Why do IT people really bash Windows?
This is page 7 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 7 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by raven2
Style vs substance, maybe this is a defining issue of our post-modern world. In my concept of a rational world, good engineering, good design, and common sense seem to go hand in hand.
But I have a nagging fear that some place in the not too distant past we have taken a turn down a road that has taken us to an irrational world. Thinking about it, maybe the not so distant past. The movies "Dr Strangelove", and "Clockwork Orange" as well as George Orwell's book "1984" all seem to have too much "reality". I must not be taking the correct meds, maybe I can find a good deal in some of my emails.
We should spin this discussion off. Maybe we could develop a "Designs for Modern Living" consultancy business, and get to tell folks how to put the pieces together.
by hal 9000
Life program to run on their PC's to tell them what and how to think today? :^O
Anyone without one of these units built by us complete with all our software could then be arrested for failing to do the best possible for themselves as we decide. That of course would be the beginning of the Thought Police. I'd better stop it there or I might give someone some ideas and they could take me seriously and make us all live according to their wishes. :(
Col ]:)
The safest vehicle that i have seen any specs on is not readily available as a standard street version - the Aust Army Perentie series Tactical Battlefield Vehicle. This is based on the long wheel base Landrover, can survive fairly high drops and most evrsions come with kevlar body panels - take that you road rage bugger, I am bullet proof.
Seriously the thing is designed to allow the people inside to live through land mines, shells beside it and driving off low cliffs, can't get much safer than that.
what I find so interesting about this whole 'street racer' issue is that more and more people are moving to 4WD SUVs simply for the basic sitting position and ease of entrance and exit. This trend is gettting so big that people ain the low slung street racers are bitching about not being able to see over or around the SUVs and some people are talking about legislating to keep them out of the city. Talk about the tail wagging the dog. Don't they realise that the next option would be the even bigger people movers, and that would make it worse for the low slung fools.
Found another advantage of being in a SUV the otherday. I drive a Nissan X-Trail, one of the smaller SUVs so it is not as high up as most. A very low slung sedan pulled up beside me at the lights, so low that I would have had to reach down to knock on the roof of the car if I stuck my hand out the window; I looked down and could see a rather good looking young lady in a skimpy bikini reclining in the passenger seat smiling up at me, any higher and the roof would have obstructed the view, much lower and I doubt I would have seen her at all.
by joeaaa22
I was with you at the beginning of this rant. The first four sentences were all on the mark. But then you went off into Never Never Land. I quote "in fact if the OS crashes then it's your fault not the OS" as the point when you completely lost the track and derailed the train. This statement is valid for just about every OS existence; from CP/M through DOS and *NIX and VM and MVS and a whole plethora of options. However, it does not hold water when referring to any version of MS-Windows above WfW 3.11. These OS options have in them bugs so large and so old that a strong breeze could crash them. No amount of SysAdmin or NetAdmin effort will curtail this flood of rebooting.
Your analogy of the leaded and unleaded petrol is good but not accurate. Yes, we should all be moving into a brighter, greater future and the evolution of computing has been one that has followed this path, for the most part [see bigass rant at end of post]. But computers aren't cars and the OS isn't petrol. In your analogy the petrol for computers is the electricity that feeds them. The OS is more along the lines of the engine, transmission and steering. The driver is the app, but this is getting to deep. The bottom line is that you should not expect your engine or transmission or steering to just break down completely for no other reason that you turned on the turn-signal. If the manufacturer of the engine/transmission/steering told you to upgrade the spark plugs to make your car faster and safer you would do it. Then when you come to find that the new spark plugs destroy the whole breaking system and give you absolutely no indication of the problem you would not be pleased with the manufacturer who trashed your car because you followed their instructions and warnings to the letter. Face it, MS Windows >= Win95 are a black box of code that has so many sinkholes and traps and just some plan old ordinary "This $#!^ doesn't work."
The real problem that any _true_ techie has with WinXX is the fact that not only does it suck, the company that so proudly presented WinNT as being weeks ahead of schedule after slipping said schedule for 3 years and has had Longhorn. no, wait; Windows Vista in the "It'll be here real soon now" mode for how long now? A true techie is one who gets the job done. Give me a problem and an assortment of tools and I will fix said problem. It might not be the prettiest or the most efficient solution, but it will work. In order to do this kind of work a techie needs tools that he knows will work. They will do the job they were put in place to do (notice I did not say "intended" as we all have bootstrapped our way to a fix, Bailing wire and bubblegum and I'm a frelling McGuyver. But that wire has to be the same every time. Yes, maybe some nicks and bends but it's still useful. The bubblegum can be Hubba Bubba Max Sour Double Berry or any of the plain gums. The gum has to stick. If you tell me that I have to chew the gum with only my left molars in order to fix something and, when I do as directed and place the left-only-chewed gum into place whatever the thing was supposed to do now doesn't do it.
More clearly: Windows are the hammer of the tool kit. You need it done and it's stuck, call on the hammer to bust it loose, So you got your hammer and start a-bustin' but the hammer head falls off. Or the handle cracks in two. Or the hammer head splits apart. You've done all the checking and maintaining of your hammer that can possibly be humanly done. And it still cracks up. It was made to crack. It's been built for over a decade with this flaw in it. The new versions come out and are bigger and faster and prettier but they still split apart on your hands.
A techie needs tools that will work. Tools that will work without thinking about how to keep said tool from splitting (as it was specifically build to do by the manufacture). He uses tools that work which never give him a second thought. They work. Period. When I, as a seasoned techie of some 23+ years in the field, make slightly disparaging remarks to my Mac OS X friends or those still cranking away in the world of the Big Iron on MVS, these are made in jest just as their snigletts at my Linux-ness are. But we respect the others tool. We know that it can do a lot of things our tools can't do. We also know that there are a lot of things that our tool can do that theirs can't. We even understand where we can overlap and make something more than the sum of it's parts. None of this is true for any version of an MS operating system since DOS 3.3, though DOS 5 would do in a pinch.
If you had a tool that was broken and unable to do it's job (no OS should EVER, EVER be rebooted for any reason other than a kernel upgrade. Again, Period!) how would you feel about it? You'd be making dumping it as fast as possible for a tool that worked. And if you were forced to work with this tool you'd be flaming the hell out of it as a frustration release, wouldn't you. You know it.
by larry brown
Hi Angus McLaren:
Here are some comments on your post.
>Why does everyone "bash" Windows?
It's funny that you phrase it "everyone." If "everyone" bashes it, it must be pretty bad in reality.
>but that is just pointless
On the contrary, bashing shoddy products is worthwhile. For example Consumer's Reports magazine has been doing us all a service for 80 years by doing exactly this.
>Anyone who claims to hate Microsoft Windows, >Linux, Mac OS or any other operating system is >not a true techie or network guru
You don't find many people bashing Linux or Mac. With those systems people tend to be outsiders, in which case they don't have much to say, or believers, in which case they don't bash.
I disagree with you here. I'd say that true techies and network gurus are more given to heated discussions about such issues than are casual users. A true techie is someone that has strong feelings on tech matters, leading to strong opinions.
>if the OS crashes then it's your fault
No OS should ever crash for any reason. If an OS crashes, it's crap. You have bought into the delusion that all of the Microsoft crashes you have ever experienced have been your fault because you missed something. Rethink your poor self image, all those crashes were Microsoft's fault, not yours.
>Why didn't you make sure that it was using the right drivers,
You assume that the OS is bug free and has no bugs that will cause it to crash unless you do something to it. That doesn't have to be true. An OS is just a computer program like any other, it can have bugs in it and crash all on its on just like any other program. What if the kernel code itself has bugs and so it crashes even without third party drivers? This has often been the case with Windows.
>Any OS crashes for a reason
It crashes because it has bugs.
> Compatability is there for a very good reason, why support something that is old
Why advertise that your OS supports something that is old when it will crash if you actually try to use it that way? Malicious greed?
I'll admit that Windows bashing is not as black and white as us haters would make it out to be, but there's plenty of reasons to hate Microsoft and Windows.
In my case I'm deeply venemous, but it mostly goes back to the DOS and Windows 3.1 days. I'll admit that starting at Win95 and foward Microsoft's OSes were waaaaaaaay better than those older days. Especially starting at Win2000 and continuing with WinXP, even someone as bitterly cynical as myself must admit, it just doesn't crash anymore. Just explain to me how Microsoft was able to make the entire world wait 15 years until they started all over and got it right this time.
IT people bash Windows because IT people have experience on other systems and know that good software is not only possible, it should be a given if you pay money for it. Non-IT people have never known anything other than the garbage that Microsoft shovels out. For them, all software has problems, and crashes are just a nuisance price that you have to pay in order to play. Be honest with yourself: have you ever had real experience on anything other than Microsoft DOS or Microsoft Windows? If not, you're in the matrix. You don't know what reality is because you've never seen anything other than your own Microsoft experience. In my case (yes, I'm an IT guy), I have experience on lots of different systems, including: Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC) PDP-11, ***DEC VAX/VMS, ***Sperry-Univac, Cray OS, ***ten or more flavors of UNIX, Control Data Corporation (CDC) CYBER, ***Data General, Perkin-Elmer, Pyramid, IBM RT/PC, TRS-80 models III, IV, and 100, Radio Shack Color Computer, Commodore 64, Vic-20 and ***Amiga, Apple II (e, +, and c), Timex/Sinclair ZX-80, and, of course, all Microsoft operating systems since MS-DOS 3.1. Particularly nice systems I have marked above with asterisks. Does this convince you that I know something about using an operating system? Trust me when I say....Microsoft is crap.
All of the systems that I mentioned are unique in their own way. Some are really weird, like UNIX and Univac. And yet, when you learn them, you get sucked into the mindset of the designers and you realize, this thing is wonderful. It's beautiful. It's a world of its own and it has depth, and power, and speed, it's breathtaking! It's art! You become a believer and you stand up to defend this truly wonderful technology. Others are plush and deluxe, like VMS, Data General, and Amiga. Using these is a true pleasure, like enjoying a Rolls-Royce. Microsoft isn't like that. That's why you see that vehemence from UNIX believers. UNIX is truly wonderful in so many ways, it inspires loyalty and allegience. No one ever said any of that stuff about Microsoft.
Let me try to give you some examples:
In 1982 when the IBM-PC was introduced with MS-DOS 1.0, we were already used to using software light years ahead of that. The VAX computer running the VMS operating system that I used in college is like the space shuttle. It's an outstanding system studded with elaborate bells and whistles. It runs jobs while I'm asleep. A single computer handles dozens of students working on it simultaneously (that's called multi-user, you don't understand that because Microsoft still doesn't do it). Not only that, but I myself, sitting at a terminal, can fire jobs off into the background so that while the computer is busy running them I can do something else (that's called multi-tasking. You heard a lot about that from 1982 (DOS 1.0) until 2000 (Win 2000), but you didn't understand it because you couldn't do it really until then.) And the VAX does all that and it never crashes. It doesn't crash because it's quality software. No software should ever crash, especially the OS. Software that crashes is crap, pure and simple. An OS that crashes is pure crap. If VMS is like the space shuttle, MS-DOS 1.0 is like a stone wheel with no axel that's flat on one side. It's primitive beyond belief, and not only that, it constantly crashes because it's riddled with bugs. MS-DOS 1.0 doesn't even support a directory structure. Everything is stored in the root folder. This system set the computing world back easily ten or more years. Incidentally, VMS was written by Dave Cutler, whom Microsoft later hired to write Windows NT when they decided to start from square one and do a respectable job.
In 1985 I was using a Commodore Amiga. This was a stupendous, dumbfounding system. It multi-tasked. It invented multi-media computing. It had stellar sound and music capabilities. It had a beautiful windowing GUI operating system. It could read to me in a synthesized voice any text. A year or two later I needed a laptop and bought a DOS machine. Even my wife, a casual user, was shocked at how primitive that DOS system was. No GUI, no multi-tasking, no graphics, no color, no sound, no music, no speech. Can you understand why someone like me who in 1985 is used to using something slightly more advanced than Windows 2000 would hate Microsoft when they gave me a system like that? And to add great insult to fatal injury, it didn't even work! It crashed all the time. I'm used to a beautiful GUI system with all these artful, well planned and executed bells and whistles, and Microsoft gives me something that is hamstrung at almost every turn by the old 64K barrier.
The 64K barrier was broken by Commodore with the Commodore 128 around 1981, and shattered by advanced systems based on the Motorola 68000 processor like the Commodore Amiga, Atari 512ST, and Apple Macintosh around 1985. And yet Microsoft software was limited by the 64K barrier in many ways up until Win2000 and WinXP. If you never realized that, it's because you are not a power user. You're ignorant and that's why you don't bash Windows. You may think "What 64K barrier? The IBM-PC was never limited by that, it supported 1MB of RAM right at its introduction." That's true, but did you realize that the MS-DOS text editor "EDIT" was limited to text files no larger than 64K? Perhaps you remember running "out of memory" on a Windows 3.1 system that had 4MB of RAM. Why? Because the three Windows 3.1 heaps were limited to 64K each, and that was easily filled. Windows 95 and Windows 98 continued to be limited by this ridiculous heap limitation. If you have ever written SQL queries in Microsoft Access, a supposedly modern database system, you can get "query too complex." Why? Because the SQL query that you write is forced to compile into a 64K segment. If it's larger than that, Microsoft Access can't handle it. THAT MAKES ME ANGRY! Why am I limited in any way in 2003 by a ridiculous barrier that was shattered 18 years ago? Remember all of that utterly ridiculous noise about fitting drivers into the 64K "high memory area" (HMA) and using the "upper memory blocks" (UMBs) and "expanded memory" and "extended memory" and "HIMEM.SYS" and Memmanger? All of that was obscenely primitive, insane, and utter torture for those of us who had to work on it daily.
Windows did not catch up in capability to that Amiga for many years something around Win98 it started to get there maybe. That's a thirteen year gap! Those hobbyists, who are today's IT guys, had an Amiga and they knew what a good OS looked like. Those are the guys who are bashing Windows. So they answer to the thread's question "Why do IT guys bash windows," is because they know Windows is lousy because they've seen much better, and long ago.
Microsoft Windows systems before Windows 2000 suffered from severe thrashing of the hard disk. Do you know what that means? If not, do you begin to see how you are not qualified to enter a debate on operating systems? Disk thrashing is a problem that was added to college courses on operating systems around 1965. It happens when you page virtual memory to the hard disk and you don't write your code carefully enough, the OS has too little intelligence to keep from constantly reading and writing to the disk, it never stops. When it does this you get severe performance degradation. Instead you have to write smarter code so that this doesn't happen. Surprise, ****25 years later**** Microsoft introduces Windows 3.1, 95, and 98, all of which suffered from disk thrashing. Microsoft's solution is what....write better software? No, simply upgrade your computer from a 66Mhz processor to something much faster, like 1Ghz. Problem solved: crap software runs acceptably.
No OS should ever leak memory. Microsoft OSes are riddled with memory leaks.
No OS should trigger a general protection fault (GPF). Yet Microsoft OSes get that all the time.
No OS should ever crash. In Windows 3.1 crashing was an hourly occurance.
Remember the MS-DOS function "continue, abort, retry?" That never worked. From DOS 1.0 to DOS 6.0, that never worked.
This is not even touching on the malice of Microsoft. Among countless examples: early Microsoft OSes would get "unrecoverable application errors" (UAE). That meant the OS had crashed. Microsoft then released a new version and convinced the world to upgrade by saying that this severe problem had been completely eliminated. Yes, because Microsoft renamed the UAE to GPF, therefore it's true we never again saw any UAEs. The problem continued just as before, only with Microsoft having bilked us of millions or billions of dollars, not counting the lost time and energy spent in upgrading and making it all sort of work again. That's malice.
Just now while writing this using the simple software application "Notepad" on Microsoft's most advanced OS (Win XP), I suffered a glitch where the cursor got lost and notepad started garbling lines of text. They can't even get Notepad right!
For an IT guy, using any Microsoft OS before Win95 was like being used to driving a reliable japanese car like a CAMRY and suddenly the entire world is seduced with a car of the quality of a Studebaker.
At the introduction of Microsoft Windows 95, Bill Gates made this remark to the audience from the stage:
"We don't want people to think that the introduction of Windows 95 is going to escalate the competition between Microsoft and Apple. In fact in some ways it's driving us closer together. For instance, before Windows 95, only Apple thought that Windows 3.1 was a lousy operating system. Now, we agree with them: Windows 3.1 is a lousy operating system." Bill had no problem admitting this to the world because it was no secret. Windows 3.1 was a bad joke and anyone who knew anything about computers or software knew that. Plus it's in Bill's best interest to educate you that what you are using is crap, just as long as he also convinces you that he's got it all solved with this next version and if you just give him your money you will arrive at computing Utopia.
