Discussion Locked

Where do TR Discussions fall in the business plan?

0 helpful
217 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

217 replies

by hal 9000

That I've just pulled 35 Vaio's out of Service this week and am decommissioning them then I suppose is it? :D

I'm only putting one back into service and I replaced that one with a 2 GHZ Duo and 2 GIG or RAM on a 17 Inch Screen and 2.5 KG with battery. Horrible thing has WiFi, Blue Tooth, Web Cam USB Mouse and everything I had to stoop to selling a NB cooler as the only optional accessory available. :(

Even the Mains Adapter is small & light but I'm not sure just how much work is going to get done now that he can watch TV on that unit as it has a Built in Digital Tuner for HDTV & Remote Control.

It's a terrible life but someone got to do it. :^0

The Vaio that he had he wants reloading for his daughter so I'll slip in some more RAM to make it look as if it's going to nearly work instead of the shared 256 MEG that it currently has. I would go nuts if I had to reload it the way it currently is.

Besides Bigger is better as it's harder to miss your target when you swing a NB like a shovel to kill off the client. :^0

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Now you have given him something more to post. :(

Incidentally Love your new Avatar as I can just imagine you going into Mutely Fits of Laughter. :p

BTW your Master Dick Dastardly prevented me logging on for nearly 2 days so he could get to Number 1 in the top 100. I just hope that all your co workers are now looking at you in that funny manner as you go into a giggle fit. :D

Col ]:)

by shellbot

that better is bigger :)

I want it light and small so i can carry it around easily..

rumour is new model can be expanded to 4 gigs of ram...suits me just fine.
its got all the bits i want to play with..only problem is the cost..have to do some soul searching (as well as pockets, under beds, down the sofa etc) to decide if i really want to spend that much

by Jay Garmon

It was suggested by some in response to my previous posts in this thread that forum participation is in decline. It isn't. Forum participation is up significantly in 2007 over 2006, especially in Questions (formerly Tech Q&A) which have [b]doubled[/b] in traffic. Discussions are up quite a bit as well, and we attribute a lot of this to better Google optimization. People can finally see the feature and are using it. Now that we have a fulltime SEO analyst, I expect this trend to continue for the rest of the year.

As the result of huge new influx of Google users, the so-called "hard core" group that made up the old TRIs are actually a smaller percentage of our posting base than they used to be, though still plenty significant, especially in terms of posting volume. However, the hard core is a very, very tiny percentage of our reader base, as our forums get read by orders of magnitude more people than the few hundred regulars. Put simply, the TRIs don't add up to many ad impressions.

Site search is still being tweaked--we have a fulltime engineer who does almost nothing but search--and it can sort by Relevance, Date, Popularity and refine by content type (discussions versus questions versus blogs, etc.) and refine by associated tags. We quietly launched this around February and have been fine-tuning it constantly ever since.

The connection issues: We have three dedicated app servers load-balanced across each other exclusively for TR community. They're touchy, and we have a team of Ops engineers that tune them constantly. These are probably the most complicated hardware/software combos to be found anywhere in CNET, because replicating session data and pulling in user data from an outside reg system and integrating with a multiplatform Web site is CRAZY COMPLEX. At its heart, Community is basically a MySQL database that gets the crap kicked out of it constantly and has to be live, realtime responsive, with bulletproof failover. Most people--which is to say everyone but staff and the hard core users--never notice the 15 minute outages when we have to restart a server, or response time crashes because the Google and yahoo Web crawlers both hit us at the same time (which is a regular occurence we have no control over). In a perfect world, we could throw multimillion-dollar Google-level hardware and bandwidth at this feature so that no one ever notices even the slightest hiccup, but we don't have the staff or the budget for that. There's also the issue that sometimes the lag you see isn't on our end. Sometimes our Akamai replication goes down, which we have no control over, and it usually takes anyone outside the US with it. Sometimes referring ISPs lose connections to whole ranges of IP addresses (very common in Europe), and we can't control if TR is in one of the downed ranges. Sometimes, due to the nature of the software, one very very active thread will lag while the rest of the site is fine. Also, whenever we deploy software updates (weekly), there's a 5-15 minute outage of the site. Unavoidable, but there it is. these are forums, not instant messenger programs. They're not desigend for instantaneous back-and-forth.

Bottom line, we're doing the best we can, but we simply can't build a system that takes the pounding ours does and promise it will never slow and never time out.

by jdclyde

You point out that reading us up, but that the actual posters are a small number.

