207 replies
by azul
I would say McAfee.
I have been supporting home users and students at a large university for the better part of the past three years.
The first year and a half was home users, 9 times out of 10 they were running Symantec.
The past year and a half has been students, end users in a university/hospital. Everyone has access and is encouraged to download and use an enterprise version of McAffee on any computer they use, home or work.
Now, 8 times out of 10 when I have a pc that has a virus, it is because the virus definitions and Windows updates have not been kept current. There are more than 48K systems connected to our network at any given time.
However, when I have somthing that McAffee cant fix, Symantec Stinger usually does.
I hope that helps, good luck.
by beads
McAffee is definitely better than that resource hog Symantec load.
If your looking farther out then I would also suggest TrendMicro. Sure they're number three but I like the management better than anything else I have seen or used.
- beads
by paguda
by wellsd
I would have to agree that McAfee would have to be the better of the Two. We use Symantec on our network at work and I have never had more viruses in my life! I use McAfee @ home and I think in the 4 Years that I have been using their products that I have had maybe a total of 3 Viruses. That compared to the 9 that I got last week Using Symantec @ work. Both Software?s have current updates applied with in a day of being released.
Mind you the only piece of software that McAfee made that works it their anti-Virus products, the rest of their utilities are better left uninstalled.
by blackcurrant
I have been using Norton's products for years. Lately, they have, IMO, gone down the pan. I got fed up with the uninstalling/reinstalling merry-go-round, I got fed up with viruses getting through, I got fed up with the firewall repeatedly preventing Outlook from connecting to the Internet, I got fed up with the programs inability to remove spyware - even in Safe Mode, I got fed up with having to download dedicated program uninstall tools because the upgrade did not remove all traces of earlier (and, therefore, incompatible), files. Finally, I was astonished after uninstalling these programs - because my PC's performance improved dramatically, and has remained so even after installing McAfee.
It is a shame because Symantec used to be industry leaders - now their products are quite simply not cutting the mustard. Not only have switched my home PC from Symantec to McAfee - I will also be moving my entire company network over to McAfee mainly because I can no longer tolerate to crippling effect Symantec Client Security 3 has on those systems that meet the system requirements. Note: If anyone installs SCS3 the clients require 512MB to run with little performance impact, and not the 256MB quoted.
NO!
The BEST anti-virus is AVG! Next to it is antivir.
by van morris
I've used McAfee for more than 7 years and I'm happy with it. However, since I knew about SafeSystem (which highly recommend) I've used this tool for complementing my other security programs because it protects my system regardless the kind of (known or unknown) virus, spyware or malicious code is trying to infect my computer. In fact, it simply doesn't allow any program to be installed or copied to my system while I'm surfing the Web, reading my emails or working with my computer. Sincerely, this gives me a lot of piece of mind because my system is always protected no matter if my anti-virus and anti-spyware are updated or not. Don't forget that perhaps they are updated but they just don't recognize the virus or spyware which is trying to get into my computer.
I found SafeSystem at: http://www.gemiscorp.com/english/safesystem/info.html
Also, you can see a good PR about this program at: http://www.prweb.com/releases/2006/1/prweb339444.htm
IMPORTANT: I want to clarify that I don't have any direct or indirect relation with the company that owns the product I'm suggesting, so my posts shouldn't be considered SPAM.
by ontheropes
I'm interested in your experiences with SafeSystem. I discovered it and downloaded it this past weekend. I'm going to begin trials, after my usual back-up cycle, this week.
Thanks.
by cdixon
I use the McAfee Enterprise version in a corporate enviroment. I have been VERY satisfied with its detection and performance. With the explosion of the adware/spyware of the last couple of years, it has done its job of keeping my region free of a lot of that junk. I do have some home users that I support that do use Symantec. What I have seen fail with those users is that McAfee almost always has virus definitions in place long before Symantec. With Code Red and Blaster McAfee had definitions almost a whole day before Symantec had them.
What I see lacking in both products retail/OEM versions (home users) is the expiration. Both products come with a trial period, but do not nag enough when the trial expires. I have found home users loaded with viruses, that comment "But I have anti-virus". You check the virus defs and they are over a year old because the product has expired.
by baketown83
I have used both McAfee and Symantec and I find that I like Symantec more. I have no real problems with McAfee. It protected my PC very well but I recently had gotten a laptop that came with Symantec so I decided to stick with it. It did its job, and it was really easy to keep up to date with the latest definitions.
Also at my job we use Symantec and that was very convenient. When updates come out at work I know to go home and update my computer or vice versa. Since then I have gotten rid of McAfee totally on any PC that I own and install Symantec. I also recommend Symantec to anyone who may ask.
by baketown83
I have used both McAfee and Symantec and I find that I like Symantec more. I have no real problems with McAfee. It protected my PC very well but I recently had gotten a laptop that came with Symantec so I decided to stick with it. It did its job, and it was really easy to keep up to date with the latest definitions.