Don't think that Microsoft hatred is simply historical. Microsoft's bully methods continue to present day. Here's a quote from a news article I saw just a few days ago (July 2005): "It's about intimidation pure and simple. Their [Microsoft's] actions in trying to prevent Dr. Lee from joining Google is clearly an illegal restraint of trade," said Nicole Wong, Google's associate general counsel." Intimidation, illegal activity, restraint of trade? I hate those things and the people that practice them, and you should too.
Some IT guys are not Microsoft bashers. I had a conversation the other day with an IT colleague as he was excitedly telling me all the wonderful things that Microsoft Windows XP Media Center edition was going to do for him. When he went on to talking about how XP would control the satellite receiver and other advanced functions, I flat out told him "That will never work. There's no chance that media center edition will do half of that stuff you just said." He gave me this argument: "What you do you mean it won't work? Microsoft wouldn't be selling it and advertising those functions if it didn't work." I punched up the Microsoft knowledge base at www.microsoft.com and searched for "media center edition" and "fails." It came with over 100 hits on various circumstances where media center edition did not work correctly.
I hate Microsoft because the other day I bought a new Dell PC for a client and it came completely choked with shovelware that I had to take time to uninstall and disable. Even then I still got pop-ups from this shovelware enticing me to log on to the web and upgrade to licensed versions. These included ominus advertisements like "your computer is vulnerable." Why is this all on there? Because Microsoft took over the world by, in part, inventing the model of shoveling software to consumers with a new PC, and shutting software vendors out of this game. In turn those software vendors sued for equal access, won lawsuits, and now Dell must honor requests from vendors to allow them to place their shovelware on the Dell desktop.
I hate Microsoft because they kill software vendors simply to keep them from getting market share, even if Microsoft isn't interested in that market. As related by former Microsoft power employee Marlin Eller in his book "Barbarians Led by Bill Gates," Microsoft introduced pen windows with handwriting analysis capabilities simply to shut down another OS vendor, a company called "GO." When the other OS died, Microsoft let pen windows die as well. It served its purpose. (Chapter 9, page 144). Read this and become a welcome member of Microsoft haters. This book is good, but even better is "Hard Drive" by James Wallace & Jim Erickson. Highly recommended.
I hate Microsoft because they don't care about quality software. The simply care about getting the money. They don't even want to write quality software because then where would be the incentive to upgrade next time? They shovel in piles of features so that when a prospective buyer compares the feature list of, say, Microsoft Word with Wordperfect, Microsoft has a much larger feature list. They know but don't care that lots of that feature list doesn't work well, or at all. The mystery is how they have gotten away with this outrageous strategy for so long. By any reasonable standard Microsoft should have been laughed out of existance starting with DOS 1.0 and following every single thing forward until Window 95.
I hate Microsoft because I was a professional Visual Basic 3.0 programmer and it was so difficult, or impossible, to get a good result when programming with that language that I looked like an idiot, and there was nothing I could do about it.
I hate Microsoft because I spent many months writing a commercial application with Visual Basic 6.0 and then Microsoft discontinued that language to introduce VB.net, forcing me to spend many months to completely rewrite my application. This would force many people out of business. FORTRAN, COBOL, and C aren't discontinued right? Those programs don't have to be rewritten. But give Microsoft control and they assasinate you.
I could go on and on and on. You see that I am quite bitter. You also see that I know what I am talking about. People don't bash Microsoft, and its software, because they are ignorant. They don't know that good software is possible. They've never used anything other than Microsoft. If the material I have covered in this article is new to you, I welcome you as you step out of the matrix and into reality. Just like in the movie, ignorance is much prettier. The truth in this case is very ugly.
By they way, Notepad continued to glitch on me so badly while writing this post that I switched to Wordpad.
by warhog73
by larry brown
Yes....I see that I'm a little late, but oh well, I'll recycle my diatribe and use it elsewhere.
Thanks for the reply man, I didn't think anyone was going to notice me at all!
Talk to you later ol' bean, ol' boy, ol' chump, ol' pal.
Lawrence
by neil higgins
by sadko301
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
GO ASSFUCK A MONKEY YOU STUPID NIGGER
by apotheon
by jdadams842
Bill Gates has no formal education in science or technology. No theoretical engineering, no physics, no computer, no software.
The winner of a newly created product like OS software however, is the best business plan. Gates formula rated new features (high added value) above quality. Someone, by fortune, will have the better plan. For instance, quality second, did not suceed for American auto manufactures, but apparently is best for software. IBM invested $2 billion on OS but failed because they had top quality. Additionally, when Gates reaches out to other hard science areas, he fails miserably, eg robotics, hardware, real time etc. His 'real time' software is a joke for another discussion.
btw I have 8 different computers at home and Windows OS sucks everytime.
'Quality second' is the best plan for a technically illiterate Bill Gates. It is also great job security for tech types because the science challenged Business educated love flushing lots of money down the drain on trash. The long term future of American business is sales and marketing only ... dumbing down. Cannot fight it. That's the trend. Eventually quality wins out in the end, just not in America building trash.
by larry brown
Hi jdadams842:
I can agree with a lot of what you said, but the key factor overriding all merchandise, over and above and before everything else, is price.
First off, you're wrong to say that Bill Gates has no formal training. Don't forget that he was a student of Harvard, of all places. You don't get in there without having a lot on the ball. Also, you don't spend two years there without getting a lot of great training.
I agree with you that Bill won, in part, by a good business plan, formal or otherwise. I also agree with you that he values features over quality, you're right on the mark with those statements. A good example is Word, which has a giant feature list, many of which don't work well, or at all. However, DOS didn't win market share by features, because DOS was feature poor right up to the end. DOS won market share largely on price, you got it seemingly free. You could have gotten something better, like CP/M or Xenix, or even DR-DOS, but you would have had to pay for it and history shows that the vast majority chose to live with the cheap and buggy over the expensive and capable.
Quality second did certainly succeed for the American auto brands. How else did they become the huge industries that they are today? You could have bought a 1970 Rolls-Royce or Mercedes-Benz instead of an Impala, but you would have had to pay more for it.
In the end we see that Bill Gates is smart, but we all know that already. He had the acumen to judge what was important to win, and he did it. Those of us who are "artists" hate his stuff because it's distasteful, but you can't argue against that he transformed the world, brought computing to the masses, and conquered the industry. Obviously he did a lot of things right, it's just that "excellence" is not part of his equation. Unlike other phenomenons where excellence is part of the equation, like: The Beatles, Micheal Jackson, Elvis, the Amiga, Star Wars....
by wordworker
>>A good example is Word, which has a giant feature list, many of which don't work well, or at all.<<
You know, Lawrence, I found in your "rants" a few interesting nuggets (and more than a fair share of misspelled words). But when I read this sentence, I had to laugh out loud at your -- ignorance? arrogance? Say bye-bye to your credibility.
Perhaps you should have been writing your rants in Word and used the spell-checking utility. That feature works, fer shur.
by choppit
by apotheon
The Word spell-check isn't so great at picking out the correct words, and its dictionary is absurdly limited. I don't like it much. In point of fact, I find that basically all spell-checks are suboptimal at least, but Word's is one of the less desirable.
Even worse is Word's grammar-checking. Worse yet is its help documentation. Still worse is its autocorrect, which is so contentious that I have to actually turn it off to get stuff formatted properly most of the time.
Word has quite a few features I'd say don't work well, and may have some that don't work at all: I haven't checked them all. Have you?
by wordworker
by apotheon
by wordworker
Because it was for years my job to research and learn and teach the application.
Edit since message max reached: Ah, but I do know what you know because you TELL THE WHOLE WORLD all the time how much you know.
by apotheon
No, this thread just couldn't be allowed to die. Somebody had to strap it to the table and have Igor raise it up into the thunderstorm.
"My grandfather's work was doo-doo!"
by larry brown
Hey Woodworker...thanks for replying. It's great to pick up this old thread. I like living in the past, it's one of my hobbies.
There is a lot of complimentary stuff in your post, you are too kind. You quote "rants," meaning that you don't actually consider my posts to be rants, you mention that at least some portion of my posts are interesting, you imply that I had credibility at one time, and you allow that I may be arrogant, just like Bill Gates :-).
I'll admit that I'm a lousy speller, and that yes, I should have used Word and its spell-checker. But don't completely knock my intelligence, I'm sure lots of other intelligent people are lousy spellers. George Lucas, for one, is very bad, according to "Skywalking: The Life and Films of George Lucas" by Dale Pollock.
