Discussion Locked

What makes for great music?

0 helpful
136 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have had many FNM nights here on TR, where people from all around the world contribute a wide range of music. Some I like, some, not so much, but the people that post it enjoy it very much.

Music is a very personal thing, so I wondered how much thought people have put into what it is they like, and why?

What is it that makes music great?

Is it the composition of the music (writing).

Is it the lyrics?

Is it the hook or a catchy beat?

Is it the vocals?

Is it the style/skill of the musicians?

What is it that makes you love a song and KEEP loving it for years, even decades?

If you have examples of something you like, feel free to post links to the song/music. Unfortunately, imeem has been bought and swallowed up by Myspace, but there is always youtube!

136 replies

by jdclyde

You are going to have a hard time convincing me that anyone that is a Britney Spears fan or Ensync fan are looking for excellence on the majority of the fronts.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

great music is subjective. Why drag pop dogs into it until someone else does?

:0 No! One of your boys has gone over to the pop side?! :^0

by oz_media

Most modern music, popular music, has so little excellence it barely registers as music.

The recording process is simply over driven and overcompressed to offer "acceptible MP3 sound" and nothign else.

I won't go on, this would be a very long post if I did, but I agree that while music SHOULD offer excellence in both musucuanship and engineering, most of today's "music" is devoid of both sucj qualities.

The bottom line is that kids don't care anymore. Listening to multitrack Pink Floyd with intense dynamics is not a desire these days, compressing the latest manufcatured jingle is completely acceptable now, from the engineering desk to teh consumer.

You should see some of the low end garbage we've released in North America and had it fly off the shelves in the past few years. Even simply compressing old bed tracks and releasing them as finished material is acceptable.

It's sad.

by drowningnotwaving

Is 'excellence' restricted to some judgement of technical competence?

Is this what you are suggesting??

Seems like a harsh definition you have of excellence, Oz!

:)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

at how incredibly difficult it is for some to grasp that what you said is, "Excellence makes great music."

Unbelievable.

by drowningnotwaving

... it seemed to have created its own sonic boom!! :)

One man's excellence is another's freedom fighter, or something like that.

by jdclyde

There are many songs that people love that have little to do with excellence.

It is like attraction between two people, it just is or isn't, and can't be decided on logically.

by nicknielsen

It's probably some combination of all of the factors you list.

But I know it when I hear it.

by nicknielsen

For some songs, it's the voice that makes it. Janis Joplin or Joe Cocker, for example. For others it's the melody. For even others, it's the instrumentation or the beat. For almost all, the combination of voice, melody, and instrumentation is what makes it good. It's really hard to pick out one thing, although I tend to prefer musically "busy" songs such as those from the Alan Parsons Project and the Big Band era.

Then, there are the songs with such a catchy beat that everybody bops to them, even if they don't admit it:

Low Rider - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8mZdSq4MTs

Brick House - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrBx6mAWYPU

by santeewelding

You gots to be one of them dumb bubs in flyover country.

Don't you get what I'm saying?

Great music applies to the varying scores that animate each of us.

In fits and starts, you are such a one.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Just 'the right' funk. If there have to be lyrics, I want them to speak powerfully to being. I think it's being. I might have called it depth in days of yore.

I like a powerful voice with an intangible unique quality of some kind. Hit the note, don't slide into it, unless the piece calls for it and you're really really good at it.

I'm partial to music of some kinds written in the minor keys.

Hmmm. Yup.

etu
(One of my pet peeves, too)

by captbilly1eye

In that order.
Although it's a combination of equal parts of each that make a song memorable.
For me anyway.

by jdclyde

I have never thought either Joplin or Cocker had the ability to "sing". Is it a generational thing? I have NEVER "got" Dillon, and I don't think someone like Elvis would get his foot in the door if he were just starting out today, but because he was doing something new......

A few of my favorite vocalists.

Queensryche - Jet City Woman (Geoff Tate)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1c8UdpiF_T8

Judas Priest - Diamonds and rust (Rob Halford)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIC7KQPDuDc

Robert Plant - Ship of Fools (Robert Plant)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uc-eDaEZ4LU

Armored Saint - Last Train Home (John Bush)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cDBBb-CzCM0&feature=related

Edit to add: I am not saying there is anything wrong with your choices, and I have long recognized there is a difference between someone not liking something, and something being "bad". The local band I saw last week, the keyboard player and drummer were "bad". :D

by charliespencer

I've always found Joplin, Cocker, and Dylan's 'style' to be grating. I can take or leave the first two. I love Dylan's songs but would prefer to hear someone else's recordings of them; preferably someone who can enunciate.