How much reading of posts will go on, if the posts are not there?

Kind of a chicken and egg deal here.
You NEED the readers, to draw the hits=ad revenue.
The readers NEED the posters, or they have nothing to read.
The posters NEED to be able to find and actively participate to generate these read discussions.

A stat request. The discussions that pull the most READS, are they more of then started by the core regulars, or not?

How many of the google crowd are one-shot reads, vs hanging around once they find the place? I know the questions used to be ripe with someone stumble on the site, create an account, post a question, and then never come back. Has that gone down, stayed the same, or gone up?

And I don't know of anyone that was making an issue about the 15 minute outage, just the four day "page not found" that led up to it.

We all understand outages and overloads.

by hal 9000

But getting th Custom TR Page Not Found error message means that I must have been hitting the TR server as I could click on the Forum Link and be taken in I just couldn't get anywhere once that happened well except for the infamous Page Not Found again. :8}

I could hit any other Web Site that I liked I actually ordered several computers in parts from 3 different suppliers and some M$ Server CAL's from another company so the problem wasn't here honest and I've got the bills to prove it. :0

If it was a general ISP error I should have got the default Page unable to be displayed message that comes with the Browsers that I was using in both Windows and Debian. Instead I was getting the TR Web Page which allowed me to click on the tabs and enter the site but then when you tried to go in deeper they would throw up the Page Not Found Error.

Now as I've been restricted from Logging into TR for a while and have dropped in my top 100 Site Rating to number 3 instead of number 1 will you please hard code my site rating to [b]666[/b] of the top 100? [b]Pretty Please![/b] ;)

I will not ask for anything else Honest!!! ;\

I will not be leading a quest for Spool Checkers and Grammer Crackers I'll be perfectly happy with a 666 Site Rating. :^0

But to be perfectly honest I was using 3 ISP's a banks Net connection whatever that is and several different computers over a fairly decent range limited to about 100 Kilometers so I shouldn't have been hitting the same error spot all the time and as I didn't touch any hardware or apply any code [b]I Didn't Break It Honest![/b]

Col

Just because I'm a little devil. :p

by deepsand

Actually, those 404s were all too real; and, they happened just as I was trying to hit the road to get to a client. Damn near didn't have time to get the thermos filled. X-(

by hal 9000

If the boot fits what more can I say?

If it looks like a Duck Quacks like a Duck and swims like a duck I feel fairly safe to call it a DUCK! :D

Now who was going on about [b]Undocumented Features?[/b] :p

Col ]:)

by deepsand

Fowl, perhaps; but, certainly no duck.

At Annapolis, those whose body fat is insufficient for they're floating, are placed into a special swim class named "Sub Squad." The purpose of such class is to teach one how to stay on the surface of the water for as long as possible with a minimal expenditure of energy. Of course, if you fall asleep, you'll end up sleeping in Davy Jones' Locker.

B-)

by jdclyde

[i]"Mutely Fits of Laughter."[/i]

When I think of GG, mute is one word that NEVER comes to mind! ;\

Matter of fact, I bet she is in a muTTley fit right now about this? :^0

by Member 25348569

It's the longest non-scientific word in the English language and it is the act of judging something as worthless.

Supplied free of charge by NITS(tm) because smartarse Geordies need to realise that there are blondes among us.

Neil :D

Actually, I've been trying to say "floccinaucinihilipilification" to myself in a Geordie accent to see what it would sound like and I think that I've burnt out part of my brain's speech centres as I now sound like Jasper Carrott.

Orroit bab?

by Jay Garmon

...are those attached to articles and blogs. Freeforms as a whole don't do as much, near as we can tell, though we're building better reporting tools to answer more of those questions. Most of the article threads are started by e-mail newsletter readers, as the articles and blogs are featured in newsletters, which start a virtuous circle of consumption.

On an individual level, the singular discussions that get the most reads are freeform threads that are "on topic"--like the "I'll never upgrade to vista" thread that won't die. If I were to pull up a list of the most-read threads (which isn't easy; hence the new reporting tools) I'd see a few very successful on-topic freeform threads near the top, then a wide swath of moderately successful article threads underneath. To invoke baseball, freeform hits homeruns but strikes out more often, while article threads are consistently reaching base.

Off-topic stuff (with the occasional exception of a friday yuk) generates a great many posts but almost no reads. The Evolution vs. Intelligent Design thread is constantly creeping up in posts but generates almost no reads, except from the very few individuals still fighting it out over there. That's why I could delete all those old off-topic monstrosities last year--they didn't get read. And this trend predates the site redesign, so even when you guys had an easier time finding stuff, off-topic didn't get reads, and articles outperformed freeform.

