Which is better McAfee or Symantec(Norton) Antivirus
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Malware
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by servicetech
I use Sophos for the School network that I take care of due to price..... $6.50 per PC for 3years of protection. I couldn't afford to go with anyone else. The others were about $25.00 per year for each PC!
Our connection to the internet is content filtered by a third party, HCCA, and they do a good job of catching most problems. However, an occasional trojan will sneek in and Sophos will clean it up for me.
What type of problems have you experienced?
I have used Mcafee without problems for years, right now I am using Verizon's Internet Security Suite. I had several problems with Norton not detecting trojans, left them slip by, and corrupted windows. Had to reformat and install everything over.
I never had a problem with Mcafee Antivirus not detecting things that it should detect like a trojan/virus or anything like that. Norton I had many problems with though.
by douglashead
Hi all ,
@Data Ninja : I use Panda as well , Panda Platinum Internet Security 2005 and I totally agree with you.
TruPrevent Technologies is a good addition to the antivirus.
Yes , the built-in firewall doesn't work that well , so I also , like you Data Ninja , disabled it and I'm using ZoneAlarm ( Free version ) as a replacement.
Let's hope they will fix the firewall problem soon , indeed.
Panda rules them all , that's right !
Greetings ,
Pcfreakske2000
by unclerob
I've used both and happen to very much prefer Symantec's antivirus client, currently using v10.x (server & client), plus have you checked out their newest deployment tool (which is included with the symantec server product), I can install symantec's av client by simply providing a machine name or an ip address, the rest of the work is done for me.
Plus, have you ever had to uninstall antivirus software off of a pc, I can do it cleanly using the Add/Remove Programs applet in windows for the Symantec product, however McAfee prefers to cause problems during the uninstall of their product leaving you with at best an unsuccessful uninstall of their software and whole lot of unwanted fluff on your machine afterwards.
Stick with Symantec Antivirus, don't bother with McAfee's software. If McAfee and their former chief Sanjay Kumar can take shortcuts with their accounting practices, where else are they taking shortcuts?
Just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree.
p.s. a great free antivirus app for home users would be IMHO, Grisoft's Free Home edition Antivirus software. Does the job admirably, and it's not a performance bottleneck.
by unclerob
same company but different apps,
I've never seen Symantec Antivirus client software succumb to the problems your mentioning concerning Norton Antivirus, I can assume they're similar but at work we only use the Symantec Antivirus client software, we don't use Norton Antivirus. Please be specific in which software you're referring to.
by unclerob
do you mean like Mac OS X or a previous version of Windows?
(just kidding, I know you mean linux - trying to add some humor to his discussion)
by unclerob
...more an issue with your users not being informed enough to know not to open emails from unfamiliar sources, surfing questionable websites, downloading & installing software or using P2P filesharing apps?
- Just thought I would ask the question. We have strict policies regarding pc hardware, internet & email usage and don't allow any of the above mentioned and we tend to operate virus free and we do use Symantec's Antivirus server & client software. I can't remember the last time we had a virus problem, and very little spyware either.
by mwradio
Good fixes all! lol But seriously IF you need to, these fixes are available. If you decide to use apotheon's fixes one and two, remember to use the removal tool from Symantec for your product, 'cause Norton can and might break your system. I suspect this is what caused the problem I experienced. Someone (not me) had removed Norton Internet Security 2004 from the machine!
If you already have the problem removing Norton might not fix it! So be prepared.
Thank you.
What I didn't know and found out the Hard Way is that Norton has different setups for each different OS on the same setup CD.
I.E. If I install it on my WinME, it will know that's it's ME and put in the appropriate programming,whereas when I updated to XP, it didn't migrate and go along with the change.
Since I had changed systems, I couldn't uninstall it anymore. Oh I tried but it wouldn't go along. I ended up having to track it down through the entire system to remove it all and then re-installed it into my XP "Before installing the SP_2 Patch, not after.
What Symantec doesn't tell you is that if you change systems "You Must" remove the Previous Norton first, before your system change and re-install it after the operation is complete. Then install the XP SP_2 Patch, I did it the other way and paid for this too, the hard way.
Man what a Nightmare, however I've learned my lesson and all is well now.
There are version for all Windows in the Setup CDs but the prior Norton must be removed First, they don't merge.
So now it's XP install, then Norton and them SP_2, and I haven't had any problems since. :)
Thank Goodness ;)
by mr. tinker
Neither of them, they just aren't doing what they used to do. Use AVG, F-Prot, Kaspersky-Labs, or F-Secure. Symantec "watered-down" their otherwise good antivirus product-line years ago, and AOL's "bastard-ized" version breaks all the rules of otherwise respected detection methods. (Ever wonder why AOL'ers still get infected even though they're using the 'security-edition' with McAfee installed AND UP TO DATE!?)
The suite products by those companies your arguing over just don't cut the mustard anymore... unless your arguing over which one is in last place.
by biskenya
Norton (Personal editions or Corp) to me is the best in terms of ease of use features. company support is great too and for those viruses that are not removed by the main product, they are quick to post their "Removal Tools" My support experience also goes back to Dr Solomon's days. Have yet to get a virus that I can't tackle.
Probably the only draw back is its dependence on MSI technology for installation beause when that gets messed up within the system, you're in trouble.
My greatest problem was with msi and All-in-One Norton Internet Security! Had to send a feedback to them about the need for a tool to just clean up ALL settings to do with msi. Next time I checked, they had a tool... though you have to re-install everything else that uses msi (maybe we should blame Microsoft that old favorite) All the same keep away from NIS.
Hi all ,
You mean Symantec instead of Symantic , right ?
I don't like both Mcafee or Norton either. LOL
I'm also an anti Computer Associates and Symantec person.
That's why I use PandaSoftware's Panda Platinum Internet Security 2005 and before that I used the Panda Antivirus Titanium 2004 and Panda Antivirus Titanium series.
I totally agree with you when you say that Symantec isn't good.
As far as you using Windows Firewall , I would recommend disabling it and replacing it with ZoneAlarm ( free version ) instead.
