Discussion Locked

Where do TR Discussions fall in the business plan?

0 helpful
217 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have had for a very long time, issues (others have) with double posting.

I have had all week, had problems getting into discussions. Over half the time, I only get this message:

[i]"The page you've requested cannot be found.

For a listing of our latest articles, please go to the TechRepublic front page.[/i]

Funny, I go to the other sections of TR, and they load up just fine. hmmmmmmm.

We can't get this fixed, but it is important enough to take the time to remove the "fix" for the arbitrarily assigned "Max level" for discussions? I am surprised that functionality wouldn't have a higher priority? While on that topic, if you feel it so critical to break the fix, why would you have not at the same time done the simple fix of making it if you reply, it puts your reply under the last one instead of making people do the dance of finding the last post two screens up, that was one level lower?

Was there a problem going beyond this apparently arbitrary max level that we are unaware of?

Will the access get fixed as quickly as taking that feature away was?

Why is it only the discussion section seems to be hit by this?

It would be nice if an official source would answer these questions, either here or in a peer message.

thanks,

jdclyde
former TR addict

217 replies

by jdclyde

GG, as well as others here, have repeatedly asked for a few more to be available.

Is it a licensing issue that you don't want to pay for a set? I am sure if that is the case, the members would design you ones that could be used free.

If not, a simple explanation WHY you won't do something like that goes a long way. People don't mind things if they know there is a reason for it.

jd
former TR addict

by jdclyde

When I went from :
[i]
The page you've requested cannot be found.
[/i]
to
[i]
This feature is currently unavailable due to server maintenance.
We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.[/i]

someone was working on something. and wow, I can get into a discussion.... for now.

how about answering the other questions?

jd
former TR addict

by gadgetgirl

none of the tabs worked, not just forums.

I've had a few more "than usual" 404's lately but page load times are extending.

The "churn" on PFMC and the main discussions page is getting slower by the day - can someone put some more money in the meter please, in the hopes it speeds it up?

Yeah, more 'moticons. jd - you're seconded!

I'm sure the last time the "maintenance" bit was pulled on us, someone on here said he'd give us a heads up before they did that again.... if I can find that post, I'll link it here.... nearly sure it was JP....

I'd love to go back to the days of the TRI-ers. At least we got to give some input into proposed changes, and Jay (bless) would tip us off where possible of necessary downtime. Ah yes. The good old days.....

I'm the same as you, jd. I'm not on here nearly as much as I used to be. Which is a shame. I like this place. Got some good mates. But it's gradually becoming more and more unworkable.

Another former TR addict

GG

by jdclyde

at least for me, was just the fact that it is so easy to not find an interesting discussion until after the coals have cooled and the party is over.

[b]If nothing else, the useless section to the right where it shows members online, replace and give the new or hot discussion list back. Does anyone care to see who is online?[/b]

And lets not forget, the changes that drove Jaqui away. The day they [b]chased him out[/b] by REQUIRING java to post, was a huge loss for the TR community.

jd
former TR addict

by shellbot

everything you guys said..goes for me as well.

Ok, I know that there are bound to be quirks and sometimes you just cannot control some things..but man..when they mess with things that work it really p1sses me off.

the posting levels are driving me mad..ever since they changed it, my posts are ending up wherever..AKA not where i want it to be.
the amount of times my posts go up a few levels to a different tree is starting to get on my nerves.. i end up looking like a right dumbass for posting to the wrong thread.

If they'd just leave the stuff alone!! However the new "view all posts" is pretty good..except for the fact that it doesn't format correctly!!!!!

anywhos..

yet another former TR addict

by jdclyde

I do like that you can view them all AND choose to reply right from there. To bad the state of finding discussions is so off that I had been using the feature for a week before I saw Smortys post telling us about the new feature.

The only thing missing is a check box or something that would make the posts show up as read when you come back in normal view.

I USED to do the print mode, read them, and then open the posts in new windows and close them right away, but when it takes two to three minutes for some pages to load, that just isn't an option at TR anymore.

jd
former TR addict

by shellbot

Its not been the same without him.

We've lost a few good people....
Maybe we should start a "dearly departed" thread to remember those who have met that fork in the road

by jdclyde

It is bad enough losing people like Jessie because of life changes, but to lose Jaqui over java?

by beth blakely

Not that I think you're going to be satisfied with any of these, but here goes...

Community sometimes goes down while other parts of the site are fine because there are multiple systems. There's not a singular fix that can cure all the reasons why we have outages.

