What makes for great music?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Social Networking Forum
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jdclyde
If a song is a perfect fit for something in your life, it just grabs a hold and won't let go.
How are things going with the band?
by jellimonsta
We haven't had a consistent practice schedule since before Christmas. Things are settling down a little more now though, so we should be getting back into the swing of it soon.
We need to get back to being show ready. We were ready to play out in November, but have played so little since then, we are not so much right now. :0
... to that person, in that context, at that time.
At least that's how I interpreted Santee's "excellence" in this instance - as completely irrational, subjective and beyond definition as the attraction that you mention JD.
But it is fun trying! good subject! :)
by jdclyde
it would be a beloved song for more than a few months, but rather decades if not a lifetime.
I still listen to most of the music I was listening to 30 years ago. I just keep adding to the list.
For something to "fall away", it must not have been so excellent, huh?
I had a drummer and producer get into a brawl in a studio once, with the producer screaming (between air-swings, of course):
[i]Just because you want a "Live" sound doesn't mean you can make mistakes you furckin moron![/i]
Plus I know also that when I played in bands I found it near on impossible to go and see another band and just enjoy the gig. Always had to over-analyse every single aspect of the stage, lights, sound, performance and all. Took years to get over that.
So I kind of get what you mean.
But sometimes I like the live sound with the mistakes as well! You can take the boy out of the suburbs but ... :)
to prescribe your own drugs ???!!!
Is that actually true - you can get onto internet pharmacies and get your own prescriptions?
If so, with apologies to Santee - EXCELLENT!!
by oz_media
No, thats not a all what I was saying. In fact it is almost the opposite.
Firstly the question itseslf is ridiculous, secondly I haver ptretty much avoided it due to replies such as yours.
Unlike IT, there is no definitive answer as to what defines art. You will not get it compartmentalized to be analyzed.
by nicknielsen
I apparently skipped past your title.
My initial answer is almost the same: I can't explain what makes music great, but I know great music when I hear it.
by oz_media
{riest have NEVER been on the sex and drugs trip.
KK was a bit of a mover and shaker with the ladies but they were never one of those bands. It has always been about the music,
Halford's voice gets a lot more post processing these days, hearing it at teh sound desk and then hearing it in the audience are two very different things.
If you hear him sing archipello, he has to slow down and really work. When he's on stage, post processing with chorus effects keep him hittings keys he really doesn't hit himself, without a little help.
He has learned to drop a key, just as teh band has also, and you don't really realize it is even being performed in a lower key.
His voice had become more finely tuned over the last three years though, due to extensive touring with Priest again (Two, Fight and Halford did not help his voice at all).
In 2006 I was on a few dates with them and it was rough but able to be cleaned at the desk. I was on quite a few more dates with them in 2007 and there was a HUGE difference. The desk did very little work on his voice and instead played with background effects such as demonic tones echoing him through some songs while he nailed the notes. Of the last dozen shows I have been to with them between 05 and 07, their bext performance was in Victoria BC.
So good they almost entirely stripped his vocal support, as you can hear on their last CD Live Evil.
But backstage sex and drugs? Not these guys.
Saturday night I'm hanging with Rob and Steve from Anvil as they wrap up in North America. Oz is here in Canada right now too and the Olympics will be underway, so it will definitley be a serious sex drugs and rock n roll backstage howler with them. Oz is happy because he's been in the UK long enough to get his drinking up to speed with Brits again, last time Steve drank him under the table in Birmingham. (Oz is really focused as a musician not a drunk though, so it's always been easier working with his bands).
by oz_media
More than one guy in that audience tweaking out on acid. :D
You're right though neil.
Another act you have to catch is the Australian cover band Pink Floyd Experience.
They are so good that Gilmour endorses them and they are allowed to tour using the REAL Pink Floyd pig, backing videos etc. They usually play midsize venues, under <8K seats and fill them for several consecutive shows.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1QrwihUzjU
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FKFB8LRDgP0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJBAxk9WQAo&feature=related
Seriously, search out a bunch of their stuff on YouTube, they really do go for the full pull and are note perfect.
by shasca
In the late 70's. These days I like.... I Like..... Um less see Pink rocks a little.
Oh kay I'm done there isn't hardly anything that doesn't get old after listening to it say ten times. Thats assuming it may have sparked a bit of interest after couple of plays on the Radio 99.9 kppl.
I have a free download for 3 songs on MSN Music that I have had for 2 yrs now. I haven't been inspired to redeem it yet.
