Discussion Locked

Why do IT people really bash Windows?

0 helpful
719 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post

719 replies

by hal 9000

Do I fall into?

I'm a consultant who works with everything and sell what a client requires to do a job. Now that could be MS Windows, some form of Nix, BSD or any other number of offerings depending on the job that is being done and what software is required as mission critical. ;)

Now it would be silly to put Linux desktops into an accounting section of a company but by the same token it would be impossible if I tried to sell Windows to a CG company who's main business was making special effects for movies. :)

While I'm no great MS lover it isn't because of the product but the business practices of the company they are constantly driving me nuts with the way that they do business. I can attend a Partners Meeting one week and then the next give a quote for a entire network and Volume License Software and then when I go to buy it like last time I was told that I had to buy 8 copies of XP Pro and Office Pro and then I could pay a License Fee for the Volume License for the 8 workstations in a small business.

Now maybe it's just me but paying twice for the same thing doesn't make any business sense to most people who are buying the product.

If you went out and bought a new car tomorrow with cash would you expect a bill of a similar amount to arrive several days latter for the same thing before you could pick it up? This is what happened in the last case where I put in a Volume License and then they added Software Assurance on top of the total costs. I really thought this was outrageous particularly as before I gave the quote I actually rang up the suppliers and got a firm price for the required software and 3 days latter when I went to buy it I was told it was going to be just about 100% more. Granted I really do not think that the person who was selling the stuff knew what it was that they where doing but I didn't get a refund either like was promised. I really do not mind paying for one item and then additional licenses even if they are 90% of the OEM price but just under 200% of the OEM price is unacceptable. :^O

But even then it wouldn't be all that bad if only the things worked all right and I didn't have numerous service calls to fix up the Software that had broken or defaulted back to a configuration which I had disabled for security and maintenance purposes. :(

Col ]:)

by jaqui

Now it would be silly to put Linux desktops into an accounting section of a company

since accpac makes thier software for linux as well
and gnucash is equal to quickbooks / simply accounting.

there isn't a lack of accounting software for linux to warrant saying it's useless in an accounting department.

by hagrinas

They also refused to let DR see any beta versions of Windows 3.1, even though they knew that Windows would not run under DR DOS at all at the time. DR managed to get their hands on it anyway and figured out that MS had undocumented hooks in the code, but MS wanted to make it clear that theirs was the "real" DOS, which was ironic given how much they stole from CP/M, which was a DR product.

by sternman

Most veteran IT persons dont like Microsoft because MS has rendered their skills useless. And here is what I mean.

Since MS has been making headway into organizations, they have been REDUCING the cost of software across the board. Everything they get into brings down the price significantly, from OS's to Office product tools. As well, at the same time, increased the functionality that those product are offering.

When you lower the price of anything, you will start to win market share. When you win market share, more people want to learn what you are selling, learn how to use and support it. IT guys who got their start in non-ms areas, are faced with skills that are on the way out, for the most part, and they are too old or stubborn to upgrade them.

Had Sun, brought down the price of software significantly when they had an edge, then everyone would be hating Sun today, except for those who knew it all along.

The general feel of IT hating windows is because for the most part, today, they dont use anything else on the desktop. If IT guys where troubleshooting Solaris 10 on 95% of the worlds computers, then everyone would has Sun. But that is not the case.

Sun, Novell, IBM, Fujitsu, Oracle, SAP and so on, decided that they wanted to keep the price of software high. They would spend millions of dollars trying to figure out how many companies where in the fortune 2000. Those millions of dollars, although uselessly spent, only added to the high cost of software.

MS saw a market space that was void of any major player. The big guys COULD have played there, they just chose not to. They chose to keep the price of thier software high. Poor planning maybe, or bullheadedness. Either way, those major players took a back seat while MS cleaned up with the market segment that had the most amount of money to spend on this stuff, the Small and Medium business. The market segment that today still cannot afford SAP or Oracle software. That is not MS's fault. That is the fault of those software companies.

So any IT guy who hates microsoft is just pissed off that the skills they learned from the company that HAD the chance and didn't dominate the market place.

You cannot win at software if you leave out the most important market segment, and that is the one with the deepest pockets (accumulatively).

Sell 2000 copies of your software for $20,000,000 or 40,000,000 copies of your software for $1000. It is the same thing.
So, who is going to win?

by hagrinas

Microsoft has done just the opposite. They always start off with software being cheap, and even give it away in the beginning. But then the price goes up once the competition is gone.

I first had Windows 2.x and it was free. It was bundled with the machine. (Not that people actually used it, but it was there.) When Windows 3.0 came out, it was cheap. Even Windows 95 was in the $60 range.

MS DOS was very cheap compared to the competition, and considering that the original PC was over $3000 (at a time when $19,000/year was a good salary) the OS was a minor part of the cost.

MS gave away Windows and made it cheap until MS was dominant. Now I can get a decent PC for $300, but if I wanted to upgrade my machines at home to the latest version of Windows, I'd be set back $500.

MS bundled Word almost for free. A competitive upgrade copy of the whole Office suite was well under $100. And the competition still is. But as the competition and MS continued to leapfrog each other in terms of features and usability, MS waited until their office product was dominant and raised the price through the roof. That was after signing contracts with vendors giving them the suite almost free if they bundled it, provided that they bundled it with ALL machines. Otherwise, the per-copy price was prohibitive. In other words, they gave it away until users got used to it and it became dominant.

Whenever they saw something as a threat, they came up with a competing product for "free." They saw Xtree as a threat since it was becoming a de facto user interface, so they made their file manager almost as good, so users would not buy from the competition. But it wasn't really free since the price of Windows continued to rise. And realistically, file managers were never a historical OS feature anyway; they were utilities.

When Netscape was cheap ($35 or less) and dominated the browser market, MS gave away a version of a browser for free. Until Netscape was almost out of the picture, that is. Then they released XP with a sky high price tag, that is more than the copy of the original Windows and all the add-on software combined. So it's not really free at all.

The one thing in the industry that did NOT keep pace with dropping prices was Microsoft.

Even in the mainframe days, something such as OfficeVision was $20,000. PC users looked at PC email software (not suites, but email only) at $35/copy and marveled at how cheap it was. But if you did the math, you found out that you got a bit more than 500 copies for the price of the mainframe suite, and had to install it on every single PC, while OV supported thousands of users at that price, and handled documents. And these days, you are expected to get email as part of an Office suite that costs hundreds of dollars per user.

Microsoft is more expensive across the board no matter how you look at it, once you factor everything in. Linux is cheaper. Mainframes are cheaper. It would not surprise me if Macs work out cheaper too.

by quantumetrics

I was there at the time, and yes, this is exactly the strategy Microsoft employed in the early 80s to achieve its industry domination.

I repeat that Microsoft is a marketing company, not a technology company. Its behavior in the marketplace makes this crystal clear.

by tony hopkinson

As a software developer my skills are not limited to any platform, hardware, operating system, language.
I am a programmer. I take complex tasks, break them into simple steps. The only thing the environment I'm working in does is define the granularity of those steps and how efficiently they are made.
I've programmed in many environments and the ones I haven't I'll put my house on that I could.

Don't buy into HR's view of IT. The skills of support, design, adminstration etc transcend environments, they are merely the syntax of how those abilities are implemented, a difference of mere degree. Now that might be a problem, but windows is dumbed down overall which means competent non-ms people have more skills than it requires.

by hagrinas

I remember when the IT industry fell into two camps: "Only IBM can save us," or "IBM over my dead body." IBM deserved both the credit and the blame for the way they were back then. They dominated the industry, but they were not the most open company to deal with.

I remember going to a Microsoft convention when they were going to release Internet Explorer (ver 3 perhaps?) It was still an add-on. By that time, Microsoft was already difficult to deal with, and at a trade conference such as that one, I would have expected to be able to meet with developers and discuss issues. Instead, if I called any of the speakers to the carpet over why things didn't really work the way they said, the standard answer was that I could call Microsoft and pay them if I wished to discuss my problems.

By that time, any IBM conferences I went to were completely different. By then, I had unprecedented access to the developers who wrote the code being discussed. IBM had changed its long time strategy of having its top people as developers and then passing the code off to a maintenance group. They decided instead to make the developers responsible for maintenance. That way, the developers heard first hand from users who had problems, and had to learn how the software was being used in the real world. Far from being adversaries, the developers were people I knew I could count on if I ever had an issue.

IBM may have lost its dominance, and I may not have used a mainframe for many years now, but at least they gained some integrity, while MS became the monster that IBM used to be.

by hal 9000

Particularly on the last bit about Beta Software Offerings from MS. While I still do work with these but now only on the finial Beta Release as the prior ones are just too buggy with no recourse to report problems to allow them to be fixed.