(Full disclosure: Back when I promoted freeform threads as lead items in newsletter, those I promoted did get a lot more play, but remove the promotion and they fell back to their old levels.)

As to Google users, we were shocked to learn that they turn about as many pages and make about as many posts as non-Google users. They really do clip through the site once they get here, which surprised the heck out of us. (Personally, I think this just means that you win or lose the usage battle on the Google results page; if they decide to click through, you've already won.)

Since the Google uptick, the value of posts has gone up, as each post becomes another page that can be read, and reads are up across the board. However, threads as a percentage of total TR pageviews has declined since the Google uptick. All pageviews have gone up, but threads haven't kept pace with articles and blogs.

Which is to say, in some ways you've gotten more valuable, and in some ways less.

Incidentally, this data is why we were able to build the View All Posts page. We built it specifically for the hard-core users who were using the Print view as a workaround for Next/Previous. SEO implications meant we couldn't do away with Next/Previous (single post pages are dynamite to Google) but the hard-core represented such a small number of page reads that we could build you an all-at-once read page and not care about the lost pageviews. The hard-core could stop reading altogether and we wouldn't notice.

We [i]would[/i] notice if you stopped posting, which is why you'll note we put Reply links on the View All page, and we're putting instant reply forms at the bottom of all threads, articles, and blogs. We want and need you guys posting, and we're trying to make it as easy as possible.

As to the outage, we didn't see a dip on our end, and traffic stayed steady, so I don't know what's going on there. It's entirely possible that something happened bewteen us and you--possibly involving you specifically--that we can't determine.

by Jay Garmon

..or at least no one has reported that to us from teh engineering group. I'll bring it up at our next meeting, but that's the kind of thing they would tend to mention (I hope, anyway).

by jdclyde

no. Happened from both home, and from work. Both on my work PC and my home laptop. Using IE and FF. (mostly FF, but tired IE as an experiment to see if someone wrote IE only code).

And of course, the pages that are getting pointed out ( easier to find ) will get the most reads. Wondered why you stopped doing them.

Question about blogs. Now that you only have a few key bloggers, do they generate more or less traffic than when any and everyone was making their own blogs, and the weekly newsletter was pointing out the highlights? Is less more? :D

by Jay Garmon

The focused blogging approach is vastly more effective, though it is more expensive (we pay most of these people). That said, teh quality and consistency of output is much higher, we're supporting a much mre secure and robust platform (easier to train 30 people on a real tool than expose an idiot-proof blog to the world). Also, way less spam, since the bulk of our old blog input was from spammers (remember the guys who mysteriously topped the Top 100 with no forum posts?).

We stopped leading our main newsletter with discussions because it only worked if you put a discussion in the most valuable lead spot. It was also hit-or-miss; some would blow up to 200 posts, some would fizzle at 30. We get more consistent results with articles and blogs. Fewer homers, but more runners on base and ultimately more runs.

I'll inquire about the outages and slowdowns. Maybe we had a destablilizng event that nobody told me about, but that would be unusual.

by apotheon

It seems like the only people who noticed this "outage" were male core discussion users like jdclyde, deepsand, and me. What's up with that? We're not even all in the same geographical area.

By the way . . . I wonder how the statistical frequency of article contributors coming from the pool of discussion forum regulars fits into all of this.

by deepsand

they're [u]not[/u] out to get us.

It seems that Col/HAL9000 was likewise hit. That means that at least 3 of the "Top 4" - I'm not sure about Absolutely's experiences - were "unserved." Hmmm.

by hal 9000

You have to ask correctly it's a [b]Spool Cheacker and a Cramer Cracker![/b] Or something like that anyway. :^0

Now I've got to go and post the bleeding obvious to Jay pointing out that I must have been hitting the TR Server and the problem was between that and the main D Base not connecting as I was getting the TR Page not found so the problem had to be at TR.

Anyway I'll ask Jay nicely and see if I can get what I want. :D

Col

by deepsand

There are any number of browser add-ons/add-ins available, both single & multi-functioned ones. See http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=navclient&ie=UTF-8&rlz=1T4DMUS_enUS219US219&q=toolbar+spell+checker .

With your own local spelling checker, you will have the advantage of being able to use it for other purposes as well, rather than being limited to using it here alone.