Because Windows Firewall doesn't scan outgoing traffic , just the incoming traffic.
You can download ZoneAlarm ( Free version ) at http://www.zonelabs.com or through http://www.zonealarm.com
Greetings ,
Pcfreakske2000
by dksr42
Norton works good but I have found that no Anti-Virus software is perfect and invulnerable. I prefer to use the free version of AVG on my own personal computers and run norton along with it. I never have any problems with them running simultaneously together.
If the people who are ignorant to the fact of keeping there computers updated properly we would not have 90% of the problems on the NET, which is an under statement.
by jackie40d9
I WOULD NOT put Nortons anything on any computer and McAfee is worse then Nortons ! I put AVG on the computers and NONE OF my clients have Worms or Virus's as it up dates EVERY TIME they go on line
I try to beat into people's heads to run the spy bot remover EVERY time they are on ! ! . . I have removed over 520 bots from a computer at one time as one of my clients did not run it for a LONG while !
by claudette
by sfarhanj
Currently i am using symantec corporate editin 10, it works great you dont need to download virus defs manually you can schedule them.
At system startup it looks for key paths of your operating system for new viruses, trojans you may have if found then symantec tries to repair it, if not then quarantine the infected file.
Another thing most of the people have lot of complaints about symantec i.e. after installing symantec my system hanged up and not working properly, my windows got corrupted bla bla..
These are the people who already have a bunch of viruses in their system and dont want to use antivirus software. Later on if they decided to install any antivirus especially symantec, their systems getting slow just because of symantec keep looking for any virus in your computer which it can repair or quarantine, this step slow down your PC if you have a good PC i mean fast PC then you wont face any problem.
In addition to this people must have enough know how that how many processes running in system background and check/ monitor them regularly, if found any new thing then he should know what is it.
by pchsiu
I had been using Mcafee since the age of Bulletic Boards, (15 years ago, I reckon),(before internet was common). At that time they charge HKD500 per year through an Hong Kong agent. I did not mind the cost. Updates were four months late, and there were only four updates each year. That's not the problem. Around 1997,(When internet first became common) I renewed my subscription through the internet on their USA web page. Then I found that I could not update virus definitions. I complained to the USA website. They referred me to an Australian website which said that they could not find my record. I went to their Hong Kong office. What I got was:"Go away before I call the police, unmistakably you are a pirate!!!" So I had to pay double for an alternative--Norton AntiVirus.
I am using an old PC:Pentium 4-1.6GHz with 512MB ram. I do not find Norton AV have caused a burden on resources.
by pchsiu
Hey! I forgot to add one more information why I hate McAfee. What happened was:
Immediately after I told McAfee (as at the end of my complaints to them.) that I would switch Anti-Virus suppliers, I received forty virus attacks in a week. I never had any virus alarm before that. And up to now, after things went to normal again, I receive less than one virus alarm in a quarter. Obviously, I knew who sent me those virus attacks.
by ffulton
I used to be a Nortonian, But Symantec has ruined Peters good name. After More then 20 Years of using and trusting Norton Product I no longer use or trust them
And Tech Support for failed installs is atrocious; they keep telling me to do the 20 minute uninstall and then the 20 Minute reinstall even when I told them I had already done that several times. I will Never Buy Another Symantec Product as Long as I Live.
I have been using Trend Micro for about 18 Months. I have two 5-user license packs all for about $90.
It uses less of my systems ram and less CPU Cycles.
I am a Very Happy Camper.
by herrroger
by demonx
by agonzalez1
by mark
McAfee finds viruses/adware but is not always able to remove them. Also I've had more issues with printers with McAfee. That said, I have a client with a verticle app in Optometry that requires McAfee - Norton just locks the system.
Both are becoming bloatware.
But uninstalling Symantec if there is a problem can be a NIGHTMARE!
Trend Micro is now my way to go, specifically Client/Server/Messaging. Less application bulk, smaller price-point for small businesses, more frequent updates, better integration, server controlled or standalone... The only downside so far is long hold times for support, if needed. Their knowledgebase is not fully fleshed out yet, either.
Mark Raintree
Raintree Solutions, LLC
Santa Cruz, CA USA
by woody goode
Earth to many of the respondents: you don't know what you're talking about. Assuming this question was "Which product is better at protecting computers from viruses?", the answer is Symantec.
That's not my opinion-- it's a fact.
The most painstaking, rigorous tests of antivirus products on Earth are conducted by an British computer security newsletter called Virus Bulletin. They stopped printing issues a while back (all online now), but they used to charge $395 a year for 12 issues, and they didn't accept ads from antivirus companies.
VB's readers either work for antivirus companies, as security consultants or in the IT departments of organizations that can't afford to go down for any length of time.
Their site (www.virusbtn,com) isn't a source for light reading (a recent article focused on the need for a better naming convention for worms), but they take their work seriously and everyone who is anyone in the industry either reads it or writes for it. Not surprisingly, their "100% Awards" are the gold standard:
1. Using the list of actively spreading viruses (as compiled by the WildList Organization (a non-profit group that monitors worldwide virus outbreaks), the staff places infected files on a set of test machines. (They rotate platforms, also).
2. If a manufacturer wishes to have their program tested, the current release is installed on a machine and checked for both "on demand" (scan the disk and see how many viruses you find) and "on access" (I'll open an infected file and see if you save me) protection.
3. To get a passing grade--what they call the 100% Award--a program must spot every infected file and also have no false alarms. Detecting 199 out of 200 viruses is a failing grade. So is finding 201.
Unlike other groups that test, VB does not charge a fee for testing (which can keep a small company's product from getting tested). They don't use only 10-20 viruses (giving you no idea of how products protect against viruses that haven't made CNN, but are spreading). They use only currently spreading viruses (so the tests reflect real-world conditions). They don't use simulated viruses (which produce misleading results). And they don't tell manufacturers which viruses they failed to detect and let them fix the program and submit it for re-testing.