Also at my job we use Symantec and that was very convenient. When updates come out at work I know to go home and update my computer or vice versa. Since then I have gotten rid of McAfee totally on any PC that I own and install Symantec. I also recommend Symantec to anyone who may ask.
by baketown83
by jdclyde
but with their recent decision to drop support for anything older than win2k and not CLEARLY state so, is going to have me looking for a new AV vendor in June when this runs out.
No, I will NEVER go back to McAfee. Systems crashing and failing to boot up were only the symtoms. The failing to clean the viruses that were contracted WHILE being covered by the updated McAfee is what made it so I will NEVER use their product again.
Even though it isn't spending advertising on this site, I will probably end up with the comercial product from AVG.
Besides the dropping of old systems without proper notice, it has worked well and their web site is always very helpful.
by rob mekel
Can see and understand why you say this. I don't like it either when support fails or is dropped without proper notice, let alone when the product corrupts your systems. Then I sure will not return to software like that.
On the other hand (was to be expected wasn't it :)), if a certain product is the best in its field it becomes more a management issue then a likings one.
The emotional or intuitive: I don't like this so I won't use it, not bases on any functionality or use facility, so just based on the likings, is not a good basis to select a product.
As a manager I can understand that if products are equal as in quality/price/service/use/continuity/strategy, that the liking or dis-liking of a brand/product/manufacturer/sales-person or any other emotional argument can be the deciding point on ordering a product from someone or a company.
But never ever based only on pure intuitive liking or dis-liking.
And in this I even will evaluate manufacturers and products that I don't like but maybe are the best in their field, line of work and, being this, the best for me or my company.
Rob
by jdclyde
I still have a few dozen Win98 systems I am STUCK with until they die. Do I go tell my boss I need to buy 24 computers because we can't run the AV software?
The way I discovered that Symantec dropped support for everything under win2k? When I went to install it. Real nice time to find that out. It then took a bit to FIND ANY mention of this on their web site.
That is NOT a matter of "like or dislike".
That is poor business practices, and they have made the choice to not support my network anymore. I will find a product that will work.
Note: Old systems are pIII 500's through 800's. Do I dump $150 EACH for WinXP upgrade just so I can continue to stay with the same AV vendor?
So no, was NOT to be expected and was purely a LOGICAL decision, not an emotional decisions based on likes and dislikes.
As for evaluating products I don't "like". If a product PROVES to be a poor product, it has nothing to do with "liking" it.
Just like we will never do business with AT&T again because of VERY poor service and even worse treatment over that very poor service. That is another bridge that has been burned to the ground. X-(
by apotheon
You seem to have been conditioned by the constant, chronic instabilities and failures of software in the Windows world to simply expect that sort of thing as the cost of using computers. That's the only explanation that comes to mind for what just happened: jdclyde laid out for you technical issues with AV software from Symantec and McAfee, and you discarded it, saying that they're the "best" AV solutions on the market and that his decision was based solely on personal knee-jerk biases.
It looks to me like you're the one with the bias: you seem to equate popularity with quality. Since they're at the top of the market, you assume their offerings are the best, and dismiss any dissenting opinions as being nothing but personal bias. I could be wrong, but that really seems to be the case here. Ultimately, what you should realize is that when something repeatedly fails due to technical flaws in a way that damages business productivity or endangers your financial security, that is simply unacceptable. Under such circumstances, it's entirely reasonable to write off the product in question and refuse to entrust anything important to it ever again.
Have you even tried anything other than Symantec and McAfee for enterprise antivirus software?
by lazerous200
by wojnar
by sleepin'dawg
with updates. I use AVG (commercial version) which updates automatically on a daily basis. I used to use Avast which was also good but the speed with which AVG updates (sometimes twice in a day) won me over. I know of several instances where Symantec and McAfee were late with critical updates that resulted in infected systems; while our systems remained secure because AVG had beaten the other two to the punch with a necessary update. Somebody above mentioned SafeSystem and we are looking at it as an adjunct to AVG but to date haven't made any decision on it. Considering cost factors, both Symantec and McAfee are expensive in comparison to AVG and definitely not as effective and the Symantec firewall is about as effective as a screen door on a submarine. There are some excellent antivirus products out there but Symantec and McAfee just aren't amongst them.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
You may be stuck with the older computers, or, like me, choose not to upgrade, but, you are not stuck with the "big names."
MacAfee was the first big AV, and has built a reputation. Now they choose to live on reputation, rather than live up to it.
For years, I have been using AVG on my ME system.
If you have 2K or XP, AVG may not work. In that case, use Antivir.
Freeware is NOT malware, as some believe. I use a lot of freeware, and it performs better than the commercial grades. If I find a freeware that doesn't work well, I find something else. Only thing I haven't found, yet, is a good font editor and creator.
by rob mekel
on wall-street?
But do agree AVG isn't a bad idea, nor is Antivir.
Rob
as cheaply as possible. I hate to spend money when
there is a freeware product that work for my
purpose.