My new Dell 740 came with the Google toolbar pre-installed. Not being a big fan of either toolbars or Google, my 1st impulse was to rip the puppy out. However, having found its spell checker to be ever so useful re. posting here, I decided to keep it until I find a suitable alternative.

by nicknielsen

Very handy. The only complaint I have is the default post title of Re: article title. Would a title box be possible?

But maybe that's just me.

by apotheon

I think a default title of "re:

" makes sense, but it should be modifiable rather than automatic and unmodifiable without editing the post after the fact. A long string of "re:

" without anything descriptive about the specific thrust of the response just makes me start skipping replies for lack of willingness to bother.

by deepsand

There's nothing to indicate that your reply will be posted to the root of the Discussion, let alone that there even [i]is[/i] a Title.

by w2ktechman

the show tunes, not your preferences for a mate!

Now that I cleared that up, I believe you meant "girlie men" instead of just Girls... :^0

by w2ktechman

Now its not just the roots. The bleach has soaked into your cranium and killed some of your basic brain functions. But they were on their way out anyway due to the blonde roots, so you really didnt lose much... :^0

by steffi28

I thought you were my friend! Don't go telling the whole world I'm thick keep it a secret!!

by deepsand

returned TR's [i]Custom 404[/i] screen, and occurred when trying to access [i]Discussion content[/i], that particular problem has to be internal.

by jdclyde

the page says:

"The page you've requested cannot be found.

For a listing of our latest articles, please go to the TechRepublic front page."

by apotheon

Hey, hook me up with the information necessary to get started building my own laptops. Seriously. I'm tired of living in constant fear that Lenovo will stop making Thinkpads I like.

by hal 9000

As your brain dies and shrinks down in size your Breasts get bigger so what are you complaining about? :p

Maybe you didn't have a big enough brain to loose and make your Breasts as big as you would have actually liked but at the moment they are still growing. :^0

Col ]:)

by deepsand

A generic 404 screen would not contain any reference to the site name, content, etc..

To get a Custom 404 one must at least reach the site's server; then, if one has established a Custom 404 screen, and the server is unable to provide the specific page that you requested, it will substitute the Custom screen for the generic one.

You got to TR's server, but it failed to serve up the page you wanted, which is precisely what the rest of us have been experiencing.

by apotheon

I didn't realize I was in the top four. I almost never notice that thing.

edit: . . . and considering that most of my posts are [b]huge[/b], that's really a heck of a lot of typing.

by gadgetgirl

I read that at home last night, whilst snuggled up with my lappie on my knee....

It was nearly an ex-lappie!

I had an immediate visual of you doing a Jasper Carrot impression, which was so vivid, I splurted my drink all over the lappie, couldn't stop laughing long enough to stop the dribbles going down my cleavage (DE, and then some!) and the lappie damn nearly made it all the way in a floor dive, as I STILL couldn't stop laughing.

If I'd had your home number last night, babz, I would have called you, and put you out of your misery. Providing that a) I'd had time to practice first (DE!) and b) I COULD have actually stopped laughing.

Muttley had nowt on me las' neet, marra!

A'reet?!

:x

GG

by debuggist

Could someone PM me or post here the approximate days or times when the frequency of 404s were high?

We have noticed the application experiences problems several hours after deployments for the last couple months. These problems would also contribute to slow response time.

Thanks,
Doug

by deepsand

for the purpose of knocking him from the no.1 spot that gave me cause to look.

I guess I should be flattered by the suggestion, even a tongue-in-cheek one, that I might have such power.

by apotheon

Just in case nobody else contacts you . . .

I, for one, didn't really keep track of which days it was that I was having problems getting into discussions. I might ask the SigO if she (also a TR member, by the way) remembers, but she's away from IMs at work right now. I just figured I'd let you know that, if you don't get messages pointing the exact dates of outages, it's not because we're ignoring you.

I'll try to remember to record dates and times of outages from now on so that if it comes up again I'll have some actual numbers to offer.

by deepsand

But, not every machine has or will have FF installed. Multiple platforms necessitate multiple solutions.

by hal 9000

I've been getting them intermittently all week till Wednesday when I was only getting them and nothing else that was of any use. I could click on the Forums Tab and then My name and get some of that page but the moment that I clicked on your Listing I was back to Page Not Found.

As it was happening all day here in AU on Eastern Standard Time which is GMT + 10 hours that should give you a good starting point.

Hope that is of some help.

