Why do IT people really bash Windows?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by hal 9000
What about the Recommended and Hardware updates?
I did this just over 1 week ago now and after SP 2 {from a CD} had gone on and the AV updated there was well over 80 Meg of M$ Windows Patches to apply and with broadband the computer took longer to apply them than they took to download.
Look at what you are claiming before you open your mouth next time. :p
Col ]:)
by dvawter
I deploy desktops with all of our proprietary software, and office 2003 sp1 in about 3 hours.
now a note on recommended updates. Do you recompile your kernel everytime there is a new release? or do you wait till you use something that requires it? I do not load recommended updates when I complete an install. The driver CD that I have from the PC vendor is fine to get the PC running, I only load recommended and Hardware updates on an as needed basis.
David
by dvawter
Linux is more stable, there is no question there, and anyone who tries to argue that is a fool.
My contention is the vast majority of bashers that say Windows crashes all the time, and doesn't wok most of the time, are just repeating someone else's argument, and have no real life experience in it. I would not use XP as a web server, because to me it's unaccepatable to have to reboot a web server once a week. But on a Desktop, that most people shut down as a matter of course when they go home, the weekly reboots are a non issue. My Laptop running 24/7 on XP has a 99.9898% uptime, so even if I am rebooting once a week or so it's not costing me much productivity. The arguments that XP is not stable enough are simply unwarranted bashing.
An It person should be able to rise above the public opinion, and realize the best fit for each situation. I am very fond of linux, but I also have to argue that Microsoft has a quality product.
David
by jaqui
like being lied to by your os?
as well as kept in the dark?
windows ( all ms os versions including dos itself ) hide the system boot messages.
then they lie to you and tell you that thier "wizard" will help you to solve the problem
on top of the lies in advertising, where they say it is stable..secure.. to get you to buy it.
sorry, but mushroom treatment is for mushrooms, not for people.
by dvawter
You can chain commands at the windows command prompt. So long as the exe is written propperly. There are very few command line utilities from MS that cannot be chained (I can't think of any right now). Third party utilities is a different story. You will find the same in linux. If the developer did not do his job, then the commmand will not chain properly. Pipes and > and < work very much the same as the windows command prompt as they do at the linux prompt.
I think the problem you experience is the economy of scale. There are a lot of lower skilled developers writing code for win32, than their are for linux. The reasons should be obvious, but for the sake of clairity.
1) linux users are more technically savvy, it follows that 3rd party linux developers would be linux users.
2) Market Share. If you are an inexperienced programmer, trying to break into the market what are you going to write code for? hmmm lets see, I can write a win32 app, charge money for it, and it will run on 66% of the computers our there. Or I can write a linux app, be pressured to make it open source, and it will run on less than a 3rd of the computers.
Don't get me wrong, Linux is a solid product, but it's my experience that most MS bashers do not have the experience to back up thier arguments.
David
by dvawter
Linux Gui Sucks, it's twice the resource hog that windows is, it's not intuitive, and it's ugly. Why would you use anything but command prompt in linux? You lose way too much performance, which was the whole reason I installed linux in the first place.
As far as your issues loading service packs I don't know how to answer that, because I have never in my 15 years of supporting windows desktops and servers run into anything like that. I have had updates cause problems, but never to that extent. 2 months ago I rolled out XP sp 2 to 40 desktops via an update server, with no trouble at all. I can only guess that you had some underlying problem before you started.
by hal 9000
Why are so many defending the indefensible? :^O
It leaks like a sieve falls over as soon as someone thinks about looking at it has no User security and allows different users to interact with each other and hose the entire OS and profiles rather than just their own profile when they do something silly. ;)
It can not be run on decent Servers as it is just not scalable enough. :)
It's only on the desktop owing to Hostage Ware that M$ promotes so hard. :p
Other than the fact that I make bucket loads of money out of each and every one of these shortcomings what is there nice to say about Windows? :D
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
If M$ was to chose to go the Linux route they need not go the GPL route. They could quite easily do a Red Hat and sell the product and support which they do for Windows and just think how much they would be making in support calls. :^O
Not to mention all the new Certs that they could sell. From where I stand it would only be an increase in profits for M$ not a decrease.
Remember that the original Idea for Linux was a more user friendly version of Unix which at some latter stage could be incorporated into the Buy it now Unix.
As far as I know every company who makes a Linux product sells it in some form or other even if they do have a GPL. Look at Red Hat, SUSE, Mandrake or whatever they are calling themselves this week they all sell boxed sets.
Then there is Turbo Linux try to download a copy of that and see how far you get. :D
M$ doesn't even need to actually call it Linux they could use th Unix tag or make up one of their own like Winix. ;)
If they did the latter however they would most likely have the Windows Side of the business taking themselves to Court to force a name change. :^O
Get the idea? :p
Col ]:)
by dvawter
I stopped reading your post at point number 2, Anyone that knows anything about Windows, as you pretend to, knows that XP came from Windows NT, not 98. the 2 are not related in the slightest. XP is the product of a complete rewrite started with NT3.51 which was released shortly before windows 95. Windows ME was the last of the MS OS's based on the 9x archtechture, if you want to sound like you know what your talking about, get your facts straight.
David
by hal 9000
They are off a LT that has recently be reloaded and SP1 & 2 where installed from CD as well as the .NET junk which IE needs for some web sites.
Windows XP family Security Update for Microsoft .NET Framework, Version 1.1 Service Pack 1 (KB886903) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Security Update for Microsoft .NET Framework, Version 1.0 SP3, English (KB886906) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Security Update for Windows XP (KB901214) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Windows Malicious Software Removal Tool - July 2005 (KB890830) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Security Update for JView Profiler (KB903235) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Update for Windows XP (KB896344) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Update for Windows XP (KB898461) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Security Update for Windows XP (KB893066) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Cumulative Security Update for Internet Explorer for Windows XP Service Pack 2 (KB883939) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Windows XP family Security Update for Windows XP (KB896428) Monday, 18 July 2005 Windows Update website
Now from my count that is 10 patches/Updates and none are hardware related.
And as can be seen it was done on the 18-7 -05 which is all of 4 days ago now in this time zone. :)
Am I right? :^O
Col ]:)
by cmartin
Microsft Bashing is so common place becuase they hold 80 - 90% of the market in desktop OS. Since more user are regulalry exposed to Microsft then the issue they have will tend to be with a Microsoft OS.
However, I chalk up OS failures usully due to improper installation/Configuration and maintenace to the Desktops.
A typical user has no idea on what to do if an error happens, so they jsut reboot and hope it will go away. Then things only get worse.
It takes training of endusers on what to do if an issue arises. We tell our users to stop what they are doing and contact Tech support right away. We all so have a very extensive maintenace plan. We also follow procedures for installing new software and apps in a test environment that replicates the actually environment it will run in after. This may take more time up fromt to get things done but in the end you will save time on troubleshooting and repiring the desktops in your organization.
by lost_one
You guys are so silly. You bash Windows all day on the internet while using Windows. Does this make any since to you?? Windows is not as unstable as some of you would like to believe. If you hate windows so much stop buying it, stop using it and stop bashing it. It Unix/Linux was so great how come hardly no one is using it?
Alot of the problems with windows does lie with the users having no clue about the operating system. Simple maintenance would fix most of the problems.
Man I should just pin a target to my chest.
by systemsgod
The reason people bash Windows more than other OS' is because of it's sheer popularity. If you bash a Linux distro like Ubuntu, most people wont know what the $*%# you are talking about.
It's the same reason more viruses are written for Windows than other OS'...why would you write a virus for OS/2 (that would have virtually no impact on modern computing), when you could bring down millions of machines with a virus written for Windows? Definately more bang for the buck and then some.