I got my DeltaCAD in a house design package that
was being closed out at Staples- $5US. The house
program sucks, but Delta does what I want, so I
use it, I also use Irfanview- freeware, for photo
manipulation, and PDFredirect V1, freeware for PDF
creation. Get the needed value for the least cost-
it's good business.
by apotheon
Question: What does stock market presence have to do with quality of software?
Answer: Nothing.
by jdclyde
means they hopefully will be trying harder to get a piece of the pie.
The big two in AV today are like IBM of the 80's. Dead in the water.
by servicetech
by rob mekel
Don't think we dis-agree JD. Matter of fact I think we do agree on this all the way.
If products are known to be poor on service or quality, I sure won't select them to deliver.
But that doesn't mean that I won't let them in on an evaluation-project. Even if their service was/is bad. It just means that they will get extra attention on that issue, whether this will be a clause in the contract, penalty if not delivering, or refund plus costs of installing a product that does work. It will be something that will keep them in track upon the agreed deliverables.
Sorry to hear y're stuck with a few dozen Win98 systems. But ain't it time to replace them by new ones? They must be 6 - 7 years old. But if they're working fine there is no reason to replace them. Then of course what will it cost you to select/install an overall new AV program to your entire installed base. Or are you planning to do it just on the Win98 systems? And move over from there slowly.
Don?t know if this is of any help but if you wanna discus more? feel free.
Rob
by jdclyde
The users do e-mail, spreadsheets, and run a terminal emulator.
I literally could have 90% of the company running on PIII 500's just fine. Of course, when a system dies we replace it with something cheap, but current.
Why a cheap computer? Manufacturing. VERY dirty,dusty conditions. Most systems burn up in a few years, and the newer the more sensitive they are. The old systems could take this a lot better.
When there is something like this software update, I get together with a co-worker and we hit every system. We will look at ALL software issues and make a check list to do all scans and updated. This once a year "hands on" has really cut down on the daily calls, so has been shown to be worth the time.
It will be a system wide change. AVG and Kaspersky are two of the systems I will be testing out in about two months. Need to make the change in June.
As for giving everyone a fair chance, if a product that I recommend fails, it makes ME look bad. It is a "one strike and your out" for me. I don't take kindly to failure.....
Symantec, your out.
McAfee has BEEN out.
AT&T is way out.
Win95/ME is history!
Win98 is getting phased out.
Outlook,gone!
Internet Exploiter, GONE!
still looking at SuSE for a corporate solution on the desktop!
Still don't like the Foo fighters. :p
by rob mekel
Users do use their email, spreadsheets, word-processor, emulation, etc. But what, or how much, of these programs do they actually use?
History: WP 4.2, yes an oldie, still covers up 70% of today's word-processing desires and yes I do like the new features in modern word-processors but do I need them?
Ever thought of industrial systems in this dirty and dusty environment. I once had soft covers for the keyboards and special foils for the touch screens so dirt and dust was kept out and they could easily be cleaned. It did work great but in the end it was more costly cleaning, time => money, wise then replacing them every 5 or 6 years or sooner if the machinery was replaced.
This "hands on" once a year looks like y're in need of a CMDB and some(maybe all) processes of ITIL. Looks like your doing some of the ITIL processes like problem management (look at ALL software issues and knowing you issues seems like you have incident management in place) and change management (check list to do all scans and updated) once a year.
You will get more benefit out of ITIL processes as your installed base is large/growing.
I for sure don't like to check every year all 1500+ systems, even not(better, special not) on a one time basis.
Y're right, addressing/tackling software issues on a regular basis is saving on daily time consumers.
Any planning on the selection/implementation yet?
Yeb, don't like it either when looking bad due to mal practice/someone else?s doing. That's why I make the effort at contract stage to keep them on track all the way so I won't have to worry about me looking bad.
I like the exploiter twist. Seems y're going to look for the Novell-thingies then.
Rob
by rob mekel
doesn't.
But y're right if it does the job for you it's the right solution.
Rob
by jdclyde
is out of our price range. We have four locations, with a total of about 80 pc's. Hard to justify the cost of the management software.
Linux servers, win98/xp pc's, so no AD either.
by hfanelli
I'm surprised I'm not hearing more noise about the #3 choice - Trendmicro. I've got the enterprise version implemented at one of our sites, and on an individual basis at another and it's been fantastic here. We haven't had one single system conflict, boot issue, virus outbreak or other software interfernece with this product on any machine since we installed it.
Highly recommended.
by mtn.brk9
I haven't used Mcafee for many years, but I recommend staying away from Symantic like the plague. I had Webroot and Symantic plus TUT and one other that I can't remembe the name of on one of my systems and it seemed like I was using much of my time just keeping up with system software maintanence so I decided to go whole hog with Symantic.
DON'T MAKE THAT MISTAKE!!!!
Before I knew it they were even protecting my (garbage pail) - recycle bin. I was using TUT to shut down start-up items I did not want and then something from Symantic would pop-up and I would have to read through their help( I call it no-help ) files to find out what they were complaining about. It was as though something else had taken control of my system. Well, things got worse and worse until I had to backup my entire system, all 2 160GB hard disks, reformat the disks and reinstall Windows XP Prof SP2. I spent almost 4 days getting back to where I had started. Symantics was no help at all with the problems. Try to find where you can communicate with them on their site. It turns out that( and I hate to say this ) Microsoft was much more responsive.