Col

by michael jay

I have been delivering a large number of Thinkpad T60's, they are very fast and fill the bill for sure. You should give them a go I do believe you will like them.

by jdclyde

really got bad sunday until when I started this discussion.

I would open four tabs from the discussion notifications, and all four would do that. If I would hit refresh, three or four times, I could sometimes get in. If I didn't get in by the fourth reload, I would walk away from the discussion.

It happened regularly from work, ( 9am till 4 pm EST ) and continue when I got home ( 7 pm till 12 midnight ).

after the system wend completely down just before this discussion, it has been fine.

by apotheon

The Thinkpad T61 may well be my next laptop -- if it hasn't been superseded by the time I need to buy another. I'm currently using an R52, which is excellent, but the fact it uses a Mobility Radeon adapter kinda puts a crimp in my style for 3D acceleration using FreeBSD. Because the T61 uses an nVidia graphics adapter, that shouldn't be a problem with that model.

I'd really like to be able to build a laptop to my own personal specifications, but even the options forwarded to me by HAL aren't really going to work for my personal use because of some of the unmodifiable configuration characteristics (such as the design of the built-in pointing device. C'est la vie.

by jdclyde

but the people that don't, especially if I don't know them, I don't even bother reading unless I am in the read all mode.

Kind of like email. subject line is there for a reason.

by jdclyde

when it was right there, you saw it all the time, but now that you have to dig for it, it isn't until someone mentions it that I even remember it is there.

wow, i am out of the top ten. first time in years, (thanks to the site re-vamp)

heck, I can even go a day or two without checking in now..... cured?

by hal 9000

I only saw that because I was attempting to get a message to Doug to tell him that there was a problem. The fastest way that I knew how to do this was enter My Profile and then click on Doug as a contact. It was then that I noticed the change.

Actually I'm surprised that I've been there for so long as it looks like I'm always on TR posting things which I'm certainly not but I suppose that the Americans and others in the Northern Hemisphere where out in the summer sun when I hit number 1 and was very surprised when that didn't change when it was your winter.

Besides like OZ I wasn't overly happy with all the requests for help directly peer mailed to me from new members who I had no idea of who they [b]were[/b] [i]Thats for you Abs.[/i] :D

Col

by deepsand

I yesterday got one from a brand new member, whose umbilical cord hadn't even been tied off yet, looking for help building a Habbo "site," admitting that he didn't even know what "Habbo" was!

by apotheon

How were you able to modify it? When I look at the reply text field at the end of an article (as of Sunday, June 24, 2007 at 15:46 MDT), I don't see any indication of how to choose my own title.

by deepsand

Simply go to that Post, and Edit it as you would any other Post made within the Discussion itself.

by deepsand

how about your springing for my vacation to your haunts, during which you can regain the throne?

Works for me, just so long as I'm back in time for the college football season.

by hal 9000

That finding a pub that sells Bud here is impossible. :p

Actually next week when things have returned to some form of sanity I may even have some time to play a bit. Till then however it's race around getting read for the End of the Financial Year and sending out as many new computers as possible. God only knows that I'll never meet the existing orders that seem to magically materialize the week before the end of the finical year.

Now I'll have to go back and see how that NB is running that was assembled today. Pity that they have run out of RAM and it looks like it's going out with only 50% of the stuff fitted so that I can push the invoice through. :(

How are you at asking questions on what will make a good PHD Thesis? I was asked this today and have no idea of what to even suggest.

Col

by deepsand

Re. "asking questions on what will make a good PHD Thesis," presumably that means [u]answering[/u] the question "what will make a good PHD Thesis?"

I don't suppose that the guy/gal bothered to mention the discipline in which they earned their Masters, so I'll just have to wing it. How about a study re. the expectations of an inverse correlation between effort & results when engaging in on-line activities; a working title might be "On-Line Stupidity: Its Causes & Possible Remedies."

by deepsand

I just stumbled across a new post to an old thread, to which I had subscribed, in the Hot list; upon popping over there, I found that I was no longer subscribed.

Took a look at some of the recent Questions to which I replied and had not yet shown signs of being resolved, and found several from within the past month that suffered the same fate.

This sucks.

by apotheon

"[i]Simply go to that Post, and Edit it as you would any other Post made within the Discussion itself.[/i]"

Please see where I said:

"unmodifiable without editing the post after the fact"

edit (ironically): Using the edit button is a dirty hack, not proper functionality, and that as our only option encourages greater numbers of very vaguely-worded post titles.

