if it falls under a minimum requirement), or you can purchase a license to broadcast with the FCC. What we have it the case of 'wardriving" is a technology that is not truely addressed by law. Although laws regulate the use of transmitting radio frequencies, and the manufacturing of these devices, as long as they are being used for the purpose in which they were licensed for then it's legal. The legality issue with wardriving is NOT covered under those laws.
I know some companies intentionally have Wi-Fi setup to allow non-employees such as sales, contract service people, etc. to be able to have access to the internet. Although this is a courtesy for business purposes it is also a somewhat intentional "public" access point too.
I leave my home wireless wide open for anyone to use. I regard it as a neighbourly public service and would be most appreciative of anyone doing the same in a spirit of altruistic public benevolence. To me it's allowing other people to use something that would otherwise be wasted. Consider it a bit like me putting my TV in my window and leaving it on for anyone to stand and watch should they so desire.
However, having read some comments above I wonder if it's ME who's being unethincal and "stealing". The ISP gives me a service as a home user, with an anticipated amount of traffic which might be exceeded if the whole neighbourhood jumps on my link.
And, as my mate Jason pointed out, what happens when someone hacks the CIA from my access point?
Scarey :)
by tim_seabrook
by lederhoden
by andrew.moore
by eldane
I guess you would advocate 'borrowing' other people's cars if they leave them unlocked.
The fact is, the only reason that WEP, WPA and security standards are needed is to prevent people from gaining access to someone elses property. It does not matter if you are stealing bandwidth or car stereos it is the same thing.
50 years ago, my grandparents could leave their house unlocked at night, whereas I have to have a 12 bolt locking steel-reinforced door on my house.
There seems little respect in this world anymore for another's work or possessions.
by csr-tech
Your example is not the same as an unsecured access point. The owner of the car took precautions to prevent theft of his vehicle by removing the keys from the ignition and "hiding" them above the visor. I would equate this to leaving your access point open, but disabling broadcast of the SSID. But if you let your neighbor know what the SSID is, it's the same as letting your neighbor know where you hide the keys to your car.
If you really want to prevent the unauthorized use of your vehicle (access point), then you take robust precautions to prevent the unauthorized use.
In some European cities, they provide public bicycles for anybody to use. You walk outside, find one of these bicycles parked, get on it and ride it to your destination, and park it for the next person to use. They are usually all painted a distinguishing color (like school bus yellow), and are designated for public use. Now if you go out and buy a bicycle that is the same color, and leave it outside unlocked in one of these cities, and someone else mistakes your private bicycle as one of the public bicycles because it looks just like them and it is unsecure, and takes it for a ride: Has he stolen it? Maybe from the owners viewpoint, but not from the user's viewpoint. The user thought it was just another publicly available item to use.
So to the owners of all those publicly available, unsecured, SSID broadcasting access points; I have one question and one statement:
How am I supposed to be able to distinguish your publily available access point from the other publily available access points that are put up intentionally for public use (in coffee shops, hotels, truck stops, rest areas, etc. - the list just keeps growing)?
If you are upset about people using the bandwidth on your publicly available access point that you failed to secure, my response is "The stupid shall be punished."
by supahtech
by ambalish
by tomhenderson
If there is some kind of agreement between you and your neighbors, then by all means, feel free to share your connection. However, if you're going to have a completely open access point (no WEP/WPA, don't secure by MAC), then expect the absolute worst to come across your network.
Think of something that you find completely offensive and is illegal, such as child pornography. If someone is tapping into your network to upload or download it, you could suddenly find yourself involved in an investigation, possibly charged as an accomplice. And as far as most people would be concerned, you *would* be an accomplice. You *could* have prevented it, by implementing even moderate security, but didn't.
by gunthr
Arguing the point of ethics is a waste of our time. It is not currently illegal therefore opinions will vary on whether or not it is morally correct. There is no way to know that an AP is free/open or private/personal unless some form of security is in place or there is some sort of banner displayed. Renaming the ESSID would never be cut and dry enough for any court, legal or moral.
Why not set the standard for the AP manufacturers. Make it mandatory for them to have some form of security on by default or have the user answer a question during setup on whether or not it is a private AP and display some sort of banner when a device connects. That would take the guess work out of it and no one could question whether or not they are welcome on that network. I think looking for a solution instead of arguing a moot point is much better use of our time.
by csr-tech
by pakaka1i
by palkerekfy
by dominic_2002
Undoubtedly there are more people that exploit the open access or inscure wireless networks as a means to commit what would be thought of as illegal activity.
There are actually people that intentionally leave 'their' networks open in metropolitan or residential areas just so that the unsuspecting person who wants to check their mail can easily get into a network that is ruled by the hacker who has the network setup and can then do all the damage or spying they want on the person who is technically not committing a crime by getting what is already free to them.
Quite simply, I think there should be a law against leaving a network open with the intent of attracting the more ignorant community of pc users who stroll around with their laptops that have essentially just school work or pictures on them. Basically there is more of a threat to the majority of people that know how to connect to a insecure wireless network than those that leave them open.
It is kind of difficult to pin-point the suspect, is it the person joining the network or the person that leaves it open for the most basic computer user to access?