MS beta stuff today is nothing more than market research with no follow up and really is a marketing ploy in an attempt to generate interest in the product so people will want to rush out and buy it just like the days of the release of Windows 95 where they had ques of people waiting for the official release like it was some major sporting event. :^O

Now days I find it a lot easier to only work with the MS provided Time Bombs which are the trial versions of the actual product at least I do get support if I have any problems with that and MS get feed back as well.

Col ]:)

by lost_one

Try pulling your heads out of your Linux a$$es for awhile.

Why is Linux so great? It won't even run over half the programs my business needs. No wonder they give it away.

Might be ok for servers, but for desktops it sucks!!

by wordworker

Fact: Not one single person in any of these threads has testified that a single corporation ANYWHERE has made a Linux desktop a corporate standard. If any exist, let them speak up. It is not fud, it is not ignorance. It is the way the world is. Deal with it. If you want to promote a Linux revolution, you need to change your tactics. Currently, you sound like a vegeterian whining about the proliferation of McBurgers. I can hear it now, "You're only eating meat because you don't UNDERSTAND vegeterianism."

Have you tested SAP clients, or any other "desktop" application under those Win-emulators? Name one. Show us your results. Else, you are giving the Linux community a bad name.

If the Linux desktop options are such viable options to replace Wintel desktops, name the companies that use them as end user workstations.

Edit: I am not anti-Linux. I recommend or make decisions about desktop and server solutions and purchases to companies of varying sizes quite frequently. Neither I nor my clients have the time nor patience to wade through an alphabet soup of open-source desktop options looking for one that works - not while the Windows workstations work just fine. But if you can show proof and not just spew unsubstantiated claims, corporate IS decision makers will listen.

by maldain

The reason MS gets pounded on is they are the big dog on the block. Also, MS has made some really silly errors that have made it into the market stream. You can't do that as a manufacturer of an item that people rely on very often because sooner or later people lose confidence in your product. That's where MS is now the IT professionals are starting to lose confidence in MS's operating systems. The IT professionals spend their days cleaning up messes left by MS's errors. It's really easy for an IT professional to take a look at their LINUX web server/mail server/database server and say gee I don't have these problems with those systems. The fallacy there is if you put the ordinary user on a Linux system they'll come up with similar problems. The difference is that with linux it doesn't screw everybody else up too.

by archaeop

Let's not confuse "has its uses" with "has strengths and weaknesses". M$ made a fortune by getting credibility from IBM, then ensuring that programs stayed binary compatible for 25 years. That, combined with an "amazing" feature-list has been unstoppable. Compatibility and rampant featuritis has had a cost though: It's hard to build a feature-rich environment compatible with DOS and the 8/16 bit 8088 that is also stable.
Don't forget that when M$ got it's start (and Apple, for that matter) hobbyist computers were $5000 (current dollars) for 32KB of RAM, a 180K floppy disk and a audio cassette for data storage. Every line of software written in that environment was a kludge. No one really expected it to work well. Unix was exclusively in $25K+ computers where they could afford things like hard disks and memory management.
When WinNT came out, it had the features business wanted and was guaranteed job security for IT folks. Back in the day, the strength of Win was that you could upgrade your computers and still run your old programs, and given that your computer would crash anyway the extra features were cool.
In this age of Thin/Zero clients, and the complete commoditization of desktop computing, the Windows weakness of having to be compatible with *everything*, layers upon layers of slightly buggy features may outweigh its strengths. That may be why IT folks bash Windows: It's weaknesses are no longer forgivable.

by ungle

You seem to be working under the msiconception that ActiveX components are always out of process components.

See, COM, in and of itself, is simply a method the DLL loader uses to reference count in-memory instances of a particular object so that it may unload that component when the last instance is destroyed.

RCP is used in interprocess communication. Most COM components are IN process objects, meaning there is in interprocess communication, no RPC involvement.

It can, however, support out of process components, and RPC and marshalling does get involved. This was designed for the distributed COM model (DCOM or COM+ as it was renamed).

Arbitrary code execution of a buffer overrun is pretty much the only way a user can take advantage of the weakness. Consider: Function A of my component - com or not - is expecting a string in the form of a Character array (primitive data type). The string is terminated with a null character. The length of the character array is coded into the application, and SHOULD be checked, but in these cases is not. The function accepts the char array and writes it to memory.

Joe Smarty writes an application to exploit the overrun weakness. He passes in a string that is longer than expected. Beyond the expected length he writes his own binary data, and the data is written to a memory space previously used by the application itself.

At some time in the future of the life of the application Joe Smarty's illicit code will be executed.

Buffer overruns are the result of sloppy programming and bad code auditing. They result in arbitrary code execution, regardless of the OS. Effectively, Buffer Overruns and "Arbitrary code execution" are synonymous.

DCOM (COM+) was a good idea for it's day, allowing distributed computing. It's out of vogue now with web services replacing it's functionality (in the Windows world) without the security risk.

Take a close look at the security sites: Buffer overruns are endemic in operating systems because of the complexity of the systems. Even OpenBSD has corrected numerous issues - although (almost) always before they are exploited. They always lead to arbitrary code execution.

Finally, there have been many buffer overrun issues found in Windows (and othe OS). However MOST do not involve COM. The applications installed on Windows use COM extensively. The OS does not. Office uses it extensively.

by ungle

MS SQL DOES NOT require a reboot. Are you sure that's what you were installing? You sure it wasn't the latest spyware you downloaded from a porn site?

Of course the service pack requires it. But then again after every RedHat kernel upgrade I've had to reboot.

Guess the score is even. As it was to start.

by ungle

apotheon, you'll be shocked, I agree with you!

You can say a lot of things about any OS, but you can knock Linux for it's ease of use. Of course, you'll have to spend the same amount of time learning Linux as you did Windows (naturally), but look, a comparison:

I was about to move from one country to another, I had all my boxes packed and left out one laptop for email while waiting for the plane. Guess what? HDD died. Run to the local shop and buy a HDD, but what about the OS?? All my CDs were packed! Run to the book store, buy a Linux book for $20, run home.

Pop in the CD, click next, next, next , next, wait 15 minutes, done. Plug laptop into LAN and check mail.

Granted, I've run into difficulties when trying to compile some esoteric library into , but it wasn't too dificult to rectify.

by ungle

I understand your post. I think you'd be very surprised just what you can do from a Unix shell script, be careful there.

As a quick point, VBScript, JScript are not interpreted languages. The scripting host compiles then prior to execution. That's how you can get such goo dperformance out of a script.

by hal 9000

But if you want just one company that uses a NIX on the desktop try Industrial Light & Magic. There isn't a single Windows box on the face of this planet that is capable of doing the work that those desktops do. :D

Col ]:)

time to go out and kill yourself. :p

Now for the poetry. :)

by wordworker

They would probably take offense at being characterized as corporate, but you're off to a good start.

by hal 9000

Should be shown some consideration. Even Star Trek used IL&M for their Next Generation, Deep Space 9 and part of Voyager.

But if you really want to have a good look at companies/organizations who use some form of Nix predominately then most of the Big ISP's, every heavy duty Graphic Rendering place, most of the printing shops the big ones who may have Windows on the desktop for the front counter staff but a version of Nix in the real work area. Any place with even part way medium Blade Arrays. Then there are the places with the big Blades and mainframes like Banks and Financial Institutions.

Col ]:)

by jaqui

mainframe entertainment.
they only use sgi, with custom written software.

thier products:
reboot,
transformers,
beasties,
...

all 3d graphics animations and none of it done on an ms based machine.

by sudheer_tp

I agree with all of ur arguments.

Unix is very good OS no second thought about it. But do u think that Non-teche people are comfortable to use it. They will say oh no computer is not for me.

Just back in end of 90?s when Linux was introduced how many people wr interested in using it. Since more and more people r started helping open source OS by giving more tips and developed friendly OS. Now becz it has improved a lot and with more and more friendly GUI common people r thinking about it. If not no non-teches and common people would have thought of using the same old Linux.

Even what may be the hardware if more and more people r started using it then the cost of hardware will go down considerably becz of manufacturing cost.

See for an example if u want to manufacture a car it may cost u in $10K. (This is an example I am giving, don?t ask me car). Think of the raw material cost and man-hour spend for it etc., Initially u have to make prototype model, once it is though u had to bring out the production model. For these entire process it will cost u about $10k. To bring out a working production model of car initially has to spend lot of money etc.,. Once first car is out using the same process you can manufacture more car for very less price like around $5K. This will happen only if more and more people started using ur car. If not ur overhead will be very high. Just think the price of first car and next 10 cars. It will be lot of difference. I cannot explain all the process to manufacture a car.