In fact, I'm starting to be of the opinion that those reply text fields at the bottoms of articles are a bad idea, and may be prone to limiting the amount of actual discussion that occurs rather than fostering discussion as the TR guys surely intended.

by absolutely

The "depth" of some discussions has got me thinking, maybe TR isn't even the place for the type of topics that really call for such depth. An IT question tends to be answered within a few replies. A philosophical argument can go through infinite iterations, and perhaps ought to be held on a site intended for such arguments. Just a thought I've had, while "contributing" to some of the worst extended exchanges.

:D

by absolutely

If you don't believe in gnomes & pixies, maybe it's a security problem. In any case, it would be interesting to keep careful logs of when we check the "Subscribe" tick mark and when we press the "Unsubscribe" hyperlink, and report any discrepancies in site behavior to the staff, to help determine whether their password protection is adequate.

by apotheon

Sometimes, the people with whom I want to have these discussions are IT pros -- not self-satisfied, half-baked philosophy majors. At least IT pros don't tend to use arguments from authority based on their field of study in college* (which, evidently, didn't do them much good if they're using arguments from authority anyway).

edit:
(* when discussing matters of philosophy, et cetera)

by debuggist

From what we can tell, it looks like these periods started around late afternoon/early evening (Pacific time) Jun 14 and continued periodically until the morning of Jun 20 when we intervened. Usually, the periods were short and infrequent but annoying and frustrating all the same.

The beginning of this coincides with a deployment. It's not necessarily what is in the deployment but the instability that the deployment process causes for the webapp.

We have some ideas to prevent this and are working on implementing them. Each one will probably be done separately. In the meantime, the workaround is that you may see a "servers down for maintenance" message each time we do a deployment.

Thanks to Apotheon, HAL 9000 and jdclyde for trying to help with pinpointing the timing of these problems. We'll post updates as they occur (or about to occur).

Regards,
Doug

by deepsand

I did not mean to imply that you were unaware of the ability to edit the Title after the fact, but merely included the details of how to do so for the benefit of other readers who may be unfamiliar with this issue.

I concur that it's a kludge.

As earlier stated, below, the Reply screen for blogs fails to give any indication as to either [u]where[/u] one's reply will be posted, or that it will be given a fixed & predetermined Title.

by deepsand

Similar to MySpace, each has his own virtual Room in the Habbo Hotel; but, unlike MySpace, the Hotel itself is a shared community space.

And, like SecondLife, one must pay to participate in certain activities, furnish one's room, etc..

by Jay Garmon

From 9:30-9:45 Pacific time, TechRepublic Community will be offline for a database optimization. Let us know if anything screwy happens afterwards.

by deepsand

Knowing when to [u]not[/u] expect service is quite helpful.

Have you considered either e-mailing members re. scheduled maintainecne, or of putting a notice of such on the Home Page.

A number of ASPs that I rely on for various services do one or both of these.

by apotheon

A message on the home page probably wouldn't help me much. I don't remember the last time I saw the TR home page.

On the other hand, an email notice would be quite helpful to me. Email basically serves as my TR homepage.

by apotheon

I think I was watching American History X (again) when that time period rolled around -- so I didn't notice anything screwy. Ahem.

by hal 9000

But then again I slept through that Time Frame so I hate this time of the year when you are running around doing nothing.

Col

by absolutely

A great feature to add, not take away, would be a visual representation of one's current sub-thread, allowing easy navigation, either to the next reply at the same depth, or to the first direct reply (when one exists) to the post currently being viewed.

by absolutely

BTW, to the Doug fellow who PM'd me, I haven't experienced, or at least haven't noticed, any of the "magically unsubscribed" episodes to which I referred, but I took the other members at their words when they mentioned those experiences, and I think it's worth documenting closely, to see whether TR's security is robust.

Now, deepsand, why are you so sure it's a system problem that is not related to password theft or cracking?

by apotheon

Thanks for the efforts, Doug. I'll keep an eye out for those "maintenance" messages, and I'll try to remember to let you know if they replace the incidence of errors that make it appear the page simply does not exist.

by hal 9000

Glad that I could offer some help to narrow down the problem and now that you know what's happening can attempt to prevent it occurring again.

Col

by deepsand

And, it is these symptoms that suggest an accidental cause.

Firstly, it must be noted that the problems re. Discussions & Questions vanishing from one's "Posted To" & "Subscribed To" lists pre-date the redesign of the site.