Regarding the spell-checker working "fer shur," I can't agree with you on that. I remember back in the Word 95 days, that stupid spell checker would crash Word every time I tried it. And I never meant to try it, I would just sometimes accidentally click on the menu option, and then Word would crash and lose my work. Did that make me angry at Microsoft? You betcha.
Regarding other features working in Word, in spite of your self-professed in-depth knowledge of Word, you are living in the Matrix. If you try to defend that all features in Word work and work well, it is you, my friend, who loses your credibility, not that you ever had any. For example, the Corel Draw import filter is lousy. It's a Microsoft product and it can't understand all of the Corel file, and it makes lots of mistakes. For me, it's unuseable. The Word encapsulated postscript (EPS) import filter is also lousy, and largely unuseable for me. Word's capaility to link to external files and have those linked objects appear in the Word document is fraught with problems, for me it's unuseable.
Working in Word 95 was murder! I had to constantly fight with Word to get documents formatted the way I wanted. Lest you say I was "ignorant," take into consideration this: when I switched to Word 97, suddenly my documents started coming much easier. Did I suddenly get smarter? No, Microsoft put some effort into making Word 97 work better.
The "autocorrect" feature of Word, in years past, was a problem. For example, if I wanted to write a document using "IT" (for information technology), Word would always correct that to "it" or "It." Later they improved this feature to show you the little lightning bolt, and you could undo the correction and even tell it "don't correct this anymore." This is a trivial, yet annoying, example. Worse is when Word tries to autoformat my bulletted or numbered lists. This is still difficult to do and in years past it was murder.
Do these things make my angry at Microsoft? Yes! Do they cause me to justifiably trash Microsoft software? Yes!
Here's an odd thing. I find that when I enter a discussion like this with someone like you, who doesn't realize that good software is possible, and I point out specific examples like this in which Microsoft software is buggy, I get a curious reaction. I get "Oh yeah, I know that stuff doesn't work, but so what? That's out on the fringes of the app, it still largely works, and all software has bugs, so what's the big deal?" Is that your reaction? Or have you never tried those features that I mentioned?
Like I said in my original post, about Windows, most of my cynicism comes from earlier days. Word 95 was torture, but Word 97 was much better, I'll admit that stuff is getting better.
As for "ignorance," just let me do a quick search on the Microsoft knowledge base.....
Searching for "Wd2002 Stops" I get 30 hits including:
WD2002: Word Stops Responding When You Use CheckSpelling or GetSpellingSuggestions Methods
WD2002: Word Stops Responding When You Save Changes to a Mail Merge Document
WD2002: Error Message, Word Stops Responding When You Quit Session
WD2002: Word Stops Responding When You Click Refresh in Recipients Dialog Box
WD2002: Word Stops Responding When You Press the PAGE UP Key
WD2002: Word Stops Responding After You Close Document Created from Template
WD2002: Word Stops Responding If You Use Spelling Checker on Swedish Text
WD2002: Speech Recognition Stops Responding After You Delete a Word from the Speech Tools
WD2002: Word Stops Responding When You Save a Document in Rich Text Format
WD2002: Word Stops Responding After Undoing All Paste Actions
WD2002: Word Stops Responding or You Receive Error Message When Opening WordPerfect Document
Regarding the "fer shur" spell checker, "fer shur" it's buggy, yeah.
Search for "Word Spell" gets at 100 hits, including this gem:
WD98: Punctuation May Cause Word to Constantly Check Same Word
When you add punctuation to the end of a word that is not contained in either the main or custom dictionaries and then click Change All, the spelling checker will enter an infinite loop while spell checking the same word
So you see, any "ignorance" is not on my part.
Thanks for the chat and welcome as you come out of the Matrix.
by wordworker
Thanks for the response. I would have to say you've surpassed rant and moved up to bona fide diatribe on that one. You are sooooo smart!
But it's "word" worker, not woodworker.
by apotheon
by larry brown
Hello *Word*worker, and also to my good friend and compatriot, apotheon.
Well that may have been a good joke to call him woodworker, but I didn't mean it intentionally. I just didn't view his handle carefully.
Thanks for calling me smart. I find that even when offered sarcastically, compliments like that feel good. You know, you're not great at sarcasm. Too much of your goodness comes through. You are like Darth Vader trying to turn Luke to the Dark Side, I can feel the good in you.
Anyway, wordworker, drop the sarcasm and give me your opinion. I gave you hard evidence, right from Microsoft, that some features of Word don't work, including your spell checker. So do you now rescind your "SAY WHAT?" incredulity, or can you, in spite of hard evidence, still maintain that you think Word works just fine?
Also, I'd be interested to know if you have noticed the various problems that I mentioned. And if so, do you just ignore them and they don't make you angry? How can you justify that? If you bought a car and the radio worked sometimes and other times didn't, and the car simply stopped dead when you turned on the headlights and you had to stop what you were doing and restart the car, you wouldn't accept that, would you?
by wordworker
by apotheon
. . . can make me feel this way.
No, wait, that's a song.
I discuss, without euphemism (except for humorous effect) or reservation, the technical issues I see with a given piece of software. Only you, and similarly Microsoft-wedded minds, can see that as hate speech.
by larry brown
Dear Wordworker:
You are a really nice guy. As a debater, however, you leave me puzzled. How can anyone persist in ignorance once shown the light? I can't understand you.
1: Bugs from old versions are useful in demonstrating trends and Microsoft's strategies. Every version has been buggy. It's easiest to point out bugs on old versions because those are the ones with which I have several years of experience. Since Microsoft introduces a new version every year or two, it doesn't make sense to wipe the slate clean and say "Oh yeah...that's an old version. I'm sure they have all that garbage cleaned up by now." If that were true, Word 95 would have been glorious because think how many versions came before that. Microsoft has brainwashed you so thoroughly. No matter how buggy the last 10 years of software were, you believe them when they say that the "next version" is going to solve all the problems.
2: Tell me, do you use the knowledge base regularly? I do, and I am horrified at what Microsoft themselves tell me are the problems in their products. I don't need personal experience, they themselves tell me. By they way, 130 hits doesn't count as "a few.". Have you ever seen how Microsoft carries bugs forward from version to version to version? You'll find a KB article about a "stops responding" bug in Word 2003, and at the top they'll have links that say "to see a Word 2002 version of this article click here." "To see a Word 2000 version of this article, click here." To see a Word 97 version of this article, click here." That's hilarious, obscene, and criminal.
3: Exhaustive research. Now it's my turn to say "SAY WHAT?" Would it be possible, even in theory, to exhaustively research Word? Can you imagine how many people are testing it over at Microsoft and still letting scads of bugs out? Besides, I?ve already gone well past ?bona fide diatribe,? what more do you want?
4: Personal use of the product. Ummm.....Wordworker, did you read my post? Or where were you? I posted lots of personal use examples of where I have struggled with Word. When you blatantly ignore information like this you show yourself as biased and insincere.
5: If "all your clients" skipped the word 2002 release, then you must have a client list of, like, three people. If you had even ten, surely some of those would have used 2002. That doesn't give you much credibility. How is it possible that an expert like you did not update to 2002 when it was available? Obviously, your outlook is limited, but of course I knew that.
6: Word has *never* crashed on you? Then you never used Word under DOS, or Windows 3.1 did you? Otherwise it would have crashed on even a light user like yourself. But even so, Wordworker, even if it has never crashed on you, why can't you see that if Microsoft themselves admit that Word crashes, that it "stops responding," that it's a piece of junk? No software should ever crash.
7: "nonproductive and negative hate-speak:" As I said in an earlier post, bashing shoddy products is worthwhile. Slinging sarcasm, on the other hand, could not be construed as such.
8: You don't indicate that you have used the Corel import. That's ok, of course no one person has used even half the features of Word. But are you going to tell me that you have never fought Word while building a list? Or that the autocorrect, before we had the lightning bolt, never used to kill you? FWIW, at what version of Word did you start your career?
9: I don't mind if someone slings sarcasm at me, just like I don't mind that Microsoft stuffs tons of features into their products. I just ask that they be good at it. :-)
Finally, I am not an open source zealot. I have never used any open source and I don't know anything about it. I am willing to believe that open source software is of good quality, but it's not the only good software that has ever existed. There's been lots of others. You see, Wordworker, what you are missing is experience on a variety of systems, some of which are good. That's what we IT people have that you don't. The only software you've ever used is Microsoft, so you can't understand that there could be anything better. The fact that there are many of us constantly screaming at you that Microsoft is not perfect, it's not what it should be, that better is possible and we have seen it, should make you accept this possibility. I don't hate you, Wordworker, I like you and I want to educate you.
by jmgarvin
I don't get it. You've seen Apo and I disagree on points in *nix, is that hate speech towards *nix?