Another simple example, think of ur TV, now u may have around 200- 300 channels, and on each channels u can watch same number of programs. Just thing only one program is telecasting in all the 300 channels, do u think the new TV?s with all high-fi technology is worth to use. No-way just u can have old TV with 5 to 10 Channels is good for ur purpuse. Same way once different peoples started giving different programs in different channels, then whatever the new development on technology will be useful.

I am the first person to thanks IBM for introduing the PC for common man. But just thing that how can u expect common man to work on UNIX or Linux with out user friendly. Since Microsoft introduced very user friendly OS, which can be, used by any non-teches and even common man without any knowledge of computers.

So even though IBM etc., people developed hardware for fewer prices, if people are not using it then it is nouse to the world.

by bite me_ax_moron

I installed my Xandros desktop OCE 3.0 in 20 minutes and that was using the full options. I picked everything I wanted. Theres never been a windows install that fast & easy. But before you go bashing me for saying so, I run Windows XP on most of my machines. Up time is horrible. The best is 3 or 4 days with programs running 24/7. And then only because CachemanXP stops up the memory leaks. Without 3rd party software, windows under an intense use such as mine just doesn't cut it. On the other hand the Xandros machine has only been rebooted for power failures...ever. At work its an all windows shop. And thats great cause it keeps me in a job. I can tell you in the last 6 months every server has been down 4 or 5 times. We now just image our machines and ghost them back when they quit. So barring hardware failures, just afew updates since the last image & the machine is back to work. On my own desktop I run Xandros, I never shut it off. Why don't we use it everywhere? I'm the network support tech. I don't have fancy wallpaper ( kind of like Windows) Even though I've been in this field since the late 80's. So I don't get the decisions. I had to fight to get the old stodgers to let me run Linux on my own box.
I will eventually only have one Windows box (at home) so I can keep up with the problems at work. The rest are being converted one at a time as I have time to train everyone to use them and when the windows install is killed by whatecer comes down the net (yes I have more security them most of your servers). The box that never goes down? It serves the files for all the other machines so I can keep them clear of anything that will kill them.
If your really serious about OS do what I did try a bunch. Oh yeah thats right only the Nix's can give you that option.

Merlin

by hal 9000

As well as Windows 3X they where hardly the most user friendly OS's out there at the time where they?

I have one customer who sells heavy earthmoving equipment and when I got him his first computer he was under the impression that all he had to do was sit in front of it and it would do everything for him, {way too much Hollywood there,} he didn't even know how to turn it on let alone what the DOS prompt was for. I think it was one of the early Pentiums back then or maybe even a 486 but he worked his way through the various incarnations of Windows and eventually spat the dummy with XP Pro.

I then loaded his new Notebook with Linux Lycoris Desktop LX and he's never looked back. He finds it easy to use is more than happy with the user interface and is constantly blaming me for not giving him Linux previously and making him suffer through Windows. The number of times that he managed to loose data and other things was terrible he just wants to sit down at his LT and work. He's not the slightest bit interested about how it works or why it works just that it works for him and he now has a Broadband Internet connection for the speed that he didn't consider as necessary only a year ago now. After all he had a dial up modem why did he need anything faster?

Currently he is now in the Philippines with a Wireless hub so he can move around his house and even into the back yard and work with his LT. From a guy who didn't want to know the first thing about computers or why they would be of any use to him he now constantly carries a LT Digital camera and portable printer so he can spit out papers while he is on site for his job. When he gets home he just plugs in a 21 inch monitor a Keyboard & mouse, a USB Scanner and a printer one of the Canon ones with individual ink tanks that prints CD Faces which he was violently apposed to when he originally got this latest one last year but now claims that he can not live without..

Now 5 - 8 years ago he had to be dragged kicking and screaming into the office to send an E-Mail and today you can not prize the LT out of his hands no matter what. Both printers can take photos directly from the camera and print them if required and he doesn't have an ounce of trouble coping images from the camera to the LT and then attaching them to an E-Mail, he couldn't live without it. When he first got a computer he was scared of the thing and was constantly complaining about just how hard they where to work with and why did you have to talk differently to what real English was?

The first time I told him to reboot the computer over the phone he asked did he need to disconnect the leads before he kicked it out the door. Now from that point to where he is now took a lot of effort and a willingness on his part to learn how to use the thing. He has moved from not wanting to touch the thing in any form to changing outgoing ISP when he is on International Trips without a second thought. Late last year or earlier this year he actually parked an excavator on one of his work computers because it was too slow for him to even consider using.

Now if a person like this can learn anyone can. The only reason that he wanted to use a computer initially was to make it easier to get sales now he finds it impossible to do his job without one constantly tied to his hand. I even got an inverter to plug into the cigarette lighter in his car so he could charge up the batteries in the LT, Printer and camera while he's driving and that is now part of his permanent equipment that he constantly carries with him whenever he goes away on trips.

But as I constantly am telling him that when he originally started using Windows there was no easy product to use except maybe for the Apple and they where far too expensive in comparison to the stuff that he had then.

Col

by deadly ernest

What we now call the personal computer was about for a few years before IBM and MS got involved. It was the dual involvement of IBM and MS at the right time in the right manner that allowed the PC to take off. Prior to that the thinking was that micro computers (their name then) and their software would only be used by higher learning institutions, research facilities and govt bodies. This meant that the high R&D costs were spread out over an estimated sales a between 5 to 25 thousand units; average unit with basic software set up was around A$20,000 or more.

IBM decided to try and hit the general public with their verion, the PC, and got software from MS. Both were calculating their costs and sales on the basis of millions of sales, and thus had lower per capita cost structures. At that time all software was hardware specific and each company protected their designs and architecture. IBM made their design and architecture available to everyone on licence at US$1 per licence, thus anyone could now make computers like the IBM ones very cheaply. Soon IBM clones flooded the market and became the PC standard, as did the MS software designed for that architecture.

MS also sold their software to the general public at about 5% of the cost of their opponents at that time. This allowed them to get the lion's share of the new general public market that was all but created by the cheap IBM clones and MS software. Since then other market pressures have been driving the hardware development and costs.

However, MS goes to greta lengths to maitain their current price structure and have done so since the introduction of Win 95, which was based on uncopyrighted code stolen from Apple.

Unix predated DOS and MS and Linux is a rewritten evrsion of Unix - all this time people have seen Unix and Linux as more stable, however it is only recently that they have both started aiming at the 'any fool can load and use' end of the market.

the tech knowledge needed to load and use Unix and Linux was exactly the same as that needed to load and use MS DOS and Win 3.x. The introduction of automatic wizards in Win 95 to allow non tech users to install and load hardware and software was what enabled MS to pull away from the others in the general use market. That gap has now closed with the latest distributions of the other O/Ss.

However we still have the root cause of the bashing which is due to MS promises re better software that are not delivered, software with faults that should have been fixed at the kernel level in earlier versions as they have been knwon about for years. yet they still charge big dollars for software with known faults and claim they are fixed and better. And that lying pisses people off.

by deadly ernest

Before I get started, I use both MS Windows and Linux, and have just spoken at length about how important MS was to the industry in the early days. This is done on an Win XP Pro system.

Why do I dislike MS and Windows? Because I am sick and tired of being lied to by a bunch of hypocrytical thieves.

MS keep telling us that they have fixed all the problems in Windows in each new release, and soon there after we get patches for problems that have been known about in previous versions, many that are years old. Why are they there - because MS did not review and rewrite the kernel code to fix the known problem. It is this constant need to fix known problems that should have been fixed pre release that pisses many people off.

Add into that the troubles with their anti-piracy processes and you get some awfully upset people. I have one system that since I loaded XP Pro onto it I have had to reactivate it 9 times, 8 times due to changes in the hardware (2 being new HDDs) and one rebuild. They go to a lot of effort to protect the software that they built on code stolen from Apple.

Then add in little things like automatic wizards that can not be turned off. I have a modem that was made in Australia and the manufacturer went to the trouble to get the operating softwrae for it certified by MS for sue with Win 98 and Win 2K. I have used it in a Win 2k System and later in a Win XP Pro system; load the Aust based MS certified software and at every reboot the MS wizard informs me that the drivers are damaged at automaticallyb replaces them with generic MS US based drivers. The modem manufacturers came up with a firmware update in 2002 and no longer bother getting their software certified. The updated equipment, and the new ones, will now work with the US drivers if you tell the system to 'not wait for dialtone'. Only MS would create as system where software certified by them would be automatically replaced as faulty regardless of what the user wants.

You will fiond that many people who complain about MS will continue to use their software as some of it does have uses in the business realm. However they are pissed off about the crap that MS put out and the cost of a MS based system is excessive for the home realm when you can get Linux based systems that are as good or better (depending upon personal view) for a fraction of the cost.

by apotheon

My two-word response to your preceding post:

So what?