If such were owing to unauthorized access, it is then the case that the person responsible has had no small amount of time, i.e. opportunity, for doing a great many things beyond merely discontinuing the subscriptions of others. And yet, we see no evidence of Posts being mysteriously Edited, counterfeit Posts being created, Subscriptions to Discussion and/or Questions being surreptitiously [u]activated[/u], etc..

That one who had gained unauthorized access should confine his mischief to a minor function, by way of tampering with it in a manner that is non-obvious, begs the question of "why bother?"

Hence, I conclude that the [u]more probable[/u] cause is a design or implementation flaw.

by deepsand

It's not like they're short of real estate for non-editorial content.

There's plenty of space available in the top & right rails for Important Notices.

by absolutely

only to act as a "burdock", so to speak? Wouldn't the observed symptoms fit that goal quite well?

Just a thought...

by absolutely

Such a troll might adopt the method we have observed for the sake of remaining overlooked & evading close enough inspection to lead to detection, permitting an extended period of time in which it might make mischief.

Like I said, just a thought ...

by deepsand

I.e., what [u]benefit[/u] would accrue to such a person?

Return to the fact that [u]most who are affected do [b]not know[/b] it[/u].

In order for the perpetrator to [u]himself know[/u] that his actions were, at the least, an annoyance to others would require that he do so on a scale that could not be easily overlooked, and such that the annoyance caused would clearly evidence itself by way of great public outcry.

by absolutely

[i]To what end?
I.e., what benefit would accrue to such a person?[/i]

Are you implying that trolls seek "benefit"?

:^0

[i]Return to the fact that most who are affected do not know it.[/i]

Reeeally? How do you know that? How, in other words, do you know that any are affected who do not know it? Do you have something to confess?

[i]In order for the perpetrator to himself know that his actions were, at the least, an annoyance to others would require that he do so on a scale that could not be easily overlooked, and such that the annoyance caused would clearly evidence itself by way of great public outcry.[/i]

Check.

You and apotheon have now complained of this phenomenon. Such may not yet constitute "*great* public outcry", depending on a particular beholder's measure of "greatness", but I suspect you agree that the annoyance caused (whether by the prankster I hypothesize, or by technological malfunction) does now "clearly evidence itself".

by absolutely

To [b]re[/b]think would require having already thought about your words once before you posted, would it not? One step at a time, babee!

:D

by deepsand

As I'd long ago brought this to the attention of TR, and had since seen no evidence of it's presence until apotheon's mention, [b]I[/b] was unaware that I had been again affected.

And, other than apotheon & myself, [b]no one has noticed[/b] this problem.

Ergo, that I can be affected without my knowledge serves to allow that so too can others. And, that only 2 of observed & reported such here, it is either the case that few are affected, or that most of the many who are affected are unaware of such.

No feedback, and the troll gets no kick. No kick, and the troll tries something with a broader and/or deeper effect.

by w2ktechman

about dropped subscriptions, but I guessed that it was probably due to an update, patch, or server issue. It has not been often enough for me (that I noticed at least) to worry much about it.

by absolutely

I was asked to notify the Management when it happens, so they can more easily troubleshoot the cause. I think they really care!

:D

by w2ktechman

But I tend to forget about a few if I am subscribed to many and do not have time to regulary read new posts.

The last time I noticed one was several months ago. that is why I said, I really do not worry much about it. These days, I am too busy to visit the site long anyway. And if something dropped it could easily go unnoticed, as I do not allow javascript on my home system. This means that I cannot view anything in forums or blogs, but can read and reply from my contacts or anything in my profile.

by deepsand

I've no doubt that those staff members with whom we have contact possess a genuine desire to be responsive to our legitimate needs; what I have questioned is the extent to which their masters have provided for their ability to act on thier desires.

Doug has contacted me re. this problem, asking for specifics as best they are recalled, as an aid in TR's investigation of this problem.

I would suggest that all keep an eye open for this problem, and record & report the following to Doug.

1) The Date & Time that the problem was discovered.

2) How such was discoverd.

3) The Name of the Discussion or Question involved.

4) Whether or not any e-mail notices of activity were not received.

5) Whether or not the Discussion or Question still appeared in your "Subscribed To" list.

6) Whether or not the Discussion or Question still appeared in your "Recent Updates" list.

7) If you then re-subscribed, the Date & Time that you did so.

by hal 9000

If I notice any thing going missing.

However as I'm facing a possible long hospital stay this may not prove of any use for a while at least as I'll have to come up to speed and be aware of what's going on and what I have subscribed to in the discussions. I don't think that the questions will be a biggie as they tend to die out fairly quickly.