I could have listened to Karen Carpenter sing the phone book or the periodic table.

by forum surfer

Upon browsing my pc, my girlfriend had no clue who they were?but that could be said of most of my collection.

:)

I still feel that Chris DeGarmo is one of the top 5 guitarists ever. I still break out Operation: Mindcrime Live from time to time and listen in amazement. The arrangement, timing and level of talent was just amazing. I like Geoff Tate, but I feel Chris carried the band with his raw talent in my opinion. When I was young and playing guitar, I could pick out most popular songs and play them but I always needs tab sheets for his music. Except for Silent Lucidity. It was beautiful, melodic, simple and the first song I ever learned to play.

That being said?the recent release of Mindcrime II was a crime against the original. :( The story line was horrible and the musical depth just wasn?t there this go around.

Armored Saint?! That makes two of us who know who they are! I bought "Symbol of Salvation" on tape 3 times because I played it so much. I just recently got all nostalgic and bought myself a drm free legit copy.

by jdclyde

must have been in 83 or 84, and The Warning had just come out. I had already been playing "Prophecy" on my HS radio show regularly, and then added in MN156.

And occasionally a special girl would get "Can you deliver?" dedicated to them..... :D By the time Symbol came out, I was already on to CD's. Still have March of the Saints on LP.

I think it was more DeGarmo's writing than his playing that gave QR their sound, but yes, I love his playing too.

by seanferd

I love that one, and Rage For Order. Never been taken with anything else they've done.

Since I never run into anyone who mentions Queensryche when musical interests are the topic of conversation, I just figured I toss by two bits in here.

cheers

by oz_media

Ironically I just got home after listening to Mindcrime in the truck.

Tate has lost his touch now thogh, last two times I've seen him he was out of his league as he just won't change keys to fit his aging voice,

Nothing against QR, it happens to all musicians eventually, even...sniff, sniff Halford (though he was in top form for the second leg of the last tour). \m/

by jdclyde

how many "slow songs" that everyone slow dances to are actually breakup songs, not love songs?

How many people know what ZZTop are talking in the song "Pearl Necklace"?

by jdclyde

I do enjoy skilled playing. That is one of the reasons I am unable to enjoy "Country music". The majority of it has all the complexity of the Barny theme song.

by charliespencer

it's the lyrics that run me off. I assume everyone know what happens when you play a country song backwards.

by nicknielsen

I've heard country listeners say the same about rock...and they're both wrong. Country and rock music are both complex. The primary difference between them is the different ways to play the same instruments.

For example, rock calls it shredding; country calls it picking, but there's very little technical difference between the two.

by forum surfer

Sorry for the "bub", the kids had me watching X-Men/Wolverine all weekend.

You said you were a fan of Queensryche and Armored Saint. I played some guitar back in those days. While Queensyrche's Chris DeGarmo had some really complex, in depth musicianship...some of his stuff (silent lucidity) was ridiculously simple. So simple that a 14 year old with a cheesy fm radio could pick it out and play it note for note. And Armored Saint? I was and still am a fan, but their music was inherently simple. The person who put the real musical creativity into the group instrumentation wise was Joey Vera, the bassist. I think Metallica even let the guy audition in the 80's. Metallica is one of those love them or hate 'em bands, but no one can deny their musical depth even if they don't like them. They put tons of thought, time, energy and creativity into their music.

by dmambo

I figured it out when I saw a completely unrelated movie on the subject. :O

by jdclyde

They listen to and love my music. Anything from Zep to Mudvayne.

Well, ThingTwo does listen to Greenday.... :0

by ganyssa

the Spawn has gone over to the dark side. His name is Justin Bieber.

I can't access YouTube from work, but I wouldn't do that to you guys anyway. :)

by jdclyde

I know this is a difficult time for you, but you will get through it with support from your friends! :)

by drowningnotwaving

... in 1999 just prior to getting hitched.