What I have now is Webroot, the Beta of Microsoft OneCare Live and the XP firewall. So far, this is working out very well.
Dave
by jdclyde
your professional description was a little lacking.
Were you using the Norton brand for home, or Symantec for corporate?
Exactly what happened as a direct result of this version being loaded on your system?
How did you identify this as a norton/symantec problem?
How did you come to the point of needing to format and reload your system?
Why would it take any IT professional four days to load ANY system?
Just checking the Symantec site, it takes five clicks to get to a phone number or email for support. Did you have a support contract?
sounds like your talking about Symantecs home security package? Has what to do with their corporate AV?
When Macafee first came out they were the best. That was for Win3. With 95 they started to go downhill, living in the limelight of their former product. Soon, they were coming out with a series of "new" releases, which were nothing more than enabling the software to use protected new virus databases- for an excessive fee.
I put Norton utilities on a 98 system and ended up reformatting the HD and starting over from scratch. I won't use any software designed by a company which is worse than a virus- nothing Norton (period).
So, I went AV shopping and found AVG (Anti Virus Grisoft). It's free, and it works! Why buy second or third rate, when the best is free? Why?
by eneimi
by jdgretz
I have been using TrendMicro products for several years now and recommend them to all my clients. What I like about it most is that is just works. No muss, no fuss, it just sits there and does what it is supposed to do - stop virii from getting into a machine and cleaning out those that have been left by other products (namely those being discussed here).
In many corporate environments I have seen Symantec/Norton on the desktop and Trend on the servers. Why? Until recently, Symantec had a better enterprise management system. Fortunately, that no longer is the case. The server folks did not want Symantec products on their boxes as they wanted a reliable system.
None of my clients who have installed TrendMicro's products have suffered a virus outbreak on their networks or stand alone machines.
In the corporate world, if I couldn't get Trend, I'd seriously look at Sophos out of the UK. Not a bad product, but not so good for individual PCs.
jdg
by cweb
by ontheropes
by oz_media
Norton is the most wasteful resource hog I have ever seen made available for the PC. Norton's products cause more PC problems than they could ever hope to fix. Over the last 10 + years I really couldn't count the number of PC 'fixes' that have been simply removing (spending several hours thoroughly cleaning) all traces of Norton from a system.
As for MacAfee, it's not as bad on resources as Norton, it doesn't try and infiltrate every running process and doesn't seem to cause as many system problems as NAV or NSW.
Personally, for business I would go for E-Trust (formerly InnoculateIT)as it is very resource friendly has a tiny footprint but is still robust, easy to manage across the network and I have yet to find any system issues caused by it.
For personal use, AVG AntiVirus (or there's even a free e-Trust personal) will do just as well and save you the headaches found with retail offerings like Norton of MacAffee.
Just because you pay for it, and it's widely advertised, does not mean that it's any better; it's just that they are making money from it...and you.
by tink!
While Mcafee and Norton are both good in their own ways, I do think that they are just like many other widely known brand names. They are such a big name that they reap the benefits off of it and don't necessarily offer all that they could as far as services for the $$.
Personally I use avast! antivirus at home. It's free for home use and it's keeping us safe.
At work, we went with Kaspersky because they are cheaper than Mcafee and Norton for multiple business licenses. One of my pet peeves is paying high prices simply for the name.
by rob miners
By far the best on the maket.
Norton bloatware on file server 300mb trouble with updates and it takes control of the PC.
E Trust 25mb so user friendly. I like the "You had a Virus" when it does find one and deletes it.
I have never understood why anyone would want to quarantine a virus and then not be able to do anything with it.
by wdewey
I you get a false positive then simply deleting the file may cause a great deal of head ache and hassle getting it back. If you want to disable it while you investigate the problem then quarantine it.
Bill
by mwradio
by ristephen
I have evaluated both enterprise solutions and we have ended up implementing McAfee's ePO solution. Running ePO server with a backend SQL for the database, 4000 desktops and servers updating every day, it is so scalable and configurable even for VPN users.
I can't imagine any better solution out there. Comes with many preconfigured reports written in crystal. It takes care of itself. Imagine 4000 machines in 50 separate sites updating virus definitions in a 3 hour window with no network impact.
We have been using EPO to manage McAfee on all of our desktops and servers and couldn't be more happy.
While none of the above mentioned products are a 100% guarantee I still say something is better than nothing!
by apotheon
by apotheon
The enterprise version of AVG isn't free: the free version cannot legally be used in enterprise distribution.
That's not any reason to use Symatec or McAfee (or MS) antivirus in the enterprise, though. AVG kicks Symantec's and McAfee's butts all over the place, and I won't ever trust MS for security products because of the clear conflict of interest that situation presents. The commercial AV software I'd recommend for enterprise use on Windows would be either AVG or Trend Micro.
by x-marcap
(I'm puking again.) Actually Trend Micro is as good as the Big Boys and AVG is very good also. Symantec for the Enterprise wasn't successful here.