Symantec is 31-6. The last time they failed a test, Bill Clinton was president. McAfee is 24-18; their last failure was February, 2005.
(McAfee has more results because they have a version for Linux and other platforms; Symantec does not.)
Kaspersky isn't bad (31-13; last failure 6/03), 2003). Trend Micro is pretty good (13-7; last failure 6/02). Sophos is acceptable (31-12, but a failure in 4/05 and 4/04). Computer Associates is OK (24-11, failures in 11/04, 11/03 and 8/03).
Grisoft's price (for home users) is wonderful, but its performance blows (11-21). Panda is a frigging joke-- after three failures in four attempts, they stopped submitting product.
I should note the following qualifiers:
1. I'm not saying that Symantec is better than anyone else. The product with the best results is Eset's NOD32 (36-3).
2. I'm also not suggesting that Symantec is the only correct choice:
* My aunt is using AVG because she won't spend money renewing virus subscriptions.
* A friend uses Trend Micro because he's a gamer and Norton slows his machine down too much.
* A friend uses NOD32, even though he hates the user interface, because Live Update keeps blowing up on his machine and Symantec's tech support group is too inept to fix it.
As the VB guys cheerfully admit, detection rate isn't everything, and you should make up your own mind based on the criteria important to you. You want to use McAfee, that's fine.
But bear in mind, if you're using McAfee, that your decision ain't based on rational evidence-- it's your silly opinion. And it would please those of us who DO know what we are talking about if you would stop offering it to other people in tones that suggest that you know what you're talking about.
Most IT questions require multivariate, conditional answers. This is one of the few that doesn't. I have more than my share of issues with Symantec, but McAfee sucks rocks and spits gravel. Period.
Mcafee has caught more for me. I use Windows XP Home Edition. https://www.icsalabs.com/icsa/product.php?tid=dfgdf$gdhkkjk-kkkk (If you look on that page with a complete list of certification you can see that Mcafee is certified for Windows XP Home). Even though I don't use it anymore, it probably goes by what os you use rather than what antivirus you use. Being that all antiviruses are not certified for every operating system.
They may be certified for one and not the other. Mcafee is the only one that is certified for Windows XP Home Edition.
by apotheon
I'm aware of Virus Bulletin's tests, and you're right: they are worth something.
On the other hand, there are problems with treating them as the be-all and end-all of virus protection standards.
A mere win/loss ratio doesn't indicate improvement of the software (or the converse).
A lot of good AV software isn't even tested.
Their tests don't effectively take into account AV-targeting malware.
Their tests don't effectively take into account system stability with the AV software in question installed.
Et cetera.
by dpskiman
by computab
by mschultz
by barklessdog
"ALWIL Software is a Czech-based company, established in April 1991."
I've used AVAST for a couple of years now and it is the bomb! New signatures are out at least a day before the "Big 3". I use it on my Merak Mail email server and recommended it to my fellow associates for home use (albeit McAfee Enterprise 8.0i is my present corporate solution).
by gavinhyde
Avast not only performs better than both McAffee or Norton, but I've found trojans with Avast! that McAffee didn't even point to... The people that told me about it had the the same results with Norton... You can't beat the price and the company's philosophy is why should you have to pay to protect yourself from Viruses? Thats like our American health care system... Why?
I would recommend and have recommended Avast! to anyone searching for an awesome alternative...
by da philster
Used to use McAfee but finally gave up over a customer service issue.
Have been using Avast home edition for a few years now and must say that it performs flawlessly.
I've replaced Norton from other users' machines with Avast and several issues magically disappeared.
Definitely a winner.
Can't imagine what Issues you could have had with Symantec,. I've used nothing But Symantec and have never had any problems with it.
Whenever I needed help regarding anything at all, they would be right there to help in any way they could. Let's not forget that Peter Norton, who started it all did so at the same time as Microsoft was just putting out it's floppies.
I'd say that one heck of a track record for a firm that most people seem determined to beat the heck out of.
I suggest that if there are problems, it's usually on the user end of the scale and it's much easier to Blame Symantec than it is to admit that maybe we didn't read enough.
I'm happy for you if you like "Avast", however I'll stick with Symantec and continue not having any problems. ;)
Regards
Aaron
by jjr.king
I have Norton on my home computers, and use McAfee at work. To date, I would say that overall, Norton is the easiest to work with, although since I moved countries, their automatic update on-line would not work, whichever way I tried it.
Now, this may be unfair to be McAfee, as I am unsure as to how the network is set up in my most recent job in Spain. However, I continually have to disenable it to allow me to continue to do the work I have to do on a contract basis (therefore time-limited). That worries me, of course, but as a contractor I have little input into the systems in place. However, to have the same warning coming up every time I try to process any email blast for example, is just frustrating. Norton I understand, and I just wish there were a way for me to complete my renewal on-line, but having moved from the UK to Spain, the on-line system doesn't allow for the differences in address standards etc.
Has anyone else experienced similar experiences? Norton are simply losing money by this block. It applies to many US hosted sites too - I wish they would say at the start that this only applies to US customers or something to that effect, to avoid my wasting time going through endless form-filling, only to find out 30 mins later that it only applies to the US.
Are we one nation or not???!!!!
Yours
Go Global
by barklessdog
Stinger is a NAI (McAfee) product. Give AVAST a try.
I run it on our email server and it catches viruses that my Web Shield appliance and desktop AV miss.
by noyoki
ClamWin is the only full a/v I will allow the honor of touching my home computer. (I'll admit to not having tried AVG.) It's way less in your face and no bloating that I've noticed.
I've one user that has Norton on his personal/business laptop and honestly, it ran MUCH slower once he installed it. And it did it's job so well that his computer was fairly unusable without some SERIOUS tweaking. He still has to turn it off to use GoToMyPc.
Everyone else's office computer has McAfee. I've been an advocate of them over Norton for years. McAfee has (IMO) a better written bit of software and trust in their users. Norton spends a fair amount of code in trying to make sure they get your money for their product.
by apotheon
by wtdriscoll
We use thier managed service, ASAP. This contains virus and spyware protection. Updates are automcatic daily, I get centralized reports and can push installs from a web page (it will show all computers online and you can select which ones to install on). I get weekly reports from McAfee. I run the Server version (8.0 +) has a personal firewall. Enterprise VirusScan.