Just because you dont hear about security issues and vulnerabilities with other OS' doesnt mean that they dont exist. When Mac's get more popular, you will hear about more security problems, viruses, etc. and the complaints will come. When I subscribed to Red Hat's update notification service, I was getting emails every week (or better) about some new fix or security patch. Truth is that if more people used Red Hat, you would hear more complaints. This goes for any OS really: the more people use it, the more complaints you will hear.
I am anything but MS' biggest fan, but, because it is the most popular OS in the world (and I am an IT professional), that means I either have to support it or get a new job. It's just that simple. If something ever becomes more popular, I will be supporting that too. But, people fear change, and because other OS' look different than Windows, I dont know if that day will ever come. Just changing from NT to 2000 freaked my users out because it "looked so different". Imaging them going from XP to a KDE or Gnome desktop...
Click on the pretty picture, fill in the boxes and the click on the buttony thing with OK on it.
What's so difficult about that ?
Who said anything about not supporting it, I just spent the last two years supporting VMS, if it's out there, you have the skills then get paid.
Again with the popularity issue re security. Wrong windows is inherrently insecure, that's one of the reasons for it's success. Name a technology that drove the internet in a big way and yet is insecure by design. I'll give you a clue the first word in the name is Microsoft...
by tommy higbee
by tommy higbee
IBM has reinvented itself over the past few years. Microsoft will probably eventually have to follow the same path when it finds itself no longer able to dictate the rest of the PC world.
Regardless, i5/OS is a vary nice operating system, but not open enough to really take over. Open systems take over eventually. That's why PC clones took over the CP/M and Apple machines, and THAT is why DOS became a near-monopoly.
That's also why Apple is only a fringe of PC computing now. However, the latest Apples have been far more open -- being built on top of open source Unix -- and that's why they're doing better.
By that standard, Linux, being the most open of all, may turn out to be unstoppable. We'll have to see.
One thing is for sure, though. Microsoft does not now dominate the back room. They were moving very rapidly in that direction, but they got stopped short by one thing: Linux. That is, Linux tore the bottom out of the economic argument for replacing Unix, acts like Unix, and interoperates with just about everything. And even for those happy with their Unix systems, just the fact that Linux was growing so fast destroyed the pressure to port to Windows ASAP.
As for me, I'm happy in a multiple OS world. I just want systems that work, and that work together.
by lost_one
There is no need for you to make a direct attact on the post for stating his opinion. You could have give a counter point but you choose to flame instead. Not very professional.
Maybe it is you who has some growing up to do.
by jbaker
by jbaker
I have been in this ball-game for about ten years, and have been playing with PCs since the dawn of time....
I did not say that I have never had a BSOD. I said that I have RARELY had a BSOD that was caused by the OS. Usually it is a bad driver, a naughty piece of software, or failing hardware. Especially on NT and 2K, with drivers trying to grab hardware directly, and the HAL slapping its hand....sometimes the driver would pout and crash the entire machine...
by humbletech99
Have you ever heard of a buffer overflow? Well, surprise surprise, they exist in Linux as well as Windows, Unix and just about any other piece of software more than a few lines long. Substance?
Anyway, I'm a Linux and Windows sysadmin. I agree that every system has it's own strengths and weaknesses, what people need is more brains and less criticism. The people who write that stuff are far superior to anyone here in skill, IQ and all the rest. If you can do better, go ahead, otherwise stop acting like a crab trying to pull others down.
I personally believe that Microsoft does as well as they can, as well as anyone can. More users means more attacks discovered. Firefox security bugs in the last 6 months after version 1 shows this (I use that too). How many did you hear of when it was Firebird? They're both still good. There's just always room for improvement. Keep working on it fellas!
by jbaker
The only OS that I have had the dubious pleasure of never having to troubleshoot is ME, and my only exposure to it was to replace it with XP Pro. Yes, I have worked with EVERY M$ OS since Windows 3.1.
I ran 98 at home and NEVER got a BSOD on it. Not in the 4 years that machine existed (Win 98, PII 300, 256MB PC 100, SCSI CD-ROM, Server level Intel mobo, 3x 8GB HDD, SoundBlaster Live!, USR v.92 modem, 3Com 905 NIC)
by jbaker
by 0b1111
I can't let you get away with that comment, even though I did smile quietly to myself when I saw it.
But the following 'jab' from David Bradley is perhaps even more apt and amusing!
Cheers.
Quote:
"This keyboard combination was designed by David Bradley, a designer of the original IBM PC. Bradley originally designed Control-Alt-Escape to trigger a soft reboot, but he found it was too easy to bump the left side of the keyboard and reboot the computer accidentally. He switched the key combination to Control-Alt-Delete, a combination impossible to press with just one hand (this is not true of later keyboards, such as the 102-key PC/AT keyboard). More advanced operating systems use its status as a "reserved" combination for various purposes, but often retain the ability to trigger a soft reboot in certain configurations or circumstances."
David Bradley is also known for his good-natured jab at Bill Gates, at that time the CEO of Microsoft, and also the creator of many of Microsoft's programs:
"I may have invented Control-Alt-Delete, but Bill Gates made it really famous."
"The design of Windows NT (and its derivatives Windows 2000 and Windows XP)is such that, unless security is already compromised in some other way, only the WinLogon process, a trusted system process, can receive notification of this keystroke combination (because it is the first to register the keyboard hook). This keystroke combination is thus a secure attention key. A user pressing Control-Alt-Delete can be sure that it is the operating system (specifically the WinLogon process), rather than a third party program, that is responding to the key combination, and that it is therefore safe to enter a password. It was chosen as the secure attention key in Windows (instead of, for example, the System Request key), because on the PC platform no program could reasonably expect to redefine this keystroke combination for its own purposes."
Quotes sourced in good faith from Wikipedia.
by dryflies
My opinion is that windows bashers are opposed to big money/monopolies. Gates is rich and greedy so they hate him. and it is not necessarily IT's fault when the OS crashes. many times its some twit installing untested software or cleaning out their file folders or surfing where they shouldn't oughta be.
Each OS has a purpose for which it is best suited. use them where they work best. Oh, and how I wish for just one second of bill gates income. :-)
by garnerl
"Windows junkies bash Apple because every major new release is really a new release, so there's no promise of downward compatibility"
True, but Windows will be bashed either way. Either "This crappy new version is just the same old one with some patches", or "How dare they change something so my Win98 program doesn't work and I have to buy an upgrade?? Conspiracy!"
"4. Windows was obviously written by programmers for programmers. Nothing about it is the least bit intuitive to people outside our profession, people who don't think like we do.", and "We will NEVER be able to sell this kind of programmer-friendly, user-hostile garbage to them"
There's a very good reason that Windows blows Linux and even Mac out of the water, and it's not simply marketing. Windows is easy. The "Start" button complaint is overblown and overused. I've never had to explain to someone how to shut down a recent version of Windows, and I think it's much more intutive than typing "init 0" (or "init 6", depending).
I think that a better rant would point to how Windows' focus on ease-of-use has compromised its security and reliability.
by tommy higbee
> It's a not so well know fact that about two thirds of the Web Server Exploits are based on the apache web server, based on the market share argument that makes a lot of sense.
I'm sure you can find someone claiming this, but that doesn't make it a fact. The only claim I've ever seen that purported to prove that, even with all the obvious flaws in their methodology, still showed Windows web servers being compromised at about 2.5 times their market share. Oops.
So I don't think that's a winning argument.
As for installing software under Windows and Debian:
Windows -> Search for the executable program, then execute it. Whatever happens next depends on how well the person doing the install program set it up.
Debian (Libranet, Xandros, Mepis, Ubuntu, etc.) ->
Use the package manager, Click Update, select software you want, click "Install".
It just isn't that hard. It's also, by the way, the same way you install patches, or upgrade your current software. And the packages are created by the same people that create the OS distribution you're using, so there's every reason to expect it to work right.
Debian doesn't represent all Linux, but they have software installation figured out. Expect other Linux distributions to follow.