Trend works well at many of my clients. I also use
Trend For my home now that most of my client base went to it...
by rob mekel
but why is it that when someone is promoting something very hard that there often is an interest in selling something, whether that be a product or stock.
But if y're not sure if KrazyKyngeKorny took it the right way then read his answer. As my post was meant to take.
Rob
by rob mekel
Y're right about the Windows world being a pain in the a$$. I sure don't like how Windows, and I assume you mean by Windows the whole lot of the MS-bundle (meaning all of Microsoft?s software), works as it is repair after failure by failure. This does not mean that, as for 95% to 98% of the time it works fine, I am discontent with the MS-bundle. But those 5% to 2% it doesn't work fine, its hell break lose on my department. And as long as there is neither production loss nor other disruptment in the service my department delivers to the company (being a governmental one) nobody, outside my department, complains. This doesn't mean that whenever evaluating new software we will not be very critical towards our installed base. Better even, we will be very critical towards our installed base, special when it fails to deliver 100% off what it should deliver.
What do you mean with my bias?
As I don't see anywhere in my previous post that I mentioned any product or brand name. There for I can't make out where I stated "that they're the "best" AV solutions".
What you (seem to) call (at least to me) as being my "bias", is that I will be and am open minded to any solution whatsoever, even the ones that have proven being a not so good solution. This with one exception, that being the product/brand/manufacturer that just failed doing what it was suppose to do, or suppose to deliver and did cause production or service-delivery loss to my company.
On the why of this objectivity or, as I prefer to put it, getting the best deal; As I am spending tax money I have to make sure that it is spend the best way possible.
Further more it is my task that there is continuity as regarding to products used. As changing products is getting to know the new product with all its ins and outs which will take time and there for money. That is, for my employees as they can't switch every year or so to new soft/hardware systems. This is about protecting invested money in knowledge/education and assets invested by my employer this not only in my department but the other departments as well.
I don't know how this works outside of the Netherlands, where I am located, but over here we can't dismiss employees just because the employer wants/likes to switch over to new soft/hardware.
Rob
by wojnar
I inherited an office where over 40 workstations were Symantec was in place. The users of most PC's were complaining how over the past 6 months, the applications were running slower. After investigating, I discovered 180 Search assistant was installed on all the 'problem' PC's.
Symantec had not detected the installation. I went with Mcafee's managed antivirus service and all infections were identified (some PC's had at least 4 virus infections.
My conclusion - Norton has some great utilities but for virus identification, you can't beat Mcafee. With the managed product, I can identify what the update level is on each pc, who is uotdated and which pc's have had infections stopped.
by alangeek
by mwradio
McAfee:
I had a bad time with AOL's companion piece McAfee VirusScan8. It claims to be able to run on a 133Mhz. I would love to see that just for a laugh. I recently spent my spare time for a week figuring out that my friends 300Mhz AMD had come to a screeching halt because of the McAfee and there was nothing AOL or McAfee was willing/able to do about it. It is a HORRIBLE machine hog! I lucked out in that I got a 1.3 GHz Intel to work on at the same time that need to be reloaded anyway. When I tried it on there, THAT machine took THREE MINUTES LONGER to boot than usual and was noticebly slower than before! Since then I have met another person using it on a 1.8 GHz Intel laptop with the same complaint. After this experience, I don't care how good there definitions are I can't/won't use/recommend McAfee. If any has any info on thier other products I will listen, But will remain sceptical.
Norton:
Recently I had to fix the Windows update on a local church's machine. Seems that Norton Internet Security 2005 broke it. When I went to find out what the problem was, I found out I was not the only one with this problem. It has been an on going problem since 2002. Many people have had the same experience, few had the answer. After three hours Googling every combination of symptoms I could think of tryng, I finally found the answer on Symantec's site under a different problem discription.
I am still using Norton AV2003, because I already have it, and a host of other spyware and adware detectors to make up for its omissions, but have been recommending AVG to most people.
Thank you for reading my long post.
by vinay_sharma
Did you heard about Antigen recentaly aquires by Microsoft and its using 5 worlds best anitvirus engine at in a one sonftware and all work together.i think its a world best antivirus solution for entherprise and for home/personal users AVG is best then other.i can prove Norton antivirus is usless antivirus.it cant handle the micro viruses.and TrandMicro has lots off bugs itself which will damage your etherpeise solution anytime.once happend with my exchange server.
Think for Antigen.
by kim.hall10
by multimedia 1
I have hands on experience with NAV where I work. I use Trend Micro's PC-cillin in my home office network and I think it is the best... hands down.
Better pricing and better performance.
by jmason55
by ontheropes
by jmason55
by dicklaw
Both do their job very well, but Symantic is by far the smoothest. McAfee is far toooooo intrusive - it is constantly butting into your daily life with a comment of some kind, Norton allows you to check up on things if you feel uneasy.