Community was down for less than 15 minutes this morning. The outage was unexpected and we regret any inconvenience it may have caused. We couldn't warn you because we didn't know it was going to happen.

You found a way to do something we don't want you to do; post beyond the max limit. When you do that, it makes our "view all" posts page look hideous.

The fix for this hack was quick and easy, therefore it made it out fairly quickly. Done and done.

by shellbot

of catering for IT peolpe isn't it :)

If it can be done, someone will find a way!

fair enough..things go down, happens to the best of us...

as for quick and easy changes..surely the formatting for view all can be sorted?? Throw a few line feeds into it??

by jdclyde

in the normal post, you don't have to add the html <.BR><.BR> to get a break between paragraphs [i]( dot was put in so it would show code, not give a break )[/i]

As soon as you look at it outside of the post, or add other html code to it, then you HAVE to do your own breaks and such.

I don't see that one going anywhere.

by jdclyde

if you click on the "go back to message", it takes you back, and then takes you right back to the page:

[i]"You cannot reply to this message.

Go back to message."[/i]

So, not only did they STOP us from doing something they [i]"don't want you to do"[/i], they are PUNISHING us for trying it in the future! :D

by jdclyde

The few minutes it was actually down this morning was not my complaint. The fact that all week, more than not, when I would go to a discussion to read a post, I got the page not found error.

I understand if a server goes down, but that, like I said, was the smallest of my concerns.

As for the max, why isn't there a happy medium to be found? Why stop at THAT level? And, as I have been saying for over a year, why not give the option to reply ANYWAYS, and just keep it at the max level, just thrown at the end of that thread?

by w2ktechman

even if they add a couple more levels, we would complain for more after a short period of time. Although adding 2 more levels should take most of the problems away.

by deepsand

Firstly, we, the [b]members[/b] value Function [u]over[/u] Form. Which is of greater import; your staff's perception of how a page looks, or that of the users' re. its usability?

Secondly, it must be noted that, with the exception of adding Reply buttons, the "View All" screen added nothing that was not already available via the earlier "Print" screen. On the other hand, usability took a big hit, owing to the fact that the white space within Posts, [u]including [b][/b][/u], has been removed, resulting long posts with multiple paragraphs becoming quite unreadable.

Members [u]quickly[/u] called this to your attention. Is this a difficult problem to fix? [b]No[/b], it is not. Has this problem yet been fixed? [b]No[/b], it has not. Therefore, to say that plugging our work-around for the max. depth was done so quickly [i]simply[/i] owing to it's being an "easy" fix rings hollow.

Members have repeatedly reported many other problems which serve to greatly reduce the usability of this site, many of which arose with its recent re-design. Examples include:

1) The "90 days" listing of Updates within one's Workspace stops well short of 90 days.

2) The "All" listing of Updates within one's Workspace is likewise truncated.

3) The "All" listing of Discussions within Forums is nothing but a listing of those Discussions which have had the most recent activity, sorted by Date/Time of last activity, and again arbitrarily truncated.

4) The Search function is barely of any use at all, as its scope is limited to certain data elements which are bound to the Root of the Discussion, Article, Blog, etc..

All of these problems serve to make for one's finding a particular thread not merely difficult, but, more often than not, [b]impossible[/b].

As for outages, to say that "Community was down for less than 15 minutes this morning" is to ignore the [b]many hours[/b] that it was [b]down the preceeding day[/b], and the frequency with which this problem occurs.

All of these matters lead to the overarching question; to what extent does CNET really care about what TR's members' pereception re. the usability of this site?

by beth blakely

I'm not going to argue with you. If you don't believe what I'm telling you, so be it. Nothing I can say will change that.

We note and try to address everything that's wrong with the site.

However, I'll say that you are not the only user and if this discussion continues, someone will point out that we shouldn't bother fixing what you've proposed, but this problem, this problem, or this problem.

We pay attention to what you ask for. We try to do what's best for EVERYONE, not just a few people.

by beth blakely

See Jay's post above to understand why I usually let Jay do all the forum posting and answering. Tee hee. I'm such a hot head.

by apotheon

"[i]You found a way to do something we don't want you to do; post beyond the max limit. When you do that, it makes our "view all" posts page look hideous.[/i]"

I hope that's the "official position" you're required to take by the guys upstairs, and not an actual technical decision intended to "make the site better" by the TR staffers. I've noticed that the same max depth rule seems to apply across all (or at least many) CNET properties, which makes me think it's not just a TR decision in this case (especially since the "view all" functionality explicitly allowed posting beyond max depth originally).