It would be difficult for FCC to regulate the security of wireless lans that have no access to a web server, but if they are able to some how have a way of controlling the policies of ISP's, then perhaps they can make a law that allows only so much time before a secure network must be established for a customer with access to the global network.
by alan.m9
If you left your keys in your car, can I claim it as my own for as long as I like? Why take my WiFi just because I left the keys out?
Taking something that is not yours is theft. It doesn?t matter if the owner made it easy - it's still theft.
I don?t' care what the laws allow - society works if we live according to a moral code - not "take what you can". This isn't about avoiding taxes; it's about getting your neighbour to pay for something because you don't wan to.
While the follows America's lead, I ask WHY? Get a conscience.
by mvmughal
If the medium used is "public" frequency and not secure I don't think there is any problem. Public frequencies are free for the public to use without FCC permission or the flip side the FCC has already granted permission for public to use and connect to those frequencies.
In the comment from "Ned Rhinelander (CNET)" he stated "no one gave me permission to connect..." No one gives you permission to connect to any radio station, no one gives you permission to connect to the emegerency channels and listen in on scanners, no one give you permission to connect to news feeds using those huge dishes... They are all public frequencies. If they don't want you they scramble their signals.
The same is true with wireless if someone doesn't want you secure it... it's public frequency in public space! How about a step further public space in your private home, your neighbors access points blasting that ssid into your private space announcing "I'm SSID-X connect to me"?
by noorman
The [wardriver] is using a connection and hardware that 's been payed for by its owner, nit the [wardriver] !
If there 's a data volume limit on that connection/contract, the [wardriver] is stealing data volume as well.
It 's not a law question !
It 's ethical; your are using someone elses 'things' ...
It 's because these things are happening that people have to PROTECT their connections, NOT the other way around.
It 's the same as with house doors; in the past there were whole communities that had NO locks on their doors (or didn't use them). Since theft (out of homes ) has gone up, nearly everyone has put locks on their doors !
To me it ain't right to [wardrive]; law or no law !
noorman
by jrtangen
jdclyde,
"if you use something that takes NOTHING away from someone else"
Are you serious? How can you take something form somenone that is nothing? If you use somones bandwidth without permission you are stealing. It is not a question of if the network owner is using that bandwidth or not. From an ethical prespective this discussion is ridiculous. If leave the key for my house in the door, does that give you the right to enter and help yourself from my fridge?
Just because legslation is lagging in this matter I think we all should use common sense. Would you like someone else to use your network without that you knowing about it?
by tmcal
What is it that people no longer know right from wrong or
understand that morals and ethics are not written into law, they are
the basis which we live by and are not to be evoked arbitrarily when
the situation suits our needs.
by not_me
by wordworker
by wordworker
by craig_b
It seems some people think, well, if their is no written law against it, it's OK, right? They try to use logic to talk themselfs into doing something they "know" in their heart is wrong.
If I use this logic that way; I could say that if you left your car unlocked and your laptop in it, I could take the laptop out use for awhile and put it back before you noticed and since their is no law about this it's OK?
Here's the law that covers all this:
Treat others as you would want to be treated.
by stsanford
What about this situation:
I'm at a client's doing an evaluation the other day. I get to talking, and leave my laptop on in his office while I walk around the site and discuss needs, etc.. I come back and have e-mail in my inbox! Obviously Windows Zero Config saw an insecure Wi-Fi network and linked me up. I didn't do it purposely, but is this wardriving or just a happy mistake facillitated by my OS?
What do I do, do I tell the person or company with the unsecured Wi-Fi AP that they do? I don't know the area or where it might be. My solution. Disconnect (after replying to a message, hey, what the heck...) and say no more...
Personally, I'm not a fan of Big Government, but I do believe that the Information Super Highway should be subsidized to an extent that there is FREE access to it via WiFi in towns and cities. Korea has it, why shouldn't the US?
by garyhussar
Unless you can prove that I have knowlingly left the system open for use by the general public you are using it without permission in an unlawful manner. Remember most of these systems are open because the people setting them up do NOT know how to lock them up properly, and the default settings are not that secure.
What is the legal and moral difference between Wardriving and the situation where you leave your front door unlocked, for any reason, and I walk in and start using your computer to do my emails or play games or use your oven to heat up my meat pie; or you have left your car with the keys in it by accident and I use the car to drive to the mall and do some shopping and then return it later after putting some petrol in it. There is no difference between the three situations; in each the things were used without the prior approval of the owner being given in any clear or implied manner - this is an unlawful use of the item, some would say theft but that depends upon your local legal definition of theft (around here it is theft only if you intend to permanently deny them use or access). Unlawful use is usually a misdemeanor in most jurisdictions whilst theft often has heavier penalties.
Using my computer or microwave, you're stealing my electricity. Using my car - even if you top up the gas, you're stealing my tyre rubber, you're stealing my depreciation, you're stealing my insurance cover.
Using some of my unused bandwidth though, is more like "stealing" an empty can from the trash I put out last night.
I use all the bandwidth I have and can not get enough, it is bad enough sharing the bandwidth with the other approved users within the household, and then nearly all the Internet access plans around here have set download limits, after which you pay per MB or part thereof. Your use of my access could actually push me into having to pay for excess downloads. When you use someone elses system without their knowledge or approval you have no way of knowing how much, if any, spare bandwidth they may, or may not, have or what their download limits and excess rates are.