DickLaw
by ontheropes
I have had Norton Internet Security 2002, upgraded to IS 2005 and bought IS 2006 with Antispy/AntiAdware shortly after release. Their IS product (firewall and antivirus) taught me the true value of a sound backup plan.
Since 2002, on the PC that ran the Norton product, I have had to restore from backup at least 12 times. Norton also taught me the value of not running just one product AND prompted me to study security in depth.
I have had to repair many PC's that have had Nortons protection.
The PC's where I have installed McAfee's product are all on Comcast cable and used by aggressive surfers. I have yet to find a virus on any of my customers PC's running McAfee when I perform bi-monthly updates at the customers location.
For these reasons, I'm going to give McAfee the real life edge.
On the 5 different PC's that are on my small home network I have run my own extended trials. The ones that come to mind right off are BitDefender 8, Grisoft's AVG, Zonelabs IS Suite, F-Protect, Avast and others. (I'd have to dig through my notes for the others)
What do I use now? TrendMicro PC-cillin Internet Security 2006. Is it perfect? No. Is it what I recommend? Yes.
I also have had and continue to use the usual, Spybot S&D, Adaware SE personal, Spywareblaster along with Counterspy, MS Defender, Spycatcher, Mozilla Firefox and PW protected accounts with a Limited account for surfing. I still have a back-up cycle that runs every other day and backs up everything on all drive partitions to external drives.
by dombenson
by vtassone
Indeed , I have to agree with you , both of them suck big time.
I don't trust those antivirus apps no longer. Nor do I advice people to install it.
I advice people not to choose for Norton or Mcafee , because they let through some virusses and other malware.
I use Panda Platinum Internet Security 2005 myself , it works great. It even has TruPrevent Technologies aboard , which scan for malicious software and new virusses and block them.
That pro-active protection really works well.
Greetings ,
Pcfreakske2000
by ole88
by ontheropes
VCom's Fix-it Utilities 6 Professional was just something I happened to come upon and bought to try because it was priced so low. Now it's one of my favorite tools. I'm one of those people that have to try as much software as I can get.
I've run trials on many system performance "improvers" and FIU6 is the only one I recommend for the average user.
FIU6 permanently resides on my daily use desktop PC.
I use the FIU6 Registry fixer along with the free tools RegSeeker and CCleaner to keep my Registry in top shape. FIU6 has yet to be overly aggressive in the Registry, unlike some other products.
As always, export a copy of the entire registry to someplace you won't lose it before running a registry tool.
The only thing I don't like about FIU6 is the AV tool. Choose custom install, if you buy it, and don't install their AV product. I think it's a case of a product trying to do too much. Also, do not choose to AutoUpdate. They never have an update if you don't have their AV installed.
If you want the ultimate defrag tool, IMHO, there's none better than Raxco's PerfectDisk. Pricey but excellent.
I've also used Systemworks for several years and I don't miss it. FIU6 works great for me.
My personal choice, after much trial and error, for an AV/Firewall solution is TrendMicro's PC-cillin Internet Security 2006. AVG free is okay though I think the TM product does a good job. Using the inexpensive TM along with some other free AV tools (which I can highly recommend)AND properly configuring your PC for surfing will give you a fighting chance to survive the Internet.
If you don't have a regular backup schedule, do yourself a favor and take the time to develop a good plan for yourself. With good backups, you should be right next to bulletproof.
by hughes
by genecarl
According to an article in January's edition of PCW, McAfee Virusscan & Kaspersky Antivirus are the only AV products that scan alternate data streams - Norton Antivirus does not.
Apparently anything can be hidden in an alternate data stream (of course we're talking Windows here) including executable files and therefore Viruses!
http://www.windowsecurity.com/articles/Alternate_Data_Streams.html
by wdewey
After reading what I believe to be the same article it said that only McAfee and Kaspersky found a removed all ADS files. PC-Cillian scaned and found one and the others jumped into action after the script was ran.
Did they list what versions were used in these tests? I didn't find any.
Bill
Yes, I re-read and you are correct in what you say.
It is interesting that no version info. was provided.
I would hope that up-to-date versions of ALL AV products would scan ADS's - it could be that they were testing with an older version.
Because they don't say which versions they were using I guess it's a bit of a null argument for which is best.
The ADS thing is interesting though from a system security point of view.
by reconlabtech
by shawnmatlock
by bschmidt
eTrust is pretty good, it came preinstalled on PCs at a place I used to work that was a PC reseller. Did a fair enough job compared to the others. But between McAfee and Norton I have to say Norton. At the place I worked we did PC repair. 7 out of every 10 PCs that came through with a virus were running McAfee. Usually the only ones with Norton were used by people that click on links to Paris Hilton videos in their email. On the other hand, Norton is a resource hog and sometimes doesn't play nice with email.
But really, it kind of makes you wonder who writes all the virus in the first place. For every big virus that comes out their stock jumps a notch. Fishy...
On another note:
SBC support is a joke. Worse than MS. By far.