The reason I'm so keen on believing it's CNET as a whole, and not TR specifically, that decided to eliminate this functionality is simple:

When the loyal userbase is so keen on functionality, and has been for so long, that it's willing to resort to dirty hacks to keep the feature when it appears temporarily (probably accidentally) and is then removed unceremoniously, that's a strong indicator of how you can best serve those users. The "hideous" appearance to which you refer may be more easily fixed by eliminating the max depth violation, but it is obviously not [b]best[/b] fixed in that manner, since [b]everyone who knew about the URL trick used it[/b], as far as I can tell. Rather than fix the [b]actual[/b] problem -- the fact that the forum software doesn't seem to handle max depth violations without turning the site into hash -- you have, instead, "fixed" the additional functionality that was obviously more important to the userbase than superficialities like whether everything was lined up in neat, orderly rows.

That shows a distinct lack of ability to serve the users' wants and needs effectively.

by tig2

I can take this a step further.

Beth- I will start with saying that I think that Apotheon is correct- the minute I knew how to violate "Max Depth", I did. Many joined me or were already there.

We actively warned people to not post the "fix" because we were afraid that what DID happen, WOULD happen. And we were right.

But it never stopped us from peer mailing contacts to tell them how to do it.

Please understand that I have no intent to slam you or TR on this- only to confirm Apotheon's assertions that this is a VERY desirable feature. We get some pretty hot discussions going and being able to directly relate your post to the one you are replying to is a key usability point.

Another element is that the mechanism that has been installed to keep us from posting beyond max is broken. The fix was not nearly as painless as may have been thought. Those of us that found it were required to do many things, up to re-booting to get out of the loop.

We are all big boys and girls and could have taken it if we had gotten a community post telling us that we had been bad and the functionality had been taken away.

At the end of the day, I have a number of ways that I keep an eye on the things that I have an interest in. It isn't always easy but it is do-able from my perspective. I would like to see some additional functionality but can live without it. However, it would be really great if we could find a way to communicate effectively between ourselves- the Community and TR. I think that such communication would ease many of these threads.

My two cents...

by beth blakely

I was in a meeting about that "useless section" yesterday. I'm trying my best to get something done about that. Business moves slowly and it frustrates me far more than it does you, I promise. This is my job, remember?

It's really easy to sit back and criticize things from your point of view. From your perch, I'm sure it all looks simple. From my seat, it's not.

All I can say, over and over, is that I work hard every day to try and give you the best environment possible.

by jdclyde

and I do not blame you or the other techs. You do not make the decisions that affect us, but work within the guidelines that are bestowed upon you from on high.

This, in no way, was meant to be a slam against you Beth.

I have my own users to support, and know exactly what it is like, so no, I am neither on a perch, nor do I think it looks simple.

off to read your other post.

jd
former TR addict

by f4a6pilot

1st suggestion no Java. - It sucks and is slow and requires a ton of overhead.

2nd suggestion - don't require MS internet explorer. it sucks and has memory leaks and takes up too many resources.

3rd suggestion - bring back the sort on forums.

4th suggestion put discussions in an Oracle DB and store indices as their relevance, keyword, age, etc. then publish the DB schema so the public can fill in the gaps in your product with mods W-O-W style....

by jdclyde

If they have a coder that doesn't understand the internet, and codes ANYTHING that will only work in IE, then I do not need/want that feature. It would also call into question the tech knowledge that is running this tech site.

What problem have you been having, and with which browser?

1st suggestion is right on-spot though.

by deepsand

We here question, not your personal commitment to providing TR's members with a useful & easily used site, but that of your masters, CNET.

Keep in mind tht many, if not most of us, here are [b]not[/b] simply geeks isolated from the real world.

by beth blakely

because you're not in it.

And my "masters" are not here listening to you, I am.

I don't have to keep in mind that you're not "simply geeks isolated from the real world" because I would never think such a thing. Geeks run the world. DUH!

And, by the way, the bold isn't necessary.

by maecuff

Next time, make a few disparaging comments regarding JD's manhood. It would be satisfying for you and fun for us! Everybody wins!

by now left tr

To replace this by punishment for possible future crimes is to replace the rights of citizens and the possibility of equal treatment!

by jdclyde

yep!

And your point is?

