Discussion Locked

Why do IT people really bash Windows?

0 helpful
719 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

719 replies

by gnunzo

There is a mistaken assumption in your post. Most criticism of any software is not due to the amount of time it crashes. This may have been true for early MS and Apple OS's, but if this is the biggest problem you are having, I agree with you--it is largely your fault. XP offers the first relatively stable windows release ever. But as far as design goes, is largely just the first stable version of Windows 95.

Most of the reasons I criticize any piece of software are due to the design of the software. For example, OSX lets me accomplish all admiin tasks while logged in as any user. It simply prompts me for the admin login and password. This saves tons of time for admins.

My longest-running Windows complaint, for example, has to do with the idiot design of the windows copying fucntions. When you attempt to copy a file from one place to another, your OS should determine if there is sufficient room at the destination location before attempting to copy the file. This has been a big problem since Windows 3.1.1 (my first windows OS). Also, when copying multiple files at once, the copying utility should give you an overall esitmate of the copy time, not the time on each individual file being copied. And finally, the copying utility in windows should give more info abou the source directory and the destination directory. When copying a file from same-named folders, you have no idea which direction the ciopy is going.

IMO, this is worthy of criticism and there is not much I can do about it other than write my own utility or buy someone else's.

See, no fault of my own.

by sendbux

Actually, NS has had tabbed browsing for several versions. Because it has been essentially Mozilla for quite a while, now.

Granted, Firefox has them, too. As you apparently have noted, they are the greatest enhancement to internet use since the computer screen. IMHO.

by apotheon

I'm pretty happy with all the major personal computer OSes these days, except Windows. I like MacOS X. I like Linux. I like *BSD. I like where ReactOS is going.

I'm not a fan of Windows the same way a Toyota driver isn't a fan of GM: the fact that Toyota's quality assurance operates on a 100% quality standard, and GM figures it can get away with a 70% quality standard, bodes ill for people being happy with GM quality, particularly if they've gotten used to Toyotas. By the same token, I've gotten used to Linux quality, and I find Windows to be a severe pain in the tuckus these days.

by jaqui

a world of software for windows

a universe of software for *x operating systems

by dvawter

I have to say I totally agree with Amcol. I think fundementally, people bash because either they have had bad experiences with something, or they have a bias towards something.

I don't bash Linux, I like it as a whole, but I think it has specific uses, maybe what I choose to use it for, is different than what other choose.

I don't bash Microsoft, I have had very favorable experiences with Windows, and have made a very good living supporting Bill's Products.

I have my opinions about what is best for what situation. I think both are pretty damn cool pieces of software, I could never dream to make something so complex work, so I admire the creators of both. I guess I see the difference between Windows and Linux as the difference between a Minivan and a Pickup. You wouldn't use the Pickup to take your 3 kids to soccer practice, and you wouldn't use your Minivan to tow your boat. I think part of the fun of being in IT is deciding the best product for each use.

David

by dvawter

"I can't believe you think so little of your users, that you don't believe they could ever use linux. Typical arrogant geek."

I am not arrogant, I am just aware of my strengths and weaknesses, I can't Dance, I suck at Karaoke, and I don't have a creative bone in my body. But I have been working in the IT industry for over 15 years now. I am good at what I do, and my users have wonderfull people skills, and are good at thier jobs. They know how to user thier PC's to the extent to get thier job done. They do not know how to configure profiles, or modify text files to configure thier system, and I don't expec them to know that.

"a linux solution would be JUST as easy to use as windows."

No it's not. Having learned both from scratch very early in the developement of both operating systems, I can state that with certainty. Linux REQUIRES a much better understanding of the over all Operating system than Windows does.

"Plus it would be more configurable to the users tastes"

If the user knows how to modify config files. Linux is clunky in it's configuration at best, it does not have the polished look and feel, and the context menus have a long way to go.

"looks better (and yes some of the x-windows packages look WAY better than XP)"

One word ****OPINION****

"and won't frustrate the user by crashing all of the time."

My users spend more time being frustrated because they can't figure out how to make the PC do what they want, rather than being frustrted by crashes. My XP desktops run very solid, and very stable. The majority of my help calls are of the How-to nature.

"It won't slow down, because it won't have viruses and spyware."

A good firewall, and good virus software pretty much solves this problem maybe you should learn to configure one.

"I can't think of ANY reason to go with Windows vs. Linux on the desktop if it is the user's first experience with a computer."

Hmm do the words Industry Standard mean anything to you? Or, do you prefer to set your users up for major frustration if they leave your company, your own form of golden handcuffs I guess.

"You claim it's easier to learn Windows than Linux, but that is because YOU'RE used to windows, probably because it was YOUR first OS."

Nice ASSUMPTION, but false, my First OS was Apple way back in 1981. Actually did some programming in Apple Basic, then a few years later moved to DOS. And on up the Chain from there.

"The fact is, Linux is FAR superior as a desktop solution"

Again with the Opinions.

"and costs so much less that I can't even believe we're comparing. And don't quote me the bullsh*t statistics that microsoft put out there about total cost of ownership. Because anyone in this industry knows that is total crap. And if Linux weren't an open source development but instead was owned by a company, they would have sued microsoft for liable over it."

First cost of ownership is a factor, I am not going to quote any statistics, but I will simply say, it is impossible for a small organization to run a Linux network without either hireing an IT staff, or outsourcing thier IT needs, this is simply not true in a microsoft Environment.

Second you can't sue for liable for statistics, if you look closely I am sure you will find the fine print describing the condistions that the statistics were gathered, and will probably be forced to accept them as fact.

"Wake up and smell yourselves. Linux kicks M$'s a$$ every time. No comparison."

Once again your Opinion.

"And your transmission analogy doesn't work in your favor.

You are making a comparison of stick shift (supposedly Linux), to automatic (supposedly windows). You said stick shift is better. Like that is a fact. Not hardly. I own a stick shift and I would switch to an automatic in a heartbeat."

Then why haven't you?

"The difference in gas mileage is so minute as to not even be noticed"

A full 3 miles to the gallon average is minute?
The average annual mileage of a car in america is about 12000 miles. If your car gets 20 miles to the gallon, at roughly $2.00 a gallon for gas your annual expense is $1,200, a mere 3 miles to the gallon saves you about $150 a year. (annual gas cost at 23 miles to a galon is $1,043) Add to that the Manual transmision is ligher, more durable, and will likely outlast the engine, this cannot be said for an automatic.

"and it's a pain in the a$$ to be shifting all the time (especially when I'm trying to eat)"

Eating while driving is a leading cause of distracted driving related accidents, I would recomend against eating and Driving.

"But I wouldn't switch if it didn't work or failed a large percentage of the time. Hell no I wouldn't. And that is what Windows is: an automatic transmission that doesn't work properly most of the time.

Where do you get Most of the time. Even with the "fabled" frequent crashes. I still couldn't justify calling it most of the time. Lets say your XP box crashes twice a day (unrealistic, but for the sake of argument) and is down for 15 minutes each crash, it would stil only cost you a half hour from a full workday, subtracting out lunch, and 2 breaks, thats 20% downtime, unacceptable yes, but hardly most of the time. Take into consideration, that I don't even experience one crash a week, You will find that you are actually in the 90% range for uptime, and that is certainly NOT most of the time.

"When the automatic (windows) works like a real automatic (that is, doesn't fail a large percentage of the time) then I would definitely switch. But as you can see the analogy doesn't work."

See above and Switch.

"And as for you having a windows 2003 server up for 3-6 months, show me your logs, cause that is crap. Having to reboot because of updates is still having to reboot."

I believe I said 2 and 3 months, but accuracy is obviously not important to you. Here ya go

pay special attention to the 65 days on 10/22
the 59 days on 12/21
and the 42 days on 5/5

obvioulsy not as good as Linux, but I would count System Availability: 99.3746% as acceptable. Also notice that current uptime is 21 days and counting.

As a side note, notice the abnormal shutdowns, I still get an occasional forced reboot due to a power outage, or an application crash, I have left these in, because I an not trying to hide anything. Please note they occur less than once a month.