You've gone to great pains to explain a lot of the specifics of how things work, programmatically, without in any way refuting anything I've said.

ActiveX isn't "just" COM: it's COM within certain applications (in the general sense of the term, not the "computer program" sense of the term). By implementing COM under those circumstances, and through such vectors as (for instance) the OS-integrated Internet Explorer, a wide-open front door to the sensitive internals of the system has been created.

Thus, security issues. I refer you back to what I've already said in earlier posts.

by apotheon

The Linux GUI isn't twice the resource hog Windows is by any means. You've got to be high, or brain damaged, or simply misinformed by some Microsoft marketing hack, to have that impression. The X Window System is regarded by many in the unix/Linux world as being a pig, of course, but compared to Windows Explorer and associated hangers-on for the GUI environment in Windows, it's downright svelte, at less than half the average resource consumption. On top of that, you run some kind of window manager, or even full-on Desktop Environment. Considering that of that all you're using that's really part of the GUI (the rest is application frameworks in a DE) is the window manager and any GUI toolkits, it's interesting to note that the Windows full GUI implementation has a greater resource footprint all by itself than the full GUI environment plus all additional hanger-on application frameworks in the most bloated of X-based DEs, such as KDE and GNOME.

The only way I can think of that you might have honestly arrived at a conclusion that the GUI system on Linux is more of a resource hog than Windows is if you did something like run top and count up RAM usage for everything related to the GUI and compared the total against the bare essential resource usage of the Windows Explorer executable all by itself, and even then you'd have to be looking at a system that reports higher than average numbers.

Of course, that completely ignores the fact that Linux handles memory management differently from Windows, and top measures current RAM residency, not active RAM requirements. Linux has a tendency to fill RAM for quicker response on application processes, and replace unnecessary stuff when RAM is needed for something new, because it's a more efficient way to run the system. In other words, when you look at RAM usage on a Windows system you're looking at actively used RAM, and when you look at RAM usage on a Linux system you're usually looking at actively used RAM plus a whole lot of stuff that's just idling, waiting to be used, but listed as being associated with a given application just in case there's some reason to use it for that purpose.

As for performance, my 366MHz laptop running a full desktop environment (WindowMaker window manager, Gorm toolkit, and GNUstep framework, plus GNUstep suite of applications) outperforms a Windows XP system on an AMD Athlon XP 1600+ with four times as much RAM (and running DDR, compared to the laptop's PC100). The Windows system, by the way, has exactly four things installed on it, and is kept clean as a whistle (mostly since I almost never use it), so there's no way to blame its comparative performance on having a whole lot of additional cruft on it.

As for ungle:

Of course you have to reboot after a kernel upgrade. What do you expect? It's the functional equivalent of upgrading from Windows 2000 to Windows XP, or from XP Home to XP Pro. What boggles my mind is the need to reboot Windows after applying a Windows Media Player patch or installing third-party image editing applications.

by apotheon

Actually, I'm not so surprised by your agreement. You're obviously knowledgeable, particularly in regards to Windows system programming. You're probably more knowledgeable in that area than I am, in fact, and possibly by quite a bit. It's hard to know that much without being able to see where I'm right about Linux usability issues in the above post.

I think our major points of disagreement are where, from my perspective, you're looking at the programmatic aspects of the Windows system from far too close to see where architectural issues that look good up close become less good when considered within the context of other architectural design decisions on the Windows platform. In other words, from where I'm sitting, you seem to know everything there is to know about any given tree, but you're having a tough time seeing the forest.

Of course, we've gotten to a point where we're nitpicking on individual details of each others' posts, so we may never reach a point of agreement on those major issues.

by hagrinas

When people use that phrase, they are generally talking about a dedication, not a dislike. When a C++ programmer extols the virtues of C++ over Java, we often hear the appellation of religion. But with Windows, it's Windows users who are doing the bashing most often.

by apotheon

1. The Windows command line is like a poor neutered poodle next to the unix shell environment, in my experience. Just compare the availability of command switches to specialize your task for a given one-shot use between the two. In other words, I agree with your statement that someone who makes a snap judgment about the comparison of the Windows DOS prompt and the unix shell might be surprised by what a unix shell script can accomplish. I've yet to see a batch file that can accomplish what bash, for instance, is capable of.

Shell scripting projects I've seen include stuff like a menu-based troubleshooting tool for Macs, a WiFi gateway system running on a LiveCD, a full software package management system, a firewall application, a Podcast/playlist/RSS comprehensive download and management system, a weblog engine, and a video CD authoring suite. Good luck doing that with batchfiles.

2. Turning VBScript and JScript into compile-at-runtime languages was one of the smartest things Microsoft has ever done. It keeps the two languages from falling entirely by the wayside. There still isn't the performance you might expect from Perl, Python, and Ruby, but it's close enough so that people are willing to use VBScript and JScript within Windows.

by apotheon

How about Disney? They've deployed Linux desktops with WINE running Photoshop.

How about Munich? The German city is migrating everything from Windows to Linux.

While we're at it, I'm interviewing on Monday with a company that needs a Windows/Linux administrator whose desktops are 80% or so Linux. Those who use Windows do so by choice, not out of need. A Terminal Services server provides access to Visio and PowerPoint for those occasions when such are needed by the Linux users.

by jmgarvin

Here is the problem: You are looking at at VERY zoomed in view of Windows. You also aren't seperating various concepts (user accounts and user space comes to mind).

What you are talking about is only part of the story. You really need to read the SANS and Cert links I posted.

by rsmith77

I want to compliment Angus McLaren for a very insightful and balanced look at the bigoted views of the different OS's. I have to agree that his opinion is exactly right. I am tired of proponents of a particular OS bashing other OS's as well, since each does have its pros and cons.

This will be a strange statement for me to make, but it is positive, but I want to thank and condemn those who have spent their useless time writing virus', spyware, malware and the like, since it is providing all the OS's the opportunity to move forward in discovering and plugging these holes and making the OS's much better. I do as well condemn those who choose this path, since it does little harm to the OS manufacturers, but more damage to those who choose the type of OS they do, you have no right to cause them pain, and I look forward to your demise as the laws continue to become more and more favorable to prosecute those who choose to be so destructive. Enjoy you jail time and fines, I hope it was worth it.

by mswanberg

I'm not so sure that VBScript and JScript are compiled prior to running.

I frequently dynamically load various stuff into the code that can only be determined at runtime. For instance, I have a class that builds and executes FTP scripts. Other scripts will dynamically execute that code to get the class definitions which are then instantiated later in the running script.

If VBScript and JScript scripts are pre-compiled prior to execution, then the typing must be EXTREMELY loose, right down to the names of classes, procedures, functions, etc. In fact, the compiler would have to frequently say, "well, this makes no sense, but I guess it will at runtime, so I'll let it slide."

As well, commands such as Execute affect what takes place in the script. But yet, the contents of the Execute statement cannot be known at the onset of the script's execution.

For example:

s="function Add(a,b)" & vbcrlf
s=s & "Add=a+b" & vbcrlf
s=s & "End Function"
execute s
x=1
y=2
msgbox Add(x,y)

How could the compiler know the contents of s in order to satisfy the results of Add(x,y)? What if s was read from a file, or input at runtime by the user? It's the same thing, but I'll wager the compiler can't be clairvoyant enough to figure out what is actually be executed.

I do know that the script executors scan the scripts for syntax error prior to execution, but that's not the same as a full compile.

-Mike

by bkinsey1

You're right about IBM. :-) I've got an old, old, old 400 sitting under a table in my office right now. It was overpriced for its intended use when they bought it, and in its 8-10 year service life (before my tenure, so I'm not sure), it was never upgraded once, as far as I can tell. The reason? Cost. . .

As with other platforms, OS400 has it's place; it's great for large volume transactional processing, highly stable, and secure (if only because relatively few people understand it). But for our application, I switched us to a Wintel platform with a distributed client-server app a couple of years ago, saved big bucks, and improved application capabilities substantially. It's about what makes most sense for your particular use, and always will be. . . .

by bkinsey1

No aiming involved. . . More of a wide-angle shotgun blast at whoever it fits - which is not you, as far as I can tell. As I said, this just looked like a good place to insert it. . . :-)

by renaissance2000

Microsoft gets bashed so often because its the biggest kid on the block. The only people they should blame is themselves. When MS started people wanted a system that could do everything except Security. No one ever thought that that was essential, what MS did is produced a product that everyone wanted and marketed as such based on the demand. When the internet and different programming predators took off then and then only did security become an issue. MS is trying to keep up but so are the makers of other OSs. Think about it the consumers are the ones who requested it. Its like if you vote for a candidate and he/she ends up screwing everbody remember you voted for them.

by deadly ernest

As they have been advertising, for several years, about how secure and how great the security in their latest versions of Windwos are. MS put the emphasis on security around 1997/98 and have been pushing it since. yet they continue to fail to deliver on their promises - and that is what is getting people pissed off.

Tell them you are selling crap at bottom prices and no one complains - tell them you want near top dollar for quality and deliver and no one complains - ask for near top dollar for crap that does not meet the promises and everyone bitches.

The best MS Windows every procuded MS DOS with Win 3.x with the 32 bit upgrade, followed by Win 98SE - both were stable and were sold as basic systems and can still do what 90% of the clients want.

by brian.teeters

Opinions are like a$$holes, everyones got one and nobody likes to hear em.

With that said, Yes windows might be flawed, yes linux is a better built OS, but if MS didn't take the lead with personal computers where do you think we would be, no MS office no MS money to do your checkbook for you we would be in a bad way without Microsoft and even if Linux Or Mac OS was out in front there would be a line of Hackers, Crackers and Script Kiddies out there trying to bring down "the man" just as long as the current one.

Before you bash Microsoft just think of the long days of trying to teach doris the receptionist how to mount her cd rom so she can listen to a CD, or trying to explain to the boss that he will have to write his own drivers for the new video card he just spent $500 on.

by alpha geek

With all of the complaints about Microsoft, I would just like to offer up something for thought: Microsoft is a shinning example of Capitalism at its finest. The main principle of capitalism still holds true. If you can do it better, you can reap the benefits. All of those that complain about MS OS are perfectly free to do the same thing that MS did; build a better product.

by hal 9000

Japanese Animation Houses which now days do it all in CG.

There are a whole rash of them out there and I'm seeing a lot more of their products on the shelves as well now.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Telling the Boss that he has to write his own drivers for that Video Card I would have thought you as the resident IT guy would have been doing that! Anyway the Hardware makers wouldn't only be providing drivers for one OS they would be providing Drivers for each competing OS and they would all be as good as each other not the current position of only supplying drivers for one OS and then having a Web Site with second rate drivers available for a different OS so really you wouldn't be that indispensable anyway would you?

But lets look at what was available before MS caused the opposition to disappear. Various forms of DOS that would run on any system and had more and better switches than anything that MS ever brought out, Lotus 123 was the standard along with Word Perfect and Paradox had most of the office covered and you didn't need to mount a CD Drive so Doris could listen to music. Mostly you didn't have a CD anyway as they where way to expensive and anyway the software came on up to 7 or 8 Floppies so what did you need a CD for? Oh I remember Windows 95 as that required 40 specially formated 3.5 inch floppies to install so at that point it became faster to install from CD rather than use the Floppy installation method that we had all been using previously. Lets see DR DOS 6 came on 4 Floppies Lotus 123 came on 4 Floppies Word Perfect came on 8 depending if you needed printer drivers as well. And we where all using 100 MEG HDD's and the old 486 DX was fast! Even today you'll have a faster loading DOS machine that is capable of doing all your office work if you wish to compare it to a Windows XP install which takes around 1 hour to install in that time you could have a DOS system not only loaded with an OS but every program that was required and tweaked for best performance and on the desktop working before you even get Windows XP Installed. If you want to see something very interesting put a DOS system and a Windows XP Pro system side by side and apply power at the same time! I'll give you one guess which will be working first. :D

Now just how is it that you still maintain that MS has made our lives so much easier?

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

MS didn't build a better product in most cases they built a second rate product.

However what they did build was a Perfect Example of a Marketing Department and your statement is correct MS is a good example of Capitalism selling second rate products to consumers for a premium price and then expecting those same consumers to pay for the required support.

Man if that is your idea of success I really feel sorry for you as you are in for a world of hurt and if you go down this track you'll find most people despising you and taking your name in vain. Is that what you want your reputation to mean?

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

I was thinking about the Self Important Accountants not the available programs. :D

You know that 25 Accounts don't have a single brain cell between then don't you?

At one place where I worked if you where caught using a company car for illegal purposes it meant instant dismissal which was fair enough. But it got ridiculous one day when the police walked in arrested one guy for stealing old railway sleepers before they where destroyed and he was handed his Pink Slip as being taken away for questioning. Two hours latter the same Police showed up said we don't want this guy he lent his company car to so and so we want to speak to the Head Accountant who had the car at the time in question. He was guilty as sin and it was him that arranged the change of cars for the weekend to one of the most junior staff in the place who felt obligated to do as he was being asked. It only took me half a day to have my tech reinstated but the Accountant was never fired and he kept the stolen sleepers and didn't even pay for them or get charged. To this day I think you'll find then used as a retaining wall at his house if he is still living there. :D

Col ]:)

by jaqui

that I understand and agree with..

~ducking and running for cover.. bookkeeper mom, accountant sister and brother in law....~

by hal 9000

But when you let an accountant run a business they seem to destroy it with alarming regulatory.

Three of the places that I used to work at had Accountants appointed to run the place when we where making a decent profit and being competitive in the market place and on every occasion they trashed the companies without a ounce of trouble. Two of the three no longer exist as they have been wound up by the banks who appointed the Accountants to run them and the third isn't far behind. All of these companies in their time where considered as the Best in their field and where industry leaders. They where the yard stick by which other companies where measured and found wanting, now they are no longer there and their products where not bad but their management was abysmal which caused them to go broke. One of the places actually sold off a production model because they where getting more orders than they could actually produce talk about a short term profit for a long term loss. :^O

Instead of spending a little bit of money to increase production capacity they sold off their most salable model and wondered why they couldn't regain their market share. :D

Even now I'm constantly being told by my accountant how to run my business and if I followed their advice I would be broke within a year and unable to pay the staff within 6 months. One day just to peeve him off I'll take all my paperwork to him in a shoe box and say here's my accounts do my tax. :^O Now that should shut the mongrel up. :D

Col ]:)

by apotheon

Gotta love that circular logic: Microsoft is better, therefore it's more successful; Microsoft is more successful, therefore it's better; Microsoft is better, therefore it's more successful; et cetera.

You go with that. I'll be over here with a "die" statement to break out of the infinite loop and look at the situation with clearer eyes than that.

by apotheon

Whether VBScript and JScript compile at run time or are simply interpreted depends on where you're running them. The system native scripting host was initially an interpreter for VBScript and became a compile-at-runtime compiler, as far as I'm aware. I could be mistaken about that, and I suspect you and/or ungle would know better. My direct scripting experience is all with languages that are platform-independent.

There's an approach to getting the sort of flexibility to which you refer that works for variable types in compiled languages, which even allows strong typing, and languages such as Objective C make extensive use of it: rather than strict or loose typing, it uses duck typing. The term comes from the idea that if it quacks like a duck, it's of type "duck". Basically, a variable remains untyped until it is used at runtime, then becomes strongly typed at that point. This allows for a far more dynamic language, which is greatly useful for object-oriented programming in general.

I know for a fact that Perl is compiled at runtime rather than being interpreted, which helps to account for its performance (despite all the hype, it still tends to perform better in common benchmarks than Python), and Perl is not only capable of the sort of flexibility you describe, but much more besides. In fact, Perl may well be the most flexible non-Lisp language in common usage, including traditionally compiled, bytecode-compiled, compiled-at-runtime, and traditionally interpreted languages. If the perl program can do it for Perl, I'm sure it's entirely possible for someone in Redmond to have made the Windows scripting host do it for VBScript and/or JScript.

by jaqui

system 1:
pII @233MHz
128mb Ram
linux, kde.

system 2:
pIII @600MHz
768mb ram
win98se

on both systems:
corel photopaint version 9
starting with same image, performed image resampling to improve the dpi in a 3 step process.

time taken was exactly the same.
how can linux gui be a resource hog?
1/5 available ram to the windows box
basically 1/3 processing capacity ( clockspeed on lower class cpu )
yet the p3 was not able to perform any better than a p2 running linux?

by jaqui

I know someone who pushed batch files to the limits of thier capabilities.
his autoexec.batt was 75 mb in size, and unless he started windows, he never left it.
he could run every single application from the menus he built into it.
( graphic menu interface )
so, on this I'll have to say that batch files can be as powerfull as bash scripts.
( if you really put a lot of effort into playing with batch files )

since batch files are more a dos thing than a windows thing this is not a pro windows post. ;)

by jaqui

LUCASFILM!!!!

they wanted Maya, and they wanted it on LINUX for one movie.
aias-wavefront ported maya to linux for lucasfilm for the one movie, it's on the market now because of that.
( softimageXSI being the other well known professional 3d modelling animation tool on linux )

by johnmcgrew

I've been developing custom apps for over 20 years now. Back then, that usually meant DOS-based database front-ends running on Novell servers. Even by today's standards, those apps were nearly bulletproof, who's only mortal enemies were either hard drive crashes or power starvation. It was a rare day when something went strange.