A few years ago I shared an ADSL service with my nephew and his fiancee (shared housing), they both used music sharing programs and the basic program gave other users of the service the ability to download their music from their computers. The unplanned and uncontrolled downloads via this system cost an extra $1,000 over 6 months before we could identify and shut down the cause; excess rates were bloody high. Wardriving could result in similar type problems for some people.
Either way it is still the same basic situation as I outlined, use without approval is unlawful. Like using my land without permission to take a shortcut to the next street is also known as trespassing.
by mill3502
What have we become as a society when we think using someone else's property is perfectly OK. It could be music, journalism, books, wireless access, you name it we have become a society of thinking it's 'OK' because they didn't try to stop us.
It should not matter if we have laws or not it's wrong!
by dave.schutz
If someone uses my car/bike without my permission they deprive me of its use for that time period; even if I did not intend to use it. That's why it is stealing. If someone uses my WI-FI signal (this won't happen as my is secure) what are they depriving me of?
I don't know if it is right or wrong, I just don't see a crime.
by curtispnkrtn
by codebubba
I disagree. Radio stations broadcast with the INTENT that you pick up their signal and use it. Someone who sets up a wireless router that doesn't know any better is not implicitly giving you permission to use their bandwidth, they simply don't know any better.
The way I look at it is an unsecured router from someone's house is a bit like a power outlet they have out in their yard for plugging in the weed-eater or bug zapper. Just because the outlet may be accessible to me (I.E. it's not behind a fence and it's not in a lock box) does not give me the right to plug my appliance into it and use the power he's paying for. I think that if everybody took that point-of-view it might become obvious that piggybacking (Or Wardriving, is that what we're calling it?) is basically unethical if not illegal.
-CB :-)
by ppg
Section 243 of the Criminal Code of Canada involves the concealing the body of a child.
I assume you mean section 342.1 which says:
(1) Every one who, fraudulently and without colour of right,
(a) obtains, directly or indirectly, any computer service,
(c) uses or causes to be used, directly or indirectly, a computer system with intent to commit an offence under paragraph (a) or (b) or an offence under section 430 in relation to data or a computer system,
is guilty of an indictable offence
Fraud is defined under the criminal code as " by deceit, falsehood ... defrauds the public ... of any property, money or valuable security or any service"
There is certainly no deceit or falsehood in this case and it is not at all clear the owner of the network lost anything of value.
by jamesrl
then you would be correct. But since many consumers pay a premium for better bandwidth (or don't subscribe to the "lite" services) then there is some value to bandwidth, as opposed to the simple ability to connect.
James
by jamesrl
then you would be correct. But since many consumers pay a premium for better bandwidth (or don't subscribe to the "lite" services) then there is some value to bandwidth, as opposed to the simple ability to connect.
James
by swats
If I move into a home that still has cable service active and connect to and use that service who is losing? The service is there. It's being sent out by the cable company for it to be used. They don't mind that I use it, right? Wrong! That is called "theft of service" and is punishable by law. Just because the cable company is in the business of selling that service doesn't change mean that it's theft to take from them but ok to take from old Joe who *is* paying for the service. It's against the law to make long distance telephone calls while bypassing the payment even though all that bandwidth was just sitting there waiting for you... It's against the law to stow-away on a cargo ship that is transiting (fill in the blank)... The ship would be going anyway, your weight is inconsequential, where's the loss.
Another angle is that it's a subtle form of identity theft since all communications from that IP address is presumed to be initiated by the person paying for the service. Legitimate use or not, isn't even an issue.
by jamesrl
Lets say JD that you had spent some money and some effort to create a reasonably secure wireless network in your house. You pay money to the internet service provider with the expectation that you get reasonable bandwidth to enable you to download files, play games etc.
Now lets say that your computer genius neighbour has some software that allowed him to quickly gain access to your net, and that neighbour uses file sharing programs, downloads movies and music files, and basically eats up you bandwidth to the point where you aren't much faster than dial-up.
Would you be okay with that? After all you are broadcasting your signal into his space?
I personally think this "their responsibility to secure it" line is a bunch of crap designed to justify theft or freeloading or whatever you want to call it. It may not be illegal, but if you wouldn't like it done to you, then its taking advantage of someone and is not ethical. Treat people the way you'd like to be treated. If it was ethical, you wouldn't be afraid to walk up to your neighbour's front door and tell them what you were doing.
James
by onamission
by billbo01028
Most people pay for electricity or water by the amount they use. If I had to pay for my water by the size of the pipe coming into my house instead of the amount of water I actually used then I would not mind if others use my outside faucet. If my car overheated and I needed to add water to it, I would not hesitate from using water that was running out into the street where someone was watering there lawn and some of the water was flowing onto public property. Just like if someone had an apple tree on there property, I would not go on there property and steal a apple. But if some fell off the tree and were laying on the public road I would not think twice about taking it.
Just my 2 cents
by redcell
The water faucet/electrical outlet is not really a good example. For it to be a good exapmle you would have to think of it as a water hose that is turned on or an extension cord that has been tossed over into your yard.
Just a thought...
by caryxander
by pwoods
by alexbra
IMO I don't think that ethics and law should be correlated. What is ethical may not be illegal and vice versa.
If you were to look at it and ask why it would be considered unethical I would imagine it is because someone is paying for use of a service so that they may benefit from it. When you use thier services, you are reaping the benefits which they have paid for and you have not. That isn't distributively just.