BTW, you can use Xandros or Linspire, both of which can be bought preinstalled on some PC's, and never know the first thing about Debian.
by jaqui
debian learned that trick from red hat, they were the first distro with package management.
( the infamous rpm )
debian developed thier own package management tool set, which is why there are now 2 options a deb or an rpm
distros that use debs are said to be debian based and those that use rpms are said to be red hat based.
slak, lfs and a couple of others are the pure linux, where you build from sources. package management is a luxury.
then there is the tool alien, that adds functionality to apt or rpm, it knows both package types and can install either, reguardless of the base distro usage.
by mswanberg
>> Debian (Libranet, Xandros, Mepis, Ubuntu, etc.) ->
Use the package manager, Click Update, select software you want, click "Install".
You're kidding, right?
Sure, that works for the packages that are already part of the package manager. What about installations off the beaten track?
My experience with it is:
1. Type command line to update and then type command to install. Package not found.
2. Scour internet for site that contains desired package (have to have the right FTP or HTTP site). Add site to .conf file. Repeat step 1.
3. Scour internet for proper configuration of .conf file. Repeat steps 2 and 1.
4. Scour internet for site that plays well with Debian installer. Repeat steps 2 and 1.
5. Discover dependency #1. Repeat steps 1-4 for the dependency.
6. Discover dependencies 2-5. Repeat steps 1-5 for each.
7. Repeat step 1 for desired package. Get some cryptic response... is package installed? Or did it merely bless the dependencies?
8. Do hard drive search for the executable (or service) that was installed. Try to run it. Then scour internet for insturctions on how to edit .conf file.
Those are the EXACT steps I went through to try to install Sendmail on Ubuntu (Debian-based). I never got it working. Took me 3 evenings (my personal machines, not work-based) to go through all of it.
Here is how I got an SMTP/POP server running on my XP box:
1. Google search.
2. Narrow google search using "free" as a search term.
3. Download program.
4. Run downloaded executable.
5. Select new icon from Start menu.
6. Configure settings.
Elapsed time: 5 minutes. And at the end of the 5 minutes I had an SMTP server set up, complete with a POP server, and had 4 addresses configged.
-Mike
by jdclyde
me from being defensive as that indicates inferiority, I suppose I'll have to be offensive
What other training is there ?
Are suggesting that a badge for memorising ms advertising blurb is a substitute for experience ?
Object to other peoples generalisations all you want just after you cease with your own.
Unlike some you decry, I have a smidgeon of familiarity with software engineeering, which is why I feel quite comfortable criticising some of the pathetic blunders in ms's attempt at the discipline.
My reasons for disliking certain aspects of the OS are perfectly sound, the fact you don't consider them imporant to you doesn't mean they aren't to me or anyone else.
by tommy higbee
Yes, you can chain commands at Windows command prompt. I used to do it all the time before I got familiar with Unix/Linux. I will say, however, that it works MUCH better under Unix/Linux.
1) DOS is really imitating Unix by using temporary files behind the scenes. For instance:
dir *.doc | find "/2004 "
will actually send the output of the "dir *.doc" command to a temp file, then execute the 'find "/2004 " command on that temp file. For small temp files, the difference is negligible. For large temp files, you can wait a long time for the first command to finish executing before you see any output from the second command. The effect is magnified by multiple stage pipelines. Linux/Unix, on the other hand, starts all stages of the pipeline together, and each one starts sending output as it starts receiving input. No long delays before you see any output.
2)Linux/Unix allows you to set an evironment variable to the result of a command. For example, getting the current date.
curdate=`date`
Try to do that in Windows. There is a way to extract the current date, but it's not exactly easy
3) Windows still uses DOS batch files. If you want to do anything complicated, you really need some sort of better scripting language. Like a Unix shell ported to Windows.
4) DOS lets you redirect standard input and standard output. Unix shells also let you redirect standard error. This lets you separate error messages from the output of your program -- a huge advantage. To do the same in Windows, you have to anticipate the error messages and try to remove them with a ' find /v "Expected Error" '
Fortunately, it is possible to install a Unix shell on top of Windows. As long as you don't mind the extra install, it might pay off.
by mswanberg
1. Yes, the command shell does imitate Linux/Unix a lot. So what's the problem?
The thing is, Windows has become a GUI platform, period. VERY few programs are written to use STDOUT, STDIN, STDERR, etc. in the Windows environment anymore. But they do still exist. And programs can easily be written to pipe to and from these standard inputs/outputs. I do it all the time.
2. The Command shell already has the environment variables %date% and %time%. What's your point?
Yeah, I guess you can't put the result of some programs into environment variables on-the-fly, but who cares, because there's...
3. Windows Scripting... ever heard of it? I write down-n-dirty scripts that do all manner of things that you could never do with ANY BASH-type scripting (or DOS Batch scripts either, for that matter). Can you open Word, open a doc, and then spellcheck it? Create and populate a database? Automagically create and run jobs on a mainframe from the PC and then retrieve the output and process the data into a report? Interrogate a spreadsheet? Spawn a web server (yes, I've seen it... German dude wrote a web server in VBScript!)? Maintain string variables up to 2GB in length? Spin through files, manipulating, and changing them? Do-while, If-then, Repeat-until contructs? Collections? ActiveX access?
VBScript and JScript are basically interpreted programming languages, and I write scripts all the time that can be piped to and from. I even pipe to and from FTP clients, Java applets, anything that I need to.
4. The Command shell does indeed let you redirect STDERR. Trouble is, few program are written to take advantage of this separate output.
A buddy put me onto CygWin, which is a Unix-like shell that runs in Windows. Didn't take me long to see it didn't offer me anything that I couldn't already do in Windows.
-Mike
by rkuhn040172
I'm just happy that the all out MS bashing days are almost over.
More and more IT people are thinking things through more logically nowadays.
Is one OS better than another? Sure...in some areas but not all areas. No OS is perfect in all ways.
There are certain people (that happen to post on TechRepublic alot and they know who they are) that will tell you Linux is superior.
Well, that kind of closed mind thinking doesn't serve anyone's best interest.
By the way, how many people live on good ole mothership Earth? What the heck makes you think for a second we'd ever or will ever reach agreement on this?
Hell, we're still taking taste test between Pepsi and Coke aren't we?
once tried to wash the awful taste away with a similar measure of coke.
Didn't work !
Soft drink bashing now that's where we want to go !
by hubbardr
I am reminded of the 1) text editor wars ("My text editor is better than yours..." see vi vs emacs, et al) 2) the Programming language wars ("My language can run through pointers faster than your language") 3) the programming style wars ("structured is better than OO is better than DDL is better than.....") and 4) now the OS wars
All of these things are tools. I haven't heard any carpenders lately going after each other because a hammer is better than a saw. They are tools.
If you 'love' a particular OS, get another job. That OS doesn't love you back. And if it changes, and you are too 'in love' with the old one to change, then you are screwed. (Insert your own comment about a crusty old DOS guy that never wanted to learn windows in the first place).
Currently, there are some well defined places for the various OS's that you would be pretty loopy to change. And even these depend on what is already installed in your environment.
So Hallelujah! It's wonderful to hear the voice of sanity everynow and then....
BTW, I run Windows and Linux in my environments, depending on what I need to do...
by jaqui
can windows do that linux can't?
( besides get infected with adware and spyware, there ain't any for linux )
by rkuhn040172
Sounds like Jaqui is one of those crusty old DOS types.
Dude, get a clue. The time and money spent re-educating your end users to Linux is much higher than the cost of security issues and maintanence of Windows.
The industry is maturing to the point we all see things for what they are.
Security 101 is not putting all your eggs in one basket. If all you run is Linux, you are more vulnerable than I am...I run a mixed environment using a hammer for hammer tasks, a drill for drill tasks, etc.
by jrod86
I've been there myself, and spent a lot of time hunting for data on a crashed HD. I'm still going to advocate the use of a network drive or something to install from (as well as a solid backup plan). Even small business has to realize the effects or poor backup management on system uptime and take steps to mitigate that risk.