I have been really happy and I can quickly see when computers are out of date.
by psbruciu
I have two computers: one working under Windows 98SE (W98), and the other one working under Windows XP Pro (WXP). On W98, I had Symantec 2005. On WXP, I had, and still have, McAfee. Between the two, I am much more satisfied with McAfee, because:
1. It does not interfere with I am doing every time I opening a Web page, asking me to allow something;
2. You can uninstall and re-install McAfee without any problem. With Symantec 2005, the things went ugly when I uninstalled it and tried to re-install it using their original CD. I could not re-install it. After several weeks and tens of e-mails to Symantec, nobody there was able to fix the problem. I spent days cleaning repeatedly the W98 computer, registry included, following Symantec?s advises, all for no avail. More over, after I uninstalled Norton Utilities, which I downloaded from their Web site for a fee, I have asked Symantec to tell me how I can download it again. I sent them several e-mails, but I did not receive any answer from them. Long story short: Symantec is the least reliable and dependable from the two in my opinion.
According to my Professor for Windows Server 2003, the best AntiVirus software application is Sophos.
Stefan.
by largo_dave
by ~atheria
McAfee has long been a problem to many of my users over the years.
Norton Anti-virus is one of the most bloated and system-slowing pieces of software ever made to "protect" one's computer.
As the years have passed, I have done two things:
1. I have opted to teach my customers about the dangers of going to websites that are not "well" known and downloading ANYTHING. I teach them NOT to open attachments from even their closest of friends and family - too many of them have received viruses in JUST this way, it's too dangerous. If someone wants to send a file, you should know in advance or at least CHECK with them before you open any attachment.
That said,
2. I have searched and found that "free" software such as AVG Free Edition is more than up to the task of protecting home and small business users. It's small size and even it's updating, which isn't too painful even over a dial-up line, is more than adequete. It will search on command, check your email silently and is the most painless of all the "free" virus protectors that I've seen to date.
When McAfee first came out, it was amazing. When Norton was small and NOT part of a larger package, it was a good program - not great, just good. Paying for subscriptions year after dog-ed year is not giving the public what it needs - we're just making someone rich for their name - just like buying designer jeans or tennis shoes. We don't need designer virus checkers, we need fast, on-the-fly, amazingly good checkers that don't cost a dime for the average, everyday user - less viruses being spread between the average user could well speed up the internet in the long run as well as give Norton and McAfee the impetus to compete and offer their own "free" versions - like they used to...
~Atheria
by eswearengin
My Experience is with both and the draw back has been almost equal on individual computers. Since installing McAfee managed service, my computer is constantly running. It sounds like its just working away, but the computer runs and works fine. Symantec would hog my resources and bog down my computer but it wasn?t constantly running. I work as an administrator on a network of computers that previously used a managed Mcafee that was to be replaced by Symantec Corporate Edition as a managed installation. This was mostly for financial reasons. The company got a good deal.
The Symantec picked up endless viruses that Mcafee never recognized. I?m not talking spyware. I?m talking real Trojan viruses. It didn?t entirely impress me, because it was a managed Symantec installation and not the client software that many of us report as being a resource hog. In my experience that Symantec Managed installation is not a hog and has out performed McAfee by a long shot. It is the individual installations of Symantec (unmanaged), that suffers.
by jim_stables
Used both Mcafee and Norton at work and at home
Didn't like either one. AVG is far superior in performance ans update frequency. And not near the "resource hog" that Norton or Mcafee is. They are both very intrusive, maybe more than you think; just uninstall one and then do a search for leftover files with the name of the program (i.e Mcafee) and see what you find.
Because of this most problems arise when companies switch from one to the other.
If forced to choose between the 2, suicide would become an option
by 93961
by general
Based on our experience, McAfee is a much more "transparent" software. Ie, you never now is there.
With Norton we had problems such as hanged processes, excessive memory usage, etc.
Chris
by absolutely
Apotheon is right, and with that here is my short list of recommendations to bypass both of those pieces of garbage (symantec or McAPieceOShit or whatever its name is):
#1: Move to Linux
#2: Move to Linux
#3: Move to Linux
#4: Move to Linux
If stuck in windows...
#5: AVG
#6: Avast
#7: F-Prot
#8: Panda
#9: PC-cillin
If ignorant, stupid, or have boss that is ignorant, stupid, or has arm twisting contracts from the mafia...
#10: Symantec
Never: McAShit
And for you fools that call Norton resource heavy compared to McAfee, you are ignorant fools, I have done a very exhaustive performance reviews for a number of AV products and McAfee came out with half again more resources consumed during latent monitoring mode, than even the worst in the list. Active scan mode resource usage is stupid to compare, because those are nearly always run at inconsequential hours. If not, the user is fully aware of not farting around with thier machine while its scanning.
And for the fool, I forget the name, who said that the users were having trouble connecting to the internet...blah blah blah. You're a retard, this thread is for AV products, not internet security, firewalls, or such. And in any case, I have ALWAYS had complaints from peolpe after they installed Norton Internet Security, or that other load of rubbish from McAfee. Just use a seperate AV, and a seperate firewall, or again, move over to Linux. Still need an AV scanner at times, but much less, and the exploits are lesser known and lesser in general, and can be minimized to zero if you go download the NSA's Secure Linux.
Thats about it...
by reconlabtech
by understaffed
by goodwisj
Elsewhere in the replies I have seen mention of the Panda Platinum Software - it is robust, updated daily, relatively cheap, has a reasonable user interface/user experience and I have used it to replace Norton that became slow, unreliable and insecure......
Try out Panda!!! You may just be surprised....
by gacooley
PcWorld just did an article on Antivirus programs. The winner is: BitDefender 9 Standard; cost? $30.
Coming in second is McAfee VirusScan 2006 for $40.