IBM is the devil.
CDW will only help when they want to sell you something.
by jdgretz
When I first started working with anti-virus vendors and the whole anti-virus community back in 1985, independent testing by the University of Hamburg Virus Research Center(I believe) showed Norton and MacAfee to be very poor in both false positives and catching all or most of the standard virus suite.
At that time, the two most reliable products were f-prot and AVP (Anti-Virus Pro). Unfortunately, neither product was available in the US as a packaged product, only as a download. At 2400bps, that was not something you really looked forward to doing.
Here, the top dog was Doctor Solomons Anti-Virus Toolkit. That's the way it remained until Dr. Solomon was purchased by MacAfee, then they went downhill.
Norton/Symantec and MacAfee have always had great advertising - and the original Norton Utilities were certainly useful and well written pieces of work. Thank you very much, Peter.
Shame these two giants do not produce the best of breed.
jdg
by daversf
Your geographic location isn't mentioned, but here in the USA this past weekend there were ads for retail XP Home Upgrade Version (not OEM) for $69 or $79, depending on retail store, which is the lowest I've ever seen it advertised.
Even though Vista is looming on the horizon, it will be several more years before the Evil Empire forces upgrades (and no doubt it won't work on your vintage boxen anyway! 8^/ ), and my own experience with XP convinces me that it is a worthwhile investment simply because of the reduction in system support and down time. XP is remarkably "self-healing", incredibly superior to Win98, SE or ME. Of course it is hardly bulletproof, so it is wise to run ERUNT (http://tinyurl.com/qtbux for complete info) on each system for a better insurance than System Restore.
On McAfee/Symantec: I got disgusted with McAfee's deteriorated support some years back and switched to Norton when it was still good, but I must agree with all the negative reports in the thread, as it got so bloated and intrusive that it requires three to four hours to extract. One major gripe about NAV was that its default updates only occurred once per week! Only on rare occasions would an auto-update happen beyond that schedule, when a particularly virulent critter was on the loose. The decisive glitch was when I'd use one or more free online scans from other companies, such as Trend or Grisoft, and they would find viruses that didn't even appear in the supposedly omnipotent Symantec's virus library. Symantec's system overhead is absurd, and uninstalling it is daunting to say the least!
That said, I'd highly recommend switching to NOD32, which has been extremely thorough protection, (http://www.eset.com/products/products.htm), or one of the fine packages from TRENDMicro (http://www.trendmicro.com/home/default.asp). I'm using NOD32 at home and have seen it update as many as three times in one day! Many of my associates use PC-cillin Internet Security with no complaints, and actually I think it is more "user-friendly", i.e., a more intuitive interface, than NOD32, which seems to have a bit higher geek factor.
Lastly, as far as office software goes, one should download the FREE suite from http://www.openoffice.org/, and get all the bells and whistles almost anyone could need without paying Gates & Company many many $hundreds! It is a remarkable package.
by firstaborean
by mwradio
See my reply to paguda at the top of this forum for a few more details.
(There are fixes to the Norton problems you mention.)
by jessie
by ccthompson
Sophos is the best I found so far, it is always running in the background, which so is McAfee, but it doesnt hog the resources near as bad as McAfee. Automatic Download, automatic update, ect....
Pretty much admin free, unless you get a virus, then you shuold always triple check it, even if the anti-virus software says its gone, always triple check it.
I have bought Symantec as a special package at Future Shop and it was Gohst and Norton Internet Security 2006 sold as one unit, so I have a safe backup (Full image and incremental also). I have the SEMPRON 3000+ and could record TV on a good quality motherboard so for me it mean that it is a good product.
I had trend micro security suite 2005 but it did interfer with my network connection making impossible for me to browse any of the machine not matter what I did try and at the beginning it was infererring with Zone Alarm also, I own four computer in my house so at the end Symantec with gohst do the job for me and offer me the backup feature.
The symantec does not interfer at all with my network connection as trend micro did and yes we did have problem at work with McAfee, some of our network were not protected for some lenght of time because of a corruption that happened in one update we did with the Anti software. (I work for the DND department here in Canada but I am sure it wasn't just because of that it must certainly play a big factor for us, DND decided to switch to Symantec all across Canada so from a point of vue of a user it work and I know that the commercial version is less ressource hog but I don't have full backup also like I have now at home but who need that if you have full backup on the server :).
For the rest yeah I don't open or go to were you will find the usual Anna Kourniva picture ;) or I don't try to open them in any email as nothing is free in this world :). If you do that for any kind of attachement you already do 90% of the job the rest is commen sens I guess and update the virus defenition of course.
by data ninja
Panda AV outperforms both McAfee and Norton, and their TruPrevent has proven to catch new virus' before they are added to the signature files.
The only slowdown that I've found is their builtin firewall, but by disabling it and using a different product - that becomes a mute point (I'm sure they'll fix the problem soon).
by tubadenis
by jardinier
I have been using Vet (www.vet.com.au) which is a subsidiary of Computer Associates, on ALL my computers (plus some refurbished ones that I sold) for 7 years and have NEVER been infected.