[i](besides the point at the tip of your pointy little head, that is?) :D

by maecuff

and the point on top of my head only adds to my overall attractiveness. On others, maybe not so much, but it works for me.

by w2ktechman

I have Java disabled in FF on several systems. I can post from each, but I have a few display issues and a nasty message stating that I need to use Java on the site. So far, it has still been working though

by deepsand

While crusing CNET's home site, I see that someone there seems to be enamored of Flash.

I'm guessing that they never found the need to copy & paste screen content.

by w2ktechman

as I only have 1 system with Flash installed, and it is ready for a rebuild.

if posts required it, I would not be posting much at all since that is my home XP media center box that rarely gets turned on anymore.

by apotheon

I don't even have Java installed on any of my systems that have Firefox (my browser of choice) installed. If Java was required to post, I wouldn't be posting here.

Period.

by w2ktechman

I was wondering if some parts of Java were actually enabled after reading that we needed Java to post.
My only problems are sometimes the page display is off a bit, and on the top of the screen it tells me that I need Java.
But posting has worked fine for me.

by deepsand

"[i]I'm not going to argue with you. If you don't believe what I'm telling you, so be it. Nothing I can say will change that.[/i]"

Argue re. what? I simply asked that you address specifics re. members' experiences which give rise to their perceptions that our words fall on deaf ears.

"[i]However, I'll say that you are not the only user and if this discussion continues, someone will point out that we shouldn't bother fixing what you've proposed, but this problem, this problem, or this problem.[/i]"

The changes that resulted in the great difficulties in finding threads were [b]not[/b] the result of TR's members having requested such. And, not only have many others addressed these issues & asked that they be fixed, [b]none have argued in their favor[/b]!

"[i]We try to do what's best for EVERYONE, not just a few people.[/i]"

Please refrain from attempting to cast this as an issue of myself vs other members. And, please note that what is best for "everyone" [b]is[/b] that which is in the interest of [b]the few who regularly participate[/b].

by beth blakely

First of all, you said my explanation for why the fix happened quickly rang hollow. That's what I don't want to argue about.

Secondly, I would caution you about assuming you know everything about this situation simply because you're a part of a group of regular participants. You don't know what our stats say, you don't know the constraints that we're under due to platform issues, advertising requirements, staffing, project queues, etc. etc. etc.

For all you know, the "changes that resulted in the great difficulties in finding threads" WERE the result of TR's members having requested such or site usage statistics indicating such changes were necessary. Surely you don't think that we rely on forums alone for such feedback?

"Participation" is not defined purely as "posting." We must serve all our members, whether they're blog readers, downloaders, or what have you.

I am not trying to cast this as a "you vs. them" issue. I'm trying to make you understand that the voice of the regular posters is but one part of the TechRepublic experience.

by jdclyde

[i]"the voice of the regular posters is but one part of the TechRepublic experience"[/i]

As I pointed out, all of the problems I have had all week were exclusive to opening discussions.

Finding the discussions while they are current, and as Sandy pointed out, re-finding them later, is a real task. This was pointed out at the time of the change to the new format, but I have yet to see anything to improve this situation.

If it is not important enough to CNET that will not be addressed, say so.

It just seems like the discussions side of TR has been of less and less importance. As no one has seen fit to share the statistics you are referencing, we have no choice but to come out and ask, [b]are we just not important in the grand scheme of things?

by deepsand

"[i]I would caution you about assuming you know everything about this situation simply because you're a part of a group of regular participants. You don't know what our stats say, you don't know the constraints that we're under due to platform issues, advertising requirements, staffing, project queues, etc. etc. etc.[/i]"

We here make no assumptions re. those matters to which we are not privy. We are also aware of the fact that you are ultimately answerable only to your masters. As above noted, we do not question the personal motivations or dedication of either yourself or your co-workers; rather, we question those of CNET.

"[i]For all you know, the "changes that resulted in the great difficulties in finding threads" WERE the result of TR's members having requested such or site usage statistics indicating such changes were necessary. Surely you don't think that we rely on forums alone for such feedback?[/i]"

Site usage statistics serve to describe the "what" & "how" of page/file requests; they do no & cannot discern the "why."

The "why" is discernible only from feedback from users, which can come from either Posts to Discussions or via e-mails. Are you suggesting that there were a significant number of the latter that stood in opposition to those sentiments exhibited by the former?

"[i]"Participation" is not defined purely as "posting." We must serve all our members, whether they're blog readers, downloaders, or what have you.[/i]"

With respect to Discussions, "Participation" [b]is[/b] "Posting." Without the latter, Discussions do not exist. [i]Q.E.D.[/i], the needs of those who Post to Discussions are necessarily of paramount import to the continued existence of said Forum.