I still say you can have a partition that contains the installs (if it's a small company, they shouldn't have too much to install) so that when you get past the OS, you can still grab the software from one place. I am assuming that they are past the dial-up stage you mentioned.
by fmcgowan
I do development of internal applications, none for sale.
I am employed by an organization that is *eager* to pay, yet again, for products that fail to fulfill those same tired old promises offered anew.
Over the years, I have counselled for various non-Windows OS products as well as non-MS applications for use *on* Windows. Thus far the "MS uber alle" crowd have bewn winning those "debates" and the "approved" sw stack is becoming more MS-oriented.
As a "counter cultural" developer, I am constantly on the lookout for ways to "get my way" by finding yet more uses of non-MS sw here, the more necessary the application, the better I like it.
Like one of the first 10 termites in the world, I am surrounded my more opportunities than I can pursue. Like any termite, I turn resources already committed to a failed purpose to new purposes...
munch, munch, munch...
by al.nelson
by twylyght
This is my take as I hear this kind of thing all the time. Part of Windows' strength is also its weakness. It was designed to be the OS that would allow anyone to use virutally any software on virtually any hardware. Of course we know where that has gone. Proprietary vendors and manufacturers have combated MSs dominance of the market by trying to create their own niches, and they have succeeded to varying degrees.
The two things that keep MS on top are marketing (which contributes to ubiquity and familiarity) and flexibility (in terms of software selection). Apple tried to corner the marketing strategy by being everywhere in the school systems, but has had to take a back seat and continue as mainstays in graphical arts and media production. Only recently has its marketing picked back up again.
This brings me to a key point in the whole discussion. I has been touched on that the more a system is used, the more it is targeted. Windows is obviously going to be the target as it is undoubtedly the big dog in the arena. It will be what hackers know and strive to beat. As Apple, Linux, Solaris, etc become more popular the attention will be diverted as such. To this day, one's best security is being unknown.
This brings me to the second major crux in this discussion. With MS being the one handling the burden of testing ALL hardware for ALL levels of its applications, it is presented with the horrendous task of researching, testing, and developing for 90% of the world's products. Sun and Apple generally know exactly what is in their systems since their software and hardware generally go hand in hand. When messing with Linux and compiling kernels for different devices, we tend to run into many of the same issues.
Hence, I tend to think that while MSs drive to be the dominant monster in the market is what is bringing in their money, it is also driving their problems with system stability and the comparably inordinate number of complaints among users and IT professionals.
by sr3h
Angus,
I appreciate you kicking off this discussion, but I gotta take issue with your statement that "it's not the OS maker but the user that causes the system to crash".
You should at least put some of the blame on developers. If a user installs a program that's compatible with their version of Windows, he/she shouldn't be blamed if it creates a conflict. That is the fault of the programmers (for the software and Windows).
For example, my father has BellSouth DSL service. He wasn't able to connect. The BellSouth "Connection Wizard" pops up. He runs it. As a result:
1. He's still not able to connect.
2. The program changes his hardware profile which sets his display to 4-bit color. He has to uninstall the display adapter and restart the computer to fix this.
I have never seen anything this brain-dead on another OS. BellSouth's programmers are idiots for writing this program, and the MS programmers are no better for allowing this crappy code to change the monitor display settings.
This is one case of many. I provide "unofficial" tech support for my company (I am a technical writer by trade, but my first job was as an ISP support specialist). I can't blame the user for doing everything the software reccommends. By your logic, users should be stuck with only the original configuration of their computer. This does not square with reality.
Again, thanks for your time and willingness to start a controversial thread.
sr3h@yahoo.com
This is a brand new pc XP SP2 out of the box, quick windows update to get the latest patches.
Then MS SQL CD and ms Service pack CD, so how could it go wrong ?
Still doesn't explain why I have to reboot after putting a new piece of software on an ms operating system does it.
Linux GUIs that I've used are just different enough to make them awkward for us chaps with the bulk of our experience on windows.
The point about the GUI was however, if you wanted an ms server solution without a GUI, how would you get it?
The only reason I ran a GUI on a linux server is when I was learning it, (slef taught) was more intuitive than the command line. I soon weened myself off it though.
by mchall
"The reasons are plain, they have priced, and complained, and alienated their way out of existence."
Exactly my point. This view no longer represents "Most Techs" because those kind of individuals are no longer predominant in the industry. They have been supplanted by individuals who are more cost conscious and customer service oriented.
by hal 9000
The place that I was at yesterday only has 4 workstations and 3 of those are NB's the guy who owns the place is completely computer Illiterate and they had 1 phone line for 3 dial up connections and couldn't understand why they needed anything different.
I only spent 6 hours there yesterday working out the problems that he had created with an I-Pod. But as he has already left now on a long trip it's working so who cares.
The newest workstation that they have there is a Celeron HP unit and they only brought that because the salesman there parked a 40 ton excavator track on top of the old one which he called "Steam Powered!" The DSL came latter as he demanded it so that he could actually sell something.
Then the owners Acer Aspire with an AMD CPU and 256 MEG or RAM is painfully slow I spent a very long time deleting duplicate songs from his play list only about 1 hour and I was constantly getting a System Not Responding message so I had to wait for it to catch up with me and I'm not all that fast on strange hardware.
The point being that it in this place is just not an option while I would love to store an image on a HDD somewhere and be able to push it out across a network it ain't going to happen here. But they are only a small business who sell very expensive hardware their average sale is in the 1.5 Million $ mark and up until 3 months ago they didn't even have a permanent Internet connection available.
Their previous salesman who I had to drag kicking and screaming into the 19 TH Century was a hard job but in comparison he was easy compared to this lot. :)
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
I take it you have already got your name down with MS for a Beta copy of Vista Right? No doubt you'll be standing beside your letter box crying until it arrives on August 3. :^O
After all you'll need this so you can have a play with the pre beta release so you just might have some idea of what the Beta release will actually look like. OH whoops my fault the Production Version will look like I forgot we are all MS Beta Testers. :D
Col ]:)
by wordworker
I went out to the sites where the gazillions of open source "apps" are reputed to be. Now can someone please tell me which of the top dozen database engines are the most reliable? No I have to download and try them all myself? Sorry, don't have time. Oh, they don't all run on the same releases of *n*x? Too bad for me if I'm running the wrong one.
Windows - better the devil you know than the open source devils you don't.
And can someone please point me to the Linux Desktop Store? I'd like to rush right out and get one of those nifty Linux desktops and start using it. Oh! You can't buy one at a brick and mortar stoer? Gee that'll make it hard to support the thing, won't it?
I can say I have actually used Linux - well Knoppix - to troubleshoot a problem with a Windows machine. (Booted to the knoppix CD, connected to Internet, ruled out problem with the connection.) But what you Linux enthusiasts are missing is the very thing you consider is the strength of the 'platform' is also its greatest weakness -- lots of customization opportunities, unobscured view "under the hood," those are good things. But what about consistency and availability? If you want Linux Desktops to catch on, you (as the Linux community as a whole) need to settle on a configuration that can be configured, sold, and used by the masses, not just high-tech folks.
by hal 9000
I don't think you'll have a single problem buying that from a Bricks & Mortar Store or SUSE, or Mandrake, or Turbo Linux. These are all available in boxed sets with real documentation unlike what you get from M$. But as you already know Windows and Office you'll not have a problem paying to be a Beta Tester when Visa or was that Vista becomes available as a production product will you?
And they are not just the OS but a complete Suite of programs most likely more than what you'll actually need. So you need a DBase but you'll then not need the graphic applications or the games will you? So all you have to do is just chose not to load them. What you pay for in the Boxed Sets is a complete system with an OS and Applications unlike MS which you only get an OS and like one customer recently was told Notepad is your Word processor so it has everything you need. They where somewhat more than disappointed when they found out that they had to spend even more money to get a computer that they could actually use instead of just one with Windows on it.
But no you want it free right? So you then download a ISO and then want to complain about the lack of support which you never paid for.
Personally I would much rather be Beta Testing Linux than paying for a production version of Windows and Office and still being a Beta Tester on that. I've had 3 occasions that I've had to actually ring MS when I've run into a problem that I can not fix and on every occasion I spent hours to eventually be told by their senior Tech "I don't know ring me when you have a fix will you?" Good thing that I'm a Certified Partner or I would have being paying for those support calls where I didn't get any support and in each and every case not only solved the problem for myself after much wasted time but then had to take the time to ring MS with a work around. And no Puking and Nuking didn't cure any of these problems as they where all on clean installs and all revolved around applying Service Packs.
Anyway you're not one to talk have you had a recent look at the number of DBase programs available for Windows? No I'm not just referring to the M$ ones but the whole range so how can you say without having the top of your head fall off from laughter
"If you want Linux Desktops to catch on, you (as the Linux community as a whole) need to settle on a configuration that can be configured, sold, and used by the masses, not just high-tech folks."
This currently doesn't exist in Windows after all if you wish to load windows 3.11 you honestly do not expect Office 2003 to work on it do you? How many home users are rushing out and buying 2003 Enterprise Edition? and how many would actually know how to set it up correctly?
If you wish to compare apples to trucks don't be surprised to be shot down in flames. If you want something for nothing than you will get exactly what you paid for SFA. Which is exactly what you deserve. :^O
Col ]:)
by jaqui
every linux distro meets the minimum standards listed here.
why would linux want to limit the (g)ui* options and become like windows & macos? ( one size fits none )
if it was to pick one (g)ui as the only option, then it would be going against what it has come to stand for::FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN EVERYTHING ABOUT THE SYSTEM
unlike windows and macos where they say you can only have a gui, and it has to be this one.
you have to use our tools or you will get lousy results. ( system lockups and crashes with windows, apps just won't run unless designed for macos )
*(g)ui as graphic interface is NOT required.
by jmgarvin
You have heardof mySQL for DB a engine.
I can point you to Fry's to buy a Linux desktop. http://shop3.outpost.com/product/4199563?site=sr:SEARCH:MAIN_RSLT_PG
Sure there are tons of tools you can choose, but like Windows, there are the popular and stable tools that everyone uses.
I'm not angry at all.
Joe Blow is because he thinks double clicking on Icons makes him an IT Wizard and some of us don't accept that. The whole point of a UI Graphical or otherwise is to isolate the none technical from the arcane knowledge. Even the DOS commands that we struggled with were a massive improvement on what was really going on under the hood.
Arcane knowledge is not obsolete, what do you think the tools used to isolate others from it are derived from ?
by tsecret
You be suprised at the i5/OS today. You get all of the advantages of "Open" with enough under the covers protection it offers. This is why it still has not been hacked or had a virus. And with Linux running on the same system it's a hard combination to beat, not to mention the independant studies on the 99.96 uptime record.
You cal open a Unix shell and even comile open source code with the native c/c++ comilier.
by oz_media
To take a comment from you rown post.
You sound like one of those old crusty linux types who thinks you need to be an IT Guru to use Linux.
I have rolled out SUSE, XD2 and ND for several companies without any user issues or learning curves to deal with. You can't tell me that ANY Windows OS is easier to use than the newer Linux flavours. In fact most new users tell me they are relieved to find out how similar to a 'doze environment Linux is when they exoect it to be tough to learn. The user issues are reduced a great deal, fewer stupid hangs, hiccups, issues with spyware (when using FF as well) etc.
As for cheaper, there isn't a suite that MS has EVER designed that offeres more for less than LInux offers.
I work in both Environments (grudgingly with some companies using Win desktops), in each and evry case, 'doze boxes are more problematic fo rusers, cost a HEAP O Money more. Mind you, I always install Novell Networks so I am used to pretty much maintenance free NOS's that don't require a team of MCSE's to keep it running in top form every day.
You're right MS has it's place, but you also took time to displace Linux as a viable and affordable solution.
You'll find that hypocrites don't fair to well on TR, you can't make an absurd general assertion and then back it with personal bias.
You wrote: "The time and money spent re-educating your end users to Linux is much higher than the cost of security issues and maintanence of Windows."
I don't believe that you fully appreciate the cost of security issues. There are numerous kinds of damage that can happen to both the business with poor security and to its customers. One of the most heinous of these issues is when the customers having their identity stolen. I suspect that if you talked to someone who has suffered the consequences of this type of personal attack they would take a dim view of your attitude. The kind of thinking that you expressed is a large part of the reason that these kinds of problems exist. People in technical support who don't believe that security issues are an overriding consideration when selecting a computer platform are a big part of the problem.
You wrote:"The industry is maturing to the point we all see things for what they are."
Apparently not. If you could see things for what they are you wouldn't be so open minded about what platform you consider acceptable for use in a business environment.
You wrote:"If all you run is Linux, you are more vulnerable than I am..."
Do you have any facts to back that up? I doubt it. Although I agree with your premise that you shouldn't put all of your eggs in one basket I don't agree with your interpretation of how that applies. You think that it means to run various platforms. I disagree. I would say that it should be interpreted as saying that you should isolate where information is stored and how it is accessed based on the business model. Having several operating systems is not good. It means that you have more systems to learn and you probably will not gain as much expertise in any of them than you would have gained in one system if you could concentrate on that one platform.
Well that's one way of looking it, here's another.
Downturn in the IT market was a business failure.
First someone forgot to figure out once you'd cabled everyone up there would be no one else to cable up.
Second some halfwit marketed a pile of new technologies such as 3G when the best technicians around couldn't physically engineer what was being sold. Internet at 4800 baud and ?1 per minute of your cell phone, yeah that's a goer.
Third you had a pile of dot.com boys running around selling businesses that just didn't exist.
All of this goes on business's expand buy into IT in a big way, skills shortage. How is the shortage adressed because academia is always 4 - 6 years behind business, easy find a load of people who can see lightning and hear thunder , give them a shiny badge and certificate that says that are skilled. Not saying all of them, but a sizeable %age.
All the chickens come home to roost, business downturn, no new market and a bunch of people failing expensively to get anything to work.
Investment cut back, end of boom, too many 'skilled' workers, massive die back and everyone in IT skilled or not takes a massive hit.
Happened before, happened then, will happen again, sure as eggs the so called captains of industry won't be at fault, RHIP as it were.
As a tech I've alienated more than a few bosses. not by crapping out , not by over-pricing either. Told 'em they were talking out of their arses is the way I did it, politely of course.
You've never heard of the MS Java Virtual Machine? It was in every MS OS up until antitrust litigation forced it out in WinXP SP1a.
The recent JView highly critical Windows flaw is a flaw in the old MSJVM. See MS05-037 or 903235.
by rapt0r
I didn't mention any hardware other than a disk drive. Surely you've done soft raid setups before. Windows tanks and my *nix boxes don't if a drive fails. On hardware based raid, Windows had better stay up (any OS for that matter) since it doesn't see the individual drives, just the raid array. Yes I know that raid companies make software for the OS to see/manage the individual drives in the array and the array itself. But as for the actual drives, Windows only sees the array as a one drive if its configured that way. BTW, because of my experiences with Windows not handling soft raid very well, I use only hardware raid. Ironically, soft raid is what's covered on the cert exams.
Next, your Windows boxes have never bsod? Well cheers to you. I have a hard time believing you, but props just the same.
As for vendors tying the OS to their hardware, you might call it money grubbing, others call it quality control and assurance. You know the OS will work with the hardware. How many times has Windows died after installing service packs on Windows certified hardware? Compaq array controllers anyone?
BTW, don't think that just because Apple is moving to Intel in their consumer class gear (they didn't mention anything about the XServe going to Intel), that we'll be able to build white box Macs. Apple has already stated that people can only get Intel Macs from Apple. So money grubbing can still happen on commodity hardware.
Also, I never said that Linux doesn't have driver issues with hardware. But it usually invovles some small company with second class hardware. I've never had problems with nVidia, ATI, 3Com, Intel, Tyan, Gigabyte, Biostar, Broadcom, etc. As long as I've kept it to mainstream hardware vendors - no problems. I have had problems with Adaptec raid cards (2200S), but the problem has been resolved. As for hardware problems, I can list just as many where people have hardware issues when they had to replace a component in Windows, booted and get the nice system hang at mup.sys (otherwise known as the joining the muppet club). Booting into safe mode doesn't work. So Windows isn't any guarantee about hardware working either.
Why did Solaris get rid of x86, well it was dog slow for one when compared to Solaris on SPARC. But it's been revived and is much better than previous versions.
by apotheon
Windows is fascism. It doesn't exist without government and business being wedded to each other.
Linux is liberty. It's separate from economics. It would fit perfectly well into free market capitalism, and in fact under a socialist system it would be nationalized and development would grind to a near-stop.
by wordworker
If nothing else you have strength of your convictions going for you. Apotheon for President!
So are gas-powered SUVs fascism too, and electric cars represent liberty?
by apotheon
I think we have accepted a paradigm that says: "Software can not be made feature-rich, user-friendly, stable, and secure -- all at the same time." We are use to bugs, and crashes, and machines "stuffed" with far to many applications ... that frequently conflict with each other. We just fix one and go on to the next.
We seem use-to the idea that a "new" OS is always around the corner. I cringe at the mention of the word Longhorn, or whatever it is now ("Oh Please Billgatus...Noooo...I finally have my system working pretty good -- Do I 'have' to join your next guinea-pig find-the-new-bugs movement?" Answer: Yes. Cuz you will sell users new machines and I'll have to know how they work.)
I see end users that really do try keeping their computers up to date but many of them just get overwhelmed: "All they want to do is -USE- the damn thing, not not become a computer specialist."
My own equipment works fine, but I spend a LOT of time keeping on top of it. Far too much time in my opinion. It use to be fun. Now it isn't so much fun.
I have to use windows because my users use windows. I find myself getting more and more ticked off at the endless problems. Developers, especially of operating systems, are focused on tomorrow -- not today. It is insane. And I "think" and "hope" it does not have always have to be so. but I am losing my optimism.
I also use Linux but am not a Linux techie and don't intend to become one. My main bitch with so much Linux software is: "Don't Linux developers know how to write instructions people can understand?" -or- "Do they think end users are telepathic?" Gimmie a break, ok.... I know the Linux community is a smart bunch, but what lousy writers many of you are. What good is your software if people can't figure out how to use it or what to do if they have a problem.
Software can be much better than it is if software developers took the time to make it so.
And I must add before someone comes lookin' for me with their shotgun: "There are some great applications out there that are well written and that have great documentation: You have my highest regards. I wish there were more of you.
I have been in and out of the software business since 1995 and figure I have about seen it all. I have made software for the military so I know what the words "critical" and "must work all the time or someone will die" means.
I "KNOW" software can be better... The question is of course, who is going to step up to the plate and make it so...
DCStrain
by apotheon
I must regretfully agree: Linux software is often opaque to the complete newbie, because it tends to be poorly documented, at least with newbies in mind. There's an art to finding useful information about Linux apps, and once you've got the hang of it there tends to be more helpful information for Linux systems than Windows systems, but the difficulty of getting the hang of it is problematic to say the least.
I'd take that over the technical disaster of Windows systems any day of the week. It's also worth noting that with a very little dedication the average newbie can be just as productive on a Linux system as on a Windows system: the problem that arises for Linux is when one wants to go beyond the simple functionality most people use on Windows.
Of course, Linux has an advantage over Windows that is rarely considered in such comparisons: Its open source development model allows you to "fix" its problems as you find them. If you know software can be better, [b]you[/b] can "step up to the plate" and start solving problems.
by jaqui
3/4 of linux documentation was written by programmers with no concept of end users. ;)
it's written "for systems engineers by systems engineers."
not by documentation specialists like the ms houses use.
comes with the cost of being free I guess, getting someone to test the app, figure out how it works from your piss poor notes, then write good user docs for free isn't an easy task.
by jrice
by jaqui
with xp professional
seems the xp bootloader doesn't like the i810e chipset.
(bios would not recognise the drive at all for 3 boots [ even then it took a win98 ebd to get access to it ] )
that same drive, which crashed weekly under xp, stopped crashing when it had either 98 or linux on it. so yes, you can occasionally blame the os for hardware problems.
by jaqui
I need windows based machines to develop applications for linux only?
why?
give me a good answer to that one please...
if it ain't an open source os, I don't code for it.
t.c.s. ( total cost security ) is more than the software to secure your system [ which comes free with linux ] it's also the downtime because someone shut thier antivirus down to speed the system up, they downloaded and installed 45 trojan downloaders, one on each workstation in thier department.... downtime, loss of data, loss of customer satisfaction.
gee your windows desktops just cost the company 20% of thier profits, in lost business from the infections.
tcs is far lower with any *x os than with a m$ os.
by hal 9000
Computers don't make mistakes! :D
Unless of course they are ruining MS products that it isn't a mistake but a Undocumented Feature and that isn't all that hard have you actually seen what Documentation comes with an OEM copy of Windows? Even that pathetic attempt I'm told by many new users is not written for the first time computer user but for what they consider as the Advanced User. ;)
Col ]:)
by rkuhn040172
See that, my reply weeded out the small group of TR members that are clearly biased OS fans.
I cannot figure out why in your environments Windows is crashing so much...doesn't happen all that often here.
I cannot get our business ERP software to run in Linux.
I cannot find or afford to hire a Linux admin in the Indianapolis market.
I haven't experienced the nightmarish security issues you say happen.
Using properly configured products like routers, firewalls, spam filters, proxies, content filters, anti-virus, VPN's, group policies, etc we have no problem keeping your doomsday scenarios from occurring.
Now, being a "business" person and tech, we are constantly reassessing our options. But at this time, it is NOT financially possible to make the switch.
I'm not trashing Linux, I do believe in it. But the decision is not made in a vaccuum and at this time the balance sheet is leaning towards staying with Windows.
by jaqui
that rikk@.. can't answer the question I asked?
even though he's posted to your comment so has seen it?
after all answering what use a windows box is when only developing for *x must be beyond his capabilities.
yet he claims that by not having a windows box I'm some sort of failure....
by wordworker
>>It's also worth noting that with a very little dedication the average newbie can be just as productive on a Linux system as on a Windows system: the problem that arises for Linux is when one wants to go beyond the simple functionality most people use on Windows.<<
Please. Average newbie can be productive on a Linux system? Kind sir, do us the privilege of showing a screen shot of your "newbie-friendly" Linux desktop, won't you?
>>Its open source development model allows you to "fix" its problems as you find them. <<
Not bloody likely! Even if well documented, programmers and systems engineers are special types, or everybody would be programming and developing systems. These two posts illustrate the "IT Arrogance" associated with the Linux user / tweaker community. You want everyone (techies and newbies) to embrace your orthogonally-designed system, but you don't want to take time to document it properly (lest you be accused of being documentation specialists? since when is that a bad thing??). No, better to expect techies and end users to "figure out" the tricks of finding good stuff about Linux on the Web. Yeah with Champions like you two running amok, I am shocked Linux hasn't become the #1 choice for desktops of techies and newbies alike.
by hal 9000
With something like the old Lycoris Desktop LX which looked very much like an XP desktop about the only real difference was that you Had to Log in to get it started. You couldn't bypass that option and it only had 2 screens available. The whole thing came on 1 CD and that was OS and software from CD/DVD recording, Web Browsing, Open Office, Graphic Programs and a lot else.