How can you say Word doesn't crash? I did a quicky search of "word stops responding," and you know what I got?
http://search.microsoft.com/search/results.aspx?st=b&na=88&View=en-us&qu=word+stops+responding
Yup, it happens! Oh my! Microsoft must publish their own hate speech!
by apotheon
The Nation of Microsofties needs its leader. Next, he'll be parting the Red Hat and saying "Let my OS go!", or standing on a balcony getting assassinated by an eeeeeeevil member of the LLL (Lib-GNU Linux LAN, I guess) after he says "I have a dream!" while waving a Windows Vista CD around. We'll have to start calling him Malcolm XP. Clearly, anyone that recognizes problems with Windows and other software from Microsoft is just an OSist.
Next, he'll be saying that reverse engineering software functionality is a "hate crime".
by oz_media
Just the mini suv's. The 3/4 tonne SUV's are built like tanks, unfortunately getting the gas mileage of a tank too. The problem is, light trucks fall into full size car regulations (not the other way around). A ford truck (F-series) will kill anything it's size or smaller, and that's the truck below Ford's full size SUV's.
The little wannabe SUV's are built to car standards, but they don't fit into a class I would consider an suv either, a car that looks like it can handle a gravel driveway and that's about it.
The one's that kill me (and many others unfortunately) are the PT Cruisers by Chrysler, they squeaked in as a light truck/full size car, due to footprint and door sill height, yet they are just a poorly built, lightweight, communter car/death trap with no safety regulations, like many smaller minivans. People buy these 'people movers' to carry around the kids, you would think they had some strict engineering behind them but they also fit into a light truck/full size car segment, they just aren't built like a truck and don't have the weight of a full size car though. Then look at the Windstar and it's a safety dream, though far less affordable than say a dodge minivan, so everyone buys the smaller, cheaper minivan and loads it with the soccer team thinking it's safe.
If you're gonna buy something designed around a truck, buy one that is actually built to heavy half or 3/4 tonne standards.
For the most part, you have a much better chance in a FULL size suv than any of todays (North American) cars or midsize SUV's, but not when stacked up to a Volvo (new or old) or Mercedes or Bentley.
by apotheon
by jmgarvin
by apotheon
by mdpetrel
by jdhannah
Why do UNIX/Linux people hate MS? That's the real question, because there isn't the same animosity - at least in my experience - among MS developers toward the open source movement. I am a MS guy, but I really applaud the open source movement because they have pushed MS into making better prioducts. IIS 6 is a good Web server. Win2003 is a good OS (feel free to disagree). These chages (consider NT4 for a moment), were largely driven by competition from Linux.
Also, we must face the fact that hackers tend not to target Linux because it's open source, it's 'free' and therefore not evil like the empire-building Microsofties. There is a socio-political dynamic as a subtext to this debate. I'm not discounting the technical arguments, but which side you fall on seems to have another dimension beyond the technical merits of the OS you prefer (perhaps this is obvious to some). So, can we simply acknowledge that competition is a good tghing, that there is space for both OSs in the universe and that each may serve customers according to their specific needs? Really, the person who said 'Bill Gates is technically illiterate' is not a rational voice and too many seem emotionally tied up in this debate. This is ultimately a business decision and if you want to be truly effective as an IT professional, drop the hyperbole and think with your head, not with your heart.
by jmgarvin
A) MS people hate Linux as well. They refuse to learn simple tasks and complain it is "too hard" and therefore must stink on ice. MS isn't creating better products, just better marketing. While IIS 6 is lightyears ahead of IIS 5, it still sucks. It has too many bugs and too many issues. IIS 6 should have been IIS 4, but no, MS had to play the marketing game (and they are losing)
B) Win2k3 is meh. While I can take it or leave it, at least MS doesn't turn all the serivces on by default. They also tried (but failed) to lock down the OS. I've said it before, I'll say it again, kernel and user space are mudged together. Plus the registry is a HUGE kludge that needs to go away (a major reason for insecurities)
C) "Hackers" not targeting *nix is FUD. It is not true and it does not fit with reality. The reason MS has some many issues is because it is an EASY target, not because of some socio-political ideal. Tell me, can you EASILY get root on a *nix box? What about getting admin on a Windows box? It is FAR easier to get Admin on any given Windows box than to get root. Why go after the hard targets when there are easy ones?
D) There is space for both OSs, but MS IS NOT SECURE BY ANY STRETCH OF THE IMAGINATION. Use it for internal AD structure or similar tasks, but that is what it is good at, not being out there and vulnerable to cheesy attacks like exploiting REMOTE PLUG AND PLAY (WTF is that?)
E) Exactly. Why choose an open and easy to hack MS web server over a highly secure *nix webserver?
by jdclyde
When Windows 2000 server came out and they wanted you to move off of your old NT4 server, do you remember what the commercials were?
They WEREN'T "more stable and secure than linux", but "More stable and secure than NT4".
Buy this new server OS, because it is better than the last crap we stiffed you for.
People are STILL running NT4 servers. Why? Because they LIKE them? Or because the applications STOP WORKING if they move it to the newer OS's.
So to migrate up, they need to replace ALL of the existing software? Now why would that be a problem?
I think the people that are extreme either way are nuts though, as stated in the old "so many zelots, so little time" discussion a little while back.
Be careful, as you seem to be listening to too much marketing and FUD, as to the REASONS and frequency of the attacks.
Look at SANS.
Look at turn around time from exploit to patch.
Look at the severity of the exploits.
Look at the difficulty of the exploits.
Anyone with an open mind HAS to give the security and scalability to *nux, just like they HAVE to give ease of use to Windows.
Linux is catching up on the ease of use faster than MS is catching on the security adn scalability.
by apotheon
MacOS X is proof that it's easier to pretty up unix than it is to secure Windows.
I wouldn't say that Windows is "easier" to use so much as that it's more accessible to the rank newbie. Of course, most of that is based in the fact that you can buy a Windows system pre-installed, and just click on stuff to install everything (when it works properly).
Once you actually get past the initial learning curve for any given task on unix/Linux, though, you'll find that it's much easier to actually accomplish things than with Windows. For instance, inserting an installation CD in the CDROM drive on a Windows system typically causes an installation dialog to start up automatically, and you click the "install software" (or whatever) button to make it go. You then spend four or five minutes clicking through things, wait another ten, and finally you're done. With a Debian GNU/Linux system, meanwhile, if you want to install new software, you stare at it for a bit wondering where to get the software and how to get it installed. If you put a CD in the drive, nothing much seems to happen. However . . . when you ask your Linux guru buddy how to install OpenOffice.org on the system, he tells you, and suddenly you realize how unbelievably easy it is to install: you type "apt-get install openoffice.org" and hit enter at the shell prompt. You wait about two minutes. It's installed.
That's it.
Much easier on the Linux system, but not nearly as accessible to the clueless.
by apotheon
There's one reason that MS Windows and Linux can't coexist peacefully: Microsoft won't let them. Microsoft can't abide competition. Everything MS does is geared toward "market share", which translates to "destroying the competition". This means that to Microsoft, there's no such thing as peaceful coexistence. MS must own the market entirely, or die trying.
As long as that's the case, there will never be room enough for both Windows and Linux in the OS market, except as bitter rivals.
by sauvecali
I agress that Windows Server 2003 and IIS 6 are respectable
products in regards for security. I have to give Microsoft credit
for doing a good job with those products. However, this much
cannot be said for other departments, like ahem, IE team, whose
response to CERT recomendations to use alternative browsers, is
arrogance.
The statement about hackers do not target Linux is really
incorrect or mischaracterization. Hackers do indeed target
Linux and other Unix OSes all the time presistantly. I cannot
imagine Linux/Unix without the notion of a hacker trying to
break in.
The question is, what do you do about it? Linux/Unix has
learned to live with exploits, and some of the best security
solutions, like SSL/TLS w/ PKI (X.509 certificates), IPSec,
Kerberos has developed from this experience in dealing with
them. Microsoft by the was has strongely adopted these
technologies. Other solutions and developments in security, e.g.