As an aside, it should be noted that the specific problems that I above mentioned were openly discussed, with the promise that some were being worked on, thereby giving rise to expectations by us that have yet to be met. Needless to say, unfulfilled promises, or the appearance of promise, give rise to doubts as to the standing of TR's members.

The core question here is this; what value does CNET place on the TR Discussion forum?

by beth blakely

'cause I'm getting ticked off. But...

How's this? An entire new department was formed because we value community. For YEARS it went unnoticed, uncared for, with no improvements.

Have all the updates been improvements? NOPE. Not by a long shot. How do we know that? Because we listen when you speak. Can we fix all the problems all at once? No. Would we like to? Yes. Can we ever make everyone happy? No way. No how.

by deepsand

[b]That[/b] is the postition to which I refer; and, yes, we here do very much understand that, as we've all experienced it. That the details re. what, when, where, how, who & why may differ is of no import.

Geeks run the world? While they may be at the steering wheel, it is capital which is the fuel.

Please accept that we here are [b]not[/b] trying to shoot the messenger.

by deepsand

See, we're not here solely for the purpose of finding fault with you & yours.

Did we not, for example, recently thank you for the "Report as Spam" function?

by beth blakely

This time for sure:
"Site usage statistics serve to describe the "what" & "how" of page/file requests; they do no & cannot discern the "why.""

Yes, but you can make inferences. Sometimes they're wrong, sometimes they're right.

"With respect to Discussions, "Participation" is "Posting." " Nope. Afraid not. Reading is also participation. Yes, if you can't post there's nothing to read. You can post more easily now using the View All page. If you can't find posts you've posted to, then you're not looking in the right place because they're all in your My Forums pages. You could also subscribe or "save" them.

"As an aside, it should be noted that the specific problems that I above mentioned were openly discussed, with the promise that some were being worked on, thereby giving rise to expectations by us that have yet to be met."

Oh, well, then let me get my magic fix it gun and shoot out a solution. Boom. There. All done. Next problem?

"What value does CNET place on the TR Discussion forum?" It depends on who you ask. You want me to list out all the CNET properties, their respective parts, and rank them?

Seriously, Deepsand, cut it out. We're trying and doing the best we can. Do you think we WANT you to be unhappy? Sheesh.

by Jay Garmon

Much of the stuff you guys complain about we refer to internally as "Frayed Edges." It's not broken, per se, it's just not as good as it could be. We keep a list of them and in the rare event we have free time for engineers or front-end developers, we try and work these out.

However, Frayed Edges will [i][u][b]never[/b][/u][/i] be as important as infrastructure improvements (like when we had to consolidate and shift servers this summer), new feature development (we've revamped site search, in case nobody noticed), SEO optimization (Google users outnumber you guys exponentially) or anything revenue related (ad sales can make us drop almost everything if there's an ad malfunction or anything related to ad impression is involved).

Nice-to-have stuff is just that, nice to have. You guys [b]can[/b] find threads, it just isn't easy. That's not the same as broken. It's not that we don't want to fix it, it's just we can't prioritize nice-to haves.

Incidentally, Beth has been breaking her back to improve the Updates and Alerts systems for TR, BNET, and ZDNET for over a month to help solve some of these problems, but it's a slow, complicated problem.

As to where you guys rank, well, let's just say that you regular posters occupy a particular niche in our reporting data that is--to be honest--very significant in some ways, and very insignificant in others. Depending on where our strategy and priorities lie at a given time literally determines how much resource bandwidth we can devote to your problems and desires. More, I cannot say without divulging confidential data and info.

I do fell comfortable saying that, just given how many regular posters we have as a percentage of our overall membership, you guys get several orders of magnitude more attention, feedback and engineering resources than our accountants would stand for, if they ever found out about it.

by deepsand

your hands are tied by the PTB, you'd like to be able to plainly state your feelings re. such here, but that, as a CNET employee, you are constrained from doing so, which is frustrating the hell out of you.

May I suggest that you start a long weekend? If anyone gives you any trouble re. such, tell them that I authorized it, and that they should see me if they have a problem with that.

:x

by deepsand

That's simply [u]not true[/u]. There are many that are literally [b]impossible[/b] to find, absent a privately maintained archive.

As for Discussion participation declining, how much of that is attributable to "Frayed Edges?"

by maecuff

Err..if you don't want your accountants to find out, you probably shouldn't have posted that comment.