10/22/2004 5:00:38 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:65d 18h:42m:7s
10/22/2004 5:01:15 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:0m:37s
10/23/2004 7:03:41 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:1d 2h:2m:26s
10/23/2004 7:04:59 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:18s
12/21/2004 9:33:27 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:59d 3h:28m:28s
12/21/2004 9:35:00 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:33s
12/23/2004 5:35:27 AM Abnormal Shutdown Prior uptime:1d 20h:0m:27s
12/25/2004 6:43:07 PM Boot Prior downtime:2d 13h:7m:40s
1/13/2005 11:49:33 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:18d 17h:6m:26s
1/13/2005 11:50:59 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:26s
1/20/2005 11:45:00 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:6d 23h:54m:1s
1/20/2005 11:46:22 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:22s
2/17/2005 11:27:42 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:27d 23h:41m:20s
2/17/2005 11:28:57 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:15s
2/17/2005 11:28:57 AM Abnormal Shutdown
2/17/2005 11:44:54 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:15m:57s
2/22/2005 12:35:19 PM Shutdown Prior uptime:5d 0h:50m:25s
2/22/2005 12:36:59 PM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:40s
2/24/2005 10:37:35 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:1d 22h:0m:36s
2/24/2005 10:39:54 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:2m:19s
2/24/2005 11:19:24 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:0d 0h:39m:30s
2/24/2005 11:19:59 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:0m:35s
3/17/2005 9:42:05 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:20d 22h:22m:6s
3/17/2005 9:43:12 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:7s
3/21/2005 10:18:58 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:4d 0h:35m:46s
3/21/2005 10:21:22 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:2m:24s
3/21/2005 10:33:25 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:0d 0h:12m:3s
3/21/2005 10:35:22 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:57s
3/24/2005 9:54:44 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:2d 23h:19m:22s
3/24/2005 9:56:50 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:2m:6s
5/5/2005 3:42:09 PM Shutdown Prior uptime:42d 4h:45m:19s
5/5/2005 6:35:22 PM Boot Prior downtime:0d 2h:53m:13s
5/20/2005 11:01:35 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:14d 16h:26m:13s
5/20/2005 11:03:45 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:2m:10s
6/9/2005 2:08:25 PM Shutdown Prior uptime:20d 3h:4m:40s
6/9/2005 2:10:38 PM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:2m:13s
6/16/2005 10:50:40 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:6d 20h:40m:2s
6/16/2005 10:52:54 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:2m:14s
6/30/2005 10:02:14 AM Shutdown Prior uptime:13d 23h:9m:20s
6/30/2005 10:04:11 AM Boot Prior downtime:0d 0h:1m:57s

Current System Uptime: 21 day(s), 3 hour(s), 50 minute(s), 55 second(s)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Since 4/27/2004:

System Availability: 99.3746%
Total Uptime: 447d 8h:3m:58s
Total Downtime: 2d 19h:34m:1s
Total Reboots: 34
Mean Time Between Reboots: 13.24 days
Total Bluescreens: 0
Total Application Failures: 0

C:\>

"And I administer our servers just fine, and have the confidence of everyone I work with."

I am sure you do, and you have more than demostrated your knowledge and attention to detail here.

"And they all like the linux servers and the linux desktops far more than windows. because they've been shown that it saves their departments money, is more reliable and less prone to attack. And they aren't too stupid or scared to learn a better way to do things."

You are obvioulsy very convincing, maybe you should consider a career in sales.

David

by regloff8

Firefox didn't invent the Tabbed-Browsing. Not 100% sure who did, but Opera had it in their browser 5 years ago - not really a new idea.

And I hate to tell ya - My XP Pro machine at home has never Blue Screened - ever. I have Office Installed, Adobe Reader, WinAMP, WinZIP, WinRAR, WinACE, VisioPro, FireFox, WinVNC, Oh heck - even more, along with about 30 different games as well. I've had the same OS load running for about 2? years, I'm thinking that's about right. I runs about 90% of the time. Still, never had one blue screen.

I can write CD's at 52X, while listening to MP3's, and doing other stuff and it doesn't hitch at all. I even play an Online RPG and can run three accounts at once on it - ok it's a bit slow then, but that's a lot of load on the memory there...

by tselca

Linux and every OS has so many holes it lloks like swiss cheese. Linux robust and great security it is obvious you do not work in the security field. secondly there is no one version of linux that runs everything without updating this kernel version or another. You got to be kidding me to say that unix or mac is better then this or that. They all have flaws becuase humans write the code for all of them.

by waterbj

I think the subject is very interesting and I've heard a few well thought out conversations elsewhere. However, I've seen only opinion without any material backup in this blog. I particularly irked at the user who bashed LINUX as a securty swiss cheese. As an IT project manager I have seen lot's of conjecture and requirements from 'security experts' without material information. Their concerns may be quite true but are poorly communicated. Therefore, I was not supprised yet further frustrated to see yet another 'security expert' raise the red flag without backing it up. These people have to be very careful to support there concerns with material information that can be weighed with risk and ROI. Otherwise, you have the old type IT person who speeks in tongue and is closed mouth about the knowledege but quick to raise a red flag. It really gives professional IT/business people a poor basis for business investment.

by keyguy13

I'm sorry but if you have never had a blue screen of death, and never had a problem with a "properly installed, patched and managed machine" then this must be your first computer, and you must have just finished installing windows 10 minutes ago...

Give it time...

by bizzo

And thanks for the comments guys. No BS flag waving here I'm afraid.

I guess I must just be lucky. I've installed thousands of machines in my 14 years working in this industry, and no, never has one blue screen. Although the only OSs I've missed out are 98 and ME.

And yes, I did finish installing windows 10 minutes ago, but it wasn't my first.

Maybe I am the lucky one!

/whistles

by tselca

Dos was stable which version are you ferrign too dos 3.3 or maybe dos 4.01 no it must of been 6.0 no mayber 6.6 and lets not forget the network capability of dos wow no issues there. Most of MS stuff is easy to beat up becuase of their sheer size and power. But here is a funny fact everyone is trying to become MS with thier products aren't they?

by tsecret

Our readers should also be aware of the current state of the IBM i5 and the i5/OS. With it's ability to run multiple operating systems and the real power of native 64-bit applications this is where IT Pro's should be looking.
I happen to prefer almost impossible to hack over almost impossible to secure.

by Member 28898618

IBM had a shot, remember PCDos and OS2?

IBM is trying to dislodge MS by giving money to the OpenSource world, really, they want to control OpenSourcers, and many of them are dumb enough to play.

Users dont care if they are sitting on a 64bit, or a 1bit machine. They care that they can write documents, and communicate. MS has and will continue to kick the guts out of anything that pretends to offer a client tools, and really, they are continuing to dominate the back room as well, so its all muchAdoAboutNothing

by apotheon

IBM can't "control OpenSourcers". All it can do is sell hardware with software installed on it, and/or sell support. Linux is developed entirely separately from IBM. It's not like IBM is running around trying to put Linus Torvalds on its payroll.

by hal 9000

Back Room are you talking about?

The one with the sewer opening?

I've only ever seen Windblows Boxes in server rooms in very small business as until the event of NT M$ didn't have a server platform and even then NT wasn't all that great Y2K Server was slightly better but still didn't capture the market share that the 2000 Pro did for the desktop and while 2003 ES is better than any of the previous offerings it is hardly all that scalable. It's great for small servers {read that as Domain Controllers} or desktop boxes that have been misused and called Server, but really it isn't much good for anything better than a Quad Processor M'Board setup and even then it is incapable of being able to handle all the RAM that is possible to be used on those M'Boards.

So I take it that you meant the "Bathroom" when you say the back room and in that I will agree whole heartily provided that none of them have any power applied. :D

Col ]:)

by avid

if it grows in popularity and gets more attention, someone will start finding ways to hack it. if MS was a less widely used OS and, say, Linux was in MS's position, this post would be titled "What's really behind Linux-bashing?"

by sendbux

If Opera had it five years ago, they are close to the first. O/W, it's Netscape, which has had it for maybe three years.

by regloff8

Here's their press releases if one is so inclined to find out..

http://www.opera.com/pressreleases/

Lemme think - I first installed it... about the year 2000, so year, prolly 5 years? A guy showed it to me at a company I haven't worked for since 2002, and it was a bit back then.

They had tabbed browsing around 2001 or so - sometime, so mabye about 4 years.

Still - Have to admit - I've always like Mozilla, so naturally I like Firefox better than Opera, but that's all a personal choice :)

by michael.techrepublic

Right on hellums...

Could not have said it better myself. It's not just bashing Windows, it's bashing Microsoft. Window's is simply the most visible culprit of thier corporate ideology. The world is starting to wake up and realize that Microsoft wants control of not just your computer but they want control of your life. Gaming, Entertainment, appliances...Anyone remeber "The NET" with Sandra Bullock? Now Microsoft is apparntly in serious aquisition talks with a spyware company (Gain/Gator) and has removed detection/reporting of these from their Anti-Spyware product. Where are thier priorities?

by mchall

As I write this I'm sitting in the middle of a group of techs that I've worked with for a number of years and I the only traits you describe that apply in whole or in part are that they are not formally (not "formerly") trained and that not all of them have software engineering backgrounds. Their lack of formal training is actually a benefit in some ways, not a detriment. They have come out of the business that they serve and are aquainted with its needs and challenges. In all ways they are professionals and deport themselves with maturity and concern for their business partners.

The caricature that you paint is a relic of an era that is rapidly fading. Techs that exhibit those traits are quickly finding their jobs outsourced because management is no longer willing to deal with such behaviour when they can get better service at lower cost. Attributing these characteristics to "Most IT Techs" in today's IT world is both presumptive and inaccurate.

by Member 28898618

All you need to do is look at the posting on this board from handles that include the term "tech" in them.

Most IT techs do include the attributes described, one way to guage the accuracy is to see how users complain about IT. And even more telling, see how IT has declined in prestige in the corporate life.

And of course even more telling, is to see how the leadership in IT is expected to come more from the business side, rather than the tech side. In other words, the techies have alienated their clients, and are being relagated to lower paying jobs, and outsourced unemployment.

The reasons are plain, they have priced, and complained, and alienated their way out of existence.

by regloff8

So - if which drive fails? If the OS drive fails? Our Win2003 server is running ahot-swap raid 5 - so if a drive fails, I don't even power down, I just tell it I'm gonna replace a drive, pull out the old, pop in the new, and it will rebuild while it's running.

So no - that's not Windows that's a poor choice in Hardware.

If you are running one drive and it fails - linux will stay up and running? So what does it do? Attempt to write to a failed drive?

Again - none of my Windows Servers has even blue-screened. I really don't understand the issues some people have with Windows.

You know - if Mac was the most popular OS, you all would bash it - if Linux was the most popular and M$ was the underdog, you'd bash Linux.

I remember all that from the Apple/Commodore days :) Hasn't changed a bit! lol

And actually - the last time I had a drive failure on Solaris, it did stay up - true, but it unmounted the drive right away. Then is became a problem, as it didn't have access to the /var folder and couldn't write any of it's logs.

If it would have been /etc or /bin - I'd bet it wouldn't stay up for too long :)

But how can you associate a hardware failure with an OS? Hardware is hardware - I can run whatever OS on that hardware, except maybe Mac... I'm not a huge fan of OS's that REQUIRE you to buy their hardware - I think I'd call that money-grubbing..

Of course it works ok, there aren't any driver issues, they built the hardware and then made the software to run it all. When an OS, like Linux or Windows allows more flexability to run on any hardware, yep - then you are going to have driver issues.

And DONT EVEN tell me linux don't have driver issues, I could link at least 50 forums in here, with plenty of posts with hardware/driver issues. But open source is just that way - doesn't mean it's bad at all.

I do think it's great that Mac is going to be able to run on some more hardware here real soon :) Kudos to Steve Jobs for that.

Why Solaris got rid of their i386 build is beyond me, I liked that one.

by Former member

I think any OS, no matter what one it is, has their strong and weak points. On my two machines, I have Linux, Windows 98SE and Windows XP Pro SP2. I think XP Pro is a BIG improvement over 98SE. But I also like some Linux stuff too. There are things I like nad don't like about each OS. For my personal and work use, I use XP Pro or Linux, mostly. I use Win98SE just to check backward compatibility but wondering maybe soon I shouldn't really bother after awhile.

I know of people who STILL use DOS! And for what they need to do, it works well. I use what I do because it fits what I need to do.

Maybe a lot of the complaints and 'bashing' as it were, are just computer users mis-matched with OSs. In other words, the OS doesn't fully suit their needs. Or, hardware or other anomolies are hindering the proper functioning of the OS, or the OS had a bug which became apparent after an app installed a library that another app isn't compatible with, or who-knows-what. Any number of things can go wrong in a computer.

I agree it isn't JUST the OS. However, any OS still can have it's flaws which can contribute to problems. Sometimes the combination of these factors can be downright frustrating.

by nick_gonzales

I'm not sure what the exact number is but since 80 to 90% of OS's in use are from Microsoft, 80-90% of the complaints are about Windows. Windows brought PC's to the masses and since most people can't even figure out the VCR, it's easy to see why windows gets bashed so much, no matter how easy to use it would get the same respnse.

by keyguy13

That is probably the stupidest thing I have ever heard. Do you honestly think that microsoft would EVER release something that could destroy them?

If they release it and it works well, they've lost their moneymaking OS. Windows would be gone forever.

If they release it and it works like every other version of M$'s OSes, noone would use it, but people would pick apart the nice features of it and redistribute their own flavor of Linux, because after all, M$ would have to release the code and the distro for free.

Once again, M$ loses their moneymaking OS permanently.

I know he is sometimes obtusem, but I don't think Bill is THAT stupid.

by dvawter

Microsoft has come a very long way since the days of Windows 98. They manufacture a very well rounded product today.

I also could not agree with your more about the licensing, and business practices.

That being said, I simply cannot find a better fit for corperate desktops than Windows XP. You have to look at the entire product, not just one aspect.

David

by richard vickery

Fact is that Linux gives me all the tools that I would ever need to use it, where Microsoft's flimsy product leaves holes in the hard drive and does everything for me so that I could revel in my stupidity. Microsoft wants me to be stupid so that I need to call on someone else. Linux forced me to learn the ropes, there are never any holes when deleting softwhere, no need to ever learn what a defrag is; much less what it is used for; in linux I am part of a community of users who have regular meetings to learn new stuff and hang out with other users; everything is a file, if I ever wanted to change anything, I need not memorize any stupid, complicated code. Linux is just a lovely product that I need not know that much in order to use or fix, and Windows just completely sucks.

If we use a car for an example, if we want to go to some place, we point the car in the direction and it goes there. if we tell Linux to do something, we would ask it to do that, we would not need any complicated code. In respect of the sturdiness of Linux, I stated once that one could almost drop a bomb on the think and it would keep running. there are so many tools at the linux users hands that one has to purchase for Microsoft's product that Linux is just plain better.

If you don't care about using a better product, don't worry about it. Some of us do like the idea that there is a better product out there and despise Microsoft and its stupid creator for quashing the choice we used to have, shoving his stupid product down my throat by killing competition and my choice. Here I will rant, because I particularly feel like it and say that I have a respect for the man and his old politics that is not worthy of the position that he thinks he has, or that he would like to have, inm society. The man is a corporate criminal: I loathe his business ethics.

by pailr

Most people shy away from Linux and the other OSes due to lack of quality software with high brand-name recognition that will run on it. While there may be a tendency to blame software makers for not more fully supporting the other OSes, to be realistic, you must look at the bottom line: fewer users of other OSes means less ROI for the product.

My main gripes against MS are along the same lines as hellum. I don't like their smug attitude, their refusal to admit, until cornered by some major IT disaster at some high-profile corporation, that there is a security issue, their insistence that you must use their POS Internet Explorer to get your OS updates/hotfixes/patches. But, my biggest complaint about them is their lack of trustworthiness. MS puts all kinds of information about you in a multitude of places within your computer, most of which is relative to your browsing habits, rather than putting it all in a single location. So, in a case where you clicked on a link that you thought was going to be one thing, got to the site only to find out it was another thing entirely, you now have to go to multiple locations across your PC in order to eradicate its remains. One location for browser caching should suffice, no matter the content of the page. Something offensive pops up on a page, you go to that location and eradicate it. And while we're at it, I strenuously object to the integration of IE into the OS without the ability to extricate it and remove it from your system. That, in and of itself, should have been enough for them to be convicted of the anti-trust violation.

On a side note... with the advent of Windows XP, there was a basic change in the OS that disallowed functionality of Norton Speed Disk in its prior strength. With the System Works 2000 Speed Disk, not only could you compact all of your free space into a contiguous block because to Speed Disk, there was no such thing as an 'immovable file', but, you could also specify that all free space should be "cleared". Clearing the freespace meant that it would be ENTIRELY FREE of latent images. The aforementioned objectionable content would, thereafter, be =>undetectable<= on your hard drive. There may have come along some successor software that will "clear" you hard drive for you since XP's introduction, but, why should I be forced to buy new software to do the same thing as I had already purchased, with more capabilities, that ran just fine before XP?

by ungle

I understand your complaint about Microsoft marketing tactics, unfair trading, pricing structure etc., and agree with them...but unstable? Are you still using Win 95??

I have YET to find/have demonstrated to me this aledged instability. I've done it all - worked on Unix where we rebooted weekly (admitedly it was mission critical stuff in a financial institute), wit MAC mail servers that had to be rebooted DAILY or die, Linux - definitely my choice, but I do question the memory management, and Windows, where in one company I found an NT server that had been up for 8 months and I only rebooted because I needed to patch it (yep, there it is again.)

Keep in mind, though, patches on my linux machines is just as regular. Also, I've only ever had a linux machine hacked!

Win 2000 became even more stable. 2k3 has yet to prove it's stability to my mind, but is well on the way.

You can accuse MS of a lot of things, but leave instability out. That is just what the original poster was talking about. Ignorance

by fmcgowan

You *do* remember, back '92 and '93 the upcoming Windows-NT was promised to be "robust", "enterprise ready", "reliable", "scalable", etc, etc., don't you?

I can't even remember all of the virtues promised for this upcoming, paradigm shifting, world conquering, competition obliterating operating system. It was going to be *so* *good* you just couldn't resist it.

Remember??

They didn't deliver the goods in '93 and - in *many* ways - they haven't delivered the goods yet. They just keep *promising* the *same* goods, year after year, version after version.

And many people keep buying those same promises. It sounds like you are one of them. I am not.

by keyguy13

"There are 10 types of people in this world: those that understand binary and those that don't!"

Gee I've never heard that one before...

LOL

by dvawter

I carry a Compaq Tru-64 certification, and have configured Linux firewalls, Mail Servers, and Web Servers.

I have to say that For Desktop you can't beat XP.

I will have it known that I am not defending MS, I am stating that they have a good product. You are simply too blinded by your hatred to see the truth.

*nix makes better servers, because Servers are used and monitered by computer experts, Experts get linux, and understand the innerworkings of an opperating system, they know the difference between a MUTEX and a SEMAPHORE. They know how to modify a Config file, or what change needs to be made to an init file. Your General Corperate User does not. Maybe you are lucky enough to administer a group of computer Savey people. Having worked for several corperations at this point in my career, including Discover Card, I have to stand by the descision of Windows for Desktop. The Average employee in corperate america does not want to know how a computer works, they just want to know how to do thier job on it.

David

by solarcarnut

I have worked on and around Operating Systems for most of my career and I have always sought to have the os immune from the application. Stability of the windows os, since it's inception, has been at the whim of the application. The os should not allow an application to harm it. Windows has come a long way and now may finally be in the class of an Operating System, but unfortunately it still has the "reputation and karma" of it's history. Besides with so many good choices available for free, why would you pay Uncle Bill for windows?

by mygetbiz

I have found open source great in that you can get source and tweak and I found it because it's free.

I couldn't find one place for code only, not an application at Sourgefource, but I use Sands' CodeXChange and found xport's xforms for neat IE pluggins and CodeProject.com, Developerland.com and Borland, Sun and IBM source code pages.

I'm using Opensource IDE SharpDevelope and love it, I just have to find out about adding C++ not c# support for some things.

My gripe with OpenSource is, take using Eclipse, for support features/addins requires too many layers and I had to do things myself and had to scrap it becuase it took too long. Alot of the task where more low level and done so I could put an app together quickly.

I do not seem to have the luxury of focusing on objects only, I spend alot of time configuring and making things I need work together before actually using it for what I downloaded it for.

There doesn't seem to be a set standard. Basically MS requires this format or it's not MS compaitible, not just for UI.

I like the power, it's like being able to do inline assembly in c with out having to actually write the inline code so that power is what is great. OS offers alot of power. The skies the limit.

I wish there were more standards in OpenSource, the only standard I seemed have found is in structured requirements for something to be open source. I think having standards make the learning curve shorter.

There seems to be too much and you can realy get lost in deciding what to use and do.

Having control allows for stability I think.

by dvawter

How many times has the US treasury changed it's currency to thwart conterfiters? I am sure they must be lacking in their QA since it continues to be a problem.

It's a not so well know fact that about two thirds of the Web Server Exploits are based on the apache web server, based on the market share argument that makes a lot of sense.

People who are even aware of Debian are a little more on the advanced side of linux users. Advanced Linux users have little trouble installing applications on any distro. Just try to imagine (if you can) knowing absolutely nothing about a computer. what are the steps you have to take to install a program on Linux vs windows. Hmmm

Windows -> Insert CD, Click next 6 times then click finish.

Linux -> Insert CD, Mount CD, open package manager yada yada yada. Start program Deamon Yada Yada Yada edit .conf file.

Or even better Make .program thats really fun for non linux people.

David

by hal 9000

Unless you can provide some evidence as to the above statement I'll have to disregard it as nothing more than wishful thinking and Heresy! :P

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

again, the GUI package manager in say Mandrake (Mandriva now) is way easier than that.

Come to think of it based on recent experience you need to look at windows again as you forgot the compulsory reboot, the service pack (after having to find it because no auto start) and reboot then the uninstall and start again because the default options didn't work, then a bit of cacking about in the gui as some of the registry entries from the first install weren't uninstalled and the second try picks them up and promptly dies with a WTF.
Latest MS SQL Server/ Latest Service Pack under XP two weeks ago !

by keyguy13

You obviously took the short bus to your job if you think there aren't THOUSANDS of open-source applications out there. And no, Linux does NOT crash anywhere near as often as windows.

Think before you post...

by oz_media

While I so see your point, the reason these old cars are KEPT around though is because they are often far more trustworthy and cheaper to repair if they do break down. If it made economic sense for people to buy new cars, they probably would, wouldn't they?

As for why I hate MS, I don't HATE MS, my favorite notebook runs Win2K and I love it to bits, not just the Os but the whole build. THus you are right, a good build that's properly maintained will work fine no matter what OS you choose.

I think the reason people don't like MS in a corporate environment is because of the AMOUNT of maintenance, patching and upgrading it requires when compared to other offerings on the market.

The initial flame off on MS was over BG and monopolization fears, this then went onward to create ludicrous pricing and licencing schemes.

All that grief and work for a more expensive system that really doesn't do anything more than others do for half or no cost at all, purely due to marketing.

There are better solutions, and when people find the reasons for their problems are due to an expensive OS not being properly secured to begin with, this is pretty annoying too. Especially when a FREE desktop may have not had that exploit that had taken 15 hours to resolve and patch.

For myself, 2KPro is fine, for networks I manage remotely, Suse, Novell Desktop or other is preferred and MS has been nothing but more work than it's worth.

by dvawter

Linux simply ignores hardware that does not play nice.

Microsoft at least tries to use that USB device.

by tony hopkinson

I don't know what this device is so I'll take a wild guess and see what happens ?
Put your hand in the flickery orange thing.
Oh so it is a fire then ?

by dvawter

Memory leeks are not an OS flaw. Anyone who thinks so is a fool. I can write a C++ program for linux that would leak memory too. I run my XP desktop at work continously, and on average reboot once a week. My desktop at home will run for 2 or 3 weeks easy, before my game will crash and I reboot for GP's

David

by dvawter

If you have the SP2 CD for XP included with technet, or available from MS, you will only have 5 or 6 updates left to install, and the install (clean) including office can be completed in about 2 hours.

David

by keyguy13

If you've even LOOKED at a Linux install in the past 5 years, you know it is NOT AT ALL hard to install. In fact, Mandrake is easier to install than windows and WAY more configurable.

Some of you seem to be stuck in the world of 5-10 years ago.

Know what you're talking about before pressing the reply button...

by rmiller

Whenever people have their choices trumped, there is resentment. Microsoft through its market, legal, and political machinations has destroyed every other reasonable choice. Why would Microsoft concentrate on destroying competitors rather than just competing on merit? It is because Microsoft fears that if people can chose they will not chose Microsoft. If the government enforced the anti-trust laws that were created exactly to control predatory companies like Microsoft, there would be far more choices in the market place. Diversity in any system is an important measure of health and efficiency. Weak minded people find diversity threatening and difficult.

Many people love a winner. They will always side with the overdog. For these people Microsoft was a pitifully obvious choice and Microsoft's victory makes them feel like winners. Weak people always ally with a bully for strength.

What can I say, Windows is ugly, uninspired, engineered for the lowest common denominator, bloated, inefficient, confused, and bug ridden. There should be a law that MS can add no new features until it debugs those it already has.

by Member 28898618

I am not a "fan" of my car. I use it to go places. It demands fuel, and maintenance.

Likewise, I use Windows and who knows what else running my cell phone, and stereo, and gps device as a tool. I like to use useful tools, that give me ways to get things done. Windows more than meets that.

If I hit my finger with my hammer, i dont blame the hammer. Blaming Windows is like blaming the hammer, to do that it more reflective of the human and their shortcoming, or ignorance, than anything else.

by raven2

This is from the perspective of a user/semi-techie, who has a 2 machine network with a DSL router. I know you folks with networks have a whole other set of needs and issues.

My perception of M$ is they value bottom line over any other measure. As a user/semi-techie, I have had to deal with hardware failures (yes I know not OS related), driver tweaks, and applications that would not work. I want to accomplish specific tasks, not have "issues" come up. My belief is that the OS is the platform to launch applications that I want to use. I want that platform to be stable, secure, and conformable.

I do not like to face a flurry of "fixes" that may fix a problem that does not really affect the way I use my computer, but may change settings or actually break something, necessitating an application reinstall or other time consuming foolishness. Deciphering a Windows error code is an annoying exercise in the light of a failed fix. I want the OS that I use to be under my control, I have set manual update procedures, because I do not like any application on my machine doing its "own thing". There would be fewer problems with computer systems overall if the OS was less suseptable to unsupervised "improvements".

I recently built and installed XPHome SP2 on two machines and am pleasantly surpised that it works so well. I have seen folks try to upgrade from SP1 have a devil of a time trying to get the "new" SP2 to work.

The forced upgrade dance where new applications seem to be deliberately designed to make the interchange of information difficult is another annoyance. Yes, you can make Word save documents in older formats. But how many times do you want to send a request to people you are doing business with to instruct them how to do this so you can read their documents? So you are forced to "upgrade" if your OS will not support the "upgraded" app then you need a "new" OS, and if your "new" OS has higher system requirements then you also need a new computer. We complain of hackers using "social engineering" to manipulate folks; I contend this "upgrade dance" is "social engineering" to manipulate more money out of the consumer's pocket.

The Bottom Line for me is:
1) My perception is that the M$ OSs have been somewhat unstable, subject to changes from unknown sources.
2) Standards seem to change with some regularity based more on economics rather than real needs.
3) If you aspire to be the single source utility that makes the computing world work, you change your mandate from a "for profit" to a "public utility" business model. Monopoly come with a price.
4) If it was not built correctly why are you selling it. I expect the wheels to stay on my car, I expect my OS to be usable without a lot of fixing.

by apotheon

If I hit a nail with my hammer, and rather than driving the nail the hammer's head splinters and sends shards of metal through my hand, I certainly blame the hammer manufacturer.

by i.t.services

when was the last time that you bought a new car? Can you say recall? why do you think the warranties are there? My house is 100 years old and cost about 165k my car is 2 years old and cost about 40k, which do you think will last longer in terms of money spent? Your OS cost how much? or was included with your machine, again for about how much?
Tech = change! or do any of your OS's still support a 14.4 modem? how about a 9.6?
Kind of hard to write for foward compatability on those new graphic cards eveyone will want in four years, and the new drivers that go with them. If you can guess what those needs (tech) will be ahead of time, have I got a job opening for you!...

by ponderworks

A little story from a 25+ year veteran....

Once upon a time, OSs were beyond questioning. Companies that manufactured OSs were shocked, embarrassed, and highly responsive if ever any potential bug showed up. You could almost "bet your life" on the OS. I personally had an experience where a colleague and I found a security problem with an IBM operating system. We documented it and sent it to them expecting nothing. Within 30 days, we were contacted, the bug acknowledged, and shortly thereafter a new release contained a fix (and then some).

So it is when you are not the "only game in town". Personally, it is not Windows that fries me and a lot of other people. It is the way Microsoft uses their hegemony and business practices to make sure NO ONE and I mean NO ONE has a chance to compete fairly against them. I'm happy to use Windows when I am not forcibly made to use it because no other company dares to try to compete. The fact is, competition is good. Monopoly is generally (but not always) bad.

That's my 2 cents.

by avid

that's it.. i am going to write a new OS AND grow a larger penis... both will be finished next week ! (ha ha)

by it.dude

Impressive! ....most impressive!

Haven't read a quality dress-down of M.S. for a while.

Thanks for the reminder of why it's better to INVEST time in learning Linux, than to WASTE time attempting to figure out the "Black Box", "super secret", " .... oh God, if hackers found out about this !!!" reason for my PDC and BDC to stop talking to each other.

I'm not going to write the novel of what kind of admin job I had been doing previous to the above issue. I will simply say that I had MS Updates done (manually installed while I watched), firewalls up, anti-virus running and updated. The two Server 2000 boxes were communicating one day, and the next had stopped.

The ultimate solution, I had to promote the BDC to PDC. Reinstall the old PDC so it fixed the problem and then set it up as BDC.

Since I've moved to Linux, I have to take the covers off once in a while to dust!!!
Admin is pretty borning unless I want to spend time tracking down the origin of an attempted Hack or brute force password attack.

Sorry Angus, ... there I go MS Bashing!

by wdewey

An operating system is supposed to provide a seamless interface to the hardware so that the Programmer/User doesn't have to know machine code do what ever it is they need to do. If the sound card doesn't work after an OS patch, that is a problem with the OS. If it doesn't run the way I want it to then it is worthless to me.

There are only a few manufacturers that produces both the hardware and the OS for their system. The ones that come to mind at this time are Sun Microsystems and IBM. Since Microsoft doesn't make computer hardware then everything is "The end user market with hardware" and therefor a "short comming" of Windows.

I like that Windows is easy to use. I like that Linux/Unix has enormous capability out of the box. I like the ideas and theories about how Netware works (some of their implementations are clunky and expensive), but some of the statements you have made about what OS are and aren't supposed to do I don't like.

Bill Dewey

by avid

yes he is there. but i don't think he will die anytime soon. the way i see it, there are 2 choices:
1. feed the monster and keep him happy.
2. sleep on the floor

we can either keep buying MS and enjoy the fact that most software will be compatible if not stable or we can go with other OS's and spend huge amounts of time dealing with compatibility issues.

by wdewey

I haven't ever hear about anyone bashing Oracle, IBM, or Cisco (except maybe about their prices).

Bill Dewey

by santulli

I guess you never heard of the "MS Blue screen of death". You?re reading your email and all at once you get the... ?MS Blue screen of death". You didn?t cause it you didn?t change anything it just happened. Call up and ask MS and they?ll say ?Well that happens some times we don?t know why?.
We bash Windows because it?s written poorly, and it?s written poorly because they know that people like you will blindly go our and buy every new release or upgrade they put out anyway. Only by criticizing can we force MS or any other OS to put more effort into their products and stop stealing and insulting us.
George the good

by i.t.services

I still have a P2@266 and a P3@566 still up and running. acctually I am posting this with the P3 running win XP. While the P2 running ME is still buggy it is just for my kid's games, the P3 has only blue screened once, and my current P4 and P4HT running XP Pro have never given me the BSOD or even locked up.
In ALL things, if you take care of your machines, they in turn will take care of you.

And for all you ADMINISTRATORS...you don't have to like the OS's...(unless you are the one paying for them) but it is your JOB to fix them.
Do you think machanics like every car they work on? or doctors like all of their patients? No they get paid because they either have the knowledge to fix them or know how to find it. So do we. If you get so frustrated you have to start bashing maybe it is time to look for a new line of work?....McDonalds is always hiring :)
I like to think, YEAH I GET TO DO THIS!!!
Better than digging ditches...by hand...in the winter. (one of my first jobs..many years ago :) )

by jmgarvin

"Likewise, I use Windows and who knows what else running my cell phone, and stereo, and gps device as a tool. I like to use useful tools, that give me ways to get things done. Windows more than meets that."

Your cell phone is probably running some *nix variant as well as your gps device. I have no idea what kind of firmware OS stereos use, but I would assume that if they are proprietary, they are using *nix.

Windows DOES NOT get things done. What it does do is break, become unstable, and crash. Hell, I had a great driver issue in Win2k that could NEVER be resolved. Windows doesn't just work, ir requires constant tinkering and tweaking to make it run right.

"If I hit my finger with my hammer, i dont blame the hammer. Blaming Windows is like blaming the hammer, to do that it more reflective of the human and their shortcoming, or ignorance, than anything else."

I blame Windows because Windows isn't a reak hammer...it is a plastic childs toy hammer. It will never pound the nail in and it will only manage to break off into small pieces and choke small children.

As for calling the wetware ignorant and unable, this is patently false in this forum. Perhaps your average user might have trouble, but those of us in these forums are quite apt with technology and are able to see OSs for what they are worth.

by greg talbott

So the system slows down, errors start to occur to a maddening point until the system becomes basically a large paperweight in the course of a year.
Are we expected to blame ourselves? Are we supposed to blame the hardware?
What once worked great doesn't work at all and the software vendor applies "patches" on a monthly basis to "fix" these problems and they don't work.
I NEVER had a DOS system crash even when I attempted to sabotage it. It just plain flat out said I could not do an illegal operation and back to the default command prompt.
See my point here?

by tony hopkinson

understand is a good thing as opposed to guessing what it is then intermittantly crapping out because it was wrong.
The whole selling point of windows is you don't have to be technical to use it. You do have to be very technical to even approach stability though.

by crake

BookLink Technologies pioneered tabbed browsing in its InternetWorks browser in 1994.

As usual, Microsoft had an "epiphany" and implemented this technology in its IE shell called "NetCaptor" in 1997.

It was followed by Opera 4 in 2000, although Opera has always had a full MDI interface (as opposed to TDI or SDI).

Mozilla integrated tabbed browsing in 2001 (through the MultiZilla extension in April of 2001 and a built-in tabbed browsing mode added to Mozilla 0.9.5 in October of 2001) and Safari in 2003.

As for your perfect computer that never crashes... bully for you.

by tony hopkinson

card when I got the PC, Nothing wrong with it after I rolled back the windows critical update either !

The reason you don't rely on return codes from API calls is the the guys who wrote said APIs don't always bother to set them, or for underlying ones outside your own code they don't bother to test them when they are set.
So you get the old error in line X or derivative when the real problem was about 30,000 instructions ago in another Dll usually, but the potentially meaningful description has been overwritten or flat out lost in subsequent code.

That architecture alone is responsible for well over half the faults in ms style code, which is why no one who knows anything about software development uses it anymore.

I don't claim to be in expert in anything not even my forte which is software design. I can safely claim to be past the burbling wet behind the ears stuff that makes up the bulk of ms's legacy OS code. Which being brutally honest would require them to rewrite the OS and most of their apps from the ground up to get rid of.

It's a regular in software engineering.
Refactoring/Re-engineering increases risk and causes some extra work every iteration.

Not doing it exponentially increases the cost of every change, until you get to the point where adding new core functionality is impractical/impossible and you start with the bolt ons. Bolt ons always have poor interfaces to existing code and make holes for security, compatibility and stability issues to fall through.

Recognising anything here ?

by bmcombrw

The point is, a bad app should only crash itself, not the OS. That is what IBM seems to have perfected, and that was one of the superior features of OS/2 vs Windows (and not just 3.1). The point is, a poorly written app shouldn't be able to corrupt one of the core elements of the OS (that darn Registry) just by installing it, and then be unable to be completely uninstalled - with little hope of reliably being able to manually rip the bad stuff back out. An app shouldn't be able to install pieces of itself into "common" areas such that they can overwrite similar pieces installed by other apps, which can result in previously working apps suddenly not working, lock up the system, and yes, even BSOD. Yes, it's not just drivers that crash OSes. I've installed something that took my XP system down, went back to a safe System Restore Point, and discovered that something had been overwritten that the Restore Point had not saved. At this point, I'm almost positive it wasn't the last thing I installed all by itself, but some weird interaction with a "bad" app already installed too long ago to make it practical to return to that old a Restore Point. And I refused to reinstall the OS, and all the apps, utilities, customizations, etc., as many of us had to do over and over with the earlier incarnations of Windows. Can you say "Poor OS Design"?

by steve_it

If the majority of users moved to unix, the focus of nefarious types would change, and we would start to see any small chinks in unix armour being fully exploited by those who now are not even trying. The evil eye of the do-no-gooders is fully focused on MS. Do we want them to change...

by deesy58

The Operating System is a program. In beginning programming courses, prospective programmers are taught that their programs should be "robust" - that they should rarely "crash." If an Operating System crashes, it pretty clearly is not robust, and probably represents bad programming. That seems to be ample enough reason to "bash" an OS. Who wants an unstable OS if a High Availability system is trying to be run? Instability sometimes carries a high price.

by stooobeee

An OS that is never used never makes a mistake. That clearly defines the user as the person who changes the way it works. OS's are optimally
designed within the developers' parameters. The user must learn what those parameters are. Since that is a learning process, he is bound to go outside the OS envelop. The more familiar he is with the OS, the fewer mistakes he makes. Sounds reasonable to me.

by sheiba

Their seems to be a tendancy to bash windows. I have debated with IT people over the years and found that most of them a incompetent, ill trained, gullible, narrow minded, lack initiative, impatient and lazy.
Found that these characterists usually indicate a poor IT individual. I never have trouble with windows98, ME, XP, 2000 Pro, 2000Svr, 2003Svr because I find the time to study, get certified and do a University degree. I also operate my own consultancy business and I am involved in all levels of deployment, designing and administering Windows on a variety of platforms, from AD to standalone. Security and privacy issues are not difficult to employ if you know what you are doing.

by jazzy5

I believe people bash Windows because is the biggest target out there. People talk or repeat what some idiot said without verifying the subject. Does Windows has flaw? You bet. Does Linux or Mac have some? Sure do.

All OS is a evolution, a constant change to be better and to be all to all users. This we know is true (changes) and imposible (be all). As I recall after DOS, came Windows 3.1, a little better but not by much. Then came Windows 95, the salvation of all computer problems, (some people thought that, ha!). To many crashers, but a big improvement over Windows 3.1. Then came Windows 98, a much improve OS, more stable, easy to operate for the masses and another boost for the computer industry. Microsoft also created for the business enviroment a different OS, which was NT and later Windows 2000. A more secure and stable platform. Each Windows was a better and easier OS for the majority of people, which made it the best seller OS. The easier to use also made it that more vulnerable for hackers. As Windows XP became more secure the more difficult is getting to do things on your computer. People get upset when Windows ask to send info to Microsoft when a crash happens. They scream bloody murder with Microsoft hinted on a new security system for the next Windows Longhorn, which Microsoft had to cancel.

What Apple has with Mac is a great system but with limited application supporting it. Of course it helps that they own the software and hardware. Which makes them a monopoly. Only from them you can buy the computer and the software. Remember when other company tried to build and sell Mac clone. They got sued. Nobody can compete with Mac. So they dictate the price, which is overboard for what you getting. And how many people can build they own Mac, and modify it like regular PC? Not many. It puts a dent in my freedom with computers.