The reality is that most people couldn't tell the difference when I had it loaded on my LT for demo purposes and once I had told them the password they could just use it without a problem.
The Menu is almost the same as Windows and other than different names for Applications these people just didn't have a single problem. This was with a light weight Linux that really wasn't all that usable either. My current Debian Install on the LT is just as easy to use by Windows only people when I boot it into Gnome and other than asking why the programs have different names they don't have a problem. Currently I've resorted to telling them that what they are using is a Beta Version Of Windows and Office and they can not tell the difference.
But since Windows is so User Friendly perhaps you could answer the other thread where someone is asking where the Device Manager is in XP! :D
You can find it here
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11183-0.html?forumID=89&threadID=178357&start=0
But since Windows is so User Friendly why is the question being asked in the first place? :p
But on the up side it is still there most likely in VISA or was that Vista it most likely will not be there as it is unnecessary for the "Average User" right? :D
Col ]:)
by apotheon
User-friendly Linux desktops:
http://tinyurl.com/94dcm Lycoris
http://tinyurl.com/84j4p Xandros
http://tinyurl.com/8t6zv SuSE
http://tinyurl.com/9nz9y Linspire
http://tinyurl.com/bgjjr Fedora
http://tinyurl.com/76bzz Debian
By the way, none of those are my own desktop. See, unlike Windows, with Linux I'm not [b]forced[/b] to have a dumbed-down interface. Mine would be incomprehensible to the average newbie, especially if he's coming to my computer from Windows. For me, though, it's far more efficient and easy to use than any Windows-like desktop.
Linux can be just as "user friendly" as Windows, if not more so, but it doesn't have to be if you want power and flexibility at your fingertips instead.
[b]--------------------------[/b]
re: fixing problems as you find them
I didn't expect you to be so dense that you wouldn't realize I was talking to the IT pros on this site when I said you could fix problems as you find them. I don't mean that Aunt Millie is going to start fixing problems with the operating system environment, no matter what the OS happens to be.
by wordworker
by jaqui
http://www.geocities.com/jaqui_greenlees/kde.jpg
a user friendly desktop
and here:
http://www.geocities.com/jaqui_greenlees/enlightenment.jpg
is my preffered desktop
by hal 9000
Be at the head of the Que when Visa sorry I meant Vista comes out as a production version and be one of the First Beta Testers that pays for the privilege of sorting out problems to M$?
That is one of my biggest bugbears with any new M$ OS we are nothing but Beta Testers who have to pay for the privilege to getting their products to actually work part way like M$ claims they will.
Col ]:)
by apotheon
by apotheon
How often do you have to restart Widnows?
How often does it crash?
You said "[i]I cannot figure out why in your environments Windows is crashing so much...doesn't happen all that often here.[/i]" I've got to wonder why you think not crashing "all that often" is acceptable. Yeah, my Windows systems have hardly ever crashed, but I'm a trained (and Microsoft-certified) professional, and they [b]still crashed[/b] from time to time. That's a problem. Having gotten used to the stability of Linux, it's [b]unacceptable[/b]. Add to that the fact that I never need to even restart Linux unless I've upgraded the kernel, and suddenly Windows is starting to look like it's all downtime in comparison.
The fact that you can't get [b]your[/b] ERP software to run on Linux means nothing in regards to how Linux compares to Windows. There's ERP software that'll run on Linux and not on Windows, too. What's your point?
I don't know what to tell you about finding employees. That's too bad. Try attending LUG meetings for a while, and I'm sure you'll find some very qualified candidates. Of course, I'm not convinced you'd even bother to try very hard.
You said "[i]I haven't experienced the nightmarish security issues you say happen.[/i]" I can only assume you haven't worked as a consultant. I have, and still do, and whenever a client gets a Linux system installed (by us, just as they typically get us to install Windows systems), disaster calls drop from whatever the previous rate (in some cases as often as monthly) for the replaced Windows systems to effectively nothing for the new Linux systems.
There are good reasons for using Windows, at least in the short term, but you're mostly mentioning what looks like a lot of bad, misinformed reasons, to me.
so they could say quite truthfully that the BSOD is a thing of the past and will no longer occur.
Bet some image/branding consultant got a sizable whack for that idea.
Same as the other trick with the name, Longhorn is no longer riddled with problems, cut down in promised functionality and late we are getting Vista early.
Hoo****ingray.
Every version of MS Office has changes to the menus and shortcuts that takes staff time to learn. I once had a client who tried staff with a new office system, they had a version of Open Office that operated just like their old MS Office for 95% of the common menus and shortcuts, the newest version of MS Office only matched to 75% of menus and shortcuts hte same.
Another good point is that the Linux stuff comes with Wizards that you can easily turn off or bypass - most MS Wizards cannot be turned off. I once had to buy a new modem for one machine because every time Win2K Pro loaded it 'Found new hardware' and replaced the manufacturer's Australian based drivers with default MS USA based drivers that stopped the modem from working. Only MS will give you an OS that stops genuine designed for MS software from actually working with their software. That company no longer goes through the trouble of getting their stuff MS approved just made a slight firmware change and you can use all their gear with USA based drivers just turn off 'Wait for dialtone' for Aust use.
There is even a version of Linux that looks so much like MS that I have seen people think it was a new improved MS OS - can't remember its name fro sure but think it was called Redmond Linux.
You can build a Linux box with Open Office to replace your Win 98 or Win2K with Office or Office 2000 and your staff would only have to learn how to use the new productivity options like tabbed windows options etc. The staff retrain things has been dead for some years.
by hal 9000
Considered as a "Windows Hater!" :D
Actually it's not so much Windows as MS that I really hate as they are hard to deal with and here I actually mean Volume License Stuff as the rules seem to change every person that you talk to. :(
Actually what's wrong with using a Mixed Environment? You just might find out that the Dreaded Linux/Unix/ BSD is really just so much better that Windows and doesn't need to be constantly shut down when a patch is applied or a new program installed and so on and so on. :)
But this is a no win position and thread as when I say something nice about MS people call me a Nix Hater and when I say something truthful about MS I'm a Nix Lover!:^O
Col ]:)
by humbletech99
Have you ever heard of a buffer overflow? Well, surprise surprise, they exist in Linux as well as Windows, Unix and just about any other piece of software more than a few lines long. Substance?
Anyway, I'm a Linux and Windows sysadmin. I agree that every system has it's own strengths and weaknesses, what people need is more brains and less criticism. The people who write that stuff are far superior to anyone here in skill, IQ and all the rest. If you can do better, go ahead, otherwise stop acting like a crab trying to pull others down.
I personally believe that Microsoft does as well as they can, as well as anyone can. More users means more attacks discovered. Firefox security bugs in the last 6 months after version 1 shows this (I use that too). How many did you hear of when it was Firebird? They're both still good. There's just always room for improvement. Keep working on it fellas!
by jaqui
all the money being spent on security tools isn't enough to pay for a linux admin, since it wouldn't need to be spent on security tools with linux.
the firwalls that come free with it are better than any but hardware firewalls.
( they equal those )
if you only have linux, 75% of the security tools you need under windows are no longer needed.
and the 25% you need come free with the os.
hmm. really can't afford the system admin...
ohhh. by getting rid of people in the it department that won't learn linux, you get all thier salaries also to work with.
now you can afford 2 linux system admins.
one to deal with the daysh|t crap, one to work nights and do the system maintenance. ( the REAL work )
by apotheon
Who said anything about programming?
I'm just talking about simple system troubleshooting. Because of the openness of the system, and the fact that nobody's trying to obscure what's going on under the hood, it's a lot easier for a knowledgeable sysadmin to fix system issues without resorting to simply reinstalling everything from scratch. Even the most experienced sysadmins on Windows still have to do a full nuke-and-pave far more often than they should when troubleshooting. Things like registry and library corruptions are an easy fix in Linux, but are the death knell for a given installation of Windows more often than not.