Even more perfect was that I didn't have a valid licence and my fiance had to do all the driving - LA - San Diego - Vegas - Canyon - up the back of California to Yosemite, SF and back down Highway 1 to LA. Very relaxing.

Perhaps great music criteria include setting, context and company.

Perhaps another is whether you are driving or not.

Whatever - there was nothing wrong at all with [b]cranked up Greenday[/b] on that trip! Plus that covers album of Carpenters hits. Screamed our heads off.

Excellence indeed.

edit gramma

by charliespencer

Lyrics usually matter to me most; it really gets my attention when someone uses the language skillfully, regardless of subject or style.

This is followed by musical / vocal skills, then the arrangement. I don't dance, so beat and hooks are dead last for me, especially when the rhythm drowns out the vocals. That's the problem I have trying to listen to much current popular music. I'm sure there's some great wordplay going on there, but I just flat out cannot make out what they're saying.

I abhor 'sampling'; it only leaves me wanting to hear the original the sample was taken from.

by jdclyde

being a musician herself, it would have been nice to get her perspective.

And I don't care about if someone gets a hit or sells a billion copies, just a personal issue of what makes something click for YOU.

I get up and dance, but that is more about how cute the girls are than the music, so it does not impact my decision process on what I do or don't like musically.

by oz_media

Me too, however it bring back a lot of revenue for older artists and even starts selling their back catalogues.

There's no hope of teaching youth what quality music consists of, as they feel quality fits in a compressed MP3 track. Even FM radio (which offers far more detail and dynamics than satellite radio) sounds like complete and utter garbage to my snobby ears these days.

Face it, if people are happy hearing 128kb music or even worse, satellite radio (comparitively,17kbps)how can they ever expect to heard real music.

It's like expecting a MacDonald's junkie to appreciate a quality, filet mignon. "Where's the ketchup?" :D

The earless are just like those with peasant taste buds.

by Member 25348569

first and foremost. Probably why I'm so fond of good Blues.

Must admit that I like stuff to be original and well performed. Karaoke - and that includes American Idol and X-Factor - doesn't do it for me at all. I rarely like covers, however good technically, more than the original.

Never thought about it before but lyrics come a long way down the list for me.

:D

by charliespencer

I can only think of a couple cases where I prefer the cover to the original. One is Gladys Knight's version of 'The Way We Were'.

Geez, I guess maybe that's the whole list.

by dmambo

Those are 2 bands I like, but as far as lyrics go, I rarely have any idea what their meanings are.

by seanferd

Way back, Stipe used to have some sort of problem with people caring what the lyrics were at all.

by jdclyde

I don't like a cover that is a copy of the original. The Judas Priest song I linked to further up was a cover, but I love it. It isn't their usual rocken version, but it is well done (for me).

I was shocked to learn that the Zep song "when the levy breaks" was a cover to an ancient Blues song when Mojo (Mae's hubby) played it on cover night for FNM. The original sounds like wet cats in a bag to me.

by dmambo

I know you don't like Springsteen, for instance, but when I was 15 and heard Born to Run and Thunder Road, it's like he was reading my mind. It was all about getting out and moving on, which I was itching to do at the time.

Later, when I became more socially aware, U2 and Neil Young fit the bill. I also always liked the jangly guitar, so some of the 80's New Wave-ish acts like Talking Heads and Elvis hit me.

On the other hand, Pink Floyd just blew me away when I listened to my older brother's music. Now, I listen to a lot of Blues. Must be that I'm married with kids ;)

Edit - Guilty Pleasure from the 70's - Minnie Riperton, "Lovin' You"

by boxfiddler Hot topic

8-track! [i]Born To Run[/i]. Purchased with Jesse Colin Young's [i]Light Shine[/i]. :^0

by nicknielsen

I've never owned one. Just one more way in which I failed at life in the 70s.

I don't know what the guys I hung with were doing to their players, but I kept hearing the wrong adjacent tracks (e.g. 2/3 instead of 1/2). Nothing quite like hearing the intro to In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida from one channel and the drum solo from the other...at the same time.

I went straight to cassette.

by jdclyde

Something about the way Springsteen's style of singing, I have never liked anything he did, still don't.

Guilty pleasure, hmmm, will have to think about that one.

by Member 25348569

in a concert at the Albert Hall in London. Along with Richard Wright, his guests were David Bowie, Robert Wyatt and Crosby and Nash.