Just an observation from an amused smartass. :)

by deepsand

Well, I know that I haven't noticed any change. That could be owing to the fact that I've pretty much stopped using it, as it never went below the date bound to the Root of the Article, Blog, Discussion, etc., and was therefore of little to no use to me.

When was this change effected? What was the change? Why are we learning of this only now, and in this manner?

by apotheon

Your suggestion, by the way, that we subscribe to discussions if we want to keep track of them is not much of a solution. I'll explain:

I'm signed up for a number of the TR newsletters. Once in a while, I get wind of an old discussion to which I'd subscribed being revived, so I go check it out. Sometimes, there's new activity there, and I think "Neat! This was a good topic of discussion!"

Then, I notice that I've missed a good couple of weeks' worth of discussion -- because I'm [b]unsubscribed[/b]. It seems that, after a few weeks, TR sometimes just "forgets" I was subscribed to a discussion. The result of this is that I have no idea whether there are dozens of discussions out there continuing without me despite my interest in them, because my subscription to them has evaporated.

When I first started noticing this problem, I thought maybe it was due to a recent change at TR that reset some of my discussion subscriptions. That's obviously not the case, though -- because I've noted on a couple of occasions that my subscriptions to the same discussion has dropped [b]more than once[/b].

I like TR. I like the community of discussion here, and I like some of the staffers as individual people. I like some of the differences in UI from the rest of CNET -- differences that make it about 300% more usable than most other CNET properties. There's a lot to like about TR.

I also find that technical difficulties mount up. After a while, some of them start looking like insurmountable barriers to my ability to maintain interest. Worse yet, the max post depth issue was something that literally dozens of users have expressed a keen interest in getting changed and, when that change finally came (it appears not to have happened by accident), everyone who said anything about it where I could see was quite keen on it. It was, bar none, the single most popular new feature of TR discussions [b]ever[/b] in my time at TR, from what I could tell -- and before I joined with this account in 2003 I had actually been a TechProGuild member for a while since -- well, I don't remember exactly off the top of my head, but I think it was late '99 or early 2000. That's a long time to see no new features that people seemed to like as much as a reply depth greater than seven replies.

. . . and yet, this functionality was [b]intentionally eliminated[/b]. I understand that there may be reasons for this change that are not obvious to us, the users. Those reasons could include corporate bureaucracy and pointy-haired bosses at the central CNET offices. They could involve poor scalability on the part of the Jive software. They could just involve a mandate that the threading of the discussion should never be allowed to wrap around or get all crunched up against the right margin.

It doesn't change the fact that the [b]users[/b] -- at least some non-trivial subset of users -- are frustrated not only with functionality that not only is broken but actively works against the work-arounds we might use to solve other broken functionality issues (as in the case of subscribing to a discussion not always working because of mysterious unsubscription occurring without our wanting it to), but also with the fact that a long-time desired favorite feature was intentionally removed.

You might even have good intentions and great goals in mind in removing the feature -- but, considering its obvious popularity with discussion regulars, one would think you'd want to come up with a [b]different[/b] fix for the problems you associate with the feature than to simply eliminate it. Maybe there's no easy way to get that better fix, for whatever reason, but:

You really shouldn't be surprised, under the circumstances, that people appear on the verge of revolt. Yes, people might not know the details of what's going on behind the scenes there at TR, but [b]they do know that their needs as customers are not being met[/b]. In the end, that trumps the difficulties of trying to meet those needs -- the reason the needs aren't being met will be less important to the users than the [b]fact[/b] they are not being met.

I'm willing to understand, and to be sympathetic, but just like anyone else there will come a time when I'll go build a reputation and community involvement somewhere else instead if TR becomes too frustrating to use, no matter how much I might [b]want[/b] to believe it's still serving my needs.

I'm not saying I'm going anywhere. I'm just not saying I never will go anywhere, either -- and that it might be helpful to understand that deepsand's obvious frustration with things here isn't just a result of being an a-hole (even if he is one sometimes -- hi, deepsand, no offense).

In short: Yes, we want to understand your position. We want you to understand ours, too -- and, from what I've seen, at least 80% of your discussion-generating userbase (measured in the amount of discussion generated, not necessarily in number of people generating discussion) has the same opinion about max depth. I'm using a little inductive logic, inferring a bit, to arrive at this conclusion, but I think these are realistic and reasonable inferences.

edit: Discussion, from what I've seen, is the biggest single reason that TR is positively differentiated from other CNET properties. Keep that in mind when weighing the trade-offs.

by tig2

Let me add my voice here with Mae's- please feel free to remind JD of the show tunes he so adores. I have a project going totally TU and reading what I KNOW you have in you would certainly brighten my day.