SE Linux kernel or jailing (chrooting), nor not even
conceptualized in any of Microsoft current or future products. It
also seems that any program can through APIs can easily hack
into the system as is the case with SonyBMB rootkit and constant
malware/spyware problem, something difficult on Linux/Unix.
by rvanderblom
Well Angus, maybe it's just a response to the marketing machine of Microsoft, which seems to be able to put a lot of messages on the internet which in some cases are just plain FUD.
One example is the "get the facts" campaign, which is targetted against Linux and uses TCO analysis to show that MS software has a superior TCO compared to Linux (which in some cases may be true, but in other cases is plain nonsense, as one companies TCO doesn't necessarily need to be the TCO another companie will encounter). I know for sure that for my company the TCO of Linux and Open Source is much better than the TCO MS is promising (company is a start-up, with technically minded people that understand concepts etc. of Linux and most open source software) Though i fully understand that this only applies for my company and doesn't necessarilly reflect the TCO of another startup.
So i guess some of the MS bashing is a response to these marketing related messages coming out of MS.
Some of the MS bashers are IMHO indeed just plain frustrations against the market leader, part of zealotism and should be dismissed as partly irrelevant and noise on the line.
Then you've got the people who just bash MS because it's fun to do and partly easy. MS has a good marketing department, but they're not particularly good in responding to security threads (sometimes they just downgrade them as irrelevant).
MS has in the past had a lot of crashed in their software (there is no denying that) but i've got the feeling that they've gotten better in that so we should give them credit for this.
As long as MS will be agressively trying to blacken competition, they will be bashed upon.
by jdclyde
A few things to look at when we say our system is more stable today than it was five years ago.
To run this more "stable" software, I NEED to have 10 times the computer I NEEDED to have five years ago.
Would you agree that many of the crashes are from running out of resources?
Have we not thrown a lot more resources at the problem?
So which was the fix? The new software or the software on the new hardware? A little of both?
Is MS better now or worse now, in working with other vendors to allow them to create applications that run in the Windows environment?
How about "value".
When the software costs many times more than the hardware it is running on, how do you feel about the pricing? How about the upgrade path? Are you happy with that?
Should your Office Suit really take over a GIG of disk space to install the complete package? What about format compatablitiy? There are more and more people out there that DON'T have MS Office loaded on their computers. I can't exchange documents with them now and will miss out on an opportunity because MS intentionally makes it so other suits can't open their files? That is a business advantage to who? (besides MS that is)
Will Frontpage EVER create a web page for your business that anyone from anywhere using any browser they want, can come and give you money? AOL's browser typically does not handle the non-standard code well, and these people have already shown they have more money than brains to use AOL in the first place. EXACTLY the kind of people I want for customers! "Fix it, here is a pile of cash!"
Compatablitiy is needed to be able to do business with anyone that wishes to hire you. Do you really want to turn them away just because they didn't buy a MS product that you have no profit stake in?
Yes, I know you can spend a lot of time doing "Save as" and modify the layout. MANY of your daily users are NOT up to that, don't remember to do it, or just won't. (not their job, let IT do it)
by rvanderblom
[i]To run this more "stable" software, I NEED to have 10 times the computer I NEEDED to have five years ago.[/i]
The amount of extra hardware is as far as i'm concerned a mather of fact!! Not using it would actually be more shamefull. Could we use it better of course, but that would mean a paradigm shift which currently no company is capable of delivering.
[i]Is MS better now or worse now, in working with other vendors to allow them to create applications that run in the Windows environment?[/i]
This actually depends on whether your competing head on with MS software. If you compete, don't expect to much help. If you enhance the windows experience they will help you, embrace you, hug you and then if it really is succesfull create their own solution (end of hugs etc. of course)
Do they provide customers a fair choice that's something else. But then again, they will ensure that will make sure that you're locked in :).
[i]How about "value".[/i]
As stated before, i hardly see any additional value in the MS offering, that's why i'm perfectly happy with my Linux distro, Firefox, Evolution, OO that i'm currently using. But then again most people are so afraid to leave MS behind because of the steep learning curve they see!
And then again, "value" is very subjective. I "highly value and appreciate" the music of "system of a down", but i bet there are more people out there who hate it.
It's the same with TCO, for some companies it's better to use MS than open source ("especially when you're short term focussed"). Change scares a lot of people, give them time and they will come to appreciate new software (depending on the part of the world you're living in of course)
In the end only time will learn what is te best course of action, but the manner in which MS is responding tells me that they are afraid of this brave new world with thin clients, browser based apps and true open standards.
by deckmonkey
Quit the whining about "My OS is better than yours" because it is hugely juvenile and proves nothing other than the plaintiffs own childishness.
Yes, windows has vulnerabilities, as does every other OS, but windows does a huge amount of stuff compared to other OS's so it is to be expected that there will be more imperfections. I'm not excusing them, after all as a developer myself I try my best not to write code which has bugs and we try to test them out of existence, but you never, ever get them all.
The only justified whinge can come from someone who has never written software with any bugs in and which is totally secure. And I'm pretty sure there are about as many of them as there are flying pigs in this world.
by gkrew
by woodhead1
Let me see...
The Company develops the Web Server edition of the operating system (2003) for the express purpose of being a web server
But Outlook WEB access will not run on it. Yep must be my fault somehow.
Registration page for an event crashes Internet Explorer because they (MS) only tested it on a version that had only been out for 2 months. Again, the fault of the rest of the world for NOT upgrading quickly enough.
A company that cannot decide from version to version what to call the OS???
NT Workstation
W2K Pro
XP Pro
NT certs will expire...no they won't...
Yep..again my fault they cannot make a decision. Must be an incorrect drive on my system. So YOU tell me, what driver is that? Not on my Computer???
by stargazerr
Or an IT Guru is it???
Its about how user friendly an OS is...before anyone says anything...YES...windows is the most user friendly OS out there...
But user friendliness also counts minimum errors and glitches....which as most people would agree is not a strong point of Windows....of course, this includes all the virus attacks on them.
I personally am no fan of microsoft either, but they are mostly paying a price of being the most popular OS out there....
by jdclyde
They are paying the price because it is more important to be first to market than to have a solid product.
I have been playing with computers for a long time. I remember a time when if your computer crashed, you had a hardware problem. Today, even the most novice of users are very aquainted with the three finger salute.
Why are there so many virus issues with Windows? Ok, you see how a virus can exploit something. Fix it or shut it off. Making a "variation" of the virus should not work because the WAY Windows is exploited should have been FIXED.
Windows will only get secure and stable if there is competition and the customers DEMAND more out of their systems.
No more just accepting that "It's windows, reboot it".
by stargazerr
I can never tell one version of windows from another :D .... they just want to be the first...who cares about Quality ??
Are the viruses just a way to get back at Bill Gates ;P ???
by semmyd
If it werent for MSoft's contued churning out of new products most of us would be unemployed by now. A lot of us have been riding the certification wave and mostly MS Certs. Now think if they stopped bringing out new products......
9x% of pcs world over run MS OS and that translates into employment being generated for us because MS products are buggy and are prone to a lot of problems. From a business point of view whats the point of having a stable OS like Linux which you will never get called in to support. I have a family to support. So all you stop wining and hating on MS coz they feed you and me. You have made careers out of their products so show some appreciation.....
I am really sick and tired of wanabee gurus who are always tearing down MS. Yes their products can be s*** but they have come a long way. You have to give them that.
Even you security people, they give you something to talk about....
by tmcclure
I have to disagree with your assumption about user freindly. As an Net Admin, I am finding the Windows enviornment convoluted.
I also have to admit I am a Novell and Linux Administrator. So it may be my lack of experience.
by han810p9
I've been saying it for years -
Form follows function.
Our AutoCAD users have to use Windows - no choice. So do it right. Carefully match hardware/software/drivers and all is well.
Our graphics people use Macs. It is the best platform for what they do, and again, we are careful in what we install.
Our servers? A mix - because the accounting system only runs on MS (it is specialized for the A/E/C industry, so don't tell me to get them to change!)
And the DMZ server? Unix. Best fit for the need.
I harbor no bigotry toward any OS - and enjoy learning the intricacies of each. Challenge yourself to do the best with the tools you are provided, and you will be rewarded with more and better assignments.
by jdclyde
and start drinking beer?
Yes, let us stand up and rejoice in the fact that we have endorsed a product that is not concerned with quality.
Let us intentionally program in random error messages to make the users call us even more!
We should all donate money to a hackers college fund so we can get more virus writters out there so we can justify our jobs to our bosses.