Need more info? Get PcWorld and read it yourself. :)
by understaffed
If you have the enterprise editions of McAfee, you get ePolicy Orchestrator, which allows central config of all details, updates, rights, actions, etc... I have it set so regular users can't disable on-access scanning at all, or change any scan settings.
That said, the ePO interface does leave alot to be desired- maybe it's just me, but there seem to be many places to make the same setting adjustments, and sometimes I get a little lost. It also wants to keep trying to install the ePO client on our copier, even though I have excluded the IP addy from the range (probably missed it somewhere else though) :)
by pchsiu
You bring up an excellent point.
What it the use of having 300 to 600 Gb in Hard Drives when most of the time you would only us it for standard purposes anyway.
By that I mean, there would be XPPro, MS Office, Norton Anti Virus,Spybot 1.4, AdAware 6SE and various other possible programs. Plus the need for expansion? However, it would take an awful lot of programming to actually fill these Monster drives to capacity. PS, I speak of the home user.
What then is the purpose? I suspect it's the old, mine is bigger than your's deal.
I've even heard, "I've got a couple of 300 GB Hard Drives, man that's speed", I pointed out that size had nothing to do with it, as they all run at 7200RMP but that he should most definitely consider partitions and never mind about the size unless absolutely needed.
I'm sure that there are actual users out there who could use that kind of room, but I suspect that they are rare.
My grand total, in two drives, is 160 GB and I have tons of room to spare, so I just don't get this bigger is better scenario.
I'm afraid that in this case, it's just not true, rather the opposite.
As an example, you take a care, run it down the road on a cul de sac flat out.
Now take that same car and run it flat out in a football filed, although it's the same car, same speed, it will take longer to get to the other end due to the size and immensity of the field.
The same can be said for hard Drives.
Not to mention, the speed is determined by the CPU , Ram and Motherboard accoutrements.
So you see, your's is a darned good question, Why the need for all that room?
By the way, I'm not putting down those who have such requirements, I'm only pointing out that it seems excessive.
Can you imagine, filling a 600Gb Drive?
I could put my whole City in one of those babies. ;)
Regards
Aaron
I am a professional geek and this is my opinion as are all the other posts you have read. You are correct, it was many years ago when all AV vendors used that methodology. It was also about 8 years ago that McAfee made the change from scanning the first and last parts of the files to scanning the entire file. It was about that time that all the vendors made this switch including Symantec.
By the way, Symantec used to be inbedded in Windows...did you know that? Probably not. It was known in Windows 3.X as IBM Antivirus. IBM sold it to Symantec because they heard Microsoft say AV wasn't going to be needed in Windows 95 because they were going to be introducing better security methods. We all know how well that worked.
As for the other features, McAfee also does more than the basic WinXP-SP2 FW. It also does more than Symantec with buffer overflow protection and access protection mechanisms. Way to many to list here. But feel free to check out the site. I think you know the URL.
While Symantec has just recently joined the IPS/IDS world, McAfee has been doing it natively in VirusScan for almost two years now. They have already addressed the surrounding issues and have tens of millions of customers who have been using it for said time.
The proof is in the pudding my friend. I would not use or recommend anything else. If any of my consulting customers say they want to use a different product I actually make them sign a form stating so. I will back McAfee 100% because I know they are the best.
Okay, I went a little beyond my opinion but still...
by absolutely
I thought it was a Symantec smear job, but it was actually a commercial [b]for[/b] McAfee 7 [b]by[/b] McAfee that described their own product as "like a monkey with a sledgehammer".
I would have picked a different metaphor or analogy if I were trying to convince a rational person [b]to[/b] buy a product!
by brad mankoff
by jackie40d9
When the first question was which is better of two companies, How did hard drives get into the
question ? ? But your right about partitions but I have a hard time explaining that to people . . They seem to want to leave it a whole giant thing . .But I try to get them to partition them down to at least a 100 gig peice's with different names like country, western, rock ect ect
You're absolutely right.
I don't kow how the Hard Drive Partioning got into this but it somehow seems appropriate.
Can't tell you how many people have had to "Convince" to Partition,and they thought they were losing a part of the drive.
Then I'd have to almost go into my Partition Sales act for them to get the idea.
Once done, they very naturally wondered weather or not the Norton on whatever would protect everything in all drives.
When I answered in the affirmative, then they would be happy.
My personal choice of course is still Norton, however if a client wishes to install McAfee, then that is what I do.
I don't quibble with them. Just do my job and I'm gone. ;)
Regards
Aaron
:)
by netadmin109
I've used Kaspersky and it did detect all the viruses that Norton [which was preinstalled with my pc] didn't detect :).
I am still using KIS 6 beta but I will uninstall it later on (End of the BETA). Although it was a BETA i haven't had any problems with it, not even performance wise.
by jackie40d9
Here is a program which is current and works as well
its called "AVG" I have found tons of stuff on lots of computers which ran Nortons stuff ( I fix them after people destroy them ) And try to talk them into a faster better computer starting at 2.7 gigahertz CPU and 1 gig of ram
So do a search at any search engine and type in AVG
and have to look for their free version but their pay for version is dam good too ! !
They both have the ups and downs. Norton's big down is that it doesn't actually detect all known viruses and its heuristic scanning is rubbish.
McAfee is relatively good but can be a pain for novice users.
I have a selection of three I use for customers depending on their needs.
VET Antivirus, or the free version EZ Antivirus, is exceedingly good when kept up-to-date. It's drawback is that if the defs are out of date it won't autoprotect your system. It's pro is that is undoubtedly has the best heuristic scanning engine around.
AVG - Both Free and Paid For versions do an exceptional job at protecting your system from viruses and are easy for a novice computer users. I experienced it's capabilities after installing it when my Norton subscription ran out. The full system scan picked up stuff that Norton didn't even know was there. It's drawback is that if it's defs are out of date, it's heuristics are not good enough to pick up new threats.