And don't worry about JD. He LIKES it when we notice his little "differences"!
:)

by deepsand

I reported that problem a [b]long[/b] time ago; when it seemed to have been fixed, I stopped looking for it.

Now, it's back? Sh!t; just one more thing on the already too long list of things one needs to try to remember to guard against and/or work around.

X-(

by hal 9000

Would be a reliable connection. I haven't had a reliable TR Connection for all of this week and none at all for the last 2 days.

Well I can get to the Front Page of TR but I couldn't open a single Discussion or Question that I had subscribed to or even get My Profile up to send an Peer Mail to anyone. Even when I eventually got My Profile the right hand side of the screen was blank and when I tried to click on any contacts I always got Page Can Not Be Found.

Actually most of the time that is all I was getting and while I could get the Front Page and even the Forums Listing the moment that I tried to go into a Question or Discussion the Dreaded Page Couldn't Be Found Error came back.

This wasn't a 15 minute issue but has been going an most of the week and getting progressively worse till about 36 hours ago when I could no longer get in at all. Now if I was unable to get in I would imagine that many of the goggle searchers couldn't either so that is an issue that affects income through Add Sales.

I actually got to step 7 of the 8 Step Recovery Program and while I've been busy being the end of the Financial Year and the like I was going totally insane supervising those Blades transferring data across the country and having nothing to do but sit there and watch them just in case something goes wrong. :_|

Then today when everything started working again I'm accused by JD of stalking some Ijiot who asks the same question a couple of times in a different manner so I didn't pick up that it was the same person. :(

Now I'm off back to the Therapy to cure me of this Frighting Addiction! Electric Shock Therapy seems so much better than what I'm currently going through. :_|

Col

[i]A Almost Cured TR Member.[/i] ?:|

by hal 9000

It's just been a frustrating week for me and from the looks of things most others here as well when we have been unable to access the Site or even look at some discussions that where listed in the News Letters. Well I was at least. :p

[b]Edited By Site Moderator!![/b]

Does that make you feel happier now Beth? :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Now I'm getting partial Page Loads and a notice telling me that there are errors on the page so most of the page is blank.

Just tried looking at Forums and Posts from my Contacts and while the top part of the page loads the rest remains blank. Just happened a couple of times now and may be nothing but it might be a new problem for this week.

Col

by w2ktechman

Hal is tha target again! WooHoo!

Sorry, just had to. A few weeks ago I had the same problem for several days, I was finally able to get to a contact page for R after 2 days. Yes, very annoying.

But I think your new problem is a glitch. I have not had issues all day today (with connctoin and page loads at least).

by deepsand

That's an example of TR's new "Customized Glitches." Just because they care.

($@(%*# 404s.

by deepsand

That's an example of TR's new "Customized Glitches." Just because they care.

($@!%*# 404s.

by deepsand

That's an example of TR's new "Customized Glitches." Just because they care.

($@!%*# 404s.

by deepsand

That's an example of TR's new "Customized Glitches." Just because they care.

($@!%*# 404s.

by gadgetgirl

- unless you have a webcam on somewhere....

;)

Now. Calm, chill, and if the sun is over the yardarm where you are, have a Lambs Navel on me .... :x

GG

by hal 9000

So what makes you think that I'll believe it now? :p

[b]It's Not a Undocumented Feature It's a Flaw in the Product and needs fixing![/b]

I'm sticking to that as well and no one can make me say any different unless they get [b]SWMBO[/b] to alter my story. :p

Col ]:)

Edited to add [b]Bloody Hell you did that deliberately didn't you Sandy?[/b] Well I hope that you get all the unsolicited E-Mails from TR Peers asking you how to fix their computers because you are number 1 of the top 100 I couldn't even get a look at that yesterday and I haven't bothered till now to see what's happened. :D

by steffi28

But I haven't had a single error for about 2-3 weeks.

Well apart from when I tried to violate max depth after it was taken away from us :p

by deepsand

And failed???

You do realize that you have a reputation to maintain here, don't you.

]:)

by apotheon

That would explain it. I have minimal JavaScript enabled here -- cut down to the barest essentials, with a lot of JavaScript functionality disallowed. It seems that's good enough to let me continue using TR.