You don't have to be a programmer to replace a library or compile a custom kernel in Linux, but you can't do the latter at all and would have to violate the DMCA to do the former most of the time if you were to try, and wouldn't even know where to start without an in-depth knowledge of Windows system architecture. I know because I've researched several such issues for clients in the past; in other words, from first-hand experience.
by hal 9000
apotheon technical expertise. :^O
Yes a "Real Tech" would Puke & Nuke the HDD's and just reload and not worry about any of the end users Data after all it isn't important is it? So what if there is an order on it for a 20 Million $ something the end user should have actioned it before the machine broke right? ;)
But for some strange reason there are some of us who actually like to repair things and not just roll out a clean install or provide a new box for every problem. Do you realize that we make far more money fixing things than by selling them new stuff? And when I say "FIX" I do mean fix not just trash and start from scratch. :)
Dear woodworker what you are advocating is something that used to happen in the old days of Radio and those so called Techs where called Valve Jockeys as they would just keep changing Valves until it worked again and charge the customer for the privilege. These people didn't really fix anything but eventually got it going again and quite a bit latter than was actually required for a proper repair as well. There was a very old saying when I was at Uni and that went something like this "A Mechanical Engineer can do for $10.00 what any fool can do for $100.00!" {I had to change the money amounts because the old figures wouldn't have meant anything at all to most people here.} The same applies to IT as well! Get the idea. :D
We are in a Service Industry and we had Bloody Well better offer that service or we will all be out the door so that includes saving the End Users Data and repairing where possible and Puke & Nuking where it isn't but no matter what always save the users data as the very first thing. After all it has far more value than the box of Plastic, Silicon and metal than anything else on the system. I can have a new computer in place within a few hours if need be but I can not recover one single byte of the users data if they no longer have a computer to work from. To the end user their Data is all important and they really don't give a RATS about the machine that it is on. :p
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
It means that you haven't wangled any Window box out of an company that you worked for so for that reason you have failed. :^O
Unless of course you have done the right thing and wiped the drives and installed Linux on them. That would not only make you successful but smart as well. :p
Col ]:)
by amcol
by tomsal
Someone run out of Sanka this morning?
Anyway -- MS isn't great (see my other posts)..I've got plenty to bitch about them for.
However to completely imply that the Windows has no value to ANYONE with a brain -- its moronic at best.
Plus that's like you are taking a cheap shot at anyone who uses Windows.
I use Windows at work because 95% of everything is Windows, though I'm trying hard to get more stuff Linux its an uphill battle in a blizzard though.
At home I use Windows -- I'm into the computer games thing -- in a big way. Windows XP runs the games perfect with very little problems -- in fact I haven't had any major "game problems" in months now.
At least that are related to windows - some of the software had issues but that was the publisher's fault.
There were all "in-game" issues.
Anyway, that's just my 2 cents. Take it or don't...either way I don't really care. lol.
by wordworker
by hal 9000
Lost me there mate I'm an Aussie so I don't know where that came from.
But for something constructive how about attempting to help this guy out he has a Sony MP3 player that he can not get to install on XP Pro with SP2 so it should be right up your alley.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6239-0.html?forumID=48&threadID=178324
I don't seem to be getting anywhere with him so maybe you'll be able to communicate with him better. :)
Col ]:)
by jmgarvin
ok...bad joke...
Still it is sad that many of the current graduates of the American educationally system don't know the difference between Austria and Australia and they have no idea where any country is (including their own).
by jaqui
by jyip
by apotheon
1. search for package's proper name (and I was using only default repositories)
# [i]apt-cache search sendmail[/i]
2. install using that package name (turns out it's "sendmail")
# [i]apt-get install sendmail[/i]
3. celebrate
Elapsed time: 3 minutes (twenty second celebration included)
I'm not a fan of Ubuntu, and Ubuntu in any case is a desktop-specific distro. You want a server, you should be using something else. Would you really want to run a mailserver on XP Home?
I'm inclined to be skeptical of claims that Ubuntu's default repositories don't contain Sendmail binaries, though I'm not running it here so I can't check.
Of course, since Ubuntu already has an MTA installed (specifically, Postfix) by default, the pared-down Debian offshoot's maintainers might not have decided to support Sendmail. By all accounts, Postfix is generally "better" than Sendmail, anyway. Maybe you should have checked to see if a Mail Transport Agent is already installed before you started screwing around with installing a new one. Installation time: 0 seconds.
If you want to use Exim on a standard Debian system, like mine, installation time: 0 seconds. Exim is the default MTA of standard Debian systems.
In fact, I'd be highly surprised to find that any full PC-install or desktop-worthy LiveCD distros do [b]not[/b] have a server-worthy MTA included in the default installation.
by apotheon
by apotheon
Thanks, Col! I've gotta say, it was amusing to see my name taken in vain like that.
"Puke and nuke" is a phrase I haven't heard in a while. I've been using "nuke and pave" to describe common Windows troubleshooting practice, since it seems such an apt description of what is usually required. If after ten or twenty minutes it becomes clear you can't fix it in an hour, you'll have to nuke and pave: basic rule of thumb with Windows. With Linux, if you can't fix it in an hour, you need a new skillset.
by mswanberg
Well, that's the trouble, isn't it? THIS distro says it's easy to use and learn (good for Linux n00bs like me who don't have a lot of free time to learn stuff), but all it seems to have is an e-mail client and a web browser (Ubuntu, Linspire, Mepis, etc. seem to be like this). And THAT distro has it all, but you have to be a guru to use it.
See, here's my dilemma. I am pretty much a power user. I want servers and compilers and all the tools that our moms haven't the foggiest what they do. I can surf and e-mail from my PocketPC, for chrissake.
But the so-called easy-to-use Linux distros don't have those things, do they? So, then you have to be even more of an expert to set them up, much less use them.
Here's another true story of my Linux use:
Bought RedHat 8 (this was several years ago) and 3, count 'em 3, books on using RedHat 8. Same distro. Same version.
Installed RedHat choosing to install everything. Went to the books on configuring the various servers, starting with Sendmail (which is why I went there instead of Postfix with Ubuntu, since I had SOME documentation and had used it some). Book says, "edit the yada-yada.conf file and find this line..." Well, I found the file, but the line wasn't there. WTF? A CLEAN INSTALL!
Later, the book says, "edit the blah-blah.conf file..." There IS NO SUCH FILE! WTWTWTF?!?!?!? Again, a CLEAN INSTALL!
As for Ubuntu, I really don't know much about the differences between Desktops and such, so to me it's just a different distro. What's the difference? But Ubuntu was the first distro I tried that a) got X running on install, and b) figured out that my old hardware (not putting Linux on any of my newer boxes) actually could run at better than 640x480. It actually brought up 1600x1200 right on install! Not bad for that ol' 400 MHz Pentium.
That server I installed is on XP Pro. I only have XP Home on my gaming box (which leads to another nit... Linux games... enough of the Tetris... show me Battlefield2 or Falcon 4.0 on a Linux box). But IIS doesn't have a POP server, only an SMTP server. The freeware I found had both, so I kept IIS SMTP turned off. Realize, I am not doing this for an organization. Just for my small 6-box LAN.
In any case, you seem like an expert. What is your advice for me learning Linux (and learning it well, as I am a power user with a n00btard understanding of Linux)? The beginning books seem too beginner and the advanced books are above my current understanding.
I do wish to learn Linux through and through because I appreciate the open-source movement and I do believe that Linux is awesome (I just don't feel that Windows is THAT bad). Hell, I just used dd to back up a Windows partition and MBR. Man, you just can't do that with Windows out-of-the-box!
So, any suggestion you have, I would appreciate. Once I am an expert at both, then can I have a truly informed opinion.
Thank you,
-Mike
Sort by Trending