[/sarcasm]
[b]
Sorry, I don't buy it. I have too much pride in myself and my work to ever fall in line with such thoughts. My job is to make sure that the user can do his. I do my job well.
by apotheon
by dbucyk
When you check out a PC and make sure all the drivers are on the HCL and are totally updated, you still have two other problems here.
The first problem is power instability. Over time capacitors can leak and this leak can cause system freezeups, or there can me problems with the power supply.
Either way, if the computer freezes up and gives you a message (particularly before windows 2000) you have to check to see there is no memory overlap or certain programs.
Next, if you are using Windows 2000 or higher, there are possibilities for the same amount of problems.
As more and more programs are added in 2000 and higher, Windows has incorporated a mechanism to prevent this from happening.
However, there is still the notion of bad or faulty circuitry.
Out of 18 years , I've done 6 in HP and 8 in VMS and bit in Unix and 2 under Linux. Windows had run through most of that time and yes I'm developing under windows now. I'm still using the same skills though. I have no time for this idea that windows development is fundamentally different for devloping under MPE, VMS, Unix or Linux, all of which I've done. People who say I should be grateful for the low quality badly implemented garbage that Redmond puts out are talking about themselves not me. I didn't need Bill to get a job, I don't need Bill to keep a job and I'll never need Bill to keep finding a job.
The only people I've seen riding the certification wave are the companies who provide the training, I have seen a lot of people continually being washed up by the tide though. I suppose convincing them that is somehow enjoyable was a good marketing ploy.
I love the wannabe gurus , does that mean you can only be a guru when you know enough to agree that windows doesn't not deserve tearing down ?
mipsv whn was da last time u were in India or China??????
keep dreaming, we buy companies who here in US who have twisted minds like u and take em to china india !!
by broodryks
by sauvecali
There are many reasons I'm sure, but the one thing for me as a
system administrator is SECURITY. Yes it is true that Windows,
the biggest installed based is under the spotlight, but that
nevertheless there just poor naive design and complete absence
of security concepts in some areas. I'll list them out and
comment.
(1) Applications Can Seize Control - Applications can apparently
install drivers and rewrite kernel tables as is evident by the
SonyBMG root-kit in the news lately. Linux this can be limited
and controlled, e.g. setuid.
(2) Cannot Jail Services - If a service gets compromised it can go
to town on your system, RPC dependent services like DCOM, IIS
services, etc. In UNIX, many mail systems and others services
have the ability to be jailed (chroot). This is often done with
Apache, to prevent damage from poorly written server
applications. There is no such facility on Windows.
(3) Services Cannot Adequately Be Restricted - Some services
can be limited, but not every department follows the philosphy
(SQL guys seem to get it). But even still, the service or its DLLs
can be compromised, and once this happens intruder can go to
town. With inclusion of SELinux from NSA into the Linux kernel
(and similar efforts with BSD type OSes), one can restrict what
the service has access to at the kernel level, something never
even fathomed or planned for Windows OSes, not even Vista.
(4) Lack of Integrated IDS - there are many advanced security
applications for Linux. Some of these are available on Windows,
but with WinXP SP2, Microsoft attempts to impede them by
artificially retarding the socket libraries (shows lack of
understanding and cooperation with security community).
There's solutions like TripWire and others that are free for Linux,
and costly for Windows. Seems spyware and malware, and
general applications, are sprinkely all kinds of DLLs and what
not in %WINDIR%\System32 all the time. There's no accounting
for them, and sometimes to remove some of them means re-
install the OS. On Linux/Solaris/FreeBSD, I don't see
applications going buck-wild in this fashion and through various
package/port manager system, there an accounting of what is
installed/where, and a removal/dependency process. Most
Windows applications roll their own (sometimes destructive)
undocumented installation process. This also makes the update
process for non-Microsoft solutions expensive (updating
Acrobat, third party apps, anti-virus, etc.).
(5) Lack of Free Virtualization System - There's UML and Xen
solutions which are FREE. Virtualization solutions help with
security as a single service can be placed on a single server.
One host can host several OSes running these isolated services.
When a hacker compromises a service, he/she/it cannot use that
information to compromise other services on that system (as it
only has that single service).
(6) Administration Culture - Both the development community
and information technology community have history of dealing
with hacks. Though Unices don't have viruses like Windows,
they are often hacked by the same techniques that viruses use.
From this, there's an intuitive understanding to build facilities
like jailing and restricting services, processes, etc. and securing
communications, which seem common sense. As the source
code is open, it is scrutized by many that don't want to have
insecure systems. Systems like OpenBSD even have an auditing
process to scrutinize source that is checked in. In many
Windows shops they seem to have the tootsie-roll approach to
security, hard on the outside, soft on the inside.
With solutions like Exchange integrated into Active Directory,
insecure traffic like POP, IMAP, OWA, will reveal account
passwords that will allow access to their domain accounts
(locally or remotely). Security is more grave of a cocern because
of this integration, but is often overlooked or not well
understood by button clicking type of administrators (though
this is gradually changing and the level of sophistication in
Windows IT seems to be increasing)
(4) The Browser that Browses You - Since IE4, MS added routines
for webscripts to save files on your hard drive. They added
access to a rich library of COM modules at the expense of
security. I've personally got infected with NIMDA through such
mechanisms. The culprit is ActiveScripting engine, which is
used by IE, WSH, and IIS. This is often compromised and
exploited, and even if secured, web scripts still have access to
your system. When IE is configured to limited such access, there
have been simple exploits in the past to bypass such
restrictions. Many times, clever social engineering is used to
bamboozle users to accept ActiveX controls that can
compromise their system.
IE iself is packaged up as a OLE module, which is embedded in a
variety of other applications, most infamously Outlook Express
and Outlook. Those programs use IE engine (with embeded
scripting engine) to show mail. Before with the preview pane,
Outlook auto-loaded scripts that were viruses w/o asking the
user. How many viruses have we heard about with IE or Outlook,
a.k.a. LookOut!
by dbucyk
When people bash any operating system (even a techie), it's because some of it is frustration. A true technician won't because that's what keeps him busy; flaws in any network or operating system and having to keep it running smoothly.
That's why I got into the field a few years ago because of the constant challenge of keeping things up and running.
So, the next time you work on a PC, Server, NOS, or OS, ask yourself this "What would technicians do for a living if everything worked smootly out of the box and there wasn't anything to do to support the hardware?"
by max.bennett
by popsprice
by dreis
OK, I do not normally replay to blogs. But I am tired of hearing about how terrible Windows is.
I am facinated by it. Sure Apple my work better, but it is a propritory operating system for a propritory system. Meaning it only works on Apple Computers. Well hell, if that the kind of system you want, go back to NT!
You take a Windows disc, put it on almost any computer, Dell, HP, Compac, etc, and you at least have a half way operating system, think on how many configurations there are.
Can Apple do that? I don't think so.
In a way, Windows had made it so you DO have time to complain, instead of looking for drivers that will work.
So think about what Windows is trying to accomplish, and have a little respect for the magnitude of what it does!
OK, I've vented and I feel better.
thank you for your time.
by absolutely
M$ $uck$ big, juicy
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Kiwis!
The real reason is twofold, both related to popularity.
First and obviously, there are more copies of Microsoft.
Second and hopefully less obviously, since Windows is the de facto standard, computing environments of beginners are mostly OEM computers with Windows, and techies get a barrage of calls from people who don't know how to tie their own shoes. Windows is used by many people who have no business using ANY computer. Other OSes are more specialized, thus used by fewer idiots who stumble across every idiosyncrasy in their ineptitude.
by dreis
by dreis
by apotheon
That's a stability problem. Your system should not crash because you have a lot of applications open.
My experience is that anyone using Windows that isn't very technically astute, or doesn't have someone like that on tap to babysit their computing environment, always ends up with security and stability issues that make my skin crawl.
by annonymous
The point is every car has its uses. You just need to choose what best suits your needs.
You don't ever bash the car. Did you fill your Edsel with gas? Did you check the air pressure on your Pinto?
The point is every food has its uses. You just need to choose what best suits your needs.
You don't ever bash the food. Did you warm up your hot-dog water? Did you properly crumble that moldy piece of bread?
Every product is not equal. Some are BETTER. Some are WORSE. It's a pretty easy concept.
I hope you're not in a position of authority, because obviously you'd be wasting dollars insisting that shit performance was entirely the fault of the techies, and paying out more or less random amounts of maintenance dollars because you couldn't understand that some systems require more work than others.
by apotheon
by absolutely
And, did you intend to add that extra "n" to "anonymous"?
Either way, I appreciated the irony of a misspelled nickname connected to the title "The Start of the Thread is Utterly Dense".
by bjbrn
Microsoft products are full of bugs (known and not fixed)and a magnet for malware. I actually get more annoyed with the protection schemes that make things like downloading patches or reinstalling office after it crashes from a MS bug SO HARD. I have to have the CD in the drive or a complex network install and the computer ON the network to upgrade.
However, whenever I rant and rave (yes, often) I also remember we buy the stuff. MS didn't hold a gun to my head. As long as fortune 500's are "all MS shops" then there is a captive market and like any monopoly, there's no need to have a good product. If we were really serious about better software, we'd stop buying MS, but few of us do.
by dbucyk
With Microsoft, they hold a huge majority of the popular software for running a computer. Yes, there is other OSs, but we still buy Microsoft.
One thing to note. With all the lines of code, a vast array of different hardware, and a wide selection of software, there is bound to be conflicts. That's what we have to live with unfortunately.
Yes, the IBM PC and clone hardware is not as stable as MacIntosh, but since they are not as strong as Microsoft yet, but I can see them gaining ground, then we have to put up with crashes, blue screens of death and alike.
It should be up to the novice, although sometimes it doesn't happen that way, and the IT professionals to make things run smoothly from PC workstation problems to server problems.
Be glad though there are people out there who try their best to make an operating system that works and all we can do is do our best to fix the problems as they arise.
by apotheon
I agree with the text of the previous post. If we don't choose to use better technologies, we must to some extent blame ourselves for the problems of using technologies that are broken by design. I, for one, avoid software from Microsoft as much as I can. I work in a primarily Linux shop, and I don't have anything running Windows on my network at home. Thanks to this, I don't have to spend as much time screwing around with software failures as I would if everything was running Windows.
You said "we have to put up with crashes, blue screens of death and alike." In point of fact, we don't. That's the point: if you choose to use something more stable, you do NOT have to deal with that, and you can even save a lot of money while you're at it.
by synapsetech
by t165
I think that the reason that techies bash Windows is because finally there is an OS that is virtually idiot-proof. As a result companies no longer need hordes of IT support people to support desktops, and Windows server maintenance can be performed on schedule with very little intervention on the part of IT. I've seen people who I don't think have enough going on between their ears to figure out how to put air in their tires, successfully load Windows XP on their home computers.
That said until they design and OS that it completely idiot-proof (around the year 3000) there will still be demand for technical support, it will just be a lower demand. Also for the first time low-level users are able to help each other out. On the positive side techies can now avoid the dreaded 'how do I format a floppy' question because Jane can call her friend June who though not a techie knows how to format a floppy.
The other horror for IT people is that unlike every other OS you can really muck up Windows with very little knowledge. I had gifted customer decide that her system32 folder was taking up to much space on her hard drive (with files that since they weren't ones she created had to be garbage and therefore were safe to delete) remove every file in the directory that Windows allowed her to remove. It would never dawn on these customers to delete any of 10G of mp3's they have loaded on the boot partition. All of this she managed to do without administrative authority. I suspect that she would have taken the whole Windows directory if she had admin authority.
Luckily there are still enough complex operating systems out there to keep the IT people of the world happily tooling away in our atmosphere controlled server rooms for the next half century or so. And now that we don't have to support Windows we can concentrate on our true calling communing with our higher level server OS's which no user will ever take the time to learn and which no company has the R&D budget necessary to make user friendly.
by apotheon
MacOS X is proof that it's easier to make unix pretty than it is to make Windows secure and stable.
I prefer free unices over Windows for a number of reasons, but one in particular is that everything you've said about the benefits of Windows is 100% wrong. The opposite is true: Windows increases the need for support personnel. It doesn't reduce that need.
I'm the netadmin for a company whose network is, at any given time, about 85% Linux systems, but the 15% of the network that is Windows systems accounts for about 60% of my daily administrative overhead. In other words, that makes for about 8.5 times as much maintenance time for each Windows system as for each Linux system.
When I was consulting, replacing servers with Linux systems was a great way to A) make our clients more loyal by reducing the problems they had with the systems and B) reduce the amount of money we made from each client because they didn't have to call us in nearly as often.
The reason I, for one, "bash" Windows is simply this: it increases my workload by a factor of 8.5. If anything, it increases the need for support techs, rather than decreases it.
by synapsetech
by apotheon
by leorivas
Ok, ok, you're right, but only to a certain level. Ive been a win/*ix user for several years now and as my experience tells, windows crashes more often than linux, no matter the use you are giving it; it has terrible error messages, that are completely unuseful for a techie to diagnose the problem (remember 'BSOD' or that 'memory can not be read' messages?). That crashes mean that the OS is not resolving conflicts, as this is one of its primary tasks...orrr...the OS has been designed under the policy that any new software can update a driver or library, overwriting the native one (the good one, aint it?). That was the worst enemy since win9x, and MS has tried to fix this signing every library or asking the user for its acceptance.
But it seems it is yet a design problem MS has to carry on his nightmares.. i dont see the way to fix this on a near future.
On the other hand, *ix's manage a standard library, that is never modified for a new software, so you can trust your OS is still sane even if you install/uninstall several packages.. several times, any new needed library goes on the program's dir, so it doesnt mix with the OS's ones. On Windows you?re never sure what OS files have been replaced on a software install, what registry keys are modified and so on, creating the feel of uncertainty about it's stability (err.. and dont forget about patches or SP's that caused more problems than fixes).
Well, from my point of view, any OS can get the job done for whatever you want, but when is time to fix problems, find the cause of an error, get worm/virus infected or any other problem, many tech people prefer *ix's over MS, but well, as the market is flooded with MS...well, ok, we'll doit for the money.
by jdclyde
I had the pleasure of wasting a few hours of my time today because I was silly enough to run the Windows XP Pros SP2 scandisk utility.
It seems that this can and will trash your system, making it so that your system will no longer boot, even in safe mode.
It will then hang on the germnuw.sys file and you get to either restore from a previous version or you get to try to edit your registry from a command line.
I would like to thank the TR members that jumped all over my TQ&A today to help me get my system back up and going. Being more of a server/networking guy, this was a real thorn in my side today.
by synapsetech
by synapsetech
People always equate windows problems with security issues. I don't have a problem with windows being susceptable to certain malicious code. Any OS will be in some form or another. I dislike the beta-testing on the public, the incompleteness of every aspect of their product that necessitates constant upgrades, and the bloated nature of the OS.
I am a windows user, and while there are many ways to maintain your system so that some of these issues are resolved, i dislike the need to do this.
Which is healthier, a 450 pound man, or a 185 pound track runner? Who will live longer? Move faster? Be sick more?
Trim and spare = good performance.
Period.
by synapsetech
by synapsetech
by apotheon
This reminds me of the public demonstration of Windows 95, where we all got to see the BSOD for the first time. Some people at Microsoft musta been fired after that.
Probably more fired now.
by ds.bishop
I agree that it is important to choose the right OS for the job, but stating that if the OS crashes its the fault of the admin is far from the truth.
OS crashes occur because they are imperfect and created by imperfect people, and often released much more quickly than they really should be.
Obviously one should keep up with patches and updates as much as possible, but it takes time to test patches before they are deployed, and I can't tell you how many times I have installed a service pack on a server only to have a stable server become unstable after the upgrade.
I think people tend to bash Windows because it is an OS that has traditionally shown to be much more lacking in security and stability in comparison with other OS's. Microsoft has made huge improvements in thses areas over the past few years, but remain a target simply because they are the bigest target. But let's face it. The Windoss os did not get the market share it has by being the best product on the market, but rather becuase of top notch marketing.
by caxe
by itjunkie
IT people that know nothing about Windows, bash Windows. Those of us who know how to set it up and make it work CORRECTLY don't have any real issue with it.
Anyone that says Windows sucks is in the wrong line of work.
by apotheon
IT people that know nothing about alternatives to Windows wander around claiming everybody else is stupid for bashing Windows. Those who know how to set up a Windows system with maximum stability and security have learned at least some of that from observing what works right in other OSes out of the box, but not in Windows. They also tend to be frustrated by the sheer man-hours required in setting up a Windows system thusly, and in maintaining it in a stable and secure state.
. . . and they also know better than to run it without an external firewall running a different OS.
Anyone that thinks Windows is the bees' knees and that people with a learned distaste for Windows needs his head examined.
It is, in fact, because of my extensive knowledge of, and experience with, Windows that I find it so aggravating and dislike it so much. Windows made a Linux user out of me.
by gnx
Sort by Trending