I ordered the DVD five minutes after it had finished and I'd got my breath back...

Neil :)

Not a bad gig for bunch of wrinkly old farts!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FM0Pl80Zf00

When Gilmour's guitar cuts in the hairs stand up on the back of my neck - just as they have every time I hear it. OK, that pretty much defines what I want from music.

by nicknielsen

I've had the set for just over a year and never get tired of it. If it was on tape, I'd have had to replace it by now.

Pity I have to go back out, or I'd watch it again tonight. :D

What I'm waiting for is having enough saved up to buy a player [u]just[/u] for my Pink Floyd collection. Once I have that... B-)

by dmambo

Take this example from back in the olden times. I don't think I ever met anybody who would classify himself as a fan of the band Foreigner, yet they were very popular for a few years. I don't know much about the technical aspect of music, but I wouldn't exactly call their music nuanced or complex. Who was buying this stuff at the time? I'm sure there are many other examples (Britney Spears??), but this one has always stood out to me.

by ganyssa

lost me at 4, which is exactly when all of my friends figured out who they were.

Sadly, I just learned that Mariah Carey covered I Want to Know What Love Is. It's on Sirius right now.

by nicknielsen

How many people know Kansas released 3 albums before "Leftoverture"? I much prefer those albums to what came later, much as I prefer the early Foreigner.

by charliespencer

The tractor starts running, the bank refinances the farm, the cows hoof-and-mouth clears up, your brother-in-law gets out of jail, your daughter stops drinking, your wife quits running around, Grandma stops chewing tobacco...

by jdclyde

I explained to him MY definition of Country Music.

Metallica on a back road.

by jdclyde

but when I ask the average Country fan to tell me a great guitar player, most can't.

When I ask them to name a drummer, most can't.

When I ask them to name a bass player, most can't.

Most that I have heard is more someone (a hired gun, so it doesn't matter who they are) playing a ride for filler behind the vocals, usually singing a song they bought from a writer.

And as for shredding, I am not just talking "screaming guitars". Dire Straights and Clapton, (solo or with a band) are also examples of non=shredding yet well played music.

I do love to hear Steve Vai play though. There are a lot of great shredders, but he is one of the most creative I have heard.

by charliespencer

"...when I ask the average Country fan to tell me a great guitar player, most can't."

Chet Atkins. Geez, I don't listen to country music and I'm not a guitar aficionado, and even I can get that one right.

by oz_media

Static X, too many funny stories with them. Just reading the name brings me flashbacks of the B stage on the OzzFest tour with Primus and Zombie. I knew they would get picked up right before that tour, and won all bets, despite their lack of longevity.

by jdclyde

those were examples of vocalists I enjoy.

As for music, complexity in and of its self does not greatness make.

by jdclyde

Although I do recall going over to Dads and he would have a Reel to reel going.

In an early car, I remember ONE that had 8-track "sky rockets in flight! Afternoon delighhhighht!"

From there, it was mostly cassettes and LP's for him, and I got most of his LP's when he passed.

by nicknielsen

Female blues vocalists seem to have much better voices than the males. Give a listen to Billie Holiday, Etta James, or Aretha if you haven't already.

If you ask me (and you did ;) ), the best female vocalist out there has for years been Pat Benatar. The woman has a voice!

by dmambo

Comparing Billie Holiday and Aretha's voices to anyone is like comparing a fine French Poodle to a stray mongrel.

Diana Krall also has a nice set of pipes.

by av .

I think music is great if it inspires you in some way. It doesn't matter how its achieved. Maybe the song has great vocals or a catchy beat. Maybe the musicians have a lot of style. If you can relate to the song, its great music.

AV

by jdclyde

it is just curious to me on how people come to their choices, and if they even know themselves.

And as we have seen here, people look for different things.

by steve.hascall

I Bough a brand spanking new Dokorder 12" Real to Real. I was rockin Dudes. I used to take my LP's and record them through the Real to Real and used "echo on". It would add an echo chamber effect to the sound track, and to me made it way more intense. I over wrote Styx, Deep Purple, Foghat, The original Reo SpeedWagon, Nazareth Foreigner (sorry),38 Special...etc..

For some reason adding the echo to those early sounds which I already loved made them seem even more magical, and enhanced.

Also anything Stevie Nixs, Ann, and Nancy Wilson sang at that time was Golden.