Linux is a secure computer. But difficult to install or operate. Yes, I know that now is much easier to do, but not for the regular people. Their are many variation of Linux as there are key on my keyboard. Which to choose? Will it be secure when it becomes the number 1 OS? I doubt it, because it will be the biggest target. And with so many variations and many people providing codes to build it, it does not make me reassured on it. Who is to say that the mafia made one and they are waiting to get many customers before they strike?

What I can say now is that Microsoft made the computer industry was it is now. It made it easy and cheap to everyone to have a computer. Nobody conceive they were going to be so many dishonest, corrupted, stupid people now to cause all the headache we have now with spyware, virus, hacks and so on.

BTW, I when thru all different Windows since DOS up to XP. Never had a crash except with Windows ME, and of course I build all of them with the right component (Apple has the right idea with controlling the hardware and software).

by yanipen

I had a lot of time reading all of the reply from our peers in this group. Sorry for this reply. When you posted this, its probably midnight to where I am.

For a reason, I agree to your opinion. But as Hal (Col) has said, it has something to do with business practice. Often times MS presents their OS based on the deadline. It has to be on the market by this date. Oh, you know what I mean. Because of this reason alone, we have the troubles that we encounter day to day with this OS. In itself, the OS is not at fault. What is at fault is the way it was released.

Windows is the most widely accepted OS in the world. Bill has made it a household name. since it was widely accepted, of course comes the issues. Heck, any OS that becomes a household name will recieve scrutiniy as much as windows as is now. The only differece is the way the company releases it and the efforts to make it a better product.

I said my piece, I hope this helps.

by h2owe2

I also have a lot more than 6 years IT experience and now work for an organisation that is scrapping it's Netware 5.1 infrastructure in favour of MS W2k & W2K+3 servers. One Netware server just celebrated 300 days up-time, the other 4 are each close to 200 days. The last restarts were due to power faults, not due to bugs in the O/S. I also have around a dozen W2K servers, none of which has lasted longer than 60 days up-time; they receive security patches every month. Our terminal server needs re-booted every night to stay reliable.
Maybe it's not Microsoft but us who should be criticised. Like kids at a fair, we are dazzled by Microsoft's glitz and glamour. After the transaction is completed we find out that under the flashy packaging Windows software is like a high-end Swiss army knife, lots of chrome and features but not too many tools that you would use if you had a choice. Not a good metaphor is retrospect as my Swiss army knife is a lot more useful and reliable to me than any MS product.

by Member 28898618

IBM participates in the OpenSource effort by paying R&D bucks to its developers to make OpenSource code. The number is very large. Oh yes, they do in fact control their staffs, and oh yes, the OpenSource weenies pay big attention to such a big pocketed ally.

by nealweidenhofer

First: A note on my qualificattions. I have been a systems programmer (that was the preferred title when I started -- I have held a number of titles since, most often containing the word "engineer") for nearly forty years. During that time I have specialized about 2/3 in compilers and related tools and about 1/3 in OS design and development.

Yes, I bash Microsoft/Windows at every opportunity because of all the OS's I have tried to use it crashes the most, the most inexplicably, and with the least hope of recovering what you were working on when it does. It is also the least user-friendly.

It is always the OS's (or possibly the hardware's) fault when it crashes, that's what "robustness" is all about. With protected memory and instructions (which were becoming popular even when I started) there is just no reason for an OS to crash no matter what the user or the user's program does, other than an OS bug or hardware malfunction.

Windows and MS/DOS before it are the claasic example of "get the OS out on time and worry about bugs later".

by donweb

Obviously you know nothing about good products or good programming practices.

The problems Microsoft has are outrageous BUT we have to live with them and work around them.

Not only that, if you ever do any development work you find that the code already done by MS is horrible. Just try to do anything with say Sharepoint. It is obvious they put 1000 right out of college coders (not programmers) on it and told them "you do this, you do that ..." What a mess. And common sense basic features are not there.

It is unfortunate that crashes by MS products are usually NOT the operator's fault but are a serious design flaw instead.

MS needs to stop trying to add new gimmicks and solidify and document what they now have.

by daavid.turnbull

Windows success relies in the most part because managers etc. can relate to it. It looks pretty.

I want an OS that runs the programs I want it to run, no more and no less. The philosophy behind Windows seems be that it wants to run your life - not the other way around.

The learning curve for Unix (and like) OS's is a little steeper but the philosophy that drives Unix means that you can chain the commands together to get them to do exactly what you want. With Windows programs this is not possible, you are at the mercy of the software author and what he thought you may wish to do with the program. The result is always a compromise.

by wlbowers

Why do I bash Microsoft? Let me count the ways.

First off I have been in computers since 1969. My first
machine that I upgraded was a radio shack model 3.

I have used every version of Microsoft OS since the
60's.

There is no compatibility with Microsoft based products.
That's why you have to download updates for products
that are new right off the shelf. In the 2 months it takes
them to get across the ocean in that container you will
find patch updates waiting for them.

You think Microsoft cares. Anybody that will produce a
product that has almost no chance of recovery from a
system crash doesn't care past the purchase price.

Windows XP is the most frustrating OS to service they
have ever made. They could have put line confirmation
back in the safe mode boot if they wanted to.

Oh sure they provide better recognition and installation
of drivers, but that is only because if they didn't no one
would ever get the dang thing installed. One pissed off
driver and that is it Bubba. That blue screen goes by at
mach 3, right before the reboot.

Our fault? Brand new load of Asus MB, WD HD
Kingston memory, Nvidia Video. It took a trip to Asus
and Nvidia's website for major patches to clean things
up. And I won't even talk about ATI.

You know why I work on Microsoft Windows boxes.
Because it is a good living. If I had to depend on
servicing Macintosh equipment I would die and turn to
dust.

My calls run 100 or more to 1 Microsoft to Mac.

My wife keeps $75.00 in a cookie jar. Bail money for for
when I meet a Microsoft programmer and "Hit any Key
To Continue"

Lee Bowers
MST

by kcb

It is just plain wrong, blaming the Techie for "... if the OS crashes then it's your fault not the OS;". People stating that truly have more to learn.

The OS programmers also have left MANY bugs in the OS. They are many in Microsoft Windows. They cause crashes. Nothing users can do besides try to avoid them when known. Some aren't published, there are long lists, they change between OS versions, and even change based on patch level.

I have used many OS and will continue to do so. They all have good uses.

But Microsoft Windows is known for being less reliable. It is even banned from being accepted among certain higher reliable uses per government agency standards. Marketing and sales agents will still claim what they will.

There are many reasons/causes for OS crashes and malfunctions. But the OS programmers also are a cause. You can't blame the intermediate user (setting up a system) and end user for everything.

Techies do need to take the best possible tailored care with each OS.

by grs

Its all about a broken product needing repair ...
IE ( service packs ) no pun intended If any other product was delivered the way Microsoft has delivered Windows , beside the fact that they stole it ....
In a truly free market it would have sank with the titanic , fact is that there is such a thing as Dll hell and it doesn't have anything to do with being configured correctly .....not to mention the glaring security holes you can drive a mack truck thru ..DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Apparently you enjoy installing windows ....
And comparing os's is the dumbest thing I've ever heard , if you truly had any experiance in the computer world comments such as yours, prove how
naive you truly are.... save it for the kiddes or send it to microslop ,Bill and Balmer eat it up.
Yes I am a microsoft basher and I'm dam glad I am !! ...You see monopolies suck because they destroy innovation and thats the primary reason I hate Microsoft ,it actually has nothing to do with there crappy sloppy programing , and while where at it Throw Intel into the mix .....
Its called Marketing and Money buddy, time for you to get some real schooling and really try growing up.

by hal 9000

Because at the last IBM Forum that I attended a few weeks ago now they openly admitted to using Red Hat and they also claimed that they are working closely with Red hat to provide solutions for their products and any problems that their users may face which is a hell of a lot more than can be said for M$. With them it's pay your money and hope for some form of result which generally only means you are far lighter off in the Hip Pocket and still don't have a solution.

I still can laugh at the insistence of a MS Tech who insisted that the error message that I was seeing on the monitor was telling me that I had no CPU fitted. I never knew that these "modern" M'Boards 98 era where so advanced that they could put a picture on a monitor without a CPU installed. With that in mind I'm constantly wondering today why I even need to fit a CPU to a system that I'm building. :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Why is M$ changing the color of their SOD from Blue to Red?