Anti-Vir - Very good at picking up any and every virus. Even works exceedingly well when the defs are out of date. Haven't been using it long enough to see any drawbacks but mayhaps everyone else can say something more about it.
Thoughts? Comments? Am I out of my freaking mind? :)
by kcrea
I've had nothing but problems with Symantec AV; and their removal process is utterly painful at best. After removing NAV and then installing AVG, a bunch of viruses Symantec missed (btw NAV's definitions were up-to-date) were detected and dealt with properly by AVG.
Since gutting these PCs of Symantec and installing AVG, the systems are running smoother (less bloatware services running) and I have had "0" complaints thus far.
It seems Symantec may have gotten caught up in pleasing the "big" contract companies and forgotten the little guys.
You reap what you sow...
by jackie40d9
And I know what you mean about Nortons being a pain
I also use a little free tool I found for removing Nortons called jv16 Power Tools . . And when thats over I do a search in the registry "Find" for either Nortons or Symatec and delete the entire key you might have to spend a few minutes as they spread their ahummmm "Stuff" all over the place . .
And I use the Same Anti virus on Peoples computers that I fix, AVG is the greatest and up dates its self daily with out fail
by carlmorris3
Symantec or McAfee? Are you kidding me? I would have said Symantec 5 years ago.. but they haven't gotten any better.. and McAfee has just gotten worse.
Sophos protects my network.. has integrated spyware protection and responds the fastest to new threats and offers the most updates.. check this out..
http://secunia.com/chronological_virus_list/
My 2 cents anyway,
Carl
by eswearengin
You really ought to cut back on the coffee.
Oh yeah, moving to Linux won't solve all the problems. Linux may be the hacker's playground but it is also a target. There are plenty of vulnerabilities and exploits to be wary of. Why else do you think there are so many kernel updates released so frequently?
The way I see it, Linux is releasing updates about as frequently as Microsoft. Granted there aren't as many but still...it ain't perfect.
As for resource utilization, fine tuning any AV solution to work in any environment is always an option. Just remember the goal is protection. If your goal is performance than you truly need to do your own evaluations and not listen to the rantings of everyone here. You will only get differing opinions and some with attitude.
Best of luck to you.
And by the way...I use McAfee without performance issues and I haven't had an outbreak in my networks (yes multiple networks at different companies) for many years.
by wanjahaloys
NO anti virus software would be efficient, meaning that, it really guards and secure our data from virus attacks if it is not updated on a regular schedule. If the virus definition files among others, are not up to date, it would be the same as no anti virus at all on the machine.Yes, I agree that Norton is very resource intensive to the pc and that is why any one who enjoys working on a fast pc might prefer McAfee.
To me, what matters first is the security of my data. I am presently facing a situation in which a home user had anti virus software installed on the pc but had never cared to download the updates. Her pc was caught by the so call Blackmal.e (I-Worm/VB.bi, WORM_GREW.A, Email-Worm.Win32.VB.bi, W32/Nyxem-D, Kama Sutra, Blackworm, Nyxem and MyWife), infecting more than 30GB of valuable business data, that no backup exist anywhere. How do I recover this data? Which data recovery software is more effecient in recoverying the deleted files?
by dr_zinj
From a security standpoint, McAfee is better. Let us break the two antivirus applications down:
McAfee offers integrated buffer overflow protection - Symantec does not.
McAfee offers integrated firewall capabilities - Symantec does not.
McAfee offers integrated anti-spyware and anti-adware protection - Symantec does not.
Symantec offers add on modules and additional application to provide the basic level of protection which McAfee offers in just the AV product. Of course they both have their separate firewall apps and such but I don't think the original question was who offers the most add-on modules.
And from a security standpoint (yet again) McAfee's core focus and business is security. Symantec isn't focused on any one thing. They are (in my opinion) busy trying to be the next IBM. Perhaps they should borrow Sesame Street's Big Bird costume for their next event... we can just call them "Big Yellow" compared to IBM with "Big Blue".
by noyoki
merging your two posts, you're actually not disagreeing with them.
Pretend McAfee is ADT (a company that protects everything dealing with the defense of a home - fire, intrusion, doors, windows, CCTV, anything and everything (I'm not sure how well known they are worldwide, or if they're just here in the US)), and Norton offers you to pick and choose.
If you choose to add a 28 complex locks and steel bars to the existing doors and windows configuration, ADT will still make sure that anyone opening the door has the password for the ADT system, but at least noone can just get in through said door because they found 1 of the 2 keys laying around. (Be they a vulnerability, definitions weren't updated, whatever.) They need the combinations for the second system too.
This analogy and thought of "more security is better" assumes, however, that McAfee and Symantec play and integrate well with each other. But the fact remains that Symantec really wants to be the absolute sole protector of the computer, gets offended when anyone else is brought in to help, and just doesn't play nice with McAfee in general. (Or so I understand at least. I've never been masochistic enough to install Symantec, nevermind Symantec AND anything else.) This may be because they are competitors, or because 2 people are in a small space, trying to watch the same door at the same time and getting in each other's way.
by tonythetiger
by gryphonphyre
If you write your own OS then you can be in control
of every thing that goes in computer.
by pchsiu
by jackie40d9
Go get AVG a ga zillion times better than either one
an will update daily as your on line and will catch bugs that either of the two mentioned do not catch
by pchsiu
by reciter
You sound very knowledgeable. My husband had 2000 pro and his buddy put xp onto the same machine without removing the 2000.
I get to do the maintenance but am getting lots of nis errors, unable to update and some parts missing.........I am unsuccessful trying to reload the symantec systemworks. on settings, add remove it says there are no programs on the comuter (weird),is there any way to correct this or should he just be running one system (he is not very informed and usually looks for quick fixes which cause more problems instead of solutions.
by jackie40d9
The Nortons stuff is screwing it up, remove it completley ! ! ! ! ! And go get a anti virus which works right like AVG a ga zillion times better than Nortons ! ( go to a search engine and type AVG it will take you to their site )
( Symantec - A Thorn by any other name is still a thorn in the side ) I am suprised you have not gotten lots of worms or virus's as they update weeks later than normal and your subject to getting them
I too am a Professional of over twenty five years in Computing.
It has been my experience and observation that most people who have problems with Norton Anti Virus is the result of lack of understanding.
I've been with Norton since the days when they were handing them out in Diskette's.
Have every Book ever written on Norton and Norton DOS and so on. I made it my business to know Norton.
As for McAfee, I can't be bothered running it down as I don't know that much about it.
Suffice to say that for one time only, I tried McAfee and it was McAfee who was supposed to be protecting our downloads from Microsoft while we were getting Trojans , Ads, virus and the Like.
It was McAfee's short stay in my computer that allowed a number of viruses and spyware to be introduced.
Some to the point where I had to wipe out and start all over again.
I had changed to see the difference and rest assured, the difference became clear, the minute I was being "Protected" by McAfee.
It should also be noted that, to this day, you can go to a Microsoft Download site, "Protected" by McAfee and come away with Trojans,adware and viruses.
As a professional, this does not sit well with me. I have been and shall continue to be a stalwart Norton/Symantec devotee.
While it is true that some people have had problems with Symantec "Me too" ;) , I suggest that most those problems would have vanished had they simply read the facts sheet of the FAQ areas. That's what I did.
Most people, "To this day" do not know that there are Multiple Versions of Norton in Every CD so as to accommodate the system involved.
If you graduate from WinME to XP, you must remove the old Norton and when you re-install, it will know that this is XP and configure itself accordingly.
This is one aspect that I like very much.
So you see.
There are as many good reason for remaining loyal as there are "Professionals"
Mine happens to be Norton Anti Virus and I'm still trouble free.
Hopefully this will continue.
I'm not saying the other are bad, I'm just saying that for me, Norton works Fine and as the old saying goes,
"If it ain't broke, don't fix it". ;)
Thank you
Regards
Aaron :)
by jackie40d9
So I have been on them too since way back when
And have seen lots of computers go down from Mcafee
and lots go down from Nortons its why I went to AVG for my anti virus I can not download a file which is not checked thru my anti virus first . . It has taken me off line in sudden chop style as some file had a virus and this screen turned RED with a message that file has xxxx worm / virus are you sure you want it ? . . So it has been the anti virus I put in new computers I sell ( they have a free version and you got to look for it )
by pchsiu
by ian lewis
Unless you have a machine with lots of memory and processor power Sophos will slow it to a crawl, particularly when On Access scanning is activated. Naturally you need it active to have a decent chance of catching nasties.
The configurability is poor and the enterprise version requires hacking of an exported XML file to change some of the undocumented and invisible settings.
Not good enough.
by serginho
McAfee ruled in the beggining. Norton relies more on marketing techniques than on effectiveness.
After years fixing customer computers, I'd use one of these only if I had no choice of a third.
AV software has been evolving as virus get smarter, so the best solution today, may not be the best one tomorrow.
So, I'd say today the best solution for small sites would be Kaspersky Labs AntVirus. Don't get me wrong, it's a good solution for large enterprises as well, but they still have to make their distribution (push) system a little more consistent
Regarding detection and update availability (every 3 hours, average), I wouldn't think twice.
Regards
Serginho
I have been using the above since about 1992, when it was a DOs/Win 3.1 program.
Now I use the Fp-Win and the Linux versions.
Adavantages.
1/ Cheap, effective, daily updates sometimes two or three a day. They get the new definition files out very quickly, even on Christmas and New Year's Day.
2/ Doesn't hog memory or slow down a PC (550mhz to 3 GhZ is the range that I use at present).
3/ Setting heuristics and Neural Network as ON and actions RENAME rather then disinfect allows you to adopt a cavilleer "shoot to kill on suspicion" attitude as it is then easy to 1/ Scan the pC from a floppy disk set to further investigate with Windows shutdown.
If it has cocked up and renamed a vital Windows file, again no problem.
Boot with Knoppix CD,(latest version of NTFS)find .vxe, vll and .vom files and rename them back.
The scan from floppy set is ideal for heavily infected PCs, the disks are write ptotected so you can "ethnically cleanse" the pC, When I give talks on IT security, I liken it to tying the enemy to a chain-link fence and then machine gunning them!
Of course you can also burn all the latest files onto a cd and boot from this to "Ethnically Cleanse" a PC.
On a Dual boot PC FP-win actually finds compressed Linux keyloggers and other "naughty" software when downloaded to a FAT32 partition.
When F-prot is run in Linux it finds compressed "naughty" programs in any partition.
Nortons and MacAfee don't do this.
The only downside to the programs is that you have to download them. They don't come on flashy CDs in pretty boxes from PC World.
The automatic update system is excellent, it checks for udates at start up and every hour or less if you want to.
But when the main program needs updating you do have to download something like fp-win_xxxx_yyy.exe save it to your download folder.Then double click on it to install and set itself up.
It works very well with Windows defender, ZoneAlarm, VisualZone Report Utility.
Another snag.
Monthly backups to DVD/Tape.
It stops my compressed "naughty software" from being backed up, so I had to put it all in a "Naughty" folder and not back this up!
FP-win costs 25 Euros/year for up to 5 PCs.
Bulk rates for many Pcs are even better, and its nice to have virtually the same product for both 98se, XP, and SuSe Linux.
You can download the Zip File to create the 3 Floppy command line F-prot for free.
This is only to find and then "bake and shread" virus infections.
Of course you have to be able to Unzip and read the help file as to which files you want on each disk.
Disk#1 (bootable format A: /s)
F-prot.exe English Tx0
Disk #2 Sign.def & Sign2.def
Disk#3 Macro.def
Write protect all, stick #1 in PC and reboot, set BIOS to boot from floppy.
A:>
F-prot loaddef
Feed in the disks as required and follow orders!
Then the "Cyber KGB" exterminate the terrorists!