The service the pays for provides satisfaction, the same as other services or goods. If I pay a buck for a candy bar and you come and scrape away a mm of my candy bar then you are taking for yourself that much satisfaction. Will I notice it... probably not, but that isn't relevant. If it were relevant then I could steal about 80% of my grandma's wealth.. they won't notice it.
by antispock
Your post talked ethics not laws. Ever post were someone says it's unethical you merely justify your own wants. I think you are denying your own concious.
It sounds to me like inadvertant (you connect to a private connection in a place you would expect public Wi-Fi), would be ethically fine.
However knowledgeable connection would be wrong.
The owner has not said you can use the wi-fi and if the user is downloading porn or mp3 your use of their bandwidth will slow them down.
It's like users at a business using streaming media so they can listen to their favorite radio station. It's only a small amount of bandwidth per user but once multiple users gobble the network serious work suffers.
by landerson
If there is some question as to whether or not something is ethical- I believe- is a sure sign that it is not. I wonder, have you had this conversation with your boss? How did they react? I would thing they might begin to wonder what other things that you think are A-OK to do and/or help yourself to. Do you also think it is okay to work 7 hours even though you are paid for 8? Is it okay to make all of your long distance calls from work so you dont have to pay for them? Is it okay to take a ream of paper from work every month- as they wont really miss it because they have so many? Is it okay to "borrow" code or verbiage from documents on the web- because the internet is so big no one will know that you didnt write it yourself- and hey they posted it on the web so they must have wanted it to be reused by someone?
Just some thoughts?
by sales
I am basing this completely on my memory (which fails me often), but it is my understanding that there was a successful conviction in the UK within the last two months, though I can't tell you under what setion of what act he was convicted. It seems a complaint was made to the police about someone parked outside a house on more than one occasion.
Even without a law against it, it seems like a pretty sneaky way of going about your business.
by ludedude25
If it can be reached outside the home, Is obviously not secured, and the person didn't make any attempt to secure it how is it stealing.
If you want security it is there, it is the owners responsibility to secure there network "or have someone else do it" if they don't want someone using their wireless internet.
Look how many places have hot spots now, gas stations, coffee shops, various restaraunts, hospitals, motels, etc. Now some hotels have went with limited bandwidth and you must request wifi at the desk so they can give you access.
Why should the average home user be any different? Or should you blame the router wifi manufacturer for having it default wide open? Regardless when you setup a router you have to log into it and configure it for your broadband connection if you have wireless and don't disable it or secure it, it's your Negligence. Now your blaming me for your Negligence!?
When I want to get rid of something around here I sit it out by the curb. You wouldn't sit all your personal belongings out by the curb unsecure would you.
Cars have locks to keep people out, Homes have locks to keep people out, Business have locks to keep people out, WIFI has locks to keep people out! It's as simple as that.
Now if someone were to hack into another's secured wifi that would be different, now were talkin stealing/ breaking and entering.
BOTTOM LINE IT IS THE OWNER OF THE WIFI DEVICES RESPONSIBILITY TO SECURE THEM!!!
ps. mine is wide open but i do check the log on a regular basis and if someone is using it excessively, bam I block their MAC address.
I love stirring the pot!
by kphayes710
I also keep my Wi-Fi open mostly because I don't live in a busy area, but the MAC address thing is genius.
About the open Wi-Fi connection. I deal with setup and securing wireless networks as well as other things but my feeling is that if you leave your wireless connection unsecured then you are basically saying "Please use my internet access. Now I heard about there being a legality with unauthorized access to a wireless network. I can't remember where it was but what the author of this post did would be considered illegal. However then you have to get into the wording of the law and ask "if someone leaves their network open is that considered authorization to use their network?" In my opinion, when someone leaves their network open then it is their authorizing anyone to use it.
by palkerekfy
First off you cant compare that, it is like comparing murder to purgery...
Listen to yourself, comparing burglary to a legal unethical activity.
And people are allowed to drive your car if you are broadcasting "My car is unlocked, the keys are in the ignition, I want care if you take it for a ride"
No different than an open WAP, anyone who doesnt have a secure router is just irresponsible. They should read and know the risk before and after purchasing and if they can not secure it they should hire an appropriate technician to do so.
OPEN WAP - Legal
by wojnar
According to you if you leave your car unlocked on a city street with the keys in it and a $100 bill in the glove box, I am not acting illegally if I take the vehicle and the money since you didn't secure it even though you could have.
By the way, can you tell me where you live and what type of car you own ????? (by the way I prefer small bills rather than 100's)
by gr6120
by zengeek
by capt.brad
My quick search uncovered a case in Florida where a man was charged and convicted for doing just that.
From the St. Petersburg Times Article "Wi-Fi cloaks a new breed of intruder"
"Smith, who police said admitted to using Dinon's Wi-Fi, has been charged with unauthorized access to a computer network, a third-degree felony."
http://www.sptimes.com/2005/07/04/State/Wi_Fi_cloaks_a_new_br.shtml
by dasdbobb
Wardriving in it self is legal, it is what you do after you find the wireless access points that is illegal.
EXP:
It is perfectly legal to drive around and pick up wireless signals for fun.
EXP:
It is illegal to pick up wireless signals and then use a packet sniffer to access routers or to attempt to do nearly any type of "shady" activities on any private router.
EXP:
You pick up a wireless signal and it is a public open router. So you take a look inside and use some of their bandwidth. Legal.