I must be becoming tone deaf............
by shasca
by nicknielsen
[i]There are many songs that people love that have little to do with excellence.[/i]
What is your definition of musical "excellence" and why should it apply to me?
by jdclyde
it isn't just a whim or a fad.
As I just wrote above, it will stay with you.
by nicknielsen
Some of the classic female blues singers had some great voices: Ma Rainey, Sippie Wallace, Ethel Waters, and Bessie Smith can all compare to Billie and Aretha.
Shemekia Copeland, Marcia Ball and Susan Tedeschi are some of the great female voices in blues today.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by jdclyde
by nicknielsen
Sweet Child of Innocence - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_FcHC0GZzw
This one rocks in that inimitable Kansas fashion.
Down The Road - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ApGw7G9vLHU
Another rocker
The title track from Song for America and Incomudro-Hymn to the Atman are also faves, but more for their orchestration than beat, although they rock too.
by jdclyde
Sweet child of innocent, more echo and keyboards than I am used to, and down the road just isn't as clean as I expect out of them.
Again, just my preferences, based upon my experiences.
Wow, that is a lot of keyboard driven music. :) I realize that is what was popular at the time. It does kind of make me think of the heavy keys in Uriah Heap.
Easy living
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfldLLadNWk&feature=related
by nicknielsen
And the songwriter difference between the albums. Plus, as you point out, the times and musical tastes were different.
It's all good. Hey, it's over four hours past my bedtime and I've got Godsmack on the stereo right now.
by nicknielsen
... my apology for using one of your favourite band's name in vain even if tongue-in-cheek!
I should have focussed my ridicule on Toto and Chicago.
I'll do better next time. :)
by jdclyde
I do consider Sully a vocalist rather than a singer though, but I really do enjoy it. :)
Am also a big fan of when they do the dueling drums. It is so rare to find an enjoyable drum solo.
by jdclyde
Yes, I'm a musician, but it's crazy how different the music is that I write/play vs. the music I listen to.
Music I write and/or learn to play is limited to my guitar skills. So, it's mostly folk, ballads, and pop music. More often than not, I create the music first, and depending on the feel or the emotion of the music, the lyrics follow. I know some folks write lyrics first, like a very touching poem, but that rarely works for me.
As for which is more important (music or lyrics), I truly think it depends on the song. I can be extremely moved by an instrumental piece, and I can also get goosebumps by an artist singing a cappella if they have a good voice and the lyrics are powerful.
Now, on the total flip side, I mostly listen to techno, dance music, and rap/R&B. A lot of techno doesn't have many lyrics - just high energy beats that play over and over and can (honestly) get a little monotonous. But I absolutely LOVE to dance, and that kind of music can't help but make me move.
Ultimately, music preferences are very much an individual thing. The only kind of music I really don't care for is country, but I can appreciate how much other enjoy it. There's no good or bad... just different preferences.
I don't think Miley Cyrus, the Black Eyed Peas, or Beyonce would be worth my time regardless of the compression or playback system.
Incidentally, I have no appreciation for a 'quality' filet (or almost any other piece of cow). But I know this, and will politely suggest in advance my host not waste his money on me. I'd prefer a grilled burger, with some bleu or sharp cheddar, a good brown mustard, and a fresh jalapeno.
by jdclyde
go see some live local bands and you will quickly change your mind! :D There are plenty of "bad" examples out there!
B-)
by nicknielsen
by nicknielsen
In my case, part of it is just not caring any more. Music plays a less important role in my entertainment options.
Part of it is the targeting of radio stations to specific audiences. Maybe I'm misremembering, but I recall the AM stations of my youth playing a wider range of genres than what stations play today. These days you wouldn't hear a range like Alice Cooper, the Temptations, and Neil Diamond on the same station. I realize those playlists were strongly influenced by the record labels (legally and illegally), but it seemed to make it easier to be exposed to a variety of styles.
I know the Internet offers a huge number of selections, but I suffer from 'paralysis by analysis' and don't know where to start. Combine that with my overall decline in interest, and that cheap thrill when the radio offers a tune I haven't thought of in years, and I just can't motivated about music over the Internet. It just looks like too much work.
by oz_media
Personal taste shouldn't play a part. I agree that they are talentless and thus there is no excellence involved.
THis is also why I dimissed the topic as a dead end question already. There is no way to determine excellence in art.
But any artist will agree, that in order to properly display excellence, if initially present, is to have engineering and producing excellence to do it justice. A monotone photocopy of a Renoir just isn't going to cut it.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending