Your suggestion, by the way, that we subscribe to discussions if we want to keep track of them is not much of a solution. I'll explain:
I'm signed up for a number of the TR newsletters. Once in a while, I get wind of an old discussion to which I'd subscribed being revived, so I go check it out. Sometimes, there's new activity there, and I think "Neat! This was a good topic of discussion!"
Then, I notice that I've missed a good couple of weeks' worth of discussion -- because I'm [b]unsubscribed[/b]. It seems that, after a few weeks, TR sometimes just "forgets" I was subscribed to a discussion. The result of this is that I have no idea whether there are dozens of discussions out there continuing without me despite my interest in them, because my subscription to them has evaporated.
When I first started noticing this problem, I thought maybe it was due to a recent change at TR that reset some of my discussion subscriptions. That's obviously not the case, though -- because I've noted on a couple of occasions that my subscriptions to the same discussion has dropped [b]more than once[/b].
I like TR. I like the community of discussion here, and I like some of the staffers as individual people. I like some of the differences in UI from the rest of CNET -- differences that make it about 300% more usable than most other CNET properties. There's a lot to like about TR.
I also find that technical difficulties mount up. After a while, some of them start looking like insurmountable barriers to my ability to maintain interest. Worse yet, the max post depth issue was something that literally dozens of users have expressed a keen interest in getting changed and, when that change finally came (it appears not to have happened by accident), everyone who said anything about it where I could see was quite keen on it. It was, bar none, the single most popular new feature of TR discussions [b]ever[/b] in my time at TR, from what I could tell -- and before I joined with this account in 2003 I had actually been a TechProGuild member for a while since -- well, I don't remember exactly off the top of my head, but I think it was late '99 or early 2000. That's a long time to see no new features that people seemed to like as much as a reply depth greater than seven replies.
. . . and yet, this functionality was [b]intentionally eliminated[/b]. I understand that there may be reasons for this change that are not obvious to us, the users. Those reasons could include corporate bureaucracy and pointy-haired bosses at the central CNET offices. They could involve poor scalability on the part of the Jive software. They could just involve a mandate that the threading of the discussion should never be allowed to wrap around or get all crunched up against the right margin.
It doesn't change the fact that the [b]users[/b] -- at least some non-trivial subset of users -- are frustrated not only with functionality that not only is broken but actively works against the work-arounds we might use to solve other broken functionality issues (as in the case of subscribing to a discussion not always working because of mysterious unsubscription occurring without our wanting it to), but also with the fact that a long-time desired favorite feature was intentionally removed.
You might even have good intentions and great goals in mind in removing the feature -- but, considering its obvious popularity with discussion regulars, one would think you'd want to come up with a [b]different[/b] fix for the problems you associate with the feature than to simply eliminate it. Maybe there's no easy way to get that better fix, for whatever reason, but:
You really shouldn't be surprised, under the circumstances, that people appear on the verge of revolt. Yes, people might not know the details of what's going on behind the scenes there at TR, but [b]they do know that their needs as customers are not being met[/b]. In the end, that trumps the difficulties of trying to meet those needs -- the reason the needs aren't being met will be less important to the users than the [b]fact[/b] they are not being met.
I'm willing to understand, and to be sympathetic, but just like anyone else there will come a time when I'll go build a reputation and community involvement somewhere else instead if TR becomes too frustrating to use, no matter how much I might [b]want[/b] to believe it's still serving my needs.
I'm not saying I'm going anywhere. I'm just not saying I never will go anywhere, either -- and that it might be helpful to understand that deepsand's obvious frustration with things here isn't just a result of being an a-hole (even if he is one sometimes -- hi, deepsand, no offense).
In short: Yes, we want to understand your position. We want you to understand ours, too -- and, from what I've seen, at least 80% of your discussion-generating userbase (measured in the amount of discussion generated, not necessarily in number of people generating discussion) has the same opinion about max depth. I'm using a little inductive logic, inferring a bit, to arrive at this conclusion, but I think these are realistic and reasonable inferences.
edit: Discussion, from what I've seen, is the biggest single reason that TR is positively differentiated from other CNET properties. Keep that in mind when weighing the trade-offs.