Remember, on any private wireless router anything more than looking is illegal. You can look at the router when you pick it up but even attempting connection is illegal.
by steve_te
"Ethics" do not depend on "the law", as it sounds like you were eluding to in your question "..If it is not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical?.." No doubt, opinions will vary, and one's ethical "admittance" compared to another's may vary, but right and wrong do not vary.
To answer your question "Based on what?" ..it is "based" on common sense and a very simple perspective of right and wrong. We know the answer already. Like all things that you "know" are wrong, once it is abused a bit, just give it some time and it will be deemed "illegal".
Here's the ethical perspective of it, and it's ALL about ethics. How many wi-fi connections do you think folks connect to (via "wardriving") that are not only unsecured, but may or may not have firewalls set up properly to keep you from open shares on LAN machines, etc. Now it is beyond hitching a ride, to intrusion. Is it the owner's responsibility to guard against that? Sure it is. Does that make it ethical for folks to abuse, even if "you" are not harming anything, and I'm sure most intentions are not to? But many "will". If you leave your front door unlocked and you're burglarized ...does that make the burglary "ethical"? Of course not. No different here. It's like stealing Mp3s. It's a non-tangible and we've somehow justified it, in our minds, to be "ok".
by ksat
One thing to understand is that legalities and ethics have nothing in common. Whether or not something is legal or not is set by laws and how those laws are interpretted. Ethics is a universal belief system which are, primarily, morally driven.
In this case, we have a home network that has been left unsecured. This is a broadband connection which a user has paid for himself and may or may not understand how to properly set up a network. While it is possible to pick up that network connection by an outsider, I believe it is both unethical and illegal. Many of you are comparing WIFI to that of radio and TV signals - this is equivalent to comparing apples to oranges. This is not the same.
It is illegal simply for the fact that you are stealing bandwidth for which you have not paid for. Essentially, you stole that candy bar out of a grocery store. It may not be worth much, but, it is still stealing.
It is unethical because it is stealing. Stealing is wrong, therefore, wardriving is unethical.
If you believe otherwise, you should carefully reconsider your personal values or morals in such situations.
Wrong.
If a user buys a wireless router the user is responsible for reading the manual. In all new wireless routers the manual easily shows the user how to set up some type of encryption. So thus if I were to pick up my next door neighboors signal and it is OPEN(not encrypted or password protected) then it is perfectly legal for me to use his bandwidth.
It is his fault his WAP is open, not mine. And open WAPs are considered public even if it is in someone's home. So therefor open WAPs are free ground for free bandwidth and it is the user's responsibility to secure it and if the user can not do it him/herself then they should hire the appropriate technician to set the router up for them.
by ksat
While it may be the owner of the WAP that is ultimately at fault for leaving the WIFI connection open, it is not the same as handing a neighbor the keys to the car. Utilizing a public WAP, such as those found in Panera retail outlets, are for the use of their customers. Is it legal to sit in your car in the parking lot to use that connection? I would say no, it is not because the intent is for use by customers.
The same holds true for a home-based WIFI connection. Even though it is open, a wardriver picking up the signal and utilizing that connection for personal gain is illegal - no matter the intent of that individual. I believe it is still stealing.
by sven thirion
by rnrnrnrnrn
A few months ago on NPR, an ethicist was interviewed regarding this same topic. His response was interesting. He stated that he thought it was ethical (within limitations) as long as the person using someone else's WIFI connection also paid for his or her own Internet connection. His reasoning was that the cost of maintaining the Internet is shared by all users, therefore you are paying for it already. I believe he was referring to casual use, not multi-megabit transfers for hours on end. For more details, search www.npr.org for the original interview.
Of course, legality is different than ethics. The legality of using someone else's open WIFI connection depends on the laws of individual jurisdictions.
by marathoner
I've done the same.. I was on a trip where the hotel not only charge through the nose for Wireless but also make you install who knows what crap on your computer. So I walked a few feet away from the establishment, found me a nice dry spot in the bushes and sucked a few K from some hapless twit who left their Linksys open, to IM with my daughter and check my mail. If the hapless twit doesn't care, I surely don't! I did him no harm, and deprived him of virtually nothing.
Which brings up another point: incompatible encryptions. I know people who can't [at least not easily] secure their WLAN's because the WAP is an apple airporter and some of the clients are windows/linux pc's and there are incompatibilities or some other such scenario. These security protocols should be as standard as TCP/IP!
by wojnar
You are wrong in assuming its ok if nobody objects. If you were able to hang a wire off your neighbor's cable and use the internet access without your neighbor seeing it, chances are they wouldn't object. Is that ok then ? The bottom line is if you are using something that requires a fee for use and you are not paying for it - its stealing. Period.
There is right and wrong. Nowhere does wrong-doing require the action to be seen/objected to in order to be wrong. What ever happened to integrity ? I hope that you are not in charge of your company's databases or according to you anybody can have access to it as long as you don't object.
by unclerob
by teligence
"The Law is for the lawless".
Ethics cannot be defined by such finite guidelines as an individual's personal scruples. The majority have a general concept of right and wrong. Some - maybe you fit in this category - choose to justify action that is contrary simply for personal interest, gain, or convenience. When such personal - and selfish, mind you - ambition infringes on the rights and resources of another then a governing body is then responsible and accountable to it's constituents to place "controls" in effect - also known as law.
