Discussion Locked

3 Linksys Routers, 1 DSL, 3 Static IP's?

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Port forwarding with Linksys Routers
Here is the basic layout that we are trying to get accomplished:

We have a small network with about 18 systems. (All Win 2000)(1 Server)

We have a DSL connection with 3 dedicated IP Addresses.

We use remote software that allows the IT members to connect to any machine in the office through the IP Address and a port combination.

ex. 192.168.1.1:5000 PC1
192.168.1.2:5001 PC2 (just an example)

The problem we have is this we are using (3)Lynksys BEFSR41 4 port routers, which have the limitation of only forwarding 10 ports.

What we would like to do is hook up three routers and have each one use the a dedicated IP address from the DSL connection.

I have gotten it working to a point but then the routers start to lock up and need to be rebooted (hourly at best)

Here is the scenario DSL connection comes into a 100 meg switch (through the uplink) then it is sent to each of the routers into their wan connection from ports 1, 2 and 3.

The routers are then uplinked to the network from their uplink connection to the main network switch.

Anyone get this done, or have any other ideas?

I have done a afir bit of reading and searching, and so far all I can see is that it should work.

Do I have to set up Static Routing Tables?
Do I need to have each router uplinked to a seperate switch or hub?
This is really frustrating.......

Thanks

14 replies

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Why do the ports need to be different on each machine you're connection to?

Cant you just connect to...

192.168.1.1:5000
192.168.1.2:5000

The combination is unique, after all... Or is there some other reason?

That, at least, would get you around the port forwarding limitation and may stop the hangs too.

Cheers,
Tim.

by toolmanz

Very simple, first yes those two address would be unique, but they are internal, and if I can't get multiple routers set up their is no way to send the request to the internal address. By having the routers setup I can then hit the machines directly, with no regard to their internal address.

by toolmanz

This is not what I am trying to do, we are connecting from an external accesspoint, so we can not use internal IP's, hence the use of port forwarding on the router.

by meganetcomputers

Do you have DHCP set up on the routers? Does your ISP require you to use PPPoe set up through the router to connect to there network? Please e-mail me directly and I will be able to assist you further. This is alittle involved to spell out every step you need to take to fully configure this. Thanks.

by toolmanz

No DHCP, Static IP Addresses in the entire network. ISP Does not require PPPoe.

What I'm going to try next to simplyfy a few things is setup a VPN router instead so that we can establish a better "connection" to the office network form home and such. If this works the way it should.... Then we will have a full time connection, and we can access the networks systems by internal IP address without having to worry about port forwarding, etc.

by toolmanz

No DHCP is not in use the entire network uses static IP's. And our ISP doesn't use PPPoe. I have ordered a VPN router and I'm going to try and get that going instead. If we can get a reliable VPN connection, then static internal IP's could be used and we don't need to worry about port forwarding at all....

by meganetcomputers

From what I'm understanding you have a switch on both sides of the routers. What is the reasoning behind this set up? What are you trying to set up that you want your 3 routers to have the external IP's? You can just have one router and hook it directly to the switch then if you want any of the PCs visable to the external network you can set them up in the DMZ.

by timthetoolman

Ah, silly me... you're coming in from outside... d'oh.

VPN is the best solution (as you already said), but another alternative you have is to port forward to one machine and then use terminal services or VNC from there.

Cheers,
Tim.

by toolmanz

Yeah I though of that as well, and we did have that working, but the overhead from having to go through multiple machine really slowed the connection down....

by isys

Does the switch between your routers and internal PCs support VLANs?

by isys

OK, VLANs are out. Are your routers set up for dynamic or static routing? They should be set up for static routing and only have their own networks in the routing tables.

by toolmanz

Thanks for all the comments, but we picked up several VPN routers (From Linksys as well) and have that setup and working well now...

This discussion is closed to new replies.