It also explains why Jaqui is gone, since he completely refuses to allow JavaScript of any kind to run in his browser [b]at all[/b].

by steffi28

Well at home at least. I have NoScript running on FF and I'll only allow it if its absolutely neccesary, here in work I have no choice they wont let me customise the browser and they left me stuck with IE6 too :(

by shellbot

Look at it this way:

In one way, isn't it nice to have a group of people that are so "into" your "work"?
If we didn't care about the site, we wouldn't say anything.

Our comments are not personally against you and your work.
I have never though "oh my god they are so sh1t at thier jobs, they can't even throw a line feed in".
However I have thought "grrr..the new view all posts is brilliant..shame the formatting is buggered..hope they can maybe fix it"

The vast majority of us work in IT, we know what its all about..I've just done my work plan for the summer..turns out I need to work about 65 hours a week to complete my current projects plus do the amount of user support i do. I'm well aware you "get to things" when yer damn good and ready to.

You have a job to do and orders to take..and then us WATB's moan about stuff all the time..

If we didn't love you, we wouldn't bother, we'd just not come back.

So take pride in our complaints..we are aware you guys exist..we appreciate you..and above all, we do understand you..but as typical users, we want it ALL right NOW (and no we didn't do anything to break it :) )

Now..i need to find a Troll to feed...(gotcha Beth! )

by maecuff

Watiba. Because my son is not allowed to say 'ass' or 'titty'. Instead, he says 'Watiba'. I'm such a good mom.

by shellbot

you speaking canadian? :)

i was just too lazy to type out the full thing!

on another note..i want my laptop, and i want it NOW. Seems the one i wanted is gone..new model out this week that replaces it..so wil find out at 3 how much its gonna cost. but if i don't get it soon i'm going to throw a hissy fit, and its not going to be pretty.

by steffi28

I wrote out a reply to what you said, it was rather derogatory to Canadians :p something about a stupid Canadian :p hee you know I'm playing Shell. Well anyway went I pressed submit, the post dissapeared!! So obviously TR dont like me being nasty about Canadians :p

Anyway I think you should flip about your laptop and they will get so scared that not only will you get your laptop but you'll also get loadsa free stuff :p

by shellbot

yer just playin :)

ya..TR's gone wonky again, pages keep hanging, can't do a damn thing on here today.

laptop..too late..hubby told them where to insert said laptop..i agree with him..if they spend a week promising it has just been shipped this morning, and then you find out after 4-5 days of this they don't even have the stupid thing in stock..whats gonna ahppen when we need support on it??

so, we going directly to Sony now..cost more, but at least get a bit service and support

yes folks..for those of you living in the UK be warned about LapTopsDirect..not fun to deal with

by hal 9000

I get exactly what I want when I want it and doesn't have to muck around making things work sort of properly. Besides I refuse to even consider Vista at this point in time and am making a killing off selling NB loaded with XP Pro and Office 2003.

Though I'll admit that M$ is making Office 2003 harder to get at the moment last week my main supplier had 8 different versions now they only have the one so it's off directly to the M$ Resellers here to get the older Office that is completely compatible with everything else. Seems that not even M$ is unwilling to take money for something that actually works almost properly as apposed to something that you need to install converters into the receiving computers to read. :D

Seems that when I offered to install Open Office instead of M$ Office I could get exactly what I wanted, not quite sure why at the moment but it worked. :^0

Col

by steffi28

I love that your son has his own way of saying it :)
In fact I think I prefer his way a Watiba sounds quite cool :)

by jdclyde

First, I said PARTIALLY.

Second, it doesn't SOUND as bad, so it ISN'T. :p

Hey, at least I remembered that he was gone and BASICALLY why! ;\

by deepsand

Lamb's Navel? I've heard of a Lamb's Martini, aka The Monkey Gland.

I'll be sure to let you know when the webcams' up.

by shellbot

i WANT a Sony Vaio, SZ series to be more precise.
Yes, I could get a NB anywhere, and many other brands, but i've foolishly decided this is what i want.
No one else does a 13.3" display. I don't want a 12, i don't a 14 or a 15..i want the 13.3.

If i could find another NB that was that size and weighed 1.6-1.9 kgs.., with similar spec..then i'd probably go for it..but I'm not finding it..

Yes, it will come with Vista..and won't be able to get drivers to run XP..so stuck with it..i'll deal with it.

Hubby has been kind enough to create a Virtual Machine for me, loaded with XP pro (which i need to run SQL 2000..)

I'm a woman Col, I'm not rational..and I'm going to throw a fit if i don't get my Vaio SZ