Under Windows, "strange" is a nearly every-day occurence. When clients started migrating to the Windows environment, I was put into the uncomfortable position of having to try to explain why their new, modern, up-to-date Windows computers were completely unstable when compared to their DOS predecessors. Ordinary folk couldn't (and still can't) understand why a printer driver that worked yesterday no longer works today. Why does their 3-gigahertz PC with half-a-gig of RAM and SATA hard drive take 4 times as long to boot up than their 12-MHz 286 did 15 years ago?

The Internet has made the support situation even worse. Non-geeks can't comprehend why it's possible that their systems should get infected with viruses & spyware, even if they don't do anything.

And finally, they don't understand why with the cost of hardware falling to near insignificance when compared to what they paid 15 or 20 years ago, that their IT costs are skyrocketing. And that IT cost isn't to implement new technology or capability, but to fix Windows so that stuff that ran just fine yesterday will still run today.

by deadly ernest

All the MS staff still use the wild and woollie methods that Billy learnt.

When I did a programming course a few eyars back I was taught that you included routines to ensure that your program cleared all memeory that it used and returned them to the system for use by other programs, the text book we used (dated 1990) confirmed this. yet very few MS apps do this basic maintenance task as part of their exit.

In the bad old days of the 1960's and 1970's this was not a problem as the system automatically did a hardware flush and cleared all memory locations before running the next program. However, today we have the system up and running between programs and do not do a hardware flush between programs. Some O/Ss actualyy have a built in routine that checks that RAM is freed and returned when the program closes, Windows does not.

The combined result is that you can crash MS O/Ss by opening and closing any basic MS application several times, it will crash due to having insufficeint memeory available as the memory taken by the app is never returned until the system reboots. At college the NT 4 system crashed after opening and closing Word 10 times.

In 1998 I found a memory management program called MemTurbo and found that setting this to automatically check and clear RAM when it got down to 25% meant that the Win 95 system rarely crashed after that - same effect with every MS O/S since.

There are many ways that you can tweak a MS box to make it work much faster and better - I want to know why the default set up for all MS O/Ss are at the most vulnerable and resource hogs that they can make them.

by svincent

"You don't ever bash the OS, in fact if the OS crashes then it's your fault not the OS". You know I do agree that alot of times an OS crash can be linked back to the user. However, it is not always the user's falut. I've seen plenty of patches bring down many perfectly functioning machines in my day. I'm pretty sure anyone who's installed SP2 on multiple machines would agree with me. Anyway I don't hate any OS, I have my prefrences but the all have their flaws.

by apotheon

There's a big difference between writing an application suite and just writing an interative conditional loop command line menuing system. All the latter requires is the ability to print to STDOUT, the ability to use a looping conditional, and the ability to execute other programs. That's nowhere near the sort of algorithmic complexity of which the unix shell environment is capable and the richness of the shell native command list at your disposal in unix shells.

Just compare the switches available, for instance.

by gentlemiant

My problem with Windows is that it is a blackbox. Redmond can dictate when you must upgrade, how long you can get support, etc.

Source is not easily available, and possession is in most cases illegal.

Not for me in the long term.

by quantumetrics

Microsoft's philosophical stance on ownership of rights to, and usage of, source code seems curiously inconsistent ...

by jrod86

UNIX isn't open source, you have to purchase the right to use it like HP and Sun have done. Linux is opensource...Just wanted to throw that out there.

by hal 9000

Today I loaded a version of Linux by Corel before MS brought into that company and at a AGM insisted that they drop their Open Source projects. Now I had heard stories about just how bad this version or Linux was so while I did have an ISO I never actually got around to burning off a copy.

Then one day when I had nothing better to do I made a boot CD and today I've installed it on a 200 MMX with 64 MEG of RAM an unknown Video & Sound Cards and it worked perfectly. Total install time involved was 45 minutes and the only question I was asked was to provide a user name & Password. It installed even easier than Windows does.

Now this is a Debian Base product and I can see exactly why MS was so scared of it hitting the streets, it is more user friendly than MS on the install, it has a cleaner user interface and generally leaves Windows for dead. It is a base model or flavor of Linux and to be sure is no heavyweight in the Nix stakes but for a desktop it leaves Windows for dead and if it was to ever have been released as a direct competition to Windows I'm sure that it would have made the Accountants eyes at MS smart quite a lot.

This is the first flavor of Linux that I've ever seen that is a direct threat to Windows so I can now see why MS was so intent on destroying it and where willing to spend so much money in the process.

Now I'm going to make install copies of Corel Paint 9 and Word Perfect 9 that have been ported for Linux and go about installing them just to have a play but the Open Office version that came with the Corel Linux is quite capable of reading any MS file that has been created I've opened word documents from the earliest version of word that was available to the latest from 2003 Office Pro all with out a single error creeping in and that goes for all the other applications that come with Open Office which is to be expected. I'm just wondering how the Corel Flagship products will run when ported to Linux it should prove interesting. :D

Col ]:)

by jaqui

photopaint 9 for linux won't run on a kernel newer than 2.4
I would assume the same for corel office 9.

the major issue the linux community had with corl linux was that it is actually an extremely bloated version of linux, the kernel and system software resource requirements are huge.

corel uses the fonttastic 2000 font server, rather then the standard xfs.
the "port" of thier products uses wine, it doesn't run natively in linux.

reguardless of that, I actually like and was impressed with corel's photopaint for linux.
it actually looks better in linux than in windows.
( I have compared )
the colour dithering in linux gives corel's products a much better look.

by hal 9000

But for ease of use it leaves even Windows for dead. This was thrown at a 200 MMX with 64 MEG of Ram and a 1.2 GIG HDD and was so easy to install just alter the boot process in BIOS as the M'Board is that old and put the CD in the drive and walk away.

This one is defiantly aimed at the desktop though and is very much a light weigh one but it is so easy to install and use that it makes Windows XP look hard. :^O

I could load this on my mothers computer and not have a worry that she could use the inbuilt applications no matter just how really bad the OS actually is. For ease of install and User Friendliness it just leaves everything in the shade. As this is an old ISO copy I'm betting it is the old kernel as I haven't even looked yet it's just sort of sitting off to one side while I do other work and I play with it when the Windows Boxes don't require my attention.

Lousy set of Screen Savers and pretty much very little added in to the basic install in what I would be expecting for a proper Nix install but the Splash Screen on install & boot up look nice and would make it an easy choice for many non technical people out there. I know it's more "Eye Candy" that is really necessary but it is a great entry level Nix with no network or other driver problems that I've yet noticed.

About the only thing is that the monitor is way too small and the defaults set way to high to easily read but if that is the biggest problem things will be easy. :D

Of course the down side is that you are logging in as Root and user profiles are nonexistent but it configures the Networking protocols and everything without an ounce of problems unlike the much more powerful Big Brother Debian. Really if this had of been developed it would have been a Windows killer as it is even easier to use than Windows itself.

Col ]:)

by jaqui

accountants can run an accounting business...maybe.
but not any other business, the decisions required do not make sence in accounting terms, so an accountant will always destroy a non accounting business.

by raven2

Yes, accountants are the bain of existance. However, it has been my experience that if marketers are running a company, they are selling things that do not exist. If engineers are running the company they make great products but no one ever hears about them; if an entrepreneur is running a company, it is trying to do 6 things that will never get completed. If you have a MBA, you get the latest fad management trend, with no leadership. With accountants you see the profits spike as they sell off the assets to "boost the bottom line" and "enhance shareholder profits", then it craters. There is no replacement for good forward thinking management. Let me know when you find some.

by simplyshaman

admiral.. while it's true that microsoft products are very hackable. think of it like this, is it that it's hackable.. or is it that because microsoft does NOT share it's source code like unix and the linux projects, that hackers want the challenge of hacking something that's not easily hackable in the sense of given source code. you gotta think with the mind of a hacker in this industry. (why go for the easy hack when i can go for the challenge?)

by sdbett

Angus,

I understand that sytems (And people that deal with them) crash. There is also the supplied hardware issue. As a builder of "Mosheens" I am constantly buggd with DVDDo this-do-that" DVD drives that don't recognise common disks. The sups say "Have you the latest drivers? DOH! The drivers come with the hardware and so-on etc.

What is not happening is some form of standard.

I also understand that "Numbs" who own machines wouldn't know where to start to (1) Protect (2)Service their software (3) etc. etc.