Col

by ontheropes

Something for everyone.

I recently used to get numerous DNS errors and at first thought it was a problem at your end 'til I actually started thinking about it and realized that it was my ISP (Hughesnet) that had to be the problem.

I wonder how many errors are blamed on TR when they're not actually your "fault". I suspect a fairly high percentage of them.

I'm going to blame you guys (and gals) for my spelling, punctuation and grammatical errors next. Makes about as much sense as blaming you for something that's the fault of my ISP or me and my public school system. :D

Anyone that actually reads my rambling rants knows that I haven't had anything, (much) bad to say about TR in my second (third?)(twentieth?) incarnation as OnTheRopes.

My first go 'round as NeverBusted was quite a ride for me and ended with my "trashing" a site that had, in retrospect, been the high-point of my participation in any on-line forum.

I'd like to apologize publicly for my wayward behavior towards TR back then and the little bit since.

Sorry.

If nobody noticed anything... cool. That's the way I'd have it.

I'd much rather be a little fish in a big pond then a big fish in a little pond.

Regardless, I know that I stepped on some toes at TR, whether or not anyone remembers, and I do sincerely apologize for doing that. Below is my best explanation for my behavior back then without needlessly pointing out specific posts (saved to my archives) and viewpoints of specific individuals.

I was shocked to see events occurring in my real-life that were directly related to my posts at TR. I'm not going to be any more specific than that, as I said, needlessly pointing out specific items isn't required. An apology is only good if you quit doing that for which you're apologizing and don't try justifying your behavior. That's my definition of apology. I don't believe that I'm trying to justify my behavior as much as I am trying to explain it. Your mileage may vary.

I think that TR is an excellent website. Errors? Sure, you've got them. Everyone does. Do I have any ideas on how to improve the site and experience for people like me? Sure. To use this analogy, "Now you see through a glass darkly and then face to face." (I probably screwed up the verse. Hopefully it makes sense.) In other words, 'til I know what you, the PTB at TR, know I'll just be presenting ideas that have likely been considered before or ideas whose practicality is limited given your budget and business realities. So... I prefer to keep my ideas to myself. After all, it didn't cost me a dime to come here and post virtually anything I want to post. I'm not going to take such a freebie and grind it up and spit it out. Not going to do it.

There was talk about beer up above. Tell you all what. Sign up a bar in Louisville and I'll throw down a twenty for ya'. http://buyyourfriendadrink.com/home.php? and http://tinyurl.com/ytbs5o
I'd "donate" more but MY budget manager would kick my... accounts all over the place. In the meantime perhaps you have enough discretionary funds to purchase one of these.



Keep up the good work.

Peace. It's a good idea.

Oscar

by jdclyde

it is a specific TR error page that we are getting, not a generic page not found.

that means we get to the site, and it is not able to feed out the correct page.

because i have gone though different vendors by accessing from home and work, showed it is not the provider OR my system, because i got the same results on numerous systems.

this is before we even factor in that I doubt Col has the same provider I do.... :0

A good try though.

by ontheropes

Have you ever noticed how a reply that is late to the thread is necessarily different than replies from someone who was there from the beginning? That's why I didn't address the TR page not found errors in my post. I read the entire discussion in one sitting and didn't feel that repeating what's already been said was worth my time.

MY point is that TR is still a great website. That's my opinion, of course everyone is free to have a different opinion. It's sad to me to see that some folks have left TR because they're dissatisfied. I can think of several that, to me, were important personalities here at one time. Some have left by choice and others have been driven away by folks from the top 100. I've participated in some of that too.

What I'm saying is that I know a custom 404 when I see one. I'm the dood that created these TR avatars because 404 error were becoming so common-place they were funny/sad. Can't get to anywhere at TR, create an avatar with the time saved.


I've resigned myself to the fact that TR is going to do whatever they have to do and CAN do within the restraints of time, space and business. I don't expect them to do anything for me, as I've said, TR is still a good place to post and most importantly it's a good place for information. I suspect that it's a rather small number of members who ever tread the seemingly slick gutter in the off-topic area where I hang my hat most often. That's too bad. The off-topic area COULD have more of a sense of community than it does. As it is now it's like the false view of rednecks, "step on my lawn and I'll shoot you boy."

Whatever. That's it. I'm not complaining. I'm just saying. There is a difference.

JD: You don't have to work at making me look like an idiot by satirically stating the obvious. I do a fine job of looking like a fool all by myself. Thanks bud.