It is people like you that are forcing government's hand to be more involved (and intrusive) in our lives than they should be.
by techrepublic
Here is the only law I was able to find that is directly applicable
to this question:
http://www.swiss.ai.mit.edu/6805/legislation/
18usc1030/18usc1030.html
Basically, it is illegal to cause damage, enter and/or deny access
to someone else's secured network.
So, if you install or send worms, viruses, spam, etc., you are
breaking the law. If the network is closed, encrypted or MAC
protected and you enter, you are breaking the law. If you
barrage the network so that the legitimate owner can't use it
would be illegal.
This has never been tested in court and probably never will. I
believe the reason is analogous to property. If I leave my car
unlocked and you enter, you trespass. If you ask permission and
I deny it, you trespass. If I lock the doors and you enter, you
trespass. However, if I give you permission, you can enter.
When a computer connects to a wifi network, it asks for
permission, if granted, then you are not trespassing. If it is
closed, denies access or requests a password and you enter,
then you are trespassing.
Also, it would be a logistical nightmare to enforce this. There are
so many open public networks whose use is encouraged, Apple
Store, Parks, etc., how do you know you are not connecting to a
network that is available for public use. The only answer is that
you do know, if it is closed, asks for a password or denies access
to the connection request, it is NOT available for public use.
Caveat emptor, your information sent over that network is
unsecured and is subject to collection, and viewing.
Of course, there are moral issues involved also. Checking a web
site or your email wouldn't be a burden on the network
connection, but downloading gigabytes from newsgroups would
be morally wrong.
by pcollins
by redcell
If you look at the fine print of almost any legally manufacturered Wi-Fi router I think you will find that they are licensed by the FCC to be used in an intended fashion. Now since the device is licensed by the FCC to transmit it's carrier and the owner does not put bounderies on it. It seems to me to be fair territory for anyone who happens by.
With ownership comes responsibility.
by dohnotgood
if somoene else is paying for something and you "tap in" but dont ask or compensate then your a thief PERIOD.
Why not go into open houses and grab a glass of water after all the Door was open and they wont miss one glass of water.
Learn respect and we might have a better palce.
Remember just because you can does not mean you should.
by dohnotgood
if somoene else is paying for something and you "tap in" but dont ask and/or compensate then your a thief PERIOD.
Why not go into open houses and grab a glass of water after all the Door was open and they wont miss one glass of water.
Learn respect and we might have a better palce.
Remember just because you can does not mean you should.
by beoweolf
With water from your neighbors water tap.
In this country the ethics are similar. Where he may not have an issue with your stopping by to have a drink or a especilly warm summer day or even offer you the use of water, during an emergency. He would be very troubled to find you had either a permenant connection to or large scale use for his resources.
In the West, wars have been fought over taking what was given, especially for something less than a necessity.
First off it is legal if the WAP is open.
Secondly, anyone who is hosting a open WAP knowingly or not does not have the right to get mad if they are being abused. Because it is THEIR fault and lack of responsibility to secure it themselves. Every manual packaged with WAPs lets users know of security risk and preventions. If the user does not read it or take responsibility to fix it whether that be themselves or the appropriate techncian, then it is their fault that they are getting taken advantage of.
It is like if you someone buys you alot of liqour and you get drunk and give him all the money in your wallet(say 1,000$). Is that illegal? No, you put your self in that situation to be taken advantage of.
by sven thirion
by randalbin
It has long been established by the FCC that anyone can legally receive a radio wave that is travelling through space if they can legally acquire or fabricate the equipment to do so. This has been the premise of the Amateur Radio Operator organizations since their inception. There were no banned frequencies or laws against building a receiver for any frequency.
However, in recent years certain equipment has been outlawed from retail sale and (in some cases) from private use. Scanners that receive cell phone frequencies are no longer commercially available in the US and lawmakers are trying to make them illegal to use if you own an older one that does pick up these frequencies. Also, radar detectors are basically radio wave receivers and were originally made and sold on the premise that anyone can legally receive a radio wave that is travelling through space. These too have become illegal in many states.
As an Amateur Radio operator I strongly disagree with these infringements on our rights (although I understand that the laws are attempting to protect the privacy and civil rights of other citizens) but in some cases simple reception of radio waves has been made illegal. I am pretty sure that many lawmakers would consider intentionally seeking to receive radio waves from a station that you know is not offered for public access an infraction of this type of statute.
I have also read on certain Wardriving websites that there have been cases of people being prosecuted or fined simply for connecting to a wireless network. Apparently in some states or municipalities there are already ordinances against the use of any network that you have not expressly been given permission to use.
So, Please don't assume that Wardriving is legal because there are places where it has already been outlawed.
by joe_t
If you do not have permission to use the wire that the wireless connects through, then you have no permission to use the wireless. Most States have laws already on the books that criminalize the use of computer networks without proper authorization.
I see this as little different than the license you are granted to enter and remain upon certain private property (such as a shopping center) unless asked to leave by the owner and the license you do NOT have to enter a private home. If the homeowner wants you to enter, you'll know.
WLANs are mostly like private homes. If the homeowner wants you to enter, you'll be told. Hotspots are like a shopping center - you've been granted license to use it (and pay!), but the owner has the right to terminate said license at any time.