There is very little dif between the various OS types. What people need to learn ------- Is about computers as theytend to do with their cars (Differance being is that numbs in cars kill people, numbs with systems kill their systems).

Finally, why when I try to correct spelling and grammardoes this flaming site deduct letters from my words?(GRRRRRRRRR).

by hal 9000

I used to work with systems that held peoples life in their grubby little Silicon circuits. At the time I was only designing Race Cars and generally speaking it would only be a driver and maybe a few spectators killed if it suffered a catastrophic failure. But today everything is controlled by computers just try going to your local hospital and gaining access to your medical records you'll most likely find you are reading the stored information on a monitor and there is no paper copy or even if there is a paper copy it isn't easily available.

So unless these systems work perfectly and never allow a fault to occur in the data that they retrieve peoples lives are in the hands of the IT people who keep these things running and they do control peoples ability to live or die. Just think on that for a little while I will not even consider the latest medical advances of allowing unskilled surgeons to perform operations under the supervision of someone else half a world away again by Silicon controlled circuitry that pushes both Video & audio signals to each of the people involved.

Now the question is have the Microprocessor controlled pieces of hardware really had enough time to mature into a stable platform to allow this to occur?

While you might say yes when you are perfectly healthy sitting in your office would you say the same thing if your life was depending upon this technology on a Windows Driven product?

I know I wouldn't and I don't even trust the Windows Embedded pieces of hardware available as I've seen the same test performed with similar machines and different results achieved one with Embedded Windows XP showed the a perfectly all right person and the Linux Embedded one showed someone about to die from an infected Gall Bladder about to rupture. Both of these tests where performed within 20 minutes of each other and as a result the Windows Embedded Ultra Sound Machines are no longer considered as reliable while the Linux ones are. And just to top it all of the people responsible for repairing these things have no idea at all about anything IT they just follow a set test procedure and if it passes these tests it's working OK as the manual say so. In one instance I saw a machine repaired and pass every test and then the transducers didn't work as the tech didn't actually physically test these it was done by the test procedure which only sent a signal to them and didn't rely on a reflected response to pass the transducers.

Just an observation from when I worked Medical equipment. ;)

And being Embedded XP that wasn't so long ago. :D

Col ]:)

by apotheon

There's probably more BSD ancestry behind Solaris and HP-UX these days than AT&T code, but BSD isn't technically a UNIX. The only reason for that, though, is the fact that UNIX (all-caps) is a trademarked term, and companies like Sun and HP have to license the name to use it.

by jmgarvin

However, Free/Open BSD seem to "feel" so much like real Unix that most people would be hard pressed to find a difference...

Don't tell Mr. Whipple! ;-)

by hal 9000

Just how many of todays IT people would even know the Source Code if it bit them on the ASS? Most have come through the IT Schools and are taught how to keep a system running where as Old Farts like Me and most likely you as well had to know how to program and read code the kids today don't have the luxury of this so if you where to push MS Windows Source code under their noses they most likely would think that it was nothing more than a document that stuffed up when sent to the printer and as a result you got a bunch of rubbish on the pages. They most likely would telly you to shred then and go and reprint them and if it came out that way again they would come and fix the system so it printed right. :)

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

We had a "Failed Engineer" run the place and he did a great job, we had an excellent product that was second to none and it was being used to set the benchmark for costs and what the Industry could charge for a product not what it was worth. While our products did offer value for money a lot of the opposition stuff didn't and there was even one place who where nothing but thieves who brought directly and sold door to door at such an inflated price it wasn't funny.

Eventually we had to take action against them because they where using a Brand name very similar to ours and using our good name to take down non informed customers who would be ringing us for service.

What you need at any organization is a good mix where the designers design the product, the manufacturing Department makes the goods the Marketing department advertises the goods and the Accounting Department minimizes the taxable income of the company. The problems really start when the lines between these different sections of the organization start getting blurred.

Today that is what has happened as the "Bottom Line" is all that is important and the time frames are from one AGM to the NEXT so they are only thinking in 12 month cycles for the share holders benefit in the short term and there is no long term program in place. When this happens that is always the beginning of the end for any company and while they may linger on for quite a while they are nothing but a spent force selling rubbish as they can no longer see the big picture and continue to produce the quality range of products that originally got them to the Market Leader position that they once where.

One of the places where I worked had a record of 1,600 in 1 month generally we ran around selling 1,200 per month and this was in the days before PC's so I'm guessing that you can imagine the money involved. ;)

Now after an accountant was brought in to run the company they no longer exist. The first thing that was done was to reduce the Tech as they didn't bring in sales. :D

And after the Techs had been fired the sales dropped dramatically so more staff had to be laid off to cut costs and the cycle continued to spiral down. Just because the Techs didn't have their names on the sales dockets they mustn't have been involved in sales but the majority of the sales generated where at the recommendations of the Techs who them passed the customers onto the sales staff with exactly what was required and the sale was already completed it only needed the paper work filled in.

Col ]:)

by johns_revelation

Lets see Unix came out sometime in '69 security was a huge issue then...Physical Security. Computer security wasn't even a beginning thought. Maybe keeping your punch cards in the right place. So basically from it's roots Unix was created WITHOUT security in mind. They tried to patch things up over the years but people seem to continue to get root kitted regularly. With all those text based files smattered all over the disk and an editor and a little help from SUID you can pretty much do whatever you want with the Nx's.

You got your rings mixed up sounds like the last ring architecture you looked at was either Windows 95 or NT 4. I remember when Windows 95 came out all the IBM OS2 or whatever crybabies said 95 was unstable and would crash all the time because of the RING issue you are speaking about. But the last thing I remember that was able to hook into the kernel (Ring O) like you are talking about was the video drivers in NT 4.

So it sounds like you are a little misinformed about Ring issues in Windows 2K's and XP

by danlm

As a programmer, and not as a tech. I have to admit that I moan and groan about windows. But, I will freely admit. That I like windows. I also moan and groan about my car. I have FreeBSD installed on my file server, and used AIX on the job for various functions.
I use windows for my desktop, and actualy do alot of coding directly to my freebsd box from here over the network. I like unix because for what I am using it for, nothing else is running. I like the idea that I can configure it so only what I want to run, is running. I don't want to use windows for those tasks, just because I want all my resources on those machines dedicated to those tasks. I doubt seriously I could configure windows to do that.
But, from a desk top environment with regard to all the tools i have used. Windows, hands down. I see it becomeing bloated, but that is due to my fault of wanting to install more and more on it to assist in my daily activities. outlook, toad, oracle reports, explorer, viso, and the list goes on and on. All of those products I just listed are bloated in themselves, and just pile onto an os that is designed to fit as many needs as possible. But, it does allow for me to use those tools. And I require those tools to get my job done. So, all things said and done. Windows does offer a very nice desk top environment for someone in my position. And I do like it.
I just look at things this way. Decide what you like about a product, and use it. What you don't like, don't use(don't install). And if need be, uninstall it.

Dan

by deadly ernest

not allowed to do that in a good political discussion. Much of what you say is true. I have similar type issues and responses. However, I am getting extremely pissed with MS due to the activation system crap and all the bloat within the OS itself.

I am about to try Mandrake Linux with WINE and see how ell that will run all my MS based apps - current feed back is that it should be better - will have to suck it and see. Got everything ready to rebuild the system with a new harddrive, just haven't been motivated to do it for the last 5 weeks.

by hal 9000

Been playing Wet Nurse to so many Windows Boxes you can't be bothered dragging yourself to doing it yet as you haven't had the time available?

Col ]:)

by jaqui

crosover office professional.
it is a more advanced version of wine.

by tmcclure

I've been reading through some of the replys. Thanks for the laughs everyone. I personally think Ford makes a better truck. After all mine has a 175k on it and I expect to make it to 200k. Of course it just also may have to do with the fact that I get an oil change every 3000 miles. But thats my opinion.

by deadly ernest

In the last 35 years I have had many cars including two Toyotas that have each run over 900,000 kms without any major issues beyond expected maintenance. Local accident recently answered the big Aussie question of "Which is safer a Ford Ute or a Holden ute?" Answer was clear in an accident where a new Holden ute went head first into a new Ford ute on the highway at a combined speed of near 200 km per hour - both were totaled and everyone went to the morgue. Clearly no advantage by either brand.

by hal 9000

You know that the air bags killed them in that collision don't you?