(I warned you)

by drowningnotwaving

.. in a discussion like this is someone putting forward their opinion only to have someone else disagree!!!

To which, I was (tongue-slightly-in-cheek) similarly guilty!

by jdclyde

No one here is going to be offended by you not liking something they do.

It is only the ignorant idiots that confuse them not liking something with it not being good. Or as the kids say, "that sucks!" just because they don't like it. :D

Sure, I tease the people that like Country, because I can. B-)

by drowningnotwaving

... is to be open to new music, and new influences that may not necessarily be new musicians, with the same zeal I had when I was 20 years old. Which is nearly 30 years ago.

Gets harder every year, but sometimes it's worth the effort.

by jdclyde

is a "hardest problem". :D

I actually am the opposite, and am MORE open to new music every year.

I loath rap more and more each year too.

by oz_media

But the recording itself is anything but excellence.

My harsh definition is the result of too many years at an engineering desk, trying to reproduce the excellence that comes out of the mikes. I admit that, as an audiophile, I have a very snobbish ear for sound, I hear flaws all the time that my friend's don't hear until pointed out to them, then they can't stand it either.

I really PO others in the studio when I ask them to edit a track over and over again because they can't hear two instruments are off the click track by 50 milliseconds, it just jumps right out at me now though.

by nicknielsen

that regardless of the quality of the performance, it's the quality of the recording that determines whether or not that performance was "excellent"?

Sounds awfully cold-blooded to me, Oz.

One of the most awesome live performances I ever heard was bootlegged using a portable cassette deck and the internal condenser mic. The recording sucked, but it allowed the person who recorded it (and me) to relive the original performance several times before the live tapes were released.

etu

by oz_media

And I am actually sharing this???

I had backstage passes to a ZZTop show circa 2001, they were the oddest passes I'd ever seen. A picture of an eye, a picture of bird and a picture of a sea captain, printed vertically on a stick-on pass.

After the show, I was talking to Billy Gibbons about his art collection when I heard the guy I was working for having an argument with ZZTop's PR agent, then he stormed out of the room. They never did get along and I was really into talking to Billy, so I just ignored it and stayed to hang out with their INCREDIBLE looking dancers and the roadies, not knowing the joke was on me the whole time.

Apparently, as I later found out, their agent was having a laff(at my expense too of course) by leaving us a set of girl's passes at WillCall.

The pictures were actually an "EYE" a "SWALLOW" and a "SEAMAN" :(

But they were really cool guys all the same and it was their best show I've ever seen.

by jdclyde

because they could..... :D

Figured there was a message, and was trying to figure it out before I got to the explanation.

So, did you? :p

by forum surfer

Yeah I loaded up my mp3 player last night with Mindcrime (and AIC Dirt since I was feeling nostalgic) and went to the gym with it after this discussion. I had the strange urge to assassinate local political figures afterward lol.

Singers have to change as they get older, plain and simple. I caught a show while I was down in Florida once for kicks and giggles. Lynard Skynard and 3 Doors Down. Wow, best accidental performance I've ever seen. Those guys put on one of the best shows I have ever seen in person. Blew away many of the "superstar" shows I've seen...but I never really saw the superstars in their prime.

Another live performance I truly enjoyed was Disturbed. Free tickets, so I figured it beat sitting at home that night. They are actually very well talented musically and their live performance made me a fan. I bought their music not long afterward. Their singer will drastically need to adjust his style as he gets older.

by jdclyde

Saw them a few years back and they were dead on, vs in the 80's when it was more about sex/drugs/and more sex than it was about the music. Now it is about their retirement fund.

:D

by shasca

"Gypsy Woman's Passion" ? 5:17
"157 Riverside Avenue" ? 3:57
"Anti-Establishment Man" ? 5:21
"Lay Me Down" ? 3:51
"Sophisticated Lady" ? 4:00
"Five Men Were Killed Today" ? 3:00
"Prison Women" ? 2:36
"Dead at Last" ? 10:08

by jellimonsta

I am fine with you promoting my band wherever you want. :D
In all seriousness, there are many things to me that make a song hit home. Being a vocalist I do focus a lot on the vocals, but pretty much every other consideration mentioned by others is relevant too, musicianship, complexity, composition, performance, hook, beat/ rhythm, etc.