If you think you can use that open WLAN to innocently get your email, why don't you walk up to the house/business and ask the owner if it's OK? If you won't because you suspect the answer will be "NO", then you already know you are doing something wrong and are justifying it to yourself because "he left it open". This is no different morally than MP3 trading, which everyone knows is an illegal copyright violation but justifies it with "the evil record companies had it coming with their high prices". It doesn't matter if the AP is unsecured or the CD costs too much - it's illegal. Deal with it.
by iainbuchanan
If its do-able then someone will do it. Illegality will therefor not stop people from doing it. Is it imoral? who cares?
Like the guy said if you leave the keys in the car someone will nick it.
The problem is that there are a myraid of conflicting laws on the books and it all boils down to who can argue their point best.
Currently we know that under the Electronic communicatins act it is illegal to listen to phone conversations. IE Wiretap.
Which is in direct disagreement with the Federal communications act of 1934 and subsequently updated in 1997 which states unequivocially that a U.S Citizen has the right to recieve any Brodcast radio signal.
So now the question posed it which law is right, well only a decision of the court can decide.
Further the Sony Beta-Max decision allows me to take any signal I have recieved and Record it for future use, and under existing copyright laws I can make copies for archival purpose.
Yet The DCMA disallows me to do so.
This is not a simple and cut and dried as you make it seem, since neither law modifies the other Each is valid as stands on its own, and will require the courts to construe each seperate law in harmony with the other.
Now in the case of WLan connections, do you have the right to recieve this signal (Absolutely/or not) depending on which law you want to believe or more importantly get the courts to believe.
do you have the right to transmit, Sure do. Since the FCC was given the powers to assign frequencies and transmit powers that the general public can use (see federal communications act.) you have been given the rights to use the 2.4 and 5 MHZ bands within certian constraints.
Does that Wlan access point have the right to recieve you signal, sure does.
Now what happens, beyond that is all a matter for the courts and lawyers.
since it can be construed that a:
Since I am legally recieving a siganl, and legally brodcasting a signal, if the operator has not secured his end to REJECT my transmissions then by Fait accomli of providing a system for recieving and processing a legal public brodcast signal they are infact providing a open public AP.
Now I know you going to say well this is "unauthorized use" or theft of service, however under existing laws it is still possible for you to argue that failure to make an effort to keep someone out (See attractive nusicance laws) you are in effect taking responsibility deliberatly or through lack of action and in effect approving this utilization.
IE: If I put up a pool and fail to put a fence around it I am responsible for it's use and misuse and under the attictive nusicance laws failure to do so consitiutes an open invatition to utilize this resource.
Subistitute pool for WiFi AP and fence for securing the thing and again you see the valid argument.
The long and the short is since there are laws in conflict, utilization of a unsecure AP is a schrodegengers cat, both legal and illegal at the same time and until the courts open the box we will not know the actual state of the laws.
by wojnar
So morally, its ok to do anything unless its illegal ??? That seems to be the attitude of a lot of people. Fortunately this isn't only a moral issue.
See if you can follow this simple logic - Hopefully we all agree stealing IS illegal. Possessing something that: 1)was not freely given to you, 2) requires a fee to use and 3)would not be available without infrastructure supporting the fee required is STEALING.
You don't have to see the negative effects of stealing for it to be wrong. The legistatures or governing bodies are the only people that can explicitly say that an action is illegal. The courts don't determine legality, of an action, only the classification of if the action was/is governed by a particular law. (don't get me started on activist judges...)
As far as taxes and social programs - I would bet the farm that you couldn't survive a day without taking advantage of the effects of your tax money. (driven on an interstate or thrown something in the garbage lately ?) Plus you can legally avoid US taxes by going to Iran - I hear they need programmers.
by resotko
Detecting the existance of wireless networks publicly broadcasting SSIDs is not strictly illegal. What you do with that information after you have found it is where the majority of this debate takes place.
First, let me state I am a technologist, not a legalist. My opinions are my own, and don't represent the views of my employer or anyone else who might take issue with my opinion. IMHO, as they say....
Law is always slow to catch up to technology. Legal views on property are quite clear (ie, my car and house has locks, my land / property has boundaries which are identified, and it is usually quite obvious when a boundary has been crossed.) Legal views on broadcast services are changing as cases are brought to the courts, so we're all a little unclear about what could be considered illegal in the 2.4GHz public space.
When you buy an ISP service and a wireless access point, that AP is broadcasting a SERVICE. The boundaries are only limited by the broadcast strength, and can cross other legal, physical boundaries. So, is the signal from my AP my property, or a service made available to me? Again, I don't want to be the test case in court trying to figure that out. Your service provider is quite capable of cutting you off, changing the terms of service, or bringing legal action against you if some outsider uses your service to do something illegal, so you should at least protect yourself from that possibility. Your altruism in turning your home AP into a public hot-spot may be the ISPs first charge in their lawsuit against you.
Security is still about risk management. You take the steps you feel are necessary to manage the level of risk you are facing over a possible misuse of your network service.
Looking to existing law on the available broadcast rules for the 2.4GHz public space doesn't offer much guidance, since it is considered an open and public space. For people worried about these issues, I usually tell them the following:
1) your ISP has "terms of service" (the network is a service, not your property.) Make sure if you decided to leave your APs open and public that you aren't violating the terms of service with your ISP. I know of one case where a user with a cable modem was rate-limited by their cable company because they left their AP open, and the amount of total bandwidth they used violated terms of service.