Give me a stock standard 65 VW Beetle any day of the week factory fresh and you'll find that is one of the most reliable cars ever unless of course it came from my factory in which case it will drink more fuel than a 747 on takeoff, be as rough as guts to drive around in, set off the new vehicle car alarms at 100 feet and generally be fun to drive although at 8 Miles per Gallon it is a tad expensive to drive. :(

But they are fun to drive. I had one guy with a 5 Lt Chevy thinking that the speedio in the VW was a Tacho and even when I stopped the car and allowed him to actually look and see the speedio cable running to the front left hand wheel he still didn't believe it. He muttered something about "A Freak of Nature." :D

But from a survivability point of view an early 70's Mercedes is about the best on the road and one of the cheapest to keep on the road provided you electrify the bonnet emblem to electrocute children who try to steal them. :^O

Col ]:)

by cfwags1

You can update BIOS, DRIVERS, Hardware, Software, or whatever else you like, but the simple fact that OS's in general are trying to do to much. Half of programing going into Windows don't even qualify as functions of an OS, but rather annoying memory/cpu eating monsters with bugs to boot. As much money is spent trying to do R&D of Windows, 10x that cost in both dollars and other resources goes into keeping it up, keep it running, and secure. If the OS didn't copy and/or
steal software developed by the little guys, then maybe they could get a piece of the money pie. So the real question is this a plus or minus for keeping the dollars and economy successful for the technology sector.

by apotheon

There's more owed to the Berkeley Software Distribution than any other single source in modern unices. It has been theorized at great length that the only reasons *BSD doesn't carry the UNIX name are related to lack of interest in spending money on the certification and licensing, and perhaps some lingering annoyance over AT&T's suit over supposed improper use of its code in BSD unix back in the day.

In other words, *BSD [b]is[/b] "real" Unix. It's just not trademarked UNIX.

by jamesrl

A word or pronunciation that distinguishes people of one group or class from those of another.

A word or phrase identified with a particular group or cause; a catchword.
A commonplace saying or idea.
A custom or practice that betrays one as an outsider.

In alt.folklore.urban, the interchanging of Austria and Australia is a shibboleth. You hear the newbies howl that someone is confused, and you hear the hats(long timers) suggest that they read the FAQ and lurk before posting. Cow-orker, and misplet are two other AFU examples.

Do we have any Tech Republic shibboleths?

James

by raven2

I don't know how your system works, but on this side US it is widely known that SUVs or uts as you call them are not repeat not built to passenger car safety standards. They are classed as trucks and therefor have lower safety engineering standards. We have a lot of fools who think bigger is better, not realizing that chances of being injured in the standard SUV is 2 to 3 times greater than the standard sedan. And your chances of killing someone else is 4 times greater. I see many of these reality challenged folks who have fancy SUVs that have never even been on a dirt road let alone a place where the "offroad" capability is needed. Marketing is amazing.

by deadly ernest

In Australia a ute (utility) it based on the passenger vehicles and look like they have been cut off just behind the front seat and a molded tray attached. SUVs are 4WD passenger vehicles like large covered jeeps. We also have light truck utes which are based on the 1 tonne vehicle body with a cab and tray arrangement - similar to what you see in the USA movies where the teen gets his truck and his mates hop in the back.

Utes are built to the same standard as the passenger vehicles as 85% of the vehicle is the same. SUVs are also built to a passenger standard as they are seen as passenger vehicles. The light trucks are different standards as they are commercial vehicels.

The biggest problem we have here re vehicles is the car designers think you are supposed to goe to sleep at the wheel and design the general passenger sedans so that you are laying down in the driver's seat and not sitting up. Add in their desire to make all cars street racers and have a low ground clearance and you end up with cars where the seat is below your knee when standing beside it. This results in a lot of people bying SUVs and vans (like the Tarago) as they are the only passenger comfortable vehicles where you don't damage your back getting in or out, as the seat is at the same height as most peoples bums. Also they have enough head room that you can sit uproght in the driver's seat without bashing your head against the roof, unlike most modern sedans - and no I am not tall, only 5 foot 9 inches.

by raven2

Yes, we have street racer issue here. Not only in the design from the factory, but a serious aftermarket push. Market capitalism at work, creating demand for idiotic things. The US has always had its car enthusiast fringe group, as evidenced by NASCAR, and the whole "hotrod" craze.

But I really miss the point of spinning hub caps, they keep spinning while you stop at a light or stop sign, and 300 hp engines in vehicles that cannot legally go more than 70 mph, (110 kph). If you give someone a car that can go 150 mph (250 kph), at some point they will want to try it out. Usually when their wits are already slightly addled.

I guess I have become an old fuddy duddy, but there seem to be more fools running around than ever before. (And then we elect some to high public office.)

As the fellow said, "Cheer up things could be worse." Worth a try, I guess.

For a personal car I am pushing around a 1982 Mercedes 300TD with 274,000 miles (440,000 kilks) on the clock. I figure that is about as safe a vehicle as is out there.

by hal 9000

When I was in Melbourne visiting some relatives they all owned "Turack Tractors" Range Rovers and this one person who drove me somewhere turned into their drive way stopped put it in 4 WD and drove up the concrete drive way. When I asked why it was in 4WD I was told that the owners manual said to place it in 4WD when ever it was taken "Off Road." :)

But Utes here are a little different to what the light trucks are in the states typically they are on a sedan floor pan but are only a half cab with a storage area in the back replacing the rear seats and boot. See the following for pictures

http://www.webwombat.com.au/motoring/news_reports/xrt_utes.htm

Col ]:)

by apotheon

Yeah, we've got a few around here. I recommend you read the FAQ and lurk a while.

Oh, sorry, no. I mean: One is the way people keep using "IT Professional" to mean "Windows User". That one always makes me chuckle.

Shibboleth is one of my favorite words, and has been for years. I don't get much opportunity to trot it out, though.

by hal 9000

I used to work as a Designer once and they only do as they are told by the Accountants and Legal Who#es. ;)

Actually we need to shoot the Accountants then the Solicitors and leave the designers to design. When I first escaped Uni I was asked to work for GM and I spent 3.5 days there. For the first 3 days we where given a blank sheet of paper and allowed to go wild in a new design and on the forth day we had an accountant explain to us why these couldn't be built. I only lasted till lunch on the 4th day before walking out in disgust.

I them spent a few years working for a small design house in Germany known to a few people as Porsche and worked on the Paris Dakar car the 959 but I did see a 911 that exceeded the 1996 emission levels for the US that was shipped over there and touted as the way of the future when all the major makers where claiming that these levels couldn't be reached.

This worked wonderfully until someone looked under the car and saw that it didn't have a Catalytic Converter so it was rejected. If designers are allowed to design a lot of the unnecessary items wouldn't be needed on the cars that are brought in by Government Regulation the Catalytic Converter is a prime example as when this was added to that Porsche the emission levels went up but some Bureaucrat said that they must be good so we are stuck with them. :(

Personally my car of choice is a 1972 Mercedes 250 CE I don't want the kids in the back seat any more as they are now old enough and have moved out of home but it has everything that the new cars have as standard equipment expect air bags and it's a bloody side more solid and far safer to drive than any or the recycled pet food containers that are the current crop of new cars. It has EFI as standard true 4 wheel independent suspension, 4 wheel disk brakes, 4 speed auto and lots of other things that would make it a sports car if it wasn't so overweight. I do like the side intrusion bars in the doors and rear panels I do like the fact that you can hit or be hit by something big like a truck and walk away with only minor injuries but I didn't like the standard front seats as they where not high back ones so I fitted Recaros so if I'm again struck in the rear by a fully loaded 10 ton truck the driver and any other front seat passenger don't suffer neck injuries. In a 1976 280 SE which this happened to the front seats are bent back-wards with the seat frames twisted the floor pan twisted to the firewall but all the doors open and close.

To me that is how a car should be made so you can walk away after a collision. A good case of designers doing their thing without being adversely affected by the Accountants and Solicitors. :D

Col ]:)

by hellums

I never said XP had blue screen of death problems. It's a legacy term from an operating system you're probably too young to have ever used. That's why some of you think it's wrong to "bash" Microsoft, because you don't have the history with them that the rest of us do. We lived through DOS, Windows 3.1, Windows 98, Windows NT, Windows ME... when you've lived through all of those and we have shared experience, we can talk. My point with Firefox isn't that they invented tabs or that it's a new idea, just that it's a prominent feature in the first mainstream browser that's posed any competition whatsoever for IE, and ONLY that will lead to IE making the same move. If you think Opera is mainstream, you need to stop playing RPGs and see what people in the real world are doing with computers.

by hellums

Sounds like you're not very good at Linux or Unix administration. There are lots of training courses and books out there. 10:1 or 25:1 ratio of Windows to Unix/Linux crashes in my experience, which dates back to the late 80s. And when I have to patch a Unix app, I never had to reboot, unless it was related to networking or hardware.

by apotheon

You shouldn't have to reboot for networking, either. Just restart networking.

# /etc/init.d/network[ing] restart

Voila.