Its very good at disinfection files, I once "ethnically cleansed" a PC with over 250 infected files.
by russellw3
I won't use McAfee or Symantec products if I have a choice. I always install NOD32 from ESET. It is written in assembly, so it is a compact and fast program. I get updates at least every day, sometimes more. It works differently from most AV products, in that it uses the Layered Service Protocol and inserts itself into the communications stack, and that way it sees everything that comes and goes. The Google desktop will not work if you have NOD32 installed, as they both use the LSP, so I use Copernic instead.
NOD32 comes in a server version as well, and because of its small size and speed it protects the server while minimizing the impact on server performance.
by info
Symantec won't install in a system that is infected with any virus, well beleived or not NOD32 will and it will also get rid of the virus and some spyware too!
I knew about NOD32 but i was using Symantec because of the strong marketing they have and I regret any second I spent on that software, it make me look bad in front of my customers.
Since I use NOD32 my life is easier and I have time to clean-up the rest of the system (temp files, Old compressed, drefrag, etc..)
I look more professional because of NOD32.
by thepan123
Zone Alarm is not an A/V program, it is a software firewall, and works very well. There are versions tath include A/V, but I would not depend on them for my A/V. They used to use the CA A/V, and may still use it. It is a poor A/V program at best.
Use Zone Alarm as your firewall, not your A/V.
In yor 14 years, you must have seen very little. Norton is more than famous for the problems it cuases on Windows based machines.
To keep with the original question, McAfee is teh choice.
In a home situation,, one is normally dealing withthe suite products. Doing tech support for a small ISP as a part time thing, I find more problems with the Norton suite than any other piece of software. I've never had to deal with any problems caused byth eMcAfee suite.
On a corporate level, the centralized management feature of McAfee are far more flexible than those provided by Symantec, which, alone gives it the edge. The fact that McAfee seems to do a better job at identifying and removing virus than Symantec, also brings the scale over to the McAfee side.
Both products do, from time totime, release definitions that cause problems, but McAfee seems to make fixes faster when they become aware of the problem.
Why the slicks always rate the Symantec product higher than McAfee, I'll never understand. I cringe when the reviews are released. They must have one heck of a PR department.
I'd never recommend a Symantec product to a client (and I am probably selling the last version of Veritas's Backup Exec, since Symantec seems to ruin nearly every product the acquire), but recommend McAfee or one or two fo the other products mentioned in other places here.
by jackie40d9
Nortons was a good program to recover files and wipe the hard drive and then they went to doing other things . . And from there it went down hill fast . .
I have had to remove Nortons (Symantec ) stuff from so many computers its not funny but I add AVG for anti virus its D- - Good ! ! They did a forceable take over of my fire wall company and I do not get up dates now . .
by rickydoo
by jackie40d9
by danlm
I have found that both are resource hogs. Norton is good, and I like its protection. But, its the trade off with regard to overhead.
McAfee and my current configuration just don't get along. That could be because it was a hacked version that my isp was offering. God, was that terrible.
I've been using stand alone products. AFG for anti-virus and I Sygate for the firewall. Yes, I know Sygate was bought out by Norton in 2003 and is no longer supported. But, I just like it.
When my subscriptions are up on what I have just mentioned, I am going to look around. Because, as I said. I really am not a fan of either.
And Panda. Good god, that dropped my system to its knees with regard to sucking up processing power.
Shoot, I know this machine is only a 1.4. But, it's sitting with a gig of memory. For one application to do that to this machine definitely got my whine and cheese vote.
Dan
How deep do you want to go?
How about e-mail? It is the program most implicated in problems with sending and recieving e-mail. Just go to the Microsoft KB and use symantec as your search term. more than 200 articles will turn up about problems caused by Symantec. On the first page, most of them refer to e-mail problems.
To be fair, you do get a similar number of articles refering to McAfee, but I noted that, on the first page of results, Three of them refer to using outdated versions of McAfee and two refer to recieve e-mail from the program itself. Only one refers to a problem with e-mail when using McAfee--and that is after its removal.
In my years of experience, I've not seen one e-mail problem from McAfee products, but I've lost count of how many e-mail problems I've seen from Symantec this past year alone--never mind in years past.
If you wish to talk about security suites from the two, I've not had to fix one problem fromthe McAfee suite, but I quite often see that the Symantec firewall decides to protect the users computer by not allowing any traffic to pass in or out. Sometimes a cold boot resolves the issue, but mostly not. Since this is telephone support where I am seeing the problem, I simply refer the people to Symantec to resolve the issue.
I can go on and on about th etwo products, but simply stated, McAfee simply causes an infintesmal number of problems when compared to the Symantec versions of Norton.
Also, while Peter Norton was (is) a brilliant person, he has nothing to do with this product and hasn't for years, other than to have his name applied to it. He should be left out of this discussion.
Man;
Where did you get your information?.On what do you base the vitriolic name calling that you have just accomplished. OR is it just that you're that arrogant and ignorant.
If I bought a system and you put in AVG or anything Else that I didn't want,you find out real quick just how fast it can be Pulled.
You must be one hell of salesman "At least to yourself"
And for your information;
This post in NOT repeat NOT about AVG , it's about which Anti Virus is prefer, and that Includes all of them.
So before I showing off just how much I don't know and flame the hell out of everybody, I'd go back to the drawing board and have another look.
This type of garbage is not needed in what is supposed to be an intelligent conversation.
So hit the books, or hit the road, either way, get over yourself and then maybe,just maybe you'll see things a little differently.
Or maybe the other man was right.
If you can't be Civil, Please S_T_F_U.
Aaron
It is to Laugh, They are the ones that make it possible for all the riff raff to get into our systems in the first place, now they have the gall to start playing Anti Virus?
Regardless of what I'm using now, count on this, I will NEVER use anything put out by Microsoft.
If it wasn't for the way the Great MS Systems are put together and shipped full of holes we wouldn't have half the problems that we do.
I'll give them this, it takes guts to create the problems and then have the nerve to pretend to offer a solution.
Yes Sir, Temerity of the fist Water.
But hey, It's Microsoft isn't, we should be used to it by now. Yes?? ;)
Regards
Aaron :)
Sort by Trending