2) if the terms of service explicitly limit the usage of the network service to your home, physical property, or your immediate location, take some effort to turn on security features in your APs, and learn how they work
The top things I advise people to do in protecting their network service are:
1)Change the default SSID and don't broadcast it, just manually enter it in wireless profiles on your home PCs and laptops
2) Find the farthest point in the house from the AP that you want to get a signal, and then lower the broadcast power of the AP to reach that location fairly well
3) turn on WEP at the very least, and if you can specify your own WEP key in the AP, change it every couple of months. If you have stronger encryption methods, use them.
4) If the AP allows you to restrict the IP range handed out by DHCP, set the total number of addresses equal to the number of computers you plan to hook up +1 (or plus however many visitors you get regularly asking to use your network when they visit.)
5) if the AP, has firewall features, use them all
6) if the AP will record the computer names of computers that connect to the network, turn it on. This way, you may have a chance of spotting if someone is "driving by" and attaching to the network.
7) Change the default channel that the AP is set to, since they almost always pick something in the middle of the channel range.
I realize fully that NONE of these steps will stop a determined attacker. They will make it difficult enough to cause the casual network leech to seek an easier access point. Further, it will make it easier for you to say you took reasonable and appropriate measures to secure your network. IF the FBI does come knocking on your door, you can meet them with a clear indication that if your network was used for something illegal, whoever did it had to hack in to make it happen.
For whether or not you have a legal complaint against your neighbor becase their AP is set to full power and is broadcasting it's SSID, I'd suggest digging for caselaw on complaints against other devices in public brodcast ranges (900MHz cordless phones, garage door openers, etc.) to see if there are any established precedents. So far, I haven't had any problems knocking on my neighbor's door, explaining the problem, and offering to spend 15-20 minutes showing them how to configure their AP using the suggestions I listed above. Your mileage may vary, of course...
by kfleming
by wojnar
by sven thirion
by stevel
Using a service that someone else has paid for with out their permission. For example:
Throwing your garbage into someone else's garbage can is illegal. You are using the garbage pickup service that they have paid for without their permission. Just because they didn't lock the top of their garbage can doesn't make it free for everyone to use. It is defined as Theft of Services and in most places you will be fined if caught.
by wojnar
by thomasderk9
Just as it is OK to receive radar signals with a car?s radar detector (except for one rogue state), so too it?s OK to RECEIVE most any radio signal. Thus, Wi-Fi is very analgous to the earliest days of cordless phones when the kid next door, cops in the street, or wife might eavesdrop simply by turning on their unit. The key, though, is NOT talking back. Such park and monitor is admissible in courts even without a wire tap order.
That answer, somewhat begs the answer. The simple fact is that people take wireless routers out of the box and plug them up and anyone in range is off to the races. This is extremely unfortunate because most people want to at least change the password on their router to prevent tampering of the router settings. So, I say, until the Quick Start Guides especially include the common sense wireless router security steps, there are no ethics whatsoever involved with sharing bandwidth in a respectful manner.
Personally, I live in apartments and I always cut a deal with Wi-Fi, which is the neighborly thing to do.
The steps to securing a Wi-Fi router are:
1. CHANGE THE PASSWORD.
2. Use TURBO, Speedbooster, etc. ONLY MODE. This requires same brand compatible router and adapters, but is a fabulous way to go. My D-link Xtreme (108) in TURBO ONLY mode is SSID invisible until one installs a D-Link Xtreme adapter! In addition, speed and distance are superb.
3. Use WAP encryption and toss older WEP encryption routers out if you can possibly afford it. However, WEP is better than nothing.
4. Turn off SSID broadcasting, which means an unsophisticated Wi-Fi hitchhiker will not know there is a wireless router running.
5. Go to MAC filtering, which means only certain Wi-Fi adapter(s) can use that router.
6. Do NOT run File & Print sharing unless you use file or print sharing.
7. Some say turn off DHCP and go to static IP addresses, but I am too lazy to do that
Mostly, though, steps 1, 2, and 3 are fine.
I have tried using Ghost Surfer in which one can encrypt in public places, such as libraries, but unfortunately, I have had mixed results because so many places already use proxy servers. With persistence, though, sometimes a second instance of Internet Explorer can be encrypted. However, I do not recommend you rely on encrypting to a proxy server. Nevertheless, Ghost Surfer is an excellent product when it works on a given network and no Road Warrior should be without it.
Now, having said all that and having expressed there are no ethics regarding jumping on someone?s Wi-Fi, and besides doing nothing hostile or illegal, there is a very important consideration of MANNERS. Usually, downloading bandwidth is so much more than Internet speeds that downloading is not a problem. However, uploading speeds are often capped at the Internet modem connection to the ISP. While a request to download e-mail is nothing to most networks, uploading music, especially on a peer to peer virtually always illegal system, can really hog up the upload bandwidth.
I had a teenage step-daughter in the early days of Napster and an IT NAZI son in law sharing a network with me. The IT NAZI was all stirred up about ?stealing,? and I was put out because it was like trying to overcome a DOS attack.
Thus, my vote is that it?s OK to use Wi-Fi whenever it is there for the using, but one has to always have good manners. However, too much of using other people?s networks is to do something illegal or even nefarious, so it behooves all wireless router owners to baton down the hatches.
Sort by Trending