It actually stops nasties (like trojans) in mid air, so to speak, before they can enter the system.
Updating occurs unnoticed in the background, usually daily or at the least every second day.
It is also very cheap. Download it from the website and the annual renewal fee is $AU 43 (say $US 30).
And you don't have to REMEMBER to renew your licence. You are mailed a reminder well ahead of the date that it is due.
As for availability outside Australia:
[b]Vet Anti-Virus purchase outside of Australia[/b]
Currently, only Australian customers can register through this web site. Other customers can register, but they will need to contact their local office rather than using the web.
We are working to improve the online registration system to allow all customers to register through the web in the future.
by apotheon
The concept of Microsoft selling antivirus support for Windows just screams "conflict of interest". It has protection racket written all over it -- if not now, then within a few years.
Thanks, but no thanks. Besides, I like security software that allows me to double-check to make sure it's not carrying a malware payload all its own.
by mwradio
by mwradio
Just for your note, and any one else running into these problems. Sorry I don't have the specifics on hand right now but there are fixes to the Norton problems you mention.
They are also Different problems. Win2000 and, I believe XP, you can check it out, had a problem with using up resources over time when coupled with certain Symantec programs.
Several versions of Norton internet Security tended to break Windows Update in one of two fashions. The one I ran into had to do with OLEAUT32.dll being changed to an incompatible version. This caused windows update to freeze at "Downloading Updates". There is a different problem yet that causes windows update to freeze during the detection process and cause XP to report no new updates available, when there actually are!
Get on Google, with a little digging you can find solutions to all these problems. Good luck! And good hunting.
by apotheon
I have three fixes:
1. AVG
2. ClamAV (and the Windows version, ClamWin)
3. use a different OS
by blueknight
At work we use McAfee and have had no problem whatsoever with it. I have PC-Cillin at home and am extremely happy with it... less overhead on my system than McAfee (even though I could have McAfee for free due to a deal my employer worked out w/Network Associates).
One I wouldn't hesitate to use also is Panda. I've done a fair amount of research and their product sounds like it also is superior grade.
Not to detract from AVG... heard lots of really good stuff about their product also.
If I ever got the time, I'd like to put together my own test bed and compare them all head-to-head for myself.
by tom chase
by scsicat
by hi_min2
hey buddy... what are u talking abt?hehehhe
Actually i don't not use either Macafee or norton coz these antivirus need lot of space and even slow down my system(i don't know abt other people what teh are using?)But now a days i'm using antivirus named Anivir which is the best antivirus according to me.
by dharris
by charincol
For all you SYMANTEC AND MCAFEE KOOL-AID DRINKERS out there that have a choice or influence at the workplace, change to a product made by a company that actually cares about more that the bottom line. Get rid of them. Use something else. For personal (and free) use there is AVG, AVAST, AntiVir, and others. For enterprise there is Kaspersky, NOD32, E-Trust, Trend-Micro, BitDefender, etc (Some of them even allow updates from a central network server like the big boys). There are those of you that choose to use a totally inferior product and say, "I've not had any problems," and choose to believe that the big 2 are the greatest when there are so many that are better. If either is detecting as good as some of the lesser well-knowns but it is still using twice the resources, then that is a problem. If you still don't think so, then just try removing either of the big 2 completely (GOOD LUCK WITH THAT!) and install any of the ones I've mentioned (the paid ones have trials) and check them out. You'll probably be amazed at how much better and smoother things will run.
I currently use NOD32 at home (have tried most of those I've listed, they are all great alternatives) because it runs so light and it is more configurable than almost anything else.
For those who want to see a pretty good comparison, see http://www.av-comparatives.org/ it tests most of the top AV's.
by apotheon
That sounds like it'd be a pretty interesting website, except I'm not willing to visit unfamiliar websites using IE (and don't have a Windows machine handy anyway), and it's broken in Firefox because of standards-noncompliant code.
I guess that's to be expected from a website using webpages produced by Microsoft Office, though.
by dbucyk
Having had to reinstall both Norton Antivirus, Internet Security, and McAfee, I have found that they can be a nuisance to remove.
My personal preference is MicroTrends PC-Cillin antivirus.
Then again, that's me.
I can't give the perspectives on how these "Other" products affect ITs.
However I can state categorically that for my money it's always been Norton.
McAfee is and undiscovered sieve.
They are the ones supposedly protecting Microsoft who then allows Trojans and viruses in to our Computers during downloads.
As for the others, Avast, AVG,etc. I have stayed away.
Norton for all that has been said and done about it has never let me down.
I've rarely had any problems and when I reported, was treated with courtesy, kindness and genuine concern.
It's the only product that I have and it is compliment by AdAware 6SE and Spybot 1.4
Add to that the XP SP_2 Patch and very little can get in.
So I'm afraid that I shall be no fun and stick that which has stuck by me. Symantec.
Thank you
Aaron ;)
Trending Malware posts
Sort by Trending