Sure it might not happen often but when it does you are in for a world of hurt as something critical has gone wrong and you will be very lucky to get it up and running again without constantly seeing the dreaded BSOD!

Col ]:)

by librarygeek

While you are correct that people must maintain the OS; the fact remains that Windows has been consistently buggy. They are forever releasing upgrades before they are truly ready -- thus we have the insane number of patches.
I would NEVER put up with such poor quality in another product. The OS problems are multiplied in a networked environment. Can you imagine if you had to do this much maintence on every light in your house?
Bashing a system that requires constant patches is not a sign of a non techie, it's the sign of a person who has had it with such time wasters.

by hal 9000

Actually MS are still selling DOS I know as I buy several copies per year all for computer controlled machine tools which where designed so long ago that there is no alternative for them. Currently M$ AU sells around 50 copies a month of MS DOS and most of the desktops that I sell have XP loaded on them.

Not because it is the best for the job but because it is the only one for the job when the software requirements are taken into account. I'm constantly being driven nuts with MS Licensing as I can never understand any of it and I only sell Volume License stuff with the occasional OEM bit thrown in for Good Will for one of the staff of companies that I do work for.

To me 2003 is only useful as a Domain controller but for a real server I alway use a form of Nix as I just don't have the license issues that come with Windows.

The last big installation that I got roped into had an excess 100 Domain controllers and with the license fees for their main servers it was going to cost the License Fee for the OS and then $80.00 AU for each unit that exceeded the limit that was only 100 Domain controllers so that was another 8K AU on 16 Boxes. For some strange reason I used Linux on these Servers and ended up with much better hardware and only about 1% of the total cost of the Server Side spent on Licenses and OS's.

I was just trying to balance the scales a bit as I'm constantly being told that I'm bashing M$ at every opportunity which I'm not really but many people seem to think this so it must be true. :p

But when it is all said and done I use the best tool for the job on any installation that I do now and today that just happens to be XP on the Desktop {although I'm getting more than a bit concerned with MS as their Life Cycle should soon be ending for XP primary support the 5 years is nearly up and currently we have no replacement available.}

What really worries me is that I'll once again find myself in the position of selling MS product knowing full well that within 12 - 18 months their will only be limited support for something that was only bought recently and has a life expediency of around 4 - 5 years depending on Tax arraignments.

At least when XP came out we could still install Night Mare 8 Sexually "E"nadequate for a while till XP became more known and accepted so I could use it with full knowledge that it wouldn't cause more problems than it cured. For some reason Y2K Pro was never accepted by my customers at least and even getting them onto XP was a fight in itself as their 98 units where doing everything that they wanted. While they where replacing the hardware they wanted to stay with their current OS and software so I've lost count of the number of XP Pro COA's that I've sold knowing full well that they will never be actually used and they these companies will continue using 98 until this crop of hardware is no longer of any Tax benefit to them.

I suppose that when the production version of Longhorn comes out I'll be loading XP to a lot of machines with a Longhorn COA on their sides as well.

So I'll say it again "Is MS doing anything about the problems that they have YES!!!! are they doing enough NO!!!!!!!!

Incidentally it made a pleasant change to be branded a MS Junkie for a change but I just somehow still feel insulted. :D

Col ]:)

by harold.jensen

Ok try this on. MCSE, CNA, CISSP, GSNA, and now working on CCIE. 15 years + hands on in all IT areas, and I am not a techie. Microsoft Software stinks. I waited until I recived my MCSE, before I said so. I wanted to give Microsoft the benefit of the doubt. They only thing they do well is... Marketing! Novell did things, better, 10 years ago then MS can now.

by dnsb

Contrary to what you seem to believe, an OS is a program. Like any program more complex than a "Hello World" written in assembler, the OS can and does have bugs that can cause crashes. Some OS are more prone to bugs than others. This can be due to design choices (moving video drivers into kernel space), sloppy coding practices (mixing code and data, poor or no range checks), poor choices in tools for compiling the OS. Ever had the sheer joy of locating a bug in library code? And then trying to convince a support drone that setting the screen to 1152x864 with 8 bit colour and then doing a write to an offscreen pixel causes the OS to bluescreen is reproducible and that it was due to a bug in a C++ library?

Some of your post seems a trifle contradictory. For instance, "compatibility is there for a very good reason" followed by "why support something old when you need to keep moving forwards". Perhaps a bit of clarification as to whither you were meandering is in order for us to understand your point.

As for choosing what OS suits my needs? For the most part, my OS choices have been constrained by such trivia as a mission critical package that runs on one OS. The only choice here is Hobson's.

by stuart_at_oz

he he he! Our 'previous' CIO (ie head of IT - who couldn't even change the resolution herself)got a talking to from the CEO (el-head honcho) for letting her SON install software and surf the internet on her laptop...

After the third time we had to clean it of unauthorised software, spyware and viruses we complained to our IT security people, and they had a word in the CEO's ear. We did a complete wipe and started again on it (something she would never have agreed to otherwise) and locked her userid down to a basic local user (something else she never would have agreed to!)

HOpe it went well for you :-)

by lukasiwicz

I think one reason IT folks bash Windows, and other OS's that make use of graphical user interfaces, is that those OS's make it possible for hoi polloi to do things on computers that used to require arcane knowledge, and so to some extent the IT folks have lost their little one up on you edge, and thus a little of their sense of being somewhat special, since by pointing and clicking Joe Blow from Kokomo can accomplish computer feats that used to require a slew of counterintuitive DOS command prompts. I sometimes think those DOS command prompts were to IT specialists what writing prescriptions in Latin used to be to MD's.

by apotheon

Perhaps you're not aware of this, G Big, but money put into R&D for Linux is either A) donated without strings attached or B) put into in-house R&D within the walls of IBM's facilities. In the former case, the Linux kernel developers say "Thanks!" and go on about their business. In the latter case, whenever IBM comes up with someone, they're compelled by the GPL to submit it to the Linux kernel developers, who can accept or discard it as needed.

You seem to have this odd impression that the Linux kernel is developed by some kind of central corporation that operates just like any other corporation in the software industry. The truth of the matter is that there are a few project managers and thousands of individuals that are simply submitting patches and feature upgrades for those project managers to sift through. It's not a singular, cohesive arrangement the way you'd get with something like Adobe or Microsoft, where you can make a deal with whoever's in charge to do whatever you want in exchange for money. The kernel developers don't have anything to offer in exchange for any money, with the exception of a still-better kernel in the next release cycle. Since a better kernel is always what everyone wants anyway, there's not really any downside to IBM donating cash.

by blarman

As accurate and thoughtful a response as you will ever see which mimics my views perfectly.

by kevinkfred

I agree that a large number of "bashers" do it from ignorance and inexperience. But I will continue to bash Microsoft's operating systems for one main probelm - the extremely poor job of memory management. More crashes, blue screens, etc are a result of Microsoft's OS failing to manage it's resources. And THAT is why I maintain that backend app's should live on an OS that knows how to manage resources properly (and I am not so sure that LINUX is mature enough to get that title). AT&T System V, VSE, AIX - these are stable, robust operating systems. Leave Windows on the desktop - use a commercial grade OS on the backend.

by leishirsute

For example, "Why didn't you make sure that it was using the right drivers, or the hardware is compatible" demonstrates OS lack of user or admin friendliness. We should not have to keep track of compatbile h/w or drivers - the OS should, and the OS should provide the means to retrieve the correct versions. Get rid of the manual process. Here's a novel thought. Why not automate admin tasks using computers?!!!!

by hal 9000

My Boxes run 24/7 and the longest that I've run a Windows box for is around 1 Month and then applied a Patch that required the REBOOT.

But lets take a long hard look at things here ring now I shut down due to an electrical storm and have just been up and running a few days 2 machines exactly the same internals one with XP Pro and one with Debian.

Debian Box uptime 7 Days 11 Hours 41 minutes. XP Box 6 hours 35 minutes can you see a slight difference there? I sure as Hell can. :p

But on the up side I'm not being called a M$ Stooge or Clown so thank you very much. :D

Col ]:)